Bankless Weekly Rollup 4th Week of June 2023
------ 🚀 Unlock $3,000+ in Perks with Bankless Citizenship 🚀 https://bankless.cc/GetThePerks
------ 📣 CYFRIN | Smart Contract Audits & Solidity Course https://bankless.cc/cyfrin
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🧠 AMBIRE | SMART CONTRACT WALLET https://bankless.cc/Ambire
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
🎮IMMUTABLE | GAMING ECOSYSTEM https://bankless.cc/Immutable
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
------ Timestamps & Resources
00:00 Intro
4:46 MARKETS https://blockworks.co/news/ethereum-staked-to-flip-eth https://www.theblock.co/data/on-chain-metrics/ethereum/cumulative-eth-deposited-to-beacon-chain-and-validators https://www.theblock.co/data/on-chain-metrics/ethereum/cumulative-eth-deposited-to-beacon-chain-and-validators https://twitter.com/eigen_intern/status/1671178301149265920?s=20
18:16 Blackrock Bitcoin ETF https://twitter.com/Delphi_Digital/status/1671221306413416461?s=20 https://www.coindesk.com/business/2023/06/15/blackrocks-ishares-files-paperwork-for-spot-bitcoin-etf/?utm_source=twitter&utm_term=organic&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=coindesk_main&utm_content=editorial https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1980994/000143774923017574/bit20230608_s1.htm https://twitter.com/fintechfrank/status/1671135185545441280 https://twitter.com/jchervinsky/status/1669502687749054465?s=20 https://twitter.com/coinbureau/status/1671805994039492609?s=20
26:08 Fidelity, Charles Schwab and Citadel launch a CEX https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20230620110605/en/Digital-Asset-Platform-EDX-Markets-Begins-Trading-and-Completes-New-Funding-Round https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7076934393608511488/ https://edxmarkets.com/join-edx/ https://twitter.com/ramahluwalia/status/1671218922589175810?s=20 https://www.coindesk.com/business/2023/06/20/new-crypto-exchange-backed-by-fidelity-schwab-and-citadel-launches/
33:42 Polygon 2.0 https://polygon.technology/blog/polygon-2-0-polygon-pos-zk-layer-2?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social
47:40 ZachXBT Lawsuit https://twitter.com/zachxbt/status/1669783717236342785?s=46&t=2ZINVXJQKx6xO_6Wiiu_2g https://twitter.com/machibigbrother/status/1670819142050652160?s=20 https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ/status/1669807545194803200?s=20
57:05 Goose Sells For $5.4M https://twitter.com/Sothebysverse/status/1669441570863566875?s=20
1:02:09 Fortnite x Nike .swish https://www.epicgames.com/help/en-US/fortnite-c5719335176219/epic-accounts-c5719365892123/earn-achievements-on-swoosh-a16225767406107
1:05:00 Metamask Integrates Conext Network https://twitter.com/ConnextNetwork/status/1669718823484764161
1:10:25 Questions From The Nation https://discord.com/channels/615592155481767941/1058053004705669211/1119374915565523164 https://discord.com/channels/615592155481767941/1058053004705669211/1121292294054760508
1:20:51 Takes of the Week https://twitter.com/ercwl/status/1670482207956168705?t=hInEHE4udRw9PEN_oe3KyA&s=19 https://twitter.com/nixorokish/status/1670484525472952320 https://twitter.com/cburniske/status/1671556663864619010
1:32:33 What Are We Bullish On
1:40:02 Risks And Disclaimers
---- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
I really do think that we could get a repaint of DeFi summer, if the timing's right. I think the timing will probably be right. Yeah, maybe just a little bit more commentary in alpha here. I do know of it, these two startups that definitely were planning on releasing a token last bull market, and then the bear market hit, and they were like, we're gonna sit on our hands and release our token later. So there is pent-up air drops that people are just waiting for bullish sentiment to reemerge so that they can release their air. Bankless Nation, happy Friday. It is the Bankless Friday weekly roll-up time where we cover the entire weekly news in crypto, which is always an ambitious endeavor.
And yet again, we have Anthony Zuzano tapping in to substitute teach for Ryan Chat RSA. Anthony, welcome back to the weekly roll-up. Thank you, sir, always a pleasure to be here. Anthony, it was a bullish week this week, which is like the first bullish week that we've had in a long time, we're gonna talk about why. Perhaps it's because tradfied decides to enter crypto all at once, black rock, Charles Schwab, and the NASDAQ. We're gonna talk about all of the things that just came out in the last one week, 10 days that has changed the sentiment around crypto Twitter and crypto in general. Then we're gonna get into polygon proof of stake and how it has just submitted a proposal to turn it into a ZK roll-up, a validity, and specifically, we're gonna talk about, I'm gonna ask you Anthony, the nuances between that, and hopefully you can re-teach me something I learned forever ago and then lost.
And then finally, Zach XBT is sued, and the crypto community is gathering to support him, and all of that is coming up as soon as I plug the daily. Gway, Anthony, this is your YouTube channel, The Daily Gway, this is where I get my news, and just as a big thank you, we gave you this plug at the end of last week's weekly roll-up, last week that we had you on, but we're gonna do it at the start this time. Anthony, who are you and what is The Daily Gway? Yeah, I guess just generally I'm in a Ethereum educator, Ethereum community member been around for quite a while, and The Daily Gway is an education ecosystem for Ethereum, so I do a 30 minutes or also a video every weekday on the YouTube channel when it's available in podcast format as well, just recapping everything that's happened in the Ethereum ecosystem for that day and just giving my takes on things, and I'm actually going to be doing a regular podcast with Eric Conner again, so we did one the other week, as you can see there, it's called The Daily Gway Drive-Thru, so we're gonna be doing that regularly, and anyone who may have listened to a podcast called Into the ETHA back in the day, that was Eric and myself as well, so yeah, it's gonna be exciting for Eric to come back there, but yeah, mostly it's just like me talking on the daily videos, but yeah, from time to time, there's other people as well, but hopefully going forward, Eric and I will be doing a regular thing as well.
Well, it's a great service that you do for the Ethereum and broader crypto ecosystem. I often say if you listener can get to the point of understanding what Anthony Sazono is saying on The Daily Gway, then you are in maintenance mode, and you can just chillax and then just listen to The Daily Gway and you'll be fine, and it's where we get a lot of just news for the Bankless Weekly Roll-up, so a lot of this Anthony is probably already gonna have covered once before, at least in the last week or so, because like he said, he does this every single day. Moving forward, Anthony, I know I've been pestering you about this, I'm trying to get you to come to permissionless.
This is a call to action for the Bankless Sazono out there. We are less than three months away from permissionless in Austin, Texas, 11th through 13th. I've tried to get Anthony to come. I haven't convinced him yet. We didn't get him last year, getting him all the way out from Australia. It's gonna be a little bit difficult, but Anthony, we're working on some extremely exciting topics that I think I can get you for, but I will reserve a judgment until those topics come out. Yeah, I mean, what are the exact dates for permissionless? September 11th through 13th in Austin, Texas. Yeah, I would have come if I can, but I don't think I can make it work.
Not just the travel time, which is brutal, of course, but also I have prior engagements around that time already, so unfortunately, won't be able to make it, but the lineup looks killer. I mean, I saw this earlier today, the lineup looks great, really, really great work you guys have done with that. Yeah, and that's without a bunch of EF members and some other topics as well coming on to the lineup. There is a link in the show notes if you want to get a ticket. If you are a bankless citizen, you get 30% off of the permissionless ticket, which basically pays for a bankless citizenship. And so stay tuned, you can follow the permissionless Twitter account as more talks and things are scheduled.
All right, let's get into the market, Anthony. Like I said, it was a bullish week this week. So Bitcoin, going up 15%, look at that. We are at $30,000 and $5. Bitcoin started the week at $26,000, ending the week just above $30,000. 15%, it is not often that you get a 15% move in Bitcoin this week. Ether, of course, also up, not as up, as much starting the week as 1750, went down to almost below 1620, but ended the week up eight and a half percent, currently at $1,900, $18.93. And then of course, what does that mean for the ratio? The ratio is down about 4% down to 0.063. So kind of a big move, downwards on the ratio.
Anthony, what's your read on the markets this week? So it's an exciting week for the markets. Yeah, definitely is. I think it's pretty obvious why the markets moved over the past week for anyone who's been paying attention, but just to recap, a lot of noise is being made around Bitcoin ETFs again, because BlackRock basically put in an application for a Bitcoin ETF, and for those of you who don't know, BlackRock is the largest asset manager in the world. They are not a small play out for them to do something like this is actually a big signal. And then a lot of other companies and money managers and stuff like that, they followed as well, and have reapplied or applied for a Bitcoin ETF.
So, and I mean, on top of that as well, there has been a string of news coming out about different trade-fine institutions getting more involved with crypto. We recently had power, actually just yesterday, I believe, give this kind of speech, or answer a few questions as part of some committee, basically saying that's the day to kind of take advantage of the stablecoins, you know, stablecoins should be regulated as money, and that crypto is kind of here to stay as well. So just a lot of positive news from, I guess, like outside of crypto, but in saying all of that, I think that, while it's been a bullish week, I think that tempering expectations is also something that people should be doing as well, because I think right now, this over the last week, what people are doing is they're speculating on future inflows of money, right?
Like the existing money that's in crypto, the traders and everyone like that, they're basically saying, okay, well, this is a new narrative, this is something to latch onto, and there's potentially a lot of money coming in because maybe the ETF gets approved. Like for those who don't know, there is no Bitcoin ETF, and every other application that's ever been put in has been declined. There is a pseudo ETF known as GBTC, which is not an ETF, it is actually a pretty crappy product that trades at discounts quite regularly, so it's not something that people really want to buy, but yeah, people are speculating on this one actually getting approved, so that's what you've seen so far, that's what you've seen this week.
Now, whether this kind of continues, this positive price action continues, I think it's going to definitely rely on new money coming in, and if in absent that, I think it would just retrace, because speculating that new money's gonna come in can only get you so far, because if it doesn't actually materialize, and what you're speculating on, then it's just gonna go back down. That's my kind of read. So I'm not bullish or bearish, I guess. It's more of a neutral stance and just the wait and see. Yeah, I think that's a smart take to have. I'll add on additionally that, yes, there are traders that have rotated into Bitcoin, so why the ratio is down, it's why Bitcoin dominance is up.
On the news of BlackRock, the largest asset manager with over $10 billion of assets under management has proposed a Bitcoin ETF. That is traders that have, there's no new money there, they have just proposed an ETF, along with everyone else that's also proposed and also gotten denied a Bitcoin ETF. And so I totally agree that this is traders making the Bitcoin price go up. Yet at this also at the same time, I think what is real is that it is different when BlackRock does it, and also they are doing it in spite of the worst regulatory environment that crypto has ever had. And so yes, you could say that there is speculation of future cash flows going into Bitcoin, so people are buying it now.
But also there's just like the crypto has gotten absolutely flooded in the last three weeks a month, or so with regulatory concerns. And so I think there is a take that the BlackRock ETF is a signal that, hey, those regulatory concerns were the bottom, the bottom of regulatory fund. And so now that BlackRock is here in Charles Schwab and Fidelity are here entering the crypto space, people are perhaps thinking that this will be the end of regulatory fund because now we have the trad players involved. Yeah, I think it's definitely a win change for sure. And I guess my comments were more maybe the short term kind of stuff, not definitely not long term, but it also means that the foundations are being laid for the next crypto bull market.
And I believe strongly that there are foundations being laid everywhere right now, not just with tradfly coming in, but also in crypto foundations, such as all the development in the Ethereum ecosystem, obviously we had staking withdrawals go live, which opened or de-risk staking for a lot of people, and we've seen inflows there, layered to stuff like that. So all of this is just part of those foundations being laid. So long term, yes, it's incredibly bullish that this is happening. It's a win change. I did actually tweet the other day that I thought that the regulatory bottom was in. And I think that was before all this news came out because it really did feel like the regulators overstepped, specifically the SEC just overstepped their bounce yard.
And it doesn't matter how much support you think you have. If certain, I guess players don't support you, then you are going to lose the support of the people that matter very, very quickly. So I think there's definitely a win change. And I'm actually trying to figure out or speculating on, who's the SEC going to go after next? Are they actually going to do any more high-profile lawsuits? Or are they going to pause now that these big players have basically shot this, shot and basically put this signal out there saying, hey, we actually think crypto is legit. We don't think this stuff should be killed in the US, and basically you guys should stop.
That's kind of my rate on it. Yeah, certainly, certainly. Really quickly, we have a $1.2 trillion market cap, which is up big. We almost fell below $1 trillion last week, but this just shows what happens when Bitcoin puts a 15% week in the green there. And then also, like you said, Anthony, Stakeman and Thralls went live. And so we've seen the post with Thralls meta-emerge on Ethereum. 23 million ether staked, seemingly up only and interestingly also Ethereum staked. The supply of eth-staked is ready to flip eth on crypto exchanges, which is just something you got to love to see. Crypto exchanges losing in their eth-supply ownership percentage versus the beacon chain.
So Staking just really seems to be up only. 23 million ether staked. Any comments on this, Anthony? Yeah, I mean, it's definitely not something that surprised me, but what did surprise me was the speed of which it happened. I knew that Staking with Thralls was going to be bullish. I just didn't think that we would see this much eth pho-moe in because it's just, I mean, the validator queue's been over 90,000 for a while now. It's like, OK, why didn't these people enter before? Well, the obvious reason was is because they felt it was risky, right? And they felt it was risky to get in before with Thralls went live.
And now that with Thralls alive, they're fine doing it now. Obviously, the proof is in the numbers. And it's just been really amazing to see that. So yeah, just generally great to see that the thesis played out with Thralls was going to be bullish. And I believe that each staking is going to be up only for a while. It will obviously slow down and taper off. There's, I think there definitely is like a finite amount of ether can be staked outside of the total supply of ether. And I think that I don't think it's going to get to like 70% staked unless there's like an outside incentive, such as eigenlayer, for example, or restaking generally.
If it's just vanilla, each staking, yeah, I don't see it going like too high because it's just the incentives aren't there for that. But yeah, generally, it's pretty bullish. Yeah, we're looking at a chart here with two lines that are converging. One is the ether on exchange and one is the ether staked. And we are basically at that flipping point. I love the caption here. It's not the actual flipping. I think one kind of nuance to this chart that I know this isn't probably something people want to hear. But a lot of the eighth staked goes through exchanges. So if they're staking it, it means it's not being counted as their exchange balance, but it's still theirs technically, because they're staking it on behalf of their users.
So I would like to see a more detailed chart breaking that out, basically identifying which ether was staked via a centralized exchange versus, but generally, I think it's still fine because you have, I guess, like, eth being productive, rather than just sitting and securing the network. So obviously, there's benefits. But yeah, that's a caveat on a nuance, I thought I would be able to bring up. Yes, yes, they're very, very important. Yeah, there should be a third line, which is eth staked on exchanges. And if we could get that line to also trend downwards, that would be great. You brought up eigenlayer, which I think this is important to bring up.
Here is a graphic of just all of the different eth staked derivatives, the staked eth from LIDO, R eth from rocket pool, and CB eth from coinbase being deposited into like eigenlayer after main net launch. And this happened in, this is an hourly timeframe. So this is a very short period of time while the, until the caps were reached, the caps of 32,000 eth, 3,200 eth, excuse me. And so not only do we have eth or staked on the beacon chain to watch, but now we have eth or staked on eigenlayer to also watch. All three of these things are capped. I think we covered this last week, or last week we had you on Anthony, but it's just fun to watch these eth or being staked across all of the different staking utility ecosystems.
Any last comments on eigenlayer before we move on? No, I mean, I didn't, I wasn't surprised by this. I actually kind of woke up to both the announcement and the pool's being filled. That's how fast they got filled up here. But yeah, it's gonna be interesting to see which ones kind of fill up and succeed like in terms of market share. Obviously it's gonna probably reflect the market share of each of these LSTs themselves, but will it actually change the dynamics? Like will there be more R eth minted because the R eth cap won't be reached as far as the ST8 cap is because it's just more ST8 out there.
So I'm, that's what I'm watching, the dynamics there between the different LSTs and how that drives the, I guess dynamics of LST market share on the beacon chain itself. All right, Bank of the Station coming up next. Tradify enters crypto all at once. We're gonna talk about each of the individual entrances into this crypto world, followed by the polygon proof of stake chain set up to upgrade to AZK validity and then of course the AZK XBT drama, the beloved crypto sleuth gets sued by a victim and crypto Twitter arises to his defense. And then we have Goose season from Thurios Capital, we're gonna have to talk about the Goose and a few other NFT things on Ethereum as well.
But first, I'm going to talk about these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. The place I used to check the charts and the crypto prices even when I'm not looking to place a trade on Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data and lightning fast trade execution. All inside, there's spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout lets you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen.
With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs. Visit pro.kraken.com to get started today. Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network. A brand new, high-performance Ethereum layer two built using the OP stack but uses eigenlayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one. Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications.
The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboarded like Game 7 for Web3 gaming and buy a bit for TVL and liquidity and on-rats. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure and decentralized Mantle. If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led layer two ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle.
All right, here's a tweet from Delphi Digital that I think sums this up pretty nicely. Over the past two weeks, BlackRock files a Bitcoin ETF. NASDAQ launches a CryptoCustody service. Deutsche Bank seeks a CryptoCustody service. Soros's fund management says Crypto's here to say and then Citadel Fidelity in Charles Schwab launch a crypto exchange finishing up with the institutions are here. And so this has been the theme of the last two weeks, I'd say, starting with, of course, the BlackRock submission of the eye shares paperwork for a spot Bitcoin ETF. There's was a rumors like, oh, BlackRock is rumored to be close to be submitting for a Bitcoin ETF.
And then about, I don't know, four to five hours later, it was confirmed that they did indeed submit a proposal to the SEC for an eye shares Bitcoin trust. Eye shares is just there branding for BlackRock. And so BlackRock, the world's largest is either first or second after Vanguard. Over $10 trillion, I might have said billion, trillion dollars in AUM. And interestingly enough, there are some stats I want to pull out. After the $10 trillion in AUM, BlackRock has received approval of 575 out of 576 ETF applications. They have only ever been denied their ETF applications once. So they've done this a few times before.
In fact, 575 times. And they have gotten approval quite frequently, except all except for once. And so this is using some crypto service providers. The custodian is going to be Coinbase. There is a Kraken subsidiary company that is providing the exchange data. And just everyone knows BlackRock plus Larry Fink, the CEO, has a lot of political power. And so in combination with, like, finally, we're getting a spot Bitcoin ETF, not the futures ETF that no one really liked earlier. We also have the weight of BlackRock. And to, if you aren't familiar with BlackRock, in addition to all the context I just gave, BlackRock is the closest thing to the government, well, also not being the government.
Like, they own half of the equities in the United States of America. Like, it is part of the, it's an extension of the government itself. It's kind of a cynical nihilistic take about the relationship between governments and public and private markets. But that's my take. Anthony, anything you want to add to this? Mm-hmm. Yeah, I think just on that note about the ETFs that they've approved, or have had to approved, and which ones have been denied. I actually looked up the one that got denied. So it was one in 2014, so quite a while ago now. And it was denied because apparently, it was just a blind trust.
So you'd buy it, but you wouldn't actually know what was in it. So you would be buying something you didn't know. So obviously, that's not something that you want to offer to retail customers, especially. So that was denied there. And again, that goes to that kind of stuff we were saying before about the win change. I don't think we bought it up before, but that point around the BlackRock seems to only file for ETFs when they know with like 99.9% certainty that it's going to get approved. It has people speculating, okay, well, there is a higher chance of this one getting approved, this Bitcoin ETF getting approved than not this time, right?
It's not like a, it's a, you know, 1% chance. It's maybe over 50%. So that's what people are speculating on, I think. That's right. Yeah, and there's just a lot of speculation going on. So Francher Power says BlackRock Fidelity Citadel, they're all making big moves into crypto despite the Gensler crackdown tree of alpha response to this and says you wrote despite instead of thanks to. And so the people with the conspiracy hat on, which I always love to put on, are saying like Gary Gensler and the SEC and the powers that be were just hammering the crypto native companies, right? The Winklevoss ETF denied, right?
Like all of the other crypto native ETF proposals denied. And they're just the claim, the conspiracy is that they were just biting their time for some of the bigger players to come in. And it's just interesting that Fidelity Citadel, BlackRock, all of these trad institutions with trillions of dollars of AUM and strong political connections all seem to come in to crypto at once, right after the SEC and other regulators start hammering crypto native orgs. And so just the timing on this is curious. I don't, I think if I talk to somebody like Jake Chervinsky or somebody a little bit more measured, they would just say yes, it's curious but there's not really a there there.
But I think everyone in crypto is like, yo, what the F is up with this timing? Do you have any thoughts on that, Anthony? Yeah, I mean, the timing is what I think a lot of people are latching onto when it comes to putting their conspiracy hat on, right? But there is another lens you can view this from. You can basically view this as these trad finds that the institutions had their hands forced by the SEC. Because the SEC went after Coinbase, the biggest crypto company in the US, they went after a bunch of different tokens or used those tokens as evidence against Coinbase. Obviously they went after Binance, which isn't US, I mean, Binance US, but obviously they're trying to extend that to Binance Global as well.
So I think that maybe these trad finance institutions were already interested in getting into crypto, they just hadn't announced their plans yet. And then because the SEC went after the Coinbase, especially, they're like, okay, well, we need to send the signal back now that we're actually wanting to play in this arena and the SEC needs to calm down with whatever they're trying to do. Interesting. Okay, so that's actually just like the pro crypto. It's like they were always ready to pull this trigger, but then they decided to like, hey, let's publicly stand in support of crypto before Gary Gensner destroys the industry that we want to generate fees from.
Yeah, pretty much. Like I think not just Gensner, but all the high ranking Democrats that have been anti crypto, these companies probably like, well, it's time to put a stop to that, right? It's time to, if we want to be involved here and make money from it, we can't have all these regulators and these politicians trying to kill crypto in the US. And that's why I said it's a win change where it was like blowing in one direction. Now it seems to be blowing in the complete opposite direction. Yeah, speaking of a win change, here's a meme that I thought kind of sums this up. Larry Fink, the CEO of BlackRock first initially said, Bitcoin is an index of money laundering.
And then the meme is, you know, first they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, and then they create a spot Bitcoin ETF. Yeah, all these comments from like, yeah, Larry Fink and like Jamie Dimon and their change of tune over time, I think like a lot of times you can just chalk that up too. They've been around a long time. They've been around markets a long time. They're very experienced there. They've, you know, they've probably seen it all. And a lot of these things, are these new things that come along end up failing, right? All these new things people get excited about end up failing.
So I think for them, crypto needed to, you know, exist for a long time and needed to become a much bigger asset class than it traditionally had been. I needed to affect maybe the political sphere as well and become a, be conversational there for these tried fire people, the CEOs, to actually be like, okay, well, this thing's here to stay. Let's focus on it, right? Because CEO has had a million things to think about. And I doubt Jamie Diamond sitting there every day being like, oh, crypto, I'm gonna go look into what's happening with Bitcoin mining. We're gonna go look into what's happening with Ethereum L2s.
No, they're not doing that, right? They've got their own things they need to focus on. They need to run the business, the existing business and their innovation arms or whatever we'll look into it. That's why Jamie Diamond was saying these comments while JP Morgan was making, I believe they were making an Ethereum client or working on a Ethereum client or something got to do with the EVM. So that's why I think these things happen. So yeah, I don't think that these CEOs really, you know, when they make those comments, they're not making it from a position of being super involved with crypto, being like a believer, they're more from the sidelines.
Sure, so yeah, certainly, certainly. And of course, this was not the only thing in the tried world about the crypto world. Fidelity, Charles Schwab and Citadel have launched a centralized exchange, a non-Cusodial centralized exchange titled EDX. I don't know what EDX stands for. What is with these acronym based exchange? I don't know. OK, so EDX is launching and say non-Cusodial exchange. Non-Cusodial centralized exchange, which I think is interesting to the crypto world, but actually is normal in the tried world. And so the EDX, the quote from the CEO, Jamil Nazar Raleigh, says, EDX's official launch allows our outstanding team to bring the crypto, the same values and standards of competition, transparency, fairness, and safety that investors in traditional assets expect and enjoy.
And so OK, so what's the big deal here? Ram Alawalia, who we've had on the podcast before, the non-Cusodial aspect of EDX refers to its settlement process. Unlike traditional crypto exchanges, like Coinbase or Kraken, that require customers to deposit assets into wallets controlled by the exchange, EDX just plans to use a third party bank or custodians to hold customer assets. So you use a custodian, a custodian service. And this is how the NASDAQ works. This is how the tradify works. There is a custodian or a bank. And then there's just like API access. And so the trading happens on paper by this brokerage, by this trading service, and then there's settlement after the fact.
Whereas crypto exchanges, Coinbase, Kraken, Gemini, anyone where you submit your crypto assets and they are the custodian and then they also let you trade, those things are co-mingled. And the trad world likes these things separated. And so this is just following the old model of separation of exchange duties and custodian duties. And so this is being a hyper-compliant new form factor for an exchange. And so the website is edxmarkets.com. You can check it out. But you actually can't trade on there. It's not for you. It's not for retail investors. It's not like your Coinbase or your Kraken. It is meant to be like a software service for trad custodians.
And then trad custodians will allow you to trade. So I would imagine if you are a customer of fidelity, which you have Bitcoin or Ether there, that trading of if you press the buy button or the sell button or I don't know, the options button for Ether or Bitcoin, that information as an API gets routed to edx. And then edx does the trading and then there's final settlement between the custodians later. And so this specifically is intended to avoid serving retail investors. Interestingly, paradigm is an etx edx investor. And also interestingly, they only offer four tokens. Bitcoin, Ether, fine.
Litecoin and Bitcoin cash. Interesting. The Nazarari CEO says we have a limited set of tokens because until there's more regulatory clarity, we don't want to trade something that is potentially a security. So hyper compliance, fitting the old form factors of trad fi meant to serve trad fi institutions backed by fidelity, Charles Schwab, Citadel, interestingly. Nazarari, the CEO is a former Citadel employee. Anthony, does this summation of the details? What's your take here? Yeah, no, I think that's a great summer of everything. Before I dive into my tech, I just want to point out that the E on the logo there is the currency symbol for Ether on edx.
I don't know if that's intentional or not, but that's pretty cool. I'm not intentional. No, I'm probably not. So the assets that you rolled off there, the ones that they're trading, right? As you said, Bitcoin, Ether, no brainer, that's fine. But Litecoin and Bitcoin cash. I mean, like what's frustrating? Yeah, yeah, so this is what's frustrating about the SCC and not giving clarity to anything because it means that these platforms are very limited into what they can trade. And they literally will trade things that just are dead, right? That no one really cares about, right? That are kind of old coins, dinosaur coins or dyno coins, as we call them, in crypto.
And they could trade all these other stuff if there was clarity because what they could do is that they could literally register with the SCC to trade securities. So even if these crypto assets were securities, they would still be able to trade them. But they can't do that because the SCC does not offer any way to actually do that. And contrary to what they've said around the Prometheum thing, which in my eyes, the Prometheum thing is like an SCC plant, to be honest. I think that whole thing is just absolutely wild. But like, yeah, not even ADX can probably register with the SCC to trade crypto asset securities because there's just no guidance there.
So it really does speak to the fact that the SCC, as I said, has overstepped completely and has just provided absolutely no guidance to anyone. And I think that's super frustrating because it means that instead of actual crypto assets that people want to trade being on this platform, you have Litecoin and Bitcoin Cash, which like no one cares about. I mean, maybe some people do, but I think the majority already don't, right? Yeah, it also just sends a bad signal to investors. But it puts Bitcoin Cash and Litecoin shoulder to shoulder with Bitcoin and ethers. Like, it's just the wrong signal. Like, that's not legitimized Bitcoin Cash when it's more of a nuanced discussion.
But really, there's just ever only going to be one Bitcoin. And very clearly, BTC has won that fight and Bitcoin Cash has very clearly lost. And so I don't think there's the investors who are clients of Charles Schwab are sufficiently informed about the dynamics of what a hard fork is and what like block space competition is. And so they're like, oh, Bitcoin Cash, it's cheaper. I'll buy it. Like, they're gonna fall for that. And so it's just like a, it's a poor service, at least in my opinion. And I will say like. I'm surprised I don't have a Ethereum classic on there. Yeah, it's a cheap Ethereum, right?
Yeah. And it's, so like, I know like neither you nor I are necessarily bullish on like Solana, at least in comparison to Ether, you and I are leaning towards the ether camp. But I will be way more bullish on Solana than Litecoin or Bitcoin Cash. And I'm sure that's a sentiment that's shared by almost anyone that's gonna have an account with some of these at Charles Schwab Fidelity types. One more comment from Nazar, Nazar Arik, the CEO of this new exchange. Left a comment for CoinDesk. Regulators like the different approach. This is talking about the separation of exchange function in the broiler dealer function.
Investors want to trade through trusted intermediaries and that is especially true post FTX. And so this is also just naturally a, it's going to service a demand for the more conservative cautious, trad investor who doesn't like any of these crypto native companies. Even the great ones like Kraken and Coinbase that we in the crypto world completely trust because they've been around. But still like to the trad investor, you put up Coinbase and you put up FTX and people are like, I can't tell the difference. Just because they just aren't informed. Any last comments before we move on? No, I mean, I think that's right.
And these other financial institutions have been around for a very long time. But as well, they're also like registered and regulated within the proper frameworks. And that's what crypto exchanges are trying to do in the US. But they just have no path towards that. But I will say that Coinbase and Kraken, particularly Coinbase, is viewed very, very favorably by US-Tradify kind of people. I mean, as you said, EDX is using Coinbase as a custodian. No, sorry, not EDX, the ETF, the blackmail. They're using Coinbase as a custodian. And to use someone as a custodian is obviously a huge deal because they have all the assets, right?
So you only want to be using companies that are completely legitimate that you trust and that have good practices around this. And I would say that Coinbase's custody practices are the best in the industry. I don't think they've ever actually had a hack at all or an exploit. Not to say they obviously won't. You can't ever say they won't. But that test of time that they've been around for a very long time, and from the youngest days of crypto to today is a huge kind of deal for these more Tradify kind of institutions. Yeah, that's a funny point where if like, Trad investors are like, I'm not really sure about these crypto exchanges.
I don't really know about Coinbase. I'm going to use BlackRock and BlackRock's like, well, we're going to use Coinbase. Yeah, exactly. All right, OK, moving on to Polygon News. The other big news of the week, there is a proposal submitted by Polygon Labs to Polygon Governance. Titled Polygon 2.0, Polygon Proof of Stake to ZK layer 2. OK, so a proposal was published to move the Polygon Proof of Stake chain, the big one with all of the actrating activity, the economic activity, to a ZK EVM Validium. So Polygon already has their ZK EVM. So this is a new chain. Well, it's the same chain, the Polygon Proof of Stake chain.
They want to turn that into a ZK EVM Validium, which is a specific kind of ZK rollup. So this is a core part of their whole Polygon 2.0 vision, where everything ultimately just becomes a ZK layer 2. So the goal here is to upgrade the Polygon Proof of Stake chain, which is actually not, people will throw a flag at the calling it a rollup, because it's technically a proof of stake side chain. So this turns it closer to being an actual rollup. And this proposal itself actually retriggered the what is a true rollup conversation on crypto Twitter, because a Validium is a rollup. But there's an asterisk there.
So like we're going to get into some of that nuances. But first, just like what is the big difference? Higher security for users compared to the proof of stake chain. Again, the proof of stake polygon chain is a side chain, turning it into a ZK Validium. Actually does produce more final settlement on the Ethereum layer one itself. There's better interoperability because of the ZK part of this component to the rest of the Polygon 2.0 ecosystem. All the applications on Polygon should continue, and fees should actually get much, much, much lower. And so, OK, what is a Validium? I'm going to briefly answer this in the Anthony.
You're going to help me define this. Validium is a lower cost, high throughput sibling of a ZK rollup. So the pros are that it fully inherits security of Ethereum, except for transaction data, which is kind of actually an important part. So publishing transaction data to Ethereum is expensive and it limits throughput. So a Validium, it has similar security guarantees to a rollup, but the transaction data is made available off-chain. So that'll be made available by a proprietary Polygon solution. And so much, much lower fees than a true ZK rollup as ZK EVM like scroll or ZK sync era. It doesn't consume Ethereum gas to store transaction data.
So there's higher scalability. But the cons are, there is an external dependency, the transaction data, the data availability for transactions is secured outside of Ethereum. So there is an extra dependency there. Anthony, what would you add to my limited definition of a ZK Validium? No, I think you covered it quite well there. There is obviously a lot to unpack here. So I will offer a bit of just extra kind of context around this. So Validium was a term that was, I think, coined by Stackweb a while ago. And it basically just describes a construction where the, as you mentioned, the transaction data is not stored on the same, I guess, like a layer that the ZK proof is.
So the ZK proof is, in this case, for the Polygon ZK EVM Validium will be stored on a 3M L1, and that's the cheap component. That is very cheap to store on a 3M L1. Whereas the transaction data, which is the expensive component, will be stored on the existing Polygon validators nodes. So the Polygon Validator set consists of around 100 validators. And there is obviously staking with the Matic token. They've got a D-Pole system or a delegated proof of stake system. So those validators will be where the data is stored. Now, what this does is that it enables cheaper fees because storing the data with Polygon Validators is cheaper than storing it with the Ethereum validators, just by the virtue of how each of these networks work here.
But in saying that there is no, in a typical Validium construction, there is no kind of limit to where you can store your data. So you can store your data on anywhere, basically. You could store it locally if it allows you to do that, right? You could store on another L1 altogether, or you could store it on a data-vailability network itself, something like Celestia or a veil, which actually spun out of Polygon, or potentially eigenlayer data-vailability layers if those things get spun up. But it's all about the security guarantee, right? Because what is the actual practical implication here of not storing your data on a Ethereum L1, but storing it elsewhere, is what happens is that there could be a withholding of data.
So let's just say, for example, that the Polygon Validators all go offline, right? And the data's gone. Like not gone, but inaccessible, right? You can't actually, so if you want to withdraw your funds from the ZKVM Validium, you wouldn't be able to do that because you don't have the data to allow for the cryptographic proof to basically say, well, you've got the proof, right? But you don't have the other part of it, which is the data, to say, hey, this is my funds. This is the state of my account. Please give me my funds on wherever, Ethereum L1, whoever else. Now, that's the worst case scenario.
They can't steal your funds. They can freeze your funds, but they cannot steal your funds because they did not have the proof that he's tied to your address. At least that's my understanding of it. So that's the trade-off, basically, where you do get more security than in the Polygon POS chain. But because the data is stored off-chain, you still rely on those validators in order to access your funds. Your funds would be frozen in that world. Now, obviously, that's not ideal, but that's the trade-off for the cheaper fees. In saying all of that, post EIP4844, which is proto-downsharing, which basically creates a new transaction type for roll-ups, if the costs are low enough for Polygon, for what they want to achieve, for the ZKVM, what they could do is they could essentially just store the data on Ethereum and still get the same fees that they would by storing it elsewhere.
And that would make it a full roll-up. So a full roll-up needs its data and its proof on the same settlement layer, such as Ethereum L1 here. And another thing that they could do as well is that with the validity and construction, they can, as I mentioned before, allow users to store their data wherever they want. So if you store your data yourself, you pay for yourself, obviously. If you want to store your data on Ethereum L1, cool, do that, but you have to pay for it, right? And by doing that, you actually now have the same guarantees. You have the guarantees of a roll-up on Ethereum, and if the Polygon Valorators go offline, it doesn't matter for you because your data is actually on Ethereum, so you would still be able to get your funds out.
But you can store your data anywhere, actually, as well, which is actually, I think a really cool kind of construction type here is where you could have it default stored on the Polygon Valorators, then give the users the choice to store it wherever they want. But we'll have to see. I think that if 48, 44 offers enough scalability for Polygon, I think that they could end up defaulting to Ethereum L1. And then maybe in times of like high congestion, they change over to the Polygon Valorators. So there are literally various different ways that this can be done, which is actually what's really cool about this.
But yeah, that hopefully gives people extra context around this itself. But just the last thing I'll say, I know I'm going on a little bit here, but the last thing I'll say is that the reason why this is really bullish for Polygon is because the POS chain has a huge network effect, right? Yes, it's the side chain. Yes, it's obviously less secure than Ethereum and everything. It's not a roll up or an L2, but it has a lot of activity, has a lot of apps, has a lot of users, has a lot of network effect. So converting this over to a ZKVM for Lidium inherits all of that and keeps all of that and just gives it more security.
And if it's a full ZK roll up, then you've literally just converted what is essentially a separate L1 into an L2 on Ethereum. And that right there, I think is a playbook for other L1s to potentially follow. Not to say that the other L1s have as much activity as the POS chain, but at the same time, it shows that it can be done. It shows that it is possible and it shows that it works. Because from my reading, this is actually easy to do. In the proposal, the Polygon said, this is actually not a difficult thing to do. We can actually do this with relative ease. And then everyone, and there's no need for users to do anything.
It's like the merge on Ethereum. The merge was obviously not an easy feat, but it's like the merge where essentially it happens and the users don't feel anything, they just get the same experience. So yeah, overall, I think very bullish, even though obviously there's a lot of nuance to the construction itself, but I think that once you understand the nuances there, you have a better understanding of all of it. God, I'm so glad I have you this week to explain this one. That was so helpful. You talked about the size of the Polygon rollup, over $2 billion of assets, tens of thousands of dApps, and an average of 2.
5 million transactions per day. That is in the current proof of stake, Polygon chain. And so just to really drive this point home about this ZK Validium, the ZK part of a ZK Validium, the ZK part is the cryptographic proof that prevents the operators of this rollup from stealing your assets. The trade-off is that you do not have the same assurances of having your data, but at least they can't steal your assets, they can only prevent you from retrieving your assets. And so it's basically like what's left is a griefing attack as they can only prevent you from withdrawing. So there's no incentive for them to do anything else because they can't steal it from you.
They can only prevent you from withdrawing. And so there's a much significantly reduced attack surface area down to the circumstances of just when a griefing attack by a layer 2 operator or a set of operators would be viable, which is just like that's much less incentive to be malicious than if they were actually able to steal your funds. So these ZK part of the ZK Validium prevents them from actually being able to steal your funds. So what's left is just like they can withhold it from you and be mean for some particular reason, but the reasons for doing that are much, much more reduced. And then on top of that, you also have the matic's taking as well, which I'm assuming if they do this, if anyone griefs or sensors you are with draws, then they have matic at stake, which can get slashed, which is an additional protection against this.
All of this is correct, right Anthony? I'm not sure. I don't actually know if Matic has, or if the Polygon POS chain validates have a slashing mechanism. And I'm not sure if that will be implemented as part of this move. I don't actually know the details of what they have there. But generally what you're talking about is the data availability problem, right? Where this is a huge problem in crypto generally. And the way Ethereum aims to solve it is by using some really fancy cryptography that is beyond my understanding that is part of the dank shouting roadmap. But with the data's thought, if it's still with the POS chain validators, I don't know if all of them are going to store all of the data or how long they're going to store it for, because they could say, okay, I'm gonna keep it for 30 days and then discard it because it's too expensive for me to keep it, right?
Or our portion of them will only keep the data. So maybe only like 30% of them will keep the data and the other 70% won't. So if they withhold the data, it doesn't matter that the other 70% don't, they don't have the data to withhold in the first place. So there's been all this research and development over data availability guarantees and how to actually do it in a scalable way because storing data is expensive and serving it is expensive because it's all hardware at the end of the day, right? You're storing the data, it's literally gigabytes or megabyte, whatever, storage, you store on a computer, it's the same concept, but then you also have to serve that and that costs money to do, right?
You need to serve it off of a good connection. You need to be online to the data is available. It's like running any kind of a node or validator or anything like that. So from that lens, when you're talking about the cost of this, the cost is always born by the people storing the data and if it becomes economically inefficient for them to do that, they're either going to discard the data or they're just going to shut down their validators. So that's where the problem of data availability comes from and how do you ensure that the data is always available even if only a subset of validators have it and that's where all the research that's going to the dang shouting has come from which uses all the very fancy cryptography, which obviously is way beyond my knowledge there.
I'm not a cryptographer, but yeah, I don't know exactly how polygons are going to construct this and which validators are going to keep it for how long, but that's why I think that they should make it so that the validity of has that option to fall back to Ethereum L1, for example, if you want to pay there. Because for example, big players who don't care about fees, they could use this chain and just post their data to L1 Ethereum so they'll have no risk of their assets being frozen, right? Whereas smaller players, maybe they don't, they, it's not worth it to them to do that. So they can just have it stored somewhere else.
So again, giving the users choice, I think is very important. But yeah, this is a huge design space when it comes to research around this. Yeah, the last thing I want to pull out is that interestingly in this blog post, they talked about like polygons talked about why this is a good thing. So they say upgrading the polygons proof of stake chain to SDK Validium would offer very high scalability and very low fees. Yes, we know this. It would be a great fit for applications that have high transaction volume and require low transaction fees. For example, Web3 gaming, social, and micro DeFi. Interestingly that they added the word micro because you wouldn't want to do a million dollar transaction with constrained settlement assurances.
So even they are admitting that like hey, this is great for micro transactions, micro DeFi. But for a, for large scale DeFi services, you would want the full ZK EVM, which polygon also happens to have supplied to the market. Okay, wrapping up the polygon conversation, thank you for helping me navigate through that one Anthony. Zach XBT, a Twitter thread says, it's unfortunate that I have to write this thread but I'm being sued by Mocky Big Brother for an article I published in June 2022. Today Mocky filed the defamation lawsuit. The lawsuit is baseless and attempt to chill free speech. I intend to fight back and defend free speech.
For bankless listeners who are not on crypto Twitter or not tapped into who Zach XBT is, he's just, I would call him a famous crypto sleuth. He has done a massive job, just like thankless job, just crawling through ether scan, tracing transactions, watching crypto influencers talk a big game about crypto assets while secretly selling them on the other side and then exposing them on crypto Twitter and generating like massive threads of research. And so I definitely call him a beloved member of the crypto Twitter community, the broader crypto community. Zach XBT was actually the one that exposed who was the, who was the quadringer founder that was also.
Oh yeah, I don't remember the name. I don't remember the name but yeah, that was the Canadian exchange. Right, they're the part of the Wonderland seafood, zero XC food. Yeah, part of the Wonderland exchange for zero XC food who turned out to be this X scammer and Zach broke that story. And so he has just done a number of, number of just jobs exposing fraud in the crypto space. And so he continues and says, my understanding is that Maki is very wealthy. I am not. He is using his money to try and silence me. I'm asking for your help so that this doesn't happen and the truth survives. He also created a donation address to assist with legal costs.
Basically the story is that Zach accused Maki Big Brother, whose name is Jeff Wein, of launching over 10 failed pump-and-dumps and NFT projects, including Treasury Management Services from Formoso Financial. Formoso Financial co-founder George H. withdrew 22,000 ether from the project's Treasury wallet in June of 2018. And then this, all of this data based on blockchain data, Zach XVD, concluded that these were Maki's addresses. So Zach XVT blames Jeff Wang for draining of the funds as the eth inflows a private round funds into the multi-sig before the two 11,000 ether withdrawals were made by both Jeff and George in June 20th, I'm 2018.
Basically Zach traced a lot of fraud back to Maki Big Brother. And then Maki Big Brother has sued him for defamation. And so I will say, everyone gets their day in court. Maki Big Brother gets his day in court. He is suing Zach because he would like to clear his name from the record and say that he is, this is none of this has happened. What Zach XVT is not correct, as claiming is not correct. And so he would like to have his name clear because Zach is wrong. And Zach who published this article is saying, hey, I am right. I also need help defending myself in court. And since Zach is so beloved by the broader crypto world, over a million dollars has been sent to the Zach XVT donation address.
The last I checked was over a million dollars. And so crypto Twitter has absolutely risen to the occasion to defend Zach XVT from Maki. And kind of judged, Maki is guilty, at least collectively, just because Zach's prowess in the crypto Twitter field is just so strong. Anthony, what's your summation of all these events? And what's your take? I mean, I think you summarized it all very well there. You gave all the relevant background. I will say that I consider Zach for those who don't know to be like crypto's Batman. But he's not a billionaire, I'm sorry. He obviously had to set up this donation address.
And obviously crypto Twitter came out or crypto people came out and donated to him and stood behind him. I am not going to, you know, obviously say that Maki, big brother is guilty or not because I don't want to get sued. But the thing about this suit is that what happens is, there's a period of discovery. And what that means is that everything's going to come out into the open about what Maki wants to actually defend against and what Zach has accused Maki of. Now, if Zach is right and everything that he's accused Maki of is correct, then Maki is just opening himself up to lawsuits from other people that will now have all this evidence to go after him with.
So I don't know if this lawsuit is actually going to continue for that long. Maybe he thought that Zach wouldn't be able to defend himself and Zach would just basically cave and apologize to Maki because Zach has actually issued a public apology before to ran, I don't know how to say his last name. But he's pretty big in the cryptic. Yeah, yeah. So he has actually issued an apology before because I believe crypto, Raman, whatever his name is, was going to sue Zach. But this time around, Zach either wrongly or rightly feels he has a good enough defense and good enough evidence here to defend himself against Maki.
So maybe Maki miscalculated here. Maybe he will withdraw the suits. But yeah, it's great to see crypto to come out with huge support for Zach. And I think obviously if Zach needs more money, if he exhausts the existing funds, people are going to come out and help him with it anyway because he has done a lot of great work for crypto and building scammers and grifters at great personal risk because he's not really an Ainoan, right? People know who he is now. He started off Ainoan, but then he was traced down and obviously he can't put that back in the bottle once it's out. So yeah, he does this at great personal risk and it's a thankless job, as you said, because yeah, okay, he's gotten some donations from people here and there, but the risk that he takes on is huge.
I can't even overstate like how big the risk is because if he goes after the wrong person, you know, that he's probably a scammer, but it's a bit crazy, they could physically harm him, not just sue him, right? They could be physical kind of violence involved here for him or his family. So yeah, it's great personal risk, but it is a duty that needs to be done because there are so many scammers and grifters just get away with things in crypto that we do need a Batman at the end of the day. Yeah, 100%. And if you've been following Zach's Twitter account, he has already published the death threats that he has gotten just from around the space.
And so this is not speculation, this is a reality. And I will say that even in the circumstance where Machi is correct and he was not doing the things that Zach believes that he was doing, I think the still a public signaling from crypto Twitter of sending Zach over a million dollars to help pay for this suit is important because even if Zach gets this one wrong in that particular version of the universe, we still want Zach to do the stuff he's doing because his track record is so strong. And so like we still want Zach around, I think we want to support him. Bankless, we sent him $25,000 just to help support him and kind of wrote a thread to talk about why we were doing this.
And so like, yeah, even in the event that like Zach misses one or two every now and then like on net, oh my gosh, he's such a valuable resource for the crypto world. So again, all of these links are in the show notes including the donation address for Zach XBT if you feel compelled to donate to Zach's defense. Okay, all right. That was all of the big news of the week. Coming out next, we got the three arrows goose get sold for how much? I will tell you. And then there's Nike's NFT platform.switch continues to grow even though no one in crypto Twitter seems to care. Metamask is going cross chain.
I will talk about that and more. But first a moment to talk about these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. Metamask has something new. Introducing Metamask Portfolio. Metamask Portfolio is the best way to view your crypto portfolio from a holistic level. See everything across all the chains all at once. In your portfolio, Metamask will report the aggregate value of all the assets in your Metamask wallets. And even the other wallets you import too. But Metamask Portfolio isn't just a passive portfolio viewer. It is a place to do all of the money verbs that make DeFi so powerful. You can buy, swap, bridge, and stake your crypto assets.
So not only is Metamask the easiest place to see your wallets in aggregate, but it's also a powerful battle station for all of your DeFi moves. So go check out your Metamask Portfolio because it's waiting for you to open it up. Check it out at portfolio.metamask.io. If you haven't experienced the superpowers that a smart contract wallet gives you, check out Ambire. Ambire works with all the EVM chains that are out there. The layer two is like Arbitrum, Optimism, and Polygon, but also the non-ethereum chains like Avalanche Infantum. Because of the power of smart contract wallets, Ambire lets you pay for gas and stable points, meaning you'll never have to spend your precious eth.
Again, the web app has numerous fiat on-ramps to make it easy to dump your fiat for crypto. And if you like self-custody, but you still want training wheels, you can recover a lost Ambire wallet using an email and password, but without giving the Ambire team any control over your funds. Check it out at ambire.com for the web app experience. But also, the Ambire mobile wall is coming soon for both iOS and Android. And if you want to be a beta tester, you could sign up at ambire.com slash app. And since you stayed to the very end of this ad read, you should know that Ambire is air dropping its wallet token to early users for simply just using the wallet.
So if you want to get started with the Ambire, all the links that you need are in the chinos. Is it a bull market? Is it a bear market? Or is it a goose market? Because apparently, you like that one. Apparently, it is a goose market because the goose, which is a ringer, one of the more famous R-block collections that famously three-euros capitals, Starry Night Fund, bought at the absolute top of the NFT market, has been sold for $5.4 million. Sue and Kyle Susu and Kyle Davis, of course, purchased the goose. This ringer is known as the goose in August 2021 for 1,800 ether, about $5.8 million. And so I think the value of the goose in ether terms has almost tripled.
August 2021, the ether was definitely around high three to low $4,000. So $5.48 million when they bought it, sold just now for $5.4 million. It was estimated to sell for $2.223 million. So basically, double the estimation. And it got sold to punk 6529, previous podcast guest in famous NFT bull. Anthony, what's your take on the story? Yeah, I mean, I don't follow the NFT space too closely. And I don't think I'm someone that gets it. I mean, I get collectibles. I get spending lots of money on things like this. But I don't know. It never really clicked me like, I look at this and I don't really feel anything.
It doesn't say anything to me. I mean, I see the goose, obviously, but it doesn't say anything to me. There's no kind of excitement for me about this. It's not something that I would even buy for like $10, right? But that's just me, because I have other things that obviously I'll spend my money on that are important to me. But I think what this says is really that NFTs here to stay, given even though 99% of them just trash right and are created for no reason for money grabs. But the NFTs that survive and that continue to thrive and continue to hold their value, it's just gonna really reflect the art market.
And the art market has been existed for thousands of years and it's gonna be a new cultural zeitgeist, I think. But it's gonna take a while to play out. It's not something that's gonna happen overnight. DC investor talks about this a lot. He's big into NFTs. He talks a lot about how this is like a multi decade thing. This is not something that's gonna happen overnight. And the things that survive for that long, you know, that's the typical thing with art. If it retains its value and stays in the cultural zeitgeist for decades, centuries, then it is incredibly important and incredibly valuable just because of that alone.
It let alone all the other reasons why. So I think that maybe ringers is that's right. Maybe in 10 years, this goose is selling for like $50 million. Who knows, right? So I think that people obviously speculating on which ones you're gonna survive and which ones are gonna thrive and be culturally relevant going forward. But yeah, me personally, it's not something for me. It's not my jam. Yeah, I agree with you. I've never really felt compelled to buy the art blocks movement. I mean, I think they're cool, but they're priced to interest a person that is just beyond me. But regardless, I will say that like a ringer, the ringer, this is now the ringer.
There's the ringer collection. I think there's always like a 10,000 art block collection. There might be, it might be a different number, but it's like that. This is the ringer. And so like, there's definitely a premium because it's the goose. It actually looks like something. There's also a moose. I think DC investor owns the moose. But like there's like art blocks or these like ringers that look like animals. And so they have a premium to them. But the goose is famous because of Thurough's capital. Like they bought it because it was the goose and then they got liquidated because they spent, money at the top.
But so like this has like a legacy to it, but having a ringer be bought at $5.4 million in the middle of a bear market, I think absolutely cements art blocks and things like this as valuable. Like these things aren't going to zero. There's always going to be a market for these. When the precedent is set that in a bear market, something will be bought for $5.4 million. That's the culture I was kind of talking about, right? That's the story. Like the things that tell stories, usually things that are very valuable. But it depends on what story you resonate with. What story resonates with a large crowd, stuff like that.
So for me personally, I put value in things that obviously I personally experienced and like trading cards, for example, that I collected as a kid. They're very valuable to me or in game items when I was playing online games, things like that. Those things more valuable to me. But other people who are into NFTs want to own the culturally relevant pieces and the things with interesting stories behind them, then yeah, I totally get why someone would go for something like the goosey art. But yeah, just it speaks to I think the different kind of, very different subjectivity there is in the NFT kind of market.
Yeah, big agree, yeah. Okay, so moving on into DotSwish. We covered this a little bit over a month ago, maybe five or six months ago or weeks ago. DotSwish is Nike's NFT platform. I think it's a playoff of DotEath, where they have DotSwish. So the headline here is that Fortnite and Nike have teamed up on NFT-gated drops. And so users can link their Epic Games and Nike DotSwish account to get achievement NFTs that grant them access to first access to future DotSwish Air Max virtual collections. And so definitely going to categorize this thing in NFTs and things that are meant for specific people who really care about Nike and that whole sneaker side of the world.
But I think the interesting thing here is that Fortnite is now being plugged into the DotSwish ecosystem. And so achievements in the Fortnite universe are tied to their DotSwish profile, cannot be traded, sold or exchanged. And so this is just the DotSwish platform growing. The DotSwish platform has attracted a lot of users. And these are all not anyone that you would find on crypto Twitter or inside of Discord or in your telegrams or talking about the goose. These are completely adjacent communities that are I'm assuming enjoying their DotSwish virtual collection achievement experience. And the fact that this is like growing, this is Nike and Epic Games are doing stuff with NFTs and NFT-gated drops.
They've created their own words that aren't NFTs that are more suitable to them. They're not using crypto transactions. You can buy these things with your credit card. But all of this is totally happening in a very crypto-native way. Anthony, do you know what chain this is on? I don't know nothing about this. I think this is my peak boomer moment because I'm looking at this and I'm like, what's going on? Obviously, I know who Nike and Epic Games are. I know about Fortnite, but I look at this and I'm like, wow, maybe 10 years ago this would have been a thing that I looked at. But now I'm looking at it being like, I understand obviously why a little bit more excited about this and why it appeals to a certain crowd.
But yeah, I'm Max Boomer when it comes to this. Well, that's the point, right? Like, it doesn't have to be for us. We are allowed to have products on our chains that are meant for other people, non crypto people. But I think this might be on the Polygon POS chain. This is on the Polygon POS chain. This is on the Polygon POS chain. The fact that crypto people don't know that is on the same chain that we do all of our DeFi things on. Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's bullish for adoption, that's for sure. And I've long said that there's going to be a lot of things happening in crypto that I'm going to have no idea about.
And I'm not going to really be following closely, but I'm going to bring in a lot of users. Okay, moving on to back into the crypto native things. Metamask has integrated Connect network. And so here, what is Connect? It's basically a cross-roller bridge. It's a bridging service between various relapses around the Ethereum ecosystem. So inside of Metamask Portfolio app, and the Metamask browser extension users can now bridge. So there's a bridge part of Metamask. Connect enables trust minimized, what does that mean? One that doesn't rely on external validators, so should be more secure. Trust minimized communication between chains and layer twos.
So eth main net Polygon, even BNB chain, optimism and arbitrum. And so the reasons why Metamask chose Connect, they cited reg recent and regular audits of the deployed code contract, battle tested with time and volume on multiple main nets, high liquidity and reliability, robust handling of failure cases. So this is a pretty cool partnership. Metamask, of course, is a sponsor of bankless and also disclaimer, both Ryan and I, and I think also Anthony are all investors, angel investors, into Connect network. Anthony, what's your take here? So Connects, obviously, as you mentioned, is like cross chain, cross L2 bridge.
But I think what they want to do, and want to evolve into and want to be more involved with, is doing kind of like cross chain native applications. So basically, applications that are made, are built with Connects that allow for native cross chain things to happen. So not just the bridge between chains, but having apps that actually deployed and kind of work on multiple chains and have that interoperability going on kind of between them. So it's cool to see a Metamask supporting it because it means that any apps that get built using Connects technology, any cross chain apps that is powered by it, will also be available to Metamask users.
And Metamask, as a wallet, has more users than I think any wallet in the ecosystem still by far. In the bull market, they reported I think 20 million monthly active users, which was pretty big. Yeah, yeah, right. So, but I think that's obviously come down a lot recently with the bear market, but at the same time, they have a huge market. So getting Connects integrated with that is obviously huge win for Connects. And Metamask already natively supports any EVM chain that you want to connect to, which is the majority of the ones that actually have anything happening on them. So yeah, it's a partnership that I think is really bullish.
Yeah, I remember during our episode with Olaf Carlson Wii from Polychain, a line he said that stood out to us was that it's all chains and bridges. As in like even bridges are also chains themselves, as in like they also have state and apps on them, which I thought was an interesting perspective. Maybe state's not correct, but the idea remains that just like, yo, bridges do very similar things to chains themselves. And so that is, I think, with the world that Connects is stepping into, let's see. Do you have anything you want to say on that, and you want me to move on? I mean, I just kind of like generally agree, but it kind of remains to be saying how it's going to play out.
I think that with the prevalence of all these new app specific altos, the cross L2 cross chain things going to become more prevalent. But it's remains to be seen if people actually want to use cross chain native apps, or they just want to use their apps on the different chains and the different app chains and just bridge between them. Thank you for the station. Coming up next, we got questions from the nation. We got some questions I pulled out specifically to be more relevant for Anthony here. So we're going to go back and forth on these questions. And then we got some hot takes from crypto Twitter.
And then of course, we're going to finish up with what David and Anthony are bullish on. So we're going to get to all of those things and more. But first of all, we're going to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. You know Uniswap, it's the world's largest decentralized exchange with over $1.4 trillion in trading volume. You know this because we talk about it endlessly on Bayclas. It's Uniswap, but Uniswap is becoming so much more. Uniswap Labs just released the Uniswap mobile wallet for iOS, the newest easiest way to trade tokens on the go. With a Uniswap wallet, you can easily create or import a new wallet by crypto on any available exchange with your debit card with extremely low fiat on rent fees.
And you can seamlessly swap on mainnet, polygon, arbitragem, and optimism. On the Uniswap mobile wallet, you can store and display your beautiful NFTs. And you can also explore Web3 with the in-app search features, market leaderboards, and price charts, or use wallet connect to connect to any Web3 application. So you can now go directly to DeFi with the Uniswap mobile safe, simple custody from the most trusted team in DeFi. Download the Uniswap wallet today on iOS. Here's a link in the show notes. Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web3 landscape.
Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1, producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With a recent addition of Arbitram Nova, gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitram home. Both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. On Arbitram, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees. With Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit Arbitram.
io, where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app. With Arbitram, experience Web3 development, the way it was meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. And we're back with questions from the nation. This one coming in from gleeman.eath. Anthony, this one I've specifically picked out for you. What all layer ones are most likely to pivot into being layer two's. This is a question I thought of while making sad. Trumbo knows his noises at my Algo and Adam bags. Anthony, what's your perspective here? So I have a lot of thoughts on this topic.
I know you do. I will try not to rant on too much about it. I think just at a high level, a lot of these L1s, they have founders who are very egotistical. And because of that, they really want to make their L1 be this thing, right? They want to grow this L1. They want to grow this ecosystem to be this big thing. They want to grow it to be as big as something like Ethereum. And they have a lot of vested emotional interest in that happening. Now, if they were to pivot that L1 to an Ethereum L2, what they're doing is admitting defeat, right? And I think you always have to look at the human element here.
Because this would be like someone who creates a company to compete with a big company, right? And then they get acquired by said company. Even though they stayed it all along the way that they wanted to compete with that company, they wanted to kill that company. They wanted to be bigger than that company. And then in the end, they're just like, oh, well, we failed at that. We'll just get acquired or we'll kind of just pivot to being friendly with them or whatever it is, right? So I think that that's a huge, disincentive and a huge point against a lot of these old L1s becoming L2s on Ethereum.
Another point is that these old L1s, most of them don't have much activity to begin with. So them pivoting to becoming an L2 is, but we're not going to help with that. I think it would actually be worse for them because I think it would just show a signal that their weak ecosystems and they need to actually become an L2 on Ethereum to even have a chance of growing an ecosystem. And then they just have to compete with the existing L2s on Ethereum, which obviously have all the favor, have all the network effect, have a lot of good will within the community already there. And on top of that as well, they have their own native tokens where people believe that the value of these tokens for better or worse, and this is not something I believe, people believe this, that the value of these L1 tokens comes from obviously it uses a staking token, but also it uses a fee token.
So would they pivot to being an L2 and then still use that token to pay for fees, or would they change to something like ETH? I think still using the token to pay for fees would hamper adoption, because a lot of people don't want to buy those tokens just to interact with the chain. And if they're coming from Ethereum, they have ETH. So you're going to have to accept ETH to be used as fees. ETH is a better unit of account. It's much more liquid. It's a better money, right? So that's going to be the asset that dominates your ecosystem. So what ends up happening to your token? Well, you now have to pivot that token to being something else.
Maybe it's a governance token. Maybe it's a staking token for sequences to accrue value there. But in saying all that, I don't believe that most of a token's value comes from its users like paying fees. I believe most of a token's value, especially when it gets to like ETH and BTC's level comes from its money-ness and its store of value, whereas a token can be equity-like where it will accrue dividends, for example, from fees being paid on the network and that fear of when you're going to token holders, but that's very different from the token accruing value because it is a fee-token in of itself.
So those are just some of the things, as I said, I don't want to go on too long about this, but those are just some of the things that I think may mean that pretty much like the vast majority of L1s will probably never become L2s themselves, but they may get forked. There is already a project working on a fork of Salana as an L2 on top of Ethereum. So maybe they get forked and turn into L2s by other people, but them actually pivoting themselves. Yeah, it remains to be seen. Maybe one or two do it. I'm not sure which ones those would be. I don't think it's, unfortunately, I don't think it's going to be Cosmos because they have a pretty different ecosystem to other L1s where the Cosmos thing is like, the Cosmos hub, right?
And then you've got these spokes around. So you would have to coordinate the spokes to also integrate with, it just wouldn't really work. And Algorand, I mean, I don't know that much about Algorand, but it doesn't strike me as one that would actually pivot to being an L2 either. So yeah, those are the some of the reasons why I think for the vast majority, it's not going to happen. Yeah, I agree with most everything that you said. And I agree with in some circumstances with everything that you said. And then there are other circumstances which I think the opposite is where the case to consider.
I do agree with you that the ego and primacy of some layer ones gets in the way of them becoming L2s. I think if you can name the founder of a layer one and you follow them on crypto Twitter and follow their tweets, that founder's not going to roll their thing into a layer two because there's like ego and audacity involved, right? Like layer ones want to be layer ones. They want to exist in of their own, right? So the major layer ones, the mayor players, right? The major Alt layer ones. I don't think we would consider it. I don't think we'll see those rolling up into layer twos because like what you're saying, it's admitting defeat.
If you are a layer one, your asset is competing in the world of money or at least trying to. And if you become a layer two, you are no longer competing in the world of money, right? You are waving the flag and saying like, hey, the Ethereum ecosystem, the peloton of the Ethereum ecosystem is just going to outrace me and I totally understand that. Like a lot of layer one founders, the valuations depend on that not being true. Now on the other side of things, there are layer one chains that don't have that demand or desire to be a layer one money and they are meant to do certain things that aren't necessarily be Ethereum killers, right?
More like chain specific, more ecosystem unique layer ones that like again, the founders aren't so ecotistical. They are willing to work inside of a peloton, but perhaps going into, and what is a peloton? A peloton is like the line of bicyclists who are all in a line and they're all drafting off of each other. And that's my kind of vision for the layer two ecosystem. People that want to join the herd, join the ecosystem, I think, and might be compelled by all of the economic activity. They might be compelled to do that. And I don't want to only make it an ecotistical thing, but also it's just like, it is a tribal thing.
And so if you are a crypto tribe and your tribe is centered around a layer one, that layer one pivoting into a layer two is against the social contract of that one ecosystem. Like they don't want to violate that social contract. That layer one tribe wants to be a layer one tribe. And so making the choice to become a layer two is against, kind of, probably, the will of the community. And also just like, it's, yeah, yeah. I was just on that point, the culture, right? And the reason why I bring up the ecotistical founders is because if you have a founder that's ecotistical, that's the culture that's set, right?
That's the culture that the community adopts. That's the tribalism that they adopt. And I think a good analogy here, just to show what we mean by the how hard it would be for an elder one to be between elder two as well, is can you imagine, like, let's use the analogy of different nation states on Earth, right? Could you imagine China becoming an ally with the US, right? And then the US effectively not owning China, but China just admitting defeat to the US. Imagine the implications of that, right? And this is obviously the extreme grand scale and grand side of things. But this is how to think about it, where you have your own culture, you have your own social contracts, you have your own ecosystem, your own community, your own tribe, and then you basically say, well, okay, we're not going to be our own thing anymore, we're going to get, we're going to get here.
And we've seen these play out in real life for tens of thousands of years, but just by force, where countries invade other countries, they go there and they're like, okay, well, you want to have part of our country, but the integration is very hard because there's different cultures, right? And there's different people that have different belief systems and different things like that. And that's why you've seen all the problems in the world around multiculturalism, right? And I'm all for multiculturalism. I mean, I live in Australia and we're very multicultural here, but a lot of problems stem from that because of that clashing of cultures, because of that clashing of belief systems and social contracts and culture over thousands of years.
So when you take that as an analogy and apply it to crypto, it's the same thing, the different communities, not at the same scale, of course, but different communities, belief systems, you know, the Salana, for example, the Salana ecosystem has a very different belief system about what blockchain should be to what Ethereum does. It's the polar opposite. Salana believes in the monolithic vision, Ethereum believes in the modular vision. You couldn't get Salana to integrate with Ethereum. Exactly, and if you try to, and if you try to cross pollinate, it may work, but it's not gonna work at scale, right?
There may be some people that can get along with each other, but it's very different because you're gonna have this tug of war going on constantly with the Salana community being like, no, you know, this is how it should be done, you know, this is the monolithic approach we believe in this approach. You can have the Ethereum people being like, no, this is how it should be done. So keeping those things separate is much better than putting them together, and then progress being halted basically because could you imagine the Ethereum governance process being weighed down by people who just don't align it all with Ethereum values and what Ethereum wants to be?
So yeah, that's how I think about this, and this is like level 10 crypto stuff, whenever we talk about this stuff, I always feel like I lose some people because it's such an intricate thing and such a nuanced thing, but this is what powers blockchain at the end of the day. This is what forms strong chains. This is why Ethereum and Bitcoin, you know, give it credit there are so strong because they have this, they have these strong social layers, they have these strong kind of things. And these other ecosystems, they're always trying to grow, they're always trying to break out, they're always trying to form their own, but it's very hard, right?
It is very hard and most will fail. Yeah. So going back to the original question from Gleamann, what all layer ones are most likely to pivot to being layer two's? I think the answer is there are some that are more likely than others. There's the specifics, you know, impossible to tell, I will say that I have a meeting on my calendar with a layer one leader call it, that is interested in asking that question of like, what does it mean and what does it take and what are the pros and cons of pivoting to a layer two? So that conversation is not irrelevant, like some layer ones are perhaps interested in joining the herd and I will leave all of that alpha at that.
All right, takes from crypto Twitter. Of course, we're gonna start with Eric Wall. He says the switch of opinion from and layer two must be EVM compatible or it's DOA.on arrival to actually a layer two that doesn't take this chance to get far away from the EVM is kind of missing an opportunity. This is kind of a hard tweet to read, but he's saying that that take happened fast within me and no notice and I just woke up and felt, one day felt different. So let me just like re-agurgitate, reiterate this take again. Eric Wall is saying that once upon a time he thought that all layer two must be EVM compatible or else it's just not gonna work.
And then he switched his opinion to actually a layer two does need to take the chance of getting away from the EVM and if they don't, it's missing an opportunity and that he switched his opinions very fast with no notice, he just woke up and one day felt different. So Anthony, again, we are in like level eight, nine or 10 of Twitter, crypto, Twitter terminology and conversation, but what's your take here? The conversation of like do layer two should they just be as EVM equivalent as possible or should they take a chance and be very, very different? And I'll just add one little bit more kind of context.
I would say things like stark net are a layer two on Ethereum that is extremely different and extremely specified and away from the EVM. Also things like Aztec, a very different, very, very unique and separated from the EVM. And then you have optimism which is like maximally EVM equivalent, arbitrum to polygon pretty similar. And so there's a different strategy here. So what's your take on these two perspectives? So my take is actually Eric's next tweet where he said, the correct take is probably, let's try both and let the market decide. This is what I have always said. I've always said that the EVM compatible stuff is fine.
It is obviously, it obviously makes a lot of sense for teams to do this because the EVM has a very strong network effect and it's very easy to integrate with all the existing infrastructure that exists such as wallets and stuff like that. But at the same time, there is an opportunity with L2s to do non-EVM stuff because you do not need to follow the rules of the Ethereum layer one protocol. You only need to follow those rules to post your proofs and data down to it. But anything else, you can do whatever you want, right? You can build whatever construction you want and start, as you said, stark net is doing, a stark way is doing this with stark nets, as tech is doing this with their new privacy first rollup which they've said and stated numerous times that they couldn't actually do what they wanted to do using the EVM, they have to build it from scratch.
So I am all in favor of trying both and letting the market decide. And in saying that, I think the market so far has decided that the EVM stuff is very valuable, right? It's very valuable and not just within the L2 space but within the L1 space as well because the old L1s that actually had any kind of economic activity, most of them were EVM compatible, right? Like your avalanche subchain that was even compatible, your phantom, a few other things. I think Salana during the bull market at least was not EVM and had a bit of activity there for a little bit but hasn't really kept that. But neither have any of the other L1s to be fair.
Whereas the L2 EVMs have gotten, you know, pretty much mostly the activity. Stock net's going, you know, it's going slower because it doesn't have that existing network effect and needs to build it. And then obviously, as tech will have that same kind of issue there, but at the end of the day, we're still very early in the game. There's still millions and tens of millions, hundreds of millions of people to onboard. So let's, you know, build these things. Let's see what people want to use, what they find to be, most user friendly, where they find to be the most value. And that's not dictate things.
And I'd be probably like a little bit bearish on L2s if it was just EVM stuff. I would kind of be like, well, this is a missed opportunity here. We need to do more than that. And, you know, it's not just Stockware and, and as tech doing it, either it's Arbitrum actually doing it as well with their stylist thing, where essentially you can code up smart contracts in non-solidity languages. So basically any language that you want to use. So that's another part of it as well. That plays into this, not limiting people to solidity, but letting them code their smart contracts in other languages. So yeah, I mean, as I said, let's let the market decide at the end of the day.
Yeah, and it's also not just completely a binary choice of being EVM equivalent or very, very differentiated. I think ZK sync is mostly EVM compatible, but there are differences that actually do separate it. And so it's nowhere near the specific specified end of the spectrum like Aztec or Starknet, but it's also not EVM equivalent like Arbitrum or Optimism. It's mostly EVM compatible except for a few small nuances. And then the ZK sync gambit is that those small changes produced outside benefits with what can they can do on their chain. Like account abstraction, for example, account abstraction, not EVM equivalent, immense benefits, right?
And so that's why platforms like ZK sync and other ZK rollups begin with account abstraction out of the gate because people have elected that that choice is just a smart choice. All right, next take, this is from nixo.eth. And so this is a retreating a picture coming from the East, take your subreddit. And the title of this post on Reddit is, had enough exited my validator. And then continues and says, sorry, the APY is way too low. Eve continually declining in price. And exchanges are being shut down or charging of fortune and fees. At this rate, crypto will be a back alley or relic. I'd rather put the money into assets that appreciate and generate a decent return.
We'd all love that. When crypto is this difficult to use, it will never see wide adoption in regardless the API is incredibly low for the effort and risk required. See ya, so ex validators exiting the service. And then nixo retweets this picture and says, this is healthy and working as intended. The Ethereum proof of state consensus mechanism doesn't overpay for security like proof of work did. If there are more than enough validators, low yield encourages you to put your assets elsewhere. Validators are in service of Ethereum, not the other way around. Anthony, help me interpret this. Yeah, so I gave a pretty long kind of take on this on the refuel the other day, but I can kind of condense it down a little bit just to give people the high level here.
So firstly, the poster that nixo has shared, there's a lot going on in that post. It just seems like a very angry person. They're not just angry about each staking, they're angry about other things. And it's funny because I think this was posted like at the bottom before we pumped or something or the local bottom before we pumped, so another funny thing. But generally, I guess the point here is that the issuance curve and the APR of each staking is variable, right? There's two sets of rewards. There's consensus layer rewards and there's execution layer rewards. They're both variable. More validators come online, less consensus layer rewards for everyone and less execution layer rewards for everyone assuming the same demand.
Now, execution layer rewards are incredibly variable because they rely on tips and MEV revenue. So if gas is at 100 whey, you're going to be making a lot more as a validator than if gas is at 20 whey, right? But assuming same demand of 20 whey, then as more validators come online, that APR is going to drop as well because it needs to be spread out among those validators. So it remains to be seen at what point or what kind of, I guess, yield percentage, people stop kind of crowding into each staking. Like, is it 3%, is it 4%, right? I think if you do like a backward looking APR over 30 days, it's still like 5.
5%, taking daily and weekly APR is kind of useless. Even monthly is not great. So, you know, because it's a yearly thing, right? You're extrapolating out a yearly kind of APR based on just like a day, which I don't think is very accurate. But it remains to be seen where people are going to stop kind of plowing at the staking because it just doesn't become worth it. But that's the thing, if they leave, if people say, oh crap, the yields are low, I'm going to leave. Well, okay, then it'll reach a equilibrium where people will be like, well, okay, I'm not going to leave because the yields are actually good now because the yield goes up for everyone assuming same execution layer rewards because the consensus layer rewards have to pay to less people and obviously the yield goes up for everyone.
So, it's a balancing act, it's designed to naturally reach an equilibrium based on supply and demand dynamics and based on obviously preferences where there is a bit of a range that gets thrown into this is the extra yield you can get on things like LSTs. So, for example, people have been talking about eigenlayer and saying that, okay, well, if the vanilla yield you're getting from the beacon chain is 1%, right? But you're a new restake and eigenlayer and they're paying 4%, then your yield is like 5%, right? It remains to be seen if that yield is ethonominated but let's assume it is, then you've gotten a 5%, but you're only getting 1% from the beacon chain.
So, that throws a wrench in things and that might be something to worry about later down the line when it comes to Ethereum's consensus and this is actually the main concern that people bring up around eigenlayer but generally it's a balancing act, as I said, it's designed to reach an equilibrium. Mm-hmm. All right, coming up last take of the week. This one's a short one. This is Chris Brinisky retweeting one of his own tweets and he goes for his initial tweet is, when it feels like it'll never end, it ends. And I'm pretty sure he's talking about the regulatory fund which just felt like an onslaught for like almost a month straight and then he retweets it and goes and so it begins.
I think Chris is just calling for a pivot in sentiment which I definitely felt this week. Now it's only one week old. Maybe Gary Gensler's got another shoe to drop or something but I think what Chris is really just saying here is man, this storm felt really dark but the night is darkest before the dawn and all of a sudden you just needed one or a few reasons to be bullish and all of a sudden it begins. Any takes here? I mean, it's amazing how fast crypto sentiment changes just generally, right? And I think that because of the speed at which it can change it catches a lot of people off guard. So I don't think that the sentiment change of the last week is going to lead us to a new kind of ball market any time soon.
I still think it's going to take a little while for us to get to a full blown crypto ball market from here but at the same time everyone's now like, okay, well, was that it for the regulatory stuff? Are we actually entering an era of positive outside or external crypto institutions and people being positive on crypto? That's a speculation right now. I think we might be, as I said, I did put out my own tweet where I said it felt like the regulatory fud bottom was in because it felt like they're overstepped but it remains to be seen. I don't like taking short term things and extrapolating them out to the long term.
I don't like looking at like one week's worth of data and saying, oh, okay, well, that means the next year is going to be amazing because that's how you very quickly especially in markets and investing, get yourself wrecked. So I cautiously optimistic, I see this. I'm okay, this is a positive change. This does feel like a win change but let's see if it actually continues. Let's see if it's not just something that happened and that's going to be short lived and then we just straight back to what we were at before. Let's wait and see and then we'll see how it all plays out but this is also when it comes to investing, this is where the maximum alpha comes from.
If you can accurately predict the win change or the sentiment change and accurately predict the timing of it, you can make a lot of money because you place your bets at the right time but most people don't do that. They wait for confirmation. Just like I was saying, you wait for confirmation but at the point of confirmation, you might be buying an asset two or three times what it was at the point of a win change. So it's like the risk reward curve just gets better and better as you go up but the risk gets lower and lower, the reward gets lower and lower as you get closer to confirming that win change rather than betting on it when the risk is still high.
All right, so as we're closing out this weekly role and once again, thank you so much for coming in and substitute teaching. Last question for you. Where do you bullish on? Man, like ETH, of course, obviously. Like that's not even a question. But there's generally I am a bit lately becoming very bullish on like just the app-specific altos just because they're finally becoming a thing, right? We didn't talk about it but Zora chain launched, I think today it was in the agenda. What's up with that? We did an entire podcast with that with Jacob from Zora. So yeah, news of the week, Zora launches an update stack chain.
Sorry for not quitting that in the weekly role. Yeah, yeah. So Zora chain Aivo, which is an options chain built on OP stack, has been getting a lot of traction lately. So just these kind of app altos, I'm getting more and more bullish on because they're actually getting traction, they're actually going live. So yeah, and I think that that's going to be a trend over the next few months at least. But then the pendulum might swing back to generalized altos once base launches because that's obviously going to be a huge launch and going to bring in a ton of new people. So yeah, that's kind of what I'm bullish on.
But what about you? What are you bullish on? Oh, I love that you've learned that. That's what you're asking me. I love you've done this enough times. I'm kind of back to the conversation we were just having, which is that sometimes bullish sentiment begets bullish sentiment, which is what you were saying. So sometimes the winds just change. And I remember going through the 2018 to 2020 bear market, thinking like, man, what is it going to take to get us out of this? We are so deep in this hole. And all of a sudden crypto Twitter just woke up bullish one day. And I know you always tweet and woke up bullish.
One day the entire industry just decides to be bullish. We're just done being bearish. And all of a sudden the bear colored glasses turns into bull colored glasses. And you see that we dumped off of the SEC news. But then we just rallied right after it. And so what is how is news impacting markets? Well, we saw a 15% rise in Bitcoin in the last week or so. And so we have capacity to go up. And I think as soon as the winds change, as soon as bullish sentiment comes, we can look back at the last year of innovation, all of the progress of layer 2s, including the layer 2s that don't have tokens, cough, Zora network, the brand new one.
And we can look back at all the things that we've built and be like, I'm not taking crazy pills. All of that is really bullish. I would like to get exposure to that before anyone else. And all of a sudden the desperation turns into hunger and good hunger, right? Bullish hunger. And so I don't know if this is that. Like you said, no one really knows when the winds change. We could be back to being bearish next week. But I do think that the time is running out. I had, oh my gosh, I know you had this too. I had so much bullish fatigue at the end of 2021. I was like, I'm just done being bullish. I'm just so tired of this.
Like we're talking about the next Web3 gaming Ponzi and NFT, I'm done. And I feel like we're, I don't know if we're at that point now, but I'm kind of done being bearish, right? I'm fatigued of being bearish. And I think that works both ways. And so what am I bullish on is I'm bullish on the sparks, the embers of bullish sentiment be getting further bullish sentiment. And so that's what I'm bullish on. Yeah, I mean, I agree with all of that. I think that, yeah, I like that sentiment of being sick of the bull market, especially for our multi-cyclers and being like, we want to break from this, you know, but bear market would be welcomed.
Even though we kind of forget, I think how many more bear markets for. Yeah, we definitely forget how painful they are. But at the same time, they're a necessary thing. They're a cleansing of the ecosystem. And just like the bear markets are necessary so are the bull markets. So yeah, even if this win change takes another 12 months to actually play out and to get us into a new bull market, if we look back on this in 12 months, and we can say, okay, well, that was when it changed. That's when the wins changed. That's when the sentiment changed. And that's what led to where we are today. Who knows, maybe we will, maybe we weren't, I'm looking forward to it.
Yeah, and maybe one last piece of clarity on this or just commentary. The wins changed very clearly during the last bear market when Compound released their governance token. It was the first utterance of governance token that we've ever had. And liquidity mining was a thing which created yield farming. And that was a very clear moment. It's like, yo, the wins have changed. There are things to be bullish on. It's also when the asset was issued. Like, hey, we have a reason to issue tokens. And that was an endogenous factor. Whereas this BlackRock ETF and Tradify bullishness on crypto is more of an exogenous factor, I do think we need an exogenous factor to truly spark a bull market.
Because every single bull market that crypto's ever had has become, has come from an appetite for tokens and appetite for minting new assets. I don't know if we have that yet. I'm not sure about that. Mm-hmm. I don't think we have that yet, but I have been saying over the past two weeks, especially that I think that we could potentially be gearing up for a layer two summer in the next six to 12 months, where that brings that back. Cheatness. You know, places for people to play with, tokens will be launched, basal their life, doing it in a lot of new users. So yeah, I really do think that we could get a repaint of DeFi summer, if the timing's right.
I think the timing will probably be right. And just maybe just a little bit more commentary in alpha here. I do know of at least two startups that definitely was planning on releasing a token last bull market and then the bear market hit and they were like, we're gonna sit on our hands and release our token later. So there is pent-up air drops that people are just waiting for bullish sentiment to reemerge so that they can release their air drop. And so not only is there like, okay, once we have a bullish catalyst, we have all these layer twos that can issue tokens, but there were other tokens that were going to be issued a couple of years ago that have not yet been issued because people were like, okay, the founders were like, the market's not right, we'll release it in a bull market.
And so you know that there's some kindling ready to light a fire when bullish sentiment gets bullish sentiment. Yep, exactly. Okay, Anthony Sisono, thank you so much for tapping in. Once again, of course, the daily way is where you can get your daily dose of Anthony Sisono. 30 minutes every single day is where I get my news. It's where so many others in the Ethereum ecosystem get their news. You can go to YouTube and type in daily way. I get it on my podcast. They find the podcast feed for the daily way is a little bit hard. So at me on Twitter, I can send it to you. Anthony, any last words about the daily way before we sign off here?
Thank you, covered it quite well. Yeah, if anyone wants to hear me rant about Ethereum every week, day for 30 minutes, then the daily way is where you will find me. Yeah, and you'll also find him actually on the weekly roll up twice in July. This time with Ryan, because I am taking my first ever vacation, ever from bankers. I think I need one of those. I think we need one of those. Well, if we're talking about a bull market starting, like I need to take our vacation before that starts because I'm not ready for that. Anyways, so more of Anthony coming, but if you can't wait for Anthony and RSA to have their first ever weekly roll up debut, you can go to YouTube and type in the daily way.
Risk and Disclaimers, Bankless Nation. You know the deal. Crypto is risky, DeFi is risky. You can lose what you put in. But we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we are glad you are with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot.