Seth Hertlein, VP Global Head of Policy at Ledger, and Michael Mosier, Co-Fouder of legal boutique Arktourous, Build Exante - FinCEN, Treasury, and Chief Technical Counsel at Chainalysis join us on today’s show to explain the modern financial surveillance apparatus. FATF, FinCEN, AML/KYC, OFAC...the blacklists, the greylists. How does it all work? Who makes the rules?
------ 🎁 Check your wallet with our brand new tool: Claimables https://bankless.cc/GetClaimables
------ 📣 AAVE V3 is Here! http://app.aave.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku
----- TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 9:10 Financial Surveillance 13:10 Data Collection 17:10 The Bank Secrecy Act 20:30 SARS 23:10 Understanding the Enforcers 30:30 Goals for FINCEN 38:55 OFAC Explained 51:11 Strict Liability 56:26 Process of Getting OFAC SDN List 1:00:50 Tornado Cash 1:11:05 What Should We Do? 1:21:05 Closing & Disclaimers
----- RESOURCES
Michael Mosier https://twitter.com/m_mosier_
Seth Hertlein https://twitter.com/SethHertlein
----- Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey, Bankless Nation. I put out a tweet last week that said this. Who can come on bank lists and explain the modern financial surveillance apparatus? Fadda. Finson. AMLKYC. OFAC. The Black List. The Grey List. How does it all work? Who makes the rules? But in the space for years, I still don't understand these dark corners. It's very much how I felt coming to this episode. Needing the financial surveillance 101. I knew it was an octopus. I knew it was this multi-headed hydra. I had no idea how deep it's roots actually go. And today we unpack this with legal experts. Seth Hurtline from the VP of Global Policy at Ledger.
And also Michael Mosier. He actually has spent some time in the belly of the beast at both Finson and OFAC. Now he's the guy inside the house. Yeah. And now he's on Team Crypto. So he's got some insider baseball that he's going to tell us as we make sense of this. This was a really fantastic episode. I know I want to get your comments on this episode. But before we do, we've got a message from our friends and sponsors over at Abe. David, what does Abe want Bankless listeners to know? Abe wants you to know that Abe V3 is here. And I mean, it's been here. It's been here for six months. So why does Abe want you to know that V3 is here?
Well, because apparently over a billion dollars of capital doesn't know that because it's still in Abe V2. Not only that, but there is a button for migrating your capital to Abe V3. So Abe, if you are Abe V2, enjoyer, which you are free to because it is permissionless open source technology, they still want you. Everything gets better if all of the liquidity goes to the same place. So if you are using Abe, but you are using Abe, an old version of Abe, perhaps consider joining the rest of the crew in Abe V3. It has more liquidity than Abe V2, but also some extra features as well. So par asset isolation mode into compartmentalizer risks.
It's got some gas optimizations. It's got some extra bells and whistles. It's just a better version of Abe, app.a.com. But then also there is Abe grants. If you are a builder building on Abe, especially there's brand new stablecoin go, there are grants available to you. So overall, there's a bunch of things to do in the Abe ecosystem and there's a link in the show notes to get started with all of them. Yeah, my favorite. I would say both of our favorites, lending and borrowing protocol in crypto. They've been around since the very beginning. Obviously, it's fantastic. David, I know this episode was my idea.
It's kind of like geeky walkish stuff, but I felt like it was so important, especially on the back of developers getting rest in tornado cash. Like, what is going on? I just realized one day I don't even understand what all of these institutions are and what gives the financial surveillance system their apparatus. What did you think of this episode? Yeah, I definitely would categorize this one as a Ryan episode. I was definitely in listening mode for the majority of this podcast. I mean, I guess I guess what it's like to be a listener here in listening mode. So I guess telling listener center or listening mode, I guess doesn't help them.
I learned a lot. It felt like story time a little bit about American history. One of these episodes that we frequently do on bankless every now and then about just like, hey, how did just the state of laws come to be in the way that they are? And how are they downstream from the original American values that this country was founded on? And what about the current settling of the dust around this new player in the world of in this universe called cryptography? How is that disturbing the equilibrium and how do we need to extend American values into this new world? Because if we don't do that, then non-American values will take over.
I think that's kind of the through line that I would that will anchor bankless listeners is that there's this new field in territory. We can have freedom enter and establish itself legally or we can have authoritarian entrance enter in that same field. And I mean, I think everyone knows which side that we want to win. We need to actually fight for that and fighting for that starts with understanding. And so I think that's why I enjoyed this episode. It helps tell that story. Yeah. And anytime David says American values, if you're outside the US and you're like American values, just think of liberal values.
Like lowercase L values, right? Civil liberties, you know, freedoms of citizens to express themselves and to transact without the surveillance of the government. That's really what we're talking here. And that's what's at stake more than anything. I think this episode impressed upon me that unchecked. This is just an octopus. This is just like a tree structure that will. It's not an octopus slime mold. It will grow. Exactly. And it is growing. And it has grown since like the 1970s. Anyway, absolutely fantastic episode. Guys, stay tuned for this. But before we do, we want to tell you about our friends over at Kraken, which is our number one recommended exchange.
Go check them out. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade on Kraken Pro. You'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data and lightning fast trade execution. All inside, there's spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout lets you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs.
Visit pro. Kraken.com to get started today. Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem. All built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network. A brand new high-performance Ethereum layer 2 built using the OP stack, but uses EigenLayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer 1. Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle.
Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboarded, like Game 7 for Web3 Gaming, and Bybit for TVL and liquidity and on-rounds. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle. If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led Layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Arbitrum is accelerating the Web3 landscape with a suite of secure Ethereum scaling solutions. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum 1, with flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems.
Arbitrum Nova is quickly becoming a Web3 Gaming Hub and social apps like Reddit are also calling Arbitrum Home. And now, Arbitrum Orbit allows you to use Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own Layer 3, giving you access to interoperable customizable permissions with dedicated throughput. Whether you are a developer, enterprise, or a user, Arbitrum Orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. Faster transaction speeds and significantly lower gaspies.
So visit Arbitrum.io, where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app with Arbitrum. Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Bankless Nation, we are super excited to host two legal minds on our show today. Seth Hurtline is the Vice President Global Head of Policy at Ledger and Michael Moser. He's the co-founder of a legal boutique called Arcturus, and he is also building X-Anti. He's formerly been at Finsen, and the Treasury Chief Technical Counsel at Tanalysis, so he's seen a thing or two in the space.
Welcome, Michael. Thanks. All right, guys, so what we're going to attempt to do on today's episode is give kind of the every man explanation of financial surveillance. I feel like this is an episode, maybe for me. It's kind of a selfish episode, because I feel like here I am in crypto, and I've heard all of these four or five-letter agencies, and it's recently started to impact my life with, like, tornado cash. I'm not entirely sure what these agencies are. I'm not entirely sure what's legal and what's not. I'm not entirely sure what powers each of these agencies actually have over my financial life.
And I'm looking for, like, the 101. I'm looking for, like, the explainer. When we talk about FATIF, and we're talking about OFAC, we're talking about whitelists and gray lists, and we're talking about, you know, can I use tornado cash or not? And I can't because I'm an American. I just don't know what every, like, what's going on here. So I feel like we need the 101 episode. So if you guys are game to do that, that's what this we're going to try to accomplish today. Sound good? Great. Absolutely. Well, let's kind of start domestic from sort of the US perspective, if we will, and then go international to kind of the rest of the world.
But I want to start with maybe a working definition. So I'm thinking of this episode as, like, a financial surveillance 101 episode. And I'm wondering if you guys could sort of describe financial surveillance. When I use that term, what does it mean to you? What is kind of happening behind the scenes? Who are some of the main agencies that hold the power? I'll throw this one to you first, Seth. Okay. Well, you know, I think, you know, for the purposes of this episode, let's sort of carve out, you know, private sector or sort of corporate surveillance. Let's sort of limit the scope of today's conversation to government surveillance.
But, you know, I think the, you know, a good working definition could be, you know, information that is collected by or required to be reported to the federal government or an agency thereof, either by individuals or by service providers, intermediaries that they use for their everyday financial lives. So just to check that definition, Seth, I hear hearing two parts. One is the legally mandated reporting requirements, which if you don't do it, you get like something like fines and jail. And then there's additional information, which it would seem that the powers that be are able to just collect by their own visual mechanisms.
It's in like it's information that's out there and they collect that information because it's available for them to collect. So that's two types of data. I mean, Mike, I'd be curious to your thoughts on this. I think it sort of converges effectively into more or less the same thing. So maybe not a need to draw that particular distinction. Yeah, I think it's a collective approach. I think for two reasons. One is, you know, some of that will come into play. David, as we think about challenges, including constitutional challenges, his courts have made a distinction between when you put your trash out, have you relinquished control of it?
And if somebody goes through it, they just go through it, through it, versus somebody coming in your house and going through your papers, which is the sort of genesis of the Fourth Amendment. And I think as that's pointing out, we're in a space here with Web 1, 2, and now 3, where there's tremendous amount that's in this gray area between what's public and what isn't. I think even the concept of like what's public information at this point is a lot more of a fine-tuned, fine nuanced issue, including, I should say, like, in a way that also these same government agencies that are collecting it for various reasons.
I mean, the mission of all of this, and I think this is important, is something when I was at Finston, we would say to the people on the hill making the laws, too, sometimes without asking us first, was that the primary mission is countering exploitation here. And so you have to factor into that, the fact that this information out there and being collected in any form is also subject to creating greater exploitation. And that includes, you know, honeypots of people's data that gets hacked, some of this recently coming up in FTX and Kroll coming out of the bankruptcy. And that's something that I think there's the policymakers and the politicians, and then there's also the operators out there, including at Finston and DOJ, who are saying, actually, we don't need more cases and more victims.
So can we protect some of this, too? It's partly why we brought in privacy experts and did initiatives on zero-knowledge proofs at home on more of a encryption at Finston. So I do think it's really important that we're talking about that very holistically. There's a lot out there. So already, we're talking about Finston and DOJ and Treasury and all these kind of institutions I want to get some working definitions on. But while we're talking about this term financial surveillance, all right? Let's just get a grasp of what sort of data is generally being collected? And like when? Is this primarily like intermediaries that are required to submit this?
Because as a citizen in the US, I don't often have to... I guess I'm not conscious of times that I'm filing paperwork with Treasury or Finston. But maybe I am through an intermediary and I just don't know it. So what sort of things are being tracked and surveilled and why? I'm happy to take the first. I mean, so it's true, you're not. Although I will say there's legislation out there, particularly in the tax space, that could make you a reporter. Whether you like it or not. And whether everyone around you likes it or not. And speaking of honeypots, you may be collecting and reporting on others.
But I think as in a traditional stand from a Finston perspective in the Bank Secrecy Act, you're absolutely right, it would be intermediaries. And in fact, this goes back to some of the constitutional issues that... And the third party doctrine that Seth mentioned. But it's really transactional information. And historically, in fact, we can talk through a little bit if you want the history of the Bank Secrecy Act. But it was exactly this. It was around reporting requirements, basically coming up through the 70s. And basically, at the time, it was purely... It was basically large cash... Law enforcement was seeing large cash deliveries to banks.
Pretty sure it was organized crime. And when they would go to a bank, the bank would say, I don't know. I don't know why Bugsy Seagull dropped off $100 million. And so the other piece of that was that there was foreign Swiss banks at the time. And so this was the foreign transactions reporting piece of it, too. That had Swiss Bank Secrecy, Bank Secrecy, which is where the Bank Secrecy Act comes from. And so the US would say, okay, well, we'll go to Switzerland where some of this money is getting sent from the bank that was brought in in cash. And they'd go to the Swiss and say, okay, you tell me about what's going on here.
And they would say, there's nothing we can say. There's Bank Secrecy here. And so part of it was going to the US banks and saying, we need you to collect more information. At the time, it was really just information of like, who's collecting it? They're basically their bank opening information. What do they live? What's their phone number? What's their occupation? What's their source of income? That sort of thing. It evolved over time to suspicious activity reports, which is much more, I think, what you're thinking through. Which is, okay, now a bank is making a determination. Seth came in the other day.
He didn't just drop off a bunch of cash. He's making anomalous deposits that don't make sense to us. This seems suspicious. He said he was a reporter, but he makes a million dollars a day. What's going on here? And so they would file a suspicious activity report that would lay out. Who is it? What did he say? It came from. And what is it that's suspicious about it? And I should say, like, you know, back in the day, that would have been, he brought in a bag of cash. Then it would evolve to checks and check numbers. Then it would evolve to wire transfers and the wire transfer information about every piece of that transaction, who the correspondent bank was.
In the crypto space, that could be all sorts of things. What wallet address was connected? What time? If it's a public ledger like Ethereum or Bitcoin, that might be, here's a graph of everything that that wallet touched historically. Depending on what the platform is, they may collect the IP address, even the device identifier that Seth used to connect. So there's a tremendous amount of data and metadata that could be collected in that report. So can we go back to kind of the history here with you guys to make sure I understand it. So there wasn't, and we're still domestics. We're still talking about the US and we'll expand international after this.
So prior to like the 1970s, am I right to say there wasn't much financial surveillance. And then in the 1970s, is that correct? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So that's correct. And then in the 1970s, basically to kind of fight crime, maybe organized crime. The mafia was sort of one organization that was in the crosshairs. The US came out with a bank secrecy act. And this started sort of the financial surveillance apparatus. And so this is this the reason basically for AML KYC, which is like, I have to be identified before I can like, you know, with a government ID, let's say, before I can open a bank account.
And this is the reason when I go to like transfer money or take out a large deposit from my bank, the bank teller will say, what are you doing with that? Like, how are you using that money to ask these questions? I'm always like, why do you need to know this? You know, and it's almost couched as if, well, I want to protect you from frauds and scams. You know, maybe that's part of it. It seems like more of it is kind of this financial surveillance apparatus. So that's why I have to present an ID. That is why they are asking questions. Like, what are you doing with the money? And can you tell me more about the source of the funds?
These are all questions. I know many bankless listeners have seen from their banks. And it all emanated from this legislation from the 1970s and the Bank Secrecy Act. Is this correct? Yeah, so it started. Bank Secrecy Act was enacted in 1970. And, you know, at that time, it was, you know, a much smaller version, you know, than it is now. Right? So in 1970, it had two core provisions, title one, title two. Title one basically said, banks have to record transactions of their customers. They have to keep an internal log of all the transactions that our customers made. Title two said, banks have to report transactions over a certain size to the Treasury Department.
In 1970, that threshold was set at $10,000 US dollars. And so that created one of these forms that the reports get made on called a CTR or currency transaction important. Importantly, that threshold, that $10,000, hasn't ever been adjusted. Right? So if you go back and you adjust the CTR threshold back to $1970, it's equivalent of about $79,000 today. Wow. And what that amounts? Yeah, what amounts that amounts to is, you know, a gradual but constant tightening of the news of a transaction reporting on the American people. And, you know, and so that's where it started. You know, but, you know, both as sort of Mike and Ryan, your comments alluded to, there's this sort of creeping nature of it where it all, it just expands.
Right? So first it was just the CTRs and the record keeping. You know, now it's SARS or suspicious activity ports that were added in 1992. There was a vast expansion of the scope of the types of transactions and the types. It just really quicks SARS. So suspicious activities report. Is that basically in comment on sort of the bank teller or bank employee to be like, Hey, there's something fishy about this transaction and I'm going to report it up. Is that right? Exactly. Exactly. Okay. And, you know, so interesting stat on suspicious activity reports. Somewhere north of two million SARS get filed with Vincent every year.
And again, curious for your insider take on this mic, but, you know, testimony presented to Congress is that Vincent reviews less than 1% of the SARS that are actually filed. And, you know, and there are, you know, way more CTRs filed than SARS filed. So, you know, most of this information goes into, you know, basically just a government database and sits there waiting to be queried. And, you know, but so these things keep getting added on to the BSA, right? So it grows over time. And there was a huge expansion and scope. BSA Bank Secrecy Act. Bank Secrecy Act. Yeah. And so there was a big expansion and scope as part of the Patriot Act after 9-11 that added a lot of new types of information that had to be gathered and reported and new intermediary types that are responsible for gathering and reporting that information.
And, you know, to your initial question, Ryan, sort of, you know, is it, you know, is it just, you know, am I self reporting this or is it just intermediaries? The answer is both, right? So you're self reporting on your tax returns, but your intermediaries are also also filing information returns with the IRS. Depending on your specific situation, you could be filing what are called F bars or sort of foreign bank account reports or, you know, any foreign financial institution that you may have a relationship with under a law called Fatka is filing reports on you to treasury as well. And, you know, so there's this sort of snowballing effects is this creep of this expansion of scope of the financial surveillance regime under both sort of AML, the AML access and the tax access such that, you know, there, you know, sort of there used to be this presumption of innocence, right?
And law enforcement agencies used to have to go, you know, get a warrant to gather information about you. And now that's no longer the case. Now it's already sitting in a fence and database waiting to be queried, you know, without, you know, without court authorization and most instances. Okay, this is very helpful for me to make sense of this. So we've got the Bank Secrecy Act and that kind of started the snowball. And then that the reason was, you know, the mafia and kind of money laundering and that kind of thing. And then we had the Patriot Act, right, in the in the 2000s, I guess, the early 2000s and that sort of expanded it.
And I guess the idea here was anti terrorism, for sure, that was top of mind for legislators and the American people at that time. And what this has done is is created a kind of like spidering creeping kind of financial surveillance apparatus. This, this is at least how it's felt to me that has become increasingly more encroaching, I would say. I would say, and you know, one, I guess feeling I have, I don't really know how to quantify this, but it just feels like now that we've entered the 1970s very much was not the digital age, right, I was we didn't have computers back then. So it literally was like bags full of cash or briefcases full of cash.
Now, of course, the 80s, the 90s, the 2000s, especially now, we have increasingly digitized everything. So it almost feels like once things get into digital format, these kind of financial surveillance institutions feel like, oh, we got to claim to that data, it's digital. So we might as well put it in the database. That's kind of how it's felt. But let me ask you a few more questions about kind of the Bank Secrecy Act and the institutions behind it and some of these other acronyms. Okay, so Mike, you mentioned Finson earlier and Treasury and these are places, by the way, that you've worked so you know kind of the inner workings of these places.
So who enforces Bank Secrecy Act, you know, Treasury Act, what's Finson, what's OFAC, what are some of these these names that that we should know for really trying to understand the apparatus here. Sure, yeah, as Finson actually has two rules in the US and as Seth noted too, I think it's important to note a lot of this development is relatively recent, at least for us older people. It's like 90s and 2000s. So, you know, like the Bank Secrecy Act has been in place since 1970, it went decades without this sort of level of expansion. And it was until 1990, you know, 20 years in that Finson was created.
Anyway, how has it created in 1990? So was there new legislation put in 1990? Yes. There was. Okay, so there's been, there have been legislative updates, I suppose, to kind of the big Bank Secrecy Act type stuff in the interim here. Yeah, there's been, there's been many, many updates. In fact, there's a great timeline on the Finson web web page that goes through sort of all of these steps. But yeah, you had the Bank Secrecy Act in 70, in 1986, it was the, it enact money laundering control act. I mean, money laundering itself was not even a crime, you know, when the Bank Secrecy Act was developed.
It was, it was much more other underlying crimes that were being investigated. Money laundering was not even a crime. Not at the time. Yeah. Yeah. Interesting. Yeah. So, you know, a lot of this has been, and then there was the, and nonzio, while the money laundering suppression, suppression act that, that required suspicious activity reporting in 1992. Like a lot of this is newer. So I think it's, it's one level set about all this is like, if you're just coming into this from a crypto perspective, you see this huge apparatus. And you're like, wow, this is nuts. This has just been here since the 70s.
And when is it going to change? But it hasn't. But it hasn't. Like it's grown and grown and grown and grown and grown and grown and grown. Like quite, quite slowly until recently, obviously the Patriot Act, you know, following on 11 was sort of a huge expansion of a lot of different information collections. But it's continued to grow. And I, and I, and I also think, you know, to your question specifically about Finson, you know, Finson's role as a dual role. It's a financial intelligence unit, which is sort of the collection of information and dissemination of it. This goes to Seth's point of like, you know, managing a database.
And so they're managing the database that, yes, they query. And they make queries sort of 1% of them. But, but effectively, they're, they're administering the database that law enforcement is querying. So you, you'd want to factor that into it. And there's all sorts of, sort of congressional oversight and questions about which parts of law enforcement have access and how much access and, you know, so Finson is kind of this aggregator of financial information. And it, and it serves the rest of kind of the, you know, the enforcement apparatus. I would say you like it. We might say in the US. And it reports up through treasury.
Is that correct? Yes. Okay. Reports. And then it's Finson, the organization that maintains kind of the OFAC list. No, that's OFAC. So we can, we can, we can switch to OFAC in a second. Okay. I'll just close up Finson. So Finson is the financial intelligence unit. They administer the bank, the Bank Secrecy Act database, which has all this information, including oversight of, I mean, it's federal, state, local law enforcement. All these people have access to querying it. And so, you know, and questions will come up at times, which including things that we've said to Congress every time you expand this thing.
Remember, you may not be the ones in power next time. Please. So I know it sounds great now and you'd love more information, but that, that state prosecutor in Texas that's, that's pulling things on, on a political adversary that you think is great right now. It could very much be the New York Attorney General doing it to somebody that you like. And so, you know, I think there was always a constant push pool for Finson of, okay, on the one hand, we're tasked with disseminating this information to law enforcement. On the other hand, our primary mission is protecting American people from exploitation.
And that can include, that sets point queries that are not appropriate. And by the way, I should say, like, there are foreign governments through this process called the Agmont process, which is basically the global financial intelligence units all over the world that have agreements to share information when queried. Don't, don't you just love that name, the Agmont group? Yes. I mean, it sounds like something out of a bond movie. Yeah. So, that's a whole another can of worms that we can open another time, but I'll just say that is another piece that puts Finson at the center of on the one hand.
When Argentina is trying to crack down corruption and an autocratic activity by the Venezuelan government on its own people and once information, you know, Finson has has a reason to want to give that over. It's it's a pro democracy issue, but the Russian financial intelligence unit can ask for information and soak in the Turkish financial intelligence unit on on pro democracy people that they think are a problem. And that's partly up to Finson to sort of catch, like, wait a minute, this is politically motivated. We aren't going to turn this over. Oh, my God. So that's all. So, so his Finson is the charter of Finson, basically more domestic facing, like, it's everything.
It's just administering this database of the financial intelligence. I mean, certainly the primary connectors, anyone that has direct access to it is purely domestic. But the goal of it, like, what is the reason for maintaining this big financial surveillance database? Like what are the kind of the policy goals or that, you know, like the stated goals? Is it really to protect Americans from exploitation? Is it like to find, you know, mob bosses and like money laundering types of like what are the stated goals for Finson? So I love that question because that's like a core piece, including at Finson, when legislators would say, hey, we're going to do this thing for you and we would say we don't want that thing.
Because that's not actually our goal is not to your point, right? Like the goal is not to collect as much information on people as we possibly can. They could be leaked or abused. The goal, this explicit mission, and I spent some time reworking the mission statement, which I think it's not out yet, but, but basically is counter exploitation of people. So it was organized crime that was kidnapping people, extorting people, that sort of thing. I think the bigger expansion to post 9-11 was, was nominally, and I think genuinely at the time, even if there was some meaningful overreach. But I think at the time was protecting Americans from terrorism.
And that is the basis of a lot of the information sharing is like, okay, we've determined there's a bomber that's going to blow up a federal building, and we need to do something about that. And we've determined that through suspicious activity reports, or there's someone's been kidnapped, and we've determined that they did a credit card transaction somewhere that showed that this was the car they rented to kidnap the person. And now we have their home address, and so you can go and you literally free somebody, that sort of thing, which is partly why the value calculus is kind of complicated on these.
But to be clear, like the mission is not, let's collect as much information as we possibly can. The mission is tailored to these risks that we're supposed to address. And I think that's partly also why Vincent itself has done initiatives on privacy-preserving technology, on digital identity. You know, like our role is the flourishing of America. It is not, we need to create a surveillance state at all costs. And by the way, it might get exploited by all sorts of people. I want to separate the Vincent as the operator from people in Congress that might be saying, oh, you need to collect all this other information, because Vincent is not asking for that.
Well, that's what's interesting, it does become this powerful tool that can be used in all sorts of ways that maybe are kind of counter to the goals of the institution, the static goals. Absolutely. In fact, your articulation of it is perfect in exactly why we said we did a whole privacy initiative that said banks, in particular, we would love it if you'd start using zero knowledge proofs and homework encryption and other ways that we managed to risk. Because you know what, you're collecting all this information, it's getting leaked and hacked. And by the way, the amount of deepfakes that are undermining your KYC process is, and the amount of identity fraud is sort of through the roof.
So I think so far this conversation has exemplified why people use the term, okay, so all of these three letter agencies, like three letter agencies. And we talked about just like the slow tightening of the news of financial privacy over time. And then in this decade, we had this new legislation and that decade, we had this additional legislation. The libertarian perspective on governments and nation states is that they always grow, like they always want to grow. There's just this natural growth to them. And they'll find a way to grab a pigeonhole and then in steps, some sort of three letter agency or increase its scope.
It seems to be that this is kind of just the pattern that we are identifying here with the growth of our surveillance state. Would you guys accept that pattern is like how to understand the growth of this whole thing? I think so. I mean, Seth has studied this from from globally, so I welcome his thoughts on it. My quick from the US side of it is, I actually would go back to the prior conversation where like from 1970 to 1990 plus, it actually didn't grow that much. But it's, you know, we're now in digitized data. There's an enormous amount that can be collected. And so you'll have folks, particularly in Congress saying, well, wait a minute, you could collect it.
Why don't you? Yeah, so the inception of the internet was like, oh, there's so much new surface area to collect. And so maybe they weren't growing just because they didn't have a reason to or the optionality to, but the internet kind of gave them that. Yeah, I mean, I think I think that's that's probably the right catalyst. I mean, the combination in particular of the internet and, you know, really for me, smartphones is is is what, you know, really started to balloon the the ability, you know, both of corporate America and the government to collect and and, you know, analyze data on on individuals.
So, you know, I take your point, Mike, that, you know, in many instances, Fincin is saying, hey, hey, we don't want this. Don't don't give us this data. Don't give us this power in Congress is like here, here, here. Collect this, you know, analyze this data. You know, the end result for, you know, the average citizen is the same, you know, which is, you know, all of this information is is is increasingly becoming available and, you know, and being used, even if not, you know, used by Fincin. You know, once it once it goes in the pot, right, it's available for, you know, for, you know, a number of different, you know, agencies to use for for whatever purpose.
And, you know, so in that sense, I often sort of think of Fincin as as being, you know, the all seeing eye at the top of the pyramid on the back of the dollar. You know, to me, that's that's sort of Fincin's place. Some people say it's like the eye that I have more door, though, you know, not that we may have dark review things, but yeah, go ahead, Mike. Let me just give a what feels like a more realistic, I would say it was like a very glamorous view. I would say it's more like a coach in a in a, P we football game where every parents from both sides are just yelling at you. You know, nobody's happy because it's either like Congress is shoving more information at you than you even want and you've got to protect.
And then, and so the, and then on the flip side, you have other parts of Congress that are saying you have this information, you better be sharing it with everybody because you should be preventing every crime. And then you have other parts saying, wait a minute, you can't share that information. That's really sensitive information and it could be politically motivated. Are you vetting every single person that's asking you for information and we're saying, geez, that's like 300,000 people. And you haven't even funded us yet. So no, we're not. So it's actually, and I'll say like there to be very concrete about it, like there have been times where even including through the AML Act, which is another sort of recent like major update to the anti monitor to be a BSA, which is a whole other that I don't want to get into 2020, 2020, 2020.
Yes, like a very substantial update to it. But in the process of that, some of it we talked with my institutions about the threshold raising the threshold as Seth mentioned. And some of them, it was the reverse. It was, you know what, we're happy to just give you an API and you can have all the stuff because we've got the infrastructure, the data is collected and you can just have it. We don't even want to have to parse what's suspicious. And the response from us was like, that is the fucking nightmare for us. The last thing I want. You were just like, we want some of your data and they were like, here, have it all.
Yeah, we're like, actually, we want, we don't want more of your data. Like, you know, this is, this is part of it is like, this is, this is why you're the ref in a BWE game. It's like, you get all this information. Half the country is saying, you need to use this and prevent everything and disseminate it everywhere. The other half is saying, you need to protect this and make sure nobody bad ever misuses this data. Oh, wow. And on many ways, like, and I should say, like to be concrete, like FinSend twice in 2018, 2020, put out rulemaking saying, we'd like to improve the effectiveness and the prioritization of the AML system.
Because we think there's just a lot of over reporting, you're just data dumping. And we're not, it's not clear to us that everybody's being as effective as they actually could. Like, we don't just want data dumping about people. I feel like we are unraveling it kind of a Gordian knot here. And, you know, this might be a multi-episode thing to cover this all. But this is at least the highlights here. So we talked about FinSend. And I guess this is this aggregator of all of this financial information maintains a database. And all of this information is being aggregated primarily, though some of itself reported primarily from intermediaries.
The US banking apparatus, let's say. Okay, what is OFAC? Let me ask that. We talked about FinSend. What about OFAC? This is another four-letter agency. I suppose. What is their sphere of power? What are their stated goals? I don't know, Seth or Mike, which of you want to take this one? Mike, why don't you lead off on this one? Sure, sure. It could also be its own episode because there's a really interesting history that goes all the way back to the War of 1812. But the basic concept of OFAC, which is the Office of Foreign Assets Control, the really core of it started about 1940. It was really coming out of World War II.
And the reason it's foreign assets, and at the time it was foreign funds control, was actually that it was protective. So it basically administers economic and trade sanctions against foreign actors. And so at the time, it was the Secretary of the Treasury seeing that as the Nazi forces were occupying countries like Denmark, they were trying to repatriate assets and basically take the occupying countries assets. So they might call up the Fed and say we want all the gold from Denmark because we're in charge now. And so part of this was actually it was freezing in a protective sense. So it basically was the Secretary of the Treasury saying we're freezing all these assets.
We're controlling these foreign funds that any U.S. financial institutions have control over. And so that same mechanism of saying to any U.S. or U.S. related financial institution, we've listed out all these funds that you should freeze, not seize, but freeze and hold at the time, protectively over time that's evolved. And there is some lineage going back to the War of 1812 when some of this was done as actual sanctions and embargoes as well. But it was very protective at the time and it was blocking assets. And so that has sort of evolved over time, including in 1950 with the Korean War. And President Truman declared a national emergency and blocked actually Chinese and North Korean assets that were subject to U.
S. jurisdiction. And that's much more sort of the current incarnation. In fact, North Korean assets I think are the longest held blocked assets I think of any country in the world. It goes back to the Korean War. But basically the authority of OFAC is to say all U.S. financial institutions and other financial institutions subject to the U.S. jurisdiction, like you might have branches here, you need to block all these assets. And one important piece of this that I think is a really important distinction from like Vincent and money laundering authorities is, this is purely a behavior change mechanism of economic statecraft.
And so the idea is the assets are blocked when you stop doing the bad stuff that you were doing that caused the national emergency. We will release these. That's your incentive to have a behavior change moment. And we can get into the authorities which are all under the International Economic Emergencies Act. But it's basically the president's declares this is a national emergency so it can be done unilaterally by the president. National emergency OFAC I want you to list out all the major actors involved in North Korea's hacking to fund their nuclear regime and their oppression, same with Syria.
Like you know the Syria gases its own people we want you to identify who are the who are the actors that can that might have a behavior change if their assets were frozen. And so with the current Russian sanctions, it's it's not just the Russian government and military. It would be who treasury has determined are oligarch supporting and the idea that you create pain points and then you undo it. And that's why also usually they're not seized assets although it can happen but but it's really a behavior change mechanism. And I'll give one little footnote to this that I won't go down now but this is also why I think the tornado cash sanctions were sort of totally inappropriate as a behavior change mechanism but we can just footnote that.
So add on that. So so OFAC is also sort of an agency within the treasury department but it it differs from fencing a little bit in the source of its authority. So we talked about how fencing is sort of a creature of statute right it was created in 1990 to oversee the bank secrecy act of 1970. OFAC derives a lot of its of its authority directly from the president's executive powers over foreign relations and trade and article two of the Constitution. Is this more like a national defense type feel? There's strong overtones to that you know but it derives from sort of the president's foreign relations powers in article two of the Constitution.
And so there's also there's a similar there's a bit of a corollary with trade and tariffs and that as Michael pointed out you know OFAC and sanctions are you know targeted at you know foreign actors and foreign assets. As our as our tariffs on trade but also similarly it's it's actually the American consumer that pays the tariff right and it's the American individual or company that is at risk of civil or criminal punishment for violating the sanction right not the foreign actor. So you know they're sort of directed you know internationally but the the impact in the sort of the constraints on liberty is applied domestically.
Because these intermediaries basically have this obligation to make sure that they what don't accept money from or report anyone who's on the OFAC sanction list if you like what is the actual obligation here and what are the penalties if they if they fail to meet the obligation. I'll just quickly start by Mike you're probably better suited to answer this question so so OFAC maintains a number of lists and probably the most partner one for our conversation is the the SDN list or the specially designated national list. And an individual that the you know the president or treasury department feels is acting contrary to the interest of the United States can be placed on that list.
This would be like a terrorist a Russian oligarch something like this right Roman Seminoff you know exactly. And then once you know once once that foreign individual is placed on the SDN list no US citizen US business or even foreign business with a US nexus can transact financially with that person. And violations of the sanctions are strict liability. Meaning that the government doesn't have to show intent right you can accidentally violate sanctions. Which is what we did right because we had ether from tornado cash sent to us on others behalf correct. Yes and you know but there's there's some sort of you know prosecutorial discretion in terms of you know whether to charge a violation civilly or criminally but but under the law it's it's a strict violation or a strict liability.
Regime so the government doesn't have to prove intent that you you know that you meant to transact with the designated designated national and these penalties can be severe can't they. Yeah they can just just clarify that that there's a their enforcement guidelines that their public guidelines so they can be very severe but the intentionality and the amount of the transaction all are all factors in the in the sort of enforcement guidelines so. And if you look through the way the guidelines which are public are set up if it was if there was no intent and it wasn't which by the way receiving wouldn't be would clearly not be intent and it was like a dusting it would it would basically literally be zero.
And so you know often those are not not surprisingly not an enforcement priority and I'm not even that they just don't happen if you look at the actual OFAC enforcements that are and they're all public most have been pretty pretty systemic major you know hundreds of millions of dollars and and pretty intentional based. But I think it's an important point and certainly for criminal it requires intent for sure but I think it's it's an important point from Seth that like technically it's strict liability to start the process for sure. Yeah so okay so podcasters with public Ethereum addresses generally don't fit the mold is people going to criminal court over these things.
Yeah yeah. Are you planning to launch a token? Is your token already live and are you granting your employees and contractors vesting token words and are you trying to figure out how to take care of taxable events for your team. To grant and administer your global teams tokens to help you navigate across the life cycle of your token from easy to use pre-launch token grant award templates to managing post cliff taxable events with payroll for legal finance and HR teams is a huge complex task to have to comply with labor laws payroll and tax obligations tax reporting and crypto regulations in every country that you employ someone it's difficult time consuming manual and costly and is drawing more attention from global regulators and governments.
Toku makes it simple for leading companies in this base protocol labs Hedera get coin and many more so if you want some help in navigating the complex world of token compliance go to toku.com plus bankless or click the link in the description below. You know Uniswap it's the world's largest decentralized exchange with over $1.4 trillion in trading volume. You know this because we talk about it endlessly on bankless it's Uniswap but Uniswap is becoming so much more. Uniswap labs just released the Uniswap mobile wallet for iOS the newest easiest way to trade tokens on the go. With the Uniswap wallet you can easily create or import a new wallet by crypto on any available exchange with your debit card with extremely low fiat on rent fees and you can seamlessly swap on main net polygon arbitrage and optimism.
On the Uniswap mobile wallet you can store and display your beautiful NFTs and you can also explore Web 3 with the in-app search features, market leaderboards and price charts or use wallet connect to connect to any Web 3 application. So you can now go directly to DeFi with the Uniswap mobile wallet safe simple custody from the most trusted team in DeFi download the Uniswap wallet today on iOS there's a link in the show notes. Is there can maybe one of you can explain the thought process behind strict liability why that's even a thing at all like why we accept the concept of strict liability like in what use case do we enjoy the idea of strict liability because to me strict liability sounds like authoritarianism we have the admin keys over your position to be in jail or not and it's our way or the highway like that's the cursory take about what strict liability is maybe Michael or Seth.
Why do we have strict liability at all? Well, this is this is taking me back to first year law school you know that's where I need to be the you know what comes to my mind and it's been a while since I was a first year in law school. You know the sort of the classic strict liability fact pattern is dog bites right so in a lot of states if your dog bite someone it's strict liability right and I think that's because in that particular instance it's to protect victims because otherwise it would be almost impossible to prove that the owner of the dog intended the dog to bite the person. This is like negligence right right this is not it's not a criminal scenario but you know it creates a you know a situation where a person who's been injured you know can can can be compensated without they get to sort of skip the step of intent.
You know that's a you know the dog bite case is sort of a far cry from from the sanction scenario and you know so I don't exactly know what the origin of that is with respect to sanctions Mike I don't know if you if you know the history there. Yeah it's a great question I it's always sort of surprised me because I think like you going back to first year law school. It was very much the what keeping a wild animal you know particularly in a closely populated place or storing ultra hazardous materials like I just looked it up in one was you aren't if you're fumigating with cyanide gas that strict liability we don't need to improve into understandable.
I did that and so I mean I think certainly the idea in many and certain product liability by the way or like that with the idea being. Oh that's the other one yeah is product liability and for certain products I think people have felt like you know what maybe maternal fetal care or something like that like we want you to be. We don't want to spend time fighting with you over how much you intended to do something bad you need to be so on notice because like using cyanide in a in an urban environment is such a bad idea that we're not going to play that game. You just should you should be really worried and I think so that's the it's I mean I can't even imagine the last time a law was passed that that strict liability in it.
But I think to that point it's always sort of surprised me particularly because the enforcement guidelines are actually pretty clear that that intent is such a major factor in this the enforcement and so sometimes the response is like well but practically speaking it's not strict liability. But it's a public policy it should be I actually think and I say this is the former head of enforcement at OFAC it should not be strict liability and I said this many times at the time and there's probably not bad in there somewhere when I have time. But I think it actually it doesn't make sense because practically speaking the enforcement guidelines already make it not that but you have this.
This color over it this cloud that people feel like wow this is really complicated and I could make a mistake and get in trouble and the answer if the answer is like well look at all the history of enforcement. It's never happened and their enforcement guidelines that say it won't happen and the answer is well yes but that can be adjusted tomorrow depending on the administration. Exactly that's why it's so alarming to be like dusted from somebody like some tornado cash. Yeah it does seem like that that Fincent or OFAC just by having strict liability they are just giving themselves the free option which is a power taken away from citizens like OFAC has the option because they have the strict liability on their side.
Yeah and I don't know this goes to that's point of like where this comes from like I don't know if OFAC asked for it or if this is what was established under IEPA you know like some of this could be statutory. I think it's a I always thought it should be changed including when I was head of enforcement because I thought it sort of undermined the messaging of it but whether they'll be able to do that especially if it's a statutory change because you've got to get Congress to undo things. And I should say to that point like OFAC itself for many years has wanted to undo for instance Cuba sanctions feeling like they're ineffective.
And because it's some of these are Congressional mandated in their statute you actually have to have Congress do it. OFAC doesn't have the authority. In fact it was it and there's nothing they can do about it so I want to be careful about not always blaming OFAC when there's there's other political actors that sometimes tie their hands in fact that was a huge issue in the in the thawing with Cuba because OFAC was unable to lift certain sanctions. Okay so we've got the we've explained Finson we've got OFAC a little bit we you've just described Seth in my kind of like the worst list ever beyond it feels like which is the OFAC SDN list all right this is like the ultimate shit list.
Because this means not only do not get invited to parties you're basically economically excommunicated. Like I was a terrible list to be on tell me about the process of getting added to this list so who gets to decide who's on this list you surely there's some kind of like rigorous process behind this can you describe a little bit about what it takes to get on the OFAC SDN list. Yeah it's a happy to start such as it's been a good bit of time but it's a no but it's a I mean it's so there's again like the statutory and the separate sort of separation of powers between the administrative and the legislative there's various ways to get on the list.
It's you know Congress can pass an act like that just says you need to put these people on the list and OFAC has to come up with the packages the bulk of it is OFAC either themselves creating these what they're called designation packages that basically you take you know usually there's a declaration by the president of a national emergency like Syria. And so you would say based on this latest gassing of its own citizens by this authoritarian dictator OFAC I want you to find who's responsible for this including the industrial chemical intermediaries and put them on the list. And so and here's the standards of that like you are clearly involved in this it ties to this you know all the standards OFAC then works with the intelligence community and NGOs frankly as well and human rights organizations depending on the topic.
And comes up with names and then they have to build basically an evidentiary package that has separate lines of information that corroborate each other and that's cleared by the the chief council's office oftentimes it goes to the department of justice the federal programs branch. And that's a pretty rigorous process in general although I would say like post 9 11 there was a there was an expediency I think that push people to move very quickly. And but I should say there's also this sort of wild card that when the president him or herself creates the national emergency they can include what's called an annex which is just the president of the United States saying I've determined this is a national emergency and by the way these seven people are 27 people or entities are part of that I'm just making that determination and they're on the list OFAC put them on the list and get their identifiers for people.
It doesn't happen a lot and a lot of times OFAC would still be tasked with creating the package and and to be clear like usually those are based on somebody having done a bit of a package to it's not it's not that arbitrary. But but that is a way that can happen quite quickly and it's and it's two things on that is just that it's very everybody has an appeals process to this. But I should say particularly if the if the president personally has put you on an annex you know foreign policy and national emergency tend to be the peak of the executive branch authority and so challenging that is not going to be an easy process.
It's for OFAC it's abuse of discretion but when the president has has you know laterally determined that you're part of a national security emergency. It's it's going to be a high bar which I'll just say goes to the fact that I think we should constantly remember that this is a behavior change mechanism and so to the extent that you cannot get off the list and people do not feel like they can get off the list it is not a mechanism that works. Because you can get off the list right so you have to be able to get off the list otherwise it's not a behavior change mechanism it's punishment. And that's not the this I think Ryan you said this early rough incident like what's the what's the real mission I think that's a great question for OFAC to the real mission is behavior change like.
The goal of OFAC is is above all to take people off the list because that means it's working you know people have changed their behavior Assad has stopped gassing his own people like that's the win the win is not oh we put him on forever this is awesome. Okay all right so we got Finson we got OFAC a little bit and I I was hoping for kind of like to get the international like I feel like this is going to have to be another podcast entirely to actually fully unravel this whole financial surveillance apparatus I wanted to get to a couple of quick things though before. We leave you guys me kind of conclude the episode so one is a tornado cash okay so takes on this some developers wound up on the OFAC SDN list I believe some open source privacy developers turning cash so did a smart contract as well there's not a person this is like some code.
So how did that happen what happened there this was not an executive order from present this is not I don't think Joe Biden saying these people in particular go get him. It was something else how did that happen and what's kind of the I guess what what's your reading of this Mike and Seth. Actually Seth will have much more I think in sort of the like the legal thinking of it and the policy piece of it I just want to give one piece of like functional very practical because this goes to your point Ryan of like president didn't just say put these on the list. My take on it is actually that it really it was not president Biden 100% but that it really was in many ways the national security council going to OFAC and saying look we get it tornado cash has been out there for a while everybody has sort of had strategic restraint on doing anything but we're at like 2 billion in Lazarus DPRK funds going through there we're getting hammered by Congress to do something on ransomware and DPRK and cyber.
And every time DPRK launches a missile missile Congress comes to us at the NSC and says why haven't you cracked down on this and somebody points to like the money going through tornado cash OFAC do it. And I can say from having been at OFAC you get those calls all the time it's a it's a go to the NSC tell them why this is going to be like massive collateral impact and we don't think it's going to be effective because we're never going to get anyone off. OFAC walks over there gets the briefcase handed back at them and tells them to go back and do it and sometimes you win and sometimes you lose and I'll say from having been in some of those meetings in other contexts like there were times where in political situations where we said there are no US nexus to this that's going to feel the impact we're just putting someone on the list for messaging we think this is a very bad idea and you're undermining the integrity of the process sometimes you won those and sometimes you lost them and I don't you know I have no inside base ball in this one but my feel on this one is that this is very much and I should say this being a fence in OFAC when tornado cash was very much on our radar like everybody knew about tornado cash for years like really of yeah for sure I mean this is their job.
I don't know like how people are moving money and I think you know it was always a conversation of like yes it's out there you know it had already been see David we thought crypto was such a niche. We're not that special you are special but I think it was it was very much like look yes it's happening like money's also getting laundered through. I was going to say HSBC but I'm not saying that because I know I get sued but like let's just say something. That may have had a letter action in the past but you know but look there'd be collateral impact that would be there'd be way more than we would do we don't technically OFAC does not designate finance institutions or major financial movers in any form because there's just way too much collateral impact which is clearly what happened here it's pretty identifiable through chain analysis and TRM and elliptic and everybody you can look at the cluster and see how much of it is high risk and how much isn't you would look at that and say I think 27 37 17% I think was the main one 17% there's no question you would look at that and say there's no way we can designate this if this was a bank 17% there's no way like there'd be way too much collateral impact.
And if it is you'd have a license that would exempt most of the activity afterwards anyway because there's too many people impacted so might might take in general is that this was the NSC saying just do it will figure it out and I think that's probably why you then started seeing FAQs come out you start seeing a read designation. Is this the first time as well that like a smart contract or like some code has been like is that unprecedented as well do you think that was totally unprecedented and I'm sure that was a conversation internal to OFAC as well right I mean because if you guys know it so so this is why this is so helpful Mike and I you know it's such a black box to us looking outside we don't know what in the world is going on we just see this scary stuff happening.
And we have like no idea how the inner inner inside the black box actually works but and that's why this is helpful and so so does OFAC have actual the actual I guess power to put something like a smart contract. On the list or is that what we're all going to find out we're going to find out okay so so so typically you know OFAC can sanction sort of two two types of things right persons whether natural persons or legal persons or their property right so you know think like the. You know the Russian oligarchs mega yacht right you don't want them to be able to sort of sell that and you know and circumvent sanctions right so historically the two types of things that have been put on the SD and list that's why it's called the specially designated nationals list right nationals refers to a person right is is people in their stuff.
You know a smart contract the you know a piece of code right some some you know executable text is neither of those things. And you know so it is it was unprecedented the first time that you know that that has has been added to the list and the legality of that is very much a question and is is you know being litigated. You know I it's either so shortly thereafter as I'm sure you're aware coin center and some others you'll file lawsuit against OFAC and Treasury on on on those grounds my coho. And it happens to be a plaintiff in one of those last it's actually. Awesome awesome thumbs up. But OFAC very quickly after that lawsuit I think realized some of the you know the well they wanted to shore up sort of the their legal standing in light of coins in his complaint and so they actually sort of.
Revoked and then and re issued the sanctions like in this time sort of you know alleging that the you know not just the code of the smart contract but like the whole the whole thing. Together represented sort of an unincorporated association like you know like a business. So kind of like user interface the website the service of his host all of that stuff as well. So so that's the sort of the theory that they're they're going under now they they seem to have won at least at the trial court level in in the van loon case in the northern district of Texas I believe. Press and van loon need the core developer whom has also been on bank list by the way it's all very very small world here.
And so you know I expect and hope that you know that that has appealed that the coin center case is progressing in in Florida so a different circuit which which gives you know a few a few bites at the apple. In terms of you know how how this gets decided. You know but you know I think you know we're in sort of uncharted waters here whether you know of fact can do this you know I think the. You know some you know some reason for caution is you know is what what you know sort of we led with when discussing OFAC which was the broad constitutional powers under which OFAC operates originating from from article two of the constitution right so this is you know this is sort of a different set of rules then.
You know a typical you know agency action that's governed by the administrators administrative procedures act for example. Yeah that's what this is that's why all of this is a is so difficult it feels like. It it almost feels like OFACs. Or its power could be almost like indefinite right it's it's just it can do what I mean unless sort of the social layer unless the the citizens in the population kind of say and even you know those inside the government say hey hold on what are we doing we're losing picture remember what OFAC was originally for back to the 1940s when we're fighting Nazis not sort of thing right and like hold on it's we've gone too far now we have open source developers smart contract code and are we sure that that is the type of society that we're trying to build unless we stop it at some point it seems certain that this kind of octopus of financial surveillance will have all sorts of unintended consequences and continue to consume our institutions and citizens of this country and not this country we're talking about the U.
S. But we haven't even gotten to international sounds like that's another podcast but it does sound like from what you alluded to and another agency I don't even remember at this point Mike that you mentioned that they're all tied into this too. So not only do we do this kind of domestically across the U.S. but fence and no fact talk to their counterparts across other countries all completely coordinated into this global surveillance network. I want to as we end this maybe maybe zoom out here right and ask the question what do we do about this are we got the tactical like you know we're fighting fights in the court system that sort of thing.
But it seems to be the case that just like recently but we don't have the civil civil liberties in place at the constitutional level that are protecting us adequately for this type of thing. This seems to be almost I don't know maybe it is in there in some of the language you guys can interpret that but like it seems to be beyond what the what the founders actually could conceive of. Like when they originally framed this whole thing right the idea of financial surveillance at this level the ability to freeze an account in this way the digitization. This goes back to a theme we talk about often on bank list where it feels like we've entered in 21st century this whole digitization of everything.
And our digital rights are in place like there is no digital bill of rights here that kind of gives us encryption or you know property rights in in some way and insurance that into our governance apparatus so I guess my my high level question is what do we do about this how do we stop it like is this going to require. I don't know big movements from our institutions do you feel like we have adequate protections in place in our in our legal system to preserve some rights that that we as a democratic republic actually want to preserve going in the 21st century mouth through this to Mike and by the way Mike I've really appreciated your insight here I didn't realize how like Finssen and OFAC in all the institutions that that you've previously served and now you're going to crypto which is I don't know if they see that as the dark side but like welcome.
It's great to have you thank you like we need people like you you know fighting for these things but let me let me throw it to Mike first and then we'll get Seth and we'll tie this all off. Yeah no thanks and yeah and Seth will be far more eloquent about this because he's doing this all the time like he is engaging with like the entire world I'm just dealing with the US mainly so it's part of the way I'm thrilled for that and and for a whole episode on how he's solving fattest. I wish I really appreciate that just in time but yeah no I think it is I think if there's anything to leave from from this from my perspective is that like there are a lot of folks within OFAC and Finssen even that that really do believe that to the mission of countering exploitation and providing opportunity and democratization of the ability for people to flourish that like in many ways web 3 in crypto isn't is an answer it's partly why I left being the acting director of Finssen to go in house it.
Express their systems you know building a decentralized sequencer and decentralized private computation was actually here's someone here's a here's a group building a solution which is resilience it's configurable privacy it's helping people have the personal sovereignty which was. Literally the founding of this country and so I think I think there is a great opportunity here if we can get to the people that we need to in time which I think. Part of what's helpful about doing this podcast about these actors is it's not it's yes it's Finssen and OFAC it's helping it's helping educate them stuff that like Seth's doing all the time all around the world is like educating people on how the tech actually works.
Because they're just seeing headlines about Sam bank been freed and doquan and that's partly why when I was at Finssen we brought in core developers from from Zcash and Dash and all kinds of folks to talk to people and get aligned of like hey if you're worried about exploitation of people let me tell you about privacy technology you know. Like this is there's a great opportunity for alignment here like to the extent that it's about democracy and preventing authoritarians which is very much you could be describing the North Korea program from OFAC or you could be describing what cryptos doing with democratizing finance and creating greater resilience like there's opportunity for alignment.
But it has to be engaging with all these policy makers it's not just it's yes it's Finssen and OFAC and including by the way arming the people in there with the talking points who do want to fight against Manuchin's wallet's role and stuff like that. But it's also going to the hill because there are politicians coming up with bills every day that Finssen and OFAC are not asking for. But they have limited ability to push back on those and I assure you that there are entrenched incumbents that have an interest in keeping intermediaries in the space that are extremely organized and out there doing that that sort of advocacy and I think that's an important piece of it is is keeping organized on this in the way and spreading the word in the way you guys are doing.
And the way sets out there educating people all around the world because it's really it's it's everybody to hear look this is not just about risk this is about all the opportunity here to prevent exploitation and it all goes back to Ryan your earlier question of like well what's the mission here and I think. Like there has to be we have to be able to get to the point where there is great alignment on the fact that web three is about counter exploitation empowering people with personal sovereignty to flourish and how can that not possibly align with United States sort of mission. Thank you I certainly well said yeah Mike Seth what what do you think do we get a shot at this how can we win here.
You know I'm I'm not super optimistic you know I think just because you know the you know these you know it's like you know turning a cruise ship or an aircraft carrier right the you know this the structure the global AML regime has been built up you know piece by piece year after year for a very long time and it's become it's become very big and a very big part of you know not just you know not just the US government but you know many governments are in the world and I think you know I hope we do do another episode on sort of international. You know and we take a look at sort of the global AML regime you know and try to put some you know some some some evidence to just sneak peeks for that though Seth is it is it worse outside the US or just as bad.
Some better some better some better some worse all right you know but you know but let's let's take a look at the numbers and see what the numbers say on you know how this system is performing and you know and whether it's it's justifying the cost. You know but anyway because it's become so big and it's existed for so long it you know it's not easy to change and you know to you know Ryan to some of the points that you made to sort of tee up this this question going back to sort of the intent of the framers of the constitution. You know unfortunately I think one of the sort of the greatest omissions of the founders was the failure to include an explicit right to privacy and the bill of rights.
And so because of that the Supreme Court has had to sort of cobble together a right to privacy under a theory called you know penumbra where they sort of look at you know the other enumerated rights and say well in order to really have or execute that right you have to have privacy in this area. Like the right to you know privacy is implied but not made explicit and we needed the courts to tell that story exactly so there's a there's a 1965 case called Griswald the Connecticut that the court explicitly found for the first time of a fundamental right to privacy under the Constitution. You know but even even still these penumbra rights don't sort of have the same level of protection that the enumerated rights do right so they called it a fundamental right but fundamental rights and other contexts enjoy strict standard of review by the court called strict scrutiny which means that the you know any government infringement of that right must be narrowly tailored to achieve compelling state interest.
You know I don't think the BSA at this point particularly the enlargement after the Patriot Act meets that standard but because it's not an explicit enumerated right in the Constitution it's very difficult to challenge and so I think you know to your question of you know how do we win or can we win. You know short of you know the Supreme Court's overturning or significantly limiting the Bank secrets act perhaps by doing away with sort of the third party doctrine that props up the whole House of Cards. You know I think that you know that that's the only way that I sort of see that we win here you know and I think as we digitize everything in Web 3 sort of you know slowly gains adoption.
You know we have the opportunity to say look hey there is a different way there's a better way to do all of this stuff but it comes down to trust right how much trust does you know does the government want to have in the people right in the current system is one of almost no trust right that's why you have to file this information and why they don't even trust you to file the information so they gather it from the intermediaries that you use right and so in this sort of the current. You know state of financial surveillance that we're in is one where the government really doesn't trust the citizens and we have this now sort of presumption of guilt rather than presumption of innocence right all this information is going to be available to law enforcement.
And you know if it's ever in question you know you now have to prove that you're innocent which is a complete sort of turning on its head the system that the framers set out you know so we've gone very far astray I'm afraid and I think it would take something very you know very significant to. You know to have a reset or sort of write the ship at this point well let's let's maybe end with that if if we have any shot at a reset here I think it's got to come in the form of crypto. Like this is kind of I mean you guys were mentioning that hey you know that this whole expansion of the Bank secrecy act and and Finson that that happened in the 90s I don't remember a time when it didn't exist and it's part of the problems population doesn't remember a time where this financial surveillance apparatus wasn't set up and yet with crypto it's off by default and somebody has to come in and turn it back on and I think crypto this this level of responsibility with with private keys this focus on encryption on this power of cryptography I think this will reignite the conversation especially when we see things happening like open source developers getting thrown in prison right that starts to I hope make society question where we're actually going with this financial sir surveillance apparatus and I do hope there's a time I took this out recently it's like I wish Americans cared as much about cryptography as they do guns do you know I mean like I wish we had a right to bear arms second amendment for encryption rights and for privacy and we don't right now but maybe now is the opportunity.
To get this into social awareness so that's what we're going to try to do because what other alternative do we have honestly guys Seth and Mike I think we're going to have to have you on for an episode two at some point in the future if you're willing to talk about kind of the international apparatus here and there are a million things we didn't touch today but this has been a great primer and I want to thank you both for your time today this has been fabulous. Thanks. Absolutely. Yeah, thanks for having us. Wow. What an episode guys. Risen disclaimers got to end with this of course crypto is risky.
You get those would you put in but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bank list journey. Thanks a lot. You