Welcome to the State of the Nation a new video podcast where RSA & David Hoffman weigh-in on topics relevant to the Bankless Nation every week.
Watch the video here.
New episodes on Tuesdays. SotN #1 - BULLISH Tuesday, June 16, 2020
The State of the Bankless Nation is....BULLISH! The Bankless boys discuss why.
Covered:
- Why DeFi tokens are the next pump narrative (but better than 2017)
- How 100m ETH accounts is like the early internet
- Do and David disagree on his Bitcoin tweet?
We show you how:
- To calculate returns on your COMP tokens
-----
Tools from our sponsors to go bankless:
-----
RESOURCES:
1) Look up COMP returns (credit Mika Honkasalo @mhonkasalo)
2) DeFiMarketCap shows COMP market cap
3) InstaDapp maximizer for COMP mining
No summary for this episode yet.
All right, guys, welcome to Banclas. This is the first time David and I are trying something new. This is the state of the nation. We're going to be doing this every Tuesday, guys. David, it is great to see you on video, my friend. We usually, it's usually just your spoken voice, but this is the first time we're doing it live video on YouTube. Yeah, this is, it turns out you're a real person and not just a voice and voice in my headphones. So yeah, we've always wanted to kind of amp up our YouTube content and and get people watching watching what we are also looking at while we talk talk about it.
And so this video format is going to allow us to go a little bit more in depth about some subjects, share some images, and also just have like a more personal conversation. So I'm really excited about it. Yeah, it's going to be fun. I mean, we started doing this big picture type of stuff like the topical events that were happening in the Banclas nation at the start of the you at the start of our podcast, but it became like it was a lot, right. And it deserves its own dedicated airtime and its own dedicated show where we can do deep dives. So that's what we're going to be doing on the state of the nation, webcast, we're going to talk about what's happening.
We're going to talk about how that relates to the big picture in the Banclas nation. We're going to try to drop some insights and action items as we go. And we're going to be publishing this every Tuesday on YouTube. We'll also probably roll this into a podcast episode too. So you can catch on YouTube in video. You can also catch it in the Banclas podcast by subscribing. It'll be kind of the second episode of the week that we release. And I think it'll give us a really cool format for doing this sort of thing. Yeah, the podcast that we were turning out, we're turning out to be like an hour 40 minutes long because they had like a 30 to 40 minute state of the nation and then an hour plus long interview or an hour plus long just you and me riffing on one.
Yeah, breaking these things apart, I think is definitely the way the way that they deserve to be. Yeah, all right. So let's do it. We get no breaks. I mean, this is we can't edit any things. This is going to be raw. This is going to be live. But why did we call it state of the nation, David? What like why nation? Because it is a nation for those that read my recent article, a Banclas nation, the thesis is that what we are building here is a new way of organizing ourselves across the world. And we as in humanity, we as in the humans, we are building a new nation that works for all of us that has very strong correlates with the previous nations that we've known.
And not just nation states, but the nations, the versions of nations that have come before it like religion. And the claim is that these digital nations, Bitcoin and Ethereum are this new paradigm for organization, how humans organize around each other. And I also think that the reason why we're calling it the Banclas nation is because Bitcoin and Ethereum are likely going to stitch themselves together into one like cohesive unit. It's kind of considered Bitcoin and Ethereum as like this binary star system that is rotating around each other. They're brothers, right? Like older brother and younger siblings.
Yeah. Yeah. The mother and the father, the archetypes of the universe, right? Yeah. Like they require each other. Like there's no way that Bitcoin can have a fully sci-fi future without Ethereum. And so it needs Ethereum. And Bitcoin has a ton of liquidity and a ton of value, which is exactly what DeFi needs. So these things are going to become one cohesive nation, which we call the Banclas nation. Yeah. And it's banclas because that's the entire point of crypto, right? I mean, go all the way back to 2009 Satoshi's white paper where he talked about appear to appear digital cash that would appear to appear.
It does it. It's not peer to bank. It's not bank to peer. It's peer to peer. It's a banclas digital cash. So from the very inception, the entire point of this crypto movement has been to create a banclas financial money system. It's a banclas nation, really, for the world. And I know your articles, David, you talked a lot about the patriots and the uniforms of the Banclas nation. I would consider both of us patriots. And we're wearing our uniforms. I'm going to have to get some more of these shirts so that we always have them on Tuesdays. People want them. People want one. Yeah, I know we got to open up the storefront soon.
