Justin Drake is a researcher at the Ethereum Foundation and is leading the charge of applied cryptography to the Ethereum network. This is the third time Justin has come on the podcast.
If you haven't yet, dive into our first two episodes with Justin, 'The Bull Case for Cryptography' and 'Ultra Sound Money.' This episode rolls out how we can understand Ultra Sound Money using data-driven models.
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ 🎖 CLAIM YOUR BADGE: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/-guide-2-using-the-bankless-badge ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
💰 GEMINI | FIAT & CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
🔀 BALANCER | EXCHANGE & POOL ASSETS https://bankless.cc/balancer
👻 AAVE | LEND & BORROW ASSETS https://bankless.cc/aave
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING http://bankless.cc/uniswap
------ 📣 DHARMA | From Dollars to DeFi in a Tap! https://bankless.cc/dharma ------ State of the Nation #44: Modeling Ultra Sound Money Guest: Justin Drake
This is Justin's third appearance on Bankless. His first, The Bull Case for Cryptography, went in-depth into cryptographic hashes and digital signatures, the basic tools used to build blockchains. The second, Ultra Sound Money, presented a thematic overview for the Ethereum economic engine. In this episode, we model Ultra Sound Money and what upcoming upgrades to Ethereum mean for issuance, supply, and staking vs. mining.
Justin recently released four models cover the granular data-driven details of what Ultra Sound Money Means. These models deal with Ether's three main cashflows: Issuance, Supply, and Collateral. Justin argues that with the massive efficiency improvements to the Ethereum Network with Proof-of-Stake, Ether issuance will decrease by upwards of 90% and will proportionally reduce sell pressure from miners. He posits that ETH's peak supply will be 120M total Ether, and EIP-1559's burning mechanism will eventually reduce the total supply of ETH down to 100M.
Justin also expects the APR for staking Ethereum to be 25% following the Ethereum 2 merge. We visualize what these numbers mean by combining the Ethereum Economic Engine metaphor, Triple Point Asset thesis, and viewing capital as having an inherent temperature. Cold ETH means that it is locked up, securing the network and/or reducing total liquid supply. Hotter ETH is that which is actively available for use, but much of this ETH is vaporized through EIP-1559's fee burn mechanism. Therefore, on both ends of the temperature spectrum, supply & issuance are optimized via staking and fee burn.
Every episode with Justin is a deep exploration of the technicals that back Ethereum's memes of being a Triple Point Asset and Ultra Sound Money. However, understanding the models Justin lays out is cause for optimism on Ethereum's future as a vastly improved economic system. The State of the Nation this week is 'Ultra Bullish' – dive in to find out why.
------ Resources:
Model #1: ETH peak supply model https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ZN444__qkPWPjMJQ_t6FfqbhllkWNhHF-06ivRF73nQ/edit#gid=0
Model #2: The road to 100m ETH supply https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XmeYkWEmaaZEUZ078A-lolchzNUrnlUllLkVXSGPzAU/edit#gid=0
Model #3: Net buy pressure https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TsrdbdusUop4NJbvjGBbOWTUwYH-Jgg1QBkQ5CtY_-k/edit#gid=0
Mode #4: staking APR with EVM fee rewards https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1FslqTnECKvi7_l4x6lbyRhNtzW9f6CVEzwDf04zprfA/edit#gid=0
The Bull Case for Cryptography https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-moon-math-the-bull-case-for-cryptography
Ultra Sound Money https://shows.banklesshq.com/p/-ultra-sound-money-justin-drake
Justin on Twitter https://twitter.com/drakefjustin?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
All right, bankless nation. Welcome to another state of the nation episode. David, what are we talking about today? What's the theme? We are modeling out ultra sound money. We put out the episode with Justin Drake a while ago. And so now we are getting Justin Drake back on to the show to get into the granular details of what makes ultra sound money, ultra sound money. There are numbers to discuss. And so we are going to discuss all of them. There are numbers to discuss. There are models to discuss. There are four different pieces to this. David, you tweeted this out pre-episode. And we're going to get into all of them.
25% staking, annualized, eight terms, and each supply. Maybe it peaks at 121 million. And never gets higher than 120 million. This is 120 million and comes back down. Long-term ETH supply target, possibly 100 million. So that's the coming down part. And the potential for sell pressure to be reduced by 90% Justin Drake has brought the models behind some of those astounding facts that I think very few people have actually looked into. I mean, the first exposure to EIP 1559 and to the merge, the staking merge in a comprehensive way, I feel like was almost the podcast that we did with Justin and ultra sound money.
Now that was very metaphor driven, that was very high level to help people understand the narrative. Now this is the supporting data. This is the supporting numbers, the supporting financial projections behind all of this. So I'm super excited to dig into this. And David, all time high ETH coincidence? I don't know. I think not, sir. I think I knew this episode was coming. I choose to believe that as well. All right, David, what's new in the community before we get to Justin? Gotta talk about badges. If you are a bankless premium member, pick up your badge. We've been saying it for two weeks.
Definitely do it. Pick up your badge. This is the week. We're doing more raffles this week. So check your email for that email from Lucas at banklesshq.com. If you have issues with that email support at banklesshq.com. Also, David, we've got a killer episode coming up on Monday. You want to just give a taste of what we're going to cover in that episode? Yeah, this this episode makes them very, very bold claims. We like to make bold claims on the bankless podcast, but this one is brand brand new. Joshua Rosenfall, who is probably a name that most people don't aren't familiar with, but he is a historian of European art, money, wealth, history.
And we make the claim that we are on the cusp of a digital renaissance that is equal to or larger than what the renaissance that came in the 1400s. And the connections here are in the 1400s. We invented the Gutenberg printing press. Thank you. And also double entry bookkeeping. And in the modern day, the printing press is now the modern day internet and the modern day double entry bookkeeping is blockchain. And that actually is unlocking a brand new renaissance, a crypto renaissance. And he did a fantastic job just going through the history and drawing the parallels. We talk about renaissance meme culture.
The meme culture actually started perhaps in the 1400s. We talked about the parallels between Martin Luther and Satoshi. And we talk about what so cool, so cool. And so there's a lot of awesome throughlines here. And it's actually one of already been one of my favorite episodes come out of the bank. When we were recording that, David, I had just like goose bumps almost almost the entire time when Joshua speaking, just talking about these these various parallels between the kind of the old renaissance and this renaissance. Be sure to check that out, bankless nation, as well. David, Dharma is still cooking some things up.
They wanted us to let you know that they have now ruled the Dharma app out. They have a direct connection to your bank account in all 50 states in the US. And David, when people ask me about DeFi, especially my friends who don't know much about them, I'm increasingly pointing them to start with the Dharma app because that is a great onboarding experience. Direct from their bank account to DeFi in one tap. Super cool. Anything else you want to say about Dharma? Yeah, we know retail season is coming and Dharma is probably the best place to send retail who are still looking for like that kind of tradify experience of like, you know, just good UX, but it's DeFi in the back, right?
And so one tap, one tap separates you between your dollars in your bank account and ultrasound money on Ethereum. Oh, Dharma.io guys, check that out, download the app. All right, David, I'm going to ask you the question I ask at the beginning of every state of the nation. What is the state of the nation today, sir? The state of the nation, it was going to be bullish, right? But we've been but we've used that before and I was chatting with Justin before the show and he asked him for inspiration ideas about what the state of the nation is and he said ultra bullish. And so the state of the nation today is ultra bullish.
As you can see, if you go and look at the ETH price chart and as well, what will be an ultra bullish episode coming to your ears in just a moment. It was crazy, dude. I have two emails waiting for me. One is a 80 page report on a why ether is sound money and the other is an institutional report. These just came out today. An institutional report, I should say, around ether as an asset, ultra bullish that the narrative is spreading both in institutional side and the story of ether the asset is spreading among analysts, too. So I've got tons of reading to do, but like it's all ultra bullish news and it all feeds back to what Justin presented to us the first time around with ultrasound money, right?
So much of those reports tie into the ultra sound money thesis. And so, you know, tip of the hat to Justin for really pioneering this message and I'm absolutely stoked to bring him onto the podcast in here in a second. This is what bankless is doing, helping to develop the narrative layer, the meme layer, also helping to spread the education of what these bankless systems are doing in the real world. We're going to get to Justin in just a minute, but before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Bankless is proud to be supported by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure.
Instead of a cumbersome orderbook system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum, which is what Ryan and I call a money robot. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. Something brand new in the Uniswap ecosystem is the Uniswap Grants program is now accepting applications for grants. We have been saying this for a while and we'll say it again. Dows have money and they are in need of labor. If you think that you have something to contribute to the Uniswap Dow, apply for a grant to Uniswap.
Just look at the size of the Uniswap Treasury. It's almost $3 billion. This mountain of capital is looking for labor. Do you have something of value to contribute to the Uniswap Dow? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a unigrant at unigrants.org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. That's exactly what we did to get Uniswap to be a sponsor for Bankless and you can do the same for your project. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring Bankless. Bouncer is DeFi's most powerful automated market maker. Typical AMMs just have two tokens inside of one liquidity pool, which can lead to fractured liquidity across the many pairs in DeFi.
With Bouncer, you can access the full power of multiple tokens inside of one single AMM, which unlocks an entirely new playing field of possibility. This makes Bouncer an awesome building block for so many different use cases. Bouncer pools can make asset indexes, but instead of paying fees to portfolio managers, Bouncer lets you collect fees from traders who use your portfolio for liquidity. Additionally, Bouncer smart pools can be programmed to have properties that change according to predetermined rules, such as changing the swap fee based on market conditions, or even liquidity bootstrapping pools, which can help you launch and distribute your token with day one liquidity.
At Bankless, we used a liquidity bootstrapping pool to sell our BAP t-shirts to much success. Bouncer V2 brings powerful new features that makes your money work even harder for you. In V2, idle tokens are capable of generating yield in DeFi without sacrificing liquidity in the pool. To top things off, Bouncer is reimbursing all gas costs with valve rewards, meaning that all your gas costs are returned to your wallet with the Bouncer governance token. Bouncer's mission is to become the primary source of liquidity in DeFi, right, providing the most flexible and powerful platform for asset management and decentralized exchange.
Dive into the Bouncer pools at cools.balancer.exchange. Bankless Nation, welcome back. We have Justin Drake back on the podcast again. This is the third podcast video show recording that we are doing with Justin. He, of course, is an Ethereum researcher. He was on two podcasts with us previously. One is on ultrasound money. The other was on cryptography, both incredibly important episodes for you to listen to and understand part of the bankless canon now. Justin, how are you doing today? Doing great. We are excited about this episode and we're going to be sharing some models that you put together in a few minutes around some of the concepts that we really dove into quite deeply in the ultrasound money podcast.
We're going to put some numbers behind some of the concepts we were talking about. But before we do, I feel like we need to maybe ground the audience again in understanding ether as an asset. Of course, we talked about the properties that are coming online for ether soon, in particular, EIP 1559, which adds a fee-burn component and also the advent of full proof of stake and the shutting off of proof of work we're calling that the merge. Those are all important concepts in the case for ultrasound money. But there's also another analogy that I think bankless listeners are familiar with that we want to want to get into here.
And that is the analogy of eth as a triple point asset that David and I have used so often before. And the concept of eth as a triple point asset is similar to sort of the states of matter that people might have learned about in science, I don't know, seventh grade science, eighth grade science, wherever you've learned about that, perhaps lower as well. And the concept is that matter can be one of three states. It can be a solid, it can be a liquid, and it can be a gas. And either as an asset can also be one of three states. It can be a solid, so it can be staked as a capital asset. It can also be liquid, so it can be used as a money.
And it can also be used as a gas, so it can be used as a combustible consumption good to purchase ether block space. So that is the triple point asset thesis and the triple point asset model for money, which which we have used. And it's kind of cool because it maps very directly to the asset super classes like an asset can either be a capital asset or a money or a commodity and ether can be all three of those. You have now extended that metaphor a little bit with a new analogy, adding sort of this this temperature dimension to ether as a triple point asset. Can we start there? Can we dig into that?
So tell us about the temperature analogy you wanted to share with the bankless community. Yeah, so I think the the temperature metaphor is as you said, a generalization of the triple point asset. So not only can we look at the individual state of let's say water that will represent money, ether, but we can look at more fine grain temperatures. So, you know, for example, money you could have money as a long time investment, which is kept cold in fridge, so that's kind of cold money. Or you could have hot money which is, for example, if you're a day trader or if you're in exchange processing lots of withdrawals and deposits in a hot wallet.
And I think the reason why this this temperature of money metaphor is useful in the context of ultrasound money is that really there's there's three big consequences of EIP 1559 and the merge and they each affect a different state of water. So, there's one kind of innovation that improves the kind of liquid money as it were. There's one of which improves the characteristics of the solid money and one that improves the characteristics of gas money. And one of the interesting things I guess is that as you say, Ethereum is this unique asset. It's a triple point asset in the sense that in addition to being this money in this narrow band, you know, between zero degree Celsius and a hundred degree Celsius, it's capable of breaking boundaries, which were not previously broken.
So, it can break down the zero degree and kind of freeze itself, but it can also break down the one hundred degree kind of threshold and vaporize. So, you know, that's the analogy of having gas and literally vaporizing it just like you would vaporize gasoline when you consume it. It leaves the system into the ether. So, yeah, looking forward to kind of explain what are these three key changes to the cash flows. Right. So, in the previous episode, we had the energy metaphor. Right. We had energy in the form of electric energy going through the various components. And the reason why I chose the electricity metaphor is because I wanted to focus on the components.
Right. There was these three components. There was the battery. There was the engine. There was a solar panel. But here, I really want to focus on the asset and on the cash flows. And as you said, I think this this episode is all about modeling the cash flows and understanding how big they are and how they circulate. And what are the consequences, maybe for total supply, what are the consequences in terms of cell pressure, et cetera, et cetera. So, Justin, let's hash out this temperature metaphor, just a little bit more. So, we have ether as a capital asset. We have ether as a store of value, and we have ether as a transformable, consumable asset.
How do these map on to the three phases of matter? Right. So, maybe the easiest one to understand is the solid state. Right. So, when you have ether and you lock it, you're essentially freezing it because you really reducing the velocity of money, you're putting it in deep freeze. And one great example of this is staking in the context of the beacon chain. Right. When you want to on-stake, there's a defrosting period, if you will. A thawing period, right. A thawing period, exactly, thank you. And, you know, we're also seeing this in the context of defy, right, with where you have the notion of total value locked, like the locked at the L kind of suggests that there's some freezing going on.
You know, it's a spectrum like different defy applications might have different temperatures. So, for example, you know, uniswap might be, you know, somewhere maybe close to the freezing point or, you know, just past the freezing point in the sense that the ether in uniswap technically can be removed with a single transaction. And actually, if you want to sell ERC-20, for if, you know, you can do that immediately. But what we've observed kind of on the holistic standpoint is that the collateral is sticky, right. So, we did have things like the vampire attack with sushi swap, where liquidity would go from one place to another, but it still stayed within the realm of dexes or the realm of defy.
If you look at, you know, total value locked on defy balls, it just goes up, up only. We also can talk about the metaphor of MakerDow, right. So, like, ether is collateral inside of MakerDow. And in theory, you know, ether in MakerDow is also just one transaction away from becoming liquid on the secondary markets. But as a, when we look at a systems level perspective, MakerDow has three over three billion dollars worth of dye, preventing that ether from becoming thought, right. So, that ether in MakerDow is stuck behind a three billion dollar dye supply that is keeping that ether being used as a cold store of value.
It's frozen in its place, right. And so, in the ether in MakerDow, it will be frozen ether, very cold ether, right. Not liquid, not available to the secondary market, and definitely not being burned because it's not being used as transaction money. It's just cold ether frozen, right. Yeah, that's exactly right. I mean, if you place your ether as collateral and you take a dye loan, for example, to buy a car or to buy a house, right. Your income is going to allow you to gradually repay that loan, but you know, it might take a decade for you to repay your maker loan. So, if we're painting the holistic picture here, right.
So, we're almost looking at this whole spectrum of like temperature mapping to ether the asset. And on the far left side of this spectrum, what we're talking about is ether, if we're thinking of ether as like, say water, it's below zero degrees Celsius. So, it is frozen, but there are degrees of how frozen it can be. And I'm guessing that you might say a Justin that like the far side, the coldest ether can actually get is when it's staked, right. That is like sort of, it's not slushy. It's not in this in-between area. It's like deep freeze, very cold, locked inside of the staking contract, and maybe ether locked in D5 might be a little right to that.
So, it might be like negative 10 degrees Celsius or so, and getting close to the thawing point, something like that. So, actually, you can go even more extreme than staking. So, you could, for example, artificially put some sort of time lock on your e if you could say, I'm going to lock my e for 10 years, I'm going to create a smart contract that does that. That's kind of artificial and no one really does it, but inferior you could do it. But there's something that does happen naturally, and that's the process of losing coins or accidentally sending them to the zero address. So, that's kind of zero degrees Kelvin.
It's like maximum negative temperature. And it's interesting because you've taken money and you've made it so cold that you've denatured money, it's no longer money, right? It's technically it's a balance somewhere, but it's no longer money is denatured because if you can't move it anymore, it's frozen forever. And you could say the same thing, for example, for the parity multi-sick wallet. So, there's this very famous bug where there's basically over half a million e if which is provably at zero degrees Kelvin. And yeah, it's basically no longer money. And the interesting thing is that when you go at the opposite end of the spectrum, you have very, very similar behavior because on the on the hot side of things, on the boiling temperatures, you're basically destroying if you're vaporizing it and removing it from the supply.
So, you kind of have this the spectrum and it turns out that on on on each extremes, you have very similar behaviors. You're basically improving the monetary qualities of ether, right? Because on the on the cold side of things, you kind of taking liquidity, like literally liquid liquidity and you're kind of freezing it and slowing it down. And on the other hand, you're kind of vaporizing it and having it leave the supply. And this is kind of a geeky kind of math analogy, but you know, I study mathematics or I'll share it. So, when you do projective geometry, you know, you have you have a line that goes negative infinity, you know, all the way to on that side and that side.
And you introduce this to one point called the point at infinity where basically these two lines meet at the point of infinity. So, you can kind of think of it as a circle and kind of the from a monetary standpoint, the two extremes are really the same places. The same place. And the interesting thing about Ethereum is that you can think of it as a machine to take this liquid money and push it to the extremes. On the one hand, you're incentivizing this liquid money to become frozen. And on the other hand, you have this other mechanism where you're incentivizing this liquid money to vaporize. And so, these are two very strong kind of scarcity engines that will suck out all the liquidity in its liquid states.
And by vaporize, what you're talking about is essentially literally being burnt through EIP 1559. That's that's it becoming vaporized, right? Yeah. So, this is what I mean by vaporized. That's just a trick today. Brought his own sound effects. That was the sound of ether being vaporized in EIP 1559. Okay, so put... Go ahead, Justin. Yeah, post EIP 1559. Every time you make a transaction, you should imagine this sound in your head. And then there's one of three sound effects that we have on standby. And I want to make sure the listeners are up to speed with why we're talking about this temperature metaphor because we're about to go into excel sheets and perhaps talk less about metaphors and talk more about numbers.
But the metaphor is really, really useful to hold in our brains as we model this thing out, both as model with numbers, but also a model for understanding these things. And I think what we just finished on right there is a fantastic through line. We have... Me, I'm picturing like a cylinder, like a test tube cylinder, and we have the hot water at the top, and we have the frozen water at the bottom, and then the liquid water in the middle, right? And that composes like the ethereum system as a whole, right? The boiling water up up at the top, which is the ether being used as transaction fees, and then some of that being vaporized and leaving the system.
And then also we have ether being deep in deep, deep freeze state, you know, in cryo, at the very, very bottom, which is ethlocked in defy and eth being staked. And the met of the through line here is that currently in ethereum, we have a very, very liquid center. And there's not that much boiling off the top, and there's not that much frozen at the bottom. But that's what is all about to change when we introduce EIP1559, which really starts to turn on the boiler at the top, and a lot of ether is being vaporized up at the top. And we all also introducing staking, which is freezing a lot of ether at the bottom of the cylinder, but I incentivize the ether to be locked locked in the staking contract.
And then there's also something to talk about with being locked in defy. That's like the slushy ether that half melted, half not. But what's really changing is that this liquid center, where there is a, what Justin, you've called a fire hose of water being being added into the system, which is ether issuance from proof of work, is actually going to be constricted into perhaps just a much more modest garden hose. And that liquid center is actually going to become much smaller in relationship to what is being boiled off the top, and what is being frozen down at the bottom. And so this temperature frame of reference is we're going to come back to this throughout the rest of this episode as we talk about some of these numbers, more explicit numbers as we model out ultrasound money.
Justin, do you want to add anything to that? Yeah, so I kind of want to highlight the three cash flows that are, I think, important for this discussion. The first cash flow you mentioned it is issuance. So issuance is you have just new liquidity that comes out of the sky. And right now it's a huge amount of issuance. It's like, as you said, it's this fire hose of liquidity. And you know, the market has to bear with it. It's like this huge amount of cell pressure. It's costly to run proof of work. One of the big innovations of proof of stake is what I call economic efficiency in the previous protocol, we're reducing by, let's say, 10x, the cost of consensus.
So that's cash flow number one issuance. Cash flow number two is related to this warm side, this hot side of this spectrum, the burning, it's it's supply, right? So we have a new mechanism to reduce supply. And this is kind of where, you know, ultrasound money came from, right? Because we have deflation. But, you know, really the ultrasound money is a very holistic meme, you know, with strong fundamentals, with many pillars. You know, this deflation aspect is, you know, just one of them, one which is easy to communicate in this kind of catchphrase, you know, if Bitcoin sound money, then if it's ultrasound money.
So that's cash flow number two, supply, cash flow number one with issuance. Now, cash flow number three is basically the if as collateral and like how much if will be drawn out from this liquid center and kind of frozen. And basically what we have here is when, when we have the merge, the transaction fees will be in two parts. One of it, one part will be burnt. We've already talked about this, but another part, which is the tip, is not burnt. And that goes directly to the validators. And so that will go, that will increase the, the staking APR. And that's basically going to increase the power of the freezer, right?
We're going to go from minus five degrees to minus 10 degrees. Or I guess, you know, the APR could be like the degrees that you're targeting. So we're going to set it, let's say, a minus 25 degrees, right? So that's a 25% APR. And it's going to be so cold that it's going to like freeze like a lot of the neighboring liquidity. So yeah, these are the three cash flows that we could highlight one by one. Before we get to all of that. So can we talk about the part that we haven't talked about in depth, very much, which is sort of this liquid piece, right? In the middle. So we talked about the free side that is steak, teeth, frozen, teeth, eth, yeast and collateral.
We talked about the burn side that is it being vaporized by EIP 1559. And of course, we use that analogy of new liquidity is coming into the system via issuance right now. And right now, there's a lot of issuance, like 4.2% or something issuance annualized per year is coming into this squishy middle part. There's not a lot staked and there's nothing being burnt. So we don't have the engine and we don't have the deep freezer. Let's talk about this middle portion because that's mostly what we mean when we talk about money, right? It's kind of liquid. It can be used as a store of value. It can be used as a medium of exchange.
It can be used as a unit of account. It can actually be spent. Is there anything more we need to talk about in this in this liquid phase or do we just need to hear the sound effect Justin? You tell us. Yeah, I think the sound effect is very important. So let's go ahead. This is the liquid phase. Yes. So we have 100 million ether roughly, which is in this liquid phase. If we remove the 3 million ether, sorry, 4 million now in the deposit contract and the ether locked in in DeFi. So we have this 100 million pool, which is slushing. And as you said, ether is used as money in the context of NFTs.
It's used as money in the context of trading into a unit of liquidity on Uniswap. 95% of the volume is this is ether. And one of the interesting things is that this traditional power of being money is what Bitcoin has explored. So you can think of Bitcoin as exploring this range from 0 to 100. And with Ethereum, we can really push the limits as I mentioned. But within this liquid phase, we have all the various use cases for Ethereum, but we have this kind of internality, this externality, I guess, which is that the issuance is this necessary evil that we have to deal with. And it's flooding us and we're drowning in liquidity at the moment.
And this issuance is representing a huge amount of cell pressure. We're talking tens of millions of dollars every day. And so one of the things that one of the things for which we have a spreadsheet is looking at the cell pressure and how much it will be reduced. And we're talking billions of dollars of relief from this cell pressure. Okay guys, so that's the metaphor going into the models. And just quick recap and we'll do it with sound. So right now, Justin, you said there's about 100 million or so of the total supply of ETH. And I don't know the total supply of ETH up top my head, 115 million.
Yes. Okay, let's say 115 million total supply of ETH right now. 100 million is liquid. What does that sound like? That's our 100 million ETH liquid, the vast majority of it, the bulk. Now we're starting to get that's frozen. It's frozen in the staking contract. I'm going to say 6 million or so frozen in the staking contract. We also have some ETH frozen in DeFi, 4 million frozen in the ETH staking contract. Justin's correcting me. We have some ETH in DeFi as well. What does that sound like? So you should imagine like the water becoming ice and I imagine that. I'm also imagining my childhood in the in the cold winters of Canada.
Justin, I get that. All right, so and we have not yet fired up the furnaces. We have not yet started to burn ETH, but remind us again, what's that going to sound like when we start burning? Sizzle. This is going on 15th. VIP 1559. Okay, all right. So that is the setup, guys. Let's dive into the numbers and there are four models that you've put out recently and I think maybe Justin, you could give us some context on why you created these models and how you came up with them. But for those that are watching and listening to this, I'm going to quickly go over them at a high level. One, we're going to look at the ETH peak supply model and you're claiming that ETH peak supply could be 120 million no more than 121 million ETH ever created.
We're at 120 million. 120 million. Yes. I keep saying it's the Bitcoiner in me, Justin. 120 million could be ETH peak supply right now at 115. So we're going to get into that model. That's model one. Model two is the road actually going backward in time, going back in terms of supply. The road back to 100 million because again, we're going to start we're going to start burning ETH and we might be able to reduce over the next decade, 20% of the total supply of ETH. What's that burning sound again, Justin? I've got to hear it. I've got to hear that burn. They're going from vaporizing from 120 million to 100 million.
That's model two. We'll get into model three is we'll get into the net buy pressure. David was talking about we have issuance of about 4.2% that is feeding this fat middle. There's 100 million supply ETH with 4% issuance or so per year. That is getting greatly restricted. We're going to talk about the implications of cell pressure, produced in ether, on Ethereum, by as much as 90%. That's model three. The last model we're going to talk about is the incentive for individuals and for people who own ETH to freeze their ETH. That is a staking APY that is getting massively increased to possibly 25%.
We'll talk about how that's even possible because it's not coming from issuance. It's coming from transaction fees. This is the first time I've actually seen transaction fees added to the revenue cash flows that stakers received. We're going to go through those four models. Before we do Justin, is there anything else? Why did you come up with these models in the first place? Tee these up for us. We've had these big structural changes with EIP 155, nine coming and the merge coming. I wanted to quantify things. I think the big story really of the last few months is that we have one mega cash flow, which is the transaction fees.
That's the root of everything, really, because it unlocks the high APR when you're staking, it unlocks the burn. I just wanted to see what were the numbers because no one was talking about it. One number that I was personally very surprised by was the 25% staking APR. We can talk about the consequences there. In terms of the supply, in my original graphic, which introduced ultrasound money, I had this projected cap, a very conservative cap at two to the 27. I just like powers of two because you don't have to bike shed too much. Two to the 28 was clearly too high. Two to the 26 was clearly too low.
Two to the 27 was the right binary order of magnitude. But people were confused. Why did he choose two to the 27? It's not a good meme number. It's a bit too geeky. Let's try to refine this to the closest million. It turns out we can refine it to the closest 10 million. The spreadsheet suggests that we will never hit 120 million. We'll be able to peak under it. Basically, once we have the merge, the total supply can go down. The reason why I created this spreadsheet, the road back down to 100 million is because 100 million is a nice meme number. It's actually feasible for us to start at 120 and then go back down to 100 million.
The answer is yes. It might take a decade. It might take two decades. It is definitely possible to have the total supply go back down to 100 and 100 million has a bit of historical significance because Vitalik at some point had this reddit post where he was making projections around the difficulty bombing. He said it's possible. We'll never hit 100 million and then we crossed 100 million and then all the bitcoin maxis were like, ha ha, you have no supply cap infinite supply blah blah blah. Well, it's possible all this kind of like the revenge of the 100 million where we're going back to 100 million.
And then the other thing that I actually there was the very first spreadsheet that I created was around the it was actually in preparation for our previous podcast. So the the cell pressure right in the previous podcast, I said that EIP 1559 and the merge combined is is going to be the equivalent in terms of reducing cell pressure of both the depotic contract and grayscale combined. So 7.2 million if annually right. So it's it's it's like a huge amount of of relief in terms of cell pressure that we're going to have from these two kind of economic innovation sci-fi economics the the EIP 1559 and the merge.
Okay, let's let's dive into it now then Justin. This of course is the meme brought to life with with numbers with an actual model of projection of supply and the economic implications what would happen. Let's go to the first model which is a spreadsheet that people will find in the show notes. Of course if you're watching on YouTube, you'll find this in the show notes on YouTube. This is a spreadsheet you put together for a model of ETH peak supply and the claim in this spreadsheet is pretty simple. There may be never there may never be more than 120 million ETH in existence ever. Again, it's back to this diagram.
We might hit a point where we go ultrasound. We grow ETH supply and then it might bend back downward and that point might be 120 million. Can you explain some of the variables behind this scenario and why 120 million is it's kind of it's an estimate of course but it's almost a conservative estimate as well. Get into this for us. Absolutely. So you know the the way that you predict supply is quite easy. You look at the supply today and then you basically add the daily supply and there's various things that will influence the daily issuance. I mean they will influence the daily issuance. So right now the daily issuance is composed of two things.
Number one is the proof-of-work issuance which is about 13,600 it's actually a little bit below that so I've put 13,550 and then we have the daily proof-of-stake issuance which is I think around 800 ETH per day but I put a thousand ETH there in the in the best guess because that's going to be the average between now and and the merge and then there's there's these key key dates that are right so the key date number one is when will EIP 1559 be activated because from that point onwards there's going to be a huge relief in cell pressure because part of the of the fees which will normally go to the miners and be converted into electricity and electricity bills and sold you know it's like a forcing forcefully sold economically is forcefully sold will now instead be burnt and not sold.
So right now the current plan there was announced a few days ago by Tim and the whole crew is 14th of July 2021 but of course you know we could slip you know we've slipped many times and so you know the my my conservative you know date for EIP 1559 is the 14th of August 2021 and the reason why I've put it there is because we actually have to hard fork and the reason we have to hard fork is because there's this difficulty bomb which will stretch the the block times and so it's a necessity and you know at this point in time the devs have extremely high confidence that you know EIP 1559 will go in this in this fork coming up in London.
So just in the variables that really drive the difference between what you're calling the best guess the more leaning conservative guess and the conservative guess are the activation date for EIP 1559 which is targeted for July but could stretch into August possibly maybe likely not later. Also the merge date so that's the date at which proof of work goes away and proof of stake becomes the consensus engine for the entirety of Ethereum. The proof of work issuance that's going to not really an assumption that's pretty like static that's you know definitely baked in. Daily average POS proof of stake issuance that could vary some but that feels pretty pretty secure as an assumption as well.
This other one average daily fee burn so there's kind of a range on that on the conservative side looks like there's an average fee burn of about 3,000 per day ETH per day and on the best guess side it's about 6,000. What are we burning per day right now is it closer to 6,000? Well right now we're not burning excuse me not burning. I met in transaction fees yes. So the 100 day and 30 day and even 7 day moving average are 12,000 ETH per day okay and then the 365 day moving average which is like the really conservative one which spans a very long stretch of time is that 7.5,000 ETH per day but you know as I see it you know the total amount of transaction fees per day is one of these metrics which is quite volatile but directionally it's up only.
So let's say 10,000 ETH per day or the 70% or let's say 60% fee burn then that's how you would arrive at the 6,000 ETH per day. Like the conservative one 3,000 ETH per day I just don't see how it could go below 3,000 ETH per day given that we have 10,000 ETH per day in transaction fees and there's no way you know the fee burn will be 30% and then so Justin based on these assumptions we get a best guess case where we have about 118 call it million ETH in total supply max total supply right because at at at this point in time it's going to start bending down and we're going to start burning more than we're issuing right that's the best guess side of things if you were a bit more conservative we get to a number that's closer to 120 million ETH as the max supply.
Absolutely yeah and the lean conservative is 119 million so yeah I'm expecting we'll peak between 118 million and 100 and 20 million and as you said from the point of the merge until kind of the foreseeable future we will deflate very likely every single day the issuance the supply will go down and down and down and the reason is that proof of stake is so damn efficient right it like you need very very little issuance to run the proof of stake and so like even a moderate amount of transaction fees will more than compensate for for the issuance. Justin is your belief that after EIP 1559 and the merge that there's no way that we are not burning more ether than we are issuing you have you seem like you have complete confidence in that.
Yeah I'm going to say 99% confidence that at the point of the merge we're going down and I have high confidence let's say 95% confidence that for the years to come you know let's say 10 years we're going to be going down pretty much every single day. So this is a massive narrative buster because I think a lot of people have heard the narrative that ETH supplies infinite right that it has no cap right well what's the difference between those narratives and what you're what you're showing in the model because I think people even hearing this are so used to hearing the narrative being told that like ETH is ETH supplies infinite ETH has no no no cap whatsoever ETH will continue to issue more and more into the future.
What's the difference between those narratives and what and and the model here because I think people are still who are hearing this might still have a hard time I guess rationalizing the the difference here because this is not the narrative that is in mainstream like if you know about this I like I'm not sure how many people have actually worked through the numbers and and and have a model like this in their mind but not it has to be not very many so can you talk about that right um so right I think of a given point in time the ETH supply is finite and there's always been a constraint on issuance right at a genesis it started at five ETH per block and we've gone enough you know we've always respected that that constraints you know we've we've gone down you know to three ETH per block and two ETH per block but you know we've we've always been constrained from day one now um the the claim that ETH has no cap is actually technically correct and the reason is that in theory if there was no fever and purely just issuance from proof of stake we would just grow every single year now it turns out that um the with proof of stake you can cap you can you can you can have a a provable cap which which is um under a million if you know we the the plan right now is to basically um cap the rewards beyond um two you know 33 and a half a million ETH stake so beyond that point there won't be any more supply and that represents roughly a a one million ETH um issuance maximum per year but in practice what's likely going to happen is that we're going to be burning significantly more than one million ETH per year at least for the foreseeable future um and so in practice not only are we going to have a finite supply which is a de facto cap it's not in it's not in theory cap but it's de facto cap but it's it's even better than a supply cap it's a decreasing cap and this is where the the ultrasound the ultra comes in I think we get to what we get to do with this narrative where you know many many Bitcoin Maxis will come and say that Ether has no supply cap but now with proof of stake and EIP 1559 we get to say well there there's no supply floor like it could just keep on going down like it could go in the opposite direction and there's nothing to stop it from going locally true isn't it yeah there's no supply floor fantastic yes all right well let's go let's go to the second model here so the first claim was there may never be more than a hundred and twenty one uh 120 million right 120 million ETH and this is the model that that kind of shows it um the second claim is I think equally interesting uh but is is also part of the first claim in that the supply might be going down and it might go down as low as 100 million in a relatively short period of time so walk us through the model where we get to 100 million ETH supply a decrease of like you know uh 20 million from 120 million in 12 years time right so I was asking myself can we reach this meme number of 100 million ETH in supply and basically there's three key you know parameters or assumptions that you need to set the first one is how much ETH is being staked and here you can take kind of the the maximally conservative approach which is to say we're going to have the 33.
5 million ETH which is the the maximum amount of ETH um you know in terms of of issuing rewards the second assumption is the the daily EVM fees in the long term right so right now we're roughly order banking to where it's 10,000 ETH per day in transaction fees now I mentioned you know there's good reasons to believe that um the fees uh total fees is up only by the way when I say total fees I don't mean the gas price right I mean the gas price multiplied by a number of transactions so you know we can have our cake and eat it too because we can have low gas price and lots of transactions with scalability and have this this high daily EVM fees and then there's this third parameter which assumption which will be removed once we have ETH 1559 which is what is the fee burn percentage right we're doing 10,000 ETH per day roughly how much of that is burned is it 70% 7,000 ETH per day is it more is it less um and it turns out that it doesn't really matter too much the ballpark is is correct if it's if it's slightly more it's it's good because we're we're deflating faster we're reducing supply um if it's slightly less then that's also good because it means the highest taking APR um for for the for the validators which you know means more um more ETH that gets frozen so either way we win um kind of the the the really important number I guess this this this the daily EVM fees a long term and so like if we plug in the numbers you know you're welcome to plug in your own numbers but my best guess is we're gonna have 30 million ETH stake long term we're gonna have at least 10,000 ETH per day and we're gonna have a fee burn percentage of roughly 70% and that gives us about 12, 12 years to kind of go down from 120 million ETH down back down to 100 million so basically to vaporize 20 million ETH if it will take 12 years this best guess of 10,000 ETH being burned per day that's actually where we currently are in in right now in EVM fees and so not only is that what you're saying your best guess is but like we've actually already checked that box in theory according to current Ethereum gas demand is that right that is correct um I mean the the gas market as I can be quite volatile you know it depends on on things like um you know what is the activity happening on Ethereum it depends on what the volatility is or the market it also depends on on competitors you know maybe some new blockchain project comes out out there which is so much better than Ethereum and all your users migrate away um there's many different factors that will influence the gas market do you know what I find funny is even the critics of Ethereum at this point a point of critique is never that um ETH block space demand will go down that's never a point of criticism at this point in Ethereum's life cycle it was maybe 2016 2017 no one will use DeFi no one will use smart contracts Ethereum is a solution in search of a problem it's not anymore in fact their criticisms are the the opposite gas fees are too high and that's why uh Ethereum will lose in the long run is is kind of a narrative playing out so even the critics you know don't don't claim that block block space demand is going down even even they think uh ETH gas demand is going is going up but what what this would mean in your best guess case where we are reducing total supply by 20 million over 12 years that's an annual supply rate decrease of negative 1.
4 percent right so right now we're issuing 4.2 percent uh if this best guess turns out to be true what you're saying Justin is we'd have an annualized decrease of 1.4 percent in supply am I reading that correctly yeah that's about right so every year the supply would decrease by 1.4 percent roughly even the most conservative can we just maybe walk through through that even the most conservative side of things where fee percent fee burn percentage is lower daily EVM fees are about half of what we're doing right now and there's a lot of ETH staked locked up even that we're still burning ETH absolutely we're still deflationary even in like this super conservative scenario we're still burning um we're still de exactly right that's crazy okay all right so that's the the second model is the road to 100 million ETH supply and you can see how that works out fork these put your own variables in put your own estimates in these are all available in the show notes if you'd like to view them and fork them and play with them this next model I think is really interesting you said you prepared this model um you know after you were thinking through the ultrasound money podcast this is a model called net cell pressure reduction and the way I think about this model is right now we've got cell pressure coming from issuance and coming from transaction fees of about 8.
1 million ETH per year uh and what you're saying is that that pipe is going to be reduced by a lot it's going to be reduced post EIP 1559 post merge to about 950k per year ETH per year I think that's if you take the daily and you sort of annualize that so that's like an 88% reduction so another way to say this is I think this model is claiming that there's about to be a cell pressure reduction of about 88% can you talk through this model with us right so this goes back to you know proof of work being extremely inefficient economically um and so here um we we need to look at at several things number one we need to look at what is the issuance of proof of work versus proof of stake and um you know proof of work is fairly stable at 13.
6 thousand or 13.5 thousand ETH per day and then for the proof of stake issuance I'm I'm assuring let's say um so it's a this by the way this this was um at merge right um the right now we have about four million ETH state and I'm kind of assuming let's say 20 million ETH state which is very conservative like there's no way what I don't think will be a 20 million ETH at the point of the merge but let's assume conservatively that we're at 20 million ETH state then the daily proof of stake issuance will be 2.1 thousand ETH now one of the interesting one of things you need to look at is the the profit margin of proof of work and proof of stake for proof of work you have a very small profit margin because almost all the ETH you have to you're forced to sell economically to buy the hardware to buy the electricity so let's say that you have a uh a 10% um profit margin but actually after tax right you have this this income tax after which is about 50% the the 10% becomes 5% so basically 95% of the ETH that you receive you're forced to sell now in proof of stake you have a very different scenario where you don't have the electricity cost you don't have the hardware cost you only have the taxes so your profit margin is 50% and you're only forced to sell the other 50% and actually at on this point I kind of want to correct one of the things I said in my previous podcast I said in my previous in the previous episode that proof of stake is not distributive right I was we were basically claiming that if all the rewards accrue to the to the validators to the stakers but that's actually not correct because roughly half of your ETH that you receive as a validator you're going to have to pay an income tax and most jurisdiction you know income tax is around 50% and so you have this this natural sell pressure which is a distribution mechanism for proof of stake anyway you plug in all the numbers and you also include the the the fee burn and you go from 22,000 ETH per day in sell pressure which is an insane amount of sell pressure we're talking let's see that's 2.
5 K ETH that's you know that's about 50 million dollars per day which is insane of sell pressure and we're going to reduce that down by roughly 10x to 5 million ETH per day which is much more reasonable and so when you when you when you annualize this it turns out that the the sell pressure reduction is the equivalent of the deposit contract which is around 4 million ETH and grayscale holding the 3.2 million ETH combined but that's not like a one-time reduction sell pressure it's every single year we're going to have you know the the equivalent of 7.2 million ETH that is not sold on the market so you can if you want you can think of it as buy pressure 7.
2 million ETH per year of buy pressure that way it is insanely cool and so just just to reiterate like removing sell pressure is the same thing and at the end result of things as adding in new buy pressure is basically two size of the same coin and what Justin Drake is saying is that by removing the sell pressure of proof of work issuance and then also also removing the sell pressure of EVM fees fees paid to the to the validator slash minors what we are able to get out of that is the equivalent of both grayscale and the deposit contract every single year and so this is a recyclable mechanism we get we get to generate an equivalent amount of buy pressure that grayscale puts in and also an equivalent amount of deposit demand that the beacon chain staking contract also puts in and we get to have this this year and next year and next year and until we until we perhaps even break through that 100 million like ETH or supply floor you know there's no floor for ETH or supply I guess going back to the original analogy that that we were talking about David you you mentioned sort of this this fire hose right that is feeding the center with the liquid portion of ETH and it's just feeding it more and more ETH every year about 8.
1 million ETH supply per year and that's being reduced by a massive amount so that's being reduced to about 950 K ETH per year so there's just like a an 80 to 90 percent reduction we're moving from a fire hose as you said to a garden hose of liquidity that is that is filling that that center part in the states of matter that that liquid part of ETH and to to extrapolate on that as well right like not only do we go from just a fire hose of ETH or issuance flooding this like metaphor of this like cylinder of various temperature where this middle part is just getting injected with just liquidity like ETH or selling pressure but on top of that we have the top part of this metaphorical cylinder which is now burning ETH right is vaporizing ETH and so that with what is being liquid is being vaporized by EIP1559 and we also have and so and so the liquidity is being dried up that way and then also we have on the flip side of things we have this incentive to stake through ETH and so while this middle this middle section of loop warm ETH is it's very quickly getting vaporized or getting staked and while it's also not getting resupplied by a bunch of new proof of work issuance it's only getting resupplied by a very small trickle of proof of stake issuance and this reminds me this turns my my brain to some sort of like kind of stock to flow analysis where the the center part is the new issuance and it's becoming very very low and a lot of that the total ETH supply is either getting burnt or staked right which is the stock and so there's very little ETH or supply that's that's accessible in liquid which is actually a security mechanism to Ethereum because not having too much ether on the secondary markets is a way to protect Ethereum from would be attackers because there's not that much ether available to them to purchase on the secondary markets and attack Justin did I say anything that tripped you up or or did you like did you like that that was amazing that was that was fantastic and one thing I mentioned is that in the stock to flow flow becomes negative right because we have more and so that kind of something for the big coin is to wrap around in the in the correct model right massive amount of net cell pressure is reduced this is this is crazy so what are we talking about a factor of of 10 or so of efficiency that self-reduction what's going to happen like when that happens when EIP 1559 comes around when the merge happens all of this net cell pressure is reduced by 80 90 percent what happens I wonder what could happen I guess we'll find out Justin we've got one last model to to go through and then we're going to talk about a few other things but before we do bankless nation we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible Avae is a borrowing and lending protocol on Ethereum and just recently released Avae version 2 which has a ton of cool new features that makes using Avae even more powerful with Avae you can leverage the full power of defi money lego's yield and composability all in one application on Avae there are a ton of assets that you can deposit in order to gain yield and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have deposited collateral here you can see me getting a 200 usdc loan against my portfolio of a number of different defi tokens and eth I'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option but I could choose the stable interest rate option if I wanted to lock that interest rate in permanently one of Avae's v2 features is the ability to swap collateral without having to withdraw your assets trade them on uniswap and then deposit them back into Avae Avae does all of this for you all in one seamless transaction so you don't have to repay loans in order to change the collateral you have backing them check out the power of Avae at Avae.
com that's a-a-v-e.com Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got into crypto in 2017 and it's been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys themselves Gemini is available in all 50 states and in over 50 countries worldwide and on Gemini there are markets for over 30 various different crypto assets including many of the hot defi tokens and it's one of the few exchanges that has liquid dye markets Gemini just launched their earn where you can earn up to 7.4% interest on 26 various crypto assets if you're tired of paying fees in defi or you don't want to worry about defi exploits but you still want to earn interest on your crypto assets Gemini earn is the product for you another product I'm stoked to get my hands on is the Gemini crypto back credit card which gives you 3% cash back on all of your purchases but paid to you in your preferred crypto asset when I get my Gemini credit card I'm going to make sure that I get my cash back in eth so whenever I buy something I get a little bit of eth bonus back to me at the same time you can open up a free account in under 3 minutes at Gemini.
com slash go bankless and if you trade more than $100 within the first 30 days after sign up you'll be gifted a free $15 bitcoin bonus check them out at Gemini.com slash go bankless yes we're getting to the fourth model so Justin I was just about to ask you how you get to a staking APR of 25% under your best guest scenario can you walk us through some of the variables here right so we have three key variables here variable number one is how much if will they be staked when we merge because this 25% is at the point of merge right it will be it will get obbed away as more if comes in and stakes but I'm expecting roughly 6 million eaf staked when we merge and the reason is because we're at 4 million right now coin base is going to add another million and then you know we're going to have maybe another million trickle through and what's happening is that right the the APY is gradually reducing right so right now we're at roughly you know 7.
8% APR but with 6 million eaf we're only at 6.8% APR so the incentives are you know going down as more if stakes comes in okay second assumption is what are the daily EVM fees at merge and I put 10k you know as I mentioned we're above 10k on the on the seven day moving average on the 30 day moving average on the 100 day moving average we're roughly at you know 12 12k so that that seems you know relatively safe but you know anything could happen I guess and then there's the feedback percentage which is one of the things I will be interesting to see one EIP159 comes in in a couple in a few months but yeah I put it at 70% and you know I guess you know one way to to try and estimate it is to to look at the slow gas price right so the the the the the the base fee is meant to to represent kind of the sustained um demand for the basal level of demand yeah the basal level thank you and so you can use that and then you can just divide out um so yeah you can just take that gas price multiplied by 15 million gas which is the current gas limit and then the divided out by the the total if received in fees uh in in the blocks and that will that will be one way to estimate a low amount on on the fee burn but of course it could be slightly greater than that because the the slow gas price might be too conservative and so when when people were previously discussing like the yields from from staking uh they were they would really point out just issuance and they didn't really people forgot to include the tip and people forgot to include MEV minor extract maximum extractible value right and so when people are seeing this 25% APY they're the and maybe they're getting like sticker shock almost of like how high like no one thought that staking rewards would be this high because everyone forgot to integrate really high gas fees and really high congestion right and so that that has been my takeaway is that like people not only did we not really understand the large implications of reducing issuance and burning fees but we also didn't understand the net effect of MEV maximum extractible value rewards being paid to each stakers and each stakers alone but this isn't this isn't MEV is it David this is just fee does it include MEV so MEV is a is a very broad term and it includes various things um one of the things that it includes is the what I call the the native fee which is the the fee that's that's paid by specifying a gas price in the transaction but MEV is broader in the sense that there's different ways that you can get paid for example flashbots what they have is a a a bundle mechanism where it's basically a whether they have a smart con they they provide a gas price of zero-gway um and instead you have a a side channel payment and the side channel payment happens in the contract which pays the block proposer which right now is the minor so I guess what I'm saying is like I think um what what you're saying David was is absolutely true um but what I'm saying is I think Justin's model only includes the protocol specific fee revenue as part of MEV so if you wanted to include all MEV it would be even more than this is that correct Justin that is correct um but flashbots have this dashboard which is currently in beta and I got the the privilege to see it and for my understanding is that the the incremental MEV which is paid in these bundles is only about five percent additional so it's right now at least it's relatively small but you know things could change and you know this this daily EVM fees which is you know right now around 10k that could go down but you're right you need to take into account the possible increase in the fees that are paid through flashbots because those will go directly this is pure tip um that goes directly to the validators there's nothing is burnt really in the in the in the flashbots fees earlier in the episode that Justin you you talked about how like the staking ether is so cold that it freezes the ether proximate to it and I think this is the time to revisit that metaphor can you can you walk us through that metaphor and how this has to do with this 25% APY right so 25% is clearly you know insane and crazy um and it's it's not going to last long it's going to be a a temporary thing and so what's going to happen is that more if it's going to come in and and stake and so the question the very natural question you might ask is how much if it's going to come in and stick and get one weight and get frozen exactly and one way to uh to answer this is using a model and what you include as a parameter in your model is what is the the fair cost of money of ether you know what is the opportunity cost of of staking ether and as opposed to doing something else with your your ether and then the other thing you need to to um model is what is the the cost of staking other than the opportunity cost so there's various other costs of for example there's the the compute and bandwidth cost but there's also the risk that you might get slashed there's some sort of bug there's also the the risk that you go offline and you accumulate these these offline penalties my my personal estimate for for the the cost of of staking is roughly one percent okay um I might be overestimated I might be underestimated that's for you to put in whatever you think is is appropriate and for the cost of money of the opportunity cost I would put it roughly at five percent so let's say a six percent you know fair um a staking APR anything over six percent will get opt opt away now if you go back to the second spreadsheet the road to a hundred million Eve um you'll see that even when you have a thirty million Eve staked in the in this best guess column number E the the staking APR is actually above six percent so if if I'm correct you know that that six percent is kind of the the fair APR that towards which the market will converge then where we're going to see tens of millions you know on the order of thirty million Eve staked so if this road to a hundred million comes true you know we're going to have roughly a hundred million Eve thirty million of it is going to be in deep cryogenic cold storage we're going to have some amount locked in DeFi I don't know like it could right now it's eleven million Eve but you know that's been growing extremely fast maybe it could be twenty million thirty million fifty million that we don't know um and then the rest which is going to be probably like a minority is going to be the this liquid uh Eve which will be you know available to be sold on exchanges and used to fuel kind of this high velocity uh a fair economy so returning again to the uh this the cylinder of ether varying temperatures metaphor we have we have very little new ether being added the liquid new ether being added to the middle and where we've gone from where we are now with four million ether locked in the staking contract that staking that ether is so cold because it's receiving such a high APY from fees and issuance that that four million ether is so cold that it's going to freeze perhaps up to thirty million more total total ether right and then we already have eleven million ether locked in DeFi perhaps like that doubles over the next year to two to uh twenty million all of a sudden we have fifty million ether frozen right either in DeFi or in the staking contract and that's all the half like a decent not not half but um 40% of the total supply of ether is frozen right meanwhile we have on the flip side of things EIP one five five five nine not EIP one five five nine burning off a lot of the excess vapor where of a water vapor and then we have only a small modest garden hose of of liquidity being trickled in via new proof of stake issuance and so that that is the complete finite finite final like model of this like ether cylinder of varying temperatures that is exactly right so you've summarized it perfectly and that is how we model ladies and gentlemen ultra sound money wow wow guys all right so that's how you got to those numbers Justin there may never be more than 120 million ether we might over the next ten years decrease that to a hundred million ether cell pressure is going to get massively reduced 80 to 90% with the efficiency of proof of stake uh and then staking APY at the start of the merge could be as high as 25% and then it will decrease from there as more ether is getting cryogenically frozen uh that's what these models are showing us just in let's maybe end with um this how soon could all of this happen i think crypto is the the crypto markets and just you know crypto crypto natives in general are very used to living these like bull bus cycles and like these almost like these four year kind of repeating cycles and a lot of this maybe stems from Bitcoin being a dominant the dominant asset and there is a uh happening every four years where Bitcoin supply gets gets gets cut in half uh so every four years we sort of anticipate something new is going to happen at changing of the cycles but i think that EIP 1559 and the merge are going to happen much more quickly at an accelerated rate and maybe at a rate that you know the crypto industry uh is not typically used to so how soon could all of this happen i know we talked about it a little bit but there's this concept being floated around of the accelerated merge uh what is this how likely are we to hit the the merge date and also the iEIP 1559 date of july right so let me talk about the the accelerated merge and and and what it means basically it it means that we try to merge as soon as possible but we have a proof of a MVP minimal viable product we remove all the bells and whistles that could slow down the merge so we remove withdrawals from the beacon chain back to um the EVM that that can wait you know a few more months for what we call the post merge cleanup we don't enable transfers internally to the beacon chain so if you want to transfer some funds from one validator to another well you have to wait a little bit more until the post merge cleanup because we really want to focus on this minimal merge um and we don't do fancy stuff like statelessness so statelessness is kind of a sustainability slash security feature where we have um we have this this massive state and with statelessness the validators don't need to store the state which is very nice but at merge we're going to be asking the if to validators to run a full node a full if one node with all all the states um and like in terms of of timelines we've really tried to accelerate things and that's for several reasons um one reason as you can see is that the the the cash flows are so large the amounts of money are so extreme that um one this is bad for the environment right because we're we're just pumping so much carbon in in in the atmosphere to to pay for the electricity bills you know on the order of 50 million dollars per day the other thing is that it's bad for the holders the eighth holders right we're getting we have this this fire hose of issuance which is just drowning us in liquidity which is putting a huge amount of self pressure um also we have miners that have you know issued some some threats of violence right they've um they've said okay let's try and and and show that we're strong and powerful that we can control the network by uh you know i'm asking 50 what 50% of all the the the hash rate in a single pool um and you know honestly i think the merge at this point is it's kind of overdue right like we're we're six years in right like the the the concept of proof of stake has been there even before the genesis of Ethereum that was part of the roadmap from day you know minus a hundred um and and really it's it's it's it's overdue i mean i think this this the fact that it took us six years really shows how difficult it is to to change Ethereum and how you know robust and decentralized and how how much due diligence we put in and how how we want to do things properly as opposed to doing things fast um but you know the the beacon chain is now running with over ten billion dollars like there's a lot at stake it's been running essentially fine since genesis and i think if we were to merge let's say in in December the beacon chain will be a one year old um so you know we we'd have a lot of value at stake for a long period of time that's quite a bit of of your stress testing uh before we um before we merge so if you go to the the the the if peak supply spreadsheets i actually have the best case lean conservative and conservative scenarios so my my best guess is that we're going to merge the first of December 2021 and now the reason i picked this date is because it's the first anniversary of the beacon chain which was launched uh on the 1st of December 2020 um but of course you know i i kind of lean optimistic in general so maybe you know like people are like generally in the team there's this i'd say there's this rough consensus at this point that we want to merge as soon as possible and that 2021 is a good development target but it's not you know an ultimatum it's not something that we must deliver we really want to focus on on security first and foremost because we don't want to put the whole Ethereum economy hundreds of billions of dollars on the beacon chain which is which is not secure and we don't we don't don't want to risk all this value so if we have to we will delay but because the merge is so minimal it's so simple from a technical perspective um as far as then there will no one believes that the merge would come after q1 2022 and so that's why i put my conservative timeline at the 31st of march 2022 for the merge and just this would be that accelerated merge and then of course cleanup would need to occur afterwards correct correct yep okay and then the eip 1559 date um that feels like it's pretty pretty strong pretty set july 14th is looking like the very likely date but your conservative guess on that was august 2021 right so you know there's extremely high confidence from the person leading this effort that eip 1559 will be part of London like 99% plus confidence it's happening all the implementations are there we have the test nets it's it's it's already you know the eip has been accepted um like the real question is timing and but we're talking about weeks that's the uncertainty period and as i mentioned we have this difficulty bomb which is a forcing function so we we have to hard fork and we will hard fork with eip 1559 the question is just are we going to hard fork in july august and potentially in the extreme case early september but no later than september 2021 so back to the acceleration that i was talking about when i when i asked this question i don't think the crypto market is used to this amount of um issuance supply chain change in such an accelerated period of time first of all the amounts are massive right going from like 4% to negative 1% like and then also the the the the timeline is greatly accelerated we're talking about nine months maybe 12 months under the the more conservative scenario so um i think that the the crypto market crypto investors crypto people in general are going to have to get their heads wrapped around this accelerated a timeline and the ramifications and implications of what you just laid out and you know thanks for putting the models together for us i think david's got one last piece he wants to cover and then we'll let you go jason and and ryan you can uh stop showing your screen just to to finish these things off um and it's just and i i want to finish off with again another metaphor or kind of like uh vantage point for viewing a theorem and moving forward and we've you've talked about uh mox when it comes to ultra sound money like if we if we were at mox one ether is supersonic and we are actually burning eat more ether than we are issuing but mox can go up like we can hit mox too which is twice the speed of sound or or what what does that mean for ether the asset if ether the asset hits mox too what does that mean does that mean is that actually an explicit thing yeah so mac one means that the fee burn exactly matches the um the issuance so we've we we it's like as if we had a cap right the the supply we're not increase it would be very similar economics to bitcoin um and we'd be like sound money if we reach mac one but if we reach mac two what that means is that the amount that we're burning is twice as much than the amount that we're issuing now by the way this is long term mac one mac two mac three if we were to look right now in the present day it's more like mac ten and the reason it's so high is because there's very few there's relatively little if that's being state only four million and so the proof of state issuance is quite a bit lower so this this little um diagram is actually assuming 20 million if which is a far cry from the current for four million if so you know I tried to be conservative but you know as you can see you know the 365 day moving average is at 6.
5 seven seven point five thousand if per day and and the the 300 day and the 100 day moving average are mac four which is 12,000 if per day so there's these these data points at the top there they're like I think like magnets right for the 365 day moving average so we can expect that this moving average will keep on going up cross max three and possibly even cross mac four I think this metaphor will do a really good job of kind of explaining the differences between the bitcoin strategy versus the ethereum strategy because with with bitcoin we have the happenings right is every four years it's programmed into the into the protocol it's a very ceremonious time for bitcoiners it's like it's just like the time of the happening it's the time for all big pointers get to come and celebrate the the happening of the supply making its way to the secondary market but with ethereum I think we could have our own mocks like and we get to have mock two mocked three mock four and the difference is that with bitcoin it's programmed into the protocol regardless of whether bitcoin is ready for it or not it is getting cut in half no matter what regardless of whether the economic stand up and and bitcoin is very much hoping that because of the happening it makes the economic stand up but for better or for worse the happening is happening is happening with mocks we you with ethereum and going from mock one to mock two mock three it's not programmed it's not guaranteed ethereum has to earn it ethereum has to viably leveraging the the just a native economy that's built on top of ethereum if it gets from mock one to mock two and then mock two to mock three it's because it earned it it's because it made the economics worked out like that and so rather than having it programmed and imposed upon the system the machining or going from mock one to mock two mock three gets to be a new ceremonious time for ethereum people when we don't know it's coming or not and when we finally hit like mock 17 or whatever and we finally we get to rejoice in this new machining machining we need to figure out a better meme for this but a new mock level where we we get to be pat ourselves on our back we like it we earned this like we we got this done like it came to us rather than it being imposed upon the protocol ethereum was ready to reach this new speed of of ultrasound money that's and that's my takeaway that I think is a nice juxtaposition absolutely and I think this this kind of shows the potential of the ultrasound money meme like really the whole thing started as as a joke right it was supersonic money from from metallic and then it was upgraded from joke to meme with ultrasound ultrasound one word and I think you know we're moving towards ultrasound money with a space in between as becoming reality becoming fundamentals and as you say these fundamentals are gonna age like fine wine right because if this this up only thesis is correct in terms of the the total transactions fees per day this this theme is just gonna keep on maturing and maturing and maturing and actually if you want to facilitate the maturing process not only can you participate of course on ethereum and be part of the economy and pay these transaction fees but this is a small plug I'm looking for a website designer backend and frontend to help with the website ultrasound dot money right so I think there's a lot of potential there to show like really nice graphics of you know the daily burn and what mac level we're at and etc etc wow that is a very prestigious position uh I think whoever ends up landing the uh that job to to help build out that website that would be a pretty cool job to land for sure Justin thank you so much for spending time with us this is number three and um you know wow like you've just uh given a given given us so much in in terms of understanding what's happening with the crypto economics of uh this system we call ethereum and uh we just really appreciate you you spend the time to do this thank you so much for having me that was great fun thankless listeners in the show notes there will be some action items for you um and one of those is to review these models the models that we went through with Justin super important play with them yourselves uh if you want to adjust the assumptions go do that give us your feedback also listen to the ultrasound money episode again I've had a lot of bankless listeners tell us that they they've had to listen to it not once but twice or you know sometimes three or four times to fully digest and understand that episode I think that's a uh a key precursor episode to this one and I'll just say that I think this is the most important thing happening in crypto right now and it doesn't get enough in my opinion yeah but like especially right now because it's going to happen over the next nine to 12 months it's going to happen so quickly and theorem is the second largest crypto network uh maybe moving into the first largest as a result of all of this and people need to understand eth's monetary policy eth's issuance schedule what's happening with eth 2.
0 the fee burn the implications of that the merge the reduction of supply implications of that and so we're trying to bring that information out to them this is alpha this is understanding this is where ethereum is going so um thanks for tuning in thanks for tuning with us as always risk and disclaimers of course eth is risky crypto is risky so are these defy systems you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we are glad you are with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommend joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me anything and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation