We think 2022 is going to be a huge year for Layer 2 scaling solutions. Cross-Chain protocols will be a crucial infrastructure for the great migration to L2s, allowing users to bridge assets across platforms.
Composability and user experience is the glue of modular blockchains, which optimize for decentralization, scaling, and cost. The projects and representatives each present cryptographic solutions for building a web of liquidity across the many suburbs of DeFi, where average users will live and engage.
GUESTS:
Ben Jones - Optimism https://twitter.com/ben_chain?s=20
Hart Lambur - UMA https://twitter.com/hal2001?s=20
Arjun Bhuptani - Connext https://twitter.com/arjunbhuptani?s=20
Chris Whinfrey - Hop Protocol https://twitter.com/WhinfreyChris?s=20
Vaibhav Chellani - MOVR https://twitter.com/vaibhavchellani?s=20
------ ONJUNO | Crypto from your Checking Account! https://bankless.cc/OnJuno
------ SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ ️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
MATCHA | SMART ORDER ROUTING https://bankless.cc/Matcha
SLINGSHOT | LAYER 2 SOCIAL TRADING https://bankless.cc/Slingshot
GEMINI | TURN FIAT INTO CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/Gemini
BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING https://bankless.cc/UniGrants
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey, Banclas Nation. It is panel time today. Panels are some of my favorite discussions we have on Banclas. A great cross section on a specific topic. And today we are talking about bridging bridges, cross-chain bridges. This goes into a theme we've been talking about in 2022, which is the great layer to migration. I think there are a few reasons we're doing this. We'll get into them. But before I do, David, we've got Ben here as a co-host for this topic. Ben, it's great to have you. Can you explain why Ben is joining us for this conversation? Yeah, we did this expert panel for EIP 1559, and that was co-moderated by another technical moderator, Tim Beco.
And that was really, really useful because some of the developers out there just ask questions that I think are really, really smart that I wouldn't have thought to think myself. So Ben, we're bringing you in as a member of the optimism team as somebody who can ask some more technical questions than what Ryan and I would have thought about. And so we're going to, first off before we get into the content, we're going to have just a little bit of a discussion. Some questions that five panelists don't need to ask like what are bridges. But before we get there, Ryan, we have some things that we need to talk about, such as our friends that on Juno, on Juno is our new checking account for the crypto natives.
And so for those that are frustrated that things like USDC or BTC or ETH aren't in your Wells Fargo account, on Juno, it might just be for you. It's a checking account that loves crypto. So inside of on Juno, you can get 4% on your USDC. You can also buy crypto assets with zero fees, and you can also get your paycheck in crypto. So when you get paid by your company, it can go straight into your on Juno account and automatically get converted into into crypto, reducing the amount of time that you need to hold the inflating dollars in your bank account. So big fans of there, anything you want to add to that, Ryan.
David, I've heard that that dollar is inflating way at 7% per year. I was just like as of this morning. So you definitely want to get a crypto native bank account. So you're not using a legacy Wells Fargo bank account that's giving you like 0.01% interest rate. This is a way to do this. They also give you a fantastic card as well. So a debit card. It's metal debit card. Really nice. Really enjoying this. I set up my accounts recently. Excited to get started. So if you're interested in doing that, use the code bankless $50 on your first crypto paycheck. You can do that on Juno dot com. David, you know, I just want to say a few more things about why we are doing this topic on bridges today, because I think it's important.
And there's really three reasons we're doing this. The first reason is there's really no future world in crypto that doesn't require a massive amount of bridges. Okay. No matter what you believe about the future, whether it's going to be a multi chain future with all sorts of different layer ones. Okay, you need bridges, whether this is going to be an Ethereum dominated world with bunch of layer twos. Okay. You also need bridges. So bridges are this nascent infrastructure and a massive opportunity. I think both for users or end investors who are listening to bankless. The second reason something that we've talked about in our modular blockchain thesis is there's really no future for users on layer one on Ethereum layer one.
I want to say that again, because I think that's a hard pill to swallow for a lot of people. There is no future for users on layer one, unless you're some kind of a whale. Okay, the main chain is actually not for users anymore. It's for chains. Okay, this is a layer to roll up centric world. You can get caught up on bankless past episodes. If you want to school yourself on that, including the one we released in early January with Vitalik. And the third reason is this we've simply never done a full episode on bridges. And it's like it's about damn time. Okay, because bridges are going to be a huge topic in 2022.
And I feel like the panel structure is the perfect way to get just a variety of different opinions and ideas and projects to the table to educate us on this subject. So we have a bunch of people on the panel. These are some of the biggest bridging projects. They bring different flavors, different approaches, different trade-offs, different design decisions. But this is a fantastic cross section. A few more housekeeping items for you as usual. If you have a question, a burning question, you want us to ask, this is a live stream. Okay, so go to YouTube, get us up with those questions, use the troll chat box for that.
We'll look at them, we'll filter them. We'll find the best ones. We'll bring that to the panel if it makes sense. And with that, you know what, David, I think we should get to Ben to give us a quick overview on bridges. So what do you want to lead with for like our one-on-one on bridges, David? Yeah, let's just start with the most basic question. Ben, what is a bridge? Because you know, most people think bridges is like the thing that you drive your car over over a river, but not in the world of crypto or across chains, cross altos. Just for at the most basic level, what is a bridge and why do we need them?
Indeed. And thanks for having me on by the way, guys, these are my first words and I feel like I'd be remiss if I didn't start there. So hi, everyone. Okay, what are bridges and why do we need them? Great question. So fundamentally, a bridge and bridging refers to the, at the deepest level, the passage of communications between two different chains. So basically taking information from some authenticated source on one chain, sending it across to be authenticated or received on another chain. So that at the, you know, most fundamental level is usually what it is. What is being communicated? Now, that is most commonly movement of assets, right?
So when you're moving your tokens from one chain to another, you've got to bridge them somehow. So that's, you know, technically, there's actually when you're moving those tokens around a sort of more fundamental thing that you might call bridging, that is like sending a message that says, hey, Alice has just decided to bridge over X amount of funds. This is the ERC 20. This is the amount. This is where the destination is. But, but most importantly, I think for users, this is talking about moving assets between chains. That's the most common form of communication. And what we have a lot of great panelists trying to help facilitate.
So diving into that a little bit more, what is technically going on behind the scenes? And I think this question actually might unpack some different kinds of bridges. There are cryptographic bridges and there are multi-sig bridges. Can you just unpack what technically happens when you bridge an asset and how that is different based on what kind of bridges out there? That's that's great question. So I'll ignore the details. You know, we could obviously get into nuance of kind of the details of those messages that I was talking about, right? Because you have, you know, the messages got to express who is depositing where they're depositing to or it could be withdrawing, right?
Where the where the assets are being bridged to. What is the asset that's being bridged and so on and so forth? I think what I would say is that there is a like what is actually going on when you're bridging is really dependent, honestly, on what bridge you're using and what chains your bridging between and also what chains your bridging between may have an impact on what bridges you can use or what fundamental things that you can do. So in general, I mean to speak to my expertise on on rollups, right? Because that's what we're building with optimism. Generally, generally speaking, we had there is a sort of native bridge that is sort of treated as the canonical secure way to move assets back and forth between the chain.
And so when what's going on behind the scenes, when you use that, which is, for example, you know, maybe the default if you go to like gateway.optimism.io, right? Usually what's happening there is basically on L1, right, on the source chain if you want to generalize, right? Assets are being locked up and they're being locked up and they're emitting some sort of message or in the case of a rollup in event or some sort of storage that says, hey, you know, Alice has locked up 100 eth on L1 and Alice wants to use that eth on L2. Please credit Alice 100 eth on L2 for this money that she locked up on L1.
And the only way to unlock those funds is if you bridge in the opposite direction, which says, hey, somebody who had this funds on L2 decided that they wanted to get it back out on L1. So they're trying to withdraw these assets. Please unlock those assets on L1. So that's usually what you're doing at a sort of native layer. And depending on the construction of the two different chains you're moving between, those might have different properties. So in the case of a rollup, we'd consider this very secure because you have these fault proofs, right, that are basically a dispute layer that are going to keep those funds secure in all cases.
But in general, what you can do is build on top of these chains and build on top of those native bridges, bridges that have different properties that might be more compelling or more economically efficient and make a different set of trade-offs in terms of things like security or user experience or what's going on. So when we talk about bridging, we're talking about locking funds in one place and unlocking them in the other. There's a lot of details that go on there. There's native bridging that can very tightly couple this in a very secure way that forms the basis for roll-ups. And then there are layers of applications that you can build on top that accomplish the same goals with some different sets of assumptions or trade-offs that you might want to make.
So that's sort of what's going on in a bit of a ramble there. Now that makes a ton of sense. And just to reiterate with roll-ups and also with multi-stick bridges going from across L1 to across L2 or across from L1 to L1, there is what you call the canonical bridge. As in ultimately, all things that are built on top of this canonical bridge use and it's the conversation of what we're going to have today is how different implementations can use that canonical bridge in different ways to make things a little bit easier for users. And so there is the slow bridge, the canonical bridge, and then there's like fast bridges that I think most of the users of these L2 cross-chain ecosystems will ultimately use.
And that is who so many of our panelists today are what they are building. And so Ben, we have you from optimism who's building a roll-up which must include a canonical bridge or else how else would people get there. And then we have many of these panelists that we're about to bring on after this who are using your canonical bridge to make different flavors of bridges that make different trade-offs. And so Ben, my last question for you before we turn to our panelists, just what are you excited to hear about from these panelists today? What do you want to learn? What are you interested in hearing about and what should listeners have in their heads as what they should be paying attention to in order to get the most out of this panel?
Most definitely. So I hope you're all ready for some gardening because I want to get into the weeds. So I definitely think we have an incredible lineup of different bridge projects here. And like I said, every bridge project makes different trade-offs, has different designs. And the implications of what the bridge gives you and what you give to use the bridge change. So I think that's going to be an absolutely fascinating thing. And I think for people listening that are trying to use, you know, these bridges, that's incredibly important. It's really important to understand the properties of the system that you're using because there are bridges that may have weaker security assumptions, they may have stronger security assumptions.
There may be ones that are more expensive, there may be ones that are cheaper. So I think that's one thing. And then I think the other part, for me at least that I'm personally excited about is hearing a little bit about the future and sort of the more, you know, next year or two years of bridging. What's that's what that's going to look like? Because now that we're starting to see many of these different chains coming online, we're really starting to see these bridge markets actually play out. And I think it's going to be really fascinating to hear what our panelists are cooking up in the background for the next releases.
That sort of thing. Well, I think with no further ado, we should go and get right into this panel because they have so many things to talk about. We have a list of questions that we're going to get through. So let's go ahead and get our panelists on the scenes right after we talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. Slingshot is a decentralized trading platform that combines the performance and ease of a centralized exchange with the openness and transparency of DeFi. Slingshot aggregates liquidity from all of DeFi in order to find the best price on thousands of crypto assets.
Every token on Slingshot comes with a price chart and trade logs to give you insights into the market's activity in real time. Slingshot is available on Polygon, Arbitrum and Optimism, saving you from the high gas feeds and low transaction speeds of the Ethereum L1. There are no fees to trade on Slingshot and any positive slippage is given to the users. Trading on Slingshot is a social experience. You can even set your chat avatar to your favorite NFT or soon a Slingshot 2099 NFT avatar. Once you bridge your assets to Polygon, Arbitrum or Optimism, go to app.slingshot.finance to trade and use the chat box to share your trades with others and find other tokens to ape into.
The Brave browser is the user first browser for the web3 internet with built-in privacy and ad blocking to keep you in charge of your digital footprint. Inside the Brave browser, you'll find the Brave wallet. The first secure crypto wallet built natively inside of a web3 crypto browser. Web3 is freedom from big tech and wall street, more control and better privacy. But there's a weak point in web3, your crypto wallet. The Brave wallet is different. Brave wallet is built natively inside the Brave browser. No extension required, which gives the Brave wallet an extra level of security versus other wallets.
With the Brave wallet, you can buy, store, send and swap your crypto assets and can even manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps, all from the security of the best privacy browser on the market. Whether you're new to crypto or season pro is time to switch to the Brave wallet. Download Brave at brave.com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. Arbitrum is an Ethereum scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Over 250 projects have already deployed on Arbitrum and Arbitrum's DeFi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly. Arbitrum increases Ethereum speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee.
When interacting with Arbitrum, you can get the performance of a centralized exchange while tapping into Ethereum's level of decentralization and security. If you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users, visit developer.offchainlabs.com to get started building your application on Arbitrum. If you're a user, keep an eye out for your favorite DeFi apps or NFT projects building on Arbitrum. Many of your favorite apps are already live, with many more coming over soon. You can find these apps at portal.arbitrum.1 and you can bridge your assets over to Arbitrum using bridge.
arbitrum.io in order to experience DeFi and NFTs the way it was always meant to be. Fast, cheap, and friction-free. All right, guys. We are back with all of our panelists. We have heart from across protocol, also part of UMA. We have VC from Mover. We have Chris Winfrey from Hot Protocol and we have Arjun from Kenex. You can see that order moving from left to right, but with Arjun at the bottom. Guys, thank you all for being here on this panel and you can all answer it once or I'll say hi at once because we'll also introduce you guys individually. But everyone, thank you for being here. Cheers.
Thanks for having us. Thanks a lot. Thanks for having us. So we're going to start with this very basic question and we're going to go one by one. What is your project? What makes it unique and what's its flavor? Does it have a flavor and let's start with heart from across protocol? Totally. Well, thanks for having me, guys. And yeah, our project is unique because across started as just a demonstration of what we must been building with our optimistic Oracle. And so sidebar here, I actually know Ben from back in 2019, sitting in a conference room, screaming at me about how I need to be more optimistic.
And this actually never be too optimistic. Never be too literally what he was saying. And this is the form that is on the address Oracle. We call an optimistic Oracle that has a really simple concept where we can say, hey, anyone can say asked a question on anything. Anyone can propose and answer that question. And that question is taken as truth if no one disputes it. And so this is an optimistic approach to ask getting data. And we realize we can use this optimistic Oracle to do cross-chain messaging and cross-chain to look at what's happening on other chains. And so that's what we must have been focused on with our optimistic Oracle.
And, you know, about four months ago, the idea came to us that like holy shit, this bridging thing is a big issue. Specifically, the specific question we're looking at is fast withdrawals from optimistic rollups or from rollups to layer one. And that's actually where we're focused. And we realized that we can come up with a design that uses our optimistic Oracle to quickly, securely, and in a capital-efficient way actually move assets back from L2 to L1. And across itself is this side project that the team behind in Microsoft is called Brisk Labs built. We built it very quickly because it's using our Oracle.
And we built it as a demonstration of this optimistic Oracle technology with this specific focus, just focused on L2 to L1. And it turns out it works really well, which gets me really stoked. It's like it's capital-efficient, user-low. We'll get in those details later. But that's our origin story and that's how we got here. Awesome. Thank you, Hart, for that. That was Hart from a cross protocol, again, a product out of UMA. And now we are going to go to VC out of mover. That's M-O-V-R. VC, can you just tell us about mover? How, does it have a flavor? What is it optimized for? What makes it unique in the world of bridges?
Yeah, for sure. So, like, movers, like, probably quite different than, you know, all the flavors here. Like, mover, essentially, we call it like a meta-bridge. Our approach here is like taking the modular approach that we saw with, you know, like scaling L2s, you know, having like different settlement, different DLA. So we are trying to take like a modular approach. We have like a standard bridge-building framework that can be plugged into any sort of bridging mechanism, be it optimistic, be it HTLC-based, be it like a Oracle or something. And that allows us or like, you know, developers to like build these hybrid sort of applications where, you know, like moment between L2s could be trustless.
But if that app also wants to go to somewhere like Solana, they could use like a more, you know, trust minimize solution. So we are trying to like go in this like modular phase where people can build their bridge applications without, you know, kind of thinking of like what the exact bridging mechanism or like, you know, message transmission mechanism would be. So yeah, that's kind of like the unique thing in the direction that we are taking with mover. And, you know, hope to showcase something really soon. Absolutely. Thank you. Thank you, VC. Moving into Chris, Chris from Hop Protocol. Chris tells a little bit about Hop what's its unique feature, what's its flavor of bridge, what's it like?
Sure. And then thanks for having us on the show. And yes, we're building Hop Protocol. We're very optimized for Ethereum's ecosystem and Ethereum scaling solutions. So we actually use Ethereum as a hub to kind of bridge between all the different layer 2s and scaling solutions. And previously, our team was working on a wallet called Ethereum. We actually built Hop just out of pure necessity to get our users onto layer 2, have them stay on layer 2 and just never touch layer 1 at all. And yeah, so it's very optimized for Ethereum's ecosystem. Awesome. And then last but not least, we have Arjun from ConnectS.
Arjun, our ConnectS has been around for a real long time and it started actually as payment channels before it turned into bridges. Arjun, can you tell us about ConnectS and what flavor of bridge it is? What makes it unique? Yeah. So, yeah, as you mentioned, ConnectS has been for Brenner on for a very long time. We actually built the first server like Non-Gestodial, a Stel2 system on Ethereum. It was pretty cool. And partnership with Spanchen in like 2018. Obviously, things have changed quite a bit since then because that was a very simple like micro tipping system using payment channels. ConnectS is an interoperability network that lets you basically transfer funds and then also do some forms of message passing between chains.
So like calling contracts and things like that. We're working towards like more general purpose interoperability. That's completely geneticistic. What we focused on is two things. Trust minimizations. We are extremely, extremely, extremely patch about making sure that like ConnectS has the exact same trust trade-offs as using Ethereum itself or at least as close as possible. And generally speaking, the security model of ConnectS is effectively the same as the security model of the role of itself and then or potentially better in some cases. And then in addition to that, we also have focused a lot on extensibility.
So like the idea there was that we don't quite know yet what the what the right mechanisms are going to be are going to be in the future around like how L2 is really built. And of course, we also have this like world right now where there are Ethereum compatible or even Ethereum friendly chains that are not actually like tied to the base L1. And there may actually be a room for for those to exist as like a lower trust environment or more trusted environments are in the future as well. And the goal with ConnectS is just to make it one simple interface that allows you to connect to all of these different systems allows you to have like a true kind of internet over Ethereum.
So Arjun, maybe you're sticking on this for a moment. Could you tell us a bit more about how we compare these various bridging solutions like sort of the trade-offs of them and also get into if you're thinking about like the perfect bridge, the success criteria for a bridge. What are the KPIs that you really look at? Is it a number of users using this thing? Is it a amount of capital flowing through it? So first, how do we compare these bridges? And secondly, what are the success criteria and sort of KPIs? Yeah. So there's a there's a mental model that we've been using. And of course, all mental models are simplifications, but I think this is a good simplification.
And the mental model is something that we like to call the the interoperability trilema or the bridging trilema, which is similar, similar in concept to the scalability trilema, where all interrupt systems can only really have two or three properties. And those properties are extensibility. So being able to like go to multiple different, you know, L2s and chains very easily and work the exact same way and all of them generalize abilities to the ability to do arbitrary data passing and then trust minimization. And what we've seen is that all bridges kind of like pick end up having to pick for just because they have to end up picking like two out of those three properties.
Everybody that's on this call has selected trust minimization and extensibility. So that's why you're able to like run the system on L2 and then also on on Ethereum and also do it without without, you know, introducing a lot of trust. But the, you know, we've talked early on this call about multi-sick bridges that, you know, multi-sick bridges pick generalize ability and extensibility, but they're obviously more trusted. So yeah, generally we've seen that there's like three overarching flavors of bridges and then of course a lot of other subcategories within them. Can you repeat the second part of your question?
Yeah, so like success criteria for a bridge. What makes a, what makes a bridge successful? Is it a amount of capital? Is it, you know, users? What, what's what are the KPIs? Yeah, this one's a bit more difficult because it's like, it depends on what the bridge is being useful, right? So like, if, if your system like hop, connects, I guess everybody that's on this call, your KPI is going to be like a transaction volume. So the amount of value that is flowing between chains because the vast majority of what you're doing right now is like helping users transfer value from one system one L2 or chain to another.
Whereas, you know, if you, if you once you start moving towards like more generalized data passing where you're allowing people to build like actually across L2 apps that are fully generalized, then it becomes a little fuzzier because it's like, now you're running this like, you know, system on top of, on top of these L2s and like the purpose of that system may not be to move funds. It may be, you know, just to pass arbitrary messages. So in that case, it would probably be something more similar to like Ethereum where it's like, you look at number of transactions that the chain is doing or perhaps even like the amount of fees that are being earned by the by the actual service providers.
So Chris, wondering if you could kind of build on Arjun's definition here. So we're talking about comparing different bridge projects. And yeah, I'm struck by all the time how much surface area for education there is here because now we, we need to do something with with kind of the community and we need to make sure the community understands the difference between like multi-sig trusted bridges and these like more trustless bridges. And it sounds like all of the panelists participants fall in the trustless category. But even within that, that, you know, trustless category, what are the other trade-offs or differentiations you would make between these bridging projects?
How can we compare them? Yeah, that's a great question. So there's definitely kind of a few trade-offs within this trustless design space of bridges. And so I I guess kind of the main types of bridges would be like, you know, I think us and across share very similar properties where we kind of have both passive and active liquidity providers. I know we're going to be talking about that stuff a little bit later. And basically, you know, have these active or yeah, have the active liquidity providers fully verify different chains and facilitate the bridging and then have kind of the passive liquidity providers take on longer-tailed risk of of stuff breaking or challenge windows not being long enough and stuff like that.
But yeah, and then the other side of things is kind of like atomic swap type of bridging and you know, that can be trustless. It can be extended to chains outside of the Ethereum ecosystem, you know, which can't necessarily happen with hot. And you know, this will, you know, you xyz, you do have to wait for kind of like two steps of of finality. So if you thinking about like an optimal bridge, an optimal bridge will be able to do a transfer within just one step of finality. So you wait for the source chain to reach finality and then you see funds at the destination. And so like an atomic swap setup, you do have to kind of wait for for two steps.
So that's kind of one of the trade-offs. But then there are big advantages around capital efficiency and stuff like that that are worth taking a look at. So VC and Mover, you guys touch a whole bunch of different bridging solutions. And I'm trying for a minute to to put us back in the headspace of a typical user who's like, I want to get from here to there, from this chain to that chain. And they're looking at the landscape and they see all of these different bridge solutions. You know, one's a two-lane bridge, one's, you know, a one-lane bridge. One is kind of just like, I don't know, built out of wood.
The other is like a nice suspended bridge. All of these different bridge solutions. How do they evaluate the differences and make a decision on which is the best bridge to take is like safety and security. The primary concern is it how much the toll is, how much it costs. What are the primary concerns from a user's perspective? So from a user's perspective, I would say, you know, it kind of depends a lot on the user profile. So it's like a region, you know, they could prefer a really centralized bridge that allows them to just kind of operate on a single database and just like move things around before the block on the sending side even receives finality.
Because the liquidity provider here can take the risk of the source side kind of rolling back. So like, it definitely kind of depends on like the user. So we've like kind of built out this thing called Funmore, which is like a bridge aggregator that kind of like allows to just like see what all options are there right now. They're, you know, like different security properties. They're different like outputs, gas fees and so on. And you know, kind of judge from there. So like a user, depending on his preference, can just like see what what he prefers to, you know, kind of move his funds from one chain to the next.
So, you know, hard. I'm wondering if you could weigh in on this, this, you know, conversation so far. So is it, it seems like there's so many different bridge solutions. Is it good that the ecosystem has a plurality of different solutions? Or is that, is that more confusing? What types of bridge solutions do you think the ecosystem needs to develop in order to get us where we need to go in this, this great migration from layer one to layer two? Yeah, Ryan, I'll give a controversial answer here. I think, um, which I hate, I think the number of solutions is problematic. And I think the different security properties that have makes it such a show and actually exposes users to a lot of risk that they don't know they're taking.
And so again, this panel, we're all aligned in that we at least are, are closer to the trust minimization side of things or the trustless side of things and we value that. There's other people that are not on this panel that are more generalized and supported with chains that aren't on that. And there's some really scary shit going on out there. The problem in my view is that users are ultimately going to pick a bridge based on price and mostly based on price alone or let's say price and speed. So I think that's going to end up being what we have happened. And that could be very scary if people pick up the cheapest bridge, but that has the worst security assumptions and then something goes wrong.
So I think that there's this, I think what we all got to do as like on this group of people, we got to get to be the cheapest and I think price really matters here. That's kind of my view. And we've got to be cheapest, well being trustless. And that means iterating on a, and then I got a lot to say on that too, but you look like you're right to say. I want to get to, I want, I do want to get to Arjun and some of the others really quick, but, but like, scare us straight for just one second here, hard. Okay. So like when she goes wrong, how, how could it go wrong if we're depending on centralized more trusted solutions for bridging?
Like why is this so bad? What is the iceberg that people don't see in the water? In some ways, I think things big brain might be actually best to answer some of the really scary shit here, but generally speaking, it's just like you don't get your money or the tokens you think you have, you just don't have, right? And like, you know, 100% losses are a bad thing. And then people providing liquidity, like losing out on that are a bad thing. And I think it's a reasonable inspection, a reasonable expectation to think that in 2022, some of the biggest hacks will come from bridges or bad bridging solutions.
That would be like my, my thesis. Ben, what would you have here? Yeah, I mean, well, definitely to hard to hard's main point, like, yeah, what do we need as a community? We need like the thought leaders and people with successful podcasts and Twitter followers to tell those users about the dangers and trade-offs that they're making. So I feel like we're doing the right thing. I would say that bridge security is an interesting problem. There are these trusted bridges, which effectively assume the same security assumptions as side chains, right? So if you want to see a multi-chick bridge, right?
A side chain is kind of like a multi-sig chain. And for some use cases, maybe that is the level of security you want. It's definitely less, but it's interesting. And one thing to add to that is that for the perspective of people that are bridging, there is one difference, which is that the funds that are in transit are the things that are currently at risk of being locked. So it's not like once you bridge your money, the bridge collapsing an hour later could affect you, right? Like I think good bridge designs, even that are centralized and do have trust assumptions, they at least give you that.
So like once I at least tell people when they're bridging, if they want to use a, you know, sketchier, more custodial bridge is literally you should be going to the Twitter immediately before you bridge and look if they went down because realistically if they're going to go down some point in the next week, you might be fine using it right now, right? So you need to understand that risk and you need to be informed. I think the question that I would actually follow up and ask this panel because I really like Todd's comment that it's our responsibility to make the safe bridges and the the trustless bridges as cheap as possible.
I actually am curious though, I think this is at least a bit of an open question on my mind. Do we think that's possible? I think there is some intuitive argument that tells me trustless trusted bridges by making trust assumptions can exercise some capital efficiency that gives them an advantage. So I'm really curious if we think that we can get those bridges as cheap as possible or do we think it's an impossibility result that there's a trust cost tradeoff because I am worried that that's the case. Who wants to take that one first heart? You're just unmuted to go for it. No Chris go ahead. Okay Chris go for it.
Sure, but I think you're right. I think that there are tradeoffs that you can do in a more trusted way that we could just never compete with in terms of capital efficiency. That being said, I do think that there are trustless models, including where we're approaching, where once you scale up the fees just get so so so cheap. And so right now we're bridging across hop you're probably looking at 10 to 20 basis points, more like nine basis points if you're bridging with beef. But as that scales up more and more, the batches get bigger, the fees really go through the floor and it might be that users are willing to stay within this more trustless environment because one or two basis points I just don't really care about.
I just have a question on this to help me understand because this new world hasn't yet come yet, right? It's still being developed. But do you guys think that everyone complains about gas fees today? As they should understand, it's very expensive to transact on layer one. Do you think tomorrow they'll be complaining about bridge fees? The toll to cross from one chain to another is too high and that'll be a pain point for users. Is that the future we're looking at? What do you think, Chris? I personally think we'll only see high bridge fees when there's a huge net flow in just one direction from one chain to a theory, or one chain to another chain.
But when things are pretty balanced, I think as we scale up, these are just going to go through the floor. Ben, you've got to go ahead. No, I was going to say, David, just add to Chris's point, I think that there are designed to Ben's question around just are there trade-offs here with capital efficiency versus trust assumptions? I think there are designs that get more specialized that actually solve for this and even get a little bit in the weeds and compare what we're doing versus what Chris and Hop are doing. We right now, we don't support L2 to L2 transfers, but we are highly capital efficient on L2 to L1 transfers.
Whereas Hop, just on the flip side here, is less capital efficient on L1 L2 transfers. It takes about twice as much money, just from like funding a pool side of things, but they can do L2 to L2 things. And so there's sort of like a trade-off here in our own designs that highlights to me, if you get pretty specialized, you can actually get really capital efficient. And like right now, for context, across-grid bridge, a million bucks, a million USDC, our average fee on that over the last few days is about four basis points. So it's like four cents per hundred dollars to do that. And that's not, Ryan, back to your original point, that's not a cost that goes up with usage.
That's like an interest rate fee. That's like a cost that only, so unlike L1s, whether it costs get more expensive as more usage happens, this isn't exactly the same thing. It's like it's a better capital. Yeah, to like add on what Hard just said, I think we are like kind of missing out on a, you know, on a mechanism for bridges that are like, you know, maintain-based, maintain-burn-based. So like, you know, kind of like imagine a world where there are, let's say, only Z-curl-ups that settle, you know, every five minutes or so. Then we can actually have like, you know, L2 to L1 and L2 to L2, you know, like fast movement of assets, you know, within five minutes or, you know, like adding like L1 latency, like 20 minutes or so without the need of external capital.
So I doubt there's like a, you know, trade-off between trust assumptions and cost. I think there's a trade-off between trust assumptions and latency. I think like that's much, much more likely. And yeah, I heard this first from James Fitzridge, yes. Yeah, just to follow on that, because I think I like completely agree, like I don't think the capital efficiency of the bridge is necessarily directly related to the trust considerations, because like if you think about, you know, systems like any swap or Thorchain, what they're doing is utilizing a multi-sig bridge that is backed by stake and the stake asset is the token.
And so like the capital efficiency of that bridge is not, like while you're normally thinking of the liquidity available in their liquidity pools, the actual capital efficiency of the bridge also includes the stake assets, because that's like the fallback mechanism. The benefit that those bridges have is not that they are more capital efficient, they're not. It's just that because they're using a multi-sig as this like cross-chain Oracle, they are able to have fully passive liquidity provision for like the system. And or they're able to like mint and burn tokens without really any recourse. So, you know, it's almost like you don't necessarily, it's like less of a consideration around how capital efficient it is and more just around how difficult it is to build.
And of course, like it's same as like side chains versus L2s, like L2s will get cheaper than side chains at some point. It's going to take more work to get there, but they will get cheaper. It's just that side chains are very readily available, they're very easy to build and roll out. It's going to take more work to get there, should be the hashtag of Ethereum, I think. Makes sense that all the people with trust minimum is eight minimized bridges are all kind of aligned on that. Ben, I want to tie off this section of our questions with this question. And hopefully that can lead us into the next phase of this panel, but we've we've we've had so many different flavors of bridges here and so many different trade-offs.
And from at the end of the day, if we want crypto to take over the world, like users are just not going to care, they're just going to want to press buttons and have things happen. So, and we've started to see some of this in the decentralized exchange landscape where first there was Uniswap and then there were other decentralized exchanges and now there's more decentralized exchanges. And then there became decentralized exchange aggregators. Some of these aggregators are built right into Metamask thing and also things like like Macha and one inch or just making it a lot easier for people to just route around different liquidity and defy to get what they want.
Is the future of bridging something like this where just an aggregator just says, hey, we'll take care of all of these complexities and trade-offs. Is this a logical conclusion? Can we take a page out of the history of defy to extrapolate into the future bridging? Yeah, I think that what Hart said is probably accurate, which is that users are probably most reactive to price. So, that argument would indicate that bridging aggregation is a very strong potential future. I'm sure that if I Bob agrees with that. What I would say to build on that is that ultimately it's not quite the same from a technical perspective as these exchange aggregators because in the example of a one inch or a Macha, the trust assumptions of the Dexas that are being aggregated are completely homogenous, right?
So at the end of the day, no matter what new bridge is apart me, no matter what new Dex that one inch chooses to integrate next, the fundamental contracts that are a part of the one inch system will enforce that the exchange rate is only held if it was agreed upon by the user and the money came from somewhere. This is not the same as these different bridges because you are relying on more than smart contract security. It depends on what details and load those trade-offs that we just talked about are made, but I do think that it's worth noting that that's a fundamental difference. An exchange aggregator, it's all contracts on L1, it's all 100% composable, all of that stuff.
That's not the case for bridge aggregation. So I think what we'll play out will definitely be dependent on cost. I think it will also be dependent on the same depth of reaction to security trade-offs that users will have actually with using chains as well. So definitely a world that I've imagined is one where in my wallet, I can kind of say how trusted I am, and then maybe the aggregator will only aggregate the top 10% of most trustless bridges or whatever. So I think those questions are just general crypto UX questions that apply to sovereign chains as much as they apply to the bridges between them.
And I hope that as we get more sophisticated software, it'll all disappear in the background, but we'll be able to keep being trustless. Yeah, Ben, I just add to you that I think there are a lot, a lot of parallels to what has happened with Dex's here too, and then there are the differences you pointed out. But parallels, for example, Pierre was Ryan or David, but you say you can kind of start with Uniswap, but they weren't the first. It was like 0x before that, and 0x was like active liquidity provision, which is kind of like connects and some of this other stuff. And then it became really useful in other ways.
The future once it got aggregated, and then like Uniswap V3 was super capital-efficient and this one thing, and Uniswap V3 is winning on the volume things because of their capital efficiency, and then it's getting aggregated up. So if you kind of want another view, I think there is going to be this pattern of these different techniques will have their strengths and weaknesses. There will be a strong focus on capital efficiency and fees, and then somebody will aggregate this altogether. But then you add in the complication like what Ben talked about is that they're not homogenous trust assumptions.
And so here, the role of the aggregator, I think, actually becomes all that more important, because the aggregator is now the gateway that's going to kick which bridge solutions are actually safe and which aren't. That would be my thesis for or my hypothesis throughout this world plays out in the next three years. And I just wanted to add something to Hart what you were saying earlier about like the whether we can achieve kind of the same fees that a trusted bridge can achieve. And I think what you were saying are doing makes some kind of sense. Like basically the trusted bridges can have just purely passive liquidity, and their active, in our cases would be liquidity providers.
The active piece of their bridges are just multi-sakes that don't have any kind of capital requirements. And so like what you were saying Hart, I think the way across is able to kind of achieve like more capital efficiency is just by shortening that challenge window. So you know outside of the passive liquidity, the capital efficiency comes down to like how long do these active liquidity providers need to lock up capital. So with Hop, we have a full day challenge period. And I think with across you've taken it down to three hours. And so like while that is you know eight times shorter and eight times more capital efficient, it could be argued that it is kind of trending into that more trusted territory by having that shorter challenge window.
I do have a response to that but we can come back to you later. So, VC, do you want to add in any thoughts? Yeah, just on the aggregator thing, I think like for dex aggregators we could like you know pretty much black box the whole thing because like you know everything's atomic you know you don't care what dex you are going through until you get you know x amount of dye at the end of the transaction. But kind of bridge aggregators are more like you know this like sky scanner wipe where you need to like you know kind of select do I want to go via Lufthansa or do I want to go via this like you know some new that I've like never heard of flight which is cheaper but I you know kind of trust Lufthansa more.
So it's like going to be there where like users have to like you know make like a manual selection or like what security properties they are opting into. But yeah, we can like kind of abstract all of that out by you know having this like we are like still working on this but having this sort of like security score per bridge that like a aggregator or like you know us as a community can decide on and then people can just be like hey man just give me all the pages with security score four and above and so on. So like I think like you know by looking on some like UX stuff we can make it happen. I should add in Suthas, yeah, go for it.
Yeah, I like this sky scanner analogy a lot and and I mean it's a little dark because basically what you're saying is like the trusted the trusted bridge equivalent is like you know your plane crashes because it's less trusted. But I do I do like the analogy because it's your right that like you know users users will eventually in theory learn to like base their choices on more than just just price. I want to touch on capital efficiency a little bit because I think that's a really important point and I think that's like one of the ways that like we tried to differentiate as well. And you know I one thing to note is that like like capital efficiency is largely ends up being determined by like the constraints around your protocols.
So in the case of hop the capital efficiency comes or like the you know the capital usage comes from the need for pass security on both chains and then the lock up. In the case of across it comes from you know the the shorter lock up and then like the like the money that is kept in reserve in the event that like fraud occurs and just do this happen. And so I think like in the interest of kind of talking a little bit more about capital efficiency I think it's important to remember that like while it's true that capital efficiency is super important it may not actually end up being the case that it results in like the best possible price.
And the reason is that like the overhead that you end up going through to be able to ensure high capital efficiency and all doesn't always end up being valuable. So like a good counter example to this is like you know so like the way that connects works for instance is like you have a set of LPs and then you and then like you basically just directly swap for the LPs. The LPs take no capital lockups, their lockups are like less than two minutes. And so it ends up being a really capital efficiency system. And like the idea behind it is very similar to like RFQ systems or clearing houses. And the problem is in many cases those RFQ systems you know like those RFQ systems didn't actually really work out that well for Dex's.
And the reason is just like the additional overhead and complexity involved in having order books to like match trades with between people and it up costing a lot more money than like using a slightly less capital efficient system like Unispop. Right like Unispop doesn't have didn't have great capital efficiency 80 plus percent of the liquidity was just never used. It was just sitting there. And but at the same time like you because you had this really easy system which is really predictable and nobody had to deal with like on chain order books and nobody had to deal with all this other complexity.
Users ended up saving a lot of like cognitive costs and also end up saving a lot of costs in terms of having to wait for things, having to like post their data upfront on chain. And I think like those things are also pretty important to consider as part of this larger conversation around costs. Guys this has been such an amazing conversation. I'm going to have to listen to this again once we are done here. We're going to come back with a question out of Ben about Vitalik's cross chain commentary, a blog post that he wrote in the past that has predictive components perhaps about the future of a multi L2 world versus a multi L1 world.
I think that's a topic a lot of us want one to unpack. So we're going to come back with that right after we get to some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. When you shop for plane tickets you probably use kayak, Expedia or Google to compare ticket prices. So why would you limit yourself to just one exchange when you trade crypto? When you make your trades you want to make sure you're getting the best possible price on your trade. And that's why you should be using Macha. Macha has smart order routing that splits your trade across all the various liquidity sources in Ethereum.
And it's also operational on polygon, avalanche, finance, smart chain and other chains. Trading on Macha is super easy because it pulls the liquidity from me in a single easy to use platform and allows me to make limit on chain orders so you can set and forget your DeFi trades and they will go through automatically while you're away. So when you're making a trade head over to macha.xyz slash bankless and connect your wallet to start getting the best prices and most liquidity when you trade your crypto assets. The Gemini exchange has been my exchange of choice ever since I got into crypto. I use Gemini to both buy the dips and also manage my regular automatic monthly purchases of my preferred crypto asset.
On Gemini you'll find over 50 different cryptos including many of the top DeFi and Metaverse tokens like Wi-Fi and Axi Infinity. Using Gemini Earn you can earn yield on your various cryptos including 8% on the GUSD stablecoin. Gemini is available in all 50 states and more than 50 countries worldwide. So if you're looking to upgrade your crypto exchange, sign up at Gemini with Gemini.com slash GoBankless and get $15 of Bitcoin after you trade $100 or more within the first 30 days. That's Gemini.com slash GoBankless. Bankless is proud to be sponsored by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure.
Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum that lets you trade any token at the current market price. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. The Uniswap grants program is accepting applications for grants. Do you have something of value that you think you want to contribute to the Uniswap ecosystem? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a unique grant at uniswapgrant.
org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring Bankless. All right, welcome back y'all. Okay, so I wanted to kick off this next question prompted by a post from Vitalik. I think it was in an AMA, but he also tweeted it. By the way, Vitalik's back on Twitter this year. Very exciting. That was talking a lot about some of the trust-related conversations that we've been talking about here. So I'll try to very briefly. It's a longer post that I'll recommend you check it out as listeners if you haven't posted on January 7th, but I think that maybe a bit of background which I would share is that originally when we were thinking about bridging or these cross-chain sort of scenarios, the actual first thing that came up with something called an Atomic Swap.
And this is actually not a direct messaging. There's actually never really a in-crotical way that one chain talks to another, but it was a way that two users with assets on two different chains. Oh my god, adorable doge, Arjun. Two different users on two different chains could agree to a price and trustlessly swap. You know, I mean, what was in the beginning like Bitcoin for Litecoin? I think that's Dan Robinson's classic joke is like what is Litecoin's use case? It's for being the example of the other coin and a cross-chain swap. In any case, that's sort of a different form of swap in some sense than what we're starting to see in more advanced ecosystems.
And it actually is very similar to analogy we were making right before the break, where 0x and ether delta had were dexes that had order books and then we moved to Uniswap which had this more passive form of liquidity. So there's actually a similar thing that's emerged in cross-chain discussions, which is basically whether you, which basically comes down to wrapping one asset on another chain. So before we had these protocols where you could exchange eth for Bitcoin and there were different protocols to do that and you could do that fairly trustlessly between two people. Later on, we realized that there were these UX advantages of having something like Weth, I mean, wrapped Bitcoin, where you would or keep where you would actually take Bitcoin and sort of express it as an ERC20 token on Ethereum.
And Vitalik's kind of argument here is that that's less secure because imagine that you take one asset and one chain and then you wrap it and express in another chain. Then you wrap it and express on another one and you wrap it and express an another one, right? You have all these hops, no relation to hot protocol, you have all these hops of connected wrapping and wrapping and wrapping. And there's a risk that if any step in that wrapping process fails, you wouldn't be able to unwrap. So if any of the chains along the way were able to unwrap, were able to go down, then you risk, you know, the entire sort of chain of wraps.
So this is what the sort of term he used was arguing that the future will be multi-chain, but it won't be cross-chain because this wrapping exposes security. So I'm just really curious. Honestly, I saw a lot of great discussion about this online. I think there were strong points foreign against, but you guys are the cross-chain experts. So I'm curious for your takes. If you guys have any spicy opinions, thoughts, agreed, disagree. I don't know. It's a bit of an open question, but hopefully someone has something interesting to say. Yeah, I think it is super interesting. Like a lot of people were thinking about IDC is kind of like holy grail.
You could do L1s L1 bridging and not have a lot of trust assumptions. My biggest takeaway here was that we kind of think about 51% attacks as these like end-all-deal like worst case scenario. And I think what Vitalik is saying here is that, you know, we shouldn't necessarily optimize for preventing a 51% attack in like all absolute cases. And that, you know, that there are good ways to recover from 51% attacks and that you're only kind of like the only things that are at risk are kind of the in-flight transactions during the 51% attack. And that his point is that once we kind of get into this like cross-chain world, not just a multi-chain world where you're using assets based on one chain on another chain that has, you know, a completely different consensus layer that now all assets are at risk.
And this is much, much less secure than if everything's on the same consensus chain and we can, you know, do our social recovery from a 51% attack. So I thought that was a big insight from myself. Yeah, so we've spent a bunch of time thinking about this as well because, you know, like I said, we're sort of this open system that can be kind of permissionally displayed deployed right now to EVM chains, but it's also possible to plug us into anything. And that definitely brings up a lot of complexity, right? Because it's like what happens if someone is, we sort of inherit all of the security properties of like the chain and tokens that were that are being used in our system.
But like what happens if someone plugs us into like XYZ chain that has zero economic security and that XYZ chain has their own representation of USDC or or die or something. You can, you can basically use that that really, really centralized very, very insecure chain as a way to like spoof US fake USDC or fake die back to Ethereum. Take it from this very low security environment to very high security environment. And it's it's unclear how that should be handled, right? Because like, you know, if you want to get to the to the ideal case where like bridges across chain bridges are like fully trustless and they're permissionless and nobody can really stop them, then how do you stop this from happening?
I think like my my personal view is that there are there are need to like bridge over blue chip assets and like have them exist in rat forms on different chains that does add to security risk. I think we'll probably have to the sad reality is like even even if we like in a closed room environment say that's not the most secure option and that adds a lot of tail end risk it's going to happen. So I almost think that the discussions should more be should more be around like how do you mitigate the risk of these of these potential cases rather than stop them because there really is no way to stop them.
And from a mitigation standpoint, I think there is some really interesting things that you can do using models like connects top. I'm actually not sure about across I would need to think about a little bit more, but like in the case of things like connects and hop you're you have like pricing on a chain change dynamically based on demand for that chain and that pricing can reflect this risk in a in a decently realistic way if if like a black swan event happens. And the other thing is that that pricing can actually adjust like you know we talked earlier about like what happens if everybody is going from one direction to another on a given chain like you know through hop or through connects well at a certain point the price is just going to get incredibly expensive and it's going to become unfeasible for people to continue trying to move more liquidity out.
I think there's some I think you can use those sorts of things as like interesting risk indicators. But yeah go ahead hard. No, Arjun always going to say is like I actually think one way we reduce the bridging of blue chip assets like cross chain like for example take like blue chip defi tokens on Ethereum like how do we reduce the bridging of that cross chain when we make it such that there's no need to bridge it to another chain which we do by making L2s really fucking awesome right to my language. So I actually kind of put this all back on Ben where like music to my ears baby. But I'm actually dead serious like to me it's never really made sense to take like an Ethereum based asset and put it on Solana unless Ethereum's ecosystem is so expensive to use there's like you can't do the thing you want to do on Ethereum.
And that's not maybe always true maybe you want to use it it's like collateral to lend in the Solana ecosystem or something but I generally speaking think that if like L2s are really really good the need to like leave the Ethereum bubble goes down. I could it would be a whole separate separate discussion if I start rambling about how L2s need to address the real concerns that Solana poses that Ethereum tries to stick in its head its head in the stand about sometimes but we'll save that for another day. Well I actually have a follow up on this because so one of the implications I think of this post so Vitalik used this this term zones of sovereignty to sort of define kind of the difference like for people who aren't tracking so on Ethereum if you have an ERC 20 on Ethereum and you put that on a layer two chain you inherit basically the asset inherits the economic security of layer one but when you bridge that ERC 20 that's token from Ethereum to say Solana or you know Tezos or avalanche or something like that then then you lose those security properties and it actually becomes a different asset right it's like an asset that you're has different trust assumptions and you can't you don't have the same security guarantees that it's actually backed by the things you think it's backed okay and so the implication of this I think everyone going into 2022 from a macro perspective and that's why I want to throw this question the bridging panel but from a macro perspective investors users everyone is looking at like two different paths to the world one is this multi chain path and by multi chain I'm not talking about the way the talix using it but multi chain meaning like there's Ethereum and then there's all sorts of other L ones and it's this universe kind of like the cosmos vision the IBC type vision of things that's sort of the multi chain path and then there's another path where you have Ethereum as a settlement layer and it is kind of the dominant settlement chain and then you have a bunch of layer two and it's kind of an Ethereum ecosystem and that's sort of the dominant player I think investors users everyone is trying to figure out what's going to happen is it going to be a like multi chain universe or B is it going to be layer two Ethereum ecosystem dominated universe I'm wondering if this the zones of sovereignty thing provides a clue here like if bridging is actually the clue here because it strikes me if you have a multi chain world you have a completely different set of trust assumptions here and it might actually break down when we start trying to bridge assets from chain to chain to chain I don't know if anyone on the panel has a thought on that but like it's something that has consumed me very much you like in 2021 and going into 2022 how do you think bridges play into that just throughout margin maybe you have a point on this yeah so there's like there's sort of like an objectively ideal solution and then there's like what's probably going to happen because the world is messy and people hate standards the objectively ideal solution is always going to be to have one settlement layer right because like the whole point of this ecosystem the whole point of the work that we're doing here is to move towards a world where you have the maximum amount of crypto economic security associated with this like base layer and so it makes sense to concentrate all of that into one chain because that provides the best kind of long-term economic guarantees against what could potentially and probably will potentially one day be like sovereign level state level actors attacking chain in that vision yes you know data availability shards altos that is that is the best world because what you're saying there is like everybody is leveraging ethereum scripted economic security no one else needs to think about bootstrapping a validator setting more because bootstrapping validator set is hard and it's expensive and in you know it fragments liquidity and instead you just focus on like execution and other other pieces built on top unfortunately as I mentioned people hate standards like even even in a non-bag holder environment like the internet itself like is made up of a ton of protocols and of course we know that you know we know about TCP IP we know HTTP like we know these things have been generally adopted at centers but also there are a ton of other protocols that people don't know about that that get used all the time and like we actually have to build adapters to all of them it's it's a huge mess and in those cases like none of these were you know like community funded or VC backed companies trying to issue a token and create their own communities like that those nobody had any any stake in the game except for ego and so I think like the reality is that you know we'll probably have some combination of the two we'll probably have this like ethereum universe and then we'll also probably have a salana universe and a cosmos universe and a you know XYZ polka dot universe and and they'll sort of follow this like long tail pattern and we'll have to kind of figure out how how it should work once we get there I totally agree with the kind of power lot distribution like you know having kind of probably ethereum captured the majority of high value use cases just because it is optimized for decentralization and security and then you know I do think we'll see other chains that you know where use cases you know might not make sense on ethereum you know even if we can get layer two's to be like the theoretical maximum efficiency there's always going to be use cases where you need you know sub one cent transaction fees sub one basis point transaction fees and you know I think it's you know while it's important that we like capture as much as we possibly can and drive those fees as low as we possibly can on ethereum I think it's also important to kind of recognize that there's use cases that that you know should be very interoperable and close with ethereum where users can like go on another chain and play a game where they make a hundred transactions and don't have to pay you know a thousand dollars to play that game and then and then can always retreat back to safety to ethereum and and so like chains like like polygon and stuff like that I think have kind of provided that more of like a playground where where users can you know keep their secure funds on say optimism where where they know that they have this this like absolute strong like I can keep my life savings here you know maybe one day maybe today and then they can also take you know say like a hundred bucks or the amount of money you keep in your your wallet your actual wallet and go go play games and and and then come back to safety all right guys I think we're going to start to wrap up some of the the questions here Ben do you have any last questions that you want to hear from our panelists before we come to our closing questions oh man I mean I I do it's like a talk with hours and do talk with hours for hours with all these folks I think none without opening up a big new thread of discussion that maybe we don't have time for I think the name of this game though was trade-offs and that would be what all my questions are about and if there's one takeaway for the the audience is trade-offs always and not just about L2s but about all things crypto but then also about all things life just trade-offs all the way down there's one last question that heart brought up during the break and it's about how are bridges going to be used and I think that heart you might even be able to ask this question yourself better to yourself so can you go ahead and ask that question and then also answer it share the ask my answer my own question Ben yeah no David my point here is I think it's useful to have a thesis for how we think this bridge usage is going to get played out and I actually really want to hear other people's opinions and perspectives um and and I want to be opinionated here so in my opinion our goal as kind of a theorem maximized ish right is we want people to stop using l1 I think Ryan made this point earlier like user stop using l1 get to l2 and our goal from a consumer perspective is to have people bridge in one direction and not go back to later one that's like something that is good for the Ethereum ecosystem so then my question actually becomes like question asked myself is like who actually does the bridge in the other direction like maybe the whole optimistic roll-up withdrawal window isn't a problem if nobody's moving back to l1 and I think actually for the vast majority of users they're not going to be moving back to l1 that's the whole point the people that will be moving back to l1 though are arbitrage errors and I think that's where this real use case comes from so you're going to have people that are like seeing price differentials on the uniswaft deployment on optimism versus the uniswaft deployment on Ethereum and you have arbitrage errors that need to move back need to balance these trades across assets and that's the thing they got to do so from a process perspective just to share insights on how what we're thinking here we're trying to be really hyper efficient and really really low cost for big transfers from l2 to l1 specifically to help arbitrage errors do that job because I think that the core user is going to go in the direction to l2 and not move back and that's that's I'm kind of want to know what people think of that there is then one other like sidebar which is what about going l2 to l2 and that's something that like we don't do right now and that I think is a strong use case where then you could have consumers that are unoptimism but one user of a tremor whatever else and so there's a bridge case there but I think I'm talking too much so a question to the panel how do you think people will use help like how would you think people use bridges what do you think the future is and like what are your produce there yeah I'll probably add at some points here so like most likely arbitrages are you know like not not going to be you know like heavy bridge users to like you know capture like there's like arbitrage opportunities because like at the minimal we have to like wait for a finality on the source side you know so like at the minimal it's like you know going to be two seconds five seconds and arbitrage opportunities are lost in like like you know like a minute of milliseconds right so it's like most likely going to be arbitrages like having two different liquidity pools and you know kind of you using and like their own like you know settle like system and kind of you know you using their own liquidity pools between these two you know chains and rebalancing via layer one yeah and apart from like maybe like the users won't directly go to layer ones but I think like conditional transfer protocols or repairman protocols like hop so like you know other like bridges could you know just like batch all of these user transactions and you know just like do a single on chain transactions for it so you know most likely will be rebalancing across the you know different arbitrage pools across you know different chains and like you know other the bridging protocols and so on but yeah most likely hopefully you know things remain on on the L2 yeah like that that was kind of our approach was really you know optimizing for layer two to layer two stuff this you know like you're saying hard you know a majority of users are kind of moving to layer two right now and then not necessarily moving back and and what we're seeing is this like really diverse and rich set of layer two solutions kind of come up and so you know like obviously optimism and arbitrum are big ones and then the the ZK rollups are starting to get traction but you know I kind of expect the ZK rollups maybe to have slower start just because a lot of them are requiring a custom language or something like that but there still might be use cases where user wants to jump over to that chain they want to use those applications and they need to be able to kind of move across this this rich layer two ecosystem very fluidly so you know I kind of see that as how users are using these bridges to go from one app to the next depending on what what underlying L2 solutions it's built on.
The ability to fluidly move from one layer to to another layer to feels like table stakes feels like a necessity this is core infrastructure if we're going to get to where we started this panel with the episode with is the great migration to to L2 from L1 to L2 something that is in process now happening in 2022 but I'm wondering as we close with this last question from the perspective of the the bridging projects themselves how long do you think this great migration is going to take like how long until we are fully off layer one into this glorious layer two world the bridges are in place people you know new users onboard onto layer two they use bridges that you know hop from place to place and and do their work that way and they never they never even need to touch layer one that is the destination but how long is it going to take to get there Chris what do you think yeah I kind of think it's going to be slow and then all at once you know what one thing we're really looking out for are token incentives and so like Lido Cohen from from our team has been working on a proposal with Uniswap to incentivize you know more liquidity on layer twos and then there's this this really kind of I don't know if it's called like a if you call it a network effect but it's kind of as more people move to layer twos the more the layer twos take up the block space on layer one driving the cost up forcing more people to then move on to layer twos and then it kind of has this spy wheel effect where now all of a sudden you can't really afford to transact on layer one because the layer twos are taking up all of the block space so you have to move Arjun what do you think timeline how long to scrape migration going to take so first of all I just want to say like there it is fully 100% possible to use Ethereum right now without ever touching a lot like that is already available to everybody we have users in our ecosystem for some reason and I don't know exactly how this happened but a lot of the users that enter into our ecosystem fresh fresh users to crypto who have never really even used metamask before and we end up having a debug a lot of that which is sometimes kind of challenging but what we're seeing though is that like a lot of these people are are kind of jumping headfirst into you know the Ethereum L2 ecosystem and some of the Ethereum friendly side chains and they are never touching Ethereum because they're completely priced out and they're only interacting with L2 applications and that's created this like massive L2 applications that don't never really exist on Ethereum would never really have deployed on Ethereum but they're just they're just L2 native um I think like you know as Chris mentioned it's like a flywheel effect like it's going to happen and like it's like sort of every hockey stick where you know you sort of see this kind of like growing like this and then all of a sudden it shoots up because like the the exponential effects just kind of kick in more and more and we're rapidly approaching that I would say for me the biggest barrier is really just going to be like token incentives really big one and then you know it'll it'll be the like the the things that drive down the cost of roll up via like bigger batching so you know our return Nitro um I think optimism you guys might have just on this uh but basically things that push down those gas costs even further VC what would you add to this timeline what do you think timelands are definitely hard you know being a dev like I I have extremely bad estimations so like you know definitely wouldn't comment on that but yeah like the graph definitely agree it's it's like going to be hockey stick growth whenever it happens there is there's still a lot of work to do as you know kind of uh uh got to before uh so yeah here's to just like you know hoping it it happens sooner than later uh and you know I think everyone here is is like you know 100% confident that it's going to happen and we are all here you know just like trying to empower that thing when it would have that whenever it happens.
All right anything to add here. Yeah my very cheeky answer is um tell me when uh optimism and arbitration beliefs are token and I'll tell you when that hockey stick. Well this is uh maybe we should end with Ben then uh you know final thoughts on this discussion then and uh maybe your perspective on timeline too. I mean we set up the hashtag guys we set up the hashtag guys it's l22 baby you know you know it's common no I feel like similarly to VC I've got an enough trouble for uh for trying to predict time lots over the years I think that definitely the most important point and I'm really interested to hear you Arjun having this from a bridge perspective as well because I mostly give bridging is being like an advanced thing so it's really exciting to hear that you are getting like new crypto users using it for once worth fiat on and off ramps are live on optimism today and I think other L2s as well so like it already is the case totally that you can move straight into L2 so I am hoping and I would think I would make that prediction that that is going to drive usage and depending on what happens with the fee markets as well on L1 I think that will just naturally continue to drive that usage so I think big things are coming this year VC is right we should never we should never put timelines on things but all the pieces seem to be in place the bridging is super nice you can buy the eth on l2 directly all the pieces are really coming together you know the jigsaw is almost complete l22 we are building that jigsaw panelists thank you so much for the work that you're doing in the bridging infrastructure we've learned a ton thanks for joining us today thanks for having us guys thanks guys thanks guys thanks thanks thanks you guys Bankless Nation the great migration has begun it's gonna start slowly at first but it is headed towards hockey stick growth that is the prediction of the panelists I heard at least three of the mentioned tokens as well and I would just echo these are my words not the panelists you should start using these systems you should start using everything in crypto because you never know how users are going to be rewarded in the future risk and disclaimers guys let's close on this Of course, crypto is risky, bridging is risky too.
Ethereum is risky, everything we do in this space comes with some degree or another of risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier, it's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence. We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience.
You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings and weekly rollups, where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content. Thanks everyone for watching.