🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: http://bankless.substack.com/
✊ STARTING GUIDE BANKLESS: https://bit.ly/37Q17uI
❤️ JOIN PRIVATE DISCORD: https://bit.ly/2UVI10O
🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
👕 BUY BANKLESS TEE: https://merch.banklesshq.com/
-----
GO BANKLESS WITH THESE SPONSOR TOOLS:
⭐️ AAVE - BORROW OR LEND YOUR ASSETS
https://bankless.cc/aave
🚀 GEMINI - MOST TRUSTED EXCHANGE AND ONRAMP
https://bankless.cc/go-gemini
💳 MONOLITH - GET THE HOLY GRAIL OF BANKLESS VISA CARDS https://bankless.cc/monolith
📈 KWENTA | DEVIRATIVES TRADING WITH INFINITE LIQUIDITYhttps://bankless.cc/kwenta
------
State of the Nation #28
Algorithmic Stablecoins, with Dan Elitzer
Dan Elitzer recently co-founded Nascent (nascent.xyz), a venture capital company that is deep into the weeds in some of the most experimental projects in the Ethereum ecosystem.
In the 2nd half of 2020, some of the coolest experimental projects have been Algorithmic, Uncollateralized Stablecoins.
These are stablecoins without dollars in a bank, or without crypto in a vault. They are completely backed by financial incentives.... and faith in those incentives.
In this episode of State of the Nation, we begin by defining the 'Stablecoin Trilemma' (https://imgur.com/a/Uj0HBL3), and discuss some of the history of stablecoins.
Then we turn to the current design philosophy behind algorithmic stablecoins, how they work, what makes them stable, and who gets the upside?
We largely discuss Empty Set Dollar (ESD, https://www.emptyset.finance/), but also discuss Basis Cash, and Ampleforth.
Tune in, to hear about this exciting emerging corner of the DeFi ecosystem!
------
Don't stop at the video!
Subscribe to the Bankless newsletter program
http://bankless.substack.com/
Visit the official Bankless website for resources
http://banklesshq.com/
Follow Bankless on Twitter
https://twitter.com/BanklessHQ
Follow Ryan on Twitter
https://twitter.com/ryansadams
Follow David on Twitter
https://twitter.com/TrustlessState
-----
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time we may add links in this channel to products we use. We may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. We'll always disclose when this is the case
No summary for this episode yet.
Aave is a borrowing and lending protocol on Ethereum, and just recently released Aave Version 2, which has a ton of cool new features that makes using Aave even more powerful. With Aave, you can leverage the full power of DeFi, MoneyLegos, Yield, and Composability all in one application. On Aave, there are a ton of assets that you can deposit in order to gain yield, and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have deposited collateral. Here you can see me getting a 200 USDC loan against my portfolio of a number of different DeFi tokens and ETH. I'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option, but I could choose the stable interest rate option if I wanted to lock that interest rate in permanently.
One of Aave's V2 features is the ability to swap collateral without having to withdraw your assets, trade them on Uniswap, and then deposit them back into Aave. Aave does all of this for you all in one seamless transaction, so you don't have to repay loans in order to change the collateral you have backing them. Check out the power of Aave at aave.com. That's A-A-V-E.com. Gemini is the world's most trusted cryptocurrency exchange. I've been a customer of Gemini since I first got back into crypto back in 2017, and it has been my main exchange of choice to make my crypto buys and sells. Gemini is available in all 50 states and over 50 countries worldwide.
And on Gemini, there are markets for over 30 various crypto assets, including many of the hot DeFi tokens like Wi-Fi, Aave, Uni, and also they are one of the few exchanges that has liquid die markets. Having both the option of logging into the Gemini.com website or instead opening the Gemini mobile app has allowed me to be able to access any and all exchange and on or off ramp services that I've needed to on a moment's notice. With instant deposits and fast withdrawals, I'm able to make my money do the things I want it to when I want it to. You can buy crypto safely and securely on Gemini with the peace of mind of knowing that your investments are insured and protected with industry leading cybersecurity.
You can open up a free account in under three minutes at gemini.com slash go bankless. And if you trade more than $100 within the first 30 days after signup, you'll be gifted a free $15 bonus. Check them out gemini.com slash go bankless. I'm doing really good, Ryan. 2021 has already shaped up to be a banger year for crypto and we are just four days into it. So much has happened in the last few weeks. And I'm pretty sure that trend is only going to continue into 2021. We are seeing so much innovation happening, especially in the realm of algorithmic, uncollateralized stablecoins. That is a brand new field that we are exploring today here on the State of the Nation with Dan.
I have a ton of questions to ask about how these systems are built, how they're designed, how they are maintained, and how they maintain the peg, how they maintain security. So it really should be a really interesting conversation, and I'm excited to see what happens in this world of uncollateralized stable coins in 2021. Yeah, I have probably just as many questions as most of the folks listening and watching today. So it'll be good to talk about them. As usual, guys, if you're watching this on YouTube live, you can ask questions as we record this of Dan or ourselves. We'll try to get to those questions as we can.
We've also got some new stuff going on in the nation, David, as usual. So we just released another episode with Vitalik where we talk about three of his articles, basically, or actually two articles. And then we talk about the launch of ETH 2.0. Fantastic episode that came out Monday. Make sure you catch this. I take it a habit of listening to every single Vitalik episode I can, oftentimes listening to it multiple times because they're just so deep and interesting. David, any takeaways from that one? Every time we talk to Vitalik, I just learn so, so much. And I often listen to the podcast back, Even though I was there when we recorded it, I listened to it again because Vitalik is just so incredibly precise in his speech that he often packs so much punch into a single sentence that I don't really always grasp it the first time around.
And so listening to it a second time or sometimes even a third time has always been really, really, really, really helpful for me. Being precise in my speech is something I definitely aspire to. And it's a skill that Vitalik has mastered extremely well, both in speaking and in writing. I'm quite impressed by it overall. And the episode that we recorded with him, it goes through his why proof of stake article, which came out in November. Really, really timely, especially for people that are staking their Ether on the beacon chain or intend to stake into the future, or just have questions as to how Ethereum came to be where it is today in the design principles and the design ethos behind Ethereum and behind proof of stake.
Vitalik does a great job laying down the arguments for proof of stake, the thesis and theories and ethos behind proof of stake, why it was chosen, why it was incorporated into Ethereum. And then we also get into his other article, concave and convex dispositions, which kind of actually does a really good job helping me formulate my theories as to why this space is so tribal and Vitalik categorizes or offers an explanation is like people are tribal because of these different dispositions and how they think and he characterizes them as convex or concave disposition so understanding how kind of like the cards have fallen in the crypto space through that lens has also been really helpful for me absolutely we also just released a new weekly NFT newsletter so if you're subscribed to Bankless you can also subscribe to this uh fungible tokens so uh digitally scarce uh art uh items um virtual worlds this sort of thing all in sort of the metaverse we think that's going to be a huge investing theme and crypto theme and defy theme for 2021 so i want to keep you up to speed we'll include a link in the show notes where you can subscribe to that as well lastly we've got chris dixon who is the uh the manager of the and Driven Horowitz Crypto Fund.
He's coming on the past. Let me see, tomorrow, right, David? So we're lining that up. That will be released the following Monday. So catch that next week. Of course, you get it early through our bankless subscriber premium member. But I'm really excited about that episode with Chris. David, any thoughts as we go into that episode next week? Yeah, Chris, to me, is somebody that gets it. He had to talk about the different price cycles, the hype cycles of crypto, which we know that these that's how these things happen. And so I think I'm focused on asking Chris, OK, we are clearly moving into a new cycle.
How is this cycle the same? But also, more importantly, how is it different? Like, why will this fourth cycle of crypto be different? What will be the new things that come out of it? Is are there any is this just going to be another bubble or are we actually going to be able to sustain some of the growth? Is this bubble going to be marked by speculation like all the other ones? Or is there something, are we able to build foundations this time that we can stand on to make sure that speculation turns into real products, real use cases? I think we're definitely seeing that with Bitcoin. Bitcoin is no longer a tool that is only used to speculate.
Some people actually do use it to save their cash rather than just number go up because the dollar is being distorted. And so that's definitely a huge theme that I think we're going to talk to Chris about. But he also is very much into the world of the technology behind Bitcoin. And his line is that I am not a blockchain, not Bitcoin person, but I think he does see a lot of value in blockchain technology, quote unquote, as well as all these other technologies, you know, social tokens, social tokens, DeFi, you know, the whole gamut, right? And he thinks that blockchain and software can really extend into the whole rest of the world.
And I have that belief as well. I think that, you know, if you can do something in the legacy world, you can do it something better using crypto, using crypto economics, using the blockchain. I think that conversation is going to be really valuable. Yeah, very cool. All right. Before we get into the main event, the main topic with Dan, I've got to ask you the question. We always start with David. This is the first time I'm asking you this in the year 2021. What is the state of the nation right now, David? The state of the nation this week is validated. We are validated as a nation. Obviously, when crypto prices go up, when the market goes up, when the market agrees with you, you feel validation about your investments.
And it's very nice to feel that, right? Like imagine if we had like the Bankless podcast and we were just like talking about all these things going on, like Uniswap, Balancer, DeFi, staking, yet all of the assets stayed the same price for years on end. That would be unvalidating. That would be very bad. But instead, the opposite is happening. Like assets are going up in price. People are getting into the ecosystem. People are starting to see the value in DeFi, see the value in Bitcoin, see the value in staking, and really just start to incorporate that into their mental models. We see both negative, but also positive regulation come out that helps protect this industry.
We saw that with the OCC comptroller news yesterday. And then also, I think what else is being validated is, I know you believe this as well, Ryan, and I definitely believe this, is that the design space for options for just building anything on Ethereum, just the optionality of building stuff, is being explored aggressively. And that's what we're seeing with algorithmic stablecoins, which is the conversation that that we're going to have today. But the point is like, if you can build something on Ethereum, it's going to be built. And we are seeing the constraints around building stuff being removed.
And we are seeing things being built more and more and more. And that feels very validating to me. I've always been a believer of the exponential growth of things being built on Ethereum. I think that new layer of exponential growth is in the world of uncollateralized stable coins. And that just the fact that these are working or so far, you know, so far working, is validating. I believe that to be true. And I'm really excited to get into this conversation with Dan shortly here. Yeah, I totally agree, man. And I totally resonate with that word validated. I would even say, you know, use the word like vindicated to describe it.
I felt like there are really three components of a thesis that we've been talking about for the last two years. One is, of course, Bitcoin. And that got validated in 2019 and 2020. money. The second is DeFi. And that totally found product market fit in late 2019 and early 2020, a breakout successes like Uniswap. And of course, you know, DeFi summer and the birth of these DeFi capital assets. So, you know, checkmark there, another thesis validated. But the third piece has always been this, well, ETH will accrue value as a native DeFi reserve as part of the Ethereum economy and his store of value in the same way Bitcoin is.
And it's finally, we're finally starting to see that happen, David. It's like ETH has woken up. So validated on all three of those points. That's how I'm feeling right now too. That's a good word for the state of the nation. All right, David, we should get right into it. So want to welcome Dan Elliser, who has been on the show a few times before. In fact, he was our first guest before DeFi summer. He is now starting a fund of his own called Nascent that we'll talk about soon. And he's here to tell us a bit about what's going on with uncollateralized stablecoins. We'll define that in a minute.
Dan, good to have you on State of the Nation. How are you doing, sir? I'm doing well. Thanks for having me, guys. uh i'm not on video yet so i don't know if uh when i bring me on yeah we're just looking at uh dan's profile shot right now and uh we're about to uh live stream there we go there is how's it going dan good to see you man good to see us too all right yeah so it's this is uh this is a fun topic thanks for having me on it's always always a pleasure to chat with you guys and really explore what i think is a very exciting the last time we had you on was right before this whole event that we call DeFi Summer.
So I'm wondering what's going to happen this time. If we have Dan on, is there going to be some kind of explosion in uncollateralized stable points right after this conversation? I'm not sure what to expect. I don't think we're front running the explosion. I think the explosion already is happening. So there's that. Very cool. Well, you're going to have to help us catch up then a little bit. But before we begin, I'd love to actually hear, because you recently made a transition to Nascent, which is, as I understand, kind of your own fund or something that you've co-founded. Can you tell us a bit about that?
Yeah. Yeah. So I spent five years at IDEO and helped start up IDEO CoLab Ventures there, did a lot of early stage investing in DeFi and in crypto more generally. And then a few months ago, kind of beginning of September, left IDEO and started this new fund, Nascent, with my partner, Josh Felker. We were focused largely on DeFi, but really we think of this more broadly as an open financial system. And we do both early stage venture, but we also are able to be more participatory. We have the advantage of utilizing proprietary capital. And so we don't have to spend time raising funds or managing LPs.
We're able just to focus all of our energy, all of our time in understanding the ecosystem, in supporting our portfolio companies, and really understanding how things play together because we don't want to just be investors. I think a lot of funds are structured where they're either doing a lot of trading or they're really doing early stage venture and that's about it. And so there are a few funds that I think are doing a fantastic job, Framework, Parify, a few others who really do both. And so we're really trying to be in bold where we use all these DeFi protocols. I was a personal user and really that's upped my understanding of the ecosystem a lot, but we're now looking at this six, seven figure positions and movements.
And so that really gives me a different lens through which I'm evaluating all these protocols and thinking about where are the gaps in the ecosystem, what's useful, slightly better in these situations. And I really think it lets us bring another layer of helpfulness to the companies and protocols that we work with. Super cool. We've been preaching investors as users from the very beginning. So really cool to start a capital pool around that, Dan. That's very exciting. Dan, it's very appropriate that your fund is called Nascent because that's exactly how I would describe these algorithmic, uncollateralized stablecoins.
It seems to be a very emergent field that is very, very recent, just in the last, you know, maybe couple quarters or so. And it's very experimental as well. And so I think it's perfect for somebody like you that tends to see things before they come because they are deep in the weeds, and then also are willing to get their hands dirty and get into the protocol, be active participants. So let's talk about the ethos and theory behind an uncollateralized stablecoin. And Ryan, if you want to bring up the stablecoin trilemma document, just so we can get our listeners grounded, there's this famous stablecoin trilemma where there's three different designs of stablecoins.
We have fiat collateralized like Tether or USDC. And to spin up a fiat collateralized stablecoin is just trivially easy, right? You just put fiat into a bank account, you issue a token on a blockchain, and then you claim that if the token is redeemable for the fiat. And that's pretty trivial. And that's the fastest stable coins that have gotten out the door, right? That's the biggest market cap. Then we have crypto collateralized, which is a little bit harder, but still more or less the same principles, right? Where instead of having a fiat and a bank, we have crypto in a smart contract. There's a little bit more technicality there.
We need to over collateralize these things because of the volatility of these assets. And there's oracles and there's a little bit more complication, but generally a very solvable problem that I think has been solved. You know, we saw DAI come around in December of 2017. DAI is like three years old now. It's been pretty decently battle-tested. And the benefit of DAI is that, unlike a fiat-collateralized stablecoin, it's nation-state regulation-resistant, right? Like it kind of exists independently of the physical landscape of the world. It just exists on Ethereum. It doesn't have any real-world dependencies, more or less.
But then there's non-collateralized stable coins, which don't have any collateral behind them, as the name would suggest, and are very, very new. And we almost had Basis back in 2018 as the project that really pioneered this, but Basis didn't work out too well. Maybe, Dan, you can maybe illustrate for the listeners, why are under collateralized or non-collateralized stable coins so difficult to spin up? Because would you say that these are the most difficult of the three categories? These might be the most easy to spin up and the hardest to make work. So that diagram you showed, I think credit goes to Hasib Qureshi from Dragonfly.
He wrote that piece that really, really influenced my thinking on stable coins and on the design space here. I think that was from 2017 or 2018. And, you know, DAI has been this kind of decentralized beacon that we've all been able to rally around in space. some very big steps. And I think we often, those of us who really focus on decentralization and transparency and openness have not loved the fact that Tether has been such a massive force in this ecosystem. And so I do think things like USDC step in the right direction. But this on or under collateralized point on the triangle has been underexplored.
And I think there have been a lot of very valid critiques of basis back in the day. There were some really good preemptive takedown posts talking about problems with this model. And my sense of the time was like, yeah, I was very much also in Bitcoin maximalist land at that time. And none of this stuff is going to work. But my impression now of the space is that there's a very good chance that that is just very hard. And that getting to these under collateralized really coins is nearly impossible. Maybe it is impossible. One of the things, though, that I think is not quite right is when we look at the initial proposal around basis that never launched.
But they used over $100 million in capital to support this. And the vast, vast majority of that ended up getting returned to investors. And they didn't spend it. So credit to them, unlike a lot of teams that raised a lot in the 2017 timeframe, they actually said, nope, we're not going to do this. We're going to shut it down and give all the money back to investors. So kudos to them for making that decision. But the plan was never to use that to buy big houses and Lambas or to hire a massive team. It was to literally this kind of backstop fund. So it was not necessarily collateralized per se, but it was to provide this deterrent from trying to break the peg in these ways.
because they're saying there's this massive $100 million fund that is sitting here ready to be deployed to support the peg, should that be necessary. And I think that that's where we're seeing some of these things move with empty set dollar planning to move in that direction with V2. You know, Frax has another kind of partially collateralized thing. Honestly, YAM, which I was involved with originally, was something that kind of came from the same idea where it took the kind of rebasing mechanism that we're seeing from Ampleforth and said, well, what if we start putting some capital behind it to dampen the downsides?
So there's a lot of design space here and we'll go through all these different things, but what is really exciting here is the ability to create potentially, right? Something that can be long-term stable and decentralized and be much more capital efficient than something like DAI. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So can we talk about that, Dan? So that is, let's zone in on like why non-collateralized, right? It's part of that dilemma. So we have fiat collateralized. We've talked about that lots on Bankless, right? It's not Bankless, basically. It's sort of a product of the existing banking infrastructure. And then we have this thing called DAI, right?
And that's grown to its credit over a billion dollars, There's lots of collateral in there. But the problem with it, some of the critics will say, it's not very capital efficient, right? It's very difficult to kind of grow the supply of DAI versus something like fiat collateralized. So could you zone in for us on what the value of a non-collateralized stablecoin would be? Is it those two things? It's both bankless, decentralized, and also highly efficient? it? Yeah. And so one of the challenges with Maker, and again, I'm a huge fan of DAI, but one of the challenges with it is that we've seen there's this massive demand for USD pegged stable coins.
And DAI can only grow to the extent that there are folks who have capital that they want to take leverage on. And so that inherently means that you can't grow the supply of DAI faster than there is demand to borrow against other assets that are supported through that capital pool. And so that just inherently caps it. And so by having something where it need to be fully, or in the case of DAI, really over collateralized, that allows the supply of stablecoin to match the demand for stablecoins. And I don't think that that's really a problem that things like UST and USTC are kind of 100% well UST who knows but like in theory 100% collateralized with dollars in a bank account the problem is that they're in a bank account rather than on chain and as soon as you go on chain you can't really have it just like perfectly percent collateralized you need some other mechanisms to bring stability because if that peg and that collateralization is fully important, then you're not giving yourself any leeway.
And so you need some kind of algorithmic system to help provide stability and supplement the collateralization for the collateralization to potentially supplement that kind of algorithmic factor. So they kind of work in tandem. And once we need algorithmic forces, not just reliance on the ability to seize and liquidate collateral, well, why leave it at a percent? Why not lean a little bit more heavily on those algorithmic components and say that the collateral is almost secondary to that? I think what people struggle with, and this is also foundational, is the question of what actually backs a uncollateralized stable coin, right?
So it's very clear with Tether. We know what, we think we know what backs Tether. Some dollars in a bank account, I hope, fingers crossed, right? We know what backs DAI. You can see that on Chain, right? It's completely open. We can see all of its collateral at any one time. But what in the world backs the value of a stable coin that has no collateral backing it? Yeah. Well, what backs the US dollar, right? It's faith. Ultimately, it's faith. And so the goal here is with these stable coins for them to work is people need to believe in the mechanisms and they need to be given very good reason to believe in the mechanisms that it will stay very close to $1.
dollar. And there's a lot of reasons to believe it won't, right? And we've got a lot of evidence for these things diverging pretty significantly from a dollar, on both the up and downside. And so that's not great, right? But what I will say is a few of these things have actually stayed a lot closer to that shelling point around $1 than I would have expected a couple years ago. and so that to me is a great starting place but it needs to get better and if it can't get better these things are not going to work okay so i think there's a lot of design space to think about how how to make that work and one of the things that um you know i when i first ample uh you know i read it was called something else originally and they had a white paper for it a couple years ago I thought this is the stupidest thing I've ever seen.
And it launched. I thought this is the stupidest thing I've ever seen. And then people started piling into it, using it. I was like, whoa, okay. So clearly there are very powerful, you know, these reflexive mechanisms that are going to drive up the market cap. The problem is it can also go down, but okay, well, then this powerful mechanism for driving up the market cap, actually expanding this again, the supply up there, that's really useful for bootstrapping. So could you modify the mechanisms once you get above a certain point to dampen the reflexivity on both the upside and downside? And that question was what originally led to the idea of YAM was, okay, if on the way up, you're building up a collateral base that effectively pulls a floor up with you, then, you know, maybe that's a way that you can dampen it.
And now that didn't, that didn't play out. So we, there were some, some problems with yams, some bugs. And we saw, you know, what can happen where it doesn't work. And then the community there, yams actually, I'm very excited by what's been happening with yams since I think Brock and Trent and the rest of the team over there have done an incredible job, But the decentralized community around it decided this is not a stable coin. And they actually just recently removed the rebasing that was inspired by Ample entirely. And now it's really this kind of community DAO saying we've got this treasury, how do we manage it?
How do we build more things? Very cool, but very different. But the idea, the original seed of the idea there was thinking along these lines, how do we take these powerful financial incentives to strap the system, but also have them in a way where they can be modified in a way so up to some level, then make it harder for it to drop down. It can grow at a more reasonable, sane pace to serve the needs that people have that they come looking to a stablecoin for. So, Dan, I want to talk about the continue the conversation about the design space for under collateralized stablecoins, because there seems to be a lot of overlap and you've touched on it just a little bit now.
To say that they are uncollateralized, I think, is not completely accurate. The collateral is just in a different place, right? With a collateralized stablecoin, the cash is in a bank. With a crypto collateralized stablecoin, the collateral is in a smart contract. And with an uncollateralized stablecoin, the collateral, as you alluded to, is the faith that when there is time, when the time comes for there to be buying pressure, there will be buying pressure. And I guess it's collateralization via faith. You're giving me some resistance. I feel like I would push back against that a little bit because I think the mechanism there is faith.
I think calling it collateral is a bit of a stretch in terms of what people realistically think of as collateral. these things absolutely to be very clear they can 100% death spiral and go to well nothing in crypto ever goes to zero zero right people will trade you know penny stocks till the end of time so right like but it could effectively go to zero for any of these things and so I think that's a very important thing to look at is right now is these things are are highly speculative I think there's a lot of interesting design space to be explored around making them a little bit less speculative.
One of the things though, that I think we shouldn't lose sight of is speculation isn't necessarily bad. I think people need to know what they're getting into. But I think that it can be a very powerful mechanism to get things up to a level where they can be broadly useful. Okay. So let's define why uncollateralized stable coins are so dangerous. And I think that will kind of ground us behind like where the buying pressure comes in at. To me, the reason why uncollateralized stable coins can get really, really dangerous is because they can get out in front of their skis, right? And this goes back to the issue of who can mint new stable coins, right?
With the collateralized method, it's the protocol if it's MakerDAO or it's the bank if it's Circle. But with an uncollateralized stable coin, the protocol can also issue freely as anyone can just like the federal reserve can freely mint new coins that's not where the restriction comes the problem is the protocol cannot revoke supply and that's where there needs to become some some strategies and so there's different strategies for how each different algorithmic stable coin revokes or takes away supply away from the market if there is a a price that is under one dollar so maybe you you can kind of go into the different strategies, the tools that these under collateralized stable coins have available to them to incentivize the removal of supply of these uncollateralized stable coins when the time comes that these things are below a dollar.
Yeah. Okay. So in all the cases of these different kind of algorithmic and under collateralized coins, there's the same mechanism is above a dollar print more and that creates selling pressure push it down easy not hard the problem is like you said on the downside how do you get it back up so the original uh kind of senior share model that basis was was planning to do and never launched um there is the you know the the usd pegged stable coin and then there's a share um like base shares or whatever. And then the holders of those base shares will receive the inflation, right? So they hold essentially shares in the system.
They get new dollars printed to them, and then they can sell those to bring the peg back down. But that's why you hold the share. When it's below the peg, the idea would be that you would have these bonds and people could burn their kind of cash tokens for bonds that when the price returns above a dollar, they can then redeem those and get the full dollar. So that's the basic mechanism there. With empty set dollar, or sorry, before we get to empty set dollar, there was one though that kind of came next. Let's kind of go almost in the chronological order as we're seeing the evolution here. So the idea behind Ampleforth was everybody gets it.
If you hold Ample and we need more Ample to bring the price down, everybody gets more Ample. And then how do you then get the price back up? Well, below a dollar, everybody loses Ample. And so you don't opt into that. It just happens across the board. And while I'm very impressed by the kind of insight and psychology around the creation of this, what's called rebasing mechanism there, I think psychologically it's really hard and technically it becomes impossible. I don't think Ample is ultimately going to work as a stablecoin, even if the mechanisms around this, the kind of the economics of it did work.
On a technical level, it doesn't behave like a standard ERC-20 token, right? The fact that the balance can keep changing without the user doing anything, it just breaks everything. And so they've had to create their own whole kind of elastic finance, they're calling it, ecosystem around it. And when you break DeFi composability in that way, it creates all sorts of problems. And I think it just makes it really hard, even if you somehow achieve more or less stability, it's going to be really hard to take advantage of that composability that is such a strength in this ecosystem. So getting to your point there, Dan, right?
So like you say, Ampleforth, the risk is borne by all Ample holders. All Ample holders have it. Okay. And they all contract to kind of get the price back up to $1, and that has led to a lot of big swings. But these new designs, these different designs, they have kind of different classes of risk-taker. So that's the initial senior share model with Basis. That was the different classes, right? So you have the stablecoin holders, then you have the kind of shareholders. And that has been then ported forward now with basis cash has more or less implemented that same design. And that is nice, right?
You avoid the need to do anything. If you want to hold just that kind of stable coin piece, it may not be stable, but at least the amount of individual tokens you hold doesn't change unless you opt into buying a bond. Now, what MTSetDollar did that I think is very interesting, and full disclosure, we have a meaningful position at MTSetDollar, but one of the insights there was saying, well, what if we just package these together in a single token? So the way that you receive inflation is actually depositing your ESD, your empty set dollar, into the Dow and staking it. And by staking it, you can earn a share of the inflation.
Or by providing liquidity into the ESD, USDC liquidity pool, that's another way that you can earn part of the inflation. and uh there there's some of the criticism for that is that well how are you ever going to have something stable that's inherently speculative in nature and the flip side what got me excited about this saying wow you know let's recognize the fact that early on people really just want to speculate with this and so to be useful as a stable coin you need to be integrated across the ecosystem. You need to be on different lending protocols and you'd be in different AMMs. And so if you want to have the liquidity, have the integrations, let's have it be on the spec coin, which, oh, by the way, over time, if the mechanisms work, should become less speculative, more stable.
And then you've already got these integrations across the ecosystem. I think the challenge with things like basis cash is people are really just interested in kind of the number go up piece and nobody's really wanting to use the the stable coin piece as a stable coin and integrate that it's really just there they're kind of leaning into the farming aspect and i think that's hard and one of the things that uh you know pointed out there are a lot of games to be played, a lot of money games to be played around this, around all of these different designs. And a lot of teams are leaning into that.
And what I got excited about Empty Set Dollar for was the ethos where, unlike the other communities that I've been a part of, this one really is focused on, let's tamp down the growth. Let's grow at a slower, more reasoned pace, right? The first fork that I saw of Empty Set Dollar was, you know, dynamic set dollar that just was a straight fork off they tweaked a few variables but it was really just a fork um and i love the experimentation you know good on them but like man they like took all the breaks off and kind of went full dgen and kind of like leading to going like super dgen like okay great you can do that but i i think there's a really important element here around community and around ethos and belief that this is something where yeah you can absolutely step on the gas.
We're playing with very, very powerful tools here. But if you want this to be long-term sustainable and successful, you need to move slowly and intentionally. And there's certain things you can't control. Apes are going to ape and you can't stop that. But what you can do is you can try to put dampening things into place to make sure that to the extent possible, growth is more or less in stride with interest and adoption of the protocol. So at the beginning of this conversation, you talked about how you are more accepting of speculation and aping, right? You think that's an important part of projects, right?
And I totally agree. If there was no speculation around Bitcoin, we wouldn't have Bitcoin, right? And something like Bitcoin, speculation is inherently good. There's almost no such thing as bad speculation on Bitcoin. And that's where algorithmic uncollateralized stable coins are very different from the other protocols that we've seen, where rampant uncontrollable speculation will actually end the protocol, right? Because as you were alluding to, if you only have a gas pedal and you don't have a brake pedal, you know, that's great for Bitcoin, number go up. If you don't have a brake pedal on an uncollateralized stable coin and you only have a gas pedal, you will crash because at some point the whole, the whole design ethos around this thing is that there will be a, a devaluation of the asset below the peg.
And that's when you need the breaks. And if you don't have the breaks at that point, you're in trouble. And so I do think that, you know, another project that I think is, is worth, there's a couple other projects worth mentioning here. So one is Frax and they've started off as something that was, you know, essentially fully collateralized to partial collateralization over time. I think that makes a lot of sense as something to play around with as a design space to explore. I think there are some elements of how it's being created and how it's being used that make me a little less comfortable.
But I think overall, the idea of starting more collateralized and moving to less a lot of is a very reasonable place to start um i think you know often they position is like they were the first and i'll be like yeah they got it into market but a lot of people have been kicking around these ideas as i mentioned you know the games initially thinking along similar paths um another one that i think we're talking about is rye uh and from reflexer which they've got a an early version, I think, launched and people can play with it. And it's not pegged to the dollar, right? It's entirely kind of stealth referential with the stability mechanism that they're using.
I don't want to get into it too much because it's very complex. And to be honest, I'm not going to do the best representation of it. But the idea of having something that is entirely algorithmically governed and done so in a way that minimizes human involvement around governance and just tries to essentially dampen volatility significantly, I think is super interesting. And I've seen a number of these projects, ESD included, that have talked about at some point potentially transitioning away from pegging to the dollar and doing something that is more crypto-native. Because I think as anybody who's spent time in this space, the dollar itself may be a reference point today, but I think we're all kind of like looking out for at what point are we no longer going to consider the dollar itself to be stable, and we're going to want a clean way to transition to something else that is really inherently more crypto native.
And so I think we're going to see more projects, I would expect, taking a similar approach where they're thinking about how do we get something that is volatility dampened and may peg to something other than the dollar over time. Dan, there's so much there that we want to unpack. I also want to ask about where oracles come into this and also your opinions as to whether this is like a winner-take-all market or winner-take-most market. We're going to take a moment to talk about some of these sponsors, and then we're going to get into some of the deeper conversations behind uncollateralized stablecoins.
So stay tuned, and we'll be right back. Synthetix is Ethereum's decentralized derivatives liquidity protocol. What does that mean? Synthetix is a platform for creating and trading synthetic assets, which are assets that are priced via an oracle rather than bids or asks. Traders can use the Quenta exchange, which hosts and trades all of the synthetic assets created by Synthetix. Traders on Quenta can trade synthetic tokens like SBTC, S-Oil, or S-DeFi. Because Quenta is powered by Synthetix, traders experience zero slippage on their trades. No, I didn't mean low slippage. I meant no slippage because that is the power of the Synthetix platform.
No slippage on your trades. You can also easily short assets with ISynths, which are synthetic assets that move inversely to their target asset. Synthetix isn't just for traders. Developers can build on Synthetix to access the infinite liquidity offered by synthetic assets, or investors can stake collateral to the protocol and earn fees that the protocol collects. If you're a trader and you're looking for a trading platform not found in the legacy world, check out Quenta.io. If you're a developer or you just want to earn yield on your collateral, go to www.synthetix.io where you can stake your SNX or ETH and earn fees from Synthetix.
If you want to live a bankless life, you need to get a Monolith DeFi Visa card. Monolith is a one-two punch of both an Ethereum smart contract wallet and an accompanying Visa card that lets you spend the money that you have in your Ethereum wallet everywhere where Visa is accepted. When you swipe your Monolith Visa card at the grocery store or at a restaurant, it actually makes a transaction on the Ethereum blockchain that spends some of the money you hold in your Monolith wallet. It's insanely cool and it's one of the best tools out there for living a bankless but still normal life. Monolith also offers on-ramp services for getting your fiat money into the world of DeFi.
So it's trivial to top up your Monolith card if you ever need to, and your deposited money goes straight into your non-custodial wallet, so your money is never held by a centralized intermediary. Because Monolith is native Ethereum infrastructure, the money you hold in your Monolith wallet still has the power of DeFi behind it. Swapping assets on Uniswap or earning yield in DeFi is at your fingertips. Go to monolith.xyz and sign up to get your Monolith Visa card today. All right, guys, we are back with Dan Ellitzer and Stay the Nation. We are talking about uncollateralized stablecoins. Dan, where we kind of left off, we're talking about some of the projects here.
I want to get into Empty Set Dollar in a minute. But something that keeps going on the back of my mind is sort of set context for everyone. You mentioned the term money games that we're playing with these things. And David and I have talked about on Bankless, Bitcoin is very much a money game. Ether is very much a money game. Any uncollectible monetary asset is a money game. I would even use the term Ponzi game for these things. It's kind of like a pyramid scheme where there's benefit to being first and you receive the upside of that. Like putting on your Bitcoin maximalist hat for a minute, right?
You said you used to wear one. uh put that on for a second so a bitcoiner or maybe a really strong ethereum might say damn what you're trying to do is impossible you're gonna invent all of these like ponzi games without any um upside or benefit to the world some early people get rich right but like the only way to get uncollateralization and some level of stability some level of stability is to become highly liquid, a reserve global asset. That's what I think some Bitcoiners might say. What's your response to that? Or did you used to think that and now your mind has changed? I think that there certainly are elements here where you can see that, right?
Where early people do very well if this works. I think that's good incentive for getting it going. The idea is that this can't be Ponzi scheme. And I think one of the great things about what Ethereum has done is because it's all transparent, it's all on chain, nobody can essentially steal funds from others. Everyone can see exactly what's happening. People can choose to play the game or choose not to, up to them. If these things are going to work, work to a place where you go down, you can't go up at an insane pace forever. And so I think the important thing is, as these things, if any of them are successful to approach closer maturity, the locus of the game being played has to move from being growth to about payability.
And so even things, one of the reasons why Tether and USDC are able to keep such a tight peg is because it's really easy to arb that back to the dollar, right? If, you know, Tether is trading at 101, somebody who's got, you know, the ability to just go wide funds in and just arb that difference down immediately. And that's one of the problems with DAI, why DAI has had trouble being as tight of a peg, is there's not this instant arb ability for professionals to come in and arb it back to a dollar. And so for any of these algorithmic, under collateralized, uncollateralized stable coins work long term, the loss of the game needs to move from how do we get it a little bit above the dollar so that we all print more money for ourselves.
And it has to be, okay, how do we get the incentive to push it down when it's below, push it up, but keep it very tightly around the dollar. And a big piece of that for something like empty cellar is around faith that it will, that people see it go through these cycles and see the cycles get less volatile and shorter, and that there's more faith. So people are willing to help push it back up rather than saying we need to get like a 50% discount or whatever in order to take on the risk that it might never come back up. Maybe we're comfortable with a 20% discount, a 10% discount, a 5% discount, a 1% discount.
You need to get that range that people are willing to play around tighter and tighter over time. And how do you do that? Is it the algorithm, the precision of the algorithm itself, or is it the mechanics of the protocol, or is it the liquidity and underlying faith of the backers? How does that happen? In my view, it's multiple things. One is there needs to be, the mechanisms need to be really strong. And I will say very, very clearly, I don't think empty dollar has 100% the right mechanisms today. There are certainly challenges with the kind of coupon bond-like system around this, where they are highly risky.
I don't think the price well, I don't think the redemption process works particularly it's worked well enough. It's gotten it back to the peg three or four times already. But everybody who's active in the community looks at this and says, we need to do some fixes here. And Scott Lewis and Will Price and some others are working on a proposal for a kind of an overhaul of that coupon system. And it is more like a bond, some with a zero bond. I think that's a very worthy thing to research and it may end up being something the SD will transition to if the community wants to do that. But there's also been fixes to the coupon system to improve it.
Each cycle, it's getting better and better. And that's a piece. The other piece is just the faith piece, right? The longer that it's around, the more times that it goes below and then returns, it goes above and then returns, the more faith people have that it will do so in the future. It's the Lindy effect around this, right? The more times that we, the longer it survives, the more times it does the thing that everyone says it's supposed to do, the more people believe it will continue to in the future. But it's that combination of faith and actual technical economic mechanisms together that will hopefully enable it to be more stable over time.
So there's an article I wrote a while ago in the Bankless newsletter that talked about Ethereum as a protocol is designed to work in the most adversarial conditions ever, right? The protocol is designed to work, like full stop. And the more that people have faith in that protocol working, the more monetary premium accrues to Ether. That's the claim that I made. And I think that is very similarly true for uncollateralized stablecoins, where you can make the system work. And once the system proves that it is working, then you get this premium of of this this benefit of the fact that people know that it works then you get this benefit of extra liquidity because of the faith that people believe that it will work then people are more willing to buy sooner when the when the value of the token drops just a little bit below a dollar because people know that you know it's going from 98 cents back to a dollar, people are willing to take just 2% of that ARB rather than like they see it at 85 cents.
It takes a lot more faith to buy something at 85 cents to get it all the way up back up to a dollar than it does to 98 cents. But the only way that you get that benefit of a premium is if you prove out over time that the protocol is going to operate under the worst possible conditions. Is that about right? I think that's a very fair statement, right? It's the same reason that we're kind of seeing similar things play out with like Bitcoin and Ethereum today. We're like, it's even though the price has gone up, you know, you know, hundreds of percent in the last year, it's in some ways less risky for people to buy it now because it has all this kind of existence proof and more people have piled in and it's easier to buy at a higher price, which is ridiculous, right?
Because you get rewarded so much more for buying at a lower price, but there is this risk reward trade-off and it is a factor in these stable coins as well. So Dan, let's maybe look at your example of empty set dollar ESD and look at performance. So I've got CoinGecko here just showing me a chart of the price of empty set dollar, so we call it ESD, right? Which is this collateralized Bitcoin, one of them we've been talking about. And this is over the last 90 days. And over the last 90 days, we could see some fluctuations. So at the start, it starts at about $1.01. And then that's at the beginning of October.
And then sometime in late October, it stays steady. We get a spike. And all of a sudden, it's $2.29. And now later in October, where we get a spike down and it's 50 cents. And then we get some flatline. You can see this chart. Anyway, there's some ups and downs. It seems like there's a range of it. It tends to gravitate around a dollar, but it ranges up over $2 and sometimes down to 50 cents. So it's fluctuating around stability. What can you say about this chart? Is this the protocol that's at work? How is this stablecoin doing so far? Yeah, I think it's doing all right. I'd say anything that went from literally zero, didn't exist six months ago, to something that is now at 400 mil market cap or so.
It's grown a lot, but it's done on the basis of somewhat range bound. And I would say the goal here is to get it into the die-like range or better. If you can stay within 5% or so, the peg is where you ultimately want to be, hopefully even tighter to 1%. But right now, early, so speculative. I think that this is reasonable performance and some of the mechanisms are being tweaked to hopefully allow it to not skew as much on the upside. One of the elements of the V2 proposal is to have a price, whether it's a dollar and three cents, dollar, 10 cents, something like that, where anybody can always mint as much as they want at that price to effectively create a ceiling on the price.
And the idea is that the USDC or ETH or whatever would be spent to mint would then be in a reserve where if the price falls below a certain threshold, 97 cents, 90 cents, whatever it is, that that reserve would then be used to buy back the ESD and potentially burn it, potentially hold it. Who knows? But that you can actually create this kind of secondary stability mechanism and create these boundary conditions around it that can tighten over time. And so I think that is a very promising direction. I'm very encouraging and encouraged by the discussions around that mechanism and effort to start moving towards implementing it.
So I'm putting my, my in the shoes of less than an ESD hole, wanting to use this for utility purposes as a stable coin, right? That's ultimately what we want to use stable coins for, right? So I'm looking at the chart, this chart, and I see, okay, I've got, you know, $100 worth of ESD, you know, and I hold that and, you know, next week, maybe that could be $100. but I know if I wait seven to 15 days or so, it's going to restore back to $100. Maybe the following week it goes down to $50. Or if I wait a little bit longer, it's going to ratchet back to a hundred. Is that kind of the user experience or am I misunderstanding this?
No. So one of the things that you're missing here is this is not like ample where it goes up And then it contracts down on like the full amount, right? So the idea is that on the upside, right, when it was going up and was above the peg, people who had staked their ESD in the DAO or were providing liquidity in the Uniswap pool, they were receiving more ESD. And so they had more units of ESD. Now, when it drops below the peg, let's say that you had 100 ESD and the market cap, you now are going to have roughly double the amount, so you'll have 200 ESD. Now, if the peg goes down to 50 cents, yeah, then you've got 100.
But assuming it's above 50 cents, you have more dollar value and more coins than you initially had. And so one of the things that I think is really important psychologically for maintaining the peg here is it doesn't have, in my view, the same crazy downward reflexivity as something like ample fourth, because full fourth when it's below the peg, you've got the double pain of both watching the value of your holdings go down and also the number of units is contracting too. And so that's just like creates this gut-wrenching thing. We saw it with YAM before the rebase was removed. I think, you Anybody who's held ample has been through that and seen that as well.
And so I think that this just psychologically does a lot better, right? If you're looking at this from an investment standpoint, really market cap is the thing that matters much, much, much more so than price. But when you want this to actually be a stable coin and when people are looking at holding it, the fact that it doesn't take supply away from you on the downside, unless you opt in to buy but potentially get more upside from getting that discount, that opt-in element for returning it back up to the peg, I think is very important. So you're saying, Dan, that I've got, if I hold a C and I'm just a utility stablecoin user, I don't have downside, right?
It can't drop below a dollar. No, no, no, no. To be very clear. No, yes, you absolutely do have downside. The price can certainly drop below a dollar. If you have 100 units or 200 units, you will never have fewer units than you did. The price can still go down, right? Right? Yeah. Well, you can have more on the upside above a dollar. You could end up with more if you're staking them. Right. But you'll never end up with, you'll never, yeah, you will never, without taking action, you will never end up with fewer units. And so I think that is an important piece. Again, there's no floor. This could go to zero, but, or it's like Bitcoin, if it goes to like 1 cent, I'd buy all 21 million Bitcoins, right?
Like whatever. So same principle here. It's never going to go to zero. Approach is zero. But it can approach very, very close to zero. So not saying there is a hard floor or something on this in any way. What I'm saying is that when it goes up and more is printed, those who receive that printing now have that inflation. They have those additional units in their wallet. And if they lose interest, lose faith and decide to sell, they absolutely can drive the price down lower. But if people want to hold it because they believe this is going to be useful, it starts becoming more stable, they start using it as a stable coin, great.
That's the goal, right? The goal is to get this to be something that is widely used where, you know, my, you know, ideal future state is that ESD becomes boring. People should be excited about it. They should not be looking at charts about it any more so than like, you know, we get excited when like a bunch of USDC or STT is like on chains like, oh, wow, that's clearly stable coin demand is up. Nobody really cares. Hopefully ESD could at some point become like that, where the majority of people using it just pays zero attention because it is staying so close to the peg. And there are professionals who are arbing it in both directions and maintaining that peg and making money off it.
like, great, like there's, I'm not against people making money. I think that there should, there always needs to be some kind of profit motive around this to maintain the peg, but hopefully that profit motive shifts from, I want to just hold a lot of this and see number up to, I'm going to make profit by actively participating in the peg restoration process. So, okay. Yeah, go ahead, Ron. Oh no, you go ahead, David. I was going to turn the conversation to oracles but i think you want to uh talk about market cap first yeah yeah so i guess that's the perspective of of maybe someone who's holding esd but um what what does it look like from the perspective of someone who's taking the the speculative risk on in the system itself right so this is a different chart different than price this is market cap of empty set dollars which it looks like this is um you know um basically total price multiplied by the supply right yeah and there's what i'll say is again this is not a a uh beginner 101 uh game to play i think that's one of the reasons why um basis cash has seen a lot more forks is it's like a lot more in that whole yield farming vein and with like the forked YAM UI and people kind of understanding how to play this as a yield farming thing.
One of the things that throws off this chart is the fact that some of the units get removed from circulation, they get burned for coupons. And so that also then reduces the market cap further. So it's not exact, it gets, you know, ballpark right direction. But as you can see here, right, it peaked around 600 mil market cap, and it's currently around 400 mil. And so yeah, that is a pretty significant decline. And it could drop a lot more, it could go up a lot more. You know, it's anyone's guess on this. I think that, you know, to the extent that people do want to speculate, this is not one that people are going to try to make it easy for you to ape into this, like do your homework, do your research, understand it, and then make an educated decision on whether to participate or not to participate.
I think that's what I try to emphasize to people. So for those of you at home, this is an advanced money game. Don't just like YOLO into this. Don't ape into it. That's what we're saying. None of this is financial advice, but I want to be clear on what, like basically the speculators, how well they've done with this. So this looks like 90 days ago, this has just done a hundred X in terms of price appreciation. So we had 4 million market cap around that 90 days ago, and now we're up to 400 ish market cap. Is that right? Yeah, that's right. And so there's, yeah, that's, that's been tremendous returns.
And there's no reason this couldn't fall back to 5 million if something breaks. Right. Absolutely. It could fall below 5 million. Who knows, right? But I think that's one of the things that's been appealing has been the fact that it has grown very quickly. It was sitting up high on the CoinGecko yield farming yield list. And so that brought a lot of more attention into it and people kind of joining, joining in. But honestly, like my, my preference is that this thing I'm talking about you guys, because I want people to understand these things, understand the differences, understand the risk. But my preference is that this grow at the rate that it's grown.
And that none of these things grow at astronomical rates. I think hopefully they will grow a little more in line with the interest, right? And I think you know, up into the range of kind of like a mid tier market cap coin here. And so I think that that's, that's kind of, you know, an okay place to be. I do want to see it grow, obviously, over time. But, you know, if this, you know, next week, or double the market cap, that would make me very uncomfortable. Because I think it's very unlikely that there is double the traction double the the real interest in this a week from now um i think you know going going this project is worth zero or with five million dollars this is you know worth 500 million in some ways that to me more reasonable it's like i think there's a lot of potential behind the idea but going from like you know 500 million to a billion or five billion or whatever like that would scare them.
Right. Yeah. I don't want to see it grow overnight in that way. They talk about the, you know, the, the investment like staircase up elevator down, but this is elevator up and elevator down. Right. Right. Yeah. Bottom basement. Yeah. I think hopefully, but that's what we've seen though. Interestingly, right. Is that we have not seen the, the straight elevator down. And, and we have seen a bit of an elevator up. I don't like how much of an elevator up I wish I wish it were a staircase moving more towards like I don't like a conveyor belt type situation where it like just becomes a lot smoother and more more muted in both directions.
And we'll see if if the community can navigate it in such a way that that is what happens. Maybe to finish off this conversation as to why the dynamics are like that. when Ryan showed the market cap, it showed something like $5 million to $600 million down to $400 million. Unlike other crypto assets that are like Bitcoin or Ether or whatever, there was no one that actually just purchased an asset and held it and then experienced that exposure, right? The only way that you had that upside from $5 million to $600 million down to $4 million is if you were taking actions every step of the way to bear the risk every single time empty set dollar dropped below $1.
And I don't actually think it's possible for someone to even actually have direct one-to-one exposure to the market cap of empty set dollar. Is that right? Ish. If you're staked in the Dow, you're going to get your share of rewards upside. But as we've seen for a lot of the early holders, if they're not participating in the coupons and taking on that risk or participating in the LP and taking, taking on, like essentially putting up additional capital, they're getting diluted out. Right. So like the, the empty set squad, the kind of founding team that hit first advanced the first Epic and, and receive the first hundred ESD as a reward, their ownership percentage has, has dropped significantly over time.
Because they've just been holding a stable coin. Because they've just been staking it. Right. And so like that, they had tremendous growth. Right. I think, you know, I think they're, my understanding is somewhere around like 10% or so of the supply, but like that's, that's come down from like upwards of 20% or initially a hundred percent, but that comes down because all they're doing has been just staking it. And so I think that is very healthy that, you know, people who are just long-term holders get some growth, but they're getting diluted out if they're not taking on additional risk, taking additional action.
I think that's very healthy. And that's not something that you necessarily see through the basis hash-like model, right? Where if you have a fixed supply of those share tokens and you have the same ownership, you're always going to have that same ownership. And so I think that that to me doesn't feel like the system that we necessarily want for something like this. I think the idea that gradually over time, you know, we improve the decentralization of ownership and it becomes flatter ownership, I think, is one of the major positive factors for empty set dollar. Because if this does become kind of the digital Internet dollar, then hopefully it is very widely dispersed.
Dan, would you say the supply appreciation of the MZ dollar largely comes from people purchasing ESD so that when the time comes for them to stake it or to buy bonds and burn it to get the bond, that they have the tools to be able to do it? because you can't get the seniorage, you can't get the upside if you don't have ESD. So you have to purchase ESD so that you can be prepared to burn it when it comes time to get the seniorage. And that actually increases the price of the token and therefore the supply of ESD. Is that right? Well, actually, let me put some nuance on that. So the way that you can receive the senior rich is to hold ASD and to stake it or to LP with it.
So, yes, that requires if you don't have any, you need to buy some to be able to do that. The problem is people do that over the peg and it drives the price up and it's not good to have that reflexive upside. So hopefully it gets sold back down very quickly. the ideal thing from a systems perspective is that people buy in below the peg, so at a discount to a dollar, which has the dual effect of giving them the ability to capture some senior edge when it goes above a dollar, but also pushes it closer and almost makes that more of a self-fulfilling prophecy. And so that's the goal. And then the other piece is this coupon system where you can burn, and there's currently, I think it's like about a 50% premium.
And so if you you know, burn like a dollar or one ASD, you get like one, you get like 2.1 coupons-ish right now, which can be redeemed for ASD in the future, but they will expire potentially in 30 days if you aren't able to redeem them, right? And so you're taking on risk, but that's a way that you can get a lot more reward as well. And so the coupon incentives, hopefully not that existing ESD holders then just burn for the coupons and hope the price goes back up. The idea is that there should be now kind of like if you burn your ESD for coupons and do nothing else and the price is going back up, you're just going to lose all your ESD.
You go to zero. Like sucks to be you. So the idea is the incentive is then, you can do that. And if somebody else doesn't push the price back up, you better step into the market and buy some more ESD to get it back up to ensure that you can redeem those coupons and you don't get zeroed. Or as a new entrance, you come in, you buy ESD off the market where it's currently trading below a dollar, burn that to get like a premium from the coupons. And, you know, that becomes kind of a reinforcement mechanism to drive the price back up. So these things play, there's different kind of risk return profiles for taking different activities.
But again, like I said, this is not like a basic beginner thing. I do not recommend people who are interested in this to play the coupon game unless they're very, very aware of what the trade-offs are associated with that. And there is that reliance, though, on net new buying to push it back up to a dollar. If there is not any net new buying and there is net selling, it does not return to the peg. It needs to be net buying to return to the peg. And so that's one of the reasons why I think it's very important that this not grow too quickly, because if there is not interest, enough buying pressure when it drops below, it's just never going to get back up.
so just everyone needs to be very aware of that think about the different dynamics as they participate in the system so the fantastic thing about uncollateralized stable coins is that there's no dependencies on other assets right like it doesn't die depends on ether and uscc and other things that back it uncollateralized stable coins don't have that vector but both vector but both die and both uncollateralized stable coins have oracles are there any differences between an uncollateralized stable coins oracle and an oracle that supports DAI or are they largely the same the same set of problems uh so one of the things that i loved about the design for esd is the way the oracle is done is it uses an eight hour time weighted average price pulled from the uniswap esd usdc pool wow and so that is a really hard oracle to manipulate and it works because you You don't need instant oracle price for liquidation for something like MakerDAO, right?
Like the fact that it's weighted over eight hours is fine. We want it to be robust to manipulation more than accurate in an exact block or an exact instance. But this is a risk, in my view, is that it is reliant on USDC, ESD, Uniswap pool, where the center foundation in theory could freeze all the USDC in that pool and therefore it's censored. And so I think the likelihood of that is relatively low, but certainly with some of the actions we've seen from some government agencies recently, I think it is not a zero risk thing. And so one of the things that has been discussed in the ESD community is, well, could we take advantage of the U.
S.D.C. keeps a very high tech and actually incentivize ESD ETH pool, which would be incredibly censorship resistance, and combine the TWAP off the ESD ETH pool with the U.S.D.C. pool, which is a very deep liquid pool. And if the Center Foundation wanted to like the center foundation is like not going to nuke the usd in the eth usdc pool right if they do that like they're done they're done so right like usdc is done if they're gonna if they're gonna nuke the eth usdc uniswap pool and so that would give esd a level of protection where it's like you can't nuke our pool without nuking everything and how are you gonna nuke the esd ETH pool.
You can't. That is about as censorship resistant as it gets. So I think something like that. But then you lose the advantage. A, you've got now trading from USDC and ESD. You've got double the transaction fees. You also are incentivizing an LP pool that is not, in theory, a stable to stable pool. There is more impermanent loss involved in LPing for the ESD ETH pool. So I don't know if that switch is going to happen, but I think the fact that you can make this more censorship resistant, using ETH as that really censorship resistant asset in the pair, it's so cool that that is possible. And that's what gives me real hope for these assets is not that we want to reference something that is censorable like USDC, but it's the fact that you can actually find a way to reference it where it's useful, but not be dependent on it in a way where you need it to be there for your system to function.
So it sounds like the oracle problem is actually a much smaller problem for empty set dollar or algorithmic stablecoins than it is for crypto collateralized stablecoins. It sounds like that's a much easier problem to solve with much more solutions at hand. yet if they're implemented in the right way, right? Because you can use the AM-based oracles. We've seen a lot of people use AM oracles in dumb ways that have led to hacks. But I think it's really hard to make it like an eight-hour TWAP on something that has millions of dollars, often tens of millions of dollars in liquidity, that that is something that's going to create oracle problems.
One observation, it's kind of been a recurring theme, definitely in Bankless as we've been exploring all of this, is people ask the question of, well, why is this the first time we've seen empty set dollar? Like why didn't we get it two years ago or three years ago? It's really interesting what you said there. I mean, a lot of this has only been possible with the money protocols that we have now, right? So first of all, we had to have this thing called Ethereum, of course. And then we had to have this thing, this money called Uniswap. Uniswap had to build up enough liquidity and VT had to ship.
So we get this time weighted like average so we can have an Oracle. And now we see the birth of algorithmic stable coins. Like it's this, this like tech tree almost that had to be built for us to get to this place. Right. It's like, why didn't we have this three years ago? It wouldn't, it wasn't possible three years ago. We didn't have the, we didn't have the technology. Absolutely. And so I think, you know, one of the, the, the hardest things I think about being in this space as a builder and as an investor is understanding timing and the dependencies around all these things, right? There's so much stuff where, you know, look back at stuff in 2017 and like say, that stuff was so ridiculous.
And yes, most of it was, but there are some things that failed in 2017 or, you know, on Bitcoin failed in 2015, 2013, whatever, that it wasn't because the idea was bad. It's because the timing was wrong. The, the necessary ecosystem components weren't there yet. And we're not, we're not mature enough yet. It's, it's the same way with the internet, right? That, you know, the big examples of like the dot-com boom found was like pets.com and web van. And then a couple of decades later, we've got we've got, you know, chewy.com and Instacart. And so like the concepts were not wrong. It was just the timing was completely off.
All the other things that needed to happen in the ecosystem, in the world had not happened yet. And so I'm super excited to look back at ideas and it's hard for me because I can be like, okay, I saw that, didn't work, saw that, didn't work. And constantly I'm to remember, okay, well, it didn't work then why? And is that reason that didn't work still valid or have the ecosystem grown and changed in such a way that maybe it's valid now, or maybe it can work now, or maybe it'll work a year from now or two or three years from now. I'm not sure. And the timing, right, is really hard. It is so energizing to work with teams that are willing to try these crazy things and are building what, you know, this is the new global financial infrastructure that we are privileged to be part of witnessing and helping to bring into reality.
And I do think that there is something in this space, and maybe it's Empty Step Dollar. Maybe it's one of these other things that exist. Maybe it's one of the things that have yet to launch. And we're actively looking at other things that are doing different approaches in this space because something here, I believe, is likely to work. maybe it's not this cycle, maybe it's in a future cycle, but I think the promise is so great and the potential is there that I want to try these experiments because there is massive, massive benefit to the entire ecosystem if it can be done and done right. Dan, well, I can think of no better person to be at the helm of the ship steering the direction of algorithmic uncollateralized stablecoins.
So thank you for providing that service to the ecosystem. It's the start of 2021, and this seems to be a very promising year for the growth of uncollateralized stablecoins. Maybe you could give us some of your predictions, your goals, your aspirations for the ecosystem around uncollateralized stablecoins for this year. Yeah. So I'm hopeful that, I think there was an earlier question around like, is this a winner-take-all market? Like, no. The same way Like, you know, collateralized centralized stable coins is not a winner take all market. I think there can be multiple ones that gain significant market share.
So I hope that we expect that we will see some of these at least briefly cross the billion dollar kind of circulation or billion dollar market cap around some of these things. I think potentially a lot higher. I think we will see some absolutely implode and go to near zero. What I do think we will start to see is we'll start to see more integrations where it does become viable to use a flat curve like AMM for some of these things because they show that they can stay close enough to a dollar over a long enough period of time that it makes sense to have that flattened AMM curve. I think that we'll start to see some of them.
Cream ESD got added to cream recently, so it can be borrowed and lent there. I can't wait to see stuff like that that's advancing. I'm actually very interested to see how some of these things will start to work across different Layer 2 solutions or potentially other chains too. But I'm more interested in the Layer 2 solutions. And I think there's a different challenge set with moving algo stable coins into layer two solutions versus something like USDC, which you can start minting them directly in the L2. So I think we'll see some experiments around that. I think we're going to see more experimentation around games to essentially incentivize people to maintain the peg tightly.
Less around growth and more around tight pegs. And there's another project that I've been working with called Faye that is experimenting with this idea of protocol-owned liquidity. and actually having a lot of essentially LPs directly by the protocol itself. I mean, it's in burn right tightly around that dollar. It's an approach that I haven't seen anyone else do something similar to that. So I'm excited to see that get live. I think for all of these things, right? There's this interesting dichotomy between what works in theory and what works in practice. and someone recently stated somewhere on Twitter, like it's the stuff that works in practice, but not in theory.
That's the most interesting. And I think Bitcoin is like that. Ethereum is like that. And so there may be some things like that in this algorithmic stablecoin space that could be really exciting. Outside of algorithmic stablecoin, something that I'm really excited about, like I said, L2 adoption. I'm very bullish on. a big fan of the the investment investor in optimism and think the optimistic roll-up approach is great i think some of the advances on zk roll-ups have also been very impressive and excited to see some of those getting more usage too and uh something that's really i think going to come to the fore and is still below the radar for a lot of people is uh what used to be referred to as minor extracted value.
And now there's an attempt to translate it and call it MAM extractable value. So it can be done by validators of all sorts, not just proof of work miners. And I think people are not generally aware of how much these games are being played right now in the MAM pool and how much value essentially being lost to users in the DeFi ecosystem versus, you know, essentially these arbitrageurs who are taking advantage of their peer technology in both mining and mempool monitoring. And so we're going to see that get more democratized this year. People are going to recognize it as a problem. It's going to be talked about, I think, you know, in similar ways to impermanent loss is talked about where if you're active in the ecosystem, you at least need to be aware of the risks and costs and dangers with it.
And more and more teams will be trying to build protocols that are MEV resistant at the very least. So I'm excited to see that play out as a new trend. And again, I always keep coming back to it. That's kind of like super fluid collateral thesis, just maximizing capital efficiency. I think Andre is doing some really, I think Spencer has some really cool stuff that they're going to be doing in their V2 that moves in this direction. Aave has been doing some fantastic stuff, including uniswap key shares as part of the kind of lending and borrowing system as well. Just more and more capital efficiency is, I think, going to allow this whole space to keep moving forward.
and I think leverage is in some ways a scary word, but really let the ecosystem grow a lot more and make it a lot more useful because you'll have much deeper liquidity. We're trying to trade, borrow, lend, do options, do various derivatives. All of this collateral is going to kind of come together and come out of a handful of pools that are going to be super, super efficient. And it's taking a little bit longer than I thought, but I think 2021 is going to be the year where everything is super fluid by default. That and then also paired with a bunch of new money and new users coming into the ecosystem.
2021 is set up to be a bang up year for crypto, probably our biggest ever. Dan, thanks for coming on State of the Nation and helping us learn more about uncollateralized stablecoins. I've already learned a ton. So thank you for your time and I appreciate you coming on and giving us your thoughts. Always a pleasure, guys. Thanks for having me. All right, guys, risks and disclaimers. Of course, I have to say this. ETH is risky. So is crypto. So is DeFi. So are uncollateralized stable coins. Guys, we're on the frontier, but this is the frontier of the frontier. So be careful with these money games.
We're headed west. It's not for everyone, but thanks for joining us on another episode of Bankless.