In today’s episode, we’re exploring the frontier of the multi-chain Ethereum roadmap. Synthetix has been leading this charge as it pertains to the application layer of Ethereum.
David is joined by Synthetix’s Founder, Kain Warwick in person in David’s Brooklyn studio.
“Synthetix, A New Hope,” is a recent blog post Kain wrote and is a main focus for today’s episode.
----- Check your wallet with our brand new tool: Claimables 🎁 https://bankless.cc/GetClaimables
------ 📣 LayerZero | Accelerating Web3 Interoperability via GoogleCloud https://bankless.cc/layer-zero
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
🔗 CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 7:08 Synthetix Networks 8:50 Growth Complexity 9:50 Phases of Complexity of Apps 14:00 Elaborating the Problem Layers 15:25 Paramartizing Risk 19:00 Defining the Problem(s) 21:00 Likelihood of Solution(s) 24:05 3 Paths of Fragmented Liquitidy 31:40 Chainlink’s CCIP 32:50 Optimism 36:00 MakerDAO 36:55 dYdX Model 44:25 Free Market Model 47:00 Other Solution Tools 55:15 Cross-Chain Shared Execution 57:50 Kain & Synthetix Main Focuses 59:00 Timeline 59:50 Other Components of Synthetix 1:02:25 Kain’s Thoughts on Regulation 1:08:13 Final Messages 1:09:15 Closing & Disclaimers
----- RESOURCES
Kain Warwick https://twitter.com/kaiynne
Synthetix, A New Hope https://mirror.xyz/kain.eth/tAXGVKMTYM8K2gUOQq9JDQ1wyV_5Msdlrn_AtmiCGEI
----- Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. And today, on Bankless, we are exploring the frontier of the multi-chain Ethereum roadmap. The role of centric roadmap has always been about producing many, many new layer tools, each of their own flavor, construction, and type, in pursuit of allowing diversity of chains to all exist under the same ecosystem that we call Ethereum. And aesthetics, an application has been leading the charge into exploring what does this mean for the application layer of Ethereum. And today, on the show, we're bringing in Kane Warwick actually inside of my apartment.
This is an in-person conversation. So you'll be able to pick up on the speed and lack of latency. There is between me and Kane, I would say. He was in New York for a main net. And so we wanted to do a show about his recent blog post that he wrote called synthetics a new hope about the next stage for synthetics in this multi-layer-to-ecosystem, and how he is thinking about some of the complexities and challenges that the Ethereum Role of Centric roadmap presents for the application. Like I said, since he was in town for main net, I was like, I can't just come on over and we'll do the conversation in person.
So that was pretty fun. It's always nice to have in-person conversations. I don't do them as much, even though I have this set of ready to go. Anytime there is a conference in New York, however, I will try and get one done. So in this episode, you're going to watch us navigate the complexities, the challenges of Ethereum's Role of Centric roadmap as it relates to applications that desire to exist across multiple layer 2s, across multiple chains. Depending on the layer 2 application, the application construction itself, different challenges can arise in various levels of complexity. Kane and I walk through the three different levels of cross-chain complexity that an application can have that is determined by what that application is trying to do.
For example, just mere independent instances like Uniswap deployments across chains is the easiest way to navigate the multi-chain world. This doesn't really matter if different Uniswap instances are deployed across chain. But as soon as there's unified governance, all of a sudden, there is complexity because we need to start to weave these chains together. And then there's the next phase, this synthetics phase, which is not just unified governance, but unified liquidity in unified state. Synthetics has always been at the frontier of navigating the hard problems in Ethereum. After Unipig, the Uniswap demo on Optimism's Optimistic Roll-Up, the first Optimistic Roll-Up that had a live in production demo of an application, we call it Unipig back then.
Synthetics was the number two. And so they have always been pushing the frontier of what is possible in the world of crypto. And now Kane is leading the charge into doing the same thing. Once again, with synthetics in the multi-chain ecosystem. So if you are curious about the super-chain idea for Optimism, or just simply the shared state of layer twos, they recomposing all the fractured composability of layer twos, this conversation is for you. And it's also just a fun conversation. Kane is a great conversationalist, and he's of course, wicked smart. So let's go ahead and get right into that conversation with Kane Warwick of synthetics.
But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. Especially, Kraken, our preferred exchange for crypto in 2023. If you do not have an account with Kraken, consider clicking the link in the show notes to sign up with Kraken today. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade. On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning fast trade execution. All inside, there's spiffy new modular interface.
Kraken's new customizable modular layout, lets you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs. Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro, or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs. Visit pro.krakken.com to get started today. Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network. A brand new, high-performance Ethereum layer 2 built using the OP stack, but uses eigenlayers' data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer 1.
Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboarded, like game 7 for Web3 gaming, and buy a bit for TVL and liquidity in on-rounds. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle.
If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Arbitrum is accelerating the Web3 landscape with a suite of secure Ethereum scaling solutions. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum 1, with flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. Arbitrum Nova is quickly becoming a Web3 gaming hub and social adapts, like Reddit, are also calling Arbitrum home. And now, Arbitrum Orbit allows you to use Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own layer 3, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput.
Whether you are a developer, enterprise, or user, Arbitrum Orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. Faster transaction speeds and significantly lower gas fees. So visit Arbitrum.io, where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app with Arbitrum. Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Biggest nation we are here in person, in my apartment here in Brooklyn with Cain Warwick, the co-founder of Infinix, semi-benevolent dictator of synthetics, house collector, and possibly, possibly, the best hair in Ethereum.
Cain, welcome to my apartment. Yeah, thanks for having me. I was hanging out downstairs for a little while. I couldn't figure out what channel to get you on, so. Yeah, just like the problem that we're going to discuss in this episode, how do you reach me? Telegram, Discord, email, Twitter, text. We need some kind of aggregator. Yeah, we need one single shared way of getting in contact with each other. You're in town in New York here for a main net. How's that been gone? Yeah, it's been good. So, main net and ETH New York slash pragma, I guess, the Ethereum hackathon slash conference. So yeah, it's been pretty good.
Bob's pretty good. Lovely, lovely. And do you go in and out of Australia or do you do a circuit before you go back home? This time I did, because I went from token 2049, landed in Sydney, and then 24 hours later, hop back on a plane to come over here. I had to pick up my kids on the way through, so I couldn't go directly from Singapore to New York unfortunately. Man, the life of juggling, being a dad and going to conferences and also being an app founder, I cannot imagine. Yeah, it's pretty hectic. But yeah, my kids are pretty good travelers now, so. Okay, so as I alluded to, there is a problem arising in the world of Ethereum.
With the roll up centric roadmap, as great as it is for producing natural, emergent solutions across the different modules that make up a chain, it also fragments composability. And this is kind of how I alluded to with how do you reach me with all the different apps that we use? The illusion here is that there's so many different networks. How many networks currently is synthetics deployed on? Really too, mainnet and optimism are the only two. Okay, why not more? Good question. I think we obviously were the first project to deploy to optimism. We worked really closely with the team. I did try to warn people about this and say, hey guys, why don't we coordinate around optimism rather than having 100 roll ups, but that should be sailed now, I think.
So we are in an environment where we're seeing even L1s converted into L2s, which I think is great. I think people who previously thought it was a good idea to launch an L1, realizing that being connected to the Ethereum ecosystem is a more viable pathway, that's amazing. So in the end of the day, I think we'll kind of accept that that's just the direction that things are going. But for us, the challenge has been cross-chain communication. So with synthetics, because we're a liquidity protocol, we need to be able to ensure that on whichever network a user is interacting, that information about those interactions are passing through to the other networks.
And that just creates cross-chain communication demands that are much higher than bridging a token. For example, where it's sort of a one-shot thing and then the tokens on the other network and you can kind of let it do what it needs to do over there. I would imagine with the demands that synthetics has, the growing number of chains produces probably like an exponential growing amount of complexity for managing those chains. Yeah, if you do it the right way. So unfortunately, we're not uniswap, right? Where uniswap can just deploy their immutable code onto a new network. There isn't even the complexity of moving fees around.
Fees sit on that network, they go to LPs. You flick a fee switch on and all of a sudden the complexity goes up significantly, right? Because now it's like, okay, well, where do the fees go? You need token holders on that network. You need token holders on mainnet. You need token holders anywhere. Do we burn the fees? Do we transfer them? Do we convert them? What about if it's all an avalanche? How do you deal with that? So as soon as you start to have any contemplation of like cross-chain communication, the complexity grows significantly. So if you can just deploy your code and let it sit there and interact only on that one network, it's much easier.
Unfortunately for synthetics, it's just not possible. Right, and so what you're starting to allude to is that there are different types of apps out there that have different cross-chain needs. Yes. Maybe there's a few categories of this in your blog posts, which is gonna be the basis of this conversation. You kind of start to progress through the different kinds of apps that have different levels of demands for complexity when it comes to cross-chain. And I think synthetics would be at like the highest order of a cross-chain, a many multi-layer to world, is the most complex for synthetics than it would be for like uniswap.
Uniswap is deployed on like 13 different chains. And that's just a property of the nature of what uniswap is. Like you alluded to, there's this one thing called a fee switch that if we turn that on, all of a sudden uniswap goes from like, well, it's pretty simple to deploy uniswap across-chain to like, okay, now we are elevating in complexity. Could you kind of walk us through the phases of complexity that the properties of an app might be? Like what properties are simple to deploy across-chain? Like the roll-up-centric roadmap of Ethereum, 10,000 roll-ups, that doesn't matter for some apps. What kind of categories of apps are those?
And then what things make things more complex? Yeah, so I think on the spectrum, you know, the simplest thing is a uniswap style deployment. It's a mutable code, so you don't need to govern it, you don't need to upgrade it, you just deploy the code and it sits there. There's no need for fees or anything like that to go outside of the protocol. So there's sort of endogenous to the protocol. LPs put liquidity in and LPs are in the fees. That's it. And so each instance is really distinct. As soon as you start adding things like governance, right? If there's any upgradability, then it's a question of where does the governance come from?
Is it governance is just on that network or is it governance that is anywhere? Because most of the time the governance comes from token holders and token holders are spread across all these different roll-ups. So it's like, well, how do we coordinate the governance? Do we want someone who is holding AVE on main net to be governing the deployment on arbitrum? Does that even make sense? Like are they the same kind of stakeholder, right? Or is it only the AVE token holders who are kind of staked in the security module or whatever on arbitrum should govern the arbitrum deployment? And then there's another area of complexity which is fee sharing.
So okay, if there's fees that are being earned on one network, who do they go to? Do they go to all token holders? Do they go to just token holders on that network? How do we distribute them? Are they paid out as a dividend? Do we do buybacks and burns, et cetera? And there's solutions to all of these things, but they all add complexity. And the governance side of things I think adds the most complexity, right? Then there's some other stuff like bridging. Do you want all your tokens on all of these different networks to be fungible? So I gave an example a long time ago, even before this was a real thing of maker, right?
So if you have die on one network that is mainly backed by USDC, let's say, right? And then you have a different instance of maker that's deployed on, let's say, arbitrum, right? And maybe the majority of the issuance of dies backed by ARB, the ARB token. Now that's crazy and that's not the case, right? But in a future state, maybe that might be the case, right? And so you look at those two things, you say, okay, we've got one network where it's all backed by USDC, another network where it's backed by treasuries, and then a third network where it's backed by in a liquid shit coin, right? Let's use SNX, right?
It's the example, rather than ARB, I don't want to trigger ARB Maxis, right? So we've got a synthetics app chain where you've got die that's being backed by SNX, right? And it's a liquid or whatever. Is that die that's being issued against those, collateralized positions, fungible? Do you want it to be fungible? Does it even make sense? Is it, on some fundamental level, is it fungible? And if it is, how do you then enforce that fungibility, right? So you need bridges, you need cross chain communication, you need to know if the die is moved onto a different network and it needs to be liquidated, how does that liquidation happen?
And so all of that stuff just adds complexity. Is this both, if I'm understanding this correctly, is this both a more higher level philosophical question of is the die fungible from the social layer? Do we perceive these things to be equivalent? And then the other problem is like, okay, maybe even if we do get to that point where yes, everyone agrees that these things, the risks of one implementation of die on one chain, we do agree that that should be equivalent with the risks of a different die implementation of a different chain. If we can cross that barrier, there's still the technical barrier of getting it to be fungible at the technical level, like contract address and equivalency.
So there's two problems here. I think there's kind of three. There is the social problem, which is if I'm using die, what is the perception of a user of die to the expect fungibility? What is my expectation as a user of die? Then there's the financial layer of, okay, if my expectation is they're fungible, are they really financially fungible assets, right? If one's backed by nonsense, and the other one's backed by, if is that even the same, right? And how do we reconcile that? Is there a way that we can set up the financial incentives such that one has a really low LTV and one has a high LTV and the liquidation means that actually they're both the safe, they've just got different parameterization.
And then assuming we get to that point, then the next thing is like, how do we even do that? What's the mechanism? What's the technical mechanism by which we implement that? Really just to drive this one point home, the way that you describe this in your article is like Alice has trust preferences that maybe Alice is very conservative. And so she only wants to use a very low LTV inside of synthetics on mainnet with very good, strong collateral because these are her trust preferences. Maybe a more adventurous bob is out on some OP stack fork that just got deployed. And if there's a synthetics instance on that network that for some reason allows for shit coin collateral to back SUSD, that's great if these instances are firewalls kind of like how uniswap deployments would be.
Then like Alice's preferences don't get co-mingled with bobs preferences. You know, conservative Alice is safe from Dgenbob. And so long as there's actually like separation of instances. Why I think the articulation of synthetics is such an ambitious project about shared composability is that the unified version of synthetics would mean that Alice's preferences and bobs preferences are actually co-mingled and those conflict. And so that's where we get into like, okay, so is SUSD on OP stack, shit OP stack fork with shit OP, with shit collateral, sorry, for the language. Just like, you know, all the risk, all the risk on one.
Maximize risk. Yeah, yeah. And then maximize conservatism. How do we even square these things? Yeah, and is there, you know, this is the financial layer, right? Like is there a way that you can parameterize this to allow both of these people to interact with one another and feel comfortable, right? And or if not, is there a way for you to sort of quarterize the risk and segment and silo the risk so that, you know, the user gets fungibility, but on the LP side, the LP's are protected from one another, right? And you know, you don't have this like cascading failure or, you know, or whatever. And so, you know, these are hard problems, right?
But then it begs the question of, even if you can get to that point, the technical implementation, there is no way to implement this. And this is where synthetics, unfortunately, has a bad habit of being like on the bleeding edge. Like the vision is... Yeah, very bad habit. Yeah, very bad habit. You know, it's like this kind of a very aspirational vision of like, what if we could do this? You know, what if this is the future state? And the reality is that the tech is just not there yet, right? Maybe this is solved with like, you know, at some point, like an op code, you know, like level of solution, right?
Where like we actually realize that cross-chain communication is necessary. And, you know, we have this reliance on like Ethereum as a, you know, a state layer, you know, where we're, you know, storing state there and somehow we have a way of communicating that back out or something, you know, maybe there's like a more or more long term solution. In the interim, we've got, you know, a bunch of solutions which are fairly novel and none of them are really yet in a position to be able to actually do this. And, you know, like anything, we do it and then we go, oh, wow, this doesn't scale, right? Right?
Like, or here's a solution that like handles the problem today, right? Ethereum mainnet, you know, back in 2018. Totally fun, enough bandwidth, right? Like, just barely enough bandwidth, right? Back in days of one great gas. Exactly. And then like 20 minutes later, it's March 2020 and you're like, oh, wow, this does not work at all. Like it just is not possible for this to function, right? And so even if we have cross-chain communication and we've got these kind of rudimentary solutions or whatever, do they scale to something, you know, that is, you know, across a hundred chains? Like at the moment, no, can they get there?
It's a technical problem solve, right? And just to again, really just hammer on the definition of the problem statement. The many app ecosystem, if you have uniswap without governance, just raw instances of uniswap deployed everywhere, that's like problem level one, not too much of a problem. Problem two is when, okay, we have central uniswap governance and decentral uniswap deployments. How does that, how do we go here? How does this one app go here into this one unified system when we're across, when a uniswap itself is across many different states? That's like, you know, not a crazy problem, but still a hard problem.
It's still like some things to us out. And then the final problem is like, what synthetic wants to do, which is shared liquidity, across states and liquidity's finite. If you have many chains, we're starting to fracture liquidity. And so the golden solution here is that when you add liquidity to one network, one implementation, you are also increasing the liquidity on a different network. And that's like the hardest level of flow through. Yeah, right. It's the hardest level problem that we've thought of today. So this is, you know, like it would not surprise me at all if synthetics or other protocols eventually come up with even harder problems that are harder problems that have to do with cross-chain communication.
There's some, you know, demand or some functionality that requires something. But at the moment, that's kind of the, you know, the most challenging thing is like, to treat these distinct networks as one network requires a level of cross-chain communication that we just can't quite support yet. Right, yeah. And of course, just to throw a bone to the Solana camp out there, this is why they are like layer one, one chain maximalist. Yes. Like they get to be the composable chain because they only want to have one monolithic chain. Yep. And then they go into this and be like, yeah, that's why it's a lot.
Of course, yeah, don't like, don't fragment your liquidity right? Of course. And, you know, there's something to be said for that, right? But, you know, there's definitely a counter-argument of like, okay, fine. But at some point, you know, the L1 monolithic thing breaks, right? And then they just kick the can down. Yeah. It's like they'll get there too. Great. Like you've got 10x more growth, right? But, you know, eventually you're going to be like, oh, this stuff really works. Okay. Without asking about the technical details, what's the vibe check on this problem becoming solved in the fullness of time?
Um, it's a really good question. And, you know, there's some ways to route around it, right? And we've, at the moment, got these conflicting drives within this synthetic community, right? One drive is maintain SNX as the primary collateral in the protocol, right? Maintain the value prop of the SNX token as effectively as possible, right? Like do not devalue the token in any way, right? And then the kind of counter to that is, okay. What if we don't need to fragment the liquidity as much by going and finding a more liquid, more prevalent collateral, like ETH, right? And the assumption is that like, there's going to be a lot more ETH collateral available and ETH liquidity available on all of these networks, then you could ever really have, you know, in SNX, right?
You know, the market caps are, I think, you know, at the moment, a couple of orders of magnitude different, right? So there's a lot more liquidity out there. So use a more liquid thing and then use SNX for something different, right? And these are just conflicting goals, you know, because if we use ETH, then it becomes much easier. Right. We're actually back to more like the Uniswap style thing, right? Uniswap plus fee switch, right? Where it's like, you've got these distinct things, you use collateral on that network, you don't need to spread your collateral out, you don't need to communicate between them.
You can maintain fungibility because they are fundamentally all the same instance. So you can bridge tokens back and forth and, you know, they're fungible because they're all backed by ETH, right? They all earn fees and, you know, the fees are paid in the stable coin and then you just figure out a way to distribute those fees across the different networks and there's a whole bunch of solutions, right? You know, I've been very against buybacks and burns as being inefficient, right? In the past, like, if you're doing a buyback and burn that means all token holders, whether they're participating in the network or not, get a benefit, right?
And so it's inefficient from a, you know, incentive perspective, but in a cross-chain environment, it actually flips and becomes more efficient because by doing a buyback and burn, the benefits accrue to everyone equally, right? And, you know, again, there's some potential issues with that where maybe everyone just wants to camp out on mainnet, the safest place, even if the highest fee yield is over here, right? And so you're not creating the right incentives, but if you have sufficient fees on the network where you want the activity to happen that goes to LPs and then some other protocol level fee that flows back to everyone, no matter where they are, then I think you can strike a balance.
Yeah, in that model, you're kind of letting the free market, you're really leaning into the free markets to solve a lot of problems, which I generally agree with and like as a design principle, the free market's powerful, let it do its work. Yeah, great, yeah. Okay, and so this is the one thing I will give credit towards synthetics with is it's seemingly like egolessness about being willing to experiment across all different, like being very pragmatic about like, do we want to enshrine SNX first and foremost? Well, let's consider the scenarios in which the answer is yes and no. And let's pick the best of both worlds.
And so in your blog post, you talk about three different paths, three different options, some make more sense than others to solve some of this fragmented liquidity solutions. And one of them is like you said, it's like, well, we can bootstrap with ether instead of bootstrapping with SNX. That's I think the first path of three, you want to take us further into the second one? Yeah, so I think it's worth calling out though that synthetics, we are very pragmatic, but we're also extremely dogmatic, right? And it's a weird mix, right? So there's like certain dogma within the community where it's like, you can't touch that.
So for a long time, it was like, you cannot siphon off fees away from the SNX token, right? Doesn't matter how good of an idea you think this is, right? And I'll give you a silly example, right? If we thought that putting 2% of the total fees towards funding bankless, right? It was going to be a really beneficial thing, right? And everyone agrees that this is a beneficial thing. It'd be amazing, like bankless is a super, amazing public good that we want to fund or whatever. I'm liking this. Yeah, okay. Zero chance that will ever happen, right? You know, back in the day, because we just said, the instant you, it was almost like the Uniswap fee switch, the instant you divert fee.
Like we had a fee switch that was on and welded shot. Right. You couldn't actually turn it off, right? Like at the opposite of Uniswap, right? It's like we basically jammed it to like full fee switch on all of the fees ever generated go to the token holders. Zero goes to LPs because the token holders are the same. And then we're like, let's make sure that no one can ever touch this thing and, you know, we broke the switch off and welded it shot, right? Well, this is just a good lesson in incredible neutrality. The similar EIP was put forth, Shadow Kevin O'Locky, EIP, I can't remember what it was, but it wanted to siphon off Ethereum block rewards for public goods or something.
So we were going to take this, what was ideally this credibly neutral protocol Ethereum, and we wanted to fund public goods with it. Who doesn't want to fund public goods? It's a great idea. But the community was super divided over this and over just like the corruption that that might instill. Like it starts off as a good idea. But what if Bankless starts making content about XRP and how apps are dumb? Like that is not something that can be imagined in this short term, but then it might happen in the long term. Agreed. Small little divergence there. Yeah, but like this is the same problem, right?
That you really are trying to avoid trusting anyone, right? Like if there's no proper incentive mechanism to ensure that the alignment's there, then it becomes very risky, right? And so the same by the same token, right? As soon as we're like, oh, but what if we just, it's just a little, just a little tiny bit of fees, just give them like, come on, we need this thing, right? And people were like, as soon as you do that, the floodgates open, right? And you don't know, and you know, there's, it is a bit of a slippery slope argument, but like it is definitely like a qualitative change, right? You don't just going from like, oh, let's, you know, send another one percent of fees to this thing which we're already doing.
We're actually saying zero percent of fees go anywhere but token holders, and now it's two percent. What's to stop it from going to four percent? What's to stop it from being wasted? The problem is that, you know, we're now to a point where we have actually started diverting fees. We finally said, we have to pay integrators. We don't have our own front end. There's no synthetics front end, right? There are three, four different integrators, and we need to pay them, right? And how you pay integrators to come and do this is a hard problem to solve, right? There's a whole bunch of different conflicting, you know, kind of motivations from different parties, right?
And this is how interesting it is, right? So there was a bit of a debate, and I'm on one hand building a new front end, right? So I'm doing an integration, right? So, you know, like, you could make an argument that, for me, I'd love if half the fees went integrators, right? Like, it's very self-serving argument, right? Like, let's make it 80 percent, actually. You know, the protocol should get some fees, right? But like, if 80 percent go to, really, the front ends are doing the work, right? So like, let's pay the, you know, let's pay the front ends, right? And we need them. They're critical to the ecosystem, right?
So there's an argument of like, to try and maximize that for my own personal benefit. And I said, no, like, I don't want to be advocating for high fees. I don't think that we should be looking at the cost of running a front end today, and setting the fee split based on that, right? We should set the fee split as conservative as possible. And if it's not working, then we can increase it, right? And some of the front ends of like, you know, come back and said, well, that's not fair, right? Because your front end is being bootstrapped by you. Mm-hmm. And you've got enough money to pay for it. So you don't need money.
You'd actually run it a loss, right? And so by that argument, the most self-serving thing for me is to say, no fees for any integrators. Let's make it zero percent. Let's go back to the old days of all the money goes to us next holders because I get those fees. I can fund user acquisition. Exactly. Yeah, you know, that I can choke off all of these other guys. And I was like, wow, I hadn't even told about that. And so now it's a situation where like, it doesn't matter what I advocate for it. Like it's bad in both cases. So I kind of have to recuse myself and let it play out in the community. But you know, it's again, just kind of speaks to, it's a challenging problem working out.
How do you split up fees? Where do the incentives go? What are you trying to optimize for? You know, all of this stuff, it's really hard. And you know, that's just talking about one network. Right. Like we haven't even gone to a multi-chain network. Where now you have the arbitrary network and the optimism network fighting, saying, well, hang on, we're generating more fees. Why don't we get more? Right. Why is it equally distributed? Why, you know, like we've got more users, we've got more activity. Let's just keep the fees over here in Arbitrum Land. And then the optimism people saying, you know, we've had a little bit of this between main net and optimism where people are like, this isn't fair.
We want more fees for optimism or more fees for main net or less fees here or whatever. So these are all very challenging governance problems. Okay. So as we're going down the rabbit hole, the idea maze of like trying to discover how synthetics has this unified vision for itself. And where are we? We talked about the three phases of difficulty. We started to define the differences in composability of governance. What's next in this conversation? So, you know, the liquidity conversation is, can you get people across the line to let go of their dogma? Right, really, right? Like that's the question.
And so we were very dogmatic for a long time about no fees to anyone other than SNX holders and no external collateral, right? We, you know, we've had some wrappers and some other things like little experiments, but like fundamentally SNX token is the collateral that backs SUSD, right? And so it's like, okay, how do we test this out in a way that maybe is not a one way door and doesn't kind of open the floodgates and risk the position of the SNX token? And how do we, you know, negotiate that amongst the community and be pragmatic about it to your point, right? How do we balance the dogmatic? Right.
If we open this door or we, you know, flip this switch, you know, we might not be able to unflipp it, right? With, we have a genuine problem that needs a solution and we don't have a clear solution and so we need to experiment. And that has been, you know, honestly, the challenge is synthetics from the beginning, right? It's balancing those two, you know, kind of competing drives. One of the tools in the tool belt for solving this cross-chain liquidity issue is just cross-chain bridges. I think chain link CCIP comes into play here. How does that help solve the cross-chain problem? Can you talk about the, it's involvement here?
Yeah, so it helps, right? In the sense that you can start to pass messages about the state of the different instances back to the main instance, right? So very good for like, you know, managing governance, managing deployments, right? So you can have a unified governance framework that exists on optimism, let's say, right? That can pass messages to the other networks to change parameters, to make new deployments, to do a whole bunch of things, right? And so that's super valuable. What it probably can't do at the moment or what it's not yet ready to do and chain link have some other solutions out there that are coming online that we'll be able to do this is to manage like a shared cross-chain liquidity profile.
Which is a golden standard, that's the ultimate aim that we want to get to, yeah. Yeah, okay, so maybe one metaphor that's helpful for people to understand this, like synthetics, long time ago has chosen optimism. You guys have been working with the optimism team since UniPig, right? I think like after you chopped it, it was synthetics, that was the second app that was using the OP TechStack. And so this is synthetics brain. This is the home base where parameters get changed and then hopefully it spans out from there. And so if the optimism version of synthetics is the canon, the home, the brain, then you use chain link CCIP to send messages down the neurons to other instances of synthetics, wherever it's deployed.
And that's passing governance messages. Yes, passing protocol updates and changes. Pulling fees back. And pulling fees back, right? And then kind of how we talked about earlier, you're allowing some of the margins, the edges of the free market to balance pools, balance liquidity, and kind of do this kind of immersion stuff where there is no one single shared state, but things do get balanced relatively quickly according to the free market hypothesis. Yeah, so you know, if you've got eighth sitting on Arbitrum or Optimism, there's a bunch more demand on Arbitrum. You know, there's just a strong incentive to move over there and capture the fees because there are some fees that are only going to LPs.
So ETH Stakers in this case, right? So people, you know, if you're staking ETH on Optimism and there's less activity there, you're going to get paid less. So you're going to move over to Arbitrum, right? Absent some very strong ideological reasoning, right? You know, same thing with Avalanche or whatever, right? So you know, you kind of pick where you're willing to deploy liquidity and you're going to get fees there, but then there's going to be a cut of the total fees that flow back to some place, right? And that's some place, then becomes an interesting question, right? Because, okay, we've been on Optimism for a long time.
We had to move to Optimism because we needed scaling. We couldn't deploy our perps solution on main net. It's just not possible, right? The latency's too high, that's a whole bunch of reasons, right? Cost is too high, et cetera. So we had to do that. But now we've got the OP sac and the super chain. And it's like, is it weird to have all of the governance on synthetics happening in this arbitrary chain, right? Because let's say, you know, in two years time, this five or 10 chains were synthetics is deployed and let's say we do get to a point where it's all ethglateral. So there's ethglateral and all these different L2 chains, right?
And maybe Optimism is number eight in terms of volume, right? It feels a bit weird for the number eight chain, you know, maybe bass is number one, right? It's like, well, hang on a second. Why are we sending all our fees back there? That seems weird. And so this towards the end of the article is where I sort of propose this idea of having a credibly neutral place for governance and fee share and all of that stuff to happen. And, you know, it might be an OP stack chain, but it'll be like a synthetics app chain where stakers live there, governance lives there, fee sharing and your other cons of liquidity around SNX and your various things live there.
And then all the other chains have a deployed instance of perps and spot and whatever. This starts to feel like a little bit what Rune was going after with his MakerDow app chain that is what he was calling the back end management of the Dow and one specific chain that's custom built for MakerDow, and then just instances of MakerDow splattered across the cross-relate because it sounds a little bit similar except minus the crazy LLM scaling. Neural token on the thing. So I'm going to head around that yet. We didn't do our cage fight in Singapore, unfortunately. We didn't have a chance to. Maybe a permission list next year.
We can put a sumo suit on or something and battle it out or have a boxing match. Yeah, yeah. The permission list game is just a meme I'm trying to incept. OK, so that would be the synthetics app chain, not that there is one instance of synthetics that is the large central instance like dy. There's that's a dy dx model. Where dy dx is like f chain, f all the chains, just a dy dx chain. We're going to go to the best place. And we're going to deploy on the best goes chain that we can find. Right. Why not do the dy dx model of building your own like Cosmos IBC or your own one single central, even roll app on Ethereum and say, hey, no arbitrum deployment, no optimism deployment.
Just this one place where you come to us, why not do that? It's a good question. And this is, I think, one of the unsolved or unanswered questions. And I had a debate that was moderated by Dan from paradigm with Antonio. I think it's a couple of years ago now, maybe almost three years ago. And I was like, this is crazy. You're crazy. Composibility is the thing. If you go and build your own siloed chain at that point on StarCware, then the only people who can interact with it are people that bridge there. That's crazy. We want to be on a composable chain. That's the benefit of DeFi. And turns out I was wrong.
At least in the short term, right? In the short term, I was wrong because what they got out of having their own chain where they controlled everything is they were able to concentrate on the liquidity there. They were able to get a much better user experience. They were able to scale faster sooner, right? And they got a significant lead over the other dexas. And so there is an argument for an exchange to live on a very specific place, right? And to concentrate on the liquidity there. The problem that I see with that is this liquidity fragmentation and user fragmentation that we have today, the thesis is that there are distinct users on Arbitram, on Avalanche, on Solana, on Mainnet, on Optimism, et cetera, et cetera.
We can go on, yeah, we can be here all day, right? And those people are not going anywhere else, right? Maybe those people that are like on Mainnet and Arbitram or Mainnet and Optimism. But if you're on only Optimism or only Arbitram, there are users you cannot access, right? And so that thesis is still kind of unproven and this is where the base experiment of, okay, let's deploy an instance of synthetics, let people deposit ETH, let's see if any activity happens there. If there's no activity there, that is a really important piece of information. Now, why do it on base versus Arbitram? My reasoning is that Arbitram is more valuable, right?
The base is very new and it's a low stakes experiment. If you do it on Arbitram and you get it wrong and you launch this ETH thing and people don't want to use ETH or liquidity is bad, you kind of get one shot at it. We waited a long time to go to Arbitram and I want us to get it right when we go there. And so let's do it on base, let's see if it works. If it kind of works, then, okay, let's do it on Arbitram. Arbitram is production basis experiment. 100% exactly, yep. And so, again, it's like if there are distinct users on these chains, then you need to be on every chain. If you believe as dydx does, that it doesn't matter what chain people prefer, they will come to your chain if you are the best solution, then that's another approach.
And that has been the approach that dydx has taken and it has gone very well for them so far. There is a third option though and this is the infinitex option, which is abstract away the chains completely, right? Use an execution environment but you don't even need to talk to users about it. But go like multiple steps further than dydx where you're abstracting away the fact that there is even a chain, right? You're just giving people an application, a trading application, right? And you're giving them what they're used to using on centralized exchanges. Use the name's passwords, no bridging. USDT, USDC is collateral, not signing transactions, a database like performance environment where it feels like you're inside the app and every time you move or touch something, something happens, right?
It's not this kind of slow, clunky, high latency thing. And if that works, then you can be on whichever execution environment you want because all of your users are just going to be signing into a front end with a username and password and not caring. You can switch execution environments out arbitrarily and they'll never know. And you're using execution environments as blockchains. Blockchains, yeah. Okay, stack is an execution environment. Yeah, exactly, exactly, exactly. Yeah, so like if infinitex is working, let's say, right? There's obviously, there's the demand side and the supply side.
Okay, so at the moment, the supply side of liquidity is coming from optimism, right? And the demand side is coming from people on optimism. You build infinitex and you abstract that away. The demand side's coming from centralized exchanges. It's coming from Binance and Buybit and OKX and all of those guys, right? And so now you've solved the demand side by building something that is feature parity with centralized exchanges, right? Maybe on the supply side, the liquidity is not actually there. Maybe there's not enough liquidity on optimism and maybe there would be more liquidity on arbitrum. You can actually switch out those execution environments and just move or combine them and you're abstracting it away.
The user does not care or even know that sometimes their order is routed to arbitrum, sometimes it's routed to optimism, sometimes it's routed to Solana. They're relevant to them. They just want to know that they get fast execution and deep liquidity, that's it. Manimask Portfolio is your one-stop shop to manage your crypto assets and to tap into DeFi, all in one place. And the most important part of that experience, buying crypto, obviously. Manimask Portfolio's buy feature enables you to purchase crypto easily without going through centralized exchanges. Designed with you in mind, you can fund your wallet directly in just a few clicks with convenience and simplicity.
What happens when you press the buy button? Rather than being limited to a single payment provider, Manimask brings together a bunch of vetted, trustworthy providers to present you with customized quotes for your crypto purchase. Once you've funded your wallet, you'll be able to plug into DeFi with all the money verbs, like swapping, bridging and staking. But first things first, you need skin in the game. Head over to Manimask.io, slash Portfolio, to buy crypto the easy way. You know Uniswap, it's the world's largest decentralized exchange, with over $1.4 trillion in trading volume. You know this because we talk about it endlessly on Bayquus.
It's Uniswap, but Uniswap is becoming so much more. Uniswap Labs just released the Uniswap mobile wallet for iOS. The newest, easiest way to trade tokens on the go. With a Uniswap wallet, you can easily create or import a new wallet by crypto on any available exchange with your debit card with extremely low fiat onramp fees. And you can seamlessly swap on mainnet, polygon, arbitragem and optimism. On the Uniswap mobile wallet, you can store and display your beautiful NFTs. And you can also explore Web3 with the in-app search features, market leaderboards, and price choice. Or use wallet connect to connect to any Web3 application.
So you can now go directly to DeFi with the Uniswap mobile wallet. Safe, simple custody from the most trusted team in DeFi. Download the Uniswap wallet today on iOS. There's a link in the show notes. The pattern that I'm picking up here is just like, again, allowing players, sophisticated players in the free market to do a lot of the big lift because it's profitable for them. And just allowing simplicity to go into the actual end users who supply the orders. It reminds me a little bit of like the whole Uniswap X intent model where people are just come to Uniswap X or cow swap and say, hey, I have this desire.
I have this intent. And then the free market like bids for that. And so they would come like the model I'm seeing with Infinix is that people are just coming in, signing in, depositing their collateral and say, hey, I want to do these things. And then more sophisticated back-end providers do the best to optimize their route between arbitrum, whatever deployment of synthetics, arbitrum optimism, wherever base. And then they just serve the best price possible to the user and they take the cut. This sounds like a design pattern that I think is going to be important for producing composability for all chains.
It is another tool in the tool belt, if you will. Yeah, absolutely. And again, it might be that something like Infinix ends up routing to multiple different liquidity pools and that there are multiple instances of synthetics where that goes. The thing that I think is interesting is my sense is that liquidity providers are a different group of people to end users or even traders. I think I kind of believe in this thesis that there are traders on arbitrum that don't trade or won't trade on optimism. I don't think the same thing is necessarily true of liquidity providers. I think liquidity providers are a bit more mercenary.
They just want yields. And they'll move arbitrarily between different chains to get the best yield. And so on the supply side, I think if Infinix is routing orders to Avalanche and it's working and as the liquidity provider, it's really high yield, I think people will move there. And they'll just be like, well, I'm a liquidity provider. I'm just looking for the best yield. That's all I care about. I'm not ideological. I'm fine. Well, because if nine liquidity providers like I'm not touching Avalanche, well, then it just increases the yield for the one that does. Yeah, exactly. And for some reason, there's, it makes sense that that is the place to route the orders, right?
Then it's this forcing function where everyone kind of has to go there, right? And so, you know, on the user side, you just strike away, you know, Binance doesn't tell you which database engine it's using, right? It doesn't tell you which cloud computing, you know, if you really love GCP and you hate the idea of AWS, like there's no Binance option for you to choose that, right? Like you just turn up to Binance, use the name password. They could switch out, you know, like computing provider and you would never even know. So there's some other tools in the tool belt that I want to bring up. Optimism's idea about their super chain and homogenous block space is their strategy.
It's a little bit of hand-waveriness. There's a lot of a little bit of unknowns, but I will accept on faith that once we get to homogenous block space, we have some other things that we can then access and it's an iterative process. So maybe there's some solutions there. And then there's also this concept of shared sequencing and shared execution espresso systems. And then like you mix that with a roll-up as a service provider like conduit, for example. So conduit runs OP stack chains. They just opened up their support for arbitrum. And all of a sudden, like say, for example, conduit or espresso shared sequencing, they just work together.
That transactions on arbitrum can be matched and balanced with transactions on optimism before settling down to the Ethereum layer one. All of a sudden, we get even more a composability cross-chain than what we had previously. And then maybe that's too far down the line for what synthetics is putting in practice today for solving the problems today. But like, how are these solutions on your radar and what do you think about them? They are. They're on our radar. And if I put my infinex hat on, or I put my synthetics hat on, there's two kind of different approaches, or thought processes, I guess, that are going on here.
With my infinex hat on, I sort of say, it doesn't really matter. It really doesn't matter about any of these things because the allegiance of a user in Web 2 World is not to the execution environment or the network. It is to the brand of the application that they like to use. They feel comfortable with it or whatever. If someone likes Robinhood, they don't care if the order is... They care a little bit that it's being routed and set it down. There's a payment for orderflow. Fundamentally, the average Robinhood user does not care whether it's Ken Griffin getting their orders routed to them or some other guy.
They don't really care. They just want to make sure that they don't pay anything to trade and that the execution price is reasonable-ish. And even that, they don't care about that much. They care about the Robinhood app. They care about the features. If you change the color of the confetti when you're going... They're going to care about that. They're like, oh, you can pay. Don't change it from blue to white. What users actually care about is the user experience and it's the allegiance to the brand. It's the allegiance to the look and feel of the app and all of that stuff. The execution environment or where the order is routed or whatever is not that relevant.
And so when I put my infinex hat on, I say all of this stuff that we're getting caught up in, arbitrage versus optimism versus whatever, may get abstracted away. And the question is, well, why have we not gotten there before? Why now? And I think that there's a couple of reasons. One, we didn't have the infrastructure in place. The infrastructure was not sort of good enough to compete with C5, whether it's on the landing front or OTC desks or spot trading, perps trading, whatever it is. We've always had this competition between decentralized and centralized. And centralized is always dominated because centralized has just been better and easier and simpler and not safer.
But all of those other things and unfortunately, safeness is on the lower end of the stack. And so if we get to a point where we have an aggregator or this DeFi super app like infinex where it's just choosing to integrate the best liquidity pools and the user doesn't care, they just care that they're getting the best experience, then all of this other stuff may disappear. Then I put my hints. But it is solving it with centralization, though. To an extent, minimum centralization. Yeah, to an extent. How is it solving it? It's saying we're creating a brand that will overlay itself over all of these different things.
And that brand will have users that will have some level of allegiance to the brand. And they will be used to the flows. They'll have an account there. All their assets will be there. And they will just want to be able to use whatever is there. Now there's a problem with that. If you take that to a logical conclusion, all of a sudden the market power that, even forget about infinex, if any app were to have that level of market power where it is more powerful than the underlying execution environments, then you get into a situation where what if that app decides to route orders here over there because of some...
We are preferring. Yes, inside its competitor. Exactly. All of that stuff. Not even a synthetic competitor, but infinex just forks synthetics with this new token. Yes. And it's like, hey, it's us now. We're doing this thing. So here's a great example. Let's say we get into a situation where we want to use a lending protocol for margining rather than building our own margining system. So infinex says, okay, Binance spent two years building their FTX, but spent a few years building their margining system. And, you know, by all accounts, it was a good margining system. It had some battle flaws. You know, at a deep level.
But like, the margining system was good. People liked it. Users liked it. Right. You could margin with a bunch of different things. You're cross margin. Yeah. It was pretty good. But they had to build it bespoke. Right. What if we just use compound or arbe? Right. Now, okay. Let's say we have a lot of market power. Right. In the sense that we can route a lot of borrow. Right. Into one or both of those protocols. Right. Okay. Well, if we want to route orders to arbe, we need to get some kind of fee cut from this. Right. The same way that you would expect in any cut, you know. Yep. Right. So who's going to give us the most fees?
Right. And then the next step is, okay, we're still not getting enough fees. What if we just fork it? Mm-hmm. If there's enough market power there, right. You could get to a point like, and I've always been so anti this like fear of forks. Right. Like, oh, don't do it. I've been sourced because you know, people will fork you because we've never had anything with that much market power. Yeah. And you can very well get to a point where, given the state that we're in now for next cycle, if you know, a defy aggregator of some kind, has enough power, I mean, one inch kind of got there for a while.
Yeah. We're like, if one inch decided to route things to your private pools, like, you remember there's private pools, right? Yeah. You would make a lot of money. If it didn't, you wouldn't. Mm-hmm. And so you have to imagine that like, that needs to be controlled, you know, that's a very dangerous thing in terms of concentration of market power. Yeah. So the centralized front end should not be top heavy with the power and strength of the foundation of the underlying protocol. But that's the reality in most of the world, right? Right. Yeah. The front end is the valuable thing, right? Right. And you know, like, this conversations happen, you know, I can't remember what the specific phrasing was.
I think it was like Chris Berniske, you know, talking about fat protocols or something like that. Yeah. Yeah, the protocol thesis, right? You know, well, maybe that could flip it on its head, right? Whereas it's actually the fat UI thesis, right? Like the UI. Well, it's fat protocols. So ethereum. Yeah. Not, like, I didn't make a statement about the app layer. Yeah. And then like, who knows about the centralized layer. Yeah. So, you know, there's a whole bunch of things that could play out. Like, we're still so early. Mm-hmm. And these things are still so unsolved. Mm-hmm. And so it's really not clear what happens there.
But, you know, we're already seeing things that I hadn't even contemplated in terms of, like, you know, this UI layer, right? Because it had never been important in synthetics. ynthetics was always infrastructure, right? We had too many infrastructure problems to worry about the UI layer. Right. It was an afterthought. Yeah. All of a sudden, we're now thinking about this thinking, well, hey, there's a lot of leverage here. Mm-hmm. If you can get this right, all of a sudden it's like, well, it's just four coffee. Mm-hmm. We've got, because it's always been the demand side, right? Like, the supply side, we've been so focused on it, we haven't been able to get the demand side.
If you control the demand, you have a lot of power over the supply. Especially in crypto. Oh, my God. Whoever's got demand has it all. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. Well, okay. So, thinking about this idea of, like, a top-heavy, powerful app. The kind of the solutions I was talking about, like, cross-changed execution via shared sequencing is a check on that power. Yeah. Like, one of the goals, I think we should all aspire to in crypto, is like, we want to get everyone on chain. We want a billion people on chain. Infinex, sorry, cane. Doesn't actually solve that problem. Yes. It actually is intercepting that problem.
Yes. And so, putting on your synthetics cap and your on-chain maxi cap, then we should be hopeful about the power of cross-chain shared execution, because that is a powerful tool of making, you know, in a synthetics instance one, composable with synthetics instance two. Yeah. So, I think where the disaggregation potentially happens, right? So, we might have an aggregation period where these, like, UI layer solutions, you know, that are abstracting way complexity and, you know, making the user experience and onboarding experience better, right? Aggregate a lot of power, right? The disaggregation comes from us learning the lesson of this abstraction of complexity is really powerful.
At the moment, it's just an idea, right? Like, people might not even care. Like, being able to sign in with the username and password might not be that beneficial, right? We're seeing in friend tech that it's kind of beneficial, right? Like, that's a good, early indicator that, like, this is actually useful, because there's a whole bunch of other things that are horrendous about that app. And yet, the onboarding process, and like, I love it, right? I'm on there, like, you know, but like, it fucking barely works, right? And yet, you know, people are onboarding. Like, there's some things that are working and some things that are not, right?
So, the interesting thing for me is, okay, you know, waves of aggregation and disaggregation. And so, if it turns out that this idea of the onboarding process being streamlined and, you know, abstracting the signing process away and all of this stuff becomes very powerful, it's easy for people to replicate that. Like, Infinix is still going to be open source. You can fork Infinix and go and do it a different way, right? And so, you know, like, yes, the aggregation could be problematic for a while. But if there's too much power aggregated in a two, you know, concentrated group of, you know, whatever controllers, token holders, whatever the governance process is, the market will kind of disaggregate it, right?
At least in crypto because everything's open source. And it's like, oh, that's the tactic that you need to use, right? You need to remove the signing and you need to have account recovery and you need to do all this stuff. And then that'll become table stakes and ever also doing it and then, you know, it'll kind of spread back out again. Okay. All right. So, I think we've done a pretty good job like laying the landscape of the problem statement and talking about potential solutions, where to look for solutions. Where are you focused? Like, where are you? What kind of solution area are you focused on the most that you most optimistic about to solving some of these problems?
Or where are synthetics specifically going towards? Yeah. So I think synthetics is looking at how do we do kind of one and two, right? As we talked about. Can you define one and two again? Yeah. So one and two would be like, how do we get on as many networks as possible and solve the governance problem? Okay. So like, deploy distinct instances and let's test out if that even works, right? And if it works, then just solve number two, which is like the shared governance fee movement sort of thing, right? Importantly allowing the free market to balance doing this. The supply side liquidity. Yeah.
Yeah, yeah. Like balance the liquidity via the market, right? Right. And then figure out a way to stitch together that fee sharing process or whatever, right? Don't worry about fungibility. Don't worry about cross-chain communication. Don't worry about unified liquidity. Let the liquidity flow where it flows and then figure out a plan for fees, right? Figure out a plan for governance and how you modify the thing. That's the, I think, short terms synthetics plan. Okay. Short terms synthetics plan. Do you have any sort of like semblance of time around this? Well, I mean, there's nothing really stopping us from deploying to base, right?
Like it's really about getting consensus within the community about that. You know, so I would imagine that deploying to base at this point, given how close ProPS V3 is, should probably wait for ProPS V3, the same thing that Infinix is doing. Infinix could deploy ProPS V2, but then the contracts change massively. So we were just waiting for ProPS V3. ProPS V3, the last I heard, is in audit. Whatever that means, you know, synthetics, right? So my guess is that ProPS V3 will be deployed probably in October or maybe November. And once that's done, then it makes sense to test out this base thesis, run the base experiment.
Cool. Well, just like neck and neck with actual with with optimism, the people that you have teamed up with with such a long time, actually straightforwardly pushing the frontier into the unknown. And it's always one thing I've admired about synthetics and then what you have been doing, like taking on the hard problems head on. Are there any other parts of this conversation that I haven't unpacked yet that are worth pulling out about synthetics or composability or anything else that you guys are working on? I think, you know, we do have this other component in V3, which is permissionlessness, right?
So, you know, synthetics has always been a permission liquidity protocol in the sense that governance controls what can be deployed, right? You can't deploy a novel instrument. No one can turn up and, you know, it's not it's not an open protocol in sense that someone can deploy some new asset, right? You're talking about the new output of synthetics, like a new synth. Yeah, exactly. I'd like to create a synth around some particular asset. It's novel, you know, like a volatility of Bitcoin index, right? Okay. So, you know, you want to like to have the BTC VIX. Okay, cool. No. Right. Great. Go to UMA.
Right. Right. Really, like go to UMA and build it there, right? Or, you know, whatever. And so now with V3, we're going to be opening up maybe not this year, but probably early next year. The ability for someone to turn up and do the financial engineering without needing to do the token engineering, if that makes sense, right? So you can turn up and you can say, hey, I've got this article. You know, this is the way that the price feed works. And I want to pump it in and get liquidity. And I think that that really kind of shifts the game in terms of, like, the ability to do novel financial engineering.
It doesn't solve any of these other problems we talked about. But, you know, it maybe makes them worse on some level because then you have, like, different instruments that exist on different chains. And, you know, it's like, well, I want the VTC VIX. Oh, no. Sorry. That's on the on-off. Right. Because David's on a different story. I've got to go to a different story. Yeah. So, yeah, you know, it really puts a bit of pressure, right? When you have permissionlessness. Because then it's like, you could have some protocols that decide to just deploy on Syndetics V3 on a specific chain. And people like, I heard that you could trade this thing.
And it's like, yes, but. Right. And so, you know, being able to abstract that away. And saying, you know, okay, well, on Arbitral, we've got these weird instances. On base, we've got these things. And then on Optimism, we've got these separate other things. And finding a way for users to be able to, like, rock that is, you know, going to be challenging, right? So, that's another level of complexity that we need to deal with, unfortunately. Oh, man. Complexly. Yeah, complexly. Yeah, right. What about just even outside the Syndetics ecosystem, broader crypto theory, 2023 regulation? Is anything else floating around in your head?
Yeah. I mean, look, regulations and regulators, I think are pretty fucked at this point. Like, there's no other way to put it in the elderly. Yeah. You know, like, it's, it's at a point of sort of adversarial attacks on crypto that I really didn't think that we would get to. Like, I wanted to believe that, and maybe this is a bit naive, right? But like, I wanted to believe that the regulators genuinely were operating in good faith. And I actually think we've crossed the line where they're no longer operating in good faith. It's actually a pitched battle. Right. And they're just trying to win.
And you're talking beyond Gensler. Oh, yeah. Like, the CFTC is now, you know, like, it's, it's way beyond that, right? It's, you know, even into Congress and, you know, different things come out on any given day about the agendas that various people have. And crypto has become, unfortunately, a partisan issue as well, right? So, you've got partisanship, you've got point scoring, you've got, you know, adversarial regulators, like, the US is not in a great place. And I love America, you know, I've spent my life here. But, you know, it's, it's not amazing. That said, like, if there's one industry that you don't want to become adversarial with, it's crypto.
It's the industry that's built inside of an adversarial environment. Like, we've been doing this for much longer than you guys and we will absolutely not lose that battle. Right? You know, I think, again, there was an assumption for a long time that it was misguided, but, you know, in good faith acting. And now it's become more obvious that it's actually not misguided. It's not in good faith. It's a very, you know, clear attack on what we're trying to build, which is sad because, you know, my genuine view is that crypto is a new enabling technology like the internet that will make the world a better place.
And of course, it can be used for bad things and it can be used for good things. But like on a fundamental level, it is a new technology that will enable new innovative solutions to existing problems that will make the world a better place. It's just unequivocal in my mind, right? So, okay. So, are you saying that, like, maybe in the era of 2021, we were harmonious-ish with the regulators playing by the rules, good faith regulation. And then swapped to 2022, 2023, all of a sudden it's no longer good faith. It's like, now it's the game of chess, now people playing dirty. And you're saying that that environment is actually favoring to crypto because- We're sure.
Yeah. Like, you know, I think we were kind of si-opsed into like being like, oh, I think, you know, we just need to educate them, right? So, you spend a bunch of time educating people that did not want to be educated. Actually knew what they were doing and we're doing it in a very deliberate fashion. And we were just wasting our time trying to educate them, right? You know, it's the kind of now, you know, then, like, then they fight you sort of thing, right? We're in the then they fight you, you know, first they si-ops you. And now they forgot the si-ops. Yeah, we forgot the si-ops part of that, right?
But, you know, like, I think we were kind of si-opsed, right? Like, we were like, no, no, no, like, you know, like, I really believe in the American system, right? Like, I genuinely believe that the American system is a market-driven, very powerful mechanism for improving the world and has been for a really long time. And so, you know, like, I was kind of si-opsed myself in being like, you know, people are not anti-innovation in America, right? Like, you know, like, you've got some people that are maybe conservative, right? And who are like, oh, let's, you know, de-risk this, let's not do something rash, let's slow it down.
But, you know, the idea that someone is just against innovation in principle, that's a weird, it's a bit far. Never been seen in America. Yeah, it's kind of strange, right? And so, you know, the idea that you have regulators and, you know, people running these regulatory bodies that are just absolutely trying to stifle innovation, that's a dark place to be in, right? But at the same time, the nice thing about crypto, in my mind, is that if you were designed a system, right? The fact that we've been, you know, able to do regulatory arbitrage to, you know, such a powerful extent, if you were designed a system that is resistant to this exact type of thing, it would be crypto, right?
So, we have the tools to resist this, right? And we know how to use it. We are the tools. We are the tools. Like, the tools to resist this kind of overreach are, it's crypto, right? And so, unfortunately, you know, they picked the wrong fight. That's the reality, right? They picked the wrong fight. We didn't know we're in a fight. Now we do. And it's like, okay, well, unfortunately, this is going to go pretty badly for you now. And so, you know, that's just the situation that we're in. And, you know, I wish that it weren't. And, you know, again, it's become a partisan issue and maybe that shifts.
And, you know, the battle lines, you know, kind of shift, but at the moment, my approach is that we need to actually, you know, be adversarial in a clearly adversarial. Bullish. Yeah. Bullish. Yeah. Well, the idea just that crypto who is full of just like relentless innovators, builders who are scrappy, like absolutely chewing glass as an industry going up against like status regulators who are just like, I know where I'm picking my mind. Yeah. I'm like, you wouldn't want to take on, you know, like the valley, right? Like, you know, you wouldn't want to say, like, if you're going to, if you're going to say, okay, I'm going to go pick a group of people, like startup founders, right?
You know, in Silicon Valley, like those are the people I'm going to go after. That's a dumb thing to do. They're insane. Like you're talking about, you're taking on insane people. Then crypto founders, it's like an order magazine beyond that. I like you. Yeah, you might as well take on a zombie horde. It's going to go just about as well for you. So, yeah, that's, that's my kind of take at the moment. And, you know, as I said, it's a bit unfortunate that we're here, but it's nice at least to know that this is the situation we're in, right? And really have a clear eye view about, okay, if this is going to be the next five years of how we play this out, then let's play it out.
Well, okay, this has been great. Is there any message any of the bankless listeners, the builders out there pointing towards synthetics or infinites or any part of that ecosystem or even just broadly any message you have for them? Just broadly, I think keep building, right? You know, the bear market noise floors dropped. It's really much easier to get attention for novel valuable solutions, you know, and innovative designs of systems. Like this is the time to build those things. This is the time to get momentum. And, you know, I'm already seeing a ton of interesting stuff like every day. You know, you just, the vibe in terms of building is amazing at the moment.
It's, which is kind of a bottom signal, unfortunately, right? Like the peak of when you feel like, wow, we're really getting stuff done and making progress is like, unfortunately, that's about to come pick up on them. And then it's going to get crazy again because the momentum starts to slip and then the noise is there and, you know, you get all kind of craziness. But it is what it is. I think we've got, you know, a solid six to 12 months of building in front of us and, you know, just keep building and keep grinding. Well, Kane, your commitment to grinding is admirable. You've been grinding since last, the prior bear market through the bull market and once again through the bear.
So I'm very glad to have you on the same team as I am, the crypto team, of course. So thank you for coming over to my apartment and doing this podcast with me. It's even fantastic. Yeah, thank you. Thanks for having me. Bank of the station. You guys know the deal crypto is risky. The cross chain composability world. It's a fog of war. Yet we are going into that frontier. And nonetheless, we are glad you are with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot. You