✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/9?referrer=0x077Fe9e96Aa9b20Bd36F1C6290f54F8717C5674E
------ 🎬 DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-the-justin-drake-vs-anatoly-yakovenko-interview
------ Ethereum vs. Solana. That’s the debate we’re having today.
On Ethereum’s side we have Ethereum Researcher Justin Drake, and on the Solana’s we have Solana’s Co-Founder Anatoly Yakovenko.
They give us the good, the bad and the ugly of each other’s blockchain, settling their endgame towards the end of the episode.
This was one, if not the spiciest debate we had on the show. We tried our best to give both guests time with minimal intervention. At times went well, at others it caused deep semantic rabbit holes. But overall both guests were able to communicate their messages.
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo 🏠 CASA | SECURE YOUR GENERATIONAL WEALTH https://bankless.cc/Casa.
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🌐 TRANSPORTER | CROSS CHAINS WITH CONFIDENCE https://transporter.io/
⚡️ CARTESI | LINUX-POWERED ROLLUPS https://bankless.cc/CartesiGovernance
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
7:16 The Good
22:30 The Bad
52:03 Global Shared State
1:06:07 Economic Security
1:30:08 The Ugly
1:47:23 The Endgame
1:55:22 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Anatoly Yakovenko https://twitter.com/aeyakovenko
Justin Drake https://twitter.com/drakefjustin
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
There is a reason why Ethereum data availability is worth more than Solana's data availability because of network effects. Yes, this notion of shared security, this notion of synchronous composability of because of the economic security. Not just that, but also access to TVL access to applications. There's only one EMS in the world, right? There's only one Ethereum and Internet. This is really weak. This is, this is why I think it's ugly and it's not fixable is it's not a fundamentally hard thing. Welcome to Bangladesh, where today we're exploring the frontier of Ethereum versus Solana in debate style format.
This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. So on the debate track today, Ethereum versus Solana. We've got a conversation between Ethereum researcher Justin Drake and co-founder of Solana and it's totally Yaka Venko. Now both of these were previous bankless guests. I'm sure you know them from their respective communities. The prompt for this episode was really simple. Give us the good, the bad, and the ugly of each other's respective blockchain ecosystems. Take the conversation wherever you want. You can talk about architecture, you can talk about economic security, and indeed the guests did.
David and I tried to give both guests time to debate each other with minimal intervention, and I think at times this went well. At other times, it probably causes to go down into semantic rabbit holes fairly deeply. But overall, I think both guests were able to communicate their main messages throughout this episode. Sometimes they were attacking, sometimes they were defending, occasionally they were throwing each other compliments, and it's a very entertaining episode overall. If you pay attention to Anatolian Drake on Twitter, you'll know of a couple of topics that are coming your way. Is economic security a meme?
Is issuance a cost? Some big dividing lines. Finally, get thrust out in long form on this episode. How did this episode come to be? It was actually kind of spawned out of just a simple ping from a member of the bankless discord asking if it were possible to get Justin and Anatolian podcasts together to have a debate. And I was like, hmm, I also want this. And since it didn't really hurt to ask, Kapan asking both Justin and Anatolian said, yeah, sure. And so after a bit of scheduling, here we are. I think the one thing I'll say about this episode, generally like crypto at large, when people enter crypto, they generally find a tribe pretty quickly.
You come into crypto, you learn about it, and then you learn about a layer one that you identify with more than others, because it aligns with your vibe. The how and why people become members of the tribe is like, personally, I think one of the more interesting things to explore in crypto. And you can really see it come out in this debate. You can really see some of the dividing lines between just who Justin is and what Ethereum is and who Anatolian is and what Solana is. So that's kind of like the frame of frame of mind that I encourage listeners to go into this episode with as they hear, Justin and Anatolian parse out some of these things, finally in a long form conversation.
So let's go ahead and get to that long form conversation. But first, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. So whether you are convinced by Anatolian, you want to buy Solana or you're convinced by Drake, you want to buy ETH, you can all do it on the same place, which is Kraken. I prefer crypto exchange for 2024. If you do not, have an account with Kraken. Consider clicking the links in the show, so getting started with Kraken today. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world.
Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone, everywhere, to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team, available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience.
So check out the simple, secure and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Cello is the mobile first and EVM compatible blockchain that's built for the real world and designed for fast, low-cost payments worldwide. Driving real-world use cases like Opera Mini-Pay, one of the fastest growing Web 3 wallets with over 2 million users across Africa. Cello is seeing a meteoric rise with over 375 million transactions and a million monthly active users.
Not to mention Tether and Circle just deployed native USDT and USDC on Cello, supported by leading exchanges like Binance. And now, Cello is looking to come home to Ethereum. As a layer two, with a game-changing proposal core contributors at Sea Labs aims to leverage Optimism's OP stack pioneering a transition as the biggest L1 to become a layer two. With TestNet arriving as early a summer, 2024. With a Cello layer two, gas fees will stay low and users can even pay for gas using ERC20 tokens, including native USDC and USDT, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets, using social connect.
But Cello is a community-governed protocol. Make your voice heard in the Cello forum to shape the future of Ethereum. Follow at Cello on Twitter and explore the ecosystem built for the real world on Cello.org slash quest. Picking self-custody of your crypto is one of the most important things you can do on your bank list journey. It's also one of the hardest things to get right, with huge consequences if you don't. If you want help going bank lists, talk to Cosa. Cosa helps you take custody of your crypto assets so you don't have to wonder whether you're doing it right. Cosa is a one-stop shop for doing self-custody the right way.
With Cosa Vaults, you can hold Ether, Bitcoin, stablecoins, all with one simple app and multiple keys for the ultimate piece of mind, with a support team to help you every step of the way. But it doesn't stop at self-custody because even though crypto is forever, you are not. We all plan on making life-changing wealth in crypto, but with Cosa's inheritance product, life-changing wealth can elevate to generational wealth. For your kids and your loved ones, who don't know anything about crypto. With Cosa, you won't lose your private keys, and you won't accidentally take them to the grave either.
Click the link in the description to get started securing your generational wealth. Bank listation. We are extremely excited to tee up this conversation to esteemed guests. We have Anatoly Yakavenko, he's the creator of Salonies, the co-founder of Salona Labs. He has Mr. Consensus at the speed of light. Anatoly, welcome to Bank list. Love that intro. Thank you for having me. And in the other corner, I don't know if I should do fighting meme for this, but Justin Drake, he is a researcher at the Ethereum Foundation. He has Mr. Ultrasound money, Justin, welcome to Bank list. Thanks for having me as well.
Guys, this is going to be a conversation between some of the design decisions and differences between Salona and Ethereum. I think this is a conversation that the entire crypto community will tune in for. It's great to have you both. I think the way we're going to organize this is in a few seconds, sections. So the good, the bad, the ugly. First, we're going to talk about the good. Then we're going to talk about maybe the bad, the things that are correctable over time. Then we're going to talk about the ugly. Of course, we can veer from one section to the other as you guys see fit. But let's start the conversation with something hopeful, something optimistic, the good side of things.
I want to start the question with you, Justin. So let's talk about the good. What is good about Salona from your perspective? So if I were to think. Oh, sorry. I was just unmuted. I had to unmute. I had to share. So if I were to have a metaphor in mind, I'm thinking of the good as a bucket with balls in it. And actually think of the good bucket as being the one with the most balls. So the largest one with the most volume. And Salona has lots of obvious good balls in its bucket. It has a very high throughput, very low fees, very good UX, low latency. It has good traction, millions of users. It has good adoption, good financial performance.
Actually, that has been amazing. We've seen Salona raised to basically position number three. So if you go to CoinGecko and sort by fully diluted valuation, Salona is the number three layer one. And I'm tempted to change the quote by Michael Sayler and say that there is no fourth best. If you look at if you look at fully diluted valuation, there's like there's a ripple, there's a BNB, there's ton, but like they don't really compete in my opinion with Salona. So it really is those three players in the layer one space. And I think what Salona is doing for Ethereum is that it's providing healthy competition.
It's a sort of accelerationism. And not only accelerationism partly because of good execution, but also because of contrarianism. Like the way that I think of Anatolia as is this constantly contrarian person, like his brain is wired in a very unusual way. And I say this in the best way possible. My wife was this is her favorite feature about me. And I think you guys, you know, bring forward like interesting insights and you have, you know, good vision. So for example, I think that, you know, you want to build this idea of a global state machine. What does that mean? The global means that a single L1 can support the whole world.
Like in my mind, we're going to see L1s that can support 10 million transactions per second, which is enough for the whole world. It's 100 transactions per second per human per day. And then the other big idea that Salona brings to the table is this idea of synchronicity that not only is there like high scalability, but also different parts of the state can call each other synchronously, at least if you're willing to pay for it. I also think that Salona has very good pace and reactivity. There's been all sorts of issues in the past that we're going to talk about in the bad section. But broadly speaking, it just keeps on checking along and moving along.
And in terms of the insights, I think like there are real insights that, you know, Anatolia, you bring to the table, for example, the fact that we live in this exponential world with Nielsen's law, right? The fundamental bottleneck for scaling blockchains is bandwidth, and we are in this very luxurious position where bandwidth keeps on on scaling exponentially. So overall, this is a massive bucket of good for Salona. And Toli, your turn to talk about Ethereum. What is in the good bucket for Ethereum? I mean, tons of stuff. I think what I envy out of Ethereum is the main net has a very large distributed network across a very large number of physical and nodes and very large number of actual internet links.
So when you look at it as a whole and you think of what are these networks supposed to do, the mission that Ethereum has is supposed to provide security guarantees that are stronger than an honest majority. So if you end up with accepting honest majority guarantees, which are fine for a lot of use cases, it's a multi-sig at the end of the day. I think you just can't really scale it to support the world in a trustless way. Just know that you can't have banks and 401k's and human finance trust some honest majority that could blow up at any moment. Nobody wants that. So you need better than that.
And I think Ethereum has been so hyper focused on this that when they started working on charting, they pivoted away from that because there's no way to do it, which is awesome. It's actually the coolest thing to see somebody be like, you know what, this is not going to work because of the security properties we care so much about. We're going to work on this other roadmap first because that one doesn't compromise something really, really important. And the execution for people like think Ethereum is moving slow, but if you look at the size of the network, its value, I would be terrified of any changes to Solana.
If it was at that value, it's just terrifying for something to go wrong. Outages at that point are much more catastrophic, I think. So Ethereum actually most pretty fast for a project at size. The four clients is awesome. I think this is again the biggest thing that you're supposed to provide is this better than honest majority security guarantees. And when you have four clients, you're not trusting a single piece of software. Even with the best of human intentions, it's still written by humans, right? Like the original BFT paper actually talks about, you need to have separate teams building stuff in isolation so you can actually have this fault tolerance across the human bus factor.
So there's a lot of envy there. And I think that's awesome. Like from my perspective, Ethereum is at a point where to cause a double spend attack, you need NATO to coordinate across the thousands of different ISPs and to have everyone execute like a thing all at once. And that's basically like, great. I don't think you can do better than that in the real world. So it's at a point which I think every other L1 should be MVSF and trying to get there as fast as they can, right? As fast as they reasonably can. All of that I think is puts it in a class, I think in my mind actually above Bitcoin. So for what that's worth.
We're starting this off on a very nice foot then. Both of you said nice things about the other primary ecosystem. And it's only just curious, your reflections on what Justin said about Salona. Do you agree with his characterization? What was going through your mind as Justin was saying these things? Sure. I mean, I think I find those to be positives of what Salona has accomplished. I think probably because of my experience working at Qualcomm for like a decade, I saw how fast Nielsen's law moves and how fast Moore's law moves when it's targeting an industry that's in hyper growth. And you just kind of your brain as an engineer shifts.
You're not writing for code for hardware today or yesterday even. You're writing for your hardware that's going to be out in two to four years. So you're expecting just everything to get faster. So this is something that I think has been something that I've been like kind of hitting the table with to all the engineers that are working on Salona's. You got to build things to scale as if the hardware is twice as fast. Just assume it's going to be twice as fast. How are you writing the code? How you're designing the SIMDs and kind of leverage that. And I think that focus is paid off honestly. That was a big but that a small team like a very small team that was had way less funding than all our competitors took from 2018 to 2020 to launch and we launched faster because we're like, don't make this complicated.
Just throw a thread pool there. It takes work, right? It takes engineering, but it's much easier to think of problems like, okay, like even look at proof of history. It's not. I remember talking to Justin like a week after we like became an official company about VDFs. And our solution was this very, very extremely dumb approach. Just verify the VDF with as many cores as you have available to you. And don't worry about this fancy math that I don't understand if it's secure or not. And that worked. So like stuff like this I think is underappreciated. And I'm glad that, you know, Justin is recognized that in some ways.
So Justin and Toli has said some nice things about Ethereum said it would take NATO to disrupt the network and cause a double spend. And like maybe they couldn't even do it. So it's, you know, like more, I forget the phrase theology and Toli, but like on a higher pedestal than Bitcoin, let's just say. So what was going through your head is in Toli was extolling the virtues and the values of Ethereum there. Yeah. So one thing that Toli said, which I agree with is that we, it's kind of bad design nowadays to try and rely on this majority. And it is true that our previous starting design did rely on this majority.
But this is something that we have moved away from just through technological innovation. So now there's this idea of data availability sampling while you don't have an honest majority, you have an honest minority. And we have this new flavor of shouting, which is dank shouting. And not only have we removed the honest majority assumption, but we've also added synchrony. So it used to be that we had a one thousand twenty four or sixty four asynchronous shots that would each have its own independent proposal. And instead now we have kind of this one big proposal that basically publishes a big block that everyone is capable of verifying is, is indeed available using very, very low bandwidth.
And this technique is called data validity sampling. And I think and I totally had a podcast called no shouting. And you know, eventually decided to change the name. I think this is good because the fundamentals are really in favor of shouting what least dank shouting in terms of other things that he said is one is that it's very, very difficult for to double spend Ethereum. Now while I agree with that statement, I think this is kind of the wrong lens. And the reason is that there is a much easier attack than double spend, which is basically around censorship and and liveliness. So I totally focuses a lot in my opinion on safety.
And to a very very large extent, I agree that safety is not one because the validity of blocks can be checked by full notes. So if you try and just create an invalid chain, it will just get rejected. And for specifically reorgs and double spends, there is this notion of slashing is just so expensive to do the attack that it's basically impossible. But there is like these these more subtle attacks around liveliness and central persistence, which I think are the ones that are most important. And I think are ones that Anatoli is under indexing upon it. Maybe we can talk about this later. And another thing that Anatoli said is Cindy and maybe the listener might not know what that means.
So I just wanted to highlight it. It's the equivalent of an EIP for Solana. It means Solana improvement document. Beautiful. As we kind of wrap up this good section, I want to give also a chance for each of you guys to maybe elevate something that is unsung about your own ecosystem. So Anatoli talked about what's good about Ethereum. Justin talked about what's good about Solana. All of a sudden, this is really feeling like therapy, but we'll ignore that. He said it wrong with therapy. We did not mean for this to feel like a therapy session, but nonetheless here we are. But maybe Justin, maybe you can advocate for Ethereum.
What's something unsung about Ethereum that you think is definitely in the good category that is worth elevating? And of course, we'll go to Anatoli afterwards. Right. So one of my mental models is that the layer one space is winner-take-most. And so we need to ask ourselves, who is going to be that winner? What are the shedding points? What are the structural advantages? And in my opinion, Ethereum has one in the sense that it is the place with the most natural effects, with the most liquidity. It is the one that is the most mature, the most secure. And so that is maybe the best compliment that you can give to Ethereum is that it's pre-ordained in some sense as Anatoli mentioned to flip Bitcoin and become number one.
And this meme where there's this guy who says, it's not just about waiting, but everyone else needs to lose. Well, it's a little bit like that, just because of market dynamics. I really do see a world where at the layer one level, the network effects are so strong that it makes it extremely difficult to be an alternative layer one. And I think this is one of the struggles that Solana will have going forward. Anatoli, feel free to reflect upon that and then also just elevate something that you think that is unsung about Solana that deserves more praise. Yeah, I guess for my perspective, I kind of treat these systems as backend systems and developers are expected to kind of learn and switch every two to five years, like it's just part of life.
So it's really, really hard to have a remote. And you see that with languages and databases and stuff like that, even though Oracle is still around, but makes most of its money through licensing. And people use Redis since SQLite and as hardware improves, SQLite becomes easier and easier to deploy for the kind of use cases that you would need like Oracle, my SQL before. So you kind of have a lot of tension and competition in the backend, even though being first mover is an awesome advantage. I think what's unsung about Solana, probably that I think why we're succeeding in a lot of ways is because the developers are not infrastructure focused for the most part.
They're focused on apps. So if you look at trying to get users, you need to give them something to use. Like that's that's fundamentally, you need to provide value to a user. And if you look at Solana investment dollars are smaller than Ethereum's, but vast majority of them are going to products that are user targeting. You can actually, I don't know if this is true or not, I haven't done the numbers, but my guess is that actual product investment to Solana and Ethereum might even be compatible. So what's unsung is that how well the Solana devs are executing on actually user capture, building products and stuff like that.
More so than, you know, people talk about Ethereum having network effects. I think most of those around in the infraside, which is just a piece that's not necessary if you have a high-performance low-cost chain. So there. I mean, while I would agree with the statement that Ethereum culture to a very large extent focuses on infrastructure, historically, I think there is a shift now. So we have L2s like base, arbitragem optimism, where you just come in as a dev and you just don't have to think about infrastructure. It just scales magically. It just works. You don't have to worry about scaling, about fast confirmations and things like that.
The metric speaks for themselves, actually. But no trade-offs, right? So there are trade-offs, but they're being taken. And in some sense, what these teams are doing is that they're making even more trade-offs than Solana and being willing to kind of play the even longer game, right? In some sense, Solana is like fake it until you make it. So it comes in with like lots and lots of technical good debt and then is using that as a strategy for user acquisition. And then, you know, as there's a new fire that comes in, you kind of have to fix your technical debt. And in some sense, what the L2s are all about is playing this game even harder.
So you know, you have chains like base and optimism that don't even have a fraud proof, right? That's the game that they're willing to play. They're willing to fake it until they make it. They have a totally centralized sequencer. But the good news, the fundamentals is that if you're willing to project ahead, there are ways to decentralize all of these things, all of these things. So a lot of my personal research in the last six to 12 months has been around, for example, decentralized pre-confirmations. How can we have the 100 millisecond user experience that arbitrament-based provider in a decentralized fashion?
And it turns out it's not that difficult. And not only that, in some sense, it destroys the user experience of Solana because Solana has 400 millisecond block times, about 5% of the blocks are skipped. On the other hand, with a decentralized pre-confirmation mechanism that I suggest, you have 100 millisecond pre-confirmations. So it's really, we can have the best of both worlds. We can have the speed of light pre-confirmations and the decentralization. I think we have moved into the bad section. Squally feels out of the good section here. Maybe to set up the bad section. Again, the good, the bad, the ugly, we've moved into the bad.
Bad, I'll characterize as temporal, the current problem set, whereas the ugly are things that are just completely untenable, unrecoverable, a final in nature. But the bad is just the current problem set of respective ecosystems. And so we've now drifted into the bad. Justin opened up the good section. And until maybe we can throw this one to you, the bad about Ethereum, we've kind of touched on it a little bit. Justin just touched on it with talking about transaction finality just now. How would you characterize the current problem set the bad side of Ethereum right now? I mean, like EVM is really like designed by academics.
It's just a VM that like no one with the M experience would have ever built. So there has a lot of technical that like designed that. It's fixable, but it's like a blood sweat in tears to do that. And I think you're going to see very slow progress there. And a lot like the because it's so central, it kind of permeates to everything. Like there's stuff that I feel like like the the expensive L1 and the split between L2s is kind of breaking a lot of the financial dynamics and splitting liquidity, which diminishes the value of Ethereum as an L1, you know, two years ago. So if you're now as an alternative L1, like Salana, you're not really competing with the Ethereum ecosystem.
A developer has to make a decision. Do I deploy on ETHL1, ETHL2? Or where do I put my focus, right? I can't focus on all of these different environments at the same time. It is difficult, right? And that means that Salana being one aggregate layer might be an easier and simpler choice for a lot of devs. So in a lot of ways, that's maybe fixable, but I don't know. That's a hard one. And because of the split in terms of you're going to have different confirmation semantics, different levels of fraught proves, different levels of security, people will take those decisions, like those factors into account, and they won't all decide to go in one place.
So it's going to be very hard to have like one single dominant winner, but it's possible. There'll be a power law distribution there. Are you kind of characterizing that as just like developmental friction? It's just like kind of deving through quicksand. Exactly. But the quicksand is never ending. Like it's just going to get worse. Like this is like I think kind of this like it's both a strength, but it's a weakness, right? You have a cornucopia of options and too many options create developer friction and create user friction at the top. I think maybe there's decisions that the old one can do on its own, but these are this is governance and that's above my pay grade.
This is interesting and it's like it feels like you're talking about the bad, but you're also bringing in some of the ugly too, right? In indicating that some of these things might be unresolvable. Would you say that's true? I think they're hard to resolve. They're hard to resolve. These are hard problems because they require a lot of coordination and potentially sacrificing, but the proof of work to proof of stake switch sacrificed, right? The POW miners. So it's possible, right? It's possible to fix these, but it's hard. Just in back to you, right? So one of the things that I don't totally ask is as a dev, should I launch on L1 or L2?
Well, I answered that for you. You should launch on L2. There is no future for the L1 directly. The L1 is a settlement layer. Now a fair question is which L2 and the reason why it's a fair question today is because the L2s are like silos. There's fragmentation on Ethereum. But my vision is that we can fix fragmentation, and there's a whole bankless episode on that, whereby the silos basically mailed together. It's almost like what we're left with is the boundaries between a small contract. You could argue, for example, that Ave and Uniswab being separate small contracts are in some sense siloed, but really you benefit from synchronous composability.
So synchronous composability is the strongest form of melding and removal of the frontiers. Now, it is true that it's going to take significant amount of engineering to get to this magical land of synchronous composability, and there's two pillars that we'll discuss in the episode. One is shared sequencing. That is actually fairly trivial, technically. It's mostly a coordination thing, where we all need as an ecosystem to choose a sequencer that we will use as D shared sequencer that can give us synchronous composability. I have a specific thesis here, which is that the based sequencer, meaning the L1 sequencer, the Ethereum sequencer itself, is the primary candidate to be that shared sequencer.
Then there's this other highly technical thing, which is real-time improving. By the way, I mean real-time snog proving. We need to be able to make a transaction, and a few milliseconds later, have a snog proof proving that this transaction is valid. So now, the various L2s don't need to trust each other, and so now you can send assets in and out of L2s, essentially, immediately, and they act like contracts at layer one, where there's no longer this boundary. So yes, today, as a dev, you do have to make a bet for the short and medium term, but eventually, Ethereum will fix its fragmentation and will be one massive virtual machine.
Now, one of the things that you said is that DVM is, for example, hard to parallelize. And there's just some cap in terms of TPS. Just one of its problems. Like, 32-by register storage values. There's a whole bunch of things that are really fugly about it from a VM design perspective. Right, that's fair. But these 32-bit registers, what do they ultimately impact as performance? So like, any single instance of the EVM will have some cap on how many transactions per second they can process. Let's say that this cap is X. Well, what we can do is just have multiple instances of the EVM. We can have a thousand instances.
And now, with synchronous composability, if you're willing to pay for this, then you basically have the ability to spread your state across multiple instances of these EVMs and still have them act like one super EVM. Now, another thing we're mentioning is that we don't have to use the EVM. The beauty of roll-ups is choose your virtual machine. And if it turns out that SVM is like the best and greatest virtual machine for the rest of humanity, well, guess what? What we're going to see is we're going to see SVM roll-ups. And there's actually teams building exactly that. One actually, one of the best teams on Solana has migrated away from Solana.
It's now building an L2. They're building a roll-up on Ethereum, putting the SVM there. And they're essentially decided to really buy into the species that the L1 is winner-take-most. And Solana is probably not going to make it as an L1. And so really, the next best thing that they can do is launch as a roll-up on Ethereum and be a dominant execution chain on top of the... I think you're a little bit mistating their intentions. They're going to run a product on Solana and one on Ethereum. I don't think they're going to migrate away. Go ahead. Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt you, but like you're kind of over-solving.
No, this is the end of my right. You don't have to use the EVM. If it turns out SVM is the answer, Ethereum will use the SVM. The core benefit of what Solana does is global synchronization. And when you move stuff into L2s and pre-conformation, you're effectively running a centralized exchange. It's trustless, and you can verify it. We have a single spot whether you're trading in New York or Singapore where stuff happens. And that's fine. But that's not a single giant global state machine. Like the whole point of Solana is to synchronize data around the world. The fact that it's high throughput, the fact that it's parallel on all the other stuff, these are secondary effects.
And why data synchronization is really, really important is because if an event happens in Singapore, that newswire has to go travel to the market where it's executing in New York. And by the time it gets there, what I want is the markets running in Solana to already reflect that price. So a trader that gets that newswire in New York cannot arbitrage it between their centralized L2, their NASDAQ exchange doesn't really matter to me what that is. But with sub millisecond pre-conformations in that little region, it's going to be as good a price discovery as this giant state machine that is propagating information around the world as fast as possible.
And the part where it's high throughput is kind of a side effect of us needing to get to that low latency and global distribution of data. Because that requires parallelism and a whole bunch of cores and fast links and all this other stuff. That's the core important part that Solana brings to the world. So when all these SVMs and everything else launch in these separate little environments, that's fine. It's just Solana is competing with centralized exchanges. It's competing with Binance, it's competing in NASDAQ. And all those things are faster than those L2s. But what they can't do is the fact that if something some event happens anywhere in the world, you can permissionally change the price of a market that is impacted by that news event in Singapore and be competitive with everyone.
That's the really, really cool part. And when I think about the world in the future, like 100 years from now and sci-fi, finance land, I see that as the winning piece. I don't see all this merit of different environments with local markets and local information, kind of synchronizing in these local spots. I see one giant state machine with new tree nose going through the center of the earth because that's faster. So you're highlighting three things. One is that we're talking about throughput. Two is that there's latency and three is this idea of synchronicity where everything comes together. And you're saying that throughput is not very important.
It's a commodity and everyone has it. Great. I would say that maybe one of Ethereum's biggest weaknesses. And so if it's going to become a commodity soon, that's all the better for Ethereum. Now, the other thing that you brought up is synchronicity. And here I do think we can fix Ethereum's asynchronous using real-time proving and chat sequencing. So now let's focus on the middle one, which is what you say is the most important, which is the latency aspect. Well, it's not you can't reduce late. You can't like fix the shared sequencing by moving it all into one giant block producer because then that thing is the NASDAQ.
All the information happens there, right? And if I'm jump or whatever, I just run my shit right next to it. One thing that we do agree upon is this idea of having very sophisticated block builders and having unsophisticated validators. This is part of your endgame vision. And really what we're saying here is that the sophisticated entity, which is only the leader for a very small amount of time for 12 seconds in the case of Ethereum, is getting rotated on a continuous basis. Now, are you saying that this number 12 seconds is just too long because there's just too much time to have a monopoly on global state?
Yeah. That's like our goal is, you know, the latency around the world is around 120 milliseconds with speed away through fiber. If we get to neutrinos, it'll be like 40 or whatever, but we're not there yet. I want multiple block producers on Solana rotating every 120 milliseconds. So there's one in Singapore, one in New York, one in every region in the world as many as we need. And every 120 milliseconds, they switch. That's the end state. What you're saying basically is that whoever is the sophisticated entity that has monopoly over the next 12 seconds, they act like some sort of centralized exchange, and this is not great.
Well, there's a few things here. Like one is that I expect transactions to eventually become encrypted. So today, we have plain text mempools and soon we're going to have encrypted messages. Only Stratos will delay what information it becomes globally available. Okay. So we are talking about latency. I thought we were talking about there's there's multiple variables to optimize. And this is the challenge. Like as soon as if you if you encrypt data and it's revealed later, you're delaying when that data is available to the rest of the global markets. If you have a follow-up of encryption, you can execute the transaction immediately, even though it is encrypted.
But the result of that is important to the rest of the world. So me as a market maker and if I'm putting price at risk, and this should happens later, and I can't respond and cancel, right? It means that I have to have wider spreads. Well, I can't because it's fully homomorphically encrypted. Well, I can come in with a transaction which says if the price is x under the encryption scheme, do such and such action. So I can still arbitrage a market even though they're encrypted. Then when me knowing when this stuff is actually executed or not is delayed and that increase of spreads, there is there's a system where everything is executed as fast as possible and that information is available as fast as possible to the entire world.
That system will have the lowest spreads and the best price discovery. That's the ideal. Okay, so you want the decryption to happen as fast as possible. Now here's the thing. We can have the decryption happen in the matter of milliseconds. And the reason is that we can have decentralized pre-confirmations. We can be in a position where the entity that is receiving these encrypted transactions can commit to including those or including them in a specific order. And once the commitment has been made, if they were to change their mind, they would lose a very large bond that they put forward. So those are communication cycles.
They're hops there. It's one it's one round of latency, which is the same as as with Solana. If I want to interact with Solana, I need to do at minimum one round of latency. But the goal there is that you submit and you know that it's going to be accepted simply because the block producer is accepted it and has very low probability of failing at that point. So you as a trader, you can start building on the next on the next block as if that data is already there and the market is already reflecting it. Okay, so you're saying there's two rounds of latency instead of one round of latency. Basically, there's one round to send you encrypted transactions, get a get a pre-confirmation and then the second round in order to actually know what the result is.
But actually that can be reduced to maybe one and a half rounds of latency because as soon as the easiest way for Ethereum to have this is to just have takes Solana blocks and dump them into Ethereum DA and say that Solana is an Ethereum all too. Right. So one of the things that we're not ready to do is have these really short block times and we'll talk about this in the ugly section and the reason is that that introduces ugly timing games and that starts weakening the security of the chain. So one of the concepts, but again, we'll talk about the later is slot to ping ratio. So the slot duration, for example, in the case of Ethereum is 12 seconds and ping time roughly, let's say, is 100 milliseconds just to make the math easy.
So we have a slot to ping ratio of 120. You have a slot to ping ratio of four. And I believe as soon as you get kind of close to one, even four is kind of relatively close, you start getting these weird effects where even optimizing a few milliseconds gives you a crazy edge. And so then you end up in a position where all the participants, the validators, the blogbuilders, everyone is basically building radio towers and programming FPGAs. And it is not fine for the validators to have access to to radio towers. That is not fine. The verifiers don't like the validators of the people verifying the data.
They're going to be receiving it sprayed around the world that I don't think that matters there. We've already seen timing games in Solana, where the validators are willing to wait a little bit to have a bit more information. They can get a similar edge just by optimizing their latency and using radio towers. That's fine. It's not fine. And that happening is that only the validators with the best infrastructure will survive. And everyone else will have a sub-optimal yield. Let's say the yield is whatever, X percent. While we're going to have those that get X percent and those that get half of X.
What's the difference between the super-mev-optimized yield on Ethereum versus plain vanilla yield? Is it 4.4 versus 4.44 or something like that? One of the things I try to do when thinking about Solana is actually trying to steal manate. It turns out that block building specifically, and I think this is something you might agree with, is something that can be decoupled from validation. We already have proposed a build a separation, but we can go even further. We have this notion called execution tickets. We have this notion called execution auctions. I don't think all the latency games with block building enemy V will be relevant in the long term.
So that's squarely kind of a temporary bad thing. But what is much more fundamental is timing game for attestors, those that are making the votes. They are meant to be as unsophisticated as possible. I think this is something you agree with. Now, if I am an attestor of voter that has, let's say, 20 milliseconds or 50 milliseconds edge over all my other fellow attestors, I'm going to be making more money. How? How? Because I'm going to be making more informed vote. Whenever I vote, I'm going to be voting correctly on the head, as opposed to voting on some sort of block that gets reogged and then me not getting getting the way that Solana distributes data is we get effectively a sample that the rest of the network has to block.
So there's very little to optimize there, even if you're like you're talking about like it's a very small portion of the overall returns for the validator to skip to never pick a bad fork. It's you're going to it's a 100th of a of a percentage. Because when the way turbine works is that you receive a whole bunch of samples from the rest of the network and you know that everyone in the network got the block. So if you vote on it, you know that everyone else is going to vote on it. Like you don't need to wait to two to 15 milliseconds to see it. Do I see anyone else vote on it and vote on it too?
Especially in the environment where the validators don't execute any code. They just vote. Did they receive the data repicking this fork or not? Like when you look at Solana, it's a long run of blocks that are all built on top of a heaviest fork. So what percentage of blocks actually are forked? It's 5%. So like 5% of your votes are skewed. It's it's a insignificant difference in return. But that's today, but that's not the fundamentals. And the reason is that put yourself in the shoes of a block builder sophisticated who has control, you know, the right to build the next. No, like the returns from votes are not tied to the value of the block.
They are. Well, they are. They are. It's subtle. Put yourself in the shoes of a block builder for the next lot. What they want to do is they want a gossip and build that block at the very last moment. And the reason is that from that perspective, every millisecond counts. And what they're going to do is that they're going to gossip the block right at the point where whatever a number of votes they need, let's say it's two thirds, let's say they need two thirds for the block to get accepted. They're going to gossip it just at the point where two thirds plus one of the validators are going to see it.
And then one third of the validators, they're just not going to see it in time. And so they're going to vote on some parent or some some other block. And they're going to get penalized. And these effects are just massively amplified when the slot to ping ratio is too small. That's how we see in the data. You actually see that because today the the block chain is immature. We don't even have PBS on on Solana. Just come on. You're not, you're not, you're not revenue is equal to Ethereum. Yeah, but you don't have PBS. You don't have PBS. This is something that's coming soon presumably. Like I'm going to have a call with the Gito guys on PBS specifically.
Like this is something that is basic infrastructure in 2024 that you don't have. The actors on Solana are not acting rationally. Like they're just running the default software because they're not sophisticated. But over time, this is something that the amount of benefit that you get is insignificant because you only have four milliseconds to build your block. You will get overrun by the next guy. And if you will miss your block, you miss it. You miss all the rewards there. You said it yourself. You only have 400 milliseconds. So let's say they have a tiny edge. Let's say you have 40 millisecond edge.
That's 10% more easy. Why would you wait to, why would you wait to transmit your block at the last moment and let the next guy an opportunity to overrun you? Why wouldn't you transmit your block as fast as possible? Because you're going to submit it right at the point where two thirds of the valid data are going to see it on time and one thought of the valid data is going to be explained. Why is that more profitable than to do it? Because you wait a few more milliseconds versus the native strategy. Miloseconds in terms of what, Mav? Yeah. Yeah. And like if you have 400 milliseconds lot times, four milliseconds is 1%.
And as a as a block builder, I'm competing relative to the other builders. And so my profit margin might only be 1%. And so by having a four millisecond edge, I could double my profit margin. I don't think so. I just don't see that as like a realistic result. Look at Ethereum right now. What is the difference between a totally no Mav client and a fully maximum Mav client in terms of API? It's it's it's it's it's it's huge is like something like two no it's not it's like 4.4 versus 4.5 APY. Uh no. New projects are coming online to the mantle layer two every single week. Why is this happening? Maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer two design architecture since it first started building mantle DA powered by technology from eigen DA.
Maybe it's because users are coming on to the mantle layer two to capture some of the highest yields available in DeFi and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the $3 billion mantle treasury in the mantle reward station. Maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants liquidity support and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application. Maybe it's all of these reasons all put together. So if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's DeFi apps, click the link in the show notes to getting started with mantle.
Are you worried about the security of your cross chain cross chains with confidence using transporter the revolutionary token bridging app designed to give you peace of mind powered by chainlink ccip transporter is your trusted gateway for securely moving assets like eth native usc and link and so many more across some of your favorite blockchains. Over 2.8 billion dollars has been hacked from token bridges today transporter puts a stop to this by ensuring your transfers are protected by the most robust security features available chainlink ccip provides level 5 security backed by multiple decentralized oracle networks and an independent risk management network.
Transporter also provides real-time tracking throughout your transaction with its newly engineered user experience so you'll never have to second guess the safety or location of your assets ever again. And the best part transporter makes it simple whether you're a blockchain beginner or a seasoned trader transporters intuitive interface lets you execute cross chain transactions with just a few clicks no additional fees just a low cost for using ccip which can be paid in link or your blockchain's native gas token but don't just take my word for it see for yourself why transporter offers a stress free bridging experience experience the future of token bridging at transporter.
io and just send it. Are you launching a token is it already live how are you managing the legal and tax obligations for providing token grants to your team it's no secret that token management gets complicated between learning all the legal language and tax obligations in every country that your team is in token grant management can feel like an obstacle course but it doesn't have to that's where toku steps in toku provides practical tools to handle token grants allowing for effective oversight of token distributions and payroll tax compliance for employees contractors advisors and investors they also handle tax withholdings through their real-time tax calculations that can be done by toku or integrated into any payroll EOR providers in any jurisdiction toku is a trusted provider of protocol labs dydx foundation mean a protocol and many more get started for free and make token compensation simple at toku.
com slash bankless dressed in can you kind of help us handhold of some of the listeners who might have lost the thread a little bit you're doing some mev calculations with regard to block times and i think you're alluding to an overly central an acceleratingly centralizing network as a result of increased value capture can you can you kind of present some napkin math and why and where that actually points to your conclusion right so as a rough heuristic mev grows linearly with time so if you have 400 milliseconds that's worth twice as much as having 200 milliseconds and like one way to think about it is that there's twice as many transactions that come in during the speed of time and so twice as many fees now true though because a lot of transactions land before your slot so you have accumulated more than a block's worth of transactions prior to your slot and then you get you may get 400 milliseconds more but your period of when you're actually receiving data is anytime just like i'm in a mumpule people just submit shit ahead of time so you have a bunch of data that you can work with the extra 400 milliseconds account for a very small window that so when you're cutting that 4% you're talking about getting the very last bit of people that are trying to snipe something maybe or just or just stare late and the one they clicked something look i'm one of the operators of the ultrasound relay which is the top relay on on the theorem and i have very good visibility on time in games you know all the builders will co-locate all the relays will do crazy optimizations to shave a few milliseconds this thing is real even with 12 second block times it's going to get insane when the block times are 400 milliseconds because the marginal improvement you know for every let's say millisecond that you get from relative standpoint it's much much bigger you know return on investment than than with a theorem where you have 12 seconds i think when you have high throughput the number of transactions you're dealing with is much higher and any individual one the ROI is much lower so you're like talking about median fiancee and salana is 0.
2 cents so that extra 400 milliseconds extra 200 milliseconds even over the amount of time that you're waiting and receiving transactions is accounting for a very small amount of actual fees no i mean if you're still time is 400 milliseconds and you have a 200 millisecond edge which you you know you wouldn't that that that's too high but let's say you have a 40 millisecond edge then you get 10% more time to build your blocks and you get 10% more transactions and therefore more fees you get because you get a bunch of transactions before your block starts but these are the ones that the previous builder didn't want to pick like they're like garbage transactions these are just people retransmitting and trying to land and like they're not garbage transactions they're okay but that retransmission is so not a problem like this is not something that we have in the context of a theorem in the concept of a theorem we have low value transactions that kind of just sit in the mempool for slots and slots and slots they're all of like the median transaction fee in salana is 0.
2 cents so if there's a matter with the medium transaction fees sure so the average transaction fee is 2 cents let's say that last 200 milliseconds is going to get you 500 times what two cents worth of extra data maybe at the best but don't you just make it up on volume I think that's Justin's point is like sure the we're measuring things in milliseconds those transactions are not higher ROI you can go look at go compute this go look at the flood of transactions and see do you actually get higher value transactions in the last 40 milliseconds versus the the first and even then does it even matter to delay sending the the previous transactions versus just I have 400 milliseconds left in my block I will take the highest paying transactions at the last moment and send those out like there's no there's no real like you have to show me that there's a massive financial advantage to not transmit whatever you have early in the block because you only have 400 milliseconds and you got to generate those sticks and send them out and this is happening in salana in a current environment we only have one block producer but the design is for concurrent block producers so you now you have multiple block producers around the world that are not aware of what each the other one has so they have to race to fill the block together and if they delay and that one particular one gets dropped that guy has pushing his boundary of terms of losing all his block rewards I feel like some of some of these details maybe a requires some follow up like after the episode if if Justin wants to like prove something danitoli and anitoli wants to refute it the interesting point here is I think the goal of salana is to solve these problems with hardware right we have we reduce the block times to the physical limit allows let's say 120 milliseconds we have multiple block producers that requires more bandwidth so we need more cores and bigger pipes and we create this very highly competitive environment from the hardware itself so when you have these games it's very very hard to get an edge over the default and that's possible you may get an edge and any given time but it's not going to be 20x or 10x it's going to be basis points so I want to zoom out at this point so last time we kind of handed the the Mike danitoli who mentioned the bad if I were to sort of summarize the bad it's almost like the bad and ugly I think what you're saying in itoli we got in the minutiae of like you know millisecond block times and MEV and all of this but I think what you're saying is the reason Ethereum is under optimized is because it's not doing like transaction confirmation as close to the speed of light as possible right and like it's not propagating this this global a shared state at that level the longer the window you have the longer that window is for front running and cute jumping and the transactions go up and the spreads go up and the fees go up and the worst experience it is for users so so Justin what what's your take on that that like we got you without going to the minutiae I don't know if you want to steal man and just always case for this but like why why does ethereum not do this why is that why is this not bad for ethereum not to you know optimize for global shared state at near the speed of light as he's saying in the way he's saying it maybe give give your reason for that and then maybe you could get into some of the bad you know that you see on the salon aside of things so one one of the pieces of good news here is that at the end of the day it's largely a parameter like it's some sort of number that we can pick how many milliseconds per slot is at 400 is it you know 12,000 and if ethereum got it wrong then you know maybe this is something that that that that we can change the way that I see it is that it boils down to this slot to to ping ratio so like we're we're bottlenecked by a speed of light here it takes roughly 130 milliseconds for light to go all around the earth and ping time you know roughly can be approximated as 100 milliseconds and what happens is that there's boundary effects between the slots that are on the order of this ping time this is where the so-called timing games can be played so if you have 120 you know ping times that are all you know one next to the other and then you concatenate the next one like where they touch each other like where this potential for the timing game is actually very very small but once your your start times become so so small then the edge cases start to accumulate this is all of salam engineering is insolving that then this is how turbine and profistry and all this stuff works well together is that boundary is deterministic from any validators perspective like so when you receive all the data from potentially a number of block producers how you receive it gives you a very very good statistical guarantee that everyone else saw the exact same partition as you time is fundamentally subjective there's no way to have a global agreement on when we receive every different validator sees the packets at different points in time and all of all of our engineering is to make the best case the average case this is what all of salam is engineering is about is make sure what happens the blockbuilders will gossip the block just at the right point so that two thirds of the validator see it on time they've got the block it's accepted and then one further the validators are left in the dust they can't do that because of how the blocks have to propagate through turbine there's a it's a deterministic path that shuffles the data around the world with the racer codes so when I receive it and recover that block I know that with a very high guarantee that everyone else has done the same thing so when I vote based on that information it's very very sound yes but that that is what you're talking about here with racer codes is you know data availability I'm talking about timeliness which is a different thing which is the same thing on my clock which in millisecond did it arrive and fundamentally different routes on the internet take different amounts of time there's jitter there's all sorts of issues and we sample all the routes so when when I when 50% of my routes for every shred that has to take a different path around the network arrive I know that statistically they have arrived for the vast majority of the network as well so when I vote I know that it arrived for everyone else the endgame is that the builders have a direct pipe to two thirds of the closest validators they don't they don't on salana they can it's just an implementation detail there's nothing in consensus that prevents them to just have a direct pipe you know even the co-location Justin why does that matter what is what is any of this even matter why have we been talking about this for so long there's there's a global world right if you have a your direct pipe is as fast as everyone else's because you still have to get your blocks to the to the validator and the other side of the world the reason I have to go through the same fiber the reason is matters is because it is a centralization vector what happens is that the own it elevates the barrier to entry in order to even be able to play the game you need to have outstanding networking infrastructure and by outstanding I mean above and beyond what is available to the to the to the commoner like one of the things that every commoner can go look through their phone book and find a data center in their city that has data centers won't make it and part of the reason is that you're going to need access to like private no you won't links that only like the hft firms have that is why we don't this is this is like that that's just the the world to get this validator if then if the salana network is actually distributed around the world like I sure in the world where everyone stuffs older validators in like two two data centers that's bad but if the validators are actually physically distributed around the world those hft links are not going to help you there's going to be an incentives for the validators to migrate okay so why why because they're going to be closer to the builders therefore they're going to be able to make better votes and therefore have a higher I feel like this again like I like I've like I've said you can't make better votes to get an edge when every block is built on top of the heaviest fork so so because a statistical sample that tells you yeah everyone else saw this block this is the whole point of like salana's design is to eliminate the the forking choice from from that as much as possible so so anatoly is your prediction that like making these design decisions for for salana will not result in centralization of the network in the way Justin's describing and Justin is your prediction that these design decisions will centralize the network in the way that you're describing it feels like we won't be able to resolve this in this in the scope of this conversation we just have to kind of wait do we not and like do we have any concrete predictions that either of you would make some point in the future so that we could look back on maybe years from now and say oh you know that this is how it happened you know like one of us was more right than the other Justin do you have a concrete prediction here as to like what the outcome of this might might become so we can you table this topic and move on yes so um if salana does go forward you know towards its endgame where it reduces slot times the minimum let's say a hundred milliseconds and this is minus dining of what salana want anatoly wants to achieve then yes I think we're going to see a hyper centralization within any given slot so in slot n what we're going to see is like all your tests is just being in a data center or in the few data centers that are all proximate to each other and and anatoly if if you are right none of that happens right that this it remains with the kind of like the the properties salana has today remain in place it doesn't centralize the way Justin's talking I think if the parameters are set correctly that we have like you know 130 millisecond block times you can have a validator anywhere in the world and vote and you will get this about the same API as anyone else all right I think the difference is going to be basis points well the future the future we'll have to see in the future we'll have to replay this episode this clip in particular and see which prediction pans out we're still on kind of the the bad section so until we had the floor no I think that was definitely the other yeah yeah it's all combining isn't it Justin do you want to give your take on either the bad the ugly or or both for the salana side that's outside of the scope of the conversation that that we just had so something new yeah I mean I didn't touch upon the the bad facts but in some sense they're they're not really important and as David said like they will just dwindle with the passage of time so there's all sorts of bad facts like the outages you know being like very proximate to the largest financial fraudster since made of the the misleading marketing like even today I went on you know Solana compass I thought this marketing was kind of gone but still there's this marketing that Solana I can do 65,000 transactions per second which is first of all that that was a claim that was made four years ago and it's still not achieved you can you can go run the code yourself and test it at a very very simple transfer okay show me on production there's also you know bad present there's there's no client diversity there's no formal spec there's there's no PBS there's just general immaturity but again I think these are not you know fundamental things because they're being worked on you know there's another client being worked on I'm sure there's some some academics somewhere that's working on a formal spec and I do know that Gito is working on PBS so all of these things will get resolved but then there's a final category of items in this bad bucket which is the bad takes and in my opinion there's a couple of bad takes Anatoli that you have been spreading which hopefully this this podcast can help you spread less one is this idea that issuance is not a cost to the network now there's a very simple reason why it is a cost and it has to deal with taxes my assumption Anatoli is that you pay your taxes is that correct of course okay so if you were to stake and you were to make let's say a million dollars of income staking you will have to my understanding is that you're based in California and I looked it up the income taxes in California is roughly 50 percent so you will have to pay half a million dollars of income taxes on your staking that is direct cell pressure that is a cost to the network now Solana is roughly speaking a 100 billion dollar network so pressure is not a cost wow we have to go into this okay wow the value like the value of an asset is not determined by how much is sold like it has if you're talking about like how much apples apples stock somebody sells does not is not a cost to apple okay so someone has to pay for these costs so for example in in Bitcoin like someone has to pay for the electricity someone has to pay for the e-waste and that is a cost that is an actual cost to run the network that's a physical cost yes it's a physical cost sure then like taxes even though it's like not so every so every share of apple stock sold is a cost to apple no like if if they would let's say that they wouldn't taxes let's say so if I sell apple stock and I pay taxes on it that's a cost to apple are you differentiating and until in between a cost that a cost to apple and like cell pressure are these kind of different compression your cell pressure is a local event that's temporal but the value of the company is based on apple is based on their future cash flow and in the US the monetary market will expand to capture that value somebody will go buy all that stock because the future cash flow of apple is at so much worth so much so like selling apple stock is not a cost to apple that's that's like obvious to to everywhere apple there's not issue stock to you know to to to pay for its security so Solana is a roughly one hundred billion dollar network roughly speaking five percent of issuance per year which means that for Solana which means that 2.
5 come from the issuance that's absurd 2.5 billion dollars per year of taxes is being born by the Solana token holders if we were to live in the world what they were no taxes then this cell pressure would not exist that is definitely a burden to this is this is like a complex thing to analyze because people that are offshore can earn the rewards offshore and only pay taxes and value they appropriate to the US okay but let's take your example sure and that's totally do you contribute to cell pressure of of Solana probably but like is that a burden to my taxes okay good yeah of course that does not change the future cash flow of any asset like when somebody sells their stock so it has no relevance on that it is it is the exact same thing as proof of work in the context of proof of work absolutely opposite of proof of work proof of work actually have to go by electricity and burn an external exogenous asset to run this you have to go buy an exogenous asset called US dollars in order to be able to pay your taxes and then doing so you're selling your Solana that's does not it's does not a cost of an outward that's like and it'll use it something else here which is like issuance does not provide economic security did I hear you correctly there I'm wondering if you could say that again first it does not provide security security the network is the physical boxes and links like if I'm running a system that cares about detecting double spans and invalid state transitions I run a whole bunch of nodes a whole bunch of clients and make it really really hard for an attacker to partition my my clients such that they can double spend so if they try to double spend they have to reveal two headers to two different size of the network and they don't know which nodes are mine right so it becomes the no more more nodes are run and the longer I weigh the harder risk for the attacker to do the double spend so it's irrelevant like this is why we don't see double spends on the Solana Tessnet we have as much economic security in the Solana Tessnet as the theory main that it's as good at defending against double spends every the Chihuahua tenderman chain has seen as many double spend attacks as a theory of may not because it's adds good as defending against double spend as a theory of may not so this ties into the second bad take that you know you've just spread and you you constantly spread which is basically that you're saying that economic security is a meme and you are right in the sense that economic security is not necessary to verify the correctness of blocks I run a full node for blocks invalid I just filter it out yeah and then there's there's two other things that economic security could potentially be helpful for one is as you said double spends now it turns out that doing a double spend you know you need to have a very very good reason for for for doing so and you know there's a little bit of a tangent but we can also just completely solve double spends with cryptography there's this notion called one-shot signatures and it's it turns out double spends is not fundamental to to consensus but now let's focus on where economic security is fundamental which is to do with liveliness and censorship resistance let's say that I can 51% attack a chain then what I can do is I can selectively filter out transactions for example I can filter out oracle transactions I could filter out liquidations I could filter out fruit proofs I could filter out by orders or sell orders I can manipulate markets now let's say that I can make a billion dollars manipulating markets through this selective censorship and the economic security is let's say one million dollars well now it's a no-brainer for me to invest a one million dollars to go 51% attack and make a billion dollars of profit and so economic security is not a meme it is fundamental to censor resistance when you talk about security it implies safety no sure no there's two aspects of security safety and liveliness this is basics sure sure but when we talk about security you would want to play safety over liveliness no no no they both are important so you would allow a network to run within an invalid state transition and no no they're both important we've talked about this the environment state transitions are easy to just because you can run a full node and you can just discard them immediately this is something that has been known for 15 years since Bitcoin if you run a full Bitcoin node and some sort of minor tries to create an invalid Bitcoin chain that prints you know 10 trillion BTC it will just get rejected of course of course and that could cause a liveliness failure if the vast majority of the network is trying to produce invalid nodes like invalid blocks you have no confirmation you can't tell right it's effectively a liveliness failure to you pick safety over liveliness any any case like economic security to a lot of folks imply safety so when we talk about censorship resistance and a liveliness it does have impact but it does not provide so it's not a meme oh I think my point is is that other networks like tenorment networks like Chihuahua chain like the Salona Tessna provide equivalent amount of security there even for liveliness and censorship resistance yes because I go on Chihuahua I buy whatever required number of tokens let's say I need to spend 10 million dollars to get enough tokens Chihuahua tokens to go for a day and people recognize that you take all of them off and they fork and slash you okay so now you do agree that now it basically depends on how much profit you make now we have ambition in the theorem which is to be the intent of value we want to have trillions tens of trillions of dollars that are settled and traded on the theorem if you can disrupt the intent of value even for one hour even for one minute that is worth an insane amount of money it's not and we cannot have the rest of the money secured by one billion dollars of economic security the rest of the world runs on t plus 2 to t plus 10 settlement it handles trillions of dollars it has outages all the time and liveliness failures it works so you're trying to replace it with a better system I get it but you can't tell me that an hour outage or 10 hour outage is fundamentally going to stop the world and everyone's going to be a panic on fire that's just bullshit so like yeah economic security protects against a very specific attack but that attack does not exist on any other chain because it requires more than epsilon steak you have to go by a huge chunk it's detected once it's detected the attacker is slashed so that that effect exists on every chain the fact that it's detectable and the fact that it's easy to intrivial to slash those are the things that secure the salon attest net and the tenderman true auto chain and this is why you don't see these attacks anywhere so you can't tell me like what why why like this meme is bad it's like you're using it as bad marketing a theorem has world war three level economic security this bullshit because one I can't tell looking at the steak and there's no way you can prove to me that all of that steak didn't come from the ICO there's zero way you can guarantee that the cost basis for all the current stakers is not what they picked like the ICO price there's no way you can prove that it's impossible I trust that it's not because I'm not a irrational person that believes in mostly functioning markets and most people are honest and stuff like that but if we're doing hard analysis and like what can we actually prove you cannot prove that so the actual economic security based on some number based on a current spot market price is meaningless the act real security is it's detectable it's apparent in any network and that's what we don't see them and even test nuts so I think we've agreed that economic security is not a meme because it is relevant to this one specific because it is relevant to this attack called censorship and because that attack is every network proof-of-sake network does this good of a job defending against that as a theory may not okay so what you're saying basically is that if this attack were to happen then the social layer can come in and do social slashing which is correct but there's a few a few points here one social interventions are extremely expensive we've gone through one in Ethereum's history it's called Ethereum Classic it's called the Dow it is not something that you want to go into secondly it's what 300 billion dollars worth of economic security to defend against an attack that never happens in any proof-of-sake network it's never happened because two things need to happen one is you need to have a sophisticated attacker who knows about this attack and is willing to and two the incentives need to be there right now almost all of the value secured on Ethereum is ether itself and it's staking so in some sense there's nothing to attack but project yourself ten years in the future where tens of millions hundreds of millions I could potentially take over an Ethereum test nut cause it to double spend right with my economic attack while shorting Ethereum and say look there's a bug in Ethereum everyone panics Ethereum drops yeah but this is actually there's a massive economic incentive to attack an Ethereum test nut that has zero cost right I assume in terms of economic security yes this particular attack wouldn't necessarily work because the social layer knows that it can fork it and it doesn't affect the rest of the market but once you're willing to censor oracles you're willing to censor for proofs willing to censor liquidations and you know market buys and market sells then you in a position where you can harvest toxic MEV and if the amount of toxic MEV that you can harvest is greater than the cost of attack then yes it's going to happen just because it hasn't happened doesn't mean it's not going to happen now you said that the social layer can intervene that is correct but that is a very expensive process how's that any more expensive than rebooting from an out it well in in the case in in in the case of of Solana you know these outages don't have real significance because there's there's no value on on Solana and the same revenue is Ethereum it's not about revenue it's about like TVL and things that Solana has 0.
7% of all USDT um it is like why is why why are outages important for TVL that sitting at Ross and doing nothing why is it revenues no no it needs to be it needs to be active so it needs to be you know like there needs to be over collateralized loans there needs to be which is determined by revenue right the proxy for all that activity is actual on chain revenue no like a lot of the revenue for the validators you know come in this form of sandwiching right like this is one of the primary forms of revenue on so mev so mev plus priority fees on Solana are about equal to a 3 ml one no so we're talking about like really really toxic levels of mev like sandwiching is nothing compared to the type of mev that you can harvest if you were to to your 31% attack but like so if somebody does that and that that's bad the network calls slashes them and moves on and it's a 24 hour thing okay let's say I can make 10 billion dollars from this attack and it only cost me one billion dollars that is that is that is a bad outcome now another thing unlike it's unlikely that that could be true because you would have to go buy up all of this it seems unlikely that the revenues within 24 hours the maximum mev revenues could be that high 10 billion dollars that are basically the threshold here is if it takes 24 hours to go fuck this fuck over this attacker right they're doing the bad thing everyone halts they get slashed in the fork and everyone continues that's a 24 hour process maybe they have to make more money than than the 50% of a stake within that 24 hours okay so there's a couple things one is that they can pick whatever 24 hours has the most impact like they can pick you know whenever like the fence decides to raise order so the potential for it doesn't take 24 hours like we're talking potentially an event that can take you know days to resolve and thirdly in your endgame document one of the things that you highlight Anatoli is this idea of sampling committees you talk about committees of size 200 where let's say you have 20,000 validators you pick a committee of size 200 and not only 1% of the validators are in control of the chain for whole epoch which is let's say two days what are you going to do you're going to slash one third of the 1% which is like 0.
3% and now the attacker can do the attack again and again and again and again and so what you're suggesting in your game and game is ugly because the social slashing doesn't even work there um I would imagine the stake representation there is going to be higher than to 1% simply because when you're sampling like power a lot of distribution of nodes your 200 nodes already make up more than like 50% what an attacker will do is that they'll spread their stake across you know equally across but then they're not going to be majority in the subcommittee they're only going to be picked right like they need like if you're if you have like 10% of the stake you're going to be in like you're going to have 10% of the subcommittee in any case there is like a degradation of the amount that is slashed is not going to slash the whole attacker the attacker can do the attacks several times sure and again that's just like in chihuahua chain they buy 10 million worth of chihuahua coins they do the attack they get detected they get slashed this is why it doesn't happen because the so you're fertilizing slashing we cannot try to buy social circle to chihuahua chain again so I just want I don't think you either of you is convincing the other one of the point so and until your position there's never been there's never been this level of attack in any proof of stake network it happens in like proof of work networks because you can do an anonymous 51% attack and this is like the big flaw in proof of stake in proof of work as one is you can roll back two weeks worth of Ethereum classic with an anonymous like chain of links and nobody knows who you are and you effectively like robbed everyone that believed the previous thing but in proof of stake you have branded validators that compete for stake and like they're staked for an epoch so there's a cooldown and more my period so they're known and it's very very hard to get to even point to what you can do and once you pull off the attack and one knows who did it immediately like it's just and like the information is out there so you're completely left yourself open to being slashed immediately this meme is is is benign an Ethereum because Ethereum does a really really good job with engineering and they actually do have a lot of validators and a lot of links and independent clients all that stuff they do it's a dangerous meme for everyone else because people will like Luna will roll up to some absurd number of stake and say we have massive economic security where it's like not real in any way and that gives people false confidence I would actually like but I would wish Ethereum would do is just like forget that meme just talk about the really excellent engineering like these attacks are impossible because the engineering is really really good so Luna is incomparable like they were not building they were building a stablecoin and the design was just flawed but there are TVL there's the amount of stake that they had stake to secure their proof of stake network was massive and they could literally just go say we have massive economic security it takes a lot of work to go and like parse those details and to tell a person that's not like plugged in no you can't compare that economic security to Ethereum's but you can literally easily say look that's 100 nodes all run by the same people this is bajillion nodes geographically distributed with a bajillion links this is secure this is not okay so once again on that item of economic securities or anything predictive you could say like so like I think listeners might be asking why does all of this matter right so like Justin why why is that bad in your book that you know you think that economic security does matter and that it's bad for Anatolia to propagate it and say that it doesn't matter and I think listeners might be wondering why like why why did we just have this conversation this debate about economic security and if you're right is there something predictive that you can say about some kind of future attack that Solana or chains like it might face if they're not considering economic security because we can we can test that in the future somebody with actually weak security will have strong economic security and then we'll get right that's your prediction I don't know okay this this is the bad outcome that I think as an industry we should try to strive to avoid right because then you're giving people like a very very easy meme to like brand themselves with versus really really hard engineering which is hard to do I see and you're saying that at some level that's already happened with something like Tara Luna as you know using economic security as a meme Justin how would you put a bookend on on why this matters I think it's more of an intellectual point for Solana specifically because ironically Solana has very high amount of economic security because the vast majority of it's I don't trust it I don't trust the economic security on salon you do trust that the social layer can slash them if they were too much behave right but you can't say that the chain is more secure like what is it 20 times more secure now than a year ago you cannot possibly say that no you can because there is money to be made from 51 percent attacks and now the money to be made needs to be so much higher to compensate for the loss of slashing now in terms of a concrete prediction what my prediction would be that like some smaller chain that has much lower amounts of economic security than Solana will get 51 percent attacked and will be harvested for toxic mv through for example the censoring of our okay all right uh let's let's move on are we into the ugly territory yet from from your side Justin or are we still on the bad what's what's ugly about Solana to finish up this conversation then maybe we talk about kind of the end game of both ecosystems and we call this a wrap but what what stones have we left unturned yeah so happy to um to finish off on on the ugly part um and it's kind of interesting because it has to do with things that seem innocuous um and specifically one of the things that I think is is ugly is the fact that Solana is is an L1 the mental model that I have is that it's decided to create an island in in the Pacific um as opposed to being connected to to Wall Street right does existing network effects these are extremely strong network effects and it's by being an L1 you don't get to tap into these existing network effects and now if my thesis is correct that the L1 is when it takes most and Solana is not going to is not going to make it now let's look at concrete numbers and I think these are extremely telling you have Solana which is a four-year-old project how much USDT has it accumulated it's accumulated on the 800 million which is about 0.
7 percent of all your USDT now let's look at it for comparison on the L2s a single L2 arbitrum which is only three years old has three times the amount of USDT why is that because they are connected to the epicenter TBL is irrelevant it's not useless it's not useless it is how much how much revenue is arbitra making off of a bajillion in in a USDT like who's who cares about I have no idea but it is a sign that people are using USDT for loans and savings and payments and all sorts of all the reasons that that's actually like very very misleading bullshit amount of TBL in a in a in a protocol is meaningless big data protocol had six billion TBL what happens it had big that was that a theory in protocol that had like a big run last cycle doesn't exist anymore what happened I thought TBL is really important if the average user put forward you know a hundred dollars of USDT wherever they're living and you know let's say there's a hundred million dollars of TBL in a specific chain that means that's you know on average you know what he's speaking like a million users if you have actually a million users that are actively using that money and doing commerce with it true but that's not what TBL actually is TBL is people fishing for more tron has a huge amount of USDT TBL why is that because tron is actually being used for payments it's actually being used by real people you can't say that TBL is irrelevant it is one of the strongest principles that you can have that the chain is actually being used those are again there's many many examples counter examples about when I'd have to look at actual tron data how much of the tron TBL is somebody's money sitting in a protocol could earning reach like useless tokens how much of it is actually spent in peer-to-peer payments you got to separate those out like there's TBL is not like a good signal Justin beyond TBL can you finish your thought on the ugly and then I might get we want to get anecdotally to to respond in your comments and then state his ugly before we get to them so finish your thoughts on the ugly the fact that tron is a lot of TBL is again a point against TBL being a good signal no tron is like providing tons of utility for payments this is a well-known fact that let's let's move beyond the TBL what else you got Justin right so basically what we have is that so that is moving towards being isolationist it being disconnected now the L1 is only one aspect there's more there's more to it one is that so that has no support for like clients it has no real-time mercilization of the states there's literally zero like clients and what that means is that the only way to interact with the chain unless you're willing to be on a data center if you if you have a phone or even if you're never blockchain let's say you have a you want to have build a trustless bridge between Solana and if you can't and so this is why the only kind of bridges that you have are trusted bridges like wormhole because Solana has no like client support and my prediction is that it will never have like client support for a couple of reasons one is that it's taken this shortcut of not having mercilization and it turns out that mercilization is the bottleneck and so if it were to reintroduce it it would affect its right ability and the TPS and that's not something that it wants to do you don't need mercilization for like clients like why all I need is like data availability proofs that's totally doable and you need a path to the vote for my transaction that asserts the value of the state like I just need to submit a transaction that's us check the state is equal to this hash okay so basically what I totally is is suggesting is that every time you want to read the chain you make a transaction that is crazy that is absolutely the same yes it is why not for a high throughput chain with media because you make all those of magnitude more reads more reads on the blockchain than you do writes so that would like increase the transaction that you care about verifying can do that as its last instruction you don't have to actually do this for every every time you need to do a read it's that if you're a payment provider that needs to receive like payment flow in your UI you force the user to do this they sign the transaction you then do the whole SPV proof and DA and you're done like this is not like it's an extra instruction for people that want to want that cost that's it that's bundle in a transaction good luck with that my personal prediction is that no one will be paying for that everyone will go through trusted intermediaries they're going to be willing to just trust whoever you know heal you or heal you or whatever it's called is telling them all the obviously providers and they will not be making a transaction first if it's a commercial differentiator for those guys to do it they can bake it into their APIs and it's only just because we want to make sure you have an opportunity to get you know like we ask you about the bad section I think that bled into the ugly for a theorem but is there anything from your perspective that we haven't talked about that is ugly about a theorems design choices value architecture I mean one one thing we haven't talked about as a theorem fundamentally yeah well I mean one thing we haven't talked about just to spark things maybe is like running a note at home like and it seems to me that maybe slanted design decisions do not think that that's very valuable at all we could talk about that but oh the floor is open now Nielsen's law takes care of that like I already have one gigabit at home and like my test boxes work fine like I think the ugly parts and the theorem are better not fixable is this focus on ultrasound money and like decentralized money and this is what pigeons it into a specific direction which is means you're trying to build the lowest possible L1 and it's very very hard to do that and do all the execution on all these L2s and have any value capture on the L1 execution is what makes money is when you have priority fees people competing for content they want this particular dog coin versus another one they're willing to pay extra fees to be their first that's all in the execution layer that's where all the money's made and that pays for a normal user that doesn't care about whether they'll end in this four-minute millisecond block or the next one and they just want to pay for a mobile phone to that user they're not they don't give a shit like when they click that paint purchase button they don't care if it takes extra four-minute milliseconds so they're pretty that the their fees are fractions of a penny right does this make sense this is all because execution is able to capture high-average fees and provide a low-median fee that's really really hard to do in the settlement part and when you move all the value capture away from the L1 what are you left with is just trying to compete with Bitcoin and being the most better money but that is not like real it's all it's a meme decentralized money like i agree is important when my parents fled the Soviet Union had these technologies existed they would have preferred USDT on Trump versus Bitcoin or Ethereum and there's no way you could convince them that hey you're gonna take this massive move and flee this country that if you take Ethereum it's going to be within 90% of the value that you put in within a year because the variability in all this other shit makes it a much riskier but um so like you need stablecoins for normal people so like once you accept that like as the thing this like decentralized money meme is like is like puts you into design decisions that are all kind of like ruin the the cool part of the network just like execution can pay for super super fast cheap stablecoin payments Justin want to get you to respond to that and then we'll end with closing thoughts from from each of you so what how do you respond to um what Anatoly said about the ugly of Ethereum so Anatoli is right that um there is no money to be made no value to be captured in the settlement of execution which is just verifying a snack but there is this other part of settlement which is data and it turns out that data scales linearly you know snogs are magic this is exponential scaling where you can take arbitrarily large computation and shrink it down to a single snog you cannot do that with with with with data like every user needs to consume a certain number of bytes um now one of the things that Anatoli said is that we're trying to build the smallest chain possible so that we can extract the highest fees that is that is completely wrong right we have a whole roadmap of scaling and it's not about per transaction fees being being high we actually want per transaction fees to be low it's about the product of the number of transactions times the median or the average transaction so we want to have 10 million transactions per second each of which are paying a tiny fraction of a penny but in aggregate that could be hundreds of millions of dollars to the to the L1 they're just paying for data right that is correct to the L1 they're just paying for data yes and data is a commodity like there's no way the L1 can charge more than a small multiple of the cost of bandwidth okay so right so we have a validator and they're on like the best connection that that that is available to them you know from their home or whatever it is we can have that's that's the cost of data to not everywhere but like that's the cost that I can get and it's going to be everywhere within a couple of years you cannot put the whole internet on the one internet connection like that's just going to work sure no sure but like today today I can get 64 cents per terabyte within 10 years the world is going to be below that and my price is going to be in low there's this notion called induced demand like this is the guy who said you know whatever like a hundred kilobytes of memories going to be sufficient for the whole world like you need to project into the future today we might only be doing 10 transactions a second but you know in the future we might have our personal AIs do you know millions of transactions per second on our behalf and so the data card will never be able to fit everything on the single internet connection the more resources we have the more we want to consume but like the data portion is not it's opaque it has no content-based pricing no time-based pricing it is just pure commodity throughput so you can't want as the old one cannot charge more than a constant factor of the physical cost of it because if it charges a hundred acts off the off the cost of the physical access so it's going to build this is like there is there is a reason why Ethereum data availability is worth more than Solana's data availability because of network effects yes this notion of shared security this notion of synchronous composability of because of the economic security not just that but also access to tvl access to applications there's only one ENS in the world right there's only one Ethereum and internet this is really weak this is this is why I think it's ugly and it's not fixable is it's not a fundamentally hard thing I thought we agreed that synchronicity is important if you're on a separate chain and then suddenly you become asynchronous relative to all the the applications that are living in the other chain sure but if you pay a premium for synchronicity and and composability if the Ethereum I mean like if it's main purpose is to charge for l2 data this is how it's going to end up it's going to be very very hard to capture value like real value capture all this stuff you're talking about is very hand wavy because you can't like do cash flow analysis on it like apple I build this phone for acts I sell it for why right like maybe it maybe it has value maybe not I don't know but it's it's it wobbly to me like if you're charging just for data there's a fixed amount cap that you can charge for it because if you charge a hundred acts on the cost of data it's just open to competitors like there's just no way you can run a business that runs a hundred acts cost on a commodity service like just providing data so last year however else we'll we'll eat your lunch and they'll be like this is the better place for l2s it's just going to be downward spiral so this is like the hard part I don't know if it's fixable it's it's easy for me to like argue how an execution layer will survive and work just in brief comment on that and then let's get to closing so what's your brief comment on what intelligence said fundamentally we're going to be limited by bandwidth even though it grows exponentially we always want to consume more that is the nature of humanity and we can't put all the internet of value every single transaction through one you know home internet connection or even one data center internet connection so fundamentally there's going to be congestion and why is there going to be congestion because everyone is going to be willing to use this prime resource which gives us network effects gives us access to liquidity gives us access to security so you're expecting that the ethereum l1 will have blob congestion 100% yes like right now there's no congestion so it's going to be underspect for its demand no we're going to have as much as we can but even that's not going to be enough I think you're overstating demand I my my guess is that the top 100,000 transactions per second will cover 99.
9999% of value on the underestimating the you know demand is like saying there's only demand for five computers in the world no no that's not true there's going to be way more transactions than you expect we're going to have but yeah again you're you're talking about science fiction future stuff instead of looking at a current data google does about 40 to 80,000 searches per second that is a single global application that is scaled to every human and permeated their lives that is 80,000 events there's always new applications every time we've 10x bandwidth we've unlocked new applications you know we've gone from text to images to videos but not not like transaction events so so there are many points of difference throughout this conversation I have thoroughly enjoyed everything I pray my competitors build for a world with infinite demand as bad as overestimating demand is as bad as underestimating and it's only once you get to kind of your closing arguments I mean maybe talk about the what you think the end game's going to be and how Solana fits there and where you think the points of you know debate are or dissimilarities here and just like it closes out on the discussion so far so you have the floor I mean I think Solana's account there's something really awesome we have high average fees and low median fees that means users can get very low access to the chain fractions of a penny I think L2s are still nowhere like not even within 10x stop and the network makes sustainable revenues I can pay for all the hardware 10x over so like it's it's a miracle like as far as I'm concerned like holy shit there's enough money to be made here that these boxes are gonna run forever and access for users and like use cases that I care about which is just selling products with did through stable coins like selling stupid phones that works that's like a I've like done created something that is useful for people and what Solana's goal is to maximize this Moore's law and yields his law as far as I can go and optimize the network because every time we do that it's a benefit to the users spreads get lower latencies get better all these things converge and just better outcomes for all the users and hopefully it still remains financially like stable so that's division and it's very very simple there's no infinities there it's just like the really current release works well at 16 cores let's get it to work about our 32 cores and and tell you how does Ethereum fit in that kind of and state vision of what Solana is to these co-exist does one become larger than the other how do you think of that in game um I have no clue like if this like decentralized money thing like I it might work like Bitcoin is worth a billion dollars and it doesn't make any sense to me like so yeah network effects tvl all these things could matter but it's not hard like it's not something that I can like bet my work on like that I would want to bet my career on like I want to build stuff that I know is going to work so for my perspective like the more l2s and networks and different environments start for digital assets the better because the more that stuff exists the easier it is for a price discovery engine that runs as fast as the speed of light allows to actually find product market fit there's just more stuff to do price discovery on right like so please go build as many altos as you can build as many ultra sound monies as you can like go go forth we're going to build a chain that is runs as fast as physics allow given you know the hardware gods like and and where they go just just in what what are your closing arguments and on this whole discussion so far and what is a theorems endgame what is Solana fit in the in the picture here I mean in hearing at a totally give his closing argument I think of an atoli as a pure technologist I am grateful for like all the technology that it has provided but in from my perspective like blockchains are one of the most multidisciplinary kind of creatures that exist out there and it's more than just about the technology it's about the culture it's about the mimetic mimetic forces it about economic forces it's about network effects it's about forces that are way larger than just pure technology and atoli is building open source software you know coming up with new virtual machines new gossip net you know new networking technologies all of these things have little mode they can be copied very easily and they are in the process of being copied on a theorem altos today what is difficult to copy our network effects mimetic forces brand reputation this is what will stand the test of time and the network effects are so large that it makes it difficult to have an isolationist you know policy we want to build everything from scratch not invented here I don't want it I want I want everything to be on my little Solana island disconnected from from from reality and that will mean that fundamentally it will you have headwinds constant headwinds and this is being reflected one of the very important interesting things is when you have an exotic island you have exotic life forms that emerge you know you have weird things like geobodans and dog with hats and all of these things and you know you can have you know circle jerking within this little island where everyone's like happy you know worshipping these little images but even even Solana which is like the primary place for meme coins is still menu skill look at look Solana has tens of thousands if not hundreds of thousands of meme coins if you take the sum of the market values of all the meme coins is about 10 billion dollars on a theorem you have one meme coin called shiba inu which is 15 billion dollars a single meme coin and this is where we see the distinction between quality and quantity Anatolia and Solana is going in for quantity quantity quantity and at the expense of all sorts of things that are more important in the grant in the grant just because I asked you until the same question I want to ask you the same question so the end game for a theorem what what is Solana look like what is a theorem look like is one larger than the other how do you think this plays out Justin again in the end game I think it's with winner take most I think the network effects are extremely strong and so there's just like there's one internet there's going to be one internet of value right there isn't I mean okay maybe arguably there's like two internet there's like the Chinese internet behind the firewall and other internet but that is kind of a bit of an anomaly really you can think of there being one big internet with massive network effects and what I think will happen is that we're going to see you know a flourishing of activity where the network effects reside and grow and and in order to to have these healthy network effects you need to have synchronous composition you need to have shared security and also you need to have shared economic bandwidth the monetary premium is not just about economic security it's also about economic bandwidth the end game for example is to have decentralized stablecoins how do you build decentralized stablecoins is by taking pristine collateral and issuing stablecoins out of that in order to have trillions of dollars of over collateralized stablecoins we need trillions of dollars of pristine collateral and so you can't discount the importance of mimetic value and there's going to be strong network effects where these these decentralized stablecoins are issued and what I think will happen is that you know you know Ethereum is the most likely candidate of of winning it all now you might ask if the layer one landscape is winner take all like how can you justify the Solana you know 100 billion dollar valuation the way that I rationalize it is that there's a 1% chance let's say that Solana can become the internet of value and that is enough because there's a 1% chance that a 100 x is from a hundred billion dollars to 10 trillion dollars and so that is a worthy bet to be making but in 99% of of the time if you were to roll the dice of humanity and you run these parallel simulations you're going to have a dominant network the internet of value that is going to eat everything up and the lead that Ethereum has is so high that a little bit of technology that is easily copyable and that is being copied right now with the L2s is not going to be a sustainable mode well there we go I think we have to end it there we've gone on for almost two hours a gentleman thank you both for joining us and having this conversation that this discussion it's been at times exciting at times heated but I always done with good faith I think from from both sides so I certainly appreciate it anything else you want you want to say before we conclude that that way and it totally you look like you want to say something no this is great I don't think anyone's mind is changed which is funny so we'll keep arguing about this it's usually how it works with these conversations that's usually how these go Justin was your mind changed at all not really I am looking forward to the feedback from the community yeah I mean I want to see for example if people really buy the fact that you know paying your taxes and sell pressure it's not a cost to network that just seems like absurd but we'll see well I think there will be some will there will be some follow-ups in community as always you can let us know what you think of this episode let us know if you want a round two at some point in the future and maybe we convince these guests to come on and resolve the unresolved questions but we'll end it there I got to let you know of course none of this has been financial advice we have no idea what the price of soul will do no idea what the price of eth will do in the near-term future you could definitely lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the front tier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bank list journey thanks a lot