(3,3)
Olympus DAO and its native OHM token have taken over the meme-osphere. With its novel tokenomics, it has become an emergent powerhouse in this DeFi 2.0 phenomenon. With Olympus Pro on the way, the DAO seeks to change the current mercenary structures of yield farming and replace it with a sustainable and stable ecosystem.
------ 📣 POOLTOGETHER | DEFI LOTTERY https://bankless.cc/PoolTogether ------ 🚀 SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ 🎙️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/ ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🍵 MATCHA | DECENTRALIZED EXCHANGE AGGREGATOR https://bankless.cc/Matcha
🔐 LEDGER | SECURE YOUR ASSETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
🧙♀️ ALCHEMIX | SELF-PAYING LOANS http://bankless.cc/Alchemix
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 7:00 Zeus and DeFi 2.0 10:21 Traditional Liquidity Mining 15:39 Protocol-Owned Liquidity 25:11 Bonding & Treasuries 30:41 Realigning Incentives 36:50 Are There Tradeoffs? 44:13 Olympus Pro 52:52 New Generation of Protocols 57:00 Olympus DAO 1:02:24 Branding as a Currency 1:08:47 Ponzi Games & Haters 1:16:44 The Ohmies & DeFi 2.0 1:20:40 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Zeus on Twitter: https://twitter.com/ohmzeus?s=20
Olympus DAO: https://www.olympusdao.finance/
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey, Bankless Nation. Welcome to another episode of State of the Nation. Super excited to dig into this. David, I feel like you and I have been on a journey, a journey to understanding what the hell DeFi 2.0 is. ZoomerFi, as some of the kids are calling it. Is this a new trend? Is this a new narrative? Is there something more substantive to it? We talked to Jay from Rari Capital last week, and I think that has helped shape some of our thoughts on this new exciting area in DeFi. And he said, really, part of the secret weapon of everything that's going on in this next generation of DeFi is this thing called protocol-owned liquidity.
This is protocol-owned value. And I think we're going to dive into that in today's discussion. David, but who do we have on and what are we going to talk about today? Yeah, we have on Zeus, the pseudonymous founder of Olympus DAO, which has really pioneered this new primitive, which is unleashing DeFi 2.0? That's what we're going to ask and find out all about today. And Ryan, man, I love NFTs, but man, I am waiting for a resurgence in DeFi. Yeah, it's been sleeping. It's been sleeping, and DeFi, I know, it feels like home for me personally. So I'm definitely into the concept of DeFi 2.0. And so, yeah, we're going to ask the questions, why is this a thing?
Is this a real thing? How does it work? And why is it cool? And so we are going to unpack all of those things here today with Zeus, the pseudo-anonymous founder of Olympus DAO. Yeah, I think Olympus DAO is like a poster child for all of this stuff too. So like even maybe more so than RARI Capital, these new token mechanics, and it's just raw unbridled token mechanics. That's what makes number go up. So we're going to dig into that and see what's going on there with protocol owned liquidity. And then also talk about the Olympus Dow story, because this has been a mega story this year and part of the resurgence.
Guys, but before we get into it, some announcements for you. First, we had Andrew Yang on the podcast, okay? Recorded last week. The episode went public on Monday. I hope you had a chance to go listen to it. Maybe if you've listened to it once, go listen to it a second time. I've actually, David, I listened to this podcast, like I think one and a half more times and I picked up more. Sometimes, you know, when you're having the conversation, it's hard to like focus on the questions and the conversation and like absorb everything. But this is a pretty meaty podcast. And I learned a lot through reading Andrew's book and getting his thoughts on crypto.
So anyway, you guys will love that. Any other comments on that, David? Yeah, we followed that podcast up with a Market Monday I wrote yesterday called The Politicians Are Coming, which is basically the pitch as to why a politician might want to adopt a crypto-friendly base, a crypto-friendly policy platform. And Andrew Yang, I think, is the first politician of many to really figure out that, like, hey, like crypto can get me elected. Crypto can, like supporting crypto can do good things for my campaign. I think he is the first of many. Get me jobs, get me money, get me all sorts of things. I think the politicians are definitely coming.
It's protocol incentives, teaching them to learn crypto and learn DeFi. Also, guys, speaking of incentives to learn things, we have the ultimate guide to airdrops that is coming on the Bankless newsletter next week. It's been under wraps. We've been working on it for a while. But if you are interested in that, airdrops are an incentive way to learn about crypto. Subscribe to Bankless. I think we're putting that out on Tuesday, I believe. And Bankless premium members get the entire unrestricted access to the ultimate guide to airdrops. So make sure you check that out too. That's coming next week.
Lastly, got to give a shout out to our friends at Pooled Together. David, what is Pooled Together, man? Pooled Together is a no loss lottery. It's a lottery where you put up some capital like in the form of stable coins or some other tokens. But if you lose the lottery, you don't lose your capital. So this is really cool. Everyone pools all of their assets together. Those assets earn interest in DeFi and the winner earns the collective interest rather than everyone else's money. So it's kind of like a gamified savings mechanism. And Pool Together has done a fantastic job moving on to the layer twos while also keeping all of their liquidity and their collective prizes, even though they're fractured across the many layers, all one single price.
And so they've also introduced some new mechanisms to allow for better odds for small fries rather than big whales. So there is some small fry optimizations going on. And if you don't like gas fees, because who does, you can go and check this out on Polygon. So they are live on Polygon where you can deposit USDC, USDT on Polygon and enter the prize pool there. Yeah, it's super awesome. It's just the feeling of winning a lottery without actually like risking your upfront capital without actually spending money uh really cool and this new version four they've got some whale proofing as you're saying david the layer two is essential they're also giving out a million dollars in prizes so again some more incentives to use this kind of thing if you want to check that out go to bankless.
cc slash pool together thanks so much pull together for uh sponsoring this and getting the word out david gotta ask you the question i asked at the beginning of every single state of the nation and that is this what's What's the state of the nation today, sir? State of the nation is evolving. We are evolving into DeFi 2.0. Allegedly, is what we're going to find out. But it feels like Pokemon. It feels like we've started at the Charmander, and now we are at the Charmeleon phase. Leaving room for DeFi 3.0, hopefully in a couple years. But right now, we are evolving from DeFi 1.0 to 2.0. All right, what's after Charmeleon, Pokemon expert David Hoffman?
Charizard. who doesn't know that yeah charizard did you not know that ryan no i'm not i didn't do the pokemon you did not just want to say that out loud that's turning into a meme immediately after the episode guys watch david flame me on twitter for not understanding what a charizard is the evolution of a specific pokemon just really staying true to the boomer ryan meme anyway let's get to the sponsor, shall we? And then we'll come back with Zeus where we're going to talk about protocol, owned liquidity, and Olympus DAO. But just a moment for our sponsors first. Thank you. Arbitrum is an Ethereum scaling solution that is going to completely change how we use DeFi.
If you've been using Ethereum for the past 12 months, you've probably noticed the high gas fees and the slow confirmation times that have been plaguing DeFi. Too many people want to use Ethereum and it doesn't have enough capacity for all of us. That's where Arbitrum comes in. Arbitrum is a layer two to Ethereum, which means Arbitrum can increase Ethereum's throughput by orders of magnitude at a fraction of the cost of what we are used to paying. When interacting with Arbitrum, you can get the performance of a centralized exchange while tapping into Ethereum's level of security and decentralization.
This is why people are calling this Ethereum's broadband moment, where we get to add performance onto decentralization and security. If you're a developer and you want to save on gas costs and make an overall better experience for your users, go to developer.offchainlabs.com to get started building on Arbitrum. If you're a user, keep an eye out for your favorite DeFi apps building on Arbitrum. Arbitrum has been working with over 300 teams, including Ethereum's top infrastructure projects, and will be opening up to all users shortly. There are so many apps coming online to Arbitrum, so you may want to pack your bags in preparation for the great migration to the Arbitrum Layer 2.
To keep up to speed with Arbitrum, follow them on Twitter at Arbitrum and join their Discord. Living a bankless life requires taking control over your own private keys. Not your keys, not your crypto. That's why so many in the bankless nation already have their Ledger hardware wallet, which makes proper private key management a breeze. But the Ledger ecosystem is much more than just a secure hardware wallet. Ledger is the combination of the Ledger hardware wallet and the Ledger Live app. And if you're used to seeing all of your crypto services and favorite DeFi apps all in one spot, Ledger Live is where you want to be.
Not only does Ledger let you buy your crypto assets straight from the app, but it also hooks into all of the DeFi apps and services that you're used to. Using Ledger Live, you can stake your ETH and LIDO, swap on DEXs like Paraswap, or display your NFTs with Rainbow. You can also use Wallet Connect inside of Ledger Live to connect to all the other DeFi apps that keep coming online. DeFi never stops growing and the Ledger Live app grows alongside with it. So click the link in the show notes to see all of the DeFi apps that Ledger Live has and stay tuned as more apps come online. And if you don't have a Ledger hardware wallet, what are you even waiting for?
Go to ledger.com, grab a Ledger, download Ledger Live and get all of your DeFi apps all in one space. All right, guys, we are back with Zeus. Zeus is the pseudo anonymous founder of Olympus DAO. That is the OHM coin. It is a fully backed algorithmic free-floating stable asset. It's competing as a reserve store of value. It's called OHM, as I mentioned. Welcome to all the OMIs listening in today. That is what they call members of the Olympus DAO community. Zeus, it is fantastic to have you on. How are you doing today? I'm doing well. It's great to be here. Well, it's awesome that… Yeah, you know what?
We want to start with like this whole DeFi 2.0 thing, I think, because this is a narrative. And you know, with crypto narratives, it's hard to understand specifically if there's substance to them or if it's all just pure kind of hype and narrative. And I think there are some people who kind of see DeFi 2.0 as more hype and less actual substance, but we want to dig into it. And one of the most, I think, tangible things we've seen is this concept of protocol-owned liquidity, protocol-controlled value. And I think Olympus DAO really pioneered that. But before we talk about that, I want to ask the question about, I guess, liquidity mining in the past, because we're going to have a conversation about Olympus DAO Pro and the new product you guys rolled out.
But what are the existing problems with, you know, what DeFi calls liquidity mining, like in traditional liquidity mining? Because I think a number of DeFi 2.0 protocols are kind of saying, like, traditional liquidity mining sucks. It has a lot of disadvantages. What are those disadvantages? Yeah, I mean, so the obvious big one is just kind of cost. So I think it really depends on a protocol-to-protocol basis. So you have some protocols like Aave where maybe it's not that big of an issue for them because their cost of liquidity is very low. You know, for USDC or DAI, they have to pay 4% or 5% APY.
And of that, you know, 2% or 2.5% is paid in Aave. For them, it might not be anything that's particularly broken. Although the nominal cost of that is still very high because they're incentivizing billions of dollars in liquidity. And it's just lower, it's just lower Zeus because Aave is so big and so popular at this point in time. Yeah, yeah. So it's just kind of a issue of scale, where, you know, if you have $20 billion and you need to give them 2% a year, you need to pay out $400 million a year. And the question is, are you accruing back more than $400 million a year to make up for that and make it a profitable, like, endeavor for the protocol?
I think that the easier case, though, is protocols that have a higher cost of liquidity. So in DeFi, we've seen really exciting products that really can change the way the finance functions. But there are these crucial pieces to them that can be really expensive for the protocol. I think that Alchemix is a really good example of this. So, you know, I think it is pretty indisputable that the service that Alchemix provides is like super valuable. This ability to unlock future yield is really cool. You know, people have really like gravitated towards that. The issue for them is that it's very intensive on their markets and liquidity sets.
So they have to pay high double digits, low triple digits APY to depositors to provide them with liquidity, which makes the entire system work. So if they don't have that liquidity, the whole thing doesn't work. But it's this issue of if they are paying that in perpetuity, it's very difficult for the economics of the system to work just because you have this high cost that doesn't really lead anywhere. So you're paying it today and the system works today. But tomorrow you have to keep paying it or also liquidity goes away and the protocol doesn't work anymore. So in those scenarios, I think that it makes a lot more sense where this protocol that's already spending a lot on liquidity would just buy that liquidity.
You know, they need it for the protocol to function. So without it, you know, this is this crucial piece. And so by purchasing that liquidity, you pay a higher upfront cost, but that is now accrued to the protocol, owned by the protocol, and will exist and provide value to the protocol in the future, like in perpetuity. So you turn this like high burn perpetual cost into a one-time cost that then provides value in perpetuity and, you know, facilitates the protocol and also, you know, can accrue like, you know, fee value where once you were paying, now you are being paid. So it kind of flips this model on its head.
I want to talk about that flipping of the model and dig into sort of the protocol owning the liquidity and the protocol buying the liquidity. but before we do, maybe just give us a quick history lesson, David, and maybe you chime in here too, in case I'm missing something. But in the beginning there was DeFi and we had some liquidity, but we had no liquidity incentives. So we had like a maker DAO, we had swap these things, didn't have tokens. And then last year, man, it seems like five years ago, but it was really just like a little over 12 months ago, not too much longer, May 2020 or so, Compound comes out and they say, we're issuing a token called Comp.
And the way you earn that token is by giving the protocol something it wants, and the protocol wants liquidity. So you put liquidity into, when we say value, when we say liquidity, we just mean like value, like collateral. You push money into the protocol. And in exchange for doing that, will give you an allocation of comp tokens. And this kicked off DeFi summer 2020, which was very much a yield farm type summer, right? And then what we found is like some of these yield farms persisted, but some of them were somewhat fleeting. And then what do you call it? The rollercoaster, David, the euthanasia rollercoaster, where you go kind of around and around and around and it gets worse and worse and worse.
And eventually like you die through all the spirals. And so the farms seemed to get worse and worse and worse. We started to see the issues with yield farming. And then there's been somewhat of a lull, I think, in DeFi. Right. And lots of maybe reasons for this. But now what's resurfacing, I think, with Olympus down some of these DeFi 2.0 protocols is this new idea, which is not liquidity farming like we're just shotgunning and spraying tokens everywhere, but protocols will start to own their own liquidity. This is kind of the trend that we're seeing, new liquidity types of designs. David, I don't know if you'd add anything to that or if I missed anything in the history there.
Yeah, the whole concept of yield farming has many edges to a sword, to a single sword. For something like Compound, it really needed to find a way to distribute its token out to many, many people. And so yield farming was one of the ways that it would do that. But the needs of compounds are not the same needs of many other protocols. And Alchemix is a great example where Alchemix doesn't necessarily need to distribute out its token as much as Compound does. It needs liquidity for liquidity's sake, whereas Compound really was a distribution mechanism. And a distribution mechanism when it comes to YieldFarm is like another way to say that is like just, you know, allowing people to sell it, right?
A great, like one of the main features that Bitcoiners talk about Bitcoin mining is that because Bitcoin mining is intensive, it forces miners to sell their tokens and allows for an equitable distribution. So that's nice if that's what you want. Not all protocols want that. Some protocols just need liquidity, and they want people who believe in their protocol to buy their token, not farm it. And so when you were talking about that euthanasia rollercoaster of just farms, forking farms, forking farms. A lot of them ultimately died because of what I like to call liquidity locus in that people with a bunch of capital see a bunch of high APY yield farms.
They come in and then they farm that thing to death and they aren't farming that system because they believe in it. They are farming it because of the high APYs. And so they consistently sell that token because they're taking the risk of being the liquidity provider and then they're receiving the tokens as rewards. Zeus here calls that like renting liquidity because protocols are issuing a certain amount of their token per time in order to incentivize liquidity to come. And so as soon as you stop incentivizing that liquidity to come, the liquidity goes away. And so we are renting liquidity in like DeFi 1.
0 with liquidity mining. But it's not actually rewarding believers. It's not actually rewarding people who want to own that token because they are just farming the thing to death. And so this concept of protocol-owned liquidity is going from a liquidity renting model to a liquidity owning model. It's the difference between renting your house for the rest of your life or just having a one-time upfront cost of purchasing your house, and then you don't have to rent it anymore. And in fact, you can actually rent it out. So it flips its model. That's why Zeus here says it flips the model on its head.
Zeus, did we get that right? And is there anything you want to add? Yeah. No, I think that's spot on. One thing that I would add is just, I think that, like, the token distribution aspect is really important. The thing that I think liquidity mining, like, gets wrong in that aspect versus, you know, something like Bitcoin, which is a similar dynamic, is that in liquidity farming, like, setups, the depositor who's earning those rewards doesn't actually have to take any exposure to the asset that they're earning. So they can kind of live agnostically from the success of the protocol that they are deposited into.
You know, there's this piece of you want the contract to be secured. So the risk that you're really taking is you get rugged or there's a smart contract issue and you lose funds. But especially in the case of like, you know, these spinoffs where you just have like a fork of whatever that everyone knows is secure, you're not really taking any risk deposited into there, and they're giving you their token in exchange. And so it's this kind of like extractive setup where you are not actually taking any of the downside, but you're taking all of the upside of the network. So in the case of Bitcoin mining, you have miners who, yes, they are earning these, you know, Bitcoin block rewards, rewards and they're selling them to you know maintain their operations but they had to do all this upfront cost to set up that operation and they're exposed to the bitcoin network as a result in the case of like you know olympus or olympus pro um you're taking exposure to the asset that you you bonded for um you you've taken some of the risk of that network and so everyone's incentives are a lot more aligned you know you're not doing this activity just to predatorily you know farm and dump because you actually have to take exposure uh so maybe you are doing that but at least you're taking on some risk in the process versus just having like freeloaders that earn all this token they take no risk they just dump on everyone else um and they don't really provide value beyond the time that they are deposited in doing so so it's like in crypto there's this classic there's like there's mercenaries there's uh tourists and there's settlers right so you You settlers being the holders.
The old style of liquidity mining, we're just kind of spraying this in a liquidity farm. It's basically, it's just mercenaries. Like you're incenting mercenaries. People just to come, not hold. They're not creating a home there. They don't really care about your asset. It could be any asset as long as they can sell it and get high APYs. But I want to ask, so I want to ask the question. So I understand that this is more, this idea of protocol-owned liquidity is rewarding holders and incenting holders rather than kind of the mercenaries. So the settlers, not the mercenaries. But what do you actually mean when you say protocol-owned liquidity?
That part might not be clear for listeners. So how does the protocol actually own it? What's the underlying mechanism here? Mm-hmm. Yeah. So it's essentially, we brought this to market. It is essentially a token swap with the protocol as your counterparty. So instead of the protocol just distributing out tokens for free and using that as like a token distribution mechanism, because I think that that's like super fair as like value and liquidity mining is that you distribute your token out. But rather than just give it away for free, it takes in assets in exchange. You know, it might provide a discount.
So you're incentivizing people to trade with the protocol instead of the market. But, you know, instead of just handing these out, it's taking out or taking assets back in return that then strengthen the network in whatever way, you know, is suitable to that network. Let's unpack that a little bit more. And I want to want you to Zeus check my thinking as I go through this so um just just to recap uh with uh traditional yield farming the yield farming that comp gave out you put in liquidity into the system and then you receive a regular distributions of the tokens with defy 2.0 uh instead what happens is that the users of the would-be yield farmers instead of in uh instead of uh providing liquidity into something like uniswap or sushi swap and then when you do that, you get a token back, your deposits, your LP tokens, then in traditionally in typical yield farming, you take those LP tokens, you go to the protocol and you stake it and you're just basically showing the protocols, hey, I have deposited liquidity.
I'm showing you I've deposited liquidity by putting it in your contracts. These contracts then issue out dividends, which is the renting liquidity model. Instead, what you're saying is you can actually purchase purchase liquidity off of the, you can purchase the LP tokens or you can create them yourselves again by just supplying liquidity to Uniswap or SushiSwap. But then you go to the protocol and instead of depositing it into a smart contract to farm, instead you sell it to the protocol. And the incentives that the protocol are for you to do that is that it gives you the protocol token at a discount.
And so if like you have a thousand dollars of token XYZ paired with a thousand dollars of ETH, you have a position in SushiSwap or Uniswap that has $2,000 worth of net capital, you can come to something like Olympus DAO, which does this program or something that taps into this primitive and Olympus DAO will purchase that $2,000 worth of liquidity from you for something like $1,900 or $1,800, some sort of discount. So there's the incentive there. And that is where this goes from kind of a one-way just farming to death system towards the actual protocol receiving LP tokens, receiving its own liquidity, and the protocol owning the liquidity.
That's where the phrase protocol-owned liquidity comes from. Is that all right? Mm-hmm. Yeah. So you end up with a pretty similar end state in that there's liquidity and there was tokens that were distributed. But the liquidity ends up owned by the protocol. And the depositors end up owning the protocol token instead of half and half for liquidity. So Olympus, when you guys do it, you guys actually have a bonding mechanism. So you get, you offer, again, these are random numbers that I'm making up. You offer to give out somebody who wants to sell you LP tokens. They want to sell you $2,000 worth of their LP tokens, and you will give them – I might have messed this up earlier.
If the user wants to sell $2,000 worth of LP tokens towards the protocol, the protocol will offer $2,100 for those LP tokens. But then the protocol asks for a five, seven-day lockup period, so you don't get that arbitrage immediately. Can you explain why that mechanism exists? Yeah. So if you provided just a pure arbitrage immediately, you know, you just have a race to the bottom. So you need this time defer or time deferral so that, you know, these things can space out and you don't just have it run into the ground, I guess. I will note that the protocol doesn't know what it's selling you or like the price that it's really quoting or it doesn't have a price that it decides to quote.
So essentially, the way that it works is that you start with some price and then it just takes down until someone decides that they want to go and buy that bond. So essentially, like the protocol doesn't care. It's all placed onto the market in terms of how it actually prices it. So let's say, you know, it's $1,000 worth of LP. It's offering $1,050 for that LP. Maybe people don't want to take that. You know, that's not enough for them. And so that price will continue to tick down until now it's offering 1,100. And someone decides, yes, I want that. And so they decide to make that trade. And as a result, each time you do, it will bring the price back up.
So, you know, it was previously quoting $1,100 for it. Now it's quoting 900. And then over time, that'll decrease back to par and then back to 1050 and 1100 until someone decides to make that action again. So I think that there's also this really cool dynamic of price discovery attached to that where you have the secondary market that is pricing the asset based on market behaviors, but in a different form than a traditional two-way AMM that I think on its own brings value as well. So correct me if I'm wrong, but so if there's like a seven day lockup or 10 day lockup, it's really pricing in the loyalty of the user who's willing to take that unknown amount of price risk over that like seven days of time.
Maybe if it were like a two day lockup period where you don't get to pocket that arbitrage for two days, you're not really incentivizing that much loyalty, only two days worth of loyalty. But if you do it for seven or nine days or even longer, you're really incentivizing loyalty because not only are you asking people to maintain exposure for at least nine days, but the longer it goes, really the more and more this mechanism really self-selects for people that believe in the system in the first place. Would you say that's true? Yeah, definitely. And in an efficient market, yeah, the discount should just be whatever the market dictates as like the required illiquidity premium.
So what do I need to get paid to be a liquid for this amount of time? Nice. So the net of this, Zeus, is that the protocol literally, its treasury, its balance sheet, literally becomes composed of all of these LP positions, right? Like LP positions in SushiSwap or LP positions in Uniswap. Like they become, rather than owned by sort of these mercenaries temporarily, they literally become owned by the protocol, which is probably why we get the protocol controlled liquidity. So first of all, is that true? And then what does that mean for, I guess, the balance sheet and the treasury of some of these types of this new mechanism?
Is this a good thing? Why is it a good thing for the protocol to own its own liquidity? So definitely true. I would say that the benefit is in like the power of kind of compounding growth so in the case of liquidity mining or you know like i like to call it renting uh you have kind of like flat uh incentivized liquidity over some amount of time so if if what people demand in terms of incentives remains the same over time then if you are incentivizing the same amount like you know ten thousand dollars a week you're gonna have the same amount of liquidity in perpetuity right if you are purchasing that liquidity as the protocol your liquidity is only growing you know whatever liquidity you already had you have and whatever you're adding you're adding and so you have this growth rather than like a flat kind of renter model you have a growth you know ownership model um it's pretty much the same dynamic that you see in just like owning versus renting in general um so like you know Houses are a good example, like home equity.
You know, if you're a renter, you don't see any of the benefit of, you know, the housing market appreciating. If you're an owner, you do. It's a similar dynamic to that where you're the protocol is retaining the equity, the liquidity that it's, you know, accumulating. Is there something to say here about realigned incentives when a protocol owns the liquidity rather than other humans? And famously, there's always the meme of pool two. There's pool two risk. Pool two is always the most risky pool. If you are farming in pool two, you're risking being dumped on by other humans. There's a little bit of alignment there.
it kind of feels like a game of chicken, like which Pool 2 farmers are going to dump on other Pool 2 farmers. And David, for Pool 2, for people who aren't familiar with Pool 2, what is that? That's the traditional yield farming mechanism where you deposit usually Ether plus a token XYZ into a staking contract. And so you are paid to provide liquidity, which can have bad incentives. If you are paid to provide liquidity, if we want to take the example of a malicious actor, a malicious yield farm. Somebody comes in with a yield farm, spins up a website, spins up a yield farm, and then they incentivize some insane APY for everyone to come and purchase the token so they can provide liquidity so that this malicious actor can dump on all of these people that are now being paid for this person to basically allow them to sell them token XYZ for Ether, right?
He's just paying other people to provide liquidity to them so they can dump. So that's because it's a human to human interaction. And again, we're trying to build trustless protocols. So Zeus, is there something to talk about, like where we see a protocol purchasing the liquidity and a protocol, like if we can see what protocols do, we can verify the code, we can see like, is this protocol literally programmed to dump on me or is it not? And if a protocol is not programmed to dump on you, which again, like the community would find out pretty damn fast if it was. Do you think that actually reduces this whole like LP risk because it's the protocol that's the counterparty rather than another human?
Yeah, I 100% do. I think it kind of comes down to like the pool two model is inherently adversarial. So, you know, just to kind of go over like how these structures work. So you generally have like a pool one, which is you deposit USDC or ETH or something. The protocol needs you to do that so that it can offer fixed income product or whatever. Then you have pool two, which the protocol is incentivizing pool one with its token. That token needs to have value to have any value as an incentive, right? You know, you need to be able to pin, this is worth this much. And so that's why I want to do this activity.
Someone needs to create that market for that token so that it has value. So you have pool two, which is you deposit this token plus Ether generally. We will incentivize you with more of that token to provide that liquidity. The issue in this structure is that you have an adversarial relationship between kind of three parties. So you have the token holders. They are, you know, reliant on the Pool 2, you know, providers to provide liquidity so that their token has value. They're also reliant on pool one and pool two that they don't just farm and dump all their rewards because that's going to depreciate the token.
You have pool one, which is reliant on pool two to provide liquidity so that their rewards are worth something. And then you have pool two, which is reliant on kind of everyone to not dump. You also have this dynamic with pool two where, you know, if you are someone who's farming this or you're holding it, anytime that someone buys or sells, they're buying or selling from the pool two providers. So they are the ones who pay you when you sell that governance token. They are the ones who sell to you as well when you buy that governance token. But you create this dynamic where, you know, Pool 2 is the one paying everyone out.
And so Pool 2 doesn't want to pay you out. You know, they want to get those rewards. They want to sell those rewards themselves, and they don't want you to sell them. So kind of these parties are all at odds. You know, their incentives are not aligned with each other. other they all have different goals and one of them achieving their goals generally is against the goals of the others um versus so if you replace that pool two component with the protocol the protocol should be happy to pay people out you know its goal is to facilitate this market it's not really to uh you know it doesn't care about when it gets to pull out its assets and you know how much of the the pool two incentives they get to dump on everyone else um where you know you get these situations with pool two and uh schemes where like one liquidity provider pulls and then that triggers someone else to pull because now they're like you know most of liquidity and they don't want to provide they don't want to uphold this entire market you know uh one guy is not incentivized to uphold the entire market of a protocol the way that a protocol might be you know so that protocol's only goal is to sustain its own like markets or whatever it's doing so it is happy to play that role versus an independent third party might not be um it's kind of this level of like being willing to take like uh impermanent loss risk and like especially in the case of like not needing to be incentivized so that you know the protocol doesn't need to be incentivized to do what's best for the protocol um you know there's this like you know imagine if everyone just like uh kind of what's the word i'm looking for generously supported protocols just because they wanted to see them succeed um you know you don't ask for any money in return you you're willing to take on downside just because you want to do well uh it's an unlikely like dynamic for any individual but for the protocol you know that's That's all it's there for.
It doesn't need to be paid to do that just because that's what it's there for. It's funny. I mean, the protocol already has all of that risk anyway, right? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So here's my big question, right? So Zeus, you've made the case that this is a better mechanism, right? I guess my question is, so why doesn't everyone do it? Why don't literally all of the DeFi protocols right now switch to this new mechanism, right? Any protocol that's offering a yield farm. Yeah, any of them, right? So YieldFarm was a less good mechanism. We've now created this better mechanism that aligns the parties.
Why doesn't every single DeFi protocol out there go and implement this? Or do you think they actually should and they just haven't yet because this is new? Are there any downsides? Are there any trade-offs here that we've left out? Yeah, I mean, so it's definitely just why does anyone ever rent anything? Because it's cheaper in the short term. You know, when you buy something, you have to pay more for it upfront. And so that can be kind of a deterrent. And it also creates like, you know, maybe in some situations, it doesn't make sense for protocol to do this. So like, you know, going back to Aave, you know, if they're paying 2% a year for their assets, probably doesn't make sense for them to buy them because, you know, that's 50 years worth of incentives, you know, the risk to reward there is probably not on their side.
And so, you know, it doesn't make sense. Can I just zone in on that really quick? So again, why is it more expensive, right? Like why is it more expensive upfront to buy this for the protocol? Mm-hmm, yeah. Yes, fill me in on that. Let's say you're trying to incentivize $100 million in liquidity and the market is demanding that you provide 50% APR for that. So over the course of the year, you are going to pay $50 million worth of your governance token. or $50 million worth of it today. You know, how much that's worth at the end of the year and how much you actually have to pay is determined by, you know, how things develop over time.
So if you were to buy that $100 million worth of liquidity, you need to like utilize $100 million worth of your token today versus in the incentive model, it'd be like a million dollars a week. So, you know, you're doing 100 million upfront versus a million a week in perpetuity. So, you know, you have this higher upfront cost that can make it difficult as a, like, I think that pool two and, you know, incentives remain this really good bootstrapping mechanism. Because you can go from zero to 100 million in the span of a weekend, you know, with incentives that are enough to, you know, bring people into the door.
But especially if you're paying 50%, 100% APR, some farms do more than that. In our case, we have to incentivize liquidity providers with 500%. It definitely makes a lot more sense to just kind of bite the bullet over the short term to have this one convert into less cost because there's a point at which you now no longer need to incentivize anything and you can even stop purchasing it. And two, you convert it into a productive asset. So liquidity is, you know, by far some of the more or most productive assets in the space. You know, most pools provide at minimum like 10% APY can get up to 30, 40, 50%.
And that's all passive. You know, the protocol can just leave it in the LP and it makes money. Yeah, so it really just comes down to that short-term cost as why it kind of becomes difficult. I'll talk about this more later, but I think that that's where, you know, Olympus kind of steps in and makes this model better for everyone. So do you think then, and I know you guys have just released this Olympus Pro type product, maybe to release this as a primitive that could be used by other DeFi protocols. But do you think the model right now is skewed for DeFi protocols far more towards like renting rather than buying?
And do you think a lot of DeFi protocols today would be far better off with this kind of protocol-owned liquidity model and they should start to explore it, they should start to adopt it? You think there's a lot of room for growth here? Yeah, I think that on the, like, industry level perspective, like, bonds and, like, protocol and liquidity make more sense than, like, the renting pull-to model. So it doesn't apply to everyone. Like, the blue chips, I would say, are the most immune. But on a larger scale, I do think that, like, most of them would be better off just accumulating their own liquidity and then owning it.
One thing that's pretty neat about this mechanism when a protocol owns its own LP shares is that protocols, they all do something. They all have a business model. They generate revenue via that business model. But now if they own a bunch of LP tokens, a bunch of liquidity tokens, they are also accruing revenue from fees from Uniswap or SushiSwap. So is there something to talk about there, Zeus, about how this might be an alternative fee generation mechanism for protocols? And how might a protocol use this new source of revenue? Yeah, so you're adding revenue, which is great. Which is great. So if you look at DeFi protocols as businesses, which there's a pretty good case for, you kind of have to look at both sides of the balance sheet.
So you have revenues, which what is the productive activity accruing back towards the protocol? And then you have expenses. Generally, that expense is the incentives that you're paying out. I think that what this really addresses is that if you look at pretty much any protocol, their expense side is way bigger than the revenue side. You know, they're paying a dollar in incentives for 10 cents in revenue. And, you know, if it's a bootstrapping thing, if this is, you know, like Amazon is a great example, you know, they lost money for 10 years before they made a dime. And, you know, it worked out, you know, Amazon is this Goliath now, and they make more money than they could, you know, do anything with.
But they use that high burn as a bootstrapping mechanism to get infrastructure in place that they own the stack. And now they make a ton of money because they're like vertically and horizontally integrated and everything. If you're not working towards anything, then you just have this scenario where the protocol loses money. And there's no like real path towards profitability. It's kind of the, you know, it's not super surprising because that's like the tech model at this point is that you have these like VC backed Goliaths that don't make any money, never will make any money. And the only real point is that they IPO and are worth something in an equity sense.
But the actual equity on the balance sheet is negative. You know, we shouldn't be trying to build systems where the system just loses money in perpetuity for kind of no reason. And how about when the token price of the relevant protocol doubles, or the protocol is successful, and then the price of the token goes up. Now, in this model, the protocol owns a decent proportion of its own token. And so when the token goes up, in theory, the protocol is actually pushing Ether back into the liquidity in DeFi because of impermanent loss, right? The token price goes up, and so people are buying the token by...
No, excuse me. The protocol is absorbing more Ether and it's distributing its token back into the ecosystem because of the dynamics of LPing inside of Uniswap or SushiSwap. How does it change when a protocol owns its own stake in its own token? Have you thought about this? Yeah. So you actually, because the protocol is the one facilitating the market, when people are buying, the protocol is accruing all of, if it's Ether that it's paired against, It accrues all that ETH that goes into the pool. So it owns the pool. There's now more ETH in the pool. The protocol now owns more ETH. So the protocol is more capitalized.
So you have this situation where like, you know, what's good for the holders, which is generally, you know, appreciation is also good for the protocol. You know, it's getting something out of that. It owns more because of that. Kind of everyone wins together and you have this like situation where everyone's incentives are really aligned towards the same goals instead of, you know, all kind of having their own independent goals that may or may not align with each other. So Zeus, can we talk about this? Because this is a product I believe that you're rolling out. Let me just share my screen here.
This is Olympus DAO Pro, which is different than Olympus DAO. But what you're basically taking is the protocol-owned liquidity model that Olympus DAO pioneered. We'll talk more about Olympus DAO soon. But you're taking that and you're exposing it to other DeFi protocols so they can use the same mechanism. So what are we looking at on this dashboard here? Are these other DeFi protocols that are creating their own protocol-owned liquidity type markets? And how does this work? Yeah. So this is our first cohort for Olympus Pro. So you can see on the left, that is the payment token so you know in the first case you would acquire fox eth uni lp then you would take that to this page um you would get you know that one is actually sold out so we'll use the frax wrapped eath slp um it'll pay you back fxs for that liquidity um you have that roi there is the discount that it's providing so the market price is 576 and it'll sell it to you for 5 or 42.
You would click bond there, you approve the LP to get transferred, and then basically you repurchase FXS at that discounted price over the course of, I think in their case it's two weeks. Your FXS will become available to you right when you create it. The FRAX protocol now owns that liquidity. And you can see that they have purchased about a quarter million worth of liquidity so far. And that's it. So is this open to basically any DeFi protocol now to set this mechanism up or you said a first cohort? Are you kind of selecting some projects? Yeah, so we're kind of phasing it out. So right now we're doing cohorts.
We have cohort two, I believe, quite soon in the next couple of weeks with the goal of I think by end of year being permissionless and open. we're definitely like learning things as we deploy this for other protocols that we want to kind of have in place before it's really just open to everyone. And what is the benefit to Olympus DAO for, you know, creating Olympus Pro as a primitive? Is there any benefit or are you guys providing this as like a public service? So there's two main ones. So one, we take a fee that's paid in the governance token of the protocol. and we don't really have any intent of like selling that.
Basically what we want to do is have upside in these projects and align our incentives with them. So when they win, we win. The second is that, you know, kind of going back to what is the drawback of this model, you know, that higher upfront cost. You know, what we want to push is that you can kind of see. So every single one of these pools is paired against me. And there's this question, you know, so they're driving demand for ETH in this relationship. They're bringing ETH off of the market, they're paying for it to bring it into theirs. And there's this question of kind of what does ETH give back to them for that relationship?
So, you know, ETH is a very large and capitalized asset. You know, it's very ingrained in this space, but the reality is that it doesn't do a lot for you as a protocol or an individual. know the the the modus of responsibility is entirely on you to pay the cost of that um what we want to do is start getting these pools to be paired instead of against eth um against ohm or against geom which will be you know our governance uh on-chain governed token um through that you know we on our end already are accumulating liquidity and you know assets and paying for it with them um they are doing the same now and if they're paying for it and sucking in ohm you know it kind of makes sense that we would do the same for them you know it's an activity that we're already engaged in and if that can be a mutually beneficial one let's do it um so you know we we see it as kind of a way to expand the utility and use of ohm uh kind of on a protocol level where you know because we might be willing to offer bonds on like the frax g own pair um or actually we have a fraction pair that we we own you know 30 million dollars worth of um but because of that the cost of capital for these protocols diminishes um so instead of having to pay that entire cost we are now paying some of it too um and we're reducing what they have to pay and so it makes this entire proposition a lot easier because you know instead of having to pay x number of months or years worth of incentives for this, you know, we cut that in half or we cut that, you know, to a third or something.
Doing an activity that we're already engaged in anyways. So it's very much I see as a win-win. So a lot of people in the YouTube chat are asking about why some of these have a negative ROI percentage. Can you explain why that dynamic exists? Yep. So these, the protocol or the bond mechanism does not look at the price of the actual market. It has no idea what the asset actually trades for. It has an internal price that is separate from anything else. It's like its own pricing. And basically what it does is for the ALKEX ETH pool, maybe it starts at 360. And over time, no one buys that. It'll just keep decreasing the price.
So it's kind of like a Dutch auction. it. Price keeps going down until someone decides they want to buy that bond. At that point, when it receives that, it just takes the price up. There's math involved here and I won't get into it, but price raises, now it's higher, and then it just starts taking down again. And it takes down until someone buys it back up. So when someone buys it, it kicks that price up. And generally what you'll see is it falls into a negative discount, where now that price that it's quoting is higher than the market price. And basically all you have to do is just wait. Over time, it'll decrease until it's a discount.
And then it's enough of a discount that someone buys it and brings it into the negative territory again. So at that spell, which is clocking in at like negative 5% ROI, does that imply that somebody just like took a bought a bunch of that, that bond and they are now, uh, and now the spell ROI is just negative five because somebody recently bought a bunch yep i would imagine if you looked at the chain yeah you would see that someone just bought a bond that was large enough to to take the discount from positive to negative so zeus i'm curious as we kind of close this section and we've got more questions to ask you on the other side of the olympus dow but like we we started this whole conversation um under the uh i guess the label of d5 2.
0 and so is this what d5 2.0 is basically what you know what we're talking about um is it is it just protocols that start to this is a new generation of protocols that start to own their own liquidity is that that a core piece of it is that the only piece of it what do you make of this whole d5 2.0 moniker in general yeah so i think that the name kind of came out of nowhere and has really become pervasive very quickly um but yeah that's kind of how I see it is it's protocols that are geared towards longevity I think at a baseline so focusing on things that accrue long-term value towards the protocol and less so on single point in time activities um and I think it's a natural conclusion of just you know DeFi you know you touched on at the beginning of this you know DeFi is pretty much only like a year old in a real since.
May last year was really the kickoff of all this. And we've had this kind of journey of incentives enabled all these products we built and become usable. And we've realized in the past year that the structure under which that works doesn't work that well in terms of capturing the upside of that protocol. So generally, if you want to do that, you're the farmer that's dumping on everyone. So I see DeFi 2.0 as really geared towards aligning incentives between the facilitators and holders, facilitators of the protocol, holders of the protocol token towards long term success. That's great. So guys, we're going to have to cut for sponsors and we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible.
When we get back, we will be talking about Olympus DAO. I think it's a case study, maybe an algorithmic stable coin that's trying to become a store of value, trying to become a money that is based on this protocol-owned liquidity incentive structure. We've got a lot of questions about that, including some hard ones on whether this is a Ponzi scheme or something else. Ponzi game. Ponzi game. Ponzi game. Yes, Ponzi game. But before we do that, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Alchemix is one of the coolest new DeFi apps on the scene. It introduces self-paying loans, allowing you to spend and save at the same time.
Deposit the DAI stablecoin into the Alchemix vault in order to get an advance on the interest it generates. Borrow up to 50% of the total amount of your deposited DAI in the form of ALUSD stablecoin. Here's the craziest part. The loan pays itself back and you cannot be liquidated. Unlock your assets potential in the ultimate DeFi savings account. And brand new to Alchemix is the ETH vault where you can deposit ETH into the application, borrow AlETH against your deposits while having your advance gradually paid back over time. V2 is rapidly approaching which will allow for even more collateral types plus a variety of yield strategies to choose from.
Harness the power of Alchemix at alchemix.fi that's a-l-c-h-e-m-i-x dot f-i. Follow Alchemix on Twitter at AlchemixFI and join the discord to keep up to date with Alchemix v2 and to get involved in governance. The Aave protocol is a decentralized liquidity protocol on Ethereum which allows users to supply and borrow certain crypto assets. Aave version 2 has a ton of cool features that makes using the Aave protocol even more powerful. With Aave, you can leverage the full power of DeFi money Legos, yield, and composability all in one application. On Aave, there are a ton of assets that you can supply to the protocol in order to gain yield, and all of those same assets can also be borrowed from the protocol if you have supplied collateral.
Here you can see me borrowing 200 USDC against my portfolio of a number of different DeFi tokens in ETH. I'll choose a variable interest rate because it's a lower rate than the stable interest rate option, but I could choose the stable interest rate option if I wanted to lock in that interest rate in permanently. V2 also features the ability for users to swap collateral without having to withdraw their assets, trade them on Uniswap, and then deposit them back into Aave. With Aave, users can do this in one seamless transaction, saving you time and gas costs. Check out the power of Aave at aave.
com. That's a-a-v-e dot com. All right, guys, we are back talking to Zeus from Olympus DAO Protocol. So Zeus, we've talked so much about protocol owned liquidity. I think we have a good picture of that. Now I want to talk about Olympus DAO as a project because it is absolutely exploded on the scene this year. I don't know what its market cap is right now. It's like $2.5 billion, something like that from basically nothing from scratch. And this is described as kind of an algorithmic stablecoin. I know it's partially backed. It's also free floating. Can you talk to us about why this is going to be successful where other algo stablecoins have failed?
Because we have been scarred, I think, in DeFi by failure after failure after failure of these types of monetary experiments. They get to a certain point and they all eventually blow up. Some of them don't even launch. But the ones that do launch, they tend to crumble away and die in bank runs and all sorts of other things. Why is Olympus DAO different in your mind? Yeah. So the first one is kind of easy. So we're not trying to be a stable coin. We're trying to build a currency. So the goal is that in the long term, it is stable and low volatility. But the goal is not to just trade at a $1 peg.
So that's one of the first issues with those previous models was that when you try to peg to $1, and you're reliant on market behavior to facilitate that, you create this dynamic where everyone's confidence in this is derived from it holding $1. So currency is all just a confidence game at the end of the day. Whether people believe that this monetary asset has value dictates whether it has value. And, you know, if you have the scenario where only when it is worth this amount does it have value, then the second that you deviate from that, you can very easily collapse. And that's kind of what we've seen with every previous, like, experiment is that it works until there's one moment that it doesn't work.
And then in that one moment, everyone decides that it's over and they need to get out. And then, you know, it becomes self-fulfilling. So it's hard for them to kind of recover from those situations. So in our case, you know, we don't have a peg. There is no correct price. And so you remove that dynamic of deriving confidence from a trading at exactly this point. That's the free-floating aspect of this. Yeah. The other one that I think we have an advantage over those previous models is that if you're relying on third party behavior and incentive structure, which all these stable coins have been, you have to pay for that.
So you need to pay third parties to go do something. Otherwise, they're not going to do it because what's in it for them? That cost is a cost on the market. And there's kind of this question of like, okay, what are you accruing for that cost? And the answer is kind of nothing. You're accruing that it holds this peg for this exact moment in time. So you're just paying money to maintain like a steady state. It's like running on a hamster wheel. And you hit this point where, you know, there's not enough coming in to really sustain that anymore. And so you flip to the other direction. And because everyone is deriving their confidence from holding this one number, once, you know, you flip in the other, like from growing to shrinking, you know, you're, you're at a very high risk of just full-on collapse as people realize that they're not going to make more money in this.
And so they, they jump out and leave. And that kind of like turns into a race to the bottom. You know, in our case, the protocol is accruing assets as a result of, you know, this incentivized behavior. So everything accrues value towards the protocol. You are, you are creating tangible value in the protocol that persists, no matter like, you know, someone was participating yesterday and they're not today, that doesn't matter. That value is already there and it's not going anywhere. And so you're actually building towards something. You're, you know, accruing something that has long lasting benefit, which, you know, I think definitely aligns people's incentives at least towards having longevity and building towards, you know, a longer term vision than just trying to, you know, keep up with the treadmill.
Zeus, can you elaborate on the currency branding? Because I could see a parallel universe where Olympus DAO is exactly the same, but instead of having a currency branding, maybe it has a fund branding. Because as I understand it, Olympus DAO is a mechanism, it's a system of smart contracts that incentivizes depositing collateral, depositing assets into the smart contracts. And then it has this OHM token, which is loosely valued based off of the total deposited collateral. And so it's kind of backed by the collateral. But in the same way, the value of a fund is backed by the value of what it has invested in.
So can you elaborate on like why the currency branding? And do you think the fund or, you know, you know, hedge fund or just like, I think, yeah, hedge fund, but like why that branding isn't appropriate or perhaps is it? Yeah. I mean, I think it really comes down to like, especially with the algo stable experiments, like what is trying to be accomplished. So, you know, the, the point of all those, why, you know, a success won't be valuable is that this is this decentralized and censorship resistant currency for people to use in DeFi. And, you know, conceivably beyond that. And, but it comes down to, so what are you trying to create?
And it's like this mirror image of the dollar. The dollar is free floating in value. There's no peg for the dollar. So why are we trying to mimic the exact dollar when we could create a new dollar? That's kind of where it comes out. Like the goal should be that we have our own native currency and not just that we have like a censorship resistant version of the TradFi currency. So, sorry, I'm kind of losing my train of thought. I mean, we're with you. We're definitely with you right there, right? That's why we talk about like, you know, Bitcoin being a non-sovereign money, ETH being a non-sovereign money, and you know, that sort of thing.
And I do want to get back on that thread because there's more to pull on there. But like really quick, another question I had in the design of this thing is, so So is Ohm fully collateralized? Is it partially collateralized? What dictates the market price of an Ohm? And then how much of that market price rests on what's inside of the Lippestau treasury? Yeah, so it is, I guess, in a real sense, partially collateralized. Essentially, it's predicated on this mint requirement. So the protocol can only create OM if it has one unit of stablecoin or equivalent in its treasury. So you create this floor where, you know, literally this token cannot exist unless that amount of value backs it.
In reality, we have, you know, 42, 44 units per token. And so there's this like surplus that allows us to mint new tokens and distribute them as rewards. But those are all fully backed at that one die kind of floor. In reality, because we trade higher than 42 or 44, it becomes partially collateralized. The difference there is monetary premium. So if you look at ETH or Bitcoin or any monetary asset, the entire value that they trade above zero is monetary premium, essentially. You do have an argument of, like, you know, transaction fees for Ether, Bitcoin, or, like, you know, industrial use for gold.
But, like, the actual market there is much smaller than the market capital's assets. You know, the value is expanded with monetary premium, which is essentially just, you know, we as, you know, monkeys decide that something is worth something, even though it's not actually. and use that to facilitate like trading cooperation among ourselves. So you don't want to like have the actual, I'm not going to, like a barter kind of like-kind exchange economy is inefficient. You don't want the actual value that you're exchanging to be equal on both sides. And so you have like this monetary intermediary that's not actually worth anything.
It doesn't cost society anything, but you can use it to transact between people. So you kind of increase efficiency and like anything that's productive, you're putting towards productive use. That's kind of where the premium comes in. And like the idea of backing is that with these monetary assets, they're entirely predicated on that monetary premium continuing to exist. If it doesn't, you're kind of hosed. and if you have reserves that back it, basically what that does is today we are agreeing that there's a monetary premium for this asset. But if tomorrow that agreement no longer exists, we can pull in this other asset that agnostic of us, we all agree has value and use that to imbue our market with value once again.
So you have this outside source of value that you can use to support the value of your own market. and agreeing that OM has value doesn't have anything to do with agreeing that ETH or DAI has value. You know, they're completely separate. And so you kind of de-risk the market because the value is not just predicated on belief in the monetary premium of OM, but also the belief in the monetary premium of whatever backs OM. Or, you know, not even monetary premium, but, you know, we hold a lot of monies. You know, and this is pretty much the currency model that has existed like past hundred years, essentially.
You know, the fiat system is a little weirder because they don't have like a hard backing requirement. But you still do, you know, in fiat currencies today, have central banks that hold assets. They use those assets to facilitate the markets of their currencies and, you know, kind of support the market for their currency, decrease volatility so it's easier to use, you know, within their economies. pretty much the same model. So I would argue if you're going to call this a hedge fund, then you would call central banks a hedge fund as well. Maybe there is an argument for that. Zeus, all successful protocols generate haters some way, one way or another, and there's no doubt that OlympusDAO has been extremely successful, especially over the last six months or so.
And so I think if you ask the Omis this question, they would call you naive. But I just want to address this question. And I think you might have already answered it in a roundabout way. But for the haters out there that think that Olympus DAO is just a Ponzi game, where it's just a game of chicken and at some point it's going to collapse, what would you say to somebody that has that critique? I mean, I would just say, would you say the same thing about Bitcoin or ETH or any of these governance tokens or pretty much any asset? You know, it's the same argument. Doesn't mean that there's no validity, but just to be consistent about it.
So you either think that all markets are a Ponzi, or you think none of the or you think that actual Ponzi's are Ponzi's. You know, there are very clear things that dictate like like it generally comes down to maliciousness and lack of transparency. transparency, you know, being lied to about what is going on here. And usually an element of like, you know, whoever is maintaining it is just taking that money and buying yachts and jet skis and stuff. But I think it really just comes down to like, this is how markets work. You know, you take something that, you know, is intrinsically less valuable, and you imbue it with more value, like that's the whole point of a market.
If you wanted everything to trade at the exact value that it was worth, then you wouldn't have markets. So I, I personally come down to the place where like, I believe like all money is basically a meme, right? And so if we do call these money systems Ponzi's, then I guess they're all Ponzi's. They're all, you know, some of them have greater degrees of transparency than others, at least when it's on chain, it does have some degree of, of transparency, but like they're, they're Ponzi's in that, like, it's all a shared myth, a shared belief that humans have, that what is going to be the point system for how we denominate things, right?
It's like, at the end of the day, it's a collective choice. Ryan and I were discussing at the start of this show that as soon as you perceive value, as soon as the value starts to become perceived, everything starts to be a Ponzi game, which is meaningfully different than a Ponzi scheme. Yeah, it does have a negative connotation. A lot of people aren't really willing to accept the term that Ponzi game is actually just like kind of the way that the world works. Yeah. I see. I think that. Yeah, I feel like if it had a different name, it would be much more agreeable because like it inherently is not a bad thing.
I don't think like, you know, the point of markets is generally to like expand value and, you know, facilitate resources. That's what that is. Well, I guess I guess my question, though, Zeus is um why do you think that olympus dao and you know the omis have a shot against all of the competing other money monies in the world right so you could take fiat right we know all the problems with fiat but even take just let's take the world of of crypto so uh could it actually compete against a bitcoin could it actually compete against an eath does it need to compete against these things to have some sort of monetary premium or is this not a like winner take all winner take most market what's your take on some of these things um so i don't think we need to compete at all i see it as very complimentary so you have this dynamic of you know two things so you have money and you have currency and you know they're pretty generally conflated to be the same thing but they're not um so you know monies are generally hard assets and they generally are like purely monetary premium.
So ETH and Bitcoin don't need to be backed because we're okay with them being volatile. We're okay with like, that's the nature of a hard asset. A currency is something built on top of that, which kind of harnesses the value of those hard assets and those monies, but converts it into a more stable and risk mitigated format. So you have a similar dynamic and then you have a monetary premium, but that monetary premium is less. Instead of infinite premium, it is something quantifiable. So do we have a better chance than Bitcoin of replacing gold? Probably not. Do we have a better chance than Bitcoin at replacing or at least like serving a role that like fiat currencies do?
I would say yes. And the biggest reason there being one, you can mitigate risk in that, you know, there is an intrinsic value to this network. And so, you know, you as a participant, you know, can quantify your downside. Even, you know, right now our premium is, you know, 5 or 6x. So that downside is still, you know, tangible. But, you know, you can quantify, which is pretty big. You know, I can't like literally just go to and sit at zero in the way that like, you know, in a real black swan, like, you know, even Bitcoin could. although you know there's plenty of people that are like i will buy every bitcoin at one dollar if it goes there um i mean i would buy my first bitcoin at one dollar if it goes there really your first bitcoin no i've owned bitcoin before but still um the other is that you have an entity in the market that is incentivized to stabilize the asset.
So this is one that, you know, time will kind of tell for these, but for Bitcoin and ETH, which are, you know, like kind of the poster child biggest ones, like I don't see any real incentive towards stabilizing these assets in to a degree that they can really be used in the same way that fiat currencies are. You know, you need like very low volatility and everyone is in Bitcoin or ETH for it to appreciate. So, you know, the incentives are misaligned where, you know, no one really wants that versus, you know, in the case of home, like, you know, the protocol is willing to fall on the knife or whatever to facilitate that, you know, even if it's not a profitable endeavor, you know, it might lose money to provide spreads that decrease volatility or at least put itself at risk of losing money in a way that a third party actor might not be.
So, you know, it just kind of comes back to like the facilitating LP and everything. You just have an entity that is willing to make actions that a third party might not be. You know, an action that, like, you know, a third party might be taking too much risk that they think that it's not worth it for them or they're not getting incentivized enough and so it's not worth it. Like, the protocol will do that because the token holders of the protocol, you know, it brings value to them. And so they, you know, are willing to kind of have the protocol serve that role. Okay, so your model of things, right?
So high level is like, we have the physical world over here, right? And that world is based on like originally these hard money assets, like gold and silver, these sorts of things. And then every time we had central banks that built on top of those things and created currencies, they created sort of fiat on top of that. Now over here, we have this digital crypto backed world. And at the bottom, you're saying our hard assets like Bitcoin and ETH. And where you see Olympus DAO is sort of the currency layer above those hard assets. It's almost like competing as sort of a decentralized DAO driven Federal Reserve.
And that's how these two worlds are modeled in your mind. Is that right? And for the record, the Federal Reserve has done a fantastic job on putting assets on the balance sheet. yes i mean they're doing kind of the same thing zeus we don't have too much time but uh more time but want to ask you about the omis so where does community come from i mean they're everywhere now what unites them why are they so um so excited and energetic yeah yeah i mean so it's definitely been incredible for me to witness um you know it's definitely beyond anyone uh how this has come to form but i think it really just comes down to like this was the vision of crypto originally you know this is what crypto was meant to accomplish and as it's developed we've kind of seen that like it hasn't actually happened um you know you still have kind of the same dynamic where it's like you know like the whole industry used to be called like cryptocurrency for a reason like i don't think that we actually have any cryptocurrencies um but you know the the narrative i guess was always that oh in the future you know these things will be usable in the same way that you use like dollars or whatever currency today and now we're sitting at you know multi trillion dollar total market cap um you know a trillion dollars for bitcoin and it still kind of behaves the same way that it did several years ago um yes it's a little less volatile like it's getting there but you know i think that most people don't feel like satisfied with the actual progress made there um and so i think that home has been very captivating in that this is the model that has worked for the last century um it kind of makes sense to just replicate what works instead of trying to go back to like a gold system.
You know, like we're like having a gold standard instead of gold is kind of how I see it. You know, there's a reason that we moved to currency in the first place. I don't know. I kind of just see OM as like the first real attempt at that. And I think that like there's a lot of demand to see something like that in the world. And so it's very captivating for people. So that's kind of how I interpret it. Very cool, Zeus. Yeah, it seems like you guys have captured a lot of latent energy in this space and occupied a lot of minds, mindshare. And you want to conclude with this question. Thank you for your time.
It's been a blast talking about all of these things. But we've been talking about this theme of DeFi 2.0 and David and I have been on kind of a journey, a vision quest towards exploring DeFi 2.0 here recently. Who else should we talk to? Who are some of the coolest DeFi 2.0 projects that you've come across recently? Yeah, so I love what Alchemix is doing. I think Tokamak is really cool under the same vein. Or under the same vein as like us, not really Alchemix. Who else? I mean, all of our Olympus Pro partners, you know, have kind of demonstrated that they see the vision here and they want to be a part of it.
Uh... Yeah, I would say like, I don't know, Tokamak is one that like still hasn't launched yet. The jury is still out. But I respect the angle that they're taking for, you know, a very similar problem. Fea is another one, you know, they're kind of tackling the same thing as Tokamak, where, you know, we're all kind of waking up to this fact that perpetual incentivization of liquidity is not something that's going to work in the long term. at least on like a large scale and for everyone. And, you know, we've got a couple of different contenders now trying to solve that problem. And I think that it's going to result in not a winner-take-all system, but a lot of different options for protocols to secure liquidity and facilitate what they need to, depending on what works best for them.
That's great. Zeus, thank you so much. We got Faye, Tokamak, Olympus, Dow, Pro. You guys are all doing great work. We're excited as you continue down this path. Thanks for spending some time with us. Thank you, you guys. Risks and disclaimers, guys, of course. Crypto is risky. DeFi is risky. So is an algorithmic coin. All of it's risky. You could lose what you put in. But we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we are glad you're with us on the Bankless journey. Thanks a lot. Hey, we hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, head over to Bankless HQ right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence.
We recommend joining our daily newsletter, podcast, and community as a Bankless Premium subscriber to get the most out of your Bankless experience. You'll get access to our market analysis, our alpha leaks, and exclusive content, and even the Bankless token for airdrops, raffles, and unlocks. If you're interested in crypto, the Bankless community is where you want to be. Click the link in the description to become a Bankless Premium subscriber today. Also, don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders, ask me anythings, and weekly roll-ups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content.
Thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation.