Ryan, David, Tim Beiko, Justin Drake, and Anthony Sassano unpack everything you need to know about today’s, highly anticipated Shanghai-Capella: ETH Staking Withdrawals.
Also, the five cover ETH staking mechanics, withdraw upgrade FUD myths, what’s next for Ethereum, and Justin’s prediction around, staking airdrops?!...
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/kraken
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
👻 PHANTOM | FRIENDLY MULTICHAIN WALLET https://bankless.cc/phantom-waitlist
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
------ Topics Covered
0:00 Intro 8:20 Shanghai-Capella Explained 10:09 ETH Staking Mechanics 14:33 Deposit Queue 18:10 Why Shanghai-Capella 21:04 Importance of Shanghai-Capella 24:52 Validators & Finality 28:12 Sassal’s Thoughts on Shanghai-Capella 32:26 Major Derisk Event? 34:30 Demystifying Withdraw Upgrade FUD 42:35 Where Will Ether Accrue? 46:20 Benefits of Competition for ETH Stakers 48:55 Bear Case for ETH Price 55:35 Solo-Staking 1:01:30 Making Solo-Staking Easier 1:04:30 Re-Keying 1:06:00 What is Next for Ethereum? 1:09:48 Anthony Sassano’s Tinkering Setup 1:15:50 Staking Airdrops?! 1:19:00 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Tim Beiko https://twitter.com/TimBeiko
Justin Drake https://twitter.com/drakefjustin
Anthony Sassano https://twitter.com/sassal0x
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
You know, you don't have to pay any fees when you're solo staking, so already that puts you above the rest from a rational standpoint, but the other thing I want to highlight is that my prediction is that there is going to be special adrops specifically for solo validators. Bankless Nation, it is a special day. Today we are hard forking. Eat staking withdrawals is enabled. David, what is going on? Who do we have on? Yeah, the Shanghai now called Chappellea upgrade coming to Ethereum coming to a blockchain near you. The long awaited withdrawals hard fork that allows stakers to withdraw ether. We hard forked into proof of stake a while ago, created the beacon chain, did the merge, but in an abundance of caution, we left out this one ability called withdrawals just to not over complicate things.
It's really the only reason why we didn't include withdrawals in this original merge was to not to make the merge as least complicated as possible. So fast forward to where we are now, we are now enabling withdrawals. And so this has caused a bunch of conversations around the crypto sphere. Is this bearish? Is the ETH price going to dump? Is it actually this bullish? And more people are going to stake as a result of this. What happens to LIDA? What happens to a rocket pool? What happens to the insane supply of ether that is in Coinbase? There is a lot of second order consequences as a result of this merge.
There are 18 million ether that is locked up in the beacon chain and that becomes to be unlocked later today. I believe at nine p.m. No, six p.m. Eastern time, six thirty p.m. And so this episode is going live a few hours earlier than that. And this is just a conversation with three guests from around the Ethereum ecosystem. We got Anthony, Susano, Ethereum community member and content producer, also solar staker and solo staker tinkerer. He gives his perspectives as what his role is in the Ethereum ecosystem as a result of being a solo staker and what he's doing and the four different boxes that he runs to solo staker.
So he's got Anthony. We got Anthony. We also got Justin Drake and we all know Justin Drake, EF researcher and ether economic thought leader. And then we also got Tim Beko as well who leaves the all core devs calls. So three diverse perspectives to all give their takes about this Shanghai Shopella upgrade. Yeah. And if we're talking about upgrades, we're also talking about staking. We're talking about staking reward. And you know what that means, David. Coming in minutes. We're talking about taxes. That's why. Oh my god. Here we go. You receive rewards and you get taxed on those rewards. And if you are sweating bullets right now because it's almost mid-April and you have not filed your taxes.
And you're looking at this tangled mess of transactions across a whole bunch of different wallets and blockchains and defi and NFT. And you don't know what to do. We got the easy button solution. It's called crypto tax calculator. These are our friends and sponsors. And because you are a bankless listener, they have reserved 30% off with the coupon code called bank 30. And you can get on this and you can allow crypto tax calculators sort out your tax situation. David, I use this tool. I've started using it this year. I've abandoned my previous tax software because this is just so awesome. Oh my god.
What are we looking at right now? We had this meme made and so everyone knows that I'm super resistant to taxes. And so I had this doing taxes. This is why I pay other people to do my taxes for me. But this is why crypto tax calculator is such a great tool. And so I made this meme. I'm not going to explain it for the audience. I will explain it. If you are on the podcast listener, it's a picture of David crying. You may have seen this before. And then David happy with some like Wojac massaging his back. This is the product of crypto tax calculator. And that's so happy. David, all we had to do is show this.
I didn't even need to say anything. Anyway, get that discount guys. It's bank 30. And you could find that at crypto tax calculator.io or link in the show notes. Also, if you are a bankless nation citizen, there is a code, a secret code for 40% off 10 more percent inside the bankless nation discord. You're a trader that pays for itself in the first month. Easy man. Okay, guys, we're going to get right into the episode. Maybe a few last thoughts here as we get in. So we're going through the what's happening. Why is it a big deal? Why it's called what it's called the effect on price liquid staking.
And what's next for Ethereum? So this is a really interesting episode. We hope you stay tuned for it. We'll be right back with Tim and Justin and Anthony. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Crackin has been a leader in the crypto industry for the last 12 years dedicated to accelerating the global adoption of crypto. Crackin puts an emphasis on security, transparency and client support, which is why over nine million clients have come to love Crackin's products. Whether you're a beginner or a pro, the Crackin UX is simple, intuitive and frictionless, making the Crackin app a great place for all to get involved and learn about crypto.
For those with experience, the redesigned Crackin Pro app and web experience is completely customizable to your trading needs, integrating key trading features into one seamless interface. Crackin has a 24-7 365 client support team that is globally recognized. Crackin support is available wherever whenever you need them by phone, chat or email. And for all of you NFTers out there, the brand new Crackin NFT beta platform gives you the best NFT trading experience possible, rarity rankings, no gas fees and the ability to buy an NFT straight with cash. Does your crypto exchange prioritize its customers the way that Crackin does?
And if not, sign up with Crackin at Crackin.com slash bankless. Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web 3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1 producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With a recent addition of Arbitram Nova, gaming and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitram home. Both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. On Arbitram, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees.
With Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit Arbitram.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app. With Arbitram, experience Web 3 development the way it was meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction free. Learning about crypto is hard. Until now, introducing Metamask Learn, an open educational platform about crypto, Web 3, self-custody, wallet management, and all the other topics needed to onboard people into this crazy world of crypto. Metamask Learn is an interactive platform with each lesson offering a simulation for the task at hand, giving you actual practical experience for navigating Web 3.
The purpose of Metamask Learn is to teach people the basics of self-custody and wallet security in a safe environment, and while Metamask Learn always takes the time to define Web 3 specific vocabulary, it is still a jargon-free experience for the crypto curious user. Friendly, not scary. Metamask Learn is available in 10 languages with more to be added soon, and it's meant to cater to a global Web 3 audience. So, are you tired of having to explain crypto concepts to your friends? Go to learn.metamask.io and add Metamask Learn to your guides to get onboarded into the world of Web 3. Bangladesh Nation, we are here with Tim Beko, protocol support of the Ethereum Foundation.
He leads the All Core Devs Call, which is the only true source of hard fork dates. Tim, welcome to the show. Thanks for having me. Also, we've got Justin Drake, another researcher at the Ethereum Foundation, lead of the ultrasound.money website, project, and also meme. Justin, welcome back. Thanks for having me, too. And last but not least, Anthony Susano, Ethereum community member, also content producer, solo staker, and solo staker, Tinkerver. We will get into what that means towards the end of the show. Anthony, welcome back. Thanks for having me on, guys. So, guys, it is a big day in Ethereum history.
I think this will be the last hard fork that is relevant to the proof of stake project. But since Tim, you are the herder of cats as relates to what it takes to make a hard fork come to be. I'm wondering if we could start with you and just kind of give us the high level details for people who need to catch up to what Shepella is from the protocol perspective. What is the Shepella hard fork and what does it do for Ethereum and why is it significant? Of course, yeah. So the most obvious thing that Shepella brains is the introductions of withdrawals on the beacon chain. So I assume anyone just need to bank this, those this.
But today, if you launch a validator on the beacon chain, you're basically depositing your funds into a smart contract, which gets read by the beacon chain, activates your validator there, credits your fund, your fund on the beacon chain. You can earn rewards and penalties depending on if you do good or bad job. But then there's no way to actually get your funds back out on the execution layer to either, you know, sell your eats, use it in DeFi, anything like that. And since the merge values have been able to receive transaction fees, so when they produce a lock the transaction fees they get are not allowed to be in chain, you know, this gets sent to any eth address.
So the main thing we're introducing with Shepella, the subgrade that's activating today, is kind of closing the loop and allowing validators the ability to withdraw their stake. And again, you know, for your listeners, some of those validators have been have locked their stakes since 2020. So it's been it's been a while. And so yeah, after this upgrade, they'll be able to withdraw it. There's a couple other small changes that we're introducing as well, but this is really kind of the big one. So within hours, as soon as that hard fork happens to him, those listening who have staked eth will be able for the first time to withdraw that staked eth.
Is that correct? And is there some sort of queuing mechanism as well? Let's say there's a there's a run on the the eth staking run on the protocol. Yeah. Yeah. Does that put us into trouble? Like what, you know, tell us the mechanics of how this might work. Okay. Yeah. So um, and there's many, many different ways to break this down. So please bear with me. So there's two types of withdrawals you can think about. So there's full and partial withdrawals. And the way that they work is that every block basically validators scan over a devaluedator who's producing a block, scans over the validator set and tries to find the first 16 validators for whom they can do either a full or a partial withdrawal.
And they they process those they add them into the block. And then the next solidator, you know, picks up or the last one left left off scans a chain tries to find the next 16 packs them into a block and so on. So if you're a staker and you don't want to stop staking, those partial withdrawals will basically happen automatically as long as you set eth eth addresses of a draw credential. And if you've been a validator for a long time, you might not have done this. It'll be possible to change it after the fork. But this is basically what what happens every block is a validator checks find 16 validators who either are fully exited or have a balance bigger than 32 eat withdraws that back on the execution layer and then moves on.
If you are a validator and you do not want to be a validator anymore, you need to exit before you can get your full withdrawal process. And just like when we have new validators join, we kind of want to to throttle them so that the validator set can't change too quickly. If there's a bunch of validators who want to leave at the same time, we also throttle this process. And the reason for this is is basically security where, you know, you could imagine if we didn't have this on both sides, somebody could either hack a bunch of ease, you know, acquire a bunch of ease, replace the entire validator set or the majority of it, do some bad stuff, exit, and kind of not be penalized.
So because we want to prevent this, we sort of slow down the flow of validators on both ends. And so this means that if you are a validator today and there's a bunch of other validators who want to stop being your validator at the same time as you, you need to send this exit message and then it gets processed basically into order that nodes receive them. And they'll be kind of a delay between when your message was received and when you can fully exit your funds. And during that period though, you still basically earn rewards and penalties, you could still get partial withdrawals processed, but to get like your 32 ease back or potentially less, you know, if you were slasher with not, you need to wait until you've cleared that queue.
And I'm not quite sure, just in probably those exact number that we clear every block. But it's, yeah, it's a constant number per block that actually, well, it's a constant number, it depends on the total stake size. So, but on the order, it's less than 10 per block basically. Yeah, and I am familiar that even with simple updates to Ethereum, there are these like edge cases that get really, really complex, even though simply put Shanghai's with draws. And then there's like a bunch of like rabbit holes and things to pull apart. But let me summarize what I think you just said, Tim, there's this bottleneck called the withdrawal or deposit queue.
And that bottleneck is the same on both sides. So it's equivalent. And all that really does like imagine just like water sloshing back and forth between two buckets. And there's like a pipe between these two things. And one is steak teeth on the on the beacon chain and the rest is ether everywhere else in the world. And there is a pipe between these two things that constraints how fast ether can move in either direction. And it's the equivalent size. And the reason why we have that constraint is that we're talking about the security of the Ethereum protocol. We don't want things to move too quickly.
We don't want to go from 18 million ether to 2 million etherstakes to 25 million etherstakes really, really quickly. So we put in this constraint that we call the deposit and withdrawal queue. And that just helps things settle and the foundation of Ethereum to not turn too quickly. Yet it still is sufficiently large enough that if you want to withdraw, you are going to be able to get your ether within a pretty reasonable amount of time. Tim, I don't know if you guys have done any like simulations, but like what's the longest somebody would expect to wait after pressing the withdrawal button before getting their ether in the normal circumstances like non-FTXE type weird stuff.
I know this is almost an impossible scenario to ask you about, but just like can you kind of put a time box on this thing? So honestly, I don't spend my time doing simulations like this, maybe Justin does. Yeah, but I think you see what the deposit queue, it's mostly empty most of the time. You know, sometimes there's like a couple of hours, maybe a couple of days, but it's like rare that you get these massive spikes. That said, you didn't get like, you know, a pretty big initial set of people wanting to be validators like at the launch of Ethereum, at the merge and whatnot. So I wouldn't be surprised like obviously this is the first time we're going to have withdrawals.
There's probably a whole set of people who want to or have to like exit their validators. So you know, we'll see some churn. And I suspect we'll probably see some churn on both sides. Like we'll probably see some people who didn't want to like stake their eth until withdrawals were alive and now can. But once we've processed that initial chunk, like I you know, I don't see why there would be like a huge exit queue on a day-to-day basis, except in cases when like yeah, there's a massive amount of the stake that that has to exit. And whether this is you know like the crack in thing that happened or something like that where they represent like an entrepreneurial part and they all have to exit at once.
Then obviously you'd have a delay. Similarly, if you know there's a new cool liquid-staking pool that shows up and people want to stake with that and they launch a bunch of new validators that don't have a delay in getting them activated. And one thing sorry one last thing I'll add is for most people who just want to stay a validator, the scan happens. I think it's every four or five days that you get your rewards after this. So even imagine you know you you haven't set your ETH with your all address yet. You set it tomorrow and like you sort of miss the first scan. You'll get it like five days later.
So I think on the pretty average validator who's just getting their partial rewards, it'll be a pretty regular process. And there's no, there's nothing that would like extend the duration of that scan significant to be except the number of validators. So if we double the number of validators and you know, look over four or five days to like eight or ten, but that's that's what how it's bounded. Yeah, well, and Justin, I'm wondering if you can comment on the economics of these things. I think the last time I remember it was around 1800 validators per day that can fit through that pipe of withdrawals or deposits.
I don't know if that's the right number. Is that right? That sounds a bit too high. I think it's in ETH the terms it's about 50,000 or 60,000 ETH per day. Not just to give you an order of magnitude. Since proof of stake happens, we've had on average 20,000 ETH per day. So the activation is a queue is definitely not not full. Cool. So 50,000 ETH per day times $9,900 basically round up to a hundred million dollars at the current ETH price can flow between the beacon chain and the withdrawals. And the withdrawals is what's being unlocked today. And so today, for the first time, at maximum, $100 million of value can go from the beacon chain back into the rest of the world.
And that is the thing we're celebrating. But up the, uh, I didn't know bank test denominated in USD. A significant portion of our listeners do. And so we're doing the big computational work on their behalf. Okay. So where do you guys want to go next? Justin, I know that this is the proof of stake world is, and the ETH is, is, is something that you pay attention, a lot of attention to. So when, when we see the Shanghai, the now called, uh, Shepella upgrade, like why, why is this so significant to you? Like when you, when you, this upgrade, like, I think everyone kind of sees something different in it.
A lot of people want to talk about liquid staking derivatives. A lot of people want to talk about ETH or cell pressure. Uh, when you look at the Shepella upgrade, what do you see? And guys, but as we get into that, Justin, can some of just, I feel like I went on vacation and it was called Shanghai. I came back and now it's called Shepella. I wasn't ready for that. What's with the name change? How did, how did this come about? Okay. I feel, I feel strongly about this. So, um, okay. So Ethereum has like this execution layer, this consensus layer, you know, before the merge, we were all doing your own thing.
Uh, obviously the networks communicated, but in terms of the network upgrades themselves, they were pretty independent. So, you know, we have London with 1559. Uh, and then on the, on the beacon chain, they had Altair, which was their first fork. Um, and then we have the merge and we sort of had to specify like the set of changes on both sides of the chain, right? Like there's some stuff that happens on the beacon chain, some stuff that happened on a proof of work chain then. Um, and so those upgrades actually had separate names as well. So, like the set of changes on the proof of work chain was called Paris and, uh, on the, on the proof state chain, it was called the Latrix.
We were lucky that we could just call it the merge and move on with their, with our day. Um, but knowing that we would be in this situation, we started to think, okay, well, it's like a way we can name these things that people don't have to like follow two different names. Um, so right now, the set of changes is on the consensus there side is called Capella. They use stars to do those changes on the execution layer side. It's called Shanghai because we use the DevCon city names in order. Um, but then most people like don't want to know that like Shanghai and Capella are the two sets of changes.
Um, and so pro-automism have the idea that we should just merge the names together. Uh, it gets us a new name. So Chepelle in this case. Um, and this is kind of neat because if you have a weird funky name, you can know it's like an upgrade on both sides, but then say that like, we just change something on the beacon chain, we can just use a star. If we just change something on the execution layer, we can just use a DevCon city. Um, so we can, you know, we can call this Chepelle because it's like the, the sum of the two upgrades. And then the next one, you know, it'll be cancun and the neb so we can call it dencun and no one has to know about cancun or deneb.
Um, so Chepelle dencun and we'll keep going from there. So every time that we talk about the naming nomenclature of Ethereum upgrades, I just remember that nerds are taking over the world. I thought it was named off the dive. Chepelle. And he's just like, y'all gonna be more of that eighth night, right? It didn't give us portion of the title. That's it. That's it. How are though? Yeah. Okay. Uh, that was a fun detour. Thank you for, for guiding us through that, that one. Uh, Tim, uh, Justin, I'll throw this back to you. Uh, the kaleidoscope that is the Chepelle upgrade. Uh, what do you see in it?
Right. So I guess before we get into that, I just want to do a couple of clarification. The first one is proof of stake. Yes, I agree. It's now functionally complete. And so if we were to leave Ethereum as this for the rest of time, it will be a functioning system. Uh, having said that there's a bunch of security upgrades and improvements that are coming to proof of stake. So we have, for example, secrets, uh, single leader election. We have single slot finality, uh, which reduces the time to finality. We have what's called enshrined PBS. We have VDF and we have maybe a dozen or so security upgrades that will eventually make a firm or three resistant.
Um, and, and the, the second detail that I wanted to, it's really a minor one is differentiating the activation and exit cues versus the deposit and withdrawal cues. So really the, the throttling of the validators is, is at the activation and exit level. Um, the deposit and withdrawal cues are basically there because the beacon chain needs to process all of these things. And it's a bit of a dose vector if they have to process too many deposits or withdrawals at the same time. Now in terms of the, the big picture of why withdrawals is important. Um, I think there's the several aspects. One of them is, is, of course, liquidity.
You know, it's a big de-risking event because so far we've mostly had early adopters come in. And the way that I see it is the big picture is we're going to go from the early majority to the, to the late majority. So we're about halfway through, I'd say. We have 18 million e-stakes and over the next two and a half years what I'm expecting is that to, to, to, to, to, to roughly double. Um, and if you were to, to, to zoom out and look at the, the shape of the, the amount of e-staked over time, it's like surprisingly shockingly linear. Yeah, it's a straight line up. It's a straight line up. And I expect that to, to, to, to continue.
The, the one blip that we're going to have is basically right after the fork, what's going to happen is that both the activation cue and the exit cue should be completely clogged. And the reason is that entities like Kraken and, and, and Celsius and whatnot will be exiting extremely fast. And on the other hand, we're going to have people restaking. So for example, Lido will be setting up automatic deposits to restake. And so these two cues, which a DQ at the exact same rate will mean that the, the amount of e-stake will be staying constant, possibly for a few weeks. But then that's just a blip and then we just continue up only at least.
That's my, that's my prediction. So you think the, the shape of the curve is going to be lit. It's been linear. You think at the moment of the, the hard fork that comes later today in something like nine hours, you think it's going to be flat for a short amount of time, maybe a couple days. And then you think it's going to resume its linear uptrend. So it's not going to go down, importantly. Well, yeah, I think it's going to plateau potentially for a few, few weeks. It is possible that there's a bit of a race condition, basically, who can set up their infrastructure first to make automatic deposits versus Kraken doing the automatic withdrawals?
We've seen today, if you go to rated.network, they have this new dashboard, which shows you withdrawals. And Kraken has already started withdrawing. Now my expectation is that Lido will start the automatic, you know, restaking of, of issuance, beacon issuance, you know, very, very soon. And then once these two process have kicked in, then, you know, we should have, we should have a plateau for, for, for a few days, maybe a few weeks. The, the other thing I was curious about Justin is, so you're anticipating like, kind of like final state being like a doubling of the amount of eith stake right now, which, which, what, what, what is that, what is that put us at?
Like 30 to 40% of the total eith in the network is stake, something like this. And if so, that I believe is a lot less than some other networks, crypto networks, that have had staking for a while, right? So like, look at some other networks and they're, they're closer to like the 60% or 70% range. If that's the case, why do you think eith won't, Ethereum won't get to like higher numbers of, of stake, teeth, you know, closer to 60 to 70% of the supply. Right. So we actually don't want too many validators and that's for a number of reasons. One of them is that we, we don't want to be unnecessarily overpaying for economic security.
So the way that we pay for economic security is with issuance. And if we have enough economic security, we've let's say 30 or 40% of stake, teeth, then, then we don't want to be overpaying unnecessarily diluting ourselves. The other very important thing in my opinion is that we want to have plenty of pristine economic bandwidth. So eith has two macro uses. One is a staking and the other one is there's a collateral asset in the context of, for example, backing decentralized stablecoins. And we want to have plenty of kind of raw pristine eith to be used by applications that want to consume the best in class collateral asset within, within Ethereum.
Now there's also other technical reasons. One is that we already have half a million validators, which is a lot of validators. And we don't want to have too much computational pressure on the beacon nodes. So the, the, the, the clients that have been built so far, you know, prison, lighthouse, et cetera. You know, maybe they can, they can handle million validators, but do we really want them to handle two million validators that may be, you know, pushing things a little far, especially that we want to do this upgrade called single slot finality. And what does single slot finality mean? It means that you get finality within a few seconds.
And in order to get finality, we need every single validator to be making an attestation and to aggregate these attestations. So we're talking about aggregating hundreds of thousands of BLS signatures in just a few seconds. And this is a very challenging technical process. So we actually want to be in a, in a position where we cap the number of validators. And there's various ways to, to, to do that. One of the things, ways we could do it, for example, is by having a issuance curve which goes negative as soon as we get very, very close to the cap that we want to, what, that we want to get to.
Another idea, which is not really a cap, but it's more of a way to slow down the growth and is, it's called MEV burn. It's a study that we do something very, very similar to IP1559 that for, for, for, for base fees, but this time we do it for MEV. And that should give us a little bit of relief and remove the urgency on, on, on, on capping. Beautiful, beautiful. Okay, so a lot of those subjects I know are highly related towards this question that we have at the end, which is what's next for Ethereum Staking? So I think we'll perhaps return to, to some of these subjects later on. But Anthony, I want to turn the same question to you.
Thank you for, for waiting. The kaleidoscope of the Shabella upgrade, there are so many things to talk, talk about. We got liquid-staking derivatives, we got solo-stakers. Well, when you see this upgrade, like, what does it mean to you? Yeah, I, I think I, I agree with like pretty much everything that Tim and Justin have said. And I really resonate with the view that while this is kind of a big milestone for Ethereum Staking, it's not the final stop, so to speak. Like for me personally, I view it as like a 1.0, right? And people are going to kill me for saying something like Staking 2.0, because we don't want to bring up the 2.
0 terminology again. But, but I think there are, as Justin said, like, there are other upgrades coming to proof of stake on Ethereum that are going to harden proof of stake, right? And make it better, make it more secure and all that good stuff. They make it more resilient, which means that proof of stake, you know, in its current form can, can work and can work just fine. That's why you would call it a 1.0, but it is not, you know, as complete as we can make it, so to speak. There are a lot of different things that we can add to it to make it a much better system, which will be added, you know, over time, especially things like as Justin mentioned, single slot finality and the secret leader election and stuff like that.
I actually personally think they're pretty critical that they actually do need to be shipped and stuff like PBS as well. I don't think they're nice to have. I think they're pretty much must have at this point. So yeah, that's why like with the roles being shared, we kind of finished the 1.0 version of staking, but then we move on to all of these other upgrades that could be considered like a 2.0 version of a theorem staking, but like that's my own kind of take on it. I don't suggest adopting that terminology for sake of not confusing everyone even more than we already have. Yeah, the environment does not have a good track record of not doing that.
Yeah, exactly, exactly. But in terms of just the significance of it, I think that the biggest thing for me is showing, well, there's two probably major things. It's showing the, I guess, like ecosystem that Ethereum is still shipping, like at a better pace than it's ever done, right? It's still shipping major upgrades. It's still executing on its roadmap, and that is sending a strong signal to the rest of the ecosystem that Ethereum is evolving, Ethereum is executing, even post the merge, which obviously was the biggest upgrade in Ethereum's history. We haven't really slowed down at all. Even all these things happening for Cancun or Dancun, as Tim mentioned, like ARP4844, they have made amazing progress.
There are devnets, there are things happening, and it's slated hopefully for later in the year, or maybe it depends maybe early next year, but with the pace that the shipping is going right now, it just inspires a lot of confidence. So I think that's a strong signal being sent out. And secondly, just related directly to withdrawals, I think it acts as an absolutely huge de-risking event. And I strongly agree that we're going to see much more east-staked because of that, and we're going to see a much healthier, staking ecosystem because of that as well. Because now, no longer are the LSDs themselves limited by market forces, where essentially the only way that these LSDs could repeg is if the market basically repeged them.
And I know they're not a peg, so to speak, but to make them actually at fair value, you couldn't do that arbitrage with the beacon chain directly. Now you'll be able to do that, which I think even though it may seem something that's kind of simple and gets done every day, and it's not something to be excited about, I think it's absolutely huge because it means that staking with LSDs is going to be much safer, much more efficient, and it's going to mean that these money market protocols are going to film are more comfortable with adding them as collateral, making their collateral factor kind of a higher so that people can use them to borrow more assets against them.
And then it opens up the whole other world of other things that are coming to staking, such as the restaking stuff from eigenlayer, distributive validator technology, like all these other things that can build, build on top and around staking, it makes those things possible and much more exciting. So those are the two major things that I kind of look at. But yeah, there's a lot. I mean, as you said, it is a kaleidoscope, people have their own different views on it, and there's always a lot to talk about when it comes to Ethereum upgrades. I know we're going to talk about price and sort of, you know, whether the amount of staking is going to like to how that's going to impact price and whether staking is going to go up or down Post Merge, because there's been a lot of discussion on this.
I could say for me personally, I see withdrawals as a huge D-risk event. And I have some of my own personal ETHs staked, but I've literally been waiting for this moment for like what we have months of trust in the network, Post Merge, you know, and you know, David's gas on brakes, right? So I'm a bit more risk averse, but I don't know what David you've been doing with your ETH, whether how much you're staking versus not. I've literally been waiting for this event, and maybe for like me to start seeing some withdrawals to start getting more bullish on unstaking my own ETH. And then once it's staked, if you're a long-term holder of ETH, why unstake is kind of the question?
So I know we'll get to kind of the whether this is bullish or bearish for ETH price and how this impacts kind of sentiment, but that's my own personal take. I'm curious, David, like what do you see this event? Yeah, so for the Ethereum archetype person, I think the I think, well, I guess it's almost just by proxy of the fact that the network increasing in total stake, like we're at 18% of all ETHs staked. My percent of personal ETHs staked has has trended upward since the beginning of the beacon chain as well. So I think I'll take some of those a little bit more today. And so like perhaps that's a sentiment that's shared by the entire network, which is why we see it going up into the right.
But like this last event is the final like bridge that needs to be crossed, where like the ETH staking, the idea of ETH staking, which I like pulled out my calculator back in 2018, I was like, all right, I need this much ETH staked and I need the ETH price to be this high, and then I'll have this much income to retire on. There's usually in that there's literally a bankless video about this. And so this is finally the event that allows that to come true. We are not currently at the ETH price that I envision, but we're still only 2023. It's still quite early. Anthony, I want to actually turn back to you because a lot of what you do at the daily way is just to provide accurate and informed information about Ethereum, kind of a fractal off of your activity with ETH up way back when, which is just to fight Ethereum.
And there is plenty of FUD about per usual about this particular hard fork simply because of the nature of what it is. All of the ETH is going to get unstaked and it's going to sell the price down to zero. Ethereum security is going to go to zero. Like what's some of the biggest Twitter FUD that you see out there that you think is totally just like ridiculous. There's certainly some criticisms and critiques and bearishness about the staking the withdrawal upgrade because like simply put, when you add more supply into the market, like there's more people that are able to press the cell button.
So like not I'm not discounting that at all. There are some people who are just like fighting this whole thing left and right. I'm wondering what's like the biggest piece of like Twitter drama that's worth addressing. So some of the most ridiculous tags I've seen around that were from people who don't actually understand how it works at all. Basically they don't understand that there is a queue for staking and unstaking withdrawing and all that. They don't understand that 70% of the stake is already in LSDs and smaller stakers can exit almost that fair value a lot of the time now because a lot of these LSDs are not trading at a discount.
They don't understand that we added more than half the existing validators in 2022 during one of the most brutal kind of like bearish periods for crypto. People were still adding validators right because they still wanted to stake their eith and there's just like a lot of different things that fall off of that. People saying oh they added a queue because they don't want people to exit too quickly so the price doesn't dump. It's like I mean there are so many different considerations here from the economic security perspective that that Justin went through and why it kind of exists. So when people say that I just laugh but I think a lot of the misunderstanding comes from the fact that people just don't understand how Ethereum proof of stake works, how it differs from other proof of stake networks because a lot of the other ones pretty much all of them are some flavor of delegated proof of stake whereas Ethereum is very very different.
It doesn't have that kind of in protocol delegation then that's why we have a lot of these LSDs that are quite popular. But the deposit and withdraw queue is definitely a huge kind of source of confusion for a lot of people and they don't understand why it exists and why it's needed and they think it's just being done as a way to like stem the bleeding or something like that which is obviously untrue. And I think that they kind of they form this bias around it as well they look at it and I'm like oh look at all the ethos going to be unlocked and look at all the other unlocks that have happened in the past and what happens to the price of the asset.
