Bankless Weekly Rollup 4th Week of July 2023
------ 🔃 STADER LABS | UNLOCK LIQUIDITY AND AMPLIFY REWARDS https://bankless.cc/StaderLabs
------ 🚀Join Ryan & David at Permissionless II in September. https://bankless.cc/GoToPermissionless
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
👾POLYGON | VALUE LAYER OF THE INTERNET https://polygon.technology/roadmap
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
3:45 MARKETS 4:40 NASDAQ https://imgur.com/fN35vka 5:00 Recession Interest Rates https://www.reuters.com/markets/rates-bonds/fed-poised-hike-rates-markets-anticipate-inflation-endgame-2023-07-26/ https://www.bloomberg.com/news/live-blog/2023-07-26/fomc-rate-decision-and-fed-chair-news-conference 7:35 Stock Market Takes https://twitter.com/biancoresearch/status/1684279348709281792?s=20 https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1684571357613543424?s=20 https://twitter.com/salmoncreek7/status/1684574718232518661?s=20 12:00 BTC Hodlers https://twitter.com/glassnode/status/1683401299956465665 14:45 Layer 2 Wars https://twitter.com/artemis__xyz/status/1684549320979419137 https://l2beat.com/scaling/summary
20:10 Worldcoin Launch https://twitter.com/sama/status/1684297687708098565 https://twitter.com/worldcoin/status/1683372181428793344/photo/1 24:35 WLD Token https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/worldcoin 26:25 Vitalik’s Worldcoin Thoughts https://vitalik.eth.limo/general/2023/07/24/biometric.html 30:40 Worldcoin Controversy https://imgur.com/IoWpAVh https://twitter.com/LefterisJP/status/1683457277477437442 https://twitter.com/zachxbt/status/1683512389105229825?s=20 https://twitter.com/resistancemoney/status/1677259644321005568 36:25 Proof-of-Personhood https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1683824355178946562?s=20 37:25 In Summary https://twitter.com/ryansadams/status/1683951898653495296?s=46&t=2ZINVXJQKx6xO_6Wiiu_2g 38:30 Sybil Resistance is Impossible https://twitter.com/nicksdjohnson/status/1683940920146763776?s=46&t=2ZINVXJQKx6xO_6Wiiu_2g 39:10 Bankless Worldcoin. https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1683444128581812224?s=20 https://twitter.com/DeFi_Cheetah/status/1683678622887059456?s=20 43:10 Alternative to Worldcoin https://twitter.com/DeFi_Cheetah/status/1683678622887059456?s=20 46:05 WLD Value Proposition 48:20 Podcast and Debrief
https://youtu.be/4HFyXYvMwFchttps://youtu.be/Pni-7EqUslY
48:35 Blockchain Bills https://cointelegraph.com/news/crypto-regulatory-framework-bill-pass-house-congressional-committee https://twitter.com/jchervinsky/status/1684368595323584512 50:25 Richie Torres https://twitter.com/RepRitchie/status/1684282890245271555 52:10 The Bad Bill https://twitter.com/RyanSAdams/status/1682098917087887361?s=20
57:30 The Law of Chains https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1683969105529806849?s=20 1:01:05 Optimism Takes https://twitter.com/gluk64/status/1683964193291087872?s=20 https://twitter.com/gluk64/status/1684168523164319745?s=20 1:03:50 Starknet Appchains https://twitter.com/Starknet/status/1681603967787122688 1:05:10 Twitter X https://twitter.com/danmurrayserter/status/1683446198663888900 1:07:00 Elon Musk’s Goal https://twitter.com/danmurrayserter/status/1683446630245187584?s=20 https://www.reddit.com/r/BrandNewSentence/comments/1580t8h/membership_only_human_trafficking_gentlemens_club/ https://www.reddit.com/r/memes/comments/159957z/it_worked_so_well/ https://twitter.com/adamamcbride/status/1684040162500657152 1:10:15 RFK Jr Bitcoin Purchases https://www.coindesk.com/business/2023/07/26/rfk-jr-confirms-bitcoin-purchases/ 1:10:50 Selling Coindesk https://www.wsj.com/articles/investor-group-nears-125-million-deal-for-coindesk-146a6faa 1:12:25 Synthetix Infinex https://mirror.xyz/kain.eth/NHmuyvkRPXB4ck7R38v_ityer-VMZAaIwLGHu1hIDtE 1:14:10 Kwenta Volume https://twitter.com/superfluid_hq/status/1681330344794923014 1:15:00 Superfluid Subscription https://twitter.com/superfluid_hq/status/1681330344794923014 1:16:00 Chainlink Cross-Chain Interoperability https://twitter.com/chainlink/status/1680970793331613697 1:17:30 Flashbots Raise https://www.theblock.co/post/241327/flashbots-becomes-unicorn-after-completing-60-million-raise
1:20:00 Questions from the Nation
1:24:00 Market Makers https://twitter.com/MikeIppolito_/status/1682756221646823425?s=20 1:26:20 David in EthCC https://www.bankless.com/david-ethcc-2023
1:29:00 What David’s Bullish On https://twitter.com/TrustlessState/status/1684596913742434305?s=20 1:30:00 What Ryan’s Bullish On
1:33:10 MEME of the Week https://twitter.com/TiffanyFong_/status/1684352877488119808?s=20
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
The World Coin project is now live. It's on Maynet, the WLD. I guess it's wild. No, world. The world token is in the wild. Orbs are deployed and the crypto community absolutely hates it. Bankless Nation, it is the last Friday of July. That means it's the last weekly rollup of July. Well, I spoiled it, but what time is it, David? Oh, Ryan, it's the Bankless Friday weekly rollup where we cover the entire weekly news in crypto, which is always an ambitious endeavor, especially this week. This one's going to be a long one. So we're going to try to move fast, yet we persevere into the frontier nonetheless this time quickly.
I have no coffee this time, but I'm sure you do. Yeah, I always have coffee. Always, you know, never doubt. Why don't you have coffee? Do they not have coffee in Switzerland? They do have coffee in Switzerland. I choose to not drink coffee at 6.41 p.m. It's late where you are, huh? It is late, yeah. Tomorrow, you climb in a mountain. You climb in a mountain? Yes, yes. Climbing mountain pollocks, which is a training mountain, then we come back and rest, and then we climb Matterhorn next day. Geez, man. Well, we'll be training. If I opened up these windows behind me, you would see the Matterhorn.
We've got a lot to talk about this week. Mountains aside. We've got a mountain of content to climb here. So number one, world coin just launched, and most people love it, hate it. Love it, everyone loved it. Everyone loved the world coin launch. Universally beloved launch. Everyone is so excited for it. Yeah, no, obviously not. We're going to go through the takes of varying degrees of quality. Vitalik, of course, had a rational take. And then there's just a bunch of things to unpack, including the topic of world coin on the bank list podcast. We were a bit of main characters. I was a bit of a main character this week since you were on the episode.
So we'll talk about that. Yeah, you know what they say about main characters, David. We got to avoid that whenever possible. But we also got a main character crypto bill that's in the house. The house of representatives that is, it's actually maybe a good one. So we'll talk about that. There's also a bad bill in the Senate. So we'll contrast those two things. Dave, we've got to also talk about this new X thing. Twitter has become X. And Elon wants to make it the everything app. Does crypto have a story in there? I don't know. I want to get your take on some of the changes that are coming down the pike.
Yeah, it's a complete mess. But I continue to reserve my judgment. But we'll talk about that when you talk about X. Also, it's weird to call X. It's just not going to stick. Yeah, I don't know. I'm still calling it Twitter. Also, the recession seems to be off. At least that's what Powell is saying. We'll talk about that. And also the phase of the market that we're in. Last week, we gave you permission to be bullish. This week, I feel like it's a phase of the market that starts with an A. We'll get to that in the market section. Before we do, though, we got to tell you about our friends and sponsors over at Stater.
They are building a liquid-staking protocol. David, do you want to tell us about it? Yeah, Stater, it's the new LSD on the block. New LSD just dropped. We want more LSDs. We want more decentralized-daking service providers. The cool thing about Stater is that if you want to run a node with Stater, you only need four ethers. One of the lowest capital requirements that I've seen around. They have a pledge, of course, to a self-cap. If that day ever comes, that they need to implement that. Permissionless pool of staking node operators. These are the words that we like to hear. So if you want to stake your eth with Stater and run a node with Stater, there is a link in the show notes.
Check it out if it seems right for you. You can also get some SD token issuance on top of your eth yield if you choose to stake with Stater. Check it out. There's a link in the show notes. David, let's get to the market section this week. And we've got to start with King Bitcoin over here in the Kraken Pro charge. Thanks to Kraken for allowing us to pull this up. Looking at what are the numbers for Bitcoin this week? 29,800 is where we started. 29,300 is where we ended. The last $500 on the week, we are down 1.6% which I call flat. That is flat in crypto. We call it flat. How about eth price?
Same, same, same, flat, flat. 1890 to 1870 down 1% even flatter, even flatter. Back in the 1800s, huh? All right. I don't like the 1800s. I don't like it was. Yeah, it wasn't. I wasn't alive back then. It would rather 1900s and then 2000s, you know, and then we're finally in the future. If Bitcoin ratio is that saying anything on the week? Up half a percent to 0.064 just under flat is flat. Well, you know where the party is, David. Elsewhere, it's elsewhere. It's not in crypto. It's over in Stockland. So we are viewing the NASDAQ chart here and is creeping even higher towards all time highs on the week.
And this is really interesting to me because you contrast that with what the Fed is saying. Flipping to our Fed watch, the Fed just raised interest rates again this week. And this is the highest level in 22 years. They increased the interest rate by 0.25%. This was sort of expected to a target range of 5.25% to 5.5%. And the question is, of course, will they raise again in September? Powell said, I would say it's certainly possible that we will raise funds again at a September meeting if the data warranted. And I would also say it's possible that we would choose to hold steady. Anything is possible is what Powell is saying.
His comments on inflation, he said it's moderated since the middle of last year. And that's certainly what we're seeing in the data. Yes, moderated inflation. CPI is now at 4.8% when you exclude food and energy. I don't know if you should exclude food or energy. But the Fed still seems determined to hit 2% and still says they have a long way to go. But here was the headline news here. Powell also said that the Fed staff is no longer forecasting a recession. No longer forecasting a recession. Recessions carry interest. If it's not being forecasted, it's not happening. That's how recessions work.
How do you take that? I mean, the people who are saying that a recession is imminent, it hasn't hit yet. And now the Fed is saying, there's not going to be a recession. A lot of different ways to say this. The recession is such a nebulous term. I like all these headlines, I mean, it's not that in my gears. It's two quarters of negative GDP growth. Like it has a definition. Yeah. But the GDP measurements are poor. Inflation measurements are poor. Recession is also something that exists in consumer appetite and consumer confidence. There's so many things that go into what we're actually trying to talk about, which is like, do we have to hunker down?
Or do we just like check a technical box saying, we're in a recession? I was talking to one of my macro friends and their hot take was that we've been in a recession. We're already in a recession. And just because the numbers that the Fed measures shows that we're not in a recession on a technical level doesn't actually mean anything. It's so qualitative. It's so interesting, though. Why would like Powell is coming up fairly strongly in saying that they're no longer forecasting a recession. He's not. Yeah, because they want to say we stalk the landing. We threaded the needle. You're welcome. It's worth the Fed.
But it would be very strange if in a quarter or two, he has to eat those words and say, oops, I was wrong again. But they're the, they're the arbiters of recession. You were still in the other state, but Jim Bianca's take might take on the Fed high statement of the presser so far. It provided the least amount of information of any meeting since they started hiking in March, 2022. Powell is going out of his way to say nothing and not commit to anything. I hate these games. I hate these games. But this is not even our reinterpreting the words so they say, now we're interpreting the lack of words.
He also added to this tweet. I spoke too soon, says Jim. This headline just caused risk markets to fall. Powell fed staff no longer forecasting recession. This is how upside down we are. This is his comment on the Fed no longer forecasting recession. The Fed no longer sees a recession as thought to be bearish for stocks because it opens the door to more hikes or higher for longer. I've often joked that stocks would make a new high if the economy unemployed enough people. I was trying to be funny, but the market appears to be taking this idea very seriously. Seriously. I don't know what's going on to be honest, David.
So the recession hasn't come yet. That's one data point. Inflation seems to be tamed. Stocks are pumping. Real estate's up. Yes, bonds got a massive haircut. They got somewhat destroyed. So there's that wealth inequality, of course, has continued to increase. So there's that. But it feels like a lot of the macro bears have been incorrect so far, so far. And so some of them are saying it sounds to you like, well, just you wait. It's coming, right? We just haven't felt the wave hit us. There's been an earthquake in the ocean and there's a tidal wave out in the horizon. It just hasn't hit yet. We're just kind of waiting for it.
But I'm kind of wondering at this point, like where is, why aren't stocks down? Here's my big question for everyone in macro right now. How is it possible that Fed interest rates have been raised to 20-year highs and get the stock market is also nearing all the time high? I was told this couldn't happen, David. Right. That is crazy, actually. A commenter on that tweet said, I never thought it could. 5% inflation would cause a depression scenario is what I thought. Yet here we are and consumers are consuming away, regardless. It's kind of unreal, in my opinion. That's kind of the contrast to me.
It's like the rates have been raised to 20-year highs and yet risk on assets aside from crypto. But risk on assets are going back to all-time highs. How does that work? Yeah, that's actually nice. If you told us back in the start of 2022 when everyone in the crypto industry, including myself, was getting our minds wrapped around interest rates and flows and risk assets and then halfway through 2022 were all pummeled and then we're all gripping the edges of our seats, saying when's the pivot? When's the pivot? And the pivot has not come. I mean, there's been a decrease in acceleration of the raising of interest rates, but there has been no Fed pivot, not even after the Silicon Valley banking crisis.
And so after all of that, we still at text docs all-time highs. If you told us that in early 2022, without have been like, oh yeah, they did thread the needle, they got it right. Look at that. That's what I'm saying. That's what I'm saying. I don't understand what's going on. I guess still, my base case, again, what do I know about macro, is that this is some kind of slow motion, excess money printing inflationary crisis, but it's just happening so slow, like we just don't really know what the effects are. I know I would not want to be in sovereign bonds. That's for sure. I know that wealth inequality is going to increase.
I have no idea what inflation is going to do in the future. I have no idea about a recession. And now I'm like, I'm not sure even even matters. That's the thing. I don't know what that it matters, what Powell does in September. And that's kind of a weird place to be, because we're talking about that. I think the markets are saying that. They just have interest rate fatigue. I guess that. So at this point, what I do is I just kind of shrug ignore macro and just keep buying crypto, because I still think that in kind of this money printing world, even when I wasn't ignoring macro, I was still buying crypto.
I mean, happy what I'm going back to ignoring it. Clearly, I don't understand what's going on here. I think the question is, where are we in the market? And I promise an A word to describe this. I call this the accumulation phase of the market. And we could see it on the chart in front of us right now. This is Bitcoin long-term holder supply. And the number is up. So Bitcoin long-term holders control 75% of the circulating supply now. And this is an all-time high. And this happens at every point in kind of the bear market, particularly at this phase, the accumulation phase, is the long-term holders.
They're not selling. They're continuing to buy. They're continuing to pile in. Those with conviction are just not only holding through it, they're actually adding to their stack. This is happening with assets like Bitcoin. This is happening with high conviction assets like Ether, it's happening right now. And so what this means is, these are going to be the winners on the other side of this market. Everyone who got scared, everyone who sold low, everyone who's not accumulating right now, those are going to be the losers on the other side of this market. And it just plays out like this every single time because human psychology has not changed in 200,000 years of our history here.
It's just a natural order of things. Like the short-termers come in, they buy the top, they get shook out. And then people have to sell for the next year due to collective reasons of other people losing conviction. They have to sell for taxes, they have to sell for whatever. And then we run out of sellers and then people start to get okay and comfortable with where the market lands and then sellers turn into buyers or buyers start buying. Like the resonance between so many of the things we're talking about in the market at stocks, pumping and crypto being in an accumulation phase, that's 2019.
We've, I've seen this movie before. That's what we were doing this time four years ago. Like the patterns is happening once again. And four years before 2019, they were doing it like in 2014, 2015. Right. This is happened before it'll happen again. I think that sometimes people tend to over-complicate crypto investing, right? They try to focus on like how to win. And what I would say is, like our years in investing this asset, we can't tell you everything it takes to win. But I know you're going to lose if you're selling your eith and your Bitcoin, right? That's the recipe for losing. Oh, I think that people who have done best in crypto, in my experience, I don't know if this applies to you, David, it's just the one thing they've done consistently is they've just held.
Yeah. Like, it's as simple as that, isn't it? You just let the waves wash around you. Yeah, you don't even, it's nice if you accumulate. If whenever one of my trades doesn't work, I just hold it until it does. That's true for every trade. I know you've bought it. It's a surprising number of though. If you have conviction, you hold. That is the rule here. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. All right, speaking of different conviction, let's talk about layer two's. So the layer two wars have continued to keep you. They're the hottest they've ever been. They're so spicy right now. This was something that happened this week.
Optimism flipped arbitrum in terms of daily transactions. That's the red line. The first time that's ever happened. Yeah, flipping the blue line. And so that is a new event in the layer two wars. It doesn't mean arbitrums out though. Arbitrum still has a 57% of all of the layer two assets inside of Arbitrum one. Optimism has a 27%. And I really, I know we said this a long time ago, but I want to double down on this. Layer two beat. This is where we're looking at all of these stats. This really is like the default DeFi pulse of like, you know, 2019 and 2020. Remember the DeFi pulse, we're just constantly like, you know, the refresh button.
DeFi is getting bigger. You know, it's at $200 million now. Oh, it just crossed a billion dollars now. I'm doing the same thing with almost 20 of us that were bullish on DeFi when we first learned about the word. We're all like using this as like validation. This is our validation website. Now this is our later two thesis validation website. Well, look, we've got now $10 billion in layer two. So that's about the highest it's ever been. From an activity perspective, we can plot the activity. And this line looks like it's going up. So you could see. God, that is a great chart. Right? The blue line right here, which is a theory, it's kind of holding study, right?
Because the theory of transactions, the true theory of transactions. This is an ax. It's already maxed out. It's already maxed out. So it's not getting any higher. But look at layer two. Look at it rise. It's just. And like, dude, that is, that is the calm before the storm phase of that line. We're not even in the bull run. We're not even in the bull run. That line is going to increase in what's the word incline. That good thing is going to get steeper exponentially. Yeah, there's, there's. So I remember when we were, our scaling factor was like 1.5. Now we're at 4.5. Yeah, I mean, I think what we're seeing on this chart is basically like optimistic rollups, which were released like, you know, two years ago.
They have a two year head start from ZK rollups. We haven't even seen ZK rollups kind of enter here. And ZK, ZK seems almost at half a bail, bro. That's not, that's not a small amount. Half a bill in 20th. It's still 4% right? So in order for ZK to catch up, it has to just not only like win, but like has to outpace what the optimistic rollups are doing. Anyway, this is why the words are so fun. And this is why I keep hitting refresh on layer two beat and looking at all these charts. But it's very good news for scaling Ethereum and for the modular blockchain thesis. One thing I would like to see, I will say, is this column right here, in terms of the stage of decentralization.
Our best is stage one, which is still training wheels on sequencers. And they're still technically young, yes. Yes, so Arbitrum is at stage one. Optimism is still at stage zero. I would like to see the zeros become ones. I would like to see the ones become twos. That will make me feel a lot better. You would like the slices. The slices all turn green. All those little different colored slices. We want those to turn green. That's right, want that too. All right, well, David, we got a lot coming up next. What are we covering? Yep. World coin launches and everyone loves it and cheered. And then after that, we have a good bill and a bad bill.
It's in the Senate, good bill in the House. Just pass the financial committee vote. Jake Stravinsky's got to take where he calls the vote a historic day for crypto policy. And then after that, optimism drops to the law of chains. Laws? We're getting laws. Yeah, we're getting laws. I'm super stoked about it. So all of that and more. But first of all, I want to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show as possible, especially Kraken. A preferred crypto exchange for 2023. If you are accumulating crypto, like we said that you ought to be perhaps in not financial advice in the beginning of this show.
Perhaps use Kraken to get that done. There's a link in the show notes to get started. Accumulating, let's go here from them right now. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade. On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning fast trade execution. All inside, there's spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout. Let's you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen.
With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs. Visit pro.krakken.com to get started today. Introducing Polygon 2.0, the value layer for the internet. For too long, the limitations of blockchains have held back app development and stifled user adoption. The internet allows anyone to create an exchange information. What's missing is a value layer that lets anyone exchange, store, and program value. That's where Polygon 2.0 comes in. Polygon Labs has unveiled a series of innovations that will radically alter the Polygon ecosystem and Web3 as a whole.
By leveraging groundbreaking ZK innovations, such as Polygon ZK EVM, the next iteration of the best-in-class plonky-2 proving system, and a first-of-its-kind ZK-powered interoperability layer, Polygon 2.0 will give users and devs unlimited scalability and unified liquidity. Right now, there is a Polygon improvement proposal regarding a potential ZK-powered upgrade of Polygon proof-of-stake. If approved, Polygon proof-of-stake would become a layer-to-ZK EVM validity. So make your voice heard on this proposal by joining the Polygon Discord today. You have a chance to help the Polygon community give the internet the value layer it deserves.
The World Coin project is now live. It's on Maynet, the WLD. I guess it's wild. No, world. The world token is in the wild. Orbs are deployed and the crypto community absolutely hates it. David, they don't love it. They hate this. They hate this. They really hate this. The least favorite thing that they've ever seen. We're going to talk about all of that. First, I want to show you this. So Sam Altman tweeted this out. This is a picture, he says. I'll read the caption in a second, but you see this line kind of forming. I don't know where this is. It looks like it's possibly somewhere in Japan. This massive line has formed.
And the caption from Sam Altman is day three of World Coin launch, crazy lines around the world. One person getting verified every eight seconds now. David, there is one. Okay, so why are people scanning their eyeballs? Because you get, if I understand it correctly, you get 25 world for just doing it and then one world a week. Then from the rest of time, World Coin is $2 right now. So the people are waiting in line for $50. What's going on? Why are we doing that? $50 right now, but I guess number could go up. And Sam calls a one person every eight seconds. I don't think number's going up at this valuation.
I mean, we'll talk about more of that. But can you, before we get into that, can you just describe what is World Coin for people who've kind of missed what this launch actually is and even what this project is? Okay, so World Coin is an attempt at a proof of humanity system that uses biometric scanning. So there is a bunch of different mechanisms that one could approach to try and produce a system that proves unique humanness. So this is an anti-sybil platform. We've had a number of these come into the crypto world with varying success. Circles from Martin Coppelman is one, Bright ID is one. There's a few others get coin used as a collection of them.
This one is unique in that attempts. Those are the ones I just listed are circles of trust as in other humans verifying other humans. This one is different in that it is biometric scanning, which is another way to prove unique humanness that also gives people the HEBGBs. And so there's three parts of the World Coin system. There is World ID, which is what you get after you scan your eyeball. There is the orb, which is what we're looking at on screen here, which is this device produced by World Coin, which also has aspirations to be able to be produced by any manufacturer that actually does the eyeball scanning and attestation that that eyeball is the same eyeball that is already scanned prior.
There is the world token, the World Coin, which is the coin that comes with this network. There also is the World Layer 2, which is an OP stack layer 2 that got released not too long ago. And there is also an app, but I think that's also the World ID. It's like this web, this mobile app that is your attestation for wherever you go on the internet, saying, hey, I'm a real human. So you could imagine it like sign in with Facebook, sign in with Google, sign in with Twitter, sign in with World Coin, except that mechanism would be kind of cool because the sign in with World Coin would be a provable human.
At least that's the idea. And then also the World Coin aspect of this is also supposed to be some UBI attempt. So every human gets an equal amount of World Coins distributed to them to their unique eyeball. And it's unique eyeball. They're unique eyeball. They're unique eyeball, yeah. And so in addition to all of the proof of humanness, it is also an attempt at fairly distributing a token equally across all humans, across the whole entire world. And that's how I would summarize this. And Sam Altman's part of his reason for this is like AI is going to take all the human beings jobs, basically.
And so we need to know who all the humans are so we can give them some form of a UBI, basically. And not have just the robots kind of rule the planet and accrue all of the capital. That is his stated vision for this. And Sam Altman is one of the founders of this, actually. So I mean, the project is he's the guy that found Alex Blania, the CEO of Sam Altman, found Alex Blania is like, you know, drop out of school and help me build this World Coin thing because I want to be building open AI. He's the vision guy. Let's talk about so this went to main net. It had been in some sort of alpha version.
It wasn't live. People were being orbed, but in kind of limited capacities. But now it's live. Now it's everywhere. This is the World Coin itself. So market cap right now, fully diluted valuation of $21 billion. I didn't realize it was so high. That is the nuts. WLD token trading at $2.15 at this point in time. But a massive amount of the supply is locked up. The circulating supply is just like a small. It's like one percent, literally one percent. One percent. So the actual market cap in terms of circulating market cap is $239 million. But fully diluted, it's $21 billion, which is an absolutely insane valuation.
I mean, what, what's is that? I guess like if you go to coin. If it puts it at right above Lido Steak to Ether and right below USDC coming in, it would be number seven. It would bump Lido out. It would be number seven. Lido Steak to Ether. Yeah, it would be number seven. Wow. That's extremely inflated. That is one of the most inflated token launches that I have ever seen. If this is not a layer one, we should say, this is sort of deployed on the Optimism chain. It's like kind of a roll up. And OP is, it's a, oh yeah, I think that's right. It is on Optimism main net and it has aspirations and it will eventually become its own OP stack chain.
One other thing that I didn't mention about the whole iris scanning thing is that they also say that they preserve your privacy by doing a ZK snark. So they're not creating a database of it. It's like, here's Ryan Sean Adams, here's Ryan Sean Adams, eyeball. They are, they're claiming to ZK snark that and in order to maintain privacy. Claiming is a key word here, I think. So let's talk about the community reaction here. I thought one of the most rational takes as usual is from Vitalik and he wrote an entire post about biometric proof of personhood that really focuses in on world coin. What's kind of your summary of Vitalik's post to your David?
I think if this isn't a direct summary, but I think my takeaway from this is that Vitalik goes through all of these different components of what makes a biometric proof of personhood system and then kind of explains, well, this is how this works and this is how it leaks and this is how this works and this is how this is vulnerable and this is how this works and this is how this is vulnerable. So you get to the end of this thing and like, there's a lot of things that really need to go right for the system to work and so he just kind of talked about every single aspect of it and talked about the ways that it's vulnerable and after you get to the end and you're kind of like, well, that's, that was a lot of things.
And so that's why in the intro to the bankless podcast episode that I did with Sam and Alex, I called it one of the most ambitious crypto projects and people did not like that phrasing and but I didn't do it. I didn't serve that up very well. I mean, it's like it has to do so much to work and it's the scale and scope of the thing is massive and the requirements of getting this thing right are huge. That's what I meant by ambitious. Yeah, it has to get a lot of things right in order for this to actually be a, a good for the world if it even can be a public good. Yeah, this, this whole post from Vitalik, I can't recommend it enough if you have, you know, it's probably 20 to 30 minutes of time to actually read through it.
But Vitalik starts a lot. Yeah, you'll learn a lot. He starts by talking about why a decentralized proof of personhood solution is even necessary. Why do we need the idea of decentralized people? Why do we need to know whether an Ethereum address is represented by one single person or many people or a bot? The reasons he give is that it's anti-concentration of power sort of thing. If we want to do like a vote in a Dow and specify that as one person, one vote. If we want to do an airdrop and ignore all the bots, ignore all of kind of the, you know, the civil attacks and all of the airdrop, you know, farmers who are creating multiple accounts and just distribute it to individual people.
If we want to do some sort of credit system like an on-off chain credit type system for individual human beings, we need some sort of proof of personhood. So that is a good thing in itself if we can somehow manage that on chain. But then he walks through this one specific implementation of proof of personhood, which world coin is pursuing, which is biometric proof of personhood. And the exact implementation world coin is pursuing is eyeball based biometric proof of personhood which presents its own problems. But this kind of table at the end of his post, I think sums it up. If you want decentralized proof of personhood, you kind of have two tries at this.
One is a hardware biometric based proof of personhood and ideally it would be a specialized version of that. You can get privacy fairly high. He says accessibility and scalability medium, robustness of decentralization is fairly low because there's hardware, supply chain issues, all sorts of reasons why security against fake people, medium. That's what world coin is pursuing. And then your other option to do this is a social graph based proof of personhood where your privacy is kind of low because you have to trust a circle of other human beings to really validate you and verify your personhood.
Accessibility and scalability has been fairly low. Like these solutions haven't really taken off yet, which is kind of the concern even though they exist. The decentralization though is very high because it's bottom up and the security against fake people is also high. So we kind of contrast all of these things and presents the world as a series of engineering trade-offs. I think one of the takeaways for me from this post is that we shouldn't put all of our eggs in one basket. That's, this is a classic vitalic tape that probably is the best solution. That's really such a vitalic line. It is a blend of all of the above that we kind of amalgamate together into like those.
Which is actually what get coin uses in order to achieve unique humanists on their platform. They don't behold, but who themselves are one platform. They just use a malgamation of a bunch. We should get into some of the other controversy here because as you said earlier, David, the crypto community actually did not like world coin. It was not received with excitement. And I would kind of classify the critiques in a few various forms. One is critiques of world coin themselves and the implementation approach that they're taking. And the other is a critique of biometric proof of personhood altogether.
And then some people actually don't like the idea of on-chain proof of personhood at all. So maybe we'll take the first one, which is like world coin sucks. This is, right. This is left-airist. What is he saying here, David? Yeah, left-air says there's a list of bullet points of criticisms about world coin and goes 20% of the supply of world goes to team and investors. There are privacy concerns about the actual cryptography that protects people's eyeballs. There's malicious orb operators. And so the idea with this orb is that the people like operating these orbs aren't necessarily world coin employees.
It's the public. The public can operate. A public person can operate in orb. But then that means that one public person can try to manipulate the orb in order to scan other people's eyeballs and take their world coin on their behalf. So that's it. That's it. You can also tinker with the orbs. So that's his next one, malicious slash compromised orbs. Bribing poor people with tokens for an eyeball scan. And then his last one, which is kind of just like the vibe of the whole thing, it just feels really dystopian. I mean, it's called word coin. It's called word coin. It's got a chrome orb that you stick your eyeball into.
The one of the founders is the guy making like AI. After bank listed, we just did a bunch of like AI doom episodes. Like it's the whole thing is just like a perfect storm of dystopia. Yeah, dystopian feeling. Here's a more specific take list of issues from Zach XBT. My issues with the world coin. He says, most alarming to me is how the world coin team is boasted about how many users they have. When in reality, they have been explaining people in developing countries. This is sourcing an MIT technology review article from 2022 about that verification that you're a real person seems to only be currently enforced at the enrollment level.
And so what this has led to is the emergence of a black market for accounts. So you can buy a world coin account on telegram for a dollar per world coin account. It's being attacked in that way. And then some criticism about the token allocation. There are a few more. So this is under the category of like world coin sucks. And so you can find a lot of critiques for that, including another one from Andrea and Bailey. World coin is still stupid and bad in four points. Number one, the team, incredibly, was not prepared for people to sell credentials. That's the issue I was just mentioning. It doesn't solve the one problem that was supposed to solve.
There's also some criticism about the foundation that world coin, the kind of the org structure they're creating. That comes with the territory. Everyone claims about the foundation of every project. Giving insiders 20% tokens. So it's that kind of thing. So one category of critiques is just about world coin and how it's implemented and how it's being done itself. But going back to those circles, another category is basically broader than just world coin sucks, that critique. It's a category of all biometric proof of personhood sucks. Like we should never use biometric proof of personhood at all.
And going down that path will lead to dystopian outcomes. Yeah, I was talking to one of my friends, Scott Lewis. He gave me a take that I like to read out actually. He goes, basically every future thinking on biometric scanning has concluded that biometric scanning is absolutely a press of technology. And there has been a dedicated effort to tell stories where the use of biometric scanning was used by oppressors. Not everyone in the world needs to become a domain expert on exactly why biometric scanning is consensus scary technology in the eyes of generations of science, fiction writers, to understand that there is a consensus that this stuff should not be effed with.
Reality land, current governments are the arbiters of who a person is in many, but not all governmental systems. If the initial read of the government seems incorrect to you, you have a clear schedule of codified rights and options to appeal and correct that decision. Replacing that oracle with a profit maximizing cooperation, composed of Sam Almancronis, who offers zero recourse is much worse. We have a good track record of corporations in similar positions offering no effective recourse to their customers when they are de-platformed. World coin would be in a position to de-platform someone from the literal claim on being a human.
Dystopian isn't a feeling in a situation like that. It's inevitable, which I thought was a good analysis of the whole context. Because there's a very specific critiques of world coin about specific implementations, and then there's the broad sweeping strokes of the whole vibe is just illegitimate and people have to trust the vibe of the spectrum. Like serializing people in this way hasn't worked out well. Yeah, don't serialize people, yeah. Don't serialize people. I mean, one pushback against that take before we get into it, though, is aren't we already being serialized in so many ways? Yeah.
I'm just like every time I... And this time we have cryptography. So you get to serialize people and then ZK Snarket. I just... I think that's a valid take. I think our tech companies are already doing that. Every time I stare down my iPhone to unlock it, right? It's like doing facial recognition, biometric recognition of my face, and it's unlocking it. You know, if you don't look at the camera, it won't unlock. It needs your eyes to look at the camera on your iPhone. Well, you even look at, you know, kind of Apple's new VR goggles, right? That's just directly iris unlock, iris scanning unlock, right?
And I'm... This is such a messed up position to be. It's like, I'm excited about that product. And like, maybe I shouldn't be. Maybe I should be fearful of that product. Anyway, so that's another criticism. It's just like biometric proof of personhood descends into all sorts of corporate dystopianism. There's another critique, I think, which is a good critique and worthwhile. And that's... We already have better decentralized proof of personhood protocols. So circle, bright ID, get coin, passport, proof of humanity. These are social graph based. You kind of build a web of trust, right? So I know you, David, so I'm willing to like vouch for you and at your real human being, because we've met in person.
So I'll vouch for you. And you know someone else, you'll vouch for that person. You kind of build from the bottom up this social graph based approach. I think that's totally valid. And I love those approaches, by the way. And we've talked about them on bank list several times. My challenge with those is they just haven't scaled yet, right? Like we don't have hundreds of thousands or millions of users on these things. And I'm worried that they just might not scale. And maybe we can crack the code here. I'm still optimistic, but that's kind of the worry. But yours might take away after this episode.
What Cypher punks seem to think about on-chain personnel. First of all, our current state is the nation, right? So we all have passports. And the nation can go bad depending on your government. So if your government goes evil or authoritarian, right? You know, nation state serialization is going to go bad for you. The second method is biometric. And the criticism, I think, many in the crypto community say is that, well, anything biometric becomes a corporate evil. Because you need hardware to go collect all of the irises and that ends up being owned by some evil corporation. Maybe World Coin is sort of one of those.
And so it always descends its flawed and can often maybe always descend into a corporate evil. And then number three, social graph. That's still decentralized. And that really remains our best shot. And I'm sympathetic towards that. I just, I worry that number three is not scalable. But there's also David, a whole bunch of people who think we don't need on-chain personhood at all, which was interesting to actually consider. This was from... I think that one's a cop out. Well, this is from Nick. Before you dismiss it, this was from Nick from ENS. He says, unpopular opinion, truly decentralized, trustless, similar resistance or proof of humanity is impossible.
You know, he's not saying that it wouldn't be great if we could do it. He's saying you can't do it. So it's theoretically impossible, yeah. He says we should stop trying to make it work and instead focus on building systems that don't assume individuals are unique humans. So he's like, mission impossible. You can't even do it anyway. So stop trying. We don't need it. We can rethink our systems beyond this. So that, I think, is a summary of the crypto community's reaction to all of this and all of the criticism. I want to turn towards something else, though, because there was also some criticism of Banclists.
Like, why did Banclists decide to have world going on? What do you want to say about that? Well, it has a ton of attention. And so that if people's attention go there, then my attention goes there. Also, there's obviously the poll of like Sam Altman. And then there's obviously also the poll of Sam Altman on Banclists. Like, that's just kind of cool. I will say, you weren't there on that episode because it was Mother's Day. It was like a Sunday. And so I was taking it while I was in the middle of Zuzaloo. Why did we have world going on? Well, it's a huge project. It's a massive project. There's only so many proof of personhood projects out there.
And this is the only one going after the biometric sector. So just as understanding the scope of the crypto rabbit hole, the biometric proof of personhood is a part of the crypto rabbit hole. It's a part of the things you can explore. So I considered it a legitimate place of exploration. Then there was also criticisms of the way that I managed that interview, which is I didn't really push back on anything. I didn't really have any critiques for them. I kind of just let them walk through the project and explain themselves and say, here's what this does. And here's how that works. And this is a world coin project.
I'm like, great, thanks for coming. Granted, I only had 60 minutes. There was a hard stop. And so that is a extreme constraint on my ability to be thorough. And also, the other half of my ability to be thorough is like some of the tech stack behind the hardware and the zero knowledge cryptography that keeps things private. I don't have the skill set to vet that. And so I have to just kind of run on trust and faith of people who actually can be more technical than me. And so my intention of the world coin episode was, hey, crypto universe, hey, bankless nation, here's the world coin project. Here's an episode with Sam Altman, discuss amongst yourselves.
And then I get back to like, bankless, why the F, did you host these people? Why did you not talk about like the dystopian nature of this? Why did you like tee it up in the intro as like one of crypto's most ambitious projects? And I'm like, I guess I got the vibe wrong. I could have been more critical. I could have pushed back more. But at the end of the day, it's just like, we're all, I'm also feeling like I'm caught in the middle of bankless. You're so opinionated. Why didn't you have an opinion on this one? Like, you're so opinionated about ether. You're so opinionated about layer twos. Why didn't you have an opinion on world coin?
At the end of the day, it's like I, sometimes I'm in a particular state, a disposition, a mood. I don't have the mental like capacity to be mean to Sam Altman. And I, a guy who I don't really know who he is. I don't know. I'm asking for forgiveness, I really, and I guess, yeah. I think, so I think, like I appreciate that. I think that we could have wrapped that episode a little bit differently. But I think what people, maybe some people don't understand if they just hear that episode, maybe didn't catch the debrief, or don't understand the wider context of what we do, is like, episode one is kind of like about world coin, is kind of a conversation starter.
It doesn't stop it. The first episode we could do on world coin. All right? We're going to do like the world coin panel of all of the critics about world coin. We're going to do the episode with all of the decentralized web of trust alternatives to world coin. We're going to do an episode of the pros of the cons. We're going to see how this whole project turns out. So, yeah, that's another element to it. And then there was also the critique that's like, oh, yeah, Sam Altman and we're coin paid bank lists to co-on the podcast. And I've said this, you've said this. Well, I take offense to that.
I take offense to that one. That one, I, yeah, they need to apologize for that one. Bank lists has never, and will never, ever, take money for content. That's never happened on the news. We have no investment interest. We have no investment interest. There's no other investors of bank lists. We're beholden to no one. People make up, you know, people can make up anything on the internet. Anyway, this was kind of a deeper take too. This is a DeFi Cheetah saying, I thought the alternative to world coin was bank lists. Basically, the implication of like, why do we even need a world coin? Like, I thought you guys were bank lists.
And I just wanted to push back on that and support the idea of decentralized identity, decentralized proof of personhood. So, guys, just to understand, bank lists is an alternative to banks. But today, nation states provide our core identity. So you get your passport. They are the arbiters of identity. Yeah, they are the AMLKYC. It's a passport, it's a license. Banks don't do that. State lists is the alternative to states. And if we want to do cool things, like one person won't vote, or on-chain credit without relying on the state to need to know who humans are, then we need some sort of decentralized identity, okay?
World coin is building a protocol to tell who the humans are without the state, all right? I don't know if this is going to work out well, or if it's going to be bad. But I just saw a lot of anger this week on crypto Twitter about this. And some of us totally warranted some of the takes that we just read were completely warranted. Some of us really uninformed. And my encouragement is basically to channel some of that anger into building. Like, if we don't like what World Coin is building, once we pop the hood and look at it, let's build another alternative. Because that's what we do at crypto.
I mean, we're crypto and we build. So that's my encouragement. Let's not give up on decentralized proof of personhood in general. And so, I guess my take on all of this, David, after listening to the conversation that you had with Sam Altman and World Coin is, I think I'm still understated about World Coin as a technology. I'm cautious. I'm open to it because I hate that AMLKYC and state identities that is the only way forward for some of these use cases. I see decentralized personhood, proof of personhood as an unlock. And maybe we can do it, maybe we can't. Maybe biometrics is a really bad way to do it.
Maybe it's not. I'm kind of taking a wait and see approach. I'm not at this point willing to get orb to myself, all right? So if that gives you my statement of faith about the World Coin project, I wouldn't do it. There's not enough value for me. I'm kind of like I haven't heard enough compelling reasons why. And I'm not supportive of WLD tokens. I have no comment about that. I have no idea what the value of WLD might be, but it's $21 billion guys. So just go think about that. What I care about most is the conversation about this that we're having as a community. I think that's important. And I think that's been opened up in a positive way.
And also competition, I just emphasized, if we don't like what World Coin is doing, let's build a better decentralized alternative. Or something else, yeah. Yeah, so anyway, that's my take on things. Yeah, on the whole World Coin token question, we have a question from the nation, Kyle Kaplan from the bank illustration discord. How does World Coin token plan on occurring any value? UBI sounds nice and all, but we all know you just can't print money out of nowhere. I think it's a huge question about World Coin. Why the F is this thing? 21 billion, is that what it is? 21 billion when it only ever gets issued.
Like the only bowl case I can articulate for the World Coin token is that the humans deem the distribution of World Coin so incredibly legitimate and fair that they want to be a part of that very fair work. It's competing as a money, isn't it? In the same way, Bitcoin, Ether, and the U.S. Maybe, and maybe. I don't even know if it's doing that. I don't even know if they have. I don't even know if they, like Alex Blania from World Coin has a statement about what he thinks about the World Coin asset. He probably can't say it because he's the issue of it. But that's a very dubious value accrual. It's just legitimacy in and of itself.
Plus, when you see Telegram snap screen shots of people selling, hey, I'll sell you a World Coin account for $1, like that very much erodes that value proposition. Like there's other like theses about it, like it's a graph for just because it's fair, like I don't see the value accrual. Yeah, neither do I. I still do think it's competing in the monetary value category, right? And it has to. I just don't think it has a good shot at that. But like it's not producing transaction fees. It's not a cash flowing asset. So meme value money. But the question from Kyle is interesting. It's like, UBI sounds nice, but we all know you can't just print money out of nowhere.
I'm like, yeah, but isn't that what Bitcoin and Ether did? If you know what I mean? If you can get a meme bootstrapped and kickstarted and enough people believe in a money in the story, they can solve the problem later. Yeah, you can solve the problem now. I don't think that's the path that World Coin is on, but I'm saying that if there is a path to it being worth billions of dollars, my take is the path is going to be a bunch of people believe it's a monetary instrument and it's used as a monetary instrument. I, yeah, that's so bearish on that. I'm so bearish. Cause then it can piece right next to Bitcoin and Ether.
Like it's not going to survive that fight. Thankless Nation, you can make your own decision on World Coin. If you haven't caught David's conversation with Sam Altman and Alex from World Coin, then go ahead and catch it. There's a link in the show notes and also it should be in your RSS player. David enough about World Coin. Let's do a good bill, bad bill. There's some good news in Congress for crypto, at least the US Congress. So this bill hasn't passed, but it's a set of bills that are very positive for crypto and they were just voted on by the House Financial Services Committee and they passed that vote, which is a pretty big deal apparently.
Jake Trvinsky calls this vote a historic day for cryptocurrency. There's two bills that are wrapped up in this in the house that are pretty crypto positive. The first is called the Financial Innovation and Technology for the 21st Century Act. So this is a framework for the issuance and trading of digital assets at the SEC and CFTC. You know that whole clarity of what's a commodity and what's a security? This bill directly addresses that. So we actually get some clarity here. The thing that Gary Gensler never gave us, that's what the fit is doing for us. And that's part one. Part two, David, is the Blockchain Regulatory Certainty Act.
It clarifies that non-custodial blockchain developers and service providers, this would be like miners, validators, if you're an at-home validator, wallet providers, that they never custody consumer funds and don't have to register as money transmitters. You know the nightmare scenario of you running your solar platform? Yeah, that's like the earliest bill that came in that like deemed, hey, if you're a part of it, if you run a node, you process a transaction, there won't be a money service. That was the very first crypto fire alarm that we had. Oh my God, it would be so scary. It would basically mean that it's kind of illegal without being registered to be a validator in the US.
Yeah, the good news here is that this is bipartisan. So 35 members voted for it versus 16, 35 to 15 at one. And 25% of those 35 were actually Democrats. So some bipartisan support that we haven't seen. Tom Emmer, of course, led it. I want to play you this quote from Richie Torres. He's on the Democrat side and he was weighing in on comments for it. Here he goes. Thank you, Mr. Chair, I'll just offer a few thoughts. I mean, they're profound philosophical differences on the subject of crypto. And there's almost no point in relitigating those differences because it's been extensively debated here today.
But I find myself unpersuaded by the notion that the status quo is working. A status quo that gave us the largest crypto Ponzi scheme in history is not working, it's by definition failing. My assessment is that the status quo is dangerously deregulated and requires regulation. But Einstein said, we do the same thing over and over again and expect a different result. That's the definition of insanity. And the time has come for us to break the cycle of insanity that governs the application of securities law to digital assets. Now, there's a difference between securities law as we as individuals might think it ought to be interpreted.
And securities law, as it has been interpreted by the courts and the Southern District of New York has held. Yeah, I really like Richard Torres. That guy's great. Yeah, big fan. Great comments there. And the one thing we wanted Congress to do is to provide clarity. And that's what this bill is doing. So Tom Emmery is going to be one of the architects of this bill. I think the next time we catch him, we'll probably be at the permissionless conference. It's happening in September. We're throwing that conference with block works. That's the 11 through the 13th. This is going to be a topic of discussion with Tom Emmery for sure.
David, we got a bad bill, though, too. It's coming from the Senate. You ready for that one? Oh, no. It's sad. In contrast to that, the Senate is proposing a bill. I'm going to read you the title here. It's called the Crypto Asset National Security Enhancement Act of 2023. Did you catch that? I don't like those words. National Security Enhancement Act. I don't give a f what's in that. I don't like it. Yes. You know it's going to sound a little Orwellian when it has National Security and Crypto Asset in it. And the Enhancement Act. This one is also bipartisan, but only, unfortunately, it's bipartisan.
Again, this is coming from the Senate. But basically, it mandates that DeFi protocols and anyone who controls them or makes them available have to impose bank-like surveillance for their users. So that would mean DeFi controllers need to vet and collect information on the customers, have to do the AML thing, have to report suspicious activity of the government, have to block sanction individual users from their protocols. Do you remember the stuff that SBF was advocating like a year ago in some of the crypto legislation that he was proposing being like, you know, I think all DeFi protocols, interfaces, app user interfaces should have AMLK-YZ in complete surveillance and are basically money transmitter banks.
Yeah, it's a lot of that. Bill Hughes from Consensus has some takes. He said, this thing is a doozy. He says, in summary, it deems that digital asset protocols defined really as any software deployed on chain is controlled by, that's controlled by backers. And the backers are those who develop or retain meaningful control over the protocols and transaction facilitators who develop and make available applications that facilitate use of the protocols. Basically, what this means is that any US originating or residing person or an entity who invests more than $25 million in building a protocol or owns that much or more in the governance token.
If you even just own the governance token, okay? Anyone who develops and offers the front end of the users or owns the governance tokens would deem to be in control of the protocol for sanctions and AML purposes. National security enhancement, get the F out of here. They're just like saying every user of crypto, get the F out of the way we need to catch North Korea. Basically, and for entrepreneurs or those investing in kind of governance protocols or those building interfaces on top of protocols that some bad actor might use, they would be part of the responsibility tree here. So Bill concludes this by saying if this legislation goes through by-by permissionless global computing, at least as the US is concerned, really bad news.
And I think David, this right here is like, Gensler is kind of a side show compared to this. To me, you know, we have to talk about the final boss. This right here, national security. National security is the final boss. Like if crypto dies in the US, it'll be to protect us from terrorists and bad guys. And that's why this bill is kind of worrying coming from the center side of things. Anyway, we've got good news, bad news this week. This one and just hope that for the best. Yeah. Well, you know, we've got some good news coming up in the next section. What are we talking about, David? Coming up next, optimism drops the law of chains.
I'll walk you through all of what that means. And coin desk is being sold to my first boss in crypto. I'll talk to you about that. Chainlink launches the CCIP protocol, all these things, and more of a first moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible, especially Metamask Portfolio. You already have a Metamask account. So your Metamask Portfolio is waiting for you there as a link in the show. So open up your portfolio with Metamask. Let's go here for them right now. Are you a Metamask user? Well, you're listening to bank lists. So of course you are. The wallet you know and love just got a whole lot better.
Metamask Portfolio is the ultimate one stop shop for all of your crypto needs. It gives you a holistic view of your crypto portfolio across multiple chains and multiple addresses all at once. You can easily view and manage all your coins, tokens, and NFTs in one convenient place just by connecting your wallet. Metamask Portfolio goes beyond just viewing your portfolio though. Inside the portfolio, you can do all the incredible money verbs that make DeFi so powerful. You can buy, swap, bridge, and stake your crypto assets with ease. It's like having a powerful battle station for all your DeFi moves, right, at your fingertips.
So if you're looking to do more in Web 3, your way, Metamask Portfolio is the answer. I already know that you have Metamask wallet. So go check out your Metamask Portfolio. Learn more at metamask.io slash portfolio. Arbitrum is accelerating the Web 3 landscape with a suite of secure Ethereum scaling solutions. Hundreds of projects have already deployed onto Arbitrum 1 with a flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystem. Arbitrum Nova is quickly becoming a Web 3 gaming hub and social apps like Reddit are also calling Arbitrum home. And now, Arbitrum Orbit allows you to use Arbitrum secure scaling technology to build your own layer 3, giving you access to interoperable customizable permissions with dedicated throughput.
All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible, faster transaction speeds and significantly lower gas fees. Arbitrum empowers you to explore and build without compromise. Visit Arbitrum.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app on Arbitrum. The Law of Chains Optimism drops the Law of Chains version zero. So what is this Law of Chains? It's starting off as a document. It's a document kind of like, I don't know, a constitution of sorts.
That is going to be iterated on in the OP stack world in the world of Optimism governance. The idea here is the problems that we have are, the OP stack is getting forked and deployed new chains like almost every single day, right? We got base, we got Zora, we got the world coin token chain as well. There's a few others ones as well. We can mention the world coin is deploying in the OP stack. Yeah, I mentioned it. We mentioned it. People are forking the OP stack. I don't want to, like putting the world coin back in the closet. I didn't forget about that. The OP stack is getting forked. So now there's all these OP stack standard chains, more chains than what can be managed.
So like what do you expect users to do? To go to Metamask and drop down and go to like, okay, here's OP stack chain one, OP stack chain two. No, we want just one. And so this is the law of chains is the first step along that process. So from the law, this is what I wrote in the tweet, from the law of chains, spawns the OP super chain. This is where we're going. And so because of every single new OP stack chain is a different chain, we still want them to behave like one chain. But since adding new OP stack chains to the world is completely free, completely open, completely, completely permissionless, how do we actually determine what is in the super chain versus out of the super chain?
Because any sense anyone can fork the OP stack and spin up a new chain, that chain could be a rug, that chain could be an exploit, that could be a bad chain. So if we want all of these OP stack chains to converge into the super chain, they all need to pass a certain threshold of quality assurances. And this is what the law of chains puts forth. It's you must be this good or higher to be included into the super chain. And so this is the document that the OP community is working on to determine what is that line, what is that threshold for inclusion. And after that, we can start to have collective bargaining power for all the OP stack chains that are in the super chain.
And so what does that mean? The cost to spin up a new ether scan, like optimism ether scan, RB scan, poly scan, or talking to inferior or alchemy. It all takes, those are deals that have to be inked. That has labor costs. But when all of these OP stack chains are formed under the same standard with a very strong level of quality assurances, all of a sudden, all of this can go here into one single collective of chains. And so ether scan and all these people can start to treat these chains as equivalent because they are. And so this is what the law of chains has started to kick off. Is it basically like, what is it though, David?
Is it like a document that, is it like a, it's a proposal of standards? It's a proposal of standards. Is it a document that is proposing standards? Okay. And then basically these are the standards for joining like the Confederacy of all of these chains. And if you meet this threshold, then you can be adopted into this Confederacy of chains. If there's some sort of like formal body that votes and it's like, yeah, this chain's good, that chains bad, we're letting this one in, we're booting the other chain, or is this, are we not there yet? The first step is just to establish the standards. I believe that is a part of the process that is being proposed.
That is what needs to be figured out. Well, very interesting. There's some takes about this too, including from Alex from the ZK sync, what did he say? Yeah, I thought this was pretty funny. So Alex has, he is on team ZK stack. So this is in the layer two wars, this is a layer two wars tweet. And so he's going TLTR, OP stack, many chains, one choice, single shared sequencer, centralized MEV distribution, protected by laws and governance. And then he goes, ZK stack, many chains, many choices, pick your own sequencer, handle MEV your way, protected by math and code. We are not the same people through.
But then his next tweet kind of walks himself back a little bit and goes, I must add, although my preference for individual and sovereignty is obvious, I admire optimism's brilliant work on governance and public goods, funding mechanism designs. We all learn by winning from each other, making Ethereum layer two ecosystems just for stronger. So some spicy takes out of Alex out of this whole like law of change thing. I will say, I mean, got to give credit to where the credits do, optimism has all the chains. Like they've got, they've got base, they've got mantle, they've got world's coin, if you care about that, but I'm putting that one back in the closet.
They've got Zora, which is the Tezos, like the media network, but now on Ethereum. And so when we were looking at the stats earlier of optimism, beating, trumping arbitrum and transactions, that's just main net. That's not what about all the other chains? What happens when all of those chains form into the super chain? That I think is really cool. We're going to do a podcast with Jesse and Ben on this whole concept because the negotiation between coin base and the OP collective as to help, what does that relationship look like? Has carved out like room for this whole law of change thing. So this is a big learning moment for everyone.
Well, since you're being the optimistic roll up bull, allow me to be the kind of the ZK roll up bull for a second. What I would say is this is just the first inning, though, David. And like we got a lot more innings. And it's actually a miracle that a ZK roll up technology has kind of come to market so quickly. And I do think that there's something to this last point that Alex said, which is protected by math and code, rather than laws and governance. It's basically like ZK cryptography. It's magic moon math, right? And you can do things with ZK that you can't do with fraud proofs. That might be what you can do with ZK, Ryan.
You can turn an optimistic chain into a ZK chain. Let the games begin. I think we'll have to see how it plays out. And again, check layer two beat for the progress here. But this is just the first inning. And disclosures, Ryan and I love the OP stack and the ZK stack. So much we are advisors to both optimism and ZK sink. The producers of both the OP stack and ZK stacks. Really the common denominators. We just love stacks. I love stacks. I love them. I think they're so great. Love decentralization. Speaking of stacks, David, Starknet, still building in the background. This is, of course, a ZK centric ecosystem as well.
They announced last week that they're incredibly excited to introduce Starknet app chains. They say Starknet is amazing. They're dancing a stack. That's what they, it's their stack. Now they have a stack. Yes, this is an app chain stack as well. So this is another fantastic team who's building the Starknet stack in the ecosystem. And it's interesting to see this, this came about in our polygon conversation earlier this week with the founders of polygon. It's just like there's some convergence in layer two's to like the stack based model where you have your kind of general purpose, EVM type of chain.
And then you have app chains and you're creating like a full stack for chain developers to deploy your ecosystem. And all of the ecosystems are competing against one another. They're also working together in some weird ways against other side chains and alternatives. It's, yeah, it's a very interesting time to be in crypto on the infrastructure side I'd say. I love it. I love it so much. It's like, finally, it took two years more than I thought it would take to get to this point, but finally here we are. Erie, Erie Kaladny of Starkware, he will also be permissionless. So if you are interested in the Starkware stack, he'll be a permissionless.
David, I got to ask you because all of the tweets we've been reading out this week, I don't even know if there are tweets any longer because this is called it. Okay, we're doing this. Yes, we're doing this. Elon Musk has just transformed Twitter into X, the everything app. All right, see the big X on the top left, no longer Twitter. This whole thing is called X. It's a big rebrand. And this is part of his plan to make, I guess, Twitter. Now X into some kind of super app. What's your take on this so far, David? Actually, it's worth noting that X.com was Elon's first startup that actually made him his first money.
I'm really fuzzy on the details, but he's had X.com for a long time. That was something to do with PayPal. It's like one of his first startups. It was going to be an online bank actually, like a startup. And it was going to be the X bank. And so this is not Elon's first flirtation with this whole X thing. So he's like pulling this out from downtown, like out of his pocket. He's, you know, just being kept up his sleeve. And now Twitter is now X. There's so many things to talk about. I don't even know if we have enough time to go into it, but it's like, man, they're called tweets. The bird is blue.
It's a blue bird. Everyone knows it. Twitter, it's Facebook, it's Instagram. And all of that is just completely thrown down the trash. Like brands take forever to get built. And now we have this extremely basic X thing. We, they're called Zeats, X-E-E-T-S. We're supposed to be Zeats. Really? Now we had a, we had a, we had a spaces with Taylor Monahan. And I do, are they X spaces now? Because that sounds dirty. I don't want to be in an X space with anyone on Twitter. Or excuse me on X.com. Like, I, okay. So this, my take about when Elon first bought Twitter was, it's probably getting, break and get clunky.
And then if he can do it, it'll get better from there. Yeah. But it has gotten so much worse than I've ever thought possible. And he's trying to rotate it into a super app. Like, you're really testing my conviction, Elon. Like, I'm not enjoying this, right? Yeah, I mean, he's saying some pretty bold things. Like, if done right, X would become half of the global financial system, right? Wow, he's saying pretty bold things. He only says bold things. I mean, Elon only says, yeah, this is, I mean, this is, is he going to incorporate crypto? What's that going to look like in the future? I just got to be honest on the branding of this.
You look at kind of the left versus the right. And this was someone's take. Gonna be honest, this new widget design looks like an app for membership. For membership only human trafficking gentlemen's club had a quarter to a quarter past. I mean, look out. Is your, my app is, my phone is still Twitter. It's still a blue bird for me. Is yours an X now? It's, I don't think it's, it's turned into an X. But just the top left even here. I don't know. I haven't looked at that. So many of these things don't make sense now because now we have the Twitter blue. If you have that circle tweet button, it's a feather.
Elon. Yeah, I don't know. I stopped messing with my life. There's a, there's a broader, I think, conversation here, which is, this may be a rumor. I'm not sure what to make of this, David. But this tweet says, yesterday, the owner of Twitter handle at X tried to sell it for $1 million and minutes ago, Twitter or X Elon, took it away from him and transferred the old at Twitter account to it. And the owner received $0. This could be some speculation here. But the point is like, your handle on Twitter, your handle on X, you don't own. It's not a domain name, it's not, it's, it's, so one thing I guess I'll say is, we all give credit to Elon in this.
I think Twitter has always told the line of trying to be like a public square and like a public good and an open protocol, but like that being a facade and not really doing it well. You know, it's just like, well, if it's an open protocol, it was a private company trying to produce a public square and they did a pretty good job of it, but it was sort of completely into the day. Then it started to like, fracture, right? Like, well, do you sense or tweet or not? Well, if it's a public good, you don't, but if it's a private company, then you do. Elon has completely ripped the mask off of that. This is very clearly a private company.
This is Elon's app. When I tweet, I am tweeting on X, Elon's private property. I know my position in this ecosystem. I am a surf for like Lord Elon basically. And so I know that at least, and I can choose whether I want to continue to invest in this or not. I think a lot of people will choose to pursue more open real public alternatives. And maybe that's where Web3 and Crypto finally starts to take off, but at least with Elon, we kind of know where we stand. This is a private company and a private application. And as a user, you can either use it or not, but you don't necessarily have rights on this platform.
You don't have any assets that you own. Yeah, yeah, I want this story to hurry up and finish. Like, can we just, can we get to the super app or can we go back to Twitter? But this like limbo, I don't like being here. There's a feel awkward stage. Speaking of awkward, I don't know if you call this awkward or progress here. RFK Junior just confirmed that he purchased 14 Bitcoin, David. So he's now joined the club officially. That's $415,000 worth of Bitcoin. Yeah, $415,000. So he's officially part of the Church of Bitcoin. He is a holder at this point in time. I don't know if he's doing that for a investment purposes.
Knowing the little bit I know about RFK, he fits right in. Right. We'll take that as you will, RFK. David. Do you remember my first job in crypto? Did you work for like some shady ICOs or something? No. No, even worse, dude, it was an ICO advisory agency. Wow, David, the scammer. I mean, only in hindsight. In the moment, I thought I was leading a revolution. I was a mere community manager. I would write blogs. Anyways, I worked for this company called New Alchemy, which was a, it did a big few, a big number of ICOs, aon network, like AION, if you remember that, 2017. Interoperability, I remember that.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then everything ground to a halt when we realized that all these ICOs that were doing are securities. And that's actually where I got my securities training. Anyways, like my knowledge base. Anyways, the owner of New Alchemy was this guy, Peter Vesnes. He was my first ever crypto boss. And so his, after that company blew up, he's been in Bitcoin since forever. He's now in like a family office, Fisi firm, capital six. And him and Matthew Rosnack, which is another name, I have not heard a really long time. One of the, another one project that we did was called metronome, which I think Matthew from, I think he's from, I remember a metronome.
Yeah, I remember a metronome. Metronome was cool. Anyways, that investor group has offered 125 million dollars for coin desk, the news agency, which we frequently use here on the weekly rollup. And so my old boss and a few other of his, you know, investor friends have offered 125 million dollars for coin desk. So I don't know if this is going to go through, but everything sounds like it will. So yeah, I think an important detail there of why is coin desk selling? It's because parent company DCG has been in some financial trouble recently. And so they need to look with it. Yeah, they need it. They have like a billion dollar hole.
So they've got 800 over a billion dollar hole. So they've got like, you know, about a billion dollars left to fill. That's an ability not too much. Yeah, that's my big casualty of that. Yeah, you know, 125 million is 125 million. We go. David. Thanks to everyone at coin desk, you now work for my old boss. So does that mean they work for you in any way? Or is there no relation? No, it does not mean that. No, it's not how that works. Synthetics is releasing something big, something new. David, what's Kane Warwick up to these days? Yeah, so Kane Warwick is releasing Infinix as a layer on top of synthetics to help go toe-to-toe with centralized platform, centralized exchanges.
And so this is just kind of a more user-friendly layer on top of synthetics. And so it is just a normal registration like a centralized exchange. User name, email password. And it will sign you a unique margin account for every user. No new token. So it removes all the steps for participating on synthetics, because synthetics now is on optimism. So you don't have to bridge there anymore. You don't have to require SUSD. You don't need to sign every action. It's probably going to look and feel a lot like Coinbase or any other centralized exchange, but you do have an Ethereum address. So this is going to release alongside synthetics to V3 later this year, anyone can join.
And so beta testing is currently in process. That's great. You know, I think partially what screwed us over in 2022 is BlockFi, Celsius, all of these centralized C5, like there were so easy to use. The app just worked, and D5 really hasn't had that. So if we can smooth out the user experience, then I think we can really grow this cycle. One theme I've been noticing, Ryan, compound, that CompToken recently has a really strong performance. Uniswap is releasing Uniswap X, even though I don't think the token price is doing all that crazy of things. Synthetics, volume, is painting numbers, bro. $500 million in a single day from Quenta, which is basically another synthetics plugin.
So if you scroll down, you see that little chart. Synthetics has never been used more than it has now. Why do I look at those numbers? That's the most it's ever been used since the D5s making a comeback. OGDFIs is, well, yeah, it's like, turns out they remember the whole D5 2.0 familiar phase, that was actually the top. Yeah, it turned out no, it's D5 1.0, man. It's D5 1.0 that's upgrading to 2.0 in the background, quietly. Something that is actually new into the D5 world superfluid has introduced superfluid subscriptions. So superfluid is a streaming payments startup. So if you would like to trickle pennies to microtransactions over time, superfluid is that.
They are releasing superfluid subscriptions. So you can manage access to software, APIs, content, community, however you want to see fit. So that's something that's been released. It's been a long talked about use case in crypto. It's a streaming money. It's a streaming money. No, it has been used in gaming, I think, has it's gotten some traction. But I haven't personally seen a use case for it that has impacted my life. But I did throw superfluid over to our web developer, Ryan. So you're like, hey, does this work? Can you slap this into bankless.com? Yeah. And so he's investigating that. Disclaimer, I am an investor in superfluid.
Ryan is not, because he forgot to sign the document. Yeah, and I lost that email. I didn't sign those papers. Oh, well. Sorry about that one, bro. Well, it's done the use case. Yeah, you too. You know what, this is also kind of a bullish use case, I think, for chain link. They just lost their cross chain interoperability protocol. C-C-I-P is what this stands for. David, this reminds me a lot of what layer zero is doing. Yeah. You're familiar with that part. Layer zero, but chain link flavored this time. OK, well, for those that aren't familiar with layer zero and with what chain link is doing here, can you kind of describe what this C-C-I-P protocol, what the C-C-I-P features is actually adding?
Yeah, so the first step to transferring tokens across chains is transferring messages across chain, because actually tokens and data, they're all the same thing. So this starts there, but it's basically a cross-chain messaging platform, since chain link has the security of the link token being staked and it has some amount of assurances about passing messages. So you start there and then you can build up further and further use cases. And so cross-chain collateral deposits, cross-chain NFTs, cross-chain gaming, cross-chain data storage and computations. It's like a super bridge. Yeah, it's like a super bridge.
Yeah, mesh network bridge thing. But it's more than that, because you can build on top of it. If you want to build an NFC, you can. Like, it supports multiple chains underneath, like Avalanche and other EVM chains, layer two and Ethereum. Then you can build that on top of this new protocol and chain link, is that right? Yes, I believe so, that's right. I have not looked too deeply into this, because A, I don't really like bridges to begin with. And B, the chain link army is always up in my mentions and it leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Yeah, I agree, but at the same time, chain link has always had great tech, right?
They support a lot of the oracles in this space, so they're doing some good things. Flashbots has become a unicorn after a $60 million raise. So unicorn status is a billion or above that is flashbots, the MEV platform. There's a lot of a conversation about the development of what they're calling SWAV, which is a new MEV chain. It almost seems to me it's a marketplace for block builders and searchers and the whole kind of block business. All the participants of how a block becomes a block, it's like a marketplace. It's a chain marketplace for them. I feel like we need a series of episodes on what's going on in the block builder supply chain space to fully unpack this and understand it, but it seems like private investors are understanding it, willing to upgrade.
But in the meantime, I think there's going to be a lot of MEV folks, including HASU, at permissionless, that conference will be another nice check-in. So another reminder to grab your privilege. There's a theme of this week. If you haven't, the theme is accumulate and grab a permissionless ticket. David, we got a lot more to talk about though. What's coming up next? Yeah, questions from the nation. We got a eigenlayer question. They seem to be pretty frequent this week. Then we got a take of the week. I got a take from Mike Epitio. We'll talk about bridges there. And then I wrote an article. And so there's five takes in there and then I'm going to burn through really quickly.
And then of course, what, Ryan and I are bullish on. And we got to hot meme. It's very hot. It's very hot. You want to stick around for that. So all of that and more, but first a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network, a brand new high-performance Ethereum layer two built using the OP stack. But uses eigenlayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one. Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications.
The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboard it, like game seven for Web3 gaming and buy it for TVL and liquidity and on-rounds. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure and decentralize Mantle. If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led layer two ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0x Mantle.
Hiring people worldwide, paying them in crypto, providing them access to benefits, it's all so complex. But it doesn't have to be, complying with labor laws, payroll rules, tax obligations and crypto regulations in every country that you employ someone is difficult, time-consuming, manual and costly and is drawing more and more attention from regulators and governments. But there is good news. Toku is here. Toku is the first employment and compensation platform for the crypto industry that makes this easy. Toku helps you hire employees or contractors and pay them in fiat or crypto legally, compliantly and with all the taxes handled in over 100 different jurisdictions.
So whether you're an early stage company with just a team of two or you're an enterprise with 200, Toku has a solution that meets your needs. Toku is already working with the leading companies in this space, protocol labs, Hedera, Gitcoin and many more. So transform your employment and token payroll operations with Toku. You can reach out to Toku at toku.com slash bankless or click the link in the show notes. Question of the week coming from onium.eth. The question is this, it seems to me that eigenlayers positioning Ethereum as a kind of security reserve for other blockchains, much like how the US dollar serves as a reserve currency providing economic security globally.
By enabling Ethereum's security to cross borders into other layer ones, eigenlayer appears to be enhancing the overall security of the blockchain ecosystem. The question is this, could you delve into this analogy and discuss the implications of this security globalization? I like that term. How could this impact the future of Ethereum and other blockchains? This idea of security globalization and eigenlayer, what's your take here? Yeah, that's a really good question. You can definitely tell onium.eth who asks that question. Thanks Onium is like, that's a bankless five question. Putting these things into like geopolitical country nation state terms.
So like the United States passport, probably the most valuable passport in the world. That's probably a fair take. You can get into the most countries with the United States passport. You can just walk across almost anywhere and everyone's like, oh, welcome to our country. I think what they're getting at is that Ether does the same thing for all of the restaking networks. So all these restaking networks is like, oh, your Ether, please welcome and sit yourself down and also consider providing us some services while you're here. It's pretty pretty similar, I'd say. Why did eigenlayer choose Ether?
Why didn't it choose Bitcoin? Why didn't it choose Solana? Well, it couldn't choose Bitcoin because it's Bitcoin's not proof of say you can start a smart contract. Why did it choose Ether over Solana? Well, because Ether has all the economic bandwidth. It has all the value. If you're going to have a system where you need to have your collateral, to be trusted, you need to post collateral. You need to post the best collateral possible on the network that has all the networks. And so that is just Ethereum. And so this is part of the story of capital against capital, against capital. And so the most number of doors are open to you.
And so your security, your collateral, can transcend across boundaries because those boundaries desire your capital the most. And I think there's pretty strong parallels with what Onium is saying here. Hopefully that was unpacking that analogy enough to their satisfaction. Yeah, the only thing I would add to that is the direct answer to the question in me is how does this impact the future of Ethereum in the context of reserve currency status? My take is at Cement's Ether as the reserve currency of not just Ethereum, but of like Repto and all of the other blockchains. In the same way that kind of the dollar has been reinforced through the US's military security and economic prowess as the reserve currency of the world.
Like the liquidity and the network effect that you were just talking about, like the capital begets capital, security begets security, sort of network effect. That just compounds if eigenlayer is successful, right? Because they'll imagine there being like 10, 15, 20 tokens on CoinGecko and their layer one tokens or their network tokens. And they're secured by Ethereum. Yeah, I mean, it is just, it is probably the single most bullish thing if this takes off for either the asset since, I don't know, staking, since it's under sound money, since EIP 1559, it's absolutely massive, I think, and it's ability to build network effect.
All right, let's go to some takes of the question, David. Coming in with Takes of the Week, we only have two. This is Mike from Blockworks and this is a post-ECC take. He goes, if there's one thing I learned from Paris, is that market makers are bridges now. And this is a conversation that's slowly been brewing and I think really has crescendo to it's Uniswap X. Uniswap X also cow swap. I think also perhaps swap itself. These are all platforms that allow for bridges to be completely abstracted and also like kind of largely routed around. It's really bridge mineral. It's a lot of solided, right?
Yeah, you still need them, but you need them in the minimal fashion. In the most loop. Yeah, and so why is that true? It's because market makers, what does it mean like why are market-branchors bridges now? Say, Ryan, you have Ether on the Ethereum layer one and you would like to have die on the optimism layer two. Instead of making a trade on Uniswap and then hopping over a bridge, what you can do is you can just post a transaction, not even submit a transaction to Ethereum but broadcast a transaction that says to any market maker, hey, I have this much Ether giving me as much die as possible on the chain that I wanted to be on.
Like I just broadcast my intent. I don't actually have to transmit to the transaction. Right. And then a market maker is like, well, I'll take that deal and maybe a different market maker is like, well, I'll take that deal too, but I'll do it better. And all of a sudden the free market fulfills your order and puts your assets in that you want and the place that you want and you never had to touch a bridge. And like the bridge security is like minimized. And so this is kind of the meta that has been unfolding is like bridges are kind of just being routed around. Yeah, this is another series of bankless episodes honestly to get into this whole world of impents rather than transactions.
I feel like we need some content on this to fully unpack and understand it. But yeah, that is an emerging meta here. David, what are some other things you learned from ETC? I saw you put a post out in the bankless newsletter this week. So what were some of your key takeaways? So yeah, I actually took some time and wrote out an article about my big takeaways from ETCs, about 2,500 words. And I'm going to read it. Let's go. I'm kidding, I'll just read the headlines. The big ones are protocols are becoming commodities. My big TLDR here is that by the time the next bull market comes around the cost of web three, trustless computation, data, whatever we need to do web drops to zero will have approach to theoretical minimum.
Like that's one of my big takeaways. And you can explain my reasoning and all the tidbits of data that I have about that. So that's the first one. Second one, protocol convergence and verticalization. So Ave just launched the ghost table coin, maker Dow just launched sparks, which is an Ave type money market. Frax has already had both of these things and they also have their own internal LSD. So these things are all starting to a become verticalize and be converged in their same design patterns. We already have the convergence. It's like, that's why I was going next. It's all the stacks. It's all the stacks.
We have all the stacks. And so those are all converging on the same design patterns. Then you have a uniswap X becoming a vertical on top of uniswap. So there's a bunch of convergence and verticalization going on. So that was my next big one. Then after that, it's like, OK, we have protocols that are maximally cheap. We have a DeFi apps that are becoming maximally as vertical and wide as possible. It's now time to think of the consumer. And I don't only just mean more apps to buy more block space, but can we build front ends like Infinix, like what Kane is doing at synthetics? Can we build front ends?
Can we build apps? Can we start doubling, tripling, quadrupling down on building consumer level stuff that is built for people that have never touched a private key? That's my call to action on there. And then my last big takeaway is the modular summit versus ETH CC. There's two different conferences here. So I'm going to just like the different dispositions of who you find where. But my big takeaway from modular summit is that whole community, which is like the Celestia Espresso, the layer twos, the eigenlayer. That side of crypto is just racing out into the frontier. They are developing and discovering things so quickly.
They are the actual frontier of thought, I'd say. And so that's my takeaway there. And then just as a conclusion, if you haven't caught the theme of this episode yet, next up is permissionless. So that's going to be where the next bankless meetup is. And the bankless party is going to be like 200 plus people for all of our citizens and friends. And everyone we want a party with. That's awesome, man. Those are some good takeaways. Each of those could be episodes as well. I feel like we need to dive into topics more. This is true. This is true. What do you both show on this week, man? Right behind me, like I said, is the Matterhorn.
And I don't climb it tomorrow. We climb a training mountain tomorrow. But then we come back and rest. And then on Sunday, I climb it. So just like a giant spike, it is a giant spike. I'm actually kind of bummed that that cloud is there, but the cloud doesn't go away. This is your picture. It's this. That's right outside of where I am right now. So how do you actually get there? So you're just like a drive-up. Yeah, no, there's no car. Actually, I'm in a city with zero cars. We have to ditch the car, park the car, take a train in. And then the Airbnb that we have is like 20 minutes away. So we took this like a little electric taxi.
It was kind of cool. Really cool town. Yeah. That's awesome. That's what I'm bullish on. I'm bullish on climbing the Matterhorn and hopefully successfully. Are you going to plan a big bankless flag up there at the top when you get there? Oh, of course. I never missed such an opportunity. Awesome. All right, Ron, what do you publish on? You know what? Despite this week and all of kind of the pushback and the anger about world's going, I'm not going to say I'm bullish on world's going because I'm not. But I am bullish on digital proof of personhood. I just feel like crypto sometimes underestimate how much we're going to need this.
There's this huge meta problem that's hitting us right in the face right now, which is like, we don't know who the bots are and who the people are on the internet. It's like on Twitter. I don't know. Those 500 retweets is how many of those are bots and how many of those are people, right? And I think that what tends to happen over time is if the bots have the level of speech that humans do on the internet and we can't tell human from bot, then it starts to fracture society. Democracy's run on trust. Democracy is kind of a conversation between all of its citizens. And if you can get civil attacked by a whole bunch of bots, if your democracy can be civil attacked in that way and destroy the fabric of trust, destroy the conversation, then you can destroy democracy.
I feel very strongly that human beings should have freedom of speech on the internet. But I don't think that extends to bots. And so if we can't tell who the bots and who the humans are, we got a real problem. And the status quo, the only way we know how to do that right now is either you have kind of like the tech companies partner with the government to do some sort of like state ID, driver's license, passport, AML KYC thing. I don't like that. That's what we're headed. That's like the default, right? And so that's bad for a lot of reasons. But I guess it's something. And I guess what I'm bullish on though is that we can get to a place.
Crypto can play a huge role, maybe the fundamental role in creating the stateless identity. And in order for a stateless identity, proof of personhood online to work, it needs to be decentralized. It needs to be permissionless. It needs to be private. It needs to be unsensurable. Those are the things that crypto is really good at. If this type of thing doesn't come from crypto, where's it going to come from? No one else is building this. Silicon Valley is not building this. The tech companies aren't building this. So I feel I've always felt like this with crypto, which is like act one is separation of money and state.
Act two is separation of identity and state, right? We need both of those abilities if we're going to make it through the potential dystopian authoritarian scenarios that the 21st century is going to throw at us. So I don't know how this will look. I don't know what kind of the best solutions are, whether it's kind of a social graph-based solution or something else, whether biometrics plays a role in it or not. But I would encourage us with all of the pushback on World's Coin. And there are a lot of good reasons for pushback to be had. Let's not lose sight of this use case of decentralized proof of personhood.
I think we're going to need this one. And I think crypto has a big role to play. So here's a podcaster telling all the devs to go build something cool, but we've got to go build something cool, guys. Anyway, that's my take. Great take. You want to get to the meme of the week? I've been waiting for this one. An old Gary Gensler meme that sort of fits in. David, you talked about this, yeah, yeah. OK, so this was like UFO week. I don't know if you caught this. Like somebody in Congress just caught the tail of this. All right. I would not get in. There's Gary Gensler, picture of Gary Gensler, our favorite, and he goes, all these UFOs, they're going to need to come in and register.
And you're going to have to come in register. We're going to need you guys coming. There you go. Come into my office. Well, I ended there. I have no take on UFOs at this point as another thing. I'm just trying to. I mean, if these UFOs can just abduct Gary Gensler, that sounds like I'm not like the outcome. All right, I'm not going to touch that one. Risk this gamers. Gotta let you know at the end of every bankless episode, of course, none of this has been financial advice. It's not alien advice. Nothing of the sort. You could lose what you put in, but we're headed west. This is the frontier.
It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot.