In this episode, we discuss escalating global tensions and their impact on crypto markets, questioning whether Bitcoin is a risk-on or risk-off asset in times of instability. We cover legal developments around Tornado Cash, the potential for an XRP ETF amid SEC scrutiny, and Visa’s new fiat tokenization platform on Ethereum. Plus, don’t miss details on the upcoming Kain vs. David fight at Permissionless! ------ 📣 0x v2 | NEXT GEN PRICING ENGINE https://bankless.cc/0x ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦄UNISWAP | BROWSER EXTENSION https://bankless.cc/uniswap
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle 🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT https://bankless.cc/toku
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/73?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ TIMESTAMPS & Resources
00:00 War And Crypto https://x.com/PeterKwoba2/status/1841177421179183405 https://x.com/lexfridman/status/1841253627190517785 https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2024/10/02/bitcoin-regains-61k-in-worst-start-to-most-bullish-month-as-israel-iran-tensions-rage-on/ https://x.com/legendarygainz_/status/1840733999930413127 https://x.com/VitalikButerin/status/1840944416997195974
08:49 Markets https://pro.kraken.com/app/trade/btc-usd https://farside.co.uk/btc/ https://x.com/NateGeraci/status/1840036803404800018 https://www.coingecko.com/en/global-charts
12:26 L2 Update https://l2beat.com/scaling/summary https://www.growthepie.xyz/chains/ethereum https://www.coingecko.com/
17:57 Rate Cuts https://x.com/Cointelegraph/status/1840819209879896455
22:58 Tornado Cash Updates https://x.com/BanklessHQ/status/1839408070524547246 https://www.theblock.co/post/318417/tornado-cash-founder-roman-storm-to-face-trial https://x.com/jchervinsky/status/1839478184808460325 https://juicebox.money/@defend-roman-storm
32:21 Ripple ETF? https://x.com/BitwiseInvest/status/1841464422557954168 https://x.com/NateGeraci/status/18412784213655720187 https://x.com/EleanorTerrett/status/1841586154258285021
35:10 SEC Director Updates https://x.com/SECGov/status/1841548406029754524 https://x.com/GOPMajorityWhip/status/1841560880955158916 https://x.com/jchervinsky/status/1841572472195305651
38:57 Visa Launch On Ethereum https://blockworks.co/news/visa-to-help-banks-test-tokenized-assets-smart-contracts
40:30 Vitalik On Alignment https://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2024/09/28/alignment.html https://x.com/RyanSAdams/status/1840026201999495332
43:08 Pectra Upgrade https://www.youtube.com/live/PWhn8KdgCl8?si=2dyOikXU9ja7lbji&t=2762 https://github.com/ethereum/pm/issues/1153#issuecomment-2377002932
47:32 Coinbase's New Exec https://x.com/jessepollak/status/1840929040854892966?s=46
48:14 Polymarket https://x.com/shayne_coplan/status/1840033666723938669?s=46
49:01 The gm Heard Round The World https://x.com/cz_binance/status/1839861237850497271?s=46
49:26 North Korea https://x.com/skesslr/status/1841421864779833494
54:35 Fight Prep https://x.com/TrustlessState/status/1841094626108748128 https://x.com/kaiynne/status/1841642359378829411 https://polymarket.com/event/hoffman-vs-warwick?tid=1727184262347
If you don’t have your tickets yet, Bankless has something for you! Bankless listeners - 10% off tickets with BANKLESS10 Bankless citizens - 30% off tickets with the link in the shownotes https://bankless.cc/PermissionlessDiscount
If you do have tickets and you are a Bankless citizen, don’t forget to sign up for the Bankless Meetup! https://lu.ma/yj5pdeqe
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Bup-bup-bup. It's actually crazy just like watching the missiles rain down on Israel. Yeah, so what you're hearing is the sirens in Israel as I were on launch 200 ballistic missiles. So I'm getting through the iron dome into Israel and Global globally markets just got really scared. Oh, yeah, this is this is a peak global uncertainty I think at least on this year, and I think we should say obviously before we get into this roll up just a sentiment check This is like not this is bad news for everybody for the entire world, right? And I think Lex Friedman put it well when he said probability of World War three feels higher than ever a global war would destroy humanity I pray for the wisdom of our leaders.
I think you know, we we also echo that sentiment This is kind of a concerning time that we're in for sure I think all eyes are kind of pointed at the Middle East right now not really knowing what happens next But neither neither side either the is anti-Israel pro-Israel side really seems to be interested in taking the foot off the gas at the present moment Yeah, I mean, hopefully this doesn't escalate into something wider and of course all of this global instability affects markets including crypto markets and that's been a theme of the week This has been the worst start to October as these tensions have Raged on and it calls in a question.
I think what we've talked about you remember that black rock report where they're talking about Bitcoin is actually sort of a An asset when there's global uncertainty it like it should appreciate the way gold does in global uncertainty It kind of wasn't in the aftermath of this which is kind of interesting last night's So this is the published the day after these attacks last night's Bitcoin price action Bitcoin was negative four while gold was up almost 1% in the aftermath of the Iranian attack and this kind of puzzling when you try to think about Bitcoin being sort of a Global instability type of hedge This is what a black rock was talking about as their frame of understanding around Bitcoin now There could be a difference of time frames here Bitcoin could just like go risk off in the very short-term while Global instability over the long term might actually benefit Bitcoin.
That is still possible Also since we're talking about this There was this a tweet that went out with this new polymarket front page We're just talking about all these these different markets that are related to this crisis in the Middle East Will Israeli forces enter Lebanon in September 86% chance will I ran strike on Israel before November? Will the US evacuate their Bebebebe embassy before October and the tweet on this the screenshot of polymarket It says it feels wrong that polymarket has an entire Hezbollah betting section that makes war look like a football game to bet on Which actually caught Vitalex attention who went and responded?
I'm actually in support of these I support these existing the point of polymarket is that the perspective of traders It's a betting site but from the perspective of viewers. It's a news site There's all kinds of people including elites on Twitter and the internet making harmful and inaccurate predictions about conflicts and Being able to go and see if people with actual skin in the game think that there is something that has a 2% chance or a 50% chance It's a valuable feature that can help keep people sane. So just it's interesting to see Crypto respond to global current events and Increasingly high fidelity fashion.
Yeah, it's like war betting does seem crazy and like viscerally when you look at this And you're like these these charts. I guess viscerally my first reaction is like is this like a war betting market? And that seems like it does seem wrong So I share the original like posters of visceral reaction and yet I also agree with Vitalex that when you look at the the the probability of all of these things is there a better source of Actra information around this like in a world where I have no idea what's going on and The risks of various escalations and attacks. This is a fantastic source of information for that So I share that from Vitalex as well I just kind of wonder what the rest of the world thinks about all of this in crypto And I do think this brings up a broader question in crypto.
It's just like I think sometimes The outside world looks at crypto and they're like oh, yeah, you guys are betting on like bunkers hyper financialization Yeah, you guys are betting on doomsday scenario and like you're hopeful that you know fiat inflates to infinity So that you can go hide in your bunker and have Bitcoin and that's like a very anti social type of like And human right but but it's interesting with Bitcoin and more so with it Ethereum I think it it's kind of juxtaposed from like it's it's not a pessimistic technology But it kind of is and also it's not purely an optimistic technology But it also kind of is it's almost like this Synically optimistic technology because the entire Bitcoin and even Ethereum project is basically cynical from the perspective of Hey, we we can't put all of our trust in centralized institutions And you know if we don't have balance of power and decentralizations They will increase in their level of corruption, right?
So it's cynical from that perspective, but it's also optimistic From the perspective of it's building an alternative and it's building a new set of tools that people can use that fosters Trust so it's just this weird juxtaposition. I find myself in being a a theorem in Bitcoin bull I think for whatever take there is out there of oh these crypto people are just betting on world worth three They're betting on the the destruction of the earth and that's just like what they're doing their whether culture is It seems to be pretty adjacent to people say that say crypto has no use case And it's because the crypto has no use case for them But go talk to somebody in a developing nation that has escaped their hyperinflating currency using stable coins And now like there is information here like two million dollars on will israel invade lemon on before november 86 percent 80 percent chance That has been that has now been able to inform people's Actions and choices about their lives as it relates to them And this of course is just the hezbollah section of polymarket There's other sections of polymarket then now people can have information Good quality unbiased Market-based information about how to make choices about their lives Aside from the fact that other people are betting on these outcomes.
Yeah, agreed David we got so much more to talk about it's not just a word stuff today Roman storm of tornado cash had his motion to dismiss yet file motion to dismiss his court case It was rejected this week and David there are massive implications for this I want to talk to you about the the judge made a ruling that might actually imply all defi operating in the united states Is illegal a money transmitter? We got to discuss that Ripple might be getting an ETF if bitwise has its way But the SEC says not so fast and wants to go back to the drawing board about the XRP versus SEC case about ripple being a security Wow going all the way back there And then also visa debuts a fiat tokenization platform on ethereum With banks as its biggest customer Powell's predicting a couple more rate cuts will discuss that also north tree and hackers are invading crypto companies like on mass This is a wild story.
We got to get into and Bekloss listeners stay tuned to the end because I got some alpha on the cane versus David fight At least I hope I did you do that's happening next week. I hope you do anyway, David I give you this alpha or do you have this? It's it's a A mix between your alpha and my alpha combined and you have alpha that you haven't given me I don't know Wait to the end and you'll hear all that it's happening October 11th And there's going to be a special offer for everyone try to get last minute take us to that flight and to permissionless So stay tuned for we get into the markets We're gonna talk about two our friends and sponsors over at 0x for building 0x of v2 a full stack upgrade of the whole entire 0x project an upgrade of their crypto trading APIs bringing you multi-hop and multi-plex routing So if you want to make a big trade or even a small trade There's a bajillion different permutations of making that trade and 0x v2 goes through all of those permutations to make sure That you get the best final price on your trade not just the quote Not just the best quote, but the best final on chain settled price the one that actually matters to you And it's just first in class for large trade small trades all kinds of trades This is what matcha is built on I'm a big fan of 0x and matchin everything that they're doing over there There is a link in the show notes bankless dot cc slash 0x in order to get started this one's for the devs right it's an API around this yeah Yeah, yeah exactly All right, let's get to the prices on the week day And I want to look at these charts in some detail thanks to Kraken for providing these charts All right, where are we on the week and where was the The missile dip that we saw earlier yeah, turns out crypto prices are inversely correlated to the number of missiles launched in the world Bitcoin currently clocking in at $60,000 $300 dipped below 60,000 But got back above 60,000 pretty pretty pretty quickly that you said do you say down seven percent on the week down seven percent That's a big one.
It's a lot. It's a lot for Bitcoin. How about ether? Down 11% on the week started the week at 2,640 currently at 2,300 and 15 I think that actually means it's more like down 12% because that's a dip to lower than when I put these numbers in Okay, so what does that tell us does that tell us that like global instabilities even worse for ether relative to Bitcoin? Yeah, ether has always been like the more optimistic Optimistic token of the two and I'll it always just moves more than Bitcoin. That's right Let's go and check on the ETF flows starting with Bitcoin Maria on the Bitcoin ETF flows It has been some big weeks up last week, but in the last two days $242 million out of the Bitcoin ETF on the first 64 million dollars out of the Bitcoin ETFs on the second At some point these are just gonna be called a equilibrium last week was a huge week There was like almost a billion dollars of inflows into Bitcoin ETFs alone So I mean, it's not bleeding that much.
I mean October first was kind of the Tuesday that the missile strikes took place So it makes sense. You'd see a drainage Is that the first day that there's outflows from the black rocket in a Bitcoin ETF? Wow. I think it might be oh wow Yeah, well the first day a while right No, I think that might be the first day ever ever. I mean, I think that might be the first day ever This chart only goes back like 15 days here. Yeah, I don't think I think that's the first day ever that Bitcoin had outflows You actually think that's the first day ever that black rock has had outflows. Yeah, it's always been inflows Yeah, that's the first red number there.
I'm pretty sure that's true. Someone fact check that. I don't know about that I'm gonna place a bet. I'm gonna place a bet No, I've done all my money's going on that cane versus David bed. Okay, all my betting money on which side Well, we'll have to wait the end to find out Ether outflows similar to Bitcoin 48 million dollars on the first actually had 20 million dollars of inflows on the second So wasn't the inflows weren't too rattled I would say by the By the Middle East conflict. Okay There was a milestone that was passed which is nice though. This is a pretty big milestone So the eye shares.
That's the black rock Ethereum ETF just eclipsed one billion in a total asset So assets under management of above one billion So it's now in the top 20% of all of the ETFs of all time and it did it in two months So it feels like that feels like a big deal But also it still feels like I don't know Ethereum's little brother syndrome of like Bitcoin already smashed all of these records So now I look at this and I'm like, oh cool like you know the second place trophy doesn't seem that great In comparison, but it's going to the little brother that's five years younger. Yeah Well, especially when you meld it with this David.
This is the Bitcoin ratio and we're under zero point four again. What are we on the week point zero three eight five So that's been as low as it has been it got this low on the 19th of September and it's back there again. It's bottoming bottoming And bottoming Bottoming can continue. It can continue to bottom. Yeah, you know continue to bottom And how about total crypto market cap are we we're still 2.2 trillion on the week. Yeah, still healthily above a two trillion. Well speaking of health one thing That is healthy in the Ethereum economy is the layer two economies and thanks to mantle for this layer to update This is what caught my eye This week so this is a new set of dashboards created by the the grow the pie analytics team It's just like you know crushing it and they call these economics dashboards And here's what I kind of picked out this is if you sort this on the one year And you look at L2 profitability you can see david a number of very highly profitable Layer two's that have built on a theorem.
So nine chains in total. We actually have to define what profit is Oh, yeah, should you do profit in the term of of chain terms. What do you mean by profitability in in the context of a blockchain? Yes, so the revenue that a layer two in particular makes is the sum of fees that were paid by users of the chain So if you use base if you use arbitrum of use optimism school et cetera, right as a user you're paying some fee Okay, so that's the revenue that they make And the cost in this context is kind of like a gross profit metric So the cost in this context is the fees that they have to pay the layer one that is Ethereum in order to settle and Provide a data availability for this service So this is why we our analog has been a theorem Like layer two's are essentially reselling Ethereum block space to the market and they're reselling that on a profit margin So the delta is gross profit margin essentially revenue less less cost is your growth gross profit margin The story here is there's now nine chains in total that are very much in the green 150 million dollars they've made a gross profit over the last 12 months is really cool to see this Economy of chains like here here was kind of my my bulltake on it david in Tweet summary Ethereum has already produced nine chains with gross profit each chain is an economy Ethereum is a federated union of economies with eth as its money.
I think this is very bullish Eath Even if the market's not reflecting it at this point in time For some reason people really just don't like this profit word and maybe you really love you with the Semantics maybe you can argue with the idea of profits, but what but what you cannot argue with is that 50 million dollars of Eath over the last year ended up in bases treasury which is coin base or it arbitrum 22.3 million dollars of Eath went to the arbitrum Treasury. I don't know what you want to call that, but there's 22 million dollars of ETH there Revenue from base over the last year 64 million costs of base 14 million that's not a lot of costs in comparison to the revenue arbitrum 58 million dollars of revenue 35 million dollars of costs And these are the the nine chains that are profitable the nine layer twos that are profitable Are nine out of the ten chains that are profitable the 10th being tron Tron is the only other than the ethereum layer one we're talking about with all the chains not just all the chains All the chains that exist in crypto The ones that are profitable are the ethereum layer one these nine specific layer twos and tron and that's because you're adding another element here Which is you're considering issuance of these layer one chains as cost right so for Which some people also debate But the layer twos do not have additional inflation or additional issuance have to have they can't issue if they choose to but is not forced upon them for security Because Ethereum pays for their security.
Yeah, and I mean the reason I say a federated union of economies with ethers Money is because there's another dimension here that the economics charts and grow the pie don't show which I think is really important is There's a massive amount of ether being used as economic bandwidth and money on say for instance base You know there's almost 600,000 ether it's like 1.3 billion dollars of ethos money on base Equivalent amount even more on arbitrum and so that is the ethos money use case But I will say david there's another way to interpret this data set So I got some pushback from some of the make the l1 grade again type folks like bread Who's got some great analysis on on Twitter and what he sees is a different lens on this So what he sees is the profit margin percent and basically he's saying that like yeah Chains are in the green.
They're making profit But almost at the expense of the l1 so their profit margins are like 95 percent I think that's I think that's of accurate take it is at the expense of the Layer one P&L sheet. Yeah, it is true It is in it in in a way because so these layer 2s are making 95 percent profit and only for every one dollar that they make They're getting 95 cents of that and they're only paying five percent back to the eth l1 That is yeah, the roll up centric roadmap. That's what that is yeah But you could interpret that and you could say well eth is not being burnt anymore It's not returning cash flows to Eathholders and therefore it's true actually bearish eth I don't know if it's bearish eth it's bearish It's bearish if you only value eth on the P&L.
Yeah, I am back to and we should have a longer discussion and podcast about all of this like I think it's evidence by the fact that we're talking about it for so long. Yeah, for sure, but like back to you Eathbie this is fantastic for eth being money and That is the only thing that matters in the l1 game. I'm coming back to like the um L one I've got to write our money Like that's all that they do everything else will be like app layer take fees and you're not going to be able to preserve that Anyway longer discussion should we talk about Powell for a minute? Yeah, Powell says there could be to additional rate cuts this year But don't get too excited because he says not that fast not that fast He said the recent 50 bips of interest rate cuts should not be interpreted as they sign that future moves will be so aggressive He says this is not a committee that feels like it is in a hurry to cut rates quickly If the economy performs as expected, this would be two more rate cuts this year a total of 50 basis points more So we would get one percent in the year 2024 this year.
We are not getting we are not we do not have like ammo loaded up with 50 bips each We're just getting perhaps if good things go according to plan just 50% more total this year kind of extra fine Kind of expect right now. Yeah, I think the things to monitor as always as you now you know post pivot are the jobs reports The fed balance sheet fed deficits all of these things will contribute to The global liquidity and therefore the demand of commodity crypto money assets And also jobs reports coming in looking good so far. Yeah, so yeah So good job openings are up and joblessness claims are although I haven't seen David this longshoreman stuff so Oh, I have not I have Costco shelves.
I can't find toilet paper anymore. There's been like another run on the shelves It's like that's happened locally where I live and it's happening around out of toilet paper Yeah, it's because of the toilet paper. No, I have toilet paper. Okay, it's like we maintain a stock all right I'm not crazy. I'm a prepper. You know this. I'm a crypto guy. Of course. I have toilet paper Crazy But yeah, that's so that's another you know kind of thing this week that I don't know if you caught but I mean that could wait Do I need to go get toilet paper David is not a prepper. No, I got it for both of us. I'll send you stuff if you need it What do we get coming up coming up next?
Why was the free speech argument rejected in the tornado cash court case and what does it apply for the rest of the industry? I think Ryan's got a little story to tell And then my story for you guys is bitwise filing for the XRP ETF But the SEC is filing for an appeal at this ripple case the case That actually decided that crypto assets are not in of themselves securities that a securities transaction could happen But that securities transaction does not create a security of the asset So we're going to talk about this and more but first I'm going to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors That make the show possible especially Kraken are a preferred place for buying crypto in 2024 If you do not have an account with Kraken by now consider Clicking the link and show notes getting started with Kraken today If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams Then head over to Kraken one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible inclusive and fair financial system Making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you Empowering you to make your first or your hundreds trade in just a few clicks And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way Along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together It's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto Whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro Go to Kraken.
com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be Not investment advice crypto trading involves risk of loss Uniswap wallet is officially the preferred wallet of bank lists And it's the one we use anytime when we want to transact on-chain Whether you're on your browser or on the go Uniswap wallet makes it easier than ever to swap anytime anywhere Use your wallet to transfer funds directly from the top centralized exchange And tap from thousands of tokens across the dirt And over 10 other chains like base, arbitrum, and optimism Uniswap wallet delivers deep liquidity, fast execution, and reliable quotes With zero gas swaps through Uniswap X And when it comes to security, you can rest easy knowing it's backed by Uniswap labs One of the most trusted teams in DeFi Their code is open source and independently reviewed So you know it's protected So why wait, download the Uniswap wallet today on Chrome, iOS, and Android And don't forget to claim your free uni.
eth username directly in the mobile wall Start swapping smarter with Uniswap Have you ever felt that the tools for developing decentralized applications Are too restrictive and fail to leverage advancements from traditional software programming? There's a wide range of expressive building blocks beyond conventional smart contracts And solidity development Don't waste your time building the basics from scratch And don't limit the potential of your vision Cartesi provides powerful and scalable solutions for developers That supercharge app development With a Cartesi virtual machine, you can run a full Linux OS And access decades of rich code libraries And open source tooling for building in Web3 And with Cartesi's unique roll-up framework You'll get real world scaling and computation No more competing for block space So if you're a developer looking to push the boundaries of what's possible in Web3 Cartesi is now offering up to $50,000 in grants Head over to Cartesi's grant application page to apply today And if you're not a developer, those with staked CTSI Can take part in the governance process And vote on whether or not a proposal should be funded Make sure your vote ready by staking your CTSI before the vote's open Roman Storm, the tornado cash developer, had a motion to dismiss his own case That motion was rejected The ruling by the judge calls into question Whether defying United States is actually currently operating illegally Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, okay That's the crazy part, dude My understanding was that the Roman Storm case determines whether or not The United States can make a smart contract illegal If Roman Storm goes to jail, it's because the ruling is yes Smart contracts can be illegal If we prevent him from going to jail, it's because the ruling is no United States smart contracts are just technology They're just software, you can't make them illegal, you can't violate the free speech That's what I thought was going on Is that what's not what's going on?
That's all true and it's also more I want to get to why this ruling is potentially Incredibly concerning to me and to some of the crypto lawyers That I've talked to sort of behind the scenes One crypto lawyer told me off the record That they're struggling to figure out how literally anyone Who's launched a defied protocol is not also committing a crime right now As a result of this ruling, David Not the future full case for Roman Storm That happens December 2nd, but this ruling So let's talk about what actually happened with this So Judge Filetia rejected Roman Storm's motion to dismiss In a New York court and ruled that the case could proceed to trial So there's a motion to dismiss that was rejected But then she also made a ruling And she made this ruling verbally, which is somewhat interesting Basically the court ruled that using computer code To further alleged money laundering is not a first amendment protected activity Okay, so the ruling says code is not speech And the she ruled that there was no custody requirement And legislation definition of a money transmitter And this is really important, this is the second part I was talking about Implicitly threatening the entire industry With additional requirements Okay, so code is not speech Like we kind of anticipated that could be some judges ruling Right, that was a possibility But the second part, that was the base case That was the known concern that we have Yes, so the second part, no custody requirement In defining a money transmitter So a smart contract can be a money transmitter A smart contract that does not like take a third party custody Right, yeah smart contract It doesn't require you don't have to be a coin base Or a block fire or Celsius Or a crack in Or that would be a custody requirement You just be a defy application And subject to a money transmitter That code that custody is money Yes, Ethereum is a legal See, that's the part that I think people are missing with this ruling The judges actually saying All non-custodial defy is subject to U.
S. money transmission laws So that means uniswap Potentially, that means AVE That means NFT trading To your point, does that mean Ethereum? We don't know that you can expand this so far Oh my god, yes If I have gold sitting on my coffee table Non-custodial Like the vibe around the gold The universe is a money transmitter Non-custodial is everything else That's not a custodian This would be hopefully an argument That an astute lawyer actually makes in court You know, he talked about physical objects Versus crypto objects And kind of like what's the difference But that's why this is such a concerning ruling And I was a little bit confused Like why is a ruling coming down I thought it was just a motion to dismiss To dismiss I thought the judge would just be saying Yeah, the court, the case will proceed for Roman Or like no, it will be dismissed But this is actual legal precedent So a ruling like this does establish some legal precedent It's almost like probabilistic finality If that makes sense, right?
It's like some proof of work This is the way the common law system works So you know, one judge says something Makes a ruling You know, the case isn't finalized The DeFi as money transmitters is not fully finalized And propagated across all of the US It's not fully settled But it does increase kind of the proof of work And the precedent is It does kind of harden the precedent here So we have the opportunity for other rulings in the future But it's kind of narrowed Yes, this is one judge But it calls into question If other courts will follow the exact same logic And define DeFi as being a money transmitter And the actual violation Is a violation of 18 USC section 1960 Okay, this is a section that deals with money transmitters in the logic And it pertains to the illegal operation of money transmitting businesses in the US And it's basically a federal crime to conduct control manage Or to own an unless license money transmitting a business Okay, and so what they're saying What this judge is saying is that tornado cash was as a mutable contract An unlicensed unregistered money transmitting business Which again, calls into question Is the uniswap code An unlicensed money transmitting business Is the AVE code unlicensed money transmitter business Who do they expect to ask for a license Exactly And the fact that Roman storm is now in jail And facing jail time as a result of a bad third party Terrorist North Korea whatever using this code I mean, the same could happen to uniswap, right The same Well, it's not in just smart contracts It's code So Ethereum Who Ethereum needs to go get a money transmitter license Right And so what are what are the penalties, by the way, for this section 1960 A violation Up to five years in federal prison For whom?
For the potentially the developers Roman storm was the developer of tornado cash in this instance He wasn't doing the money transmitting himself He was uh, he developed the code and put it on the code Now on chain Up to five years in federal prison Forfeiture of the business Finds up to 250k Right, so are you following why this is like potentially a big deal And again, it's one judge ruling But it's the proof of work precedent In our common law system that makes this incredibly concerning Do you think the judge understands the implications that they are creating So um, she actually didn't give this opinion in written form Usually judges do Usually judges give the opinion verbally And they also publish it in written form She didn't in this case She, this is Jake Chervinsky Uh, she said she's not going to write an opinion She read her decision from the bench and that's all we get All right, she didn't actually give a written opinion to defend this She just read it from the bench So the best we're going to get and we do have now is a transcript Of what she said from the bench But Jake says I think it says a lot that she's not writing it up So I expect she does know that this is contentious And has potentially disastrous uh, implications here And I think all of this causes a chilling effect, David It's like how how do you feel as a founder in the US or in any country Launching an immutable DeFi contract When potentially it's a money transmitter And the penalty for this could be arrest and going to jail That's that's the worst that this can get This is this is like a nuclear bomb for crypto It's kind it's kind of bad it's kind of that now now people will hear this and they'll say look It's one judge you're being chicken little about this uh, you know The DOJ might say something like don't don't be crazy.
Okay. This tornado cash These guys were tied in with uh, you know north korea DP arcade stuff. It's like bad dudes We're not going to bring criminal charges against avay or uniswap of course like But that's kind of like a trust me bro legal system It doesn't that depend entirely on who's in control of the deal of course Yeah, that's not how coursework yeah, so I'm worried because this court case feels like Nothing's protecting us from this The the trial of Roman storm where this will get determined to need either Even greater degree that's still scheduled for December 2nd in New York So that's expected the last two weeks We're going to be paying attention to that because it has massive implications Not just because of what you said earlier whether a smart contract can be sanctioned or not or can be deemed illegal That's part of it But also the future for all D5 protocols in the United States Well, I mean, I'll hammer on this point again It's code that is being like marked as the money transmitter Which means if you're a m bit coin like layer ones are therefore also money transmitters in this context right I don't know what we're going to do about this, but uh, we'll be taking a look I I am going to be talking I think you'll be out David you're flying somewhere But I'll be talking to Jake Turvinsky this Friday about this issue And hopefully getting some more legal analysis I'm not sure it's going to make me feel any better But um one thing that might make you feel better Is actually donating to the Roman storm court case So he's still trying to raise funds He needs more in order to pay the legal fees for this highly expensive Court case and if you want to go support that will include a link in the show notes So you can donate to that cause Are getting into subjects around ripple everyone's favorite blockchain Ripple wants an ETF, but Gary wants probably to say no So bitwise has filed for the first spot XRP ETF So now it's the ball is in the court for the SEC to approve or disapprove it Well, what do you think they're going to do David?
I don't know Nature RC commented bitwise position to file for the XRP ETF is highly noteworthy in the short term This is likely a call option on the November election he says Bitwise is a highly credible crypto native fund firm that does not just throw stuff out of all Yep politics matter clearly here in the short term, but I think it is all inevitable over time Are they basically saying if Trump wins then you probably have a shot at getting ETFs like the XRP ETF through But if he loses like either snowchance Yeah, that's probably right and I think there's probably actually some amount of demand It will be really interesting to see the amount of demand for an XRP ETF The XRP market cap has been a complete mystery to be as wide as been so high for so long There's some pool of demand somewhere.
I don't know where not in my not in my friend circles But somewhere on the universe So like seeing that show up in an ETF will be interesting But that's not the only ripple related news of this roll up the SEC wants to overturn a ruling by judge On Alisa Torres who decided that XRP was not a security and its secondary sales did not constitute security sales so this would imply that any token that's traded on like uniswap on any sort of decks or even on crack under coin base It's just because it's being traded does not make it a secure. That was great news, right? When XRP win ripple won this court case against the SEC.
It was great news Yeah, it took a lot of wind out of the sales of Gary Gensler's if in theory of investing Which is basically everything is a security But the SEC is coming back for a do-over asking for a do-over Just to be like this And so this can also delay the approval of the bitwise XRP ETF It's so you know the SEC not not done yet It's not even like once upon a time Jake Shurvinsky gave me the take that like maybe the SEC's position is that they're just going to take everything to court and Just they'll just let the courts decide by litigation or ruling by litigation Which maybe was a take but the fact that they're like losing and then going back to a deal Money is just like another layer of evil coming out of the SEC.
Yeah, I don't understand why the Democrat like Democrats don't just like Like get this guy out. Cut him loose. He is just completely rogue. I don't understand Like I haven't heard from Biden in months Kamala is busy trying to get elected Where is his basic support? Who's like? Yeah, Gary? You're doing a great. I guess we saw some of it in Congress when we saw that Brad Sherman's like cheering on Yeah, yeah, all the like Elizabeth Warren neo-bankers. I can't believe that's still a contingent He is just doing such a terrible job for the US right now and you didn't crypto, but not just crypto Some good news though this week his chief attack dog so SEC enforcement chief gray wall decided to step down.
It's not the gray wall from coin base. That's our guy to Paul gray wall So no our gray wall they're gray wall. Yeah, and he was known for aggressive policing of the crypto industry Just kind of leading the charge under under mr. gray walls leadership the commission authorized more than a hundred enforcement actions Against the crypto industry. So he is stepping down and there is some chatter about this Jake again, Jake's getting a lot of quotes in this episode. Jake Trvinsky saying it's this is not normal Not normal for an SEC enforcement director to get disappeared like this Gone on nine days notice with no replacement lined up Perhaps the inevitable end to a campaign of unlawful harassment and misrepresentation resulting in many embarrassing defeats in court So this could be a precursor to Gary Gensler also, you know being given his exit slip maybe Maybe this you know the door goes first Yeah, don't let the door hit you on the way up All right coming up next Fatalic has a solution for making Ethereum alignment great again And also has a take as to what the Ethereum road map should look like in the near term We're going to go through all that and more and also visa launching a tokenization platform on Ethereum for fiat aka stablecoins With banks is the customer that's kind of interesting banks bank the banks all of this and more but first I'm going to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible launching a token Don't let complex legal and tax issues slow you down Toku provide specialized support to optimize your launch and ensure that you as a founder and your team and your investors Get the most tax-efficient outcomes the Toku team understands the crypto space inside and out And will ensure your token launch is fully compliant while maximizing tax efficiency Toku can connect you with the best attorneys if you need them to make sure that you have the best advice And Toku can help to optimize your taxes So you pay the least possible amount of taxes while still maintaining legal compliance with Toku's guidance You can concentrate on building your company while Toku handles the logistics token launches don't have to be complicated Talk to Toku today to get a free initial token valuation The arbitrum portal is your one stop hub to entering the Ethereum ecosystem With over 800 apps arbitrum offers something for everyone Dive into the epicenter of DeFi where advanced trading lending and staking platforms are redefining how we interact with money Explore arbitrums rapidly growing gaming hub from a immersed role-playing games fast-paced fantasy MMOs to casual luck battle mobile games Move assets effortlessly between chains and access the ecosystem with ease via arbitrum's expansive network of bridges and onwards Step into arbitrum's flourishing NFT and creator space where artists collectors and social converged and support your favorite streamers fall on chain Find new and trending apps and learn how to earn rewards across the arbitrum ecosystem with limited time campaigns from your favorite projects Empower your future with arbitrum visit portal dot arbitrum dot IO to find out what's next on your web3 journey New projects are coming online to the mantle later to every single week Why is this happening?
Maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer two design architecture Since it first started building mantle DA powered by technology from eigenDA Maybe it's because users are coming onto the mantle layer two to capture some of the highest yields available in DeFi And to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the $3 billion mantle treasury in the mantle reward station Maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants liquidity support and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application Maybe it's all of these reasons all put together So if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto Or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's defi apps click the link in the show notes to getting started with mantle Pretty cool scoop by blockworks visa launches fiat backed tokenization platform on ethereum They are developing a new product to help banks issue fiat back tokens on the ethereum network The visa tokenize asset platform vtap will enable the development of fiat back tokens power by smart contracts to help Digitize and automate existing processes that will then power the exchange of real world assets Yeah, a bank would use visa's new platform to purchase tokenized real-world assets such as commodities or bonds with near real-time Element using a token the statement said The first financial institution to use vtap will be a Spanish bank bbva who expects a rollout of a life pilot in 2025 pretty cool all the visa visa on the ethereum layer one It's all based on ethereum hot so you know when you deposit funds into kind of your Wells Fargo account how it's not like a A dollar it becomes like a Wells Fargo dollar.
That's sort of thing. Yeah. Do you think there's a world where every single bank has their own version of like a tokenized dollar Yeah deposit on chain like there'll be like a Wells Fargo stablecoin kind of thing and there'll be a um, you know a bank of america stablecoin thing. I mean all of these will be fine robins 31 different Yeah, maybe yeah, maybe something like that would be so bullish for curve for curve Yeah, yeah, basically like a curve in a while. That's interesting Yeah, cuz it has completely just flipped into just like the background back end of like stablecoin exchange volume Just hopefully it's not illegal David Thank you for that render David you read this blog post fatalic shared early this week his thoughts on how to make ethereum alignment legible So he's getting to kind of like what are the values that really define ethereum and he mentioned a few things open source So allowing for the inspection of code to ensure security and reduce risks of lock-in So open source is a big ethereum value according to him open standards, you know things like ERC 20s ERC 1271's account abstraction that kind of thing Decentralization and security and he defines this a little bit like the walkaway test which is Does the app remain usable if the team and all the servers disappear like if everybody walked away Is it still usable?
I mean that's one definition of a decentralization and what's the potential damage if the team attempts to compromise the system So and then and then lastly he talked about positive some network effects for ethereum being kind of a core value So things like using ether as a token to enhance the ethereum network effect So this was kind of like these are soft and I would say more squishy values oriented Dimensions of what constitutes ethereum alignment But then he also created like a call to action to start measuring some of this And he gave some great examples of ways. We're already measuring it Which is it kind of cool like mev watch is a fantastic dashboard tool that measures basically the censorship resistance of ethereum You know what uh blocks our o-fax action and what aren't so that's good good kind of transparency checking balance We also have dashboards for a client diversity which shows kind of the you know the portfolio of diversity of all of the eth clients We have dashboards like l2b which is just phenomenal and kind of tracking the the centralization or decentralization levels of later To's and these are the the dashboard metrics.
He's kind of calling the ethereum community to kind of develop So we can have our own internal regulatory system. I got to say I think this is It's an unspoken value proposition of ethereum It's actually like a core strength ethereum has is these dashboards is kind of regulators as a check on the system To maintain the decentralization. They're certainly doing a far better job than any of the nation-state regulators Yeah, and I see this pretty uniquely in the ethereum community I mean there's some bitcoin there's some in other communities for sure But ethereum is really doing a stellar job at this I think regulation via dashboard It's kind of based actually.
Yeah, it's kind of cool. It's awesome Because like the dashboards actually don't enforce anything and actually just helps the social layer Become more informed and take more action about things Not the only vitalic take of the week on a core dev call Vitalic made a pretty strong appeal for increasing blob counts start for the petra upgrade Petra has been split into a very big hard fork has been split into two hard forks with Pure dash Which is the kind of the qualitative upgrade of ethereum blob space just allowing blobs to just pack more punch That has actually been pushed out into the second half of the petra update So tbd on that is being pushed out into the future As a result of that vitalic it makes an appearance on the core dev call saying since we are doing that We should create increase the quantitative amount of blobs today I thought that there's actually a pretty useful clip from the core dev call so we'll go ahead and play that right now I think I mean the reason why we need to think about this is because like if you just look realistically to me It's just clear that is yeah, like just scaling actual use it Usage is just incredibly yet important and I mean if ethereum does not offer this then like people will find it elsewhere and people are going to have Like insecure blockchain experiences that are just not on ethereum right and The yeah It's and I would even argue that like even a yet 33% blob increases probably more valuable than like even three of the yet Factory at peace at this point.
So if you're just like look at Like the yet ratio of efforts to value or just like the amount of actual value here is a quite high in terms of Increasing the increase in the amount of activity that can happen that was interesting like he almost never Appears at these core dev calls and ways in right and so this is not unprecedented But I haven't seen this in a while and you sort of making the case David that like if we don't do this Then users will turn to other communities that are less secure and less decentralized So is this war mode Vitalik this is the first time I've seen Vitalik actually been like hey Let me like draw out some of the actual points that he's making He wants to increase the blob target from three to four and the max blobs from six to eight And he cites the fact that currently blob space blobs are 75% full and making the case that if we reach 100% full Then as as a result of just being at capacity blobs are going to get expensive and layer two's are going to Choose to use different DA providers that aren't a theorem citing In unstable blockchain experiences And think it like therefore implying that Ethereum has a higher quality block space Which I think is pretty hard to argue that it doesn't but also he's like it's like a market competition Perspective of those like if we don't do this we're going to lose market share of rollups who use our DA And we want to we want to ensure that we have the best pricing of the best quality of it It's like it's kind of war mode but yeah still it's still penetration pricing right for it to get all collect all of the l2s and lock them in So some summary of the takes around the ecosystem dankrad as well are in other base devs are in huge favor of this Jesse said that base is actually interested in consuming even more blob space So he would approve any sort of just increasing of the blob space availability on the Ethereum layer one There's some pushback as well But generally I think people are leaning into supportive of this and what I think Tritologist it's just going to increase slightly to some degree the You know node requirements were banned for validators and stakers not not node requirements because that implies hardware It's just bandwidth costs and the bandwidth is like the big bottleneck for all Ethereum scaling in this present moment Yeah, I don't I've never seen those measurements actually like how much how much bandwidth does it take to actually run a Validator pre this and post this, you know, it's like obviously you have to have high-speed internet But do you need like you don't need gigabit internet at this point?
I think the argument being made by many solosakers is that solosakers live in places where like internet's not amazing And we want to be able to run a theorem in like you know, like your 5G network should be able to run There's a lot of places in the world that have like okay internet and we want to make sure that if you're I'm can run in places with okay internet. Yeah, I get it It's an interesting debate that's going on but Vitalik kind of leaning into the let's get competitive and let's go win this Speaking of a Jesse Pollock he has been elevated. He's been promoted to the Coinbase exact team So congratulations.
He's now actually working on the Coinbase wallet project as well as base In addition to joining the Coinbase exact team the Coinbase exact team. I don't know if it's these are the only eight people But there are eight headshots here from this Coinbase website saying our executive team starting with Brian Armstrong Of course Emily Choi and all of these very very professional like warmly tinted pretty uniform headshots And then when it gets to Jesse. It's his god damn crypto I love that like a trad investors and Wall Street are gonna see this you know and ain't all the annual filings They let him keep his crypto punk as his head shot.
That's just great This is kind of cool. You know Polly market has an app too So they recently released a I believe an iOS app might also be available on Android that allows you to just like Look at all of the different Election forecasts that Polly market is putting together because try to find medias is recognizing Polly market as a fantastic source of this type of information prediction information Of course, it's read only because actually participating in these markets like is illegal in the US right But it's number two on the download charts right now and that's above And download charts of news download charts of news and that's above the New York Times and CNN right now Yeah, it's kind of cool.
Okay, Shane Copeland the founder of Polly market calls this the flippening the news edition. So CZ tweeted out GM this last week. That's the news Why did he tweet out GM because it got released from prison So congrats and she's easy for getting out and a tweeting out a GM that got almost 200 Crazy 16 million I was wondering if you come out as a hero if that's what like, you know How crypto would sort of view him and certainly that seems to be the case. Yeah, definitely Um talk to me about North Korea Ryan talk to you about North Korea. Yeah. Yeah. Well, okay So the the relevant news about North Korea was this article from Sam Kassler From Coinbase and the title of it is how North Korea infiltrated the crypto industry and the subcaption is this More than a dozen blockchain firms inadvertently hired undercover IT workers from rogue states Mostly from North Korea.
So David over the last four years or so. This is starting to come out Seems like the crypto industry 12 companies that have just reported this. I'm sure it's far more that have gone unreported Uh, you know Organizations like sushi like urine finance like cosmos like phantom like injective. Okay. These are some sort of crypto DeFi related projects. They all inadvertently hired North Korean agents like accidentally So they post it. It works like this. You post a job post right software developers something And what's kind of the open source way you hire based on merit right like show me your github show me your like code I don't care where you live.
I don't care. You know who you are Can you share your race? Don't care your dad. Yeah, big question is can you ship and so these North Koreans are showing up with fake identities Let me show you an example. This is a fake identity from from Texas Okay, this is like a driver's license from Texas and there I would that would pass my They're even doing this with professional background testing. So this is a um a North Korean Agent which has a passport. Okay, and they're getting into these companies and starting to ship code And guess what why they're there David It's not to actually productively work These are agents North Korean agents working for the government and they were looking for ways to siphon funds Put some you know malicious code in a protocol find an opportunity to steal money in order to ship it back to North Korea and support North Korea's weapons programs and other things.
Okay, so Do you know dude Korea is doing almost anything that they can think of do you know, um zaki Manian zaki mania from from cosmos. Okay, it's like we've known him for a long time So apparently zaki inadvertently hire he got a message from the FBI saying there's some weird crypto transactions coming your accounts What's going on he looked into it and it turned out he had hired To North Korean employees at his like cosmos staking infrastructure company inadvertently And his comment was this I talked to them for every day for every day for almost a year They did the work and I was frankly pretty pleased Like they were good employees for an entire year Before they just imagine if it's your job to go get a job Be a good employee as somebody else like that's her job talking about playing the long game man like the long con here And this was kind of eye-opening for me because you know go further in the articles Is someone made the statement that It's looking like almost 50% of job applications for crypto jobs at this point in time crypto developers Crypto dev jobs might actually be North Korean agents All right, so what does this do to this trust fabric of everybody is hiring in crypto there are North Korean listeners of this podcast right now That is terrifying People are listening to this but there are people listening to this who are in North Korean Infiltrators of crypto companies jobs and they're like Fuck they might be on well like yeah, maybe maybe in their interviews.
They're they're you know dropping bankless Episodes that they've listened to or something like this right it could be relevant This is absolutely wild and god. I think what obviously if you're if you're hiring in crypto Be on the lookout for this be extra careful. You got to influence that friendship. Show them a Texas license Yeah, and I think this is this might be just scratching the surface like my nightmare scenario is Want to like a North Korean agent gets into kind of some core dev client code You imagine that Inject something like if you're the Ethereum foundation you're reading this. I hope you guys are doing some robust screening Right every single uh, yeah, that's working on a client because we have been a bit Trusting in this industry again the open source rule you can ship code you have merit.
Well some of these North Korean agents can do that Yeah, they're good employees maybe at efforts to seems and also another thing is do you know it's highly illegal To actually hire any North Korean Inside of the bankless discord inside the bankless ventures Ryan Sean Adams here drops a comment where he goes Hey, FYI, we need to make sure that portfolio companies aren't hiring anyone from North Korea hiring someone from North Korea is legal Yeah, I'm like, huh Well, but like it's illegal and it's one of those things where um if they decided to enforce it I mean, it's like possible like jail time and like like all sorts of bad things David all sorts of fines and stuff like this They haven't even forced down these crypto companies.
17,000 ways to go to jail Oh, I love this industry uh anyway, we're leveling up like no one else is front running all of the the chaos of the 21st century like crypto We're doing that for for everyone else Yeah, that's that's what I was here to do David uh you are getting ready for your fight. Mm-hmm. Okay. We're on the eve. Yep. We are what like seven days out eight days out the time of recording So uh we promised him alpha um you give some alpha. This is you. Is this a real life picture the picture of you Yeah, so Josh our podcast editor uh just came over to like this one on one time I had with my coach Because he you know everyone was very hyped about Nick Carter's video when he did his video So like you know, I I want one.
Yeah, uh you got a hype video coming up Yeah, I got a hype video coming up just stay tuned for that and I saw this hype video I think this is Kane Warwick's hype video I was not very hyped by this. I don't know about you. He didn't do too much to for me. Oh, wait I don't I don't know what it does to me, but I guess it's impressive He's getting that sound that you're hearing podcast listeners can getting slapped in the stomach by his trainer Like a slap in the stomach. It's not that hard. I mean he did he did 10 sit-ups my coach does that to me I don't film it. He's what was so weird to me is like you guys just recorded a podcast like the week before your fight So he came over the podcast it'll come out next week in in-person podcast all right, so we actually just settled the fight with A thumb or actually so like we're good No, what do you think?
I mean he's sitting probably on the couch behind you He's probably sitting across from you. You're you're staring into the face of you know somebody that's You're either gonna beat down or he's gonna beat you down and like what do you think? Were you intimidated or do you feel like I got this? I think it would be a pretty good fight I think we're pretty good fight. All right. Well, I mean, that's the alpha Honestly, I just wanted to hear what you said about this. Um, the polymarket right now could be an opportunity Bankless listeners. Polymarkets. That is a steady value Hoffman is deep value on the polymarket deep value according to David Hoffman 32% odds so this could be the buy of a lifetime Yeah, well, it's a 32% odds is the middle of the market if you buy me you're buying it 39% Wait, how's that work?
Uh, because they're the markets kind of the liquids. Oh, it's a spread. There's a spread Yeah, there's 10 KM this right now. I mean, yeah, we could boost those numbers up I think there's could be a fantastic. I wouldn't take too much to move this market pretty far Well, this is a I guess final notice because permissionless is this will be this is the last warning to come to permission I'm excited about it. I can't wait to see everyone in person It's going to be like content is going to be incredible Who are some of the speakers like I'm I'm talking about sticks in the first day I'm super excited about that.
I had the pre-call last week We've got a lot of things to say. He's got a lot of things to say. It's going to be interesting me and Jill Gunter from espresso are going up against Kyle Samani and Max Resnick wow about whether or not ethereum layer twos are ethereum I think that's going to be pretty hot wow and the the great thing is is that is just like four hours before my fight with Kane So I'm just going to be fucking jack I'm going to be ready to go just a dreddle and pump it All right, who wants to fight? No, it's it's going to be a great event and a reminder There's still if you're a last-minute person you're like, I don't know if I can just go it's in Salt Lake City It starts on what Wednesday Wednesday and Wednesday the 9th day of the 9th and Bankless party on Wednesday at 5 p.
m. At a brewery free drinks. I will not be drinking Ryan might be drinking So if you are a bankless citizen going to permissionless make sure you're coming to our party and Bankless listeners you get a 10% discount off these tickets So bankless 10 for your last-minute ticket if you are a bankless citizen There's a 30% link in the show notes for you where you can get a major discount guys You know crypto is risky you could lose what you put in but we are headed west next week We're headed to Salt Lake. This is not for everybody. We're literally going west We are going to the frontier But we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey.
Thanks a lot You