“Energy is the base layer of money” - that’s how our guest Luke Gromen puts it in today’s episode.
Luke is an Author and Investor who gives us a completely new way to look at money, through the lens of energy costs.
The essential learning of today’s show is that you can’t understand money until you understand energy markets. Apart from that Luke explains why the price of oil is about to force a monetary system change, why the 60/40 portfolio is dead and much more.
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/11?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ 🎬 DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-the-luke-gromen-interview
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
⚡️ CARTESI | LINUX-POWERED ROLLUPS https://bankless.cc/CartesiGovernance 🏠 CASA | SECURE YOUR GENERATIONAL WEALTH https://bankless.cc/Casa
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🌐 TRANSPORTER | CROSS CHAINS WITH CONFIDENCE https://transporter.io/
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 5:57 Luke’s Thesis 12:23 Energy lens 23:23 Arc of the Dollar 28:31 Why Oil? 31:31 Energy as a Denominator 38:12 Energy Price Changes 45:31 Energy Miracles 59:22 Monetary System Change 1:10:41 Capital Controls 1:18:12 Future of the US 1:24:56 How to Prepare 1:30:37 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Luke Gromen https://x.com/LukeGromen
FTT, LLC https://fftt-llc.com/
Luke Gromen Weekly Newsletter https://fftt-treerings.com/
Visualizing the History of Energy Transitions https://www.visualcapitalist.com/visualizing-the-history-of-energy-transitions/
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Most people are still assuming dollar equals oil. They're assuming the denominator is the same. And I think they're different. And not even I think I know they're different. I can show it to you on the charts. S&P 500 total returns in January, 2020 in dollars, up 75%. In gold, up 15%. In Bitcoin, down 81%. That chart's telling you the denominators are wildly different. Welcome to Bankless, where today we're exploring the frontier of energy, empires, and maybe the end of the petro dollar. This is Ryan Sean Adams, and I'm here with David Hoffman. And as usual, we are here to help you become more bankless.
Energy is the base layer of money. That's how our guest, Luke Gromin, puts it in today's episode. We look at money and empire through the lens of energy costs. And we see why Luke says the price of oil is about to force a massive monetary system change. David, I really think this is essential learning for people in the bankless journey. We haven't often unpacked an episode that looked at money primarily through the lens of energy, which is what we're doing in today's episode. And I walked away from this kind of convinced that you don't really understand money until you start understanding energy markets and all of the forces surrounding them.
One of my favorite parts of this episode is in addition to exploring these topics, Luke actually leaves people with some actionable ideas on how to prepare, like what to invest in, and here's maybe a hint. The 6040 portfolio is dead, folks. That's a definite takeaway from today's episode. Understanding what Luke means when he talks about their relationship between energy and money is certainly interesting. I think any topic that unpacks a little bit of how money comes to be is worth discussing. Definitely learning from this episode before there was money in finance, there was just resources, and money in finance is built on top of just commodities and resources.
In the 21st century, we're blessed to live in a sufficiently stable global economy that we don't really have to think about what's going on in the basement of financial markets, the trading of physical commodities, and that's relationship with geopolitics and financial markets. But things aren't always so calm. And as we've been exposed to over the last five years or so, the world's just getting pretty crazy, so it's probably best to be kind of informed about how energy resources impacts economies. And that's what Luke gives us on the episode today. So let's go ahead and get right into that episode with Luke Gromint.
But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Like Kraken, our preferred crypto exchange in 2024. If you do not have an account with Kraken, consider clicking the links in the shown up, so getting started with Kraken today. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive, and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto.
Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro.
Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Have you ever felt that the tools for developing decentralized applications are too restrictive and fail to leverage advancements from traditional software programming? There's a wide range of expressive building blocks beyond conventional smart contracts and solidity development. Don't waste your time building the basics from scratch and don't limit the potential of your vision. Kartezi provides powerful and scalable solutions for developers that supercharge app development.
With a Kartezi virtual machine, you can run a full Linux OS and access decades of rich code libraries and open source tooling for building in Web3. And with Kartezi's unique roll-up framework, you'll get real world scaling and no more competing for block space. So if you're a developer looking to push the boundaries of what's possible in Web3, Kartezi is now offering up to $50,000 in grants. Head over to Kartezi's grant application page to apply today. And if you're not a developer, those with staked CTSI can take part in the governance process and vote on whether or not a proposal should be funded.
Make sure your vote ready by staking your CTSI before the vote's open. Taking self-custody of your crypto is one of the most important things you can do on your bank list journey. It's also one of the hardest things to get right, with huge consequences if you don't. If you want help going bank lists, talk to Kaza. Kaza helps you take custody of your crypto assets so you don't have to wonder whether you're doing it right. Kaza is a one-stop shop for doing self-custody the right way. With Kaza vaults, you can hold ether, bitcoin, stablecoins, all with one simple app and multiple keys for the ultimate piece of mind with a support team to help you every step of the way.
But it doesn't stop at self-custody because even though crypto is forever, you are not. We all plan on making life-changing wealth in crypto, but with Kaza's inheritance products, life-changing wealth can elevate to generational wealth. For your kids and your loved ones who don't know anything about crypto. With Kaza, you won't lose your private keys and you won't accidentally take them to the grave either. Click the link in the description to get started securing your generational wealth. Bank list nation, we are very excited to bring on Luke Grom and he is the founder and president for a forest for the trees.
That's FFTT where he helps investors see the big picture so they can prepare for the future and we're going to be doing some of that preparing. I hope on the podcast today because Luke thinks there is a coming monetary system change up in the works driven in part by high energy costs. It's going to shake up everything we know about markets, about investing. We'll talk about that. How to prepare Luke. Welcome to bank lists. Thanks for being on guys. It's great to be here. So let's start with a question maybe just to frame up the entire conversation we're about to have. I think every good investor has a thesis for how things will play out.
It's just like something that they believe the market is fundamentally mispricing. So for bank lists, our thesis has been, hey, the world doesn't understand crypto yet and they will and it's going to have a massive impact. I want to begin this conversation by asking what your thesis is in the broadest strokes. What do you think the rest of the market isn't seeing right now? I think the market is not seeing that I guess two things. Number one, the productivity enhancements implied by AI, humanoid robotics, etc. are over time exponentially deflationary and fundamentally incompatible as a result with the global sovereign debt backed and based monetary system.
What does that mean? That means if AI and humanoid robotics are even directionally do directionally what people think they're going to do over the next five years, 10 years. Global central banks are going to have the fully reserve consumer debt, sovereign debt, starting with sovereign debt, fully reserve. What does that mean? Buy it all with printed money. Can you illustrate why does it mean that? Simple because I just saw in Korea there's a Starbucks running with two people and a hundred robots. There was an article on rethink X last month, earlier this month actually, suggesting that humanoid robotics wages will go towards a dollar by 2035 and 10 cents by 2045, an hour.
Who can afford their student loan payments if global wages go to 10 bucks an hour by 2035? The answer is barely anybody. Who can afford their car loan payments, barely anybody? Who can afford their mortgage payment, barely anybody? Who can afford their apartment rent, barely anybody? Their credit card, barely anybody. Deflation is fundamentally incompatible with a debt-back monetary system which requires exponential growth. So, practically speaking, those people won't be able to afford their payments. They will default as they default. They'll take down banks. They take down banks. Banks would sell what they can, not what they want to.
What do they hold? Is their wealth reserves? They hold treasury bonds. They'll sell treasury bonds. We saw that start to happen last March and we saw what the Fed did. BTFP, more dial liquidity. They'll buy it all. So, that is the, I think, perhaps the biggest fundamental thing. It's quite the paradox. Normally, if I say, hey, there's something in deflationary coming by bonds. You don't buy bonds when debt to GDP is as high as it is, when sovereign debt is as high as it is, when you have deflation. It becomes impossible to pay the debt back for the whole system. So, that's number one. Number two is at the same time, it's getting much more expensive to find a marginal sources of oil, to find marginal sources of copper.
We're going to build all this electric stuff to replace the use of oil except it's going to require a lot higher prices of copper, a lot higher inflation. Great. Who wants to hold $35 trillion in U.S. government debt if inflation has to rise to get the copper to support the electricity transition? Not me. And nobody has a 35. No one has a balance sheet to hold that except the Fed. So, here too, you get to the same point. They're going to have to reserve much of the government debt. So, these two things, and I guess the last thing is just per capita, you know, people say, well, great, we'll electrify, and then oil won't matter.
China right now is a billion four people. They use one fifth the oil of the U.S. per capita. India has 1.4 billion people. They use one 15th the oil of the U.S. per capita, both of those numbers are 2021 numbers. If India goes from using one 15th to one 10th, oil demand will explode. If China goes from one fifth to one fourth, oil demand will explode because I'm talking about in total 2.8 billion people. And why would they begin to use more oil per capita? Simple. Why does the U.S. have, why does the U.S. consume so much more? Is it because we're better? Is it because we're smarter? No, it's because we can print dollars for oil and we've been able to 40 years.
And guess what China and India are starting to be able to do? They are in the pregame. They aren't even in inning one. They have just started print, be gaining the ability to print you on and rupee for oil. And as they gain more of that ability through gold, and through their own productive capacity, their economies, their per capita oil consumption is going to rise. So there's this fascinating set of conflicting dynamics, one deflationary, one inflationary, all of which, though, point to the unsustainability of a sovereign debt-backed system that's been in place for the past 50 plus years. And all of which suggests that we're going to continue this trend of higher rates, rates get too high, cause a crisis, Fed comes in essentially caps rates with more dollar liquidity or the Treasury, it doesn't really matter.
They're basically both the same at this point anyway, Fed and Treasury. We get more liquidity asset prices, go up, washer, and so Pete, and away we go. So that's what I think are the two, are the two biggest fundamentals, the energy side, and then this, everybody's hyped up about AI, et cetera, maybe for good cause, but I don't think they've, I know they haven't thought through the second derivative, it's cause they wouldn't be doing what they're doing. Bonds, a 10-year bond in the US wouldn't have a forehandle. The Fed wouldn't still be selling bonds if that was the case, if people really understood what it meant.
So Luke, you really think the market really hasn't priced these things in and you're kind of like maybe front running this. I want to ask you to give us a energy lens on things, because this is something we've not really explored deeply in our content. We've explored all sorts of different lenses on like this question. Of course, that's very relevant to crypto, which is what is money, but I don't think we've done the energy lens justice. And I know, you know, Helen Thompson uses this term energy blindness to describe policy makers who basically like make policy in a vacuum and don't consider the geopolitical social ramifications, monetary ramifications of seeing the world through the lens of energy.
And I kind of fear that like maybe I don't I don't see the world through the energy lens enough to and I have got some energy blindness here myself and maybe some bankless listeners do as well. Can you give us the story of why energy matters so much? I noticed in the intro and I asked the question of like, what do you see that others don't see? Like one was AI being deflationary source. The other answers was all to do with energy costs and energy demand. So like, why does energy price matter so much to the world, to asset prices, to empires? Like, where should we start this conversation? Energy is the base layer of money.
Why? Because human life is finite as much as we'd all like to live forever. None of us are going to live forever. Okay. So if we have finite lifetime, during our lifetime, we work. How do we work? We expend energy. So when we work, we work for money. Money comes to us. We work is just the expenditure of energy. Okay. So if work is just the expenditure of energy, when I borrow money to buy something more than I can afford today, a house, a car, whatever, I am promising to work in the future. I am promising the future expenditure of energy to pay my loan over time so I can afford something today.
If the price of energy changes, if it goes up a lot, if I can, if my wages don't keep up with energy, I can't afford my house, the whole system, the whole, the, I default, etc. So energy is, it is, it is really debt is simply a future promise to expend energy. And so once the challenge within that, I guess, is twofold. Number one, in order for that to work, energy has to remain a small enough percentage of the overall economy. If energy gets too big as a percentage of the economy, it becomes impossible to pay back the debt because people are consuming too much of their own energy just to pay for energy.
It doesn't leave the extra funds over to pay the interest on the debt. The debt starts to default. Similarly, if you make a bunch of promises, unbacked promises like governments do, sovereign debt, entitlements, etc. Those are all promises to expend energy in the future. And once you promise too much, if you promise too much relative to the size of the energy market, you either in the, in the future in terms of what the energy market evolves to, you either have to default on those promises, which has a political and monetary and inflationary impact, or you have to inflate the energy market to be, quote, unquote, big enough to back those promises, which also has an inflationary monetary systemic impact.
But either way, the energy is just fundamentally the base layer, because debt is nothing other than a promise to expend energy in the future. Money is just nothing but a manifestation of the expenditure of energy. Okay, so do the central bankers know this? Does the Fed know this? Does Treasury know this? Does, do the lawmakers know this? Does, does, does the president know this? How come we have this energy blindness? How come so many people, if energy is the base layer of money? How come people, so many people have had the luxury of not having to think about it? Like, in, you know, I would argue, I don't think about energy costs in my day to day life, like maybe price of the pump, like just that sort of thing.
But, but you're saying it's the base layer for money, which means it's also the base layer for the US dollar. And of course, the dollar is so central to, you know, US financial capital markets dominance as well. So it must be central to the US empire. And yet we don't think about it. We have this luxury of like not having to worry about it, at least up to this point. Can you explain this? Sure, because you get the media to tell people that you're not in Iraq because of the oil, it's because of freedom, it's because of weapons and massive destruction. You, you, you know, why does, why is there something called the Carter doctrine?
You know, that existed from the 70s up until just recently, which translates to no Russians in the Middle East. Why does the US even care about the Middle East? The answer is in plain sight. It's hiding an absolute plain sight. Why have we, why have we been at war in Afghanistan and Iraq and what, like, why have we done these things? Why, why do we prop up? If we're, if we're so pro free, if we're pro-democracy, explain the 80 year relationship between Saudi Arabia and the United States. The answer is right there. It's all hiding in plain sight. The answer is that energy is fundamentally that that's why we don't think about it.
We don't think about it because the US military and, and, you know, people willing to do violence in our behalf have been doing it while we sleep comfortably in our beds. I mean, I'm, I'm going to call the, the US an empire for, for a second. I don't know if you use that frame, but I've heard others use that framing. So, so let's go with that. So, like, to what extent do you think every empire in history has based sort of their empire on having access and securing a cheap source of energy? Is, is that a thing that is just central to the US or have other empires done this throughout history? Is this just table stakes?
If you sort of like, you know, 101, if you want to become an empire, like step one, go get a cheap source of, of energy, and then like step two is secure it and then make your population, like, forget how you secure it and just like that fades into the background. But how central is this to, to empire in general? It's central to the life of empire. It's central to the life of every living thing on this planet, right? Energy's just food. You stop eating, you're going to die. Full stop. I can tell you within, you know, roughly a couple days when it'll happen. So you have to secure enough energy.
There's something called, there's a concept called entropy, which is essentially what the, the, the, I'm going to misphrase it, but it's the amount of energy you have to expend just to kind of keep stuff together and empires the bigger and more far flung they get, the more energy they require just to avoid collapse. There's lots of ways you can do that. Lots of them are unpleasant, but they all involve around fundamentally mispricing or buying energy on the cheap. You can do it with gigantic pools of slaves. You can do it with robots and productivity enhancers. You can do it by militarily enforcing a deal where the world has to buy oil and your currency full stop or else you invade it and replace the leadership.
There's lots of ways you can do it. And like I said, this is what's true for empires is true for humans. If we stop eating, all of us are going to be dead in under three weeks. It's scientifically proven. If we stop fertilizing our lawns, our lawns will eventually die. It'll die a lot faster in Arizona than it might here in Ohio, but they'll die. Same concept. It's just natural law. So I think ultimately it's just about how do you couch that? How do you achieve that? What are the various ethics, morality of the regime in question? What's your worldview? What can you do culturally, etc? And that varies over time, but empires require lots of energy.
And that's where you can see things. That's the fundamental miscalculation. Most Americans and most people in Washington think American power comes from the dollar. But without the energy, without that dollar, think about it this way. How many dollars do you want to hold if every gas station in the United States is empty? If you show up with your dollars to fill up your car and they're all empty, what value is the dollar? We have at least the directional experiment we can refer to. It's called the 1970s gas lines. Dollar didn't do so well in 1970s. No fiat currency really did. But that's the fundamental base layer for currencies is energy.
And that, look, that can change. That doesn't necessarily have to be oil. If we were had a lot of foresight, we could build up an electrification and a domestic infrastructure and build up a bunch of nuclear power plants and run tens and hundreds of thousands of miles of electrical trains and completely, you know, and electrical vehicles, there where we didn't need oil. And oh, by the way, this is what China has been doing for 15 years while we spend seven billion dollars for seven charging stations, like the Biden administration just did. Energy is the fundamental error. It is understood at the highest levels of finance, at the highest levels of US administrations dating back decades.
It's understood at the highest levels of US and global militaries. And you just, all you have to do is watch what they do, not what they say. They're not where they are for freedom and democracy and all this stuff. Come on. I mean, if that happens as a side benefit, great. That's not why they're there. We've done macro episodes talking about like the primacy of the US dollar. There's always kind of this connotation of an arc to the dollar. And like growing up as a child, maybe it was just because I was naive. Maybe it was because in the United States was in good times in the 90s when it had like energy backing the dollar.
And I just kind of remember as we invaded Afghanistan and Iraq just like obsession around like the price at the pump, it turns into like a reoccurring news headline on like my local news. So like flashing red lights, price at the pump and then like the price of gas would just like be on the screen. And that was like a news story for like all my childhood. Maybe it still is. I just don't watch TV anymore. I'm wondering Luke, if if like the arc of the dollar is like coming to everyone kind of alludes to like a coming to an end of the arc of the dollar. And I'm wondering if like this is something that you are also similarly doing just with the context of using energy to kind of frame that conversation.
Is there like a like a collision course that the dollar is having with like energy? Is that kind of what you're alluding to? I think it's well underway. I think when you again, when you watch the behavior of players at the highest level, I think it's been well underway for 10 years. So when global central banks stop buying treasury bonds and buy gold instead, they're telling you in essence, we are nervous about the purchasing power of treasury bonds in oil terms. The deal in essence, the US had with the world in 73 after you know, this sort of set up the petrodollar system was never expressed, but you can see it in the financial prices of charts of treasury bonds and oil and rates etc, which is the US had to keep the dollar as good as gold for oil.
They had to keep the treasury bond as good as gold for oil. If you go back 150 years, the price of oil and gold is remarkably steady. And if you go from 1973 to 2003, the price of a treasury bond in barrels of oil is fairly steady. It's 15 to, I'm doing the math right, you know, say it's a thousand dollar face value of treasury bonds and oil from 73 or 74 through 2003 or 2004 consistently traded between 15 and 30 dollars, right? So 33 barrels or 33 barrels to, you know, 60 barrels per treasury bond give or take 33 to 33 to 50 something like that. Anyway, the dollar was as good as gold for oil.
That was the deal. And so people didn't mind holding dollars is starting around 2004, 2005 combination of factors China entering WTO and growing. And so their oil demand was exploding. Geological realities where peak cheap oil was starting to bite as some of the world's biggest oil fields that were account for a remarkably high percentage of the world's daily oil production began peaking and rolling over things like Cantarell in the Gulf of Mexico, some other ones. Oil prices stopped that the dollar stopped being good as gold for oil. The treasury bond stopped being as good as gold for oil. So much so that by summer of 2008 oil was 150, right?
So now you've gone from a 30 year period from 73 to 0304 where oil is, you know, 15 to 30 dollars a barrel or when you know what did I say, 40 to 60, 40 to 60 barrels per treasury bond. Now you're getting six barrels of oil, seven barrels of oil at 150 for your thousand dollar treasury bond. That's not a good deal to hold treasury bonds anymore. And I think ultimately the reason why central banks have been spent the last 10 years slowly and more recently much more rapidly moving away from treasuries instant and holding gold instead is a big part of it is energy awareness. We have to have a reserve asset that holds its value in energy terms or else we're dead.
And you can see this with China. You can see this with Russia. You can see this quite honestly as far back as 99 with Europeans with the structure of the euro with how they treated gold. More recently, there's been some sanctions issues as well that I think accelerated this meaningfully, but this fundamental monetary reality that nobody's going to hold paper if paper falls against the necessities of living energy for very long. And they will switch to reserve assets that hold their purchasing power in energy terms like gold if that situation is violated for too long. It's really interesting when you're looking through an energy lens and you're looking at what is money and you're answering that question.
We often talk about money as a store of value, a medium of exchange, a unit of account. And you could just add the suffix for energy at the end of each of those. What is a good money? It's a medium of exchange for energy. It's a store of value for units of energy. It's a unit of account for energy. It's all of those things. And the petro dollar has had that in the past. I want to ask this question, though, and this might be still a one-on-one type question for you, Luke. But I think it's on many listeners' minds. When you talk about the price of energy, you were going back multiple times to a barrel of oil.
And it's like, why a barrel of oil? I've got a chart open. This is from Visual Capitalists. It's starting human energy use from the 1800s all the way to 2020. In the early days and the 1800s, we're using a lot of traditional biomass. I imagine that stuff like wood as energy, like coal, burning coal on a whale blubber, stuff like this, biomass. And now, of course, we're well into the 2000s. A lot of energy comes from coal, oil, natural gas, nuclear, and renewables. That's kind of the energy mix. But you keep going back to barrels of oil. Are these things like composable? Are they fungible? Why barrels of oil when our energy mix is more diverse than just oil?
Oil is still, I mean, you can look at that chart, right? Especially if we take out traditional biomass out of it. We're talking about coal. We're talking about oil. We're talking about gas. And then there's nuclear renewables and everything else. And it's oil, eyeballing it looks like it's probably still 40% of the mix. Oil and gas is still easily a majority of the mix, particularly as they're phasing out coal. So I look at it as it's still by far one of, if not the biggest marginal sources of energy, it is still the primary transport fuel by far, which is in a globalized supply chain world is critical.
So it's still a very critical. It's the biggest marginal source. It's still 40% of the production. And it's easily identifiable. We could certainly use B to use a gas. We could use, I don't even know what we would use for uranium. If you want to use whatever the thermal unit is that they're using, end of the day, it doesn't really matter. It's basically proxy for B to use. And so I guess I followed this. One thing I've just learned in my investing journey, and this is probably one of the most important learning lessons in general, is pick your denominator very wisely for how you measure investment returns.
What is your denominator? Is it is it dollars or maybe should it be something else? I remember a conversation David and I had with Arthur Hayes, who said like if he could pick any denominator of wealth, right? He probably picked barrels of oil. In fact, if he could like store enough oil, he'd have like a little oil can around his belt, he said, and just like store his wealth that way, he says hydrocarbons are essentially the denominator is units of energy, right? So any investment return is it's not enough to outperform dollars, not enough to outperform the stock market. You actually have to outperform barrels of oil or else you're better off like holding energy.
Let me ask you the kind of the same question. When you approach investing just in general, is energy kind of your denominator or do you use something else? How do you think about this? I think about when I think about what oil is, I think gold is just a proxy. I think about Bitcoin, Bitcoin is just a proxy through the proof of work, expenditure of energy. Gold, you have to expend energy to mine it and refine it and then you have it and you hold it and there it is. So it's it is I think about the denominator. I mean, I live in a dollar country. It's a dollar reserve currency world. And so I consistently have two things in mind.
What's the dollar return and what's the real return? And that's I think ties back to my initial point that I think most people don't understand what's happening still, which is most people are still assuming dollar equals oil. They're assuming the denominator is the same. And I think they're different and not even I think I know they're different. I can show it to you on the charts. I can I can I have a chart on my Twitter feed or X feed today. S and P 500 total returns in January 120 in dollars up 75% in gold up 15% in Bitcoin down 81%. That chart telling you the denominators are wildly different.
And yet most people are still viewing bonds in particular, but markets more broadly in general through this lens that the dollar is as good as gold for oil. And demonstrably empirically it's not it hasn't been in it. More importantly, the debt load of America unless we are going to slash defense and entitlement spending by probably 30 to 40% tomorrow forever. And then deal with what would fall out of that, which would be a worse than the great depression probably times two. There's there's no way the dollar can stay as good as gold for oil can't it can't you so we're watching in real time a breaking of that long standing relationship of 73 to oh three or oh four where the dollar was as good as gold for oil.
And then we had broke down for a bit right I said oil went to 150 by you know from from oh four to eight oil went from 40 to one one 50. And then we had the shale miracle right we had shale from coin at 2010 through I don't know 2020 we'll say and shale reestablished the dollar as being as good as gold for oil again at a higher rate right so the new number wasn't you know oil didn't trade you know 73 to oh three oil trades 15 to 30 most of the time 20 to 30 most of the time post shale oil trades 50 to 90 most of the time really now the numbers price 70 to 90 most of the time but I can look at shale production and and most importantly in the mother of all shale fields the Permian it's flat it's that U.
S. shale's flat to rolling over and to keep it from rolling over really fast they need higher prices but to get higher prices between higher inflation which is going to blow up the bond market which we can't abide either so what what's happening in shale we're basically in the early days of sort of the second round of this dollar equals oil denominator being broken it was broken in oh four oh five and then it sort of was reestablished by 11 12 by shale and now it's breaking again and there isn't a shale fix coming for oil the fix is hey let's all drive electric cars except there's no chance we're going to have the grid for that anytime in the next 10 years and that assumes we have the copper for any of that which is a very low chance any time in the next 10 years and that we have the nuclear power base load for that any time in the next two 10 years assuming we could get the first two sooner than minimum of 10 years and there's no chance there's no frigging chance so I think we're again in this re-entering this period of time that we last on oh three oh four where there's this recognition of oh my gosh the dollar is not the dollar is breaking its tide of energy again what do you want well then gold did awesome gold went from 300 to 2000 in eight years you know that sounds probably about right eight you know seven x six x it's probably about right and now we didn't have bitcoin then now we do so I think you're gonna see that do really well I think you'll see industrials do well I think you'll see inflation be sticky and high I think commodities will do well but that's it's it's when when we when when you talk about the fundamental misperceptions that's it people are still thinking that the dollar and a unit of energy are equivalent and they're not anymore they can't be we're watching the early days of that breakdown again but you you said a few things before so it seems like gold is better able to preserve its oil its energy purchasing power and you've said this gold is rebecoming an oil currency which is interesting and maybe taking some of the the the place of the dollar and the petro dollar at just like the the highest of levels Luke what why does energy get more expensive in dollar terms and fiat no terms and then why why does it get cheaper is it basically kind of like a supply demand like like type of thing where you know it seemed like energy prices in in dollar terms like decreased as a result of the the shale boom because we you know got a civilizational unlock and we just discovered all of this you know shale mining cheap natural gas resource and so that was a big unlock for us so it seems like maybe a pattern here is technological unlocks can decrease the price of energy at least relative to a fiat so long as that empire is maybe like controlling that resource so is that a pattern that plays out and then why does it get expensive over time like so what are the puts and takes of why energy increases in price and why goes down at least in fiat terms question we can go back to 1970 US oil production was peaking and rolling over we were the world's biggest oil producer it was starting to roll over and you could see that it was going to leave us dangerously dependent on the Middle East we're starting to see oil imports rise what have you you can read various takes on it but it was under remember in 1970 the dollar was gold back so when we talk about the price of oil in 1970 it wasn't priced in dollars ultimately was gold so what's one way of dealing with a geopolitical situation where the US domestic production which we control is rolling over it's going to leave us have a more much more heavily exposed to cheaper production from places that are either very volatile the Middle East and which may not really like us the Middle East or that we were involved in a cold war in the Russians how do we deal with that well there is a view that American politicians at the highest level understood that oil liked gold in other words the Arabs liked gold they liked the gold back dollar great close a gold window what happened we disconnect gold from the dollar disconnect the dollar from gold price of oil goes up a lot because it's no longer connected to gold you can see that right so we disconnect the oil from we disconnect the dollar from gold and the price of oil goes from about three to about 12 in a very short period of time that right there tells you the difference between oil and fiat and oil and gold geopolitically strategically it's brilliant on two fronts number one if you're involved in a cold war with a major power the Soviets who derive a lot of their revenue and power from oil and they have to expend the real energy to lift the oil move the oil refine the oil blah blah blah while you simply print the dollars because you've struck a deal with the biggest marginal producer the Saudis that it's all priced in dollars now everybody has to have dollars to have oil you just print oil you can print dollars for oil you're gonna win the cold war eventually it might take a while and and sure enough 18 years later we did number one number two it was strategically brilliant because the resulting price of energy increase made economic oil basins that were unackenomic assuming a gold back dollar gold back dollar oils at three UK North Sea they knew existed wasn't like they just discovered it just couldn't afford to produce it it's too expensive it's underwater blah blah blah Gulf of Mexico same thing prudobae Alaska same thing so as oil explodes through the 70s guess what comes online in the 80s massive amounts of oil supply in very friendly areas Alaska Gulf of Mexico UK North Sea great yes you have an inflationary shock and blah blah blah 70s but now you can print dollars for oil on the Russians can't and now you bring on a bunch of oil supply at the higher price once you disconnect the dollar from gold and you bankrupt the Russians and you win the cold war well ah so when you look at it through that lens like like shale was a miracle and and the sort of the the steerable length of the of the of the horizontal fracking runs that clearly was a technological advance no question and some of the the 3d mapping and all of that stuff incredible but they knew about shale in the early 80s they knew about those basins in the early 80s they knew they were there again when oil goes to 150 voila hey guess what's affordable now US shale so we so then we fract it so it was a combination of currency devaluation the dollar fell 90% against oil right from 98 through oh 8 98 oils 10 bucks a barrel oh 8 oils 150 a barrel right that's 90% decline in the value of the dollar against oil and what did we get for that we got a big exploitation of the shale basin when you combine it with some of the technology of improving and fracking as fracking wasn't invented in you know 2010 but some of the technological the the long laterals and the steering and the imaging and that stuff that clearly improve the productivity of those those basins so the point is is that you the question is a big one because you can make it do whatever you want it to do based on your geopolitical goals do you want cheap oil offer a deal where you'll send a couple grams of gold with every barrel and then they'll take very little fiat and on the qt you send gold over and boom oil prices will stay low do you need more domestic production for geopolitical reasons okay you're gonna need more oil inflation to do that so how do you do that you you you you shift it to a poorer currency a weaker currency fiat oil will get more expensive so it it just it depends on your goals of what you're trying to achieve geopolitically domestic policies etc the rule of thumb is is it's a version of Gresham's law if you're going to pay in fiat currencies oil is going to be expensive if you're paying gold oil is going to be really cheap I think this is part of the reason that many of us have an energy blindness is because like the last 40 years energy has been like relatively cheap so we've just like lived in that world we've never lived in a world of of kind of energy you know cost spikes and this type of thing but look maybe I before we get into how this affects monetary the monetary system and the us as a dollar as a global reserve currency status I just want to ask a final question on energy and that's it so it and that's this it seems in the 2010s we got this like shale type natural gas miracle right and you said as the price of oil increased it's sort of incented us to go like gets you know extract some of this natural gas are there any other energy miracles out there just like waiting for us I mean if if price of oil spikes can we just not tap into some other natural resource it's like for the history of my life something is always emerged as a technical solution to the energy problem and it's just we've been able to continuously kick the can down the road like why can't we just find another miracle are there are there others waiting for us here do you think this time it's different I think you can always it's always a question of what's the miracle and what are the second derivative impacts right so um you know AI can be a productivity miracle and what are we going to do with the you know 10% of population that's unemployed by AI or you know are they all you know we we the happy version of that is oh they're all going to be artists sitting there to pursue what they love and all these things and like that sounds good and the reality is like we have an we have experienced with that China was a productivity miracle China into the WTO in December of 01 and then the next nine years six million manufacturing jobs were lost they went overseas those thirty five percent of global manufacturing we know all sort of how that played out they didn't all become artists they didn't right there was there was there was it the reality is much messier are there energy things that could be classified by the government or or that we have sure there's stuff that could happen there's there's small modular nuclear reactors we've seen discussions of um there's probably stuff they have that they don't necessarily want to roll out unless they have to or want to um that wouldn't surprise me in the least but again what are the second derivative implications of that you know nuclear fusion like nuclear fusion's you know 10 years away it's been 10 years away for 80 years um you know we'll see so there's you know it depends on what you think the second derivative impacts might be and those things can be pleasant or unpleasant depending on how they are allowed to evolve so we have been in a paradigm of the petrol dollar which i'm sure bank listeners are familiar with that term like the formal coupling of basically energy uh petrol and the dollar and this has been like the equilibrium that we've been in for many many decades uh and we've been watching like over in the east uh China's using the the the you want to start to do some of their trade uh in violation of the petrol dollar uh and we've heard you say this line in in other podcasts uh the price of oil will ultimately force a monetary change uh and i'm wondering if you can kind of unpack that because i think what you're alluding to and what the world is heading towards is that well previously the oil the price of oil backed the dollar and now the price of oil is going to work against the dollar that's kind of like the divide that i've been getting i'm wondering if you can kind of unpack this this take about the price of oil forcing a monetary change well i think that dollars can remain the reserve currency i but gold is empirically replacing treasuries as a primary reserve asset and that will force a repricing much lower of the dollar ultimately in my view uh you can understand why energy is forcing a change by putting ourselves in the shoes of the Chinese Kyle Bass famously said in 2019 look the Chinese they're they're they're importing a lot of oil they have to they have to pay dollars they have a finite amount of dollars their oil consumption is up every year because they're growing and sooner or later they're gonna run out of dollars and when that happens they're going to have a late 90s Southeast Asia currency crisis and political crisis where they have to shrink their economy they have to devalue the yuan and they're going to have an inflationary debt crisis and and and and then the Chinese Communist Party is going to tip over you know he said that in 2019 none of that's happened why because China has gained the ability to buy energy in its own currency why not because China necessarily wants to end the dollar or or create problems for the treasury market this is existential self interest um and oh by the way this whole thing that Kyle's rooting for uh if China tips over Lehman had an eight hundred billion dollar balance sheet it went bankrupt it nearly brought down the financial system China has a thirty seven trillion dollar balance sheet like if he thinks that you know and if if the China hawks think that that this the China tipping over because a dollar shortages around their commodity import bill isn't going to blow up the system they're kidding themselves um they're just kidding themselves the Fed's gonna have to buy everything and in which case the system's gonna change anyway so anyway bit of a side track uh the best thing for China to avoid this currency crisis that that what Kyle laid out is one hundred percent true is switch the currency you pay for it like number one uh is is go around and buy you the exchange dollar stop buying treasury bonds start buying oil fields oil refineries ports coal mines copper mines gold hard assets around the world which they've been doing for fifteen or eighteen years uh with dollars basically every year we send China three hundred billion dollars with a stuff and they use a bunch of that money to buy finite hard assets and since 2018 at accelerating pace they've been converting that into you want denominations so now what they do is instead of paying in dollars they'll pay Russia and you want for oil Russia ends up with you want China ends up with oil okay what is Russia do with the you want well turns out China's the factory of the world and it's no longer making cheap plastic crap at Walmart it's satellites weapons semiconductors Huawei 5G some actually of the cheapest electric cars in the world etc etc etc they make some pretty good stuff so Russia will take their you on they'll buy Chinese goods and with whatever's left over they will buy gold in you want terms except the gold that they buy in you want terms can't be from inside China Chinese rules allow disallow any gold inside China from coming outside of China so if they're going to buy it in Hong Kong Dubai Singapore London elsewhere Shanghai's free trade zone the gold has to first come from London or New York which we can see happening people have been saying wow look gold's going up in price but instead of how it always worked gold ETFs in the west are losing gold tonnage London is losing gold tonnage I wonder why this is hey look Russia's gold holdings are going up or China's gold holdings are going up hey India's gold holdings are going up what's going on here I can tell you what's going on here China knowing that nobody wants the you on and China doesn't want to offer you on denominated government debt because they don't want to end up like the US in 30 years are net settling these oil use you want oil imbalances in gold that floats in price in you want terms and so it's a virtuous cycle allowing this recycling of oil this basically local currency net local currency denominated commodity trade being net settled in gold and the issue is that the oil market alone an annual dollar terms is 12 to 15 times the size of the annual physical gold market gold has to get way bigger so you just have oil this inexorable monstrous bid oil copper gas uranium nickel coal local currency net surplus is being settled in physical gold because nobody wants a paper promise a gold they want the gold the Americans made sure that when they see Russian FX reserves they're going to take the gold they're going to bring it home where they're going to store it in a trusted third party area but at any rate that's what we're watching happen as we speak gold is be rebecoming an oil currency and so what does that mean for the dollar well it means the rest of the world Eurasia doesn't need to store treasuries anymore and they've stopped and so who buys the treasuries well in the short run paradoxically this is really good for the dollar because what happens is there's too many treasuries not enough demand relative to the supply of treasuries and the and rates go up dollar goes up and that's allowed to go on for a bit but the US government has so much debt it can't afford much more beyond four and three quarters or five percent on the tenure so what happens when it hits their treasury market breaks fed treasury command more dollar liquidity washer and repeat gold goes up more so this system is it's a self free and force and systemic transition that is being driven out of geopolitical existential necessity by the Chinese and the Russians who people say who cares except the Chinese are the world's biggest commodity importer the Russians are the biggest commodity exporter that is a market a free market and so they can adjust terms of it gold oil ratios so on so forth as they see fit as they need to that will keep this all going and the Americans will turbocharge it periodically when the treasury market breaks again and they inject more dollar liquidity again because there isn't enough demand for treasuries because foreigners aren't buying them because they don't need to hold treasuries as met as many as as as commodity reserves like they did for the prior 50 years new projects are coming online to the mantle layer two every single week why is this happening maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer two design architecture since it first started building mantle DA powered by technology from eigen DA maybe it's because users are coming onto the mantle layer two to capture some of the highest yields available in defi and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the three billion dollar mantle treasury in the mantle reward station maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants liquidity support and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application maybe it's all of these reasons all put together so if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's defi apps click the link in the show notes so getting started with mantle are you worried about the security of your cross chain transactions cross chains with confidence using transporter the revolutionary token bridging app designed to give you peace of mind powered by chainlink cc ip transporter is your trusted gateway for securely moving assets like eth native usc and link and so many more across some of your favorite blockchains over two point eight billion dollars has been hacked from token bridges to date transporter puts a stop to this by ensuring your transfers are protected by the most robust security features available chainlink cc ip provides level five security backed by multiple decentralized oracle networks and an independent risk management network transporter also provides real-time tracking throughout your transaction with its newly engineered user experience so you'll never have to second guess the safety or location of your assets ever again and the best part transporter makes it simple whether you're a blockchain beginner or a seasoned trader transporters intuitive interface lets you execute cross chain transactions with just a few clicks no additional fees just a low cost for using cc ip which can be paid in link or your blockchains need of gas token but don't just take my word for it see for yourself why transfer offers a stress free bridging experience experience the future of token bridging at transporter.
io and just send it solo is the mobile first an EVM compatible blockchain that's built for the real world and designed for fast low-cost payments worldwide driving real world use cases like opera mini pay one of the fastest growing web three walls with over two million users across africa celo is seeing a meteoric rise with over three hundred and seventy five million transactions and a million monthly active users not to mention tether and circle just deployed native usd t and usc on celo supported by leading exchanges like finance and now celo is looking to come home to a theory as a layer two with a game-changing proposal core contributors at sea labs aims to leverage optimism's opi stack pioneering a transition as the biggest l one to become a layer two with test net arriving as early as summer 2024 with the cello layer two gas fees will stay low and users can even pay for gas using ERC 20 tokens including native usc and usd t sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect but celo is a community governed protocol make your voice hurt in the cello forum to shape the future of the theory follow at celo on twitter and explore the ecosystem built for the real world on celo dot org slash quests look that that was great i want to bring some data points uh to to what you're saying the first is this is a new york times headline china is buying gold like there's no tomorrow and as you're saying there their look uh this looks like to be mostly physically settled the global price of gold has reached its highs levels as as Chinese investors and consumers by the metal at a record pace there's a another uh tweet i think i found this on your timeline as well this is the start of de dollarization this is a graph showing the share of china's trade that settled in rmb just uh china's currency and uh for the very first time in march of 2023 the rmb um share of trade for cross border payments overtook the dollar in terms of uh the currency the china uses for for settlement and there's also uh this um china has a competitor to the swift system which bankless listeners will know what swift is it's basically kind of like the global payments system that is like primarily us and allies uh controlled china as a competitor to that and um they did last year in 2023 over 17 trillion in business volume so you can start to see um the the eroding of the dollar supremacy in this type of a world that is repricing um like currencies at at the base level at the energy i've heard you say this too luke and i i want to ask the question uh of how does the us react to this uh in in terms of its monetary system and like what happens next but you've said this that the us has a choice either bail out the currency or bail out the bond market and this to me is kind of the crux of where we are today and what they choose or how much they choose and one side or the other will probably determine many of the outcomes of what this monetary system change actually looks like but what do you mean when you say the choices between bailing out the currency or bailing out the bond market in a sense what this evolving new monetary system does is leave insufficient foreign demand for treasuries and exponentially rising supply of treasuries and in any asset class if you have more supply than demand you're going to have the price go down well when the price of treasuries goes down rates go up this wouldn't be a problem except the United States has run up thirty five trillion dollars in debt a lot of it doing things that in hindsight weren't very advisable they weren't very good uses of money over the last 25 years Iraq, Afghanistan, bailing out wall street the way they did Syria i could go on and on anyway the issue is then is there is a rate where this supply demand mismatch of treasuries that is being caused and reinforced by this monetary system change in terms of who's reserving what as a reserve asset for net commodity surpluses do they fed and treasury stand aside and let the markets set the interest rate for them and if they do that rates are going to go up and up and up and everything else is going to go down and down and down and the dollar is going to be the strongest currency in the world and there's almost no limit to it um and that is basically defend the currency now the problem of course is that at some point not too far down the road in that process US interest expense will overtake US tax receipts because US tax receipts as it turns out a very interest rate sensitive so as interest rates go up and the dollar goes up it tax receipts are going to go down non-linearly interest expense will go up non-linearly and not too far from here interest expense alone will be more than US receipts at which point either the United States will default on treasury bonds or they will print the difference they will print the interest and that's also known as hyperinflation that's if they stand aside and do nothing and let the currency be strong and let the bond market take the hit that's not going to happen what's going to happen what has happened repeatedly and it ever shorter intervals since the repo rates spike of 2019 September 2019 is rates will hit a point bond volatility will hit a point and then Fed and or treasury will come in and cap US treasury market volatility to prevent further treasury dysfunction they do that by injecting dollar liquidity which then weakens the dollar reduces rates basically it's sort of a temporary version of yield curve control and in that case the release valve is the currency inflation asset prices etc and we've seen them they have you know it's it's almost biblical right where we're we're Peter denied Christ three times well the Fed and treasury and or treasury have come in and and capped bond treasury market volatility one two three four five or six times since September 2019 so at any point in time they could theoretically not do it they're never going to not do it they could let markets twist in the wind a little more than they have but again unless they're willing to let interest expense crowd out defense and entitlements and then ultimately overtake tax receipts where they have to put them in a very bad position that's not going to happen so they will in my view continue to choose support the bond market at the expense of the currency support the bond market at the expense of the currency so every every time they're making that choice are they sort of just like printing money like like who wins and who loses in these scenarios here and then the scenario you predict most well you could call up you know call up a chart of the S&P 500 over TLT long bond ETF over the last five years it looks like this you call up NASDAQ over TLT this is looking at hockey six yeah hockey stick up hockey hockey stick up Bitcoin over TLT hockey stick up gold over TLT ever since global central banks stop buying treasury started buying gold in 2014 it's an exponential hockey stick that is because that that that that describes who wins and how they win home prices over TLT over the last five years if they're going to support the bond market over the currency markets are reflexive and they learn they're going to figure out okay they've done this five times now why bother with treasuries treasuries underperform when markets are selling off like today someone texted me this morning zeros long long and zero coupon bonds are have 4x the beta today of the NASDAQ 100 four times the beta on a down 300 down day right look okay so stocks are down and treasuries are worse okay well when they inject money what out performs on the upside treasuries are NASDAQ well that's an easy one the NASDAQ so when stocks are down then long bond does worse when stocks are up the long bond does worse when you know same thing with gold stocks are down today risk off today gold is outperforming treasuries long term treasuries when they inject the money which they inevitably will gold outperforms on the upside so you you can see what's it reinforces and accelerates this sovereign problem which is not enough demand for treasuries so basically what wins is everything but but treasuries and what wins is inflation what wins is nominal GDP growth what wins is increasing political instability what wins is the 1% and the 0.
1% the people with the assets and that's what we've been watching for five years and I think it's going to continue accelerating you said the the US will be just like Japan but feel like Argentina explain that what does that mean yeah I mean you can read any number of strategists and economists and investors who said well Japan's got all way more debt than us and and they're fine and I know of course you know they've gotten a lot quieter in the last three to six months when all the sudden the whole Japan's fine thing is not working out so well but but they had a point as long as you don't dig into it at all Japan does have more debt than us but Japan has a positive net international investment position of like 65 or 70% of GDP in other words they have a foreign piggy bank of 70% of GDP they own more assets overseas than foreigners own of them they finance internally in other words their own people finance them so that's a really big deal because if you're you've got a lot of debt and you pay them 0% but you're in deflation people are happy to make 1% or 0% on a bond if their cost of living is going down one a year you're standard of living arising no one's complaining your money your bonds are buying you more money every year real rates are positive up the United States is externally funded we don't have the option of of of having a 0% coupon on rates and certainly not having deflation we we can't afford positive real rates we need negative real rates which means we need to steal money from the people who are our bonds we need them to hold bonds while the value the real value of those bonds declines in energy terms like we've just discussed that's that's very different and then lastly China runs a current account surplus they got more money coming in every year we were on the twin deficit by virtue of the system structure we got money going out we got big deficits to finance every year so there's a chart I've showed before it shows that the the bank of Japan's balance sheet is percent of GDP just hockey sticking and people say we're just going to be Japan like yeah sure our the feds balance sheet is going to hockey stick just like the bank of Japan's and the easiest way to frame up why it's going to feel like Argentina right now the feds balance sheets I don't know 35% of GDP 30% of GDP I don't know bank of Japan's like 110% imagine if I told you that in five years the feds balance sheet was going to be 70% of US GDP so 70% that's one four one eight okay so that's about 18 trillion more feds balance sheets be 25 trillion dollars in America in seven years five years is that inflationary or is that deflationary is that Japan or is that Argentina it's Argentina it's 100% Argentina sounds kind of bad I what's bad I what's bad right like what's normal for the spider is chaos for the fly that you own a bunch of long bonds yeah you're gonna get paid every dollar your road if you want a bunch of long-term treasuries but they're gonna go from buying you you know diamonds to buying you cubic seconia to buy you cracker jack on a string because you know what you didn't react fast enough I don't expect a lot of bankless listeners will own a lot of bonds right it's just I think they're they're they're hedged into a different different assets sets we you know like definitely skews younger skews use crypto not the bond bondholder type but in all these scenarios you described bondholders take a massive haircut I guess my question though is what what if that's not enough right that's at some point the demand for bought bonds has got to kind of like you like shrill up the markets a smart enough to understand the the play and what's going on and like is there our other measures going to be needed we had a recent podcast episode with Lin Alden where we talked about a world of of capital controls as well and we can already see some of that creeping in maybe not so much in the US but maybe in some ways you know like there's talk of a CBDC I think you've called that that dangerous before do you think that things could ratchet up to a level where giving bondholders a haircut is is kind of like not enough and the capital has to come from somewhere else and we we move to a regime of of of capital controls I've heard of this book I've not read it yet it's called the great taking I believe I don't know I don't know if you've read that or have a preview of that but that type of a world where the government comes and and basically force confiscates like some some level of wealth or I'm not sure exactly how this this would turn about but do you have any thoughts so the financial oppression side we've already we're already 10 plus years into that right so in 2014 the Fed regulated US banks and the holding more treasuries as high quality liquid assets and we saw how that worked out less spring right with BTFP the banks started selling treasuries or they couldn't sell treasuries because they were so under water they would take the earnings hits of the Fed came in and basically swapped them out at par so that they didn't create a run on treasuries as a result of the run on a few banks 2015 money market funds in the United States were regulated in a buying more tea bills um it crowded out private money market assets sent live order up sent the dollar up 2018 Trump tax reforms incentivize had to contain to pro clauses incentivizing uh US pensions to buy more treasuries um and they did uh so you've you've seen all of this happen and this is just stuff that like Brazil and Argentina and various the emerging market Latin American Asian uh Southeast Asian they're not in the late 90s countries do when they have fiscal problems and it's not been enough to your point and so ultimately there's ways you can there there are extreme measures you can take um you know i've talked about this before if you go to the financial accounting manual for federal reserve banks you can google that it's online it's a public document section two period one zero uh treasury secretary can instruct the fed to revalue the gold on the US government's balance sheet 261 million ounces every four thousand bucks is about a trillion dollars mechanically dropped into the treasury general account free and clear no debt offsetting it twenty thousand dollars announces five trillion dollars yelling could take that five trillion wait into the treasury bond market buy back five trillion and bonds overnight um increase basically the money supply by five trillion dollars overnight voila US debt the G.
P. you just revalue the gold because the US has a ton of gold right i mean it's like the the most gold reserves of uh any country in the world it's like what do you mean revalue it you could just like name your price i mean don't they have to go for a market value what's the market men with their guts like mine and guns tell you what the price is wow hmm that's the it's it's in the federal reserve operating manual so there's levels they didn't know the fed has an operating man right there's a financial accounting standards manual yeah you can look it up google it it's it's right there and so yeah so what happens is yelling gets five trillion dollars deposited into the tga and she buys back five trillion and bonds boom overnight now the US debt the G.
P. is you know between taking out five trillion and bonds and the resulting nominal gdp growth which is going to friggin explode because you just increase the monetary base by five trillion dollars uh so inflation is going to go nuts like that's in the cake that's going to happen no matter what because we've done a bunch of stupid stuff with borrowed money for 30 40 50 60 70 years so now you end up with debt the gdp 50 60 percent now you can raise rate take rates to eight take rates to 10 now you nasty recession who cares you know you're going to put some private sector people out of business but who cares you're not going to threaten the solvency of the US government don't be able to pay 10 percent rates and i'll be happy don't you know if you buy back all that debt and i'll be happy to sell my gold at 20,000 an ounce and buy 10-year treasuries at 10 percent great it's just a wealth transfer now so that's yeah that's one extreme thing you can do the great taking as an example of another extreme thing you can do and and uh what i can say is i don't know David Rogers web personally i know he's a former Cleveland guy i know uh he was his firm was once a client of my uh of my firm uh that that's the author of the great taking like what is the thesis of that book that the thesis of that book is pretty straightforward which and it's very meticulously researched and annotated and and and footnoted which is over the last 30 years US and global policy makers have quietly converted ownership of most financial assets from an ownership uh from legal ownership to uh i forget the legal term but it is basically like a general claim on legal ownership so that in the case of a too big to fail bank or series of too big to fail banks failing under the way it used to be you owned the stocks in your mutual fund those were yours post these changes quietly and surreptitiously made over the last 30-40 years you don't own them anymore they now in the case of a too big to fail bank failure or series of failures your mutual funds your 401k your IRA your pensions the paper wealth of this country go into a general collateral pool to bail out the big banks derivative books first and then if there's anything left over you get your 401k back your IRA back blah blah blah blah blah and with a quadrillion plus and derivatives the answer the the chances of you getting much of any of your assets back on net is slim and num and slim probably left town a few years ago so that's the great taking it a nutshell they just take your assets just confiscate the kind they already took they already took your assets you just don't know it yeah wow that's that's the the great taking was something that unnerved me in a way that I haven't been unnerved in some time I have I'm adding that up to to my reading list because it was just like so fascinating when I when I stumbled across it um you're like look maybe just two more things so we've talked about energy we've talked about the monetary system change who's gonna who's gonna lose from that maybe maybe um who the beneficiaries of that might be I want to talk to you about preparation what we can do as individuals but one quick topic before that is the US itself okay it seems really weak right now uh at least the the tenure of this conversation has been right we got uh you the terrible balance sheet debt to GDP at like historic highs uh you you have a tweet in your timeline somewhere it talks about the Baltimore bridge you know remember the collapsing bridge how estimates for that rebuild uh take 10 years change like we've got other uh countries like China outpacing us in in every way we've got um you know the the um our interest rates on the debt that we pay in the US are now starting to exceed and have exceeded uh the cost of military right which is like also historic for the US but but yeah you've also said you're bullish on the US over the next two decades can can you square this for me with all of the headwinds that we're facing some of the issues we've talked about even just uh if you on the list I I just listed out why are you still bullish on the US for the next two decades why am I still bullish on the US so the US has still I think the best uh legal system property rights etc it's not using it to its advantage as I think it might eventually uh and I I think importantly it's certain more areas certain areas of the US I'm much more bullish on than others um and ultimately you know there's an apocryphal quote by Winston Churchill where he says the Americans always do the right thing after they've exhausted all the alternatives and everything you just listed and in particular that the interest expense is above defense spending we're about out of all the alternatives so like look at at the end of the day what's the right thing to do bondholders are gonna get killed on a real basis we're gonna go through a period of inflation that's really high and we're gonna rebuild and we're gonna do industrial policy and you know we're gonna play catch up for a bit and wages are gonna explode and you know things are gonna be good it's all a question of sort of how does it look like between here and there and what have you and then look there's ways it could go really pear-shaped and and like I said there are parts of this country where I'm not bullish at all on um there's parts I'm very bullish on so some of that depends on where you are in this country so um because some of the leadership is really really bad and some of it's actually decent people who get it so um and the people at Washington they're not there are there are people in Washington that absolutely understand what's happening what has happened what needs to happen and they're brilliant and we don't ever get to see those people we get to see sort of you know the weather people who you know are on TV all the time um you know the spokesperson models and they're not very impressive by and large uh and they haven't been impressive for some time so but the people that are actually sort of behind the scenes there are something they're very very good and they know what needs to be done they know and so it's just really a question of sort of how that plays out where we clear the decks on debt however we do it and then we start playing to our advantages instead of trying to you know maintain the real value of the bond market to keep them wall street guys and some you know some dollar people happy they're gonna be unhappy it is what it is they had 40 years of fun so they're turning the spanking machine well hopefully the the US can take its turn in the spanking machines while it's medicine and and come back stronger and it certainly seems like that that's the necessary course of action and that it won't be the end of the world uh to go through that and to well yeah I mean look a big part of the US has been in the spanking machine for 40 years the US has spent the less 40 years subjugating the US middle and working classes to support the bond market wall street and Washington DC and Washington DC has generally made horrible decision after horrible decision and trade policy foreign policy economic policy and 40 years later they're now admitting that when you have the treasury secretary of the United States like Janet Yellett come out and say well basically throw 40 years of economic orthodoxy in the trash in the wall street journal like she did three weeks ago I miss she gets what she do there she came out and said for 40 years we were taught that if someone wanted to send you cheap goods you should send them a thank you note I would never ever again send China a thank you note national security advisor Jake Sullivan last year to the Brookings Institute went up and gave a speech US economic policy for the last 40 years has been wrong political highlighted in February um the Biden administration is selling treasuries and buying uranium semiconductor fabs copper nuclear power plants as of today and yet there's still all these people they want to own long-term treasure bonds they're telling you this paper is bad on a real basis you don't want to hear the message and that's fine they'll hear it sooner or later um markets are starting to hear it but like there's not one US there's there's multiple US's um and the part of the US that got subjugated the middle and working classes for the last 40 years to support wall street to support certain Washington DC interests as those DC interests sort of you know kick the pieces all over the board in foreign economic and trade policy those interests are now going to lose on a real basis and who's going to win is America you know and you can see this right the 1% the point 1% against the bottom 50% total net worth over the last 30 years done this high inflation high wage inflation isn't bad for America plumbers are making 20% more year and they got a 3% mortgage that's called a debt jubilee on their house so maybe this is exactly what the US needs then Luke 100% it is well maybe to close this out I guess the last question is for individuals when it comes to preparing so we talked about a world of high energy prices at least denominated in dollar terms and fiat terms and this whole monetary system changed the shift um how do investors prepare for this does this at everything that you said it's effectively tells me that the old you know 60 40 equity to bonds like stocks to bond type ratio that is like dead dead of the dead uh at least for you know like investors of our generation this generation what is that true what do we replace the 60 40 with what like what what do we need to know how do we allocate these storms and navigate this as investors if I wanted to keep it really simple I think 60 40 is dead the 40% that's in bonds I would keep 10% of the 40% or a quarter of it maybe maybe maybe maybe even half of it if you're conservative in T-bills at 5% I've got a lot of T-bills I'm happy to clip a 5 and a quarter coupon and roll a paper I see no interest in owning long-term government bonds that makes zero sense to me and then I would take the remainder you know if 10 or 20% in T-bills I would take the other 20 to 30% and I would put it in golden bitcoin and then I would go to the beach that's it that's not hard not hard I mean like I said it's people say oh it's gonna be so bad again what's normal for the spiders chaos for the fly and you keep you keep the stocks you think equities are gonna you know perform okay in this environment yeah I think they'll be fine I think they'll be fine like it's it's and I think a low leverage and low leverage and low consumer loans right like I wouldn't go taking out a huge mortgage to buy a house unless you're really cash flow and it's in some sort of luxury area or something like that like don't go out and and borrow a bunch of money to buy to buy consumer goods because the odds that this is bumpy are very high right like this it's gonna be fine on high volatility how does high volatility high volatility doesn't matter unless you're levered for the average investor it's irrelevant unless you're levered perfect example I've used it before if you look back Dan Oliver at Mermercane Keppel's a great chart showing the price of gold overall and then month over month in Vimer Germany so this is one of the great hyperinflations of all time you should be easy borrow a bunch of money buy gold in German rights marks and get rich except if you were levered you lost all your money four or five times in three years so volatility is so volatile so it's it really is it's it's like equities will be fine I personally prefer stuff that will invest in and benefit from the reassuring and reindustrialization rebuilding of US defense industrial base I have a big personal investment in electrical infrastructure manufacturing it's a private equity investment I like those types of investments I like US industrials I like US energy producers industrials more broadly but I I think equities will be fine generally because again the bubbles in long-term government debt that's where the bubble is everyone wants to believe the bubble is where the last bubbles have been and it's not the bubble is in long-term government debt that's still a variant perception that's start to change but that's still a very very in perception it might be I think that go to the beach part is essential to because what that implies is you're just kind of buying and holding just like relaxing you're forgetting it you're not trading all that volatility you're not like sweating those those details and going on margin right uh yeah that's yeah people think they can trade this why bother what what's happened it's not even I mean a why bother but even if you were inclined to okay good luck but I what's your analog for what's happening you know peak to your boil first global sovereign debt bubble 100 years a quadrillion in derivatives the geopolitical situation a man global monetary system change uh sovereign bond bubble uh western sovereign bond bubble reserve asset of last 50 years is a bubble the volatility is going to be face peeling it has been face peeling it's going to continue to be face peeling and so and and highly political no less right so like look if you're Nancy Pelosi you want to buy calls on Nvidia great but if you're not Nancy Pelosi's kid for the average investoristic are not yeah so just I think it's important to just understand that having low leverage is really really important in terms of managing through this volatility for the average and just playing out now so this is like how long will this take to play out this entire thesis does it does it happen quickly we're talking like you know months to years are we talking still they could continue to kick the the can and get another you know decade out of this old uh rusty car we're we're 10 years into this shift US interest expenses above defense spending you can see the geopolitical impacts um I I think over I think the world could look very different in a good way by the end of the next presidential uh you know by the time we're sitting here getting ready for the election at 2028 I think the world could look very different uh and and the the reason why is interest doesn't sleep compounding interest doesn't sleep and at five and a quarter percent like the US has on a hundred and twenty one percent that the GDP the exponential factor the exponential interest functions a killer moves fast Luke this has been so great thank you so much for joining us I learned so much about energy and and some of these related topics uh I was great to pick your brain today and I think bankless listeners will benefit as well so we certainly appreciate you thanks for me on right it's great being here also bankless nations some action items for you today you know what you need to do is go sign up for Luke's weekly report it is absolutely fantastic dives in deep in some of the the topics we've been discussing today will include a link in the show notes for that as well as his Twitter account where we sourced a lot of the material and and grass for today's conversation it got to let you know of course this whole finance thing is risky so is crypto you could lose what you put in but uh man it's better than the holding bonds right we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot