Welcome to BanklessTV, featuring Peter Van Valkenburgh from Coin Center and David Morris of The Rage, freshly back from the SDNY courtroom with the inside scoop on the Roman Storm verdict. In this episode we unpack the split decision—how Storm beat the money-laundering and sanctions-evasion counts yet was found guilty on the hot-button “unlicensed money-transmission” charge—and what that single conviction means for every non-custodial developer in crypto. Peter breaks down the legal tightrope between FinCEN guidance and DOJ prosecution, outlines three clear appeal paths (including the Blockchain Regulatory Certainty Act), and explains why Roman’s case could still become a rallying point for financial-privacy legislation. David shares firsthand color from the trial: jury deadlocks, high-stakes witness drama, and the emotional moment Storm walked free to see his daughter. Join us to hear why this verdict is both a wake-up call and an opportunity, what Congress, the courts, and the next administration might do next, and how the outcome could reshape DeFi, privacy tech, and open-source innovation for years to come.
------
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAX | SELF SUFFICIENT DeFi
https://bankless.cc/Frax
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
https://bankless.cc/unichain
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
https://bankless.cc/Mantle
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:28 Introduction to the Roman Storm Case
0:58 Reflections on the Verdict
3:37 Understanding the Charges
4:07 Breakdown of the Conspiracy Counts
8:40 The Sentencing Landscape
9:29 Courtroom Atmosphere and Reactions
11:18 The Appeal Process
15:20 Roman's Optimism After the Verdict
17:08 Legal Standards and Implications
21:58 The Role of FinCEN Guidance
26:03 The Bigger Picture for DeFi
29:25 Jury Dynamics Explained
34:08 Optimistic Outcomes and Future Paths
36:25 Legislative Changes Ahead
39:54 The Potential for Re-prosecution
47:43 The Impact of Political Climate
51:37 Paths to Clarity in Legislation
55:45 The Future of Non-Custodial Projects
1:02:08 The Importance of Precedent
1:08:27 Closing Thoughts on the Case
1:09:13 A Call to Action for Support
1:15:37 Supporting the Cause
1:18:13 Final Reflections on the Journey
------
RESOURCES
Support The Rage’s on-the-ground reporting
https://therage.co/donate
Support Coin Center’s policy work (fiat & crypto options)
https://coincenter.org/donate
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
All right, Ben Clisnation, we are live with Peter Van Valkenberg from Coin Center and David Morris from The Rage. Peter, you've been on the show before. David, you're brand new. David, you have been reporting, doing some of the most in-depth reporting in the front lines in the courtroom with the Roman Storm case. We are, I think this took four plus weeks for all of this to wrap up and we just got the verdict just a few hours ago. About three and a half weeks. Three and a half weeks, yeah. Just as a naive, non-lingual, legal-minded person, my summary of the verdict so far is mixed with definitely cause for concern.
I think if we are primarily concerned with Roman Storm, the individual, we are happy. He is flying home to Seattle tomorrow to spend time with his daughter, but the story is not over. As an industry, a crypto industry, there are things to be concerned about and the fight continues. That's kind of my summation of everything. Maybe you can give me your immediate thoughts and reflections since you were just there and you watched things go down firsthand. Yeah, I think that the verdict reflects sort of a really thorough chaos at every level of this proceeding from start to finish. There were really constant fights and constant uncertainty about which witnesses would be admitted what they would be allowed to talk about within some very fine green lines.
Just to pick one example off the top of my head, there was considerable discussion and debate over whether evidence could be allowed with that. Crypto holders were threatened with kidnapped or physical danger because of the public nature of blockchain addresses. In fact, one witness for the defense was sort of talking about hiding his investment portfolio online and not wanting to have a quote-unquote target on his back. Then there was a big objection and that was taken as some metaphor for physical threat. This is just one example of things were being fought on a moment-to-moment basis with incredible precision about the nature of the language being used around every charge.
At the same time, the government had some real problems with the evidence that it did get in, particularly reliable tracing of whether certain transactions ever actually connected to tornado cash. One of the jury questions that came back very late in the process was having to do with whether intermediary wallets that connected a big hack to the sanctioned North Korean hackers and in turn to tornado cash. The question came up from the jury, are these intermediary wallets also sanctioned? This is just one example of very fine details that sometimes were glossed over by the prosecution and I think that the confusion of the verdict which on two counts was no verdict at all, not guilty but no consensus could be reached.
I think that that really does reflect both the ambiguity of what they were being tasked with interpreting and just the general complexity and difficulty of the case, as well as I think some skepticism on the substance from the jury for sure. So maybe just to provide maybe a map for listeners to really understand and navigate this question, there are three counts that we need to pay attention to and each one of these things is a conversation in and of itself. And on each one of these things is there's just confusion generally. So maybe I'll turn to Peter. Peter, can you talk about the three counts that Roman was up against and what happened on the outcome of each individual one?
And we'll just keep at high level at first and we'll kind of dive into them as we go on. So simply stated, all three counts are conspiracy charges. I want to say that off the bat, which means you don't have to prove that they did the target offense. You have to prove that they agreed with others. So it'd be Roman. It might be Alexi Pertsov, the developer that's charged in the Netherlands. It might be other co-conspirators unnamed as well. You need to prove that Roman agreed with these other co-conspirators to do the offense and took one tangible step towards that offense. And then what are the three offenses?
The first one is money laundry. So that's knowingly and with intent hiding the proceeds of some illicit activity, some crime. So you're making it hard for law enforcement to investigate the trail of money in a crime. The second is unlicensed money transmission, which, and I'll probably talk the most about this one. And this is also the one where he was found guilty, the only charge that stuck for the jury. Where this one is you were transmitting money and you didn't have a license. And in the specific subcharge of unlicensed money transmission, it was transmitting money without a license and knowing that the money you're transmitting is the proceeds of crime is an illicit transaction.
And then the third charge was evasion of sanctions. And so what specifically alleged in that charge is, well, we know that North Korea used tornado cash, North Korea, the Lazarus group, the hacker group, after they hacked the Ronan bridge, used tornado cash to hide their hack, North Korea, and the Lazarus group are sanctioned entity. So you conspired to evade US sanctions along with others, which ostensibly could even extend to North Koreans. And so it's conspiracy in all those cases. And you know, the case is incredibly weak in a lot of regards. First and foremost among them, just with respect to conspiracy, like there isn't evidence that Roman, you know, got on the phone with somebody else in the world and said, I know you've got some, you've got some illicit funds, you've got some proceeds of crime, I'll help you hide them.
That's the simplistic view of money laundering. That's what a jury expects with money laundering. Nothing to that effect in this case. You know, there's a lot of allegations of, you know, he produced the software, he knew that people would be using this software in a certain way, and therefore he should be culpable. But that's a very different legal standard than proving agreement and a tangible step towards committing the crime. We can talk more about why the unlicensed money transmission charge is particularly upsetting to me, and that is the one charge where he's found guilty. The first and the third charge, the money laundry charge and the sanctions evasion charge, we got a hung jury.
