Payment chains are heating up. Not every “stablecoin chain” is playing the same game.
Codex cofounder and CEO Haonan Li joins David to map the real landscape: what neutrality looks like in practice, why the bottleneck isn’t TPS but fiat-to-stable friction, and how on-chain FX could pull global flows.
We dig into the Bear-Chain incentive trap. Why Codex chose to build as an Ethereum L2. The case for app-specific rollups that return value to ETH. And the growing split between projects that bundle value toward Ethereum and those that pull it away.
---
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
---
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAXNET | MINT, REDEEM, EARN
https://bankless.cc/fraxnet
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
https://bankless.cc/unichain
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR L2 NETWORK
https://bankless.cc/Mantle
💤EIGHT SLEEP | IMPROVE YOUR SLEEP
https://bankless.cc/eight-sleep
💠BIT DIGITAL ($BTBT) | ETH TREASURY
https://bankless.cc/bit-digital
We’re being compensated by Bit Digital (NASDAQ BTBT) for this segment promoting their company and BTBT. The compensation is paid in cash as a one time payment. You can find additional information about Bit Digital and BTBT on their Investor page at https://bit-digital.com/investors
---
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
1:10 Codex’s Market Positioning
2:24 How Stablecoin Chains Differ
4:55 Neutrality For Chains And Customers
8:11 Codex’s Focus: Fiat Friction & Wholesale FX
14:16 The Golden Goose: On-Chain Transfers Vs On-Ramps
17:49 Liquidity, Demand, Exotics: The Case For On-Chain FX
24:55 Why An Ethereum L2: Technical & Economic Rationale
32:50 Founding Codex, Contrarian Thesis & Focused L2s
40:23 Community Dynamics, Tempo, Bundlers Vs Unbundlers
1:00:16 Closing Thoughts
---
RESOURCES
Haonan Li
https://x.com/haonan
---
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Most cross-border transactions involve an FX component and so if you are the cheapest place for FX to happen That chain will be a natural magnet for all these stablecoin flows And we want to be the cheapest place for T to C swaps You want to be the cheapest place fastest place to do this fiat stable swaps as well This is not what typically happens at a chain company a chain company classically doesn't want to think about fiat Why don't you think about fiat? I'm at a crypto company. Why would I think about fiat if you think about The reality of these systems like how do you make it so that stablecoins aren't just useful to it like people in crazy countries like crazy situations Well, you need to make the friction go down to zero you need to make it so that moving between a unit of fiat and stables is Frictionalists on a cost and speed basis need to delete the border between fiat and crypto So that that's what we are focused on we're staffed against that We wake up every morning.
We think about this. How do we delete this border make it go to zero Big list nation. I'm with how to end the co-founder and CEO of codex codex is a stablecoin focused layer two on top of a theory How then welcome to big list. Hey, David good to see you So you are working in a pretty competitive part of the market There's Stripes tempo. There's circles arc. There's plasma. There's stable not to mention the deep incumbent tron Competitive are you intimidated? You know, I think there's a ton of competition if you think about it from the perspective of a VC PowerPoint slide Right if you had a category that said stablecoin chain you would have all these logos I think what that abstracts away is actually most of the reality in the detail underneath and The reality is that these different chains are pursuing totally different directions and I can just say for us I can't speak for others when we are going to market against our customers We don't really hear about any of these other chains We don't hear about plasma and stable because they've taken this sort of maybe more bear chain type approach We don't hear about arc or tempo perhaps they're quick.
It's perhaps not quite clear exactly what it is. They want to do yet And so we just see all these charts going up into the right and we're growing a lot and And customers seem to like what we are doing and you know, we just want to focus on focus on the customer Maybe you could teach me and the listeners a little bit about what makes these chains so different from each other Because like if you I think you talk to the average person in crypto They're like, oh, yes, there's just this whole payment as chain sector Where we're all trying to disrupt visa and we're going to put stable coins on the very fast blockchain And that's going to become the payments chain And that's what all of these all the the chains that I just named that's what they're all going after again tempo arc plasma stable Tron has been the payments chain the stable coin payments chain Is that is that is there more nuance there or like what are the construction the construction differences between all these chains And how they point to different outcomes maybe you could be educate us a little bit there Yeah, I think there's multiple layers to it and there are a lot of differences across multiple layers I think let me start with saying that it's such a new category that Nobody really knows what they are doing quite yet right they're all exploring this idea maze this giant design space And people have chosen different parts of the maze to start with So you know, what is the approach of say a plasma or perhaps a stable right the approach is the bear chain playbook So what is the bear chain playbook right you do you do a token event And you attract a bunch of flows that come onto your chain Of course able cop right you're giving away free money Then you try to make it stay Because if it leaves, you know, you're screwed So how do you make it stay well you fork over a bunch of defy stuff that exists elsewhere the same you know 10 apps that exist everywhere And you sprinkle token incentives on top and you hope to God it stays The problem with this approach historically is that nothing of different differentiated or substantial Results from this right and of the day you've got the same defy apps And so what ends up happening is people dump the tokens These are mercenary farmers right this is we are far far away from the days of like The unier drop right this is like industrial scale farming type dynamics People will dump the token The price will go down But you still need to keep the money there as much as possible So you give away more tokens to hit the same APY People dump the tokens more the price goes down And then eventually all goes to zero right or near zero so We've seen this movie play out before with the bear chain or a blast Will it play out this way at this time round?
It's not clear Perhaps it won't It's just a very different approach from maybe our way of processing the problem When it comes to a tempo or an arc I think both these guys run into a ton of problems when it comes to neutrality So imagine that you are And here I like to say like neutrality is not just like an ethereum prayer Right it's not this like religious word that we say to each other at these ethereum Parties but like not to come off like that yeah It comes off like that right it's it's almost like the word deluxe It just means good to a lot of people like deluxe cheeseburger is just a good cheeseburger right But neutrality means something What does it mean here it means if you are a competing fintech from stripe Do you really want to bet the future of your business on stripe chain If you are a competing issuer to circle do you really want to bet the future of your business on circle chain It's hard for me to imagine like imagine the Sort of CEO of a large fintech going to his board and saying hey guys like we really fucked out like stripes way ahead of us Like we're just gonna go use their thing.
I don't know. I don't It's not very sort of credible to me So that would be maybe my first cut at distinguishing all these different approaches Isn't that the neutrality aspect isn't that just true for all of these chains all brand new chains in my mind have On day one have the most compromised neutrality that they'll ever have and then I'll ideally they become more Decentralize more equitable more spread out over time But ultimately any brand new chain is always just not neutral It's just by the by the truth of the fact that it's like brand new like There's all all of these have VCs all of these have early insiders like ultimately is the neutrality thing Neutrality is not really something that you can engineer There's neutrality and then there's neutrality right there's sort of like compared to say a Bitcoin You know some would argue with hearing is not neutral, right?
But I think that's somewhat of a pedantic point I think the neutrality that really matters in the market today instead of like this kind of pseudo religious thing that people might have on Twitter The neutrality that really matters in the market today is are you really going to bet the future for a company on a competitor's infrastructure? Are you really going to see that control to them and does that really sell at the executive level And I think what we are discovering what we're seeing is that it doesn't really sell and nobody wants to use a competitor's substrate Mm-hmm. I think another way saying this is like let's take us for example codex we don't run an issuer and we certainly don't run a fintech We're not going to be competing against our customers So isn't that so that same aspect is probably also true of plasma and stable And you're just saying it's not true of arc and stripe because stripe is stripe or tempo because stripe Tempo has stripe and then arc has circle.
They're they're the issuer But and then but then what your critique is of plasma and stable is like well They're kind of doing the bear chaining as well With which is separate cure except for critique But at least they have the neutrality going for them is is kind of like a summary. I think that's fair I think like if you dig in like they're mostly focused on tether right so is there really issue neutrality there It's you know somewhat debatable, but I think you know the the main thrust is correct Well, you're highlighting the differences that you're highlighting is kind of like to go to market But ultimately are these all the same things at their endgame like do they all converge on The payments chain like landscape and that actually that part is actually the comment denominator That there aren't any nuances there.
They are actually the same kind of outcome that everyone's going for it Is that true? It's not clear to me at the end state here will be necessarily I think certainly in this first sort of leg of the race people are taking totally different approaches and They're building different products really right because if you think about it you're like okay I'm going to make a change for stable coins. Great. What does that mean? What matters what doesn't like here? Here's one thing that could matter right you could say well I think it's really important that people can pay for their gas and all kinds of stable coins So I'm going to enshrine a dex And you know this way I think this is super super important and obviously if I enshrine a dex Then I've got to really make sure it's robust and how do I figure out this like the effects mechanics of that And how do I make sure that doesn't break you could do that Mm-hmm.
You could say that you know what? I think the most important thing is to build a neo-bank So I don't keep too close with what stable and others are doing But last I heard they were doing something like this right What is a neo-bank? It's like a you know payment app with stable coins in the back And you say that's the most important thing to build And so you're going to pick up these like little flows one by one and you put it on your chain do that Or you could do what we are doing which we think is much much smarter. What's what's that with that thing? Yeah, so I think what we want to focus on is at wholesale effects flows Okay, why is that well because Most cross-border transactions involve an effects component And so if you are the cheapest place for effects to happen Mm-hmm that chain will be a natural magnet for all these stable coins flows And so that's what we're focused on right we want to be the cheapest place for T to C swaps We want to be the cheapest place Was that you USDT to USDC the stable coin people don't want to keep repeating USD Yeah, I said okay Those cheap swaps you want to be the cheapest place fastest place to do this fiat stable swaps as well And so this is like this is not what typically happens at a chain company right a chain company classically Doesn't want to think about fiat why don't you think about fiat?
I mean I'm at a crypto company Why would I think about fiat? I want to think about shared sequencing schemes and you know like I'm going to rotate the sequencer and and all these every time we're off Yeah, like much more interesting from an engineering perspective certainly right but if you think about The reality of these systems like how do you make it to that stable coins aren't just useful to the like people in crazy countries And like crazy situations Well, you need to make the friction go down to zero You need to make it so that moving between a unit of fiat and stables Is frictionless on a cost and speed basis need to delete the border between fiat and crypto And that means like understanding the fiat infrastructure right which again is very contrarian So that that's what we are focused on we're staffed against that We wake up every morning.
We think about this. How do we delete this border make it go to zero? Introducing at Frax USD the genius aligned digital dollar from Frax It's a secure stable and fully backed by institutional grade real world assets custodyed by black rock superstay and fidelity It's always redeemable one-to-one transparently audited and built for payments defi and banking the best of all worlds at the core is Frax net an on-chain fintech platform built to align with emerging US regulatory frameworks where you can mint redeem and use Frax USD with just a few clicks deposit usc send a bank wire or tokenized treasuries and receive programmable Digital dollars straight to your wallet Frax net users benefits from the underlying return of US treasuries and earn Just by using the system whether you're bridging minting or holding your Frax USD works for you Frax isn't just a protocol.
It's a digital nation powered by the Frax token and governed by his global communities Join that community and help shape Frax nation's future by going to Frax.com slash r slash bankless Frax designed for the future of compliant digital finance Imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly That's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking a revolutionary new category at the intersection of trad five and web three At the heart is you are the world's first money out built fully on chain It gives you a Swiss iban account blending fiat currencies like the euro the Swiss fronk the United States dollar or the Remembee with crypto all in one place enjoy real world usability and blockchains trust and programmability transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with trad five rails and packed with integrated defi futures You are transforms mantle network into the ultimate platform for on-chain financial services Unifying payments trading and assets like the mi4 the me's protocol and functions f btc backed by developer grants ecosystem incentives and top distribution through the urf reward stations and buy bit launch pool for mint holders every economic activity in ur drives value back to you embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem Follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking That's x.
com slash mantle underscore official ethereum's layer two universe is exploding with choices But if you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens make your next stop unichain first liquidity Unichain hosts the most liquid uniswap v4 deployment on any layer two giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like eth USDC more liquidity means better prices less slippage and smoother swaps exactly what traders crave the numbers back it up Unichain leads all layer twos in total value locked for uniswap v4 and it's not just a deep It's fast and fully transparent purpose built to be the home base for defy and cross-chain liquidity when it comes to cost Unichain is a no-brainer transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than ethereum maintenance Slashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity want to stay in the loop on unichain visit unichain.
org or follow at unichain on x for all the updates I think the Conversation we're drifting into is the golden goose conversation is that's what I'll call it And each one of these chains kind of has like what their perceived value is And I think the most basic way to articulate this value is like Kind of similar to like this a lot of idea of just like a ton of volume at very low fees And stablecoins clearly is the killer app after Bitcoin right after like non-sovereign store of value And then we get stable coins maybe defy is is like our second killer app then stablecoins And so like stablecoin transfers payments, you know, romances The same like words that we have used in crypto for like a decade now It's like now we have now now the time is actually here Let's put all the flows on chain and then what does tempo and arc and plasma and stable and codex want to do They just want to transfer a ton of stablecoins and charge Half a bit on a trillion dollars of of flows And I think that's like the level one like bull case articulation They're getting a little bit more nuanced than that It sounds like what you what you're saying is like yes And there's a whole FX market that is extremely large that we are also We want to go for maybe you could just like color in The ff the fx golden goose is like why is that so big?
Why is that the logical conclusion for you guys just like help me imagine that a little bit better the ERC 20 cent of this is the simplest thing like you could throw R&D at it and make it faster better Whatever sure, but that's not really the problem Right the problem is the friction be going from fiat staples. So what you'll hear a lot BC's observers like Twitter thread people right is this concept of stablecoin sandwich Right, it's like you start off in fiat and country A You turn into stablecoins You send you know as an on-chain send then it comes out and fiat the other side and this is great Right, this is the story The reality is across most countries today.
It doesn't make any sense whatsoever Because they're too expensive the fiat to crypto conversions are too expensive And so on ramp cost right that's right That's right because the only people that have truly figured out the on ramp Solved that the on ramp problem are exchanges because a they have the ability to lock up your money and b Like if you do like a chargeback right if you like like do a transfer and then you like youink it from coin base They it's kind of like a loss leader So They just kind of like lock up the money and they have some sort of assurances But then they also have like other Money generating vowed products on the actual exchange to like it's kind of a customer acquisition tool The peer on ramp startups that have just been an on ramp have been a terrible business Because they have to deal with chargebacks.
They can't charge ancillary fees. They can't upsell their customers And so the only people that to really solve the on ramp problem are exchanges because of their unique positioning And I think that's kind of what you're saying is just like this fiat fiat to stablecoin pathway Is a hard problem to solve are we talking the same language? That's right I think it's an incredibly hard problem to solve and it's thorny right It's not just like pure research task This is like you got to go figure out the fiat infrastructure. You're gonna have open bank accounts You know to get licensing Have a deal of all this gunk that nobody wants to deal with We deal with that gunk And for us it seems to me that instead of optimizing the sends which already work quite great What you really need to do is deal the actual problem So we talked about the chain fees and you said the okay, yes I'll change collect the chain fees.
That's the Normal business model is what you're saying is dealing with a gunk the actual way that you guys are trying to like Is that your golden goose? That's right. That's right because you know people get to charge fees for solving customers problems Right So if you are in the business of saying look guys like I'm gonna make your urc 20 send not 10 cents But now like nine cents and the dude sends on average a million dollars per transaction He's gonna look at you and go like okay cool like all right that doesn't do anything for me Right This is this is I think What not enough people do which is like go speak to the actual customer.
What does the customer want What the customer wants is for us to deal with this gunk and so we're gonna focus on this gunk Isn't that what circle does circle has banking partners Right, and so I would imagine transferring my money to circle and then receiving stablecoins would be trivially easy compared to any other Payment chain. How is this different? There are all sorts of problems with circles banking infrastructure I think to begin with like there are sort of volume limitations certainly much much imposed by circle themselves Even then even if you strip out the volume limitations much of these transactions happening on a T plus two basis Because the banking infrastructure is not adjacent It's very ironic right like the sort of 10,000 foot level view of stablecoins the I don't know Jason Calcanis's View of what how stablecoins works is that everything is instant and everything is fantastic and everything just works But you dig into the actual details and none of it works like that a lot of this stuff is still happening on T plus two basis Even to emit a stablecoin which is crazy Yeah, but doesn't that also apply to you whatever you're doing?
No, so I think what we're focused on is eliminating all these frictions right we want to make it so that Folks can access stablecoins on a wholesale basis on an instant Instant basis sub 10 minutes and on an extremely extremely cheap basis. That's kind of what we're focused on And we want to also have the effects infrastructure so that we can ship the effects from being off chain to being on chain On chain effects is this kind of a holy grail that people have been trying to pursue for a while And our diagnosis is that we have the pieces today to actually make it happen What are those pieces? I would imagine what you're saying is like okay, so you have the banking infrastructure In the United States, but if you want on chain effects don't you need to get the banking infrastructure like fucking everywhere across the whole world?
Seems hard Yeah, I think there's some secret sauce there David some maybe I won't dive into all the details I think that means I'm pressing on that means I'm going in the right direction You're a good interviewer David at I think you know the high level intuition is that The classic problem in on-chain effects historically Has been that non-US dollars tables have no liquidity So you can't move you can't really move volumes for them right And that's problem one problem too is that you have no demand for it Like who the hell wants to move money through this on chain mechanism if the spreads are wider If it's costlier if there's technical risk like why the hell would you want to do it?
And so for us we have solutions on both sides Yeah, okay, and I suppose this is where we wrap back around to the neutrality conversation because Not only do you want to be neutral for all of the reasons that you talked about earlier But you also need to be neutral because there's going to be a ton of issuers of not just dollar stablecoins But would imagine the if you're going to do on-chain effects you need All of the fiat currencies that have volumes in the effects market I would I don't know what those are but I would imagine there's at least six of them Yeah, there's a number of them. I think there's a couple of defining characteristics They have they tend to some are run by great people High-quality people some of their infrastructures are not bad None of them in product markets are the euro Japanese yen And what are the other obvious currencies that you need to get on to codex?
We're really interested in exotics the more exotic the more interested we're in Oh interesting. Okay, so long tail developing country currencies That's right. That's right. We're really those are the ones that want to get out The most the most is that right as in like if I have Argentine pay so like please connect to me to some other Fiat currencies on the blockchain is that is that kind of the idea? Well, we're seeing a couple things I think To give away some alpha here. I think one thing that we're seeing is that you're seeing this Shift in how commerce works globally. So in trad rails Almost all effects transactions go through to dollar So, you know, you might be going from I don't know Malaysian ringget to Singapore dollar and actually you go first through the US dollar Right What you're starting to see on chain is that that is not that is breaking down And folks are swapping be directly between currencies Which is a radical restructuring of how markets work and how commerce works globally So so if the United States dollar is currency a then people are swapping from currency b to currency c Without going through currency a That's right.
That's right. And that actually is all sorts of interesting National security as well as less. Yes. Yes, government. It's the opposite of what it's got best intents That's right. That's right. And if you zoom out here like what's happening? What's happening is that you have this stablecoin so far have been a dollar phenomenon right they've created this wonderful structural buyer US treasuries It's sort of this kind of modern euro dollar right and it's been really great for you as government And I think the genius act was pretty smart right the whole point is let's try to move more of these offshore flows onto Sablecoins because again, there are structural buyer US treasuries I think other countries see that and well, they're like interesting I'm not sure if it's necessarily in my interest that stablecoins be only a dollar phenomenon And I think you're seeing various pieces move around on the chessboard now Hmm I imagine nation is going.
Okay, so you said exotic currencies and you didn't really give me too much clay to go on But I think if we're also understanding the concept of neutrality And large fx flows and maybe an alternative interpretation of the word exotic is for truly thinking of cipher punk neutrality here It's like dollar to Chinese yuan and Russian Ruble like the three economics superpowers on the same chain which offends all three of them equally And then the a serious aetherium cipher punk is like oh yeah, that's that's what neutrality is you don't have to comment on that But I do want to actually talk about neutrality and like the aetherium context who so codex is the only payment chain stablecoin chain that is an aetherium layer two and like right now the Crabrod crypto audience might actually say like oh that actually makes you guys Less neutral.
That makes you guys more opinionated actually because you're an aetherium layer two not a layer one and between the pendulum of valuations that seems to swing back and forth between layer ones and layer two's the Premium the layer two premium has given way to the layer one premium And so we are we're currently in the the stance of like oh, there's a layer one premium out there and the layer two premium Is not really here and so talk to me about like why build as an aetherium layer two What does that give you guys and why make that trade why make that trade off? I think there's a logical case and there's an emotional case if I'm candid about it.
I'll start the logical case First of all this l one l two premium thing is kind of dumb Because it swings and really what drives it is like product market fit Right who has product market fit That's what matters If it's in a form of an l one and l two is very much a secondary consideration Not so long ago you had chains swapping from being l one to being l two's that can swing any day So we don't think like that right we're not gonna make choices that don't make sense just Try to pump up about it satisfy Twitter. Yeah, yeah I think then the second observation to make is that most of the stable coins are on aetherium This is kind of like a maybe an underappreciated fact right soon somewhere around 60% of all stable coins are on aetherium Now they don't move quite as much on aetherium, but we can help there They're like they're like store of valued slow defy stable coins whereas like the tron stable coins They're like payment high churned stable coins.
That's right. I think there's also higher value transactions on aetherium You know what if you're trying to move $10 million you probably are using something that that's not tron but I think the observation is that aetherium is actually the default choice today among stable coin users is one way of saying it Right it's 60% of all the flow six percent all the outstanding rather And if there are in other words is the dominant Where stable coins are and I think our mission at codex is to make sure that aetherium continues to be the dominant place for stable coins I think what aetherium needs to do here is It needs to keep up it needs to run a tight feedback loop between go to market and product and research ruthlessly focused just on stable coins This is very hard to execute at the L1 level That's where we come in We wake up every day.
We think about stable coins. We go to bed. We're thinking about stable coins We're in the bathroom. We're thinking about stable coins We just do this one thing And so Maybe the broader point here is that I think we need to rethink how L1's how aetherium L1 works with L2's And you know, we have a model in mind and I think is a win-win Okay, so I'm hearing three different arguments as to like why aetherium there's like the technical argument I don't think you really touched on that but I'm I'm sure it's there There's the economic argument which is All the stable coins are on aetherium all the high value transfers are on aetherium That's the place to be and then there's like the ideological argument Which I think you call the emotional argument of just like yeah, we kind of believe in aetherium Maybe we can kind of like actually run through all through those again the technical argument So like technically why is a layer two construction?
What does that benefit you guys as a stable coin focus chain? I think the main trade-off there that people need to make is are you Are you more interested in stability and speed to market i.e. being L2 right or are you more interested in You know incremental experimental Technical properties at the chain level. I think that is the fundamental trade-off so Our view is speed to market matters to most in our views as stability matters to most you know, I think When they find bugs and get nowadays They are bugs at the go level That's how robust that code basis It's just like you know the The aetherium yeah the aetherium stack is just so robust right everybody's tried to attack it so many times that When they find bugs nowadays, it's like at the programming language level Right, so it's the bug at a programming language not not sort of the At the sort of theorem software level I'm also really sure like what that means is you're working off this incredibly hard-end and robust stack Your other choice of course is to not work on not work off that stack and to do something experimental That's probably going to take a long time for R&D and might have all sorts of issues that So I think that perhaps is the the technical argument there I think there's also strong sort of guarantees that it's your meltooking offer then no i'll tell one can offer For instance Yeah for altos users always have to write to exit Dr.
L1 In a way where if you're stuck on striped chain or circle chain, there's nowhere to go Yeah, I was suppose a user is it's not like when I When I talk about the exit hatch in all two altos, I'm talking to my listeners right So like yeah users like you can use the layer two because you have the exit hatch For you and I think for broadly like we might also want to talk about countries As well because like if we're putting global effects on chain and like Russia wants to put their bonds on codex I don't know if you want me to even say these words, but like if one of Russia wants to put their bonds on codex But hey country of Russia if we Do something bad you guys have an exit hatch the whole entire country has an exit hatch And then and then that's actually part of the consideration there Yeah, I think just just on the sanctioned stuff like like We have a great legal and compliance team here my mandate to them is that I want no orange jumpsuit risk Please yeah, not interested in orange jumpsuit risk Right.
Yeah, okay So okay with tempo tempo announced itself as a layer one when they did that where you like Nice, that's good for me. That's good for codex. What was your reaction to that? I think like the tempo saga is really interesting because it's just such a small world You know my friend Liam is pretty involved there and One of reasons I think that Liam is interested in stablecoins in the first place is because of a conversation I had with him three years ago, and so it's it's really interesting that uh You know That three years later, you know, he's that probably convinced strive to do this.
It's it's very interesting Well, I think what was the nature of that conversation? Well, you know I Early on like stablecoins was quite a contrarian view right because at the time like its payments Dude like why are you doing payments? That's fucking sucks right like If you think about these chain foundations, and I was at one right like You think about who has the most cloud is the defi guy That's the bulk of the product market fit if there's a payments guy around this is not a this is not an interesting guy, right This is not something like back in back in 20 21 22 22 back then That's right payments was sort of like the graveyard of You know graveyard a crypto companies, but you know, I think at the time I was just that Looking at this information from first principles, and I'm like actually I think stablecoins might be the realest product market fit in crypto Right and Tron in a weird way may have actually some of the realized product market fit in crypto And this was not a popular view in you know, Ethereum circles at the time, but I think those are some of these early conversations that give give rise to Uh, you know a lot of the folks working on the system today.
Yeah, yeah So like codex as a name has like a risen alongside of the the rise of the like the Mind share of Payment stablecoin chains, but you guys got started forever go talk about maybe we can just interlude We're still in the technical argument of like with technical argument economic argument I do a lot of argument, but let's put in pain in that conversation When did codex just come around when did you did it when did you guys found it? I started codex when When I was at I left optimism the start codex I just had this observation that it seemed like nobody was really working on the realist part of crypto in a way And so I went off in search of something that hits three boxes for me the the first box is that It genuinely moves space forward in a way that my grandmother can understand Second that it is a massive economic opportunity and third that I had some sort of a unique edge to work on and So codex is what came out of that at the time when we were working when we first started thinking about this This was a deeply contrarian view, right?
Yeah, nobody wanted to work out of my mind as well Nobody wanted to work on this and you know, I think But if you just stare at the data, it was pretty obvious And now you know sort of that idea has gone from contrarian and sort of maybe fringe to like mainstream But that's been good for us. I think you know, we have maybe More time and the idea maze and then others and I think we can see the map perhaps clearer than others Interesting talk about why it was so contrarian what what about codex are the contrarian elements Again, we might have to teleport ourselves back to 2021-2022 But like what why the seaweed I think the first piece of consensus at the time was that well roll-ups ought to be general Right We can go into the history of this more.
I think there's all sorts of interesting counterfactual histories that could have happened But the consensus at the time was well roll-ups should be general and There's no need to focus on any particular use case And let's run these foundations No, I launched optimism token, right? So I clap my hands together one day and 15 billion dollars appear from thin air And then the next day we're like well, how do we how do we give it away? We don't know how to give it away And so you know, you spin up all these foundations and all these people are in these foundations and you're trying to figure out Well, how do I how do I allocate this?
And it's very clear that You don't really know how to give it away, right? Because you're so You're spread so thin across all these different use cases. How are you going to be opinionated in smart ways across all these use cases And so you know, I was there sitting and observing all this and you know It's a seem to me that really there was room to focus right focus down on one thing And then the question becomes which thing and based off my readings of data. It seemed like stable coins was a way to go Wasn't that kind of the thesis of the super chain though or is still the thesis of the super chain Which is likely the cluster itself is very generalized But the optimism Organization project doesn't really know where to be opinionated So they kind of leave that up to the to the market and what the market is is all of the Individual chains of the super chain.
How is how is what were what you Believed what you saw different from what that thesis is I think even for the super chain thesis I think the super chain thesis sort of maybe revolves centers around this idea of interop right so Maybe I'll give my take on this like Carl will probably have a sharper and more correct take than mayor and Carl and jang but My understanding of this was that Look, you have this problem because you first launched You first launch we roll up at the time of experimental technology right and you for a time it was Just one or two teams who could do it And the moment kind of passed where not all the activity migrated to a single L2 And in fact the tech got more and more commoditized and it actually became productized into RAS Meaning that anybody could go launch a roll up At which point you have this problem, which is well if anybody can launch a roll up like What is what exactly is the value cruel for a company like optimism And so then the thinking is well look let's let's Stitch them together Right or in stitch them together.
It's going to have these wonderful properties. It's going to be great That's kind of maybe I from my view the kind of heart of the super chain thesis Like for us today, how much is interop matter It's not clear to me how much interop really matters to me individually at codex And so maybe that's that's where those DCs diverge a little bit Mm-hmm So maybe to articulate why codex was contrarian at the time that it got started was a Stablecoin payments focused B Appchain narrow narrow chain construction rather than a generalized chain just a just narrow narrow focus chain Do you think that's where ethereum roll ups are just going generally speaking?
Because like one of the coolest new like roll ups that the ethereum community is talking about is lighter And lighter is like just as narrow if not more more narrow than what you are doing Which is just like it is a perptex and it's enshrined in the actual like zk circuits that they built And it's grown immensely in at least tvl I mean, there's incentives there But nonetheless like I don't think anyone's arguing with a product market fit of perptex these these days So like is there a broad comment to make about the trajectory of ethereum layer two designs Yeah, I think we need to wake up as a community And I think we need to recognize some uncomfortable truths The first truth that we need to recognize is that general-purpose altrups Are parasitic tell one What I mean by this is if you just spin up an l2 And it's does everything you know as defy it's nfts It's something something payments is something something a i What really is the difference between that l2 and l1 You are most definitely splitting the user base no and and what is this l2 added tell one exactly Pre IP 44 for you might say okay No, it's it's it's batch submitting on tell one it's paying all these wonderful gas fees Sure, okay, but post IP 44 for like that set of economics is de minimis So then what where is the value cruel It just doesn't work right the system doesn't work And so like what is the future the future is you need Roll ups into people working away with l1 where it's a win win So what is that win win the win win is the roll ups should focus on things that l1 cannot do well What are things that l1 can't do well?
Well, it's very very difficult at the l1 level to run a really tight product research And engineering loop Because it's very hard to focus right it's very hard to focus on specific problems And so the role of altrups is to get deep on one thing And so in our case we get deep on stable points And in this way we can sustain a theorem's dominance in stable coins and in this way we can also eventually return economics back to the theory That I think is the win win that is the future Isn't there kind of just like a migrating over 10 window of what parasiticness is As it relates to the capacity of the a theorem layer one and so I think it now in 2025 People look back on the generalized roll ups of 2021 arbitrary optimism polygon And they're like yeah, those are actually parasitic to a theorem But at the time there was no choice like a theorem was doing 15 transactions per second at least we're doing 45 now And we just needed something like that to keep people at least One click away from a theorem while also having like you know 100 transactions per second plus And now we retroactively judge you know generalized roll ups in 2025 of the role of 2021 It's like oh, yeah, there's a parasitic to a theorem And also a theorem in the meantime has kind of like increasing capacity gaseous have gone down And now we're saying like okay the actual right construction of an a theory world was actually an app chain where we can like Zoom in go focus be focused do the product development cycle loops that a theorem will never do But in 2030 and five gears A theorem is supposedly going to do a 3x layer one capacity increase over the next three years We're going to zk the chain We're going to get to a million transactions per second according to dress and drake and then maybe in 2025 We look back on the app chains and being like you know what well Howon and said that the reason why he's building a layer two is because of all of the stablecoin tvl on the a theorem layer one How is that not parasitic and actually just in the grand scheme of things a theorem is just going to become just as monolithic as all the salana people said that it was And and we're just going to retroactively judge the options of layer two is being parasitic to a theorem Which is doing the same thing the tempo is doing which is just a theory beating a theorem to the punch on scalability in products What say you I think that's an interesting way of cutting at it I think there's sort of a premise embedded in there which is all that matters is throughput Do you see how easily people can slip into that Whereas most of that car the car conversation so far David has been kind of me talking about All these other things that matter right that nobody's actually working on because they aren't just some throughput number that people can Sort of wave around on Twitter So in a world where a theorem is doing gazillion transactions the second fantastic That's great the set of products and the set of features that codex is building is entirely compatible with that and entirely differentiate it from that If we are unable to do that we deserve to die and so When it comes to sort of the over 10 windows shifting over time.
I think that's right right. I think I think for a while I think it was possible that optimism would actually be the only out to I think for a moment. It was possible the token launched right mass evaluation You know my view here would be that we should have done a migration aircraft Where you Selectively target the top defi apps on L1 you move it all over You know the pejorative here would be to say vampire attack right you're kind of vampire attacking on L1 And I was an advocate of this you know perhaps like controversial approach But at the time the consensus was look like execution debt should happen on L2 right So That let's do it.
Let's have execution happen on L2 as move it all over But of course, you know first of all hindsight 2020 and it's much harder than being the decision makers seat then to be Early pulley like myself kind of you know just throwing ideas around and You know that that moment passed right and so then when emerged is that there were multiple roll-ups with some fragment of the theorem ecosystem on it At which point then we're headed down this raspath that has happened sets And so yes, the over 10 windows shifted over. I think they're all sorts of these kind of interesting counterfactual histories They're interesting to think through as well So we've already touched on the economic argument.
I think we've covered the technical argument Let's finish up talking about the ideological argument, which we've kind of like Been dancing around but like why Ethereum ideologically speaking Why a layer two on Ethereum? Yeah, I think I used to word emotional because I think there are ideological reasons as well Let me start emotional. I think emotionally like I grew up in the Ethereum community, right? I I quit my job. I was very lucky joined optimism pretty early I lived in a house of like six seven other people in metallic You know, I'd come downstairs and Vitalik is on the phone to be on musk or something and One day and the next day ashen crutches in the kitchen and you know, all sorts of crazy shows That's right.
That's right And so like that's how you grew up in this in this ecosystem And so I think if I'm intellectually honest about it, I'm probably bit biased that way I think you know ideologically I think first of all you don't have to reach radiology quite yet I think in the empirics back it up right like most of the stable points are on Ethereum We just have to stay in that dominance into the future And if you think about which which ecosystems are truly kind of Truseter values or neutral that are likely to really be a settlement layer globally for the world I think it's here is obviously that I think anybody who's arguing otherwise is you know, maybe Raising money for now one Crypto is risky your sleep shouldn't be eight sleeps mission is simple better sleep through cutting edge to Their new pod five is a smart mattress cover that fits on the top of your bed It automatically adjusts the temperature on each side so you and your partner can both sleep the way that you like It's clinically proven to give you up to one extra hour of quality sleep per night eight sleeps pod five uses AI to learn your sleep patterns Regulate temperature reduce snoring and track key health metrics like HRV and breathing with a new full-body temperature regulating blanket and built-in speaker is the most complete sleep upgrade yet Upgrade your sleep and recovery with a sleep use code bankless at eight sleep dot Com slash bankless to get up to three hundred fifty dollars off the pod five ultra That's eight sleep dot com slash bankless you also get 30 days to try it risk-free link in the show notes for more information bit digital ticker bt bt is a publicly traded each treasury company that combines the two biggest metas of our time Ethereum and AI compute bit digital believes that eth will power finance and AI compute will power everything bit digital Gives you direct exposure to both bit digital holds more than 150,000 eth with institutional grade staking and validator operations On top of that the company owns roughly 73% of white fiber an AI infrastructure business that runs high performance GPU data centers That has a meaningful exposure to the growth of AI compute with over 27 million shares This is an eighth treasury backed by real operations designed to capture staking yield today while positioning for the future of intelligent computing tomorrow The ticker is bt bt this ad is not financial advice do your own research learn more about with bit digital and try their m nav calculator at bit hyphen digital dot com that's bit hyphen digital dot com bankless has been compensated by bit digital for this ad You can find out more information by clicking the link in the show notes There was there.
There's a while. I was hosting an episode like a roundup episode with like a handful of different people on it And one of them was bred from mega east and this one very strong Ethereum community discord I was in was giving me shit for hosting bread from mega east and I'm like what the hell do you guys want like It's mega eth is an ethereum layer to they're doing the logical conclusion of like the ethereum rollup design And all of a sudden like hosting bread from from mega eth is is antagonistic to ethereum So some some parts of the ethereum community have their Antibodies Very sensitive very turned up and so What would you say how would you address those people who are just like very tuned to be like no you're actually Extractive to ethereum.
What what is codex what is codex giving to ethereum? What what values is codex giving to the ethereum project? Yeah, I think you see this happen quite a bit with Communities that become sort of more and more mature, right? I think you see some these are some times In 21 or 22 it would be like these are kind of bitcoin-y traits, right? Yeah, yeah or like any any attempt at changing Something about the Bitcoin ecosystem is an attack on Bitcoin and let's get the pitch forks out and let's string them up Let's hang the guy, you know, which which which so I think it's a natural human tendency. I understand it I think what we need to do as a community is discern between true threats and like Progress So like what are true threats true threats are all tell ones Attempting to supplant ethereum right tempo is a real threat and We should not engage in motivated reasoning about it, right?
So like one version I've heard about this is Well, I use as the EVM. So therefore it is ethereum I mean come on right like That's that's BS like sit down and really think about that for a second, right? That's that's BS So we need to be able to discern between like true threats and progress. What does progress look like progress looks like Well, what is the future here, right? We have this problem where you know Perhaps general purpose L2s are not all that additive to the ethereum ecosystem Well, then how do we proceed because we have we have rass, right? You can't spin up brohops We have a thriving ethereum community And there are all these threats on our horizon.
So so what should we do? Let's sit down and think about what we should do well We need to move quickly We need to run a tight product iteration boot And we need to preserve ethereum's dominance And probably the best form of doing that is in a stablecoin focus L2 And so I mean obviously I'm talking my book here, but you know, we are very much not as threat to the ethereum or very much aligned with the ethereum And you know, we hope to preserve the future of stablecoins on ethereum What about the whole like topical conversation of like beta based and native roleps? What do you think about those?
In terms of like technical even stronger technical alignments to the ethereum layer one. What do you think about that conversation? Yeah, I think those are interesting. I think we're happy to explore those things I think again this falls in a bucket of like interesting technical conversations that customers are not cared about Sure, yeah, so like if you go on one of these chain websites and all they talk about is stuff that sounds good to like R&D teams, right? I would I would look out, right? Yeah Mm-hmm Want to say one theory I have when thesis I have about tempo You know tempo is like, you know, what is good for tempo is good for ethereum where evm We're gonna our software contributions will flow back to ethereum We're gonna increase the pie for everyone and and also we're just like stablecoins, you know So like don't mind so we're not we're not coming for defi we're just stablecoins And I think anyone who says that on the tempo side of the aisle is like probably being true and authentic Like yeah, they're just focused on stablecoins and payments and I don't think anyone in the tempo Complex is being dishonest if they just say yeah, we're just thinking about stablecoins I think as tempo grows in in the future where tempo does Get adopted as a payment chain as a stablecoin chain and like the the weights of stripe actually gets expressed in the dominance of tempo Tempo evolves from just a payments chain just because of the fact of that's how layer ones work It's like why would you not put avay on tempo?
There's going to be an avay on tempo Why would you not put any sort of defi app on on tempo and why would There's no difference between a stablecoin payments focus chain and just like a very high capacity high capability Generalized evm chain and so yes everyone in the tempo orbit is like yeah, we're focused on stablecoins But tempo as a construct tempo the actual If you give agency to tempo the blockchain tempos like yeah, no, I want to become the dominant layer one to generalize layer one What do you think about that that these is that that rings true to me? I think the play here It's a very smart team up over there, right?
There's a lot of great people I think if I were them what I would be thinking is Let's allow me to slice Salami slice the shit out of this what what I mean by this is you just progressively and slowly Inch through everything So you make no moves immediately that are threatening to others You just slowly and progressively get there Under cover of maybe some smart rhetoric my general attitude towards almost everyone in this base is like to everyone in crypto is they in one of two camps You are either Like the end this is the perspective from ethereum. So again ethereum is the agent here ethereum is the organism Anyone in crypto is either unbundling ethereum and this is like The archetype of multi coin capital.
What does multi coin capital want to do? They just want to unbundle ethereum like one by one take all of the Different values of ethereum different different value that ethereum produces and like make a faster alternative version of it As somewhere else that they invested in it's like the the archetype of of ethereum unbundled so tempo big ethereum unbundled And then there's the ethereum bundlers, which is like ethereum is the chosen open source ecosystem It is this gravity center of open source contributions And that is like naturally accruing of of mine shares credibly neutral things just gravitate towards ethereum even even tempo Even though it's like an alternative layer one with no material Technical alignment with ethereum.
It's still the evm and that evm grows in the gravitational center And it actually is ethereum at the center of the orbit and so I'm interested in growing the ethereum project So I'm an ethereum bundler I will say that you are an ethereum bundler because you're building An ethereum layer two that's focused on bundling up payments and stable coins into ethereum And so actually don't really have a question here But like that's how I view the world is like you're either you're either And a bun a unbundler of ethereum or you're a bundler of ethereum from the perspective of ethereum What do you think about that?
Yeah, I think there's Like you're just like ethereum's kind of like craigslist right is kind of what you're talking about here Yeah, I think I think that's interesting Yeah, I think the thing is is that the ethereum bundle like Well, what is what is the reason why you might unbundle ethereum you might unbundle ethereum to focus Right, so somebody might focus, you know craigslist has rentals and you take out rentals and you just do that and it's Airbnb Right I think in the case of ethereum we have this wonderful thing called l2's that allow you to do that You can go focus on one thing and yet the whole thing still coheres So it would be like if craigslist had an incentive for people to spin off little sections of it While still being economically aligned with craigslist I think that's what's powerful here right that this is the model we have to get to And I know there's all sorts of factions inside ethereum community that have different theses on it I've heard one version of this which is look like Sorry fdl2's right fdl2's and let's just focus on l1 and let's do that There's obviously another camp which is like don't don't do that like focus on the alt2's And I think the truth here is somewhere in the middle like we need to be pragmatic about this Yeah, we've got to make sure that it makes sense Like alt2's need to interact with l1 in a way that's additive And obviously l1 needs to like don't use me a reason why you you want to be in ethereum out to right So I think again, I'm biased, but I think the model that we are we are pursuing is the future Yeah, yeah, I think I agree with you there So it's like let's split the difference between fdl2's and focus on the alt2's And but I'll give us slight bias or like tie goes to the ethereum layer one So we're not I'm not perfectly splitting it down the middle I think like in 2021 the ethereum community over index on layer 2's and they were like all layer 2's are valid by default 10,000 generalize roll ups.
They're all they're all valid. They're all they're all great That's right and I want to actually my perspective is like actually by default a layer 2 is not valid It's not legitimate You can't just you can't just spin up a layer 2 you have to earn your keep You have to do something net additive and being a generalize roll up is not net additive to the ethereum space You have to like earn your place as a valid contribution to like ethereum landscape And if you're not valid then like you're actually parasitic right and so like the way that you are valid is you have Type product development research loops you do grow the pie and you grow the pie in a way that is additive to the ethereum side Not in the tempo way where it's like yeah, we're growing the pie, but we're all shooting it too So that's that's my kind of fault.
It's like don't don't Discard the layer 2's but also they're not valid by default. They have to they have to earn their Their ethereum logo branding not not get a pie default. I think that's right. I think that's right I think another way of thinking about it is if a roll up is adding nothing other than existing It is fragmenting the user base Mm-hmm. That's the truth of it So it better either address some use case better than l1 It better be attracting new users better be attracting new flows creating new functionality Or we really ought not exist. Yeah, there was a previous year Maybe a couple years ago where that was like blast for me But I I hope that this becomes like the status quo like Thought in the ethereum community when tempo announced itself and They're the rabbling from the ethereum community got really really loud and matt Huang had to like Answer to the fact as to why it was in a theory oh why it was a layer one rather than the theorem layer two He said something to the effect of like not wanting to be Tied to ethereum's development roadmap and like a bunch of other things like the the general answer was like If we were a ethereum layer two we would be constrained by ethereum by like ethereum through put the 4844 like blob space growth targets When you read that analysis from from out of Huang of like we wanted to be just Technically independent from ethereum.
What was your reaction to that? I think matt's in a tough spot right. I think matt has to balance a ton of different things. I think you know, well, there's paradigm lp's to balance right Why is the gp of this fund starting up of port co and how is his time split between paradigm and and this new port co He is invested in much of the ethereum community as well, right? So is he now adversarial towards those those investments I think he's got a tough balancing act and you know, obviously a very smart guy So I think he's doing a good job of it. I think again, it has this is R&D fetish That we were talking about right?
I think it's very easy to slip into like oh well We just all what we really need is just more throughput That's what we really need all right. We need a gazillion transactions a second and often that's really not what is actually the bottleneck And so again, I'm biased, but if you I think you do analyze the situation correctly and you spot the true bottleneck You would conclude that in ethereum l2 is the faster way to win Hmm How then I'm I'm into it I hope the best for you guys for my If there are any other parts of this conversation that I haven't asked about any stone. I've left unturned I think it's just a really exciting time for the space I think I think we're seeing all these sort of geopolitical forces play out on chain as well And I think all this all this will get decided in the course of the next half decade So you know, it's excited to be on the frontier Cool.
Well, I hope the best for you guys written for you Non-investor spankless nice and no, I just like the ethereum road map. I like the ethereum project To what degree codex has a firm foot planted inside of the ethereum ecosystem I'm a supporter so how and then thanks for coming on the show and just educating me about this base Thanks David good to chat talk to you soon Banklessation you guys have the deal crypto's risky you can lose what you put in but nonetheless We are headed west this is a frontier stuff for everyone, but we are glad you wrote us on the bank this journey. Thanks a lot You