Well you have to contextualize this. If some token has a massive VC unlock well that's going to be a very different unlock to what Ethereum is doing with staking withdrawals right and there is no actual kind of what's the word I'm looking for kind of there's a word for and I'm still bleeding me right now. There's no prior events like this that has happened before where a major network like Ethereum has enabled staking withdrawals later and there's been all these value at stake and there's nothing been like it so people can very easily form their own views on this just based on nothing because there's nothing to point to and I think that leads to as I said like people forming their biases and then reasoning about it from that with all the lack of information that they haven't got around how Ethereum proof of stake works so that's why I've tried for many months now to correct all of this but it is really really hard because as I said when lots of people make up their mind they have their own biases they're not really open to reason about this especially when it comes to the price where they're like oh you know this is going to be really bad for the eth price because billions of dollars is hitting the market and then you try to explain to them that's literally not what is going to happen because of all these reasons they're going to be like oh crap oh what no I already made up my mind that that's not actually true it's going to be really bearish so I mean I think that's that's what kind of happened Anthony most basically I was told like right after the mergers told for months don't stake your eth from like you know floodsters because you'll never be able to un-stake it withdrawals will never be enabled or if they are enabled it's up to Vitalik and you might do that you know by his good graces five years away right like it's just the amount of misinformation about Ethereum is pretty staggering particularly on this point.
Never seems to go down that's that that flood point is pretty funny and I just noticed I didn't even mention that because it actually is so unbelievably stupid that I think it was just about to be disproven in a few hours and that's true right but but yeah again that just goes hand in hand with people having their own biases or towards Ethereum that if you already don't like Ethereum then of course you're just going to not care what the relevant truth is here right you're not going to care that they're going to withdrawals are going to be shipped especially for years if you said the mergers never going to happen and then the merge happened and you're like internally in your brain being like oh crap what do I pivot to now in order to fight Ethereum and then you pivot to these next things it's just it's just a forever kind of goalpost move so yeah I mean we're about to ship it at the end of the day what these people say is relevant I doubt any of the core devs or researchers give a crap about what these people say they just do the work that they want to do and they focus on what they want to focus on and and the community keeps moving forward at the end of the day so guys I think we've covered a decent amount of the low hanging through about the this conversation like what it is the withdrawal and deposits queue why we call it chappelle when we previously called it Shanghai some of the some of the fun but there's some more nuanced conversations that I think probably a lot of listeners are waiting for and that's really just the big question of like okay 18 million ether can now move it can be sold it can also be moved from liquid-staking project to liquid-staking project more ether could be staked because of this de-risking event so like I think these are the three big umbrellas that that I see like how much is going to be sold how much is going to be reshuffled and how much more ether will come in as a result I think these are kind of the three big categories so I think that's where I want to turn to next but first a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible you know uniswap as the world's largest decks with over 1.
4 trillion dollars in trading volume but it's so much more uniswap labs builds products that lets you buy sell and use your self-custody digital assets in a safe simple and secure way uniswap can never take control or misuse your funds the bankless way with uniswap you can go directly to defy and buy crypto with your card or bank account on the ethereum layer one or layer two's you can also swap tokens at the best possible prices on uniswap.org and you can also find the lowest floor price and trade NFTs across more than seven different marketplaces with uniswap's NFT aggregator and coming soon you'll be able to self-custody your assets with uniswap's new mobile wallet so go bankless with one of the most trusted names in defy by going to uniswap.
org today to buy sell or swap tokens and NFTs the phantom wallet is coming to Ethereum the number one wallet on Solana is bringing its millions of users and beloved UX to Ethereum and Polygon if you haven't used phantom before you've been missing out phantom was one of the first wallets to pioneer Solana staking inside the wallet and will be offering similar staking features for Ethereum and Polygon but that's just staking phantom is also the best home for your NFTs phantom has a complete set of features to optimize your NFT experience pin your favorites hide the ugly's remove the spam and also manage your NFT sale listings from inside the wallet phantom is of course a multi chain wallet but it makes chain management easy displaying your transactions in a human readable format with automatic warnings for malicious transactions or phishing websites phantom is already saved over 20,000 users from getting scammed or hacked so get on the phantom weightless and be one of the first to access the multi chain beta there's a link in the show notes or you can go to phantom.
app slash weightless to get access in late February. Banklessation we are back with the questions that you guys really want answered which is what's going to happen to the 18 million ether that gets unlocked and so Justin I actually want to get your perspective on this because you have this mental model of like frozen liquid and boiling ether and I think this kind of slightly relates to that whole idea we have a bunch of frozen ether that's available to be thought I got 18 million ether that's frozen in the beacon chain it's going to some of it might go through the hole and become thought and become liquid ether that can go to defy that can go back into a different uh uh staking derivative project like lido or rocket pool or some of the long tail ones um it might be sold on the secondary market uh and so of all the destinations that ether could go do you have an opinion or or an idea where the most of the ether might accrue right so just thinking in qualitative terms I think there's two very healthy things that happen once you can fall if um one is competition so for two and a half years if you've been sticking one with one service provider you've been locked in and I think that has kind of led to a little bit of staleness in terms of innovation and competition so don't want to pick specifically on coinbase but it's an easy one to pick on they are very large um operator and they charge a 25% fee and I think a lot of their users you know have joined the staking service maybe a year ago 18 months ago or even more and in crypto land 12 months 18 months is an eternity it's uh you know maybe enough time for you to get comfortable with the concept of staking um comfortable with the fact that you know now it's it's been de-rest and you understand what's going on and so I'm hoping that there's going to be you know a move outside of you know these very large pockets of stake like coinbase towards maybe solo solo validating because really withdrawals is uh an unfair unfairly good upgrade for the solo validators because they haven't been able to access liquidity whereas projects like like lido and coinbase you know they get a tiny upgrade so um you know as was mentioned uh you know they have a slightly stronger peg because now it can be economically arbitraged um but really the key upgrade comes for the the the the solo validators um now another interesting kind of thought experiment is in terms of of of lido and I think that there might be an opportunity for a vampire attack so basically lido right now is huge right it's something like 31 or 32% of all staked if and so the the question I have is could a competitor come in and basically set up with the small contract so that you deposit staked if and then it gets automatically on-state with lido and then restaked with the competitor and the competitor says if you do that we're not going to charge you any fees for the next X years um and so that could be kind of a very interesting dynamic that we see shortly um maybe a few months after withdrawals are enabled is this is this a Justin Drake brainchild thought experiment or is this something that you've seen out in the wild and have seen perhaps a liquid-saking derivative project actually talk about no I haven't seen anyone talk about it so I guess it's brainchild um but yeah I would like to in the episode so yeah this is a huge opportunity I think for a competitor to to step up and and and maybe provide healthy competition in the ecosystem and Justin can you just underline that healthy competition how does that benefit um eth-stakers does it lower fees so you see mentioned coinbase with the 25% fee I mean I guess you know implicitly that would be unsustainable if you bring more competition in the market so does it does it lower staking fee prices what are the other benefits for eth-stakers when you have more competition right um so one thing could be lower fees um so right now lido charges 10% fee but maybe you know that could be reduced to six percent or seven percent I don't know but the other big improvement is that it makes Ethereum stronger more robust and so as an ETH holder you know you want you want Ethereum to be maximally successful and this competition will kind of make the value of your principle your 32EF hopefully grow because of that competition so there's almost like this this notion of activist staking where you know you will consciously make a decision to move away from the large pockets of stakedief and and go to the smaller ones now this is not only rational just from a mimetic standpoint but it's also rational from a fundamental standpoint and the reason is that within the protocol we have infrastructure which we call anti correlation you know incentives so if there's some sort of correlated failure so for example if many validators get slashed at the same time or many validators go offline at the same time this is where the penalties really start hitting you hard because the more validators are affected around the same time the greater the penalties and so you want to try and avoid being correlated with many other validators and so for example if there's some sort of small contract bug within LIDO or if there's some governance issue with LIDO well you're going to get the maximum penalty if things go really wrong and the reason is that the penalty for slashing at least is three times the amount that is that is staked so there's 31% of all ETHs staked with LIDO three times 31 would be 93% you get slashed 93% in the worst case whereas if you're in a much smaller pool which is only has 1% then the worst that you could get slashed would be 3% if that whole pool gets slashed and only that pool so it's kind of a way to buy insurance against tail risks and people don't often think about these tail risks but they are there I definitely want to focus back on that comment of Shiapella string high withdrawals upgrade whichever you want to call it benefits this solo staker the most but first before that I think that's where we'll kind of tie off this conversation first I want to go back to that idea of this withdrawal curve so like like Justin said earlier it was linear he thinks it's going to be flat because because of the withdrawal slash deposit queue they're going to cancel each other out while these things settle but I think it's pretty reasonable to assume that withdrawals will ultimately outpace deposits just because of the pent up demand to withdraw that's built up over the last like two plus years that the beacon chain has been has been online now whether that amount that extra withdrawal pressure that in my opinion perhaps we'll exceed the deposit pressure whether that just returns into new deposits into LIDO or rocket pool or some others taking a derivative or perhaps goes into defy or perhaps gets sold I don't know but let's present let's put on the bearcaps because it's bear season and say that like a decent amount goes to the secondary market to it's also may or excuse me it's also April so it's also tax season so like perhaps there is some some sell pressure out in the market so Anthony I want to turn this one to you can you put on your I know this this hat does not fit well on you but put on your bear hat what's the bear case for for Ether in the ETH price why is the ETH price going to go down this is an impossible question to ask me so you know that so so you mentioned you mentioned taxes right I think that like there are a lot of taxes that have been accrued by stakers via the consensus layer rewards obviously that they have not been able to sell those rewards to cover those taxes they could cover those taxes using other funds that they have if that's the way they're being taxed or if the tax office or the guidelines basically say that you're not taxed on that ETH until it's actually unlocked as part of the the shepella upgrade you may need to sell that and I ran through some rough numbers on on my show a bunch of times where I basically said let's just say 30% has to be sold for for taxes right 30% of the consensus layer rewards which I believe is like 350,000 ETH or something like that I don't know the exact numbers of the top of my head but at the same time like all that's not going to be sold at once right there are going to be people that are not going to want to sell that ETH they're just going to cover their taxes with other fear that they have right not everyone's going to be at a 30% tax rate so the numbers are very hard to get for that kind of scenario right for the tax selling purposes now in terms of the actual ETH stake itself and how many people are going to sell the stake that they put in well I've seen many charts floating around that basically say that most stakers based on the USD value of when they actually stake their ETH are underwater now that's not going to be totally accurate either because people could have bought ETH at a cheaper price and then staked at later right it's going to be it's very hard to get those accurate numbers there but you know you look at that and you're like okay well who's going to who's going to sell that people underwater they might sell because they're like oh you know I need the liquidity I need a panic out of this position you know it's been locked for a while I want to get out now but I doubt many of those people are solar stakers I think those people would have staked with LSD's and they already have the exit liquidity available to them if they wanted to exit they're fully staked position even if they took a haircut from selling their LSD for ETH and then selling that for for dollars or something like that that would have been an option for for most people already so it is actually very hard for me to come up with a bearish scenario where a lot of ETH is going to be suddenly unlocked from staking and sold on on the market the most bearish I can think of is really just the tax selling for the consensus layer rewards and even that I don't think is that much sell pressure given how much liquidity there is for ETH as an asset already if not like this is some random ELC 20 token on uni swap this is eighth we're talking about which has a huge amount of liquidity and a huge amount of people ready to buy it I think for a number of different reasons so Anthony is accurate to say and by the way we're talking about like price we're talking about short term price right obviously this you know people have forgotten this in like three months basically like withdraws the thing and so but but short term people are still curious and it seems like there are two opposing forces here there's there's the one force that's my ETH has been unlocked and I've been wanting to sell it for a long time but I haven't been able to and I'm underwater and I was panicking and now the ETH is unlocked so I can sell and maybe I have to pay some taxes so that's one force over here in the sell pressure and I guess maybe the stake pressure over here is like isn't it great ETH Ethereum continues to ship it's incredible they just pulled off another successful hard fork and now this entire staking thing has been deep risk it's sort of the sentiment I was expressing a little bit earlier some of the long-term holders might be like now's my chance to really pile into ETH's staking and these two opposing forces are sort of fighting the the bull in the bear case you know and like the market will decide whether ETH price goes up or down is that a way to think about is that how you think about it or where do you add something to this no that's a good way to think about it I think and there are also a lot of other demand factors for just eight as an asset as well like if you're talking about what the price can move even in the short term based on supply entering the market well obviously you have to consider the demand case as well and every day we have millions of dollars of ETH being used as gas fees right on the network so there's a demand driver as well people have to buy ETH in order to use the network and then there's ETH as an investment vehicle and ETH to stake so yeah there are those opposing forces but I feel like the demand side is just stronger than than the side overall Anthony I would expect nothing less but you think the withdrawals getting deployed is more bullish like and good for ETH price than bearish even in the short run well yeah because people have been saying bearish for the ETH price since eight was eleven hundred dollars and now ETH is like nineteen hundred dollars so like and that wasn't that longer I was like two three months ago or something like that so like that that's why as I said it's very hard to find the bear case if you run through all the scenarios and you try to make it maybe I'm not the best person to make a bear case of course but I think that just going on the on the logic that I've put out there it'd be very hard for anyone to do that and you know what the people that I've seen that are the most bearish are the ones that don't actually have any arguments to back up their bearishness they just put these kind of views out there and say all this it's going to be unstaked and sold it's like okay but why why is that going to happen oh you know because of this and then they don't really have any reasons right so that's why I kind of say that and that's why I try to raise them about it from these first principles rather than coming to a conclusion first and then working my way back okay so I want to turn this conversation to the thing that makes the entire ethereum ecosystem tick which is the solo staker and so we said earlier that the the chappelle upgrade unduly benefits solo stakers the most but there I feel like there's such as some other conversations about what solo how this impacts the solo staking environment and Tim I'm wondering if you could guide us through that conversation what's the significance of chappelle as relates to solo staking and guys let's be do can we just define a solo staker so when we say solo staker in in our world what we're saying is basically somebody who is staking at runs their own validator staking their own kind of their it's their ether and their validator okay so this is not rocket pool this is not wider we would not consider these pools kind of stake it's definitely not coin base somebody who's running their own validators a solar state is solo stakers that correct yeah cool I think I think that's good um yeah I think there's probably two things that like make solo staking significantly better than it currently was um like the obvious one is just like getting the rewards periodically right like because what you're saying is you know you're locking that capital and and you know staking east but you're also getting sort of compensated for it and and can receive part of those rewards over time and this has been like a bit true since the merge because of the transaction fees but obviously there's a big difference between you know locking up your ether and getting absolutely nothing out of it versus you know locking it up and being able to actually get the funds get the funds out and I think the other thing that's really neat with the subgrade is you can also try it right like being a solo staker was a pretty big ask to people prior to withdrawals being live because you were sort of signing up for this indefinite amount of time right some people signed up in like 2020 and you know have no idea that like April 2023 is what they would they would be able to withdraw um whereas now it's like you know if if you've been on defense you know you you're not quite sure about it like I would I would probably wait until this you know this this uh straight line that Justin mentioned has gone through like this sort of flow of withdrawals and deposits has like passed but you know after that you should be able you can spit it up your validated why to make those in a couple days you can try it run it and like you know keep it running if you want and if you don't want to you can shut it down and get your funds back out you know and in a couple days as well so I think there is something there where like once you've done it and you've sort of run through the flow like you know putting your funds up locking yet running the evaluator getting your funds back out seeing that it's actually working it was not rocket science or you know maybe you messed something up on the first try you want to try it differently the second time um you can do that right um especially when it comes to things like potentially you know changing your setup changing clients and what not like this is something where I think subtle stickers are like extremely anxious and like you know you can shut it down and get the penalty in the meantime but I think just even if it's economically worse like from just like an anxiety of managing your your validator know when you can like fully exit the thing if it was running on I don't know like death and prism and you want to try like nimbus and bazoo you can like exit that validator get your money back literally you know formats that drive like that you are using your wipe it clean and start again um so I think hopefully like what we'll just see like a bit more experimentation on that front um and one thing we've been trying to do as well uh at the EF is set up like some ephemeral testnet for stakers as well so like we we have this new thing called ephemery where we have these testnets that like launch and completely reset every two three days um so you can like start from scratch you know get some like genesis eat on a testnet launch your validator make sure that it works exit your funds and run through that process because I think up to now it's felt like something where a lot of people who are less experienced or like knowledgeable about this like set it up and like somehow it works and then they never want to touch it again and they're afraid of like any mistake and and to be fair you know a mistake was costly if it means you know you you get your validator slash or or whatnot then then you have to wait two years for it to be exited um whereas now it's like yeah I think we you get a little bit more confidence like if something goes wrong you can at least get most of your funds back pretty quickly and and try and change your setup so um yeah hopefully it leads to more experimentation yeah and Tim this gave me kind of just like flashbacks to the first few times I set up my own uh private keys uh and so like wrote down my private keys loaded them up in my ledger erased my ledger loaded them up again made sure the addresses were the same deposited a small amount of ether erased my ledger again loaded up the same private keys yeah made sure the ether was still there and that's how I got like comfortable with and you were scared every single time every single time I was super scared right and so Tim what you're saying is like okay we're we have that same pattern but now we're doing it for solo staking but we weren't able to have those people who were timid and kind of exploring the frontier because of they weren't able to withdraw they weren't able to complete the loop and so like now like once upon a time we were all doing our practicing our self custody with writing down our own private keys and now what you're saying is like people can practice their own self validation of the chain and so this is like the self custody but now for validators and now that this loop is complete people can go one step further beyond just self custody and do the thing that Ethereum was has always been set up to do which is apply self custody and self validation as closely as possible and so you're saying that now that this loop is here people can explore one step further into this crypto economic frontier and and feel safe doing it and if it's not for them and they just want to go store it with coinbase then they can freely withdraw but at least they were able and enabled to do that in the first place this is what you're saying correct yeah I feel like we need though on solo stailing is staking is for this to be like there are people who will never set self custody because setting up a ledger matter of ask is too difficult right and you'll see see mom there's a lot of people that are are able and willing to do that but there's a smaller subset of people who are able to kind of maybe run their own validator and like work through client command line and do the DevOps and and feel confident on that front like I might like throw up my hand as as one of those individuals as well are there any steps to make solo staking as easy or close to as easy as just running like a ledger for example because to me that's what it's going to take to actually get the big takeoff maybe that does not include Lido or rocket pool in your answer exactly exactly because Lido and rocket pool are sort of the the easy button right now the question to me to to see solo staking really take off is can we make solo staking maybe as easy as running a let as itself custody on a ledger do we see anything like that on the market yeah so um what what the the term that I use for for kind of unstaking and restaking is re-keying basically creating a new set of keys and this flexibility comes with various advantages because it means for example that you can improve your security setup so for example some of the institutions that might have like the really fancy NPC to generate the keys they have what's called remote signing whether it's like a separate piece of software or hardware maybe that is air gap or like kind of segregated in some way or never and for solo stakers there's actually this uh this technology called SGX from Intel that can be used to basically mimic the functionality of a hardware wallet it's kind of a way to have your staking keys in a hardware wallet in such a way that you can't be slashed so the service provided is kind of anti-slashing protection and there is a company working on it for disclosure i'm an advisor um called puffer puffer finance puffer.
fi um and they you know they provide this for free as so you can just go download it and then you basically have a hardware wallet uh kind of there is the same kind of grade of security as as an institution in the context of remote signing now another kind of really healthy thing with with re-keying is that um you know it might unlock certain services for some of the operators so for example insurers uh might require that the the keying process follows certain standards and the fact that you can now re-key means you can satisfy the requirements of the insurers and so now we could start seeing service providers provide slashing protection or provide all all sorts of all sorts of insurance and refresh us Justin when you say re-keying what do you mean there what is re-keying right so when you are a validator you have a private key which is your your your staking key and you use this private key to sign messages on a regular basis so every epoch every six point four minutes you're going to be signing what's called an attestation basically a vote on what you think is the current state of the chain and then every once in a while every few months roughly every six months you kind of you win a lottery and you get selected as a as a as a as a proposal and here you're going to sign um a block a proposal now one of the things that you don't want to happen is that this private key gets gets leaked um and i think what's happening right now is that solar validators are today kind of you're lowering it without even realizing it and the reason is that they have a computer where the staking key is like essentially in hot within the the machine and if there's some sort of virus or whatever it is then they are liable to get slashed so it's kind of this unnecessary kind of psychological you know fear that you know at any point in time because you don't really have this strong protection you could you could be slashed so really what we need is the equivalent of a hardware wallet for staking and this thing does exist you can use sgx to provide the anti-slashing protection very cool this has been a definitely a big moment for a theorem and it's good to see hard forks major upgrades so close so back to back I mean it it feels like only yesterday when we were on a massive call as a community celebrating the marriage and now here we are with another hard fork so it got a got a conclude with this can end the show in this way what is next for a theorem so let's look beyond chappelle to the next uh portman toe uh that that you were talking about um tim which is the next a theorem hard for can upgrade what is the next area of focus for core devs and the development team yeah um of course so the next big upgrade is called ben coon so the maven can coon together um but uh and the main thing we've uh started to work on for that is eip4844 there's been several bankless episodes about this already but on a high level it's a scalability upgrade to a theorem which uh introduces a data availability layer which will reduce the data costs for rollups and so if you look at the transaction fees on a rollup today it's like 90 to 95 percent the cost of posting data on a theorem uh forge44 will massively reduce that cost um basically because the network won't store the data forever so because we have like a bound on how long the network needs to retain that data um whereas right now the rollup data is like stored in in the nose forever um we we can charge much less for it um so and and those savings kind of get passed on to users in the form of lower transaction fees um so this is extremely important if we want rollups to scale and and you know the general usage of a theorem to scale um so that's the main thing we're working on the other big thing i will mention um is uh changing how self-destruct works uh so right now on ethereum if you deploy a contract you can basically delete it there's an upcode called self-destructs for that um this is nice in that you know it allows you to delete a contract but it's kind of the one area of the EDM where we don't know how long it's going to take to execute the code that's running before we run it so you can think of like if you delete the tiny contract you know it deletes super quickly but imagine you deleted like the uniswap contract or the cryptokitties contract you know deleting all those records takes the computer way more time than deleting like a tiny contract and partially because of that um it's it's it's kind of incompatible with a lot of changes we want to do in the future and a lot of the changes around statelessness and and um and whatnot can't deal with this this idea that like we need to delete an arbitrary amount of data um so this is something that is used by contract developers so right now like we're looking at all the different designs that we can use to you know deactivate this in a way that like ideally does not break any existing contracts um but do you fear a smart contractive listening to this um it's linked in the blog post we have like a deactivation EIP just as a or sort of a deprecation EIP as I can notice the people um but that's something that I think contract developers should be aware that uh likely within you know the next year or so self-destruct as it exists today will not work um they'll you know the idea that like the funds get sent back that the color address will will be preserved um but like what actually happens with the contracts um and you know how possible it is to like deploy something and replace it with something else um that's that's going to be changing um and and as we let it time maybe slip out there within the next year or so I noticed you saying yeah yeah I'm trying to be extremely conservative um yeah you know so that people will be happy when thank you doesn't happen in April 2024 yeah thank you thank you it's great Tim I know uh you got to drop so feel free to hop off if if you need to but I do want to ask about Anthony and his solo staker tinkering Anthony uh as somebody who explores the uh the frontier of solo staking what does it mean to tinker what you what you up to over there what you what you're doing uh I think I have one of the weirdest staking setups or solo staking setups out there for a few different reasons so I I said on Twitter recently that I'm currently running for different EL CL uh kind of combos uh and it's put a lot of strain on my network and my networking devices which has caused me to tinker a lot with with different things so the reason I'm running for is because I have my soul my normal solo staking box which has my personal funds on it I have my rocker pool odour box which is my mini pools and uh my obviously my my role in the odour I have another box which is my archive node box which I'm running for the rocker pool odour but it's a separate box altogether so that's running another combo and then I have another solo box which is my retirement fund so my entire retirement account is in eighth but I can't stake that eighth with my personal funds because of some regulation so I have to have another solo staking box for that so I think that's so funny so he has his personal staking box in his retirement staking box it actually had a two different boxes because of nation state regulations and like you put them on top of each other if you want to do yes and my and the funny thing is my retirement box is a little device called a proteus which is something um Joe from the rocker pool community uh sold so it's basically a rock 5b uh board in a nice 3d printed case um and it's a low power device but it's running a bunch of solo validators on there that is my retirement one so it's literally sitting right in front of me I could see it right here next to my rocker pool box my solo staking box is in the other room but as long as as long as they're separate that's apparently okay but um and yeah and and they're all running off of my home network so my home network is a hundred a thousand mega bits down so one gigabit down and 40 mega bits up unfortunately the up is is pretty pretty crappy and I haven't got any way around that but it does put a lot of load on my network I'm using currently 15 terabytes a month just on my staking boxes because they're all using different EL and CL combo so they're basically running their own Ethereum full node essentially and I'm running an archive node as well so that put a lot of strain on and I had to replace them networking gear because some of it was leading to missed missed asset attestations as all my boxes because that it just was overloading my network so yeah that's that's a lot of the tinkering that I've done but there's so much more but yeah it's it's been fun it's been a lot of fun but when you're running such a weird setup like I am uh yeah you're running to these issues that no one really runs into and I was troubleshooting things with um actually a core dev and it was like what's going on and it was the network it was the networking equipment issue because it's like you shouldn't be missing out to stations you're doing nothing wrong I'm like I don't know man I don't know and it took me a while to figure it out but I figured it out in the end so that was okay yeah the the surface area that you have to be a solo staker I think it's pretty immense these days and we've come we've come a long ways away from where we were previously bullied by the dick corners for not ever being able to run a phone you know I never ever true in the first place I still think culturally we should totally honor solo stakers like I just want to say good job Anthony like that's totally I know it's it's it's more difficult what you're doing right now is more difficult than just kind of staking it with some sort of a pool provider but um uh you're performing your civic duty as an ethereum above and beyond yeah I think that should be a celebrated for sure we should put on a little keep today Anthony I mean I would be doing it the service to everything I believe in if I was not solo staking that's that's the way I view it right and I think solo stakers are the beating heart of of ethereum they are the beating heart of ethereum values and decentralization we didn't create ethereum proof of stake the way we did to just go stake with centralized exchanges right and uh and and I've been a solo staker since day one literally part of the genesis of the beacon chain um you know a bunch of my validators which yeah I'm very obviously very proud of but uh my setup just for people that listened and heard how complex it was this is not a normal setup if you don't have to do that we can we can make it easier than what you just said so you're saying yeah it's a lot easier than that okay you can you can very a setting up a solo staking box is actually very easy um or and and actually just one other quick thing my solo staking box while I was in Denver for if Denver decided to uh basically or while the ssd that it runs on decided to just like die um and it caused my solo staking box to go offline and I had no idea this was the case until I got back home um and and then I got back home and I looked at it so I had to basically redo my entire setup again so I had to reinstall everything but it only took me like half an hour because there's a guide that I follow from uh he he's named me summit summit east side he's on medium and there's a coin cashew guide they're very very similar you follow that and it tells you all the commands to put into the command line uh to do it to generate everything into the and to do everything and it only took me half an hour to get back up and running with a new ssd uh it's obviously not going to be like that the first time you do it but I think there's this misconception that solo staking is really hard when I don't think it is and as I said you can do it on very low powered hardware my my proteas box is um I think it was like 700 US dollars or something like that around that um for the whole kit and it comes pre-loaded if you don't want a solo stake but stake as part of rock apple it comes pre-loaded with the rock apple smart node stack so you can get started straight away so and and for solo stake as there's the avada or dap node boxes uh which you can also use so there are multiple different ways to get started and I think that there is definitely a misconception that solo staking is this really hard thing that's only reserved for the super technical people I'm not very technical the command line I'm a beginner at it I'm not I can't do the always copy and paste yeah I mean a lot of the time I just copy and paste and and learn how I go and and it is it is a lot of fun as well so I just I figured that was worth mentioning too well I think that was a great exploration down the world of solo stakers dressin uh yeah give us your give us your last thoughts while we stand off here yeah just to try and chill solo uh staking a little bit more you know you don't have to pay any fees when you're solo staking so already that puts you above the rest from from a rational standpoint but the the other thing I want to highlight is that my prediction is that there is going to be special adrops specifically for solo volunteers and the reason is that um for example eigenlayer some of the services that they require is that pure economic security so just lots and lots of if but some other services are maybe more subtle they kind of require you know proof of humanity or they require proof of decentralization and what is happening right now this is you know information that I know internally is that like there's some people that are kind of looking at the set of metadata for validators and there's a lot of metadata you can look at the positive addresses you can look at withdrawal addresses you can look at fee recipients you can look at IP addresses you can look at correlated failures when did they go offline at the same time um you can look at so it's a fairly simple resistant dataset of like your most involved Ethereum citizens exactly yes and then you can identify okay we know who crack enters you know we know who coin bases and we can just not give them an adrop if the purpose of the adrop is to adrop to specific individuals that are running solo validators that's a cool incentive uh possible incentive hypothetical incentive to sign off on and and as we always say crypto pays you to learn about crypto maybe crypto can pay you in a way to learn how to to go through the some of the more difficult steps that uh Anthony was just talking about David you want to say something yeah and if anyone just had the gut reflex of this uh benefits whales who can afford 32 teeth uh and above and not the people who are fractional eat stakers but would desire to be a solo staker i'm wondering if something like oval and shared secret validator uh could actually solve for something like that where four people could come together with eight ether each and count as a solo staker that technology is not here yet uh but i think it's already on the corner because that is something that Anthony I know is tinkering with was actually one of the answer i was looking for you to get to to say but yeah so i can't i can't reveal everything just yet but i've been really king the alpha on my show that david's technology is is live uh right now on on main net uh and uh yeah i've been tinkering with it a lot and it is definitely a solution to that um you know people can pull their teeth together you know just means as a solo staker team solo staking basically yeah squad staking oh wow are we using that are we doing that i like it staking is a good name i like that name yeah you heard it here first guys this has been a fantastic episode thanks for guiding us through shapela you can now withdraw your teeth but why would you want to just put it back in see if you can and then put it back in just go through the pipeline once uh anyway guys this is very exciting for a theory and we're glad you're with us on bank list will include some links in the show notes to a few of the things we reviewed got to end like this as we always do none of this has been financial advice it wasn't tax advice either despite what anthony was getting into a little bit earlier don't get your tax advice from bank list at all ethos risky cryptos risky so is defy you definitely lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bank list journey thanks a lot you