First Friday of August, 2022
------ 📣 Forta | Help Make Web3 a Safer Place https://bankless.cc/Forta
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🚀 ROCKET POOL | ETH STAKING https://bankless.cc/RocketPool
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🌴 MAKER DAO | DECENTRALIZED LENDING https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🔐 LEDGER | SECURE STAKING https://bankless.cc/Ledger
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro
5:00 MARKETS 7:23 All Time High https://messari.io/screener/bear-market-vibes-C66F0A22 9:30 Mainstream ETH https://twitter.com/TheStalwart/status/1554061312443006976 11:15 Bullish on the Merge https://twitter.com/data_always/status/1554521769591144448 15:20 Ethereum ESG https://twitter.com/Data_Always/thread/1554560847585886210 17:02 ENS Boom https://twitter.com/ensdomains/status/1554099225352290304 20:20 Opensea.eth https://twitter.com/degentraland/status/1554592812674449410
22:00 NEWS 24:00 $200m Nomad Bridge Hack https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2022/08/02/nomad-bridge-drained-of-nearly-200-million-in-exploit/ 31:55 Returning Funds https://www.theblock.co/post/161175/nomad-hack-ethical-hackers-return-9-million-to-exploited-crypto-bridge-platform 33:45 Are All Bridges Vulnerable? https://twitter.com/bkiepuszewski/thread/1554375783577276416 38:45 Bridge Security https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1483803596055621632
48:35 Solana Wallet Hack https://thedefiant.io/solana-wallet-breach/ 49:30 Explaining the Hack https://twitter.com/milesdeutscher/thread/1554853898497576960 52:20 Plaintext 54:00 David’s Wallet Advice https://twitter.com/trustlessstate/status/1554628479848685572
59:05 Ethereum Proof of Work Chain https://twitter.com/ceterispar1bus/status/1553113853361258505
1:06:00 Other News 1:08:00 Aave Multichain Strategy https://cointelegraph.com/news/aave-devs-propose-freezing-fantom-integration-citing-lack-of-traction-and-potential-vulnerability 1:10:10 SushiSwap Chef Compensation https://thedefiant.io/sushiswap-head-chef-may-pocket-a-third-of-all-tokens-paid-to-staff/ 1:10:40 Optimism Bedrock https://twitter.com/optimismFND/thread/1554528451767451650 1:13:15 Happy Birthday Ethereum! https://twitter.com/BlockGeekDima/status/1553331229285548044 1:13:35 Michael Saylor Steps Down https://twitter.com/tier10k/status/1554558287940669440
1:15:30 NFT News Tiffany CryptoPunks https://twitter.com/tiffanyandco/status/1553742328652877827 Magic Eden Supporting ETH https://twitter.com/MagicEden/status/1554497669032206336 Rainbow Wallet https://twitter.com/rainbowdotme/status/1551978336359890944 StarkNet https://twitter.com/aspectdotco/status/1554119172262490112
1:19:00 Robinhood Fined $30M https://twitter.com/alyssachoo_/thread/1554493577249669123 1:20:08 Commodity Senate Bill https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/senate-bill-would-hand-bitcoin-ether-oversight-commodities-regulator-2022-08-03/ 1:21:00 SEC Charges Forsage https://www.theblock.co/post/160624/sec-charges-forsage-founders-promoters-in-300-million-crypto-ponzi-scheme-lawsuit
1:21:50 Quick News Hits Celsius Leak https://blockworks.co/celsius-admits-customer-emails-leaked-in-third-party-data-breach/ Babel Finance https://www.theblock.co/post/160230/babel-finance-crypto-lost-280-million-proprietary-trading-restructuring Coinbase ETH Staking https://twitter.com/CoinbaseInsto/status/1554186523800526848 Swell Network https://twitter.com/swellnetworkio/status/1552891765237026816 Immutable X Gamestop https://twitter.com/Immutable/status/1552821358773448705
1:23:36 Raises Variant Fund III https://variant.fund/articles/introducing-variant-fund-iii/ Vee Friends a16z https://blog.veefriends.com/veefriends-closes-seed-round-from-a16z-crypto-afa151561051
1:24:15 Jobs https://pallet.xyz/list/bankless/jobs
1:26:00 Questions from the Nation 1:27:30 DCA into a Token https://twitter.com/Madge_80/status/1554862719223963652 1:31:00 Getting a Job in Crypto https://twitter.com/patduds/status/1554876401928454144
1:33:00 TAKES 1:33:30 Authoritarian vs Libertarian https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1552776283968323585 1:35:30 Goalposts Moving https://twitter.com/sassal0x/status/1553750144515842049 1:36:30 Call Out Scammers https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin/status/1554258761727938561 1:39:55 Caring About Decentralization https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1553488247564767234 1:41:00 Fees-Driven Bulls Market https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1553477269544484864
1:42:12 What David’s Bullish On 1:43:25 What Ryan’s Bullish On
1:46:20 Meme of the Week https://twitter.com/memejority/status/1554493706945720321?s=21&t=tu1DynjBZTppSHroSEfswg
----- Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
There's just the bridge risk. People understate the bridge risk and events like this kind of highlight what a mistake it is to understate the bridge risk. Bankless Nation, happy first week of August. David, it's Friday morning. What time is it? Oh, Ryan, it's the Friday, Bankless weekly rollup time where we cover the entire week of news in crypto, which is always an ambitious endeavor, yet we persevere on into the frontier nonetheless. To the frontier, that's right. And I got to remind you, enjoy this rollup with a cup of coffee. David, you said you got a coffee upgrade earlier this week and I forgot to ask you about it.
So, you know, has coffee at the department in New York? You know, coffee's a tough thing. I was making my coffee with an AeroPress, which I love. That's good. But it's really consuming. It's a little time consuming. It's a little laborious. It's really meant for like camping or just like things when you're in a pinch. So I got a Chemex, which is, you know, definitely like a standard. It's not nothing special. But it's just like a trip. Chemex? Yeah, it's a pour over. Yeah. It's more suited to like the particular ground that I have and the kettle that I have. So definitely got an upgrade, but still lots of work to be done on my coffee setup.
So I'm looking forward to that. I'm glad you're in better shape. And I know it's a continuous improvement. Just Dave's got to remind you. Just like all of your coffee. Or it becomes a beverage. All right, we're not talking about coffee today. We're talking about crypto. And a lot happened as usual. What's the first thing we're going to cover today? Yeah, it's a bad week for crypto this week. Some exploits. Another bridge hack. So reset the clock on that one zero days since our last accident. Nomad was hacked for almost $200 million on a smart contract exploit. So we'll go into how that happened.
Because it's very unique. Actually, first of it's kind of a hack. And so we'll talk about that and kind of what it means for the whole like multi-layer one thesis. Speaking of hacks, all right, almost 10,000 Salana wallets were just randomly drained this week as well. Also kind of fake hack. That's not supposed to happen. And a lot of the week was spent with people trying to figure out how in the world this happened. So we're going to talk a little bit about that and the conclusion of what happened with this wallet hack, pretty alarming. What's the other thing we're going to cover? And lastly, there's just been a bunch of hubbub, a bunch of drama about the ETH pow chain, an ETH proof of work chain that is probably going to come out of the fork.
When once we merge, we're going to leave a proof of work chain behind. And so some people are descending upon that proof of work chain as a shelling point. Are you listener about to get some free ETH pow, pow ETH? Peace. Peace. Well, personally, I wouldn't get your hopes up. We'll talk about that. Well, I don't know. I'm a little more bullish on it. We'll definitely talk about that. And of course, if you like the weekly rollup, if you like Bankless content, make sure you like, subscribe, rate, and review. If you are listening to this on a podcast channel, on Spotify, especially, you can now get this in video format.
There's always better in video, seeing faces, along with the words, David, before we get into it, gotta relay a quick message from our friends and sponsors at Forda. Did you know, in 2021, that was just last year, speaking of hacks, we were talking about hacks in the intro, there's $2.3 billion in crypto-web-3 related hacks. And Forda has something to help with this. What is Forda doing, David? Forda is a live smart contract monitoring service. And so what they do is they monitor the mempool. And so there's plenty of things that you need to do as a smart contract dev, like go through audits, do formal verification.
But there's still plenty of stuff you can also do while your smart contracts are live in the wild, live in production. And there are types of transactions that can be detected that are incoming that are known to be like malicious. Like they drain treasuries, they hack bridges, they mess with your governance or whatever. And so Forda, there's that like video game that way back when in the 90s, like this meteor game where the meteors were coming in and they would shoot them before they hit the earth. Right? So like they would zap the incoming meteors. This is what Forda does for incoming malicious transactions.
And so you can identify a set of transactions if they do this, then you know they're malicious. And Forda will zap them before they get into your smart contract. And so there's over 36 billion in TVL monitored by Forda's decentralized network, including protocols and applications like DYDX, compound balancer, maker, Lido, Yuma, not Nomad, not Nomad. That's interesting. Maybe they could have used Forda. Yeah, there's a little show notes if you are interested in learning more about getting a smart contract exploit zapper on your squad. One thing I know is you don't want to find out that your smart contract has been hacked on Twitter.
You want to receive some alert and have a defense system set up. So Forda monitoring is there for that. And of course, Forda, thank you for sponsoring this message. Ryan, shall we get into markets? Yeah, let's do it. What's Bitcoin shown us this week? I'm going to show some charts. Yeah, got some new charts on the screen. Bitcoin, we are down a whopping 0.9%. Which I would consider flat. I would consider that flat on the week. Started the, started the week at $23,100, ending the week at $22,900 flat on the week. Thought on the week. Just flat on the week. Now they're up or down. Just tepid. Just flat.
How about you, the same thing? Yeah, started the week at 1640, ending the week at 1620, down 1.5%. Again, I would just consider that flat. That is a flat week. All right, David, how about the ETH Bitcoin ratio? What's that looking like on the week? Yeah, super flat on the week. Down half of a percent at 0.0707. So nothing. Nothing. Market's still deciding. Bitcoin or ETH? No, no. Bitcoin, ETH, blue chips are flat. Tokens, Ryan, up bigly. We'll talk about that later in the show. But token's like DeFi tokens? DeFi tokens, yeah. They're on the move. Yeah, they're on the move. Well, we will cover that in what I am bullish on at the very end of the time.
We'll bring our DPI chart back. Oh god, I'm not toast. I'm not ready for that. Not quite that much. DeFi tokens, please. How about global cryptocurrency market cap? Are we at a trillion yet? Yeah, we've been at a trillion for a while. We ended last week at 1.14 trillion. We are at 1.11 trillion. So down $30 billion again. If it's less than one Terra of downwards, that's flat. It's less than one Terra. Wow. Do you soon, David? Gas markets. Gas markets in real life kind of suck. Price at the pump. But price at the Ethereum pump is still kind of good. Is this nine-gay this week did it here? It's low as 9-gay.
Yeah, you can scroll down to get that chart a little bit. Yeah, so last week it was, keep going down. Every single time you miss this, there we go. OK, green chart and green. Top right. Yeah, so the average, what we'll start here. The average total transaction gas distribution, the peak, was at nine-gay this week. Down one-gay from last week. Seven, Ryan, is the number we got to be to be deflationary in the merge. And we are at nine. That's too close for comfort. All right, that would be so disappointing. But let's take a look at Bitcoin and ETH from all-time high perspective. Bitcoin down 65% from all-time high this week.
ETH down 64% and the difference between ETH and Bitcoin from their respective bottoms is ETH is up 76% from its bottom. And Bitcoin is only up 26%. So ETH took a harder crash, harder dip than Bitcoin, but it has recovered much faster. And now it's kind of neck and neck on the percent down from all-time high. What do you make of this? Yeah, I mean, this is definitely the merge trade. It's very infrequently that I feel like we can confidently say what is making the market do the things that it's doing. But right now, I have some of the most confidence I've ever had to this is the merge trade. This is what this is.
This is, yeah, merge is bullish. Let's look at the other percentage tokens down from all-time high. So besides Bitcoin and ETH, how about Binance chain? What's that looking like? Yeah, Binance chain, B&B always does very, very well. And also one of the reasons is because it's one of the few tokens that actually has cash flows embedded in it. Like it's kind of got this like manual EIP1559 buy back and burn, because that's what Binance does with this revenue is it buys B&B and burn it. So it's a massive exchange, which is a cash cow in bull markets and bear markets. It's still a cash cow and that's still sort of backing the Binance chain.
Always has. We're sorry, B&B chain. B&B chain, yeah. So it's down 56%. Compared to Bitcoin and ETH is down 66%. So definitely better than those two. XRP, down 88%. Cardano, down 83%. Salana, down 85%. Pokedown, down 85%. Dogecoin, down 91%. Polygon, down 69%. Nice. Avalanche, down 84%. Uniswap, only down 28%. Wow, you need only down and 28%. That's pretty good. That's pretty good. I gotta admit, David, I look at the start and I see a little bit like nature's healing. Yeah. This makes more sense to me than the bull market. This makes complete sense to me, but like it's still more reasonable than things in the bull market.
Let's talk a little bit more about the bullish ETH narrative. It's kind of going mainstream. You know Joe Weisenthal, right from Bloomberg. Bit time. Yeah. He has a podcast. I listen to occasionally also has a newsletter. And in his newsletter this week, Joe Weisenthal, who's never really been an ETH bull at any point in time, any of my reading of his, he just wrote why ETH is taking over the narrative and why Bitcoin's narrative is busted. And yeah, I think this is starting to escape into mainstream is probably the takeaway here that ETH like surpassing Bitcoin on the narrative front is a real thing that's happening right now.
Yeah, and there's two reasons for this. I think if you're inside of the crypto industry, you are bullish ETH, if you are bullish ETH over Bitcoin, then it's because of ETH or being deflationary post-merge. But if you're outside of the crypto industry, you think that Ethereum is going to be in a better place than Bitcoin because of the ESG green energy narrative. So it's kind of pick your reason, but we got two of them. As to why people are trending in favor of ETH lately. Ryan, really quickly, I just talked about how Uniswap was only down like 28%, 29%. That didn't feel right. It's actually down 70%.
It's down 80%. I just checked on it. Yeah, that was weird. Yeah, it's actually down 80%. I don't know where that came from. Yeah. Thanks for that correction. Yeah, but to your point, and the two reasons to be bullish, when you're inside of the space, you're kind of bullish because of the structural cell pressure that just decreases in a post-merge. Am I the correct reason for being bullish? I think so. I mean, like the narrative side, we knew proof of stake. We knew proof of work was going away, and Ethereum was becoming ESG, it's kind of forever. I think this is less well known, but this has a greater, more immediate impact.
What is the chart that we're looking at on the change in theoretical annual structural cell pressure with the massive issuance reduction? All the proof of work issuance, it's like 4.1%, something like this, it goes away completely the day of the merge. What are we looking at in this chart? Yeah, so we are looking at a bar chart that's titled reduction in theoretical annual structural cell pressure. And what that means is that some bigger chains have gone through changes in monetary policy throughout their history. Ethereum, Ethereum used to be issued five ether per block at Genesis that got reduced down to three in 2017, and then it got reduced down to two in 2019, to where it is now.
Other blockchains have also done similar things like the Bitcoin happening famously. There was a 2016 Bitcoin happening, a 2020 Bitcoin happening. And the sizes of these bars are a function of how much cell pressure is getting reduced. So when Bitcoin goes through a halving, you take how much Bitcoin would have been issued in a year, multiply that by the USD price, and then take away how much is not being issued as a result of the halving. And so the 2020 Bitcoin halving reduced $3 billion in theoretical annual cell pressure that got reduced from the happening. The ether reduction from three to two eth in the proof of mining reward, in 2019 removed 500 million in yearly annual cell pressure, but reminder, that's when ether was like $1 or $200.
And so if you multiply that by 10 or 20 to where we are now, that would control for that. On the very far left, we have two upcoming changes. We have the Bitcoin halving in 2024, which, again, multiply the amount of Bitcoin being issued versus its current price, where it is now at $23,000. You, Bitcoin will receive almost a $4 billion reduction in annual cell pressure. This is why Bitcoiners love the happening, right? We reduce cell pressure. This is why the halvinging celebrated like scarcity is coming in. And it's scheduled every four years. You know it's coming. And then in the eth merge, the eth merge, which is upcoming very, very quickly, is going to be a theoretical reduction in $7.
5 billion of annual cell pressure. And so almost double the annual reduction in annual cell pressure from eth to Bitcoin, which is also saying something, when it's double a reduction in US dollar cell pressure, but the difference in market cap between Bitcoin and Ethereum is about 2.5x. So the Bitcoin market cap is $440 billion. The Ethereum market cap is $195 billion. Call it 200. And so the Bitcoin market cap is 2.5 times larger than Ethereum's, but the Ethereum US dollar cell pressure reduction is twice as big as Bitcoin's. And so this is why this is so incredibly bullish. It's such an outsized reduction in cell pressure versus the much smaller Ethereum market cap.
Yeah, another way to say this, too, is in a post-merge world, Ethereum's going to have to find, in order to stay flat, in order for prices not to explode upwards, Ethereum's going to have to find $7.5 billion in new sellers. Right. And if it doesn't find those new sellers, here Ryan, if it doesn't find those new sellers, has no choice but to go up. That's no choice, but to go up. That's why the economics of the merge are so interesting and so attractive. And I think why the market is starting maybe to price this in, though, I don't think they fully priced it in. You know, of course, you wouldn't have like, checkmate sellers.
I just don't, why would you sell? There's like, there's two times you can buy or sell eth, right? One is before the merge and the other is after, right? I'm definitely a buyer before the merge. I think it's a historic opportunity. Anyway, not financial advice. Okay, but the second reason that the reason may be mainstream thinks this is interesting as well is the whole ESG narrative. So this is the energy reduction narrative when Ethereum transitions to proof of stake and gets rid of all of the energy inefficient mining that happens. What tweet are we looking at here, David? Yeah, so we're looking at just a chart of Google searches for ESG over time.
And it's like a hockey, on the beginnings of a hockey stage, hockey stick, it looks like popularity of Google searches for ESG over time. I don't really know what this x-axis is, maybe it's arbitrary. But we are roughly three times higher than we were in 2020 if that is any sort of an indication. So we're extrapolating here and saying just like ESG as a concept, which is just like insustainable investing both in ecological standpoint, but also like a political and governance standpoint. And so implying that ESG is invoked, and so a reduction in energy usage by a leading blockchain will be a very popular move with people because ESG is invoked.
Now personally, I don't really enjoy the ESG. I think it's just adding a political element to investing, but that is just a political take, I guess. I think there's better ways to optimize for investments, but it's what the people want, and the people want things that are green, and that's what Ethereum is doing when it goes to the merge. You definitely have to track it as a narrative, and the bottom line here, as the tweet said, is Bitcoin has decided to ignore the ESG issue entirely, whereas Ethereum is unlatching itself from proof of work. And that's the narrative going forward, and I think people are buying into that narrative as well.
David, people are also buying into ENS. We just got the July 2022 stats, and ENS is an NFT that just is doing very well in this bear market. What are we looking at for the high level stats here? Yeah, let's go through some of the numbers. 378,000 new.eth registrations, bringing the new total to 1.86 million ENS names that have been minted. That's $6.8 million in protocol revenue going to the Dow. That's 5,400 eth in revenue, with 48,000 new eth accounts, new Ethereum addresses that have at least one ENS name in it. And I never have understood this last metric. Greater than 99% of an open-sea domain volume.
Does that mean ENS is dominating open-sea volume by 99%? They're not interesting. There are other domains, besides.ethes and ENS. They're dot cryptos, or all sorts of other dot.ethes. Okay, so it's market share. Like ENS is not all that makes sense. Yeah, the domain space is like a monopoly game. So that makes sense. ENS definitely has one that game. It's kind of feeling like it's the dot-com, right? At least. Yes. Yeah, this is really interesting. And all of that protocol revenue goes to the Dow. Yeah. 6.8 million protocol revenue. That was 6.8 million for the month. Just one of the month for the month, yeah.
What? Yeah. That's a cash cow. Right, and like, I can't imagine the Dow has all that many expenses. Okay, what is the token price of ENS? Yeah, that's a good question. How's that doing? Remember that, yeah, ENS token, you got some air drop. Yeah, I wish I couldn't claim because my Argent Wallet lost my private keys. My Argent Wallet. It's off the bottoms here. Yeah, it's off the bottoms for sure. It's still climate. Bottom around nine. I got the ENS. It's a good buy. It's a good buy. Stubble from the bottom. Yeah. But I mean, if you go to cryptofes.info, for just talking about the DAPs, Uniswap $1.
5 million in revenue in one day of a $0.6 million of revenue in one day GMX, which is an app that's bidding out East to a token holders, 0.2 million SushiSwap 1.16 million ENS coming in in one, two, three, four, coming in fifth at 1.15 million dollars per day, $150,000 per day in revenue. Still three times more than Solana. I don't know what to say about that. It's not a fair comparison, because Solana is like explicitly like, we won't collect any fees. We will not have economics sustainability, and that's how we'll just like onboard everyone by collecting zero money. Yes, but I think it's more of a fair comparison than people actually think.
It should, people should think this. Yes. We actually get into this conversation with, I was going to say, Pauli Nia. Pauli Nia. Pauli Nia. So David and I did an Anon interview with Polenia last week. We talked a lot about previously known as Pauli Nia. It turns out we have not been pronouncing that name correctly at all. Anyway, it's not coming out this Monday, but the next Monday we talk all about alternative layer ones versus the theorem and layer two's and where the value cruel is going to lie. And anyway, don't miss that episode is all I'm saying. We get into this discussion around fees and how it impacts valuation.
David, what else we got here? Speaking of E and S names, OpenC bought OpenC.heath for $165,000. Yeah, so nice payday for whoever minted OpenC.heath congratulations. Oh, that's basically a hundred east. Well done. I'm glad we got bankless.heath back in the day, David. Yeah, before this. Could you imagine how much we'd be gouged or just if we hadn't gotten a bankless.heath. Be so sad. I don't know if I'd do it. Would we pay for that? We pay like $2,000 for that? Like goodbye. We paid for it. So you have to translate that into each terms maybe. Maybe it's worse than that. Who knows? But eat this down.
Oh, I don't know. No, we're probably going to go. I'm going to go find this out right now. Ryan, we bought bankless.heath. August 2nd, 2020 for $5.15. That's more than $2,000. Sad. That's very steep. So what is that? Right now. Oh, yeah. That's like $8,000. $5.15. Yeah. $5.15. Yeah. You know, under $10,000. $8,250. Yeah. I mean, it's steel over the long term. Yeah. Over the long run. I mean, we would have paid. We would have had to pay a lot more for it now. An egregious amount. And by the way, we caught this when somebody let it expire. So somebody had purchased it and they let it expire. We came in and sniped it in the bid process.
Wait. How did we, if it expired, why do we pay $5.15? Because there was like this bid process that they had in place with some expired domains where it started very steep. And then over the next 30 days, like it descended in price. But anyone could buy it. Anyone could buy it, but we bought it right away. Oh, yeah, yeah. So we bought it kind of at the top of the earth, because it's not taking the risk. Anyway, guys, coming up next, we're going to talk more about the hack season that seems to be happening. It's sort of a bad week for hacks across crypto, especially if you are using the bridges to some of these other ecosystems or $200 million hack.
And then this Salana private key hack. I'm going to talk about that. And then also, David, you're to tell us whether proof of work, eth, a fork of Ethereum. If that's a real thing or fake news. And I'm still hoping for my eth, forked tokens that I could sell for more eth. Don't hold your breath. We'll see. Guys, we'll be right back. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. So follow maker on Twitter at MakerDow and learn from the oldest and most resilient down existence. All right, guys. We are back with another big bridge hack this time, a bridge called Nomad was drained of nearly $200 million in an exploit.
This was a code type exploit. So a technical exploit. David, you want to tell us what happened. Yeah, so cross-drain bridge Nomad. It goes to a number of different ecosystems, avalanche Ethereum, EV, EV, EV, MOS, EV, MOS. Cosmos, James. Cosmos, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Right. Milcoma and Moonbeam. And so there, like you said, it was a smart contract exploit as opposed to like an economic or oracle attack. We lost almost $200 million. And the person that really unpacked this the best is a Sam C. Son who put a thread together. And so we'll go ahead and read out the thread because it's not too long. So Sam says, Nomad just got drained for over $150 million in one of the most chaotic hacks that Web3 has ever seen.
How did this happen exactly? And what was the root cause? How do we take you behind the scenes? Please do, Sam. And so he says, it all started when somebody, a Twitter telegram account shared, another Twitter accounts tweet. And Ethereum security telegram channel, although I had no idea what was going on at the time, the sheer volume of assets leaving the bridge was clearly a bad sign. And he shows a tweet of 100 WBTC leaving the Nomad bridge, like transaction after transaction after transaction. So 100 WBTC, 100 WBTC. And somebody says Nomad bridge getting rugged looks very, very suss. Sam says, my first thought was that there was some misconfiguration for the tokens decimals.
After all, it seemed that the bridge was running a send 0.01 WBTC, get 100 WBTC back promotion. And then here he's showing a tweet where somebody was sending in literally 0.01 WBTC, but 100 WBTC were going out. That's a bad promotion. That's a bad promotion anyway. Sam says, however, after some painful manual digging on the Moonbeam network, I confirmed that while the Moonbeam transaction did bridge out 0.01 BTC, somehow the Ethereum transaction bridge in WBTC. Further, the transaction bridge in the WBTC didn't actually prove anything. It simply called process, like a function process directly.
Suffice to say, being able to process a message without proving it first is extremely not good. And so what they mean is by proving it is that, if there's a thing called a prover, maybe this is what we're talking about. But basically, anybody can send a message to a bridge, but the message needs to be correct. And that's part of the functionality of the bridge. At this point, there were two possibilities. Either the proof had been submitted separately in an earlier block, or there was something extremely wrong in the replica contract. However, there was no indication that anything had been proven recently.
Again, this is terminology about how these contracts need to be receiving messages about that are correct. To whatever degree that the smart contract in that bridge deemed something correct, it's like kind of up to how the bridge was constructed. But a correct message would be something that is like coming from one chain to another and like a proof is generated that is correct or so. Sam continues and says, there's only one possibility left. There was a fatal flaw in the replica contract. But how? A quick look suggests that the message submitted must belong to an acceptable route. Otherwise, the check online 185 would fail.
Fortunately, there's an easy way to say to check this assumption. I knew that the root of the message, which had not been proven, would be 0x00, because message brackets underscore message hash, bracket would be uninitialized. All I had to do was check whether the contract would accept that as a root. And then the next one is oops. That's the only thing the tweet says. It says oops. Hopefully for Sam just put in 0x000000 as an address and it comes back true, meaning that every single thing will come back true, meaning that the bridge is like an open vault. Everything is true. The contract returns everything true.
So that means anyone could go. Anyone can function and pull funds out. More or less, yeah. Of the bridge. Yeah. And so Sam says it turns out during a routine upgrade that the nomad team initialized the trusted route to be 0x0000. To be clear, using zero values as an initialization value is just a common practice. Unfortunately, in this case, it had the tiny side effect of auto proving every message. Oh my god. So every message, every possible message was approved. As in like, hey, can you send me 100 WPTC? Approved. Approved. And so Sam says and finishes, this is why the hack was so chaotic. You didn't need to know about solidity or a miracle trees or anything like that.
All you had to do was find a transaction that worked, find and replace the other person's address with yours and then rebroadcast it. So not every single transaction works. You have to have a certain hash. But it's just you need to find a transaction that starts with 0x00. And you can go find that by going to a previous bridge transaction and then copying that transaction and just replacing it with your outbound address and then sending that. And so TLDR, routine upgrade marked the 0 hash as a valid route, which had the effect of allowing messages to be spoofed on nomad. And that attackers abused this to copy and paste transactions and quickly drained the bridge and it frenzied free for all.
So once one person realized it, everyone realized it that the gates to the vault were open. There was an open vault and all the money was just like sitting there. Well, somebody realized it and then as soon as one person realized it, everyone realized it. That's the analogy, right? So this nomad bridge had code that essentially vaulted off massive amounts of money, hundreds of millions of dollars in value here. So like close to $200 million. And then they issued a update to this vault. And the doors swung wide open. And they didn't even realize it. And then you realize it for 43 days. So this vault has been open for 43 days in a row.
Only two or three days ago that somebody was like, hey, there's money there. There's money there. No one stopping me from going and getting it. And so they went and the first couple of people grabbed the money. Yeah. And then an entire crowd assembled to go pick up the money from the vault. And like, you know, stuff under their trench coats and run home with it. Yep. Wow. Are these white hats, David? Yeah. So, I mean, so not everyone who's doing this is evil, of course. There are a number of people that just went and grabbed the money. Because if they didn't grab the money, then somebody malicious would grab the money.
So like if you're a person, say, well, that money is free. Everyone's taking it. I'll be a good person. And I'll take the money and I'll return it. Before someone else does. Before an evil doer does it. And so it's kind of like a little bit like game theory. If you know that you are going to return the money, then you can safely go get the money and return it to the people later. So somebody who made a transaction to go get this money and knew what they were doing. They write in the message field and their transaction saying, I'm returning this money. FBI, please calm down. No, I didn't plan to seal it.
And yes, I know this address is closed. That's amazing. Just leaving a message for the FBI. My hands are up. My hands are up. Don't shoot. That was a super funny tweet where somebody says accidentally exploited the nomad bridge for $17,000. Real return the funds. Did you see this clip of the monkeys? Yeah, so this is a tweet from Haska trade saying the nomad hack explained. And here's just like a classic bin of a bunch of bread. And then there's like a hundred monkeys coming in. They're all grabbing the bread out of the basket. I mean, this is kind of, you know, of the $190 million. Apparently, $9 million has been returned.
So there's $9 million worth of white hacks that are actually doing the right thing and returning these funds. But that's quite a gap, man. That's like $180 million that has not been returned. And what was that? 5% was captured by white hackers. Yes. It's not zero. I mean, the big question is, do you remember the wormhole hack that happens? Man, it feels like another lifetime ago. But honestly, it wasn't that long ago. But that got a bailout from Jump Capital. The question is, what's that $1 billion bailout? Yes. Something like that. It was a lot of money. I can't remember. I don't know if it was quite a billion.
But I don't know if the deep pockets are coming to rescue the bridge this time. Right. What do you think? Well, less money in the ecosystem now. $320 million was what it was. $320 million. Yeah. So this is a pretty big one. Plenty of people have hundreds of millions of dollars in the top of the market. Fewer people have hundreds of million dollars in this currency of the market. I mean, I think Nomad has recently been funded as well by VCs. Yeah. But not for 190 million. They raise like 22 million. Even close. Not even close. So what are you going to do? And that's what's going to happen. They have to pay employees with that.
What's also interesting is this was a bridge to many kind of of the like alternative layer one ecosystem. So as you said, avalanche, cosmos. Evie. Milcoma. Milcoma. Milcoma is. That's Cardano. It's Cardano. Cardano. And what's Moonbeen? You know what Moonbeen is? Moonbeen. I do not know what Moonbeen is. Yeah. Neither do I. So what do you think this means? A very powerful dragon fly a dragon type attack from Pokemon. Really? Yeah. Okay. Your Pokemon lore exceeds mine. All right. It's a Pokemon platform. It's a Pokemon platform. The question is. It's a Pokemon. Yeah. It's not Pokemon. Nothing to do with the Pokemon.
So the question is, are all bridge, are all bridges susceptible to this? Yes. So you know, like bank, that's where we're very excited about some layer two is obviously. Yes. Opticals also have bridges. Arbitrum, the ZK, EVMs. You've heard us talk about these before. They also have bridges to David's point. These bridges are not susceptible to economic attack, which is one category of attack, and probably less susceptible to oracle attack. We haven't got delved into that in all the details. But is susceptible to this two similar kinds of technical attack as we saw with Nomad. So does that worry you that like, hey, any time we bridge from main aetherium, there's some smart contract risk here on any of these layer two ecosystems.
Do you think that'll be an inhibitor to scale? Yeah. So layer two, layer twos are bridges that have less attack surface area. Like you said, you can't do an economic attack on a layer two bridge, and you also cannot do an oracle attack on a layer two bridge if that bridge has an oracle. But smart contracts are smart contracts, and bridges are smart contracts. And so a layer two bridge to optimism, ZK sync, you know, Arbitrum. These are all have bridges that all have smart contracts, and those smart contracts can be exploited. There is one major difference for optimistic rollups, and that optimistic rollups have a seven day withdrawal window.
And so if you have a bunch of ether on optimism or Arbitrum, and then you exploit that bridge, it's going to take you seven days to get back to the aetherium layer one. But that's, I guess that's only true if that smart contract exploit happens on the layer two side, because that ether does exist on the aetherium layer one inside the bridge contract. So if the aetherium layer one bridge contract is exploited, I guess you could just get it out immediately. So smart contract risk is always going to be smart contract risk. The spicy hot take that I'll have is that if you are building a layer two on aetherium, one of the core reasons why you would choose to do a layer two on aetherium, rather than I'll turn it to layer one, is that you believe in you prioritize security up most.
Like if you are doing your own blockchain, your own layer one blockchain, you have to build your security from scratch, and you're going to be inherently less secure than in the aetherium layer one, because that's what the aetherium layer one has optimized for. So if you are a layer two, you are prioritizing security, that is in your culture as a team. So if you are a team that prioritizes security in your culture, you're likely also doing a much higher effort on securing your bridge and your bridge smart contracts, then you would, if you are a team that doesn't prioritize security as much. And teams that don't prioritize security, don't build roll ups, they build alternative layer ones.
Is that a fair take? I feel like that's fair take. I think that's a fair take, but also at the same time, I mean, it's nice to say, right, but like, I don't know, it's kind of verified, don't trust. It's not great to be in the position of having to trust the expertise and the skill level and the security, like the consumer security profile of devs of a particular bridge. So yeah, I would say I am moderately worried about this, and it's not something that we should take lightly, like the good news, I think, with all of these bridges in the roll up ecosystem is they're upgradable. So we haven't like turned off, we haven't removed the upgrade button from any of them.
So if something goes wrong, you know, patch could go in quickly. But yeah, I think there is some risk, and we should be real about that when people are bridging to even layer two ecosystems, they have this risk. Now I think that risk will decrease massively over time. There was a time, David, where I was too freaked out to put any funds inside of a multi-sick, like the NOSUS multi-sick wallet, for instance. And do you remember there was a NOSUS multi-sick wallet, kind of a V1, and then they created a V2, and you sort of reset the clock back to zero when a new upgrade is kind of issued. And now I'm not, like, NOSUS multi-sick holds tens of billions of dollars at this point.
It's been around for years, has a very strong Lindy. And I think the only way around kind of, the bridge hack concern is you have to have bridges that have been in place without being touched for a long period of time, securing massive amounts of money, and this is going to take time. So I don't know, I'm not putting all of my funds on a layer two as a result of this, because it's still in the early phases. Do you think that's a fair take? I definitely think that's a fair take, and just to, I think we should definitely take some time on this topic, because the bridge is always, has been a huge theme of the last 12 months.
This is a bar tech thread from layer two B. Layer two B is doing a fantastic job just putting in risk frameworks and helping to define the risks of bridges and layer twos. So bar tech puts this thread together, and he says, with a recent hack of nomad, I think it's time to reflect more broadly on bridge security, as by now they have become far more the most critical piece of blockchain infrastructure. Here are some things to consider. Externally validated bridges, as in bridges that require a kind of multi-sig to process messages, can obviously be drained by the key owners, and the keys might be compromised, but the smart contract there is very simple to implement audit and independently verify.
As in your trade it here, there's a trade off here. Your smart contract is more simple, because you've exported a bunch of risk to the multi-sig. And sometimes, especially in the beginning stages of a bridge, I would definitely advocate for this model. Let's just like, remove all the complexity and just trust the founders, trust the multi-sig for the beginning stage. This is similar to the polygon bridge, to the purpose of stake chain. Granted polygon has an extra layer of defense, because it has ethereum side, matic staking, which is a very meaningful difference than your typical side chain or cross layer one bridge.
BarTech continues and says, there is downside, of course, with that bridge you need to trust the off-chain code, which is completely opaque, who knows what's going on there, shout out Ronin, Ronin bridge with the Axi network. BarTech says, Nomad is way more complex, and it fell due to an obscure bug in a smart contract code, not an architectural flaw. Compared to Nomad, optimistic rollups are still more complex. Compared to optimistic rollups, ZK rollups are insanely complex. You do the math. It makes sense to let the bridge code ossify with time before you move bigger funds, but after the upgrade, the authentication timer is reset to zero, as the upgrade may introduce a critical bug as it happened with Nomad.
This is what happened. They upgraded their bridge contract. It was fine, and so yeah, it was fine, and they're like, okay, cool, let's up the security, let's up the hands-off nature of this bridge, and that upgrade was the thing that introduced the risk. BarTech says, Nomad is also permissionless, anyone could process messages and bridge, the bridge could not be stopped. No central actor to trust, which like, yay, we like that in a bankless world, but also, ooh, scary in the early days. This removed power from Nomad team, but also left them helpless watching the bridge being drained. As noted many times before, this space critically needs a solution for design that is trustless and secure against critical bugs at the same time.
Seven-day delay windows in optimistic rollups gives an honest actor, an honest operator, plenty of time to stop withdrawals, hence it makes it virtually impossible for an attacker to exploit the bug and smart contract, so the operator could pause things. Operator could pause things, and I actually think that that actually does protect against ether deposits on the layer one from being revoked, or like, exploited from the bridge contract because that contract has a seven-day window on it on the ether. Yeah, totally. That actually makes me feel better about optimistic rollups. Yeah. Therefore, and so what he's saying here is there's a balance here with like, this seven-day window, we can make things trustless and smart contract-based without it being a multi-state thing, but you also have like, if it comes down to it like an operator can step in and do something inside of that seven-day window.
Same as what saved Ethereum during the Dow hack. Right, and same with the upgrade ability, while that is like a knock against, you know, it's more centralized for an optimistic rollup team to have upgrade ability, the fact that they have that sort of makes the funds more secure if you have some trust in them to be an honest actor. Yeah. Last few tweets from Bartek, hence it makes it virtually impossible for an attacker to exploit the bug in a smart contract because of that seven-day window, ZK rollups. If they contain the bug, might not be so lucky as there is no delay window there. Fun fact about ZK rollups, you can go in and out of ZK rollups instantaneously, but then you lose that seven-day window protection.
Bartek continues and says, therefore, it may be good to have a delay for big withdrawals and a cap on fast withdrawals to limit the potential damage. This is the approach that Maker Dow is taking with its teleport for canonical multi-chain die. They're making, Maker Dow is making wormholes for dyes across layer two's. So this is relevant there. Bartek says, if the fast withdrawal infrastructure is breached, Maker Dow, not die users, will take the loss, but up to a predefined limit. Is it risk that the Dow may be willing to take? The risk is no different than issuing a bad loan. If this is one bad loan out of a thousand good loans, this is okay.
You can be even more fancy and have more complex risk framework taking advantage of architectural properties of a given layer two to which you want to bridge to. Check out this proposal if you want to dive deeper. Then last couple of tweets, one prominent project that limits deposits in Starknet, openly admitting to still being alpha is one thing, but users typically ignore that. Deposit limits, keep Starknet's TVL artificially low, but this is good and responsible. We still need to look for the perfect bridge design and the cost of mistakes for the whole space is massive. In the meantime, users should be reasonable with how much funds they're moving out from the base layer.
I just want to go back to my culture statement. Bartek, previous at MakerDow, which is one of the dows that has been optimized for security, sends before this whole multi-chain world. MakerDow has been so risk-focused in its culture, and so that has now extended to Bartek and what they're doing at layer two B and all their risk frameworks for layer twos. Now all these layer twos are also focusing on the layer two B risk framework, coming from this very conservative layer two B team that's optimized for security the most. I will ask you, if you consider yourself a citizen, to be a citizen of a different chain, layer one chain, whether it's avalanche, salana, pick your chain.
Is there a culture of security in those chains that it resembles the culture of security that happens on Ethereum? This is the thing that has saved Ethereum from all of these bridges, from all of these exploits that you see happening elsewhere. There's a reason why so much exploits is happening external to Ethereum, because Ethereum only the paranoid survive. Only the paranoid survive, that's a great way to put it. This culture of security is why so fewer exploits happen inside of the Ethereum ecosystem. But also knock on wood there, David. Oh, I know what I mean. I know what I mean. Gladly knock on wood.
We can also compartmentalize out parts of the Ethereum app layer, like Wonderland for example, very risk-taking. There's many DeFi apps on Ethereum that are very, very not risk-adverse. But that's different. It's different from being risk-adverse on the app layer versus risk-adverse on the protocol layer. You definitely want to prioritize projects that... You definitely want to lean into projects that prioritize security over speed, in this case. And there are many shortcuts. Kyle? And the speed in front of things should cause some money. But we're dealing with a lot of money. This reminds me to what we always, you know, and bankless with, which this is the frontier.
You could lose what you put in. It's not for everyone. The frontier has kind of moved from main net Ethereum into the layer two space and into the side chain space. So now in order to bridge funds to a side chain, you know what, David, I need to receive a bit more return on my investment because it's a bit more risky over there than on main net. So these are all considerations as you're thinking about your journey, your bankless journey and your journey into crypto. I'm confident though, over time, these, you know, kind of like technical challenges. The code will become trusted, cemented, ossified, and that's really going to save us, kind of similar to a nososave.
I was skeptical of that in the early days. Now I'm not. Like, I'm fine putting, you know, a lot into inside of nososave. But I do think this is back to kind of a sad prediction that we made, bankless made, the beginning of 2022, that there will be more of these monster bridge hacks. So this is what we said. There will be some monster bridge hacks in 2022, we're starting to see them that will make people question their multi L1 chain thesis. And here's also what I mean because over time, you can get rid of and reduce the risk, the technical risk and the code risk, but you cannot reduce the economic risk and the Oracle attack risk, okay?
And unless you're on a layer two, unless you're, you know, doing some level of a roll-up strategy in the side chain strategy where we've got like, you know, networks of side chains, you will always have the economic risk of bridges. You will always have the Oracle attack risk of bridges and that ain't going away. And so this is a reason why I am much more bullish on kind of the Ethereum roadmap pooled security vision than on kind of like, there will be many chains and like, there's no real settlement platform of shared security between them. And because because there's just the bridge risk, people understate the bridge risk and events like this kind of highlight what a mistake it is to understate the bridge risk.
Anything else on this story, David? Yeah, just to finally tie it off. Like this industry is built on top of settlement assurances, which is basically property rights. Are you in a bankless paradigm where you own your own assets and no one can revoke those assets from you? Like that is what this industry is built on. Everything is built on strong settlement assurances. And so this is by the same way, the same vogue that the strongest, most secure layer one will always end up winning out. The most secure and strongest bridges will also be winning out. And this is why bridges that have the least amount of risk surface area will win over the bridges that have more surface area.
And those bridges are always going to be rolled up cryptographic bridges. There. There's your bridgication there. I think we've covered that thoroughly. Let's talk about the mysterious Salana wallet hack, too. That was crazy. Unrelated to bridges, but it was crazy this week. It's something there's like 5,000 wallets upwards, maybe closer to 10,000 wallets, basically Salana wallets. People looked inside of their wallet and they were like, oh my god, my money is no longer there. And I'm not talking about a centralized exchange wallets. I'm talking about sort of you have the private key to your wallet.
It's an, you know, phantom or some sort of, you know, metamask, for instance. And then all of a sudden, the fees are like the funds are withdrawn. How could this even happen? That was the question. So like a lot of a lot of Salana users for those that don't use Salana. It's like they opened up their metamask and like there was no money there anymore. Yes. It was all gone. And so big question of how does this happen? And how did it happen? Because there's kind of like a Sherlock Holmes, you know, the entire community, Ethereum Salana, the entire crypto community, was trying to figure out how this mass wallet drain actually happened.
Fortunately, not a lot of money, but it was like $6 million or something like this. But a lot of wallets were affected. You want to tell us the story here, David? Yeah. So here's the tweet thread. I'll just explain it better than I can. Because $6 million of soul and USDC have been stolen from over 8,000 Salana wallets. The hacker used private keys to drain user funds in what has been one of the craziest and most mysterious hacks in recent times. It all started when a few people noticed that some unusual outflows were happening from phantom wallets on Salana. Phantom, I think, is the most popular wallet on Salana.
Numerous reports started to pop across Twitter and Discord of users having fun drains from their wallets. Phantom wallet was quick to issue a statement saying that they do not believe that this is a phantom specific issue. Interesting. Interesting. And so developer and auditor X Fubar found that the attacker was stealing both soul and USD tokens from people's slope and phantom wallets, slope another wallet in the Salana ecosystem. The most logical thing to do, like this, is to revoke any access to any depth, as in like, you know, undue all permissions. But avalanche co-founder MN asserted that it's likely that the attack acquired access to private keys.
How did they do that? How did they get the hand on 8,000 different private keys? Not supposed to happen. And so this means that the only way to protect your assets is to move them onto a hardware wallet or onto a centralized exchange. So this was a hot wallet exploit. Salana finally responded after hours of speculation that stated that over 7,767 wallets have been affected by the exploit so far. But what was soon made matters worse was that RPC nodes started pinging as offline. This indicated that the Salana network was down, causing more panic across Twitter. It was theorized that the nodes were being purposefully de-dost by developers in order to slow down the hackers.
This backfired as it caused additional confusion, oof. Supposedly, the de-dost attack was aimed at the hacker, which subsequently resulted in RPC nodes failing. Oh god, what a mess. Okay, keep on. The most concerning part of the lack of clarity surrounding the cause of the issue, even Salana co-founder Anatoly couldn't offer verdict despite alluding to iOS imported wallets being the key target. He and other key Salana figures surveyed their audience for data trying to get to them to the bottom of the exploit, almost attempting to conduct an on-the-go-porse modem. This indicates to me that we are dealing with a highly complex exploit.
As of now, the issue is still being investigated. Salana's latest update says that they continue to investigate the route's cause, and it does not appear to be a bug within Salana core code. We do know the route cause though now, I think this tweet thread kind of trails off at a time when we didn't know the route cause. Do you have any information on the route cause, David? So, in a different tweet, Zerox Fubar, who is apparently really good at deducing stuff like this, says, it looks like the slope wallet sent plain text seed phrases to external integration partners. I'm sorry. What? What? They've not mysterious at all, just like another new mistake.
They just sent... Okay, so that's like... You know, Metamask, it gives you your seed phrase, and it lets you copy it down. That's like if Metamask was sending that same seed phrase to, like, Infura, and Infura was just like logging that. And so, that's absolutely crazy. Compromised phantom wallets came from seed phrases importing... It ports used in slope. Compromised ETH wallets were also from seed phrase reuse. So, I guess some Ethereum wallets were even compromised for people that generated their wallet using slope. This is not a blockchain or a random issue, randomness issue. This is a terribly irresponsible service provider issue.
People are then later issues of correction saying the slope wallet did not send seed phrases to external partners, but may have logged them in their own centralized servers. Okay, well, then they're the external partner. Apologies for getting a bit ahead of myself for working on some programs. Whether they sent it to a third party or not, the fact that they were logging seed phrases in the database, anywhere in plain text, where it could be hacked, that is a massive problem. That is terrible. Don't save other people's seed phrases. I think mysterious here is just a really bad wallet provider, basically, which is generally bad wallet provider.
I mean, people were worried that there was like a blockchain issue, a randomness issue. It's like quantum computers, it's like hacked people's private keys. Something like this, it was so mysterious and it turns out it was just average, everyday sharing private keys via plain text, and that's what screwed it over. So, mystery solved, I guess, David. Do you have any private key advice for us, though? I do have one, but actually, before I do that, I would like to actually just show the Coinbase app. I'm not logged in because I don't have a Coinbase account, but they have a multi-party computation wallet, so you can go and use your Coinbase app as a centralized exchange, as everyone does.
But you can also go and trade specifically on Uniswap or do stuff on MakerDow or pull together, because Coinbase has a multi-party computation wallet built into their app. So not only is it a centralized custodian with a exchange built in, like we know, but it's also a self-sovereign wallet with multi-party computation, meaning that they have a shard of your private key, your phone also has a shard of your private key, so they can restore your private key, but they don't have your private key. That's crazy. So, Coinbase doesn't get enough credit for that, and so Coinbase, Coinbase app, and this is not even Coinbase wallet, this is the Coinbase consumer app.
I want to go find out more about that wallet, because that is a really cool feature. We talked about it on a roll-up, remember they came out with the permissionless conference? Yeah, I didn't realize they had already rolled it out to the main core consumer app. Yeah, it's great. It's great. There are some pieces of the design that are a bit more centralized than, say, a smart contract wallet, but it's like this nice place in the middle where it's a cool compromise, and as you said, they're getting it out to users right away. It's much better than a completely customized centralized wallet provider.
Anyway, wait, wait, before that, though, we had a guest on it, who was like, they were explaining me, he was Mark Cuban, he was talking to his friends, and I downloaded Coinbase, and I couldn't find the DeFi tab. There is now literally a DeFi tab in the Coinbase app, and you can do DeFi things, and from the user perspective, they get private keys, but they don't even know it, and they can't lose them. It's great. So here's what I say. This isn't the best advice, but it definitely works. It's a little bit of a brute force method. I say, every six months or so, I generate a new set of private keys, and I rotate my walls.
And this removes all build-up of smart contract approval risk. And so I generate my own private keys using like my ledger, and then every six months ago, I just take my assets, and I plop them into the new address. There are ways to achieve these same results. If you're worried about approval risk, you can just manually unapproved things. But also, this also risk is another thing to worry about. It's not at play in either of these two acts. It's just yet another thing you have to worry about. Yes. If you approve a contract, it sets permissions to all, like that contract can do whatever you want with all of your money.
But you can manually revoke those, so you can get security that way. But this also removes any sort of accidental internet exposure to my private keys. There's been one times, I have a piece of paper. I don't have it with me. I keep it elsewhere. Careful, op-sexer. I have a piece of paper with every previous seed phrase that I've ever used, whether I've generated it with Metamask, whether I've generated it with ledger. It's got all my historical private keys on it, and it's somewhere in the world, I'm not going to say where. It's not with me. It's not where I live. But the reason why I keep that is for like, airdrops, right?
Sometimes, some airdrop happens, and I'm like, fuck, I have to go like, type in all of these old seed phrases to go, let's check out which one of these airdrops is relevant to the airdrop. I typed them into Metamask, and so what was previously a ledger seed phrase becomes like a Metamasky phrase, making it a hot wallet, I'm basically putting all of my previous ledger seed phrases into my Metamask, making it exposed to the internet. What I do is I generate a new set of private keys, and then in the appropriate way, not release to the internet, and then I make it find a new address, and I send all my assets to that brand new address, and so it's like always like a rotation of just like, you don't, can't find me, can't catch me, can't catch me.
I do not do any of those things, but I'm not sure if your method is like better than what I do. What do you do? Well, yeah, I'm not going to disclose that, David, but this is a beautiful thing about this is like, I can tell about my private key management, because it doesn't matter, because it's always changing. Yeah, so I do think we should have an episode that is just all about like best practices or op-seq in private key management, like on the bankless journey, just, you know, it's not somebody that needs to disclose what they're doing, but it's like, what are the best practices? 10 best practices, different methods, practical, real world, because like, this stuff's hard, as we call it, the bankless journey for a reason, like, and bad things can happen to you, like bridge hacks, like Oracle attacks, like economic attacks, you have to be careful what you use.
And suddenly, one day, if you use the wrong wallet, all your money gets stolen, like, this is not easy stuff, and the rewards are great on the other side, as we always say, with, you know, kind of going bankless, but, um, so are the risks, the risks are great as well. Anyway, uh, that's your strategy, that's David's strategy. It's a nuclear of a strategy, you know, like, there's definitely other ways to achieve the same ends, but it's interesting, yeah, it's definitely cool. Uh, all right, are we going to get any tokens, David, last thing, are we going to get any tokens from a new ETH proof of work chain, do you think, uh, some free forked ETH before the merge?
No. No, you will not. Yes, I mean, yes, you will have ETH or proof of work, no, it will be worth pennies. Uh, there's like a bunch of, like, people on Twitter talking about, oh, the proof of work chain, the proof of work chain, we're going to fork Ethereum and get all the, like, this extra tokens and extra ETH, like, no, no, you're not, some, what's going to happen is that some people are going to, are writing, already writing transactions right now, that are going to be sent in that very first or second block on the Ethereum proof of work chain that sells all of their tokens for Ether and Uniswap, it removes all of their ether from compound and maker, it basically, there's going to be a massive run on the bank, except the bank is proof of work ether.
So every single token is going to go to zero, uh, and there's actually a thread that, that we should read. Uh, so let's go to the thread by the, uh, lemonscape. And, uh, this is Mark Zeller from AVE and goes a short thread about ETH proof of work and was quite, like, quite likely to happen overnight with a fork, a carbon copy of the full Ethereum ecosystem appears. You have 10 ETH, well, you also have 10 ETH proof of work. You have a position, an AVE, now you have that same position on proof of work AVE. So let's begin with the big simple consequences. ETH proof of work means no proof of stake.
So, stake's ETH is now worth zero because it'll never be redeemable because it's on the stake's eth chain. On AVE proof of work, that means there's a 1.0 billion dollar hole in the book because it's an AVE accounts for the value of stake's ETH, but the proof of work's ETH is goes to zero. On maker proof of work, that's a 100 million dollars of dye backed by zero. That is absolute mayhem by the way. That is absolute mayhem. Yeah, all of this on all the collateral and all the lending apps go to zero. You can't have any fiat back stablecoin doubling the supply, obviously overnight. So USDC and USDT proof of work supply goes to zero.
So also collateral and maker Dow and elsewhere. Circle and tether can perhaps later support ETH proof of work, but the only way is to issue new ERC20 tokens and forget the old ones. That's an additional 1.7 billion dollars hole in AVE proof of work that also means that 73 percent of collateral, maker Dow collateral overnight is worth zero. So sorry to say, but this means that dye proof of work and MKR proof of work are now also worth zero because MKR needs to get minted to cover debts in the maker Dow system. But when your debt is billions of dollars and that brand new MKR token on the proof of work chain is already worth zero.
So like, you know, you have to inflate your token that's already worth zero by infinity, making it worth zero even more. And so like just massive holes in collateral because like none of these tokens are worth anything on the proof of work chain. Basically, what's happening is like the token ecosystem, the DeFi app layer is going to be comfortable. It leads mayhem. The application layer of the proof of work chain is dividing by zero. It is imploding on on block number one. And so this also happens for like uniswap, sushi swap, all your favorite protocols, all tokens become worth zero because there's nothing there.
And so if all the tokens are worth zero, what happens? And this is where like the whole run on the bank metaphor comes from. The agenda for, yes, the conclusion DeFi proof of work is debt on arrival. And so here's what Lemons gate says, the agenda for ETH proof of work shills, AMM liquidity will still be around because there will be like uni versus ETH pairs on the proof of work chain. But if you have any uni tokens, you're just going to like remove them all and buy as much ETH power as possible. You have stakes, ETH tokens. And ETH power is the new ether. It's going to the left over ether. Yes.
And not officially. This is what people are calling it. So do you have any stakes, ETH tokens, because those are worth zero. So you go to curve, proof of work curve, and you dump those for ETH power until AMMs are full of tokens and empty of proof of work ether. So all tokens are being immediately sold for ether, proof of work ether, because it's the only token that has any like feasible semblance of having any value whatsoever. The plan is to collect as many ETH proof of work tokens as possible, while shilling it on Twitter as like the one true ETH, that's what people do, that's what opportunities do.
And then they wait for tier C centralized exchange listings, like Polonies, a deposit there, and then try and dump it on like victims trying to buy this shill. That's the plan. Everyone knows it. People have been talking about this for years. We've known this is going to be a thing for years. And so if you are a listener, and you're like, ooh, yay, I did like proof of work ether, I get some extra ether, are you going to be the bot that writes these transactions? Because there's going to be a war on the first and second block of the proof of work ethereum chain to do all of these things, and it's all going to be over in two blocks.
Are you the listener capable of fighting that fight and getting your transaction in first ahead of the box? Because if you are not, then you are not getting anything. That's the end of story. I still think, so yes, that's one thing you're having right now, dude, what do you still think? What I still think that what could happen is some narrative spinner rises up, you know, the Craig Wright of Pow-Eath, the Roger Verre, Paul Jesus rises up and says, I will bring you a new narrative for this asset class. This is the truth. And like we've just seen this happen so many times, David, yeah, there have been a lot of Bitcoin forks previously, most of them have completely failed.
But a few of them have had some actual like multi-month, multi-year shelf-lives, and those are the ones that are led by kind of some benevolent dictator, cult figure, you know, sort of religious figure. But ultimately, I don't know about it in Roger Verre's case, but Craig Wright's case very clearly manipulating the community and trying to kind of like exit, exit scam, exit dump them. I know it's more complicated than a Bitcoin fork because Ethereum has this massive DeFi app layer. But as he said, that's going to sort itself out, it's going to be completely drained. It's all going to go to Eath Pow.
There could be a figure that rises up and says, I'm going to take this narrative, I'm going to push it forward, I'm going to create a developer roadmap, I'm going to gather some funding, I'm going to get the help of Eath Pow minors. And the narrative could have a shelf life longer than a week, maybe multiple months. Again, I really don't care in either case. Like if that happens, then maybe there's some Eath Pow, I can later sell. And that's a great thing. But all I would say is, I think that is also a possibility. Possibility, this thing fades out in like a day or a week. It's also a possibility because we've seen it before, some cult leader rises and brings a narrative to this chain and gives it some level of life because we've also seen that before.
Is that going to be you, Ryan? You're going to be that cult leader? It's not me, man. It's not me. I mean, like, I do not have that will and no interest in doing that. So there's a there's a video that I like that I think resembles what's going to happen in blocks one and two of the proof of work chain. And here's a video of a San Diego fire, a fourth of July, where they accidentally had like a computer exploit, a computer bug. And instead of having a 45 minute firework show, every single firework just went off at once. So we had like 45 minutes worth of fireworks all going down in like 30 seconds.
And that's basically what's going to happen to this proof of work app layer. You think it's just going to be short, very short show. And then it's over. Yeah. Next. All right. Coming up next. Sailor stepping down as CEO of micro strategy to do what? To do what? Perhaps to buy more Bitcoin, probably. And also Tiffany's selling CryptoPun jewelry? I have a CryptoPun. Will I be getting a Tiffany's CryptoPun necklace? I really like it. Stay tuned to find out. But I think you already know. But if you don't, stick around to find out. We'll be right back right after we talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
Arbitrum is an Ethereum layer 2 scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Some of the coolest new NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home, while DeFi protocols continue to see increased liquidity and usage. You can now bridge straight into Arbitrum from more than 10 different exchanges, including finance, FTX, Kuobi and Crypto.com. Once on Arbitrum, you'll enjoy fast transactions with cheap fees, allowing you to explore new frontiers of the crypto universe. New to Arbitrum for a limited time, you can get Arbitrum NFTs designed by the famous artist Ratwell and Sue Goi for joining the Arbitrum Odyssey.
The Odyssey is an eight week long event, where you can play on chain activities and receive a free NFT as a reward. Find out more by visiting the discord at discord.gg slash Arbitrum. You can also bridge your assets to Arbitrum at bridge.arbitrum.io and access all of Arbitrum's apps at portal.arbitrum.1 in order to experience DeFi and NFTs, the way it was always meant to be fast, cheap, secure and friction free. The layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day, and we need layer 2 bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live in layer 2 life. Across is the fastest, cheapest and most secure cross-chain bridge.
With across, you don't have to worry about high fees or long wait times, assets are bridge and available for use almost instantaneously. Across is bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic Oracle to securely transfer tokens between layer 2's and Ethereum. Across is critical ecosystem infrastructure, and across V2 has just launched. Their new version focuses on higher capital efficiency, layer 2 to layer 2 transfers, and a brand new chain with Polygon all while prioritizing high security and low fees. You can be a part of a crosses story by joining their discord and using across for all of your layer 2 transferring needs.
So go to across.io to quickly and securely bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Polygon, Arbitrum or Boba Networks. Alright guys, we're back and speaking of bridge compromises again, Abe seems to be stepping back from its multi-chain strategy and why? Because there's some of these bridge compromises that have been happening. So Abe stepping back from phantom, I believe, which is sort of an EVM fork chain. Mark Zeller, who we were just talking about, said this, the rationale is after the Harmony Bridge event, the recent Nomad Bridge exploit, the Abe community should consider the risk benefits of keeping an active Abe V3 market on phantom.
As this network is dependent on any swap multi-chain bridge, Zeller actually, in the tweet thread as well, he said he was wrong. He said, hey, I was wrong to be so aggressive on kind of the multi-chain strategy. And yeah, that was just really, really interesting to hear from him. It's like not wrong in a big way, but maybe a bit more aggressive during the bull market and now seeing that, hey, some of these risks are real. And by the way, who knows that anyone who ever admits they're wrong in crypto? Certainly. Because that is a rare event in and of itself. Yeah. I mean, basically, this is a classic cost-benefit calculation.
Is how much fees is Abe generating on phantom? And how much is that risk of that multi-chain bridge? And Abe governance, this isn't a formal thing. This is a governance proposal, but the proposal is saying, hey, the cost of rewards is just not there. So let's just trim phantom. I mean, it makes sense in a bear market where some chains don't really make it. So phantom, not doing so hot. All right, moving on, SushiSwap, new head chef is asking for one third of all the tokens that are paid to the staff, which is a very contentious proposal, but there's a Dow debate with SushiSwap about how well compensated the SushiSwap head chef should be.
I kind of think that SushiSwap means some sort of highly competent, highly centralized leader to kind of steward this ship, especially as we're seeing things kind of like drift off in the bear market. But SushiSwap, going through some governance debates right now. That's like executive compensation debate in Dow's right now. That's kind of interesting. Right. Here's a great thread out of optimism about optimism, bedrock, which says optimism, bedrock coming soon, TM. And when it does, it will change the roll-up game forever. It will lay the Protocols Foundation for years to come and serve as the model for knit roll-up architecture.
Its name is bedrock for good reason. There are a few awesome things that this bedrock architecture does for optimism. It reduces the L1 to L2 deposit time by 4x, and it also slashes the cost of data submission by 20% making fees, 20% cheaper. But those are all really cool things that all the users can understand. But really, the really bullish thing is this third thing, cuts the difference with geth down to a slim 500 lines of code. And so Kevin Filstner, who is on the optimism team, he puts this tweet together and goes, optimism's bedrock design is the most advanced roll-up architecture ever built.
Is not a competition, bedrock is close to theoretically optimal on every front. Optimal transaction fees, optimal diff, difference, optimal networking, optimal block production. And what they are mean by optimal is related to this 500 fee difference between optimism bedrock and geth. They're trying to get as close to Ethereum equivalents as possible. And so when we talk about bridge risk and all these smart contract risk, when you reduce the lines of code down to something like geth, which has been tried and true in Ethereum for eight years and running now, then you have stronger assurances that there's less and less attack surface area.
And so when I see these words like theoretically optimal on every front, I get like really hot and bothered Ryan because I love things that are theoretically optimal. And so the fewer lines between geth and the layer 2, the more secure you can feel about using these layer 2s. And the other thing I'll say about this is when you have something that is closer and closer and closer to geth, the software that we've already been using Ethereum for years, you can like bedrock can become like a foundation for a thousand roll-ups to bloom because it's not that complicated. It's so simple. It's so close to this infrastructure that we've already had.
So the forcibility of bedrock to allow a thousand secure layer 2s to bloom is like off the charts. So I'm just super bullish about that. Yeah, I am glad that optimistic roll-ups are innovating. And of course, Arbitram's Nitro is coming up too. So it's like bedrock versus Nitro and they're kind of competing for attention and energy. Nitro also something that is trying to emulate geth as well. These are the same design structures. Yeah. Very similar design structures and patterns and I'm just happy to see them worrying it out for users. David, did you know the theorem chain is seven years old? Happy birthday to Ethereum.
Happy birthday to Ethereum. Yay. Hey, here's a picture of a talent in his dad. Unrelated actually from Ethereum's birthday. Definitely related, father son. Sure. Yeah, great to see them on Ethereum's birthday. Big coin stuff. Big coin stuff. Yeah, Michael Saylor leaves the CEO role to assume executive chairman role. So Michael Saylor no longer the CEO of MicroStrategy is stepped down while a different individual stepped into the CEO of MicroStrategy was making sense. I mean, he's become so interested in big coin. He's much less interested in like, you know, MicroStrategy is a business analytics company.
Right. You know, kind of software for like business dashboards and stuff like that. Things are unrelated to Bitcoin. Yeah. Yeah. So he's very interested in Bitcoin. He has like 70% voting majority over MicroStrategy. It's basically he governs MicroStrategy and now is decided to step down to pursue Bitcoin initiatives. So to buy more Bitcoin. I guess I guess that's what he's doing. There's a take from the seem to lab here. What is he saying? Yeah, and the seem to lab who's all famously anti Bitcoin says, how much of the 120,000 Bitcoin will they have to sell another nail in the coffin to the will never sell?
I actually don't think there's any precedent. Like no, like actually they're leaning into Bitcoin not trying to sell, but it's just fine. You mean MicroStrategy? Yeah. You don't think like Saylor was kind of like asked to leave or something and go focus on Bitcoin. If that's what he's so interested in. I think that is what happened. They're like Saylor, like this MicroStrategy company still needs to do its MicroStrategy things. You become like the chairman of buying Bitcoin because like you have Bitcoin CEO. You have Bitcoin CEO. Yeah, but no, Nicholas just wants to grave dance even though there's no grave to dance on.
Anyway, I don't know. They might sell more Bitcoin as a result of this, but hopefully not in the bear market. I still I still contend. I think MicroStrategy's Bitcoin buys are going to pay off for them. And like these kind of tweets will not hold up well because Bitcoin is going to go up in price. That's still like the bottom line to me and just people are impatient and they always like the point when things are down and say, oh, it'll never work out. And then they never come back and correct themselves. Right. But Tiffany's, what do they do in the NFT space? They are doing NF tips. NF Tiffany's, I guess, releasing on August 5th is that tomorrow?
Yeah, that is tomorrow. 250, I believe, Tiffany's crypto punk NFT necklaces, jeweled necklaces are being released at the low, low price of 30, 250 limited edition crypto punk necklaces being sold for $51,000 price of 30. What's the crypto punk necklace? Yeah. So here's the video. It'll play out. Wait, how much is this? What are we looking at? $51,000. This is just an NFT. So you can't have a real necklace. It's a real necklace. It's a real necklace. Real diamonds, real rubies. Yeah. It's a real necklace. What's the NFT part? So you can't mint any crypto punk, you can have a Tiffany's necklace of your crypto punk for 30th.
Is this something that is wanted, like, what's the market for this, David? Well, there's only 250 of them in this, and it's one of these things where, like, if you are somebody who's going to buy one of these things, you're going to confuse all the other people who are, like, why the hell are you buying it? Like, it only takes 250 people to, like, yeah, find out by one of these. $50,000. I love this. Here's a take from Aubrey. Aubrey's trouble. Imagine your boyfriend gives you a Tiffany box, and you open it up, and it's a crypto punk. I'm sure that they would just love that. That would be so great for them.
I'm sure they would just be overjoyed. There's someone out there, though, that's going to buy one, and be happy to receive one. But you just have to find that special someone, David. All right. Keep on looking. Magic Eden. Oh my God. They changed their Twitter handle to Magic Ethan. Well, first of all, what is Magic Eden? Yeah, it's a Salana NFT platform. It's like the Open Sea of Salana. What are they doing? They are now becoming the Magic Eden of Ethereum. So they are integrating Ethereum into their NFT platform. That seems like Wise Expansion Strategy. What do we got here? David. Yeah. So this is like, of course, I'm sure triggered some of the Salani Maxis out there.
I was like, oh, you guys are abandoning Salana to go into Ethereum, even though they are just trying to make the best NFT platform that exists. And Shaq replies to the sweet, Shaqilo Neal replies to the sweet and says, I wonder, and people wonder why I took Dot Soul out of my name. I didn't even know Shaq had Dot Soul in his name. Ryan. Ryan commenting saying, but you didn't add Dot Eath. 1700 likes on that. Shaq wearing what it looks like, some sort of like ape as his profile picture, that's what he's saying. This is not clear to me. Why did he take Dot Soul out of his name? Is it because? You can scroll down and they will be a little bit more of a conversation.
He says, there's no point in picking a side anymore, everyone needs to stop tearing each other down. Yeah. Well, I take that to you. And then Evan Van Ness says, no one needs to tear Salana down. That's always down. Oh. Cheers. Man, great culture. Oh, man. Yeah. What's Rainbow doing? The Wallet NFT Wallet. Yeah. Speaking more NFT stuff. Now supporting NFTs on mainnet, Polygon, Arbitrum, and Optimism. For some reason saying, thank you, TreasureDow for the gift. I wonder, oh, they got a little, some small, the TreasureDowes and ecosystem, NFT ecosystem on Arbitrum. Anyways, NFTs on Rainbow Wallet.
That's cool. Optimistic NFTs, Arbitrum, NFTs on Rainbow Wallet. What do we got here? Aspect. Yeah. StarCnet mainnet is this NFTs for StarCnet? Yeah, NFTs on StarCnet, the generalized ZK Rollup platform out of StarCware. So cool. That means super cheap NFTs, super cheap, super fast. Regulation. Let's talk about this really quick. Robinhood was just fine $30 million from the New York State Department of Financial Services NYDFS. And why were they charged for this? It looks like some sort of money laundering issue. What did they do? Yeah. They said the NFNYDFS charge Robinhood because they were inadequately staffed, didn't have sufficient resources to address risks and failed timely transaction from a manual transaction monitoring system to one that was adequate for his user size and transaction volume.
Really not adequately monitoring like AML and money laundering, shenanigans. I have no takes on this kind of, you know, New York State Department is always a bit, you know, crypto unfriendly, I would say, I wouldn't be surprised if they're blowing a big, small thing out of proportion, but also I do not know. But this is cool, David, a Senate bill that would hand Bitcoin and Ether oversight to the commodities regulated, the CFTC basically institute by law and say that Ether and Bitcoin are commodities. It's kind of a reigning Gary Gensler in the SEC ban. I know they're spit like the SEC's never given us a super straight take on whether Ether is a commodity or security or how they view it.
They've been a bit more clear on Bitcoin as being a commodity, but we sort of need this legislation, spit of reigning in from the SEC to at least say, these two assets we know clearly are commodities. Right. And this follows from, I think, Hester person a few others takes of saying, like, good crypto regulation is ultimately going to come from Congress, not these three letter agencies that we do not elect. And so if Congress could go ahead and please approve this one, that would be great. Gary Gensler, Niner, Niner, Boo Boo, get your hands off our commodities. And yet I got to give credit where it's due, the SEC this week charged a group called Forsage, Forsage, Forsage, Forsage, Forsage, I don't know, Forsage.
This was a $300 billion crypto Ponzi scheme. And I vaguely remember this. It was just blatantly a Ponzi kind of bit connect level stuff. And this is the sort of thing that we want the SEC to do. It's like, there's so many bad guys and clear scams in the crypto space, please help us go catch them. Right. Like go after them, give us clarity, give the good actors in the space, sandbox a playground and go chase after the clear scammers because there's enough of that work to go do. And this is an example of them doing that, doing the right thing, going after a clear Ponzi scheme. Well done. Thank you, Gary.
Well done. You did something great. David, can you believe this is still happening? Yeah. So like, add insult to injury. What's happening here? Celciates admits customer emails linked in third party data breach. So not only did you lose your money, but you also lost your privacy with Celciates. And two for one punch. Thanks guys. Babel Finance, $280 million loss. People finance as a CFI crypto lender. We've seen them before lost $250 million in customer funds, doing trading. They're trying to trade their way into profit, but they traded their way into losses. With their customers fund. With their customers fund.
Another CFI company, more popular in Asia, David, some good news on the releases front Coinbase Prime is now offering a theorem staking to institutions in the US. More staking heating up. What is the swell network here, David? Yeah, swell network is also part of the Ethereum staking world. Lido, Rocketpool, Stakewise, a few others, but it's also swell network soon. This is a kind of an oddly anticipated staking as a service like Dow, kind of like Lido, but also a little bit like Rocketpool. Mainnet release candidate is now live, which means that they are only one step away from Mainnet Go live.
So I'm very excited for swell. So we know that GameStop has been working with Immutable, but now that relationship is formally intertwined with a GameStop wallet. And so the GameStop NFC ecosystem and the Immutable Layer 2 system are now integrated. So you can only imagine that like the Immutable X Layer 2 is going to be facilitating the marketplace for GameStop getting a little bit closer to that here. I think the wallet has been based on loop ring. So it looks like they're using multiple Layer 2s as their strategy, not just loop ring, but also the Immutable. Both CK rollups though. Yeah, absolutely.
David, on the raises front, variant fund. This is a fund from Jesse, who else is on the side? Jesse Walden, Lee Jen. Yes. Lee Jen, of course. $450 million to support the leading founders in Web 3. This is kind of the creator economy type of investment, and they just raised $450 million. So impressive. Yeah. Gary Vee from V friends just closed around with A16Z crypto. So this is a $50 million round. I believe. That's a lot of money. That's a lot for Gary Vee's NFT project. Yeah. Kind of impressive valuations happening during the bear market still, too. So I guess there's money. There's raises.
What does that mean for jobs, David? That there are jobs. If there's money and there's raises, then there are jobs. That's how it works. Let me read a few out. The first from Boardroom Labs, they're looking for a software engineer over Dow governance. It's a core games, a manager of crypto marketing. That's not technical. We're looking for thread ores. You can write it. Twitter thread. Twitter. Twitter. Yeah. As we are, but apparently we don't have time to write enough threads. Vertex protocol, a marketing coordinator. That's not technical. That's not technical. Bankless, we're looking for a UX UI designer.
Bank is also, we need a senior newsletter, engineers, crypto streams, a financial analyst, stakefish, smart contract software engineer, also a backend software engineer, also a blockchain marketer. No, I'm technical. Also, a dev ops engineer in the bankless academy is hiring a product manager. There's a ton more jobs here. You can go find them at the bank. Wait, wait, wait. There's a head of marketing at pleaser, Dow. I just want to shout that one out. Also got to be a very, very cool job. One hundred to two hundred thousand dollar salary, head of marketing at pleaser, Dow. Come join the Dow.
A Willy Wonka. Pleaser, Dow is the people's Louvre and the 21st century and a Willy Wonka factory combined. That's very attractive. Only in crypto. All right, when we get back, some questions from the bankless nation. What's the safest token to dollar cost average into over the next 12 months? Also, the best advice for actually getting a job in crypto and some hot takes from crypto, Twitter, as usual, will get right to those things. But first, we want to tell you about the sponsors that made this episode possible. There is a brand new staking feature in the Ledger Live app today. We all like staking the assets that we're bullish on and now you can stake seven different coins inside the Ledger Live app.
Those most polka dot, tron, algorithms, tezos, Solana, and of course, Ethereum. With Ledger Live, you can take money from your bank account, buy your most bullish crypto asset and stake that asset to its network all inside the Ledger Live app. Through a partnership with Figment, Ledger also lets you choose which validator you want to stake your assets with. And Ledger is running its own validating notes, offering a convenient way to participate in network validation and it even comes with slashing insurance. Ledger Live is truly becoming the battle station for the bankless world. So go download Ledger Live.
If you have a Ledger already, you probably already have it and get started securely staking your crypto assets. The Brave browser is the user first browser for the Web3 internet. With over 60 million monthly active users. And inside the Brave browser, you'll find the Brave wallet. The secure multi-training crypto wallet built right into the browser. Web3 is freedom from big tech and Wall Street, more control and better privacy, but there's a weak point in Web3, your crypto wallet. And most crypto wallets are browser extensions which can easily be spoofed, but the Brave wallet is different. No extensions are required, which gives Brave browser an extra level of security versus other wallets.
Brave wallet is your secure passport for the possibilities of Web3 and supports multiple chains, including Ethereum and Selama. You can even buy crypto directly inside the wallet with RAM. And of course, you can store, send, and swap your crypto assets, manage your NFTs, and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps. So whether you're new to crypto or you're a season pro, it's time to ditch those risky extensions and it's time to switch to the Brave wallet. Download Brave at brave.com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. All right, guys, we are back and just a reminder, if you have a question for Dave and myself to read out on the rollup, make sure you follow bankless HQ on Twitter.
Every Wednesday, Tweet goes out and asks for those questions. Here's the first question from mag80.eath. If you had to monthly dollar cost average into one asset for the next 12 months, what would it be? Except ETH. I'm thinking RPL, that's the Ruck Pultokin and Uni. Of course, got to say, none of this is financial advice. Of course. Asking David's personal opinion from an entertainment perspective. I want the real answer, but also it's fine if it's entertaining, David. I actually genuinely want to know, what would you buy besides ETH right now? Yeah, I think Madge is on to something with Uni.
I think that is, if we're not talking about ETH, and we're not counting staked ETH, which I'm assuming we're not, then the Uni token definitely comes next. The reason why I feel like very arguably the safest is because it's generating the most fees. That, I feel like, is a great definition of safety. Right now, Uniswap generated $1.1 million two-day in 24-hour fees. There's already discussions on the Uniswap governance forum about turning on the fee switch, so we're getting there. If we're going to find out what is the best asset for the next 12 months to buy, it's the one with fees. The ones that come after that, like, AVE, GMX, also surprisingly up there, and so tokens with fees are bullish, and so there's probably some analysis to be done about how much fees is the protocol generating compared to how big that market cap is with a controlling function of how much percentage can that protocol capture as a result of those fees.
Some analysis to be done there. Great token because the merge trade is a merge trade in the last for 12 months. I'm not sure, but Uniswap fees will definitely last for 12 months. I agree. I'm going to ignore Bitcoin because I actually think I would still prioritize DeFi tokens right now over Bitcoin, and maybe that's for the first time ever. I would have generally, my answer is Ethan Bitcoin, those are the assets to dollar cost average into you. As my personal opinion, it would probably be some of those blue chip DeFi assets. I like Uni and AVE, know they're going to be around very strong, although I also like a lot of the strong layer 2 projects that have tokens right now.
I feel like that's a decent bet, and I would pick those over the alternative layer 1 bet. Even though Slon is going to survive, obviously Cosmos, they are all going to survive, but I still feel like layer 2 is being unappreciated, so you got Matic token, you got OP, some of those things as well. I would consider dollar cost averaging into some of those as well. This isn't necessarily the question that's like, what's the token, the asset that you're going to make the most money on in the next 12 months? This is more the one that you're going to buy and hold from a risk reward perspective. I do think that even, it's like RPL and Lido and Stakewise are all benefiting from the merge trade.
I think general DeFi tokens that you swap and synthetics are also going to benefit from just the beta of the merge, like Ether goes up, taking as a service tokens goes up, but then Ethereum apps are also going to go up. It's going to be an Ethereum rotation, so I think the beta is in heavily favorite of the Ethereum ecosystem at the moment. Yeah, I would say that too, and I do like some of those Staking tokens as well. I'd start to classify them as close to Blue Chip. Here's another question, David, from Patrick Dudley. What advice would you give a college student looking to get a job in crypto after they graduate?
I'm going to my senior year at SDSU and really want to pursue a career in crypto. Yeah, definitely the unequivocally best advice for getting a job in crypto. If you want to get a job, the formula is as simple as this. Write really good threads on Twitter. People are doing this. If you want to get a job at a fund, funds will notice you on Twitter. If you want to get a job at Bankless, we are literally hiring a tweet thread or people that can write threads and get a thousand likes and just generate a following and capture attention on Twitter. If you can do that, you will be handed a job on a silver platter.
For people who are on Twitter, what does it take to actually write a thread, David? What does a thread do on Twitter? It distills information down, and the reason why Twitter is what it is in the crypto space is that it forces big ideas to be condensed and collapse and concentrated down to into a very short, single tweet, 280 characters. What you are doing when you are writing a tweet thread is you are learning how to communicate and explain things with extremely small packages. That's just good, efficient communication. It's basically a litmus test for can you communicate very, very well. If you can thread well, you can communicate well.
If you can communicate well, that's like the meta skill. People are judging other people's abilities to do good work by their ability to write threads. Yeah, I'm going to plus one that also forces you to go digest some complicated information and break it down atomically. You have to really understand it if you're going to publish in thread. Of course, because Twitter is a social network, it's basically your online resume, you can tweet people and do it. Get off of LinkedIn. Get on to Twitter. Totally. That's where crypto is. That's where you get noticed. I've seen so many people launch their career by doing that is becoming threaders.
You start to write in other areas or you get hired by a VC company or whatever your main skill set is, that's the way to launch. Both me and Ryan launched our public personas on Twitter and then we found each other on Twitter and then we started bankless on Twitter and now we're hiring tweet threaders for Twitter. It's like, there's just such a serendipity to it. You got to be part of it. You can't ignore Twitter right now. All right, David. Let's get to some takes. First from Balaji. This is, I'm going to read it out from Balaji, Shrinivasan actually podcast episode coming with him on Monday.
That is a do not miss episode. We talk about concepts like this, but here's what he's tweeting. The real lining from red versus blue to orange versus green, decentralized network versus centralized state, internationalists and capitalists versus nationalists and socialists, the cloud versus the land and Bitcoin versus the dollar and he's showing that political compass square. I mean, you can describe this image for us what we're seeing here, David. Yeah, the political compass is on the left. You have the left on the right. You have the right. So liberals on the left conservatives on the right politically, but top to down, you have a authoritarianism versus libertarianism.
We've said on bankless, bankless isn't a left for or right movement, but it is an individual versus authoritarian movement. So we lean down towards the libertarian side of things. Although would you appreciate structure, it's definitely prioritizing the individual over the state. What Balaji is saying is that what is previously a red versus blue left versus right phenomenon is slowly turning into a 99% versus 1%, which he's resembling as Bitcoin versus the dollar. The dollar being the state, Bitcoin being the people. And so I think that makes sense, especially as we've been putting this into a context of the end of a cycle of nation state power, where the nation state is no longer concerned about like, do we want to be conservative or do we want to be progressive?
We are now just like, all right, who's capturing all the value? Is it the individual or is it the incumbents? And so this is the instead of left versus right, Balaji is saying it's top versus down. Yeah, and this goes into his idea of book he recently come up with that we talk about at length is a book called The Network State. He's really beginning this as it's kind of the authoritarian nation state versus the people's network state. Anyway, really fascinating conversation with him. Stay tuned for that on Monday. David, a tweet from Sassal, Anthony Susana, what's he saying? Yeah, first he says, first layer two's won't work and are useless technology.
And now it's, if layer two's get big enough, it will become its own layer one and abandon Ethereum. First time you've heard this take, it means you need to get on Twitter. And Sassal finishes saying, when you see the goal post move like this, it means the critics never actually knew what they were talking about in the first place. Do you know what else to do? I do know what this also means, I think, is I think the rotators are rotating into layer two or they're getting ready to and that's why they're seeding this as the next kind of narrative. I think the old one trade is somewhat dormant right now, somewhat over for the time being.
And now the L2 narrative trade is on. So what do you have to do? Prop up layer two's and their value accrual mechanisms from a narrative perspective and put down ETH in order to get that trade going. So I think they'll probably be effective and I'm starting to see some of the rotators rotate in. Of course. The rotator's going to rotate. Always going to miss Susu in three hours capital, the ultimate amount of rotators. Not going to happen this cycle though. This is a valid tweet. What's he saying? Yeah. Vitalik says, call out scammers. You get hate in the moment but time vindicates you. Even if you're some CEO with quote reputation and need for quote professionalism, do it anyways and be savage.
People look up to you and your warning will be taken seriously. Is this Vitalik speaking? Be savage. Yeah, be savage. Yeah. So Vitalik called out the four-stage people that just got charged with the SEC forever ago. And so. 20. And then he got attacked probably. I think this is a Chinese community, Chinese project, maybe, I don't know, which is why I didn't really hear about it. But he said he's alluding to how he got attacked by the four-stage community probably. But now, now they're being charged with running a positive scheme. So who's laughing in the end? He said this about four-sage back in 2020, please leave and don't pollute the Ethereum ecosystem in the future.
Thank you. Thank you. Very Vitalik being to say, what do you think about this? Is it incumbent on the community to call out scammers more often? Well, one thing I struggle with about this, David, is sometimes the term scammer gets overused, right? I think in this case, it was like very clearly a scammer. So maybe when something is very clearly kind of black in the black category, there's no gray about it. That's the time to pile on. But it was not clear to me, for example, if we start putting like Luna and Tara into that category, whether Luna and Tara was a complete scam at the time. I thought it was like a flawed mechanic and like a very risky, broken thing to invest into you.
And I didn't think it would work long-term, but I can't necessarily call that a scam. I don't think that Vitalik is talking about that category of things, is he? I think so. Like, it's definitely one of the things that I learned out of 2020, is that like my intuitions are better than I thought they were. And so like, you know, I got into that fight with Danny Sesta from Wonderland. And then like his army like descended on me and like made me put my tail between my legs because of like Twitter drama. And then he blew up. And if I had been like how to like a little bit more like confidence and conviction, it's like, yeah, this is not right.
I might be would have said something. Same thing with Do Kwan, just repeated it. It's like, got attacked by Do Kwan and it's like, damn, their army is really loud. I don't really want to, don't really want to like pick my head up. And then boom, they blow up. And if I had a little bit more of just like, I don't really give a fuck about you, I'm going to be proven right in the long term. Then I think I would have gotten more credit than we did, even though we did like call out terror. I think decently, I think we could have done it better. All right. So maybe Dave is going to lean into that a little bit more.
I'm still probably going to be a bit more conservative. Like I think, I think Vitalix, right, for calling out something like this. But sometimes I am wrong, right? Like sometimes it's not like the mechanic does actually work in the, in the long run. Anyway, I think there's time for me, at least me personally, like a period of skepticism before I start using the S word. But then there are things that are very clearly scammed like, for example, Celsius. Some people are saying Celsius was a scam. I just didn't have enough information to know whether it was or not, right? But like it turns out it was.
I don't know. It's stuff like that. There's a lot in the gray area. Because it's a scam? I thought it's Celsius. It's just a gregiously mismanaged. I think it, I think that verges on scam of like Alex Mishensky calling himself a D5 bank and then taking himself as, yes, calling himself D5 would not have been good. Yeah. That makes sense. Yeah. All right. What take for me? I say this. It's true. Centralization. There's a lot of talk about that this week, a lot of talk about people not caring about decentralization. And I said, it's true. People don't care about decentralization. People don't care about decentralization until they get Mt.
Gox, or Siuzud, or Doquan, or Mishensky. They don't care because they're new and haven't been screwed yet. Eventually, people care about decentralization. When I got into crypto, very beginning, I didn't care very much about decentralization. You know what I cared about, David? Number go up. Number go up. I cared about other things. This idea of Bitcoin, you know, sovereign money, but I didn't understand the intricacies of like why decentralization matters until I started to see things in the crypto space. You know, read about the Mt. Gox, see kind of the centralization vectors. And I do think people start to care about it over time, but they don't start with that position as they're default.
They have to kind of learn it sometimes by being crypto for a period of time. Of course, as one does. What's my take? What's yours? I think this was my take last week, but here's my take. The best thing that could ever happen to crypto, a fees driven bull market. AKA a sustainable and rational bull market. Is that like too much to ask? Is a rational bull market? Why is that more rational? Because if it's fees driven, it means it's revenue driven. I mean, if it's revenue driven, this is how we've been like measuring assets since like the beginning of time is fundamentals. It's asking for a fundamentals driven bull market.
Can we have real people? Real people are paying for the service and it's actually providing real profit to the owners of the asset. Yeah, that would be pretty healthy. That would feel pretty good. I would like that. You think we're going to get it? Can I have this, please? Is that crazy? David only wants one thing for Christmas. Feed driven bull market. Yeah. Some people think it's cringed wine that we read out our own tweets as it takes the week. No, really? Yeah. Some people think it's whatever we do is cringed. I should read out your tweets and you read out my tweets as it lets you. That's what we usually do.
Yeah. I mean, they're called takes of the week. So we have takes sometimes. Yeah. We have good takes. Sorry for the cringes, guys. Ooty, I'm sorry for the cringed. David. People don't know that metaphor. What are you excited about this week? I'm excited for tokens, Ryan. There's a bunch of tokens. This is my coin gecko wash list. And so these are the tokens I'm currently looking at. And there's a bunch of them that are up bigly. Stakewise, up 107% in seven days. Optimism up 90%. You will are up 69% nice. Yarn, up 51%. Again, about fees. GMX, up 42%. I don't own you that. But perhaps I should look into how much fees it's making.
This is making a bunch of fees. Rocketpool and Lido, both up 32 and 37%. Immutable X, a layer 2, up 30%. You don't swap up 10%. I just feel like it's ETH maxi token season right now. And it's just making feel really good. There's almost an oxymoron about ETH maxi token season. Because if you're an ETH maxi, then you only buy ETH. But that's not actually true. Because if you're an ETH maxi, quote unquote, then you also must believe in the tokens in the ecosystem. So when I see all of these tokens that are heavily aligned with the Ethereum protocol going up, I'm like, nice. Are you going to set?
Like, how much of these would you sell ETH for in order to get in though? That's the harder part, right? Fiat's easy, but which of these are going to continue to go up and eat denominator terms? It's always hard. That's the hardest part. I thought it's hard. No. Whenever I get to that point, I'm like, I don't want to sell my ETH. Right. Right. What do you bullish on? I am bullish on the Ethereum roadmap. So we obviously have like a fizume out. We have the merge coming up, right? That's an economic upgrade. So we 90% issuance reduction, more security. We talked about that. Our discussion with Polenia around EIP4844 this past week made me excited about kind of the next upgrade of Ethereum.
The first we have an economic upgrade with the merge. But hopefully, fingers crossed, the hard fork after that, we'll get something like EIP4844, which makes rollups 1,000X cheaper potentially. When you add all of the rollup compression techniques with EIP4844, you get 1,000X cheaper rollups this according to Polenia. That's big. So we got first the economic upgrade. Yeah. And then David, we just had a conversation with Stefan from Flashbots this week about MEV, that's maximum extractable value, mitigations. And that is kicking in right after the merge. It's a long story, but Flashbots has a project called MEV Boost that all validators will use, that also generates more returns for anyone who uses it as a staker.
But I'm actually really excited about the MEV protection that's going to be baked into Ethereum at the protocol level, as well. This is called Protocol Builder Separation, PBS. And that is coming sometime after EIP4844 in the future. All this to say, I've probably never been more excited about the Ethereum roadmap. And the reason I'm most excited is because, I feel like we finally got our shit together on it. Like from an... Like actually defined it. There was a while where honestly Ethereum didn't have it together from a roadmap perspective. Yeah. It was late 2019 when it finally came together.
Yeah. We didn't have... Like kind of the monetary policy was like, I don't know. We'll wait for proof of say. We have that figured out with the merge, scalability. I don't know. Plasma, state channels. What's it going to be? No. Now we have a path, roll up centric roadmap, EIP4844. Like that's within site. How are we going to solve this MEV problem? MEV Boost, PBS? Like the roadmap's looking good these days. I'm pretty bullish on it. Yeah. It's looking good. And it also makes like fundamental sense. Kind of like going back to like Kelvin Finch, remember saying about the theoretical, like maximum.
Like there are things about the Ethereum roadmap, the design philosophy that is just like the theoretical best way to execute on an idea. And I don't have enough time to go into that right now, but I'll tease an article that and think it's coming out next week. Which is what you're alluding to, which is about the blockchain supply chain. As in like how a block becomes produced on Ethereum and where the value goes in that supply chain. And how ultimately always converges down to the EStakers. And so I think we are bullish on the same thing, brother. All right. What's the moon of the week this week?
What are we looking at? Even the week. Even the week. We are. This is a top gun poster. Top gun Maverick. But instead we got Nancy Pelosi in this F-18 zoom in her way to Taiwan. Why? For people who haven't been watching the news. What's the context for this? Yeah. Nancy Pelosi went to Taiwan of her own accord, interestingly after her husband bought a bunch of calls in Taiwan semiconductor businesses right before a bill went to Congress. So that's a different story. But then Nancy Pelosi of her own accord, not as a part of her job as Secretary of State or whatever she is, Speaker of the House.
Because it decides to go to Taiwan. And thoroughly pisses off China, who is now now as a result doing military exercises in that region as well. So Nancy Pelosi just going rogue top gun Maverick style, getting herself into Taiwan and pissing off the two biggest superpowers, or one of the biggest superpowers in the world. Nice job, Nancy. Well, 2020 is geopolitical tension. That's going to be fun. I feel like we need to grow on that in the future. Yeah. Guys, as always, it's been great to have you. Of course, crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in. But we are headed west. This is the frontier.
It's not for everyone. But we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot. Thanks a lot.