NYSE and Securitize are laying the rails to bring real, issuer-backed securities onchain.
Michael Blaugrund of NYSE and Carlos Domingo of Securitize break down how blockchain-native equities could work in practice: transfer agents, tokenized issuance, interoperable trading infrastructure, 24/7 markets, and what it will take for public stocks to move from legacy rails to crypto rails. T
They also explore how onchain equities could unlock faster settlement, better shareholder utility, and new DeFi use cases without sacrificing regulatory compliance.
------
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------
🔮POLYMARKET | #1 PREDICTION MARKET
https://bankless.cc/polymarket-podcast
🪐GALAXYONE | SOLANA STAKING
🦊 METAMASK | DOWNLOAD NOW
https://go.metamask.io/BL-Pod-Download
🏅BITGET TRADFI | TRADE GOLD WITH USDT
🎯THE DEFI REPORT | ONCHAIN INSIGHTS
https://thedefireport.io/bankless
🐇MEGAETH | 1ST REAL-TIME BLOCKCHAIN
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
0:52 NYSE x Securitize Partnership
4:57 Digital Transfer Agent
8:39 Blockchain Infrastructure
11:07 NYSE Alternative Trading System
17:01 Every NYSE Asset?
22:30 Portability & KYC
33:38 RWA Decentralization Debate
38:47 New NYSE Paradigm
44:46 24/7 365 Markets
48:03 Clarity Act
52:21 Issuer Choice
57:08 Tokenized Securities vs Perpetuals
1:00:24 Securitize Going Public
1:03:20 When Launch
1:04:04 Closing & Disclaimers
------
RESOURCES
Carlos Domingo
Michael Blaugrund
Securitize
RWA Decentralization Debate
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-h-PeUOvDw
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
the tokenized treasury space that the middle place, which is still the largest asset, I think it's worth 2.3 billion or something now, it was like 300 million two years ago, and now it's 11 billion. I don't think any part of crypto has grown that fast. So it kind of fills that way for tokenization that we're at the end of the beginning. Now the beginning has happened, now we need to get into the real growth because the space is so massive as we discussed before just taking 1% or 2% of the stocks on chain doubles the size of crypto, so that the fact that we have tens of billions of dollars still feels like very, very early days.
Bankless Nation, I'm here with Carlos Domingo from Securitize and Michael Bloggerand from the New York Stock Exchange. Carlos, welcome back to Bankless and Michael, welcome to Bankless for the first time. There was an announcement out of both of your guys' neck of the woods from the Securitize and New York Stock Exchange, neck of the woods, that last week about a partnership between your guys' two companies, about getting tokens, securities tokenized on public blockchains. Now I want to drill down into the details of that announcement because I just want to learn a little bit more about what this partnership means, how it works, and like some of the net products are at the end of it, and so we're going to go line by line.
I just want to start reading off some of the first lines in this announcement just because I want to get down to the actual nuances of it all. The first line is Securitize is named as the first digital transfer agent for the New York Stock Exchange. What is a digital transfer agent? What role does that do in the whole world of securities and trading them and all that kind of stuff? I guess I can take that one since it was Securitize. I turn every publicly traded company or every TF, anything that trades on a nationalist change, has a transfer agent which is responsible for keeping the books and records of who holds the securities, which in publicly traded companies, most of the only thing you see is DTCC because all the shares are under DTCC.
Most people don't realize that when you hold shares on Roryhood, you actually don't own the shares. The shares are under DTCC. It is the past story, but in any case, you need a transfer agent. If you wanted to issue tokens outside of a current market structure or on a blockchain that represents the same instrument, the same equity, the same QC, the same rights, sporting rights, the speed, the data etc. The natural entity to do that is the transfer agent. Securitize is a transfer agent since 2019. We refer to us as digital in the sense that we use for our ledger technology, our public blockchain, as opposed to, let's say, more traditional database technology that all the transfer agents use, and all our procedures are all digital.
We don't do anything with share certificates or paper certificates or all the type of non-digital activities. We have been accepted by the New York search teams for the new venue, which I guess is the next thing that we need to explain what it is to be able to be in work with public blockchain companies. We should talk ends that represents, you know, native representation of equity, and then you know, those tokens will trade on the New York store as changed digital venue. Why does managing investments still mean juggling multiple apps, accounts, and currencies? Crypto trades around the clock, stocks, ETFs, and commodities are moving on chain.
Yet most platforms still keep everything split apart, turning diversification into unnecessary friction. BitGaT is delivering a different kind of experience with its universal exchange. One platform where users can access crypto, tokenized stocks, ETFs, and other assets in the same place, all traded directly using USDT. No constant transfers, no currency conversions, just a single account built for how markets actually move today. As the line between crypto and traditional finance continues to blur, BitGaT's goal is straightforward. Make trading and investing simpler, not more complicated than it needs to be, learned by clicking in the link in the show notes.
This is not investment advice. If you're already holding soul, here's something you may want to pay attention to. Galaxy 1 just launched Solana Staking, and you can earn up to an estimated 6.5% in variable staking rewards on your soul, with no platform commission fee charged throughout December 31st, 2026. While many other platforms charge up to 35% commission fees on staking rewards, Galaxy 1 offers you 0% platform commission through December 31st. Other fees may apply, you should see the terms. This is powered by Galaxy Digital's own Validator infrastructure, one of the largest Solana Validator operations in the world, and now available to individual investors directly within the Galaxy 1 platform.
Once you stake, rewards accrue and compound automatically, no active management needed. You can track everything in one place, including balances, rewards, and tax reporting through tax bit. Getting started straight forward, you can buy soul directly in the app or transfer it in. If you want to put your soul to work, you can now start staking on Galaxy 1 today. Click the link in the show notes to learn more and get started, not investment advice. As I understand it, what you just said is the digital is more of just a word that you guys added. There's no such thing as a digital transfer agent.
No, transfer agent, but transfer agents. In the industry in general refers to blockchain based transfer agents or digital transfer agents. And Carlos, just to understand, because we don't have this concept with our crypto native assets, of course, there's no transfer agent. What data does the transfer agent have? Is that sort of like an ownership cap table of who owns what? Well, basically, we are the transfer agent for middle of BlackRock and for other products. So it's basically the regulated S&S-C register entity, and that basically manages the securities on behalf of an issuer. So you basically issue securities, you control transfers to update the cap table, you pay dividends, you do conduct votes.
If you need to, you do a sort of asset servicing if there is any type of, I don't know, somebody needs to move their shares or somebody lost access to their shares. In the case of blockchain, somebody lost access to private keys, and you need to burn and reissue like all that work is what a transfer agent does. Okay, and every security has to have a transfer agent. It's in the regulations. And I guess it moving this to kind of particular security. Not every security, okay. No securities is mandatory. Okay. Registered securities, public utility securities are mandatory. Reggae plus security is mandatory.
Most funds is not private funds. It's not mandatory, but asset managers tend to use it because it's safer to use an entity to do that. But for instance, they, a private company, like, let's say, you know, the shares of Bangladesh, you can just keep them in Karta and you don't have a transfer agent, you just have like a technology to do it, but not an entity that controls the capital of who wants shares in Bangladesh. I'm assuming you have a company called Bangladesh somewhere. Does that mean that I'll publicly traded companies or at least the vast, vast majority of publicly traded companies have a transfer agent?
You can't go public without a transfer agent. Okay. Can't go. Okay. And so if we want the, so there are tokenized securities on chain. There are a bunch of different ways to do this. One of the ways out there is like condos model, which it's not a true native security. It's not a equity. Yeah, it's, yeah, exactly. And so what we're, what we're talking about with a digital transfer agent is bringing the word native. So the token itself is the equity. It is on a representation of the equity. It is on a, an IOU of the equity. It is the equity and making it the equity is because of the transfer agent.
The correct, the, the ondo and other companies model, the problem that does have, besides that they block the US because the way they do it, probably not regulatory compliance here, et cetera. But it's also that every tokenized equity, which, because it doesn't represent the actual equity, you end up having five different versions of the, of the same thing, which none of them is the real equity. Like you can go to rw.exe, you can see the six different versions of tokenized coin, which none of them is actually equity on Coinbase. They're all different derivatives issue from different jurisdictions with different counterpartities towards the company that is issuing different rights.
Some of them, if you're voting rights, some of the don'ts, some of them accrued dividends in their own way, some others in another. They don't track splits. Like I think on the other problem recently, where one of the shares in the public markets didn't split and they didn't do the split and he was trading at five times, different price, et cetera. So I think that introduced a lot of fragmentation and obviously creates issues for market making, for, you know, investor discursures and investor risks of taking counterpartities. This is not, this is just basically like buying a share through Rome, you couldn't, but then you get it on your wallet and tokenized for them.
Securitized is named as the first digital transfer agent, eligible to mint blockchain native securities. I think we kind of just did all of that. This is truly a native to the blockchain securities on IOU. It is that security. But the question I have for you is Carlos is on which blockchains is this chain agnostic? Are there specific chains under consideration? How are they selected? Blockchains can mean a lot of different things. And so like talk to me about that nuance. From our tokenization point of view, and I let Michael answer the question about where the ATS, the trading platform sits, but we, we support most of the major public blockchains, obviously Ethereum, but we also support most of the L2s, we support Avalanche, we support Solana, of course, we support Aptos, etc.
So we will, we will be able to tokenize once we work with Azure in any of the public chains, and then being able to move tokens across chains, it required to be able to then deposit them on the trading platform for trading. So your chain agnostic, but then who determines on which chain does the asset go? Typically we work with the Azure. The Azure chooses that. I agree on that, because we are a service provider, right? Like we're not going to impose things, we obviously have the bill, which change to use. As you guys know, BlackRock launch on Ethereum first, and it was only on Ethereum for a period of time.
And then after that, they started like going to other chains. We do a lot of also kind of due diligence on the chains to make sure they're sufficiently decentralized. They have, you know, they have a hard downtime and things like that. So, but ultimately they assured is their security, right? Like we don't do things without the Azure permission as opposed to other tokenization modes out there. Okay, so there's a preference on the issuer and the issuer can just choose based off of whatever their particular preferences are. And quickly the issuer here, who is issuer? Is that the company with the stock?
That's the company of the stock. So every issuer could have a different preference around this, right? Like Exxon might have a different preference versus like Bank of America in terms of where their stocks might be issued. That's cool. Could you do multiple places? You could just issue them. And yeah, there's no restraint here. There's no restriction for us. We can either do like we do on the on the case of BlackRock every ledger, let's say every public blockchain is treated as a separate share class of the same fund, or we can just aggregate tokens across multiple chains. And the cap table is found across different ledgers.
And we provide transparency for the issuer with respect to that. Okay, let's get into the third part of this line that we're breaking down bit by bit. Okay, starting from the beginning, securitized name is the first digital transfer agent, eligible to mint blockchain native securities on the upcoming New York Stock Exchange affiliated tokenized security platform. Michael, this is where I'm tapping you in. What is this? What is the digital trading platform? What would tell us about what that what that's coming down the pipe? Yeah, happy to glad to finally get in the game. So we're launching a new trading platform.
It'll be a ATS that stands for an alternative trading system. That will be adjacent to the existing traditional exchanges that will trade tokenized equities versus stablecoins will support what I often describe as kind of crypto native user experiences. So things like 24 seven operations, things like instant atomic settlement, which are vastly different than the traditional exchange operations and rails. But we're going to conform with most of the significant market structure conventions of the SEC, thin rob and the broker dealer subscribers that'll be participating on this platform. So it's going to use on chain settlement, but off chain matching.
So it'll be using the NYSE's existing matching technology, market data technology, order entry technology, allowing for the community, broker dealers who already trade on exchanges to have a very low friction glide path into supporting the on chain settlement that we believe a lot of retail investors will be excited to take advantage of. So with this platform and the tokenized securities that go on to the ATS, the alternative trading system, is it its own blockchain or is it aggregating the security tokens issue by secure ties that are issued on Solana, Ethereum, all the public blockchains? Is it aggregating those or is it its own thing?
It talks me a little bit about the back ended infrastructure. Great question. So the way to think about our system is we will run a private permissioned on chain core ledger that's going to allow for inventory to be brought in or brought away from the platform from either digital transfer agents like secure ties or from DTC, which is the traditional book entry depository that will allow for tokenization upon request for previously issued securities. In both cases, securities are tokenized either natively minted like Carlos describing or converted. They're moved into the custody of the broker dealer operating our ATS and then they're available for pre-funded trading and instant settlement versus stable coins when they're sold.
Okay. I'm still looking for a little bit of clarity on where those assets actually live. That question makes sense. So in the example of a digital native issue token let's say Carlos works with an issuer and they decide that they're going to issue natively on Ethereum. Carlos through his broker dealer can move those from that Ethereum wallet into a broker dealer wallet in our infrastructure. I see. We will then make that available on our RIS systems and our trading platform and it can instantly be sold on behalf of that client. Okay. And so with the trading platform, the digital trading platform that you guys, I don't know if this was the first time that this was announced, but in this announcement with you guys and securities, you named this digital NYSE affiliated tokenized securities platform, the ATS we talked about.
What I'm hearing is an aggregator of tokenized securities on Ethereum, tokenized securities on any blockchain, any layer two that you guys choose to integrate. Those tokenized securities will be sent to the wallet of a broker dealer and then that is the person, which is matching the stratify stack of equities that then all of that gets pointed to the ATS. And so the tokens are on chain. They're on the public blockchains, which is what I'm kind of excited about. And then for this NYSE affiliated securities trading platform, it is done through you send the assets to a broker dealer and then those get deposited into your account and you can go and make trades like that.
Is that right? Yeah, I think you put it well. We haven't used the word aggregator before. I think that's a fair word to use. The way we've described it is that we're going to have fairly broad interoperability with a number of different blockchains for settlement purposes, having EVM compatibility to have broad access to wallet infrastructure and developer kind of community applications is important for us. But we know we're going to need to support a range of different solutions as well as a range of different genus ad compliance stablecoins for funding purposes as well. So interoperability will be a critical component of the solution.
Michael, the newer stock exchange, you guys have over 2400 assets. Will all of these assets be available at some point? Or is this going to have to be sort of an issue or buy issue or a conversation? I think it's going to be a dual track process. They're going to be crypto forward, tech forward companies that are very interested in being early amongst the native issuers. Carlos mentioned BlackRock. That's a great example of a company that actually wanted to take a fund and make it digital native to try to position it for access and utility amongst the crypto native investor community. They're a bunch of both corporate and ETF issuers who want to be among that cohort.
At the same time, there are a bunch of traditional companies that may or may not decide that they want to actively engage in tokenization. Whether they choose to or not, the reality is that the DTC, which is the central securities depository for US equities, has announced that they plan to make all of their securities available for tokenization conversion over time. They're starting with the Russell 1000, so the 1000 securities that are in that index, plus a number of other ETFs. Eventually, I didn't anticipate that all NYSE listed stocks, all stocks listed on other exchanges as well will be available or tokenized trading.
But I think at the Vanguard, you're going to have companies like those that are working with Carlos and prospects that haven't yet come to market that are interested in going public as tokens, really leading the charge. How long do you think that'll take to play out until the point at which we have basically all publicly traded companies, or close to all 80% say, all of them available on chain as well? So I think there are more problems to solve than just making the tokens available. There's a lot of complexity in managing the recreation of all of the trad-fi infrastructure, the investor protections, the market structure conventions that issuers have come to expect from that the SEC requires under the law.
So I think it will probably be the case that all US equities could be converted into tokens within a couple of years. But I think your question is probably when will tokenized trading become ubiquitous? And I think that's going to take longer because it's going to require not just minting tokens, but then creating the right infrastructure that those tokens have outstanding utility and can operate with an efficiency that's as excellent as the one that exists in the current market structure. So it's companies like Securitized, like NYSE that are trying to build these platforms today to enable to facilitate that migration over the next, let's call it three to five years.
I just want to give you some metrics so you understand even if not everything moves, how big this could become very quickly. So first I think a good parallelism is what happens with retail participation on IPOs because that was not available to retail people and you started with Robinhood five years six years ago and then every single IPO now has a retail transfer. And at the beginning it was some companies only the most tech forward ones like my convention that had that allocation and it was only Robinhood but then you got Sophia and then you got E-trade etc. And then now you have a SpaceX which is apparently doing a 40 billion IPO that is saying that 30% will be retail which is massive.
So I think that the token is strange for IPOs and for trading for public equities will start small and then it will grow over time but given that New York Stock Exchange only has 40 I think 44 trillion in market cap and the whole market if you add the competitors is like 100 trillion even if it's just like let's say a 1% or a 2% you're looking at 2 trillion which is probably bigger it's like the same size of the entire crypto market today right because this is like the largest you know asset class out there and the mostly create and therefore the most suitable to put it on blockchain rates and make it even more efficient is an asset class that is very difficult to to do things with it because it's all in this way you know kind of rigid infrastructure and market structure etc.
that you know you can go and invest in Nvidia 5 years ago and today you've made a few million dollars and you want to borrow against it and it becomes very difficult or you know somebody is doing short selling and is borrowing your shares and paying 35% to prime brokers and you're getting 3% and like there's so many inefficiencies that people don't realize that once this gets free of the existing market structures and put on blockchain these things will open up and I do believe will start small with one is sure then five then ten and then hundred and they will grow from there. So that is a good reminder of how large this market is so a hundred trillion in US securities it sounds like something and then your stock exchange is like 44 trillion I mean these numbers are pretty pretty astronomical.
New relatives great. We have smart accounts around like 60 trillion I think global equity is 100 trillion. Okay and why is he the single largest market? Okay okay amazing and now obviously so goes the US I think so goes the rest of the world. I want to ask another point about sort of how this works from a user perspective so retail investor buying a tokenized security let's say my co-hosts your David uses Robin Hood right I'm a little older I use fidelity let's say okay so fidelity is my broker and so if I want the in five years time all of these tokenized securities on chain if I want to buy an asset like Exxon which is listed in your stock exchange I want a I guess tokenized version of that so that I can have it in my non-custodial wallet and I can by the way I can bring that wallet to another broker if I want because I'm sort of the custodian of that wallet rather than the broker so I'm not locked into fidelity I can switch it at any point in time but I should have the ability to do that essentially through my existing broker so I log into fidelity I go and I buy the tokenized version of Exxon assuming they're an issue that that lists their their tokenized security and then I can bring that into my crypto wallet and I can go take that wherever I want that's the future state we're talking about right that's exactly the future state I think you're describing a future state that's that's probable right it's it's not the immediate reality right and the immediate reality these aren't likely to be permissionless bearer instruments I think that we know that that is the direction of travel some of the you know sort of wrapper products that you know you were describing before David that are in in the marketplace offshore those are permissionless because they they they sort of defer some of the complexities of complying with the US you know regulation so I think in order to find the solution that's going to blend permissionless you know kind of self-custody and all the applications that we know are high potential with the sort of regulatory blessing in order to be within the the US perimeter like that work is still to be done but it's you know kind of the the rails that are being laid right now by firms like securitize they're going to help us get there but by the way today with tokenized securities you can have it on your subcustody wallet the only difference is that that wallet has to be wireless to it because you got KYC at some point right but you also KYC when you go to your broker dealer right you also KYC when you go to Binance you go also KYC when you go to Coinbase like there is this negative connotation about you know how it took KYC and and in reality we're being KYC every other day in any other venue and then the infrastructure is still permissionless right you can still interact then with like we we integrate with Horizon or integrate with you know with oil and like lending markets where the market itself is a permissionless infrastructure for lending but the asset itself that you post as collateral is permission and your wallet has been wireless to that some point but what you're saying right and about connecting to a broker dealer and being able to take your securities with you yes the broker dealer knows you KYC they can wireless the wallet they will allow you to then move the tokens to your wallet and then if you connect that wallet to another broker dealer then your securities have instantly moved as opposed to today where if you're trying to move securities could like with that it's going to take you oh my god I tried it's exhausting it's actually like literally phone calls and at some points I've used fax machines in order to get you know securities from from one broker to another it's very it's very different it's very different than just like moving stablecoins let's say and I wish for a world where it's as easy as that it will be at easy as that as far as you've done wireless to your wallet and you move this across wireless wallet because as Michael said these are securities and the US and therefore permissionless tokens today you know do not necessarily comply with with securities relations that are forced you know AML tags that force you know if you need they're transferring needs to know who the holders are and they certain obligations for transferring about knowing you know the name of the investor and and things like that so Carlos you bring up the defying composability conversation here so if if I'm white listed on a particular asset if I'm if I'm white listed do I get access to the whole set of assets produced by this partnership or do I is it like issue or by issue or how does that work you are less ones with the transfer agent and we might list your your wallet any security will be able to gather and then I tell you what my wallet is and legally speaking I am just claiming that this wallet is mine rather than like my friends who just wants to be able to my offshore friend who wants to be able to own an security well the way we do it is we we actually ask you to connect your wallet to our platform so we we know that you and send a transaction so we know that you have the private keys of the wallet right okay and then legally speaking is like a more amount of it or or do wallet connect like we use the same the same wallet connectivity protocols are any defy protocol uses to connect to our platform and then we while we know the wallet is controlled by you and then we while is it right and then you have as the transfer agent you have my identity you have the security added to my name and then you also have my wallet where it's all kind of held and so if I lose my wallet I can go get the security on a new wallet correct correct because the I am the owner it's not my wallet that's the owner it's me that's the owner correct so so the this is not a very asset that's Michael said it means not like Bitcoin or if that is a very asset that if you lose it you lose it this is a secure this is an unsertificated security that is represented in our blockchain and therefore if you lose it you can come to us we'll verify that who you are who you say you are and then we'll then burn the security tokens on the on the wallet that you access to and and remint it on a new wallet that you have connected with us so because the risk of this is much lower than the cost the risk of this that's right because this would apply Carlos the same thing if my ex-onchairs were hacked or stolen or something like this or correct or if you have shared certificates like papers shared certificates which believe it or not that still exists and I don't know and they have fire in your house and they burn down and you can do that still your shares like you can go back to the transfer agent and and get them back so what about if I want to take my shares and I want to put them in AVE that gets a little bit more complicated AVE not a legal entity you just you technically just need to whitelist the smart contracts and then it can work legally speaking I get a guessing it's a little bit more complicated than that what are the what are the nuances here that we need to understand okay that's a very good question so so this kind of two paths to integrate with with defy and let's break defying in lending versus trading because these are two different things on the on the lending side of things you know there's kind of two paths one is companies like AVE are basically building you know versions of AVE in the case of AVE is collaborative horizon that are already designed to take you know tokenized securities as collateral so they've already built all the necessary hooks there for me as an investor that I hold let's say Exxon shares as Ryan was saying to be able to post them on AVE horizon and then borrow against it and then there's a liquidator that will take them like semi structures and normal defy lending protocol but AVE has a separate marketplace called AVE horizon that works for permission assets then there is other we've released something called the the the vault register which is basically a vault where any defy protocol can integrate this vault technology to be able to take security as collateral under defy protocol and we have some people like Euler and Luke scale Zarta that they are now integrating that so it's the same protocol they don't need to do anything that and they just need to keep the collateral on a separate vault that that you know we provide to them because that vault basically does not change the ownership of the security because you're versus a collateral but just till the owner until he gets liquidated and then we have to wireless the liquidators because the liquidators might take possession of the security so it's not actually a lot of friction to be honest with you.
White listing the liquidators is kind of similar to just like white listing a market maker. Right because the liquidators kind of efficient so they're already known entities to any protocol right so yeah they are they're already professional professionals etc so okay no I do believe that and by the way this is a massive opportunity right because if you think about stock lending this is not something that is simple to do for people like as I mentioned today just go and try you you're you're sharing in fidelity of Exxon and try to get a loan against them try and then next program tell tell the audience the experience of doing that it's going to be impossible for you to do and you get the coins against your entire portfolio to trade more all brokerage will give you that but if you want to buy a house against your you know Exxon shares that have a preceded over time good luck with that yeah so these are things that are they're going to open up big mark tags also you know equities are good source of collateral like a lot of training firms deposit equities as collateral and again a collateral moves very inefficiently because the securities move very inefficiently because moving securities from place to place is a commercial process so tokenize securities will be able to trade there then they will be liquid because of the the New York Stock Exchange venue etc so this is going to open a lot of interesting applications so Carlos basically what I'm hearing in summary is that while it's not a trivial thing to whitelist a defi app it is also not that complicated either and that the ideas we will actually be able to have tokenize securities under the condition that we are whitelisted whitelisted KYC with the transfer agent we will be able to have securities in defi apps we sounds like we also need some participation on the defi app side of things it has to be a two way conversation but it ultimately doesn't sound like there's any in a fundamental road blocks between here and there I don't think so I think it's more about educating the market towards that I do believe that defi because it's a very it's a very efficient lending technology and market has a very bad source of collateral for lending so introducing higher sources higher quality collateral like tokenize equities or tokenize trustees or tokenize you know CLOs and bonds etc into defi markets is going to make defi markets grow because it would be more you know institutional participation because from a borrowing from a lending perspective they are very efficient markets right but that's not what people are leveraging against in the traditional finance so if we give them those tools I think people will come and and if I will grow again excuse me man we're defi will still be low 2021 levels people don't realize that we take at 180 billion and now we're 100 so so we need to we need to do something about bringing institutions then and that's not going to happen if you're you know lending against lots of coins bankless isn't just a name it's a genuine belief that you shouldn't need permission from an institution to use your money metamask has been around since the beginning of Ethereum and they carry the same DNA we do metamask was my first wallet and well if you haven't opened up the app recently let me tell you they've been shipping creating the one app to finally replace your bank and exchange you can trade just about everything right from within metamask leverage perps via hyper liquid prediction markets to polymarket tokenized stocks like Nvidia and you can swap tokens gassiously and across networks and even spend your crypto with your metamask card at real merchants all around the world it's better than institution services but from a self custodial wallet and this is what we've been talking about for years money that's open and it's happening so give metamask trading features a look at the link below some exciting news we are launching a new podcast to help people figure out the crypto cycle how to navigate it the best crypto cycle investor I know his name is Michael he runs the defy report this is the guy that sent me a sell alert before the 1010 price drop happened his cycle analysis has been absolutely on point I've been following him for years and this year we started recording weekly podcast episodes each one we get into his portfolio what he's holding the market structure entry targets fair market value of Bitcoin ether and where we are in the cycle there's new episodes that are released every Wednesday they're 30 minutes they're short they're punchy I think this crypto cycle is harder to navigate than most so let's do it together go subscribe to this podcast search the defy report wherever you get your podcast YouTube apple Spotify we'll find a link in the show notes there's a new episode waiting for you now what one of the arguments that has been made recently on bank listen this is actually a debate we had with two professors but maybe I'll give you Austin Campbell who was on one side of the argument he's a professor at NYU Stern he's also kind of crypto native very familiar with this he actually argues that open public permissionless ledgers the change that we all love the theorems of the world for instance the layer two's are not necessarily the right place to tokenize securities and the reason he says is because like what happens in the event of a hack there's no kind of rollback these the these environments are optimized for maybe for more for bear instruments they don't have identity they don't have amlkyc and so there has been a push for some real world asset activity to happen on more permissioned ledgers this has been a debate that's ongoing I'm wondering what do our thoughts are on the content versus a theory on share yeah wait wait in wait on this debate what do you think I don't think that's true so public permission so first this debate to me feels like the the and you guys are a lot younger than me but maybe Michael remembers this is the debate about American online versus the internet oh no American online is safer because we control who puts their content there and who is accessing it blah blah blah and guess what happened it died and then the the public permissionless infrastructure that is the internet is what flourish right because open open innovation happens on open networks right because anybody's allowed to create new stuff and that's why innovation happened there and didn't happen in American online so that's my personal view of the world is respective of the blockchain this debate and now in terms of whether public permissionless networks are suitable for securities I will tell you that if you do it so regulated intermediary that has the ability obviously you can't roll back what happens right but actually in my opinion that's a positive thing because it keeps track of what history has been if there's something that goes wrong but you can always burn and remain to you know reverse a transaction because the keys of the smart contract that you know means those securities is in the hands of our regulatory intermediary which is a transfer agent and yeah I know that people don't like the word intermediary but this is a better intermediary than the intermediaries we had before in the sense that it's more less friction you know less in the things he needs to intermediate etc but this is still sitting there to provide that piece of mind to people so I don't understand why this kind of happened on Ethereum to be honest with you.
Well I mean on this episode we have a representative from New York Stock Exchange and Michael I ask you I mean is there anything scary about permissionless open ledgers when any reasons for you to preserve prefer more more permission structures rather than something open like Ethereum? Well I think our regulatory obligations are going to be the same regardless of the technology choices we make I mean today we're working under securities laws are written in the 1930s that didn't even you know begin to contemplate you know electronic trading we still have to you know kind of meet those standards even though we're employing much more advanced technology and I think whether we choose to use you know a sort of private chain or a public permissionless chain we're going to have the same you know responsibilities how we meet them how we manage you know kind of all of those will be different implementation choices and frankly between NYSE and our parent company intercontinental exchange we expect to use a number of different L1 and L2 selections across our six global clearing houses as we begin to support tokenized collateral the NYSE tokenized trading venue some other projects that were developing so I think you know you're going to see us probably use a number of different architectures a number of different technology selections but I don't think that it's going to be I don't think it's particularly fruitful for you know the community to sort of beat each other one variety or another you know it's going to be permissible I think all of these could be used it's all about how you use them but by the way the SEC published few months ago and I think you were they explicitly said that transfer agents are allowed to use public permissionless networks to keep what is called the master security holder file is a technical term that means the cap table if you want which is where the record of owners of the security so they explicitly said it's okay to use that that a public permissionless network so I don't know to put these professors on why he's saying that it's not possible because the regulator doesn't agree with that so I mean as far as the regulator tells me it's fine I'm going to do it we'll make sure to clip that and tag in my Twitter yeah no maybe I'll follow you on Twitter and I don't know we have a reason to say that but my bomb unit the regulator doesn't agree with that so and by the way this was the argument on the Gensler time of uh you know saying whether you know because we were using a public chain whether we could wrap some securities there and we they asked us to have a separate license for the in custody remember this permission guys that got this special for the broker dealer license etc and that has all disappeared with a new regime right Michael I want to learn a little bit more about this NYSE affiliated tokenized securities platform let me allow me to read between the lines and then you can correct me how far off course I get so you have New York Stock Exchange great business been around for for decades decades maybe maybe longer I don't know actually 230 plus years thank you centuries that's the centuries centuries and then on along comes blockchain like a new way to do a lot of very similar things that the New York Stock Exchange is doing but you don't want to like disrupt what you got going on tradify is still basically all the finance don't really want to like shift that up but we have this parallel financial system it's got tokens it's got blockchains and you guys also need to kind of keep up with the times and so you're building not a you're not replacing or disrupting yourself you are building a new parallel trading venue to go along with the new parallel financial system that runs on blockchains and it's kind of like it well we'll get growth over here and if the tokenized thing and the blockchain thing really works out we've got our flag planted with this and New York Stock Exchange has affiliated tokenized securities platform and the old New York Stock Exchange kind of just stays doing exactly what it's doing it it'll remain like trading with trading hours well the new one has 24 7 365 trading markets and the new New York Stock Exchange tokenized trading platform will just grow will grow alongside that market independently of the New York Stock Exchange and if it gets to as big as the New York Stock Exchange one day that's great if it doesn't also great but we have now two independently moving parts of the New York Stock Exchange this is kind of like my read on the whole thing how how close to my yeah I think that's a pretty fair read the you know reality is the the New York Stock Exchange is you know the home of 24 hundred listed companies who you know absolutely depend upon the liquidity and the you know kind of market infrastructure that ensures that they are priced at the right values that they're you able to support the capital formation and you know fund the entrepreneurial visions of those companies leaders to the benefit of public investors so it has a very important mission it does that at great scale you know a single closing auction can be hundreds of billions of dollars of value transferred so these are these are really you know significant markets that we expect to evolve but you know we'll evolve you know very deliberately meanwhile with the NATS that's running alongside we can be more experimental we can support the issuers that want to you know kind of dive in versus dipito in into the space and frankly you know I think we've grown up over those two hundred and thirty plus years and certainly you know since since the 1930s when when the the you know federal securities laws were enacted you've grown up in a world that was very deliberately you know broken into swim lands where there were segregation of duties where you had clients represented by broker dealers and broker dealers traded on exchanges and exchanges had market makers and those you know transactions were held by clearing houses and custodians and and like everyone had a distinct job on purpose and from time to time we've had you know reminders of why having those segregation of duties matters a lot in traditional finance but we're now in a world where you know on chain infrastructure can create so much utility for end investors that the risk reward of potentially like blurring those swim lanes begins to be pretty compelling and so I think it's not just you know NYSE can kind of run the traditional business and see if it works out with with blockchain I think our expectation is like this is going to transform like we are going to need to move this business on chain there's some other market participants who are sort of waiting to see if the existing utilities can evolve and once they evolve then that will be kind of the the queue to begin to do things in tokens our view is that you know we need to be building we need to get very familiar with the technology we need to work with leaders both in the issuer community and in the infrastructure community to to become really you know conversant in that in that space and so you know I don't know you know I don't know how quickly it'll be 1% 2% 5% 10% of us equity trading volume in tokenized form but by 20 36 you know 10 years from now like I'll be stunned if it's diminimous and so I think it's crucial that you know given the pace of technology adoption and change and regulatory change you need people to sort of stake out a leadership position and and begin and so we're really excited to do that admitted you know admittedly you know beginning in sort of a modest way with you know a a a a reasonably narrow you know field of what permissible but trying to build in a way that'll be extensible and allow for that composability self custody and you know greater utility that we know is the real promise of on chain infrastructure yeah yeah I I want to think I'm curious about is to what degree does successful innovation on this alternative trading system things like at 24 seven markets you know the tokenization in the back end all the innovation that is being allowed to be unleashed in this alternative trading platform how much might we see actually float backwards into the traditional stock exchange like there is a big conversation there has been ever since blockchains really became notable in in trad five like oh you know the the direction of travel is 24 seven 365 markets is that something that the New York Stock Exchange wants is it like open to doing that level of transformation for this 235-year-old business or is it just saying hey if the market truly values 24 seven 365 markets it'll be expressed on this alternative trading system and we'll just allow that to grow and you know tradition on the New York Stock Exchange side of things tradition is tradition and we just have two options here like it will there be a blurring of the lines or more of a separation of responsibility yeah I think it's a it's a really good question our view is this is going to be a long-term migration from traditional you know the same way that we moved from four-based trading to electronic trading I think we imagined like we will see 25 years from now we went from electronic trading to digital on chain I don't think it's going to move you know in in kind of a consistent pace across all investors I think retail will move faster than institutional but you're already seeing the traditional exchanges expand their market hours to 23 hours five days a week so you know some of the you know sort of you know agitation that began as as kind of pesky retail you know desires has now already impacted things like the consolidated tape and thinras you know trade reporting facility it's like very very you know kind of tradify infrastructure capabilities so I think it's you know question of when not if I think you know Ryan gave his example of you know trying to move things you know in a fidelity account and like he's choosing to buy the tokenized version of exon you know in order to be able to have you know his his sort of self custody I actually think of a more realistic example is like in the future he won't need to make a determination to buy a token or not buy a token people like NYSE people like secure ties like we're going to abstract away all that complexity you're going to own exon you're going to have the ability to move to a different broker you may have the ability to lend it yourself you're going to have you know kind of a much broader menu of capabilities as an individual investor that will depend upon tokenize infrastructure but you're not going to have to be an expert in you know blockchain in order to make use of those types of capabilities I think bringing those to a broad audience like that's that's the work that's ahead of us I'm going to ask you regulatory question because a lot of this has been brought about by a much clearer regulatory stance from from Paul Atkins with SEC and obviously the the new CFTC chair Mike C.
Lig and including you know two or three weeks ago they provided some fantastic guidance with respect to a taxonomy for which crypto assets might be securities and which are commodities and surprise surprise by the way if it was a security before it's it's still a security so tokenized securities will be securities I think I have a question about the legislative process and maybe like do we still need the clarity act for the New York Stock Exchange and for securitized to proceed with tokenization I know it would be nice like acts of congress can be nice and they're almost hard coded into the United States operating system so we now have to worry about what regulators regime shifts might might bring in terms of changes that said we do have some pretty clear taxonomies and rulemaking guidance coming from the CFTC the SEC it's hard to imagine even in a future administration that's maybe a little more dim with respect with respect dim in many respects maybe but dim their view of crypto is more dim and they try to reverse some of this it's unclear whether much can be reversed I guess what I'm saying is do we still need the clarity act is that still important or can you guys proceed if we don't get that with the full tokenization plan as is we can proceed with virtually no significant regulatory exemptions and no legislative change for the NYSE's tokenization platform that being said getting a bill done I think is very valuable to the marketplace you know our our parent company intercontinental exchange operates global futures markets global clearinghouses having a bill that enshrines the intention of congress into law to ensure that we you know don't have you know kind of a you know let's say like kind of a arbitrariness in regulatory shifts I think will be very very valuable I don't think that we need the clarity act for tokenization I think if you look at the clarity act it's more about providing clarity about which digital assets are securities in which ones are commodities which is in the main problem in in crypto primarily because most most of the tokens in crypto are people are are you know saying they're not securities and the piece of administration took the view that everything was security right including like Ethan Solana and things like that and so that's where they that's why it's called the clarity act because it's attempted to provide clarity there but you you started the the discussion Ryan saying tokenized securities are securities so this clarity already there like nobody's arguing that if we tokenize excellent shares magically does not become a security by with some crypto people in crypto are trying to do that to create regulatory arbitrage and going and do shenanigans offshore etc to with securities to try to bypass securities regulations but at least here in the US I tokenize security security you need to follow the same security regulations now are there other things beyond the clarity act that we could benefit from that will allow more things to happen on on tokenize securities that's a different discussion with certainly as a transfregion you know the clarity act actually talks about modernizing transfregions as one of the mandates but it doesn't actually say what they're going to do specifically that's an interesting area like you know I don't want to have as a transfregion believe it or not we need to cut the physical address of a person which is completely unnecessary if I operate on the blockchain I just want to have a wallet address on a name I don't need a physical address so there's you know all other kind of things that will require could you could modernize there like you know some of the reganimized rules that apply to a market structure like everybody should follow the same price best price best execution or maybe if you trade in a digital 80s maybe you don't need to do that and market make us both figure out how to make markets efficient like captain's encrypted word you don't have those regulations and markets are efficient across miners and Coinbase etc so there's other topics of improvement but the clarity act if it doesn't pass I think it's really bad for the crypto industry but it's okay for the tokenization industry we talked about how in order for all these these equities to become tokenize securities this is issuer choice so the kind of like if Microsoft wants security tokens on Ethereum it has to make that choice it's not going to be because the NYC said so it's not going to be because because the securities said so it's going to become a it's an issuer choice how do we convince them to do that and whose job is it to do that is that your job Carlos we're gonna work together it's not gonna be my my job obviously that's my job for sure but we might be speaking about that but obviously the one that has a relationship with the issuers is my club but to be honest with you I think that once like we've been talking to many issues about this the moment we announced that there's going to be a venue a legit venue because obviously it's a nicer right so it's just legit as it gets where this security is straight the conversation has completely changed right because the question before was like yes you're I'm gonna talk about what are my what I'm gonna do with the tokenize security what is it gonna trade like what is it what I'm gonna be able to do with it and you walk them through like in a scenario future scenario of things you could be able to do that you it was not a reality yet now this becomes a reality I think you will get more issues because there's no necessarily downsides right you know they'll get more investors they'll get more liquidity they'll get you know more happy investors they will come up with new ideas like I'll just give you an example the beauty of tokenize equities is that you can just prove the ownership because you hold it in your wallet right it's it's a it's a it's a it's a it's a it's a it's a it's a global proof of ownership of a security well today it's impossible for you to prove that you bought Apple shares because you know yeah you might show an screenshot of Rory but that's that's not there under your name there's like a hundred different broker dealers with different apps except what is a wallet and a token you can always you know badly they don't change that you own a particular security this could open up different ways to interact with your holders right because like you say okay you hold my security is then I'm gonna give you a discount or I'm gonna give you a preferential ticket for the seven or for this other one which today is impossible to implement because it's impossible to verify ownership of securities because there's no ledger that you can read and validate it right so I think that these will allow issues to you know become more creative especially issues that have a lot of like retail following of what they could do with their securities to attract more investors so yeah Michael if you want to add anything yeah Michael Carlos is on our side of the aisle here he's a crypto person I consider you to be on the other side of the aisle and in the track five person so like do you agree with Carlos and our sentiment that like this is inevitable or is it going to be maybe a little bit more nuanced than that no offense taken by the way no offense taken you think I wait it's fair for thinking so look I so our CEO Jeff Sprecker you know he has a great track record of seeing where the puck is moving and I think he has a tremendous amount of conviction that you know we are going to be in a world where on chain infrastructure is the core of capital raising of trading of clearing of settlement you know it's so so I think we would we would agree that it's you know when not if but you know I think you have to you have to demonstrate utility because there's so much inertia right there's so much you know inertia in the existing system and so Carlos just gave a couple great examples where you know if an issuer can get new benefit from instantly knowing who's on their cap table instantly knowing if someone's buying or selling you know that's something a CFO or an IRO would get really excited about now institutional investors are going to you know do everything they can to obfuscate their activity in the market so it's even if technology could solve this there may be reasons that it won't immediately come to bear but I think you know we're going to have to you know find ways to tokenize the existing inventory not just new issuance if we want to really move tens of trillions of assets quickly so I think it's going to be you know not just the sort of issuer by issuer progress that that you know Carlos and his brethren are pursuing but it's going to take industry-wide shifts and that's where regulatory clarity no pun intended you know can be helpful because you have these collective action problems that really need a catalyst that that operates at the scale of you know a nation state because of that inertia that that Michael's been talking about there is another way this could play out and I'm interested in your take on this Carlos so love the idea of actual issuer back tokens on chain that are securities right because this represents actual ownership on bankless we talk so often about the importance of property rights and that gets you the closest thing to a property right as possible there are these synthetic type token products and even maybe perps as an example of this on platforms like hyper liquid and that doesn't give you actual ownership of the security or asset but it does give you price exposure seems like price exposures what a lot of traders at least are looking for and a lot of the capital quite frankly is looking for how does a digital transfer agent and kind of the slow path of getting all of these issuers and assets on chain one by one how does that compete against the synthetic versions of these things that can just like be quicker even if it's not giving you full ownership it is at least giving you the price exposure and maybe that's the product market fit maybe that's what people actually want well what do you think about this I would not put perps and derivatives in the same category I think perps are valuable because I mean equity markets have future markets as well right and the coexist and future markets and perps is a kind of a variation of a future market where the futures do not expire right but they also need the spot markets because they need to take the price from somewhere and I was actually the other day with a company building perps infrastructure and after we announced the the project with the New York Stock Exchange since it was saying this is great because perps operate 24-7 but equity markets do not operate 24-7 so during non-market hours you don't have pricing reference for spot price for perps right so I think that you know spot markets moving 24-7 helps perps and I see them as completely different instruments as you said one thing is you want to own you know the stock you want to hold it if it goes up you know over the over time you know 10 times you benefit 10x perps is a different story you have a funding rate risk you know if you go up but you go up like these you can get liquidity and lose all your money and you need to purchase kind of a completely different audience right so it's not about the same type of investors and I think perps and spot markets are complimentary the same way that future markets complement the spot not the derivatives I do think that once the native tokenization exists why would anybody actually touch five different derivatives all of them different all of them with different counterparty risks etc where you have an actual asset that is what you actually want to do so that because the derivatives is spot market those guys are trading spot markets so that's why I want to separate them from from perhaps they're just trying to compete for creating an spot market for the derivatives of equities so I think those disappear once you have the real asset and instead of having six different versions of coins if coin base tokenize coin and there's a token that is the native representation of coin what would you actually buy the derivative what would you actually take counterparty risk to a random company having to buy enough sure you won't be able to actually in the US etc so that doesn't my view go down to zero at some point now obviously you know because there's nothing else that's what people are are purchasing Carlos says we bring this to a close and thank you Michael and Carlos for joining us today there has been some rumor about securitize maybe it's more than a rumors actually somewhat of an announcement at some point I may have seen which is that securitize was going to go public by route of of SPAC at some point in time do you have an update on that Carlos what are the plans right now yes it's not a rumor we actually announced that last year that we are merging with a counterfeiteral sponsor SPAC it's called counter equity partners to it's already a SPAC that is trading we've announced that we're merging with them in the at the beginning of this year we file the s4 which is kind of the filing you need to do with scc to approve the the public filing and the public listing and then we're now waiting for you know an updated s4 and hopefully get the regulatory process towards the end and get listed in the next few weeks so I guess that brings the question are you going to tokenize yourself and put your hands off of this release we're going to be with part of when we announced that was a condition for any SPAC we talked to that you know we want to tokenize our own equity because we want to showcase all the cool stuff that you can do with native tokenize equities and what best to do it with our own equities so 100% Carlos last time we had you on before this time was I think two years ago when we were talking about Biddle and this was the beginning of real Biddle and you guys were the first one pouring it yeah what's if we if we broaden this and maxima a maximum view what's been the progress in bringing real world assets on chain from two years ago and until now what what significant milestones have we accomplished well I think the growth of the entire SPAC and again it's it's very controversial the metrics because what do you count as tokenize assets do you count these close networks are there or not but by any metric this has been growing faster than anything else it's grown faster than stablecoins that have been growing is certainly grown faster than crypto that has been declining so so this has been the fastest part growing part of the market I do believe that blackrock entering the space was a catalyst for adoption because obviously they're not they're a very influential company they they tokenize stress to space that the Biddle plays which is still the largest asset I think it's worth 2.
2 billion or something now it was like 300 million two years ago and now is 11 billion I don't think is any but any part of crypto has grown that fast but that said I think we're still scratching the surface I like last week a dust chair at Kim's in his speech he said we're at the end of the beginning so it kind of feels that way for tokenization that we're at the end of the beginning now the beginning has happened now we need to get into the real growth because the space is so massive as we discussed before just taking you know 1% of 2% of of the stocks on chain doubles the size of crypto so so that the fact that we have tens of billions of dollars still feels like very very early days before we let's you guys go I want to ask about the timeline for this whole thing so this is an announcement of a partnership when does the actual product happen is this like a 2026 thing or a 2028 thing Michael I think maybe this is a question for you sure so subject to regulatory approval we'd expect to launch in q4 in this year for you for issues that are interested that's right for for issuers that are interested in in native issuance they don't need to wait for our ats to be live they can begin to you know work with securitize and and and there appears to you know begin on chain issuance and then those products would be eligible for trading on our platform once it's approved wow okay so firmly in the 2026 time frame that's great that's great well congratulations guys pretty cool to see some of the very early visions of tokenization manifest into partnerships that we can do yeah I mean welcome on chain yeah welcome on chain to the stock is chance so they get to be here in these bungalows there will know your bungs there you're doing this the bank this way would be fantastic guys we've got to leave you with this of course none of this has been financial advice you know crypto is risky even the tokenized security form you could lose what you put in we're headed west this is a frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot you