What happens when stablecoins break apart the traditional business model of banks?
Economist Charles Calomiris explains how the “unbundling” of payments and lending reshapes finance, why politics matter more than technology, and what this revolution could mean for the dollar’s future.
------
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAX | SELF SUFFICIENT DeFi
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
🎩DEGEN | JOIN THE COMMUNITY
🌳KGEN | REQUEST A DEMO
https://bankless.cc/KGEN-podcast
🏄 SURF | UPGRADE YOUR CRYPTO RESEARCH
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 What Are Banks?
7:56 Chartered Banking
30:44 The Unbundling
51:48 Stablecoin Yield Concerns
1:01:42 Death of The Dollar?
1:15:45 Stablecoins Abroad
1:20:52 Future of The Dollar
1:24:38 Dollar as a SoV
1:32:10 Are Stablecoins Winning?
1:36:30 Closing & Disclaimers
------
RESOURCES
Charles Calomiris
Fragile by Design (Charles' Book)
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
What are banks? Like what function at their core for society do banks perform? Wow, I love that question. I have to put a plug in before I even answer it for the book that I wrote about a decade ago with Steve Hayber called Fragral by Design, which is about the modern era from the perspective of banks that is understanding the history of the world from the perspective of something that started about 400 years ago, which is the chartering of banks. So the first thing in answering your question is somebody has to do is decide whether they want to talk about a generic thing called financial intermediary that does some kinds of transactions involving lending, maybe, or maybe payments transfers, or maybe both, or maybe managing a portfolio, or maybe, you know, who knows what financial transactions.
So, you know, by that, by that sort of definition, the Rothschilds were clearly a bank. They were a private bank. Lots of other, the Medici were a bank. But when I use the term bank generally, that's not the way I use it. I use it to talk about a modern element that is when I say modern, I mean something about the modern world starting around 1600 that distinguishes this world from its prior worlds. The reason I focus on that way of thinking is that the nation state created by the modern world, charter's banks, and it's the chartering of banks that makes them in my mind so interesting, not just as an economic function, but as a political reality.
Now, I want to really emphasize every nation state, charter's banks. By the way, not every nation state taxes. Kuwait does attack. Not every nation state has an army. Costa Rica doesn't have an army. But every nation state, charter's banks. Banks are the sine qua non of the nation state, because it tells you something about the way of organizing the world with power that a nation state creates rules for the existence of banks that it regulates. The chartering of banks is all about deciding as a nation state that the functions of banks have to be ruled by the political nation. Those, that is what a bank is.
So that bank has done lots of different kinds of transactions. Economic theory can illuminate why banks combine different transactions. But if you don't start from the political reality that the modern nation state charters banks and regulates them for its political purposes, you're never going to get really very far in understanding how banking systems evolve. Because banking systems don't evolve through some sort of automatic process, they evolve under the restrictions and under the opportunities that are provided by the nation state. That can be an opportunity if the nation state charters a bank like the Bank of England whose sole mission when it was charter was to help organize the finances of the state so that it could fight France.
That was the point of chartering the Bank of England. Was it so you, Ryan, could do something that you wanted to do? And by the way, that bank was given a monopoly in England and Wales over no creation, that is printing money. And so that wasn't a coincidence either. That was part of the partnership between the people who operated the bank and the sovereign. There's no way to understand the history of banking in England without taking into account that banks weren't allowed to exist in effect except as small private entities. Very small. They were restricted in their size. If they weren't the one that state chartered.
So a bank, yes, okay, we can now talk about all the functions that banks may or may not do, depending on what the sovereign allows. And we can also talk about shadow banks, the banks that aren't chartered by the sovereign, which just do any kind of financial transactions that they can get away with if they're not prohibited. But we don't start off, if you start off talking about banks as some kind of natural abstract idea. You've really missed the boat. In the modern era, banks are either, and this is the most important one, chartered entities of the state or things that operate in a shadow if they can get away with it and aren't prohibited by the state.
All of them do financial transactions. But if you don't start with the state, you don't have a prayer of understanding what's going on. In the Wild West of DeFi, stability and innovation are everything, which is why you should check out Frax Finance, the protocol revolutionizing stablecoins, DeFi and Rolex. The core of Frax Finance is Frax USD, which is backed by BlackRock's institutional fiddle fund. Frax designed Frax USD for besting class yields across DeFi, T-bills and carry trade returns all in one. Just head to Frax.com, then stake it to earn some of the best yields in DeFi. Want even more?
Bridge your Frax USD over to the Frax Stole Layer 2 for the same yield plus Frax Stole Points and explore Frax's diverse Layer 2 ecosystem with protocols like Curve, Convex and more, all rewarding early adopters. Frax isn't just a protocol. It's a digital nation, powered by the FXS token and governed by its global community. Acquire FXS through Frax.com or your go-to decks, stake it and help shape Frax Nation's future. Ready to join the forefront of DeFi? Visit Frax.com now to start earning with Frax USD and staked Frax USD. And for bankless listeners, you can use Frax.com slash R slash bankless when bridging to Frax Stole for exclusive Frax Stole perks and boosted rewards.
Ethereum's Layer 2 universe is exploding with choices, but if you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens, make your next stop Unichain. First, liquidity. Unichain hosts the most liquid Uniswap V4 deployment on any Layer 2, giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like each USDC. More liquidity means better prices, less slippage and smoother swaps, exactly what traders crave. The numbers back it up. Unichain leads all Layer 2's in total value locked for Uniswap V4. And it's not just a deep, it's fast and fully transparent, purpose-built to be the home-based for DeFi and cross-chain liquidity.
When it comes to costs, Unichain is a no-brainer. Transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than Ethereum maintenance, slashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity. Want to stay in the loop on Unichain? Visit Unichain.org or follow at Unichain on X for all the updates. Introducing KGen, aka Verify. The world's largest verified distribution protocol or VDP. If you're trying to grow a real protocol or app, you need real users doing real actions. If it's not Verify, it's just noise. At the core of Verify is Poggi, KGen's identity and reputation framework. It helps you reach humans, not bots, and proves what your users actually did, so your budget goes to the right people.
With Verify, you can run Verify user acquisition with confidence, keeping people coming back with retention tools, like loyalty rewards, quests and achievements, and even power AI training and evaluation using trusted Verified user groups, ensuring your models learn from clean data. And when it's time to reward your community, there's the KStore, a global rewards marketplace where users can redeem perks that connect directly back to your app. Put simply, when growth is built on real users, you grow faster, and that's exactly what Verify delivers. If you're building a web3, AI, or gaming, request a demo to grow your protocol at www.
kgen.io slash demo. That's www.kgen.io slash demo. Okay, Charles, this is a really good context in history. Basically, you're arguing that that banks, particularly the form of a bank that you're talking about when you use the word bank, are chartered banks, and they're really products of the nation state, and you don't really get a modern nation state without a bank to accept that all nation states, some may or may not have armies even, but they all have some sort of chartered bank function. Using this term chartered bank, is that effectively a license that the state provides a spacey regulation, and it will give you something like a taxi cab medallion, let's say.
If you're just operating a taxi cab in New York, you have to have this medallion. Is that what a charter actually is? In some literals or strict and narrow sense, the answer is yes, but to answer that way, this is a big point. A chartered bank is the outcome of a bargain. That's the more interesting thing. A chartered bank is something that's the outcome of what Steve Abraham and I called the game of bank bargains. So there's always a coalition, whether it's an autocratic regime or democratic regime, populist versus liberal democracy, different kinds of regimes that are going to strike a bargain.
There's going to be a coalition formed coming out of the power of the individual entities within that nation. It's going to decide what they want to achieve with a bank charter, and the bank charter is the answer to that question. It's not just a license. It defines the powers of the entity and the limitations on those powers. It also defines things like what will happen when the entity can't fulfill a contract. There's doesn't get bailed out or not. Some of those contracting provisions are explicit. Some of them are implicit. So if you really want to understand what's going on, you don't just look at the letter of the law.
And of course, a bank has to function under the law. And so if it writes contracts, those contracts are only going to be as good as the legal system, which is another political outcome. So the nation state is going to create laws governing creditors' rights and debtors' rights generally. But it's also going to create as part of the licensing of the banks, limitations on powers, opportunities for powers for the bank, and then also policies that are either explicit or implicit about bailing out that, that call that a law-sharing arrangement. So that the bank is set up with a certain explicit or implicit law-sharing arrangements, like all chartered entities.
It's so helpful when you're starting to think about this, to go back to 1600, when this whole idea was created, because then you remember that chartered corporations were special privileged corporations created by the state. At that time, special corporations, not general incorporation acts, that allowed anyone to apply to be one, special corporations. And our own revolution is caught up in some of that and also caught up in some of the law-sharing arrangements. So let me just take us a little bit out in the weeds for a minute. What was the Boston Tea Party about? And I'll bet you you'll get it wrong.
What was it about, Ryan? I'll give you this civic answer, which is taxation without representation, right? Completely wrong. That's what the Stamp Act Congress was about in 1765. And some of that still fed into some thinking about the revolution. But the Boston Tea Party was about special monopoly privilege that the East India company was given, because it had fallen on hard times. It was suffering losses. And so the Crown and Parliament decided to change the navigation acts, which were acts governing transport in British Empire, to give a special privilege. I won't go into the details, to give a special privilege to the East India company for transporting tea, which ended up having the effect of sidelineing the New England merchants who were acting in trafficking the tea.
It caught the price of tea dramatically at my recollections about the half. Why did the Boston merchants, why do people in Boston have to do this when I think is a reprehensible thing? By the way, there's nothing. Most of our founders found it reprehensible, except the people in Boston. The other founders found it reprehensible. Why? Because they were really just acting in a way to preserve their own interests and acting contrary to the well-understood principle that the sovereign England got to choose international rights and privileges as part of its sovereign power. And it granted special privileges to the East India company.
When the East India company fell into trouble, they tried to help it by changing the menu of privileges. It disadvantaged some people, but it was not viewed by most people in our country at the time as some kind of terrible action by the crown. It was just part of the navigation system, part of mercantilism, imperialism. And if you weren't one of those merchants in Boston, like the Adamses, by the way, you didn't have a big problem with it. What you did have a problem with was the Stamp Act, which was in 1765, tried to say that for the first time, the parliament was going to impose taxes on local domestic transactions, which should be under the purview of the legislatures in the colonies.
The colonies had their own legislatures. That was unprincipled. That was a violation of the rights of British citizens. And that's why we didn't like it in 1765. The reason I illustrate our discussion with that example is not to just highlight the widespread ignorance that Americans have about our own history, like the American Revolution. The Boston Tea Party was not popular outside of New England and was viewed as unprincipled and wrong by most of our leaders. But that's not the way we learn it. But the more important thing is to understand the whole system that was taken for granted of the management of the interests of the nation state had to do with creating charters, both for corporations and for banks, which were corporations, to try to be a kind of representation of and a way of executing the interests of the sovereign.
And that wasn't viewed as somehow wrong. So the notion of general incorporation, the notion that you, Ryan, have the right to form a corporation, to act as an abstract entity to engage in transactions and maybe have stockholders in that corporation and maybe even have limited liability in that corporation. The notion that that's going to happen as a matter of general right, what's called general incorporation laws, and also along the other side of that, there were not going to do specially privileged corporations. That was not something that became part of the American way of thinking until the 1840s.
So what happened with banks to get back to them is, of course, they started off being specially privileged entities, just like the East India Company, chartered by the national government or by the states. And it wasn't until the 1830s, in some states that we had general incorporation laws governing banks giving anyone the opportunity to charter one under pre-specified rules. And then, of course, we have the national banking system created by Lincoln in the 1860s, in 1863, which then created a national government set of charters. Again, licenses, as you said, but not just licenses. Just like the East India Company, there are deals explicit or implicit about how losses are going to be allocated.
And the reason I mentioned that is, because you can't understand the modern state of the 21st century without understanding the way that bank charters effectively create, lost sharing arrangements that are bailing out banks, and that those are all about imposing losses on others to subsidize banks. So once you understand that banks have always served from the very beginning, the interests of the state and are the result of the political game of bank bargains, then you really have some insight and you understand it's not just about their license, but it's about who supports them, who creates them, who will bail them out.
And that's all part of the political game that creates banks. And I know we spend some time, we're taking time on this, but I want to emphasize, you can't have a prayer of understanding what the future stablecoins is without coming to grips with this fact. If you think stablecoins are technologically determined, the future stablecoins is something that comes from my fantasies about the economic logic and empirical evidence of what works and doesn't work, you're really missing the book. Stablecoins have to be if they're going to work, they have to work within that coalition building game of bank bargains.
And we've already seen in the genius act, the way that that coalition tried to shape the way stablecoins would or wouldn't happen. And Ryan, the most important fact is, four years ago, the Biden administration wanted to kill this idea as best they could. And in fact, even before them, the first Trump administration, which I served as chief economist at the OCC with Brian Brooks as the act in control, the Trump administration didn't want this to happen either. They've changed, they've changed their tune. And so when Brian Brooks and I am now going to tell tales out of school here, Brian Brooks and I were very eager to see the crypto future realized, these stablecoins realized and we recognized that would have to happen by shardering entities that were allowed to do stablecoin transactions.
There are a lot of advantages to come from that. And of course, what's the administration in US history, the only one that since 1863 that did not actually appoint a controller of the currency confirmed by the Senate. The answer is the Biden administration. Why? Because they wanted it to do nothing. They wanted the OCC to be a complete nothing, to not do anything to go down the road that Brian Brooks and Jonathan Gould and others at the OCC and I had hoped to start, which was bringing into the game of bank bargains a formal crypto presence so that it could actually occur as a legitimized financial transaction that would have real legs.
The Biden administration completely captured by the incumbent banks and by other political interests, they're part of a coalition of the status quo did not want that to happen. The Trump administration this time wants it to happen the first time it didn't. Can you explain that a little bit further, Charles? Yeah, but I just want to point out, what am I really getting at? What I'm getting at is what we've already experienced. If we understand what we just lived through for the past eight years, what we just experienced is how much the political wins have affected the timing and capabilities of the empowerment of crypto.
If you think crypto is happening now because of some exogenous technologically driven reality, you really are just completely hopeless, right? I mean because the technology has been there all along. It's been there for and that's going to matter for what we're talking about today because I'm going to point out the technology that exists today will predictably completely transform, can predictably completely transform financial transactions. But the main obstacle to getting that to happen is the resistance that's coming from members of powerful coalitions who have vested interest contrary to that.
The incumbent banks finally saw that they were not going to be protected enough. So they needed that's what happened in the Genius Act. They needed to get the ability to make shardering the way that stablecoins could happen. Notice you can't run stablecoins without a charter now. That's what the Genius Act did. The Genius Act, but notice that the incumbents changed their political strategy. Pay attention, listeners. Pay attention. The incumbents changed their political strategy from ignoring and stablecoins and having Biden's report say, oh, risky, risky, risky, risky, but still allowing them, you know, they didn't have the power to stop them legislatively.
They didn't have the coalition built to stop them. So they just threw a lot of sand at them, said they were risky, risky, risky, and definitely didn't want to follow up on what Brian Brooks and his team, including me, had been trying to do, which is bring them into the modern chartering of the banking system, legitimize them, allow them to be regulated, but regulated in a way that gave them a future. Well, the incumbent banks didn't want that to happen. They were very happy with the Biden administration's approach. But then as things started to change and they realized there would be an inevitable growth of stablecoins, which have grown dramatically over the past five years, then what did they do?
They said, well, we have to somehow try to limit stablecoins and allow them to be part of the chartered entity. I don't think that's ultimately a crippling limit. In fact, I think it's very helpful for stablecoins to be part of chartered reality, especially if we have other ways for stablecoins to exist. For example, they don't have to be just chartered by the national banking system. They could be chartered by the individual states or different ways. So there's competition. So anyway, I think that it's a very positive step. But I really think you can't understand this as a technological phenomenon.
Only it is a technological phenomenon. But notice, the Federal Reserve is extremely threatened by stablecoins because stablecoins can create a payment system network that completely sidesteps Fed wire. And they will. Eventually, it's so much better that it has to beat the Fed. But the Fed doesn't just sit in there passively. What are they trying to do? Oh, let's create central bank digital currency. It's going to be so great. And then what was the Biden administration's view? Well, they didn't beat up central bank digital currency. They knew it wasn't very popular. So they didn't push it too hard.
But then they completely just threw sand at stablecoins so that what are the incumbent banks doing? Well, they're part of that same coalition. And by the way, there are a lot of other community and other sort of activist organizations that have benefited from their partnerships with the chartered incumbents, the big banks, which became big banks very recently in US history in the 1990s and the 2000s. We didn't have big banks prior to that. That was the merger wave. And when we got those big banks, the way they got big was to avoid political opposition from activist organizations, they gave the activist organizations money in order to testify for them in support of their mergers.
I bet your listeners don't know that either. Do you know how much activist organizations were granted contractually for merging banks from 1995 to 2007? Take a guess, Ryan. Total contractual. These are explicit financial contracts. You, Ryan, come testify at the Federal Reserve Board to say, I'm a good guy. That's it. I'm a good guy. And my mergers should be approved. And if you do that, I'm going to give you a contract that gives you some money. Some of that money is to pass through to your friends as subsidized loans. Some of that money is outright grant to you 10% of it. How much do you think changed hands?
When you, when you want to understand the politics of what charters mean, this is crucial. The entire creation of the big banking system since the 1990s was the result of a bargain among several parties. But in fact, a lot of those parties were community activist organizations. So let's just get your listeners to learn something. What's the total dollar amount of those contracts over the period 1995 to 2007? What do you think? Let's be clear. These are contracts between who? Merging banks. Let's say Bank of America is going to merge with a bank, or let's say when Fleet and Bank Boston merged in 1999, I think it was, they entered into contracts with local activist groups.
So this is how does the local activist group think Jesse Jackson? Oh, okay. Interesting. Yeah. Yeah. So how much did those groups get either to keep for themselves 10% or 90% of it to pass through to their members? By the way, how do you get to be a member of the group? Show up for political protests, then you get access to a subsidized mortgage. You understand now how political coalitions are built. I see. So that's how much money are we talking about? I'm going to guess tens of millions because it was a more innocent time. Ten million have picked for something like this. No, from 1995 to 2007, two and a half trillion dollars of contracts.
Wait, what? Trillion. Two and a half trillion. That's what you guys don't know. That's why you don't get it, right? That's why nobody gets it. Can I let's suck your kiss? All the money. Yeah. I mean, that's I guess the total value of the contracts, you know, I mean, I guess very stakeholders would skim off the top in various ways. I actually think, Charles, so a few things that you're communicating to us, bank listeners, that that's important is that stablecoins in particular aren't just a technology. Of course, they're not. They're a political banking mechanism. It's always infused together.
I actually do think that crypto has somewhat learned this a little bit in the small over the last couple of years because crypto has become incredibly politically engaged and involved. I think in no small part that led to the passage of the genius act, do you look at kind of the political crypto fintech lobbying that the industry has done over the past couple of years? I mean, it's been spectacular. There's been a lot of money pouring into kind of the political games in order to get this this legislation through. So we're starting to learn those lessons. I appreciate you. I'm not trying to be a jerk, right?
I'm just trying to tell people that they're stupid, not that or ignorant, but I am I am telling people that they that it's not easy. And the reason it's not easy is, so first of all, if you don't understand the political equilibrium, then you can't oppose it. You can't change it. You can't you can't try to build your own group. And yes, they have started to build their own group. But the point is, these things exist within a legal framework, within an engineering framework, and within an economic framework. What I found when I was involved in crypto is those are three different minds and they rarely come together.
And then that's to limited because then there's the political framework that makes that allows the bringing together of these three minds. And so what I found when I was working crypto is there are people who know one of the three ways of thinking, engineering, economics, or legal, very, very few who understand the combination and almost none who understand the political contingency of actually being able to succeed. And I hope we're going to talk, you know, about the distant future because, you know, I think crypto, but especially stablecoins, everyone understands that they have extraordinary promise as a medium of exchange, right?
But I want to go a lot farther and point out that the the amazing thing about the blockchain distributed ledger technology is that it will it can allow not just the best medium and exchange system the world has ever seen, but it can also allow the best unit of account system. It can basically create a substitute where I wouldn't say substitute. Let's just say a new definition of the dollar. And of course, when you start thinking that way, now we're talking about not only replacing all the incumbent banks and all their entrenched allies who have gotten so much money from them, but also the Federal Reserve.
And you know, let's remember that chartered central banks, which which were called central banks, they were called banks of issue when they were chartered in the 1600s, but central banks like the Fed, which are really something it's only been around and call the central banks since about the middle of the 19th century. They're very young. They're not likely to be a permanent feature of our economy. In fact, my own work suggests that this is a technology. It's, you know, really it's time to get rid of it. And they're not going to go easily, right? Those people aren't going to go easily. Before we get into the far future of what this technology is capable of, let's talk about the here and now.
So we have the genius built signed, of course. You have a presentation talking about the stable coins are here and they're going to transform banking. Seems like you're making the case that they're going to unbundle some of the services that banks offer today. What pieces are stable coins going to unbundle from the banks? I mean, there has to be a reason that the existing incumbent banks are threatened by this that no progress was made during the Biden administration that they've thrown sand in the gears at every corner. Why? What are they scared of? What's going to be unbundled? What do they lose?
Great, great question. Okay, so first, a confession. I made my reputation largely off of the theory of bundling of bank services. My most cited article is a theory article that explains and there's another theory article using slightly different logic that explains why banks do and have historically bundled payment services with lending services. Why do banks lend and clear payments? Why do they do both? Because there are entities historically that have done just one or the other. For example, the world's most successful intermediary of the early 17th century was something called the Rieselbank, the Bank of Amsterdam, it's also called.
It was initially entirely about clearing bills of exchange in international merchant commerce. Then I mentioned the merchant banks to Medici, the Rothschilds. They weren't operating clearing systems. They were lenders. So banks can do one or the other, but if you look at chartered banks, what you realize is the history of chartered banks has been the combining of payment system services with lending. So we, as economists, have developed a few different theories about this. I'm happy to go into the weeds on it, but the theories really have to do with some kind of mechanism design advantage generally related to some kind of information cost or information problem that encourages banks to do both so that the competitive equilibrium isn't that banks do one or the other because it's more efficient to do them together.
Now, that idea has a lot of empirical evidence behind it and a lot of theory, but let me just point out that because it's grounded in a theory of information cost, it's contingent. The idea that bundling is efficient depends on some kind of information cost argument. If one of the things that modern information technology is doing is changing the cost of information and reducing the cost to, if that's happening, it might undermine the logic that creates bundling. That's exactly what I believe. That bundling made economic sense for banks and no longer does. And bundling specifically, Charles, you're talking about the banks' existing business model is to bundle both what you're calling payments and also lending those two together.
And I think when you say payments, you also mean basically the checking account. So deposits, is that correct? Yeah, that's the mechanism in the US that we're using for making transactions through Fenwire. So it's all the centralized payment system operating through the central bank. You might think, and you're listening to me, I think, well, wait a minute, I used Paypal or I used VEDBO or something. All you're doing is going, that's just stuff up here. It still is all going through the centralized payment system of deposit checking accounts at banks that work with each other through Fenwire typically.
If stablecoins take off in the way I think you predict, maybe Secretary Scott Besson predicts, certainly, we predict at bank lists, right? The checking account and payments that becomes unbundled from the bank services. So your checking account is basically as an individual, you know, in a US society becomes basically a stablecoin account. And the banks are just left with lending. And they don't like that very much because I've got to assume they make a lot of money on the checking and payment side things. Is this suppose that? Not quite, but yes, I mean, you've got it, but let me just complicated a little.
Let me point out that there are shadow banks, not just charter banks, shadow banks that specialize in lending. Just as their shadow banks or shadow payment services specialize just in payments. So yeah, the shadow payment provider is tether. They have more than 90% of the market, right? In stablecoins. But then there are all these lending services that are done online. They don't fund themselves with deposits and they're not connected to stablecoins. So the first thing for us to notice is in the shadow banking area where only market competition and efficiency governs the structure of the intermediaries.
What if they chosen to do? They specialize. They don't combine services. They're not doing lending and stablecoins. They're doing lending or stablecoins. I think that makes perfect sense. And in my articles recently, I've talked about why unbundling is so illuminating. So when you look at the shadow, you're seeing that the modern solutions are unbundling. Now that's partly because if you're a shadow bank, it's very hard to do. You can't be involved in the checking system. But there's more to it than that because people aren't choosing tether is founding itself strongly driven toward what? Trying to create a kind of payment system without a lot of risk on the asset side.
So that is very important that whatever those old bundling advantages were, I would argue that they've been undermined by improvements in information technology that no longer require these two things or really are benefited from doing these two things together. That's a complicated and fairly deep economic argument. But I think people can get the basic gist of the job that what we're talking about is look at the shadow banks. You see stablecoin providers aren't trying to do lending lending providers aren't trying to do stablecoins. That's very interesting because if there were big synergies as there have been in the past between combining the two, they would be trying to do both, but they don't.
So the future, I think, is now coming back to your statement, which I agree with. The future is that the incumbent bank see that they no longer are going to have this basically chartered bank subsidy of having this kind of a all and gopitalistic control of a deposit based system that then funds and subsidizes their lending activities. That is not going to be that is not a permanent feature of our financial system, but it's not going to go away easily. It's because the banks have huge power by virtue of their political influences. They are extremely powerful organizations and they even operate through the organization that today is the most evil organization in the United States.
I wonder if you've ever even heard of it. I'll guess your listeners have it. It's called the Bank Policy Institute. It sounds so objective. It sounds so scholarly. It sounds so wonderful that someone who is out there doing the public good of talking about bank policy. No, no, no, no, no. It's the worst. It's Darth Vader on steroids, okay? Darth Vader on steroids. This group is not just about colluding, not just the biggest banks colluding, but using their power to try to stop things that will help citizens in favor of themselves and they are they're really evil. I can tell you when I was chief economist at the office of the control of the currency, I would read their their statements whenever we had a regulation.
They were the most excruable things I ever read. The idea that an economist working for the Bank Policy Institute could write such things must be so alienating for them and so miserable their existence that I you know, I don't see how they can stand it. But that's what power is all about. These aren't just operating individually. They're operating collectively through this collective action entity and it funnels. It sponsors conferences at universities like it where I used to be Columbia University and controls professors through the money that it provides for sponsoring those conferences. You kind of understand politics to understand banking.
Yeah. Charles one thing we want to explore. I think it is on the this same thread. Ryan and I probably the vast majority of our listeners anecdotally understand the trend shift about where money and banking is going like Ryan and I use Ethereum as our banking layer. I write a monthly check to my landlord because he that's the only way I can pay him money and that is the only activity that is left in my Wells Fargo account is like my monthly rent payment and over time like as this bankless thing that we have tried to encourage evolves and becomes more mature, I think that's probably true for just a larger and larger percentage of the population.
Our banking activity is done in our Ethereum wallets on stable coins and it's coming at a loss to our account activity in Wells Fargo our deposit base in Wells Fargo and that's because of the hundreds of billions of dollars that are now available on Ethereum. Now is the Bank Policy Institute that you just named as Darth Vader which I'm a huge fan of. I would like to learn more about that but I'm already a fan of calling it Darth Vader. Is that what we are up against? Is that what we are doing? They don't like they're coordinating entity just as and I'm not trying to be partisan here. The Democratic National Committee is another coordinating entity.
The Democrat Party is all in on this. A lot of the Republican Party is too but the Republican Party isn't in agreement against this future as we can see now and in fact you even saw the Genius Act had bipartisan supports. You're seeing cracks in the coalition. That's what's so interesting. This coalition that had decided not to even appoint an OCC controller. They had decided to just block all the progress Brian Brooks they tried to do. All of a sudden now we have legislation allowing this with bipartisan support from this Congress that can't even agree on what day of the week it is. That's pretty interesting.
That tells you that there's been a political shift and it's worth analysis that I don't claim to be fully understanding every aspect of that but that's where we need to go and of course you're right that you're seeing it with Ethereum and by the way my understanding is I think you said it that you have your stablecoins in a wallet on Ethereum and you can also my understanding as tether can be both in Ethereum and in Bitcoin. You can either put it on the platform of an exchange or you can put it within the blockchain and I think that's really interesting. That's where we're going. We have of course we have a long way to go because as you pointed out you still pay your landlord with a chat.
We have to get it so that you can buy coffee off your cell phone with stablecoins and that means that we have to create a decentralized network for stablecoin retail transactions. It's not just about buying and selling crypto mainly using tether mainly for crypto transactions but using them in the real world but this is easy. This is creating a little box on retail just as they have credit cards where they're doing it with stablecoins. The technology is already there. In fact the technology is already there not just to completely sidestep the bank incumbent payment system with stablecoins but to actually change even I know this is very futuristic.
We'll get to it to supplant the dollar to create a new concept of transacting a new unit of account but I want to emphasize that can't happen without politics under article one section eight of our constitution. Congress has the power to determine to control the money and they have used that power and interpreted that very much as their own right to decide what a legal tender is. That means something that can actually be used as a payment mechanism legally to satisfy debts. If Congress doesn't want the new unit of account to happen that I have in mind creating this new synthetic dollar out of the blockchain to and get rid of the Federal Reserve dollar then it doesn't have to happen.
So until the politics what we see with the genius act is the beginning of the cracks in the anti-stablecoin coalition now we have a bipartisan agreement to have to make to allow charter banks to do stablecoins. By the way this is huge because when I was at the OCC I can tell you the one thing the OCC has done right for the last 160 years has been examining as a credible third party. So you want stablecoins issuers because let me tell you something a lot of your listeners aren't going to like it. I think tether is kind of sleazy. They have been right they kind of let's just use the word that your generation likes sketchy they're sketchy right they're little sketchy and imagine now instead you've got some boring bureaucrat who's paid just to examine the algorithm make sure that the algorithm is what you what the stablecoin provider says it is and examine the reserve balance held at some fiduciary and make sure that it is what they say it is and that examination is pretty much the entire role that we need the regulator to do and what we really need is for the regulator to somehow commit not to let the political compromises of the future lead it to try to control stablecoins and that's tricky because let's you know I'm not telling you I got the magic bullet for that either so the genius act cuts both ways right once you stay stablecoins have to be part of a chartered entity you open up the possibility that that thing can be regulated to start giving subsidies to Jesse Jackson just like our chartered banking system decided to do in the 1990s so it's all politically contingent so if you guys think that because we are forward looking people who like technology and want to see good technologies happen that they will automatically happen it's not true you have to be a political force to build a coalition that represents the public's interest if the public isn't informed like like you guys weren't informed the two and a half trillion dollars had been contracted from merging banks to these activist local activist organizations that's why they succeed right so the political coalition doesn't always represent the common interests of the public in fact it almost never does so that so this is where the real you know problems are we can talk about how yes of course we can take we can circumvent this whole centralized payment system run by the Fed and we can have it immediately a medium of exchange done more securely more quickly when ways that allow you to combine messaging with payments so you can enrich the whole process of the payment system all of that can happen at the speed of light in a decentralized network that can't be hacked unlike Fed wire which will definitely be hacked all of this is true however it's all contingent and then going beyond that to create to use the the data that's in the blockchain in some kind of anonymized way to create information about what the consumption bundles are so that you can then construct a new unit of account it's more optimally configured than the dollar is using economic theory that we've had for 150 years so yes that that can happen but not if Congress decides that that definition of the dollar won't be a legal tender so so we have to we have to get mobilized to educate ourselves and to therefore exert the power on on politicians so you're going to have to create organized groups there's no such thing as decentralized political activity you have to create organized groups to promote this future imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly that's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking a revolutionary new category at the intersection of trad five and web three at the heart is you are the world's first money app built fully on chain it gives you a Swiss iBan account blending fiat currencies like the euro the Swiss franc the United States dollar or the remembe with crypto all in one place enjoy real world usability and blockchain's trust and programmability transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with trad five rails impact with integrated defi features you are transforms mantle network into the ultimate platform for on chain financial services unifying payments trading and assets like the mi4 the me's protocol and functions fbtc backed by developer grants ecosystem incentives and top distribution through the ur app reward stations and buy bit launch pool for mnt holders every economic activity in ur drives value back to you embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking that's x.
com slash mantle underscore official dgen started as a tight-knit community on forecaster and organically grew into one of the top meme coins on base what began as a simple idea tip anyone who joins the fund sparked an economy that turned into a movement the community runs the show from the logo and the lower to funding and building ambitious ideas together over one million dgen now power each other with their generosity creativity and ability to get things done at the center is the dgen token it rewards engagement fuels tipping and drives the marketplace for builders and fans that same energy gave rise to dgen chain a fast low cost layer three for new projects and now the dgen app the easiest way to connect earn and participate in decentralized social media with a built-in wallet and real token utility in dgen the has stays on join dgen and get on the app weight list at www.
dgen.tips when you research a new protocol you shouldn't have to juggle 12 tabs just to get the full picture market data on chain activity social sentiment developer updates they're all scattered across different platforms surf brings it all together it's the first crypto ai platform that combines institution-grade research with on-chain execution in one interface from discovery and research to action surf gives you a full end-to-end experience instead of bouncing between dune d philoma twitter and github surf gives you the story behind the data in seconds whether you're evaluating a protocol tracking positions monitoring whale moves or exploring the next narrative surf upgrades your workflow so you can spend less time piecing things together and more time making informed decisions check out surf today and experience crypto ai that actually works sign up now and use code bank list to get a seven day free trial to surf pro click the link in the description for more information i want to get your take on um a current political battle that is happening right now on the back of the the genius act i'm gonna throw some things out there just to set the landscape um and then a lot you know allow you to comment on it so this is on the element of yield uh from staple points sure okay and so it's an active issue right now so the genius bill prohibits issuers so when it do you like tether or circle from uscc from actually um providing yield to their consumers however there is a loophole let's call it which means any other yeah any other entity uh sort of in the value flow can actually provide that interest from treasuries back to the stablecoin recipient you know in the form of rewards so for instance you keep your usdc on coin base and you actually get the four percent from treasuries and a bank doesn't get that okay so this is an active fight right now i actually read i don't know if you've seen this but there was a article in Brookings uh from uh Aaron Klein this week okay and i don't know if this is the influence of the the bpi and Darth Vader sure or if Aaron Klein is Aaron Klein is a huge defender of the status okay let me let me give you what he says and then i want you to poke like tell me what you think about it what stands up from an economist perspective so he basically says rewards are a dangerous loophole he says uh it's be you know if you look at what happened to money market funds okay so money market funds through history 2008 et cetera had to be bailed out by the government and he's saying the same is going to happen to stablecoins you also highlights the deposit flight concerns basically it's going to bleed bank deposits checking counts dry that is going to hurt lending and financial stability for the entire banking system so he says yeah Congress should actually go back to the genius bill and close the loophole make it such that consumers individual citizens the stablecoins do not get that interest under any circumstances and he argues that it's pivotal so so Ryan i mean you've you've mentioned four fallacious things in a sequence so you have to get a little slower and let me point out why each of them is fallacious all right let's take them all take them all okay so first of all money market funds bailouts were not economically inevitable they were a political outcome so to say that the fact that money markets were bailed out when they broke the buck was somehow had to be true is is wrong um if if instead the government hadn't bailed them out the world would just be fine okay so so then now now let's give them a little bit of a credit and say well what he's saying is that the rail politics will be that stablecoins will that path of least resistance will lead to bailing out of stablecoins when they have lost okay so i don't believe that's true either because one of the things that we can do with stablecoins is we can require them to have automatic resetting algorithms so that what if they suffer a loss now we have a couple of alternatives one is to restrict what the assets can be so they only hold short-term debt treasury debt as assets in which case there's no real possibility of loss or we can allow them to have a broader set of assets but then to have an automatic reset algorithm that then when there's a loss of assets has an automatic thing happen in the stablecoins so that people when they buy stablecoins know exactly what they're getting into my own view would be to allow both to allow both the riskless stablecoins and the risky stablecoins with the reset and i think that my understanding of political economy which is fairly deep is that if it's done that way there won't be bailouts with stablecoins so the notion of stablecoins will be risky if no that's not true if they're examined and if they have either the algorithmic adjustments with full transparency or or if you don't believe in that you could you could say well and i want to initially restrict them to only hold treasury bills again chartered and monitored i can't understand that that argument makes sense but no he's wrong of course this is what the advocates of the incumbents are all about doing whether they're bp i or air inclined what they're really about doing is they operate organizations who pay their salaries to make up arguments like this so i'm sorry go ahead tell me more i i just want to get into that that's great so that's the first one let's get into the deposit flight concern okay so it's going to bleed the bank's deposits dry and that's going to cost the first of all plenty of course no no the deposits banks should in equilibrium because there's no longer an advantage from bundling the equilibrium should be that banks raise their money their money from outside market sources so you can think of it as securitization which is a well-known banking source of funding or outright debt issues by banks that aren't part of the transacting medium why shouldn't banks do that finance companies do it finance companies have been doing since the 1960s maybe because it's harder they don't like it and Aaron knows they're paying his salary and working believe me they are believe me they are can i ask you Aaron he's a nice guy but i know where his salary comes from i know where Brookings i know what Brookings is all about okay and so so yeah of course they don't like it they don't like competition they're going to fight it and they're going to hire people at the bpi or the air and clients of the world or they're going to have politicians like Maxine Waters risky risky risky risky or Joe Biden creating his white paper from his little commission it's all risky risky no it's not risky risky risky if it's designed properly um and i think you know as a historian and a theorist of bank runs i don't think there's anybody who knows them as well as i do that just doesn't have to be the equilibrium let me also point out stablecoins should not be debt obligations in my opinion they should not be constructed as debt obligations they should it so in my papers about this i pointed out why not take advantage of it some existing law and make them perpetual preferred stock so i know that this isn't necessarily the way people are all thinking but if it's perpetual preferred stock then notice you could have dividends in principle and i'll come back to your question on that because of course when i asked the person at circle before they announced their IPO how they were going to deal with the genius act the answer was you can create a securities wrap for owning the stablecoins and the securities wrap can pay interest think of it as perpetual preferred stock so perpetual preferred stock never has a maturity date if you don't pay the coupon you're not in default you don't go into bankruptcy so you could have an algorithmic readjustment if there were a problem but think about perpetual preferred stock with a dividend that actually owns the stablecoin so that you when you buy the stablecoin you also buy preferred stock that owns the stablecoin preferred stock pays you is a perpetual preferred stock that pays you a dividend and let me tell you another reason this is so potentially advantageous if you ever heard of the the global dollar network yes that's a that's a stablecoin as well right is it paxos behind that it's a joint venture yes it's a joint venture by robinhood um anchorage and paxos and but their their vision is their big economies of scale to having a single stablecoin but there are all these economies of relationship of consumer relationships that mean that they need to partner with amazon wallmark you go down the list right why not let those individual entities who partner with them bring who bring the relationships the consumer relationships to the stablecoin network why not let them retain the customer relationship so you could imagine that you Ryan want to you want to get global dollar network because it's it's going to build itself as a as a rail as a kind of infrastructure of stablecoin to be able to compete with tether through high scale great i really think they will and when they do that though when wallmark brings someone to that stablecoin wallmark maybe could construct their own preferred perpetual preferred stock that owns the stable the global dollar network stablecoins that are its customer relationship and it can decide the interest it pays on that perpetual preferred stock yeah so of course you know that the only way you could have gotten the incumbent banks to be part of this is to try to limit it and to think but then the other people in that political bargain had already figured out before the genius act was passed the person at circle i talked to told me this that this was their strategy so it's kind of like you know of course this is not going to work limiting the interest on stablecoins is so stupid and it's so country it it shows you how the incumbents hate you they hate the the american public they they have only contempt for us that they don't want any product they can compete for our business to be able to pay us interest so that they can keep us how disgusting are these incumbent banks wow Charles you might hate banks more than bankless does which is uh absolutely saying something i i think i know more about them than yeah i know you do well again can i ask you a broader question if this is fully realized let's say we win this political battle let's say it's inevitable let's say basically what we talk about it in terms you you're talking about perpetual perpetual preferred stocks we talk about that in terms of yield right it's like let's say the yield goes back to the end my question is like here's something i don't understand so maybe put your monetary economist hat on for this which is i don't understand that in that case why we actually need dollars so here's what i sort of mean basically okay so if david and i and david was talking about paying his landlord let's say he can pay his landlord with a stablecoin that's wrapped in yield okay so we could totally do this from a technical perspective there could be some sort of stablecoin that effectively gives david the fed fund rate of of four percent then he gets that as a dividend let's say all the intermediaries are pretty much cut out the margins are compressed so that mostly david receives that he'd rather hold that four percent yield stablecoin thing rather than dollars and so would everybody like on the planet everybody would rather use the yield thing rather than dollars but doesn't this just cut dollars out of the equation everyone's using these sort of you know treasuring instruments so not completely okay so so now this is really important we have to distinguish the role of the dollar is a medium of exchange from the role of the dollars a unit of account notice tether and almost all stablecoins are denominated in dollars some are denominated in euros and yet but more than 90 percent are denominated in dollars i think the short term the growth of stablecoins will actually strengthen the role of the dollar in global markets it'll allow people in countries they have really bad currencies to switch some of their liquid balances to dollar to nominated accounts so the first thing to note is the short term effect of using stablecoins as a medium of exchange will actually be probably to strengthen the role of the dollar as a unit of account there only a couple trillion of these actual physical dollars that are being handed back and forth mainly by criminals i have something my wallet too i'm not a criminal but yet but mainly by criminals so but the so the dollar doesn't serve a very big function right now as a medium of exchange in physical dollars but then there are other dollars that are called reserves that banks hold that are basically what is the backing thing the the sort of small piece that allows deposits to work so that's another medium of exchange so the federal reserve not only creates it creates two media of exchange effectively one or reserves the others dollars and that's a medium of exchange use but it also the dollar as a valuable thing that's exchanged in the market that has a value relative to your commodities and services and other currencies that's a valuable unit of account stablecoins are denominated in dollars so the dollar doesn't disappear just because stablecoins displace deposits and currency as medium of exchange because the dollar still retains its role as a unit of account but it doesn't have to why because what is a unit of account a unit of account is just how we denominate all of our transactions we could decide to create so so let me let me give an example suppose that we lived we all this lived in champagne or battle in champagne champagne or battle pretty much the whole local economy other than the university is soybean and corn that's what's produced there and in fact even the stores that sell other things you know if soybeans and corn do badly they do badly right so think of it for a minute like let's get rid of soybeans it's just corn they grow corn and eat corn let's say it's a really simple life that's all there is to it all that we do in this one location is we grow corn and eat corn and when we work we we work to grow corn so when we work should we be paid in dollars should we denominate wages in dollars should we denominate prices in dollars wouldn't it be just simpler yes the answer is yes if we just pay people in units of corn and we denominated everything in corn because there's only one commodity called corn why should you if you lived in champagne or battle you wouldn't want if if if you were only eating corn i'm not saying that's true of people in champagne or battle but suppose it were then they wouldn't want to denominate things in dollars they just denominate them in corn they'd be paid in corn and they'd eat corn they grow corn eat corn get paid in corn that's it you wouldn't need a dollar numerator okay now let me generalize that point jevans one of the great founders of modern economics in the late 19th and early 20th century develop the theory of the unit of account and what an optimal unit of account is and basically showed us something very intuitive which is the optimal unit of account that we want to be paid in would be our consumption bundle because then if we know so if if you consume 10 different things in certain ways you'd really like your your payment to be denominated in that because then when you get paid you know you you get you know in advance you're going to get a certain amount of consumption so your your pay contract translates directly into your consumption and that means that when there's no like slippage coming from variation in the value of your payment relative to your consumption preference right so that's what jevans realize now here's the amazing miraculous thing blockchain records and allows you to extract in an anonymized way what the consumption bundle is once it becomes a network in which services and commodities are all transacted through the blockchain we actually we actually can know in a particular location what the consumption bundle is so we can get a lot closer to an optimal unit of account and we could even now it gets really interesting maybe some locations will have their own specialized unit of account so we don't just have one unit of account but we have subunits of account now they'd be aggregated to create the national dollar that would be trading with other economies but that they could have separate units of account so that people could have their own value of the sort of New England dollar and the the southeastern dollar and the western dollar and and then allowing those to all be legal tender and then having a national dollar that's a weighted aggregation of that would allow us to all be paid in ways that would be much more optimal for us as from the perspective of consumers is this really practical the answer is yes because blockchain allows the recording of all that information in perpetuity which we know we can access in an anonymized way it's not trivial but the technology already exists to do that selective anonymity is what it's sometimes called in blockchain transactions so yeah of course you can do that physically it's not not problem but then will will the political game of bank bargains allow it how do we get that to happen the other thing that's an important wrinkle of that is to actually transact in something that's this sort of basket you're going to need reserves that the different stablecoin issuers transact with each other basically bundle of the consumption good and how do you do that well you have believe it or not you would have not everyone but some finite group you'd denominate the bundle let's say as a stake for roots Chris stake house a filet mignon from roots Chris stake house plus a bag of lace potato chips both sold by particular sellers okay and then those so how do those sellers create a reserve bundle that combines the two they issue instead of um issuing these little cards that allow you to buy you know root at roots Chris you issue a filet mignon IOU so the really interesting idea is to tokenize IOUs that are linked to specific commodities provided by or services provided by particular local firms this sounds really far out but actually technologically it's trivial the tricky thing is to actually create how somebody comes up with what the optimal bundle should be and in my papers I talk about the different tradeoffs there it's going to be there's going to be a tradeoff where you want to have sums you know what everyone in the economy to be producing these tokenized reserves but you do want it to be a small number who kind of span the consumption bundle reasonably well but who have very low default risk we're going to have to have algorithms about what to do with the tokens when you want to go to roots Chris to redeem your filet mignon but they're out of business so we're going to have to there's a fair amount of algorithmic kind of complexity to creating these reserves but the the promise on it the reason it's worth doing is it will create so much better outcome in terms of making the unit of account much closer to what we consume so right now we have this compromise unit of account the dollar it's a one-size-fits-all no matter what location you're in you you have to deal with it now there going to be lots of other issues like well should this whose consumption bundle should this be should it be kind of an aggregation of the whole region that would be my preference but you could also imagine that this could be a political football where we use poor people's consumption bundle some people advocate that because they think of it as it's it's a form of trying to subsidize or help the poor so I just want to you know keep emphasizing all of these economic ideas have to be filtered through the political system because politically congress decides what the legal tender is and then finally just point out once we get this great system it's still contingent I mean congress could decide to start taxing stablecoins congress could decide to require stablecoins to give subsidies to particular targeted individuals but I think from the standpoint of economic theory we can see clearly that getting rid of the federal reserve getting rid of the incumbent banking system in terms of the payment system forcing the banks to fund their loans through securitization and other kinds of market means getting rid of the fed as that not just as a clearing mechanism but even as a creation of the unit of account would be hugely beneficial finally I want to emphasize that doesn't mean that you couldn't do countercyclical policy the way there's a fair affects the economy during recessions to try to counter recessions is that it all operates through an interest rate spread basically by exchanging reserves for treasuries it really that's its whole mechanism it's affecting the yield on treasuries by exchanging reserves for treasuries that's what the Fed does that's it in a nutshell well you could imagine a fiscal authority constructed in the same kind of independent ways the Fed that would instead just tax and subsidize loans to affect loan spreads so you could just say oh you know we're in a recession from now on when you're paying a loan on your consumer debt or your mortgage you're paying let's say x percent we're going to now tell the government's going to pay a five percent of your acts and then that will make economic activity happen more and then if we think the economy is going too fast the government taxes it the interest rate adds to the interest you pay by five percent so we could imagine using us just as we operate on the interest rate spread between treasuries and cash we can operate on the interest rate spread in loan contracts with a fiscal device so I just want to emphasize there isn't just there is no real need in fact it's kind of straight these central banks that have been operating for the last in the world let's say about 150 years there's just no reason to think that this is the technology we need for the payment system or for counter-cyclical policy or for lending for that matter of course they are an entrenched interest and all of the decisions about what our financial system can be our political decisions we can't fool ourselves this is not about technology technology is required but not sufficient I think what's fascinating about everything you just said is just on the back of mass tokenization and stablecoins where basically the entire US economy is converted to blockchain and crypto like for this what sort of new unit of account types of things you could dream up that's what's fascinating you're also making the point that from a monetary policy perspective there might actually be more tools at the disposal of monetary authorities than there were previously these kinds of political like notions these these ideas now that stablecoins are here in the US do you have any sense for how they'll play out in other sovereign countries other nation states let's say so like it's a great question going to do what's China going to do it seems like Europe has been moving direction let me make a recommendation sure if you haven't had Luis Garicano on your program okay Luis Garicano is a professor at the LSE and he is the authority on the European political struggle over stablecoins right now okay and so you should you should have him on to talk about what they're doing my understanding so in Europe the incumbent banks are even more powerful within the state than they are in the US and they are very much blocking progress trying to create a banking monopoly of stablecoins too it's kind of the way it's heading in Europe what will it not mean just like one it just basically yeah I mean in the US you don't have to be an incumbent bank to run the stablecoins but in Europe that's kind of the way it's being done that's my understanding so have Luis come and talk to you he's he's more knowledgeable than anyone on this topic but I think that here's what my training and knowledge from history tells me countries are all different from each other so let me give you an example how many countries can you name in the world that have managed for the past 30 or 40 years to not have a banking crisis and to have a very rich sort of credit to GDP ratio that is they have a very highly functioning banking system with a lot of credit available and no banking crises and so I would say at least Switzerland is one that comes to mind okay Switzerland has had a banking crisis oh they have okay yeah so yeah now I'm out of ideas yeah I mean my my my second go to these would be something like Singapore but you're close Malta would be one Malta would be one Singapore would be one so I'm just going to use those couple of examples what do Malta and Singapore have in common they're very small they're small but it's not just a size thing but the size creates the more important characteristic which homogeneity hmm banking systems are political foot political footballs the coalition of the winning coalition of the game of bank bargains is all about taking money from the losers but if you're homogenous you don't play the banking game that way so much because there isn't an identifiable group of losers to steal from which is what bank charters in the US have always been a mechanism to build a coalition that takes from someone else and preserves our stability at their expense now and that's what we've done that's what most countries do so there are going to be some countries that are going to figure out hey we're a small homogenous country we don't use our banking system as a way to build a coalition that takes from others within our country and so maybe we should be like a global player in stablecoins and create all the advantages of a chartered stablecoin system with international access the challenges these backward corrupt countries like the United States and Western Europe so that's where it gets interesting and then will the United States and Western Europe then try to put pressure on those countries not to do that so it's a question like why isn't Singapore more active in trying to create a mechanism that could work in the US but with somehow I mean so the genius act kind of prevents some of this already but I think you can see what I'm getting at that there's going to be different countries you're going to have different strategies depending on their own political economy and I haven't got a great forecast for how all that's going to play out but it's going to be interesting to watch you're going to see in the mirror of stablecoin legislation and chartering you're going to see the mirror of that country's political economy Charles how do you think this all plays out maybe for the dollar so as we you know bring this episode to a close let's let's talk about the the powerful network effect that the dollar has today which is it is the world reserve currency it's used by the vast majority payments above 70 percent and then treasuries are the world reserve asset at least right now there's maybe you know some move to other harder type assets and we we see ebbs and flows of that throughout history you said in the short run this is going to help the dollar I can't help but agree right this is right going to dollarize economies around the world that basically have a subpar local currency and they far rather use the dollar and we're starting to see some of that but long term how does this play out I think it plays it depends of course on how the dollars constructed you could even imagine creating something called a global dollar so you know there have been such things like again the bank of Amsterdam you know create an abstract units of currency we could create a domestic dollar and an international dollar like a global dollar like an SDR type of idea no it's but it's more like trying to be based in a global consumption bundle so suppose that this future that I'm talking about happens where we use the the recordation of transactions in the blockchain to create a better unit of account than the Fed's liability treasuries will be denominated in that account international transactions will be the dollar it'll still be called the dollar it'll just be a better dollar so you can even imagine constructing not just a new England dollar a southern dollar a US dollar which is a weighted average of those which you can imagine creating a global dollar as a unit of account which would have a deal by virtue of the fact that it is more linked to the global consumption bundle or maybe you could create a dollar for each major region of the world so if you really wanted to compete give the how does Amazon compete for business in another country it tries to do something that that people in that country might find beneficial so maybe if we want to compete to preserve the role of the dollar maybe one way to do it is to make the dollar better I know that never occurred to a damn politician but it doesn't occur to people in the business community well say stable coins are better dollars because they have better payment rail so in that sense we're we're making it better but you're saying medium of exchange okay you're talking about a unit of account I'm saying sure in the short term as we go to more stable coins that will strengthen the dollar because stable coins will find that by denominating dollars they will they will spread more right and more countries and people but the longer term issue is what about this unit of account and I know a lot of people wonder well if we got rid of the Fed would we even have a dollar of course we would with the dollar be competitive in international markets would people still want to hold treasuries as their reserve assets yes you in fact you can make the dollar better you could even create a dollar by making it legal tender in the US you could create an international dollar you could even create a European dollar that's legal tender in the US for transactions between Europe and the US that would be more attractive to the Europeans than the current dollar so the point is if you really want to strategically build this on this reserve currency advantage that we have why not actually try to create a better product well can I can I ask you on this because you you're emphasizing a better unit of exchange basically medium of exchange sorry with with stablecoin payment networks better unit of accounts and innovation there but what about the other function of the dollar which is store of value and I think like people worry about that I mean look at our deficit this year you know two trillion dollars and it's continuing to escalate and debt to GDP continues to go up well now we worried about that yeah so that's that's not about the dollar that's about treasuries that's about assets are stores of value so yes the dollar the physical dollar is one of those but if you had stablecoins that were denominated in dollars and if the dollar then becomes this inflated thing then people might decide not to denominate stablecoins is that kind of where we're headed it is actually I've written an article about this too it's it's called fiscal dominance that is the fact that our fiscal policy is inconsistent with low inflation that's a separate issue and what it tells you is though another advantage to making to creating a consumption bundle definition of the dollar if we did if we did that suppose it right now I snap my fingers and my vision in the future can happen all of our transactions are denominated our consumption bundles there's no longer this physical thing called the Federal Reserve currency well that means that we no longer where do we get inflation from when the US government has too much debt and the Federal Reserve has to print money to buy the debt because no one else wants to that's where inflation comes from well if you don't have a Federal Reserve what happens when a government issues too much debt it doesn't have anyone printing money under its thumb to buy its debt right so what does it do it defaults that's not scary that's not scary country's defaults let's do it all the time I mean you know that's better in your in your mind you're like mind then kind of the slow over time default and deleverging that we basically I'm not saying that I'm not saying that I know it's better I'm just pointing out that if you're worried about inflation coming from the government debt and I am and by the way my estimate of the inflation rate depending on accompanying policies if we don't solve our physical problem we're going to have at least let's say 10% rate of inflation a year and I would say more realistically complicated to explain it maybe as much as 30% 40% inflation per year like CPI right exactly that's that's what you know that's that's what the arithmetic tells you it has to be if you don't fix the government debt problem now my St.
Louis Federal Reserve I have a paper in 2023 published by the St. Louis Fed review that basically explains that you have me on for another time I'm happy to explain that but so yeah that's a pretty high inflation you could say which would I prefer having the US government default on its debt when it runs out of room to issue debt or being able to inflate its debt away well that's the choice I'm just pointing out that if you went to blockchain based unit of account then you wouldn't have the government with the option to inflate away the debt it would have to default but maybe that would mean it's more likely for the government to do something different which is called fix the problem maybe you know so your generation of course is going to be completely screwed I mean you guys are really idiots if you ask me like why you haven't been out there with pitchforks and torches and you let these organizations like the AARP by the way if the BPI bank policy institute is Darth Vader I think that the AARP is like Darth Vader's captain that was strangled whatever his name was general something right they're pretty bad too and they they make it sound like we older people have this all oh we've paid this money no no no no no Medicare benefits and Social Security benefits for for this current generation that are getting it far far exceed what they've paid in and because something doesn't come from nothing what this means is the very generous welfare state that is created for me is not going to be available for you because I'm stealing from you that is real that is not just some that is not that's arithmetic right how come you guys don't seem to know how to advocate for yourself how does Donald Trump or the entire democratic party get away with just avoiding talking about this how do they do that well Charles I can tell you what we do which is we buy Bitcoin instead that's our protest that's not good enough this is the problem right I said this at the beginning if you don't understand that everything is politically contingent you can't isolate yourself you live in the United States you you're earning a salary and it says you're like you you don't isolate yourself by doing some like tech bro nonsense okay sorry David I have to tell you you have to organize and play the game engage and you haven't done it your generation hasn't done it and I'm really sorry I won't be a member of the AARP under any circumstance I regard them as a horrible or selfish organization the worst example of that kinds of thinking that people of my generation and others are capable of because it's so selfish and so purposely mindless of others thoughtless about others so we need to start raising the level of our political discussion ethically you know we just have this terrible event of Charlie Kirk's death I didn't agree with everything Charlie Kirk said I thought he was too much of a Trump kiss ass to be honest even though I loved so much of what he did I'm being honest you know I admire Charlie and I I also pray for him and I think very very highly of him but you know we need to think for ourselves neither the Democratic Party which is a bunch of corrupt you know cynical losers nor the MAGA sort of pretense that tariffs are good don't worry about the debt like what's going on with our country you guys you're the blame if you want to know who to blame look in the mirror that's hilarious because I think a lot of people in our generation probably blame you know baby boomers for like where we are now but the point is this is a political game engage engage I won't be part of that I agree with you the baby boomers have selfishly stolen from you you know you don't just find Bitcoin and can solve that problem Bob I think that's a fair call to action Charles you know thank you for that admonition as we as we in this episode I guess maybe my last question for you before we let you go is do you think we have won sufficiently with the genius bill signed you think we've won I know there's going to be political battles ahead but have we won enough such that stable coins that the horses left the stable they're going to keep running we're going to get into the trillions of dollars it's like it's no you don't think we've won yet on stable I think it's I think it's a great first step but now you've actually put stable coins into the arena now what's going to happen once you put them in the arena what will the next congressional bill about stable coins be you think this does it that would be like saying that when the national banking system was created that that prohibited Jesse Jackson from making so much money off of bank mergers in the 1990s it didn't you never sleep politicians in there and their coalition never sleep and you better not be sleeping either I guess the cost of freedom is ever present vigilance I guess that's that's the message to the end my personal worry as well in addition to that is that some of the new crypto organizations around stable coins become more and more bank like in the future it is interesting that entities like circle and tether they get to keep that 4% yield right now and you sort of wonder like do they really want to give that up it's not inside of they know that's what competition will do yes that's what and you know that that's what we need we need competition which will will get them to relinquish that yield and that's the future that we're really all hoping for you know that the little guy doesn't have a representative in Washington unless he insists on it by organizing and has clear vision understand of history I don't say cynical but I say realistic and I don't trust any of those politicians and I don't think the organized groups that are lobbying in Washington generally really are informed and have aligned interests with you know the average person so you really you know you have to somehow convince people it's it's very hard because we all have our own jobs we all have our lives you know how much time can you take out so the answers you have to come up with a credible delegation of this interest and they have to have money they have to have political power that comes for money and influence and having a great network of people who will pressure politicians so I think we're already seen a little bit of that but it's very fragile you know this is not something that you can say oh well we've won the battle oh no you never win the battle you'd have to be ever vigilant as you just said and you know I think you know in that's something you know in memory of and in gratitude to Charlie Kirk who I think very highly of I think we that's a good way for us to be thinking he was somebody who really went out there and did that and had a huge effect but he had an organization you know turning point and we need we need to be thinking about that we need to think about how to really create intelligent organizations that aren't captured by incumbent interests and that really can put forward our collective interests and that means fiscal lobby and that means protecting crypto from being seized by some other special interests the whole history of banking is great ideas bank checking account for a great idea in the 19th century loans were a great idea lines of credit with the scots which the scots invented in the 18th century great idea these are all great but they all have to work through the political process and then they get captured and transformed stablecoins in the same thing great technology blockchain is a great technology don't believe for a minute that you're immune to the government that you can operate in the cloud or something you know you operate off of a machine and that machine is governed by US law you can't escape it and we need to really get engaged anyway that's my view well it called action then Charles and I gotta say I didn't expect you to be you know so close to the bankless movement as as you have been in this discussion so it sounds like you are fan of banks and are looking forward to their disruption by crypto so on that count we're we're allies on that for sure completely bankless nation gotta let you know none of this has been financial advice crypto's risky you could lose what you put in but we're headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot and thank you Charles thank you bye guys bye