This episode takes place in the geographical heart of Layer Zero: the middle of DevConnect, the 2022 Amsterdam conference. With the backdrop of a lively conference center, Simona Pop explores heavy topics like the 1989 Romanian Revolution and the pitfalls of DAO governance.
When you cut off the head of top-down totalitarianism, you must replace it with something better—otherwise, another hydra head will appear. Simona thrives on the cutting edge of big problems like these, working on DAO Engagement Strategy at Gitcoin, Community Strategy at Status, and founding the Bounties Network.
When Simona talks about crypto and the Web3 space, the epic proportions of this moment in history become clear and present.
------
📣 THE GRAPH | Graph Day in San Francisco | June 2-5
------
🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/
🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALED ETHEREUM
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2
🏦 ALTO IRA | TAX-FREE CRYPTO
👻 AAVE V3 | LEND & BORROW CRYPTO
⚡️ LIDO | LIQUID ETH STAKING
🔐 LEDGER | NANO S PLUS WALLET
------
Topics Covered:
5:00 Simona, Amsterdam, and Real Life
8:55 A Revolutionary Childhood
12:45 Successful Evolutions
18:03 The Wheel of Time
25:00 The Governance Problem
30:30 This is Water
37:00 Replacing Nation States
40:55 Generational Change
48:50 Status and Networks
55:34 Why Simona’s Optimistic
58:44 Working for DAOs
1:02:41 Advice for Noobs
------
Resources:
-----
Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
I'm a little bit of a child of the revolution, and I know what it's like to not have freedoms of expression, travel, all of that. And I think it's very, very important and very ingrained clearly in me to be able to enable that for other people. Welcome to Layer Zero. Layer Zero is a podcast of unscripted conversations with the people that make up the Ethereum community. Crypto is built by code, but it's composed by people, and each individual member of the crypto community has their own story to tell. Cypherpunks understood that the code they write impacts the people that use it, and Layer Zero focuses on the people behind the code, because Ethereum is people all the way down, and always has been.
Today on Layer Zero, I'm speaking with Simona Pop, and we recorded this episode in the middle of DevConnect. And so there is a big conference room, a co-working space, where a lot of people are heads down, building whatever it is that they're building, so there's a little bit of background chatter. but hopefully that adds to the vibe rather than detract from it. We talk a lot about governance, and Simona is a child of the Romanian Freedom Revolution from the Eastern Bloc, from Russia's dominance with communism. And so she was very, very young when the revolution in Romania happened and broke Romania free from communism.
And we use this as a metaphor to discuss Tao governance of all things. she talks about how yes you can cut off the head of top-down totalitarian communism but you have to also replace that with something else or else the same sort of structure just grows back in its place and so we we take this idea of if we are going to kill something we need to replace it with something new otherwise the same patterns will will unfold once again which is what happened in Romania post-communist Russia. And so we talk about the different structures of Dao governance. We use this metaphor for a flowing river of liquid governance, of liquid representation, and allowing this river to adapt, as rivers do, to its surrounding environment.
And if Dao governance needs to change and adapt over time, it also needs to act like a flowing river. And so there's plenty of metaphors with rivers and adaption in there. And overall, Simona is just a beloved part of the Ethereum community. She's working extremely hard figuring out DAO governance, which is the problem of problems in this space right now. So let's go ahead and get right into this conversation with Simona Pop right after we talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. Aave is the leading decentralized liquidity protocol. And now Aave V3 is here. Aave V3 has powerful new features to enable you to get the most out of DeFi, including Isolation Mode, which allows for many more markets to be launched with more exotic collateral types, and also Efficiency Mode, which allows for higher loan-to-value ratios, and of course, Portals, allowing users to port their Aave position across all of the networks that Aave operates on, like Polygon, Phantom, Avalanche, Arbitrum, Optimism, and Harmony.
The beautiful thing about Aave is that it's completely open-source, decentralized, and governed by its community, enabling a truly bankless future for us all. To get your first crypto collateralized loan, get started at Aave.com. That's A-A-V-E.com. And also check out the Aave Protocol governance forums to see what more than 100,000 DAO members are all robbing about at governance.ave.com. Arbitrum is an Ethereum layer two scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Over 300 projects have already deployed to Arbitrum and the DeFi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly.
Some of the coolest and newest NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home. All the while, DeFi protocols continue to see increased usage and liquidity. Using Arbitrum has never been easier, especially with the ability to deposit directly into Arbitrum through all the exchanges, including Binance, FTX, Huobi, and Crypto.com. Once inside, you'll notice Arbitrum increases Ethereum's speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee. If you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users, visit arbitrum.io slash developer to start building your dApp on Arbitrum.
If you're a degen, many of your favorite dApps on Ethereum are already on Arbitrum, with many moving over every day. Go to bridge.arbitrum.io now to start bridging over your ETH and other tokens in order to experience DeFi and NFTs in the way it was always meant to be. Fast, cheap, secure, and friction-free. Living a bankless life requires taking control over your own private keys. And that's why so many in the bankless nation already have their Ledger hardware wallet. And brand new to the Ledger lineup of hardware wallets is the Ledger Nano S+, a huge upgrade to the world's most popular hardware wallet.
With more memory and a larger screen, the Nano S+, makes it easy to navigate and verify your transactions. And the paired Ledger Live desktop app gets you increased transparency as to what is about to happen with your NFT. What you see is what you sign. The Nano S+, gives you the smoothest possible user experience while you're doing all of your crypto things. So go to the Ledger website to check out the features of the new Ledger Nano S Plus and join the waitlist to get yours. And don't forget about the Crypto Life card, also powered by Ledger. The CL card is a crypto debit card that hooks right into the Ledger Live app, right next to all the DeFi apps and services that you're already used to doing, like swapping tokens and staking.
So if you don't have a Ledger hardware wallet, go to Ledger.com, grab a Ledger and take control over your crypto. Hey, Sona, what's up? Everything's damn fine. Why is it damn fine? Because we're in Amsterdam. We are in Amsterdam. For DevConnect. Yeah, have you been to Amsterdam before? I have, and it was raining, and the city was beautiful, but in the sunshine, it's a totally different experience. The consensus that I've gotten about Amsterdam is that everyone loves it. Yes. Everyone just has the best words to describe Amsterdam. It's beautiful, all the flowers are in bloom, it's tulip season, and we are here.
as a connoisseur of plants i will have to say the plants of amsterdam are top notch right on point yes and the street flowers what is the thing that's like a whole different level of street flower yeah i have walked hours yes i've only been here for two days i don't know when you got here but i've been only here for two days and i have walked for like four or five hours total agreed yeah and it's like why would you take a means of transport like canals flowers trees in bloom Do you know how Amsterdam was chosen? DevConnect? Do you know who made that choice? No, I don't actually. Well, they made a good choice.
They absolutely did. And the weather, they arranged that to a T. So, pleased. I've asked you this question before, but not in a long-form podcast capacity. So we're going to go into this a little bit more. But why real life? Why is real life important? This industry is on the internet. We don't need to meet in real life. Why can't we just go meet on Discord or Zoom? Why can't we meet in the metaverse? Because we're people and energy is important and being able to spend time with friends. Because at this stage, a lot of us are friends. Let's face it, we've known each other for, what, five years?
It's a long time and it's actually a really, really nice kind of group of friends. And if you think about it, it's a really, really good dynamic that we have together. And new people coming in and the OGs. it's just really really important to just catch up now and again and obviously the hugging now the hugging is back on the menu it's like it's great i have been warning people that i am a hugger so they're not surprised but it's also like no one is surprised because like the last time i've seen most of these people was months ago yeah uh and so just the enthusiasm of seeing people here in real life is is just lovely plus like we get to lock all of the uh developers in a room and force them into having a merge date so that's what's going on right now amazing very true um at an undisclosed location.
Yes, a very secret location of only the privileged parties can get to. But yeah, look, and again, everything does happen online and we can obviously reach a lot more people online, but it is important to create all of these little moments that we can touch base, we can interact with each other face-to-face and then go back to being online. And I think having those catch-up moments is important. Certainly, yeah. Dev Connect. It's called DevConnect for a reason. We are here to sync our nodes. Because even though I think obviously the crypto industry is probably the most adept at working online, we can be the most productive versus any other industry online.
But still, in real life, there's always these tailwind benefits of being in real life that will never be replaced. And think about the fact that most, I mean, I don't know about you, but a lot of the relationships that I have and a lot of the friendships and a lot of the collaborations, that I've worked on started at certain events, 2018, 2019, and so on, when we were first kind of doing these things and establishing the schedule of events. So yeah, it's important. So what class are you a part of? What cycle of the crypto industry did you come in? Are you class of 2017, earlier? End of 2017. End of 2017.
Okay, same Zs. When I actually started genuinely working on a project, because that's when I met Mark. Well, end of 2017, beginning of 2018. And that's where I became the co-founder of the Standard Bounties Protocol and Bounties Network. Yes, Bounties Network. Right. So what brought you in? Like Bounties Network is very, very Gitcoin ethos aligned, which is kind of where you found yourself, right? Very close to Kevin Ohwaki, very much like finding ways to push development to the margins. Like what about crypto brought you in? So I think for me, it was always this ability to level out the playing field and allow more people a seat at the table.
In fact, rebuild the table with a lot more seats. Right. And that's one of the main things that attracted me to bounties. And actually, because Gitcoin was built on top of the standard bounties protocol. And so we were very much value aligned. But in terms of the core interest for me, and that's what continues to be my core interest, is how can we enable access to resource for everybody, regardless of geography, regardless of social status, regardless of education, regardless of language, regardless of all of that. And everything that I tend to do is to push that forward and to try to create more pathways in for a lot more people.
What were you doing before crypto? Did it kind of align with all that stuff? Or what was your mode of operating before crypto? It was very much in comms and experiential and always in tech. But, you know, the web too. Sure. Yeah, yeah. So kind of trying to get the listeners grounded for who Simona Pop is. What did you know before crypto that you brought to crypto? Like what information have you blessed the crypto industry with? I think for me, it's interesting because being originally from Romania and having experienced, albeit a very small part of, I was very young when the revolution happened in 89, but you still have that sense of what it is like to live in a country where censorship, complete lack of privacy and restrictions is the norm.
And so I think I see this sometimes where I'm a little bit of a child of the revolution and I know what it's like to not have freedoms of expression, travel, all of that. And I think it's very, very important and very ingrained clearly in me to be able to enable that for other people. And so with that knowledge and also the fact that knowing that, I'm also aware of a lot of, I guess the importance of why balance matters when you are trying to completely redesign the flow of things. Because you want to make sure that if you're going to redesign it, you're going to not redesign it in the same image as what came before.
Learn from what came before, but try to redesign it in a mindful and balanced way so that we don't end up in the same place or even a worse place. So this is going to reveal my little knowledge of that era of time in Eastern Europe. But I think this is what we should definitely dive into. The revolution. Let's go into that. How old were you when... Six. Six? Okay, so you didn't know much else other than that. No. No. But also, when you're a kid, you kind of don't really realize the true... Magnitude of what's going on. No, no. And we're talking about... Is this communism in Russia? Is this relevant here?
Yeah, so basically every... Give us a quick history lesson, yeah. They call it the Eastern Bloc because everything that was around Russia and below was under Russia's influence, right? You had the USSR at the time. So anything Eastern Europe was like communist, controlled by, had the same modus operandi as the USSR. And the idea was that it would be made in its image. And so what you had was the Prague Spring that kick-started revolutions in all of these countries in the Eastern Bloc. And it almost went like a domino effect. And so all of them then removed communism from their governments and went on to hopefully rebuild and redesign so that it is, you know, in a democratic way.
Now, what that also kind of showed me and made me understand is that sometimes a revolution doesn't really do much. You cut off the head, but the body stays the same. So then you just replace the head. But everything else, particularly when you're talking about a bureaucracy, will just be exactly the same. Which is why when I talk about crypto, it shouldn't be a revolution. It should be an evolution. It takes longer, but it changes the whole organism versus just the head. Yes. I think there's a very common pattern throughout history that revolutions are really good at breaking things. Right. But not necessarily putting them back in a way that answers to the problems of why the revolution decided to happen in the first place.
Right. All it does is says, well, this isn't working, let's end it. And kind of fails to follow through. It just creates the vacuum of power. It creates the vacuum of power. And I think also, let's remember that a lot of the revolutions that have happened in the world are really orchestrated by completely other interests outside of that country. So you also have that. Okay, so the revolution started when you were six? So it was all of a week. Oh, wow. Pardon me. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. It went like this. Okay, very fast. Yeah. Okay, so it was more the process of recreation that probably, because I don't know when people start remembering their first memories, but about six is about right?
Right. So that's when it started building, let's say, towards a democracy again. Right. A democracy. Right. Right. So your formative years were all about just looking at and being under the paradigm of how are we going to re-architect governance? Yes. Yeah. Kind of. In hindsight. Attempts to it. Yes. And so like, again, like history lesson, how would you rate that re-architection if you had to rate it on a scale of one to ten? Minus one. Uh-oh. Why? What should we learn from this? again it's it's very very important to um understand that things that have been almost cemented in a certain way take a lot longer to break through like if you think of plants growing through the pavement right that's gonna have to push and like really work to get through it when it's so solid right and because like i mentioned earlier usually the body of the beast remains the same.
And so you have to work with a lot of things that were already in place and then try to slowly remove those and replace them with better, with better, with better. And so what you get a lot is, and I think that's still valid for the whole of the former Eastern Bloc, you have a lot of corruption. You have a lot of people who are in power who then decided that they could maintain power, but this time it would be financial. and so you have that switch um yeah using the plant metaphor if you have a like a tree for example like a in the middle of a storm it blows over but it doesn't die and then it'll start to regrow in a different direction but it'll always be scarred by the storm it'll never be the perfect emblematic vertical beautiful tree it will be the kinked tree and it will never get away it'll never get away from that kink right like it'll always have this in its base like dna right not the dna the epigenetics right how the dna is expressed and so if you're telling me that like the romanian government did a or the romania did a good job of taking the head off but forgot to like replace the culture right the culture was the same which is why the layer zero is always so important indeed it is and also taking again from that tree metaphor of breaking i think what looking at web three and what we're doing now with governance we need to look more at a willow model where it bends And it's a lot more flexible versus, again, just very rigid.
Right. Because as soon as you start potentially being very rigid about things, you could miss or could be, let's say, a little bit more fragile when something happens and you can't adapt. Yeah, that rigidity aspect is really, really important. We'll go down to that in a second. One thing I learned while kind of going down the Ukraine versus Russia rabbit hole is that this same thing has already happened. This happened in the 1800s. It happened in the 1900s. And now it's happening again. And my takeaway from that was that there's this like Russian, like Putin is very like focused on like this, like kind of this manifest destiny of Russia.
Right. Like this Russian sort of just like ethnic imperialism or something. like putin is like this embodiment of this weird like russian energy that wants to like dominate eastern europe right i mean yeah yeah and and this the the story of the russian empire in the 1800s whatever it was called back then coming in to dominate ukraine and then ukraine did like um just not wanting that and revolting against that that this story has already played out once before and so that when you know that that was like three generations ago there's something in the dna of Eastern Europe that like makes this story happen again and again and again.
And how do we get people to be aware of these things? Because isn't it education that is how we get through this? It is education. And it's also a, you know, a level of respect for what has come before. Not necessarily in a must be revered, must be, you know, glorified in any way. But it must be understood. Sure. Because if you, like you were saying, you notice patterns. And what that enables you to do is when you notice those same patterns repeating again, you can bend, adjust, flex away from it. You don't end the pattern. You redirect the pattern. Or you work with it and you kind of go, okay, what is it that we could do to essentially go on a different path versus just repeating this one?
Right. And that's a big thing that I think sometimes in Web3 we kind of go, yeah, everything's trash. Let's just rebuild everything. Everything's new again. New paradigm. New paradigm. Which is great because that's, you know, we're enthusiastic and we want to do these things and it's wonderful. But are there lessons for us to learn in that process so that we don't just again follow that same pattern, go down the same stuff, and then at the end of it go, shit, did it again. Right. The wheel is something that I think Chris Berniski talked about where like, you know, in the future, we're going to be the boomers.
And like our kids are going to be like, you know, you guys got to, you know, you guys bought Bitcoin before it had a market price. Right. You guys got Ether at the ICR price. What did you do? You got Ether before. Remember when you got into Ethereum before it was proof of stake? Like you boomer parents, like work is hard now. Like things are now like saturated and difficult. And just like the same complaints that millennials are having about the current institution. So when you see these governance structures, because governance is all of the rage in Web3 these days. It is. Governance, governance, governance.
Win airdrop, win token, win governance token. How do you see us falling into the same traps if you do see us doing that? I think one of the main things, and certainly this is very much something that I'm interested in from kind of a multitude of different perspectives. I'm obviously one of the top delegates in Gitcoin, in ENS And I also work together with Gitcoin on what I like to call governance engagement Because right now, governance and engagement are like this There is a lot of rubber stamping There is a lot of... There's high, high lack of context for different conversations happening and decisions being made That is because things are not transparent.
Things aren't necessarily easy to grasp context for. And also, most people are so insanely busy that to dig through notions, discords and all of this to gain context to inform a vote that may actually influence quite a few things is quite taxing. Right. So like a snapshot vote comes into existence and like the many, many voters of this snapshot vote are like, all right, like yes or no. Right. And there's like, there is perhaps hours and hours of like debate and deliberation and arguments as to even what are the parameters of this vote to begin with. Or there should be. Or there should be. Or at least with the people that put this thing to a vote, right?
Yes, right. Okay, these four people are talking about this governance decision, and they are the experts in the yes and the no cases, but they need to give it to the community because that's what decentralized governance is. But then the community is like, they spent 30 seconds reading the snapshot, and they don't know the extent of the details, and they don't know the impact. And that's a problem. Because if I want to have context to be able to make an informed decision, that's incredibly important. And you would do that in, you know, in any other area of your life, you would want to know what you are making a decision about.
And so with regards to and coming back to your original question, how could we perhaps make those same mistakes is that, again, we go in this direction where voting remains binary. There is no respect for nuance. There is no respect for, let's say, the in-between, the maybe, the ambiguity. Because a lot of things that we're dealing with right now, it's okay for them to be ambiguous for a while until we figure out how they can be clearer and simpler and easier to make a yes-no decision on. And so with that in mind, I think being comfortable with ambiguity and being comfortable with nuance and a spectrum of decision making and a spectrum of discussion versus just, no, it has to be this or the other is important to not only think about, but also weave into the processes that we're putting in place.
Like, I love a standard, obviously. But I think that's important, especially when you navigate various different doubts. Like, for me, even in these major two that I am one of the main delegate in, it's hard because they're structured differently. Right. And they have a different flow for the governance. Right. Not majorly different, but different still. Importantly different. Right. Yeah. And so I think for us to be able to really have the context and be able to make the right decisions, it's important to have a flow that is... Uniform is not the right word. Something that enables that access again in a very...
Right. Right. So there's one way to tackle this problem, which is just making governance easier. Yes. Being able to make the nuance more digestible, the debate more digestible. But the other solution is just like, let's just centralize it. Let's just centralize the governance. Yeah, but we don't want that. But why is that bad? Because we call these things DAOs, but most of them, they're not autonomous. They're definitely not autonomous. And they're definitely not decentralized. I really call them digital organizations. Now, the cool unlock is the actual decentralized part of it. Yes. But we don't have that yet.
So, like, why can't we just, like, have the centralized governance while we figure this out? Because I think you want to... And look, we are in a very difficult situation right now just as an ecosystem because we're so embedded in the current world whilst trying to build a new one. And so you're almost constantly enmeshed in the current way of doing things whilst trying to envisage what the new stuff will be. So it's hard. It's a continuous exercise and you almost have to do that daily practice, that daily exercise to maintain whatever it is that you want to build, right? That muscle mass, maybe, or those habits to build those new pathways and those new habits.
I think the important piece is to have the right either groups or structures dealing with different stages of the flow. And that's the thing that can unlock that decentralization where you put things, you know, imagine a river, right? Because we're in Amsterdam. Imagine all of these bridges and all of those. But at each one, you have a different checkpoint almost. And then the whole thing becomes clearer and it evolves and it involves conversations. It involves dialogue. It involves certain amounts of decisions, but not a yes, no. Right. And you evolve it that way. But to create that flow, you have to look at, OK, who is going to be involved?
What is the end goal? How long can this take? What is the process? Will it be different for certain types of proposals? And will it be different for others? when you have something to do with a budget, with a treasury, does that go on a different path versus one that has to do with, I don't know, removal of stewards, right? And you have to map all of that out. And I always, always use this analogy because I think it's so important. When you go to an amusement park, you see the map of everything that is there and you know where you're going and you know how to get there and you know if that is where you want to get to, or you want to go here, in fact, or there, or stop halfway through there.
And we don't really have that right now. And that should be something that is almost, because we talk about doubt tooling. Oh, my God, doubt tooling. Doubt tooling, doubt tooling, doubt tooling. It's raining doubt tools. But I think it's important, again, to look at those and create those mindfully and from a place of experience. Like for me, I see the pain on both sides. I'm working on governance engagement, but I'm also a steward. And I know that, for instance, the other week, like two weeks ago, I was focusing so much on that and curating Shelling Point that I dropped the ball in my NS duties for a week.
Right. Right. Because that's what happened. Right. Yeah. Duty calls. Which is fine. Right. In a decentralized world, nodes are going to drop. Right. Right. Right. And so figuring out how to make sure that that isn't a tragedy or that isn't something that breaks something is something that we need to bake into the whole flow. Because we are humans. The whole Tao governance thing should be fluid because, again, using the river and the flow and all of that, it has to be fluid. It has to flow. It has to enable people to kind of go, oh, OK, I can't do this at the moment, but I'm OK. to come back in when I have more focus, when I can dedicate more time.
Okay. So just to, I want to recap all of that. I think both for the listeners and also for my own benefit, the answer to like, why not centralize is because of obvious reasons. And the alternative is micro centralization in pockets, which I think are like committees where like you, you talked about these certain proposals, such as if we're talking about a treasury, like a treasury proposal, as in, we are going to do this with the treasury. and perhaps we can have two different versions. It's like if this proposal is above $10,000 or below $10,000, the river will split. Right. And it will go to this committee first and then this committee will tinker with this part of the proposal.
Maybe this is the Clarity and Definitions Committee. Sure. And then the Clarity and Definitions Committee do their work. Maybe there's four nodes, four council members of that particular cabinet of sorts. And then once they're done, they pass it off to another node which does the, I don't know, the allocation of funds committee or something, right? And it flows down this river. And you always ensure that those little pockets have the right representation in them. Yes, right. Okay, so like micro-centralization as in like, all right, four people have the role and responsibility. Four people have the block.
I wouldn't even call it centralization. I would call it... Delegation? Specialized delegation. Specialized delegation. I think we mean the same thing. I think that's a semantics difference. But it sounds better. But it definitely sounds better. It definitely sounds better. And so, okay, so we have, like, this, like, mesh network of, like, a river. Right, yes. And the concept of a river is that it always flows downstream, right? Like, water will always go where it's easiest for it to go. And, like, right now, when I said, like, dhows aren't autonomous, rivers are autonomous, right? Like, they just go.
And so one of my bull cases for dhows, not dhows as a concept, but the dhows that are the most bullish are the ones that lower the threshold for participation down to the bare minimum, right? Like how can you make a verifiable contribution in the easiest possible way? And so if we're going to extend this to governance, it's like how can we make sure that the governance proposals always go downhill? Whether or not they're accepted, like maybe downhill means it's rejected, but like a rejection is a choice either way. Like successful governance can reject a choice. Oh, absolutely. So how do we make like a governance proposal hit all these subcommittees to refine and digest and do all these things with these governance and make sure the thing always flows downhill so that it comes to a conclusion.
Because I think so many of DAO governance right now is like we forget to come to a conclusion on a lot of things. Like it gets lost in the river. Or we rush to a conclusion, right? And sometimes that's not necessarily a good conclusion or it's not necessarily thought of as much. But keeping it, as you say, on that path, I think that's where potentially those standards that you put in place come in. Because then it's almost like the banks of a river. Sure. Right. And you create that versus just like letting it spell all over the place, in which case, again, with the river, you lose control and it damages things.
Right, yeah. Yeah, it turns into a flood. Right. And so what you want is to have that, and because you were saying with the flow of water, obviously you have like the whole Bruce Lee thing, be water my friends like all of that right and you take that shape and you enable those the banks of the river to be that tooling that you put in place but you have to understand what the substance is right because you could make the you know the banks of the river out of material that is not conducive to the flow right right it could be too porous it could be like breakable it could And then the river always automatically corrects for that because the river will erode.
Of course. The broken banks. Voila. Right. Lovely. Lovely. And this is beautiful. This is so, I mean, I'm impressed with us right now. Also, just quick side quest. Rivers are inherently decentralized, right? And so like top down government could become like, I want to stop this river and build a dam. But all dams break over time. Like we can just route around the river, right? There's that meme of just like governments banning Bitcoin. And it's like the fence that has no edges. And people just like walk around the fence. Same thing with the river. You can dam up a river, but over a long time frame, the river always breaks.
Exactly. Or the dam always breaks. Exactly. Let's take this back to Romania and governance. Okay. Where we cut off the head, but then the same similar shape reappears. Yes. How does this model fix that? I think, and again, another analogy that I particularly like is this idea of the puzzle. If you lose, you know, you're making jigsaw puzzles and you lose one piece, you have to replace it with a piece that is exactly the same shape, exactly the same pattern, exactly the same. Sure. So what we are doing is we're scrapping that puzzle or at least the image that's in that puzzle and starting from scratch.
Because if you just remove the piece, one piece, the head, the rest keeps it. Right. The void still has the same shape. Same shape. Yeah. And so my hope is that what we're all doing here is actually redesigning and replanning a whole new puzzle. Learning from how puzzles work, learning from how long it potentially takes, what type of thing you need in there, what type of material, what type of whatever. But it's a different image. It's maybe a different structure. Maybe it's 3D one. Hopefully it's a 3D one. That's a lot more fun. Right? So you're kind of evolving it. And again, that evolution from your very basic one to something that can really, really capture the richness and the not richness in the cash bags.
Right. The aspect of it. What's the other word for this? Vibrancy. Vibrancy of what we can all do to ensure human thriving, to ensure that we are in a much better place, that everybody is in a much better place. The many, not the few. The era of proof of stake is upon us and Lido is bringing proof of stake to everyone. Lido is a decentralized staking protocol that allows users to stake their proof-of-stake assets using Lido's distributed network of nodes. Don't choose between staking your assets or using them as collateral in DeFi. With Lido, you can have both. Using Lido, you can stake any amount of your ETH to the Lido validating network and receive STETH in return.
STETH can be traded, used as collateral for lending and borrowing, or leveraged on your favorite DeFi protocols. All this without giving up your ETH to centralized staking services or exchanges. Lido now supports Terra, Solana, Kusama, and Polygon staking. Whatever your preferred proof-of-stake asset is, Lido is here to take away the complexities of staking while enabling you to get liquidity on your stake. If you want to stake your ETH, Terra, Sol, or Matic and get liquidity on your stake, go to Lido.fi to get started. That's L-I-D-O.FI to get started. The Layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's Layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day, and we need bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a Layer 2 life.
Across is the fastest, cheapest, and most secure cross-chain bridge. With Across, you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets to the chain of your choice. Assets are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously. Across bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens from Layer 2 back to Ethereum. A token proposal is being deliberated as we speak in the Across forum, where community members will decide on the token distribution. You can have your part of Across's story by joining the Discord and becoming a co-founder and helping to design the fair, fair launch of Across.
If you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely, go to across.to to bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Arbitrum, or Boba Networks. If you're trying to grow and preserve your crypto wealth, optimizing your taxes is just as lucrative as trying to find the next hidden gem. Alto IRA can help you invest in crypto in tax-advantaged ways to help you preserve your hard-earned money. Alto Crypto IRA lets you invest in more than 150 coins and tokens with all the same tax advantages of an IRA. They make it easy to fund your alternative IRA or crypto IRA via your 401k or by contributing directly from your bank account.
There is no setup or account fees and it's all you need to do to invest in crypto tax-free. Let me repeat that again. You can invest in crypto tax-free. Diversify like the pros and trade without tax headaches. Open an Alto Crypto IRA to invest in crypto tax-free. Just go to altoira.com slash bankless. That's A-L-T-O-I-R-A dot com slash bankless and start investing in crypto today. This is actually accidentally turning into a very logical progression from a couple of other layers of yours I've done. Yeah. Starting with Terum and then also most recently Tracheopteryx. Yes. We were talking about like, okay, cool, DAO governance.
Eventually we're going to get this thing perfected and refined. Right. And the engine's really going to start to turn. Right. And all of them are like, well, eventually this will start to eat at the role of nation states, right? Like eventually United States governance, the original Dow, by the way, will start to start to incorporate some of the models and the efficiencies that we innovated and developed with Dow governance. Yes. Tarun gave the example of how he thinks that it's really going to be the finance sector that comes first, where a lot of financial contracts use prices of a certain thing at a certain time to be embedded into the contract.
And we'll just agree that the price of this thing is at this time, at this date, by this oracle, which is like the NASDAQ. But they could start, instead of using the NASDAQ, which is a centralized company with that kind of a gameable system, instead you could use the oracle of Uniswap. And what we're doing is we're taking out the NASDAQ puzzle piece and we're re-implanting the Uniswap puzzle piece in its place. And his theory is that over time, we're going to find more and more ways to swap out old puzzle pieces with new puzzle pieces. Until you create a new puzzle. Until you create a new puzzle, right?
From the inside out. Do you have any thoughts on that? So, again, I think it's really, really interesting thinking about, because you mentioned the financial system and because we chat about money, It's really interesting to remember that we came up with that whole thing. And we just perpetuated in the normal system now in the world. It was decided at some point, but we can always change our minds and decide something else. And this is something that for a lot of people, I guess, even sometimes when they come into our space or into the Web3 space, it's very difficult to really get comfortable with the fact that that is just a decision some people made at this one time.
Right. It's not canon. It's not canon. You're not contractually bound to do anything. People just agreed that the U.S. dollar was going to have some value. People just agreed that this other thing was going to have value. That's all it is. It's an agreement. And we are making new agreements. And we can make new agreements. And we should make new agreements if the ones that have been in place are no longer serving us. Because that's what you would do. If a car, if you had a car that broke down as much as the current financial system, are you joking? They would remove it from the market. It would be a death trap.
we've had more systemic crises in the financial system since i don't know when they started measuring it right but it's 50 60 across the world and again think about the analogy of a car it broke down that much you'd be like i don't know i'm not getting into that death trap i need to buy a new one how do you think about um the rate of change right because the younger generations the millennials especially zoomers seem to be in their own world but they're going to get the brunt of this and eventually uh probably once they graduate from college but like the rate of change of the world seems to be not not be satisfactory for a lot of the younger folk yeah i mean and so like they're just asking for change now now now now now meanwhile the other half of the world like the older folk the boomers are like this is pretty gucci we kind of like we kind of like where things are right now so we're at we're at the speed limit this is nice right let's not go cruising no change no faster change like no more change like i haven't even figured out my iPhone yet.
How do you think about this conflict? Again, I always say balance in all things. I think nature, if you look at nature, and again, I love all of everything that comes with biomimicry. I love everything that we can learn from nature in the way it behaves and in the way it does things, because it's very clever. And there's this thing in nature called the optimum window of viability where it's in between diversity and efficiency and it's always in the middle point what we tend to do is always go way too efficient anything happens restrictions sanctions all like every austerity you always go way too efficient and you disturb the balance too much diversity is also bad because then that doesn't work because there's too much right there's There's no coordination.
But in the middle, that's where the sweet spot is. Now, in terms of the pace of change, I think if we again look at evolution, if a fish swam up on the shore and suddenly grew a leg out of its gills, that would not be very good because it would die. It wouldn't evolve. But slow evolution, little by little, ensures that it can become a successful new species, a successful new thriving organism. But it takes time because it needs to take into account all of the elements that it needs to build and build well. You rush one, you're like, I don't know, one side is lopsided. And again, it's not conducive to thriving.
so I think if we can get to that point where we balance out the speed because we do need to move right we can't just be like I'll be fine because again things aren't rosy in the real world right so I think if we can reach that balance of doing things mindfully and doing things properly that we don't cut corners very important but we move because stagnation is also not good right Do you think we have time? Like, global warming is not being solved by nation states. No, it's not. And I think that's generally a thing that most people across, outside of the crypto industry would agree with. Like, no one's really taking nation states seriously.
Granted, it's not like the crypto industry is doing anything for that. But we kind of think that we can. But also, do we have the time to actually be methodical about this and not rush this? I think I think it's almost a conversation around having that urgency but not making mistakes because you're on under pressure which again is is not easy like we're not in an easy situation it's a big ass right go like okay so the world is gonna end so but you need to be like you know make sure you focus so look it's not easy but i think it's one of the main reasons why we're sort of more and more people are coming into the space because like okay okay but this is how we can right and this is what at the end of the day this is what the web three piece is about it's that choice it is that alternative because for so long we had none right and we were just stuck with that track and that was it you can do you know turn things up and down over here and up and down over here but really it's the same road now we have a chance to a new one and all obviously with a new path you have to you know remove some thorns pave it do all of these things and we're doing it whilst were carving it so hard.
And it takes a lot of people because you need everybody involved to be able to get to where you want to go. Right. Hence DevConnect, right? Why can't we cut corners? Why can't we cut corners to get there? Because look at what cutting corners has got us into. Everybody has been cutting corners for like decades, for generations. The point that I'm making there is I think the technology that we're building is so, so powerful that if we enable back doors, cut corners to, you know, deliver for VCs a little bit faster, don't quite focus, ah, privacy, meh, all of that, right? We need to ship. Again, the balance, it's important.
Yes, move. Yes, ship. But don't sacrifice the principles to go get your VC some returns because that's what everybody has been doing. Okay, my next question was going to be, what's the corner that you see being cut the most? But would that be your answer, like optimizing for VCs? I think privacy and security. Privacy and security? Yeah. What's security mean? Just think about the amount of projects that have like one, the first version of their contract audited, and then they say they're audited, but they have had like five since. Right. Okay. So we're talking about bug exploits. just a plethora of risks that is just not exposed not addressed not even thought about and it's important right you're building these new things and we've seen so many recently oh this oh here's another one oh here's another exploit oh this broken it's cool everyone gets exploited right it doesn't matter oh is that the trend oh yeah yeah cool cool damn i didn't get exploited Oh, shit.
Right. Right. Is it a rite of passage? I don't think it should be. Okay, the other one was privacy. Yeah. How are we cutting corners on privacy? I mean, just, I think the concept of privacy has been so diluted and so, I don't even know what the word is, But almost we've just become so detached from what privacy actually means that for a lot of people, as we know, you know, why do you need privacy if you have nothing to hide? That type of thing. It's like, well, no, that is not what privacy should be about. Privacy is a human right. And you should not be tracked for things that you spend on. And you shouldn't be tracked for everywhere you go.
And you shouldn't, your face shouldn't be scanned by a supermarket checkout. Are you joking? But again, it's that erosion of, and people are so comfortable giving away so much of their stuff at all times, that actually now there's this process of having to claw it back. And for a lot of people, it's like, yeah, but why bother? There's like so much out there already. It'll be fine. But again, getting back into a place where our identity isn't correlated with our money and everything else, so that a simple switch through a backdoor of an application can just cut your access to everything. It's bad.
I'm reminded of, I'm a Clear member, because there was one time I was not going to make my flight, and so I had to sign up for Clear to skip the security line. And all you have to do is go and get your irises scanned, and boom, your name comes up with your birthday and everything. And every time I do that, I'm like, that's going to come back to bite me in the butt one day. It really will. And I love that you spend those seconds to think about that and then like, carry on. And then get on my flight, right? Oh, well. Well, at least I'm not going to miss my flight. Silver lining everywhere. No, but it's that, right?
And we've been so pushed to think, or like, of course you realize that's like probably not okay, but like, what can you do? But it's, we've so been pushed to being comfortable with all of this stuff that the moment like status perfect example the moment you kind of go actually let's build the whole thing as a pseudo anonymous thing that doesn't require a password a phone number of who you are people go this is hard right right this makes sense oh and i can't pull all of my contacts from my address book on my phone oh well this is a bit shit right can you let's go into the full status shill mode can you get can you give the listeners and me the the pitch for status what is it what does it do and why is it good status was obviously one of the first um players in the mobile wallet um space back in 2017 and then they also started building a chat and the idea with it and a web3 browser the idea for me is that now it is perfectly poised that Stack is perfectly poised to create spaces for the Web3 community to actually switch from the centralized tooling that they use to a Web3 native stack, space, app, whatever it is that it's going to become.
So one of the things that I came in back in 2020, again, and we say it's important to have that balance between speed of shipping and doing it properly. I propose this feature of the communities feature that is now being worked on but there's obviously so many implications in that where if you are going to have let's say hundreds of thousands of people on it you want that messaging reliability to be on point which right now it is not okay you want the design to flow right now it does not it needs a refresh it needs like updating it needs a lot of things but even something as simple as pulling from the open c api to show your nfts in your wallet that's technically let's say an infringement on your privacy right because you're like i'm finding things out about you but the point is the user should make that decision right give the option right and then for those who don't care that much just pull right for those who do go and via the browser to access your open scene and it's those little things that actually make a big difference and it's important to make sure that when you do build it like that you do take your sweet time but again urgency is needed there sure so that's that and uh again that connecting us back to like real world uh stuff back in the uh the uh revolution uh what was what was the revolution called?
Draw my memory. So the whole kind of sequence of events in the Eastern Bloc was the Prague. It started with the Prague Spring. Right, right, right. And then all of them kind of... Right. And so the fact that it went off like fireworks, right? Like it was like a... Domino. It was like ready to go. Yeah, yeah. And it just needed this one thing to light the match. What was missing probably was like a messaging network of people who were like... To disseminate. Are you tired of this bullshit? because I'm tired of this bullshit. And if we had a messaging network that was private, people would have been more comfortable communicating their dissent.
Communicating and congregating and being able to coordinate. Yes, coordination technology. Exactly. And it's important. And this is the thing. And again, we're drawing parallels here between, you know, late 80s, early 90s and where we are now. But if you think back then, you had landlines and the phone was probably bugged. 100%. Couldn't trust it. Right? Couldn't trust it. You couldn't say, oh, meet me there. We're going to like throw some shit. Blow up the Russians. Yeah, right. No way. And now you're in the situation where you have all of these like privacy messaging applications, privacy used in the loosest of terms.
Right. That again, if you think of most of them, it has your phone number. Right. You know what your phone number tells about you, your address, who you are, everything. So unless everybody has burner phones, which I doubt that they do, we're not that far off. Okay, it's not as nefarious or as entrenched as it used to be, but maybe it is. That's all I'm saying. And then if you start, and again, this isn't necessarily about, I think that's the other perception, that you will always use these things to do bad things. no just you can have conversations for the drugs right like all of the things that can be bought with u.
s dollars and have been for generations right yeah all all the good stuff but it's that thing that perception and maybe that again has been the narrative that has been uh publicized of oh these guys that's why they're using it for like bad things it's like come on i just want to have a conversation about things that I maybe don't agree with, or I want to have a conversation to be able to coordinate some sort of protest, movement, whatever, something that does not agree with my values and my human rights. There's so many countries in the world where you need people to also be protected. Journalists, because we brought up Russia, because we bring up all of these different countries where journalists are genuinely at risk all the time.
You want to be able to offer a space, a safe space for them to be able to speak to their sources, speak amongst each other, be able to share information, be able to share situations that would put them in a safer place than they are right now. I mean, all of these things, that perception of it's always bad is simplistic. And a lot of it is, dare I say, just it potentially can be dangerous for all of those people who need that protection. Certainly. Victims of abuse. Again, there's endless. Simona, what about the current state of the crypto industry makes you optimistic? I think everything that we, and this is a great segue, because obviously one of the main reasons why I'm at DevConnect, not only to support and speak at the different events, but also I'm curating Shelling Point again.
So Shelling Point Amsterdam is happening on Thursday. And for me, and this is the way I've kind of designed the experience, is for it to genuinely be that antidote to a lot of the events that we're seeing popping up now and that usually tend to happen in a bull market that are all flash, no substance, and kind of gross. From what I've heard it described as a pile of money searching for a soul. Mm-hmm. Yeah. With a hint of dumpster fire. Right. Right. So I think a really, really important thing to keep in mind is that we must protect and elevate the conversations around what we are genuinely changing and where we're going.
And that's what I want Shilling Point to be. That's kind of what we did in Denver a little bit. But this time around, I'm doing, we have almost three hours of workshops just on climate and what Web3 is doing on climate and bringing all of the projects working in that space to have these hands-on workshops, chat about things, have conversations, involve the participants into whatever the solution may be. We also focus a lot, a lot on, again, discussing this governance situation, discussing public goods. How are we moving the needle? How are we progressing things? Discussing decentralized science.
Discussing all of these things that we need to be focusing on because that's the stuff that actually matters. That's the stuff that's going to evolve us from here to there, not a sprinkle of cash and like a party. Parties are great. Don't get me wrong. And the Shelling Point one is going to be amazing. But it's important to have those conversations and delve deep into those conversations. And I'm playing a little bit with the format as well because after so many conferences, I am born to tears of the traditional format. And so what I've asked all of the speakers to do is to do 50-50 in terms of their content.
50% can be you talk about whatever it is you want to talk about. The other half, you involve the audience. I don't care if you do yoga with them. I don't care if it's plain Q&A, do something. Engage. Where it is a collaborative effort. Everything that we're doing, it isn't the work of one person, it's not the work of 10. Everybody has a contribution to make and everybody can and should feel comfortable making that contribution and figuring out what is on that amusement park map. everybody should see the whole map and decide where they want to go and how they want to get there what are you looking in addition to all of your work at shelling point which may be taking up a majority of your time here but what else are you looking to get done here here at dev connect so i think it's it's a lot um of again catching up with a lot of the stewards so because of the work that i do with with gitcoin around um governance there's a lot of the stewards uh particularly in Gitcoin and in the new store council that we created, a lot of them are here in person.
And I think it's important, again, to have that connection because we do have a lot of, let's say, flows that we're putting together, together, right? And we're figuring out, hey, does this work? Is this better? Did we achieve something here that is moving us closer to that flow of the river, to that more structured pattern. And I think in addition to that, of course, there's also, so that's important to have those governance conversations also IRL, right? And then be able to take them to the online realm and be, okay, here's what we've decided. We're going to observe this for a while and then improve it.
But of course, also ETH Amsterdam, I'm a perpetual judge of the IF Global Circuit. And I absolutely love seeing all the new projects. I'm excited every single time, especially after a week like this. How inspired will those people be? What will they take from everything that they've listened to, that they've participated in? What will they take to genuinely create something that is better, that is getting us, that is a stage of evolution? A new Lego. A new Lego. A new Lego. Yes. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. So at Bankless, we often say like, hey, go work for a DAO. And it sounds like you work for at least two DAOs, if not more.
For the people that hear Ryan and I say go work for a DAO from our privileged position of having a centralized company, what is it like to work for a DAO? Do you get compensation for the DAOs that you work for? Is this how you buy groceries? So right now, actually, this is a fortuitous event because I am actually now transitioning into the Gitcoin DAO. where I'm going to get paid by the different work streams within the DAO. So, for instance, because I do the content curation, I did the content curation for Shelling Point, there is a certain amount that will be allocated to me for that work. Okay.
Then the stuff that I do with governance engagement will come from another work stream. Then I also help out with funding public goods. There's a lot of relationships that I have and we pull funds for the grants rounds. That's going to come from another stream. So it really is this very interesting and multifaceted, again, taking that whole thing of streams into a river type dynamic of what is it that you contribute to and what is the level of that contribution. And that's how it flows. and do you feel that the DAOs that you are part of, how would you rate their adeptness as to properly balancing contributions to her?
We're just getting started. Okay. A lot of that needs to be improved. And a lot of that, it's fine that we don't know and we haven't figured it out yet. And again, coming back to that thing of like being comfortable in ambiguity and not feeling like we have to get it right from the beginning because every single time we kind of miss something or we don't do it right and so on, it just enables us to improve on it to do it better to make it a little bit more transparent to make it a little bit more accessible to make it a little bit less taxing nice but like yeah yeah contributions over taxes they're the same thing but one people like word that one word much better than the other um uh what was gonna be my last oh yeah so for the newer newer comers to the crypto space, people that came in 2020 or beyond or more recently.
Oh, welcome. Well, yeah, welcome. Thank you for being here. Thank you for being here. We're so glad you're here. What advice do you have to help these people actually stay in the crypto space? And why should they stay in the crypto space? I think definitely make sure that, and again, man, this is going to be your most analogy laden episode of all time. Oh, I'm not so sure about that. Oh, really? Oh, yeah. We're pretty hot on the analogies at Banquet. So I'll keep going. So I think, again, with that whole idea of the path, right? There is this one that just is established and everything. And when you start off a different path, it's going to be a little bit trickier.
You're going to have some obstacles in the way. You're going to have to be like a little bit more uncomfortable. Like I say, there's like some stinging nettles here and there and whatever. A rug here and there. But just casually laying out in the grass. but um for me it's don't feel or don't give in to feeling overwhelmed or being scared if you read some article about something or if you go into a discord and you feel oh this isn't really my vibe i would say look for those communities that are value aligned with you and what you want this is one of the reasons why particularly with get coin right there's so many people coming in because they are genuinely interested in regenerative stuff public goods solar punk stuff like all of this impact and it's it's that value alignment that really makes that ability to start contributing so much easier than if you go into into uh let's say a discord that you found somewhere that's full of price talk and all of this that you just don't feel like, where do I even start?
What do I, do I even want to be here? And so I think there's that kind of shock sometimes of, oh, I didn't think this was, or you go to one of these events that I mentioned earlier, not the good ones, but the other ones, and you go, oh, is this what crypto is all about? It's not. It's not. and so that exploration I think almost have that explorer mindset go and look behind this go and talk to some other people who are also on this path with you maybe share some maps okay I've got this bit you have that bit maybe let's do things together kernel also is a very very good example of where this can be done right kernel was started by one of the the Gitcoin co-founders and it's a great great journey to take people from that very edge of the path a little bit further it won't take you all the way but it will take you and enable you to meet some people to have that journey to take that journey together so explorer mindset absolutely but like again the curious nice kind not the yes invader kind yeah yeah simona thank you for coming on layer zero thank you so much this has been fun cheers and i will see you all around amsterdam see you in the down.
In the town, of course. Beautiful. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to Bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a Bankless Premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be.
Click the link in the description to become a Bankless premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the Bankless Nation.