And that means that, you know, under the six amendment of our Constitution under New York law, you need unanimous juries in order to find that someone is guilty of a crime, and actually also to find whether someone's not guilty. And if you can't force the jury to agree, if they can never come together, then you get a hung jury or a mistrial for that count. And David, you were there all day and no, no better than I. And thank you so much for your reporting, by the way, David, you and the rage have done. The judge even gave the jury an instruction saying, I need you guys to reach an agreement and the defense pushed back on that said they shouldn't be forced to reach an agreement.
And then ultimately the judge gave the instruction, but the jury still wouldn't agree on those first and third charges, which I think just speaks to, as David said, the confusing case presented by the government and the very weak legal ground that they were on as far as like showing that he was actually culpable of these crimes. Just just to recap those three counts, right? So the first count was hungary, not unanimous. The third count was, I thought it was not holding you, but it was the same. No, it was, yeah, it was misreported. What I'm sharing on the screen was misreported. So the first and third were on unanimous.
Hung jury. And basically that means you don't, you don't have agreement. You need a complete agreement for those. And you're not guilty. The ramification does mean that the government can regroup as to re-prosecute, which would be bad. But that would be their choice. The DOJ would have to continue to be as aggressive as the DOJ has been with respect to this case and continue to pursue that. Now, and the second count was guilty. And as interesting at high level, let's talk about like for Roman, right? There was the max charge was like 45 years of jail time for across all three of these counts.
And so the, but since the first and the second and the third were hungary, the second where he was convicted as guilty by this jury actually is five years in prison. Is that maximum? Of course. Okay. All right. So he, he, some scary ones, I guess, for Roman were avoided in this case, which is, I guess, part of the, I don't know if this is a silver lining here or like how we're actually viewing the outcome. But I don't know what I'd like to do. Maybe first is here. David, when, when that, the judge was going through this in the courtroom, because you were there, like, what was the atmosphere? What was, what was kind of going on?
What did Roman look like? What did the prosecution look like? I saw, I quote, like the judge has to instruct the jury and all members in court to like show no emotion. So I don't know if that held. Well, first of all, I would, I would add one other item to your inventory of like silver linings or whatever you would call them, which is that the prosecution did after the verdict was was sitting make a motion to remand Roman to jail while he awaited sentencing on the one conviction charge. They made the argument that he was a flight risk because of his international, international connections and access to capital and resources.
The, the defense made the counter argument that, you know, they were planning to appeal this. And ultimately the judge did not choose to remain in custody. He's going to be out on bail. It's secured against his house in Seattle. And what was very interesting about that moment was, and this is the big silver lining. And I think of this for everybody not just Roman is the judge said, just in open court, while we were there observing that there were many roads to appeal on this particular conviction count. I'm sorry, my cat is Jane here. But judge file had said that there are many many options for appeal essentially she just acknowledged it directly.
And that was in fact part of the logical for choice not to remand Roman to custody wall awaiting sentencing. She basically gave a certain amount of a vote of confidence to the appeal that is likely to be filed even on this count. But as to the bigger question of atmosphere, I think that I would define for the most part the atmosphere as very professional on all sides. Roman was extremely stoic for most of the trial. And I think that it probably was to his advantage. He didn't show a lot of like, you know, stress behaviors or anything like that. And my main point of reference for a lot of these things is the sampling and free trial and Sam sort of notoriously was like twitching and playing on his laptop for the entire thing.
And Roman was not even doing not not doing anything really just like closely observing. I will say that it was pretty interesting in the last couple of days. I think maybe it was Monday. There were, you know, a long period of you just wait in the empty courtroom for the jury while they deliberate. And for the journalists, you're kind of sitting there waiting for that verdict to come back so you can then go and, you know, report it and have your after action report and and let people know. But the council and Roman himself were also sitting there for a lot of the time while we're waiting on this verdict.
So you, you know, you sit there and you see this guy waiting to see what's going to happen with his life. And he was very stoic through much of that. But then starting on Monday, he actually sort of was mingling with, you know, there were supporters there in the gallery observing the trial. And he's sort of very briefly. And to a certain extent, I'm not sure whether this is like entirely kosher appropriate. But, you know, he seemed in fact somewhat relaxed. He seemed to be really optimistic as the jury debated. And there was reason for this because one of the sort of rules of thumb of criminal trials is that, you know, in a guilty verdict, the jury generally comes back very quickly.
If they've made up their minds and they, they, especially if they've decided guilty, they tend to come back quickly. The, the safe moon trial, which happened recently, I think the jury took four hours to reach the conclusion. I think in SPF, it might have been as little as like three hours. And so then by the time we were coming to Monday and the jury by then had already been in deliberation for almost 10 hours and was in its second day and even began like, you know, by Tuesday, we had no. By the end of the day Monday, the jury was trying to figure out its schedule for the entire week, which was really striking.
We had one juror juror number five, I believe, who had a heart out at the end of this week. So she would have had to leave, which would have meant actually adding in an alternate juror who hadn't been present for deliberation and restarting the entire deliberation process. So that was one factor on Tuesday, a juror had a grandmother whose 90th birthday was happening and a pedicure appointment and a pedicure and unfortunately the pedicure had to go. And so on Tuesday morning, they were there for half a day and, you know, we were kind of digging in and I was starting to frankly feel a little bit of despair at my fate, but it did come in a little bit sooner.
And yeah, so I guess my summation would be that it was actually like, I think that Roman was feeling optimistic towards the end and it turns out somewhat rightly so. It's certainly for for his own, you know, safe. In addition to everything you said, you just said, we have this tweet from Eleanor Tara who tweeted out that she saw Roman storm coming out of the classroom and she asked her to excuse me. It feels like a classroom a lot of the time. She said in a quiet voice, but with a noticeable smile, Roman said it's a big win. The 1960 charge which we'll get into is bullshit and we're going to fight it all the way.
And so I think in like I was actually able to meet Roman just for a dinner this last weekend and he feels very convicted in that he has a 99% chance. This was before the verdict was ever read that he had a 99% chance of a mistrial because of shenanigans that were going on in the courtroom between the prosecution and the judge. And that he alluded to the fact that the prosecution and the judge seemed to be very friendly and there was, yeah, I guess shenanigans might be the best word. Maybe you can comment on if what you saw as are related to anything anything messy in the trial, David. I mean, a lot was messy and you know, with with all due respect to Roman though, I will say I think that judge Fyla did throw a lot of decisions to the defense as well as the prosecution.
And some were pretty substantial in terms of like setting the table in a way that let them get their point across. So I mean, for example, on this question of crypto kidnappings and blackmail and things like this. So obviously the defense wants to like put forward the broader context of there's a privacy issue here with life on the blockchain. And this product was created to fulfill a very specific need and there was this kind of like entirely non criminal reason that Roman storm was building this tool. And part of how they sort of ideally wanted to drive that home was to make reference to some of the crimes that have been committed against people whose holdings were were visible on the blockchain.
And you know, judge Fyla. I think there was some misinterpretation, frankly, online of this motion in particular where judge Fyla, you know, ultimately said the reason this matters is how much it speaks to Roman storm state of mind when he was creating tornado cash because again this conspiracy charge is about their men's ray of their state of mind. During the creation and then to a certain extent ongoing in their operation of elements of the tornado cash system. And so what she allowed was anything that predated or coincided with the 2020 to 2022 period that was in question for the trial, she said you can bring this up because it's plausibly an influence on Roman storm state of mind.
And basically she did let the jury let the defense bring that in it is certain to a certain extent to show that this privacy issue was part of what shaped Roman's thinking for building the tool. So, you know, I certainly and to be clear, you know, we only have access to what's going on in this is the third time he's tried it guys this is everybody. But, you know, anything so she just to say that George judge Fyla we don't have access anything it's not happening in open court, but judge Fyla to my observation of that part of the proceeding was really calling balls and strikes and you know it's worth keeping in mind that at various stages she she has, you know, expressed skepticism of the government's case in proceedings.
That I think shows her open mindedness inevitably the SCNY lawyers the prosecutors inevitably have a better relationship with the judge than the defense. This this prosecution team specifically included Thane ran who was part of SBF's prosecution team and he you know they just tried cases in this courthouse full time they cross paths with these judges. The defense team I think mostly is based in California closer to Roman so they don't have that kind of intimacy with the judge on an individual personal basis, although I will say the judge also seemed quite personally fond of one of the defense lawyers.
Gosh, why am I forgetting her name axle carry carry axle they they had some good banter, you know, so even on a personal level the judge was not like icing the defense or anything like that that I saw. So yeah, I don't you know I don't think there's there's shenanigans at stake I would say that you know judge Fyla actually had a prior career as a prosecutor and did prosecute on licensed money transmission crimes in the SDNY so you know this is her territory and I think some of that goes to maybe informing her legal reasoning which I think is wrong. But you know it's our that's the way our judicial system works the judge rules on the law and that could be appealed and so there's absolutely nothing inappropriate there but I think I think she wasn't in many ways a tough judge for Roman to have but a fair judge and it's time to appeal that bad legal reasoning which we'll get.
Okay, so that's the thing we could still appeal the count that he was convicted on that still they will and they will and what's the probability that that not only yet not only that but and this is something so. To go back to Roman's statement that Eleanor reported it's a big win the 1960 charges bullshit and we're going to fight it all the way. You know I'm glad he's feeling optimistic glad he wasn't thrown jail immediately that was an important procedural step he's right it's bullshit. You know coin centers been ringing the alarm bell on 18 USC 1960 and unlicensed money transmission prosecutions now for years including working with Finson in 2019 to make sure that when they offered guidance on who's a money transmitter and needs to get a license in the crypto space.
They offered really clear guidance that said the only people who need to register under our rules set and were the money transmitter regulator at the federal level are people with total independent control of customer funds and you know Roman built some smart contracts and maintained a front end but never had any control of customer. That was 2019 guidance that Finson the only guidance that Finson was a regulator of this territory has ever provided crypto has been basically that fits non custody these things don't apply to you. You don't need to go get a license you don't need to register with us you don't need to worry about doing a ML KYC and so the question is if that's been the loss in 2019 if Romans lawyers because he had lawyers when he was building tornado cash relied on that guidance and gave him regulatory counsel.
If others in the space like Uniswap or God knows who else relied on that guidance wire people being prosecuted. But here's what I didn't understand why couldn't the prosecution just be like here's our case it's here's the guidance that was given us here's the rulemaking from a regulator like Roman doesn't hit any of these boxes you mean defense yeah defend excuse me case close how is that not case close they did and this goes to some complex issues here so what we just learned about is the jury's verdict of the facts but to me one of the biggest losses in this case was actually last way. And it's when judge failure ruled on the motion to dismiss and the defense in the motion of the dismiss on the unlicensed money transmission charge said this is absurd you know you're accusing of unlicensed money transmission but the regulator on point said that someone without total independent control that doesn't need to license with us so like this this charges utterly inappropriate should be should be thrown out on legal grounds right not even fit for a jury to rule on judge fair.
Judge failup agreed with the prosecution ultimately that the criminal code which is 18 USC nineteen sixty has a different definition of money transmission then the bank secrecy act which is the regulatory code that fins and offers guidance on and that they overlap but are not fully you know code terminus and so criminal code can be interpreted broader than the federal regulations under the bank secrecy act and therefore. So they can proceed with this prosecution. Wow someone should mention that in the roadmaking I mean come on. Wow well it and it speaks to a lot of things that I think are going to come up on appeal and to Romans sort of energy about that appeal is there some massive due process issue here you know in this country under the due process cause of our constitution you can't be held culpable for a crime if the law was not clear on the books as to what course of conduct you were and we're not supposed to take right and not only do we have a lack of clarity we have been.
So basically contradictory statements from the regulator you get a license from and from the prosecutors who then say actually you did need a license even though the regulator told you not to and you have these conflicting definitions you have ambiguities between the criminal code and the regulatory code and when you have ambiguities you do as an innovator you're supposed to say oh well should I listen to the regulator should I read the criminal code myself or have my lawyer read it and just think about the worst way a prosecutor would squeeze that to hurt me now if you're very risk averse you might do that and those are all the people who decided not to build tornado cash right even though it's a good tech to build.
On the law another thing that should be brought up on appeal apart from due process is lenity if there's ambiguity in the code like we don't know exactly what the word money transmission means because the regulator defined it one way in the criminal code you suggest defines it another if there's ambiguity and someone's liberty is on the line the rule of lenity in judicial theory in an American constitutional practice says that you have to interpret it in the way favorable to the person whose liberty is on the line which would be a narrow definition of money transmission not. It's not one that allows them to go after effectively anyone so that aspect of this prosecution has always been hyper aggressive and it really does stem back to the origins of this prosecution which is the prior administration it's not exactly like there was a massive conspiracy against crypto but we as as we know from looking against their at the SEC from the policies at Treasury from the investigations into other defi protocols and from the prosecutions of Roman and the samurai wallet developers which was a Bitcoin privacy wallet there was a lot of energy gold.
And some of that slowed down some of that stopped you know we got to a point where now with the SEC Hester purse the commissioner is issuing amazing speeches about the importance of financial privacy in crypto but it hasn't fully slowed down it hasn't fully stopped. So Peter if it was if it is so obviously BS right you could understand what like I'm there's a world where you see why the DOJ and prosecution went after him and storm this way and maybe even failure you're like allowing this case to continue but what was in the jury's head I mean they still gave a guilty verdict why they don't have much of a choice on that count right.
So on the counts where they were hung where they were unable to to agree there were higher bars of proof for the government. If you're going to say someone's you know guilty of money laundering you have to show that they had some specific intent to actually hide some specific proceeds of crime right. And the best that we can see from any of the provided evidence is that they had some general knowledge Roman had some general knowledge that the tools he's building might be used for those bad things just like if I build if I build a safe like a guy might put stolen jewels inside of it or just I can imagine the entire Ethereum network.
Yeah yeah like yes anyway so the standard is a little bit higher there and I think it it's it's it's clear that the jury struggled with voting yes uniformly that the prosecution met their burden of proof with respect to mens rea with an unlicensed money transmission charge. The standard for whether you knowingly transmitted the listed funds is lower and there's a reason for that because there's a predicate to that it's not just I'm a normal guy walking around in the world and oops I knowingly like took some money from a drug dealer and then used it to buy a can of coke. No the low standard for knowing that you're dealing with criminal funds only comes into play if you are not a normal person you are a financial institution you are an entity who holds itself out accepting and transmitting customer funds your credit suisse and Russian oligarchs show up at your door you have some due diligence to do you can't just be like la la la I'm going to move this money.
And so that lower standard that the jury found the prosecution met that might be fair and the jury's determination might be fair if Roman was a money transmitter if he had day to day exposure to other people's money and actual control over it but he didn't. And so applying that standard and asking the jury to judge him by that standard is inappropriate and it's not the jury's mistake it's a legal mistake and that legal mistake goes back to those motions last winter when judge fail I said yeah I know fence and said that this isn't money transmission but the definition under the criminal code is broader so I'm going to treat him as a money transmitter I'm going to say that he's a money transmitter and now this lower standard for the jury will apply.
Wait so you're saying that the jury was basically given instructions to say that first of all jury Rome's activity was a money transmitter now based on that criteria now render this judgment on this 1960 count. They were given standards to say that money transmitters includes people who who have sort of secondary or tertiary involvement in the transfer of funds not necessarily just people who have total control over customer funds which is fence and standard. So they were given what I think is an incorrect interpretation of money transmission and then mostly given this task to focus on this low burden of proof for knowledge of illicit funds and I think that's you know and i'm speculating because I don't wasn't in the room like you know with the jury.
I'm speculating that the jurors were able to come to unanimity on that lower standard of culpable conduct which is relevant for money transmitters but were unable to come to agreement on those higher standards for culpable conduct for money laundry just as an individual or for sanctions evasion as an individual not with that heightened standard. And Peter would you summarize the difference in the standard as being between knowledge of and intent to yes yes the intent requirements important in the and in the money laundry charge whereas it's more of just a knowledge standard in the money transmission case.
And it makes sense like think of it intuitively again go back to credit suisse like credit suisse probably doesn't intend to longer oligarch funds but if they have knowledge of it and they don't you know take action and there are money transmitter they should be culpable for that activity right they had some due diligence and failed it but a normal person unless you intend to actually hide the proceeds of crime if you just merely know that you've been handed some proceeds of crime and then transact with them. Then it's a then then that applying that lower standard as culpable conduct doesn't make sense from a liberty standpoint just from a freedom standpoint.
And if I can sort of extend the thought experiment about kind of the jury state of mind and what they've been shown in court I mean I think that that that question of intent is is key and was really focused on by both the prosecution defense and closings. And that sort of brought in a few things that I think are going to be very interesting to on both sides to your listeners in particular. So the prosecution really worked hard to show that or to draw out examples of Roman and the others kind of talking about criminals and and the impact after the fact of the killer of like we're going to get in trouble basically because we're seeing these reports.
That Ronin has been funneled through tornado cash things like that. Going back a little bit further probably the most damaging bit of evidence on that intent question for Roman from representative prosecution was some people might already be familiar with this t-shirt that tornado cash created sort of 2019. This is very early if I'm not mistaken this was actually at the hackathon where they initially created protocol or an early version of the protocol. They were these t-shirts that are washing machine and tornado cash logo and various slogans about I think one of them was if you want to know how to keep your Ethereum private ask me that effect.
And the prosecution really went to the mat to make this washing machine is a very literal metaphor for money laundering. So this came forward as their sort of evidence for you know this was a criminal enterprise from start run as a criminal business. And I think it's quite notable that we did have this verdict because you know the evidence presented by the defense me other side of that man's reaction was Ethereum community sentiment that was cited by a lot of defense. To the effect of the importance of these privacy product or users of the system things like metallic having communicated with Roman about importance of privacy technology as a next step to the area.
I think that what it reflects reading the tea leaves obviously a little bit but I think that we can see a jury that seriously the idea that privacy technology was important for this like legitimate entity legitimate project of Ethereum and of cryptocurrency. So I see a really pretty and again I'm like three entrances down the road on all this but I do see some like really some major silver lines in that's with decision even though it can theoretically be retried so we're not off the hook on that stuff. But that like idea that you I think did have a jury where at least a few members kind of saw the innocent application of this technology as legitimate and you know there were defense witnesses who talked about their usage and so the defense did present that in other ways too.
But I think that was one of my most optimistic takeaways and again you don't need to retry the facts like when this gets appealed I think the big thing for that 18 USC 1960 charge is going to be whether judge fail a back last winter when she denied the motion to dismiss. She got the long the law wrong you know and she should have dismissed that charge because that charge was inappropriate and the rule of lenity which I talked about earlier ambiguity should be on what is money transmission should be ruled in favor of the criminal defendant. The law wrong on the due process are a defense because obviously he got contradictory statements from the regulator as to what money transmission was and so being convicted of unlicensed money transmission is inappropriate here from a due process standpoint.
And statutorily that the US criminal code that definition should be read in parity with the regulatory definition from the regulator otherwise we're just happened nonsense interpretation of the US code so those are all legal questions and when you bring a criminal case on appeal you can't really unless there was some sort of manifest issue with the way the jury did its fact finding or the way the jury did its deliberations you can't retry the facts. But the legal questions which were all to do with that motion to dismiss are definitely fully right for to no vote review the judge at the court can say no judge fail I got the got the law wrong so the jury found certain facts but those were not the right facts to find to find them guilty so we're going to overturn that charge and I think.
A lot's going to be left to Brian Klein and the defense team is exactly how to do that strategy but I think have laid out some of the best arguments here that I hope and expect them to pursue. And it's not just a deep it's fast and fully transparent purpose bill to be the home base for defy and cross chain liquidity when it comes to costs unicane is a no-brainer transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than a theory of maintenance or asking the price of creating or accessing liquidity want to stay in the loop on unicane visit unicane.org or follow at unicane on x for all the updates imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly that's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking a revolutionary new category at the intersection of trade five and web three at the heart is you are the world's first money app built fully on chain it gives you a Swiss iBand account blending fee out currencies like the euro the Swiss franc the United States dollar or the Remembe with crypto all in one place enjoy real world.
All the usability and blockchains trust and programmability transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with tradify rails impact with integrated defy futures you are transforms mantle network into the ultimate platform for on chain financial services like buying payments trading and assets like the m i4 the me's protocol and functions f b t c backed by developer grants ecosystem incentives and top distribution through the you are app reward stations and buy bit launch pool for m in t holders every economic activity in you are drives value back to you embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking that's x.
com slash mantle underscore official defy stability and innovation are everything which is why you should check out frax finance the protocol revolutionizing stable coins defy and Rolex the core of frax finance is frax usd which is backed by black rock institutional fiddle fund frax designed frax usd for besting class yields across defy t bills and carry trade returns all in one just head to frax.com then stake it to earn some of the best yields in defy want even more bridge your frax usd over to the frax still layer two for the same yield plus frax still points and explore fractals diverse layer two ecosystem with protocols like curve convex and more all rewarding early adopters frax isn't just a protocol it's a digital nation powered by the fxs token and governed by a schoolable community acquire fxs through frax.
com or your go to dex stake it and help shape frax nations future ready to join the forefront of defy visit frax.com now to join the frax.com start earning with frax usd and state frax usd and for bankless listeners you can use frax.com slash r slash bankless when bridging to fractal for exclusive fractal perks and boosted rewards. I think it's on this point that I just remain optimistic about the path forward and maybe it's because I'm listening to you guys and we're on the bankless podcast and maybe if we inverted the world and we were having the prosecution on the bank full podcast and this was all upside down maybe I would be convinced in the other direction but Peter I'm seeing just surface area for opportunity here for Roman storm to appeal and while we have certain unfortunate outcomes here mainly the guilty on the 960 thing.
There seems to be grounds for an appeal to go to to be appealed and then go our way with force and direction especially when we like maybe I'm going to have to tap into your legal mine here when we reroll the dice on the court and we now have a new department of justice that's under the Trump administration not the Biden administration where this court case with Roman got started in the first place. I continue to be looking at this thing with a glass half full but maybe I'm naive so there's a few things to be cautious about one is that that count one which was money laundry in the count count three which was sanctions evasion where the jury couldn't decide prosecution could decide to retry those charges because we all have the same prosecution the same people again.
All we have is a mistrial we don't have a not guilty verdict so there's no double jeopardy at play here and so that'll be one of the first things we'll find out about whether this DOJ is taking a different approach then the Biden DOJ that brought these charges originally and we'll find that out probably in the next few days. The second caution is all right so with the guilty charge your only strategy if you're Roman is to appeal it to the to the appellate level and challenge especially that motion to dismiss and how judge failure might have gotten the law wrong. A lot of that's going to come down to who they get on appeal like some judges there are going to take a more textual approach to the way the U.
S. code should be read some might be more prosecutorial friendly as to way that like prosecutors should actually have leeway to interpret broad laws in certain ways and others will be more different. There's no reason others will be more defendant friendly that the rule of lenity you know controls that if there's ambiguity it should be resolved in favor of the criminal defendant so you know that's going to be tough and ultimately it could even get appeal to the Supreme Court like the questions of statutory interpretation like what is the underlying law are I think significant enough that you could see that going all the way up and and I like to think that there's a lot of good textualist out there who will look at the U.
S. code and and think that interpreting these words to mean that you're doing my transmission even if you're just publishing software is absurd but I could see that going in different ways just procedurally can we talk about like how that happens so there's an appeal what's the time delay when does that appellate court have to give an answer and then it could be appealed again like how long what's the duration of this thing how long is it going to play out in the so kind of branches of possibility here. David you might have more experience with criminal appeals we've brought some civil suits ourselves and I'll tell you it's on the order of months and years but I don't David use something to think about not I mean I'm not intimately more familiar but that is definitely the scale that we're talking about and you know again makes it all the more good news that Roman is is going home this week because the prosecution could have had him in jail like if they want their ass more it could have had him in jail for like years while this was playing out through a pellet call.
There was a motion to remand and I I apologize we did another show immediately before this one and I can't remember what I haven't haven't talked about but you know the fact that judge file in the course of denying this motion to remand did refer to the appeal ability and even the like I think basically her language was there are many options to appeal this conviction and so that was that was quite encouraging to herb quite good for the defense to have the judge just acknowledge that it's going to be a good thing. This is something that's out there and Roman's been so respectful in court he's never missed a court a court date like the idea that he'd be a flight risk when he's obviously become a public figure because of this case who's fighting for his rights like is absurd I think it's actually quite sad that the prosecution pushed for that you know immediate remand to jail.
It seems punitive it seems like they're just trying to twist a knife that's bad for you. This this gets to some hard questions that I've been struggling with here at coin center is you know President Trump comes in with with this you know let's make America the crypto capital the world verbiage and I want to get on board and I believe in some of it. I've seen huge changes at the SEC you know which we've you guys have talked about on other episodes of this podcast and we've talked about a lot. But then we still see in the unlicensed money transmission arena the charge that actually stuck with Roman and the jury because I think of the bad legal reading from judge failure.
Not as much support from the administration so there was a memo from deputy attorney general Todd Blanche Trump's deputy attorney general saying we're going to end regulation by prosecution. And if you ask me this is the clearest example of regulation by prosecution because the regulator said you don't need to get a license but then the prosecutor said you needed to get a license to be charged with unlicensed money transmission. So it's really a prosecutor making law by charging people with felony crimes. And so you might say all right well they published that Todd Blanche memo that said we're going to end prosecution by regulation.
There are like vagaries in that memo that allow you to read it as we're only going to stop these prosecutions in situations where it's really just somebody who published software and had no knowledge of or involvement with any criminal activities you know and that brings us right back to this. If you take that to the absurd extreme everybody who publishes software has knowledge that it could be used by criminals like that is the nature especially open source software that is the nature of open source software. And so there was a way to read that memo from deputy attorney general Blanche that the prosecutors in the southern district New York seized upon they dropped one of the two unlicensed money transmission charges they said they're not going to bring one of the two charges to trial.
And that was the one where they said you failed to register as a money transmitter and the only one they brought was you are a money transmitter and you knowingly transmitted criminal funds. And so you know there's a way to read that as oh we see we're sticking to the to the you know the guidance from the deputy attorney general memo because this one involves knowingly transmitting criminal funds. But again they weren't transmitting and so you know that that charge should have been thrown out from the beginning and that knowledge standard is inappropriate in this context because if we're going to apply a low level knowledge standard that your code could be used for bad things everyone's going to still be potentially on the hook for regulation by prosecution.
So I would have loved to have seen another memo from Trump's Department of Justice and I hope on appeal we can get some statement some guidance that like this is the way the law should be. I hope that the administration defends the finson 2019 guidance and says that's actually the standard we think is the correct standard. And the last thing I'll say on this is so coin center is supporting Michael Lou Ellen he's a software developer who lives in Fort Worth, Texas. He developed a protocol called ferros that is a like go fund me type crowdfunding protocol but non custodial it's all done on chain and it uses privacy pools type technology to keep donors anonymous when they're giving to good causes and they want to fund them.
The coin center wants to use this tech because we're a nonprofit we want to raise money this way. Michael is suing the Department of Justice in Fort Worth, Texas for declarative judgment saying I see what you're doing against Roman storm. I'm publishing software that's very similar I'm going to maintain a front end to very much similar to the way the tornado cash protocol worked. I'm not going to publish this stuff until you give me declarative judgment that I'm not going to be your next target for unlicensed money transmission prosecutions. And what's interesting is we supported Michael when he first brought that case right at the end of the Biden administration.
So the original defendant was a G Garland and then the defendant changes to a G Bondy and even with a G Bondy as the defendant the defense in that case filed for a motion to dismiss saying Michael faces no credible threat of enforcement. Meanwhile, Bondy's DOJ is continuing its prosecution and Roman storm. And if I can offer a slightly downbeat extend extension of these observations, I think that one way to read this that tends to be mine is that you know the Trump administration Trump DOJ and whatever conjunction there they exist, you know, they're making these noises that a certain segment of their base of support that's in the crypto world sort of has a general sense of what's being discussed in a general sense of maybe the vague goals, but when the rubber actually hits the road and you're looking at something like tornado cash, I think probably a lot of those same people might recoil at the implications of what at a very high level their political leaders are promising them.
And I think that that's also reflected in unfortunately you know I felt I would luckily we had a very generous supporter who was able to send me to do this work, but you know the media model is not what it used to be in the coverage and attention on this trial has been I think minuscule relative to its potential impact and its implications. And so I think that it is kind of just this unfortunate and uncomfortable gap both between political rhetoric and legal reality and between frankly the public's sort of signaling of enthusiasm for certain ideas versus actual commitment to following the legal process paying attention to people who are in jeopardy.
In connection with these things and taking action to influence those things it's just there are certain things that are fun to say and a lot of hard work to really pay attention to. Okay, but going into that so would be the ideal thing that you'd like to see the Trump administration do so Peter you mentioned the DOJ publishing a memo right so let's say they publish a memo. Does that like call off dogs in the in the computer is it just if we pause and rewind yeah like the Trump administration pressured the southern district in order to drop the charges against Eric Adams mayor of New York City right and they did right and so ideally they would have just dropped these charges at least the unlicensed money transmission charge because you know.
And they had so we're not doing that that's a decision that that was a decision point that it was a decision but I should say that I my interpretation or you know my inference I doubt anybody in a position of real influence in the Trump administration is actually act like in the White House is even actively paying attention to this I think that like the DOJ has its own process and you know obviously there are people there paying attention to it but in terms of like you know Pam Bondi her. Even herself probably doesn't know this is happening I mean I'm not so sure I think I think I think there are plenty of people in in treasury and DOJ who are aware of the tension between national security and privacy here and that tornado cash has become a lightning rod sort of test case for those questions and I think.
I think I think possibly because of fear of bending too far in the privacy direction and away from the national security direction listening to people who've been you know involved in these battles for a long time I'm not going to like sort of like deep state type stuff like you know I'm not I'm not so sure I think. I think that it may not be saying is that the political cadres the public faces the not so deep state have not chosen to intervene because I don't know about their local awareness obviously I think that what you're saying is absolutely yeah I mean you look at the president's working group report which came out last week actually on crypto and this is this was like the end document for the mission that they were set on at the beginning of the administration to make America the crypto capital the world.
There is a section in there that says Congress should pass the blockchain regulatory certainty act the blockchain regulatory certainty act addresses exactly the charge that Roman is convicted of in in in trial today it says that if you are a non controlling blockchain developer. You are not engaged in money transmission and should not be liable for unlicensed money transmission prosecution and so great yeah it's great and it's in the pwg. We report and for that we are grateful and thankful but they're kind of they're pushing it off to Congress to to pass that law to offer that clarity to to rain DOJ in and now I should be charitable.
There is historically a sort of wall of separation between the political powers and the DOJ for the very reason that the DOJ is also there potentially to investigate and and charge the president right and so the DOJ guards its independence the southern district of New York as a subdivision of the federal DOJ. It sees itself perhaps rightly so as a as a very autonomous body so maybe it just wasn't the political will to to give firm pressure on these charges but but this is where we are now and so so yes the president's working group on digital assets is calling for Congress to fix the unlicensed money transmission issue they don't I mean tornado cash by name but they're calling for that fix and that that is massive like if we think about where we were a year ago.
I I've gotten greedy and crazy that's that's amazing yeah I mean but ideally we'd have the truth social post about this case right I mean that would be the ideal scenario and there would be some focus on it yeah I mean I'll say right here that that tweet that Eleanor Tarot put out with Roman statement where he said that the 1960 charges bullshit the next thing that Roman says in that tweet is you know like Trump says yeah yeah fight fight yeah yeah I think it's a not so not so not so subtle nod to the guy that can potentially pardon him or at least apply some pressure here and that'll be interesting I mean I wouldn't rule it out.
Let's talk about where we are now though because we're in this great like gray zone areas not a great spot to be for open source software developers for non custodial D5 projects let's put privacy aside all right it's like so privacy is a thing and there's national security concerns and it's a thing right we you know we can understand some you know a part of the government at least think so but this has sweeping ramifications for all non custodial D5 projects out there and there let's let's remember this is precedent so there was a guilty charge and they said that you know that tornado cash the protocol maybe the app as well maybe both pieces like fit under the money transmitter definition so I mean that's okay so that that doesn't seem great though right like we're in a bad place so I'm going to say I'll say two things one you're absolutely right to point out that set privacy aside the DOJ's theory of the case in this prosecution has never relied on we're able to go after Roman for this stuff because his tool was privacy protecting the unlicensed money transmission thing is just you were transmitting money which he wasn't because they're definition of transmitting is insanely broad and you knowingly transmitted illicit funds says nothing about whether you hid them and so it's so let's be clear that could happen to uniswap that could happen to a way that could happen to any D5 protocol if a bad actor starts using it yes yes so so the the theory of the case is incredibly broad and potentially reaches effectively all D5 developers irrespective of whether they're using zero knowledge proofs or some other cool stuff which they should be using by the way because it's good tech but even if they don't they're on the hook for prosecution here if you run a front and right well I mean no even more than that the government's theory of what is money transmission is just extraordinarily broad and that's why again that ruling as as to whether that that should stand a and feed into jury instructions that then that happened back last winter is so problematic like like like your home ethereum validator yeah what's that anything that has any modicum of surface area to a transaction yeah I mean I can actually there was a specific exchange in the trial I believe one of the defense witnesses are defend with one of the defense witnesses the defense asked him you know does an ethereum node help operate tornado cash and the answer was yes of course yeah yeah and there were questions about folks that invested in pepper sec the the company that that Roman started to build tornado cash frankly if you read the law that the government is arguing is the binding law here the way the government's reading it a Bitcoin core developer is a money transmitter and needs to do KYC AML on everyone who uses the Bitcoin platform like wow there's an absurdity here and it's not bounded by law it would only be bounded by prosecutorial discretion like oh well we just won't go after the ones that are you know and that's not how the law supposed to work I think it's on oh sorry well let me take us on a slight entertaining diversion here and hold like so speaking to the issue of the the investors I think this is what this was another one of the really wild procedural moments of the trial because the defense wanted to bring in an investor from dragonfly capitol who actually were the primary funders of tornado cash and the investor whose home we later found out had actually been rated as part of the investigation he played the fifth he just and I can't recall at the moment exactly what it was that the defense was trying to elicit from this witness but mostly I think probably to the effect that you know tornado cash was a promising technology that we invested in because it serves an important purpose in XYZ ecosystem but he played the fifth because he believed he might still be under threat of investigation himself just having been an investor in this thing and his communications were also used to establish a venue for the charges now the reason that this is interesting is not that he had like in his own mind some fear of this but that in a hearing on a Friday when Jerry was not present the prosecution declined to state that he was no longer a subject of the investigation they used this term subject and not target and that became somewhat misunderstood and perhaps amplify a bit but they actually also had this segment of the trial expunged from the transcript and then on Monday put into the transcript that they actually had not in any way signaled that this person was still a target in the investigation so there was a real two step in terms of we're going to put it put forth just enough of a threat against this witness to make them credibly plead the fifth and not come testify for this defense but then we're going to actually just withdraw because this is absurd because this was an investment that was made five years ago and also investing in something is like a very strange way to impute criminal intent so you know this is just a little side note that I found interesting do you think that that was a 4d chess move by the prosecution or was they there's making the next logical move in one move after the other I mean frankly that's how it read in the courtroom is planned with as a 4d chess move where the prosecution is going to suggest just enough threat against this witness to make it credible because you know if you can't just plead the fifth and say like I'm pleading the fifth you have to have a good reason and the judge in this case in this moment had the option of kind of overriding or rejecting his fifth amendment plea and saying no you don't actually face any credible threat of implicating yourself in this and the judge ultimately declined to do that in part because the prosecution was continuing to in so many words suggest that his name is Tom Schmidt from Dragonfly was potentially at risk of being implicated in what was going on and then hold it back on Monday that's like the bounds of the bounds of this broader than what you're saying you Peter you said it was boundless right it's like we're talking about you running a no being like a developer this is an investor are you an eithholder like what the hell yeah remember that it's not just an unlicensed money transmission charge with an incredibly broad theory of what transmission is it's conspiracy to do unlicensed money transmission which means you just need to agree with one other person to commit the target defense and take one credible step towards commission of the offense like invest in a protocol.
Okay, but this is why I don't actually have any fear about this because of the level of absurdity that it's the whole they're trying to take down the whole entire system and so at some point like I don't care about the outcome here because it's absurd and the level of absurdity is actually giving me a sense of like solace. I mean a couple years ago I'd say yeah it's absurd but like watch how many devs end up going to jail right we're lucky that it seems like politicians on the hill the president and this isn't just partisan it's a song both sides like are finally getting that like what are we getting for this villainization of developers like what's the bang for buck here like who are my voters who are like yeah go after those crypto depths like what and so and so I think the winds have changed but there was a time a couple years ago right but now we're today right and Roman feels pretty I'm guessing like right as he said ready to appeal to overturn this to re-roll the dice and he feel good to back but here's the thing right but it's like well we're well we're still open here to this like a boundless prosecution it just depends who's in power right and it's like we would have thought it was BS but we got Shane Goblin the founder of polymarket FBI busted in his house all these rates happening yesy from cracking how absurd is that Roman storm all of these things next to be Hayden Adams from a lot of a lot of that happened before the change administration exactly it seems a cool off after and maybe we're just still suffering the hangover of it and this is a guilty verdict so to go back to your earlier question Ryan about precedent it only has persuasive precedent so this is just one verdict in one case in the Southern District of New York and so similar cases in other districts in other circuits of U.
S. federal court system can look at it and think yeah that's some good points or they can disagree with it and even in this other district of New York another judge with another case can try certain things differently when we get up to the appeal which will be so important that's why I'm super glad Roman is so gung ho and like fight fight fight about this then we start getting into the world of like now we're talking about binding law for first the second circuit where the Southern District of New York is and then later if it goes up the Supreme Court which then we're talking about binding law and what transmission is it's still very bad and this goes back to my earlier point about Michael Luel and the software developer whose challenge and for work were supporting like yeah it's bad he faces a credible threat of enforcement even if it's just the Southern District of New York that's gone crazy like this they claim jurisdiction over anyone who's software they can run on a server in the Southern District of New York so like Michael lives in Fort Worth Texas he's seeking declarative judgment from a court that hopefully will be more skeptical of the administrative overreach and the powers of tyrannical governments but he could easily get dragged into the Southern District of New York if he doesn't get declarative judgment in Texas if they just install pharaohs the privacy preserving client he's building for fundraising and then decide to go bully him like they bullied the tornado cash developers and the Samurai wallet developers which we haven't talked about a lot who got pushed into a guilty plea last week right in advance of this verdict which is kind of interesting I think there was probably a moment to apply pressure and these guys are sharks they're not bad at their job they're just I think on the wrong side of the legal issue here so as we close this out maybe let's talk about the more optimistic scenario so is there still as you know David Whistley your glass careful it seems like we can still win in a big way crypto can win in a big way so let's talk about if this goes to pellet court gets tried again is there a possibility here and what would this area look like where we actually win and have some precedent that non custodial open source software are not like do not apply here for this type of money laundering you know legality three three paths to an optimistic outcome one Roman appeals the second circuit court of appeal his lawyers argue among other things that the rule of lenity controls and therefore the ambiguous divergent interpretations of what transmission is between Fincens regulatory definition and the criminal code get resolved in favor of the defendant whose liberty is on the line hence the rule of lenity now effectively Fincens understanding of transmission which is you accept and you transmit which means you have in control at some point is the law of the land okay at least in the second circuit and then Roman gets out that's the end of that path to Michael Lewellan in Fort Worth Texas he's right now fighting off this motion to dismiss because the DOJ is saying you don't face a credible threat of enforcement I think that's nonsense because his course of conducts very similar to the publishing the software and the technology that Roman did and maintaining a front end as well so maybe the court and Fort Worth denies the motion to dismiss that the government's pushing for and instead rules that he gets declarative judgment that the law the statutory law of the bank secrecy act and the criminal code 18 USC 1960 should be interpreted such that this is not transmission and he's not you know on the hook for a potential unlicensed prosecution that could get appealed up to the appellate level the government might challenge it they might not then that kind of depends on how broadly presidential it is for the rest of the country the third and perhaps cleanest and quickest option unfortunately this I'm realizing what I'm saying that Congress is the quickest option that also tells you how different things are from a few years ago though is the blockchain regulatory certainty act which defines a whole category of persons as noncontrolling blockchain developers and service providers and so it's not just open source software publishers it's like people running nodes it's people who you know are operating front ends as long as they're non custodial these people are not money transmitters and are not engaged in money transmission and should not to face liability for unlicensed money transmission prosecution if Congress passes that forward looking you know it's it's too late for Romans too late for the samurai developers but forward looking were set now that law has already been attached to clarity which is the big market structure legislation that Congress is pushing and the president wants them to deliver oh wow it's past the house with a overwhelming bipartisan majority which I'm like still kind of in shock about but so happy that we managed to convince enough members of Congress that this is an important issue and now it's headed to the Senate the Senate has to create its market structure package they don't really like to be bullied by the house so they've got to do their own thing and that's fair but the Senate discussion draft already has this blockchain regulatory certainty act language in it so that's the starting point of negotiations we just need to hold on oh god I'm going to make a total joke and then and then and then pass it in the Senate which will happen over the next few months if it happens by the end of the year and so there will be a key moment where we need to call our senators and say like this matters to me Romans prosecution was like horrendous and I want to develop stuff like that because it's good for people's privacy if we pass the Senate the president has already said Trump has already said he's going to sign it he wants the BRCA in there then we fix this and wow and that would be hard coded that be hard yeah hard coded and so far as it would take another act of Congress to change the law whereas you know the regulator which is treasury you know if we've talked about finson as the good guy here for a long time because their guidance was based on total independent control it's just guidance a hostile future finson either in this administration if they completely change their mind on things or in the next administration they could write new guidance and say no actually money transmission includes all these sorts of things you know they could they'd be hemmed in a little bit by the statutory definition of money transmission but that's actually a definition is you know unfortunately capable of being read different ways so yeah we'd be in trouble and if Congress actually just created clarity here that would be great oddly the bill that's attached to his name clarity so we want clarity through clarity well Peter three different possible paths makes me feel good the more paths the better one of those paths is being taken nonetheless the other two are in the course and each one of those is a gamble but man when you sum it all of those together I feel like maybe I'm just a guy who's feeling good today but like when you add them all together I feel like there's a pretty good likelihood of outcome like checking on that what do you feel and I hate to say it because Romans in such a good mood I'm gonna say it like at least based on that tweet like I hate to say it because nobody should be found guilty of an absurd crime like the regulator told you not to license and then you guilty of unlicensed conduct the Romans in a good mood he's ready to fight so I'm gonna say it Romans loss is a good way I think to galvanize support to convince folks in the Senate that this is this is actually something that matters the BRCA needs to pass and I think it's also a good way to convince the district court in Fort Worth Texas that Michael the well and faces a credible risk of prosecution because look somebody who's just found guilty and so Romans taken one for the team in a way by by pushing those other initiatives forward with what just happened Yeah, what I'm seeing here is an opportunity to really slingshot us forward into a much better equilibrium some things have to go right but they don't seem that crazy I think we've been stacked up against crazier odds in the past David we are technically at the end of this one court case it actually now feels like we somehow ended it in the middle of a game now we just jumped backwards into ending four or five what are you looking at in the short term what is left to come out we're looking at the prosecution to see if they are going to just try and do this all over again what are you looking at in the short term in the next week?
well in the very short term I'm looking at a nap but in the in the next week or so we will get motions from both sides I'm not sure and maybe maybe Peter will know better than I but I'm not sure will actually get any decision on whether they're going to refile those charges for a little bit longer I don't think I don't I don't feel like we're going to get like a recharging in a week I think that's probably a longer process but you know we will get an appeal notice we won't get details of the appeal for a little while longer but we will hear relatively soon about appeals indeed I mean we already know the intention to appeal so that's not really going to make much difference but there there might be some follow up motions from from both sides that will give us something so I guess maybe my answer is that we actually don't have a lot of new clarity coming our way immediately but maybe Peter has more insight into the refiling part of the process in particular but I guess it's criminal too so it's not your special name I know yeah and I think a lot's going to come down to some hard choices at the Southern District of New York and I hope that we'll have another moment for the Trump administration to apply some pressure there I think one thing I just saw was that apparently Jake Clayton who's former SEC you might remember the name and is acting US attorney for the Southern District of New York said in praising the prosecution the speed efficiency and functionality of stable coins and other digital assets offer great promise but that promise cannot be an excuse for criminality adding that criminals committing age old crimes like money laundry undermine the many innovators who operate lawfully so Trump's appointee to the Southern District of New York right now is praising the prosecution and also maybe this is a misquote but seems to be confusing the money laundry charge with the unlicensed money transmission charge so that's not a great sign but at the same time he's acting US attorney for that district so he's not going to criticize his own prosecutions my hope is that they just sort of like take their win and don't refile those other two charges I think that's probably more likely and my hope is that the appeal goes forward and yeah and I will say this is the way in which in some senses the hung jury could be a bad outcome for the broader environment because if they don't refile these charges then there is not a chance to set a precedent in the negative not a chance for somebody to be found not guilty in this kind of situation which does again have like that presidential at least some sort of exemplary power going forward on some level obviously the legislative solution the Peter is talking about closes a lot of these ambiguities going forward but at the same time I guess ideally we would have had a not guilty verdict that would have basically made some kind of statement about the relationship between a developer's intentions and the uses to which a tool is put and currently we don't have whatever would have been taken away from that and if we don't get a refiling of those charges it you know again leaving aside the legislative issues it might wait for somebody else to fall into this trap and have to do all of this all over again yeah I see that perspective David I also do see the perspective that Roman storm is flying home a free man tomorrow to see his daughter and while that's not a legal precedent that is what is truly happening and so call it call it soft precedent and so I do appreciate that fact and yeah as an industry we live to fight another day to do this all over again and like Peter said I think we all feel a little bit more galvanized there are multiple paths towards that the happy outcome here and you know we got there from a variety of different efforts David you're reporting every single day in and out was just incredibly valuable thank you David Peter your support from coin center and then also Roman storm himself like I alluded to a second ago we we thought we were at the ninth inning and we finished a game but we actually just got teleported back to ending for and so now we're gonna have to do this all over again Roman is going it sounds like potentially going to be appealing this so we can seal this and get a final sealed victory for Roman and for the industry which will take more money and you know in and David what you're doing at the rage it was has been incredibly valuable I would like to tell all the listeners that bankless sent you $5,000 yesterday just as a donation to what you're doing so you can continue doing it if Roman goes on the offensive with an appeal is what I'll call it I hope that you can resume something to coverage which will take even more money to keep supporting you you have a donation page the rage.
co slash donate we will put that link in the show notes so any listener who has been consuming some of the rage's content can just support some of your work there and if I can just put in a little bit more nuance there you know low leads is the founder of the rage and she and I have been you know working together a bit more over the last year it has really been a productive relationship and we're basically poised to start thinking about how we're going to expand and make this more sustainable and so you know donations right now or essentially you know I would say a bridge towards a future where this operation becomes more self-sustaining and we begin we're able to you know fund this kind of coverage on an ongoing basis so it it means a lot obviously we really appreciate you guys support.
yeah of course and then on Peter on Peter side of things you guys are doing the coin center dinner in New York in September I will be in attendance about a ticket looking forward to it that is one way to support coin center but I believe you guys also have coin center dot east as well. yep we have the coin center dot east address you can find our donate page on coin center dot org on that page you'll you'll find a fun little radio show nice between how would you like to donate anonymously or dox myself but get a free jacket gift which is like a be sure a bit quite decent. I actually would encourage people to give anonymously and that's legal right.
it's legal in America in America you have a first amendment right to associate with other people anonymously. and so your donation to coin center is your way of expressing that association right the government doesn't have any business knowing precisely who all our donors are because that's exactly how they target suspect political organizations that they want to quash. it's also good practice for the listener just to engage in privacy technology there's there's another benefit to and David you know this because you are co-point if in the lawsuit challenging the tornado cash sanctions. because we received donations using tornado cash we had standing to challenge the sanctioning.
contracts because we're like no we want to keep using tornado cash to receive donations and by the way that's a first amendment association right so give to us using some weird theory and based privacy tool and then we'll have standing to defend that tool of the ever come. to defend that tool and normalize that tool so privacy can be normalized in society as much as possible Peter David thank you guys for coming on and just doing the Lord's work just defending Roman reporting on privacy in America and making sure we have the freedom to use these bankless tools. thanks guys it's been great thank you all for having us on thank you.
bankless station you guys know the deal crypto is risky somebody might try and take you to court we don't want that but we got people like coin center we got people like David on our side which makes you feel very good nonetheless you can lose what you put in we are head west is not for everyone but we are glad you are with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot. you