So before we dig in, David, we've got to talk about two of our sponsors. So I'm going to talk about the first one. So this is a banclas way to run your business basically doesn't require a crypto exchange doesn't require a bank account. We've written articles about multis on banclas actually in the next week or so, we're going to be doing a video walk through live on this channel. This behind the scenes, it uses the multi the notes is multi save. So your funds are always secure and it creates like a banking interface on top of a smart contract system. And allows you to run the entire thing without a bank.
So really cool sponsor, great to have them will include a link to them where you can sign up and get some special banclas perks. Just check the YouTube notes. Our other sponsor is Ave you guys know all about Ave. It's a borrowing and lending platform, but it's also much more than that. It's a suite of services that started with borrowing and lending and it has spawned into many new things. There are a tokens, which are tokens that receive the supply rate of all the assets on Ave. And what's more is Ave allows for stable interest loans. This is a very crucial tool in the legacy financial world to be able to pull out a loan from somewhere without having that interest rate change under your feet.
And so that's what Ave allows you to do allows you to plan out your financial future far in advance, because you know those interest rates aren't ever going to change. You can check them out at AAVE dot com. Is that right, com. And multis by the way is M U I L T God, what is multis check that just check the video notes. I think it's a dot code though you check the video notes are David. What is the state of the banclas nation right now, my friend? The state of the banclas nation is bullish, dude. So much is happening. It's that could be your answer every week. Well, I mean, in my life, it's bullish.
Yeah, the reason why it's bullish this week is because of the DeFi tokens really is DeFi tokens. Okay. Our sponsor had a has their own token, which I'm categorizing as a DeFi token that has gone like 300% like in the last like six months. Maker just jumped up by like double on its listing on Coinbase, comp just got added to uniswap and it's comp. And then the company is the token, a governance token of compound now comp unlike AVE or or maker doesn't give you access to cash flows. But like we all know that's coming, right? So it's a governance token. So so like it's people are going governing over compound, which has cash flows.
And eventually it's I'm I'm thinking everyone else is assuming that in the future, they're just going to vote in cash flows for themselves. It seems inevitable that there'll be a convergence, right? Right. So we published something in back list called like voting in cash flows, which is basically what comp holders are incentive to do. If you're a holder of comp, you want to turn that comp token into a higher value comp token. Right. So what's one of the initial things that you're going to do is you're going to vote in cash flows so that you take a cut a percentage of all of the assets under management in compound and have that accrue to the token that seems inevitable to me.
And it also seems to be the case like that's where we ended up with stocks, right? So like stocks were invented into 1600s and the 1700s by the Dutch, right? And they slowly converge into what they resemble today where they are capital assets. So they can be essentially valued based on future cash flows, but they, but they combine that and they also combine a governance piece as well. So they're both part of the governance and the cash flows are both part of the same thing. I really agree with you. It feels like there's going to be convergence here too, which is cool, because this means it's like the birth of a new asset class.
I know Chris Brinnitsky wrote that paper about Bitcoin back in 2015 or so. But this is a second asset class, right? That was sort of the Bitcoin is like a money monetary asset class. This is a second asset class. It's a total asset with everything. All of the cash flows settled on chain. So it's like completely transparent brand new. Super exciting. Yeah, absolutely. And harping on that, the point of voting in cash flows, like if you don't think this is going to happen, like the onus is on you to prove to why this isn't going to follow the same path as like as history. I can't remember who said it, but they said something along the lines of like the cryptocurrency industry is just relearning the lessons of finance that the human species has learned throughout time, but in a sped up manner.
Now it's now it's the time for capital assets on Ethereum. Like now is the time for tokens that represent some sort of equity in these defy applications on Ethereum to start producing cash flows, which some are already doing in comp, our compound has been doing. And now there's this governance token called comp that governs over the cash flows of compounds, like it's just it's just a direct line like this is going to happen. I mean, I feel like it feels like we're in the maybe the 18th or 19th century in terms of like traditional finance, where we're just starting the joint stock company, right, it's like brand new.
We're just starting with lending, but it's all collateral back. So there's no notion of reputation. Everything has to be backed by real collateral. But I think we're accelerating in a much faster pace. So it's going to be really exciting as we'd like reinvent this parallel bankless financial system. But I want to ask you something on that we're going to get into comp in a bit more detail, I think, but some people have criticized this as like I see a mania 2.0, right. So I'm going to I'm going to show comp market cap in a few minutes right to go through it, but it has quickly risen just in like a day of trading just yesterday started trading on you to swap 900 million dollar market cap.
Like it's almost a Silicon Valley unicorn one billion dollar company. This is a protocol, right. It's worth 900 million dollars. So people see that and they're like, oh my god, I'm having flashbacks to you 2007 to teen I see a mania for everything. Yeah, it's already above mkr in market cap. It is the highest highest token value on Ethereum other than right. Right. All right. So people see that and they're like, not again. So like what's your take what's what's going to happen here. This is why I'm saying I'm bullish, right. And when all these tokens are accruing these insane evaluations like right off the bat and important distinction is that compound and the and the next lowest value market cap token on Ethereum mkr.
They totally deserve it or at least deserve something right at least and start comparison to like the ICO mania right like where the ICO mania was total vapor and it was an actual bubble that just needed the smallest pin prick the pop. Like the there are real cash flows behind these things like mkr has real income compound has real income. And so like you know it was easy to criticize the ICO tokens of 2017 and there is a lot of parallels between the DeFi tokens that have like gone up 300% over the last you know X number of months. But the point is is that these things are real right these things are generating real cash flows.
And and I remember of a colleague tweeted about this in 2017 2018 after like the market cap of all crypto hit like a trillion dollars. And and then the bubble popped and it started to deflate he said something along the lines of like the next the next bull market is going to be based off of real world fundamentals like real real things that are are tangible and that's what we are seeing here. Yeah absolutely and as you're talking David I put this up this is the DeFi market cap which is one of my favorite it's you know better than coin market cap in some ways because it shows the actual like DeFi bank lists.
A few times alright so upload that up there so you can see compound to market cap 9.45 million dollars today and there's maker as you said and you know this might not last right it's like right you know very limited liquidity just on uniswap it's entering this this price discovery phase. But I absolutely think you're right this is going to be this is different than I see a mania because in I see a mania the tokens had no value of cool mechanism what's so ever it was kind of like like by my token we haven't even shipped a product maybe we'll ship a product maybe. How am I token right and like you know how is the how how is the token value the answer is like fat vertical ceases thesis bro it doesn't matter it's just going to work itself out right.
And this time around we might see some crazy value like valuations and we might see some mania enter I don't think we're at that stage yet but at least it will be based on things we can fairly value as as capital assets things that are real producing actual real world value and actual cash flows so to me it's a lot different. The other thing is the distribution mechanism is a lot different and I know we want to talk about that with the ICOs it was. You know very early I see is very much retail mania you got it you know by the token in this model of sort of the defi token area you sort of you have to earn them right so so compound just released a mechanism for earning comp tokens yesterday i'm going to talk about that but but do you see that is a something different as well as that important.
Yes and also know right so like part of the ICO mania was that like you would contribute work to the protocol and then you would receive tokens as a reward and. And the only problem with that is that like it was inside the context of the mania right and so like it and and we really hadn't figured out the distribution mechanism but the main thesis of the distribution mechanism is that you use the token to align incentives with your users. So that you can grow your ecosystem right like the token was a community management tool where like it would attract users attract the community. But it happened inside of the context of this absolute mania with zero fundamentals but like the token these days are doing the same role that ICO tokens.
Earlier claimed to do but this time they're actually doing it right so like if you want comp tokens if you want balancer tokens balancer token is like doing the same thing where like you get the token if you supply liquidity. But like the work being done is the type of work being done is much more valid right like for compound you submit capital and there's zero way to fake that you can't fake capital there were their previous ICO token were totally gameable. But like if you want to supply if you want to get the comp token you got to supply liquidity to the compound protocol which makes the compound protocol better which makes more people use the compound protocol.
Which which just generates the whole the whole feedback loop the flywheel that these tokens were claimed to have created in 2017. And so like it's almost comical to me like exact the how how perfectly these new defy tokens are resonating with the original thesis of ICO tokens but actually doing it correctly. Yeah I totally agree and maybe we should walk through sort of an example of what what comp actually looks like so folks can see how this works because what you said is exactly right David that this is essentially a growth hack for these defy protocols so what it's going to do is. And this is just in central liquidity and juice liquidity inside of these inside of these money protocols these defy protocols and as we've talked about before.
That's the end game for everything there all of these protocols even Ethereum and the asset itself they're just liquidity monsters the more liquidity you have the more like a money system you become so these things are chewing on liquidity so can you see my screen David okay so this is the original comp medium post where they talk about distribution allocation of the comp tokens how their governance tokens about. Let's see is it 10 million or so of these tokens yeah I think it's a total of 10 million of these tokens are going to be created. Close to half of those are going to be reserved for users of the protocol so that's what they just launched on Monday a way to issue these tokens for users of the protocol and by that they need liquidity providers but here's essentially what that what that means.
It means that as you provide liquidity to the comp token you get an increased return and this is where it's kind of an action item or something interesting for the bankless community to look into. A friend of mine put together a predictions exchange like a basically a calculator so you can see how much comp tokens you can earn and so if you go through this exchange we'll include this in the show notes if you go through this calculator rather you can sort of see how much how much you can earn in comp tokens by supplying the various liquidity numbers so if I supplied a thousand die. And I press calculate my annual comp returns.
We can see right here my supplying die to the compound protocol normally you'd you'd earn a supplier rate of 1.09% right so die again as a stable coin that's a bit better than what you might do in a traditional bank account for something that's like peg to the US dollar. But those returns are juiced by the comp token that you're receiving so you get the 1.09% but then you also earn about $10 per year well let's see here. Yeah you you're in 1.21 comp in on an annual basis and additional returns and at the comp valuation which again as we've talked about is you know it's just one day of trading it's it's trading but it's currently trading at.
At you know 999 million market cap with each token worth i can't believe that i'm saying that over over $100 so anyway your net. APY return is going to be 12% so in addition to that 1% that you're getting from the compound protocol I think they may have total this so it's the 1% plus the comp to give you a total annual return of 12.2%. I think they may have totaled it but that's your total return so it's it's absolutely juicing your returns and it's increasing the incentive to provide liquidity to this this protocol so it's it's an ultimate growth hack and that's just with die so let's check out tether.
And so token has its own interest rate that it gives you in comp tokens right or are they the same for dollars of capital different curves different different up you know drastically different amounts of comp tokens that that you can earn so if I put $1,000 in USDT I click calculate. So USDT is regularly going to give me far more than die and 0.83% but look at my APY right and that's going that's going down right now this morning it was over 100% so arbitrageers are getting in there like they're exchanging USDC for tether and they're taking advantage of this opportunity but that's a 99% return right now.
So this is also a way to like smooth out the differences in different pools right so like you are yes I think I think you get more comp for supplying tether because there's more demand for tether and so this is a way for the compound governance system to like. Nudge capital to be supplied in a particular pair is that is that correct yeah exactly and it's also a way to compete I think with the crypto banks so the crypto banks have many different advantages right including you know better user interface and in some cases the ability to provide additional incentives some in some cases their own loyalty tokens and this is defy kind of.
You know striking back against that and putting its own growth hacks in place to incent liquidity and I think it's going to be absolutely absolutely massive for all of defy all the protocols are going to implement something like this yeah totally totally. Crypto banks understand chance yeah there i mean there's other there's other stuff you can get into to which i'm which i'm trying to figure out at at the moment which is you know instant app is allowing you to actually take leverage on staple coins and further juice your returns. Wow instant app already has a tool for this that's crazy they ship that fast i know so they just built it on top so anyway more stuff to figure out here but.
We will include links to these interfaces in the shed out so you can you can see just how much. APY your annualized return can be by depositing some of these various assets into into comp and you can really see I mean I get why your bullish David I understand it seems like this is a very bullish move for defy and yeah could could be part of the next bull run for sure. So not only that like defy tokens are bullish in their own right but also because of the way that market cycles work right if all these defy tokens have gone like 3x to 30x over the last. Six months like that's going to rotate back into ethude like if if the all the tokens on Ethereum went like collectively 3x in price people are going to people are going to rotate.
Well that's how it worked in in 2017 very much right and if you look at sort of what's the leading trading pair for comp right now on uniswap which is the only exchange. Which is basically selling comp tokens it's all eith it's all in a pair off the top of your head you know how much eth is in that trading pair. I don't we could look that up I mean I know the vault the volumes about a million a day right now so not a ton but there's going to be a lot of time to eat it's going to suck up a ton of eith yes and not quite like 2017 so right 2017 basically all of the I see a raises sucked up eith because you had to contribute in kind with with eith.
But but this has advantages in that it's still sucking up eith as kind of a trading pair it's growing the Ethereum economy certainly and these are real assets now that's not to say like if you do it net present value calculation of comp tokens right now like if you work backwards to get to the 900 million number. It probably doesn't make sense right like the you know the P E ratios price earnings ratios have to be absolutely insane to pop up that valuation so it's not to say that this won't get crazy speculative but the difference as we said is compounds are real like it's a real protocol it's working people are using it and like potentially there's some real cash flows associated with this right and we can actually calculate it which did not happen in 2017.
We actually have numbers to go off of we have numbers to go off of we have models I think we're starting to understand this more so yeah I mean that's that's huge I think and you know what here's the other thing is stocks don't have any room to talk right now because they are like. It's the it's the fed is it's not it's not the company anymore it's like or are they going to print more money. Okay so is that what's going on with like the rock robin hood is like the new finance right it's just the file that all the stock like chic ones I can't write like so what what's happening are people like getting their their check from the fed they're seemingly check from the fed and just like oh nothing to do I'm going to robin hood May as well like buy some hurt stock buy some carnival game aside man it's no longer what it once was it no longer is a place to find and discover value it's a place it's turning into a casino which is what finance was like it's turning into something that is separate from reality.
Like the stock market couldn't be more separated from reality right now it's a decent amount of the stock market is at all time highs and 50% of the United States have not has not opened up for business like it's disconnect is huge. I feel like I feel like so I feel like you know to the S&P is like your drunk bro go home. Like we sleep it off sleep it off because we I feel like people in crypto have lived through this we know what drunk looks like because we had 2017 where things were just stupid it was just dumb yeah I thought I thought ETH was going to 20,000 like in six months but you know turns out I was drunk turned out I was drunk at that time right I mean it happens with all markets but I mean how does this end do you think for robin hood traders is this the Fed just keep bailing them out man so so this is what I was talking about with Christian on POV crypto pod the if we were to witness a dollar inflation event or perhaps dare I say hyper inflation event we would see exactly what we have seen so far like inflation shows up in the stock market first and if they keep on printing money because because like you know the another hurts went bankrupt like it's just going to blow up confidence in the whole rest of the system while these particular stocks just moon because stocks are now a savings technology not a way to invest in a company it's just a way to preserve wealth.
But can't the Fed just continue to print the money like forever infinite quantitative easing I mean does that ever run out yeah yeah after after it blows up sure yeah but not before blows up yeah they can keep on printing money as long as people are buying the dollar that's the thing is like they're they also have this interesting position where like there is a global deflation of dollars right like the world wants dollars and so the dollars going up in value and so when they print the dollars actually means more but like it's not going to go up the demand for dollars isn't going to go up forever especially when they're flooding the market like the amount of new dollars in the world is staggering.
Yeah I mean it feels like that's the last thing that's that's you know we talk about kind of debt and you know the 20 trillion in debt that the US is in all of that and but the bigger debt the debt that we are taking out right now is debt against the US's future status as a reserve currency for the world right I feel like you know maybe boomers I love you I love my parents they're great but like it feels like that's the last thing. That the baby boomers are taking is like on their way out it's like well this is the last honey pot we're going to you know it's the reserve currency status of the US dollar now I guess I want to retire in luxury right at least not in poverty right right I guess the saving grace is that you know all the other fiat central banks are doing it do so maybe like everyone's you know playing the same game and so it matters less than the US is doing this right now but I think all of the economic theories like if you look at modern monetary theory and the ability like the idea that we can just continue to print money as long as we keep inflation and check it all seems based on this assumption they all make this core assumption that people the population the citizens of the world don't have another alternative like they don't have another on fiat alternative right right and what if they do and what if they do yeah no that I've heard this from Bitcoin is over and over again is Bitcoin isn't the bubble it's the needle it's it's the thing that pops the bubble and there's no better way to inflate a bubble than money printer go bear yeah absolutely all right bullish yeah you know what David we should talk about our our second round of sponsors so want to talk about ramp so ramp is a fantastic way to do fiat on ramp so if you are a DeFi app developer one of the biggest pain points you probably have is when the the user goes and tries to do a transaction in Ethereum and doesn't have funds doesn't have any teeth to pay for the gas so ramp solves that in like five minutes one of your users can get access to fiat right in their account connects directly to their bag account so it's super easy it's a magic experience and it's one of the biggest pain points that DeFi needs to solve so check them out in the YouTube notes go to ramp dot network for more info on ramp the coolest thing about the bankless nation is that it knows no borders and so if you want to store your money and your wealth on in the bankless nation on Ethereum you should absolutely get a get an account set up with monolith because monolith will spin you up a smart contract wallet and then they will also give you a DeFi Visa card and Visa is basically a accepted all over the world but instead of using dollars in your bank account it uses die in your smart contract wallet so you can go from country to country when coronavirus is over and we're all doing that you can go from country to country place to place hop on a plane and swipe your Visa card and it will still use the same die smart contract wallet on Ethereum because the bankless nation knows no borders so go to monolith dot XYZ and sign up and get your DeFi card today very cool alright man so that was topic one second topic we want to talk about yeah big topic big topic too let's move so second one we want to talk about is crypto in the internet so I know recently David we've been comparing crypto to nation states a lot and you've got your second article coming out shortly on that which has kind of a similar table as this like with nation states but there's another comparison we can we can make and that's comparing crypto to the internet protocol the communication protocol it was really interesting to me so just last week Ethereum hit a hundred million bank accounts you know I say bank accounts but but what I'm talking about is eath addresses right so a hundred million eath addresses created on this new protocol this new value protocol this new settlement layer it took the internet until about from from 1991 to 2006 to get to a hundred million websites now I know those apples in orders they're kind of different but those numbers like feel significant anyway right like you can you can see sort of the network effect and the saturation of that and so I was thinking a lot about the comparison of the internet as a communication protocol that's really what it is versus what crypto is bringing and crypto is really it's it's part of the internet right like so crypto and the internet they're not different things what crypto is basically is adding a another layer to the internet so the internet was all about communication another realm right another like property that the internet previously didn't have so the internet is all about global distributed permissionless credibly neutral communication right so we saw that and everything that was built on top of it email and social media and you know even like e-commerce lists are things but crypto is doing to value what the internet did to communication it's a different protocol and it's layering that on top of the internet and there's a lot of different a lot of different parallels I mean do you see this too yeah yeah absolutely and it makes it makes a ton of sense and it fills a missing gap that the internet has always had right and there's even the web three movement the web three movement is kind of nebulously defined and I kind of I I there's the internet of value which can be considered as well as the web three but also the web three movement is also about rebuilding the web to which is like taking the internet the old internet systems the communication digital media attention economy and rebuilding it in the crypto land but using the crypto money systems at the bottom and I'm really excited about that marriage but what you're talking about Ryan is like the correlates between every single thing that has made up the web to movement and how you can find an equal network for what it does when we had it mar from from Argent on on the bank list podcasts we talked about how like the Argent wall is kind of could be like the net scape browser but for crypto where the net scape browser that you know the the internet before the browser came around was this very dense and difficult to navigate system and the browser made it usable it made it sexy to use and that's really what we see like the Argent wall doing with with Ethereum and DeFi right it like it makes the experience easy it's it's a it's a it's a sexy UI UX on top of DeFi on top of crypto and then you can you can make all these same comparisons for all these different you know actions that you've made here and and I think they they they we say it's an apples to oranges comparison because it has to be but it's the best it's the best apples apples comparison that we can also come up with yeah yeah apples and oranges you know the both are fruit so you can't compare that's what we're doing I mean but one one of the big things I feel like folks in the crypto space or in the blockchain space one of the big mistakes they made early on is looking at the wrong metrics right they they they came at this thing from a internet world from like a web one web two world and so even when they were like in the early phases measuring success in networks like Ethereum they were measuring it's still in like how many daily active users do you have right like how many views do you have oh I mean there's only a thousand only a thousand people using maker like that's a thousand addresses that's nothing it's just but those a thousand dresses each of those addresses could be a bank account right essentially that has millions tens of millions in value in it and like they were measuring the success of crypto by internet metrics when they should have been measuring the success of crypto by crypto metrics so like the metrics are value liquidity volume that's the real you know currency that's that's the real thing that you're you're seeking you're not seeking attention anymore it's not the attention economy this is like the the money economy the value economy so it's different so you have to look at everything in crypto with that orientation absolutely you can't you can't use the internet metrics in order to compare it so now we do need people right like we do need daily active users to some degree like if crypto and Ethereum and the bank was world ends up being just like you know 50,000 people and that's it like that's not that great like we do need those stars right that's not great but the way that that we get daily active users is by getting you know volume liquidity money total value we get that first because those getting pumping those numbers up is what makes these systems operate better for a wider audience and so it's got to be the the volume the liquidity numbers that get up first because that's what attracts the daily active users the daily active users doesn't bring the liquidity the liquidity brings the daily active users yeah for sure and I do think that we are starting to realize this like like two years ago I was talking about this and it's maddening to me where people were talking about like maker being a failure because there are only a few thousand users on it and you know the people are probably still saying makers are failure but right so so maybe but like it's crazy to me because what you should be looking at what we're starting to look at now is like like DeFi pulse so value locked in DeFi that's huge right and then like loan originations so the way to look at the success of maker is how much loans did it originate oh wow you know turns out it's already originated like 2.
4 billion in loans right it took um lending tree like peer-to-peer lending credit like you know five years to reach 250 million right it's like whoever like asks Wells Fargo how many daily active users do you have like that's a nonsensical question it's a stupid how many times do you open up your bank account like hopefully not very often yeah it's a it's a very internet like Silicon Valley question and we need to be starting to look at this through the lens of finance so I think we're doing that more uh but man two years ago it was a mess and uh hopefully people continue to look at this as a protocol for value and not um yeah not a protocol for attention and communication it's totally different absolutely absolutely all right man anything to add to that or should we discuss topic three let's let's move on all right so we we'd not discuss this all right so I put out a tweet um last week a week and a half ago or so I said uh and this is a little snarky you know this Twitter's fun what's the security cap on your blockchain I mean supply cap same thing so what I was saying there is basically there is this relationship that bitcoiners do not acknowledge between um the the the the fixed cap of their issuance policy of 21 million and that also being a security cap so if you you fix the issuance of your monetary policy right by definition you're also fixing the amount of security budget that that you're providing so it was a little you know snarky it's like you know I think I was maybe triggered by somebody who was uh celebrating um fixed cap as like the best thing without looking at the trade-offs of fixed cap but then you jumped in you were like oh bad take Ryan I said oh don't like this one yeah yeah exactly so so tell me why don't you like it so what's um let's talk about I think it's because maybe I'm taking it literally um and and maybe you don't mean it's just quite in such a literal sense but like the the security of a blockchain doesn't doesn't come from its issuance right uh not just that it can um however if you take it literally uh like when bitcoin reaches maturity it has 21 million and it is captain not issuing anymore like it is still going to have people paying for its security so like the security the where you get security doesn't come from only issuing um issuing the currency and it also comes from transaction fees is that what you're saying yes it also comes from transaction fees right and we also are are going to see that dynamic play out in Ethereum as well right and so in in Ethereum 2.
0 when they're starting when there's a bunch of uh total uh transactions per per time and those transactions are being burned in eip1559 those transactions those that are paying the fees are going to burn ether which makes it more scarce which means that when we issue ether that the that each ether is more valuable which increases the security and so it's there's there's a yin and a yang here there's like the issuance and then there's the fees uh and you also get security from fees and fees are really really important in the long-term security because if you are only relying on issuance then the the value of your asset is going to go down which means you have to issue more to make that make up that same security which means you have to issue more which means you have to issue more which then just totally ruins the whole value of your of your asset and so the more you can actually get security from your fees the better because that means you actually have to issue less all right well that's a little disappointing because I thought we were going to like disagree on this or something but um yeah I um yeah yeah yeah so exactly I mean I think the tweet wasn't a a complete thought on that right it wasn't um you know it didn't didn't say but if your network successfully transitions to receiving you know security budget from transaction fees then everything's okay which is like the addendum to that um I do I don't you know I think you share this but I don't know like do you share the concern that so um what what bitcoin is doing it's got to cross this castle right um in people like hasu and the bitcoin community talked about this by the way we're having hasu on the podcast um tomorrow we're going to put that out next week uh so catch that guys we're going to talk about this issue um but but so he recognizes the issue here is bitcoin because of its monetary policy has to move from a security budget that's paid for by issuance so the mimetic power of the bitcoin is is gold meme right that's like really strong for for bitcoin so it's got to move from a uh a security budget that's paid for by that in all of its strengths to a security budget that's paid for just pure demand for its block space and what can you do with bitcoin block space right now um the thing you can do with bitcoin block space primarily is move bitcoin like that's that's it and so if everybody's holding no one wants to move a lot of bitcoin right or like I'm not saying that they're uh that bitcoin's economic like its security budget will collapse to zero just that it's very likely with that sort of a monetary policy uh an issuance policy that it will be exceeded by another network that doesn't make those right trade-offs right right because if you look at if you look at Ethereum right now um it it feels like it's on a trajectory for a flipping in terms of block space demand like Ethereum blocks are more useful I mean why because you can put stable coins on them you can you know run compound transactions you can vote on got there you do tons of things with them and um you know its block space might be in higher demand than than bitcoin so it's kind of you know playing to its strengths anyway I just see that as a mostly unacknowledged trade-off in the bitcoin space when they're talking about the virtues of fixed supply so even the most avid bitcoins will say like either bitcoin works completely or it doesn't uh and there's no there's no middle ground uh and that's to say like either the transaction fees become enough or they don't and what worries me is like the communicated narrative the communicated value proposition is that you can buy and hold bitcoin forever and just store it and and that'll be enough for you but it never ever talks about like and you need to like have block space to band nowhere in the bitcoin narrative is there room for um that room for increasing the demand of the block space bitcoin is just kind of assume that the the block space will be in demand if the asset is valuable which is like it's an it's an okay assumption so long as we are aware that we are assuming it and the difference between bitcoin and ethereum is like ethereum reprioritizes things it says that we are going to put security first and we are going to do our best to make our block space in demand and so that we are no matter what there is no you know binaryness in the success of ethereum it will rise or sink to the level of its success and so that and and bitcoin it does this hard it's hard hard plant of the flag and say 21 million hard cap and people are going to love that 21 million hard caps so much that it is going to ultimately make the system extremely successful to the point that it means itself into existence by generating enough fees and ethereum is doing the opposite where it says we are going to make our block chain so incredibly secure that everyone will uh believe in its existence into the future no matter what and then that will create value in the asset and so we're doing these same things but like for me the existence of ethereum into the long term distant future seems more secure because that is what the goal of ethereum is and I think that is the right priorities whereas bitcoin you kind of have to take it on faith and ingrained in the in the social contract of bitcoin is that you don't talk about how it couldn't fail because that also increases the likelihood of it working so it's the responsibility to do that if you doubt you decrease the security of bitcoin if you doubt don't be a doubter you can't you can't doubt you can't doubt okay so so here's something interesting is right so um I mean we just talked about the digital nation analog right we're compared um crypto to mostly we compared it to the nation state right yeah and you did right so what about a digital religion they're both it's definitely both and there is a different and difference in balance right I would say ethereum is closer to a nation state and bitcoin is closer to a religion that's interesting right because you do have many aspects of a religion with these digital nations as we've called them in particular bitcoin right but you just you just were used words like you got to take it on faith right and there's definitely profits so we were talking um on twitter just last week uh Gavin and Dreson like he tweeted something about ethereum um he's clearly a fan uh and we said hey Gavin yeah and he by the way for folks you don't know he's one of the OGs he's like he was like the third guy second no he was second right it's like he's a totally out of the kingdom of the kingdom to Gavin right he was like he was like you're the number one like you know continue this without me I've got other things to do so but but we said Gavin you should come on the like podcast come on bank list let's talk about bridging bitcoin ethereum the very first you know tweet after that when they got the most likes from the bitcoin community uh somebody goes oh no Gavin's not not a bitcoin pointer like he's not a bitcoin anymore no he failed the purity test right like he's he's out he's ostracized it's like it's like the it's like the church it's like a religion saying like you no longer believe the canon of acceptable beliefs right therefore you're you're out you have to keep everything pure you have to keep the faith pure you have to keep it so so but you know that's both a I think a weakness but also weirdly a strength huge bitcoin huge okay so so you're saying a limit on its scale however you cannot scale the bitcoin community that way why well we need a whole bunch of people who are going to like be dogmatic enough to exactly yeah and then and then be the followers to believe in that but I want to make a distinction because you don't need the bitcoin blockchain and the growth of the bitcoin blockchain can be independent from the growth and scale of the bitcoin community so the bitcoin chain can still grow and serve the needs of the world it's just the bitcoin community can't scale because of how dogmatic it is yeah if I if I hold bitcoin I don't have to be a maximalist who believes all of these things right I don't have to be I don't have to be I don't have to be I don't have to be a dick I can like but I can just hold it right it's like it's like independent of that but so but you think that's interesting do you think Ethereum would be better off if it injected a bit more religion yeah um maybe perhaps I kind of like Ethereum where it is um it does that limit it's you know here's here's a counterpoint does but actually does that limit Ethereum's scale I don't think so because I think in the same way that nation states eventually assumed religion that like the fundamentals of Ethereum will eventually take over the role of faith right and what you and I have been doing and and all the people that have been like ethos money ethos money ethos ethos value go up we have been trying to get the fundamentals based side of Ethereum to like be a little bit more religious but at the same time I would rather lead with fundamentals because fundamentals are facts and facts you cannot just prove uh and so I I put facts above faith all the time and I think the the doing that in your crypto nation is also the right way to do things well we'll see I mean I do think that these are these uh these kind of different visions and different experiments that are that are playing out and um you know Nassim Talab has talked about the value of intolerant minority that's very much what I see uh in their ability by the way it just takes like one to three percent of the population to be an intolerant minority to like bring about major change right and as long as they're allowed right because they are allowed they are steadfast and they are immutable they will not change uh and in some ways oddly though I can't get there like because it's just not how I'm wired um oddly that's a weird strength for Bitcoin and um you know it's something I'm just in the process of wrapping my head around but um get to see how it plays out David I think we hit all three subjects man this is going to good first state of the nation first state of the nation state of the nation is bullish all right so what do we do it state of nations bullish uh we're going to be releasing this every Tuesday sometime during Tuesday and then when's it going to come out on the podcast we're going to put it out Wednesday Thursday yeah let's we can do it let's do it Wednesday Wednesday morning that's great that's it that's it state of the nation guys um you're one action item we went over that comp opportunity uh we will include that in the in the show notes uh so you can take a look at how much you can make in comp tokens right now by depositing some assets uh this has been Ryan Sean Adams David Hoffman signing off state of the nation episode one fantastic success thanks