Joining us today is Ryan Selkis, who is here to walk us through his crypto thesis for 2024.
We cover big investment themes, people to watch, the future of stablecoins, policy takes and so much more in this wide ranging episode.
----- 🏹 Airdrop Hunter is HERE, join your first HUNT today https://bankless.cc/JoinYourFirstHUNT ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku
🌐 Layer Zero V2 Launch https://bankless.cc/LayerZeroLabs
------ TIMESTAMPS
00:00:00 Intro 00:05:11 Recapping 2023 00:07:50 Are We In A Bull Market? 00:12:09 Investment Trends 00:16:48 BTC ETF Winners 00:20:03 Ether 2024 Predictions 00:26:57 BTC Security Model 00:33:06 Investment Strategy 00:36:56 VC and Private Markets 00:42:28 IPO's and M&A's 00:45:04 People To Watch 00:50:56 Why Does Elizabeth Warren Hate Crypto? 00:57:54 Grayscale 01:04:55 Products to Use in 2024 01:07:00 USDC Flips USDT? 01:11:32 Coinbase and BASE 01:15:46 Crypto Money 01:21:17 Privacy 01:27:54 How Crypto Wins In The US 01:40:07 The Political Bull Case 01:44:42 What's Most Exciting
------ RESOURCES
Ryan Selkis https://twitter.com/twobitidiot
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
The important battle that must be won is in the Senate. There is no future for crypto in the US if the Democrats hold the Senate. Really? At least not until 2030. I think if it's a clean sweep for the the the Dems, then move your family. Wow, really? Move your family or or pick another industry, right? I mean, I'm not going to be doing crypto in the US if it's a clean sweep from the from the Democrats. You see like, why? What do you think happens? What will 2024 have in store for crypto? That is the question on today's episode. To answer that question, we brought on Ryan Selkes. He gives us his crypto thesis for 2024.
This is from a document that he publishes every year where he goes through. I think this one is 200 pages of all of his predictions, all of the themes, all of the narratives, all of the things he thinks will be in store for us in the following year. A few things we talk about in today's episode. The big investment themes in 2024, including Bitcoin, Ethereum, and all the other tokens down the market stack. Also, the people to watch, including Larry Fink. Ryan thinks he's about to get a lot more bullish on crypto. How we defeat Elizabeth Warren as well, we talk about that. And why Ryan thinks Barry Silver will make a comeback.
I think he called him in this episode undefeated. We also talk about the future of stable coins. Ryan is particularly bullish on Coinbase's layer two. It's called base. Of course, we talk about that. And finally, we conclude with some policy takes. And Ryan has some particularly spicy takes here. Just me on today's episode, David has out today. He is ice climbing true story. Guys, we're going to write to our episode with Ryan Selkes. But before we do, I want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our number one recommended crypto exchange for 2023 and 2024. That's Kraken.
Go create an account. Kraken knows crypto. Kraken's been in the crypto game for over a decade. And as one of the largest and most trusted exchanges in the industry, Kraken is on the journey with all of us to see what crypto can be. Human history is a story of progress. It's part of us hard-wired. We're designed to seek change everywhere, to improve, to strive. And if anything can be improved, why not finance? crypto is a financial system designed with the modern world in mind. Instant, permissionless, and 24-7. It's not perfect, and nothing ever will be perfect. But crypto is a world-changing technology at a time when the world needs it the most.
That's the Kraken mission, to accelerate the global adoption of cryptocurrency, so that you and the rest of the world can achieve a financial freedom and inclusion. Head on over to Kraken.com slash bankless to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Cryptocurrency services are provided to US and US territory customers by pay-ward ventures eke, pvi doing business as Kraken. Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications. Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale, with low fees and faster transactions.
Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs, and is quickly becoming the Web 3 gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitrum.io Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum orbit chain? Arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. Whether you're a developer, an enterprise, or a user, Arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum.
Experience Web 3 development the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Visit Arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. Metamask Portfolio is your one-stop shop to navigate the world of DeFi. And now bridging seamlessly across networks doesn't have to be so daunting anymore. With competitive rates and convenient routes, Metamask Portfolio's bridge feature lets you easily move your tokens from chain to chain, using popular layer 1 and layer 2 networks. And all you have to do is select the network you want to bridge from and where you want your tokens to go.
From there, Metamask vets and curates the different bridging platforms to find the most decentralized, accessible, and reliable bridges for you. To tap into the hottest opportunities in crypto, you need to be able to plug into a variety of networks, and nobody makes that easier than Metamask Portfolio. Instead of searching endlessly through the world of bridge options, click the bridge button on your Metamask extension, or head over to Metamask.io, slash Portfolio to get started. Bagless Nation, our next guest needs no introduction, because we do this every freaking year. We have Ryan Selkis.
He is the founder and CEO of Missouri, which is a crypto analytics firm and media company, helping bring clarity to the crypto space. And every year, he brings for us toward the end of the year his thesis going into next year. Today, we are ending 2023, actually not today, but this month sometime, and we are entering 2024. So it is time to take a look at Ryan's predictions. His thesis going into 2024. Ryan, how are you doing today? I'm tired, man. This is... You tired? We were just talking off camera. This is the longest one yet, and it's still under review. We didn't even get you the full draft yet, so I appreciate you doing this, but I'm...
Yeah, no, we're looking at... We're looking at 100 today. I'm 102 sections into the 105 overall, so 102 sections. The last, the last three I think I'm going to finish tonight, and then we'll go through better week or so, that it's, and then ship it out right before the holidays. So, Bankless Nation, this is a 200-page document, of course, that we're gonna try to distill half of this into an hour or so long episode, which is an absolutely monumental task. But of course, we'll have a link so that you can download the full document and get your digest. This is some fantastic holiday reading for you, if you're interested in kind of a recap of 2023, and the things going into 2024.
I'm wondering before we get into kind of the various sections here, and we've got a number that we're gonna cover, if you could give us sort of a recap of the year. So, you start with this welcome letter. The carnage of the past 12 months in crypto have been brutal for all of us. We've grinded through bankruptcies, lawsuits, layoffs, turnovers, and a general malaise that comes with a bad hangover after a big party. That's very much how I felt. We ended, you know, 2022 and 2023, I suppose, for much of the year was part of that. How would you recap the year that was 2023? And how are we positioned going into 2024 at the highest level?
I feel good about heading into next year and where we are. We have a number of tailwinds that I think should be pretty encouraging for most of us. There is a weird backdrop in the private markets, like the private venture markets, where there's still pretty significant dislocations in terms of prior valuations. And I do worry that some of the non-token affiliated companies might be getting a little bit of a false sense of security or this might be a false start in terms of like resetting certain levels of optimism, particularly for folks that have been around for a while. But that's mostly a function of both the public, software, and kind of private venture market still being relatively icy.
I think seed stage feels good, series A feels good. Obviously, the token markets are coming back. There's different narratives that are starting to get people excited. And then at the very highest level, Bitcoin has a number of tailwinds. We'll talk about Ethereum as well as we always do. And kind of about that around. But I think the Bitcoin spot ETF tailwind is probably the biggest kind of wealth generator, or potential wealth generator for folks within the crypto ecosystem, and then that usually has a trickle down effect. We're in this little bit of a weird transition phase, but all things are generally trending positive, including policy right now.
It might not feel like it, but I can certainly share some thoughts on why I think things are slowly coming back to a good spot. Maybe this is the dark before the dawn there. Right, Ryan, would you call this a bull market? Are we in a bull? Well, technically, we've been on a bull market all year. I mean, the coins up 150%. Ethereum's almost 2x off the lows. Solana and some of the other highest performing big protocols or mid-cap protocols or up five, in some cases, even upwards of 10x. So I certainly think it's almost undoubtedly and indisputably a bull market from the bottom. But there is still a ton of recursive investment within the industry, right?
So when you think about infrastructure companies, when you think about where we are from an ecosystem, health standpoint, a lot of our long-term growth and really hitting the potential for crypto and all these emerging protocols, it's going to come from real-world adoption and cross in this chasm, either with users or in the case of defiant financial instruments with Wall Street. And that's where we're starting. We're still in a bit of a halting pattern. I would say it's probably more cute. On the DeFi side of things, then it is for just Bitcoin on kind of the currency front or some of the other emerging applications, like D-Pen and non-financial.
We're not explicitly financial applications, but it feels like we could be on the cost of a really fun year. It really just depends on how a couple things break. So going into 2024, do you have an analog for what year 2024 will be most like? Is this like, you know, if we go back to the previous market cycle, is this 2021, or is it 2020, or you can even go back further than that? Is it 2016? What do you think 2024 will be? It feels like 2020 in a six-month delay or so, because what we're seeing right now in the Salani ecosystem in particular, and this hotball of money trade, and all the enthusiasm for different alternative L1s, or farmable ecosystems, it's very reminiscent of DeFi Summer 2020.
And of course, DeFi Summer 2020 was basically like, rocketing off the COVID crisis lows in March to a new hire right after the last Bitcoin having. So it does feel a little bit like, I'd say, mid-2020 in some respects, I always try to shy away from the different calendar year comparisons, just because I think that there really are a series of overlapping hype cycles and kind of rhythms to the market. On the one hand, you've got the Bitcoin having cycle, which for whatever coincidental reason has just happened to work in pretty nice tight four-year cycles. And then others, you're kind of analogizing a previous historical events.
So for Solana, it's the crashed $80 of ETH and all the kind of nuclear events that happened around consensus being very distressed at one point in that low. You can kind of analogize that a little bit to what happened at FTX and some of the supporting infrastructure around Solana and kind of their resurgence. But yeah, I think 2020 feels like the vibes, depending on what part of 2020 you look at, though, that could be very scary because it was a shit show earlier in the year. And obviously, I think there are some things politically and kind of socially, culturally, that probably cause some related fears, even if it's not quite a pandemic, that locks everybody down to their houses for two or three months.
Yeah, interesting. I mean, 2024 in itself will be an election year. So I'm sure we'll get to that. But let's set this up. Okay, so we've got five sections we want to touch on. And we're only going to be able to cover the highlights. We've got the investment trends for 2024. We've got top people to watch. We've got some products to use, the top products to use. Top crypto monies, talk a little bit about money. And then some policy trends will end with that. But let's start with the investment trends for 2024. You've listed 10 here. Let's start with King Bitcoin here. So what's the investment case for Bitcoin going to 2024?
Who is buying? Are these some of the standard crypto natives? Are we have net new buyers? How would you describe Bitcoin as an investment trend for 2024? I know you mentioned the spot Bitcoin ETF. Maybe it starts there. Is there more to it than that? I think there's a bit more to it than that. But that is probably the most important. And again, this does depend on an actual Bitcoin ETF getting approved in January, like many people expect, including myself. I think that's a high probability event. If it doesn't happen, it would be both a surprise and potentially introducing a pretty big variable into the mix.
We don't really know how the market will react. But I'd imagine it would be net unfavorable compared to what the year could look like. But the thing with the Bitcoin ETF is Mike Novgerats and a number of other investors that we had at Main Netscare. Mucci said the same thing, Raul Powell said the same thing. The one thing about Wall Street is that assets are sold, not bought. And you basically have a dozen or so of the largest institutions on Wall Street that are going to be falling over themselves and ruthlessly competing with each other on who can market Bitcoin harder to their investors. Is that really something they say, by the way?
Is assets are sold, not bought? That's something they say on Wall Street? Yeah. I mean, it makes sense. It's a very sales-oriented industry. And you have a situation where yes, there are all these kind of tailwinds, right? Could you see increasing adoption of Bitcoin and high inflation countries, and is Malay in Argentina going to be the second Bitcoin president, right? That's kind of one thing in the background. You've got this four-year cycle of the having narrative. And you could argue whether that's overplayed because the inflation rate is so low now as the marginal impact is muted, blah, blah, blah.
We don't really know. Then there were smaller but really important changes like the, you know, FASB financial accounting standards board, their treatment of Bitcoin as a balance sheet asset has changed in a net favorable way, where, you know, you don't have to list it as an intangible now. You can actually market to market, which is one of those boring, but important structural changes that I think was an underappreciated tailwind for this year, particularly. And why is that important, by the way? The FASB. Essentially, in the past, you would only be able to take an impairment if your Bitcoin fell below its fair market value.
But the second that appreciates above that, you can't market to market, right? So you're basically taking a loss in your financial statements. If it dips below, but then you don't subsequently market back up, given the way that intangible assets are treated. So, you know, there's I think a ton of things like that that all add up. But, you know, those are every single data point, every single kind of narrative that I just mentioned. Those are going to be the same things that are put on glossy investment materials. From all these big professional salesmen at the companies that are going to be falling over themselves to gather AUM for their new Bitcoin ETF products.
And the only way that you really compete as an ETF provider is through distribution on the one hand. And basically marketing, right? Customer acquisition on the other. And there's no real difference between these spot ETFs. You can argue about, okay, one's going to be, you know, 50 basis points, one's going to be 75 basis points, like, ooh, gives a shit, right? Like, at the end of the day, whoever does the best job with marketing and distribution is going to mass them as assets under management, right? And if you follow that logic, then the incentive is for people to, you know, go above and beyond in terms of, like, how they're marketing these things and the dollar spends, are going to directly equate to that new AUM, which that new AUM for financial product and an ETF is new deposits, right?
And this is the first time Wall Street has had a product in general. Any act? I'm wondering if they've had a crypto product to sell. Right. And so you see, basically, the largest asset managers in the world just got their first crypto product and they're going to be petal of the metal in trying to sell it to the market and distribute it. And we've got some pretty big names here, right? I don't know. You know, I've heard from the analysts that generally ETFs are a power law winning game. There's like, you know, one big one and then there's a long tail of smaller ones and they're all competing to be the biggest one.
And we have some of the biggest names here, don't we? We have BlackRock. We have, you know, Vanack. And I guess GBDC in Grayscale has somewhat of a head start too. Do you have any commentary on who you think the big winners will be? Besides maybe the price of Bitcoin through this competitive experience. You think it does BlackRock just always win these things? Do you have any takes? Well, I think Grayscale is probably going to be the big winner. In some respects, and it will lose in others. But in terms of long-term assets under management, Grayscale is going to be tough to display, even for someone like BlackRock.
I think there's a bit of a misconception about what an ETF approval or an uplifting does to Grayscales and business based on the fact that they're going to have to lower fees and offer addemptions. Just because they will begin to offer addemptions and have to lower fees does not mean that that business is going away overnight or everything's just going to go to BlackRock and there's one very simple reason, Texas. So, you know, there are a number of clients of Grayscales that are not, you know, I own GBDC shares. I'm not going to immediately redeem or transfer assets to another ETF product or even to Coinbase, necessarily.
Because that's a tax event for you, right? And you have to trigger that tax pool and that's the cost based on it, right? So, you know, do I want to lose, you know, 30% of my Bitcoin on a per-shared basis, the second that I do that, or do I want to just hold it for 1% a year or whatever they reduce the fees to? Now, I do think the fees will be reduced for Grayscale, but it won't be sizable enough that it, you know, basically hurts them net, net. I think you could see a scenario where, you know, they Grayscale cuts their fees by 50%. Maybe they lose, you know, 10%, 20% of their AUM, but I could also see them gaining because they already have a liquidity advantage and they've already got this, this kind of marketing engine in place and all the other products that basically, they could come out net ahead with just some modest price appreciation expectations next year.
All right, so the interesting question, of course, is whether the market has priced this in or not. It seems to be consensus that we are going to get a spot-going ETF, some ETF sometime in Q1 of 2024. I don't know if you depart from that consensus. The best prediction market here is the GBTC share price, right? Yeah, which is close to most. And why I'm watching that gap that had grown to 50? Now, I think 50% was very much an overshoot based on the fact that those shares were being liquidated as this kind of bad collateral assets during the credit crunch last year. But when you see it kind of slowly steadily tick up from, you know, 50% to sub 10% now, let the last check maybe it's changed a little bit.
That's probably the best prediction market that you're going to get in crypto for whether people anticipate that there will be an uplifting and a spot-bid coin ETF approval. Okay, so let's talk about another investment trend prediction. So Ether and the world computer. So currently the second largest asset, about 225 billion or so, something like that. So about one fourth the size of Bitcoin, but still an order of magnitude larger than kind of the next crypto asset, I would say. What's your prediction for Ether? So where does Ether stand going to 2024? It seems like the market has been fading.
Ether may be lately, particularly. There's been a big soul run up. I think in your report, you're talking about Ether maybe being squeezed between Bitcoin and all of these alternative super fast layer ones. Yeah, what's your take there? So squeezed, you know, one way to put it, you know, I think I wrote straddles, which may be slightly different. I don't think people are getting squeezed out of Ethereum, but I find it maybe not as unlikely now, as it was a few weeks ago, just because the markets have continued to move in one direction at some point, you'll have a reversion to the mean potentially, but Ethereum out of L1s and kind of network tokens.
Ether as an asset still is around 60 plus percent of the market, right? And if you believe that network tokens are a winner, take all market, or a parallel distribution market, like search, Google versus Bing, then maybe that's sustainable and maybe what you're looking at is, you know, ETHBTC, right? So should Ether be, you know, X percentage of Bitcoin or ultimately is a going to catch up and maybe even flip because people think that there's more utility in the Ethereum network. I think the issue that ETHBTC has is it's trying to be both ends in the straddle, right? So Bitcoin, it's very simple.
It's a very easy meme. It's got all these narrative tailwinds. It's going to be the first out of the gate. You've got all the institutional investors who are not overthinking this, right? They're looking at the back of the napkin pitch that I just made, and they're all thinking the same thing and thinking that everybody else is going to think the same thing because they understand it. The triple point asset thesis, or the ultrasound money, which I know you guys have advanced, that resonates, but it's not quite as simple, right? It's, you know, it does take a little bit of an unpacking and you can pull it different parts of that thread.
You can pull on the money thread, while everybody just kind of gravitate in a Bitcoin, you know, El Salvador is not buying ETHBTC that I know about. Javier Malay is not talking about ETHBTC as far as I know. Central banks aren't thinking about, you know, digital gold and naming ETH in the same part of the conversation. And by the way, you've got this other asset, it's a lot of this really kind of coming up the curve and seems to be eating a lot of Ethereum's value. So now you're kind of taking questions from both sides. And I don't think that that's necessarily an indictment of Ethereum and the whole roll-up ecosystem being fundamentally unhealthy.
So much as it is, a recognition that has been so dominant that it's tough to retain 60% market share unless you truly have a monopolistic business. And I don't think the block space is a winner take all or even winner take most market. I think that ultimately application builders and kind of other kind of para chains or parallel networks will ultimately go where they find the trade-offs between costs, security for block space to be the most compelling. And by and large, that's going to make it very difficult for Ethereum to continue to compete on both availability and kind of cost on the one hand.
And if they do, if the ecosystem does get more and more scalable than the drive-down fees, right? Because there's more block space and so the supply and demand dynamic change on that side too. So I've thought more about Ethereum historically versus other alt L1s in general, almost more like Visa versus MasterCard versus Google versus Bing. And if that's the case, yes, it will be tough for Ethereum to maintain its market share. But having said that, everything mean reverts. And Solana and some of these kind of alternative assets have rallied so hard this year compared to Ethereum. If I'm wrong, it will probably be because of mean reversion not because I necessarily think the long term thesis is wrong about this competitive positioning dynamic between the two.
Do you think that Ether has any tailwinds of being sort of the second most institutionally adopted asset at all? So there is talk of Ethereum getting its own ETF as well. And there's even talk that that could happen as early as this summer is one possibility. What do you think that does for Ether if anything, the cycle? I'm not sure. Look at the Ethereum futures ETF. It didn't really do anything. I think the assets of our management are negligible. I think it's in the eight figures. I don't even think they've had nine figures collectively. It's up $100 million and the futures ETF versus what you saw in the first 48 hours with the Bitcoin futures ETF.
Very different. So I don't necessarily know that that is going to be a driver for Ethereum going forward. But I do think that Ethereum benefits if any other kind of core narrative building blocks for Bitcoin or the other Alts L1s. If they start to break down. If you have another major Solana outage, there's a series of hacks that impact some of those early emerging DeFi projects on Solana. They've got a lot of heat recently. Basically a number of things could happen. I'm using Solana as a placeholder as kind of the second in line behind Ethereum and that hurts that community collectively on the one side and it helps Ethereum net net.
On the other hand, at some point we do have to start talking about Bitcoin's security model. The having is a double-edged sword at this point because now your network security is down to about 0.8% per year. And I think that there is a question as to what level is too low. I don't know that 0.8 is too low to secure a trillion-dollar network that's still tens of billions of dollars per year and in security spending to the mining community. But it certainly is certainly less compelling than it has been historically. And if you get down to 0.3% or 0.1% or whatever it is, at some point either a few more companies to develop or there's going to be a breakdown in Bitcoin's core security model.
We are seeing some of that fee model with the ordinals activity lately. Does that make you optimistic at all? And I wrote about this during the report. I think that the irony is that everybody should be rooting for Udi and Eric and the board know that it's going to take hold. And instead you've got the Bitcoin religious that just of course they hate it because why not. One of the things that I wrote about in a later section at the investment transaction is Bitcoin essentially a long-term has four different options. There's either going to be a fee market that develops and it'll be thanks to something like inscriptions and ordinals or other kind of Bitcoin layer two demands.
You will ultimately find people starting to agitate for a switch to proof of stake. And this could potentially have, I mean it sounds crazy now just based on where the kind of Bitcoin community is. But you can imagine a scenario where Bitcoin gets financialized. And half of the Bitcoin in the world is ultimately managed by regulated financial custodians on behalf of basically we've basically created digital gold. And it's the same as the old players and kind of incumbents that are are custodying these assets. That makes it a little bit easier on margin to have that conversation. At some point in the future if the majority of the economic voting interest says this network is no longer secure.
We need to kind of fork a proof of stake. Third way would be you think about the 21 million Bitcoin cap as a soft cap versus a hard cap. So in other words, there is some lower bound of security that we should be spending as a network. The fee market is not maturing. We must maintain proof of work as an alternative to proof of stake otherwise what do we just build all this for if the block rock and three other banks can just make the ultimate network decisions at scale. That might be an alternative that people take seriously because they'll say okay half a percent annual inflation destroys the 21 million Bitcoin meme.
But at the same time it allows us to incentivize these third party energy intensive actors to secure the network. And that is a trade off that we're going to make because look it's still better than gold. That's still better than any other kind of fiat currency. There's kind of a natural equilibrium there. And then option four is a relevance long term because you can't secure a network with negligible fees that's measured in the trillions. The security model just doesn't work. So I put it in the report I think it's equal probability before those four. But the one outcome and I think the one kind of future of the world that everybody should be rooting for if you're in a Bitcoin community is bucket one, which is that a few market materializes.
It actually costs money to generate Bitcoin transactions on chain. And then you do push out some things like payments to, you know, layer twos. I just wish that, you know, at some point in the last six years we would have seen any sign of life in the lightning market. But but so far I just don't think that anyone should be able to be 24. It could be the year of the lightning Ryan. Next year, next year is always the year of lightning. Yeah, that's how it's been since I've been here anyway. You know, I will say the one thing that gives me pause is knowing that, you know, should talking against lightning or or even coming across this should talking lightning does feel a little bit like betting against David Marcus and and light spark and there are some good teams that are building, you know, on lightning protocols.
So I don't want to I don't want to bet against David. But I do think that he might sometimes this happens where you just get so jaded and so emotionally scarred from a traumatic experience that you can't possibly imagine, you know, someone else figuring out what, what, you know, you didn't. And and if light spark can figure out, you know, how to make lightning apps work, I think it'll mostly be because, you know, David went through the the Libra treatment at Facebook and just the full iron of the state, you know, going to block what they were trying to do with it with a private stablecoin. And then extrapolated that to a private stablecoin and will never work or these kind of, you know, private, public private partnerships will not work at scale.
So, you know, I need to build on Bitcoin. But, you know, who knows? That's, that's, that's, it's interesting conversations for me or you to have with him at some point. Well, certainly, certainly. I it's interesting those those four kind of ways that that Bitcoin could handle the economic chain security discussion, right? At least two of those feel like they could result in forks. And what's what's fairly interesting about that is now we have an ETF, right? And so how does Wall Street handle a fork? They could get very interesting, I think, over time. But I guess one high level question for you.
You don't think that this is the chain security budget of Bitcoin is not going to be a factor in 2024. We can continue to kick that can down the road. Can we not? Yeah, so, so I guess what I mean is not necessarily that it's going to be a factor and people need to worry about the security of the network. But at some points, if this is not addressed and people start to see this dwindling, you know, fee market or, or, or, or issuance rate, as a liability for long term security, ultimately that begins to get priced in. But it gets priced in very slowly. And I think the way that that would get priced in is net in favor of something like Ethereum.
I see. Or another, or another asset. So, yeah, so, so kind of, you know, closed, closed in the loop on the first part of the conversation. I think, you know, to the extent that Ethereum outperforms in like the medium term versus Bitcoin in particular, you know, and that that will probably be one of the factors. Well, tell me about the liquid field then. So, we talked about Bitcoin. We talked about Ethereum. So, but there's a long tail of other assets. But just you put this so, so people are kind of recognizing Bitcoin, ETH, and dollar backed stablecoins actually represent 75% of the total crypto market cap.
That's about 1.6 trillion. This won't always be the case, you say. And yet, you also say a little bit later in this section for your friends and family, I wouldn't recommend investing in anything outside of maybe five or so crypto assets. And by the way, you're not telling us the other three. Although, I'd be curious to ask you what the other three are. So, what do you think about this long tail? Well, I kind of, I kind of outed myself in the disclosure section at the back. Yeah, I see. And then we'll get to that too. So, Solano was the third, but I won't mention the other two. And mostly that's not because I feel uncomfortable sharing them, but I just don't want to get yelled at.
So, you know, now if anyone from any community and it tells me that, you know, I should be taking their asset more seriously, I can just fib to them and say that they were part of the other two in private. But I think the point about, number one, it's simplicity, right? So, the reason to keep things simple is not that other assets won't outperform Bitcoin and Ethereum. But because for someone that's just looking to get exposure to crypto as an asset class, definitionally, if you were just at Bitcoin 2014 or whatever the conference was that Vitalik introduced, you know, Ethereum at, you would have captured 75% of the market upside since 2014, right?
So, you would have captured that 100x, you know, plus if you just invested in the Ethereum ICO and Bitcoin back then. And I always joke with folks that like if you knew the early like Ethereum crowd, you know, there's a reason I missed the ICO, right? You can know too much about this industry and not keep things simple because it was like the island of misfit toys. And, you know, fortunately, I got in, you know, while it was still relatively early but not as early and as dysfunctionally as maybe the first couple of years were. But I think, you know, that's going to hold true for a while, right?
So, you know, maybe there's a handful of assets that make up the index that you want to expose or to. Just so all of your eggs aren't explicitly in one basket being Bitcoin or two baskets being Bitcoin or Ethereum or vice versa. But, you know, there's probably is, I think, a heavy bias towards being invested in the names that have a lot of name recognition just for the, you know, the 70 IQ play on crypto on the one hand. The other reason not to get overly excited about any individual asset or basket of assets in the other hand is one is just really expensive and time consuming to kind of parse through the other $300 billion worth of, you know, economically, you know, interesting or not so interesting assets.
But also, most of them are relatively high inflation, especially compared to Bitcoin and Ethereum. And I use inflation a little bit liberally just so that we can compare these on an Apple's to Apple's basis, you know, and I'd include things like insider sales from some of the big foundations and labs and kind of founder stakes that are prevalent in many of the other assets, you know, three through 10,000, right? So, you're the price that you're looking at and the market cap that you're looking at, that's not enough fully diluted basis, necessarily for the rest of the asset class. So, you're basically trying to, you know, not only compete against the top assets in the industry and Bitcoin and Ethereum, but you're also trying to beat the dilutive impact of all this net additional issuance, whether through the form of new tokens that are being issued through high-staking rates or new assets that are hitting the market through token unlocks or kind of early-team investing schedules.
Okay, so what's your take on? You got a section here on private crypto markets and I think a lot of people who are unaccredited investors, they don't have any funds inside of a fund structure or a VC of any type, they get a little bit of FOMO, right? Because they see the VCs participating in these early-stage deals, but you've called the private markets before losing alpha. Yeah, what's your take on private investors? So, the VCs of the world and the funds of the world, are they outperforming like an index-weighted, you know, top 10 or top 25 in crypto or do you think it's a losing game there?
I think if you looked at the aggregate investments in private crypto funds, hedge funds, venture, all strategies, at the time there were raised and the time that they were deployed, and you took all of those assets and you invested in Bitcoin Ethereum alone, it wouldn't even be close, right? It would not even be close, Bitcoin Ethereum. Bitcoin Ethereum would weigh... Yeah, they would perform just absolutely fucking destroy. Not just good for retail, that's not for retail. But my point is, I don't think that is true universally, but of course it's not going to be, right? You're always going to have a couple of outliers in that field that do very well, right?
So, multi-coin comes to mind betting early and really going all in on Solana, right? So, credit to them, but is that 100% skill, is that a confluence of factors, skill and luck, is it whatever, just throw a dart and you're going to have, if you throw a dart 100 times at a dart board blindfolded, one time out of 100, you might hit the bull's eye, regardless of your skill level. I'm not saying that about multi-coin in particular, but rather, in general, you're always going to have outliers on either side. But if you aggregate all of those dollar flows, they're not going to probably underperform the liquid markets.
And for illustration of this, you can even go back to look at Coinbase's Series B with Andreessen Horowitz, who's in the fall of 2013 that they closed that. I think Bitcoin was trading around $100, $120, probably when it closed. And if you look at their valuation, I think Coinbase was around $140 million post-money, if my memory serves me correctly. So Coinbase is a public company now, is $35 billion. So just do the quick math there. They've done very well. It's about $300, but it also $300 from $100, $400 actually, is the king, right? So even Coinbase, the most successful, I think really the only company to arguably outperform the market at that scale has been Binance, right?
But remains to be seen whether that's something that will persist long-term. But that is to say, it is exceptional and rare. And the odds of you picking that as an investor and going all in on that thesis as an investor, such that it outweighs the relative underperformance of all of your other dogs, it's probably not going to be worth it. Having said that, I always was of the opinion that folks that were heavily invested in Bitcoin and Ethereum should be investing in critical infrastructure because without the critical infrastructure, their bigger positions in the liquid tokens are not going to hit their potential, right?
So you do need those picks and shovels. And as these big networks hit the scale that they're at, the odds of another 100x in Bitcoin, if we have a 100x in Bitcoin, then society has fallen, right? So yeah, that's not a good thing because that means that we've experienced hyperinflation events in the US dollar. You can get 100x, you know, investments, you can't get venture scale investments, I think much more easily today than maybe historically. So it'll be interesting to see some of those funds perform, but the reality is, and Nick Tomino from one confirmation who's at a tremendously performing, well performing fund, I even think that he had kind of broken this down in the DPI for their kind of early funds.
How did it do relative to the liquid markets? It was, I think, neck and neck, maybe slightly, slightly under, but credits of them, they were transparent about it. And I think one of the reasons they were transparent is basically to say, we've done very well by venture standards. And, you know, even we, you know, having done well by venture standards, you know, face a tall order now performing the liquid crypto markets. The last thing I'll say there is, because of that dynamic, people will see that historical performance of the private and kind of infrastructure related venture markets. And I do think that you'll see many more liquid investors begin to deploy against strategies, especially if we see market momentum picking back up, the one access to some of these liquid tokens, because you can just as easily see if you avoided leverage and you avoided exchange blowup risk, the funds that really did well and absolutely crushed were mostly private and they're mostly liquid.
Yeah, it's a fascinating dynamic. So I guess for bankless listeners, don't get too obsessed with the FOMO of getting into that hot VC firm because there's a lot of opportunities in the public markets. And by the way, I pick on multi-point because they've crushed, right? So like they're, you know, you're picking on them in a good way. Well, I'm not from working on them in a good way. And, you know, I also think that no one is happier to troll people than Kyle, so. Yeah, I read his Twitter too. All right, so let's talk about public markets from a different vantage point. And this is, you got a section here in investment trends, IPOs and M&As.
What's going to happen? Are we going to get another crypto IPO? Do you think circles on that short list? We obviously have Coinbase. We have Galaxy out there. But there haven't been a ton of other large US public companies in crypto. Do you think that changes in 2024? I would honestly, I mean, I'd be surprised by just about any other company with the exception maybe of a circle coming out, right? I think to get out in this environment in the US in particular, I'm not as familiar with the international public markets. But for anyone to really get out in this environment in the US, you just need to have an exceptionally strong regulatory positioning and no one else fits the job description with the exception of circle right now.
There are other great companies that I think operate the right way. They've never had a hack. They've had minimal slaps on the wrist for different issues. So Kraken is one that comes to mind. But Kraken has been in the crosshairs of the SEC twice over this year. One for their staking product that they settled and ultimately had to wind down in the US. And now, again, more recently, they've doubled it and come after them with the same types of facts that they alleged against Coinbase. So that's to take a company public in the US in that environment. But when the SEC that would have to approve your listing is also coming after you for various reasons.
So I think that's unlikely. But I think circle is one of the few that has both the numbers, the narrative and the regulatory positioning to support that. Jeremy had mentioned earlier this fall when we spoke. And this is public, you said this on stage, but the company had done 800 million in revenue and about 200 in EBITDA all of last year and the first six months of this year, they had matched that. And that's probably going to persist. That's the most interesting environment. So yeah, just really well-rounded. And so obviously, circle is a company to watch and then Jeremy and Dante who's there had a strategy in their chief policy whisperer.
Not just in the US, but kind of internationally, we're also part of the two of the people who watch as well. We'll get to some policy later. That would certainly be a pretty bullish thing for stable coins. If circle, I think went public and got through that gauntlet. But let's turn to the people to watch going to 2024. There's a number of folks on your list. I want to start right at the top. Larry Fink in Kathy Wood. So Larry Fink, of course, the CEO of BlackRock, Kathy Wood, ARC Invest. Why are these names at the top of your list? Kathy's first. ARC is the first name on the calendar. So as the ARC ETF goes, it goes the rest of the industry.
So go the rest of the listing, I should say. So if Larry Fink gets all the attention and oxygen, but if you just look at the calendar, literally, ARC is going to be first out of the gates. And this is literally tradify coming to crypto and that product to sell. As you were talking about earlier. Let's talk about Elizabeth Warren. So she made your list. Elizabeth Warren in minions, I would say. Why is she on the people to watch lists? People don't understand why and how Senator Warren is as powerful as she is. And this took me a couple of years to learn and really is just a function of the just enormous amount of time and energy that I've spent in DC.
Not just with policymakers, but I'd argue even more importantly, with so many other policy leads at the different industry groups and many of the other companies and projects. And these folks have, by and large, come into crypto from DC, not the other way around. And they understand that Warren is as powerful as she is, not because she passes bills, but because she places personnel and places of high importance. And in fact, there was a good Atlantic article about her probably six, seven years ago that essentially kind of walked through the logic, which is she never had any interest in going to Congress and passing bills that were renaming post offices and stuff like that.
She explicitly said from day one, both explicitly and through her actions, that she wanted to pull the country to a more progressive direction and she wanted to basically have an outsized influence on financial policy. So much of your influence as a Senator or Congressman depends on your position with respect to committees. And from day one, having come from Harvard and then the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which she was the first chair of, to the Senate, she always had a very strong bias towards financial services. And ultimately, she ended up on the committee that oversees most of her financial regulators being Senate banking.
When she ran for president in 2020, she didn't win. She fizzled out actually pretty quickly, but it was such a crowded field. And she was otherwise splitting the progressive vote so closely with Bernie Sanders, there was a bit of a devil's bargain between the Biden campaign and Warren that in exchange for her support, she would have pretty decently sized influence in financial policy and his administration. And that was both a horse trade that's an open secret in DC circles as well as a just logistical necessity because Biden, even when he was vice president, had much more of foreign policy bent than a kind of domestic policy bent.
So he did not necessarily have the staff on economic policy and financial policy to begin with and by aligning with Warren, it both helped him solidify the nomination and then ultimately she was able to place people in positions of high importance. So now if you look across the financial regulators that are across the board, almost universally hostile to the industry, they are almost universally well aligned and in many cases have direct hooks with Warren and are either former staff or just very long-time allies. So, you know, I won't keep people's families out of it, but you know, again, you had a close family member that interned with Elizabeth Warren, you know, the deputy director of the National Economic Council that has been our biggest obstacle and one of our biggest critics within the Biden White House, Barat Ramamurri, he was a former Warren staffer, he actually resigned in September, who do they replace her with?
Warren's current chief of staff, or then current chief of staff directly in the same position. So there's pressure that she's able to exert from the financial regulators that she helps place senior most personnel in and then directly from the White House in some cases, if you're talking about the NEC, where some of those phone calls ultimately came when people hear about the pressure that the White House was putting on, for instance, Maxine Waters and the other chamber, the House, not the Senate, to slow down or walk away from some of the bipartisan bills that came out of the House this summer.
Those calls were coming from the White House, they were coming from staffers, closely linked to Elizabeth Warren, and so you basically have this situation where she is, I've called her the shadow of President of the Economy. I don't think it's too far of a stretch because at the end of the day, this is an administration that is very, I'll be diplomatical, say it's very heavily weighted towards autopilot based on who's at the helm and kind of the age of the President. Can I ask you a question here, Ryan? So I think I have totally underestimated what you just said. So you look at it just from a votes perspective, you're like, oh, this is one senator, one of 100 senators, one senator, one vote, and sure, she's more popular, more well-known, so she's got a little bit of that.
But when you paint the portrait of this is a senator that has massive influence in the executive branch, basically, in terms of placing a key personnel at the Treasury House as well. Yeah, okay, so you got all that. Can I ask you just a meta question about Elizabeth Warren that I haven't been able to figure out? And I don't know if you have any answers to this. Why does Elizabeth Warren hate crypto so much? What progressives will tell you is that it's about financial stability, consumer protection, and national security. Those are lies. It is ultimately about control. And the progressive establishment led by Senator Warren, I'd say, when it comes to financial policy, what they really care about is getting the federal governments and the be fed through central bank digital currency to have a greater direct impact on and greater direct accessibility to everyday citizens, right?
So they think, by and large, that the private banking system, the kind of federal banking system is a mistake as currently incarnated because it's, and there is some truth to this, in terms of the privatization of gains and the socialization of losses that you see kind of throughout Wall Street historically. But they still view that as a glitch in our system that ultimately needs to be brought to heal. And ultimately, we should be centralizing as much of the financial rails and the economy as possible. In theory, I don't think that that is a bad thing in terms of solving for some of the criticisms of the existing banking system.
In practice, it's the most hellishly dystopian thing you can imagine because you're giving the federal government direct control over the financial banking and kind of where with all of basically the entire citizenry. So we've already seen what happens with the platforming risks in social media. We've seen it in overdrive with Operation Chokepoint, which people don't remember or either don't remember or weren't paying attention is not like a crypto-bro conspiracy. This was an explicitly named fucking program in the Obama administration that the current FDIC chair, who was also then the Obama FDIC chair, ran for payday lenders and firearms dealers and the like basically to de-platform them, debank them from the financial system extra legally because they were politically disfavored industries.
They basically just ran Operation Chokepoint back. They don't call it Operation Chokepoint 2.0. We kind of came up with that moniker, but they're running the same playbook that they did with the explicitly named Operation Chokepoint a few years ago for some of those other other politically disfavored industries. So I think that's, it's incredibly dystopian to give the federal government that kind of control just because we're not governed by angels. And ultimately, I think the same reason that you and I are excited about crypto and kind of the decentralization of finance in general are the same reasons that I'd say, you know, 90% of Americans probably agree with us that the decentralization at least of the banking system is probably better than having like a central bank government digital currency that's going to be able to direct debit or credit your financial account as well.
So what's fascinating about that account and maybe that kind of clicks for me and kind of rings true is you're saying it's very ideological and it's about control. But I think somebody like Elizabeth Warren and that whole kind of anti-crypto army, they seem to think what they're doing is right the way. And maybe it's more ideological than I thought it was. And that would make sense because crypto as well as an ideological movement I think on kind of the other side of things. But it's less about, is it less about like direct benefit more about this is the way it should be and we think we know best and therefore we're pushing this out there.
I think what it boils down to, I don't find myself particularly ideological. I just look at history. And the history of centralizing the economy and the financial economy in particular is I don't live in that country. I don't live in that world, right? So like a period. Like just because we don't do centralized power very, very well. And I have never really seen compelling counterpoints. To the extent that people use China as kind of a modern example of the CCP and its control the economy kind of shepherding it and into like this kind of new dawn. You know, one of the reasons that their models have successful is because they kind of hotswap the back end of communist China in the 80s and 90s to capitalism, right?
So I think that it is if I heard a progressive case for further centralizing Wall Street or disintermeeting Wall Street and kind of being able to go directly to the Federal Reserve and kind of further federalizing power that had any historical analogs that didn't end in national disintegration or fascism. Then I would love to hear it. So maybe a listener here will be able to send me some links or counter examples, but I've just never seen it. And so until I see some historical example that would disprove this, I'm tend to believe that this is one of the most evil things that could be foisted on the American people and in general.
And the onus is on the proponents to prove otherwise that this could be managed in a way that wouldn't be outright dystopian and kind of frankly contrary to the Bill of Rights and all of our constitutional protections are kind of indebted in the operating system of the US. And I think that's really where this fight boils down. As you know, I've been outspoken on this and at times in polite. And one of the reasons that I'm in polite is because if it comes to our constitutional protections and people that I think are going to run rough shot over them because it's convenient or because that's just their political persuasion, I think that we should tell them to fuck off.
There you go. A challenge issue maybe to Rowan Gray to come up with an alternative if I know he's a regular person. I would love to see. All right, so we're still on the top 10 people to watch. We're going to get back to policy. Hopefully we have some time at the end. So we don't have time to cover all of these names. But if there's one other person on this list or a group of people, Ryan, you think is worth highlighting, maybe somebody that the crypto industry, I feel like Elizabeth Warren is maybe in the top 10 people to watch but maybe keep an eye on that kind of watching. How about a more positive case?
Who's somebody in the industry doing some good? Does the name come to mind here? Well, I know we talked about the ETFs a bit. But I think Son and Shine, my son and Shine from Gray scale who I used to work with is on the list deservedly. So we talked about the economics of that business. Gray scale was able to mass a massive, massive AUM base. I don't think it's going away. Even if it does shrink slightly, which even that's arguable, that business is going to be strong for a long time. And it's really led the charge in many respects, both in terms of institutional adoption. A lot of people don't know this, but I mean, I was a Gray scale responsible for three bubbles in one burst.
2013 when the product was originally formed, that was kind of the first institutional exposure that people could get through second market, kind of a massing into this Bitcoin investment trust product. Obviously, the levered Gray scale trade from the last cycle. Where funds were plowing in Bitcoin using leverage in terms of massing more shares, and then open to flip them on the open market. That arguably led to the late 2020, and it can only 2021 rally until that trend reverted. And then if you think the next year is going to be a third bubble, then I'd argue that they're probably going to have a pretty meaningful part of driving that forward just based on their loss in victory against the SEC.
So I think that company and kind of sunny, and in particular, is interesting to watch just because of the drama at the rest of the DCG. Yeah, I was going to say, do you think he can get out from under that gray cloud that seems to be hanging over the DCG? Well, I know, you know, I know, Ram, he's at the theory that will the New York Attorney General's action against Jenna says DCG and then Barry in particular lead to an outcome where gray scale has to spin out. And I mean, I make the point in the section about sunny that I think that's overstated, but the importance of gray scale, and I think the steadiness of sunny kind of a top, yeah, that part of the empire is a pretty important piece of 2024 story.
I personally think that Barry is unkillable, and I think people underestimate his ability to navigate a bankruptcy crisis or really anything like this. And I'd give him the advantage over the T-shirt James, you know, basically 99 times out of 100. Oh, fascinating. Barry Silver being unkillable. All right, we talked about people to watch. We talked about the top 10 investment transfers. I even linked, by the way, and I don't know if you caught the link, but I even linked to like the Jesse Pinkman. And he can't keep heading to like, you know, basically for anyone who disagrees with going on. That's how I feel about anyone that is surprised when they walk away, and this is ultimately resolved.
And I think this whole, I think everything with Genesis probably does get resolved for one reason and one reason only, because the number is going back up, and there's more money to go around, right? I mean, even the FTX bankruptcy is looking kind of okay these days with the asset price going. And Genesis is, small potatoes compared to that, you know, for multiple reasons, one, I think in terms of the, in terms of the divide that has to be bridged, but then, you know, two, in terms of the earning power of grayscale and grayscale is a bill to earn revenue in Bitcoin and crypto-denominated terms, right?
Would allow for some make holes that otherwise wouldn't have been available at something like FTX as part of the remediation. So I think those are important factors that people are overlooking. Guys, we're going to get right back with Ryan and we're going to talk about products, the crypto monies, and some crypto policy going to 2024. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Cello is the mobile first EVM compatible, carbon negative blockchain, built for the real world, and now something big is happening. Introducing the Cello Layer 2. It's a game-changing proposal that's going to bring Cello's rapidly growing ecosystem home to Ethereum.
Vitalik has shared his excitement for the Cello Layer 2 on the Cello Forum, so it has been Jones from Optimism. But why? The Cello Layer 2 will bring huge advantages, like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, and one block finality. Which does all that mean? Rock Solid Security, a trustless bridge to Ethereum, and more real-world use cases for Ethereum without compromise. And real-world adoption is happening. Active addresses on Cello have grown over 500% in the last six months. With the Cello Layer 2, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas using ERC20 tokens. But Cello is a community-governed protocol.
This means that Cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Cello Forum. Follow at CelloOrug on Twitter and visit Cello.org to shape the future of Ethereum. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax for providing token awards for your team? Toku simplifies everything about managing token grant compensation, and you can get started with them for free. You'll have access to top-notch legal and tax support to handle the distribution and management of tokens for your team. Toku caters to every step in the process from user-friendly legal templates for granting tokens to tracking vesting periods and calculating with holding taxes.
Toku understands every grant structure, token purchase agreements, restricted token awards, restricted token units, token options, and all the other ones. Toku is already simplifying this today for leading companies like Protocol Labs, DUIDX Foundation, Mina Foundation, and many more. You can learn more about how Toku can help you streamline your token management and get started for free. Visit Toku at Toku.com, slash bankless, or click the link in the description below. Introducing USDV, a better type of stablecoin. Currently, billions of dollars in stablecoin yield each year are paid to tether, circle, and other central issuers of major stablecoins.
But what if yield could be shared with the protocols that use it? Those protocols, in turn, can decide how to reward their users. USDV shares its yield with a community of apps and developers that mint it. Every USDV is backed one-to-one by US Treasury bills which pay yield. This yield flows out to the community of USDV issuers, so your Protocol, or app, can get paid for helping any users convert other stables into USDV. This works thanks to a breakthrough technology called ColorTrace from Layer0. Without it, it was impossible to attribute users of a token with a specific issuer, but now we can.
USDV is live on Ethereum, Optimism, Arbitrum, and other chains, and it's already available on over 20 exchanges such as Curve, Bitget, Velodrome, and Stargate. Start participating in the yield from Treasury Backstable Coins at banklist.com slash USDV. All right, Ryan, let's talk about some of the products to use in 2024. The first one that makes the list is Tether on Tron. Okay, so this is the Tether Stable Coined USDT on Tron. Why does that make your list of a top product for 2024? I just thought it was fascinating to look at the metric that I included as part of the visual, which is the number of addresses that hold $1,000 of USDC versus USDT.
And essentially, it's about 200,000 wallets in each case. At least it was at the beginning of the year. And then basically all of the net losses for USDC wallets in that regard. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but I think it was like 240 down to 200,000 wallets with that description for USDC. For USDT, Tether, it was basically the inverse and they've climbed all year, particularly on the back of the Silicon Valley bank crisis in March. That I think hurt circle because they had their assets at SVB. So the great irony is that, you know, a circle probably needs better protection from the US banks than the US banks need protection from crypto.
Ridiculous. And I think Tether on Tron and Tether just in general, but I think Tron being the primary settlement platform, you know, in terms of the availability in Latin America and Africa and Southeast Asia, it really is, you know, I'd say probably the most widely used killer app for crypto, particularly when it comes to financial inclusion that we've seen to date. So I did not have that on my Bingo card for the most widely used and most important apps that we have, but I do think right now is probably the case. I mean, it's just a Tron usage of USDT is just a slightly trailing Ethereum at this point, which is incredibly impressive.
I thought it was higher. It may be higher too. And by the time we were recording this, actually, we had Matt Siegel on from Vanneck. And he had kind of a contrary prediction, I want to run by you. He actually thinks that USDC will flip in Tether. In 2024. And the reason I think his, his unceded reason is basically treasury goes after USDT in a big way and tries to squash it out and snuff it out and shut it down. What's what's your take on that? Well, I wrote about this later. I don't blame you if you didn't actually read all 90 pages in the first half because it's a beast. And I didn't give you a whole lot of turnaround time.
But I, I could be very wrong about this, but I just have a hunch that it's all K-fabe. You're familiar with this concept and wrestling, right? K-fabe and refresh me. I think generally people should be, should be aware of this when it comes to politics. In general, K-fabe is essentially the, like it's all somewhat scripted, right? So like all the anger, all of what's happening in public, right? It's it's performative, but in private, you know, the reality is very different. And I think if you, if you look at Tether, like this is a perfect, you know, situation where, you could see like real like crypto K-fabe between the US government and a project like Tether.
Tether is this, you know, one of the largest buyers of US Treasuries. They work very, very cooperatively with the US government when it comes to things like AML KYC. And the alternatives for the US government are basically shut it down and lose a surveillance partner. Or to, you know, let it go on and, you know, keep an eye on it and make sure that, you know, it doesn't get too bigger out of control. But, you know, otherwise, you know, we'll sell them some Treasuries, we'll keep an eye on it and ultimately, you know, if they want to survive and not go to jail, then, you know, they'll play by our rules.
And I think I find it very difficult to believe that the US government wouldn't have found a way at this point to go after Tether, unless there was that dynamic in the backgrounds. And, you know, frankly, I think that's kind of good for all parties, but especially for Tether, which literally and figuratively just prints money as a company, since they sweep, you know, the interest on those Treasuries, basically to the company versus anyone that's... Do you think all the talk from Treasuries like performance art? Like, they really don't, you know, they're just talking a big game, but when it comes down to it, they're happy that Tether exists.
And they'll be happy to let them to continue to exist. Yeah, because ultimately, I think they'll be able to seize those assets a little bit more easily, right? Like, you know, it's different from Binance in the sense that, you know, Binance... Well, it's similar to some cases, right? I mean, Binance gets a big fine. There is a deal that's ultimately cut in terms of what CZ is going to have to cop too, and we'll see what a sentencing is, but obviously, it could be radically reduced versus what you might expect, given the magnitude of what was accused of Binance. But the trade-off there is, you know, now the US government is a little bit more closely tied to Binance, the platform, and now has better surveillance capabilities.
So to the extent that you see anything at Tether, that is similar in terms of the government kind of cracking down and then we're going after them, I would imagine it's probably not dissimilar from the Binance situation. And that Tether is basically allowed to exist. Maybe they pay some sort of fine even in the case that the government really comes after them. But the US government just finds a way to tighten its surveillance hooks into the project, and the more they play up the Wild West nature of Tether and the more they fight them in public and kind of engage in K-Fabe here, then the more credible looks, right?
And the more people will continue to use this asset, they can then be fully surveilled and that liquidity and all that demand doesn't just flow to something that is even more difficult for them to wrap their heads around from a sanction standpoint or just a general surveillance standpoint. So, Pinklist listeners, there are a number of other products on Ryan's list, Celestia, Fire Dancer, Farcaster, Lido, CCIP from Link, Project Guardian. There's two layer 2s on this list. We haven't talked about layer 2s up to this point. Maybe let's talk about base then from Coinbase. So why is that on your list as a product to watch and use?
Well, I think just generally Coinbase had a monster year. They stayed out of trouble. They'd been on the right side of a really good relative positioning on all these legal battles. They're the net benefactor or sorry, beneficiary of the drama at Binance on the one hand. The concentration of kind of custodial assets on the other when you look at all the ETF providers that have been choosing Coinbase as their surveillance sharing partner and ultimately their custodian for these applications. But I would actually say that one of the most interesting things about the business is all of the on-chain and kind of permissionless infrastructure they've been building.
I think the Coinbase wallet is best in class right now, the NPC wallet. They've made a lot of investments in terms of the embedded wallet as a service. Infrastructure they've been promoting. I even joked with Brian at Mainnet. I feel like I'm kissing his ass and I'm usually pretty tough critic. But I just think that they've been monsters this year from a performance standpoint. They're almost back to break even even a pretty kind of hellish exchange backdrop. And I think base is kind of that last missing piece of the puzzle, right? So they had the wallet but base basically is the parallel chain that allows them to quote-unquote kind of take an L2 or an exchange-affiliated blockchain network public without all of the baggage associated with BNB or kind of actually issuing or selling a token and then trying to prop up an ecosystem that way.
So they're basically able to use the optimism stack that can be contributors to that community. It's highly performed to their specifications. They'll be able to build an ecosystem around it. Now the line's getting a little bit blurrier between the base blockchain coinbase the company, all the permissionless tools that they're building and you've got this kind of spectrum of lock-in across both centralized and decentralized alternatives for people getting into the crypto industry. So it's equal parts, I'd say, a way to continue to keep their users. Essentially have their cake and needed to keep users locked into the Coinbase ecosystem.
But I think it's also a really invaluable hedge to have given the positioning in the US for a regulatory standpoint where they need some way to play in these frontier markets where historically they've been penalized by the uncertainty in the US and not being able to fully engage. They were handcuffed by the number of assets they could do versus in overseas exchange, it was less to everything. And so I think that patience is ultimately getting rewarded in the stock price, but more importantly, I think it's just a really excellent addition that they made and core asset that they have, not that they own it outright.
Maybe they'd object to my framing, but I think that affiliation that outlet for some of this on-chain activity to this L2 is going to be pretty invaluable for them moving forward. You think they're going to make a big play with USTC and stablecoins on top of base? Well, yeah, I was one of the big additions here is the ability to actually natively pay for transactions using USTC and not just another kind of roll-up token. So I do think there's some 40 chassis being played on base and all of it is kind of net good for users. If you look at kind of friend tech and the explosion that it had over the summer, that whole onboarding process, the bridging on the Coinbase wallet to base, the kind of scalability of that MVP, I think they knocked out of the park.
Some of that was friend tech, obviously. Good chunk of it was, but I think that infrastructure that's been laid was part of what powered it. So Ryan, you've got an entire section here on crypto monies and we've already touched upon a number of them that are listed here. We talked about Tether, we talked about USTC. Of course, we talked about Bitcoin, right? And when you look at USTC and Tether and you look at Bitcoin, we see both ends of the spectrum. I think Nick Carter calls Tether and USTC crypto dollars. I kind of like that term rather than stable coins is like kind of like a dollar-backed IOU, if you will.
And then we have our completely separate store value assets like Bitcoin. So we have both sides of those spectrums. Do you think we get anything else in between? I mean, every cycle seems like we try something with crypto collateralized stable coins. I mean, you could say maker, maker Dow has been somewhat successful with die. That's still at play. It's not growing as fast as maybe the bulls would have hoped. We tried some Algo stable coins last cycle that absolutely collapsed. What's new for us in the crypto money thesis going to 2024? What do you think will work? Honestly, I'm not sure. So I was interested in Terra in mid 2020 because the because of the affiliation of Chia, the payment application and what I thought at the time.
And again, there's a lot of like allegations have been thrown around. But now, folks are saying that all those volumes are fake and that application wasn't real or what not. But at the time, it seemed like you had a payment application that was useful with some underlying economic model that could ultimately feed the algorithmic stable coin and create at least something that wasn't just turtles all the way down in terms of a crypto collateralized money. And the issues in the blowup risk were well known from day one, but at least you had that kind of fee engine and that potential path to sustainability that was interesting.
And I forget the market cap at the time, but I think it was low. It was like $50, $60 million or something like that. So it was, I think, a reasonable bet to make if you thought about, you know, could someone or could some model ultimately come to fruition that figures out how you can bring a under collateralized stablecoin to market that doesn't just collapse from day one under its own weight. And I've kind of gotten, I don't say jaded. I'm very skeptical. I feel like that was probably the closest we were going to get to running that experiment at scale. And I'm almost not sure whether it's worth running again.
Because the risk will never disappear. And you saw how catastrophic the losses were from Terra getting to 40 billion or whatever the high water mark was. I could imagine the repercussions of an algorithmic stablecoin that tweaked some of the model parameters and then got to 400 billion, right? Or 4 trillion, right? Now you're, now if that unwinds, you're collapsing the global economy. So I don't know. I think that there's, I think there's some interesting plays that are being contemplated right now. I know, you know, a couple of folks have written about flat coins. And you know, do you have stablecoins?
It could potentially map to purchasing power versus like actual, you know, like US dollars. I don't know. I think it's going to be extremely difficult. And I think at some point, you, we're going to have to have cooperation with nation states when it comes to stable currencies. That's not to say that they won't ultimately all fail or hyperinflate or at least at the very least inflate. And so you lose purchasing power over time. But, you know, part of me kind of things like that's what Bitcoin's for, right? So I get that on the coin and then $100. But like, don't try to mix the two and then create another just catastrophic kind of a barbell type strategy.
Yeah, right. We have our crypto needs assets. And then we have. I don't mean to knock, you know, any of the entrepreneurs or any of the folks that are trying, you know, because maybe someone figures out a model that works. But I don't know. I think it's just, you know, this is actually one area where I'm probably more on the side of, you know, financial regulators that people would think that I would be. I don't think that we should be fucking around with algorithmic stablecoins anymore because, you know, because the bigger they get, the riskier they are. Sure. You can look at, you could, you could point to any algorithmic stablecoin project right now and show me a thousand positive metrics.
And the question is going to say, okay, well, what happens when this becomes 100 million, right? It comes a billion when it becomes 10. But like, the more successful it is, the more pronounced the risk get and the higher the incentives, the greater the incentives are to break that. So, um, you know, I, um, fortunately, you know, uh, I've gotten good at identifying top signals. So I, I didn't lose my entire, you know, uh, terror investment. I sold a good chunk when, when Mike Novigraz got his tattoo, because I thought that was a top signal. But that was also a few months ago. Talk about that tattoo.
That was also a few months before, before, before, you know, Dokwan got, you know, really started to go off the rails, probably. So, you know, I kind of dodged a bolt there. Well, let me ask you another question about our crypto mining, a missing feature is a privacy. But, um, do you think we're going to get that? I know you've long been a supporter of the Zcash project. Um, but also, I mean, I feel like if there's one battle that feels somewhat unwinnable in the US, it's just like privacy. And we've got tornado cash, smart contracts being, being sanctioned. Do you think we can get privacy on our crypto monies, either at a, you know, crypto native store of value, like ethos, some sort of set of smart contracts, a layer two, something to give us private transactions?
I think, um, I think that what Zuko and the kind of whole Zcash team did, um, in terms of advancing, like that whole field of cryptography, um, is I think it's been credible. And I think it's going to be, you know, it'll be a notable achievement for a long time. The original sin of Zcash was restarting from the same issue and schedule that Bitcoin did, which I don't think could be repeated, right? Bitcoin was kind of a miraculous bootstrapping mechanism because it was first. Um, and, and with Zcash, you had this instance where from the second day launched, it was a straight shot down, right? So you could never, you could never build excitement out of the early, you know, base, you could never, um, you know, really get people fully bought in and, and kind of fully endorsing or kind of, you know, promoting this technology.
And then you also had all of the headwinds, um, from, uh, from the regulatory state. But even today, if you look at Monero versus Zcash, you know, Monero is, is almost in order of magnitude bigger now. And part of that, um, might be because, uh, of the issue and schedule and kind of the way that they brought out the token of market, but I think another big element is maybe ZK tech, um, I would argue, it probably is, um, but one of if not kind of the best privacy preserving tech that we have, um, but it's better instantiated at the, um, uh, the application layer, uh, for these networks and it is at the base layer for two reasons.
One, not everything needs the same level of privacy. And so if you, you know, privatize the entire chain and you basically render, um, all blockchain analytics obsolete, you have, um, you have bigger problems, even than, um, MLK YC, right? You know, with, with Zcash, if everything was private by default and shield of transactions, it also, its scale would have been very difficult to, um, audit the supply long term, right? Um, and, and, you know, that creates, I think some, some rest that, that, you know, financial regulators, worldwide just, you know, would, would never allow for, um, but, um, I think the other, uh, element is the, the flexibility that you get from having like quasi-public, quasi-private, and like the spectrum of, of privacy, um, is probably going to be better for, for almost all users, right?
Because you, because think about, think about the case of like an audit, right? Yeah. If you're a big bank, you can't just, you can't showcase, um, uh, or, or kind of tip your hand as to what you're doing with customer funds on chain, right? Because someone like chain analysis could come in and they could review the wallet addresses and they could say, okay, this is JP Morgan and they have this customer said and, and this company just reported earnings and so like, maybe this address or like this, this on chain movement is due to like, you know, this particular transaction, whatever, um, you just can't have that.
So, um, I think the kind of hybrid privacy model is, is probably something that is, is going to work, you know, better at scale and, and, um, the paper that's, uh, Vitalik, uh, I mean, Solomani, someone from chain analysis, a couple of, uh, other academics, you know, came out with earlier this year, privacy pools is kind of this, you know, I say bridge model that, that might work. Um, do you think the regulators go for that though, Ryan? That, that's actually my bigger worry. I'm with you that privacy needs to be an app. Well, I think it's, yeah, I think it's going to be a fight no matter what.
I don't think they want crypto to exist. At least not this administration, right? This, this financial administration doesn't want crypto to exist. So, um, we were talked about that with, with, was with Warren. I think, um, you know, if, if, yeah, depending on what happens in the election next year, you know, the US, just any administration, right? Like, just the financial surveillance, uh, no fact, you know, North Korea hacking billions of, of, you know, like in DeFi, I'm worried that neither, um, side of the spectrum actually wants crypto to be private. Well, we know one doesn't, um, we have our work cut out with the other, uh, the French and, and, and I think, you know, the one thing I will say is, um, uh, there are kind of two camps on both sides, right?
It, it's kind of weird when, when you think about privacy and, um, um, and civil liberties, the old wing of the Democratic Party and like, the old school progressives, like Ron Wyden, have much more in common with the new, uh, quote unquote conservatives, the more libertarian conservatives, um, that, uh, you know, are, are kind of pounding the table on, on civil liberties and, and like, you know, uh, the bank secrecy act as an overreach or, you know, but whatever, whatever the case may be, right? Just trying to rein in like the, the surveillance, you know, powers the state. Um, um, you know, Ron Wyden fought for crypto in the 90s, um, in terms of like crypto being encryption, right?
And, and now I think you're sure no crypto wire is on the right. And then if you, if you kind of run it in reverse, right? Like the, the Dick Cheney, um, uh, you know, Patriot Act school, uh, of the Republican wing and all the Neocons, um, you know, now they're getting lambat, lamb acid in, um, in presidential debates, right? As like, you know, Dick Cheney is a slur in Republican debates now. Um, and, uh, and, and I think that Neocon, you know, uh, establishment is, is essentially dead. I mean, I, I think that, um, they're right now, probably 70% of the demand for, uh, or, or maybe even close to 75%.
Um, and the Republican party, if you just look at kind of leading candidates, you know, it's, it's for, I'd say like anti-Neocons, right? Um, so kind of this, this new, more libertarian strand, uh, the Republican party. So it's kind of like freaky, um, uh, yo-yo of the two parties and kind of where they stand, uh, from, uh, you know, at least that form of progressive, uh, progressiveism or, or kind of libertarianism, uh, civil liberties, uh, in particular. So, um, yes, there are some, uh, old school, like classical liberals that are on the right side of this, but, uh, playing the percentages, it's, it's very skewed in one direction.
All right. So we can, you know that, everybody knows that. We got some fights ahead. So, so let's, let's maybe talk about the, the, the last piece of this, which is, um, policy. So your, your, your takes on, uh, policy and, uh, you've got an entire section. I think it's like a 30 pages or so about policy trends for 2024. And I want to, you know, zoom out and get the context because we're not going to be able to cover all of this, but, uh, you say this, I wrote this chapter for people who want unfiltered perspective, but what it will take for crypto to win in the US, uh, that, that's really what I want to hear.
An unfiltered perspective on what it will take for crypto to win in the US. I know you're based in the US. You know, bankless is also David and myself are based in the US. You know, bankless is, is also worldwide. And you've made the case very strongly, which I, which I agree on, uh, which is like, we have to fight it here, right? Because if the US falls, uh, and does not protect, protect, uh, crypto liberties, then where do we go? Right? Do we? I mean, Europe may follow suit. We, we have Mika, which you can weigh in on. Anyway, let's get to this. What do you think? Give me, give bankless listeners the unfiltered take on what it will take for, um, crypto to win in the US going into 2024 and beyond.
I'll start with an interesting disclaimer, which is I'm probably not going to talk much about politics next year. I gave myself like a one year. I know people don't really believe me, about this, but, um, I wanted to give myself a year buffer between the election and, um, uh, and, and my political discourse because I just, I think it's going to be, I think it's, it's a losing battle. Um, I won't give you that maybe overbears, I'll give you the, the, the full anecdote, but literally there was one conversation in particular that happens, uh, like a week on either side of the, um, of the one year mark before the November 5th election.
And the change in attitude between this person, like a week before and a week after, in terms of, like, some of my rhetoric was, um, was, was, was like hilarious. And I was like, this is just kind of confirmed that, like, this is way too spicy to be involved with, um, as a, a sitting CEO in an election year, right? Like, I'm not full-time politician. And, um, and, and so, you know, some of the things that I'm saying, I think about, you know, more through like an analyst lens, um, and as someone who just kind of knows what we're going to need to do to win, for the industry, even if it's, you know, politically unpopular, because it is, it does skew in one direction, uh, pretty, pretty decisively.
Um, so that's one disclaimer. I'd say, um, the, we already talked about, um, Elizabeth Warren at length. And I think that's, that's kind of the, the thrust of where we should maybe, uh, dovetail the conversation, because this is actually a good segue from, from the previous point. And this is a criticism that I hear sometimes, it's like, well, you know, if Trump is the Republican nominee, the Trump administration was no friend of crypto, right? Steve Mnuchin tried to ban. That's what I think of specifically. It was, it was like January 2020, wasn't it? And he, that was one of his last acts, right?
I almost got there. And, and, and, and there's some truth to that. And it's one of the reasons that, um, uh, again, personnel is policy. And the, the, the reason that Elizabeth Warren is so effective is the same reason that we can actually make pretty significant strides as an industry, um, on both sides, but particularly on the Republican side right now, and making sure that, um, some of the voices that are elevated have like a strong libertarian or kind of civil liberties focus, bind their, their personal platforms, their, their personal ethics, because those will ultimately be the people that are selected for another administration.
If it is Trump and, um, we get the same kind of Goldman Sachs, you know, uh, bankers that, that we had, you know, in the last administration and the last however many administrations, um, that just don't like this industry, you know, we get another Mnuchin or, you know, basically maybe he comes back, right? For instance, then yeah, we don't, we're not really marginally improved, um, or maybe we are marginally improved, but only marginally improved. There's nothing that's like really different about the, um, you know, whether it's the Biden administration or the, um, or the Trump administration, depending on who the personnel are.
So, um, you know, for instance, I've been very supportive of Vivek Ramaswami, um, as, you know, you probably know, and, um, he has a small path, um, to actually getting the nomination, who knows what happens in 2024, um, but just looking at the polls, it's a very narrow path. If Trump is out of the equation, he has a much greater pet, you know, potential path, but, um, if, uh, if Trump, you know, is in the conversation, he's probably going to the nominee and you want as many people like Vivek, um, in that inner circle and in a position of influence as, as we can possibly have, because the administration is just that it is a large group of people with one person at the home, but it matters who's in the room.
And, um, we didn't have that with, with Steve Mnuchin. So I think this proxy game is really important and we can actually learn from Elizabeth Warren in that regard. Um, so I won't spend too much time going on the, you know, with what I, I don't want our, our options to be, um, what they are, uh, for the presidency, you know, I don't get to pick. Um, the important battle that must be won is in the Senate. Um, there is no future for crypto in the U.S. if the Democrats hold the Senate. Really? Um, uh, at least not until 2030. So, um, the good news is that the electoral map, or 2029, effectively, right?
When, you know, um, when, when there would be, you know, another administration that's warranted. And that's because, um, Elizabeth Warren and Sheriff Brown, who's the chair of Senate banking, will remain, um, blockers on anything productive and essentially let any financial regulator kind of run roughshod, uh, over the industry in perpetuity, um, if, if they're in the oversight chair, um, and, and in that position of influence. So, um, if you have a changing control in the Senate, um, and it goes from, you know, 5149 in favor of the Democrats to 5149 in the other direction, which is really only going to require one net seat since, um, West Virginia's Joe Manchin, uh, has decided he's not going to run for reelection.
Um, that's the difference between, you know, who has the final say on financial regulators. Um, and so if it is a Biden reelection, then the, the radicals will just get kicked back outright, right? Someone like Gary Gensel will never make it through again. Um, and, uh, if it's a Trump administration, you're going to have, um, more of like the Hester purse camp, uh, or someone like, you know, Christian Carlow or Brian Brooks, who's served in the last administration, uh, that, that said in some of these positions, uh, a authority. And that is a very material difference for, for our prospects as an industry.
The Senate matters. And obviously, you presidential matters, um, does, does Congress? I would say this, I'd say the Senate is the most important, right? So, you know, we can, we can survive, um, arguably, um, I, I've strong feelings on this personally, but, you know, we're not going to have an impact on the presidential election. Um, uh, but I do think that we can survive, uh, another, uh, by administration, if, um, if the Republicans have the Senate and, um, and we have our ducks in a row, when it comes to who are some of these, you know, nominees for the financial administrators? Um, but I think if it's a clean sweep for the, the, the Dems, then, um, uh, you know, move your family.
Wow. Really? Move your family? Like seriously, like, tell me about that. How much if, if this is a pure, well, I mean, anti-corrected Senate, or, or, or pick another industry, right? I mean, I'm, I'm not going to be doing crypto in the US if it's a clean sweep from the, from the Democrats. You see, like, why? What do you think happens? Like, I, I, I think it's important. I mean, you know, well, you just need to open your eyes, Ben. I mean, like, we're all seeing what's happening. I mean, this, this, this, this hostility is not going to end, um, from, uh, from this party under his current leadership.
I mean, you know, they've, they've, they look at their hands. I mean, it's, it's really bad now. But like, I, is there a world where I mean, ban D5 frontends and, you know, I would say I would say it doesn't, I think that's the wrong framing, right? Well, what it would be worse is no light at the end of the tunnel. Hmm. Um, and I just, I think that everybody will come to this conclusion naturally, um, when it gets to that point, um, if, if it gets to that point, that the US is just not, uh, for crypto business. And, and you already see this, you know, writ large, every entrepreneur that's starting a new project, you know, encourage them, but they're going to touch anything related to crypto protocols and you have the ability to do it offshore.
You do it offshore. Um, don't do it in the US. You're seeing this with all of the major, um, crypto companies, um, kind of hedging their bets expanding to Europe, expanding to Dubai, expanding to Singapore. Um, and, um, you know, this is, this is the, the, the worst kept secret, you know, with, within the industry in the US, um, people are saying it privately now out loud, but, um, but, you know, I've, I've been saying it publicly since kind of mid 2021. I mean, we're going to need some, some political changes in order to, you know, just have a workable framework, um, within the, within the US.
So basically, if, if the Democrats win the Senate and Democrats win, uh, the presidential, you basically feel like it's lights out for, for crypto in the US for the next four years, at least for the industry. Because because that, I don't, I don't, I don't see a, I don't see a scenario where, um, the, you know, democratic party keeps the Senate and shared Brown is not still the chair of the Senate banking committee. And Elizabeth Warren is not still in the cat bird seat in terms of influence when it comes to crypto policy in the Senate banking, which are the oversight. We do have any defense in that other branch of government, which is the court system.
I mean, we've won a few things lately. Yeah, it, but it'll, it'll take years. I mean, that's the Hail Mary, right? But, uh, you know, at that point, um, again, if it's a clean sweep in one direction, uh, you know, these justices don't live forever either. So, um, the, the window of time where, uh, there is a majority on the bench, though, would be sympathetic to, you know, crypto as an industry and, and, you know, at least leaning in that direction to, to check the power of the administrative state, um, you know, that's, that's not permanent either. If you extend that out another, you know, five years, we're just as likely to get, uh, an unfavorable court ruling from on high as, uh, as a, as a fair, I didn't know your takes were, um, you know, like this, uh, this ride, I guess you promised Ron unfiltered, but basically, like, this is existential for like the 2024 election, it's kind of existential.
I know, I know this is, I know this is going to, you know, this will probably rub some people the wrong way and, and, you know, maybe we'll even hear some policy folks kind of chirp, but just trust me, if, if you hear anyone chirp, it's k-fabe, that's a word. Um, you know, this, this, you know, this is, this is more or less known, and I'm looking at this, just, um, as an analyst, no bullshit. Yeah. What the state of, of, of affairs, uh, actually looks like, and at some point, you need to take people to the word. I mean, Elizabeth Warren, when she, when she's raising money, I believe for now, um, to raise and to, to, to, you know, recruit an anti-crypto army, and every single story that you hear, um, from, uh, you know, kind of leaders, you know, on that side of the aisle, you know, in the Senate, and basically in the positions of, of kind of greatest authority, um, it's all tying us to North Korea and money launders and tax evasion and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
Like, it's just a really scary accusation. Honestly, Ryan was when she got, um, Jamie Diamond, uh, saying the exact same thing in front of Congress last week, basically, just saying, yeah, it's criminals. And, and, um, uh, you know, I, I saw all the means about, you know, uh, JP Morgan and, and Jamie Diamond. I mean, I didn't really think too much of it. I thought the best interpretation was, you know, if you're Jamie Diamond, you've got the in-house team that's working on, you know, permissionless blockchains and, you know, if it's, uh, a democratic runs, and I know, I know, I know, I know white house, then, you know, if you're saying the right thing, you're not going to get a nasty gram from Elizabeth Warren.
And if it goes the other direction, yeah, there's still going to be the net beneficiary because, you know, the role playing both sides, classic. The role is JP Morgan always wins. Okay. Well, let's, let's not leave folks here, though. That's his responsibility as, as kind of see how that comes to. Let's not leave folks here. So what, what's on the flip side? Let's say, uh, crypto wins, some, you know, crypto friendly, uh, politicians in, in the Senate and also, you know, like, presidential, what do you think is there, uh, rosier picture here for the next four years? Look, I just, I want to be very explicit about this and just reiterate, like, there are some very, uh, excellent leaders in DC.
They tend to be 20-year younger, um, that understand the tech, that understands, you know, the potential for this, um, technology, you know, across the board in terms of financial inclusion, in terms of, um, uh, you know, economic development. And these leaders span the aisles that you would say. Yes. Uh, Jill Brandt, uh, Ron Wyden, uh, on the, on the Senate side, you know, Richie Torres, Rokana, like, there, there's a number of folks, right, uh, in, in the house. So this is not a universal truth, but the reality is the folks that are in the most important seats on that side of the aisle, the senior most kind of committee leaders and the people are ultimately going to be blockers on, on policy.
Like, that's what's at stake, right? It's not whether they're good individuals on either side, but this is just kind of the dynamics that, you know, and power sharkism play. Anyway, that's my final disclaimer there. I feel like I've, I've had like six disclaimers. I'm still going to get a little, uh, this segment. So, um, but, um, I think the, um, um, on the, in, in the kind of long arc of history, uh, time as our friend, crypto remains inevitable as a technology. And it's just a matter of where it blossoms first, right? And, and, and where kind of, you know, firmly takes root. And I think the economics, uh, the incentive structures of, of crypto, um, incentivize competition in much the same way that, um, start-up certain incentivize to disrupt the incumbents.
So it would not surprise me. And in fact, it's probably the expected outcome that, um, a technology like crypto is going to be fully formed, and, um, and brought to, you know, mass adoption by an economy not named the US, um, for this whole reason that's, uh, the US currently has the reserve currency, the dominant financial system, and the world largest military innovators. So I'm a type stuff. And so we, we've got an innovator to limit that record, right? So, um, that would not surprise me. But, um, I, uh, you know, I've got my family here, and I, I, I like it here. And, you know, um, what's that line from off the space?
Like, uh, why should I change my mind? Why should I move? Like, like, why should, why should I move? Like, they're the one to suck. And, and, and, you know, they just won't refuse to step aside, even though like so many of these folks are, you know, closer to, um, uh, uh, closer to the end of the line than, uh, than, than crypto is, that's for sure. But, um, I think, um, compounding, uh, just if you zoom back, like zoom out a little bit and you just look at everything that's been developed, you know, crypto Bitcoin didn't exist 15 years ago. Um, Ethereum didn't exist until 10 years ago, uh, even as a concept, right?
Didn't launch until, you know, nine years ago, Solana was born five, six years ago as a concept. DeFi really didn't blow up until the summer of 2020. Uh, NFTs a year later, just, you just go through the list, man. And, and it's just, um, one development after the other. Yes, are these type cycles. Yes, they're these big crashes. Yes, there's a ton of headwinds, um, from some very powerful people that don't like us right now. But eventually growth almost always wins out. And you can be in a stick in the mud for as long as you want to, uh, be, you're, you're either going to come along for the ride or you're going to get left behind.
Um, and I, I think whether that happens to the US or internationally, maybe it starts to happen internationally. Um, and then that'll like Churchill saying, uh, it comes through, like you can always count on the US, do the, um, the right thing when all other options have been exhausted. Yeah. Um, yeah, maybe that's, maybe that's our, our saving grace, um, in terms of, you know, how, how crypto, you know, comes to proliferate in the US. But I think there's multiple paths to get there. One, um, I didn't say it's over forever. I just said until 20, 20, 29, or, or so, depending on the outcome of this election.
But that's not a permanent condition either way, because this technology's not getting unadvented. There you go. Uh, what a great way to end it. Maybe, maybe we'll wrap here, but Ryan, I just want to ask you a personal question. So, uh, what's still exciting to you about crypto? I've, I've seen you tweet before, like, you still love this industry. I'm assuming you still do. What's, uh, I'm excited. Why are you still here, man? I'm, I am, I am literally excited about everything. So just, you know, I'll end on another positive note. I mean, I think, um, I think it's going to be costly and, and really intense battle next year.
But, um, I have never been more confident that, you know, we're going to move the needle politically. Um, and, uh, so I'd encourage people to, you know, check out the, the resources that I link to in the, um, in the Theses, I think the three to watch, uh, are going based to stand with crypto, uh, movement. Um, the blockchain association, Kristen, you know, has done a great job, uh, uniting the worrying tribes and, and the blockchain association summit, uh, just had a, who's who of speakers, um, a couple of weeks ago. Um, and then Mike Carcase from Fair Shake, uh, who's, uh, who's running a super pack.
Uh, I think he's going to, uh, I think he's going to raise some eyebrows in the new year. So, um, so I think there's room to be, uh, optimistic and, uh, and I certainly am, and I'm probably most excited. The, the thing I'm most excited about, Ryan, is I wrote the policy section first, knowing that I'm, my work here is done. And now I'm going to spend, I'm going to spend 2024 being a political degenerate and playing and playing with all the toys, have fun. And, um, and, and, and literally just dog fooding and, and power using our product as a, uh, as an investor and, uh, showcasing all the fun.
Yeah, what, what a great, I mean, and it's speaking of the long arc of history, 13 years from magic internet money from zero all the way to, uh, an ETF. And, uh, I believe we'll get that in 2024. So crypto has come a long way. It's, we got a ways to go, but we've come, uh, such a way. Ryan, thank you so much for putting out these thesis. Uh, it's been a pleasure talking to you about this. Likewise. Thanks Ryan. Bagel station, uh, action item. We've got, uh, Brian's report right in the show notes. So go check that out. Read all of the pages. They are fantastic. Got to end with this. None of this has been financial advice.
Certainly not political advice. Uh, crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. It's the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bank. This journey. Thanks a lot.