Hear how their recent deal with Tesla (yes, the real-world electric car manufacturer) happened, what it means for their future, how the $MKR tokenomics work, and so much more!
------ 📣 MAC NFT DROP https://bankless.cc/MAC
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALED ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🏦 ALTO IRA | TAX-FREE CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/AltoIRA
👻 AAVE V3 | LEND & BORROW CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/aave
⚡️ MAKER DAO | THE DAI STABLECOIN https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
------ Timestamps:
0:00 Intro 7:30 What is MakerDao 14:30 $MKR Price Action Curse? 19:10 Maker’s Meta Goals 21:36 Increasing the $DAI Supply 33:53 Increasing the $DAI Demand 45:23 The Future of Maker’s Collateral 51:45 Tesla Taps MakerDAO 1:01:34 Legal Structural Components 1:06:00 Bridging Real World Assets 1:12:05 L222 1:18:39 $MKR Tokenomics 1:31:11 Why Bullish MakerDAO
------
Resources:
MakerDAO: https://twitter.com/MakerDAO
Sam MacPherson: https://mobile.twitter.com/hexonaut
Niklas Kunkel: https://twitter.com/nomos_paradox
monetsupply.eth https://twitter.com/MonetSupply
Maker Burner www.makerburn.com
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to this very special episode. Today we are talking all about MakerDow and the bull case behind MakerDow. You guys all know MakerDow. It's the organization. It's the the Dow behind the die stablecoin, the first ever trustless stablecoin that crypto has ever seen. But I'll ask the listeners, do you really know MakerDow? Have you really been paying attention to what's going on behind the scenes? Because of my mind from my understanding, it's a Dow like none other. And MakerDow has made fundamentally different choices, less about different smart contract design choices, but more about how the Dow operates, how the Dow is organized, and what is going on behind the scenes.
I've been a long supporter of MakerDow. Before I started writing about Ethereum, I started writing about MakerDow first. So I've been very close with the team and organization behind MakerDow. They have been an organization since 2016 and has blossomed and grown since then. It really started very emergently. People that were just interested in figuring out how to produce a decentralized stablecoin all came together. This was before DeFi was a thing. This was before the ICO boom. MKR, the MKR token was minted and distributed to early stakeholders. And a treasury of MKR was maintained kind of as you see in the current Dow landscape.
But again, this was in 2015 and 2016. Then the Maker organization realized that they really needed to have real-world footprint. They needed a centralized foundation. The MakerDow turned into a foundation that operated as a typical company more normally would. And that foundation existed for years. And then that foundation was disbanded almost a year ago. And once again, the Dow, which started as a very emergent bottom-up organization, is now returned to a Dow structure. But it's not just a Dow structure. It's more a Dow of Dow structure. And Maker governance really is just capital allocation decisions rather than voting on what the brand or icon should be or who should be able to tie their shoes with a snapshot vote.
So entire companies work for the metadata, the bigger Dow rather than just simply individuals in a discord. I think that there is a very strong bull case for MakerDow that the market does not appreciate. We're really fairly appreciated MakerDow, at least in my opinion. And so we have brought on three MakerDow community members to give the bull case for MakerDow and to illuminate what is going on behind the scenes with MakerDow. Because in my mind, it is a fantastic story that's very rich and is extremely compelling and interesting. And so we are going to give out the bull case for MakerDow here on this live stream.
I got a few more things to say before we bring on the panelists. But before I do, I want to say that in honor of national youth, HIV and AIDS Awareness Day on April 10th, M-A-C Cosmetics has created the first ever NFT collection featuring the work of the iconic artist and activist Keith Herring. They are minting NFTs. This is the NFT project where a 100% of the purchase price of primary sales of the Keith Herring NFT collection will be donated to the M-A-C Viva Glam fund to support to support youth impacted by HIV and AIDS. There are three rarity levels in this NFT drop. 1,000 total red tokens, a variable for $25 each, 250 blue tokens.
NFTs are available for 150 each and 25 yellow tokens available for $8,000 each. Minting has not yet happened. That is coming up on April 10th, so mark your calendars. If you have never been a part of an NFT drop, this might be the first one for you because of how everything is going for charity. It's like an NFT drop where you can feel good about everything that happens. There is a link in the show notes to sign up and learn more and you can access all of that information there in the show notes. With one last comment before we get started, this is a coming up an experimental show model out of bankless.
Future bullish blank shows are definitely going to be a thing. This is the bullish maker show, which I think has a compelling story, but I'm sure many other communities, many other dolls, many other projects that have the bull case for that project, for that token, that the rest of the market might not understand. This is a new format that we're trying on bankless. If you think that the market is underappreciating a particular token, a particular doll, a particular community, here's what you need to do. Assemble a team, write down some notes, hit bankless up on Twitter saying you've got the bull case for your particular token ready to go and you've got the team ready to go.
This is, I think, will be a very fun show moving forward to help spread the alpha about what is going on behind the scenes with your particular favorite doll. We are getting started here with one of my favorite dolls, MakerDow, of course. We will be right back to get into the show and the bull case for MakerDow teaser, they actually just announced a deal, they're financing a deal with Tesla. This is something that the market just doesn't understand. It's a little ridiculous. We're going to get into MakerDow in the bull case for MKR right after we talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
Arbitrum is an Ethereum layer two scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Over 300 projects have already deployed to Arbitrum and a DeFi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly. Some of the coolest and newest NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home. All the wild DeFi protocols continue to see increase usage and liquidity. Using Arbitrum has never been easier, especially with the ability to deposit directly into Arbitrum through all the exchanges, including Binance, FTX, Quoby and Crypto.com. Once inside, you'll notice Arbitrum increases Ethereum's speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee.
If you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users, visit Arbitrum.io slash developer to start building your DAP on Arbitrum. If you're a DGen, many of your favorite DAPs on Ethereum are already on Arbitrum with many moving over every day. Go to bridge.arbitrum.io now to start bridging tokens in order to experience DeFi and NFTs in the way it was always meant to be. Fast, cheap, secure, and friction free. The Layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's Layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day and we need bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a Layer 2 life. Across the fastest, cheapest, and most secure, cross-chain bridge.
With a cross, you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets to the chain of your choice. Access are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously. Across bridges are powered by UMA's Optimistic Oracle to securely transfer tokens from Layer 2 back to Ethereum. A token proposal is being deliberated as we speak in the across forum where community members will decide on the token distribution. You can have your part of a cross's story by joining the Discord and becoming a co-founder and helping to design the fair, fair launch of a cross. If you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely, go to across.
io to bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Arbitrum, or Boba Networks. MakerDow is the OG D5 protocol. The MakerDow produces die. The industry's most battle-tested and resilient stablecoin. Using Maker, you don't need to sell your collateral if you need liquidity. Instead, you can spin up a Maker Vault and use your collateral to mint die directly. With Maker, the power to mint new money is in your hands. The Maker Protocol is extremely hardened and operated by one of the most experienced DAOs in existence. They've been here since the beginning, they've seen it all, and so you can mint die with the assurance that your collateral is safe.
Soon, Maker will be present on all chains and altos, so minting die can take place on oasis.app, zaryon, zapper, or any other D5 protocol that you use. Follow Maker on Twitter at MakerDow and learn from the oldest and most resilient DAO in existence. Alright, thank this nation. Here is our bullcase for MKR, a bullcase for MakerDow panel. On the top left, we've got Sam, all the three of these DAO or DAO members. We've got top left at Sam, bottom left, we've got Monet Supply. You probably know him on Twitter, and then bottom right, we've got Nick Kunkel, who I've actually had the pleasure of spending COVID time with.
Nick and I went skiing a lot during COVID, and that has been a fun time. And so guys, are you guys ready to get into the bullcase for MakerDow? Yes. Alright, let's do this. I gave a little bit of an intro about the Maker Foundation, the originating story about MakerDow. But I want you guys to pick up the thread and take it from here. And Sam, I want to start with you. Just like, let's zoom forward to the present. Like, what is MakerDow? And what about MakerDow? It was just so different than the typical DAO that people are familiar with. And also, just who is a part of MakerDow? Like, who composes it?
And how is the culture of MakerDow just different from other organizations that we find in D5? Sam, I'll start with you. Yeah, sure. First, thanks for having us, David. And congrats on the bankless arena you've got today. Very, very bullish news. So I would say one of the big differences between MakerDow and other DAOs is we don't have an associated legal entity. We used to back in the day, the Maker Foundation. People probably know that pretty well, but they are fully dissolved now. So like, yeah, we're fully a DAO, no legal entity. That's an interesting piece. Another thing is that we're completely sustainable.
The protocol revenues more than pay for all the expenses of running the workforce and, you know, paying out various things on the protocol. So that's something that's really interesting and unique, I think. In terms of who's involved, there's a number of different groups in the DAO. We have what's called core units. This is like our main unit of like workforce. So me, I'm on the protocol engineering core unit. So we're responsible for maintaining and building the smart contracts for the core protocol as well as other things involved with that. You know, we have risk. We have monies on that. Next on the Oracle's team.
So this is sort of the fundamental unit we have. We also have what are called mandated actors. And so these are sort of elected people to sort of run the day to day operations of the protocol. This is sort of mixed in with core unit facilitators. Essentially, we have a once a week meeting that like we kind of go over like and synchronize and stuff like that. There's also delegates, which do the voting. And there's maker holders and just the wider community, you know, anybody can be involved. Nick, what would you add on to that? How would you illustrate the differences between maker Dow and how maker Dow came to be and how people think about Dow these days?
Well, okay. So right. I mean, we had the the Dow. Right. And right, right, right before kind of the Dow blew up, right? You had a every project was trying to be a Dow because we thought we had just discovered this new kind of social primitive a way of like, you know, like collectivism, right? And so you had maker Dow and you had digics down and you had a couple of these other ones, right? And then the Dow got hacked. And then Dow was kind of a dirty word for a long time, right? A maker, we considered dropping the word Dow from our name, you know, for like a long time. And now it's almost like enough time is a lapse that like Dow's are like this idea that came back to that people are like, no wait, that was actually like like a very useful concept.
What I think kind of makes maker like unique and special really is not just the way that we we structure ourselves as a Dow, but the way that we build is just very comes from a perspective that's very adversarial, right? We really think of like truly every little thing that could go wrong and try to have as little kind of direct human control or authority as possible. You know, we as, you know, the developers like we don't have special knobs and switches of turning the system on or off or deactivating stuff or activating things, right? It's really completely controlled by maker governance. It's completely controlled by the maker token holders.
And that type of full decentralization, I think, is is quite rare in, in, in, in DeFi, especially, right? I think many teams take the argument that, oh, well, we need to be a little bit centralized at the start right in order to innovate quickly to scale quickly. But then later, they don't actually decentralize. And I think maker is one of the few that really stuck to that promise and is following through on that. Monet, I want to get your perspective in on this as well. What are really the properties or characteristics about maker Dow that stand out as unique and special that only really maker Dow exhibits?
I wouldn't say only maker Dow exhibits this, but I feel like the maker community is really mission focused. Part of that might be from the token sort of stagnating, I think, in a certain way, but it's people don't get into maker because they're just typed about number go up. You know, we have a clear goal of making a really reliable financial system that people can trust and that that people can actually be safe to put their money in. And, you know, it attracts just kind of like a special committed group of people. And I think, you know, other protocols really are striving for that, but maybe are still in the like hype phase.
That is something that I think stands out to me the most is the ability for maker to retain the same talent that it had years ago. I find the same people, the same maker Dow community members, every single maker Dow event year after year after year. And for some reason, something about the maker organization just retains developer attention and talent attention inside of it. So it's the same cohort, it's always the same builders and that's really, really rare and defy when there's so much journal of the time. People that seem to work for maker tend to commit really, really hard to maker. Monet, you kind of alluded to this and I want to ask this next question is, I've always thought the story behind the fundamentals of maker Dow and then the MKR price on the secondary market to tell completely different stories.
Like there is, I don't think there's any other Dow that has had so much thought and attention and attention to detail and conservative labor built into the protocol yet none of these properties seem to be reflected in the MKR token. And so I want to get your guys' thoughts on like the historical price action of this thing as it relates to some of the fundamentals that have been built over the years. Like, is there like a curse on the MKR token? I just want to ask that question. Does the MKR price kind of feel cursed to you? Sam will start with you. Yeah. So like, I mean, I kind of went through a phase, I guess, where I was like, you know, concerned about the maker price and stuff like that.
At a certain point, you just kind of become numb to it and all you can really do is just keep delivering on building fundamentals and stuff like that. And, you know, the price will catch up at some point, you know, like the market can only remain irrational for so long kind of thing. So that's kind of the way I look at it. Nick, same question to you. Like, what's up with the MKR price? The maker now has been building so hard for so long and just do you see like a discrepancy between what the story of the price is being is telling versus what's actually happening with the fundamentals? Yeah, but I, but I think it's quite obvious how we kind of ended up here.
There was never a focus on trying to showcase MKR trying to advertise MKR to get MKR listed on exchanges to build liquidity to incentivize liquidity. It was never just a focus. The focus was always die and I think the rationale was quite reasonable, right? Make die have utility make die useful scale die as much as you can. And if die successful by proxy MKR becomes successful, right? All of the profits that are generated by the system right are diverted to MKR token holders. And so it's really one of those things that in the end, it'll work itself out. Yeah, I think that you make a really, really good point part of the legacy of the maker foundation for what I've gathered from being an outside observer is that the legal side of the maker foundation really hamstrung the market ability of the MKR token, right?
Like we can talk about die, we can talk about the contracts, getting a vault, all that stuff. But in a industry which clamors for attention, the legal side of in the compliance side of the foundation is like you guys can't talk about MKR. Monet, would you agree that that was kind of one of the influencing cultures of the maker Dow as a result of the foundation is that there was a removal of a culture of attention to put on the on the MKR token? Yeah, I think that I imagine that a lot of that was like some legal influence, but I think it's also, you know, kind of goes back to just the discipline of the project, which, you know, if if you just are disciplined and you keep doing the right things for long enough, like it does pay off.
And I think there's, you know, lots of advanced new tokenomics that we've seen people deploy in the last couple of years. A lot of that is like kind of very flywheel based where you can accelerate your growth, but then, you know, on the reverse it also kind of accelerates your decline. And I think maker has just been very sort of conservative about those sort of changes like we don't want to like over leverage ourselves and put die holders in a position where their their funds are at risk. So yeah, I think it's it's like not surprising that you don't see the maker token rallying as much in a bull market, but hopefully it won't be crashing in a in a bear market as much.
And I do remember the MKR token was one of the leading tokens in the 2018 to 2020 bear market. I was kind of where a lot of people put their attention, including, including myself. All right, guys, so there are so many subjects to get into. We're going to talk about the supply of die where supply comes from the demand for die, how demand, how demand is induced into die. We're going to talk about makers penetration into real world assets. We're also going to talk about makers L222 strategy and then also finish off with maker tokenomics. Each one of these subjects has just some insane development and progress to talk to talk about.
So, but before we get into all of those things, I want to talk about just like the meta goals of the maker DAW protocol. What are the goals of maker? What does the protocol want? Does the protocol want? What does the protocol want? Die number, die supply to go up, loan fees to go up. Like what are the really bullish metrics for maker DAW that you guys are trying to optimize for? And Mune, I'll throw it back to you on that one. I think total die supply and then also like usage and integrations across different platforms, you know, being able to use it in real commerce. As well as just, you know, defy.
And then I think kind of more directly to the bottom line, like what's our actual, like amount of die that's being generated through. Through vaults rather than through stable coins, because that's where we are actually able to earn revenue. So yeah, I think those are probably the two biggest fundamental drivers. Sam, Nick, anything to add on about the optimizing metrics for maker DAW, which metrics are the most important? Yeah, I would say like in the short term, what Mune said, we need to get sort of the interest bearing supply up to replace the stable coin supply. I would say a medium term goal is to at least for me is to reactivate the die savings rate start getting a die demand growing in a more organic way.
And long term, yeah, sort of like several orders of magnitude scaling of the die supply such that we're in sort of the fiat currency scale as like a credibly neutral alternative. Nick, anything to add? No, I think that the covers are very well. All right, so let's start with the supply side of things. What is the actual strategy for increasing the die supply? Sam, you just talked about interest bearing collateral. So I think we can also talk about USDC and like the dominance inside of USDC inside of maker DAW. Do you guys consider the dominance of USDC in maker a problem? And if so, how what's the plan to fix that and overall what is the overarching like strategy for increasing the total die supply on the secondary market?
Sam, I'll start with you. Okay, so I've put out along with some of my colleagues recent strategy to address the problem of lack of sort of organic die supply generation. I put this out as a tweet and a post called the aggressive growth strategy. So really this involves two parts. The first is we want to do a cap race. It's sort of debt or equity offering or some mix between the two. The idea behind this is the surplus buffer. If you can see in the image. This is sort of our making sure we're solvent kind of number. So currently it's at 65 million. And this is just growth from revenues in the protocol, but we kind of want to move that up another five X or so to like 250 million or even above.
And what this gives us is the ability to basically take basically move up the risk curve and take the faults on individual loans without breaking the protocol. And so as you can see here, we don't really do high risk loans all that much. Because we're kind of limited in how big they can go, but we increase the surplus buffer. We can increase the size of all these sort of more high risk loans address a larger market and sort of grow the revenues in a good way. Let's camp on the surplus buffer. Can you just let's define that a little bit more. What is the surplus buffer in maker? How does it grow?
Where does it come from? And why is having a large one good? Right. Okay. So the surplus buffer is basically. Well, okay, it's a buffer of direct. So let me start with I guess stability piece. So if you open up a vault on ETH or something like that and you take out a die loan, you're paying interest on that. So currently it's I think 2.25%. So where does that go that goes into what's called the surplus buffer. So this is basically an excessive die that the protocol controls. And it can be used for a couple of things. So we use it to pay for things like core units and whatnot, but it's also there just in case we take a loss on one of the loans say one of the loans defaults and we have bad debt.
This will eat into the surplus buffer, but it will as long as the surplus buffer is larger than this bad debt, the protocol is still solvent. We're all good. We can continue operation. So by growing the surplus buffer to a larger number, we can sort of increase our tolerance for individual defaults. The idea is that we spread this risk across many, many different protocols and sort of lenders and stuff like that, such that we have sort of independent risk on every single one of them, such that we can tolerate losses and sort of plan for them. This is more how traditional lenders work. They don't usually plan on no losses.
They account for them. So the growth of the surplus buffer comes from the revenue on the interest rates on the collateral inside the vaults. And you say that we want to like 5x this to the supply of the surplus buffer to give maker a larger buffer so that it can start to lean into more risky loans than what it currently has because if it can service more risky loans, it can also service higher interest rates on those loans. And so the idea is that a larger surplus buffer allows the protocol to get higher yield on a larger array of loans without having to really increase the risk because of the supply of the increase supply of the surplus surplus buffer is all that correct.
Yes, exactly. So by doing a cap raise, we can basically say, hey, we've got 10 billion in dye demand. People love dye. We've got a very good value prop. It's probably going to be very likely to be able to raise capital in anticipation of the future. So, you know, how we do that is some sort of combination of debt and equity offering. So, yeah, basically what this gives us is the ability to experiment more integrate with more protocols under collateralized lending reputation based lending loans to trade fire where we don't necessarily have all the legal recourse in place yet. These are the types of things we can do with the largest surplus buffer.
And so that we have low risk loans up top and those are really big bars and I think that just indicates the total supply of collateral inside the maker Dow system, but those low risk loans have low interest fees. And then below that we have the high risk loans, which doesn't have a lot of collateral because of how they're high risk, but there's a lot of interest rate. There's a lot of money to be made on those high risk loans. And so, in theory, if the surplus buffer increased like 5x, viewers who are watching the YouTube would, you know, you could imagine that dashed dashed line moving very, very far to the right, allowing for more collateral to exist in the high risk loans, which would just yield a lot more dye on a yearly, yearly base.
Is that all right? Yeah, exactly. Manay, Nick, anything you want to add or any additional element to discuss here? No, but I did want to circle back. Because part of your original question was trying to address USDC and what were we going to do about this problem? And I just want to push back on that a little bit because I don't necessarily see the maker protocol having a lot of USDC is a problem. I think of it as a capital battery. So when we say, like, right, anyone can mince dye one to one against USDC, right, what we're essentially saying is that if dye is trading above a dollar, right, meaning that there is a bunch of demand for dye relative to the supply.
There's more demand than anyone can go and give USDC to the maker protocol get dye and sell the dye in the open market and essentially arbitrage that that pagan balance and bring it back down exactly towards a dollar. So I think that's very useful property because one, even though dye has a kind of market based kind of algorithmic peg because it's not hard redeemable for dollars. We essentially get an artificial hard peg to the dollar and that's incredibly useful when you're dealing with kind of more traditional kind of trade five counter parties. So, okay, so we've accumulated a bunch of USDC people kind of refer to this blacklist like risk and I don't really see the difference between having like 200 million of USDC versus having five billion of USDC the blacklist risk right doesn't really change right it stays the same.
But what you're getting out of this is one you're getting extremely deep deep liquidity for for dye against dollars and so what this really is is a capital battery to super charge real world asset lending. So I know probably later you want to get into this a little more right what are we doing with real world assets but essentially it's maker lending you know against against assets that exists in the real world instead of off chain. And essentially what they want to do is these lenders they don't necessarily want dye right they can't do anything with dye what they want is they want dollars for their business to go execute on some opportunity right.
And so having the ability to go to a trade five lender and be like we have five billion dollars of dollar liquidity allows us to do much, much larger deals, then if those trade five partners had to try to find like OTC liquidity right for 200,000 or 300 mil. Sam I see you nod in your head can you elaborate and just add to that if you have anything to say. I know I think Nick covered it pretty well. Okay so yeah this USDC supply in maker I'm seeing a question if I'm wrong but I'm seeing 227 million USD dye generated from USDC a compromise of USDC locked in a locked in maker Dow and then the stability fee on that on that that 227 million is about one percent.
So maker is is charging 1% on that 227 million dollars which you know that's a decent amount of revenue. But is that is is USD revenue from USDC collateral inside of maker just like less revenue than your typical collateral because of how just like low risk it is. And is the idea that you still want to displace the USDC collateral with other collateral that you can charge higher revenue for. So so David I think you're misunderstanding something so from USDC right we're not making any money right it is it's just a swap facility right you can go and you swap you give us a USDC we give you a die.
If if you want to say okay well okay there's 5 million USDC we're not really making any money from those. I would say that that's a completely different problem right okay that's just saying how do you monetize your balance sheet right and and Monet can probably explain this a little better than I can so I'm going to butcher it first and he'll probably correct me and and come up with a much more eloquent explanation. But but the way that I would describe it is. Make your dad was sitting on 5 billion dollars and can decide on how they we want to allocate those 5 billion dollars into some productive asset that produces yield right.
So probably we want to look at something very low risk something like triple a rated so something like US treasuries right where the yield will be very very low. But it's an extremely extremely safe yield and it's also extremely liquid so being able to go from treasuries to dollars right you're not going to really have any slippage no matter what scale you're trading at right even if you want to do like half a billion dollars of treasuries. So it's it's it's more of an opportunity of how do you want to allocate rather than a oh this sucks we don't make any money off USDC. And now you want to add anything to that.
Yeah, I think like all else equal USDC is I think it's a lot less risky than many people assume. But there is still you know some small amount of risk holding it so. Yeah, I think it's it's a positive if we can allocate that intelligently to real world assets maybe stuff like treasuries or other you know kind of safe reliable investments and then maybe also some little bit higher risk investments once we get enough surplus to really support that. So yeah, I'd agree that it's it's an opportunity you know it's just we're methodical so we're not just going to eat you know a billion dollars if USDC anywhere we want to make sure that it's it's truly like a safer better bet.
Okay, guys, I think that covers everything on the supply side like the very basics are you put collateral inside of MakerDow you charge a fee on it number goes up. We also have this USDC is what Nick is calling like a battery unless there's anything else to cover on the supply side I want to turn into the demand side the other side of things like demand for die. And so like putting on our like 101 explain it like I'm five hats how does die demand how is that good for the protocol how is that good for MakerDow and then where does die demand come from and how does the Dow plan on increasing die demand.
Anyone want to raise your hand and take this one. Yeah, I think the way that I look at it is it's it's kind of similar to banking but when people are willing to hold die they're basically lending MakerDow money that we're then able to lend out to the other people who are. So that's that's kind of a key part of our system is when we have a lot of excess die demand we can always be sure that there's you know we have the capital to lend out to people borrowing kind of like banks you know they. They use the money from people who are depositing with them to make the loans that they're that they're then an interest on.
So yeah it's a really key part of of MakerDow it's probably our biggest asset is that we have so many deep integrations with people like curve and compound and Ave. A lot of people are really interested in and willing to hold die even though we're not actually currently really paying them anything to hold it through something like the die savings rate. You mentioned integrations with other defy protocols and I think that actually opens up a subject that I think a lot of people kind of forget about there's something different about borrowing USDC or borrowing die from something like Ave or compound then there is borrowing die directly from MakerDow makerDow can mint die whereas compound and Ave cannot and this is an huge advantage which is in the optionality to be able to mint die to control the supply of die.
And there are you alluded to some integrations with with Ave and I want to turn this to Sam next is how Sam can you kind of just illustrate how those integrations with other defy protocols work and how the ability for Maker to actually mint die is a useful thing for other defy protocols. Yeah so for Ave in particular if you remember last year around April May their interest rates on all their stablecoins were like skyrocketing they went up to like even as high as 20% and if you're taking leverage on Ave and you just get hit with that intermittently it's brutal. So one of the mechanisms to alleviate this for die was that we recognized Ave was a very reputable rock solid protocol so we basically just extend them minting rights such that they can sort of squash these excessive times of borrowing.
So we built and introduced the what's called the die direct deposit module or we shorten it to D3M in conjunction with Ave and basically this module enforces a max variable borrow and it does this by basically. Like as soon as if somebody borrows a bunch on Ave and the interest rates spikes it will just shove die into that pool put the interest rate back down so nobody gets like screwed over by this and how does maker pocket money in that scenario how is that how is that generate revenue for maker down. So it's essentially just as if maker is any other lender so we collect interest rate on the lending and like so if if Ave interest rates like jumps up to 20% and then they tap into maker's credit facility how much interest rate would make or make that scenario.
So we would enforce a max rate so we would basically I think what is it now it's probably like 2.5% or something we're enforcing around there so that would be the max borrow we would enforce and then we would there would be some spread and then we would earn some portion of that interest you know 1.5% I don't know exactly what it is but it's yeah it's about that. There's an old model that old as in we haven't talked about a lot on bank list but we talked about we talked about the protocol sync thesis where like deep incredibly neutral protocols are find find themselves at the bottom of the defi stack and other applications are built on top of it.
And so I want to get into the other integrations as well but using that as a frame of mind for the listeners like Ave in this particular arena is built on top of maker down because maker down can supply Ave with the credits and with that it needs in times of like a supply squeeze. And ultimately that value flows back to maker down because of maker down's ability to meant to die it's the extreme privilege maker down has its own money printer the own ability to print money and other protocols need to access that ability in times of supply squeezes Sam and Sam or may or whoever wants to take this one excellent can we just talk about all the other defi applications that are also integrated into maker down that are leveraging this property of maker.
Yeah so this is sort of the general version is exactly what you said so the recognition that maker is not going to be the best at everything there's other protocols that specialize and are very very good at what they do so instead of maker trying to do this all ourselves let's use defi Legos let's connect all these various protocols and extend them credit lines such that we can kind of exponentially grow together. So what we're focused on right now so we have the Ave one up and it's been a great success so far we are now integrating with compound to give them something similar as well as sort of newer protocols maple finance who does reputation based loans.
There's true five does similar things yeah so these are all sort of protocols we're looking at rari fuse pools that's sort of a new thing that's pretty interesting that we're looking at so we're wanting to go wide with this and sort of just you know switch from you know lending out against like individual collateral assets and instead just sort of empowering others to get die everywhere basically. Yeah and I really want to hammer that point home it's really maker can provide die liquidity as a service right and so what really this does is it just you know this goes with the kind of protocols like sync thesis that you were talking about David is it really puts maker on a base layer below any of the other secondary lenders right.
We're a primary lender only we can generate die like on demand secondary lenders need to source liquidity right from somewhere from users or from maker and so it's really quite synergistic right for maker to be able to have. These distribution channels for die right it's it's a specialization of saying what is maker good at well maker is good at having this really stable decentralized stable coin called die and we're really good at providing you know hundreds of millions of dollars of concentrated liquidity wherever it's needed. And it's acknowledging that there is secondary lenders who are better at us in in other things right and they specialize for example in distribution right if you look at something like Ave right you know how many chains says has Ave already deployed on right it's it's practically everywhere right and so you can.
Have this really synergistic relationship right where Ave can go and you know deploy on all these chains and we can provide targeted die liquidity there and we basically get a free distribution mechanism for die. I think a great model for understanding this it feels like a central bank with commercial banks where like compound and Ave are the commercial banks that tap into the central banks liquidity and the cool thing about maker and again the cool ability that being able to mint the money being able to mint die. It allows for maker to really be like a bulk order credit facility like I think it's actually kind of skew morphing maybe not skew morphing but just like you know it's just a sign that is early that individuals are going straight to maker doubt to open up vaults when really it's far more appropriate for things like Ave or compound or just like other larger organizations to come to maker to open up vaults and then give those like like you said Nick distribution maker can use all these other applications as distribution.
So I think it's really important to the individual how do we like that that frame of reference is calling like maker doubt a central bank of defy like appropriate or how would you guys change or amend that. I would be central bank the decentralized bank yeah many many tapas in here I would add that I think maybe our our vision is bigger than just the central bank of defy like we already have some of like the sort of titans of see five. We already do you know a lot of business with us among you know other defy protocols as well but you know that's already kind of like an interesting like cd fi scaling solution that they're running where they're lending money to their customers on their their own close platform but then they're sourcing all of the liquidity not all of it but some of it from maker.
And this this illustration of maker as the decentralized bank of the crypto universe gets even more exciting in my mind when we get to the topic of real world assets which I think we definitely will will get there here in a second guys is there anything else that we should talk about when it comes to. It comes to die demand where die demand comes from and like the long term roadmap for inducing died die into the world. Yeah one one thing I'll add is the die savings rate you know it's kind of gone away for a bit but I think this is a very very critical tool that when we reactivate it the value prop for die is going to be huge compared to holding like a US dollar derivatives of other kinds.
Why will it be so huge. It's a risk free interest rate right it's just going to like why would I hold say USDC when I could be just earning a risk free rate on die right. And this again kind of goes and lends itself to like what is a new treasury this is the new like native dollar denominated interest rate where I've always thought that there's going to be two major interest rates in the world of crypto economics there's going to be the east staking yield rate which is going to be the risk free rate of a non store value asset non sovereign store value asset but then there's also the die savings rate which is the yield that you can get on dollars in in defy.
Is anyone want to riff on that for a second. Okay one last question I have for you guys is like let's zoom forward and and like kind of and this will tss up for some real world asset conversations and layer two conversations but like let's zoom forward like 10 15 20 years. What do you think is like in a in a world where makers maximally successful and it's achieved all its gold what do you think the collateral inside of maker down looks like like what what would the maker overall portfolio look like in an ideal world where everything about maker down was achieved is that something that is known or is that something that we kind of just need to iterate on nickel start with you.
It's staked east Bitcoin and real world assets just those just those three things just everything else will look infinitesimally small relatively at my opinion. Well you want to can you elaborate on that why why will those three things be the dominant things. Well it is the it is kind of like to me just the the future proof kind of network of networks right it's the internet was is a great network but it has some shortcomings right it doesn't really have integrated identity and it doesn't really have integrated payments. If it literally just becomes a network that has integrated identity and payments right it's already.
It's it's already like such an order of magnitude improvement right and then you start adding in okay well. Well, ETH is this global network that right anyone can can connect to right you have for the first time this concept of like a globalized liquidity pool rather than like this fragmented kind of regional nationalized kind of liquidity. And to me it's just it's just clear it's obvious there's there's no other alternative for for the real world asset side it's really just acknowledging that maker right has the superpower of right and our superpower is that we can just. Just meant die right and that there is incredible amount like deep deep liquidity of died of dollars and as long as we have that superpower right we have we have no cost of capital right so unlike a traditional lender right which would need to somehow kind of source capital right to to give out loans or to to finance something right makers and have that right we don't have that overhead and so we're going to be able to.
And so we're going to be able to under charge on on these rates and that you know on on the macro scale is just going to allow us to be incredibly incredibly successful when it comes to financing real world assets. I really like that line you're going to be able to undercut the rates because you can mint die you can always outcompete other lenders because getting receiving capital for maker comes for free it's just like one single transaction that means a bunch of die and maker doesn't actually owe anything to anyone because it has the power to mint die so like the Jeff Bezos Jeff Bezos is line your margin is my opportunity definitely comes to mind where if some commercial bank offers 4% well maker can always offer three.
Many may say I'm any of the last comments before we go into the second half of the show. I'm good. Well all right guys okay so there's some really hot topics coming up next warm holding between all the layer 2s and the other layer ones is definitely something that we're going to talk about and we definitely touch on real world assets but we're going to dives headfirst into the topic of real world assets because I think that is something that no other credit facility no other defi app is really tapping into in the same way that that maker is and it's really the untapped field of opportunity that really only maker seems to be capturing and then of course we're going to get into the mkr token the current tokenomics for mkr and perhaps how that might stay the same or might migrate into something else moving forward.
So those are the three big subjects where all the alpha is we're going to get into those subjects right after we talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. If you're trying to grow and preserve your crypto wealth optimizing your taxes is just as lucrative is trying to find the next hidden gem. Also IRA can help you invest in crypto and tax advantage ways to help you preserve your hard earned money. Also crypto IRA lets you invest in more than 150 coins and tokens with all the same tax advantages of an IRA. They make it easy to fund your alternative IRA or crypto IRA via your 401k or by contributing directly from your bank account.
There is no setup or account fees and it's all you need to do to invest in crypto tax-free. Let me repeat that again you can invest in crypto tax-free diversify like the pros and trade without tax headaches open in alto crypto IRA to invest in crypto tax-free. Let's go to alto IRA dot com slash bankless that's a L T O IRA dot com slash bankless and start investing in crypto today. The Brave Browser is the user first browser for the web 3 internet with over 50 million monthly active users. Control your digital footprint with built-in privacy and ad blocking. Inside the Brave Browser you'll find the Brave Wallet the first secure crypto wallet built natively inside of a Web 3 crypto browser.
Web 3 is freedom from big tech and wall street more control and better privacy but there's a weak point in Web 3 your crypto wallet. Brave Wallet is built natively inside the Brave Browser no extension required which gives the Brave Wallet an extra level of security versus other wallets. With the Brave Wallet you can buy, store, send and swap your crypto assets and it can even manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps all from the security of the best privacy browser on the market. Whether you're new to crypto or in season pro it's time to switch to the Brave Wallet. Download Brave at Brave dot com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started.
Ava is the leading decentralized liquidity protocol and now Ava V3 is here. Ava V3 has powerful new features to enable you to get the most out of DeFi including isolation mode which allows for many more markets to be launched with more exotic collateral types and also efficiency mode which allows for a higher loan to value ratios. Allowing users to port their Ava position across all of the networks that Ava operates on like polygon, phantom, avalanche, arbitrum, optimism and harmony. The beautiful thing about Ava is that it's completely open source decentralized and governed by its community, enabling a truly bankless future for us all.
To get your first crypto collateralized loan get started at Ava dot com that's a-a-b-e dot com and also check out the Ava protocol governance forums to see what more than a hundred thousand down members are all robbing about at governance dot Ava dot com. All right guys we are back on our maker doubt bull panel again three doubt community members all talking about their perspectives of maker doubt and really why the fundamentals are so bullish and there's a really bullish announcement that happened not too long ago. I think it came out yesterday and Nick I want you to take the lead on this one maker doubt is giving a good line of credit to Tesla facilities maker Nick can you kind of unpack what's going on here and how what are the details of this.
Yeah so like you said we we just announced this this deal yesterday really huge news and it's basically facilitated by one of our real world asset partners six s capital led by a guy called Matthew Rabinawitz and he's been a maker community member for a long time and so this this is like one of those like really cool. I kind of success stories where he saw the division of of maker and defies so early and then one day kind of a light bulb went off and was like wait like I can actually use this. And so what what. The success capital is kind of doing here is they're kind of acting as this go between liaison so maker can effectively interface that the maker protocol can interface with you know borrowers like like Tesla.
So in particular what's happening here is that Tesla wants to build a network of collision repair centers. I believe right now in the US, but I think eventually it's supposed to be a global thing. But they don't have the capital right to build all of these things themselves. And if you think about like them doing a capital raise right them trying to take out debt well debt on your balance sheet isn't isn't the best thing right from when when you start like analyzing the health company right and it would really slow down their ability to execute on this right it shows up as a capital expenditure.
So what they're doing is they're using credit tenant leases in order to raise the cash to build these so what a credit tenant lease is it's essentially saying that. If someone were to finance the construction of this then Tesla will promise to pay a certain amount of rent right every year. For X number of years and maybe the amount increases by Y per cent every year right it's kind of each one's a little bit unique in that respect. And now right this isn't debt on Tesla's balance sheet right so capital expenditure and now it's an operational expenditure right and so op X and CapEx are treated very very differently.
That's why credit tenant lease is like a very attractive option for Tesla to scale and build out this network of collision repair centers like extremely quickly. So essentially right what we can do is we say okay well we know that Tesla is going to be right paying a certain amount right and that's generating yield so essentially you can kind of almost like treat this as a as a bond right there's it's a fixed income type of product right and that has a speculative value to investors. So maker is willing to right supply the a dielone right against that kind of fixed income stream. So we're start I think we just announced the first deal and I think the amount is like 7.
8 million dollars but this is just the first one we have more deals or well success capital has more deals in the pipeline with Tesla that they plan to close in the next quarter in the next two quarters by the end of the year. So really this is an opportunity that we once it gets going into flywheel and we're just going to snowball this up right and you know the amount that maker can lend right we said it's near limitless right he can just mint as much die. As we want and so really it just comes down to the risk perspective of how much risk exposure does maker want to have right to these Tesla collision repair facilities.
And that's that's a really good problem to have right where you're saying right oh there's too much growth and we from a risk point of view we have to throttle the growth but the opportunity here is is absolutely huge and we're super stoked that that this finally went live. And I want to get your perspectives in on this so what how does this how should we be thinking about this in the frame of defy I think a lot of like you know cipher punks would have be puzzled about this is like wait a second how are we getting real world assets into the world of defy how does even work can you just like give us your thoughts on this like how how does this illustrate the story of maker down and what it's optimizing for and just like how bullish is this.
Yeah, I think I think make it out you know by and large is taking the approach of like engagement and hopefully we can influence the entire economy that we're you know that we're living in in a real world to operate better rather than trying to like strictly bifurcate ourselves or like separate ourselves from real world assets or other stable coins or anything that. You know the government might be able to touch through a couple layers of of interference so yeah I think we're we're taking the path of engagement. I think maker does have like a really unique opportunity though compared to if you look at like a lender like compound or a they always need to maintain you know enough liquidity so that people can withdraw their money if they want to when maker is you know much less much less constrained.
About that so you know some of these these you know real world asset deals like lending to finance building something they're going to need that money for a year more and we have like a really unique opportunity that we're able to fund stuff for a longer commitment and other other protocols you know they they kind of have to adjust how they work to really do that effectively. I think a lot of people are probably wondering how like legally or technically this actually happens like how do we how does Tesla pay money to make her down like what are there are legal structures in place. I'm I'm pretty sure as well and like just overall how do real world assets become collateral inside of a defi app how does how technically does this even work.
I'm not sure who's most equipped to answer that so I'll let you guys kind of figure that out. It is enormously complicated and we could probably spend the whole hour talking about well this thing talks to that thing is subservient to this and there's an outside auditor here. Suffice to say that this is a structure that was purpose built around real world assets and it was purpose built for the Dow to effectively have as much control over where the money goes where the money can't go and how it can be handled right. This isn't just kind of you know pop up out of thin air this is the culmination of you know over a years worth of like blood sweat and tears and an enormous investment of of you know resources of capital right to to create this structure.
And I would say it's probably the most advanced real world structure like asset structure out there today and of course it's going to be iterated on right we're going to want to you know diversify to different jurisdictions as well right you don't want to just have concentrated you know risk just in a single jurisdiction. But this is a huge first step right because it shows that DeFi is not just right a tool for speculators and you know traders or whatever right to to get margin and to get leverage right it's really a tool that can be used in the real world you know the fund real tangible things and so you know even though the amounts are so small.
The symbolism of what it means and of what DeFi can can grow into become I think is extremely significant. If you said it was extremely complicated I just want to reiterate that it's complicated on the meat space side this isn't like a technical smart contract complication this is a network of legal structures that you've alluded to are complicated but if I could just press you on this what are just really the main components that really make this thing work like what what are the key unlocks that allow for real world assets to come into a smart contract and in DeFi like where are the where do the actual assurances law.
So I would say of note is that there is a fiduciary right who is not was you know kind of like think of them as like an independent kind of party and they are you know legally required right to kind of do what is in the interest right of their of how you structured this agreement. Right, and so it doesn't matter what some meat space partner wants right it is the fiduciary. So it doesn't matter what some meat space partner wants right it is the fiduciary has to execute like the the the kind of legal will of of like this constitutional document and so every step of this has basically been designed to protect maker right and so how the money can move and how money can be replaced right there.
There, there is literally a mechanism for the Dow right to do a governance vote to send a message to someone who then and that message is required right to execute on an action right there legally not allowed to do anything without you know this this signal by governance so it's literally been designed end to end just to have. The makers interest basically aligned at every step and protected. Yeah, so there's smart contract innovation in defy but this really seems like legal legal contract innovation in the real world and when we get into the subject of bridging real world assets into defy we must ultimately talk about normal paper pen and paper contracts not just smart contracts.
But now I saw you raise your hand do you want to add anything on to how this kind of legal structure works. No, but I was well, I guess just short thing is that I think it you know maybe for defy native people it helps to like think of this kind of like a bridge where like you need some sort of. Like almost like an oracle to kind of take the messages from from the blockchain like how maker Dow is voting and then execute that in another domain in the real world. But there are there are companies that you know in a more like proud by context have been doing this for years like trust companies basically they're just supposed to like take info from one contract or like another domain and then execute it.
So I think that we're just figuring out how to like use all of these pre existing mechanisms to to our best effect. Nick you said that this is a really complicated how easy is this to scale out like if it's complicated is it easily reproducible you used to talk about like you know perhaps we can iterate on this model and make it more efficient. How is this going to go I think you said something like $7 million deal with the first Tesla facility but then that can roll from there is this model that this legal structure that's been created can this just kind of be like replicated over and over and over again for many many different types of real world assets.
How easy is it to reproduce this in order to scale the size of real world assets inside of maker Dow. It's solely replicable right the difficult part is constructing it right and is ensuring right that that it works right that all the parties right are are doing their roles and are comfortable with with the actions that there's supposed to take right but once you have this up and running right. You can definitely just clone this to different parties. I want to go back and take a frame of reference as like the D central bank of the Internet but now put this into a context of there are our bridges as many said there's bridges between real world assets and like this D central credit facility that that's based on the Internet.
And if you talked about like one of the long term goals of collateral inside of maker is Bitcoin, Ether and real world assets like is the position for maker Dow to be it's a kind of like. Rug pull the actual central bank and allow people to rather than having to go to their commercial banks or or even the commercial banks having to go to the central bank is is like maker Dow positioning itself to be the new credit facility of the digital age. I wouldn't describe it as a rug pull right it's just it's just more competition and consumers will win right because ultimately it'll lead to lower rates for for everyone right so that's how that's how capitalism works right and.
You know lower rates right we can we can fund more things we can do more good in the world right and the world can can advance and innovate quicker. Okay you said innovate and compete with the central bank of the United States of America and like the thing about the central bank is that it has a complete monopoly because it is the only bank in America and in the West that can print money except for maker Dow maker Dow the only other like institution that I can think of that can print. New money is maker down I mean there's other decentralized stable coins like us T and we can talk about that but like this is at the new level of competition that the central bank of the United States has never ever had before because no one else has the legal right to print money but now in the world of defy we we have this ability to do that.
And so this is kind of one of one of the bull cases for maker Dow is they are the first credit facility to offer competition to a whole entire central bank that controls the world reserve currency any any comments or thoughts on that. I think it's I think it's very collaborative to as well as competitive though. I look at maker sort of like a little bit like commercial banking where we can we can mint as much as we like but we do actually need somebody who is willing to own that die to kind of balance the supply that we're making versus you know the demand that there exists in the market. So we're operating a lot like commercial bank you know we create money but it's all still kind of underlaid by the actual you know US dollar that that's getting made by the Fed.
I think the collaborative part is that we're totally expanding the breadth of people that actually have the ability to own US dollars so people in you know Venezuela or other Latin American countries or just anywhere around the world where dollars and reliable you know financial services are not available. Now they can they can own die they can use die and you know that ultimately does kind of anchor back to the US dollar system at least while we're we're pegged to the dollar so I think it's you know I think it's kind of giving competition to like commercial and central banks but also kind of a tailwind for for the US economy I would say.
So I think one last angle on this real world asset conversation before we get into layer two to two stuff I think some people would say like oh like if you're going to integrate real world assets you're just going to become regulated right you're the real world instantiations means that the regulators are just going to it's going to be super easy for the regulators to come knocking and so you know the bear case is that will make her doubt will just become you know regulated defy entity and that's not really crypto that's not really you know defy that's not really crypto. The other the bull case the bull argument I think is that well if you integrate so much of real world assets into maker now you kind of become too big to eliminate from a regulatory standpoint and you actually are playing very very nicely with the real world abiding by like real world legal structures and playing inside the real world game.
So I'm wondering your guys thoughts on on this like this bear versus bull debate about what it means to actually integrate the real world into the maker system is it does it provide like a regulatory shield or is it regulatory weakness as in like it's actually a risk for maker down from the regulatory standpoint wants to take this one. Sam. Yeah so in terms of regulation I would say sort of in what jurisdiction that's it that's important so like if we were just in one jurisdiction I mean this could be a problem but like I'm a big fan of we need to play nice with regulators but if we go wide in terms of like geographic political diversity.
They'll be incentivized to play ball with us right and we're like I'm not a big fan of sort of like you know crypto anarchy and stuff like that and fighting against regulation I think we should embrace it and we should work with regulators to make sure the whole world can benefit from defy and not just keep it as sort of a niche product. Yeah so do you think something like the products that maker now is building with for real world assets will make people like Elizabeth Warren warmer to defy is that perhaps an angle we can take. I don't know about Warren but I think I think it can win hearts and minds generally maybe for people who have like less personal stake in in sort of combating crypto but yeah I think it's not going to be.
It's you know when we can show hey like we finance X many hundred jobs in your district for like all the different people who are working in government it's got to have an impact. Guys I think it's time to get into the layer 222 side of things and Sam I'm going to throw this one to you generally speaking what is maker's layer to strategy and is this time to talk about worm holding. Yeah sure so I'll pull up a diagram here so yeah maker is incredibly focused right now on sort of the multi chain future we see it is all but inevitable at this point so like initially we're we've deployed canonical diverges on optimism arbitrum and stark net.
But the plan is to basically go to wherever the users are and this includes side chains if people want to use it you know maker should be available there it's it's up to the users. So like this this kind of plays in with this if you see in the diagram sort of like this D3M module type strategy where we can basically just have the core of mcd extend credit out to these. What we call domains but you can think of them as chains to arbitrum optimism stark net polygon avalanche whatever it happens to be and then empower these other protocols that people are using and they love to basically meant die of course we have to take risk into account so we extend only certain levels of credit now.
Now with wormhole this is the other new product we've been working on for the past year which we're actually just rolling out the first phase of this just in the coming weeks so once wormhole is fully deployed across all these chains what it allows for is essentially a super high way of liquidity between all these chains. Because again it goes back to our superpower we have the right to mint we can we have zero cost of capital so that if somebody wants to jump from arbitramed optimism all they have to do is signal to us the intent. And then our Oracle network will basically say sign messages saying this is okay and we can mint the die immediately on the other chain we do not require liquidity providers and so we think this is our big advantage essentially other than some sort of technical details we can offer this for free.
People can go from chain to chain with and is once the security models are solidified for these altos in particular the debt ceilings can be raised to pretty much infinity as these chains basically inherit a theory of security at that point. So let me make sure I get this right for every single like EVM compatible chain or anything that can hook into a theorem there is the ability for maker doubt to like replicate its credit facility on every single chain so dig minting can happen natively on every single chain and it's the same die across the chain. And so you don't actually do how do the actual canonical bridges of layer two's like between the theorem layer one and optimism or a theorem layer one and arbitrum are how are these relevant or are we just like skipping right over the bridges.
Yeah this is an important point so in order to make die fungible and give minting rights on it on these other chains we need to deploy what's called canonical die this is slightly different than your sort of out of the box what we call wrapped tokens which are basically just generic ERC 20 bridge where people can deposit locked their funds in the L1 and then mint new tokens that look and feel like the original one we do a similar thing but we also get this. We also can cremate some extra die on the L1 escrow and then give minting rights to multi collateral die which is deployed on the L2 so it's a little bit different in that regard.
Okay okay well and so what would happen if what the canonical bridges broke for example what is that a risk for you know that's a risk for most people because that's how they get to and from the the layer one to layer two does that change the risk parameters for maker doubt. Yes so people just bridge normally it's it's you know it's permissionless it's up to them if the chain they're going to is compromised user funds will be lost and you know we have no control over that nobody does it's like just a permissionless nature of. The ecosystem now for die that we prevent into the bridge that could potentially be stolen and that would be in the sort of worst case scenario where the chain is compromised now how we limit that is we use debt ceilings on all of these as chain sort of solidify their security.
We can continually raise these but if we're concerned about these types of hacks we can limit our exposure via debt ceilings and on the wormhole in particular we can say you know from this chain let's say I don't know I've got some side chain that's you know not very well known and I'm wanting to go to arbitrum we would set the. Arbitrum die that we're minting from that source chain that we're not you sure about to some low number so people can do it but if it's compromised will shield ourselves in that way and the bottom line is that maker holders are responsible for this loss we make sure we do not put this loss on the die holders.
So the maker holders are making a decision on which but that that ceilings are they should be responsible for the loss if they make a mistake. Can I put like ether into the Ethereum L1 maker instance and then mint die on like any of the other maker replicas like if I have a thousand dollars of ether collateral in the main maker down can I mint 500 die on like arbitrum. Yeah this across sort of lending thing I've been hearing more about that and we have no plans at this moment but it's something we're sort of initially investigating it could very well be in the near future. Neat neat mene or Nick anything you guys want to add to this later to conversation.
No spam is the Sam is the layer to man is these are God. I think maybe only one thing I'd add is just it's like exciting to think that we can kind of balance liquidity needs and rates across all of these different domains not only with wormhole but we can use stuff like the D3M's to target specific interest rates on different platforms. So yeah I think you know we're just going to bring a ton of utility to all of these altos amazing alright guys this is I want to bring us unless there's anything else to talk about in the layer to section I think what we want to get into the final topic. Just the mkr token and mkr tokenomics first question I want to ask is how much revenue is maker Dow as a as a platform making right now and then how does that relate to the value of the mkr token in its current form.
So I think we're earning currently around like 60 million dollars in profit and then we on a yearly basis on a yearly basis. We have overheads we have numerous core unit teams that were we're paying for so the actual amount of stability fees that we're earning is is significantly above that I want to say it's over 100 million or I'm not actually certain right now but it's it's a pretty significant amount. So yeah we're we're very strong from like a revenue and earning standpoint and then how does all of this revenue translate into the mk the value of the mkr token on the secondary markets. If we have met our goal for how much we want to have saved in that surplus buffer anything above that we we use to buy back mkr tokens and and burn it and you know as a regular mkr holder what that means is that your percent ownership of the protocol goes up a little bit whenever maker is burning tokens so it's almost like you're passively being you know distributed that income.
I think at the moment we're actually not burning because we want to build up those reserves even more so that we can you know take on more risks and then hopefully over time just kind of accelerate our earnings potential even more. It's going to be the tokenomics model for maker going forward I've heard some clamoring some there's been debate about the how the burn the buy back and burn model maybe doesn't actually capture value all that well I'm wondering if you guys have any thoughts on on the the future of the mkr tokenomics model. So so there's been several new tokenomics kind of proposals actually there was there was one I think even just like a couple of weeks ago from from a recent Horowitz from from a 16z where they came up with a model and I believe even runa right runa is the the co founder of maker even leaked kind of some some of his own ideas.
I think yesterday or two days ago and in the discord around some some potential tokenomics changes so I would very much say there's a lot of different ideas on implementations but I wouldn't say there's a solid consensus yet on which direction that the community wants to go yet. Is there a consensus that change is wanted even though we don't know what the change should be is there consensus that we should move into something else. I think so I think the burn mechanism was was was good for when it was created because it showed a clear transfer of value right from the protocol back to the token holders.
Remember that you know in 2015 2016 you know this was when you had utility tokens right you know you people were trying to make their tokens as useless as possible right you know to make sure ensure that you know this could never be misconstrued as a security. Right so the burn mechanism at the time was already fairly I think revolution in that respect but I think it's it's shown to be rather dated right and because it incentivizes the wrong things right when you're burning mkr right you're really. What what really happens right is there's an auction I guess triggered right there's a certain amount of die that's up for auction and people bid with their mkr right and whoever wins the auction right they get the die and the auction that the the mkr that the auction return from the bitter right that gets burned.
The problem here is that this is kind of incentivizes right the people who are selling their mkr and this is almost like the wrong incentive that you want to create right you don't really want to. You don't really want to incentivize people to sell right if anything you want to incentivize the holders right and so I think there's a lot more interesting crypto economic. Kind of innovations that we've had like in recent years right that that we can. That that we can implement primary one being right you want to you want to incentivize the holders right so you want to incentivize you know locking up and serving as some kind of sponge or sink right for for the tokens on the on the sell side.
One of my favorite things about the maker doubt protocols there's just so many data and so much data and numbers to be able to consume one of my favorite websites is maker burn dot com which I'm going to ask for Sam to pull up here in a second. There's just so much so much numbers to be able to look at and this definitely will kept me entertained during the the bear market of 2018 to 2020. I just want to kind of zoom out and get like a gist for the fundamentals right the current state of the fundamentals of the mkr token Sam can you kind of just walk us through what we're seeing on the screen here and allow people help viewers interpret what it means to what the fundamentals of the mkr token are.
Yeah so as you can see some of the stuff we previously talked about as you can see in the top you know there's a countdown to 10 billion die there's the surplus buffer which we talked about previously we can see the total die supply which we're just shy of 10 billion. I think we actually crossed it not too long ago but we've slightly retraced as well you can see the system surplus which is actually kind of synonymous with the surplus buffer this is the amount of sort of extra die we have to take on losses and protect the system. We also have annual profit estimate here. This is you know maker burn the guy that sees like compiled everything right like it's sort of you can see it here actually takes into account stability fees liquidations even sort of stuff that's kind of a little bit off chain sort of how much of the core units cost as well as like maker investing and the DSR so this is actually a profit estimates it's not revenues.
So that's pretty interesting you can see like PE numbers and stuff here it's pretty low and then you see the maker price down here. Let's go back and maker burn tokens burn so far on the bottom right here so we burn 2.24% of the supply there's some amount sitting in the treasury as well yeah 83,000 these are sort of like famously given from the foundation to the Dow back in I think that was August of last year as the maker foundation dissolve. So yeah this site's really great if we're break down of like what's going on in detail the guy who runs this he's doing an awesome job. And so I think this gets me into my very last set of questions the cost of the protocol there are maker Dow core groups is what I think you guys call them and it's one of the very unique things about the Dow the maker Dow in the sense that it's not you know a discord with 10 you know 50 people all doing work it's actually different organizations.
That are all focused on their one particular set of goals and then they lobby the central or the central Dow for capital right saying hey this is the work they were doing please give us capital. Can you guys just talk about that model and how it's unique and also can we illustrate some like these are the cost of the protocol right the we got to fund the salary is got to pay the bills. So how much do all of these core groups cost the protocol and maybe you guys can just talk about why this model of a of a Dow structure is advantageous at large wants to take this one. I think I do it right so so David right what is the what would what are dials optimized for right how are dials different from companies right companies optimized for efficiency and dials optimized for resiliency right so.
If you're going to do a Dow and then still just be some kind of company in on the legal end it doesn't really make any sense right you're kind of just doing Dow like decentralization theater right. If you want to be a real Dow if you want true decentralization you cannot have a top down hierarchy you cannot have right everyone in in this same legal entity like to get that resiliency you really have to have this type of hub and spoke model where it's really just these different autonomous groups right. You know it's almost like right to if if something happened to me right it wouldn't be a problem right because someone else can just come in and be like well you know we're I'm leading the Oracle core unit now or if I go you know rogue or I'm deciding you know I hate this shit or whatever right anyone else can go and just like say like you know what hey Dow.
i'm going to do oracles for you from now on right and this is the amount of budget i'm going to need more to pull it off right do you approve right. And what you eventually want to build this into is you don't even want just like you know one like smart contracts team one oracles team one risk team one real world asset team you really want just like redundant and redundant layers of different teams right in different geographical areas locations right. All kind of you know just adding layers and layers and layers of extra resiliency and and that's really where this this core unit model comes from.
It's just these these isolated operating units and while I would say that you know it's it's not all flowers and rainbows right you know there are disadvantages to working in this kind of like distributed fashion I would say coordination right becomes. Is something that centralized corporations do a lot better than kind of like distributed decentralized house right that's that that's just the trade off you make for resiliency and so I would argue that anyone who's doing a doubt that's not doing it this way right is is really not being true to you know and taking advantage to the benefits of being a doubt.
Sam or Renee guys want to add any perspectives as to the structure of maker down. Yeah I think in my view maker has like a really good balance of trying to not be too like centralized and to hierarchical like a company but then also not trying to be too flat of an work like some days I think. You know it ends up just kind of everything is like bike shedding and I think we have a good balance of you know we have clear accountability that runs up to the token holders and the delegates teams have their own kind of accountability that they are able to like figure out themselves because they're kind of self sovereign.
And yeah I think it's it's like a really good mixture of like really distributed but also not not falling into like the flat work like curse or siop or whatever you want to call it. Sam I want to let you take this home for us let's zoom all the way back out and just view this whole entire episode this whole podcast and from a bird's eye view and especially maker down from from you know a bird's eye view why bullish maker down. I mean so many things from like I guess our strategy to branching out into the real world sort of there's just so much opportunity out there like we are just scratching the surface and you know maker as usual is kind of taking the lead we expect others to come along with us.
But yeah sort of getting into this much bigger market us like sort of spearheading that and sort of providing I would say the backbone infrastructure for modern day defi which I view as sort of incredibly diverse set of chains and sort of connecting them all together provide like these basically being the liquidity powerhouse of multi chain defi. Guys this has been a fantastic panel thank you for for coming on and helping me illustrate the bull case for for maker down bankless listeners you know what to do like and subscribe that's how we get the views and if you guys like I said in the beginning in the intro if you think that there's a doubt or organization or token that has really bullish fundamentals yet the market isn't appreciating it assemble a team put a put some notes together hit us up on Twitter will make a show about this Sam and they and Nick thank you for coming on and kicking it off this new series that we're doing out of bankless and then really helping us illustrate the bull case for maker down.
Thanks so much David. Alright cheers guys bankless listeners thank you so much for for tuning into the show as always this is not financial advice crypto is risky Bitcoin is risky ether is risky defi is risky maker down is risky you can lose what you put in but this we are headed west it's not for everyone. Glad you are with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey and