Luke Gromen makes the case that “debasement” isn’t a trade, it’s the new regime.
We unpack why assets look strong in dollars yet stagnate in gold/Bitcoin terms, the global reserves shift back toward gold, how a U.S. gold reprice to $10k–$20k could fund a balance-sheet reset, the risks of “paper gold,” Bitcoin’s potential catch-up (and a possible East=gold, West=BTC split), AI as an accelerant, and a pragmatic portfolio framework for navigating a 100-year reset.
------
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAXNET | MINT, REDEEM, EARN
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR L2 NETWORK
💤EIGHT SLEEP | IMPROVE YOUR SLEEP
https://bankless.cc/eight-sleep
💠BIT DIGITAL ($BTBT) | ETH TREASURY
https://bankless.cc/bit-digital
We’re being compensated by Bit Digital (NASDAQ BTBT) for this segment promoting their company and BTBT. The compensation is paid in cash as a one time payment. You can find additional information about Bit Digital and BTBT on their Investor page at https://bit-digital.com/investors
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
4:15 How Long is The Trade?
11:23 Gold vs Treasury Reserves
19:34 Gold All Time Highs
23:17 Gold Buying Pressure
29:08 Back to The Gold Standard?
37:37 The Transition
43:10 Central Bank Gold Accumulation
49:20 Gold Demonetization
57:00 Types of Gold
1:05:17 Gold vs Bitcoin
1:10:06 The Future of Bitcoin
1:16:19 4-Year Cycles
1:19:02 Tokenized Gold
1:24:19 100 Year Reset Portfolio
1:28:25 Closing & Disclaimers
------
RESOURCES
Luke Gromen
"The Debasement Trade"
https://x.com/LukeGromen/status/1974184554782220583
FFTT, LLC
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
When is the debatement trade end? The answer is never. It's never. It's a good time maybe it takes them on a dip. Sure. Can you have 20, 30% corrections? Sure. So, if 20, 30% corrections are stock market all the time, no one's ever like, oh, it's over. Yeah, the stock market's over. No. It's a currency issue. It's a currency issue. The choices we have made over the last 30 years with borrowed money, they're coming home the roost. And what that looks like is it's not at the basement trade. It is a debatement secular trend. And, you know, the behavior's very big. You don't sell rallies. You buy dips.
Luke Grimm, and I want to start with a chart. This is a chart that you put up not too long ago. And this is a chart of the S&P in various denominators, let's say. One is a denominator on dollars. So, Kat, the way investors tend to view their portfolio. The other denominates stocks in the S&P in gold terms. And the third kind of denominates it in Bitcoin terms. Now, in US dollar terms, over the last five years, it seems like everything is booming. We've got stocks up triple digits. We've got homes up, double digits. Like, everybody is more wealthy, right? But then you start to look at this in gold terms.
And you realize that stocks in homes, they're flat to negative. That real wealth is actually stagnating. Then, of course, you look at it in Bitcoin terms. And it's like, oh my god, what happened? This is bleeding in Bitcoin. What's the story here? What is the big story? Is this debatement? In a word, yes. This is the big story of our time, I think. You know, the chart shows, you know, S&P Nasdaq in home prices in dollars, gold and Bitcoin. And it's telling you the use case of gold and Bitcoin, right? How often do we hear? What's the use case at gold? Gold isn't used for anything. Bitcoin isn't used for anything.
When sovereigns find themselves in a position where they need to have negative real rates to keep their debt nominally money good, this is what happens. They have a printing press. And so they call it whatever they want to call it. Right, and we've seen it this time. I think I can't remember. That was from COVID, right? So obviously, we had pretty obvious money creation during COVID. But you can run the same chart. In fact, I have since BTFP, right? The Fed's whatever bond bank term funding program, whatever it was. It was by the F&K paper. More globally known. But, you know, the purists all said, well, BTFP isn't QE.
It's not money creation. And the chart looks exactly the same from BTFP, which is to say, hey, you can say, well, maybe there's some lag defect from COVID, whatever. In the end, I don't care. Right. I don't care. My clients don't care. What is happening here is we have a, you know, what is, we've gone from the denial stage that there isn't a problem to now somewhere between anger and bargaining, right, of consensus, which is there's a debatement trade. But if you read the paper over like the last week and a half, they've sort of finally acknowledged that there's a debatement trade. So, you know, good on consensus moving out of denial.
But now they're into like somewhere between anger and bargaining, which is like, oh, the debatement trade is stupid. Why are you buying gold? And the, you know, in bargaining, right, the next stage of grief, which is, well, it's not going to go on forever. And we still have to get through bargaining. We still have to get through depression. We still have to get through the acceptance phases of grief. And I think by the time all is said and done, you know, that chart that you showed, I think, you know, the prices of the S&P and the NASDAQ and homes are going to be a lot higher in dollars. And I think they're going to be a lot lower in gold.
And I think it'll be a lot lower in Bitcoin. And so that's, that's where we are. You know, it is what it is. When people call this a trade, I think in many cases, they are thinking that it's something short term of this aberration in 2025, where gold is up 60% on the year. Like, it's a trade. It's just a trendy thing that some traders, some investors are doing. It won't last. Is this a trade or is this something that's more measured in years, let's say, or decades? Is this a long-term investment trend? I think it is, it is a critical and a super astute question because the first principle of which almost everybody, every American investor is operating is, well, this will be just like 1980 when, you know, this will be like the 70s.
Right? So we had, we went off the gold standard 71 and gold went up a bunch and then Volker came in and raised rates and gold went back. It was just a trade. There was a debatement. Volker took care of it all. Well, Volker took rates to 15%. If the Fed did that to stop that, if the Fed took rates to 6 today, they would literally blow up the entire, not just stock market, but housing and the Treasury market. We know this. This is not speculative. We've seen empirically the Treasury market dysfunction multiple times well before 5% over the last five years on the tenure. So there's this, the first principle of view that most investors are investing on is that, well, this will, there will be a reversion.
And so that we wrote for clients a few weeks back was, you know, let's look at the debatement trade in Indian rupees. And if you call up a log chart of gold priced in Indian rupees going back to 1985, it looks like this. And there's like this little dips along the way. But in the end, it looks like Apple. If you go and you look at Brazilian real gold priced in Brazilian real back to 2000, log chart looks like this up into the right with little dips along the way. So am I saying gold's never going to dip again? No, of course not. I mean, it's probably a little corrective action now. What I'm saying is that the most important thing to determine answer that question is to look at the fiscal situation of the US and ask yourself, is it really the same as the US in 1980, as the US in 1970, as the US in 1960?
It's not even close. It's not even close. And it looks much more like Brazil in 2000. I don't know, by the way, those aren't my words. Those are the words of former Dallas Fed economist John Welch who wrote a piece right after the Fed did BTFP in 2023. And he goes, this looks like fiscal dominance. This reminds me of Brazil around 2000. And it was probably the best Fed call of this decade so far. All you needed to hear was that. And he's not there anymore. I'm not going to let him for I forget which big bank, right? So he wasn't just sort of talking out of the side of his mouth. He was, he had experience being there.
He's like, wow, this is so familiar. So that to me is, is I think something, one of the big variant perceptions. I think 99% of US investors are investing in the debatement trade based on this assumption, well, were the USA? We look like Brazil. Fiscal debt, domestic politics in 2000. Again, not my words. Former Fed economist in Dallas Fed's words. And if that's the case, when is the, when is the debatement trade end? The answer is never. It's never, you know, it's a good time maybe takes them on a dip. Sure. Can you have 20, 30% corrections? Sure. So if 20, 30% corrections of stock market all the time, no one's ever like, oh, it's over.
Yeah, the stock market's over. No, it's a currency issue. It's a currency issue. The choices we have made over the last 30 years with borrowed money, they're coming home the roost. And what that looks like is, it's not at the basement trade. It is a debatement secular trend. And, you know, the behavior is very big. You don't sell rallies, you buy dips. Introducing at Frax USD, the genius aligned digital dollar from Frax. It's a secure, stable, and fully backed by institutional grade real world assets, custodyed by BlackRock, SuperState, and Fidelity. It's always redeemable one-to-one, transparently audited, and built for payments, defy, and banking.
The best of all worlds. At the core is FraxNet, an on-chain fintech platform built to align with emerging US regulatory frameworks where you can mint, redeem, and use Frax USD with just a few clicks. Deposit USDC, send a bank wire, or tokenize treasuries, and receive programmable digital dollars straight to your wallet. FraxNet users, it benefits from the underlying return of US treasuries, and earn just by using the system. Whether you're bridging, minting, or holding, your Frax USD works for you. Frax isn't just a protocol, it's a digital nation, powered by the Frax token, and governed by its global communities.
Join that community, and help shape Frax Nation's future, by going to Frax.com slash r slash bankless. Frax, designed for the future of compliant digital finance. Ethereum's layer 2 universe is exploding with choices. If you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens, make your next stop, Unichain. First, liquidity. Unichain hosts the most liquid Uniswap V4 deployment on any layer 2, giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like ETHUSDC. More liquidity means better prices, less slippage, and smoother swaps, exactly what traders crave. The numbers back it up. Unichain leads all layer 2s in total value locked for Uniswap V4.
And it's not just a deed, it's fast and fully transparent. Purpose built to be the home base for DeFi and cross-chain liquidity. When it comes to costs, Unichain is a no-brainer. Transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than Ethereum mainnet, slashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity. Want to stay in the loop on Unichain? Visit Unichain.org or follow at Unichain on X for all the updates. Bit Digital, ticker, BT, BT is a publicly traded ETH Treasury company that combines the two biggest metas of our time. Ethereum and AI compute. Bit Digital believes that ETH will power finance and AI compute will power everything.
Bit Digital gives you direct exposure to both. Bit Digital holds more than 150,000 ETH with institutional grade staking and validator operations. On top of that, the company owns roughly 73% of white fiber, an AI infrastructure business that runs high performance GPU data centers, that adds a meaningful exposure to the growth of AI compute with over 27 million shares. This is an ETH Treasury backed by real operations designed to capture staking yield today while positioning for the future of intelligent computing tomorrow. The ticker is BT, BT. This ad is not financial advice. Do your own research, learn more about Bit Digital and try their MNAF calculator at bit-digital.
com. That's bit-digital.com. Bankless is being compensated by Bit Digital for this ad. You can find out more information by clicking the link in the show notes. Luke, there's a chart that has been circulating around Twitter pretty aggressively over the last week, and it is just two charts, two lines, the foreign central bank reserves, percentage of treasuries versus percentage in gold. Up until 1995, gold was dominant, but then between 1995 and 2025, so 30 years, treasuries were the dominant reserve asset inside of central banks. And that, as of just this month, has flipped. So gold is now the dominant reserve asset in foreign central bank reserves instead of US treasuries.
And I think this kind of goes to your point. Is this a trade? Is this the debatement trade? Or is this just debatement, just remove trade? Is this kind of like a before, after a moment, like in 2025, gold flipped US treasuries in foreign reserves? Is this like a, when we look forward, we go forward in time 5, 10, 20 years. We'll look back on this year when gold flipped treasuries and kind of understand it like this is kind of when world powers re-equalized. There's a new equilibrium. What would you say is a significance of this moment? I think it is possibly hugely significant. I think it depends on events and two events in particular.
Right? So if, if we think the United States is going to change its mind and suddenly say, you know what? We're okay with having China make more and more the critical components of our military. Let's just go back to the way things were. Then that chart in theory could reverse. If the second question, are China and Russia going to say, you know what? We think the US was just kidding about trying to choke us out, trying to break us up, trying to tip us over, trying to regime changes. We actually think that we want to go back to the way things were. And so we are going to start stockpiling treasuries at real rates that are wildly negative.
So basically the Americans will be stealing our real wealth by us buying treasuries at negative real rates. And we're going to replace our leaders with Yeltsin like Boris Yeltsin like leaders who basically position our countries as economic vassals to the Americans and proceed to sell off the wealth and companies of our country to pennies on the dollar to US Western interests. If the answer to either of those questions is no let alone both, then that chart I think is monumental because I think it is telling you what is happening, which is there's no chance the Chinese and Russians are going to say that.
And there's no chance the US military, especially after this last year is going to go, you know what? It's a good idea. Let's finish soul sourcing. We're already too heavily sourced to China. Let's soul sourced to China for all the stuff, all the weapons that we want to use to point at China. So neither of those in my opinion the odds of either of those things happening is zero or very close to it. And if that's a case, then we're going to see gold continue to rise in reserves as a share of treasuries. It's just sort of de facto. Luke, can we talk about that chart a little bit more and can you give us the history of how this even happened?
So the world used to be on the gold standard. This was not too long ago, even under Bretton Woods, it sort of held. At that time, as you saw in the chart in the 1970s, into the 1980s and into the early 1990s, the share of central bank foreign reserves was skewed towards gold. What if you're central bank? What's the main reserve asset that you hold? Well, it's a hard asset to sound money. It's gold. It's not a fiat. But then in 1995, this is almost the the flipping that's weirder to me. In 1995, it started to be the case that treasuries exceeded gold as a share of central bank reserve. And that number continued to increase and gold continued to go down.
And so even my home country of Canada where I was born was looking at their balance sheet. They went from top 15 countries in the world in terms of their gold holding. To now they have zero Luke, they sold all of it, not even 1%. They have nothing left. And so what was the motivator here? What was the force that was in play the secular trend, I guess, in the 1990s that was in play to get central banks to hold treasuries, another country's fiat debt as their foreign reserve rather than gold. I think it was a combination of triumphalism around the Berlin wall coming down the USSR collapsing. 1989, 1992, I think it was.
We had Fukuyama's book, The End of History, which was sort of captivated the mood. That was it. It was over. So there was some triumphalism around that. There was some dogma around that. There was some hubris around that. And it also looks a mathematical reality. The fact is, the US was the most powerful nation of the world. We still had a huge industrial base. We had all this technology that we were sort of expanding and letting out of the military into consumer markets. We were growing really rapidly. Russia was on its rear end, a collapsing backwater. China was a backwater. Europe. We still had US troops all over Japan.
We still had US troops all over. So it was sort of like peak empire. At the end of the day, combined with the mathematical reality of us, look from 97 on, 97 through 01, we ran surpluses. We ran fiscal surpluses. So the treasury market was a much smaller instrument or much smaller market. Global FX reserves were smaller. So FX reserves really began exploding after the 97 Southeast Asia crisis. Because basically, Southeast Asia and the world's creditors also how fast Southeast Asia ran out of dollar reserves. And they all said, we're never doing that again. And China had a front row seat to it.
And they were like, we ain't doing that. Because that means we have this currency crisis and the Americans come in with the IMF and they sort of get to pick and choose what assets they want to buy and how they get the restructure. And so that was really, you know, FX reserves were always a thing. But they weren't that big until after that crisis. And at that moment in time, we need more FX reserves. Well, you weren't going to do anything to piss off the Americans. And buying gold was going to piss off the Americans. And so Southeast Asia was in crisis. Russia was a backwater on its butt in crisis.
I wouldn't even say it's a backwater. It's not fair. It was in a moment in time where it was though. It was, you know, it was in collapse, you know, coming out of the, you know, in collapse, Southeast Asian collapse. Japan was only eight years into its, you know, 30 years of lost decades. China was nowhere. Europe was, you know, basically occupied by the American military and certainly defended. You know, we had just bailed out Mexico, right? So Latin America was sort of, you know, on the back end of 20 years of crises, you know, starting in the early 80s. That was when there was no alternative.
And so when you start ramping FX reserves, it's an advent choice. You don't buy gold. You buy treasury. So that's, that's sort of how it happened. And it was at a moment in time it made sense and regulatory actions certainly supported those choices. But that's how it happened. Let's talk more about gold. So there was this clip earlier in the month. I think it was on the Bill Mar show. You have Mark Cuban. You have, I think Andrew Sorkin and, you know, from Bloomberg. And they're talking about the price of gold. And there's some comment of, you know, gold is probably, like, just shot up above all time highs this week.
And they were kind of laughing about it. Like, why would you hold gold this sort of thing? But there's also underneath it sort of a sense of alarm. Maybe there's like, oh, well, should gold be doing that? Like, almost seemed like they were nervous about it. And I guess my question to you is, should we be alarmed at the aggressive price action of gold on the year? And maybe if you have gold, you're not alarmed. So who should be alarmed by this if someone should be alarmed? Pens which side of the American fence you're on? What side of the world economic fence you're on? Look, if you are part of the American fence where you want to go back to those grand old days of the late 90s and early 2000s where treasuries with a reserve asset and we were offshoring our industrial base as fast as we could to China.
And, you know, you know, basically American policy economically was do it out, you know, subjugate the working in middle classes of America and subjugate the defense industrial base to China in order to support the bond market and Wall Street and Washington deficits. Yeah, if if you think that was a good thing, if you liked that outcome, if that was good for your paycheck, yeah, you're very alarmed about what gold's doing. I would put right Andrew Russ working into that camp. Now, if you are of the view that you want the defense industrial base to come back, you want wage growth in this country, you want to inflate away our debt to put us on a sustainable, sustainable competitive footing with China because we went way too far with that past monetary regime.
Then you're rooting for gold to go higher and that's the camp I'm in and I think it's the camp most, you know, most Americans should be in most of the world should be in and it's definitely the camp that the bricks are in actually what China and Russia doing with gold they're literally trying to do us a favor. We'll see if our leaders let us let let them, but you know, it's, I think the administration in the office today, I think is happy to let them bid it up at it. You know, there's there's of course, look, you don't want to go on $4,000, $10,000, $20,000. Boom, that's that can begin to risk confidence.
So there is a rate of a cent, but like it's got to go way higher. If we want to do, you know, if you asked Andrew out, so it's a good idea to reassure the defense industrial base, get less, we're lying on China, he would say yes. But it tells me how early we are in gold still that he doesn't make the connection. He's a very smart man. He's written some very good books. He's very well connected. He doesn't get that, but they're starting to get it right because literally the week after he said that Jamie Diamond came out and said, you know, I could see gold at five or $10,000. And look, why is Jamie Diamond suddenly thinking gold at five or $10,000 is a good idea or certainly not something to be afraid of.
So that's that's how I think about. I mean, I think it's just a sign of how early we are that either they're making fun of it and be that they're not making the connection of like higher gold. Look, there's not a world where the US can win against China. Again, I may be too, too absolute. It is highly unlikely the US can win against China in the great power competition. It is engaged in unless gold probably is way higher than where it trades today at 4,000. Look, I've got a second chart for you. This one I actually got from your Twitter. The tweet reads, in 1970, the amount of gold reserves were equal to currently currency reserves.
This chart is inclusive of the United States Federal Reserve. And then it follows saying today currency reserves are six times the gold reserves will the gap close the gap meaning will we just simply have much more gold reserves to maybe get to par with currency reserves in the United States Federal Reserve. I think my big question maybe ever the big question is what is the implied gold price if that does happen if we do think that gold reserves in the central bank are accelerating our central bank are accelerating how much buying pressure does that represent on gold. I think it's going over 20,000.
I mean, look, I think that chart is super interesting for a number of reasons, not least of which is there was other charts by people whose work I very much respect out there pointing out that well. You know, the gold US or sorry, all above market global gold is now equal to I think USM to money supply. And to me, that was like comparing like apples and like octopuses, you're like, what? Like, if you're going to use all above gold supply, you should use all global M2 supply. If you're going to use USM to supply use US gold US official gold supply, you're mixing and and the point was that that post was like, well, $4,000 gold is about it, right?
Like those two numbers was like $4,000, that's about it. And that to me, yeah, like that A, it makes no sense, you know, struck me as a bit disingenuous. That reserve chart, that second one, you know, it suggests they're going to continue to buy and that, you know, they'll be, they'll be tonnage increase and there will be price increase, but I think a lot of this, you know, there's always been that there's not enough gold, right? There's not enough gold to use gold as a reserve. And every time I hear it, I just want to face palm because I'm like, gold's price rise can rise infinitely. There's plenty of gold.
It's just a question of price. It's just here watching it in real time, right? Central banks are buying gold. They have bought a lot of gold in the last five years and over the last 10 years. The price is rising a lot. And so, you know, I think ultimately those numbers will, will move to par over time. Now, are they going to move to par in the next two years? Probably not. I mean, it could, but that's, that would be a bit of an interesting scenario. But over time, I think those two numbers are going to par for two reasons. Number one, I don't think currency reserves are ever rising again. If you have the Americans who have come out and said, all right, we hyperinflated Iran in 2012 by kicking them out of the swift system or making the Europeans do it.
Chinese were like, holy cow, the Russians were like, holy cow, like that's unacceptable. 2013, the Chinese came out and said, we're done by intrasories. You know, they said it in their Chinese way, right? Is no longer in China's interest to continue to grow affects reserves. That was we're done by intrasories. And then they can monitor since on that. None. In fact, they've net sold. Russia was done around the same time. 2013, you had a treasury official, former treasury official ones, erotic, come out with a book called Treasuries War. And it was maybe the most heubristic piece of writing I've ever read.
It was just like, hey, we just hyperinflated the Iranians. And here's how we're going to use a dollar to hyperinflate everybody else to make them who we want. And you're like, Jesus. Hey, Alabama, I we know you're pretty tough, but we're just going to run the ball left every time because we think we have a really good left tackle. Come on. And so guess what? The world stopped by intrasories in 2014 global central bank holdings of treasuries stopped rising. And I don't think they're ever going to rise again. Again, unless we go back to those two questions. Is the U.S. willing to offshore its entire defense industrial base to China?
If yes, then yeah, maybe treasury reserves will start rising again globally. Our China and Russia willing to become total U.S. economic vassals and sell off their countries and impoverish themselves. And then if yes, then sure, maybe they'll start rising it, but failing those two being answered. Yes, treasury reserves are never rising again. Why would you put your money in treasuries? Oh, by the way, we then sanctioned the Russians in 14. We sanctioned the Russians in 2022. We froze their sanctions. You got the European saying they're going to take the trip. You would have to be a galactic moron to store the revolve of your country, the short places of your country in Western sovereign debt.
People say, well, don't invade another country. Okay, like like your rock, right? Like, like, like, whatever. So I think that those charts are going to continue to converge over time. You have to have control of your effects reserves and knowing the fiscal situation of the West, which is they have to have negative real rates. To make their debt not implode. It's a double whammy, right? You're going to surpluses occur naturally. They just, you know, some countries sell by and sell more. It's usually around oil and commodities. You're going to have some level of surpluses over time. Those are not going back into Western sovereign debt.
I don't think ever again unless those two conditions are satisfied. If they can't go into Western sovereign debt, they're going to go into gold. And as more people understand that, why would you sell your gold? No, like, there's a tidal wave of money coming for the next 30 years of surpluses every year, relentless buying a gold. You would have to be an idiot to sell your gold in front of that. Hey, sovereigns are going to buy a trillion dollars with a gold from the next 30 years. How much would you like to sell today? None. I'm going to buy more. I'm going to participate alongside them as the system rebalances through gold.
I'm wondering to what extent look that if we get a six X in the price of gold and gold is above 20,000, it's heading towards 30,000 and the central bank for like reserves kind of switch back to the 1970s and favor of gold. At what point are we on a gold standard? And this is an interesting question, because I think, at least in the US, and maybe I'll speak to the typical investor in the US, we have been conditioned to believe that gold is, I think, Keynes words in 1924 were a barbarous relic. Basically, it's an anachronism of a distant past that we have evolved our monetary policy in our nation states above the need for gold.
And by the way, the gold standard, that was responsible for elongating and worsening the Great Depression and that the chief innovation of central bankers was to move beyond this barbarous relic. And I'll just add another perspective here, which is earlier you were making the case that actually like more of a gold standard would be good for America. I think most investors are maybe among the American elite, they think the opposite is true. They think that they'll lose their ability to sanction foreign adversaries like Russia. They think that it's a good thing that treasuries are the world reserve asset because then we get 30 year fixed rate mortgages at the US and it's a good thing to maintain that dominance and supremacy.
Talk about that. Are we just basically moving towards a gold standard? And how is that not a de-evolution of our financial system? And what ways is that really an upgrade for America? So it's interesting because a gold standard implies the gold being pegged to a value of currency and then the gold moving as it was structured for many, many years centuries with a few exceptions up to call it the 30s. And so the people that rail against the gold standard, they are fond of pointing that out and they're fond of using Keynes's words and I think it's very disingenuous that they do that they know exactly what they're doing.
And why do they do that because they want to maintain control of the system that they have? I understand it. If I was in their shoes, I'd probably want the same. And so they lie by omission about that period in history. They lie by omission that Keynes proposed something called the bank or at Bretton Woods, which was a neutral reserve asset made up of commodities that you would settle that would rise in price to balance imbalances. And so what I'm describing is not a gold standard. What we would be on is not a gold standard. It would be Keynes's bank or it's a neutral reserve asset. And it would fluctuate in value in every currency to reflect inflation expectations, reflect trade balances, right?
So America runs massive massive deficits. The world's just not going to stockpile treasuries anymore. They're going to start buying gold. Oh, by the way, this is what the world has been doing for the last 10 years. That puts upward pressure on gold in dollar terms. The more deficits America runs, the more the dollars going to fall versus gold. The more gold the other currencies have. And the price is still going up in their currency, just maybe a little more slowly than in dollars. You're going to end up getting, say for example, the yuan rising against the dollar. What is it that the American government wants the Chinese to do?
They wanted them to strengthen the yuan versus the dollar, right? So step one in which it is beneficial for the U.S. is, what is American policy makers want China to do? They wanted to strengthen the yuan, stop with mercantilist policies, check. And they want the Chinese to consume more their own production. Well, the Chinese government paradoxically has been encouraging the Chinese, the Chinese people to buy gold for less 25 years, right? So it's a paradox because they're authoritarian and communist except their government's been encouraging them to buy gold while our government's been encouraging us to buy the paper of central control, which are treasuries can't make this stuff up.
So as the price of gold goes up, Chinese balance sheets are going to improve Chinese consumers are going to have more money to buy their own production. The move in gold year to date has has improved Chinese balance sheets by over a trillion dollars in one year based on their holdings one year over the last five years. It's like four or five trillion dollars that their balance sheet is improved. So to high enough price a gold China consumes more of its own production. The balance sheet issues are fixed vis-a-vis real estate. It strengthens the yuan relative to the dollar and then sort of the other thing, yeah, it takes away our sanctions.
But this is I think one of the things that so many Western commentators miss behind sanctions is a perceived threat. Let's call it what it is. We're going to put dollar sanctions on you and if you don't play ball, we're going to duty what we did to Saddam. Everyone forgets we had sanctions on the Iraq for like 10 years. And then when they started breaking down and Saddam went to the, you know, he left the dollar and went to the euro, he announced that in October of 2000. And you can find articles about an earlier three about how much money that had made him moving to the euro from the dollar as they had supported the euro because it was five percent of world oil production.
The threat was we're going to come and kick your head in the problem with the dollar system that these people leave out is it's become a victim of its own success. There is no threat to kick your head in anymore because guess who makes all the weapons that we're going to use to kick your head in China. China makes critical components of the weapons were you why is that the case because of the dollar system we literally there's you know there is the only place there's still a threat that we're going to come kick your head in is on Western Wall Street investors in the real world. U.S. policy makers U.
S. military people U.S. military strategists the Chinese the Russians they all know U.S. ran through 15% of its high end air defense missiles in 11 days of medium combat in June helping defend Israel. What do we got a month to two months three months and all by the way these missiles take years to replenish. Everybody knows this and and oh by the way China makes critical components in these missiles across services like of a startling the high percentage of these missiles like literally if China should. And how you know I knew this ahead of time when you want look at how the American administration is reacted to the shutdown of military grade rares have you ever seen the American administration react this way to anything anything.
Why they're acting like an addict who just had his supply cut off you ever try to take booze away from an alcoholic. It's the same reaction the American dollar system has gone too far it has become a weapon against America why would I be in favor of a weapon against America why would anyone be in favor of a dollar system that has left American national security in a position where we literally everyone knows we can't do it for any extended period of time everyone knows the Russians can last longer they had a NATO came out early this year said the Russians out produced all of NATO four to one everyone knows China like everyone but a certain class of western and U.
S. investors who start with the first principle of China can't win America always wins America hasn't won this one guys like wake up. Now I don't say that to you I say that to these consensus guys but that's why I think it's you know why would anyone want gold well if you're in favor of America not being beholden to China to make weapons and if you're in favor of rebalancing trade in the way that we've been trying to get the Chinese rebalance trade for 10 years with no success then you should be in favor of this and if not then I would question where your loyalty's lie. It'd be one thing if we are transitioning from just a U.
S. dollar base system to a gold base system and really the only significant repercussions of that were the treasury charts went down and the gold charts went up if that's all that would happen that would be it's a fun topic for all the people in the world of finance and an econ. But when something so fundamental shifts from one phase to another there's collateral damage just like left and right and you know to your point what happens when you take away. It won't be the most safe thing that you ever do in your life and so there's like the happy case where there's just like kind of fair and orderly transitions you know the Indiana Jones swaps swaps the bag of sand for the gold for the gold icon but then there's like very disorderly transitions that are also possible where are you on this spectrum between.
A fair transition a fair and orderly transition to a disorderly transition from one one phase to the next. It's a good question it depends on events but I would say that every day that the administration does not take its medicine and just do a big you know there's something in financial accounting the big bath theory right like you're the new management team you come in and you you know if they were. Engaging in fraud or bad the best thing you can do is like day one you come in you sit down with investors you say listen the old management screwed this up we're taking a huge charge to write off all of the bad stuff they had done and we are going to reinvest and do this so give us 12 months.
My hope was that the Trump administration would come in and do that day one. They didn't they came in with like fantasy land we're gonna do is two trillion dollars and wasted three months and then had to admit well it's actually 160 billion and all by the way but one of the most brilliant industrialists of our era. Fought Washington and couldn't win right so sort of sort of hurt you know the credibility of future statements from the administration. Next up we get liberation day and we get the treasury secretary who Wall Street by and large still thinks is sort of you know the ace at the table in these negotiations and he says we have all the cards as the debtor we have all the cards and China has no cards and Trump repeats it and seven trading days later a bond market essentially blows up and they do the first episode you know episode of taco Trump always chickens out the bond market.
And then we get into June and we're you know our ally in Israel you know attacks. Iran while we're negotiating a deal which is a really bad look for us no matter how you slice it and then needs us to help bail them out basically. So now we've delayed again so my point here is is it's October 27th as we're doing this they've been in office for nine over nine months now. The optimal strategy and when I was most optimistic that we can get out of this without severe disruption was hey president Biden president Trump myself president Obama president bush president Clinton. Groot up and here's how and here's what happened and I am standing here today as president Trump asking you from both sides of the aisle.
We are going to take the big bath we are going to write down this debt what does that look like that looks like gold at ten thousand or twenty thousand dollars an ounce. And we are going to put it into the treasury general account we're going to fight on our debt we're going to invest massively we're going to ask our partners to step in. And we're going to decouple from China and listen we want to manage a peaceful transition we will even allow the Chinese to invest in parts. But maybe in certain parts only in certain non critical parts and we want to do this multilaterally that had a real chance of being successful and every day that is past that they have not done that their odds of success and their odds of hey you know we switched the bag of sand for the gold icon.
And it goes down and down and it's reached the point now where we've added in a complicating factor of AI. You know we came into this year and AI was kind of like still a little bit out there on the horizon and it ain't out of there on the horizon anymore. Every like last week New York Times came out and said there's a hundred sixty thousand people we would have hired that we're not going to hire because of robots. And that number is going to be six hundred thousand by twenty thirty three and you're seeing big banks say we're not hiring because AI and so now you've got this further complicating factor of an exponential deflationary technology arriving faster than you think.
And that is going to hurt receipts that's going to make the fiscal picture worse that's going to make political stability worse. And so you know to answer your question I'm not that optimistic anymore that this can be done without severe you know severe disruption severe chaos and I wish that wasn't the case but it is what it is. Can you help me understand this loop one thing I have not understood about central banks accumulating accumulating gold is really how it works and so if a lot of the gold price here recently has been driven by foreign bank central bank accumulation namely Russia and China they're always the top the list seems like the western countries have not got the memo on this summer still selling their gold but say Russia China if gold appreciates in the way that you're talking about how does that position kind of the the countries around the world.
So on paper if you just ask chat GPT you know the United States owns eight thousand one hundred tons of gold and most of anybody so one would assume the U.S. does fairly well I mean it loses treasury bills as the world reserve asset but we got the most gold in the world and have since world war two even though we're not buying more we still have a lot Fort Knox New York I don't know where it is. Then you've got Germany they have you know 3,300 then you get Italy and France in the 2000 range now China's listed at 2,200 and that's their official estimates are these numbers accurate like how do we really know how much gold these countries actually have and what are the dynamics behind this accumulation gain.
Yeah the audit side of it I think is a question for everybody involved on some level it's fascinating the only area that I see China hawks taking China's word at face value is on what they have in gold right China lies about everything except their goal the 2,200 tons that's exactly what China has and we think they have a lot more you're assuming a lot more why would they lie about this why are they you know why wouldn't they tell us when that just like play yeah what I guess what's the game theory of why they would underplay the amount of gold that they hold. It's still a form of Biden hide right the old Chinese by your time you know hide your strength and by your time hide and bite why tell us till they need to tell us it is a political statement right you we want you surpass the Americans like that is.
So why why stick it in their face why I would if I was doing it I would do exactly what they're doing which is they're buying it left and right I mean I people very. I have talked to people that have that a very long term relationships in that country and when you tell them hey they have 2,200 tons of gold it's all they can do to not laugh like yeah they've got 2,200 tons of gold. So I think I think it's a form of hide and bite because of the the political nature of it the other thing too is like look. If you flash what you're doing you know the the New York traders are just going to front run you and make you pay more the London traders is front run you and make you pay more just for the stake a stick it to you and to get on a momentum trade so it's that's the other side of it like just market sort of practical you know practical trading dynamics because well you know it's very easy to buy lots of you know $100 million in paper done.
It's actually hard to buy physical gold in real size like it takes some real planning lead times et cetera which then gets to sort of the first party question of like what are they doing that. Ultimately they're probably buying from some of their own domestic minds certainly in the case of Russia and China and then yeah I mean West Westerners are willing to sell gold for their currencies and so. To the extent Russia and China end up with Western currencies hey we'll take we'll take gold and we'll take delivery you know some of the there's probably some barter aspects to it with all the sanctions regimes in place where you know you can go back in time to 2014 something called the lawmakers look for the golden loophole in Iran sanctions.
And they're just going straight gold for oil and it was hundreds of billions of dollars. With you know turkey was facilitating it the Iranians were getting gold and Chinese and others were getting oil and so there's lots of different ways they can do it but yeah that the the Chinese $2,200 or $2,200, $2,300 tons wherever they are now like that's a joke that's not the real number. Imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly that's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking a revolutionary new category. At the intersection of trad five and web three at the heart is you are the world's first money out built fully on chain.
It gives you a Swiss iBand account blending fiat currencies like the euro the Swiss franc the United States dollar or the Remembee with crypto all in one place. Enjoy real world usability and blockchains trust and programmability transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with trad five rails and packed with integrated D5 futures. UR transforms mantle network into the ultimate platform for on chain financial services. Unifying payments trading and assets like the MI4, the me protocol and functions FBTC backed by developer grants, ecosystem incentives and top distribution through the UR app rewards stations and buy bit launch pool.
For MNT holders every economic activity in UR drives value back to you embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem. Follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking that's x.com slash mantle underscore official crypto is risky your sleep shouldn't be eight sleeps mission is simple better sleep through cutting edge technology. Their new pod five is a smart mattress cover that fits on the top of your bed it automatically adjust the temperature on each side so you and your partner can both sleep the way that you like. It's clinically proven to give you up to one extra hour of quality sleep per night eight sleeps pod five uses AI to learn your sleep patterns regularly temperature reduce snoring and track key health metrics like HRV and breathing with a new full body temperature regulating blanket and built in speaker is the most complete sleep upgrade yet.
Upgrade your sleep and recovery with a sleep use code bankless at eight sleep dot com slash bankless to get up to $350 off the pod five ultra that's eight sleep dot com slash bankless. You also get 30 days to try it risk free link in the show notes for more information do you think they could have more than the US does right now. I think they absolutely have more than the US. Oh my god. Okay, so in this whole gold accumulation story. How does this position in the US because maybe the Chinese have more than us. We don't know the US still has a lot. You're mentioning one thing that you would have loved Trump to have done is you said something like free price the gold.
And to use that money to pay off debt now I'm a little bit fuzzy here Luke. I think US has all of that gold that I was mentioning on the balance sheet on its balance sheet. But at a much lower price not the market price and this is all for memory something like value to add a much lower price like valued at a forty dollars per ounce or something in this rate. 42 okay why in the world why like don't we mark everything up to like mark to market like why is that still on the balance sheet at 4200 and like so. So why don't we just do that why don't we just reprise that's completely honest it's completely rational to just kind of like reprice and that's what you're advising Trump to do why haven't we done this already.
You know I think it's I can't well I think in prior regimes look if we would have done that that would have said look golds the reserve asset that's that's a voice saying gold is a reserve asset not treasuries at a time we were trying to convince the world. You know after 70 what was the price in 71 it was it for it's the right as wondering the 42 is the price in 71 it just frozen time at that amount right. So I think for from 71 through I don't know 2010 2012 2020 we kept it there because we didn't want to encourage anybody to buy gold. Because we wanted them to buy treasuries and so if we just we have demonetized gold you hear all these sort of former IMF hands and you know saying what we demonetized goal those part of demonetizing gold just leave it there.
Fast forward today Chinese are like we're a culture with 5000 years of history and we've been around 5000 years or 2000 years sorry 5000 we don't have 2000 years of history and like. At a 2000 years you know the number of fiat currency systems that haven't gone to zero against gold they're like. It's like the Steve the Steve ismen the steam you know mark bombing how many currency systems have not gone to zero against gold in 2000 years zero. So the Chinese are like alright they basically been calling bullshit on the gold price for 10 15 years right oh you think it's 800 we'll take it 1000 we'll take it 1500 we'll take it just keep waving it in.
So now for all the reasons we highlighted early strategically it is in the interest of the U.S. to reevaluate go now. In theory they could come out and print dollars and and set a price and then they got to defend that price right they have to you know hey it's 20,000 well you got to be a buyer in a seller at 20,000 now we can do that. You know we have a printing press you know we defended levels on bonds offended QE right you know Ben Bernanke go back to 2002 he specifically sites how. They used gold to devalue the dollar you know he specifically sites how the Fed has in its mandate the ability to buy foreign sovereign debt and gold they could do that but that's that's a political choice that is a treasury choice.
Treasury handles the dollar if the Fed was doing that and Bernanke in his O2 deflation speech says this I have to tread carefully because I'm dealing with the dollar now and that is typically the purview of treasury. But it was very we were very able to defeat deflation in 1933 when we devalue the heck out of the dollar versus goal okay we could do that. So that's one way you could do it but that would require you know that is essentially a statement dollars reserve status as it has been structured is done gold is now the new reserve asset that's what that says and that's why it's so political and the DXY is going to get reprised.
Way lower and that's not the Fed's choice that also presumes you have a Fed willing to try to do the right thing for the country in terms of. D you know rebalancing things and you have seen an unwillingness of the Fed you know you're to date to do that and certainly earlier this year there's been no connection between the strategic imperative of the United States the country and the fed's mandate of inflation slash. Employment maybe that's shifting on the margin to me the whole Fed independence thing around Powell is Powell basically being given a gold or the lead discussion like either you help us.
In doing this or we'll find someone who will many is maybe you know softening on this now with the rate cuts and what have you so. They could do it up front but it's tricky now. There's a lot of paper gold out there you can read about that there's and so in theory an easier way to do just be basically yell fire in a crowded theater you know strategically bit up gold using the exchange stabilization fund at key parts and for short squeezes higher and higher and higher and higher and let the market sort of take it there for you with you giving it you know nice little. Strategic goose is a tactical pivot points and then once the markets there then say hey we are going to revalue it Powell calls up their fed calls up Powell says that treasure treasury calls up Powell best calls up Powell says okay revalue it from 42 to.
10,000 it's going to put you know mechanically you can find this in the financial accounting manual for Federal Reserve banks it's a public document online section 2.10. Treasury can call the fed and say revalue the gold it mechanically creates a deposit right into the treasury general account or TGA it's literally money creation using the gold the best and can do pretty much whatever he wants with the 10,000 it's 2.5 trillion at 20,000 it's 5 trillion 5 trillion you could buy back a lot of the treasury market you could buy back it will put it this way you could buy back the entire long end at 5 trillion bucks all of it.
And so paradoxically most people say off goal to 20,000 you know there's no bid for treasuries would need to be he could buy the entire long end. Treasury yields would go down 10 year treasury yields would go down in that case not up would it be inflationary eventually is that what we need yeah if we wanted you know again. We can either win and bring back our defense industrial base or we can have low inflation and a bond market that you know that that requires China and you know all the two preconditions we can't do both inflations in the case so that's why I think they haven't that's what I think they are I think they're eventually going to do that.
You know I think part of it was hey let's try the doge thing first right because we you know real politic is there's a bunch of people who thought they could doge like serious people to me it was like guys look at the math this is like third grade math like come on. But it's a very serious people were like oh yeah they can doge and that's how we'll get out of this okay well have at it right and was like oh we can't doge like oh really that's a surprise huh interesting so I think there were some political things they had to try first. But again the debt doesn't care the interest grows no matter what every day that goes on makes it more likely that this doesn't end in sort of a smooth sort of shift from icon to sand but rather the big goal to running after us after we misjudge the amount of sand relative to the icon.
I mean the debt doesn't move it is interesting that in contrast to like maybe Brazil in the 2000s that the US does seem to have some of these aces up the sleeve right like just like repricing gold and we just suddenly get you know three trillion dollars right the good the the size of the US economy the you know position as the world's reserve access some of these things are beneficial. I want to get back to a term that you use which is like all this paper gold in circulation and I think any any bagless sisters come to this point of the conversation of course they're probably predominantly crypto holdings will get to crypto look in just a minute but it might also be interested in gold right because.
At this point in the cycle what is the. D nationalized asset that central banks are buying its gold it's not yet Bitcoin maybe in the future but it's not yet Bitcoin it's it's gold and so they might be thinking okay well how do I go. By gold then might go log into their brokerage account and see ETFs like GLD and like go just market by that. Paper gold though that's what that is can you talk about like what are the different options for investors to actually hold gold I think I've heard you say you prefer physical gold but like if an investor is doing that in size it's not about stacking gold bars at their home that can't be the solution here right.
Were used to crypto this bear asset that just like you know doesn't require it does require some storage but doesn't require kind of the volume of of storage that gold bars do certainly so. Can't they just buy GLD like or are there other options that you would sort of point people to to recommend on the physical gold side of things it just seems like a more much more cumbersome asset than the digital gold assets that we're used to. So paper gold is a is an all encompassing term that actually has some sort of nuance to it that's worth digging into for one second at the risk of sort of boring people but.
So there's paper gold ETFs right which is a paper claim one to one back by gold and I think all those ETFs have all the gold they claim and that gold sit somewhere was like in London it's somewhere usually in London right you know sometimes elsewhere. But right so that's sort of one form of paper gold that's you know fully reserved paper gold you get into things like gold futures which are sort of levered but there's for every buyer there's a seller but that is there's some amount of leverage in there there's more paper way more paper trading every day. On the comics them there is physical gold that they have by a wide wide margin and but again for in futures for every buyer there's a seller.
Where a lot of the leverage has historically been in that business is the what is called unallocated gold right centered in London you've allocated gold which is I buy gold from you London bank or London branch of an American bank and it is fully allocated in other words. It is mine I've got a number here's the bar bar numbers boom that is mine there is a very long legal precedent that that is my goal then there's unallocated gold which is. Buy me a hundred million dollars a gold done okay and you that is not gold that is gold credit. And if anything happens to that bank you are a general creditor of that bank and there are that at one point in time that unallocated gold number was estimated to be 20x 50x 100x who knows nobody really knows it's a big number within the context of all of this.
That's the most risky sort of paper gold right then futures you know there's leverage involved such that puts and takes but again you don't own gold you can get cash out right the the the in a crisis. You go back to the hunt brothers right when they try to buy up futures to squeeze silver and then take delivery what did what did the powers that be due to them they turn the futures sell only so no longer you could you could no longer buy futures only sell. And they wiped them out and so that's an example of if you don't hold it you don't own it. And when you look at ETFs and various ones again I think they all have the gold they say they do that's not the risk point the risk point is it's sitting in London.
In a lot of cases as in the case of GLD and if there's a real monetary crisis that unallocated gold market. Means there's way more way more people than there are seats when the music stops it's like so fractional reserve it's fraction it's fractionally reserved within the city of London itself and then it becomes a political question you as a GLD or ETF holder are one to one reserve no question. What if the Saudis are shorted gold who's going to get that gold the Saudis the Russians the Chinese or you Mr retail GLD holder retail ETF holder. That's why when you and I don't know the answer to that question why I'm proposing that question is is that is the question every investor in gold needs to ask themselves of their custodium if you want to buy GLD you want to buy any other gold ETF.
Great the risk you are taking is in a real crisis it is entirely possible I'm not saying probable but it is entirely possible that they say Friday you know we have a crisis over a weekend. Sunday night gold trading at some really big number and the ETF goes due to unforeseen market circumstances we're declaring force measure and all holders of this instrument this paper instrument will get cash dollars cash your currency whatever. At the Friday night close closing price of where gold traded not and then you get to take that gold and go out and buy your own gold. I'm Monday morning when it opens at the new price how high is the risk of that happening I don't know but that is is it a tail risk yes is a fat tail risk yes.
Do you trust the Canadian government not to do that to you after the last five years. Do you trust the American government not to do that to you. Ha ha. The Russians are fighting me. Do you agree with who do you trust not to do that to you. So what do you do can you buy you can buy like physical gold you should own gold. That's that's what I'm saying here. I like in size like in a vault that someone else maintains like kind of the coin-based gold. Yeah there are private vault vaulting areas. I mean you can you can do it in a bank security deposit box and there's some risk to that too because in 1933 FDR you know confiscated gold.
When it was money not private property like it is today and you were not allowed to open a bank security deposit box for decades without the presence of a treasury official if there was gold and there they took it. So basically you had to let it sit for years and years and years. There are independent vaults in various cities and you know you'd have to call up where you are in yours where they are outside the banking system. That is what I do because I don't want to be in that banking system. There are allocated gold options held in different vaults around the world that I trust that's how I would do it.
The average investor buys it sort of this western paper you know there's always some element of risk to it. But if you want to own gold you should own gold and understand the risk you're taking. Most investors don't understand the risk they're taking yeah and and misunderstand like oh well I can't you know not saying these ETFs don't have the gold they do. I'm not saying I don't trust the management of them I absolutely do I think they're honest good people trying to write an investment what I'm saying is I don't it's not their choice in a real crisis. Do I trust the western and eastern governments not to grab this stuff.
I don't trust anybody not to grab it look at a lot of listeners. Won't be holding gold or at least not a significant amount of gold because you know we're a crypto podcast. The closest we typically go is Bitcoin. And so there's also just kind of like a general generational mismatch like I'm a younger millennial there are like zoomers are coming online into like you know substantial amounts of wealth. They had to have just golden holding gold just seems a little old school old school I'll say that. And also a lot of people just kind of want to own internet stuff you know like we're internet kids like our lives are on the internet.
And so when I see gold just running. And here you talk about all like the macro transitions to me I'm like yes okay I will let the war of nation state reserve assets unfold you know nation states operate at the law of the jungle they're these titans fighting over the reserve currencies and I'm just going to be patient. And I'm going to hold my crypto because that's the generation that I am and that's my preferred investment strategy. Will that all will all of that everything that we've talked about so far in this episode the gold the debatement trade or not again not the trade just the debatement the gold appreciation to you know $20,000 how much of that do you think trickles down into Bitcoin.
And how patient do you think I'll have to be in order to be on the receiving end of that. Depends I my base cases it will trickle down into Bitcoin. And I think my base case on that is is my confidence in that base case is rising with how we've seen the US government effectively to me trying to marshal Bitcoin into helping it with the stable coin side right they're not saying Bitcoin they know they're only talking about Bitcoin is a strategic Bitcoin reserve. But I think sort of implied in what they're trying to do is stable coins which is essentially just trying to find a large source of repressible balance sheet for the debt.
You know what they're trying to do is stable coins to me I just don't see how it works without a much higher price of Bitcoin. And so I think a lot of it would filter into Bitcoin I think there's a possible world where look what do we do get a hard break. And you end up with what is essentially a contest where the east is standing up gold and the west you know stands up Bitcoin. You know that's that's a possibility to me is it a high degree of possibility not right now but I could see something like that happening it's wait so you think the east so like the China block let's say they could be hard money on the gold side and maybe the US and some of its block might go hard money on the Bitcoin side.
Possibly possibly I mean I'm throwing out a scenario it's not my base case per se but you know I'm personally investing like I've got you know gold and Bitcoin are my two biggest positions. The US very clearly understands that it is no longer in its interest to maintain the dollar system as it has been structured. That is absolutely the case and that is bipartisan at this point almost bipartisan what I think there is still some question is around gold versus Bitcoin I think I think the US administration sees gold as a means to an end right they can't write up Bitcoin and get a bunch of money in the TGA as a magic money machine they can with gold.
And they're still talking about Bitcoin to the east is looking at this going listen we're not going to touch this Bitcoin thing because it doesn't have the history and you know the different rails and you know there is a theory a theoretical risk around quantum and things like that to Bitcoin that doesn't really exist with gold sitting in our vault. And so there's sort of you know I think we could see it those two compete that way you know it's very interesting to me that since 2021 golden Bitcoin are basically the same performance right that's a very long time in Bitcoin years for golden Bitcoin to have basically the same performance that that's different you know when when when relationships change like that.
They can often be the sign that something's happening so I have you know I don't have a strong view on that I have different theoretical ways it could play out that I've thought about but I don't have a strong view on either one I basically I hold gold my whole Bitcoin. And you know I've been making money on both so like that's okay I don't have to be right of making money on both. It seems to be the case Luke that if what David says plays out it might take decades to play out and it might be the case that until say millennials and younger generations are like the central bank gray hairs right it doesn't fully play out maybe that's an element of it.
I think the case for gold that you're making is basically that's the here and now solve to the problem that we have here and now so it's interesting if you just kind of run the numbers you said if the US revalued its goal to you know 20k per ounce or something like that I don't know it's like three to five trillion right right now the amount of Bitcoin the US has is about 35 billion now all note they keep getting more Bitcoin they're not buying it. But they are post Trump strategic Bitcoin reserve which was supposed to be budget budget neutral they are seizing a heck of a lot of it there's two weeks ago they just seized 15 billion more.
And to your point about China who knows how much they have and what they're doing in the background but if they're running the same play on Bitcoin that you seem to think they're running on gold they're not going to tell anybody that they're acquiring. And so maybe this is what's happening in the background but it's got to be the case that this is going to play out over many years and decades because i'm trying to just think through a scenario right now Bitcoin is almost 99% retail owned even institutions that own it kind of filters into pension funds it's not central bank owned how does that flip how do we get to the you know scenario where the majority of Bitcoin is central bank owned does that have to play out over decades.
Probably probably you know it's interesting the US government sees is Bitcoin and they don't sell it right. They don't seize beanie babies and if they do they apparently sell them you know they don't they don't have a classic car reserve right they turn around and they flip it right away right if you see if you see a boat or a car from a drug dealer they don't have a you know they don't have a boat yard somewhere. You know down in Norfolk Virginia of all the seized drug boats that you know you can go rent from the US government it's not what they do so it's it's an interest it'd be an interesting cognitive dissonance triggering question to people like oh this is just you know tulip bulbs or beanie babies like okay well when the US government ceases assets they usually sell them why aren't they selling this if it has no value.
That's I think an important tell it's a dog that doesn't bark how long will it take yeah probably takes a long time in terms of but here too you know it depends on events right I don't know that it'll take decades for the simple reason that AI isn't going to let it take decades. Like I think we're in within two to three years at most of AI causing significant employment disruption and when that comes if when that comes that's the mother of all crises because now you know it's like oh we're going to have all of this AI productivity and we're all going to live in harmony and everyone's going to self actualize and they're going to do art and you know they're going to build architecture and and they sort of write translate all of these sort of you know human self-actualization goals and having been in the rust belt for when China went into the WTO which was the original AI productivity boom right you'll note that economist ask a mainstream economist do they call it the China productivity boom or do they call it the China shock call it the China shock why manufacturing jobs went down 33% in the United States in like heartbeat like five years and then they got papered over with subprime mortgages for a cup of coffee till those blew up and then when those blew up the fed step then and grew their balance sheet and oh by the way a million Americans from 08 to 22 died of drug overdoses and when you factor in suicides and alcoholism the death rate we're at rivaled that of Soviet Russia post Soviet Russia so like there's this happy time talk around like how this is all going to play out with AI it's not going to play out that way well it's going to play out as it's going to get here fast and then we think it's going to cause more job disruption than we think it's going to cause it among white color workers who all have mortgages good jobs mortgages car loans you're going to start to see car loans decline in value you're going to start to see home loans decline in value and all of a sudden you start to see banks running to trouble in consumer loans it's already starting on some level arguably perhaps certainly you can see unemployment among bachelor degree 20 to 24 year old is 7 percent you take overall unemployment in this country to 7 percent the whole thing goes and we know how they're going to react when I say what that means that is stocks down for a second GDP down for a second 10 year yields down for like two days and then they take off like a scalded cat higher in a recession and then the fed comes in and goes whatever it takes will print it all well just at some form a yield curve control and when that happens right what we're really talking about here is why I say it'll happen faster than decades when I really think about it is the debt is an exponential doing this AI is an exponential doing this we put the two together this bottom the middle is the amount of money they need to print to keep the banks whole when this goes like this and because they're exponentials the amount of money they need to print to keep the banks whole when AI does what it's going to do and the debt does what it's going to do is doing approaches infinity very quickly and once that happens then you get to a spot where it's like you better have gold you better have Bitcoin and that's you know I don't think they'll be discerning at that point that might force central banks to do it do you have any view on the cycle so the here in the now so you I think are very much in the mindset of a long-term investor and your patient who willing to let this play out over years and decades and you expect volatility along the way think in the mindset of the crypto investor right now everything has played out in crypto and cycles we get these four year cycles looks like it's the end of a cycle at least from the online perspective for Bitcoin and people are looking at gold and saying hey that's the debatement trade but we have Bitcoin over here and that's also a debatement trade I'm using the term trade because people are looking at this in the short run too and they're saying gold is just moved up to 30 trillion dollars it's time now for the Bitcoin catch-up trade so do you think it's as simple as that do you think sometime in the next six months or so given the the move that gold has had that Bitcoin is just bound to catch up as maybe it was tight more tightly correlated in in 2020 and 2021 or times when it's not been correlated but there are times where it is correlated could this be one of those times you have the view on this not a strong view other than just sort of as a you know patient investor I have noticed it's sort of you know gold goes and Bitcoin goes and gold goes and Bitcoin goes and so I would be open to that happening again until proven otherwise basically I'm also you know not to you know like the the two-handed economist right like you know on the other hand you we are getting to that time of of a four-year cycle where historically Bitcoin hasn't done great right so in my own mind it's something I do think about of like hey where you know which of these two are we going to get that have tended to happen Bitcoin chases gold after a big gold move or you know Bitcoin has a lousy nine to twelve months at the end of a four-year cycle I don't have a strong view either way I'm open to both some of it depends on again on events right if if we get some sort of big deflationary aspect I'd probably shade more towards the latter than the former but it doesn't look like we're getting that so I'm still you know gun to my head I think it's more likely that Bitcoin chases gold higher than it is then then Bitcoin sort of you know falls apart here for you know the next nine to twelve months like it did in whatever I guess 2021 you know kind of peaked in what November December of 2021 and then it was like you know 12 months of getting kicked in the nuts every day for you know for for 12 months but I it's it's not like I'm like oh I'm so confident it's going to chase gold I'm not that confident I hope it's my base case but anyway my base case by a lot so you know we'll see Luke there's going to be a lot of listeners who are just going to shut down this podcast and go look at options to buying gold probably but I know I am tokenized gold is a growing sector of the crypto world there's like two pretty good like quality products tokenized gold products on Ethereum one from Paxos one from Tether just what's your first thought that comes to mind when you think about these tokenized gold products look I think they are really interesting products that I think they're good products again I think to me you still end up having that same risk ultimately right you're trading it comes down to what do you think your risk is you know your risk you know your benefit of liquidity and ease of use right it's very easy to use and spend and I think that's a good thing relative to your risk of risk if we have a real crisis where you really need gold where governments really need gold like you know the guys with the guns are going to go knock on the doors of the vaults and go you know yeah I know this is backing this centralized instrument cash settle have a good day and you know they'll be able to sue and this and that and the other but suing the government in times of emergency when you need to keep like the bank's whole when you need to keep the system whole not a real long track record of success like good luck legally and at the very least you're going to have you know years and years while you're waiting so you know to me again I'm not telling people oh we have to get rid of those things anything like that I just think as an investor understand the risks you're taking understand the game you're playing you know like you were saying before millennial zoomers like then even I'm a gen XR right I've never really a gen XR in America have never seen that type in environment I have friends that are Ukrainian they immigrated here 20 years ago and they tell me about 1998 when they're like hey we had enough money in the bank to buy five cars real richest family in the village and then they weekend they closed the banks and when they reopen them a week or two weeks later the money that did buy five cars bought a months of groceries and if I had gold I did great and and if I had silver I did dios fine and if I didn't they just stole my wealth that was it that they accumulated wealth of years and years this is something that Americans think can never happen even though it has happened in this country this is something Canadians think could never happen even though they watch the whole trucker protest and this sort of increasing authoritarian creep of western governments you want to get into the UK right do I trust these governments not to do that like governments for time immemorial when they find themselves in a pinch do that that's like what they do and so I would just encourage people to understand like we are off the reservation in terms of the overton window of policy options because we are off the reservation in terms of crises and how bad and how quickly this could get and so look the answer might be you know if you're a sort of a crypto native person you know own selling you want to own gold own some of that but then buy some coins too like the you know what's the worst thing it's going to happen like you know you got to go sell the coins at some point oh by the way you know you can sell coins to a coin dealer American gold Eagles or Canadian Maple Leafs up to 25 a year and there's no reporting requirements in America to the you know for the dealer so you get you know four thousand dollars in cash from a dealer it's like Schrodinger's investment did you make money on gold did you have gold you know as long as you're not you know like the guys in good fell doesn't go out and buy a fur and a car like you know you know that's not a solution for 20 30 50 million dollars of course but for like the average sort of you know millennial zoom or who's probably doesn't have 20 50 hundred million dollars to invest in gold like look by five gold coins stick them in your sock drawer and then what it's time to do what the old timers do right the gold one of the gold dealers I talk to he's like oh yeah like where'd you source these one ounce coins they go there's an old timer around the corner and you know he bought gold every week for years at 200 or 300 400 600 800 thousand and now once a month he comes in he sells a coin we give him his cash and he buys groceries and he pays for gas and he gives his grandkids some money and you know what right so that's what I would you know I'm not encouraging everybody to cheat under taxes I'm not encouraging I want to cheat under tax I'm simply telling you the rules you make your own decisions and I'm not telling people not to own centralized gold back throughout this I'm simply on telling you what the potential tail risks are there that I think you need to hedge because we're in sort of you know we're off the reservation in terms of where we are there are risks like that property rights risks in a debatement trend line for certain and we've seen them in America just look at the 1933 FDR executive order everybody turning near your gold type of things we could go on just about that alone I want to maybe close with this Luke so I think you've called this a hundred year reset right and it does feel like the pendulum is kind of swinging back from treasuries and from the US dollars the world reserve currency and treasuries is the world reserve asset to something else maybe something like gold sounds like you would advise the the typical investor to think about gold in their portfolio and maybe actually I want you to put it more strongly what what is a portfolio to have some family protection let's say during this 100 year reset what are the assets and percent concentrations that people should consider listening to this for me I think the ideal portfolio for for most investors is something that that approximates the advice that Jacob Fouger gave who was the richest man in history on a percentage GDP basis he was he was a Dutch merchant in the middle ages I could be wrong I apologize if he's of another nationality someone to get offended but anyway he recommended 25 percent gold 25 percent cash 25 percent real estate 25 percent essentially equities and you know productive real estate right so Timberland or farmland or something and then rebalance over time and interestingly Ray Dahlia who's obviously been very successful that's essentially a model for his all-weather portfolio or was and I think that that's as we sit here today knowing what I know I think that's probably for most investors pretty wise right like you know the the you know 25 percent in for me it's some combination of golden Bitcoin depending on your age depending on your volatility tolerance you know either if you're younger it's probably more Bitcoin less gold if you're older it's you know a little sliver a bit coin and mostly gold productive real estate you know whether it's Timberland farmland you know some sort of rental things and and attractive areas equities I think you know I think there's certain areas of equities are you know for me I would rather own industrials and certain sort of you know commodity assets at this point of the cycle than I would than I would some of the the more frothy or tech stuff but you know that's that depends on one's personal preference and then look with cash still yielding almost 4 percent that is both I think a volatility buffer and a and an optionality right you know if if if we wake up and gold is cut in half or Bitcoin's cut in half like that gives me out the ability to play the long game I'm gonna take some out of that cash I'm gonna buy more and and you know likewise with equities etc so if I think for most investors that's the right portfolio I don't want to own long-term government bonds I understand maybe there's a trade here they maybe they might rally if they do yield curve control but it's such an inefficient way to play yield curve control right of like oh well they set the yield curve control limit at two and the 10 years gone from four to two and I made you know you're gonna make decent money not as much as you're gonna make own a Bitcoin or gold or equities they're gonna go bonkers on the upside so you know when the government needs to financially repress you like why it's like Indiana Jones will continue with the metaphor right and last crusade right where he's running through and there's like you know the you know the knives coming through and all the bodies from people that have gotten cut up and passed attempts like why like just just sit tight and wait for like you know you know just you don't need it doesn't need to be that complex Luke this has been great fantastic takes I mean you you've got to feel good about how some of your predictions have held up here especially recently and I'll remind bankless listeners that they can access all of Luke's brain maybe not all of it but much of his investor brain including a ton of data including a ton of charts at forest for the trees capital fftt hyphen LLC dot com you absolutely must sign up for the newsletter we'll leave it there Luke thank you so much for joining us today thanks for me and it was great talking to you guys again I appreciate you man bankless station got to let you know none of this has been financial advice crypto's risky gold is risky but my god so is the basement you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us in the bankless journey thanks a