Jonathan Mann has been writing a song a day for 16 years and 211 days. Today, he and Brian Frye are suing the SEC.
In today’s episode, Jonathan, better known as ‘Song a Day Man’ is joined by Brian Frye, a law professor at the University of Kentucky and NFT/security law expert.
Hear why Jonathan and Brian are suing the SEC, why this lawsuit is so important to the crypto industry as a whole, and what winning would mean for the future of our space.
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦄UNISWAP | BROWSER EXTENSION https://bankless.cc/uniswap
⚡️ FUEL | EARN FUEL POINTS https://bankless.cc/fuel
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle ⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT https://bankless.cc/toku
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨
https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/40 ------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 4:58 Background on Suing 7:34 Jonathan Mann’s Backstory 9:58 Why Brian Got Involved 13:28 The 101 of the Lawsuit 17:22 What Does Winning Do? 22:14 Game Theory 25:14 Fear & Songs a Day 27:18 Logistics of the Suit 32:31 How to Support 34:41 Closing
------ RESOURCES
Jonathan Mann https://x.com/songadaymann https://x.com/songadaymann/status/1817959431206023653
Brian Frye https://x.com/brianlfrye https://youtube.com/live/jo1ZuhuCVZE
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
It's not every day that some of our own sue the SEC, but that is what's happening today. Jonathan Mann, otherwise known as Song A Day Man and previous podcast guests Brian Fry, are suing the SEC, preemptively, in order to protect their livelihood and their passions. They want to make sure that their ability to produce art and sell them as cryptographic tokens on Ethereum is a legal thing to do without triggering the ire of Gary Gensler and the securities law of 1933. Because as of now, as a result of the SEC lawsuit and settlement against stoner cats, the 2021 animated TV show, the president stands as art sold as tokens are unregistered securities.
Before legal, making the SEC, the de facto regulator of digital art, so long as it has a digital token to go along with it. Is the SEC supposed to regulate art? Does it even want that for itself? How did we end up in a place where artists and their art are colliding with the securities regulators? What timeline are we even on? Today on the show, Jonathan Mann and Brian Fry discuss their lawsuit that they are serving the SEC, the game theory behind it, and what its impact will be for our industry when they eventually bring home the dub. So let's go ahead and get right into the episode with Brian and Song and Dayman, but first a message from these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive, and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone, everywhere, to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks, and there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos.
With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. Have the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash banklists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications. Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions.
Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs, and is quickly becoming the Web 3 gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitrum.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum orbit chain? Arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. Whether you're a developer, an enterprise, or a user, Arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum.
Experience Web 3 development the way it was always meant to be. Work, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Visit Arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. Launching a token, don't let complex legal and tax issues slow you down. Toku provides specialized support to optimize your launch and ensure that you as a founder, and your team, and your investors get the most tax-efficient outcomes. The Toku team understands the crypto space inside and out and will ensure your token launch is fully compliant while maximizing tax efficiency. Toku can connect you with the best attorneys if you need them to make sure that you have the best advice, and Toku can help to optimize your taxes, so you pay the least possible amount of taxes while still maintaining legal compliance.
With Toku's guidance, you can concentrate on building your company while Toku handles the logistics. Token launches don't have to be complicated. Talk to Toku today to get a free initial token valuation. Bankless Nation, I'm here with Jonathan Mann, otherwise known as Song a Day Man, and Brian Fry, previous podcast guest and lawyer. Actually both of you have been on the podcast if you count all of the times that we have added Jonathan Mann songs to the end of our weekly roll-up, but in other words, Jonathan, welcome to the bankless podcast in live and present form. Thank you so much. I am very excited as you know, a big fan.
And Brian, we had you on to talk about our NFTs securities, which was one of my more interesting episodes, and it was really not trying to actually ascribe a legal assertation as to whether they are or not, but more of a thought experiment as to the question of securities and the idea of NFTs. And you're kind of back for round two. So gentlemen, who wants to kind of drop the hammer on what we are actually doing here today? What you guys have already done here today in the legal process of the United States, but also here on the podcast episode today. Who wants to take lead here? Let me give some background.
Let me set the stage and then I'm going to, and then we'll let Brian do his brilliant lawyer, lawyer ring to take us deeper. The SEC brought a case against Stoner Katz back in 2023. If folks will remember what Stoner Katz was, it was a big project that launched in 2021, in the height of the frenzy of that time. It involved Ashen Kutcher and Milakunis, although as I sort of like found out later on and as I dug into it, it was really made actually by just some like working Hollywood animators. Just like people who I actually really identify with is just like artists who are just trying to get by making their work and they just happened to like hook up with Milakunis and her whole thing and that she brought in the NFTs.
And then they get slapped with this SEC lawsuit claiming that they were selling unregistered securities. The NFTs aspect of this cartoon animation were unregistered security. The Kat JPEGs that they sold according to the SEC were investment contracts that they were doing with the people that bought them. If you read the complaint, if you read the sort of action that the SEC took against them and what ended up happening was that they ended up settling for a million dollars, which is like what I learned later is like a million dollars is like a really good deal in this case actually. And it would have cost them many times that to fight.
So they settled a bunch of things but like they had to like one weird thing was that they had to destroy, they had some stoner cats left over that they were going to use for contest and stuff. One of the pieces of the SEC thing was that like they had to destroy any stoner cats that they had in their possession, they'd like burn their artwork. Anyway, when this happened, I got really angry because as I read through the complaint, as I read through the action that they took, I realized that it sort of implicated everybody in the NFT space. It implicates me, it implicates Brian, it implicates you, David, if you've ever, so I think you've sold an NFT at some, like, you guys have bankless NFTs like, we are all implicated because it's so broad and there's no kind of like, Brian, it doesn't make sense.
And so yeah, so I got really angry by this case. I wrote a song. Jonathan, explain a little bit of your backstory, Jonathan, a song of Damien, why are you so angry? I love it to you. Yeah. Well, since 2022, I've been basically making my living, selling my songs as NFTs. Every day I make a song, I put it on my website to go up for auction, we're in this kind of fallow period for NFTs, but I have like a small and hearty band of people that want to buy the songs and they do and sometimes they go viral and they get more money and that's how I've been making my living. So I took this sort of as a direct affront to my livelihood in a lot of ways.
And just like, everybody that I know who's making NFTs, there's so much creativity here, there's so much just brilliant artists doing their thing to feel like we are all implicated in whatever machinations the SEC has going on made me so angry that I wrote a song called this song as a security, which I believe you guys actually played that week at the end of the, uh, banquets at the end of the roll up, um, and as a result of that song, I started talking to some like lawyers in this space and talking about like, what would it actually take to like, take this fight to the SEC, how would that work?
And, you know, the, the, the balls were rolling and they said, do you know anyone else who might be interested in suing the SEC in order to get some clarity on whether NFTs are actually securities or not? Um, and I said, I know just the person, uh, my friend Brian Fry, who I actually originally heard on banquets, that's the first time I ever heard of Brian, uh, who, you know, he can introduce himself. He's a brilliant, uh, lawyer, but also an artist. He has this kind of, uh, conceptual artist lawyer crossroads that I imagine he may be one of one of one interested one of one intersection. Uh, so when, when these lawyers are talking to you, say, hey, we think it would be better if we have at least one other artist on this case.
It sort of helps us cover more ground and we can, I said, let's talk to Brian and Brian said, let's do it. And so Brian, yeah, come on down and tell us your role in this whole story. Yeah. So I've been waiting for this lawsuit for 20 years, right? I started thinking about this problem when I was a baby lawyer at Solvenin Cromwell, working on securities law, the more I looked at securities, the more I talked to myself, that looks an awful lot or sounds an awful lot like conceptual work. And everyone just kind of looked at me like I was crazy. And what are you talking about? And that doesn't make any sense.
So I was so forth. So in, in, in, in, in 2019, I actually wrote a, or other, I, I released the work of securities art titled SEC no action letter requests, which I styled in the form of perspectives that I wrote as a law review article in which I described how I was sending a no action letter request to the SEC proposing to sell a work of conceptual art titled SEC no action letter request consisting of sending a no action letter request to the SEC, right? And telling them like according to everything that you say, what I'm doing is issuing an unregistered security. So you really ought to tell me I'm not allowed to do this.
And unsurprisingly, the SEC declined to respond to my no action letter request, although a young friend of mine did manage to eventually FOIA from them and almost entirely redacted set of emails that preserve nothing other than them calling my theories, answerful, right? Well, fast forward to 2021. And if team market explodes and I'm like, wait a minute, this is just proving everything I said in my article. They said before, well, this isn't really a security because people wouldn't really buy it. And therefore, it's not a real market. And I'm like, hold my fucking beer, man, right? People are going to buy this.
So I mean, I just took that article. I made it into an NFT project, dropped it on to OpenC. And it sold out in like 20 minutes, like, you know, $30,000 worth of if there's something. And I was like, this is an amazing proof of concept that literally what I'm doing here is according to the SEC illegal. So when Jonathan came to me with this proposal, I was like, this is, this is perfect. Right? Because I'm already on record literally going to the SEC and say, what the hell is wrong with you? You got to explain what you're doing. This doesn't make any sense. Your theories are cockamaining nonsense, right?
It can't be true that the SEC is authorized by statute to regulate the entire market. That can't be true, right? And any theory of what is a security that says the SEC can regulate the art market is bananas, right? Because the art market was around when the SEC was created, right? And 100 plus years later, still ain't regulating the art market, right? No one expected it to. No one wanted to. It doesn't know how. It doesn't have the capacity to do it. There's no reason for it to do it. It doesn't make any sense, right? And I think that the SEC really needs to kind of take stock of what it's real purposes, what it's real institutional competencies are, and why it's regulating things in the first place.
What is it trying to accomplish by doing this regulation? I just don't see that the SEC has anything to add to this market. And so I think what's happening here is as a result of the expansive interpretation of what a token is by the SEC, the SEC has run up against some edge cases, which have started to push back against the SEC. I think we saw this when Richie Torres was challenging Gary Gensler on a greater example. Hey, Gary Gensler is this Pokemon card, a security if it's a token on Ethereum, and Gary Gensler is like, well, it's facts and circumstances is what his answer was. And now you guys are presenting a very similar argument of like, hey, Gary Gensler, is art a security?
Hey, SEC is art a security if it comes in the form of a digital token. And that's like kind of the core message of your guys is lawsuit, right? Kind of like walk us through the 101's of this lawsuit because just really just to remind listeners what's going on here is we are suing the SEC's two people on the show today are suing the SEC trying to establish a precedent. What's the 101 of what's going on here? So we've created we've each created our own new project that we are presenting to the court. We've created we've we've we've created these new projects specifically to present to the court as a example of here's something that we're ready to release.
We want to put this out and we are asking the court to do something called a declaratory judgment or a summary judgment declaratory judgment saying saying either yes, this thing that you are presenting to us is a security or no, in fact, this thing you're presenting to us is not security. So mine is you know, it's a programmatic remix of my this song as a security song, you know, I made a bunch of layers and I I remixed it and it'll be remixed 10,420 times which is the same amount of NFTs that the stoner cats put out, you know, we're you know, the projects that we are putting out while they're not exactly like stoner cats because nothing is ever the same.
There is no real difference between the material difference between the projects that we're presenting and things like stoner cats or or even impact theory which was also another case that that got settled. So we're presenting this to the court and we're saying hey court give us some clarity here like give us a ruling and hopefully Brian can talk to this but hopefully what will happen is that the SEC will you know come and and have a good faith exchange with us of of why why they think that these things are securities and we'll you know get into and Brian can get into that more specifically. Yeah so so I created a project that's a little more pointed in some ways in Jonathan it's titled cryptographic tokens of material financial benefit it's a work of conceptual art that consists of the concept of thinking about why art is valuable and I'm selling this work in conceptual art in addition of 10,320 NFTs for .
01 each and essentially what you get in exchange for buying one is the feeling of being a winner because because you understand what it means for art to be valuable and you know as with previous works I've explained I'm gonna explain to people exactly how this fits into the securities slash cryptographic art ecosystem and I hope it's really clear to the SEC that if they're going to pursue the line of argumentation that they have been then they have no choice but to tell me that I'm not allowed to sell conceptual art. Okay so we're taking this lawsuit to the SEC and there's going to be some back and forth it's going to be some conversation something's going to happen what are we hoping what's the wind scenario look like.
Well so I mean if I may right this is a really this is a really particular kind of lawsuit right so what you're allowed to do under federal law the law is stupid but we're finally in federal lawsuits right what you're allowed to do under federal law is if you have a reasonable belief based in fact that the government or someone else but here the government is going to do something that will prejudice your interests in one way or another it's going to harm you in some way you can preemptively file a lawsuit against that other party in this case the government are specifically the SEC saying hey I want to do this I think that if I do this the government is going to sue me for it they're going to prosecute me for it they're going to bring a civil action against me or therefore I want the court to preemptively say that what I'm doing is something that I'm allowed to do and that the government isn't allowed to bring a lawsuit against me for doing this these called declaratory judgment action because the court declares that what you're doing is something that you're allowed to do so that's what we're doing in my now hometown of New Orleans Louisiana in the fifth circuit bringing an action against the SEC saying hey we want to release these projects they haven't done it yet because we're worried that if we do it the SEC is going to come after us and the SEC is going to prosecute us further and it's going to do like it did to sonocats and make it make it make it give it a lot of money as like a final we don't want to do that right we want to be able to do our conceptual art making and songwriting in in peace and specifically in my case right one of the reasons I think I was an attractive plaintiffs but here was that I've already gone to the SEC a couple times since I wanted to and they refused to respond to me right they refused to respond to my letters that I wrote to them describing exactly what I wanted to do explaining why I thought I was a problem in the form of an entire law review article laying out the entire kind of theoretical concern that I had they just adore me and then and then and then they go and sue stone or cats totally totally in line with what you were saying to them in the first place they ignore you and they sue sue stone or cats it just it it boggles the mind how how how stupid that and how annoying that is new projects are coming online to the mantle layer two every single week why is this happening maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer two design architecture since it first started building mantle d a powered by technology from eigen d a maybe it's because users are coming onto the mantle layer two to capture some of the highest yields available in defi and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the three billion dollar mantle treasury in the mantle reward station maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants liquidity support and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application maybe it's all of these reasons all put together so if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's defi apps click the link in the show notes so getting started with mantle introducing fuel the purpose bill operating system for ethereum rollups fuel is revolutionizing the ethereum ecosystem with features like paralyzed and state minimize execution cross chain interoperability and native account abstraction plus supports walls of all networks ensuring you can use fuel no matter where you store your crypto but that's not all you can join the fuel points program today to earn points unlock rewards and qualify for future incentives as fuel marshals towards main net fuel points are off chain points earned by completing on chain actions that positively contribute to the growth of the network and the holding fuel points can automatically qualify you for future network rewards so don't miss out on the fuel opportunity click the link in the description below to get started fuel points are here go get it the uniswap extension is here the self custody created by the most trusted team in defi uniswap labs designed to make swapping feel effortless this extension lives in your browser's sidebar letting you swap sign transactions and send or receive crypto without ever losing your place on the internet plus with human readable transaction messages you'll always know exactly what you're signing navigate a multi chain world effortlessly with support for 11 chains like ethereum main net base arbitrage and optimism no more chain switching or token importing all your assets are right where you need them to be the uniswap extension is designed to level up your swapping experience with other uniswap labs products as well easily on board to the extension using the uniswap mobile wallet to begin managing your assets across platforms and take advantage of smooth seamless synergies with the uniswap web app so go and download the uniswap extension today by clicking the link in the show notes just another way uniswap is helping you swap smarter and so johnson you're you're one of the things i enjoy about this is that this is a continuation on brian's arc against the scc like this is the next logical like like milestone in the quest line that is brian fri versus the scc and i think the role that that you play in in this johnathan is that as i've watched brian engage with the scc it's like it's it's an it's an attempt in a conceptual art manner to like pants the scc more or less and the way that i'm seeing this unfold is that say that this goes to court say the scc wants to take this to court and you have like defendant gary gensler versus uh versus uh johnathan man the song a day man and we have johnathan man the guy that writes a song a day every single day and he's just simply asking for the court to protect his ability to write a song a day every single day and if you go and you juxtapose some of the songs from johnathan song a day man which with gary gensler the defendant like gary does not want to be in that position of being the guy that says that johnathan man does not get to write a song a day and listen on a theorem that's just like it's just a bad look for the agency and so that this is a part of like the game theory going on right you said it not us you said okay we didn't say we we we we have no comment on that specifically but i would say you know i would just say that i uh you know it's as we we can joke about it and it's funny and and there's things but i am genuinely angry like i'm like like like every time i actually talk to like the stoner cats people and like mm-hmm i get angry all over again it's just the unfairness really is driving me baddie and so i would relish an opportunity any opportunity and this is the opportunity that i'm relishing to like just make it stop you know it hopefully and so the for me the end goal is like NFTs are forever more you know we can just be artists and not have to worry about this bullshit so i'm like i'm like johnathan i would say that i'm disappointed and i'm disappointed in the scc and my jesus mother would tell you but that's way worse that's that's way worse than angry right and i'm disappointed in the scc because i don't think they're doing their job i don't think they're doing their job right i don't think they're thinking about what their job is i don't think they're thinking about what they're saying and whether saying it i think they're being irresponsible with the incredible amount of power that they've been given as a government agency to regulate people's lives and people's ability to express themselves and i think that's a really profound problem that they should be thinking about and i'm disappointed i'm disappointed that they don't have it in them to even recognize how they're affecting people's lives and then johnathan you say you're angry but i would imagine if i was in your shoes and i'm an artist who is creating and selling NFTs and then i observe stoner cats getting sued for a million dollars i would also feel fear yeah absolutely my livelihood of my job how many days in a row have you been singing songs we're on 5,689 today and that like if the scc comes and suits you you could still write a song but your material income and your hobby of your career your life's career of like writing a song a day for five over five thousand days would be materially threatened yeah it would be you know i mean i came into nfts in 2017 specifically with the hope that this would be a really great way to monetize song a day that i hadn't been able to do before and so i finally get there and to yeah to face up against this like weird government agency overreach which is not really like my bag normally you know but but here i am uh it's just it's really it's really strange it also is very like song a day song a day is always leading me in these really weird places and it's like i i just sent my friend Ethan buckman from cosmos chain a meme because he was the first person it got me interested in blockchain way back in 2017 so the meme is the uh it's the it's the domino meme where it's like a tiny domino and a big dominoes meet meet Ethan buckman at a conference tiny domino sue the scc big dominoes like just one thing leads to another and here i am but that you yeah no absolutely i would be uh if if the scc continues down that path of of attacking capriciously attacking nft projects not only not only does it like threaten me directly but also you know everyone in the ecosystem is harmed and everyone who maybe wants to collect a song they're implicated everybody is implicated i have purchased nfts from an artist friend of mine uh Nate molar uh and uh as a result of that interaction i had with him him and i have become friends i have met his friends i have learned from him and had just like amazing experiences like learning from this artist and his network of people and that was because of just like the purchasing of a financial object on ethereum that is associated with digital art with an mp4 file uh i would be very disappointed had i not been able to have this experience that ethereum and nfts have created for me um Brian can you walk us through some of the logistics of this uh suit uh you guys are filing the suit today congratulations thank you what are the next steps how does this proceed from here well for the for the time being it's basically an scc's court and so the scc is going to have to decide how to respond to the lawsuit and essentially there's there's two initial ways that a defendant in a lawsuit can respond to it and that you know that's what the scc and the various commissioners are here is defendant so they got two traces they can either do what's called what's answer the complaint right in other words file a responsive document or a responsive pleading answering all the claims that we have in the complaint saying you know yes or no that's true that's not true we agree to this we don't agree to this we don't know about that with respect to the various claims that we've made or they can take it a procedural approach and file a motion to dismiss under rule 12b of the federal rules of civil procedure in this case they'd probably go for rule 12b6 which would essentially be them saying based on this complaint you haven't actually stated a claim against us we don't have to respond to this because everything you said you know even if everything you said is true it doesn't matter we're still allowed to do what we want to do and there's no basis for you to bring this declared to a judgment action in in the first place typically what a defendant will do is file that second motion that motion to dismiss because it kind of is like in the camp down the road right it's giving an opportunity to kind of air your best position to the court and let the court kind of let you know what it's thinking about you know where you're at whether or not the plaintiff has any possibility of success I'm really interested to see what if anything they say in that 12b6 motion if and when they file it however in this case I actually think and this is kind of unusual I think there's a third option right where the SEC at least conceivably could just say our bad right we didn't mean it right we don't actually want to do that and everything you've said are things that we have no intention of regulating therefore you can have your declaratory judgment action we agree with you on the marriage and they just they just fold and I think that I hate to be a predictor right but in this particular case it wouldn't shock me if they fold right because this will be a very awkward lawsuit for the SEC it's not it's not a good look it's not a good look no and they've already had a bad experience with our lawyer so you know that what's fit in twice shot as it were and while we've like hoping for or being optimistic for optimistic outcomes with the SEC hasn't historically been the right horse to bet on but the political climate is materially different six months in the last six months so like kind of playing slate here like as an November election draws close like there's a different calculus being being played out here yeah that's definitely true Brian I want to ask you a question that I don't actually know the answer to is there a timeline do they have a certain amount of time before they have to they have to respond one way or the other technically yes but realistically no oh interesting right so there is a timeline they have a certain number of days before they have to file their motion to dismiss but they can ask the court for more time and in a case like this one and especially with a defendant like the SEC like a government agency in general courts are pretty receptive to defendants in general but the government defendants in particular asking for more time to get it to a lawsuit of this kind they'll get it they can take as much they can kind of drag their heels as long as they want on on this one until the court kind of loses its patience with them but I mean I really think the the harder question for them it's going to be do they really want to litigate this at all right well guys I find this immensely entertaining as a piece of as a piece of art I'm enjoying it so thank you for thank you for taking this to the court taking this to the SEC is there anything we can do as listeners as onlookers as supporters any way that we can support yeah I mean from from my perspective I have a couple things that I've set up so as always purchasing my songs helps me helps my family this is a great thing you can do you can bid on today's song which is called I'm suing the SEC and it's a it's inspired by classic TV intros and it imagines Gary Gensler and me in a sort of TV show together that we're experiencing so please go bid please go bid on that I've also set up a PFP that people can mint for free on my website to use as their avatar if they want to like signal support the good news is the lawsuit is taken care of so we don't need help we don't need financial help with the lawsuit itself but uh at you know this is my livelihood and any any help people want to throw my way is always very much appreciated uh is it appropriate to ask who is is funding the lawsuit I think we were told not to say so no comment on that secret benefit yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah and in my case uh you know you can follow me on twitter I always love that and I would love interacting with with new people and I've written a lot about this subject I've tweeted recently just earlier this morning a lot of this stuff I've written so if you go to my SSRN page you can download all that material and read it for free learn more about my kind of journey in securities law and cryptographic tokens and I'd be delighted to you know how people check that stuff out and enter podcasts that's right oh yeah I have a podcast podcast it's a Dixit podcast ipse dixit it focuses primarily on legal scholarship broadly defined as a whole bunch of crypto related content on there's yeah and if a bankless listeners you guys are entertained and peaked by some of the conceptual legal crypto art being presented here uh and you don't want this episode to end I would actually go and suggest our other episode with Brian fry highly suggested I one of the more entertaining fascinating insightful podcast episodes that we've done in a very long time uh about how there's this secret fifth prong of the how we test and that's kind of the one that really matters the most it's the only one that matters uh so we'll link we'll link all of these things just mentioned in the show notes uh Jonathan Brian uh congratulations on suing the scc uh and thanks for coming on the episode today thank you so much for having us thank you bye bye my name is Jonathan and you be perfectly plain this wasn't part of my plan like i've been growing up with a distant dream of some days doing a government agency there's a smoke regulator who's been up to no good doing his level best to try and best to allow me so while there's a million other things that i'd rather be doing projects that i've got ruined instead i'm suing the scc i'm doing this and when you buy them that's an investment that i'll take contact that's an investment contract every single entity that's been sold uh oh there's a legal under this uh one i'm doing this i'm suing the scc is filmed before a live studio organ Gary right what's his running good morning good morning well doesn't this look wonderful did you have any trouble no not a bit you