In this two-part Bankless Series, we're exploring the Nouns DAO. In episode one, we're chatting with The Nounders, aka the founders of the Nouns DAO. In episode two, we'll be chatting with a few Nouners, aka some Nouns DAO members.
The Nouns project has taken the crypto ecosystem by storm. Hear why and how in the episode!
------ 📣 Forta | Help Make Web3 a Safer Place https://bankless.cc/Forta
------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🚀 ROCKET POOL | ETH STAKING https://bankless.cc/RocketPool
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
❎ ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
🦁 BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
🌴 MAKER DAO | DECENTRALIZED LENDING https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
🔐 LEDGER | SECURE STAKING https://bankless.cc/Ledger
------ Timestamps:
0:00 Intro 6:00 Nouns DAO Origin 9:05 CryptoPunks vs. Nouns 11:55 4156's Tweet Thread 13:05 Noun Distribution Mechanism 22:20 Noun Art, Properties, & Rarity 37:00 Nouns Governance 44:25 Nounish Culture & Direction 52:00 Nouns DAO Proposals 54:50 Nouners Wednesday Episode 57:05 Closing
Resources:
4156 https://twitter.com/punk4156
Vapeape https://twitter.com/punk4464
Seneca https://twitter.com/cryptoseneca
Nouns DAO https://twitter.com/nounsdao
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome, Bankless Nation, to this very special episode where we cover, is it going to be a two-part series? This is going to be our first ever two-part series. We're talking to the Nounders of the Nounsdale. In the second episode, we will talk to the Nouners of the Nounsdale. If you haven't guessed, the Nounders are the founders of the Nounsdale. So on this particular episode, we're talking to three of them. We got 4156, Punk4156, who I now think just goes by 4156. Also VapeApe and Seneca. So these are three Nounders of the NounsDAO project. And the NounsDAO project has taken the crypto ecosystem by storm.
And as to why it's taken the crypto ecosystem by storm is an interesting question, one that we will unpack in this episode. Because is Nouns an NFT project? Is Nouns a DAO? Is it a DeFi app? yes to all of these things. So we're going to explore what about the Nouns Project has captured just the beloved attention of so much in the crypto space and how it's perhaps brought something new to the table as to something that can be copied and pasted and brought forward into the future as a primitive for so many different things to unpack. And so I hope you guys enjoy this podcast. We're going to talk to these three founders in just a quick sec.
But before we do, we're going to talk to our friends over at Forta. And as we all know, DeFi is risky. We say this every single time on the podcast. And Forta offers real-time security and operational monitoring for whatever value that you have in the crypto world, whether you're a DeFi app, you're an NFT project, or you've got governance contracts, or you're a bridge. Forta is a real-time monitoring network. And so, you know those little games? There's that asteroid game back in the 80s or 90s, and you'd had to shoot down the asteroids before they hit the Earth? That's like Forta and your incoming malicious transactions trying to rob you or your DeFi projects of their treasury.
It'll monitor some shady shenanigans going along in the mempool, and it will destroy those incoming transactions to the best of its ability before those transactions come and mess up your day. And so you can check this out. There's a link in the show notes, banklist.cc slash Forta. Top protocols like Maker, Lido, Compound, Balancer, DYDX, all are leveraging Forta to make Web3 a better and safer space for us all. So you can check them out also at Forta.org. All right. and so as we before we go into the show i just want to talk a little bit more about a moment a little bit about the show format so i do these show formats every now and then uh we call them out there alpha leaks or panels and amas basically if you are a part of a community part of an organization and you think that the bull case for that org needs to be presented on bank lists you got to let me know and here's what you got to do you got to grab up to three members of your community maybe just one maybe just two maybe just three no more than three though uh who can articulate the bull case for your project, for whatever you're working on.
You've got to slap an agenda together and let me know. And so I know for a fact the Rocketpool team is doing this right now. They've got a thread in their DAO about their bull case or Rocketpool agenda on Banklist. We've done this a few times before with the Treasure DAO community. If you've got a bull case for your project, your DAO, your community, or whatever, and you think that it needs to be told, you've got to get fined up to three people, produce an agenda together, and send it my way, and we'll get that story told. And so today we're telling the story of the Nounders, the NounsDAO with the Nounders.
This is, like I said, a two-part series. There is the Nouners, the community members of the NounsDAO. Then they are coming on the show on Wednesday. This is our first ever two-part series just because there's so much to unpack here in the Nouns organization. So let's go ahead and get that started with unpacking this story of nouns from the Nounders side of things. So we will be right back with three of the members of the Nounders side of the NounStyle right after we get through some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible. RocketPool is your decentralized Ethereum staking protocol.
You can stake your ETH in RocketPool and get our ETH in return, allowing you to stake your ETH and use it in DeFi at the same time. You can get 4% on your ETH by staking it with RocketPool, but you can get even more by running a node. RocketPool is the only staking provider that allows anyone to permissionlessly join their network of validating Ethereum nodes. Setting up your RocketPool node is easier than running a node solo, and you only need 16 ETH to get started. You get an extra 15% staking commission on the pooled ETH that uses your node to stake. You also get RPL token rewards on top. So if you're bullish e-staking, you can boost your yield by adding your node to the decentralized RocketPool network, which currently has over 1,000 independent node operators.
It's yield farming, but with Ethereum nodes. You can get started at rocketpool.net and you can also join the RocketPool community in their Discord. You can find me hanging out there sometimes in the chat, so I'll see you there. Arbitrum is an Ethereum Layer 2 scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Some of the coolest new NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home, while DeFi protocols continue to see increased liquidity and usage. You can now bridge straight into Arbitrum for more than 10 different exchanges, including Binance, FTX, Huobi, and Crypto.
com. Once on Arbitrum, you'll enjoy fast transactions with cheap fees, allowing you to explore new frontiers of the crypto universe. New to Arbitrum, for a limited time, you can get Arbitrum NFTs designed by the famous artists Ratwell and Sugoi for joining the Arbitrum Odyssey. The Odyssey is an eight-week long event where you can play on-chain activities and receive a free NFT as a reward. Find out more by visiting the Discord at discord.gg slash Arbitrum. You can also bridge your assets to Arbitrum at bridge.arbitrum.io and access all of Arbitrum's apps at portal.arbitrum.one in order to experience DeFi and NFTs the way it was always meant to be, fast, cheap, secure, and fiction-free.
MakerDAO is the OG DeFi protocol, the first DeFi protocol to ever exist, even before we called it DeFi. MakerDAO produces DAI, the industry's most battle-tested and resilient stablecoin. Using Maker, you don't need to sell your collateral if you need liquidity. Instead, you can spin up a Maker vault and use your collateral to mint DAI directly. With Maker, the power to mint new money is in your hands. And there's something new in the MakerDAO ecosystem. Every time a new MakerDAO is opened, the owner can claim a POAP, which contributes funds to One Tree Planted, an organization with ongoing global reforestation efforts, creating a world where digital participation and the health of our environment can live side by side.
Soon, Maker will be present on all chains and Layer 2s, bringing the biggest and best DeFi credit facility to everywhere there is DeFi. So follow Maker on Twitter, at MakerDAO, and learn from the oldest and most resilient DAO in existence. Ladies and gentlemen, introducing the Nounders. In the top left corner, we have Seneca and his beautiful, cute little noun with head looks like... I don't know what his head looks like. Seneca, what is your head? You're talking to a milk carton. A milk carton with a milk carton head. In the top right corner, we got Vape Ape, which is an ape vaping. Actually, not a real noun.
I just discovered this right before going live. Vape Ape, welcome to the show. Thank you. Thank you for having me. And then in the bottom left corner, we got 4156 with a horsey head and a lol shirt. 4156, welcome to the show. Thanks for having us. Like I alluded to in the intro, the Nouns Project has just captured the attention, captivated so many of us for so many different reasons. Like, is it an NFT project? Well, almost certainly, because it definitely comes with a JPEG. But it also is a little bit like a DeFi app in this like auction that goes on every single day. But it's also like a DAO because the NFT is also like a governing share over this org.
We're going to unpack like the full story of this, but we got to start at the beginning. Where did the idea for nouns come from? Like who should tell this story? 4156, I'll throw this to you. Yeah, sure. So, yeah, I mean, now this was, I guess, to a certain extent, my brainchild. I had been, you know, I've been in the crypto space for almost a decade, but, you know, I'd been spending a lot of time in the CryptoPunks community and, you know, just generally around the NFT space and had been thinking for a while about, you know, what could CryptoPunks 2.0 look like? you know, what, what were the sort of like primitives missing from, from that project that, that could make it, you know, more crypto native could, could potentially kind of elevate it so that, so that it could kind of do things beyond mostly just kind of cheerleading the price.
And so I, you know, I had been chatting with some friends, been writing down different ideas about, you know, what, what, what could this look like? And then, you know, one, one day I just had this kind of like moment of, of inspiration where I decided that I was going to write everything down, um, tweet it out in, in like Twitter thread format, um, and just see if anyone wanted to work on it. Um, so the, the white paper, if you want to call it that for, for nouns is, is the Twitter thread. You can still find it on my Twitter. I can, I can send you the link. Um, and, um, yeah, basically, you know, describes a lot of the properties and very high level that nouns has today um and um kind of at the end it says like you know does anyone want to work on this with me um and of course fave ape and and senek are two of the people that said yes i'd actually like to explore the the crypto punk side of things because crypto punks have captured there's a significant overlap between nouns and crypto punks and i think you know you already alluded to a little bit as to why it seems to like both projects tried to capture some of this like ethos of crypto that while we can't really articulate it, the vibe is there, right?
It's just like, it's the same vibe. It's not, it's not the board apes vibe. It's a little bit more of a bottom-up community driven project. But what would you say are the weaknesses of the CryptoPunks project that led you, that motivated you to start thinking about what a CryptoPunks 2.0 could look like? Yeah, sure. I mean, I wouldn't necessarily call them weaknesses. Like the way I've always thought about it, and I've said this on other podcasts, are that like CryptoPunks are sort of like, if you want to use a filmmaking analogy, CryptoPunks are like the Citizen Kane of the medium, right? Like they define the form.
And so, you know, it's inevitable that like when you push things to a certain extent, when you kind of define the form, there are certain things that will be missing just because, you know, by way of defining the form, you've covered, you know, 80% of the interesting ground, but, but maybe there's an additional 20% or more that, that hasn't been covered. I mean, for me, I think that the two, the two big things were like one, the, the sort of like lack of, of organizational structure, like lack of, I guess, doubt Dow infrastructure is, is how, how the problem was solved. Or maybe actually three things.
So the, the, the kind of the lack of, of organizational infrastructure such that like the punks could kind of on-chain coordinate their activities to do things together. The distribution mechanism. So like, is there a way that's kind of like more fair in terms of distribution for the kind of building of the community, right? Can that happen over a longer period of time rather than just being a function of like, you know, who happened to be online, you know, on a Thursday in 2017 when these were all released and claimed. And then the third thing was just this idea, and I guess I was probably most vocal about this, and this was one of the major motivating factors behind nouns, the idea that the JPEG, the thing that the token is referencing should kind of have this symmetry with the token itself, where it is as permissionless and open as the token.
So effectively putting all of the intellectual property into the public domain and making it CC0 so that people could use it and build on top of it without worry of what might become of the IP. Certainly. And 4156 is actually the name of your punk, not your noun. And so there's still a homage paid to the CryptoPunks there. And that's also shared by you, VapeVape. Your Twitter handle is punk4464. And so, Vape, I'll throw it to you. When you read 4156 tweet thread, what stuck out to you as like, ooh, neat? and captured your attention? Yeah, I think there was a lot of components around drops that were happening at that time.
It's kind of like the ICO era of the NFTs where there's a lot of 10K PFP drops and 4156 really laid out, I think, materially different and novel mechanism for both launching, distributing and governing a set of NFTs. And so that was initially very intriguing to me. Seneca, what about you? What about the tweet thread stuck out to you? Yeah, the one thing that really stuck out to me was the infinite aspect of it. The fact that it could go on so long as Ethereum lives on, nouns could go on forever. And that I feel is very unique to blockchain, something that couldn't really be done before. And so that unique property of it really reeled me in and got me thinking in a million different directions.
Right. And so as we've alluded to, there's a number of different things about the Nouns project that has captured so many different people's attentions. I think the distribution mechanism is a primitive that this industry is going to be able to take forward and use. And we've already seen this being used by little nouns. And I bet you there's a number of projects that I'm not familiar with that are using this mechanism. And I'm sure there's hundreds more that have yet to be released that are thinking about using this distribution mechanism. So who wants to take, how do we define what this distribution mechanism is?
Who wants to define the distribution mechanism for our audience out of you three? I mean, I can give it a try. You know, I mean, I think we've sort of like taken it to, taken to calling it a noun-ish distribution, whether it's, you know, used in the context of nouns or outside of it. But, you know, this idea that of like a continuous auction, I think is powerful for a few different reasons. You know, I think one is that it's just more fundamentally fair, like we alluded to when talking about CryptoPunks. You know, this idea that, you know, crypto history, if you've been around for a while, is just kind of like littered with these like very narrow windows of opportunity, right?
Like, were you here when the Ethereum crowd sale happened? You know, were you here when the Punks distribution happened? And, you know, we can probably collectively think of like a dozen of these examples. And so this idea that, you know, there could be equal opportunity for participation over this like extraordinarily long window of time, and that equal opportunity would create this kind of, you know, more credible neutrality, more fundamental fairness at the protocol layer, I think, ends up being quite important. Um, the, the, the other thing I would say is, is, um, that, that, you know, the, the, the Nounish distribution mechanism, the, the kind of like, um, continuous cadence, um, ends up, um, being important, um, for, for the reason that it, it potentially could create like a perpetual source of funding for an organization, right?
Um, this idea that, um, to the extent that, that there is a bid for, for nouns forever, that the organization always has this perpetual inflation to rely on, to fund itself, to organize itself. And of course, we've seen in the context of Ethereum versus Bitcoin, this idea that inflation is necessary to keep things working, I think is this important idea in crypto. And just to concretely define what this mechanism is, one noun per day is minted and sold. and in perpetuity forever. And was there any supply ahead of time or anything other than this mechanism? Or did the supply of nouns literally start at one and increase serially up from there?
Yeah, so the second tweet in the original kind of like white paper thread is initial supply of zero. So there were no nouns initially. And on the first day, one noun was created. And what was the price for the first noun, if you can remember? like who set that price how much did that go for um here we can we can pull it up you guys do you have it off the top of your head santa cara babe i think it was around 600 600 eath around there wow what about the second noun that was a big drop that we would have to look up so yeah i've got it here noun one was six six hundred and thirteen eath and then noun two was uh here one second go ahead 69.
69 eath of course of course this is one of the things that has really captured uh captivated me is because you know because there's such a strong supply constraint that it these prices of these nfts are off the charts. I mean, for a 10K PFP project that releases 10,000 all at once, they do a mint price of 0.03 or 0.5 if they're really expensive. But nouns are going for the lowest nouns for a while. I saw it going at 60, and now they're going at 100 or so. And it's off of... It's with such a low supply that you actually can command such a high price for these things even when it's like so early in the project, right?
And I thought just like this model of extremely constrained NFT release is actually a fantastic pricing mechanism because it's commanding prices that all the other NFT projects would have dreamed of. Vape, do you have any thoughts on this? Yeah, I think it's an interesting dynamic where all the demand for the project really gets funneled through this daily auction every day. And so we've seen relatively, you know, compared to other projects, relatively low secondary market movement usually happens after somebody has been outbid several times on the primary auction and they kind of capitulate and then go to OpenSea and will buy a noun there.
But this has been a really interesting mechanism for driving demand directly through the primary auction. You sort of get this continuous, you know, pricing of the noun as these auctions are happening every day. I think it's acted as a funnel for a lot of the community to come in sort of the front door, look at the primary auction, and try to compete there first before they ever go to secondary to try to score a noun that way. You know, there's also, I think there's a couple of other like interesting components related to nouns as a meme, right? Where it kind of like benefits from one, this idea that there's like a daily event, you know, we call it noun o'clock, this like daily cadence that happens every day where people want to pay attention to the project.
And then, you know, the other thing that, you know, it's a bit more in the weeds, but this idea that, that, um, you know, there's not kind of like explicit trait scarcity in the nouns universe. Like all nouns are, are in essence, like equally rare, but the thing that is sort of notable in that, in that context, like the thing that, that becomes rare is, um, the timestamp, right? Like the date on which the noun was minted, you know, is it a Christmas noun? Uh, and then also the ID, you know, how, how long have you been around the community? How long have you been in the project? If each ID sort of like, to an extent corresponds with day, the ID like sort of carries this meaning about, you know, time-based participation.
Interesting. Interesting. I mean, I was shocked to hear that noun number one went for 600 plus ETH. But I mean, if this nouns project is actually massive, having noun number one is kind of equivalent to a flex, even though noun number one is largely going to be like indistinguishable from noun number, like whatever, because like the properties are so random. it's actually the number one place that's actually kind of the unique thing about that, isn't it? That's right. Yeah. We've seen lower ID nouns go for a premium as well. So like a two-digit noun or a one-digit noun obviously fetches a higher premium than the current primary auction price.
One thing to add there with regards to the daily auction is that it served really well to prevent It's crazy hype cycles. So because you have the daily inflation, you tend not to see the pump and dump mechanics that you see in a fixed supply PFP project, which is nice because it sort of infiltrates the culture as to focusing on other things that are not price related. Right. The emphasis on the daily auction rather than the secondary market removes some of the bull market shenanigans that we saw with NFT projects. How much secondary market liquidity is there, though? And why would somebody go to the secondary market rather than be patient and wait for the primary?
yeah i i think um you know with with nouns there is a a real sense of i want to find my forever noun so given that there's only one daily auction right there's only one head that is being auctioned off with through the secondary you can find the the auction that that you prefer right the one that you actually want to hold okay so so is it so i'm sure some people would love to buy their forever noun off the daily auction and be like oh that this daily auction's mine but uh i mean we you know full disclosure i mean me and ryan have been waiting for like the bankless noun to pop up and it hasn't really have popped up yet and so at some point in time we're probably gonna have to peruse the secondary market to find like somebody with a bank head or something uh and but uh i'm sure many many other people are playing games like this i'm sure that is true the the the auction is a a big uh a big party every day as uh 41 kind of stated um bidding winning the audience that surrounds the auction every day is pretty fun um so yeah there's a whole event around the the auction and which which we call nine o'clock sir can we talk about some of the the properties uh first off who was who was the artist behind all of the properties how were they decided how is the art decided let's lean into like the art and the property side of things uh just who wants to who wants to tell this side of the story yeah sure i can i can tell this side of the story um yeah so so you know like again shortly after this tweet thread went out we we were kind of assembling the team of 10 nouners um in in uh the discord channel.
Um, and it, it was, uh, I think it was roughly like six kind of tech, technical nanders and, and, and four, um, four kind of artistic nanders. So there, there was a Grimplin who's a, of course, a very well-known NFT artist, uh, e-boy who, um, you know, they're, they're effectively like the godfather of, of, of pixel art, uh, tempers, uh, who, who is also a well-known pixel artist. Um, and then I, I worked on, on the artwork artwork as well, uh, to an extent. So it was really like the four of us that, that, um, kind of attempted to define the, the noun-ish, uh, aesthetic. Um, and, and that happened like relatively quickly, um, after we started working on the project.
Um, and, uh, what about, uh, just the properties who decided on what properties, how did that happen? Um, yeah, I mean, so, so I think we knew early on, that we didn't really want to emphasize kind of trait scarcity. So, so like really, we just started drawing stuff. And, and I think we, we, one of the, the kind of early decisions was that it would be pixel art. And that ended up being kind of very important in terms of storing the nouns actually on chain, right. And being able to kind of compress them such that they would fit on chain. And then, you know, we, we started trying to draw, you know, these characters with different kinds of heads.
um i believe so like i i think that the initial genesis was um uh gremlin drew this this like sort of like duck man type character uh and and it had the eyes like the you know the the very kind of contrasty characteristic eyes that the nouns have um and i i just kind of like took that image with another prototype i'd made and i i don't think it was like a a moment of genius or insight or anything it was just like goofing around i just drew the the glasses around his his eyes and you know just fired it back into the discord channel saying oh hey you know i think this looks kind of cute with your eyes and the glasses um and then we all i think we all just very quickly agreed that that it would be interesting if every single one of them was wearing the glasses and the the glasses could be this kind of like iconic you know central meme of of the project um and again you know it was this i think like the creation of nouns was was this like pretty special time, both in terms of the wider space, but also just in terms of like aggregating 10, like really world-class builders in a discord channel and just like, you know, going off for, for a couple of months.
And so like almost everything we did happen very, very quickly. You know, I think within about 24 hours, we had had sort of defined the nounish aesthetic. And then we, we went on Twitter and just started like asking people what, what sort of noun heads they'd like, and then drawing the noun heads for them. That was like the initial genesis of, of like coming up with the different ideas for the heads. And I'm sure you guys didn't have any specific criteria as to like what kind of head you would accept as an idea and what kind of head you would deny as an idea, but like overall, like what was the vibe?
Like what kind of ideas pass? Like, oh yes, we will do that as a head versus like, oh no, that's a bad idea. Was there any sort of like social contract about this? Um, I mean, you know, we, I think we, we did ultimately like filter and reject certain ideas. Like, you know, we didn't want to have like a gun, like, you know, there, there, there are certain properties of nounishness that, um, you know, it, it, it's a kind of optimism, uh, and kind of like absurdity and silliness. Um, so I think those were our filters. Um, you know, we, we ended up with about 235, uh, heads in the collection altogether.
And I, I think we cut probably about another 50 or so. So we, we drew 300 heads altogether, which is of course, you know, that's a lot of artwork. um so so you know we we kind of took to like within the the discord channel all just kind of like listing out nouns and then the artists kind of like picking up on the ones that they they thought were funny and and drawing them so you know it would be like a list of like igloo aardvark hair you know goldfish and then someone would go and draw the aardvark and and then we'd iterate on it from there so what are all the properties of a noun so you have the shirt you have the head you have the color of the glasses and then the hair, what are all the properties?
Yeah, sure. So, uh, there, there's a background, so it can be warm gray or cool gray, which I actually think is kind of to only two, only two. Yeah. And I actually think this is like one of the kind of underappreciated traits of, of nouns. Cause if you have like this sort of like binary trait, you can do all sorts of fun, fun things with it, right? Like someone could, could create a game that's like warm gray versus cool gray or you know maybe it's notable when there's like you know seven seven warm grays in a row that's like seven heads in a row and that's like a form of scarcity in the collection um so so the background color is can be warm warm or cool gray um there's a body um and and so you know the the body is is like the torso with with the kind of characteristic one arm um there's an accessory which in most cases is is just like an overlay on the body.
And then some of the more kind of the complicated looking accessories just kind of completely overlay the body. There's the head, of course, which is really what we define as the noun. And then there's the glasses. So there's about roughly about 20 different types of glasses. And so 4156, you have lol on your shirt. Seneca has pop on his shirt, their shirt. Are these the accessories? Or is that something else? yeah that's right that's right that's the accessory okay so there's there's not very many parameters there's not too many properties out there yeah that's right components yeah components excuse me yeah uh how many different shirts are there do you know off the top of your head uh here hang on it's on the answer wtf and uh while you're thinking about that i'll ask either seneca or vape just like what what's the uh what was the talk a little bit more about like the the choice behind not really having rarity in the properties.
Why was that important? Yeah, sure. I think it's important because within, you know, pre-nouns, the focus of a lot of PFP communities was always the trait rarity, right? So in effect, you'd have this hierarchy within the community. And I think one of the goals within Nouns was not to emphasize any sort of hierarchy between one member or the next, but rather we're all sort of more or less the same, right? That said, there are rarer heads just because one head can pop up once a year and another can pop up five, seven times a year. But to your question, it's not to build a hierarchy within the community.
Wait, so are those heads programmed to only show up once a year versus other heads are programmed to show up more often? Or is that just a... No, that was just an example of what could happen. So how, quote unquote, rarity is defined, although no noun is particularly rare, there can be rare nouns because randomness, right? So not too long ago, we had, I think, three voids, three void heads happen one after the next. Right. And so if you think about the amount of heads that there are, which correct me if I'm wrong, there's 230 something. yeah 234 right it's about one a year more or less one and a little bit more right so you'd expect that but given randomness you can uh you can see multiple heads happen in one year or three in a row as we saw recently right but it's not it's never ever programmed rarity and i really like this this concept because if everything if all properties are not are the same are treated equivalently then you have like emergent rarity right and so it's more about just like the random uh serendipity of certain properties coming together or like you said like the random serendipity of the days of of time in a row or just like rather than like controlling for rarity and having top-down uh rarity created by like the organizers you have like this bottom-up community decided what's rare uh which i think is a little bit more true to the ethos of crypto Totally.
It's chaotic rarity. And there's something to be said as well by by the since the only sort of quote unquote rarity is time. Right. If you have now one, two, three, you can think of rarity as well as now in 69 went for a lot higher than now in 68 or 70. You can imagine now in 420 we'll do something similar. And so, yeah, it's definitely chaotic rarity where there's no predefined rarity. It's more all nouns are rare, but then randomness will give us whatever it wants to give us. Yeah, and then just adding in there. So since we use the previous block hash as our source of randomness for the next noun that's minted, really interesting game called FOMO.
FOMO nouns has popped up where the community actually votes on. So as blocks are ticking by after an auction is finished, you can actually see if you were to mint in this particular block that's about to be mined next, you can actually determine what the noun is going to be. And so the community has created this voting game where they get on spaces every day and we play FOMO after the auction ends where you can actually, the community sort of voting up and down these various potential next nouns. And if there's enough upvotes on the next noun, then a transaction is triggered, the auction settlement happens, and the next noun is voted and minted on.
And so this has created sort of a game of aesthetics for the community where there's, you know, the community really wants aesthetic nouns, aesthetic nouns will drive more demand at the primary auction. And so the DAO started funding these FOMO games to sort of create this feedback loop of demand and aestheticism, which has sort of created this new game within the nouns ecosystem as well. And actually I do have FOMO nouns up on the screen right now. I know you guys can't see it, but the viewers can. That's pretty cool. but excuse me sorry um but also the jpeg's not necessarily the point right like i mean it's it's a fun feature but it's not the centerpiece is that a fair take of the nouns ecosystem i would say it's the centerpiece i think that yeah i mean i i think you could like there's lots of different ways to think about nouns but like i think you can in some sense like think of it like these sort of like concentric circles.
And, and I would, I would think that in that context, you would probably put like the meme, the artwork, the feeling in, in the center. Um, you know, you, you could maybe argue that like, it's the treasury in the center and it's the meme surrounding the treasury. But like, I, I think like I would personally view the treasury as like the means for proliferating the meme rather than the meme as like the way to accrue the treasury. Um, so I, I would probably put the noun-ish artwork and the noun-ish feeling in the center. In the center, or at least the next closest to the treasury. I think that is a fantastic way to segue into the second part of this conversation, which is the DAO aspect of nouns, because this is also something that's very, very unique about it.
But also 4156, you kind of alluded to it, is what is the long-term vision of this whole thing? What is the DAO oriented for? Are there success metrics? So we'll talk about all these conversations and more in the second half of the show, right after we get to some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. network all inside the Ledger Live app. Through a partnership with Figment, Ledger also lets you choose which validator you want to stake your assets with. And Ledger is running its own validating nodes, offering a convenient way to participate in network validation. And it even comes with slashing insurance.
Ledger Live is truly becoming the battle station for the bankless world. So go download Ledger Live. If you have a Ledger already, you probably already have it and get started securely staking your crypto assets. The Brave Browser is the user-first browser for the Web3 internet with over 60 million monthly active users. And inside the Brave browser, you'll find the Brave wallet, the secure multi-chain crypto wallet built right into the browser. Web3 is freedom from big tech and Wall Street, more control and better privacy. But there's a weak point in Web3, your crypto wallet. And most crypto wallets are browser extensions, which can easily be spoofed.
But the Brave wallet is different. No extensions are required, which gives Brave browser an extra level of security versus other wallets. Brave wallet is your secure passport for the possibilities of Web3 and supports multiple chains, including Ethereum and Solana. You can even buy crypto directly inside the wallet with Ramp. And of course, you can store, send, and swap your crypto assets, manage your NFTs, and connect to other wallets and DeFi apps. So whether you're new to crypto or you're a seasoned pro, it's time to ditch those risky extensions and it's time to switch to the Brave wallet.
Download Brave at brave.com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. The Layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's Layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day and we need Layer 2 bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a Layer 2 life. Across is the fastest, cheapest, and most secure cross-chain bridge. With Across, you don't have to worry about high fees or long wait times. Assets are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously. Across's bridges are powered by UMA's optimistic oracle to securely transfer tokens between Layer 2s and Ethereum. Across's critical ecosystem infrastructure and Across V2 has just launched.
Their new version focuses on higher capital efficiency, Layer 2 to Layer 2 transfers, and a brand new chain with Polygon, all while prioritizing high security and low fees. You can be a part of Across's story by joining their Discord and using Across for all of your Layer 2 transferring needs. So go to across.to to quickly and securely bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Polygon, Arbitrum, or Boba networks. All right, ladies and gentlemen, we are back in the second half of the show where we're going to talk about Nouns Governance. And Governance over Nouns DAO is different than Governance over your particular DeFi app or your particular DAO, because it's governance by NFT, not by ERC20.
And so who wants to take the difference between governing an organization by an NFT versus an ERC20 and why this is perhaps better? Question mark, if you do believe it's better. Who wants to take this part of the story? 4156, go for it. Yeah, sure. I mean, I think, you know, for context, I haven't spent much time at all in, in any like ERC 20 DAOs. Um, you know, it's kind of funny, like in, in the kind of initial specification for nouns, I just, you know, I had this idea that a DAO would be cool and kind of dashed off this idea that, you know, oh, there, you know, there should be a DAO attached to, to the NFT collection without necessarily understanding like the gravity of, of, of what that would mean long-term and, and, you know, like all, all of the, the kind of complexity that, that goes with it, but, you know like the the high level one noun is one vote right one one nft is one vote so in in essence you can think that you know when a noun is being auctioned every day yes like there's you know there's a jpeg there's a kind of like meme nft being auctioned but also there's like one vote one membership one voting membership in this organization that's being auctioned every day um and you know to to the extent that um i guess like non-fungible uh governance tokens kind of produce different outcomes than fungible governance tokens.
These are the differences in behavior of nouns DAO voters. But I would say my best guess is that the effects of the votes being non-fungible are, at least at this point in history, sort of negligible. I think a lot of the positive outcomes that we've seen on the DAO side of things related to engagement and things like that are really like much more a function of, of like now the noun ish meme and the culture. And then also like the slow cadence of, of like Dow membership growth, rather than like being specific to the idea that, that votes are non-fungible. Hey babe, do you have any experiences that you want to share about nouns governance and how it's unique?
Yeah, I think some other interesting aspects are around the treasury, like the assets that make up the treasury. So we, you know, our project makes ETH and ETH goes directly in the treasury where a lot of other DAOs have sort of minted their own token and the bulk of their treasury is this minted ERC-20 token that they've created. And they, you know, do other things to try to convert that into ETH or stables to do various DAO operations. And I guess what's interesting about nouns is there's no native mechanism to get nouns into the treasury. So this has been a big topic of conversation of like, how do we get nouns in the treasury?
Some people prefer to be compensated in nouns for the proposals rather than ETH as well, or some combination of the two. So I think that's been another interesting dynamic. And I also think like the proposals are, in some sense, compared to other DAOs, like much less risky, right? So when you're talking about a compound or another, you know, pretty heavy hitting DeFi protocol, every proposal is under an intense amount of scrutiny because if you set these parameters incorrectly on a money market or something like that, very bad things can happen where we can sort of throw a lot of darts against the wall here and try a lot of different experiments.
And sort of the impact of an individual proposal or individual initiative is probably a lot less than going and tweaking parameters down the smart contract layer for these various DeFi protocols. One thing I'd add there is on the conversation of NFTs versus ERC20s, I think what 41 said is true, the fact that it is the now-nix culture that allows us to do all these quote-unquote fun things versus when you compare it to changing parameters in a finance protocol. There's also when you talk about the voting token, when you're when you talk about that NFT, it's not this faceless sort of fungible thing that you have 10,000 of, but rather it's it's a noun.
It's a thing with eyes. It's an identity almost. Right. And you sort of become that within the DAO. And I think that plays a role in in in how the DAO not necessarily functions, but maybe the engagement in how people feel towards government governance and in the community as a whole. Yeah, go for it. Oh, yeah, I was just gonna add to that, you know, and that's a great point. I was just gonna add to that, that, like, if you go to nouns.wtf and kind of take a look at any specific noun, you can actually see the voting record of that noun, you can see everything that it's done. So, I mean, yeah, that's certainly true that, you know, the non-fungible nature of nouns governance kind of lets the NFT sort of have a track record of participation.
So you get both an identity and then also this kind of like persistent track record of how that identity behaves. It's interesting to put an identity onto an NFT. And that's often like that's a meme in like the NFT space. like like you know board apes are an identity for many many people but board apes don't represent like one membership vote in a DAO and so like that is like the unique angle and so I would imagine if you go to like the nouns governance forums and like you see a proposal and you see people commenting on that proposal and they all have nouns as their profile picture probably and like you're looking into those nouns as you do governance stuff so like that dynamic I don't think exists anywhere else across across defy especially not with like erc20 token like you when somebody proposes something it's like oh yeah it's that one noun with like the banana head or something they're always voting about this stuff and that's that's unique and i think probably adds a little bit more of an engaging governance experience is that is that am i on the right track here yeah for sure i think it also like an important thing about it is that it sort of like de-risks the enterprise, right?
Like there's a sense, I mean, Vape was alluding to this with all of the kind of like DeFi projects. Like there's the sense that like all of these things that are built on top of this, like very new and experimental tech stack are like so serious and so high stakes and so intense. And so like, you know, the idea that it's like a banana and a milk carton and like a horse, you know, and a cotton ball are like collectively, you know, controlling tens of millions of dollars to do governance. Like it somehow kind of makes it feel like a bit more absurd, which is, I think, probably like a little bit more closely aligned with the stage of crypto history that we're in.
So what would you guys say is the direction of the DAO? Was the Nouns DAO established with some sort of like, here's our goal, here's what we want to do? Or has that kind of been left up to the community? Or overall, like what would you say is like, what's progress defined by? by the nouns. Seneca or Vape Vape, you want to take this one? Either you two, Seneca, go for it. Yeah, so I think to a large degree, the sort of direction of the DAO and where the treasury is allocated has been left up to the community. That said, I do think there's a culture, which is what we call a nounish culture, that is very hard to define, but I think everybody more or less abides by it and thus votes accordingly.
So things that are nounish get whopping 90% votes. Things that are obviously not nounish don't do as well. And so the question then is like, what exactly is nounish, right? And I think the answer would be a bit different between members and people within or outside the community. But I definitely say it's something it's something along the lines of optimistic uh 41 mentioned absurdist definitely has that that component um trying new things right there there is that culture that that is being defined but it's very mushy it's very meat space it's there's no sort of technical around it but um yeah so and then going back to to your question i think at the very beginning our focus was optimized for getting anything out of out the door right so fun whatever does uh proliferate the meme but i feel that as we've grown as we continue to grow and evolve the the nounish meme what started as maybe just the glasses and an aesthetic uh becomes something much deeper right and so for example while initially you could fund you know merch with announced glasses Now you see more trying to fund more, how do you say it, more ambitious projects, right?
Something like public infrastructure, which doesn't necessarily proliferate the glasses per se, but it does proliferate a sense, a meaning that goes much beyond the glasses themselves. so what would like victory or success look like for a noun style if we like fast forward 5 10 15 years into the future and however you define it nouns the noun style is super successful what does that look like like how how would we gauge success i mean i would say one of the ways i think about it and again this is this is not you know i i i I think we try to avoid saying, you know, this is the direction that the DAO should go.
I think like to actually have like a truly kind of permissionless DAO, permissionless pool of capital, you know, it's, of course, up to the DAO to determine its own direction. And, you know, as Seneca was kind of describing, like that will be like a function of certain kind of initial conditions, right, including the meme and the nounish feeling. Um, but you know, when, when, when I think about like, you know, what, what is the best possible case here? You know, what, like what, what could this, this become kind of in, in, in the maximum? I, I would, I would think about it as like potentially the, the, the governance layer of the metaverse, right?
Like the, the idea that, um, maybe the first instance of nouns to, to the extent that, you know, we're, we're correct or, or that we've actually like invented something substantial, right? The first instance of that substantial thing, and again, to the extent that that thing is kind of like auctioning daily NFTs, like the first instance of that substantial thing would have the kind of greatest claim on sort of like provenance, right? And that would make its NFTs the most valuable. Um, and, and, and that would mean that, you know, it, it would kind of accumulate the most capital and it would have the most capital to, to kind of like distribute, you know, what, whatever that capital might be used for if it's, if it's public goods funding or, or kind of like funding Ethereum infrastructure, et cetera.
Um, and, and, you know, the, I think the feedback loop in the long run would be that, you know, the, the, the kind of larger the pool of capital becomes and kind of like the more influential the organization becomes, the more kind of valuable or the more kind of critical, um, it is to be a member of that organization, right? And so in the long run, you could imagine that at scale, you know, Ethereum has scaled, the kind of economic bandwidth of Ethereum has scaled, the value of the ETH and the treasury has, you know, increased by a couple of orders of magnitude. And, you know, there are lots and lots of these kind of nounish DAOs that kind of point back to the original as having this kind of like provenance.
You know, in this scenario, nouns are very valuable, and the organization is very large. And in this context, I think you would probably expect that most individual nouns would not be owned by a singular person, but they would potentially be owned by communities because those communities would want to kind of share the cost of ownership. And those communities themselves could then become organizations, you know, maybe organizations as large as nouns is today. You could have a single noun, you know, noun 386 or 387 or whatever, has a community of members and kind of engaged members kind of on the order of magnitude of nouns today.
And then nouns kind of like the, you know, the DAO, the meta organization is sort of like, you know, the UN of all the individual nouns and all of those kind of individual nouns have participants and delegates that choose how the individual noun votes. So, you know, I think it's certainly possible to imagine the organization kind of like scaling up to look something like this over the next few years. And I think that that would probably be like the best case scenario we can imagine today for the future of the project. I think I may be able to add anything to that. hard to follow that up i think we talk about this stuff a lot of times so so yeah i think i echo a lot of the uh the narrative there and the goal there and um yeah i mean i think you know first is trying to reach some sort of brand ubiquity within nft culture the metaverse culture um that's really kind of the stage we're at now and then i think 4156 did a good job of laying out yeah kind of the future vision here.
Yeah, likewise, I echo everything that both 41 and Vape said. The one thing I'd add is with that sort of meta org, I think the one thing I focus on a lot is what do the rails on which that org runs on look like, right? And that takes a lot of innovation, a lot of building both within the governance layer, for example, on the IP layer, on the funding layer. There's a bunch of things to tackle that I think if we are to be successful, we have to build a lot of this infrastructure for the rest of the organizations to be able to easily build on. I'm wondering of all the proposals that go through nouns, governance, how much of them like what proportion of them is like promoting the nouns brand or versus something to do with like the treasury so for example like i could see nouns uh either like using something like oval network or just whatever just like staking their eth right and like growing the treasury that way or diversifying their treasury into something else or just like it one possible future of Nouns now, in addition to growing the brand, is also like growing the treasury via like on-chain investments or maybe off-chain investments.
I don't really know. Is there any like, is there any proposals or in like something in the culture of Nouns to do some of just like direct treasury management and like an actual investment with the funds that Nouns have available? Or is it more focused on just the brand side of things? yeah you can go ahead yeah i see you guys like muting and muting each other yeah sure so i mean um you know i think again it it is ultimately up up to the dow to to decide but um i i would i would say that it there there are some kind of incentives to to kind of like stay away from kind of complex you know management of the treasury you know one like the the kind of like the form, the form factor of like doing that is, is, is challenging.
You know, there's all kinds of like added like regulatory complexity and risk in doing it. And then I just think like the risk reward is probably such that there's just like a lot more leverage in, in kind of proliferating the brand, proliferating the meme, kind of funding, funding public goods, making people aware of nouns than there is in like trying to earn, you know, some, some kind like APY on the treasury. You know, the treasury is denominated in ETH. I think most of us who like deeply understand Ethereum are like extraordinarily bullish on, you know, the future of the asset. And to the extent that nouns is, you know, treasury is denominated in ETH, our card is sort of like hitched to something that has a very bright future.
And really like, you know, nouns won't necessarily succeed until Ethereum kind of like, nouns won't succeed at the scale that we think it can until Ethereum kind of like scales its economic bandwidth by a factor of 10 to 100, which would mean a scaling of the treasury by a factor of 10 to 100. So in that sense, I think it's just like, you know, kind of accumulate the ETH, you know, we stake the ETH, we do some like very basic stuff. But in my view, there's just so much more upside that's possible than kind of, you know, some kind of yield on the treasury. Well, Fam, thank you so much for for joining me.
And I know I could keep on talking about nouns with you guys for another hour, but I have the nouners coming on the show on Wednesday. So I'm going to talk about their perspectives of nouns now. What should I ask them? I'd love to know what you guys think that I should ask the nouns, the noun holding community about their perspective on things. Do you have any question or question suggestions for me that I should ask them? yeah i think there's been a really interesting dialogue around uh potential failure modes for nouns and so it's something that we talk about a lot i think that it'd be interesting to get some broader perspectives on uh community members because you know we're pretty headed heads and head down head in the weeds over here um and so talking about a lot of the various failure modes that are uh possible i think that's probably an interesting topic to touch on I think it'd be very interesting to ask them about the Nounders.
I think we kind of look at the community and have things that we want to work on and things that we think should be prioritized in terms of risks. It'd be interesting to know what they think we should be spending time on. And then also just how much involvement, how much direction do they think we should kind of continue to have in the project? Again, we have internal discussions and ideas about what is correct, but it'd be interesting to hear the noun owner perspective on that topic. Edek, anything from you? Yeah, I'd ask them each specifically, what's top of mind within nouns? And more importantly, why is it that?
Not much else. I think 41's question will be an interesting one. Well, thank you for helping me write my agenda for next Wednesday. So I appreciate that. Seneca, VapeApe4156, is there anything that you guys want to say before we sign off? The nouniversary is on August 8th. So that will be one year of nouns every day. So happy nouniversary. I'm sure that noun will have a decent premium associated with it. I'm sure it will. Awesome, guys. Well, thank you so much for joining me on this show, exploring the noun style. Again, the first ever two-part series that we've done on Bankless. So, nouners, thank you so much for joining me.
Thanks for having us. Like I said, for everyone watching the stream or watching, or if you're watching the stream, the nouners will be coming on in about 48 hours. So, it'll be happening on Wednesday. If you're listening to this on the podcast, that means it's Tuesday. So, then I'm having the nouners on tomorrow, the next day, Wednesday. Either way, I will see you there and thank you everyone for tuning in Cheers