2nd Week of July 2023
------ 🚀 Join Ryan & David at Permissionless in September. Bankless Citizens get 30% off. 🚀 https://bankless.cc/GoToPermissionless
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | TRACK & MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
👾POLYGON | VALUE LAYER OF THE INTERNET https://polygon.technology/roadmap
----- Timestamps
0:00 RIPPLE VS SEC Breaking News - https://twitter.com/tier10k/status/1679512873498816519?s=20 Explained - https://twitter.com/BillHughesDC/status/1679525517068759040?s=20 A Huge Win - https://twitter.com/adamscochran/status/1679515814272155648 Tom Emmer - https://twitter.com/GOPMajorityWhip/status/1679525171479150592?s=20 Richie Torres - https://twitter.com/RepRitchie/status/1679534903661301761?s=20 Coinbase Relisting - https://twitter.com/coinbaseassets/status/1679575239657758721 RSA Take - https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1679534121100476417?s=20
5:20 Waking Up Bullish 7:15 Permissionless https://bankless.cc/GoToPermissionless
7:55 MARKETS 9:10 Bond Markets Trad - https://www.visualcapitalist.com/ranked-the-largest-bond-markets-in-the-world/ New - https://coinmarketcap.com/view/staking/ Fed Funds Rate - https://panteracapital.com/blockchain-letter/bonds-down-crypto-up/ 16:30 The Internet Bond https://ultrasound.money/ 23:22 Liquid Staking https://www.bankless.com/whats-next-for-liquid-staking-2 31:25 Tokenized Treasuries https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2023/07/11/tokenized-us-treasurys-surpass-600m-as-crypto-investors-capture-tradfi-yield 34:30 Bank of America Bullish https://rsch.baml.com/access?q=s-i517792VNkDKydHLEioQ 35:20 Correlation with Stocks https://panteracapital.com/blockchain-letter/bonds-down-crypto-up/
NEWS 41:00 Arkham Intelligence https://twitter.com/ArkhamIntel/status/1678339355314900992 46:55 Technofascism https://twitter.com/scott_lew_is/status/1678772359648641028?s=20
51:15 Are the Devs Leaving? https://www.developerreport.com/blog/newsletter-20230706
53:12 Google Play NFT Policy https://android-developers.googleblog.com/2023/07/new-blockchain-based-content-opportunities-google-play.html 55:45 Solana Phone https://twitter.com/aeyakovenko/status/1679278533800235009?s=20
58:30 Linnea L2 to Mainnet https://twitter.com/LineaBuild/status/1678738006646177793?s=20 1:00:13 Mantle Network https://www.mantle.xyz/ 1:01:20 Gitcoin Public Goods L2 https://twitter.com/pgn_eth/status/1676972199423668228
1:06:30 GHO Stablecoin Mainnet https://app.aave.com/governance/proposal/?proposalId=268 1:10:25 EigenLayer Reopening https://app.eigenlayer.xyz/ 1:12:30 Vitalik Bitcoin Takes https://cointelegraph.com/news/vitalik-buterin-ordinals-revived-developers-on-bitcoin 1:16:45 Gemini Suing DCG https://twitter.com/cameron/status/1677327395869581316?s=20 1:17:22 Jay Clayton BTC ETF https://twitter.com/DefiantNews/status/1678434627768446977 1:19:15 Rishi Likes Crypto https://www.wired.co.uk/article/london-wants-american-crypto-refugees 1:21:1 Brazil Ethereum CBDC https://twitter.com/vinibarbosabr/status/1678511772775374850?s=20
1:27:00 Questions from the Nation
1:30:00 TAKES 1:34:30 The Fink Effect https://twitter.com/mskvsk/status/1677937403733106688 1:36:00 Still Using Venmo https://twitter.com/ryansadams/status/1679236595105382402 1:42:00 Crypto is a Scam https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1679077948463144961?s=20
1:45:50 MEME of the Week https://twitter.com/spreekaway/status/1677316680588967937
1:46:45 The Daily Gwei https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCvCp6vKY5jDr87htKH6hgDA
1:47:30 Where’s David? https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1678473614818156544?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
A US court has ruled that XRP, the asset, is not a security in the words of the judge. Ripple sales of XRP do not constitute an offer of investment contracts. XRP, not a security. This is absolutely huge because if XRP isn't a security, then nothing in crypto is a security. Now that's a little bit hyperbolic. Of course, it's possible to tokenize a thing that is a security and issue a security on chain. But what it does mean is the SEC's overreach, their regulation by enforcement, their allegations that clean base is an illegal securities exchange. Their court filings indicating that Salana, that Filecoin, that Matic, that Adam, that Cardano, that all of these are securities.
Well, how can they be securities if XRP isn't? How can eth be a security if XRP isn't? This is important precedent that was just set in, I think, puts Gensler back on his heels. It's a step back for Gensler and for anyone in the SEC who thinks that this regulation by enforcement activity can continue. It's a check on their power and all of this came about, of course, from a multi-year court case between Ripple, which is the company that originated XRP and the SEC. We haven't talked about it much because it's been on the back burner for so long. But now here it is. This is a tweet from Bill Hughes.
He is a crypto lawyer. He says this, the SEC versus Ripple, in brief, here's what you need to know. Ripple putting XRP on exchanges for trading and funding their operation with those sales is not an investment contract and therefore not a security. That's what the court said. Also, Ripple paying people in XRP is not an investment contract and therefore not a security. And XRP is not a security in and of itself even when offered through securities transaction. So this turn-of-phrase investment contract, XRP is not an investment contract when it's on an exchange. If you pay people with it or even when it's offered through a securities transaction, that's what the court ruled.
However, the court did say that Ripple's original selling of XRP directly pursuant to contracts was an investment contract and thus the security. So originally, XRP was a security and became not a security at some point in time. Bill also says, I'd be shocked if the SEC doesn't immediately appeal this to the second court because of course, this is a big setback for the SEC. I also agree with Adam Cochrane's take here. He says, overall, this is a huge win. XRP is one of the more centralized foundations with a key figurehead who has had standard sales via exchanges and formal distribution programs.
If those aren't securities, nearly nothing sold via exchange is. We also have some weigh-in from politicians. This is Representative Tom Emmer, majority whip. He's been on bank lists before. The Ripple case is monumental development in establishing that a token is separate and distinct from an investment contract. Did you hear that SEC? The token is separate and distinct from the investment contract. It may or may not be part of. Now he says, let's make this law. He wants to take this court president and make it law, generally applicable. Representative Richie Torres on the Democrat side also weighs in on all of this with an attack against the SEC saying the SEC is acting like an overzealous traffic cop arbitrarily ticketing drivers while keeping the speed limit a secret.
It prefers to communicate by enforcement rather than by rules or guidance, but that's no way to regulate digital assets. I'm calling for an investigation of the SEC, so some heat from that as well. Some of the major exchanges including Coinbase also issued within hours. Coinbase will be re-enabling trading for XRP on the XRP network. They say I suppose they feel safe in doing this given that the US court system has ruled that XRP is no longer a security. That's what just happened. With my take here, which is this doesn't really matter what you think of XRP, the asset or ripple of the company.
I personally think XRP is an overvalued project riding on some vapor, riding on a passionate, some might say a shilly community. I never thought I'd be saying this. Thank you XRP. You stopped Gary Gensers onslaught against crypto because if XRP isn't a security, then almost nothing is. We'll end it there. We're going to discuss this in more detail on Bangladesh in the coming days. I'm sure there's some things I missed here. This is breaking news. As I said, there's questions of whether Gensers in the SEC can appeal this. There's questions like, is it clear skies ahead for security regulations in the US?
I imagine there's some subtleties there. I imagine there's still some work we have to do. We'll get to all of those details. In fact, later today, I'm recording with Mike Sellig. He's a crypto lawyer, and we're going to explore this in some more detail. But today, for now, on the roll-up this morning, we get to celebrate this win, and I can't believe I'm saying this, but thank you XRP. Bangladesh Nation. It is the second Friday of July, and it is time for, of course, the weekly roll-up. I have Anthony Sassano from the Daily Gway with me for the second week in a row. Well, David, it's up exploring some mountains, and we got some topics to cover this week.
Anthony, how are you doing this morning? I'm very good. I'm very bullish today, actually. Wait, you woke up bullish. That's the thing you say on the Daily Gway, right? So what constitutes Anthony waking up bullish versus all of the other days of the year? I think I wake up bullish every day, to be honest, because what the price is doing. I just wake up, and I do my usual check, Twitter, routine, and I'm just like, you know what? I love this industry so much. I'm so bullish. So you still have faith in this industry? You haven't given up on crypto. No, no. No. Look, crypto to me is a broad term, right?
I obviously focus mostly on Ethereum, but no. I mean, everything that I'm seeing in the Ethereum ecosystem just every day, it's just crazy. I honestly can't keep up with it anymore. It's just this too much. Well, guys, if you want that bullish energy injected straight into your veins, this is the place to get it. This is the weekly roll-up where we cover everything going on that you need to know about crypto a few topics of the week. Number one, let's talk about this new marketplace for doxing. Crypto addresses is everyone in crypto about to get doxed some controversy surrounding a new bounty program that rewards people for doxing crypto addresses.
We're going to get it into that. Also, the Google Play Store, they just did an aboutface on their policy in a good way. Now NFTs are unbanned. They are allowed to discuss that as well. Awe is about to launch its new stablecoin as well. It's called Go, and is this the stablecoin we've been waiting for? Or is there another Anthony? I want to pick your brain on that. As always, you've got to make sure you like, subscribe, rate, and review. If you're on YouTube, subscribe. If you are listening to this on a podcast player somewhere, give us a rate and review, and let's propel this thing to the top of the chart.
So much to cover in markets this week, Anthony. But before we do, a quick shout out, we are going to the permissionless conference. That is the bankless nation, David and myself. That is coming up on September 11th through the 13th. So we're almost all the way through, somewhere in the US, and it's time to book your ticket guys. I think the bear market is the best time to go to a conference. This is an opportunity to network, to meet all of the settlers who stayed during crypto winters, and to find your bear market buddy, as David and I like to say, a fire lineup. There's 120 speakers. We're expecting 6,000 attendees, 1,500 different crypto projects, and it's all in Austin.
If you're a bankless citizen, you get a 30% discount. There's a link in the show notes to go do that. All right, Anthony, let's get to the markets, thanks to Crackin'Pro for showing us these charts today. Bitcoin price. We're about flat since the last time you and I talked about this, about 30K on the week. Any takes on Bitcoin this week? I think, I mean, similar takes to last week, where I basically said that I thought that the market was trading just purely based on narrative, that ETF narrative, and I didn't expect any wild moves from here because of that, because it doesn't seem to be any new money coming in.
And I think that's basically been playing out over the past week, but it's only been a week, right? Next week, we could go up 10% for, that's the volatility in crypto, so yeah, I think just more of the same really over the last week. Well, eth is more of the same as well, kind of down a little bit, but pretty much flat. I'm just going to call it flat, 1880, at the time we're recording this, which means, of course, that the Bitcoin ratio is flat. The good news here is crypto market cap is over a trillion dollars. I don't know about you, Anthony, but that's kind of a meme number for me. Are we above a trillion or below a trillion?
Of course, there are a lot of tokens in this market cap that maybe should be worth a lot less, but it feels good to be above a trillion. We are at 1.3 trillion on the week. Well, if there's nothing going on in the short run, or at least not much, we're waiting for the next price action, I want to zoom out a little bit, and I want to talk to you about three things in this market section. One is bonds, the second is staking in ultrasound money, and the third is real-world assets. Let's start by talking a little bit about the bond market, and I want to do almost like a tail of two bond markets here, because we've got the fiat bond market, and then we have the crypto bond market and the Ethereum bond market.
I think there's an analogy that fits, that spans across both of them, that I want to you implant in listener's head and get your thoughts on here. First of all, when people say bonds, a lot of times it just sounds like this obscure financial instrument, but what is a bond actually? A bond is just a form of debt. When you buy a U.S. bond, that would be a treasury, something to that effect, you're essentially lending money to the U.S. government. In the same way, when you buy a liquid staking token, we call these LSDs, or when you stake your ETH, you are lending Ethereum, the Ethereum protocol, some money.
That's why we call staking ETH, or staked ETH, a bond, essentially, it's an Ethereum bond. I don't know if you've seen this infographic Anthony at any point in time, but this is what the global bond market looks like. I'm going to describe some of this for listeners who are listening on the podcast. This is all of the sovereign bonds. It's about a $60 trillion market. These are all of the bonds that nation states issue. Call these nation state bonds, if you will. And 60 trillion worth of that, 51 trillion is the U.S. actually. These numbers are a little bit larger. Maybe this is 70 to 80 trillion.
20 trillion or so is China. You can see all of the other nation states encompassing this pie. That's the size of the sovereign bond market. I want to contrast the nation state bond market, which is about 60 to 70 trillion dollars or so to the network state bond market, which is only about 70 billion right now. Of course, Ether, the asset, the bond, composes the vast majority of that, about 40 billion or so. We've got Salana, we've got Cardano, we've got some other chains here, of course. So we've got a tale of two bond markets. And I was reading this report from Pantera earlier this week, Anthony, about the U.
S. bond market. And Pantera's perspective, obviously they've been in crypto for a very long time, but their perspective is that the U.S. is totally screwing up its bond market, like turning it into a complete Ponzi scheme. And one way you can see that is this metric called the real Fed Funds Rate, okay? So the real Fed Funds Rate. So what you can see on this chart is the Fed Funds Rate is basically the interest rate set by the Fed. That's sort of in yellow, that's this yellow line here. And then you see CPI. So core CPI, that is consumer price index, that is the measure of a measure of inflation, is this dotted line.
Everywhere where you see kind of red, the shading pattern of red, that's where the Fed Funds Rate is below the core CPI rate. It's basically like you're buying a U.S. bond, a sovereign bond in order to get a yield, say, yield of like 5%. But CPI, but inflation is like 8%. In which case, how much are you making in real returns, in real Fed Funds Rate? Well, negative 3%. So you're kind of losing money on that. And it's very interesting, you see, like post 2008, the great financial crisis here, it's been red, basically ever since. And up into, it hit at a high point, I believe, lowest point of the year, negative 6.
3%. That's the lowest in the last 50 years that the real return on bonds have been, essentially is Fed Funds Rate, which is pretty crazy. So you can start to see the case that this sovereign bond market is not actually producing a real rate of return. I want to pause here, because next we're going to contrast that with what's going on in crypto, and maybe we'll take a peek at the Ethereum bond market in some detail. But what's your take on this, Anthony, who in the world is buying bonds right now? So I mean, I got to preface this and say, obviously, I'm not an expert on this kind of stuff, definitely more of an observer.
But it seems to me that the COVID, I guess, response in COVID generally has distorted a lot of this, because you can see it in the chart, right? It seems to have distorted a lot of this. And also post 2008, as you were pointing out how it was, rates were so low for so long. But then you can see that they were kind of trickling back up and then COVID happened and then back down again, right? And it's kind of funny how similar a lot of these charts look with COVID, like there was the COVID dump, I guess, initially in stocks, right? And crypto, and then we went up after that, because the rates were basically at rock bottom again.
And then the rates started going up and everyone got scared, and I guess, like, risk on assets kind of went down. But yeah, just generally, when you're talking about like buying bonds and getting that real return, I think that if you weren't in a bond and just in cash, obviously, and that's not cash in like an interest bearing account or something like that, you're losing even more. Exactly. Yeah. So it's kind of like, yes, you might be losing like whatever it was, 0.3%, but you're much better off still doing that than just leaving cash lying around. But at the same time, you know, it's all about the appetite of investors, right?
Like buying a sovereign bond, especially the US bond is like the least riskiest thing you can do because you have the full weight of the US government behind that, right? Like you literally, it's that you're buying into the US government essentially. So it's considered the least riskiest thing you can buy. But at the same time, like, is it really like worth not taking on a little bit of extra risk to just get much more return, potentially, with your dollars, right? With some risk assets such as a BTC or an ETH, right? Or even a gold, which has done comparatively well. So yeah, it certainly begs the question is like, who is buying the bonds, right, over these other things?
Well, what's interesting is part of the answer to that question is in a big way, banks. So central banks are buying their own bonds. That's why Panthers calling this kind of like a Ponzi scheme. So central banks own about 50% of the sovereign bonds that are out there. That's what quantitative easing is. So many of these modern central bank policies actually do is they buy bonds on the open market. So that has kind of a distorting effect as well. But it's really interesting when you start to look at real returns, which is, okay, what's the yield of the underlying bond? But like you have to look at the yield minus inflation, right?
That gives you your real return. Now let's contrast that to Ethereum, which I think is kind of interesting here. So remember, Ethereum is very much like staked ethers like a bond. You are a lending ether to the protocol of Ethereum. Anthony, when you're saying the risk-free rate, it's kind of the lowest risk type of financial asset you can have is owning US bonds or US treasuries. Staked eth is the lowest, like the highest yield, it's almost like the risk-free rate of ether as an asset, right? You can't deposit your ether anywhere else and expect to receive a return of any size at lower risk.
So it almost represents the risk-free rate here, which is kind of cool. And the contrast here is, this to me looks a lot, I'd call it healthier, but because you don't have the money printer, the algorithm, doing open market operations and purchasing, staked eth, like LSD tokens in the open market, that's what central banks do. It's completely transparent, so you can see it kind of blocked by block. There aren't arbitrary decision makers who are adjusting the dials up or down. It just kind of follows the algorithm. And if you look at kind of, I guess maybe the comparison is the real rate of return.
And since the merge, the real rate of return has been what, like something between four and six, the actual rate of the nominal rate of return has been about between four and six percent. And then if you take the burn there, then you have to kind of like add that. So you're at like the burn since the merge has been point three percent. And so the real rate of return looks far more attractive on a staked eth versus sovereign bonds versus something like a US treasury. And I just think this contrast is so stark and so interesting. And does beg the question of like, if you are looking at any sort of time horizon, you have some extra capital.
You're looking at a time horizon that's longer than like a year, let's say. Why would you hold these sovereign instruments that are bleeding effectively, like your real rate of return is going down when you can own an asset like ether, where, I mean, it's a positive rate of return. Now people say, but that's eth denominated, right? It's not like, you know, real money, you know, but I don't know. I kind of go back to like look over the longer time horizon. One eth is one. What are your thoughts on this in this comparison and general Anthony? Mm hmm. Yeah. So I mean, there's generally a lot of things I could say about this.
Maybe the denomination thing is somewhere, somewhere good to start. So yeah, when people say, oh, but it's eth and it's not US dollar. So it's completely different. The way I think about stability generally is that as you said, one eth equals one eth, one US dollar equals one US dollar, you know, one AUD because one AUD. But the thing is is that like it's stable relative to itself. So if you start comparing a US dollar to your grocery bills, well, over the last two years, your US dollar hasn't been very stable compared to your grocery shop, right? Your grocery shop has gone up because there has been inflation and because of just prices generally going up because the supply chain constraints and all those sorts of stuff that have been because of COVID.
And the same is true for any asset. You can compare any asset to any other asset. And that's where we come to things like stores of value like where do you store your wealth in order to protect yourself in the in the most kind of like, I guess, risk free or riskless way so that you're not taking on a massive amount of risk like investing in a brand new company that has a 5% chance of succeeding or something like that. And traditionally, it has been obviously the strongest currency, USD, which is the world reserve currency, or it has been gold for a very long time. And then over, I guess, like the last, I want to say 10 years, but probably less than that in terms of BTC and 8 being considered stores of value, you can say five to 10 years, I guess.
It's been those assets, right? People say, well, you know, I can store the my wealth in these crypto assets. I mean, I do it. You do it. We store our wealth in ETH. And then we stake the ETH, of course, as well, to get that return. And you were mentioning how it's a real return. So when you stake your ETH, there are really, I guess, three parts to it. You get a new ETH issuance that gets paid out to you as a reward. You get the ETH that gets paid out as fees as a reward as well, anything that's not burned, of course. And you get MEV related payments to, if you're running the MEV boost software, which most people do, I think it's up to 95% of validators are kind of talking to that software.
So the later two parts, the unburnt fees in the MEV, that is not new issued ETH. That is existing ETH that already exists in the Ethereum economy that is paid by users to do whatever on the network. The only new ETH that is issued is on that consensus layer side rewards, which is the new ETH that is printed. But the thing is, is that we're burning more ETH than is issued, and we've been doing this for quite a while now, especially since the merge, which means that the net result, as you mentioned, is that since the merge, we are at negative 0.3% inflation rate or issuance rate for ETH, the net rate.
And on top of that, it is much harder to print new ETH than it is to burn it because you have to basically outrun the burn. So even if the burn is really low, even if gas fees are quite low, and the burn isn't actually at high amounts, it doesn't matter because you're still burning almost the same if not the same as what's being issued. So the issuance isn't actually increasing from that, it just basically stays flat. And that's what we've seen at periods of time, you can actually see this on the chart. For the last few weeks, we remained relatively flat with increasing slightly, but then we started burning more ETH again over the last, I think a couple of weeks or so.
You can see, yeah, over the last 30 days, you can actually see how it worked out here. And then we're just going straight back down because it's much easier to burn ETH than it is to issuance. Now of course, issuance changes as more ETHs state, there's more ETH issued, but still, I feel like the more ETHs get staked, the more activities happening on the network, because people are using that staked ETH for different things like restaking such. So the fees will probably level that out. And yeah, all that just culminates in such a nice real yield on your staked ETH and a very, very attractive asset as a store of value.
Totally. So you woke up bullish, Anthony, I woke up bullish on staked ETH. Like it's just incredible. You got to look at the real return here and the real return of an asset like ETH when it's staked, when it's bonded is just incredible. I want to ask you another question because people listening to this section might also get kind of bullish and they have some ETH and they're like, okay, guys, I still haven't pulled the trigger. I still haven't staked my ETH. Where should I stake it? How do you think about that question, Anthony? So there are a lot of different options in terms of staking ETH, including, by the way, all of these liquid staking tokens and options as well.
So bank was just put out a post about this and there's a slew of new ones. ETHs must swell, unsheath, origin, ether, diva, there's tons of them. I can't even keep up with all of the new ETHs staking protocols that are essentially innovating on the bond market by making some of these, some of the staked ETH liquid, and that's really interesting. But for the average listener thinking about how to stake, they could put their ether into an exchange, for example, centralized location and stake that way. They could use a staking protocol, one of these new ones, or some of the established ones like Rocket Pool or Lido or something like that, or they can solo stake.
What's your take on that? What advice do you generally give? Yeah, I mean, the thing is, there's a bunch of different questions that you should be asking yourself before putting your money into any of these things, or before putting your ether into any of these things. I think the number one question is, how old is the protocol? The security of the protocol and its contract should always be top of mind, because the newer protocol is going to be less secure than something that's older, that's been around for a while, that has been able to be battle tested, so that should be top of mind for everyone.
Particularly these new ones, you're just a little bit like, oh, they don't have a lindy, be careful. Exactly. I'd be more careful with them than say something like a Rocket Pool or a Lido that's been around for quite a while now, I would definitely be more careful with the newer ones. Not to say that they're insecure or that they're going to get hacked or anything, but you need to be aware of that risk, especially when using newer protocols. Of course, all the protocols can still have bugs in them, but it becomes less and less of a possibility or a probability as time goes on. On top of that, I would also say, depending on what kind of size you're staking for these LSTs, if you're planning on selling on secondary market when you want to exit this position, you should really be aware of what the liquidity is like for these LSTs.
Because some of them, especially the newer ones, aren't going to have that much liquidity to start off with. If you're putting in a substantial amount into these things, you may not be able to exit with the same amount you put in because you'll cause some kind of price slippage because you're just trying to sell too much at once or something like that. That's something to consider. Other things to consider, obviously, are you putting Ethan to something that he's decentralized or he's going to be decentralized or you're staking with the centralized service, are you staking with the dominant player?
A lot of people say, well, you shouldn't stay with Lido because they already have a very large market share. You should stay with one of these other players, and I definitely agree with that. At the same time, you do have to consider these other questions that I brought up, especially around security and liquidity and things like that. Also, the models of these things, as well, depending where you are in the world, there are two different ways that these tokens, these LSTs, can operate. They can either be rebasing, or they can pay you out extra tokens as rewards, or it can pay out, sorry, the token value increases with the rewards, and that could have tax implications for you.
You could owe tax on that, or you could owe tax on the rebasing, it just depends on where you are. That's another question to ask as well. There are a lot of considerations here, but generally, I would run through all of those things before staking with anything, really. Then when it comes to solar staking, there are really just considerations with solar staking of a different nature, because with solar staking, you're running the software. If you're buying an LST, you're not running the software. You're just buying the token. Someone else is running it. As a solar staker, you are running all the software, you are managing all the hardware.
There is a lot more that goes into it in that respect. Most of the same questions around the things I just brought up, but you also have to worry about uptime, you have to worry about making sure that you are upgrading when there's an upgrade. If you're a network upgrade, upgrading your clients, if there's a bug. What's work is this? I know you do this with solar staking, so per month, how much time you spend in babysitting it? Zero now. Honestly, once it's set up and going, you don't have any hardware issues where something breaks for some reason, generally it's zero. As I said, unless there's a network upgrade that you need to upgrade your software for or there's a bug or something, because you can set it up in a way where the instance that you're running, so I run Linux, you can set it up so that automatically updates itself and then automatically reboots to install those updates, so you literally can be completely hands off.
It really just depends as well, because if something could go wrong, like your internet going off or something, then you have to diagnose it right or some other thing or something becomes corrupted, but if everything's running fine, then yeah, the maintenance is generally pretty low, but yeah, people have different reasons for being actively maintaining it, and some people want to optimize it as much as possible in order to kind of like get like near that 100% uptime or something like that. So if you're not too worried about that and you're okay with 99%, then yeah, it's pretty much like hands off most of the time.
Do you know the thing that scares me or a lot of people I think about this is just like the idea of losing your private keys, like walking yourself out somewhere, right? Yeah, I was going to mention that. How much of a concern is that? So a lot of people listening, of course, to Bankless will have taken custody of their own keys and then wallet like Metamask or a ledger or something like that, right? And that you have to know a little bit what you're doing before you go do that, right? If I'm advising, same my parents or something, I'm just like, yeah, that keep the money on Coinbase. It's fine.
And until you learn how to do private key management, how much more technical do you need to be in order to safeguard your keys in a solo staking type setup? So the keys themselves, it's no more involved than just like doing a self custody kind of set up with a ledger hardware wallet or a good plus or something like that or even just securing a Metamask seed, right? It's basically the same approach where it becomes a little bit more complex is that you have these validator keys that are on the, I guess like machine that you have your validators on. Now, if that machine becomes compromised, so say someone hacks into it, they can't access your eat because they don't have your private key and they don't have your seed phrase, but what they can do and Vitalik is spoken about this, they can do like a thing where they slash you, they get you slashed, right?
They want to be malicious. They don't make any money from this, but if they want to be malicious and get you slashed, they could literally run your validator keys with their validator right on their software and then do something that gets you slashed. Now that I don't think is a huge concern, to be honest, I don't think it's something that every day person needs to be worried about, especially the incentives for someone to do that. It would just be because they hate you, like they're not, yeah, they're just burning yourself down. It's like arson. Yeah, pretty much. Yeah, so definitely the incentive is not there to do this at kind of like a scale unless you like really hate someone or you really want to target someone.
And the bigger players, I mean, you would think that they do generally, but you would think they have a better secure setup than just a smaller place because some people will have something that they've set up and haven't secured it properly. But yeah, I mean, for someone to go in there and get you purposely slashed, they'd have to hate you or something. And this is no benefit for them to do that other than that. Well, you're very cool. Anyway, lots of options for you to look into if you're looking at sticking your eith and some ramifications, but more options is always better here. I guess in contrast to what I was just talking about, about like no one buying bonds, here's a headline from CoinDesk, tokenized US Treasury surpassed 600 million as crypto investors captured, tradify yield.
So we are actually increasing in crypto, the tokenization of these treasuries and these sovereign bonds like US treasuries past 600 million dollars is the latest number. What are your thoughts on like tokenized treasuries and real world assets on change? Do you have a general perspective on this trend? Yeah, I mean, this is the bridge, right? This is the bridge from DeFi to to tradify. I think that we've had real world assets being incredibly successful on Ethereum in the form of stablecoins for for very many years now. I mean, people forget that stablecoins are real world assets USDT. The first at scale stablecoin that's that's absolutely massive has been around for a very long time and that is a real world asset has real world USD in a bank account that backs up the USDT same with USDC and now what we're doing is we're taking all these other assets and we're saying, Hey, we can bring these on chain as well.
And then everyone around the world can get exposure to these things. Yes, they're KYC and AML and things like that as well. But I mean, I don't think that's necessarily something to to worry about or necessarily a bad thing. I think that that is just the way the old world operates and what the way they will continue to operate for various different reasons. But yeah, I mean, I've talked about real world assets generally for quite a while now. And I said that they were going to be a main theme in this bear market, especially, but also in the bull market because at the end of the day, everyone in crypto likes to call stocks like boomer things.
But I mean, the young people still love stocks, like it's not like the only people buying stocks of boomers at the end of the day, a lot of young people, even if they're not buying stocks directly, they're buying it through their 401k or their retirement accounts, right? So at the end of the day, stocks that they're going to be popular, people are going to want exposure to it. Honestly, I would probably be more inclined to buy stocks if I could buy them using crypto rails than traditional rails. There'd be so much more convenient than using like my Schwab account or fidelity or whatever else.
It's just better infrastructure. Exactly. So yeah, just overall very bullish on real world assets. Well, I mean, to your point earlier, like, you know, I was disparaging, I guess, treasuries and sovereign bonds, but they are better instruments from a real return perspective than just holding the dollar relative to inflation. And so when we have treasuries that are yielding like four to five, you know, percent, and if you could tokenize them and hold them on chain, I'd rather hold up four, five percent yielding treasury than USDC. If that was tokenized, it'd be really cool if circle or someone was able to come out with a product around this where we just ERC 20, a size, a treasury or a money market of some type.
Of course, the difficulty here is regulatory headwinds that you face in trying to do anything with tokenized securities. But this was the interesting report I saw this week, which is the Bank of America is actually very bullish on real world assets, which is very interesting. And they say the expected value of tokenized asset markets could reach $16 trillion by 2030. Less than seven years, it's 10% of global GDP. I do think that real world assets are something like the Bank of America's of the world, like the banks can kind of understand. They both understand and probably can support it and appreciate it because it's the same financial instrumentation that they use.
It's just on a new set of rails on a new platform that's much more programmable. So I'll include a link to this report in the show notes. You can go check that out, see what the banks are saying about tokenized assets. The last thing I just want to touch with you in the markets section here, Anthony, is correlation here. We spent a long period of time, I think in 2021 and 2022, with Bitcoin and other crypto assets, the very correlated with the S&P 500. So we're just talking about stocks as boomer instruments. We were trading just like those boomer instruments in crypto. And this like punched a hole in the narrative that I think crypto folks, particularly the Bitcoin community has been preaching, which is Bitcoin is a non correlated asset.
It's kind of like gold. It's not correlated to your fed rates and what stock price does and all of these things. But for a very long period of time, we were pretty correlated with stocks. Now that correlation has actually dropped. So we're back from something like a high of 0.76 correlation to about 0.1 correlation. So is this nature healing, do you have any takes on this? I've maintained for a while that even though these correlations are like this, that crypto likes to do its own thing, right? Crypto seems to follow its own cycles where it doesn't necessarily follow stocks up or down. I mean, stocks have been going wild for a little while now and crypto seems relatively flat compared to them.
Even though I think atheists up almost 2x since the start of the year or something like that, right? And BTC as well. But generally everyone's looking at stocks right now being like, oh my god, every day, stocks are going higher. The S&P 500 is going to hit a new all time high soon, all these sorts of stuff, a lot of these other tech stocks that got just obliterated last year are coming roaring back. And I look at that. OK, that's true. But at the same time, I don't think that there is that much correlation between stocks and crypto. And I think that the recent correlation was in anomaly.
You can see the rest of the time period here where correlations weren't that high. And I think if you look back at what happened last cycle, the S&P 500 was going up and hitting new all time highs for I think a total of maybe at least 12 months before crypto started really moving. So it seems that the stock market was going to go up before crypto anyway. It's kind of a leading indicator, I guess, for a number of different reasons. I think the two main reasons are that crypto is more risk on generally than stocks. Even if you consider Bitcoin and Ether to be low risk assets, the majority of the world does not think that, right?
I still think that BTC and Ether highly speculative and very volatile, which they are, but to be fair, there's been a lot of tech stocks that were more volatile than Ether and BTC in this last cycle, which is funny. And I think the second reason is that generally what you kind of see in crypto market cycles is like this four years cycle, right? That seems to follow the Bitcoin harvaining. And I think that we're still respecting that. I think that maybe this might be the last time we respect that because there's going to be a lot more trad-fi involvement in crypto than there has previously been, as we talked about last week with the BlackRock stuff and things like that.
So yeah, that's the second reason for your cycle. That four-year cycle points to next year being a really positive year because the harvaining is next year. And it's right on smack bang for years since the last bull market. So it will start the last bull market. So yeah, it seems to be following that still for better or worse. I think the start, too, when you look at the long-term is the case that you made last week for kind of ignoring macro in crypto and that like, yeah, aside from, I guess, events in 2021 and 2022, crypto as an asset class hasn't been correlated to the S&P. It has not been very correlated to macro.
And so if that's the case, the start is showing what we think it's showing, then why not just ignore all of it, which maybe that could help listeners filter out some noise in their minds when they think about how to invest. We got a lot more to talk about, though, Anthony, including crypto doxing. What happens when we have a new marketplace for buying and selling information about any blockchain while it address anonymously by a smart contract? Also, there's a new developer report out and some developers are leaving. I want to talk to you about that and see if you think that that is material.
And lastly, the Google Play Store just had an epic unbanding of NFTs. And maybe there are some people to thank for that. We'll talk about that, too. But before we do, we're going to get to the sponsors that made this possible, including our number one recommended exchange, Kraken, go check them out. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade. On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning fast trade execution, all inside their spiffy new modular interface.
Kraken's new customizable modular layout lets you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs. Visit pro.kraken.com to get started today. Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem, all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network. A brand new, high-performance Ethereum layer 2 built using the OP stack, but uses eigenlayers' data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer 1.
Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboarded, like Game 7 for Web3 gaming and Buybit for TVL and liquidity in on-rounds. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle.
If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Okay, the question in my mind is everyone in crypto about to get doxed, Anthony. Let's talk about Arkham. This is a tweet thread that a project called Arkham released announcing the world's first on-chain intelligence exchange. You can buy and sell information on the owner of any blockchain wallet address, anonymously, via Smart Contract. You can see by the screenshot in the image of their interface, they have created an exchange of these bounties.
So if you want to identify a particular hedge fund or if you want to identify the owner of a particular ether address, there are bounties for all of these data sets. And I guess a community of Slooters can go through and de-anonymize, identify who the owners of these addresses are. There's lots of tools to do this, of course. I think the government has their pulse on a lot of these tools and probably actively uses them in various prosecution types of cases. But what's your take on what Arkham has released? And by the way, they've been active for a while, so this isn't necessarily a new project.
I think it's getting a bit more play because they're doing something with a token. But this whole idea of a marketplace, a bounty system, to de-anonymize crypto addresses. Is everyone about to get doxed and what does that mean? Yes, I mean, I think generally people should understand that Ethereum and Bitcoin, I guess as the two largest change and most change out there are not anonymous. They're pseudonymous, right? Because everything is already public on the ledger. If you look at it from that lens, what Arkham is doing here is they're basically just monetizing that fact, right? They're monetizing the fact that all that information is out there, all that information is ready to be consumed and sorted and organized.
But we just need to provide an incentive for people to do that. And you mentioned that governments have already been doing this. They do, channel analysis is not quiet or not, I guess, like secretive about the fact that they work with governments on this. And channel analysis has been doing work for a very long time now. I would wager that they have probably every single address on the chain doxed at this point. They probably know everything about Ethereum and Bitcoin at this point, just because they've been doing it for so long and they do have big government clients for things like anti-money laundering and they have big exchange clients too, I believe.
So they have a database you're contending with all of the transfer addresses out there and then like identifiable names. Maybe not all of them, but say like 98%. I mean, I would assume like that channel analysis is already de-anonymized or kind of like tagged everything just because that is their job to do that, right? Their job is to categorize and sort everything out for run reason or another. Maybe they haven't got like names attached to these things like people's names, but they have sorted it, organized it and you could quickly just search it up. Like if you search in the dress on it, it'll probably be tagged with certain things and categorized in a certain way to make it easier to filter through.
And just because that's their main kind of like business, right? That's what they do and they have government clients, they have other clients out there that that requests this information. But at the end of the day, like I can't be mad at chain analysis. I can't be mad at Arkham because it's really a failure on our kind of half to allow this to happen, right? Okay. And on private blockchains to proliferate and people have been going on about privacy for a long time now saying, you know, we need privacy by default because a privacy by default means that everyone is protected and there is no need to worry about these sorts of things.
But because we don't have that, now you have Arkham coming along and saying, well, there's a business case here, right? There is a business case that we can stop a token on it and we can monetize this and we can do like bounties on things. And obviously, it's highly moral, it's not something that I consider to be a good thing. It's not something that I consider to be morally right, but at the end of the day, you know, we're building open, permissionless systems. Morals don't factor in at that point because the permissionless system and open system will let you do whatever you want because and it's decentralized too, right?
So it'll let you do whatever you want. And I think people grapple with that sometimes because their morals don't match their technology and I think people have to understand that that's what we've created. And if you want it to improve, build better privacy tools that protect people. I know that obviously there was tornado cash and then they got sanctioned, right? So we did build a better tool and the US government came along and said, no, you can't use that anymore because of North Korea, really. And that just makes it worse because it's like, okay, well, every day people want to protect themselves, but now they can't because the US government has said that we're not going to allow you to use this tool anymore.
So that's why I'm saying it needs to be by default. It doesn't have, it can't just be an app. It has to be the entire chain is always private. No one can see what you're doing. And I think maybe Ethereum gets there eventually, but it's more likely an L2 will do it before the Ethereum L1 will do it. And at the same time, it's not like we're going to be able to make everything that has already happened private. It would just start from that period of time onwards. So yeah, there are a bunch of different kind of things that I think people have struggled to grapple with that they probably assumed that no one would build something like this or that they were okay.
But at the end of the day, everything you do on chain is completely visible to literally everyone in the world. And if you didn't know that, now you know, and this power is no longer in the hands of just big governments, it could be in the hands of just about everybody. Scott Lewis takes the counter this, Archim intelligence is techno-fascism. Of course, it's backed by Sam Altman, founded company, the guys building a dark and terrible future for humanity. We all get to choose whether we resist or submit. So calling kind of what Archim is doing basically evil. I think your point is a bit broader than that in that, well, if Archim didn't do it, you're like more morality aside or ethics aside for Archim specifically, somebody else would have.
And so it's incumbent on us as a community to actually solve this. I'm wondering if you see any, I guess, upside to Archim coming to, it's like, does it make us now think seriously about privacy and tell you if people are getting doxed all of the time? I guess one negative effect is they might use crypto less. If the average person listening to this knew that all of their on chain activity was fully transparent and could be revealed at any moment by some tool like Archim publicly, not just to governments of the world, but just publicly, they might stop using our on chain systems, right? I guess on the flip side of that though, is that starts to create market value and actually solving the privacy problem.
Maybe we start to get serious about privacy by default. Do you think this works out in our favor of the long run? Yeah, so I mean, I'll say first that I do agree with Scott here. I mean, I'm not in any way trying to defend Archim and what they're doing. I do believe that it is definitely immoral and something that I don't want to see exist. But at the same time, like before Archim, I mean, you can literally dox most people with just either scan because most people are not doing sophisticated hiding of their addresses and their funds. They're doing probably the bare minimum and the bare minimum is maybe sending coins to an exchange, like washing it through an exchange to a new address.
Do you know how easy that is to track still? Like it's not difficult to track that, but that's what people are doing as the bare minimum. So generally, like, it's already kind of like happening. It's already been happening and people can follow it to scan and dox these things. I mean, Scott, Scott, Zach XBT does this a lot, right? He uses it to scan in similar tools to follow the funds of scammers and grifters with pretty great success. Well, it's not good. Like, so what if we have privacy by default though, Anthony, we lose that, don't we? What we do, but we gain a lot more, I believe, I believe we gain, obviously, privacy is generally, but we gain the fact that people already have, I guess, privacy from just everyone in the world or every day people in the traditional finance system, really, most of the time.
Like, the people that see your transactions are, I guess, like the financial system itself and the people running the infrastructure, but it's not like everyone can see. Like, it's not like everyone can see what I'm doing on my bank account, for example, there is a kind of wall between those two things, whereas with crypto, there's no wall. There is literally everyone can see what you're doing, doesn't matter if it's a government, doesn't matter if it's, you know, your neighbor, and that is definitely a problem. And to your point, I think that this problem coming to the surface a lot more will spur on more of this activity, but there already has been a lot of this activity and there already is a very promising layer to called Aztec network being built out that is going to be private by default.
And they're building what they're calling an encrypted blockchain, where basically everything on there is encrypted in private. So it's already happening, but yeah, I can see that over the long term, this could definitely spur a lot more research and a lot more development into this space just by virtue of people being aware of it. Because I don't, as I said, I don't think a lot of people are aware of the fact that anyone we'd eat the scan can with pretty great, I guess, like odds, docs, all of your addresses if they wanted to. Yeah. One thing that I'll add to this is I don't see Ethereum mainnet adding privacy by default any time soon on the layer one, right?
We'll probably have smart contracts that do sort of mixing type things, tornado cache, style, while have layer twos that add privacy by default as a feature, but layer one will not be, like, mainnet will not be privacy by default. I haven't seen any pursuits in that direction. All right, let's talk about another report that came out this week, which is a developer report from electric capital, Anthony, it's looking like some of the devs are leaving actually. So we are down 22% in dev activity and contribution from about a year ago. Should we be alarmed by this? I mean, it depends where they down from, right?
It depends what ecosystem, I guess, they're down from because if you're measuring from June of last year, then you're measuring basically the depths of the bear market, the second half of last year, right? Where everything was was blowing up, so many things are blowing up and then you had FTX blip and all of these narratives that were formed in the bull market, especially around these kind of like layer ones, right? That they went crazy during the bull market. We came off of that. So are these developers basically leaving from those ecosystems because they're only got involved because there was money flowing.
There was developer incentives, things like that. I think that's more likely the reason because it actually isn't that hard of a fall. Only losing 22% when we basically went to a brutal bear market, but we're much higher than we were from the last bear market where you can see here on the chart. And as I said, I feel like most of the developers probably left from the ecosystems that have just stunted in growth, right? That have just stopped growing altogether. Whereas Ethereum and the layer 2s kept growing, right? So I wouldn't imagine that a lot of those were from there, but just like users, there are tourist developers, right?
There are people who only come during the good times. And then they're like, oh, well, I'm pivoting to AI now, right? So I think there's a lot of that going on too. I agree with that, Tick. My Tick is it's healthy. And if you look at this chart, which is actually 2015 up until now and number of monthly developers, if you were to view this chart in log rather than linear, I'm sure this looks similar to 2019 and 2020, 22% dropoff is probably about what we needed at this point in time. This was pretty big this week. Google Play changing their policy and allowing NFTs in apps and games. The reason I love this, Anthony, is because I also think it puts pressure on Apple to do the same.
And so we have, of course, these app stores, Apple and Android and Google, they could be gatekeepers to what sort of wallets that are issued inside of the mobile ecosystem or what sort of NFT games we have. And this is Android saying, hey, we're opening up. We are going to enable NFTs in apps and games. We're not going to charge an additional fee. And I think this puts pressure on Apple to do the same. Any other takes on this? Yeah, I agree with you on that. But I think I'm well aware of the fact that people know about these duopoly right between Google and Apple when it comes to app stores and how they can exert some pretty big control over things.
And people want to break that as well. They want to basically create a new ecosystem that is outside of Apple and Google. But I think what people miss is that not only is creating a new ecosystem for mobile, incredibly difficult. And there have been multiple big companies like Microsoft that have failed to do this. You not only need to do the software on you also kind of need to do the hardware and doing the hardware is even harder than doing the software side of things. So when you take all that into consideration, it's much better for us to focus out effort on basically not forcing but encouraging forcefully Google and Apple to allow these things to exist, right?
To allow these things to exist on their respective app stores because bootstrapping a whole new ecosystem is a pretty, I would say, impossible task. I don't think it's something that should be pursued. And I know that Salana had an initiative recently with Salana for doing this. I said it then and I'll say it now. I don't think that's really going to go anywhere. I don't think anyone's going to buy a Salana phone over an iPhone just so that they can use a new ecosystem and kind of like get access to apps that wouldn't be able to get access to on the Google Play Store app store. The vast majority of people, 99.
99% of people do not care about that. So let's not service the micro niche kind of thing of crypto. Let's service the rest of the world. And as I said, I think our energy is better spent making sure that we can get these apps approved and enabled on these these existing app stores. Anthony not bullish on the Salana phone, but that didn't stop Anatoli from taking. I just want to take a hundred percent credit for shifting multi trillion dollar titans of industry. So making the case that because crypto provided another option, that's a very bold change. Yeah. There's very little adoption right now of Salana mobile, but anyway, you know, cheering them on.
This is a good, this is definitely a good step forward for crypto and something we need having the Apple or the Google store open up. So let's see the same from Apple Anthony, we got a lot to talk about coming up next including Ove's new stablecoin about to hit the market. Is this the one we've been waiting for brand new ZK EVM hits the market as part of layer two summers, a lot going on layer two world. I want to talk to you about also Brazil with a central bank digital currency on Ethereum. I saw something about this. I want to dig into it some more and the UK, they are turning crypto friendly.
What does that mean for us? Guys, we'll be back with all of that. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web 3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1 producing flourishing, DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With a recent addition of Arbitram Nova, gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitram home. Both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar and fully EVM compatible.
On Arbitram, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees. With Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit Arbitram.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets and start building your first app. With Arbitram, experience Web 3 development, the way it was meant to be, secure, fast, cheap and friction free. You know Uniswap, it's the world's largest decentralized exchange with over $1.4 trillion in trading volume. You know this because we talk about it endlessly on Bayquus.
It's Uniswap, but Uniswap is becoming so much more. Uniswap Labs just released the Uniswap Mobile Wallet for iOS, the newest easiest way to trade tokens. On the go, with a Uniswap Wallet, you can easily create or import a new wallet by crypto on any available exchange with your debit card, with extremely low fiat onramp fees, and you can seamlessly swap on mainnet, polygon, Arbitram and optimism. On the Uniswap Mobile Wallet, you can store and display your beautiful NFTs, and you can also explore Web 3 with the in-app search features, market leaderboards, and price drives, or use Wallet Connect to connect to any Web 3 application.
So you can now go directly to DeFi with the Uniswap Mobile Wallet, safe, simple custody from the most trusted team in DeFi. Download the Uniswap Wallet today on iOS, there's a link in the show notes. Layer 2 Summer is here, three things to know. I think the first is this, Consensus is launching a Layer 2 on mainnet. This is an alpha release right now, it's a ZK EVM. It's called Linea, Anthony, what do you know about this? What Consensus is building? Is this just another Layer 2 joining the ranks, and welcome, great to have you, or is there anything special about this particular Layer 2? It's relatively new, so I haven't dug into it too much myself, and I haven't seen much about it recently.
But yeah, I mean, it's another ZK EVM joining the ranks, obviously, as you said, from Consensus. Consensus has been around for quite a while now. The developers of products such as Metamask and Fuhrer that everyone uses pretty much. So yeah, they have a track record of launching products and maintaining them for long periods of time. So I'm curious to see where they go with this, because I think that the generalized L2 market is becoming very saturated very quickly at this point. It seems like we have more block space than apps at this point, a good problem to have, I guess. Yeah, definitely.
But it does begin to feel like what we saw with the L1s, right, where there were so many of these L1s launching, they all looked pretty much the same. They had their own claim to fame. But at the end of the day, people just wanted more block space, right? They wanted those cheaper fees and not wanted to pay Ethereum, main net fees. But I'm still excited for it. I'm still excited to see these things blossom and basically play it out in the market. Battle it out, see which ones people actually want to use and which ones can survive and thrive and which ones just go by the wayside. Yeah, that's just it.
I love the competition. I think it's going to level us all up. And here's another competitor that's entered the fray from Mantle Network. This is a layer to developed by BitDow. Their thing is they're going to use eigenlayer as the data availability layer. So fees will be super cheap. Maybe this allows them to optimize on user experience, really fast smart contract wallets, low cost. The news this week was they are launching a eco fund. Mantle, BitDow is from Mantle of $200 million investing in the Mantle ecosystem. And what I think is interesting about this is this comes from BitDow. If you've followed BitDow, Anthony, but they maintain one of the largest treasuries, on-chain community treasuries of any Dow, including $500 million worth of eth, $2 billion total treasury.
A lot of those are Mantle tokens, but $500 million in eth. That's quite the warchest to be investing into this layer too. So another competitor throws a tat in the ring. And I think it's kind of cool. Lastly, getcoin is releasing a public goods layer to as well, a public goods layer to. What's going to be different about this one? Yeah. So these are the kind of things I guess I get a bit more excited about because they're specializing, right? They're not just trying to be another generalized L2. They're actually specializing. And in getcoins case, they're specializing on public goods. This has been their bread and butter since day one, right?
They've been doing this for quite a while now. And the way I'm kind of envisioning this is that you want to have an ecosystem that develops around public goods, but you don't want it to be necessarily fragmented, right? You want to be able to have it in kind of a guess for lack of a better term centralized place where people can kind of interact with all these different public goods applications. They can do payments on this chain. They can have like some light defy. You'll have a unisop on there, being people will obviously want to swap tokens when they're doing these sorts of things. But having it all in the one place and having these protocols be able to integrate with each other and cooperate with each other in a really close knit way and being aligned to grow the public goods network together, I think is just speaking to getcoins called values and what they've been trying to do for a long time.
And also something that I am incredibly bullish on because it differentiates itself from the competition right from the pack. And as I said, I don't necessarily think it's trying to compete with the other L2s either. It's more of a compliment. It's like, hey, you want to do some public goods stuff instead of having to go to all these other different ecosystems, you can just go to public goods network and here you go. You can find your home on there. You can find cool things to do, really cool things to fund and to ask to join and things like that. And I really do think that probably the biggest thing that's going to come out of this is that there's going to be a network of people that join the public goods network and basically become the governors of many different protocols out there.
And they call the public goods network their home, but they're governing apps on arbitrary and optimism and polygons, all these other chains. And they come home to public goods network, that's their hub where they coordinate and do all these stuff. So yeah, I'm pretty excited about it. Do you worry at all about fragmentation, all of these different L2s, like we kind of get too fragmented, can't keep up. There's no one single source for kind of state and we just become diffuse. I think I worry about fragmentation, not on the technical or kind of economical side, but more on the social side of things where humans will generally stick to something longer than they should a lot of the time, especially if it's something that they've found it or if they're very close to, we all have this experience that we hold the crypto token down way too long because we can't cut out losses, so to speak.
So I think that from a technical point of view, interoperability is pretty much solved with these bridges that we have now and same with the economic side of things where you can just bridge assets between change relatively easily. But on the social side of things, what's going to happen is that you're going to have these L2s that exist for quite a while because they're going to have a massive war chest from issuing tokens, things like that. And they'll be like these L1s, they're basically zombies, but the social capital is still there. The people are still getting paid. They don't want to cut their losses on it because they're like, this is a cushy job, right?
It's like dying corporations. It's the same thing. They're around, there's money coming in and then they just stick around for way too long. So I worry about that, but at the same time, I think over the longer term, it fixes itself anyway. As we've seen with the L1s, over the longer term, everyone just comes home to roost on Ethereum. You know, they, they, they, they abandon these other L1s, they come home to Ethereum and Ethereum grows. Ethereum becomes a better ecosystem because of it. So I think with the L2s, it's going to be the same thing. There's going to be a bunch of them that don't work out.
They just exist as zombies. And then the people from there eventually will come to the, to the other L2s, there are six seeding and kind of like, you know, migrate. It's like, it's like the, the countries around the world, you migrate from a country that you believe doesn't have an economic future for yourself to one that does. It, I think it's a similar kind of thing, but you usually wait too long to do that a lot of the time. And this is like an immediate threat. Obviously, war in the real life is an immediate threat and you move. But if it's, if it's a slow burn, you tend to wait longer because it's a, you, you're, you're kind of like stuck in that ecosystem for one reason or another.
So I think that's what I worry about the most, but not the technical, economical stuff. That's much easier to solve than social stuff. Yeah. That's a great point. And to your point, you and I were just laughing before the show began on the crack in charts, the top gaining tokens this week or things like, um, kin, uh, you know, P O W R, right? These tokens that are still around and you, you wonder, um, like, it seems like tokens in crypto can never die and it's probably for the reason you, you just said they'll just be around forever. They might not grow and they might have this one weird breakout day where suddenly they're up 30%, um, but they just don't fully collapse to zero.
Do that. No, no. And I, it's kind of funny because you can always find at least one, there's always one, I don't know why person who's still holding a bag of an old, true believer. I, I remember in the bull market towards the end, someone was shilling feather coin in my Twitter. It replies, feather coin is from like 2013 or 20, like serious believer coin. Yeah. Yeah. Someone's serious being like all the teams coming back, they're going to reinvent the thing. I'm like, wow. What is going on? Yeah. I, you know, you can't, um, can't destroy the faith of, uh, human beings, I guess, sometimes. Okay.
So we've got the, uh, a new stable coin from Awe. It's called Go. This has been talked about for a while. This is a proposal on the governance of form of Awe to actually launch this thing. There was an algorithmic stable coin, so you can admit exactly a dollar worth of tokens when there's a dollar worth of, um, you know, cryptocurrency and cemented against a diversified set of assets that are in Awe. To me, this is very similar to die, I don't know what your take is on it, but, um, high level question. Is it go time? I mean, is this the decentralized stable coin we've been waiting for? Where do your thoughts on this?
I have, uh, a lot of thoughts on decentralized stable coins generally. And I guess the TLDR of my thoughts is that I don't think we're, um, we're going to have one that actually works at scale, um, because when you think about it, and I was talking about stability earlier in, in the episode, right, where I was basically saying, your measuring stability against something else. If you have a, a decentralized stable coin that is pegged to fear, I mean, it, it, in my mind, it's not decentralized really because you're pegging it to a centralized asset, right? Even if it's only backed by a, that even if it's got no governance attached to it, and it's like completely just existing on Ethereum, uh, as in a decentralized state, it's still pegged to the US dollar.
So when, if that's the case, and if you're collateralizing it to, to mint it, you're limited as well in terms of scale by the collateral. So you're limited. If, even if you're just using a, you're limited by each market cap, and that's the upper limit. The real limit is much lower than that because obviously not all of the eat is going to go back in your, your stable coin, right? And if it's an LST, for example, but as soon as you do LSTs, it doesn't become decentralized anymore. Like if you're backing with ST8, that's not a decentralized asset anymore. ST8 decentralized with, with Lido. So if you're just using ethos example here, you're sealing for how much you can issue is very, very low.
It's, it's super low compared to the eight market. I would say you could get to 10 billion or something, 10 or 20 billion. So that's not, not way near enough to service the whole world, right? As a decentralized stable coin. Okay. So if we run along that path, well, then how do we make it bigger? Well, we make eats market cap bigger. Okay. How big this eats market cap have to be? Well, probably has to be $100 trillion plus dollars in order to issue enough of the estate point. In which case, if becomes the stable coin, exactly, exactly where I was going with it. In which case, it, it, it becomes the stable coin.
So in my mind, these things are good in like little kind of niche areas and maybe just for the crypto economy to play around with and use. But the end state of, of a decentralized stable coin really is just eat. ETH is going to be the decentralized stable coin if it succeeds, if it gets to a large enough market cap. Because as I said, it's, it's stable to itself. But then if it becomes stable relative to everything else in your life, your expenses, groceries, bills, whatever, then why wouldn't you use ETH as money? People use things as money when they're stable relative to what they're trying to purchase with it.
Just like people in hyperinflationary countries, they want to purchase USD because USD is way more stable than their currency, right? So it's going to come to a point where ETH is way more stable than their currency and probably in far into the future at this point. But you purchase that and then you just use ETH as your decentralized stable coin. So your take is, you like, you like go, it's cool, but yeah, to assume it'll have more success than something like die is, you know, probably overstating it. It's going to be sort of a niche stablecoin for crypto enthusiasts, not nearly as scalable as something like a USDC or a tether at this point.
And you're pessimistic on the overall ability for us to get a true decentralized stablecoin out there. Be it based stablecoin. Yeah. Yeah. Like something that's pegged to, to feed and I think that's what I think that's what history has shown so far. So we'll see if it go can be different, kind of cool to see some innovation here. But Eigenlayer has just reopened as well. So the LST restaking cap has been increased from 9,600 to 30,000 staked ETH. Anthony, you're going to restake any time soon or you're going to wait on this one. So I don't hold any LSTs because I am a solid staker and a rocker pool node operator.
So node operators in rocker pool don't get the R-ETH. They basically just obviously there's a kind of plumber can expand the whole rocker pool protocol. So the node operators don't get the R-ETH. The R-ETH is given to the people that are putting ETH in a deposit pool, which matches the rocker pool node operators. You guys just met the R-ETH as a node operator, right? Yes, essentially. Yeah. That's probably the correct terminology there. So for me, I don't have any LSTs because it's always taking rocker pool. I don't own ST-ETH or anything like that. You could always find some Anthony, just buy some to stay.
I could. I could. But right now, right now outside of farming and potential possible air drop, which is what I think a lot of people are doing right now, I don't see the point because there's nothing really alive yet for I-G-L-A, it's literally just deposit these funds here. And they're doing this as a bootstrapping mechanism. Obviously, you can't have things go live using R-ETH if there is no ETH that's being R-ETH, right? So that's what they're doing here. But they are going to have native R-ETH as well as they've listed here where you can change it withdrawal credentials from your solar validator to I-G-L-A, I'll probably do that when there's something that's actually live rather than this because I'm not interested in farming any potential air drop or anything like that.
And at least, as I've mentioned before, anything new is always risky. So I definitely take that very seriously, especially when it comes to my steak-ETH. I'm very protective of my steak-ETH, that's why I saw my steak. But yeah, I actually think this is a really cool way of bootstrapping, right? Just raising that TVL cap, doing a guarded launch and then eventually launching their products like the I-G-L-A-G-L-A, which you mentioned before, which I think is one of their first products. And then harnessing what's already been steak-T-L or restates and using that to secure these things. Yeah, I agree.
So if you want to be on the frontier, of course, you can put some ETH in there, but definitely don't feel like you should be pressured into that. There are risks associated with it. I don't know if you've been following this, but Vitalik did a Twitter Spaces, and here's a quote from a coin telegraph article, Vitalik Buterin says, ordinals have revived Bitcoin builder culture on Bitcoin. He said later, he praised ordinals and the BRC-20 token standard. He said, ordinals are starting to bring back a culture of actually doing things. Feels like there's some real pushback to the laser-eyed movement, which is good.
I think he was talking to Udi Ruthheimer and also Eric, who are, I think, well-known Bitcoin revolutionaries, let's say, in the kind of Bitcoin is almost having a cultural revolution type of moment where there's sort of this builder community that's starting, and then there's the laser-eyed maximalists who don't want to do any of that. Do you have any weigh-ins here? Do you think Bitcoin culture is getting any better? Do you pay any attention to this? I pay a bit of attention to it. I think it is definitely, I guess, the most interesting thing to happen in Bitcoin in a while, which says a lot considering that Ethereum was doing this in 2015.
So like doing tokens and NFTs, which is basically what ordinals are. I will say that I actually side with the laser-eyed Maxis in this case, and this is something I usually say. Yes. Oh, that's Bitcoin. I think Bitcoin doesn't need any of this. I don't think Bitcoin should be doing NFTs. I don't think Bitcoin should be doing tokens because it is literally just a budget store, a dollar store Ethereum. It's not doing anything better than Ethereum. So why Bitcoin, you're just going to hate you for that on both sides. I know. Yeah, I think so. Do you compromising on what makes Bitcoin special to do things that you can just do on Ethereum and even other chains that already have existed for quite a while?
People will say, oh, because Bitcoin is more secure, it's got a lot of capital there. We can harness that. And there's a different culture. I get that. But at the same time, in my mind, Bitcoin is no longer what it used to be. Bitcoin has changed now, fundamentally. So I think people are going to look at that and be like, okay, well, Bitcoin is not this unchanging thing that we can kind of store our value in and be certain that it's going to be very similar, if not the same, in 10 years as it is today. You're not going to know what Bitcoin's like in 10 years because this functionality was actually introduced on accident with the taproot upgrade.
No one, as far as I know, knew that this was possible using taproot. So if something can be introduced via accident like this, what's to say? It's not going to happen again. So for me, it basically adds a cloud of uncertainty to Bitcoin that didn't exist before. So that's why, and I think that's the argument that the laser-ride maximalist make. Even though I mean, I disagree with them on pretty much everything else, I think they're right in that Bitcoin should not be going down this path because at best, it becomes a dollar store version of Ethereum, right? You just see it as like, building on Bitcoin is just like, you know, TI-83 calculators, just like computer computers, just like shitty Ethereum.
So like why go down that path at all? But at the same time, like for the laser-ride maximalist, you can't really stop it, can you? No, you can't. All of the tweets and the kind of the vitriol and the, you know, jihad you wage internally, it's not going to stop builders from building on Bitcoin if this is a permission most protocol, and they have the ability to do it. Yeah, no, I definitely agree, and I don't fault anyone for building on there, and I do agree with the fact that it revived some kind of builder culture on Bitcoin. I don't think a lot to be honest. I think that there was a short term, kind of maybe three months or so of it going kind of crazy, because it's this new thing, everyone loves the new things, right?
And then it seems to us tape it off a bit. But at the same time, as I said, like it fundamentally changes what Bitcoin is in my mind. Bitcoin is no longer what it used to be. And I think that there are a lot of people in the Bitcoin community, not just the laser-ride people, but generally, Bitcoiners that don't like this, that feel like Bitcoin has changed too much. And if these changes continue, and if it keeps changing, I don't know what that's going to look like. You're going to be another civil war, is there going to be another split between the Bitcoiners, right? Like Bitcoin cash and Bitcoin in 2017?
I'm not sure. There's something happening. It's certainly, if nothing else, it's entertaining to see what's going on in a metallic way and is interesting. Just to conclude this story, we talked about it from last week. So the Wiggle Vosses were saying they would sue Barry if he didn't return all the hundreds of millions, the 640 million he owes. And indeed, they did sue Barry, it's Albert and DCG. Of course, the statement from DCG Group is that this is yet another publicity stunt from Cameron Winkle Voss to deflect blame and responsibility from himself and Gemini. We haven't done anything wrong, et cetera, et cetera.
Back and forth, back and forth, as you'd expect, Anthony. So that's where that is. So this was interesting this week. The former SEC chair, Jay Clayton thinks that we should get a spot Bitcoin ETF. His reason was this. He said, when the SEC approved a futures-based ETF, they said, let's look at the future market. They're surveillance. We see the protections in that market for the investor that are sufficient. We don't see them in the spot market, so we're going to make that distinction. He said, there should be no distinction. If you're going to approve a Bitcoin futures ETF, which has been approved, then the SEC should also approve a Bitcoin spot ETF.
I still think we're going to get a Bitcoin spot ETF this year. I mentioned that a couple of years ago, but I sort of confirmed this fantastic podcast with a kind of an ETF expert at Bloomberg. And he went through all of the various scenarios. He tracks all of the different ETFs for approval. There are like 77 different crypto ETFs in some state of either denial or approval. And he thinks that this year could be the year. And if not this year, into January, for a couple of reasons. One, there's this grayscale court case where a GBDC and grayscale are essentially suing the SEC saying, hey, we should be allowed to convert our trust into an ETF type structure.
This is, you know, there's no reason for you not to approve that. So that's going through the court system. Some legal analysts are saying a verdict could be delivered by September. Obviously, that would be a big game, game changer. And then of course, you've got BlackRock coming in here and Fidelity and some of the others continuing to apply pressure on Gary Gensler and the SEC. So I feel like he's got a bend. I feel like politically he's got to give something. And so that's why I think a Bitcoin ETF is going to happen this year. So I know we've talked about that a little bit. The last thing I want to get to though is London and the UK becoming a place maybe for American crypto refugees, the Prime Minister of London, Rishi Sunak.
He seems to really like crypto, Anthony. Do you have any takes on like jurisdictional arbitrage? And it always seems like some place around the world is either cooling or warming up to crypto. And right now, the UK seems to be warming up to crypto. Do you think we'll get some crypto projects over there, some favorable regulations and crypto natives may be moving in that direction? Yeah, I mean, I think so if the US continues down this path, right, of just being hostile to crypto, it will just naturally happen. I think that the UK generally from what I've seen is trying to reinvigorate their economy after leaving the EU, which seems to have turned out to be not that great of a decision.
So they seem to be trying to reinvigorate their economy. Grow their economy and it seems that I mean, Rishi seems a lot younger than the politicians we're used to, especially in the US, right? So he may be have a favorable outlook on crypto because he probably understands it better just from a fundamentals point of view. So I think he seems to be pushing it. The UK seems to be putting in those regulatory guard rails, that regulatory clarity that the US doesn't have that should logically attract a bunch of teams. As we're talking about before about switching costs, right? And how people can constate in one place for way longer than they need to and they don't cut their losses.
I think the same thing's going to happen. I think there's going to be a lot of US-based crypto teams that are just going to stay put because they'll be like, no, things will change, you know, just give it a couple of years. We'll get more regulatory clarity and we'll probably end up just seeing that existing people that live in London or the UK will probably just start crypto businesses there that maybe otherwise wouldn't of because they have more clarity now on that front. Yes. And hopefully this puts pressure on other jurisdictions and maybe the US in particular to become a bit more crypto friendly.
So that is definitely the bull case for that. This caught my eye as well. Anthony, I don't know if you've followed this at all, but a pilot project of Brazil's Essential Bank Digital Currency, apparently it was deployed to Ethereum, I believe. The tweet thread here says, of course, the Central Bank Digital Currency, Brazil's currency, it can be frozen at any time, you'd sort of expect that for any nation state deploying a Central Bank Digital Currency to have the ability to freeze various transactions or block various transactions. I'm not super surprised at that, but deploying this on a public network.
And again, this is probably just a prototype, it's just a pilot, it's just a test. Do you think that Ethereum will be the recipient of Central Bank Digital Currencies of ERC-20s? Is it a net gainer in a world where Central Banks all have their own digital currency? Or do you think most Central Banks will not deploy on a public blockchain, they'll kind of trade their own blockchain digital apparatus the way China is doing? Yeah, so I think with the Brazil one here, what they want to do is create a private fork of Ethereum, sort of like an intranet for their CBDC, right? So in that world where let's say all the Central Banks in the world do that, I could imagine Ethereum as that interoperability layer, right, as that internet to the intranets, so to speak.
So that's where I see Ethereum playing a big role where they'll probably use the ERC-20 token standard just because it's widely accepted. And then it'll be easy to interrupt right between these different kind of ledges, these private ledges and the public ledger. So that's where I see the meeting. At the same time, I'm not exactly very bullish on CBDCs for the reasons you outlined, obviously the massive centralized control that they exert, but at the same time, people will say that they're not bullish on these things and they don't want them to exist. But currently both USDC and USDT have the same freeze function in them.
But any time circle or tether can freeze assets in any address, right, they have the power to do that. And yet they combine market caps for over a hundred billion dollars worth and they're the biggest stablecoins, right, in crypto. So when looking at it through that lens, I really do wonder what the uptake on CBDCs is going to be like. Is the population just going to use them because they're way more convenient than the existing system? Are they going to become popular because of that the government's going to obviously and the banks themselves are obviously going to inject a lot of liquidity into it to get that liquidity network effect.
So I think that's inevitable that we get these things. I think it's inevitable that these things are pretty dystopian and that are probably not going to be great for society. But in terms of where Ethereum fits, yeah, they'll use the Ethereum technology because it's just there. It's open source for them to use. It's free for them to use. I wouldn't blame the Ethereum ecosystem or like anyone for working on Ethereum enabling this, which I've seen some people do, which I just find bizarre, but I've seen, I've seen especially the Bitcoin maximalist. They said that they, it's a botalex fault that the Brazilian central bank digital currency exists because he invented Ethereum.
Okay, let's take that big coin to the conclusion. Exactly. Exactly. So you know, it's a silly reasoning there, but yeah, I think they'll choose Ethereum technology because it's just the standard, right? And then I'll choose the ASC20 token standard as well for the same reasons. And then that it'll just all interoperate with the Ethereum public ledger, which is being my thesis for Ethereum for a long time, that it's going to be the settlement layer for all types of value. It doesn't matter if it's a CBDC or otherwise, it's going to exist as that layer. And that's where Ethereum, as a network, benefits.
Well, we've got more to talk about, Anthony, coming up, I want to pick your brain on what DeFi and protocols you are looking at. This is a question from the nation actually addressed to you. Also, the entire world it feels like thinks crypto is a scam. Is there anything we can do to change that, want to pick your brain on that as well? But before we do that, got to shout out the fantastic sponsors that made this episode possible including our friends over at Metamask who want you to go check out the Metamask dashboard. If you have a Metamask wallet, if you view all of your assets in their portfolio, it's portfolio.
metamask.io. Go check it out. Metamask has something new, introducing Metamask Portfolio. Metamask Portfolio is the best way to view your crypto portfolio from a holistic level. See everything across all the chains all at once. In your portfolio, Metamask will report the aggregate value of all the assets in your Metamask wallets. And even the other wallets you import too. But Metamask Portfolio isn't just a passive portfolio viewer, it is a place to do all of the money verbs that make DeFi so powerful. You can buy, swap, bridge, and stake your crypto assets. So not only is Metamask the easiest place to see your wallets in aggregate, but it's also a powerful battle station for all of your DeFi moves.
So go check out your Metamask Portfolio because it's waiting for you to open it up. Check it out at portfolio.metamask.io. Are you planning to launch a token? Is your token already live? And are you granting your employees and contractors investing token awards? And are you trying to figure out how to take care of taxable events for your team? Toku makes implementing a global token incentive award simple. With Toku, you will get unmatched legal and tax support to grant and administer your global team's tokens. Toku will help you navigate across the lifecycle of your token from easy to use pre-launched token grant award templates to managing post-cliff taxable events with payroll.
For legal finance and HR teams, it's a huge complex task to have to comply with labor laws, payroll, and tax obligations tax reporting and crypto regulations in every country that you employ someone. It's difficult, time-consuming, manual, and costly, and is drawing more attention from global regulators and governments. Toku makes it simple for leading companies in the space, Protocol Labs, Hedera, Gitcoin, and many more. If you want some help navigating the complex world of token compliance, go to totoku.com, slash bankless, or click the link in the description below. Here's a question from the nation this week.
Sassal mentions, that's you, of course, Anthony. Protocol mentions newer DeFi protocols that he's been looking into, which ones does he mean and what makes them new and innovative compared to the blue chip DeFi protocols? This is Jay Miles looking for some Anthony Sassano Alpha here. What DeFi protocols are you looking at, or maybe if that's too specific, what sort of trends are interesting at this point in time? Yeah. So generally, the trends, I would say, are things like Oracle-S protocols or protocols that just do not have Oracle's involved in them at all? Like a unisop style protocol, for example, unisop doesn't use Oracle's.
It works without them, which is pretty cool. So that's one thing I'm paying a lot of attention to. There is a company that I invested in recently that's launching, I think they're launching today, actually, called Agina Finance, which are doing an Oracle-S lending protocol. So essentially trying to disrupt the Aves and compounds of the world and trying to do that without Oracle's and with a minimal governance and things like that, or basically no governance for a lot of things, so that kind of trend there, I'm paying close attention to, because if we can make protocols work without Oracle's, that removes a centralization vector.
Not to say that Oracle's a bad, and we definitely need them for a lot of things, they're definitely revolved assets. We can't really remove it in that kind of realm from what I've seen, but that's one trend that I'm paying very, very close attention to. Another one is new AMM designs. So I know that unisop V4 just got announced, and that's a pretty broad design, and a pretty exciting design. But there are other protocols being built right now, and I don't think I can name any of them off of my head right now, I think a few of them are in stealth, but they're basically designing AMMs in a very different way to what we're used to.
They're building them from the ground up in order to be fully generalized and modular to give the liquidity provider as much control over the liquidity as possible. So that, to me, has been done in various ways, obviously unisop V3 did it with concentrated liquidity. Now, they have V4 with their hooks, which they're basically trying to modularize it even further, but some of the other protocols I've been looking at are taking it even further than that basically, and making it so generalized that it just provides a lot more value to the liquidity provider itself. So those are some of the things that I'm paying close attention to.
Generally, as well, I guess you could call these DeFi protocols, but I call them Steak Fi. So things like eigenlayer, of course, with restaking and newer LST protocols that maybe are trying to do something a bit different than the older ones, those sorts of things I'm interested in as well. And yeah, that's what that's basically in the kind of DeFi sphere, what I'm looking at right now. Yeah, those are some good takes. I'm a plus one on kind of the oracleist protocols. We did an episode with Dan Ellitzer from nascent on the oracleist protocols that folks should go check out as well. More money Legos to build here, really.
That's what it comes down to. A lot more DeFi innovation needs to happen. Here's another question about account abstraction. There's been a lot of talk late last year about account abstraction, the beginning of this one from the subject, but things seem to have cooled down. How needed is account abstraction, what are some projects working on this front? Can you remind us what account abstraction is and then tell us, has there been any movement lately on it? Or is it cooled down? Yeah. So basically account abstraction refers to this ability to create these Ethereum wallets that basically have superpowers, right?
So essentially, they're sometimes referred to as things like a smart contract wallets, where basically you can have controls in place like white lists directly on the wallet itself. So you can have white lists on like your metamask wallet, for example, right? But with a smart contract wallet, you can have it inbuilt into your actual public private key pair itself as a smart contract. I mean, that's a crude analogy because smart contracts don't have kind of like private keys here. From that kind of perspective, that's how it would work. And you could have like spending limits, things like that.
You could do things like multiple kind of, I guess like string together transactions as well, so that you could do an approved and swap in one transaction instead of having to approve a token for swap and then click swap to do it. So in two different transactions, that I think is very powerful for people because how many times if we all go into uni swap and we've been like, oh, I have to approve this token. And then I can swap it, right? It's better on the UX side of things. But in terms of like how much talk there's been, look, there's a lot of development happening in the background, but just by the very nature of what this is and how it's not really a speculative thing, you're not going to hear much about it unless you're actually looking for news and updates on it because it is stuff that's happening in the background.
It's at the infrastructure layer, but it is not infrastructure in the sense of a layer two or a layer one. It's more of like the middleware kind of protocols that you don't hear too much about. For example, there is the graph and chain link as well that are out there, but those things have have tokens, right? So you do hear about them sometimes, whereas account obstruction, things like the wallet connects and an agent working on these things and people just working on standards, they don't have tokens attached to them. So there's no speculative attention. And generally they don't have much marketing because it's just infrastructure that's being built in the background for now.
So there is still a lot of stuff happening, but what you'll see is a slow rollout to these different wallets because it is a change on the user facing stuff. So to change things for users, especially their wallet experience, you need to be slow and methodical with that. You need to make sure that the users aren't scared if you change something on them. That's why something like Metamask is so slow to change and they recently did a UI update actually, and I looked at it and I was like, oh, okay, this is this is new and I looked at him, okay, he's this and this, but then that's me as a pro user, imagine someone that's completely new using Metamask for like a couple months and then it changes on them.
So when it comes to wallets and integrating with account abstraction, they have to be very careful. They have to definitely do it as a gradual rollout, a slow rollout. So that's probably why you're not hearing too much about it. And generally when you hear something talked about a lot in like maybe a couple month period, it's because people are releasing all these new things that they've been working on and they're doing it at like major events such as eDevite as a kind of marketing tool sort of speak. But generally, most of the time you won't hear about these things unless you're actively looking looking for it.
Be on the lookout though for these improved account abstraction while it's smart contract wallets is sort of what you'll see and the experience, if we get this right, it should be very much like fintech. So we're all kind of the gas fees and all of the multiple steps and transactions. It should feel very seamless. So I don't know. I think we're probably a year away, a year to like three years from this, like getting really good and polished, but the infrastructure is starting to be built. Some takes this week, here's one, a take about the fink effect here. Host BlackRock Forbes, of course Larry Fink in BlackRock came out in favor of crypto in Bitcoin.
This poster says, Bitcoin suddenly has become greener, helps third world countries, and it's not being used by baddies anymore. We love to see it. And the postlings, all bunch of articles, everything you need to know about Bitcoin in environment, how Bitcoin helps civilians escape the ones who can, Bitcoin network to reduce more emissions and its energy sources produce. All right. The idea here is, of course, once big finance and big Wall Street gets on it, Larry Fink that the BlackRock CEO, nothing could be bigger. Then mysteriously, the narrative in mainstream media begins to turn pro crypto.
Is there anything to this? What do you think? I mean, yeah, I guess Lex is probably cherry picking here to be honest at the same time. And to call something a trend, I think you have to have a longer than maybe a few weeks of data. But there is something to media organizations changing their tune based on different trends, right? Because at the end of the day, they're for-profit organizations, they don't want to be going against something that's going to lose them money or lose them clicks or things like that. So, yeah, they're definitely going to probably align themselves more closely with these things.
And at the end of the day, they could be doing this as well as a way just to ride another trend of the public having a more favorable view. But in reality, they don't carry the way. They're just going to publish whatever gets them the most click. So, I don't know. I don't have very much faith in mainstream media. That's for sure. Yes. Do you, one wonders whether it's more working by algorithms at this point, and whether there's a kind of new ideas being created? Okay. So, one other take this week, I want to ask you about. So, this was actually somewhat controversial. I said this. It's embarrassing that even my crypto friends use Venmo, not crypto, just split a dinner.
And we have to change that this cycle. We can't guilt people into it. We have to make crypto wallets so useful if they're irresistible. It's that idea of account abstraction that we're just talking about. It's like, where's the crypto wallet? Where we can, I don't care about paying at Starbucks necessarily because that requires some Starbucks point of sale type system, right? I'm just talking about, you're worth a bunch of crypto natives, right? And you just had a dinner and you're going to go split the bill or something like that. And it's a peer-to-peer transaction. And I find myself still using fintech tools for that, still using Venmo.
And I wish that wasn't the case. Here's part of the controversy. DC investor says, it's possible small P to P payments like this are not a value prop of public blockchains in most societies. In fact, I'd argue they are not, even though the narrative was popular for a long time, starting with Bitcoin. He's basically saying, actually, P to P isn't the use case that crypto is focused on. It should be the more kind of the large, like store of value would be more of a use case, for instance, or collateralized loans or something like that. And P to P micro transactions will be one of the last things we solve.
I get that, but I still want my account abstraction crypto wallet. Like, why am I still banked here? I want to be bankless, Anthony. What's your take on this? I think, really, I agree with DC in the short term and disagree in the long term. I think P to P payments are a value prop of blockchains, generally. But at the same time, we're just way too early still. There doesn't exist a wallet right now that would be able to do this, right? In a cheap way, in an efficient way. And also, at the end of the day, the reason we have dollars in a bank account still, we have money in a bank account is because crypto is not integrated with many real world things.
You can't pay a lot of things in crypto, right? So when that changes, it'll be people will have crypto on hand, right? For everyday expenses, and they'll be able to do that Venmo payment at dinner, or that Venmo-like payment at dinner. So I think it really just comes down to building out that infrastructure, getting it more integrated with the real world. And then eventually, we hit the tipping point where people are like, oh, well, why would I use this old world money when I can use this new world money, so to speak, right? And yeah, it's going to take a while. It's definitely more of an end stage crypto adoption thing, rather than an early stage.
And it's going to require a lot of work to get there. That's why I agree with DC investing in the short term, disagree long term. I know people will sometimes say, well, it's been like 15 years, Bitcoin's been out, and we still don't have P2P payments. It's like, yeah, because Bitcoin isn't suited for it, right? Ethereum layer one is not suited for it. Ethereum layer two is just getting started now. Stable coins, you know, in terms of being used for a scale on Ethereum, they're not that old, right? And the infrastructure obviously is getting better all the time, but at the end of the day, we're still super early.
I think we're still way too early for the world that you want, Ryan, unfortunately, but it's a world that I want as well, but I think it will come with time. That's cool. And you know, you're talking about like, you know, it's been 15 years, right? Why do we have this? You know what we do have, though? And this is sort of, I was reminded by this after I tweeted, it's actually a project manager at PayPal, product manager at PayPal, he sent me after this. He DMed me and he's like, yo, you know, we could do this crypto thing in Venmo. And he just sent me 0.005 eth in Venmo. As if to say, like, yo, we got this, like we can do this too.
And he has a, you know, a dot eth name. So this is somebody who is clearly crypto-pilled inside the company at PayPal and Venmo building this out. And so it was kind of cool in my Venmo app in Fintech to receive some eth. And of course, like it's an IOU, but I, for eth, right? It's cusses, not fully bankless, so it's not the full vision. But we have gotten to this stage in 15 years. And Venmo and PayPal have hundreds of millions, 400 million or something, customers worldwide. That's absolutely massive progress that we're able to do this. And recently, I think it was within the last six to 12 months.
Venmo has also enabled the ability to withdraw to a bankless non-custodial address, which is a big step. So now we also have an off ramp from these systems. Anyway, I was, we were sending money back and forth. And I'm at the stage where I'm trying to get to AMLKY seed, of course, in order to send him back the money on his, on his bankless address. And I'm almost there. But look, man, that's progress. That's very cool. The original back in 2013 or back when you started getting into Bitcoin, Anthony, imagine being able to buy a crypto-native asset in a Fintech tool and send that to a friend, even if it's fully custodianed.
Like, that is progress. And I think we're getting there. We're just in this weird interim phase. Yeah, it definitely is progress. I mean, as you said, it is custodial. So it's like the easy way of doing this, so to speak, because you can just run a ledger in the background. And there's no need to do on-chain transactions for this. So it's like a centralized exchange, right? So it's essentially at this, yeah, well, yeah. Essentially, it's a side-chain to Ethereum, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. But I guess the dream that you were referencing in your other tweet was the fully bankless non-custodial payments.
We'll get there. We'll get there eventually. But yeah, I still think it's too early, unfortunately. I don't want to be doing this podcast with you in like five to 10 years and still not there yet, all right? Like, we got to, yeah, I want this to do. All right. Well, the last question I have for you this week, as we bring this to a wrap, is another question I put out on Twitter. The world thinks crypto is a scam. How do we change that perception? What's your take on this, Anthony Cisano? This idea that crypto is a scam. Obviously you and I disagree. Most listeners will also disagree. But the world thinks it is.
How do we change that? So I really think it's a perception at the end of the day, right? Like, there are so many scams in the world that aren't perceived as scams because they are marketed in such a way that convinces the general populace that they are not a scam. And you could stretch the definition of scam to meet a lot of different criteria, right? But there are certain things that people say are scams. Like, so let's say, student loans in the US, they're predatory, they have high interest rates, they lock people in for a very long time, and some people consider them a scam, right? But then there are other things that may also look like a scam, but no one's calling it a scam because they've been able to successfully market themselves as not a scam.
And I think when it comes to crypto, we both believe it's not a scam. And we obviously, there are scams in crypto, but so how do we change that perception? And I think that it's a very tough task to do because there is no centralized marketing for crypto, right? There is no crypto overlord that says, this is the way we're going to market crypto to the masses. At the end of the day, it's a very disjointed ecosystem, a very decentralized ecosystem that has different sectors to it. Some people will never pay attention to certain assets, but pay attention to other ones or pay attention to certain sectors and not other ones.
Some people will spend all their time at NFTs, but not look at defy it all, for example, right? And let's say you're in NFTs and you get rugged a bunch of times, you're like, you're going to throw up your hands and be like, oh my god, crypto is all a scam, you know, screw this, right? So I think it is just a perception thing at the end of the day. So how do we change that perception? I don't have a good answer to that. And I was reading through the replies and I'm like, it's kind of funny reading the replies. I was singing the whole time. Like, there are so many different replies that it speaks to exactly what I was saying that because there is no central overlord dictating the narrative or dictating the marketing, you're going to get all these different replies that imply different things and there's not going to be a kind of like correct answer here.
So I don't have a good answer for this, but I think that people should read through the replies on your tweet to get the different answers and to get the different perspectives here. But generally, if you kind of held the guns on my head and said, like, okay, you have to answer this, you have to have a take on this. I would say, let's just keep building, right? Let's just keep building. Keep building products people want to use that actually provide value. And eventually, if we build things that enough people use and it shouldn't change that perception and change the narrative in the minds of the masses.
But yeah, even in that world, it may not, right? It may not be a thing. It may not happen for a lot longer after we do that. But yeah, we'll have to see how that plays out. So we just need the builders to build and then we just need some time and your other messages, hey, scam is in the eye of the beholder, all right? Well, yeah, I mean, it is though, because like there are legit scams in crypto that people don't think of scams. And I'm like, that's literally a scam, dude. Like it's pretty obviously a scam. And they're like, no, it's not a scam. I can't tell. Sometimes in crypto, I feel like we overuse the term scam and other times I feel like we don't use it enough.
Other times I'm like, oh, no, we should call these things out. So I just don't even know how I feel about that. But yeah, it's interesting. We definitely have a narrative problem right now. But of course, we will when prices are down. Let's get to the meme of the week here. This is a tweet from a spreck. Crypto company announcement translation guide and one column. Today is my last day. I'm excited to spend more time with family working on new projects, what that really means is I'm quitting because of massive fraud and looming legal actions. Here's another one, what it means if you're looking for the translation, we are excited to announce our expansion to insert island nation state.
What that really means is we are under investigation by the CFTC. We are excited to announce our expansion to the UK. That really means is we are under investigation by the SEC. I love this. Or what decentralization actually means. Founders and investors are ready to dump their tokens on you. Wow, that is I think a negative take, of course, but well, that's where we are in the market cycle. So I found this funny. That's your meme of the week this week. Anthony, the daily way keeps on popping out videos. I'm gonna give you a shout out. This is the daily way YouTube channel. So if you are listening to this on a podcast, you gotta go look up the daily way in your podcast feed.
You can get episodes daily, right, Anthony? And this is the daily way, of course. And if you're watching this on YouTube, you gotta go over to the daily way channel and hit subscribe. Anthony, you do the fantastic episode every day that is technical, that is Ethereum focused, that is absolutely fantastic to get a refuel on everything that is going on in the Ethereum economy. It's a fantastic place to go. And Anthony, I wanna thank you for doing so many episodes with David and myself on the roll-up. David should be back starting next week. He is up on a mountain. This is him climbing Baker Mountain.
He's doing three mountains and I'll be back next week. But Anthony, you've done a killer job in helping David and I manage some vacation and keep these roll-ups going. So we definitely appreciate you. Thanks, man. Yeah, thank you very much. Thank you for the shout outs. And yeah, thanks for having me on. It's always really fun being on these roll-ups and talking to you and David. You guys have a great perspective on things and I think that I really liked the back and forth instead of just talking to the camera on my own a lot of the time, right? I love the back and forth with people. So yeah, thanks for having me on.
Absolutely, well guys, thank you for listening to the bankless roll-up. Gotta end with this. Our typical wrist and disclaimers, Crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot.