Tracheopteryx is the founder of Coordinape, the intersubjective coordination tool. Coordinape allows DAO contributors to collectively reward each other as an alternate—and more elegant—means of compensating work & value.
Trach has been on a podcast circuit lately, cruising through big cerebral topics orbiting DAO coordination and biomimicry.—addressing technology and civilization from a biological perspective is underrated.
How do we shift from a ‘command & control’ approach to ‘sense & respond’? How can we take lessons from nature and plug them into novel systems powered by technology?
------ 📣 CONSENSYS | M·A·C: NFT Collection for a Good Cause https://bankless.cc/MAC
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALED ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🏦 ALTO IRA | TAX-FREE CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/AltoIRA
👻 AAVE V3 | LEND & BORROW CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/aave
⚡️ MAKER DAO | THE DAI STABLECOIN https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
------ Topics Covered:
4:30 Tracheopteryx & Biology 10:25 Sense & Respond 16:04 Organizational Empathy 21:25 The Digital Shift 27:43 The 100 Year Plan 33:17 Trach’s ETH Denver Talk 40:15 DAO Coordination 46:00 Are We Ready for This? 54:38 Guide for DAOers 1:01:58 DAO Tooling 1:07:51 Crypto Culture 1:16:20 Create Your Reality 1:22:35 Legacy and Art 1:28:20 A Quest for Freedom
------ Resources:
Tracheopteryx on Twitter: https://twitter.com/tracheopteryx?s=20&t=0h3kPUe5VlnDmfCi1bpAfg
Trach's ETHDenver Talk: https://youtu.be/anDAtWrhDnE
Yearn Finance: https://twitter.com/iearnfinance?s=20&t=0h3kPUe5VlnDmfCi1bpAfg
Coordinape: https://twitter.com/coordinape?s=20&t=0h3kPUe5VlnDmfCi1bpAfg
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
It's like going from the nation-state environment of who can command and control the best, going to a digital nation-state environment, which is who has the best carrots, and which has got to be a sense in response. Like, who can sense the needs of their constituents, the best, and respond to the needs of their constituents the best? Welcome to Layer 0. Layer 0 is a podcast of unscripted conversations with the people that make up the Ethereum community. Crypto is built by code, is composed by people, and each individual member of the crypto community has their own story to tell. CypherPunks understood that the code they write impacts the people that use it, and Layer 0 focuses on the people behind the code, because Ethereum is people all the way down, and it always has been.
Today, on Layer 0, I'm talking with Tricky Optrix. He has been on a number of podcasts, talking about very big cerebral topics about DAO's, DAO coordination, how DAO coordination mimics nature, and this is all stuff that just really gets my mind going, and I just love all of these very just like far out subjects. As you can tell, if you've been listening to the Layer 0 podcast, so we talk about how one of the most underappreciated lens for viewing this crypto industry is one of biology, how DAO's will have bio mimicry in their organizational structure, and how just computers will become part of humans, as we know, like we're building out AI, but it's not going to be external to us, it's going to be a part of us, like our DAO's, and so we are just creating these technologically enabled futures, these technologically enabled humans, with AI, but also with DAO's, and DAO's being one of these stories.
We talk about how DAO's can help change society from being one of command and control to one of being sense and respond, and how does that change culture when our organizations, our institutions don't have this scarcity mentality of resource competition, but instead have this competition of how best can they sense the needs of their constituents and respond to the needs of their constituents with the best possible carrot. There's so many different angles of this conversation that I thoroughly enjoyed with Chakyock Dricks, so I think you will also enjoy this conversation as well, so let's go ahead and get right into this conversation, but first a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible.
If you're trying to grow and preserve your crypto wealth, optimizing your taxes is just as lucrative, is trying to find the next hidden gem. Also IRA can help you invest in crypto in tax advantage ways to help you preserve your hard earned money. Also crypto IRA lets you invest in more than 150 coins and tokens, with all the same tax advantages of an IRA. They make it easy to fund your alternative IRA or crypto IRA via your 401k or by contributing directly from your bank account. There is no setup or account fees and it's all you need to do to invest in crypto tax-free. Let me repeat that again.
You can invest in crypto tax-free. Diversify like the pros and trade without tax headaches. Open in ALTO crypto IRA to invest in crypto tax-free. Let's go to ALTOIRA.com slash bankless. That's ALTOIRA.com slash bankless and start investing in crypto today. The layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day and we need bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a layer 2 life. Across is the fastest, cheapest, and most secure, cross-chain bridge. With a cross you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets to the chain of your choice.
Access are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously. Across bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens from layer 2 back to Ethereum. A token proposal is being deliberated as we speak in the across forum where community members will decide on the token distribution. You can have your part of across the story by joining the discord and becoming a co-founder and helping to design the fair, fair launch of the cross. If you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely, go to across.to to bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Arbitrum, or Boba Networks.
Arbitrum is an Ethereum layer 2 scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Over 300 projects have already deployed to Arbitrum and a DeFi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly. Some of the coolest and newest NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home. All the wild DeFi protocols continue to see increased usage and liquidity. Using Arbitrum has never been easier, especially with the ability to deposit directly into Arbitrum through all the exchanges including Binance, FTX, Quoby, and Crypto.com. Once inside you'll notice Arbitrum increases Ethereum speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee.
If you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users, visit Arbitrum.io slash developer to start building your DAP on Arbitrum. If you're a DGen, many of your favorite DAPs on Ethereum are already on Arbitrum with many moving over every day. Go to bridge.arbitrum.io now to start bridging over your ETH and other tokens in order to experience DeFi and NFTs in the way it was always meant to be. Fast, cheap, secure, and friction-free. What's up, Drake? How's it going? Good man. How are you? Oh, fantastic. Fantastic. You've been on the podcast circuit lately, and I think everyone is realizing that you have a lot of interesting things to say.
And so I'm bringing you on this podcast because I think I can do it better. Let's do it. That's great. Thank you. I've said it a few times on the show before, but I think the most underappreciated lens for viewing this industry is biology, and that's why I appreciate your takes the most is because we're looking towards nature for guidance, more than just trying to pop down architects, create this thing without any feeling around in the dark. Like crypto, it's a new frontier. We don't really know what we're doing here. We get some semblance of an idea, but I think looking to nature is one of the best guiding lights that we have in this industry.
I'm wondering your thoughts on that to kick this conversation going. Absolutely. And just in general, I'm always looking at ways to expand my perspective and like step back and see things from another angle. And I think we can get so caught up in what we're doing that's just everything's within this one little space and becomes topological or something. It's all just in here. And then biology is one bigger lens we can look at. And there's many, many others to step back and reframe the context of what we're doing. Do you remember like a first early moment or a ha moment where you're like, hey, this crypto thing relates to nature pretty well.
Do you remember the first realization you had with that? Yeah, let's see. I think it was basically right right away. I've always been interested in developmental psychology and bio and physics and various sciences and I tend to like see echoes of things everywhere. And so I think one of the things that really drew me to crypto is Dows. That was the thing that from the beginning that that idea. And to me, that was always part of a kind of biological framing. Release how it resonated with me. And was it strictly like the org structure of Dows or how Dows coordinate you thought was going to be like nature mimicking nature in some way or what was the angle?
Well, I guess just I've never really agreed with this idea that we're different than other things, you know, like like it's all like, okay, so we have computers and we have technology, but really that's just another extension of the phenotype that's another part of this organism. It's all kind of where you draw the circle and how you draw a boundary around something, what you define the self, like it gets very confusing. You look at bees or at ant colonies or at siphonophores or all of these different or the bacteria in your gut or whatever and this notion of identity really melts away as soon as you kind of interrogate it.
And so yeah, like the human condition of trying to create things and working together, like I ran a started a bunch of companies and ran teams and things like that. And to me, it's always very much about that interpersonal piece. And that always felt like part of some expanding mammal broad set or something, you know, it's always just some like piece of turbulence. And so, you know, the idea that a Dow could put this structure together that can hold these types of interpersonal dynamics and this creative energies, you know, is the kind of the the first thing I thought when I saw them. I can't remember where I heard this first, but if you look like at a beehive or an ant colony and you're looking at like the bees in the ants, the organism itself isn't the individual ant or the individual bee.
It's the hive itself, like it's which makes it intangible, which is kind of cool. Like there is no actual center of a beehive of the organism. It's just like the whole many, many individual moving parts. And when you talk about the self, like you can even get into the human body and talk about our individual selves, like we have our body, which is our container, but our cells come and go, our brain cells come and go. And you alluded to it like your gut microbiome, which is a very critical part of who you are, literally is not part of you. And how we have you extended this concept of what is alive to douse?
Like what is alive with a douse? Well, it's you can very easily get into kind of like semantic corruption here by stretching the definition down, but let's not worry about that for a second and just play with it. And so you can think about like the douse within. You can think that just like you say, like it's a little bit more obvious when you look at a beehive, but it's the same problem when you look at a human being. You know, there's a notion of cellular psychology or you know, on the bacteria and all of these different pieces that create this colony that is me. And there has a lot of the same kind of relationships, dynamics as a organization as, and you can look at a company like Apple, you know, and you can think of that as a life form.
You really can. The definition of life is pretty flexible and you can at least it's worth, you know, the curious thought experiment of thinking about it that way. And think about what it, if you draw the boundary of life around that organism, what does that do? And how does that function? And then around a douse and just keep drawing different circles and seeing how they they compare. Yeah, the way that I try and like understand, if something is alive or not, is if it is self-interested in its own well-being, right? And so Apple certainly self-interested in its own well-being, right? And we'll take both defensive and aggressive moves in order to make sure that it stays alive.
And so like, you know, if it's self-interested and it's actionable, it is alive, like whether it's like a cell or a company or a doubt. And I think like when life begins, like when some sort of life form forms, like we started off as singular cellular organisms, but then we started appending on like newer structures onto these cells that could sense the world around it, right? Like receive inputs and allow it to process data. And so I think what, a lot of like what your work has been doing over at Cordenape is like building out like one of the first appendages that allows douse to like receive inputs to make sure that the douse can know about the information that it needs to know in order to self-perpetuate its own ideas into the future.
How do you feel about this? Yeah, I love it. I mean, whenever I'm building things, I'm thinking about biology and science fiction and fucking spirits and all the different weird things, you know, like that's the terrain I'm walking. And so like with Cordenape, yeah, I think of it like that like an organ, you know, and particularly like I love this idea of sense and response, which I think I heard from Zach Anderson first, who's a co-founder of Cordenape, which is a totally different kind of modality for operating, you know, rather than just command and control of this kind of dichotomy as one I often use, like where most corporations and nations about command and control this idea that wait, we can actually work in a different way, which is like listen and react, you know, sense and respond.
And like what do what do tools look like? What do apps look like that are designed in that way and to support that kind of interpersonal anti-riverous behavior? Do you have any just thoughts about like what society looks like when it migrates from a command and control dominated version of coordination versus a sense and respond like version of coordination? Like if we all if we all shift on the spectrum from command and control to a sense and respond, like how would society be different? Well, I think the first thing is that we won't like there's we won't all do that, right? And like there's always just a super heterogeneous diverse population of people.
There's always going to be people that are in arrival risk mentality. There's always going to be people that, you know, are in scarcity ideas and that's okay. I think it's but to the to the point of your question, I think there it does become a threshold where there's enough people that are starting to work in this sense and respond abundance mindset that things really do start to change. And I really like one of my kind of favorite thinkers Ken Wilber talks about, you know, in the in the 60s there was a similar kind of big mindset change, the countercultural movement, you know, which he looks at as being this kind of developmental tier.
It's kind of pluralistic intelligence or the sensitive intelligence. And because about like, you know, 10% of the world around that time started to have this level of development, it created these huge systemic changes. And I think we're at a similar, you know, not just me, a lot of people I've read and others think that we're at a kind of similar focus right now and that this new level of development, this new intelligent kind of integral or sense and respond or nonribal risk is starting to get enough. There's enough people with running this operating system, you know, that things like you know, the dows that we work in happen.
You indicated that like the whole command and control type of modalities, one of of a scarcity mindset. Is that true or like can you go into that? Why is command and control a scarcity mindset and why is sensor and spawned abundance? Yeah, that's a good question. So I can't say that they are both like synonymous, but I think they tend to align more. So like what's the point, right? Like it kind of goes back to that just that question. What's the point? What world view are we operating from? You know, if you're operating from a world view where you're going to die unless you take this other dude's shit, you know, a command and control like program makes a little bit more sense.
It's like let me control all the variables, make sure that I'm safe, you know, create a strategy that I can then execute to get the reward and then I'm good. And the thing about those strategies first is that they're really closed. It's like in my little brain, my little view of things like I can control all the variables and like probablyistically I'm going to get the thing that I want and that's going to be good. Like when I get that scarce resource now, I've won. But we know that that's never really the case. You just want another scarce resource and another scarce resource and that doesn't actually solve the problem of trying to say it.
So you come from a different world view. One that's more about the journey than the destination, sense and respond makes a lot more sense. And I think it tends, I have to think about this more, but I think you could use sense and respond in a scarcity dynamic as a type of strategy. But I think it's more natural fit for different kinds. Yeah. A sense and respond organism, whether it's like something as small as a B or a human or something as large as like an organization, corporation or a nation state, sense and respond seems to have connotations of like empathy and cooperation. And certainly, I think it would be I think I could say without without you know, too much evidence that people, the culture of today is we are looking for institutions and corporations that have more empathy.
I think it's something that a lot of like perhaps the left but like has really nailed down. But I think we're all kind of looking for it. Is that like these ultra capitalist like late stage capitalist large corporations are all lacking empathy, right? And maybe it's because they're all operating on this command and control paradigm. And they don't have this sense and respond paradigm. So there's a thought. If you have any reflections on that one, go ahead. Yeah. Go for it. Yeah. Yeah. I think that's very true. And there's a lot of ways to look at that. First of all, it can be strategically advantageous advantageous to like numb your own empathy if you're in a really hostile environment.
So like there's nothing wrong. First is like, you know, if people haven't developed empathy or they're functioning in a kind of low empathy environment, like I don't want to cast any blame or shame, they're like that that can be the best thing that that person needs to do. And you know, I think a lot of the systemic issues in the world do come from a lack of empathy. I mean, what are we talking about coordination issues? How do we how do we share resources together? And if you if you know, for playing the resource game, resource war game, you know, then you know, we're really depleting the resources on the planet too fast.
And I think, you know, it also goes to notions of divine masculine and feminine. And I don't mean female sex, male sex. I mean, you know, the idea of, you know, receptive and transmitting and listening and speaking. And the world has been really dominated by a kind of masculine energy for the past long time. I don't know, thousand years or something. And that's manifested through nation's conquest and corporations conquest and command and controller both these very like, you know, emissive like controlling ideas of subjugating, you know, things. Whereas sensing is more receptive. It's more more the divine feminine and also just more the feminine energy that each of us can source within ourselves.
That the world isn't kind of dire need for, which also tends to be more empathic because you're you're listening. Do you know if we've ever had a paradigm of sense in respond before? You alluded to like the counter culture revolution in the 60s and how that became a very strong component of society. But I don't think it necessarily resulted in a complete phase shift from command and control to sense in respond. Do you know if we've ever had a society of that was dominated by sense in respond? It's a really good question. I mean, I think from the little I've read about, you know, tribal communities, I think there's some examples in those types of networks where it is much more like, you know, you have a really strong matriarchy and a really strong patriarchy and they both have different roles in the community and then you have shaman and you have outliers and, you know, altogether the tribe becomes this kind of organism that can work in balance with the world.
So sensing responds much more about balance. Like so much of the command and control stuff that's happened has been about the opposite about conquest, you know, expansion by all means cancerous growth by all means. But that's part of that, you know, critical operating system change is to get into a mode of balance with the environment and each other. Right. So if you're if I'm interpreting your answer correctly, you just said like we haven't had like a strong dominance of sense in response since we were hunter gatherers, which was, you know, many, many, many thousands of years ago is basically before we invented any meaningful amount of technology, right?
Like the first version of technology we really invented was the agricultural revolution. And it's been command and control ever since. It's been concrete. It's been the resource game is playing the the resource game aggressively ever since then. Yeah, that's, I mean, I certainly don't have a comprehensive knowledge of everything here, but that sounds right in a lot of ways. And, you know, I was thinking about this the other day talking to Kevin Awaki like that, you know, from from the moment of agriculture, like there's some interesting research showing that like when agriculture as well, we stopped being hunter gatherers, we started having, you know, need to be rooted in certain areas.
And then all of a sudden this notion of paternity certainty became important. Whereas before there was much more kind of free love and families like raise the children's tribes, raise the children's together, all of a sudden now you have property and you need to staff that property and you staff that property with your children. And so you need to know who your children are, you know, all of a sudden there's the notion of labor and a workforce right at the beginning. And I think you maybe we can think like look there's this kind of, you know, all of a sudden masculine imbalance that emerges. Oh, that's super interesting.
Right. Okay. So going from hunter gatherers to agricultural revolution is we stopped moving around this society and the action of stopping and like planting ourselves into one place on the earth because that's where we would need to grow food, right? Like you can't move your farm. So obviously when we stopped being nomadic, when we stopped, we started being fixed and that allowed people to have more things because then we didn't have to move with them. We could just keep them, you know, in our huts in our houses. And then we established property and then that turned the resource game into like the next level, right?
Where it's more than the things we can carry on our backs, it's like the things around us. And then all of a sudden that kicked off a much more aggressive and less holistically coordinated version of society. Is this the right conclusion to be tracking on? I let's go with this because I think there's a lot of far out ideas that come from this. So we can say that there's been this kind of arc in in history that has started from that transmission transition to agriculture where all of a sudden you're like locked in a location all the way to, let's say, even 2020 where I love this thing, Balaji Road, which was that 2020 was the first year that we became digital first citizens, you know?
Yeah. And I think that that was this kind of germination event of COVID that forced us all to like move into this new territory of the digital network. And the crazy thing is that that starts to change that constraint of place because we've been really stuck into this notion of place and property for 10,000 years. And so if we want, like, let's say that that's the arc that we've just come to the end of a 10,000 year arc in human evolution. And now there's this opportunity to move around more, you know, like, but move around in this digital space, which has totally new properties. And you know, when I think about this comes kind of goes back to Dao's, Dao's, you know, this idea of cloud nations too, that we'll be able to create these digital societies and like, look, there's lots of questions about that.
We're already creating them, but one cool thing is a kind of modular politics where, you know, if Dao's or digital communities can start to intermediate between governance, legacy government, like nation states and corporations and start to take more power and hold more power, which I think they will, because they can outcompete financially in many ways, then we'll be able to have this ability to choose our allegiance very easily without moving our physical location, which is like, actually goes back to this interesting idea I learned about a number of years ago, sea-steading by Patrick Friedman was this really the idea of the kind of modular politics that the reason that we're fucked is that, you know, we can't move very easily, the cost of moving is so high, so you can't change your politics, but if everybody would live on a boat and we just tied the boats up into a giant island in the ocean, then you could just sail your boat to a different political island if you wanted to to like, you know, but we don't have to have boats, we can just do it on on blockchain.
Right, right, yeah, the every single Dao or every single like nation state in the cloud is inherently opt-in, right? Like nothing can force you to become a part of it. This is something that's also in the sovereign individual where all these nation states compete on monopolies of violence as in like, who can have the strongest armies? Because if you have the strongest army, then you control the world. And something I actually got out of Bitcoiners in their reaction to, their very, very strong reaction to COVID is that like a lot of countries started like locking in their citizens. Like you couldn't leave Australia for like two years, almost, without like a lot of friction.
And really the only people that could leave Australia are the wealthy, or the people that are wealthy enough to afford it, you know, being able to like lock themselves into a hotel for two weeks because that was a quarantine protocol. And Australia wasn't the only one. That was like a lot of countries like that. And like as the arc of nation states comes to an end, they get more aggro with controlling their property. And one of their nation state properties is their humans that live inside of them, like that's where they get their tax money from. And so the arc of nation states is as they kind of come to the end of their lifespan, they start to clamp down harder and harder and harder on taxes and on their citizens.
Meanwhile, and I think we all kind of feel like we're coming towards the end of the nation state arc, nation state arc. Meanwhile, we're creating these digital nation states, which are inherently opt-in, which we can choose to align with based on our own personal values. And one of my talks at East Denver was about how Web 3 protocols are going to compete for our love. Because of this opt-in forcing function, they can only compete with our love for our love because they don't have any, they only have carrots. They don't have any sticks, right? And so it's inherently a sense and respond competitive environment.
It's like going from the nation state environment of who can command and control the best, going to a digital nation state environment, which is who has the best carrots and which has got to be a sense and respond like who can sense the needs of their constituents the best and respond to the needs of their constituents the best. Yeah, I mean, it's a much more sovereign kind of place to be, right? And I think, you know, you can look back and you can see this kind of trajectory of these different dominant coordination methodologies, basically, like or phenomena, like religion for a long time was the dominant coordination story on the planet.
Like most of the human interpersonal relationships were mediated through that fiction of religion. But that didn't go away when the nation state started to rise to dominance. Like, just it started to take some of that coordination function into its sphere. And then the same thing happened with the privatization of so many services through corporations, you know, private prisons and private services, everything like that. And I think we're going to start to see the same thing now with on with Web 3. And for instance, privatization of governance and politics and public goods can all be better, you know, coordinated through these substrates.
So really big claim, right? And I love the idea that makes sense to me if we zoom out and look at this industry from the hundred year time frames, like, oh, yeah, Dows will eventually be able to coordinate global resources and coordinate governance way better than nation states. But then it feels like one of those things where it's like, you know, step one created Dows, step two, question mark, question mark, question mark, step three, we crossed the world. Like, yes, this, this step two thing I'm really confused about. Don't worry about the details, man. We got this covered. Sign your check right here, please.
Okay, do you have any ideas? I was like, what is like the first few steps we need in order to actually unbundle the role of the nation state? Yeah, I mean, I have some ideas. And I think, I think the important thing is like really early, right? Like, so we're having all these grand ideas. And that's great, you know, that's, that's, it's inspiring. Like, like people are asking me to talk about this stuff. I don't know. Fuck, I'm saying or just spouting bullshit. And like, there's all these beautiful sci-fi fantasy ideas and like, those are great. Those are, let's not forget about the value of those.
And look, why are they coming up? Because we're seeing some like, some hooks, some anchor in this stuff that we don't know and should about yet. But we're like, maybe, maybe, maybe, right? But now I think one of the things that I'm starting to do this work with a couple of people now is to really look at the, the problems, like in, in really, really, really high detail, like, like, like, Daniel Schmachtinbacher's work and Jordan Hall on the metacrisis. And so working with those guys and like, like, can we define the nature of the kind of systemic problems? Because it's so, it's so hard to figure out, like, that's a long rabbit hole.
But just defining what the problems are and then what the design constraints are for solving them. And then seeing like, hey, do dows, like, can we probably say that dows have the mechanisms or can they have a shown potential for solving these problems? Because we're stuck in this, you know, bad Nash equilibrium right now, where, you know, in this nation-state, you know, resource war corporate world that we can't get out of, do dows really fundamentally change that equilibrium. And we have to actually do the work of proving that. So, okay, we're like, it's still a cool-aid time. That's fine. Not going to knock it.
It's great. I drink it too. And we have to like, really drill down now. Right, right. I'm going to ask you the same question. Like, where do we start? Like, what is the first thing that we do with that, what's the first w that dows have that's going to like, wake up the rest of the world to be like, okay, that's a real thing now. Let's see. Well, I think we're already starting to see some of them, you know, like, like these massive kind of flash dows that coordinate to buy historical relics and other things like that. I think that's interesting, but that's just like kind of like one little like, oh, wow, what's that?
And we're seeing these, you know, defy dows that are, you know, doing these incredibly financial things that are kind of like, oh, that's interesting. But, you know, we're not solving major governance problems yet. Right. I wouldn't suggest that, you know, apply a doubt to the actual governance of a political territory yet. But, um, I think we're going to start seeing some, uh, some impact there. Like, you can imagine some cases where you use dows or web three coordination to start to become part of it, not just through like donating to Ukraine, but like through some type of decision making or some type of public policy sense making.
Um, I think that potentially one way that we start to really see more provable goods. Yeah. I was talking with a Taroon on a layer zero and he had the idea that, um, the first way we do this is actually through the financial industry. Uh, so like, uh, financial industry is all lawyers and contracts. So like, you put money into the financial industry. It goes through a lawyer written contract and then it goes out and turns into finance. Right. Like, um, all finance is the combination of contracts and money. That's why smart contracts are really cool. That's how DeFi exists. But importantly, like a lot of, uh, he, he talks about how like a lot of the financial industry can be unbundled and like, um, uh, put on and, and start to use like crypto rails.
And not, and I'm not talking about just creating DeFi like, like, disintermediating Wall Street. Well, what I'm talking about is like, some certain like financial contracts need to have the price of something in the, in the contract, right? And so the price of something could be in that contract could reference something like a uniswap oracle, right? Uh, and then it's the uniswap oracle that becomes the arbiter of truth. Uh, and we can start to like, you know, expand on this and all of a sudden the financial industry is being made easier because it's tapping into the truth of DeFi rather than just like hard coding it into their manually inputted smart contract.
Uh, and then all of a sudden the, the financial industry back end starts to become whatever the state on Ethereum is. Uh, and then, and then we kind of go from there. Where do your thoughts on that? Yeah. So I mean, the kind of like the disruptive innovation model, where like it just, we're starting to do work in this space that, you know, isn't the same territory that the traditional model has, has taken and it all of a sudden becomes useful and it's a better product and they start to use it for things and all of a sudden eats away at the whole system. I can see that happening. Sure. Yeah. Well, your talk at East Denver was really interesting because you, you gave a bunch of like, uh, uh, I don't know what like, like, if like like a scan of, uh, of an organism, right?
And, uh, like really unbundled and you could see the different parts of the organism and the functioning roles and you map that out into like a metaphor, it's like, well, this part of the organism is like this part of the Dow, right? And this part of the organism was like this part of the Dow. Uh, and one thing I think what that we're seeing is that like, Dow's are kind of a little bit of the epicenter for a lot of things in crypto. It was like, first we had DeFi protocols and then separately we had Dow's and then all of a sudden in like the, the DeFi summer, what that really was was the smashing of these two particles together of was like, let's put the DeFi protocol into the Dow and like have this same thing, right?
And we're actually seeing element finance do that right now. So they just launched their token. Uh, so now the element DeFi application is now being put together with the element Dow, but they're also appending on an NFT project. And so now like, what is element? Is it really a DeFi project? Because now it's also a Dow, but it also has its own NFT ecosystem. And so now like this Dow has like three appendages, like it's got the prefrontal cortex, which is the Dow. That's the decision-making. Uh, then you've got like the, the digestive system, which is how the Dow gets energy, which is the DeFi app.
Uh, then you have like the, the cultural expression, which is like the NFT thing. Uh, and so like these are the three things. And, and I think like for every single thing that we invent in this crypto space, like the Dow will be at the end of the center and we'll just keep on like appending all of these things into how and then boom, we have an organism that is like a sense and feel and respond type organism. Uh, that's on that. And you can, can you also kind of just give listeners who haven't listened to your, uh, your East Denver talk just like a taste of what that was about? Yeah, I was talking a lot about different like biological models for decision-making and minds basically.
Like, um, like you can look at, so the amazing thing about web three is we have this like kind of unconstrained networks. Like you can, all these different people can come together and work on things and whatever way you want in a much, much more free and open topography than we're used to in a corporation, let's say, uh, where there's very strict, often roles and reporting and everything. But now is everybody swarmed together and do something. And so like what type of nature of mind does this create? Like, you know, you, you can look at the corporate, uh, kind of model for a mind. And I kind of, uh, use the metaphor of a robot there where you have like a sensor processing unit and you have sensors that send information up the direct report to the process or makes decisions and then sends electrical impulses to the actuators that then executed exactly versus like a slime mold, which is more like a dow or just everything is sensing and responding and, and, and moving and making decisions based on whatever it's seeing around it.
And then there's things in between too. Like, um, the, I think the thing you're referencing was the saffon of four, which is a colonial organism. It looks like a kind of jellyfish, but it has like four or five different species that are all in a really strongly coupled symbiotic relationship together so that they fit together like one organism, which is just wild. Um, which to me follow like, like, douse. Yeah. Yeah. Well, can you go, can you just elaborate on that? Tell us, tell me more about that. Yeah. I actually don't know. I don't know that much more about it. Uh, sadly. Um, but like, I've imagined a lot about it.
It's like, especially a lot about it. Um, all I know, like, factually is that it is a, like, it's a colonial organism they call it, which is made up of multiple different species, but that all function together as a team as one that looks and acts like one animal. But, you know, you could say that about the human being in a sense, you say that you got bacteria, right? But this is a little bit like more far out because you can like see each different animal and they're all kind of like fitting together, um, to like float around like, uh, like a little guy. Um, that's not how many, like, so the, these things all have to be like born around each other so that they can find each other.
Like, how does that process work? Do you know about that? I mean, can we get an expert on to help us with this? Because I have the same questions. Okay. Okay. Fair enough. Fair enough. Uh, but I think the, the model to extrapolate this to dows is that like, um, there's a lot of overlapping dows, he says, like, bankless dows very tapped into metafactory dows, which is like, and, and so like, yeah, is this kind of the idea where just like, we're actually going to thrive not by solo dows doing well for each other, but just by absolutely sharing resources and sharing capabilities and just hooking into each other.
Well, I think that the whole, I kind of, um, physics and friction of the work decentralized, of the work space changes with blockchain and with web three, right? And, um, you know, Jack DeRose wrote beautifully about this talking about the, uh, coast article, 1937 article, the nature of the firm, in which this, you know, economist defines like, why vertical integration basically is a good idea at that time is because of the overhead and, you know, you benefit from centralization. Why not just a bunch of independent actors work together at that time. There was no, um, open public goods infrastructure to allow for that to happen.
So you have these monopolies are ized. But now we have this open public goods infrastructure that can allow for decentralized work to, and where independent sovereign agents can come together and do stuff. And like, as we're starting to like, skate out onto this new ice, we don't really understand it. So what you see is a lot of, um, corporations on the blockchain for lack of a better term. They're just, you know, repeating the same model that we know, but doing it in this new space. But there's also ones that are trying lots of new weird things. Um, and what we're seeing is that the idea of like a corporate entity kind of doesn't make much sense anymore.
At least I'm like, what I'm seeing more is these permeable networks where you have like the year in protocol and the coordinate protocol and the curve protocol and the bank list out protocols. And, and, but there's people that are in all of them kind of working together and working for multiple at the same time. And the dows are collaborating together. They're often, you know, directly interacting between the protocols. So it's this kind of big open mess. Um, and like the, uh, the kind of nature of work change, the work group that the boundaries, the surface tension changes instead of being this big hard boundary around a 10, 3,000 person company and it can't be the same as this other one.
Now it's this little one. Non-complete clauses. Yeah. Yeah. You can't, like, you can only work for one corporation at time, blah, blah, blah. Doesn't matter anymore. Yeah. Right. And, and the coolest thing too is like, you know, it, it, it, it does, I believe that it does become anti-rival risk in that, um, a better strategy in this environment is to be composable and open and collaborative than competitive and closed. Like you will make more money and have a more successful product, product, if you take that strategy. Yeah. And you can actually see that, uh, concretely, in that a lot of, uh, Dow discords have channels in them that hook straight into other dows discords, right?
Like these are actually hard-coded bridges that we have in our communication coordination tools, which is what discord is. It's basically Dow coordination. I was, I was kind of blown away with that when I first joined year and like, a couple of years ago and like the main, like, chat at that time, you know, there were leaders of, like, 10 of the other top protocols in that time. I was like, wow, this is like the headquarters and like, it's people from all over DeFi in here, all together. It's like, like, wow, this is wild. Yeah. Um, uh, I wrote an article all the way back in like 2019, I think, that was, uh, called, uh, oh, I can't remember what it's called.
Uh, it's basically arguing that DeFi is not just one thing. Like, you don't have the uniswap app. You don't have the, uh, your own didn't even exist at the time. Uh, you don't have just maker Dow. You don't have just compound. But like, over time, the composability of these things, like, die from maker goes into uniswap, allowing you to go and, you can also get like C tokens out of compound and all of a sudden, like, it's not just one DeFi app at a time. It's one DeFi superstructure. Like, these are all composability means all these things are coming together. And if you actually are not composable, then you're left out.
And if you're not composable, like, there's an insane amount of value and economic activity going on in the superstructure. So if you're not part of the superstructure, you're just not going to make it, right? Because it's advantageous to be a part of the superstructure to contribute your value to the superstructure so that you can pull some of that value back out. And so you can start to be part of this like positive feedback loop of composability. And I think what we're seeing is the same thing with is going to work with Dows where Dows are just going to become one sort of massive superstructure of Dows.
We're all going to support each other like kind of individually. Dows won't work like they're too messy. They're too chaotic. But when you put 50 Dows on the same spot and you have a lot of overlapping talent and labor, people can start to like meld these things together and bootstrap themselves. Yeah. And it goes to the question of like, what are we doing here? Anyways, like, I think we've all gotten really gaslit in this idea that you're supposed to work hard every day and make the product and make the money and like, serve the boss and like, why? Like, yes, we need food. We need to pick up trash and things like this, like all those things still exist in our real.
And it doesn't require that logic of like, um, conquest really, you know, and like, we have to, I have to make my shits of other people can't take it and I have to build the walls and like have my business plan and sign an NDA and like, no, that's not the only way to be productive, creative and happy in the world. Like this, the logic of blockchain and of open source software and the internet creates a really different environment to thrive in, which corresponds to a change in global consciousness that's in the same way, right? Right. Now, this is, this is the layer zero. Like, as soon as we have enough dows to, if not accept everyone as laborers, but to accept everyone as, at least consumers of whatever the dows got to give, the idea is that it flips people, it inverts people's mental models as to like, how they exist on this world.
It's like, don't, you know, you don't got to work for your nine to five. You just got to give the protocol what it wants. And if you don't like giving that protocol what you, what it wants, find a different one. Uh, and keep doing that until you find your place and all of a sudden, boom, you're in web three. And what's, what's magic about this? It's like, it's really profound that change really, and it's really new for a lot of people like, um, and it can be really confronting for a lot of people too, because a lot of us only have this experience of like, our parents or our bosses or our society telling us what's good and what we're supposed to do.
And then you have this ladder that's consensual and you climb it and you, you know, you check the boxes and now you've done a good job. Good boy. Right. But now we don't have that really as much. And all of a sudden, we have to say, well, why am I doing any of this anyways? Um, and that's like profoundly valuable for personal and ecological development. Makerdow is the OG D5 protocol. The Makerdow produces die. The industry's most battle tested and resilient stablecoin. Using maker, you don't need to sell your collateral if you need liquidity. Instead, you can spin up a maker of vault and use your collateral to mint die directly with maker.
The power to mint new money is in your hands. The maker protocol is extremely hardened and operated by one of the most experienced dows in existence. They've been here since the beginning. They've seen it all and so you can mint die with the assurance that your collateral is safe. Soon, maker will be present on all chains and altos. So minting die can take place on oasis.app, zaryon, zapper or any other D5 protocol that you use. Follow maker on Twitter, at maker.dow and learn from the oldest and most resilient down existence. Ave is the leading decentralized liquidity protocol and now Ave V3 is here.
Ave V3 has powerful new features to enable you to get the most out of D5, including isolation mode, which allows for many more markets to be launched with more exotic collateral types and also efficiency mode, which allows for a higher loan to value ratios. And of course, portals, allowing users to port their Ave position across all of the networks that Ave operates on, like polygon, phantom, avalanche, arbitrum, optimism and harmony. The beautiful thing about Ave is that it's completely open-source, decentralized and governed by its community, enabling a truly bank this future for us all. To get your first crypto collateralized loan, get started at ave.
com. That's a-a-b-e.com. And also check out the Ave protocol governance forums to see what more than 100,000 down members are all roving about at governance.ave.com. The Brave Browser is the user first browser for the web3 internet, with over 50 million monthly active users. Control your digital footprint with built-in privacy and ad blocking. Inside the Brave Browser, you'll find the Brave wallet. The first secure crypto wallet built natively inside of a web3 crypto browser. Web3 is freedom from big tech and wallstreet, more control and better privacy, but there's a weak point in web3, your crypto wallet.
The Brave Wallet is different. Brave Wallet is built natively inside the Brave browser. No extension required, which gives the Brave Wallet an extra level of security versus other wallets. With the Brave Wallet, you can buy, store, send and swap your crypto assets, and it can even manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and defi apps, all from the security of the best privacy browser on the market. Whether you're new to crypto or a season pro, it's time to switch to the Brave Wallet. Download Brave at Brave.com slash bankless, and click the wallet icon to get started. We've hashed this out a little bit, but I want to go back to it.
There's always a conversation with technology is that, you know, write technology wrong time, like maybe we're too early. What indications about the current state of the world? Would you say that is indicative of like, oh yeah, the world really wants this new like Dow paradigm, like this new web3, like what about the world is like really, really ready for this? Well, I can think of so many things, but it's hard to tell if there's like a kind of causal or just correlative relationships. I mean, you can never really know, but the anti-work movement, you know, like all of these people that are so mistreated by the corporate paradigm and getting paid the minimum wage being solo, comparatively, historically, then there's a really fascinating thing that happened like with Russia, where there is a massive network effect at play in, you know, where it wasn't just that the EU and the US and some Western countries sanctioned Russia, it was like all these businesses pulled out too.
And that wasn't something that you could like control from one hierarchical position, right? That was a network effect, which is kind of like a Dow. And it turns out that the, at least from some analysis, that that network effect of all of these different agents kind of autonomously deciding to retract their business services, like create a much bigger impact and a much bigger stick, you know, for that behavior. And so it's like, look, like the world is trying to form into these networks anyways. And Dow's and Web 3 are like the perfect kind of like network substrate for that activity. So it seems there's that.
And then there's also, yeah, just the global consciousness change of people wanting to be whole beings and confronting this like our parents generation of like, you know, working hard for the system and the death of the American dream and and seeing how, you know, that often doesn't work and really wanting something different, wanting to be a whole being, you know, with the people we work with and not just have a work mask, like these things have all been developing independently of Web 3, but they all kind of fit together to support it. What do you think are the biggest fallacies that we're making right now?
Like one thing I'm worried about is like one of the reasons why so many people can work for Dow's these days, whatever that means for that particular Dow is like, well, I mean 2021 was really bullish for crypto prices. Like a lot of people are sitting on a pile of savings that they perhaps didn't expect to have like maybe when these savings run out, maybe working for a Dow isn't so glorious anymore. Like what are our fallups here? What are we tripping up on? Well, I think we're making a ton of assumptions is the first thing, but also think that that's okay. Like I think to assume that we're going to have everything figured out and if like not all the line items are properly annotated, then like this isn't going to work is silly.
Like we're at the beginning of a really gigantic change. Like we do not have to figure it out. That's fine. We can make some assumptions as long as we do it lightly. So I think the fallacy is one that it's all figured out or that it's not going to work. Both of those are, you know, suitably, they're similarly wrong. And we don't really know what the financial you know, support is going to be like if there's we don't know the future of the market or the macro global situation. Like who knows a lot of those things could put like crypto is not going to be absolutely definitely turnover the world in the next five years.
Like a lot of us believe that, but there's a lot of ways that nation states could stop that and slow it down at least. I mean, you can stop it by killing everybody, which could happen work. Yeah, at least it'll delay it for I mean, if you think of I tend to think of crypto really as a developmental like it from a biological perspective, it is a is it a force it's a part of the force of the development of the universe. Not something that like one guy is going to figure out. Right. So in that sense, you can never stop it because it's always the next tier for any civilization, but it can certainly be delayed or stop for thousands of years.
Yeah. It's a frequent trope in this crypto space is that like, oh, yeah, we're trying to onboard like the next one billion people into crypto, right? Like this doubt is going to onboard a billion people or my product is going to onboard a billion people and every time I hear that, like everyone loves to say that just because like it's a it's a fun like we all want to onboard a billion people, but I'm also at the same time like, bra, like we do not have the infrastructure to onboard a billion people man. Like every single blockchain would break. So long it would break. Arbitram would break. Like avalanche would break there.
We literally do not have the block space capacity to onboard a billion people. And definitely with Dow's like, no, you can't just go work for a Dow. There's not that much room in Dow's in its current state of things. Like we just do not have that capacity. And so like one of the reasons why I think a lot of like, there's the NFT haters out there. There's like the gamers that hate the play to earn gaming revolution. And they just hate all the things that crypto is infiltrating in their industry is like, oh, crypto is infiltrating culture. And I hate it. And crypto is infiltrating games. And I hate it.
And I think just one of the reasons why they hate it is because it's a natural organic reaction saying, hey, your guys aren't ready for me yet. Like your blockchains have high fees and your games are boring. And your NFTs are shitty. So what they're really saying is, yo, crypto, go figure your shit out. And then I'll and then come back for me. And I think it's like this natural balancing act of like, we cannot onboard a billion people because we do not have the capacity for them. But we could onboard like, I don't know, the next thousand in the next month or so. And then maybe the next three thousand two months later.
And then they're going to help build out some of this stuff. And then, you know, maybe the next month after that, we'll get five thousand. But then it starts to like perpetuate and roll out. And so how do you feel about like this model for like this natural reaction of just like, people hate crypto. And that's why they're not coming over to us. But it's really just them speed giving us feedback that like we haven't built out the solutions for them yet. Yeah, I think that that's true. And I think it's okay. Like as much as we all or many of us really want to see total open equal access to all these tools and to onboard everybody and and bring down technology to underserved communities and and change government, we want to do all these things.
And it's also okay to realize that maybe not all these things are ready. You know, the the world is full of all different types of people coming from all different perspectives. And we are very privileged and that we've had the education, the opportunity, maybe the support, the finances to engage in this new like space. It reminds me of the often used William Gibson reference like the future is here. It's just unequally distributed. And like we're in the future now. But most of the world's not. And that's normal. That's the way it works. And they will, if this space is as promising and fruitful as we think it is, it will expand.
And more people will join us here over time as the meeting from both top down and bottom up as as people grow and develop to be able to handle this way of being. And as the tools become more sophisticated, better UX were open. Do you have a so we're trying to build out these new organizations that sense and respond like sense our our needs and respond to them appropriately. Like I say, our web protocols are here to compete for our love, not to force us into paying them taxes. Do you have just like basic do's and don'ts for Dow builders out there? They're like, Hey, if you're if we're building out this Dow ecosystem and to be an actual new paradigm, not just a recreation of the old paradigm, do you have any interesting basic do's and don'ts for the Dow builders out there?
Yeah, I think the biggest one is just like take a breath and when you when you want to get something done, the the driving force will be to take something that you know from the corporate legacy kind of coordination system and just bring that in and apply that to the Dow and be like, look, maybe maybe this Dow is not efficient enough. So let's let's implement some direct reports, you know, or you know what, this Dow is not moving fast enough. It needs a strong leader. Like if you like if if you want to do that form of coordination, you can you can create a company. What I would say is like like be open to the possibility that there are other alternative ways to work and to be and Dow's are really suitable for that, but it is going to be confronting and it is going to be messy at times and it's not all figured out.
You don't have to do that, but like the opportunity is there to try new things and to relate to people in a new way and to allow for the timeline to be a little bit messier and the product to take a little longer or whatever else happens, you know, in these spaces. I was doing a show with Treasure Dow yesterday and they have like they're one of the projects that came out of the loop ecosystem and they have like I'm pretty insane. First off, their community is extremely energetic. So you know, so I know they're doing something right. And then I was as I was unpacking their their organization. I was like okay, there's a lot of labor and talent here being coordinated.
How do you guys coordinate everything as a Dow? And they said like oh yeah, we've actually brought in like a lot of like web to project managers, like leaders into the Dow. Is that like the old mentality or like where how do you think about like top down project management inside of Dows? Is that antithetical or like how does this fit in? Like how does this become a component of Dows? Well, I think Dows are a big tent and like they transcend and include the corporations. So you can it's totally legitimate to do a web to style business in a Dow vehicle. That's fine. You can do that. Nothing wrong with that.
And you see that happening and that can be really successful and can provide a lot of good. And I think the the the the thing that we're all figuring out is there's also this new other web three native way to work. And it's different and new and and not as efficient sometimes because we're still learning it. And that's I think like the most exciting and interesting place for me. And that's where I've tried to spend all my effort. But you know, teach their own everyone. You have me people where they're at different things are going to work in different times. Do you think there's like the possibility of when you when you say slime mold now I'm thinking of something with absolutely zero epicenter.
There's no center point and it's every and to me that's actually the original version of a Dow a Dow has in my mind is misappropriately named in this modern day and age like we really have digital organizations rather than decentralized autonomous organizations. The only true like decentralized autonomous organization that really think is out there. If you want to be a massive purist, it would be Bitcoin. Ethereum comes second, but there is still some central control. Uniswap comes to mind where it's code at the center and humans at the periphery. But like there, but then if we wanted to get into like the Dow model that we kind of know of today of people in a discord making and doing and contributing, do you think that's actually possible to create a structure of a Dow where there is no actual central processing unit and is just slime mold as in like there's only labor at the margins.
There's only people at the periphery without any rules without any structure. But the Dow somehow exists and thrives and grows from the collective labor of its like a beehive, right? Beehive without the queen. Like is that even possible? Do you think that's possible? I think it is. I think it is and I'm not sure. I think it's going to be one of the different shapes that emerges and there's going to be value in all the different shapes. The thing I often think about with this is like what is the governance scope? What is this organism doing? So slime mold is good at certain tasks and a human being is good at certain tasks and those are different spaces of tasks.
So Bitcoin is really good at certain tasks and I love Vitalik's article on April 1st because he made some really good arguments for why and they weren't jokes to me. Those were good arguments. And that's great. That's one way for what it does. That's the right thing. But if you're trying to let's say govern a complex group of many different individuals doing different types of work, like we don't have any way to make that an immutable smart contract right now. You can governing an immutable smart contract like the Uniswap V2 protocol for instance. Like there's a defined set of function calls that can be made.
You can create an on-chain voting system with on-chain execution and have a single channel decision-making system which is a kind of mind. And you can have this big swarm of people that operate it but that's not the same as Uniswap Labs which is a group of creative workers organizing together to create a work product. That has a different governance method. I actually don't know how much about how Uniswap Labs works but a lot of these types of central development companies, corporations work like normal companies where there's a leader and a hierarchy. And that's fine. The opportunity and the place that I've spent my time is trying to figure out how do you govern in a decentralized way these groups of creative workers.
And we have some fascinating potential there because once you figure that out, it breaks all of the limitations. It becomes that beehive network where actually with some alpha leak we're working on something like this but eventually it's not ready for disclosure. Yet it allows you to scale the opportunity and the promise for real decentralized work is I call it the party bike. You know a party bike. It's like 10 people can sit on it and you can pedal as much as you want. You can drink a beer. You know one person's steers maybe they get bored steering somebody else's steers and you get somewhere cool.
It's like imagine that for work. Like anybody can work as much as they want. They get the value out of it. There needs to be a whole new set of structures and decision making processes in order to enable that and support that. Yeah. I actually intended on asking this next question before you talked about the little alpha leak. So for the record there's like been an explosion of like Dow tooling startups in the last like six months. Like and everyone is building something relatively similar to each other a few different shape points. But like the number of of these projects is like through the roof.
I'm thinking that I'm thinking like there's over like 20 of these like Dow tooling startups going on at least. After like what does what is missing in the Dow tooling landscape that after like the dust settles with all these Dow tooling startups what is the real problems like getting solved like what is the project the thing that Dow tooling is trying to get done right. What's the next step for Dow tooling? Well man there's a lot of stuff. I think a lot of the Dow tooling that we're seeing and I know a lot of the people working on these things and a lot of the projects and I think they're awesome.
Like there's some really great stuff. Like to going back to the thing we're talking before like a lot of it is taking processes that we know about from Web2 or the normal traditional corporate world and making ways to do them easily on chain in for decentralized communities. And that's great. But the blue ocean the the the undiscovered country is what are the real Web3 native ways to work and there's very few tools that are really being made for that. Understandably it's very very new and like self-shilling a bit like I think coordinate is one of them. Coordinate is is the only form of doing decentralized compensation that I know of and like understanding compensation is a huge challenge for really decentralized creative work.
Like how do you get paid? How do you share resources? How do you make those decisions? And and the other side of that is the decision making space itself right. So we have on chain coin weight token weighted voting right and we have snapshot and things like that. These things are great but they're just single channel decision making. It's like one thing you put a proposal up you people vote on it but there's so many other types of computational social choice mechanics that are available and really important because there's all different types of decisions that need to be made in decentralized ways but also with the balance of centralization is good for some things permissioning is good for some things and decentralized and permissionless is good for other things and to create tools that allow for a fluid movement you know with it that's accountable and transparent to create these structures like there's not really any tools that do that yet.
What's the what's the role of data when it comes to DAO's? A lot of DAO workers are individuals who have their own skill sets and their own like resume in working in web 3 and DAO's from from as far as I can tell don't have a way of sensing the makeup of an individual worker. How do you think about this problem in the DAO space? I think this is going to be a huge unlock and I think ceramic network is amazing. I don't know if you've talked to those guys like this idea the dataverse where you know basically a blockchain for rich data and what that allows for is like way more composable and easy to start frontends like you know you go to one DAAP and you put in your profile and your your your picture and whatever and all of that is stored in ipfs through like you know these kind of shared data structures that then you know you open another DAAP and your stuff automatically populates or you know you open a canvand board at dework which is an amazing like project productivity tool startup and you put in a bunch of tasks and then you go to clarity which is another awesome tool and those same tasks are there because they're both being stored through ceramic network on ipfs like that type of data availability for rich data for DAO workers is going to be like massively massively expansive for the system.
And and fits right into the theme of DAO sensing and responding right like DAO can sense sense their own needs and then also sense who are the candidates that are best equipped for the DAO to give the DAO those needs. And I think they're respond appropriately. I think this is actually one of the big pain points like in a lot of DAOs and we talk to a lot of DAOs that they have the same the same problems. How do you surface needed work? How do you create bounties? How do you know who's done what? How do you keep people accountable? How do you do offboarding? Like all of these everybody has these same questions and I think part of the problem is that without that data layer that data blockchain you kind of have you can't create there's not a good enough shelling point for this stuff like you can create there's a bunch of these different bounty systems but because they don't interoperate and you don't have it all moving down to one data layer like none of them's really gaining enough traction but once we do have that then it's going to explode and that's pretty soon.
Okay so this data layer is like an interdow communication layer is that a way to frame it? I think you could think it with that way sure or like it's a public good and sense for for data that many you know front ends can bloom from and you can have like this is what will beat Facebook right like you can't beat Facebook because of the network effect but when every new profile can get stored in the same data structure that's open you know and public good then all of a sudden it's just going to start growing you know and then you don't have to have the one front end that you know beats them all you can have a thousand of them.
Drake you go out and and go to real life crypto events you're at East Denver I saw you at Encon I think you've been to a few others that I haven't been and I believe if I'm remembering your bio correctly you also came from like a web 2 startup world I think maybe I might be wrong about that. Not web 2 but I not web 2. Tried 5, Tried something. I was an artist and designer. Artists okay okay. Yeah. Anyways same question just the culture of the people that you engage with and interact with at these crypto events what about the culture these these like web 3 enabled individuals what about the culture in these in real life events stands out to you as unique and compelling.
Well it's it's it's great it's um at least the there's a bunch of different cultures in crypto right there's like finance culture there's investor culture there's builder culture there's Dow culture and like I didn't know anything about finance before I I wasn't I wasn't an engineer and build code and engineering various engineering projects but finance I didn't know anything about that's not really my people in a way not that there aren't plenty of them that I resonate with but the people I really vibe with and that when I go to these conferences I feel like I you know coming home in a sense is that these people making douse you know that are that are trying to figure out really how human beings can collaborate and this is something I've cared about my entire life and this is like the most important thing that we can figure out on the planet because that is what makes or breaks like our ability as a civilization to thrive and they're not coming from there it's very new thinking you know like very lots of polymaths and people with all different information bring it to share and work together and it's very open you know it's very welcoming and not competitive very collaborative and it's that overwhelming nature of collaborative and open spirit that like yeah I'm a sucker for that any day why does this industry have all of these types of characters like what about this industry attracts that type yeah so I think it this goes to my kind of like developmental theory of organizations where you know before blockchain you know like a human being has these different levels of intelligence we have like survival instinct you know we have sexual instinct we have power we have heart we have our voice you know we have our intelligent our cognitive ability all these different layers they all build on top of each other in the same way organizations in societies has that too and so it's like where are the jewels kept are the jewels safe and that's the first thing that we all need to think about am I safe and you know before blockchain you had to trust the government and you had to trust the banks you know for that personal security and that's not a very good trust situation so everyone's kind of starting scared you're all starting kind of scared and so you can only go so far but when you have blockchain you have this trustless coordination system to keep your jewels safe and now obviously there's ways that they're not safe but it's a lot better than we have before and so what I noticed is that from that much stronger foundation like the other stuff can bloom and like people how many like handshake deals like oh send you some teeth like send me the tokens later like that happens all the time like I was an entrepreneur I started a bunch of companies everything was paper everything was contracts lawyers everywhere it's like this we're way more because of this trustless infrastructure we're way more trusting because like the jewels are safe and that's profound you know that's that's that's changes everything yeah um I think a lot of this world depends on assurances right um we have like models of governments where we have slow medium and fast versions of government executive is the fast congress or the legislative is the medium uh and then the judicial of the supreme court is the slow and the slow government is the hardest one to change right so when the supreme court says this is the new the version of the law this is the new law uh businesses and people have the like the strongest level of assurances that that is going to be the law moving forward because they're getting something overturned by the supreme court is like the hardest thing you can do in a country uh and so that gives businesses the assurances that they can operate on those laws and they can build around them and gives like startup founders assurances that they're not going to get rug pulled because the supreme court determined that this is the law uh and I think what I what I heard from you there is that like private keys give you just a new level of assurances over your assets that you've never been able to have before uh and then like smart contracts give you assurances and so you know uh and and I don't think that like I'll be randomly sending somebody some eth and telling them to just send me the tokens later probably in 2040 when all of society is onboarded and but it's like the this kernel this or in these first adopters who got attracted by this technology is probably a little bit more conducive to that but I do take your point that like smart contracts and private keys and these assurances allow for the trustless base allows for a trusting uh structure like a trustless foundation allows for trust to be exhibited by the world at large because we don't have to like you said rely on the banks relying the governments or rely on the courts to get things right because even the courts can be gained like the courts is a gameable system where a theorem is not uh and so that that imbues whatever gets built on top of a theorem is uh more uh uh creative playground for trust to be exhibited absolutely and it doesn't mean that we need to be we should be naive and not you know care about obstacle key management you have to have that piece too and you have to know that there are sharks out there and it isn't at there are like it's really important to know what playing field you're on are you in an adversarial space are you in a collaborative space you're in a creative space your trusted space what level is that and then operate you know um in that way dude after after mcon this uh this stood out to me so much uh after mcon last september i think in denver september 2021 uh a bunch of us went out to just like a a bunch of arabian bees out in like the colorado countryside just for like the weekend just to get away who sunlight just walk around just go on some hikes uh and everyone kind of converged on one arab and b a arabie b as the meeting place like the biggest one and everyone had their stuff like their backpacks with their laptops and their ledgers and so everyone just dumped their backpack into this arabian bee and we all started going on a hike everyone had their ledgers in their backpacks and everyone just left all of their ledgers in the backpack and just in the arabian bee and no one thought twice about it and i only knew about like 50% of the people in that group but it was the meta factory it was like half of them was the meta factory bros and and ladies uh and i was like yeah like no fucking way would any of these people like go into my backpack and try and find my ledger like that's not going to happen and again wouldn't do that in 2030 probably but like with the particular people that meta factory of a particular dow has created and just like the collaborative yes and culture of that of that community and others it just felt so like no one thought twice about how like there is like millions and millions of dollars like collectively on these backpacks that are like laid on the ground yeah it's amazing and i think you're right like part of that is still early and part of it is that you know they're higher reputation people in this space that understand the substrate they were working on and and are able to trust each other which you know that notion of trust is one that i think about a lot which is like there's the impetus in the space often you see like everything needs to be trustless everything needs to be trustless and i think that's a great goal in many ways but it's not the reality because you can't like there is still a hugely important space for interpersonal trust um and and like that is where the like third mind the mind between minds like really emerges you know in the collective intelligences between these interpersonal relationships and yes like those can be broken and yes that's okay uh i'm gonna tell i want to tell a quick story and it might actually be completely irrelevant but i think your brain might pick up on something anyways so i'm gonna go and see what happens um my first job out of school was working at a mental health agency for uh kids that were deemed by the state to be unsafe to themselves unsafe to others or just like not functioning enough to be able to take care of themselves like schizophrenia or whatever um uh and then so this working it worked at this company for a while and we had a workshop like a weekend optional workshop where we would be able to go and work with um just like hanging around uh traumatized horses and horses are extremely emotional animals right uh if you like walk quickly towards a horse it'll get scared and run away from you but if you walk uh you know passively and and like you know calmly and not add a direct line to a horse but like adjacently and then you go and walk adjacently again you get closer than the horse is calmer in a response to you and so uh they were the the people that were leading these workshops were uh getting us to like okay you're going to grab a horse and you're gonna uh lead it right you're going to walk with it and the horse is going to determine whether it's going to follow you or not based on your body language based on like the vibe that you give off and I was watching one of the therapists that was that was with us in this organization who was like you kind of a timid guy uh not not really too like you know confident he would go up to the horse and like grab the reins and be like uh come on horse like we're gonna go now and the horse is like what are we doing here like yeah it's like off bro like I'm not going anywhere uh it's like he couldn't get the horse to walk uh and so like I was watching this happen and uh it's like okay well that's not what you do and so when I did it I went up and I grabbed the reins I didn't look at the horse I just like looked elsewhere and started walking and the horse just immediately started going it's like oh okay I guess we're going this way now and the horse has started following me um and like uh to say since I'm going into the story uh this this was a kind of a chaotic workplace so some of these kids were like conduct disorder like uh not read not really able to control themselves and sometimes they would just like aggressively act out and they were like between the ages of like 13 and 17 and there's was one kid who uh was having an act out moment and like starting to get a little violent uh and there was a moment where like I was engaging with him and I needed to like deescalate the environment and but he was violent he was being aggressive being violent like trying to hit us and I like I can't remember what I said but I basically just turned or turned around and walked the other way to disengage but I'm turning my head away from this kid so I don't know what he's going to do next and so I turned away and and started to walk away and then the back of my head I'm like he's going to hit me he's going to hit me uh but because I acted as if I trusted this kid and I acted as if I didn't think that he was going to hit me and I confidently turned away and walked away to disengage and he didn't hit me and I was like whoa my guy didn't hit me and so like it's a a lot of like our um what we communicate is how we perceive the world is embodied in our actions right and so when we have a bunch of people in a Colorado countryside Airbnb and they're all leaving their ledgers on the ground we're all indicating to ourselves like hey like this is this is the vibe like this is the culture this is the emotional like uh state that I'm going to express that I think that we are in and because I'm expressing that everyone else also thinks that is true reflections on that yes yeah I think we um we create our own reality right like like I think if I um I'm acting from a place of of confidence and openness and um you know clear direction and integrity it tends to create more of that in the world around me and if I'm operating with a hidden fear in my system that I won't look at that I'm going to get hit that I'm gonna get hit get hit gonna I'm gonna I'm gonna make that reality happen and someone's gonna hit me um because we tend to this goes to like spirituality and psychology and all these different wisdom traditions that we tend to recreate the same patterns in our lives over and over again and you know there's this idea that you know the world is this concrete thing that has these specific rules and you know there's an order to it and it's kind of yes and no you know like really like reality is this kind of psychedelic experience that each of us is manifesting in our own way and um and we can have the ones that are full of suffering and the ones that are full of of less suffering and each of those is just what we happen to need at that time I'm not sure that's where you were going with that story but no there was no I was going nowhere with it but um uh how do you how do you think dals or dals like an amplification tool for this kind of like behavior where if we if the dals just assume that they trust us and we assume that we trust the dals like do you think dals can be like an amplification of just uh the values that we want to see in the world I think that they really are and I think this is like this development is going in concert like at the same time as these collective super organisms are are developing so too or the parts you know the within it like each individual also has to develop and so um that's one of the things it's like super exciting to me about it like working in a dow that's not you know a company on the blockchain even a company in the blockchain is going to push you in some areas but working in a dow that's you know really trying to push down as forward um each person is going to be like their their development gets amplified I think and and you you get these lessons and these um signals that help you orient to this new way it's like one of the biggest you know risk factors for being obese is having a lot of obese friends friends yeah it's like we we we do we garbage in garbage out like what's around us becomes us and so if you put yourself in a space with all these sovereign beings that are you know acting in these more developed ways like you will take those traits on and you will grow and you'll become more like them and dals become like a shelling point for that type of consciousness track if we uh zoom forward to like 2050 2060 2070 and we're got gray hair and old and dals are infinite at this point uh what do you hope your legacy is you is an individual yeah i mean i i just hope i help you know i hope i help all right and we're done yeah yeah yeah just i i i love working on this stuff like i i love solving these problems and sharing them with people that i care about and um and co-creating this thing together and being part of this kind of movement it like it it weaves together all of these things in my life that i care about and i didn't even realize i didn't plan to get an acrypto like i kind of got sucked in in 2020 um and it's because of all these different things like this cycle this psychology the spirituality of it the technology of it the you know the revolutionary aspects like um it's it's so compelling and so just to if my legacy is just you know someone that added some good to that system that's that's all i want um Jake you said you were an artist uh what were you an artist about like what would you create um interactive sculpture so i used i used technology so my training was in human computer interaction i used to invent new types of computer interfaces you know physical interfaces mostly using like um mechanical engineering and electrical engineering and industrial design and software and i did that in research for a while um trying to reinvent you know computers basically um and then i started using it to make art um i'd always made different forms of art in my life but then i used that same material but as an artist so i made um sculpture that's really cool that just opened up a whole nother can of words uh uh uh so when uh Gary Kasperov lost to deep blue i think or yeah uh people thought i was like oh the chest is over like the computers are one like the art of chest is lost what actually ended up happening is that the new frontier of chest came uh with the grandmasters of the world the Gary Kasperovs of the world finding their preferred chess ai and then competing with other grandmasters who have their chess ai and so it started to become a human computer cyborg uh and that it was the new frontier and we've also seen this in online poker too uh it's gone from just individuals on a table playing poker to online poker where like the new meta is like how computer enabled can you be like you have scripts running to tell you about like probabilities and then you have to make the gut choice using that data uh and i think there's a conversation to be had about this with dals too uh where dals are like the cyborg side of us that are doing like the smart contract basic stuff but it's still humans at the periphery um do you have any thoughts about like the future trajectory of humans and the digital side of the world that we're creating yes many and i think that's what i'd like to do yeah yeah it's like many many um i think um technology is a part of the human organism right there's this idea and there's been this kind of misconception i think that it's something external you know and that and that when we're building these like we need to build an ai that's outside of us and it's a mirror of us but really the the progress the the procession of technology is of of identity creation and and like every the phone becomes an extension of the mind is like a cognitive co-processor and you know just because it's not inside my skull doesn't make it any less me you know and i think you people can feel that you lose your phone for a while and you feel a huge sense of loss um there's a there's a phobia word for this i don't know what it is but there's a phobia word for if you do or without your phone yeah and you know i was talking to metadreamer about this the other day actually and uh like maybe what we're doing in daos is we're creating a agi artificial general intelligence because um if you think a lot of the the progress in in strong ai you know has been around constructing these logical systems like it started marviminsky gave a you know famously gave one of his uh summer uh students like the job of general computer vision and like the 60s like they figured that they'd be able to solve that and you know a summer in like the 60s um but i realized that you know it is not this divorced logical system that can work on its own it's really a part of the human matrix and for then ai developers started to they realized that it needs to be an embodied intelligence they made robots and they thought that my robot body is going to but again this is outside of the human and now you see like gpd3 and whatever they're really synthesis of human beings because they take all of the human output and they weave it together statistically into a new output right um in these kind of limited domains but what are daos other than you know these aligning mechanisms for human output that can scale and function more rapidly than any other human coordination system before so eventually it might be that all of these different human actions are getting woven together through the technology of the dao um to become a real intelligence you know operating maybe not in a realm that we can directly communicate with but taking action on the same realm the same planet with us um because that question it's not outside you know it is extension of us uh and there's oh gosh there's so many different directions to go in but we talked about the um the digital like metaverse nomadic lifestyle that is now being enabled via daos yeah and really just like this whole concept of crypto is always about freedom like the the the layer zero of crypto's freedom like if crypto is here to do anything it's to help us become more free like bitcoin and it's 21 million heart cap is freedom from tyrannical monetary policy ethereum and smart contracts is freedom from like the the capturing a financial system uh and then like you know NFTs is a freedom from just like uh I don't know licensing and uh uh like labels and people that try to to own the music industry in a in a corporate sense we all it all sets you free and and it's and that's really what technology has always been about is like how do we get how does technology allow us to access the things that we want more and that's always been what technology is and really I'm just seeing like daos as being just like another instantiation of ones and zeros that allow us to get what we want out of life even more um and so we have these AI developers that are building out these AI's and like I love the what you said where they're trying to build it externally which is like naive because how can you build something external when you are the one actually building it in the first place like your biases your values your culture is being built into the thing that you are building so there is no even if you try to make it maximally external use can't pull the human out of the out of the technology because it's the human that built it in the first place that's why we have it a layer zero podcast to talk about these subjects uh and so like can you talk about just like the the importance of self-reflection about who we are as we build out these technologies and how our own persons get in like uh imbued into the technologies we create oh yeah i mean the most important question to ask is just what am i to start you know who am i what am i and and understand and understand the nature of the reality that we are in more and more and then you know see that it's all a piece you know it is it's divine uh wisdom life force energy flowing out into the into the into manifestation and it's flowing through all we're all a piece of that same thing of god of this you know the the polarity of the universe and the unity of it all and that is going to flow through us into technology it's going to flow through us into everything that we that we make and you know it reminds me um a lot of people sometimes think like i think of it like the vulcan fallacy or the spark fallacy that you can have this purely logical uh take on the world divorce from your emotions and um the reality is if you look at studies of split brain patients like if you don't have access to your emotional system then you cannot make any decisions you know there is no lot just logic without emotion like it all flows from that same creative force and it flows up through all these different layers so it's the same thing is thinking you could create like this a that's a i that's outside of the human organism because it's like saying it's outside of life and without life it's just dead it's just concept um which is a part of experience but not all of experience and experience cannot is irreducible to concept and vice versa so um seeing it all is just this divine expression of the universe in action um i think really helps to better contextualize what it is that we're fucking doing in the first place uh trake i think this is a good place to wrap it up man thank you for coming on to layer zero and sharing your thoughts thanks thanks for having me man great talking to you as always likewise likewise hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommended joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for airdrops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation