Ram Ahluwalia, CEO of Lumida Wealth Management, joins us to discuss everything that's happened in the past five days post-SVB collapse. Ram has his finger on the pulse on all things finance (crypto included), the U.S. Banking System, and The Federal Reserve.
Was USDC ever at risk? Is crypto being targeted? Could DeFi have fixed this? Answers to these questions and much more in the episode.
------ 📣 RhinoFi | Makes DeFi Frictionless https://bankless.cc/rhino
------ 🚀 JOIN BANKLESS PREMIUM: https://www.bankless.com/join
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/kraken
🦄UNISWAP | ON-CHAIN MARKETPLACE https://bankless.cc/uniswap
👻 PHANTOM | FRIENDLY MULTICHAIN WALLET https://bankless.cc/phantom-waitlist
🦊METAMASK LEARN | HELPFUL WEB3 RESOURCE https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
🚁 EARNIFI | CLAIM YOUR UNCLAIMED AIRDROPS https://bankless.cc/earnifi ----- Timestamps:
0:00 Intro 7:48 The Last 5 Days 10:30 Technology 15:35 Fractional Reserves & Assets 19:17 Banking & Venture 21:44 SIVB Outlier 27:35 Risk Curves 29:35 Carry Trades 35:05 Money Markets 38:15 Who's Next? 40:55 Feds' Goal 47:15 Sneak Attack on Tax Payers? 49:30 Longtail Banks 57:39 Was USDC Ever at Risk? 1:03:10 SigNet 1:07:15 Is Crypto Being Targeted? 1:12:18 Interest Rates 1:18:35 Could DeFi Fix This? 1:22:24 Closing & Disclaimers
----- Resources:
Ram Ahluwalia https://twitter.com/ramahluwalia
SVB is not like other banks https://twitter.com/ramahluwalia/status/1635464465142480896
Why was Signature Bank targeted? https://twitter.com/ramahluwalia/status/1635267951610810370?s=20
“Settlement Risk” https://twitter.com/ramahluwalia/status/1635113232909373441?s=20
Conclusion https://twitter.com/ramahluwalia/status/1634203375880265730?s=20
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
We have a special state of the nation for you today. Got to talk about the banking crisis that happened last weekend. I think, David, this week we're in a whole new world. A lot has changed. We want to dissect what happened and what's changed, what this means moving forward. We brought on an adult in the room, someone that understands the financial system and the banking system much better than you and I do, or maybe then we ever will and also understands crypto. What are we getting into today, David? The big question is, are we in a new market? Did something change fundamentally? This throws me back all the way back into January of 2022, where I remember Jim Bianco tweeting out that we have entered a new paradigm and that was the rising interest rates of the Federal Reserve.
I didn't really understand the significance of that phase change of markets, yet Jim Bianco called it like a nail on the head all the way back then and so now I'm wondering and now I think the market is wondering is, are we entering a new type of phase change in the market? Bank stocks were down across the board yesterday. Crypto started responding in like a logical fashion, which is like even though it was logical still new and different and so I think this is the big question that we really want to really ask is what has changed? Is there a structural difference in the world of investing these days?
And David, it's not just you and I in this episode, who do we have on to tell us that story? Yeah, we're bringing on Ram Alawalia, who's the CEO of Lumida Wealth Management. We will introduce Ram shortly in a little bit, but we were, I asked Matt Walsh, our friends over at Castleyland Ventures podcast, who should we bring on and so Matt suggested Ram. And so Ram actually had a Twitter space this last weekend during the middle of this confusion that was very insightful for me and put a lot of perspective into my brain. So shortly, we will be bringing Ram on here in a second. Guys, before we get in, want to tell you about our friends and sponsors, Rhino Phi, embrace the inner Rhino, all right?
This is a DeFi platform. So none of this behind what I'm showing you on the dashboard here, none of this is custodial. This is an overlay on top of decentralized protocols. David, tell him what Rhino Phi is up to and how folks can get started with this really cool application. Well, while we have trad banking, totally breaking down, we have new banking, which is bankless banking across all of these different chains. And that's really what Rhino Phi enables you to do. All of the many different chains with all of the many different verbs that one might engage with as they do their bankless banking activities.
So all these different changes on one space and you can do all the things that you like to do, trade, swap, invest, pool, bridge, send, all the verbs on the left. And it obfuscates and abstracts a lot of the complexities that one might engage with while they are going across the multi-layer to multi-chain vision. So there's a link in the show notes to get started. You can also go to app.rinow.fi to start working in the bankless world of banking because sooner or later, it sounds like we all might need it these days. That's why we're all here, isn't it? To go bankless, this is the way to do that.
Go check that out. Rhino.fi. David, what should folks get out of this episode? What should they pay attention to as Ram speaks today? Yeah. So there's a bunch of big overarching headlines. And I think we're going to try and touch on one by one by one. One is bank runs in the internet age. Is that the new arena that we have stepped into? Was Silicon Valley bank a special case? And in what ways was it not a special case? Nature bank. Why was it targeted? What is the impact on crypto? How is this changing the landscape of banking altogether? Yields are down. Fear is up. Is that a temporary blipper?
Is that a complete and utter phase change in the market? I think these are all very big, important questions. And the answers to these things are really going to determine what the world of investing is like. Going forward. As always, guys, we are learning as we go. We are on the journey with you. Okay. This change, we need to know change because we need to know about it. We start every episode. This is front running the opportunities. So what is the next opportunity we need to front run and what do we need to watch out for? That's what we'll get into right after we hear from the fantastic sponsors that made this episode possible, including Kraken, our number one exchange for 2023.
Guys, these folks have been with you since 2011. Go start an account with Kraken. Kraken has been a leader in the crypto industry for the last 12 years. Dedicated to accelerating the global adoption of crypto, Kraken puts an emphasis on security, transparency, and client support, which is why over 9 million clients have come to love Kraken's products. Whether you're a beginner or a pro, the Kraken UX is simple, intuitive, and frictionless, making the Kraken app a great place for all to get involved and learn about crypto. For those with experience, the redesigned Kraken Pro app and web experience is completely customizable to your trading needs, integrating key trading features into one seamless interface.
Kraken has a 24.7 365 client support team that is globally recognized. Kraken support is available wherever, whenever you need them, by phone, chat, or email. And for all of you NFTers out there, the brand new Kraken NFT beta platform gives you the best NFT trading experience possible, rarity rankings, no gas fees, and the ability to buy an NFT straight with cash. Does your crypto exchange prioritize its customers the way that Kraken does? And if not, sign up with Kraken at Kraken.com slash bankless. Learning about crypto is hard. Until now, introducing Metamask Learn, an open educational platform about crypto, web three, self-custody, wallet management, and all the other topics needed to onboard people into this crazy world of crypto.
Metamask Learn is an interactive platform, with each lesson offering a simulation for the task at hand, giving you actual, practical experience for navigating web three. The purpose of Metamask Learn is to teach people the basics of self-custody and wallet security in a safe environment, and while Metamask Learn always takes the time to define web three specific vocabulary, it is still a jargon free experience for the crypto curious user. Friendly, not scary. Metamask Learn is available in 10 languages with more to be added soon, and it's meant to cater to a global web three audience. So are you tired of having to explain crypto concepts to your friends?
Go to learn.metamask.io and add Metamask Learn to your guides to get onboarded into the world of web three. Arbitram 1 is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the web three landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitram 1, producing flourishing, defy, and NFT ecosystems. With a recent addition of Arbitram Nova, gaming, and social apps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitram home. Both Arbitram 1 and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EV incompatible.
On Arbitram, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees. With Arbitram's recent migration to Arbitram Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit Arbitram.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app. With Arbitram, experience web three development, the way it was meant to be, secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. We are back with Rahm Alawala, who is the CEO of Lumina Wealth Management, which is an investment advisor specializing in investing in digital assets.
He's a self-professed elder millennial. I subscribe to that title as well. Rahm, we got to keep the younger millennials in line from time to time, as you know. It's great to have you on, Rahm, thank you for joining us. Can you help us make sense of what just happened in the past five days? Happy to lay it out. Thanks for having me. Long time, bankless premium subscriber, big fan of the work that you do week in and week out. Let's take a step back. What we've seen is the demise of internet banks. These are banks born of the internet and destroyed by the internet through social media, the speed and information contact in digital withdrawals.
So those banks started with, of course, Silvergate, Silicon Valley Bank, which were highly indexed to technology in the crypto sector, and of course, signature bank. So three banks in one week that are either in liquidation or in FDIC receivership and in a putting context. At the last time we had a major bank run, it was in 2008, and it was in the UK, it was in Northern Rock Bank, they had lines around the block, physical lines. And in today's world, you have digital bank runs that are enabled by better UX where you can put a wire transfer online and the fragility that the public has confidence in their bank can help to accelerate these bank runs.
I'll pause there. Ron, you're saying that this is maybe the world's first large example of a digital bank run. That's how you see the events of the past five days to week or so. That's correct. These are digital wire transfers. Now, there's some other special circumstances around this. So the three banks were primarily commercial banks as opposed to retail banks. And that matters for a few reasons. One is, as you know, the FDIC insurance cap is up to $250,000 and commercial deposits from a crypto venture fund, a hedge fund, protocol, VC, etc., is well in excess of that. So there's a higher propensity for depositors and commercial depositors to panic if they believe their bank is not going to be safe and sound.
And Ron, commercial just means not retail, more business focus, so larger account holdings in general, usually above $250,000 because they're trying to meet payroll, that sort of class bank user business startups, venture funds, hedge funds, exactly. And part of the crazy story that we're going to be talking about is the multivariate nature of it. There's like interest rates. There's Elizabeth Warren to talk about. There's all these things. But I really want to just carve out and silo off this topic of conversation of internet banking in the age of the internet era and social media, right? Just the connections that I've been seeing being made here is that the pipes for fitting a bank run through are larger than they've ever been before, as well as the viability of social media is larger than it's ever been before.
So forget crypto, forget inflation, forget interest rates, forget political targeted sectors of banking. We are simply just talking about the modern day technology of banking is probably the most susceptible to a bank run that they've ever been before, ever just by a nature of that's what happens when technology progresses. That's like one big pin in the story, correct, Ron? You nailed it. These are banks born from internet. They were destroyed by the internet. And banks rely on public confidence in the United States and across the world. We have a fractional reserve banking system. No bank can survive a full-fledged bank run by design.
By design, banks are one of the few entities that deliberately engage in borrowing short lending long and have the backing of a centralized authority in this case, the FDIC and the Federal Reserve. Banks are doing liquidity, credit, and duration transformation. It's a kind of a financial alchemy and you've talked about aspects of this in your prior podcast around money and the history of money and all the rest. But maybe I can just walk through a quick contrast of what banks do and then I'll tease up the kind of the multivariate issues that you laid out, David. So let me contrast a securities brokerage account from a bank account.
When you have a brokerage account, let's say a troll Schwab, let's see you own some stock, Tesla, Apple, et cetera, those securities are custodyed by Schwab or maybe BNYMell and the DTCC. And they're not generally being lent out. In fact, you can have those securities delivered to you, to your tour, if you want. On the other hand, when you make a deposit of bank, the bank reports to you that you've got, say, a $10,000 cash deposit. Now the reality is banks and these custodians are very different. Banks behind the scenes are re-hypothicating. What that means is they're taking your deposits and of course they're lending out.
And what the banks are doing is you're giving you instant liquidity. You have a demand deposit. You've actually made a loan to the bank that's a perpetual loan, that's priced at par and has the perception of no credit risk and a zero-dip duration loan. But on the back end, what is the bank doing? The bank is making longer-deer-rated loans. Those loans are illiquid and therefore the banks are engaged in this kind of like a financial alchemy of liquidity transformation, maturity transformation, meaning longer term loans. And credit risk transformation, you have the perception of no credit risk.
But in fact, they are taking on some risk. And the way this financial alchemy or this kind of magic works is you need two things. You need to prevent bank runs. And the way we do that in the United States is FDIC deposit insurance. And we learned this from the Great Depression when there were a number of bank runs that caused the Great Depression. If you can stop a bank run by guaranteeing deposits, then the magic show can go on. And the second thing you need is a central bank, like the Federal Reserve, that can provide liquidity to the asset side of the bank's balance sheet. If you have those two things, then the banking system should work.
And I'll say one of the comment. What you saw in crypto the last two years was non-banks pretending to be banks. If you want to explain the failure of Voyager, Celsius, BlockFi and Genesis, what were they doing? They were taking short term deposits. They were lending long. It's great to be a bank, but it doesn't work if you get a bank run. So for example, Genesis could incel their illiquid assets in time. They also got caught up in this aspiration mismatch. So with all of the insolvencies that insolvencies, whether inside in crypto or now that we're seeing them outside of in crypto, you're saying it's the same underlying pattern through and through.
So the insolvencies of Celsius, regardless of the mismanagement of Celsius, the insolvencies of Celsius, Genesis, et cetera, all the crypto firms that have already happened. Now we've seen them in three banks, but you're saying the underlying structure is still the same. There's people that had instant obligations while they were also taking long term stances in the market. Yes. When non-banks pretend like banks watch out because when the cycle turns and the liquidity leaves the system, you're going to see it's naked. Now obviously, there was fraud in the case of Celsius and other actors as well.
Can I ask a question, clarifying question about this, Ram, so, all right. So fractional reserve means if everyone tries to withdraw their funds at the same time, it breaks down because there are assets there that have kind of longer maturities and kind of the money's not there because it's being lent out and that's how banking business model works. I got it. And that's true, whether you're Celsius or whether you're a Silicon Valley bank understood, all right. But can you tell us about the assets that these banks are actually investing in? Because it's got to be different than Celsius. And it's got to be different than BlockFi, right?
So in the case of a Celsius or a BlockFi, they're investing in these highly volatile crypto assets. I hate to call them risky. In some cases, they're very risky, but like definitely volatile, right? They could lose 80% at the snap of your fingers. You never know. Yes. I got to assume a Silicon Valley bank is not going and buying like defied tokens and going levered long. They have to have much less risky investments here that are similar to dollars, much more similar to dollars than volatile crypto asset. Can you tell us about that side? Because that does seem like it's different. It should be different than you as banking system versus a Celsius or a BlockFi or a Voyager.
That's absolutely right. So let me talk about what banks are generally loaned to or invest in and then SVB because SVB is a very unique animal. So community banks, and about 4,000 plus of them, generally loaned against commercial real estate. And that could also be financing commercial industrial loans or construction loans. And that's the bulk of loans for community bank. Now you have these mega center banks and these other regional banks that also offer credit cards. So they take those deposits and they finance credit cards or auto loans, historically in the past student loans. And banks will also finance mortgages.
Now generally banks will make a mortgage and then sell it to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. But to the extent that, for example, first republic makes mortgages that Fannie and Freddie will not buy and they'll just fund that with their deposits. So that's what they do. And in general, you'll notice that banks finance real assets that have cash flow. If you're financing a mortgage, you've got a collateral, it's called a house. If you're financing an auto loan, you've got collateral, it's called a car. Business finances, Apple cell phones. And if you're financing a student loan, there's human capital behind it generating cash flow.
So banks are conservative. In fact, the average return on an asset for a bank is around 2%. Silicon Valley banks have been different. Silicon Valley bank not only had primarily commercial depositors and 90% of those deposits were uninsured because of that concentration. They also did venture debt uninsured, sorry, Ron, by FDIC, uninsured because they're above the 250K limit. You got it. Exactly. FDIC uninsured. And they had two types of lending programs, an venture debt financing. And they also provided credit facilities to VC phones, I'll explain that briefly. So in venture debt, let's say you do a series a round and you need some additional capital.
You want to do a quick bridge. Silicon Valley bank could underwrite you and give you a loan. They might take some warrants for that. And Silicon Valley bank gives you cash flow and you pay back Silicon Valley bank in the next round. So very unique business. Silicon Valley bank does no other major bank does a much less a community bank. The other bank, the other product I had, of course, is financing venture firms. So for example, a venture firm might have a hot deal. It takes three weeks to do a capital call. They want to provide an investment now so they'll borrow from Silicon Valley bank. That's called a credit facility.
And so we're starting to what sounds like mix the world of banking with the world of venture. And in just normal financial services applied to these various different venture firms. But just at a high level, like spinal reflex response, banking and venture seems to go hand in hand a little bit less just by a nature of the risk that the venture industry does have. Is that a fair intuition? One seven important role to provide bank accounts and enable payments to businesses. I mean, banks are in the business of payments lending and custody. That's what a bank is. So making venture debt loans, look, the jury's out.
There's a reason other banks don't do that. And Silicon Valley bank had an edge in that business and that edge was the implicit backing of Silicon Valley to refinance or have a new equity around so that they wouldn't actually have losses. This is one of the reasons I believe that you haven't seen a major bank acquire Silicon Valley bank. Because if that venture debt portfolio is $70 billion, and they're going to experience the faults as we go through a cycle, then they don't want to destuck hold in the bag. Right. So Silicon Valley bank specifically engaged in banking and financial services for a particular industry because it had edge, as you said, that made that activity probably less risky than other banks.
But other banks aren't still won't touch it, just because it's new and novel and potentially more risky because they don't have that edge. Is that a fair summary? It's risky. So what Silicon Valley bank was doing was making loans to unprofitable tech companies. That's what it is. So when you're taking a loan, you're taking credit risk, you expect to get paid back more than the equity should hold. If you take a loan to unprofitable company, arguably, you're actually taking equity risk. And now we had 14 years of QE, we had valuations, we had easy money, it was easy to refinance, and the risk was low, and it was a great growth engine for Silicon Valley bank.
But of course, in addition to that Silicon Valley bank had egregious investments they did with long duration treasuries when getting to that, which led to their demise. Okay, so they have a different portfolio of assets that are protecting the deposits in Silicon Valley bank than almost any other bank. And those are skewed towards like credits towards these kind of startups and VC firms. I'm wondering, Ron, if you could kind of explain this to us. So this is a tweet. You said, one of these banks is not like the other. And then you're showing this chart of impact of unrealized securities losses on capital ratio and apologies for the podcast listener.
But there's a visual here that if you want to catch that, you got to tune into YouTube for this particular part. But what we're seeing here is SIVB, which is Silicon Valley bank, I imagine. It's like kind of an outlier dot. You see all of it a little bit. It's a lot by a lot. You see all of the other banks and they're kind of like, you know, up to the, I guess, six to 14% range, you know, the trend line looks like it's between like eight and 13% or something like this. And then you have this outlier bank. So what is this chart showing us? So what this is saying is that Silvergate effectively had no equity.
This is Silvergate. This is not Silicon Valley bank. Okay. This is Silicon Valley. Correct. So banks by law are required to hold capital. So what is a bank? It's got about 10% on average of what's called tier one capital. That's the equity of the bank. And then 90% of the balance sheet is financing primarily from depositors. And in general, those depositors are unsure by the FDIC, so you can see why government actually has a key risk on banks and they supervise and regulate banks. So we talked about the lending side of Silicon Valley bank. Those are those a liquid loans. But Silicon Valley bank and other banks also have a securities portfolio.
And by regulation, these securities portfolio consist of what's called HQLA, high quality liquid assets. Those are generally treasuries and mortgages. So what this is saying is that if you mark to market the treasuries and mortgages on the balance sheet for Silicon Valley bank, that Silicon Valley bank has zero equity. How? What? How? So how is that possible? That's because the mark to market of the securities that they purchased is just a lot lower than the power value of them. What? Right versus the purchase price of the bond, right? So in Q421, now this is peak crypto. This is peak venture funding.
Record funds raised, Silicon Valley bank had record inflows of deposits, or like tens of billions of dollars record inflows. And in a short interval of time, what they did is they bought the longest duration treasury bonds. And duration is when you expect the average time you expect to receive a cash flow. So the longer the duration, the more interest rate risk you have. So this is before the Fed started raising rates. Although the Fed was talking about raising rates, then an inflation was going up. So this is what that seems dumb because they were essentially betting that they were about the Fed wouldn't raise rates.
I don't know that they were conscious. It's in my view, it was grossly negligent. They took tens of billions of dollars with deposits and they bought long duration treasuries. And now what happened last year, of course, we saw 60, 40 didn't work, right? The stock had come up. Hopefully they work. Well, the 40 is bonds. Those bonds were down 20%. And here's what happens. So here's one way to think about a bank that people don't appreciate. I mentioned earlier, if you look at the bank's capital stock, meaning the bank is financing assets with the mix of liabilities, deposits, and equity. That equity components about 10%, it borrows 90% through deposits.
That means on average, your bank has 10 turns of leverage. A bank is borrowing short, they're lending long debt, 10 turns of leverage. So now your securities portfolio goes down 20%. Imagine you've got $50 billion in securities. And now that $50 billion of lawyers worth $45 billion, you've lost $5 billion. Now you've got 10 turns of leverage. That is why you have this unrealized loss in the securities portfolio. By the way, this was known by regulators. Regulars have talked about the issues in the HTML portfolio for some time. In fact, the Federal Reserve has about $1.5 trillion unrealized whole to maturity loss.
The difference is that the Federal Reserve can hold to maturity and the regulators hope that these other banks can hold to maturity, in which case they'll actually make money on the bond. And I just want to clarify for people who you said, bonds fell 20% in 2022. Bonds aren't supposed to fall 20%, right? That's correct. That's like unexpected. I mean, for the crypto listener, there'd be like just 20%, that sounds fantastic, sign me up. But this is supposed to be a less foundation of the entire global financial system. Yeah, it's an important asset to not fall. And it was obviously a core asset that Silicon Valley bank was betting would not fall by anything close to 20%.
You nailed it. So bonds prices drop when rates go up. They're the same thing, right? So we had 14 years of ultra low interest rates. We had the Federal Reserve buy about $9 trillion in Treasures and Mortgage Back Securities, $25 trillion in quantitative easing globally. Other central banks, in fact, had negative interest rates. What about the banks that bought those negative yielding bonds and holding maturity for a loss? So that's the backdrop. And then we saw inflation increase, of course, that was partially driven by $2 trillion in COVID stimulus, which is multiples of what we've ever seen in any other recovery package.
So yet inflation and now rates are going up at the fastest rate since 1981. And there is a new regime. And that regime is called higher real rates, which is what, as you mentioned, Jim Bianco has talked about. Yeah. So we often talk about this idea of going up further out on the risk curve. And that's actually a really easy thing to visualize when we talk about bonds and bonds yields. And what you said, the longest term maturity bond yields, I can't remember the actual specific name of the correct asset, but just like they are buying the longest dated bonds possible, SVB is Silicon Valley Bank is because that's where they get the most return in interest rates.
But they also take what you said is the highest interest rate risk because they are so far out on the risk curve. But that's what you must do in an era of zero interest rates in order to have any margins whatsoever. And so one part of this equation is like, I think everyone agrees, Silicon Valley Bank totally mismanaged their risk. And also, we also had the fastest interest rate hikes in history or in my lifetime. And so these two things have collided and so that's really what I think we're seeing here on this chart. And Ram, I want to check my understanding of this chart. We're seeing two different lines here.
One is a line of blue dots. And one is a line of yellow dots that are scattered and below the blue line. And the blue line is titled common equity tier one capital ratio. I don't really know what that means. My gut is that this is what it would have been like if the interest rates hadn't been going to infinity really, really quickly to be hyperbolic. And so all of these bank, all of the yellow dots, all the banks, individual banks, you see JP Morgan there, you see Bank for America, et cetera, you also see Silicon Valley Bank at the very, very bottom. The gap between these two lines, my correction, my understanding that that is the interest rate hikes, like that is and so people who are further down, fell, fallen down are people that have taken further risk than other banks that haven't taken as much risk.
Am I interpreting this right? That's exactly right. You know that. Cool. Okay. So again, so now we now we've pinned, I want to really like go through our conversation so far, mobile banking and and time to withdraw is the fastest it's ever been. This is moving faster than it's ever been. So bank friends are more susceptible, regardless of conditions, then we had this one bank, Silicon Valley bank that serviced a higher risk end of the spectrum in terms of financial services which was the venture world. And then also it happened to just take more risk itself being inside of that milieu that it was and then also interest rates got, got jacked up faster than it's ever been before.
So these are the, these are the big parts of this multivariate story. I don't think we're done yet. Ron, where should we go from here? Well, let's do math for a moment. What you're seeing is the unwind of carry trades. Let me define what a carry trade is. So a carry trade is when you borrow short in a currency, used to be the Japanese yen, low interest rate economy, economy and then you make a loan and a higher interest rate economy and you capture that spread. And that hedge fund strategy works along as the policy rate environment is stable. So in this period of ultra low interest rates, all sorts of carry trades were created.
One of them was the great scale Bitcoin trust trade, which you guys have talked about in your show. Another is in the convenience of your brokerage account, you could have borrowed and bought muni bonds. You could have levered muni bonds and get a nice equity like return. And that's also taking place across these non banks that have had issues. And that's what's happening now. So think about silver gate, for example, silver gate in a way is a carry trade. It's not a critique of the business model. They're responding to incentives. They paid out 0% to their depositors and they're earning that spread.
And that game works in a zero interest rate world. But what happens is when you raise rates and you have an inverted yield curve, the incentives change. So remember we talked about before, what banks are doing is they're borrowing short and lending long. The expectation is that they borrow at a very low interest rate. Gaping Morgan today is still borrowing around 0% into deposits and they lend long. And there's an expectation that that yield curve is positive and they make that spread. Now this yield curve. Just really want to, for once a ton of time, I remember when I did not understand a yield curve.
What this really means is a yield curve means is that as you take more, as you go further out on the time, go from two year maturity to 10 year maturity, you get paid more. That is the normal course of events. An inverted yield curve is actually when you are paid to take less time. And so the two year treasury pays you more than the 10 year treasury. I just wanted to place that on the ground there. That's right. Exactly. So the yield curve is a plot of duration or time, access and then the yield. So for example, the 10 year bond is at 3.6 right now and the fed is expected to raise rates to call it 5%.
So now what are the motivations and incentives? So first off, if you're a bank, why would you lend long if you can just lend in short duration treasury securities and take zero risk or you take in the risk on the federal government less inflation? So you're starting to see that happen. And that also, you know, that's what drives us low down on the economy, of course, right? So credit card rates, auto rates go up and that starts to lower to then. But there's a challenge that's happening here because as the fed raises rates, what's happening is it's creating a six hundred seven hundred billion dollar whole to maturity unrealized loss across the banking sector because those banks are now under water.
So the more the fed raises rates, the more the banks have these unrealized losses on their balance sheet. And also the federal reserve has losses on their balance sheet and the federal reserve will continue to pay out more than it brings in when we come back to that later. But here's the other side. Here's the other challenge. So the capital markets, meaning like money markets as a product are paying out more than the deposit than the yield you get from your local bank. So if, for example, you buy Vanguard money market fund, we're helping protocol treasuries do this now, right? They're saying, Hey, how do I get yield?
We put them in an ultra short duration bond fund that pays off four and a half to six and a half percent. So why would you park your money at a bank? Then these banks, they don't offer that kind of yield. And for them to hold on to deposits, they have to raise their interest rate. But now what happens? Now recall, the average return on assets is around two percent for a bank, maybe three percent. So if they raise the deposit payout, they're going to, they're not capturing as much spread. And they can't really raise it above two to three percent. And it can't really compete with the money market fund.
So this is why if you look at signature bank over the last year, we saw about 20 billion dollars in with the draws from signature bank. It's kind of, it's not a bank run, but it's a slow moving bank run because commercial businesses are responding to incentives. And arguably, you could say silver gate was subject to that. And to some extent, SVB as well, but that's true for other banks in the land as well. So in some sense, the Fed is like in this checkmate position, where if they raise rates, things go bump in the night, we see those lagged effects, they lower rate, they get inflation. And that's the common dream we're in.
And really quick, Ram, a money market is not the banking system. That is sort of a separate ETF. It's like a separate pool of capital that is basically competing against bank deposits. So the question of why would you keep money in your Wells Fargo account, right? And it's giving you like 1% interest versus putting it in a money market ETF in vanguard, which is giving you 3%. All the capital is going to flow to the 3% money market, which is a different pool and out of the banks, which kind of causes the slow motion bank run. Is that right? What's happening now? There's a chart in the document that shows us about like a high single digit drawdown in deposits in the banking system.
So right now, it's mostly corporate treasures that are conducting that behavior change. Although the headlines from the last week created awareness in households across consumers. It created also some urgency and some panic maybe. And that's causing them to shift up for full year, but it's still early days. Is it the graph chart? No, it's another chart. Yes, scroll down, let's see this one. No, it's not there. I can send it to you. I can send it to you later. Okay. But yeah, so real quick. And this has like policy implications to an economic implication. So what's on money market? Let me define that real briefly.
So a money market consists of investment grade bonds that are just about to mature and pay off their last payment principle, right? So those bond issuers of those companies can access the capital markets. Google, Apple, IBM, Ford Motor Company. There you go. That chart. So look at February 22. Sorry, there you go, about two and a half percent. Sorry, draw down from the bank deposits at peak, right? So what is this chart here? This is this is like, remember when we talked about stable coin outflows out of crypto exchanges, Ryan? This is like the trad version of this where you're nailed it. Yeah.
So this is a stable coin at a dollar outflows out of banks and into money market funds, which is kind of like investing in in the spread of compound or something like this. Is this a fair? Yeah. That's my God banking is making sense to me now that I understand it in my terms. Just like just like higher rates with drew funds from DeFi because people want to get to T-Bills, not it's exact same thing you nailed it. Is this what trad five feel like, by the way, when they're trying to understand crypto, they have to go in the opposite direction. Yeah, it's pretty similar actually. They're a lot, they're a lot of what is crypto?
It's payments, it's lending, it's settlement, it's custody and that's what banks do. Okay. So this chart is super interesting because we can see this big spike down in February of 2022. We haven't seen a spike this large since 1981, which that was a bad year, right? Well, right. That's where you had record rate increases by poll-voker. And of course, you had a bear market that ended the year following and that set in motion of 40 year bull run and equities as well. So yeah, we're doing a kind of a playbook there from 81. Okay. Is it okay if I put this Google doc in the YouTube chart? Yeah, go for it.
This is another question I have for you, Ram. Okay. So you mentioned that the problem is this carry trade and you explain the carry trade and you say that meta pattern is the reason Silvergate died. It just happened earlier because it was involved in this super risky category of assets called crypto and you saw basically the carry trade playing out in GBT and Bitcoin spot price and that was that. And then the symptom of that eventually like dominoes are following and then the Silvergate domino fell. But it's the same fed raising rates carry trade type problem. And now the dominoes have collapsed and now we're in Silicon Valley bank.
My question to you is. The virus has gotten to try to find out. Right. So like I feel like maybe it's a meme of like a bankless not bankless but everyone saying maybe bankless to David to be honest, we're like, oh, that was the last domino to fall. It's good. We're good. And like we said that at the end of last year is like FTX and okay, if we only get through this DGC thing, then that's the last domino to fall. But now the dominoes have and it maybe it was in crypto, maybe that was the last domino to fall in crypto. Now the dominoes are falling into the banking sector and the traditional finance world.
We had Silvergate and then very shortly after just days later, we have Silicon Valley bank, the same symptom. It's the carry trade problem. What's next? Who else has the carry trade problem? It's a great, it's a great question. So yeah, first off, the positive yield curve motivates credit creation and it creates leverage and that boosts asset prices. That's the simplest way to think about it. Fourteen years of that and people are equilibrated to these low rates. To condition their behaviors, human psychology around that and they planned around that. Now invert a yield curve and that leads to credit destruction because people pull in, banks are slowing down the pace of lending, for example.
Now here's what's going to happen in Tradify. It really will turn on policy and there are two policies you have to look at. What is going to happen with monetary policy and the behavior of the Federal Reserve? They have to make a choice. Do they want to stamp out inflation at the risk of creating more risks or do they want to reflate the banking system by lowering interest rates and of course now market starting to price a lowering of interest rates? That's one policy. The other policy is what will the bank regulators do for other regional banks that apparently have liquidity issues? Will they intervene to protect depositors?
Those are the two things to watch to understand what happens from here. But Ron, here's where I want to understand it. We've been in crypto since the early days of this kind of crisis, this yield curve inversion and the carry trade collapsing. We've seen all the dominoes fall. We've been tracking it up to here. Now the dominoes have fallen. Wasn't the action on Sunday the Fed actually putting its foot down? The end point is the end of all finances, we know it, the world is burning, the rest of the dominoes. It's arm again. It's terrible. I'm saying the Fed, but I don't mean the Fed. Didn't basically the US government treasury the Fed collectively just on Sunday put their foot down in top of the dominoes, send some domino scattering but put their foot down in the middle of the sequence of dominoes falling and say, this stops here.
They said basically Silicon Valley bank, equities wiped out, but depositors are secured. Signature bank, equities wiped out, but depositors secured. This contagion is not spreading any further and therefore it can't spread. It can't get through Jerome Powell and Janet Yellen's foot because they have their foot placed on the row of dominoes here. Is that effectively what happens? It's how they stamped it out. That's their goal, that's what they want to happen. They did as you pointed out, they insured all uninsured, they're going to make sure all uninsured depositors are made whole. What they did not do is provide a system-wide guarantee to deposits.
Why? Well, they cannot. The FDIC in terms of their authority, it's beyond their limits. By the way, the FDAC has $125 billion in their insurance fund and there's $20 trillion in deposits. You would take an act of Congress to put a system-wide guarantee. That said, they did roll out a program to create confidence. I think in broad brushstrokes, you're right. That's their goal. They're saying to the public, hey, banks are safe, work with banks and I believe they will do everything they can to stop a bank run. Okay. So the letter of the law for FDIC is if you have a deposit of the bank, it's only insured up to $250, and above that, it's not insured.
What they basically said is, for Silicon Valley bank and for signature bank, we are breaking that rule and we are ensuring all depositors up to infinities. Yes. High impression is like de facto. They're signaling to the rest of the entire banking system that we will insure your deposits up to an unlimited amount. But you're saying maybe they implied that but they actually don't have the power to grant that ability because that requires an act of Congress and you actually have to go vote on something and change the laws. I think you got it right. Look, I'm betting, that's correct. I think everything you said there is correct.
I'm betting on that. I bought financials yesterday, for example. I'm betting that the regulars will do what they can to safeguard the public's confidence in the banking system and stamp out runs. Overall, on broad networks, you're correct. That said, they haven't issued a system like guarantee, which is what Bill Ackman has been arguing for and keeps arguing for it. But they don't need to. If they're, I guess if they can stop it here, they can just say the signal that we're prepared to do this is the signal in the market. As long as that stops bank runs, they'll never need to actually get to the point to put a new law in place and increase FDIs in mandate.
That's right. They're trying to stamp out the fire before it becomes a force fire. And by the way, no taxpayer funds put to work, the FDIC fees are assessed against the banks. The banks will pay for this, which is great. However, here's the other thing. And this is outside the control of the FDIC, which is, it goes back to the other issue about higher interest rates. So if you continue to see a movement from banks to money markets, not because of fear of banks, because consumers are responding to incentives, then it doesn't matter if you've got a system-wide guarantee. So if the money market tray continues to exist, that may not stop the forest fire.
That's correct. There's a slow burning, right? Go back to like signature. They've had a $20 billion year of year decline in their deposit, which is about 20%. This flow that we have to see does it accelerate or not? Now, I don't think consumers, retail households, by and large, had much behavior change. We know that because JPMorgan's deposit is still a growing, and they're paying out 0%. But the commercial treasures have started to adjust. And last weekend was a wake-up moment for the household, for some households that read periodicals like what we do, more for looking. And they're saying, gee, inflation's at 5%, I'm earning 1%, why don't I get a Vanguard money market fund?
If that happens, what are you going to do? System guarantees are not going to help that money movement. So that's not quite a bank run, but that's what you're calling as a slow motion withdrawal that's happening just because there's this arbitrage opportunity, basically. And I guess how does the banking system yell in and powell stop at that? It's hard. It's very, very. The way you stop it is you lower interest rates. The lower interest rates. This is the conundrum. But then how do we fight inflation? Exactly. Exactly. And this is the, you got it. This is the aha moment. Now, what can a bank do to stop deposit flight?
They can raise interest rates to create an incentive to give money market funds. But it's not mathematically possible for a bank to offer a 4.5% interest rate. They would be unprofitable. And so that would impair their equity. So one way or another, you can see how the banks are in a bad position. If rates go up, that whole to maturity portfolio declines in value. If federal reserve raises rates, the whole to maturity portfolio declines in value. If they raise rates, they lose money. Silvergate went through this as well. They issued CDs that they're paying money out. And they have to pay an interest rate on that.
They're going to lose money on that. I want to ask about one last thing. And then I know we want to get to sponsors. And we've got a lot more to cover, though. You said something that perked my ears, which is taxpayers aren't responsible for this, right? Or this is not going to cost taxpayer money, I think, was the word you used. That's also what I saw in kind of Biden's tweet outs and that sort of thing is not going to cost. But didn't they do something else? Didn't they also effectively say that long dated treasuries would not be marked to market value for banks, but would be par value? Didn't wasn't there some move of treasury to sort of or whomever is responsible for this kind of reset the value of this collateral on the banking balance sheet?
And isn't that a net effect, not a direct tax on taxpayers, but a tax by way of money printing, by way of quantitative easing, by way of supply issuance, seniorage, whatever we want to call it, isn't that in effect attacks a sneak attacks on on taxpayers or at least kind of money supply inflationary pressure. Well, it's, it's really, I look at it differently, I mean, the existing laws, the land already in terms of banks, how banks account is allows for whole to mature the accounting. Right, so banks can hold bond at cost, and that's what SVB did, that's what all the banks are doing, but it's all disclosed to the public.
So if you go to the, the 10 cure, the 10k of a bank, you can see what the unrealized losses on that bond portfolio, you can do the math and ask yourself if they were, if they had a bank run, which would force them to liquidate, which of course, what happened with silver gate, then you can calculate what that loss would be to the bankholder equity. So that's existing long the land, I did not see any change around that you can send me a link I can take a look at that. The regulators did introducing new program, it's called the BTFR program, essentially it's like a fund that's meant to, you know, step in to help the banking system.
And again, the fees for that fund are assessed against the banks. Rum, I just want to check my understanding, you said that it's simply just like not profitable for banks to be offering a sufficiently high yield to maintain deposits. Is that what, and I'm going to show you on my screen here, this is a tweet that we showed out yesterday, this is already 24 hour old data, so I don't know what the banking sector did today. But to me, this is, this is that being reflected in the market where the smaller and smaller banks are getting hit with a repricing event because the market has understood that the long tail of banks.
And here's my question to you is that like the 0% interest rate paradigm has created a long tail of banks is allowed for banks to exist. Many, many more banks to exist because they never had to pay our interest rates. They had no costs for deposits. And so now I think perhaps what is happening here is when we talk about a phase change in the market, the long tail of banks are being made unprofitable, and is that what is being reflected in the market. The banks are still making money. The banks, they can hang on to deposits if they raise interest rates, but increasingly savvy depositors starting to migrate to money markets.
So if that, if that accelerates, then the banks have an issue because they cannot compete with the money market fund, they have to raise rates. So far, the banks are making money to be clear, but there's this issue where the more the fed raises rates, the more incentive there is to shift out of your depository. Institution into a money market. Why do we have money markets in the first like couldn't you just like delete money markets entirely and then have some sort of a central bank digital currency and like provide everybody who is a holder of US dollars digitally some sort of return directly from from treasury.
Well, so treasuries are part of the money market corporate bonds, investment grade bonds, you know, asset back securities are all part of the money market money markets the collection of bonds are about to mature so when you say why do we have money markets like saying why do we have capital markets and capital markets played incredibly important role in driving capital formation right those equity capital markets think about as an IPO, but they're also initial debt offerings initial debt offerings create the bonds that eventually work their way into the money. Maybe I mean more why do we need why do we need banks as a middleman to good question to question the positors funds is probably more what I mean I do we need banks.
I have a pro pro question from bankless co host and I never would have we're going bankless by taking three banks out of no week here's why so the capital markets are open to large institutions right an S one filings when you go public and IPO it's an incredibly high standard. We cannot access the three of us cannot access the capital markets Apple Google Microsoft tech overlords can access the capital markets so where does mom and pop or Joe six pack or the farmer access funding they get it from their banks and by the way the top five banks including JP Morgan Bank America they're on the coasts so you're talking like middle America and rural America and the populations not benefited from the growth.
And asset price inflation that population so banks play an important role in extending credit by the way bank loans are cheaper than equity cost of capital. They're the cheapest source of funding in fact in the land and so they play a very important role you know if you want to look at a world without banks there's a wonderful book by Hernando de Soto called mystery of capital like David you're not in the head right and his basic headline is you know one is you need property rights entitled the property. But the second message is once you have that you can liquefy that so if you there are people in Egypt let's say that have a home they the convention is they own it but it's not recognized as such and they can invest in their home so you'll see them put a roof on one year two years later they paint the house you ask them why because they can't get a mortgage.
Or you know a farmer can invest in a plow they're trying to make an economic decision but they cannot finance the productive growth that investment because there's not a bank so instead what you have are de facto equity markets those are called like loan sharks so banks play an important role in credit intermediation right right. Ram there's a bunch of other topics that we have to get into that I want to ask you about what's your opinion on whether or not silver signature bank was targeted I know we got to talk about the impact on crypto and the impact on us DC and then we also I want to get your take on yields and interest rates whether or not this is the pivot moment that we've all been holding our breath for or not so we're going to get into all these subjects and more but first a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible.
Uniswap is the largest on chain marketplace for self custody digital assets you swap is of course a decentralized exchange but you know this because you've been listening to bankless but did you know that the you swap web app has a shiny new fiat on ram now you could go directly from fiat in your bank to tokens in defy inside of you know swap not only that but polygon arbitrum and optimism layer to are supported right out of the game but that's just defying you know swap is also an NFT aggregate. Letting you find more listings for the best prices across the NFT world with Uniswap you can sweep floors on multiple NFTs and Uniswap's universal router will optimize your gas fees for you.
Uniswap is making it as easy as possible to go from bank account to bankless assets across a theory and we couldn't be more thankful for having them as a sponsor so go to app.uniswap.org today to buy sell or swap tokens and NFTs. The phantom wallet is coming to Ethereum the number one wallet on salon is bringing its millions of users and beloved UX to Ethereum and polygon. If you haven't used phantom before you've been missing out phantom was one of the first wallets to pioneer salon is taking inside the wallet and will be offering similar staking features for Ethereum and polygon but that's just staking phantom is also the best home for your NFTs.
Phantom has a complete set of features to optimize your NFT experience pin your favorites hide your ugly's burn this fam and also manage your NFT sale listings from inside the wallet. Phantom is of course a multi chain wallet but it makes chain management easy displaying your transactions in a human readable format with automatic warnings for malicious transactions or phishing websites. Phantom is already saved over 20,000 users from getting scammed or hacked. So get on the phantom wait list and be one of the first to access the multi chain beta. There's a link in a show notes or you can go to phantom.
app slash wait list to get access in late February. Hey bankless nation if you're listening to this it's because you're on the free bankless RSS feed did you know that there's an ad free version of bankless that comes with the bankless premium subscription no ads just straight to the content but that's just one of many things that a premium subscription gets you. There's also the token report a monthly bullish bearish neutral report on the hottest tokens of the month and the regular updates from the token report go into the token Bible your first stop shop for every token worth investigating in crypto.
Bankless premium also gets you a 30% discount to the permissionless conference which means it basically just pays for itself. There's also the air drop guide to make sure you don't miss a drop in 2023 but really the best part about bankless premium is hanging out with me Ryan and the rest of the bankless team in the inner circle discord only for premium members. Want the alpha check out bend the analyst degen pit where you can ask him questions about the token report got a question. I've got my own q&a room for any questions that you might have at bankless we have huge things planned for 2023 including a new website with login with your theory madras capabilities and we're super excited to ship what we are calling bankless 2.
0 soon TM so if you want extra help exploring the frontier subscribe to bankless premium it's under 50 cents a day and provides a wealth of knowledge and support on your journey west I'll see you in the discord. I'll see the stable coin ever at risk here and also note that we are talking in 24 hours with Jeremy a layer. Oh, and the same questions well asking the same questions. Well, as you know replay last week so USDC broke the peg traded down as low as 80 cents in the dollar on reporting that 3 billion plus of the USDC reserves of standing were held at SVB. Then on Sunday the FDIC announced an action to make uninsured deposits whole USDC closed the peg I think it's like 99.
9 cents on the dot it's there effectively. And circle has shifted their banking relationships to be in wide melon which were the deposits are and they shifted their fiat ramp to cross river that was my old shop I built the crypto business there. The biggest irony of this whole thing is that USDC is now custodyed as at a systematically important financial institutions called the CIFI USDC is too big to fail USDC is held in a institution that is branded known to be too big to fail. As ignited by the regulator as a g-sip BNY melon not going to go anywhere so USDC one of our guys cracked the code they're in the emerald city.
We adopted the defenses of the banking system right so USDC is in scanced behind the NY melon and were protected from bank runs so basically we got someone inside on the inside we did it we the Ewoks took over and so. So so USDC only fails if the US banking system fails exactly that's right that's right and and that relationship is hard to get and we like USDC had to go through these smaller banks like silver gate first and signature and and now somehow like how were they able to get this big too big to fail type banking relationship. Well, Jeremy can elaborate more but they had a prior relationship with BNY melon and circle has a number of banking relationships they have five to seven they try to diversify across that but the principal institution is BNY melon and you're right you had to start somewhere silver gate was the pioneer and then other banks like signature got in there as well and so but now those deposits are at a g-sip institution.
So was never about this we're happy about this right I don't know how tell me how I should feel about this. It's I'm trying I have my mind is blown I'm trying to process this myself it is look we need us we need a centralized table when a decentralized table coin is one take. That censorship resistance on the one hand regulated C5 but make it bullet proof on the other and USDC was never going to be the decentralized. Correct correct and may arguably USDC is the first CDBC may I totally think it is yes I'm it's perplexing to me that regulators and and those and DC haven't realized this. I think they're going to connect the dots real quick now and by the way you know the American banking system does rely on private markets.
Like Americans as an ethos in terms of the bank I know it may not seem like this in terms of banking regulation they do lean on private market infrastructure. The idea that USDC is our first CDBC is not a not a crazy idea in fact JP Morgan has a stablecoin called JPM coin as well and in the 19th century before the creation of you know certain banking regulation has passed a great national bank system you had wild cat banks you had banks issued their own form of of currency. It's not a it's not a crazy idea it's familiar to the history of the banking system I am totally waiting for like the Fed to just be like oh yeah we're researching a central bank digital currency and like whatever we'll do it and then them basically to co up co up something like USDC and be like this is mine now.
I think they could I think if you were at US Treasury which is like the policy think tank the brain for the US government. I believe I haven't heard this from them but if US Treasury their thesis is probably hey we need big mega money center banks like JP Morgan and city bank to issue these stable coins. I'm not saying that's what they should do I'm saying that's what I would expect them to. This event just fast-tracked us towards that do you think well yeah in a certain way did it did and maybe you know JP Morgan acquires USDC or circle that could be interesting acquisition to complete the loop.
Interesting. But that's a logical conclusion right and ROM was was USDC ever under threat like over the past weekend. Well you know there's breaking the buck is one thing but as you know there is rumors of Wells notices that SEC chart Gensler has issued and you know the unknown is will Gensler consider stable coins unregulated money market funds and if so that could put stable coins at risk so we don't nothing. Money market funds are securities right money market funds are securities tight tight tight. Part of the USDC story is I'm ignoring that by the way I'm moving on. I'm glad you have glad you're ignoring that you talked to Hester about that tomorrow.
We'll talk about that in the agenda we're in court with Hester personal as well as Jeremy earlier one part of this USDC story ROM is this thing called Signet which was a product out of signature bank I think it's answer signature network or something like this. What was it used for is it dead and what should we think about this. So Signet is still operational the FDIC is running a global 24 instant settlement crypto network. That's what it is. Signet 24 seven settlement for crypto banks or crypto exchanges and institutions and hedge funds so it's used. So let me give you an example right let's say I'm Coinbase David is winter mute and Ryan is John and David be jump so let's say I say David is borrowing from jump Ryan and David is at risk of getting a margin call.
I send David some funds because I contractually I'm contractually obligated to deliver that if you've got a wait time if you've got like say T plus three settlement which is standard in US markets. And you cannot make Ryan whole on let's say your DeFi smart contract you get margin calls even though technically you're solving that's called settlement risk you just get the cash in time. To deliver and cash is there it's on the way but because of T plus one or T plus time you get liquidated even though you have all the money is just not in the right spots checks in the mail exactly so you need a 24 seven instant settlement layer to match a 24 seven crypto market.
Silvergate send played that role signet played that role without that it creates settlement risk operational risk. Unforced errors mistakes for the category. This is like a shadow Ethereum right. A shadow instantaneous payments rail right it's like a layer 0.5 or something like that. So sure well it's like its own bank and inside of its own ledger right so all of these customers have to be customers of the same bank in order to it's a side chain it's a side chain yeah that's right that's right. So what what is what happened to signal is it now that signature bank is gone where. So signature is in receivership that means management's not in charge the FDIC run signature bank has a new name and silver big silver SVV excuse me is also being run by the FDIC okay so signal is still running today so the FDIC is currently running which is mind blowing again so so the federal government has the federal government has nationalized mission critical crypto infrastructure I don't think they realize obviously they were not that was not their objective.
But we need to get a meme talking about how we federalized mission critical crypto infrastructure we're behind the wall right. And it's a Trojan horse this receivership but look here's what's going to happen the FDIC is going to auction off and attempt to find a buyer and hold for signature and failing to do that the auction off the assets and then the liabilities so the buyer of signature or their assets will look at the deposit base and say do I want that depository customer. And if they do then they have a second question of signal of the signal network my hope is that they want the depository customer and they maintain signal but right now the federal government is running instant 24 seven crypto network by the way this is important to add because there's been so much fun against silver gate.
About and I want to get into that topic now again about later but around how it's just alleged it any money laundering network it's nonsense if that was the case the regulars could have done before they oversight over silver gate and allegedly the federal government is running any money laundering network now clearly that's not the case. So this gets into the question that David was asking before our last break which is was signature targeted maybe could answer that but the wider context is crypto is like we're kind of reeling about this because we don't know who are friends. And the government are in who are kind of the enemies anti crypto people who just don't want this new financial system at all or trying to squelch it and so my worry is like we're kind of laughing yeah FDIC controls now now manages a crypto side chain without them knowing it ha ha ha but what happens if one of the large banks acquire this signature thing and acquire.
Signet along with it and then the regulators or the anti crypto government people are like well you got to stop doing that we're going to put into that let's squelch that will kill it. We're wondering is is crypto being targeted in this and what do you expect after there's a lot of rhetoric I mean Elizabeth Warren put out an op-ed piece an opinion piece yesterday and named crypto control F search named crypto as being responsible for these bank failures. Three different times is there any concern there why should we be worried about we're going to learn a lot about the regulators intentions because back to Nick Carter's operation choke point 2.
0. So the fact that signature was put into receivership was a surprise it was a surprise even for the hedge funds that were short signature. It is it's a concern we need clarity we will learn over time through FOIA through investigative journalism. FOIA is free to invoke information act correct I imagine the House Financial Services Committee led by Chair Patrick Henry will also learn more and I'm sure you may have seen already senator Frank who co author dot Frank was on the board and he said he believes that it may have to do with crypto but that's his interpreter we don't know just because we really don't know.
It was a surprise you know there are allegations that there are credit risk issues around signature they certainly had a deposit run which could be called which would be cost for receivership so we really don't know. If signet keeps running with a new acquirer then that's evidence that the regulators aren't trying to kill crypto if signet is shut down it's not evidence the regulars trying to kill it so it could mean the acquirer doesn't want that this we won't know so we'll have to find out it does raise a concern on the other hand signet is running today. And it's run by the FDS so we don't yet know but it could be a it could be a bad sign about the intentions of the regulators and those in power like it were unclear on why signature bank was put into ownership and it could be a bad sign for crypto if it if it was targeted because it's a crypto bank and they wanted to knock it out.
And my presumption yes my presumption is that it was bank run driven the regulators have to abide by rule of law as well because that would be illegal doing that to target a specific bank industry because of services as a population. That is not something that rule of law and that is permitted against the law right so it would be my interpretation of the law not a lawyer not even legal advice is that the violation of the administrator procedures act which requires regulators to treat like scenarios likely meaning if you put a bank and receivership you got to look at the facts apply to the law and say those criteria met.
And the regulators have to hold themselves to account to that and again I might I have a presumption of good faith here let's see what happened let's learn more and I we will learn more in the coming weeks and months my presumption is it was bank run driven but I don't know. Yeah, I think we're just we're getting mixed signals on both sides right like if there was true actual risk of contagion is actually not that crazy to think that a second bank beyond Silicon Valley bank was also at risk that would be actually kind of the indication that you would you would see right. Correct and look if the regulators really wanted to kill crypto is there any better moment than post FTX right right the Gensler could declare a security which would be horrible coin base would be forced to deal with it he could declare coin base and crack in an unlicensed securities exchange right and they haven't so.
And this is why we need clarity interpretive guidance that we need. Don't know I just go back to like Barney Frank saying this was a direct quote that they're targeting signature because of crypto he is no fool I mean he knows he knows how the system works inside now. And also care to defend crypto just because it's crypto I don't. Crypto positive or supportive he's on the board did you have a privileged point of view we don't know my read of his statement was that it was his interpretation as an observer of the facts but yeah wow. So I want to get into this last topic here which is interest rates the market has signaled that this is something breaking and it's time for the fed to pivot yields are down the most that they've ever dropped in.
Since the aftermath of black Friday it says biggest one day drop in yields for 12 months T bill since black Friday indicating panic buying of treasuries the Vicks fear gauge has become elevated so fear is up yields are down the market is saying hey this is the feds totally not going to continue to raise interest rates. Rom do you have a stance here and how do you how should we think about this right so the fed has nine days between now and March 23rd before they make a decision and they will look at every piece of data between now and then obviously we saw CPI come in and still you know warm.
If if not for the recent bank runs which are deflationary because it caused consumers to pull back and spam yes and you know crouch a bit more if not for that you know would have been 25 to 50 bits right now markets are pricing in a 25 dips increase that's my base case as well I'd expect that if you continue to see a waning in public confidence and banks and that changes like the only two things that will try drive a fed pivot are one. Our one is a significant weakening in the real economy which is what they're trying to engineer to lower inflation they're trying to destroy demand this is what fed share policy when he says we're going to have pain in the Jackson Hole Summit August.
The second thing that will cause the fed to pivot is a financial market dislocation they're very concerned about financial market dislocations they want markets and the public to be able to rely on their visa mastercard working their banks to work the ability to go buy a bond right if you recall in covid. Financial market structure broke down you couldn't buy a munibond credit markets were locked and that caused the fed to provide it you know credit facility and liquidity to the market so my base case 25 bits but we got to see what happens we now then yeah I was going to say isn't this financial market dislocation if it's not there yes it's not there because it hasn't hit retail.
Right so the failure of these banks is not yet at the level of systemic that's the view of the regulators also my view to these are these are banks that were indexed to technology in crypto and you know when the tide goes out those institutions that were the major beneficiaries that liquidity again SVB grew their deposits tens and tens of billions but of course those deposits went away quickly as well and obviously you know we've seen what's happened. You know you're seeing the tide go out you're seeing who's naked who's over concentrate too much commercial risk exposure it's not systematic however if you know consumers or mimetic creatures we look at others behavior we imitate we follow etc if there's a shift in consumer behavior if consumers start to doubt their banks I don't think we're there yet you know talk to people not in crypto Twitter ask friends family mom dad Joe six pack yeah they're not they're not there yet.
They didn't go through 2022 of like Luna Tara FTX like BlockFi Celsius and now this they're they're not quite there yet so you're saying that you think Powell and the Fed have some room still to tighten because this hasn't completely broken. I believe I believe that they well do they room to tighten it's another thing I believe that their base case would be to tie that's their own dot plot their own projection is to tighten they're on path to tighten you know two or three more times got it but certainly this had to be a shot across the past this week oh yes oh yes they're going to be like every every day they're going to be looking at the integrity the banking system they're going to look at deposit flows and you know they they want an all clear sign for sure.
This is you know banking crises are extraordinarily deflationary the great depression was not caused by 1929 crash it was caused by a bank run right that's why Ben Bernanke you know I want a Nobel Prize in economics and became the Fed share it's also why policy makers you could argue over reacted to 2008 and slam the gas with quantitative easing and ultra low interest rates. So in a way this is the counter response to the significant deflationary shock of a banking crisis in a way and the pendulum has come full circle we're paying the consequences of that now with the central the central bank as well as obviously you know the US government debt to GDP ratios at a very high level.
Sure yeah so I think what I'm hearing is that we were previously charging into high interest rates and now we are tiptoeing into a little bit higher interest rate that's right the Fed is they changed their gear shift from 75 to 25 bips they try to be deliberate methodical they're trying to lead markets as a question are arguably markets are now leading the Fed the Fed was setting pace up till now meaning markets were expecting a Fed pivot for three quarters in a row and if you just look at the quote at chair Powell's prepared remarks not the Q&A don't focus on the Q&A look at the prepared remarks and the transcript they're very deliberate every sentence now it's changed we've seen the two years you pointed out drops substantially yesterday by the way we haven't seen these kinds of treasury market movements since like 1987 the tightening and the pace of the tightening in of course that tightening is capital markets tightening not the Fed that flight to safety and the 10 year of course drop flight three quarters.
3.6 rapidly so now the question is are markets going to lead the Fed going forward and there's that chicken and egg game so the Fed so far has been leading the markets and the markets haven't puked when the Fed has continued their rate high campaign will if the Fed stays the course and the markets are calling for pivot or expecting a pivot how does that disappointment translate into risk assets pricing. Ram this has been fantastic and your your wealth of knowledge and traditional finance in the banking system has been super helpful for us is we're kind of learning all of this through the lens of crypto through the lens of DeFi and that's why I want to and the last question for you as we as we close this out is I know you are as familiar with crypto and DeFi as you are with traditional markets and the banking system could DeFi DeFi have fixed this is crypto the solution to these sort of problems how might we rather than getting blamed for banking crisis is that weren't precipitated by crypto how might we paint the case to finance the banking system and Treasury and pal and everyone else that crypto can actually help with these sorts of problems.
There's a positive story here for crypto the 2008 crisis would not have happened if you settled securities on chain you'd have the transparency you'd have the liquidity you wouldn't have the counterparty risk and you would have had the instant settlement what is DeFi represent it represents payments it represents lending settlement and custody so there's an incredible opportunity for crypto to strengthen our banking and financial markets I wrote an op in the Wall Street Journal in q4. By the way with former SEC trim Arthur 11 fun fact he was on the board of bid pay by the way first crypto Bitcoin so not all SEC chairs are created equal for looking guy and there's there's an opportunity for crypto but we need policy to advance and we also need to invest in more institutional infrastructure.
There's a reason why Genesis existed DeFi was an institutional grade and so we need more engineering more technology and we need a policy environment as well as a positive vision for crypto the values for crypto censorship resistant lower transaction costs those are noble qualities and they improve the quality of life for ordinary people. Are there more of you out there straddling these two worlds there yeah look I think there's a big flow of people from traffic into crypto traffic people look we we like technology we were forward looking as well I promise you we know there's quite a few of us out there.
That's awesome tell us a little bit about your company women and what you do sure I'll be brief thank you you know Lumina is we're building a web 2.5 private bank so we believe crypto grows the more interacts the real world as opposed to like a dragon eating its own tail with DeFi expands and contracts like a court look at like maker for instance so we're building a private bank we're focused on the top. You know one 5% of the crypto market and we're providing service and investment management we're helping them manage how to generate yield securely and completely. Through traditional securities as well and we're all helping them with alternate investments the interesting about crypto like the way you made money crypto previously really investing in early stage venture because those venture firms have a structural advantage due to securities laws because they can legally participate whereas you can't do an icy.
So we're building a private bank we think there's a gap in the market for a trusted institution we come from crypto we come from traffic you know my investor base includes regulators like SEC chair author 11. Raj Dottay former treasury advisor also crypto natives like Mike do this and Ryan Selkis you know we think that's an opportunity we're excited about the promise and potential of crypto and we want to play a role in in in leading that area. You are very well positioned it's a perfect place to be kind of bridging those two worlds and making sense of the banking system for crypto natives and for crypto natives to help kind of translate to the other side to it's great.
Thank you. Thank you so much for joining us today we appreciate it. Thanks for having me thank you Ryan thank you David be well. Of course got to end with this bankless nation none of this has been financial advice got to end with our traditional risks and disclaimers but I'm going to change them up this time crypto is risky but so are banks all right you could. What you put in you never know we are headed west this is a frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot. You