In this episode, we talk with Tom Lee, chairman of Bitmine, about the rapid growth of his ETH treasury company and its goal to secure 5% of the total ETH supply.
Tom believes Ethereum could surpass Bitcoin in value, forecasting potential prices between $4,000 and $15,000. We discuss market dynamics, risks of excessive leverage, and his insights on valuing Ethereum and NFTs like Pudgy Penguins.
Tune in for key insights into Ethereum’s future and Wall Street’s role in crypto.
------
📣 LISTEN TO THE EXCLUSIVE DEBRIEF:
https://www.bankless.com/podcast/debrief-tom-lee-treasury
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAX | SELF SUFFICIENT DeFi
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
2:57 The Rise of ETH Treasuries
8:27 The 5% ETH Strategy
12:08 The Role of Ethereum in Wall Street
17:57 Accumulating More ETH
26:39 Wall Street's Misunderstanding of Crypto
29:41 Ethereum's 2017 Moment
37:09 The Potential for 100x
45:52 Estimating ETH's Value
50:08 Navigating Market Risks
59:36 Closing Thoughts on Ethereum
------
RESOURCES
Tom Lee
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
I think the upside case for ETH is actually higher than, let's say, Bitcoin did a hundred X. You know, could Ethereum do a hundred X? I think that that could happen because there is probably a non-significant probability that Ethereum could flip Bitcoin as well in terms of network value. Bankless Nation, we have Tom Lee here, legendary Wall Street investor chairman of the newly launched ETH Treasury company, Bitmind, the ticker is BMNR Tom. Welcome back to Bankless. Yeah, thanks. Good to see you guys again. It's great to see you. It's been about a year and you've been pretty busy. I got to say I did not have on my Bingo card that Tom Lee in 2025 would create an ETH Treasury company and yet here you are at the time of recording Bitmind where you chair has 833,000 ETH as closing in on 1% of all ETH supply and you are now, I believe, the largest ETH Treasury company in the world, at least publicly traded company.
How does that feel? Well, I guess, I mean, we move very quickly because we started this, announced it on June 30th and it closed on July 8th. So in 27 calendar days, since the close, we've moved at very high velocity to acquire this ETH quickly. But I think it's important because MicroStrategy really has demonstrated that his 30 times return, his pivot when MicroStrategy was $13 in August 2020 to now Bitcoin made a big step move from $11,000 to $120,000 but his Treasury strategy delivered another 20X on top of that. That's how we got a 30X total return and I think Ethereum is one of the biggest macro trades over the next decade.
So we want to move quickly because we want to get as much ETH at $3,500 or whatever before it makes its step function gain similar to what Bitcoin's done in the last five years. Even like MicroStrategy, Tom, when you launched BitMine and just announced that you were doing the ETH Treasury company strategy, other ETH Treasury companies were hot on your heels. Coincidentally, or maybe not coincidentally, SBET from Joe Lubin Consensus, which sharply gaming was announced within like five days of you announcing yours and now there's a whole host of ETH Treasury companies. Did you know that there were others that were hot on your heels?
How did all of this happen all at once? Why did this all happen seemingly in the same like two-week period? Maybe great minds thick alike, I don't know. You know, you're right, there have been for a long time, there were just Bitcoin Treasuries and then a couple of Salana Treasuries and a couple of hype ones. But Sharplink was the first Ethereum Treasury. That was announced in May, so we came after Sharplink. But I think that Ethereum itself makes a lot of sense to do as a Treasury play because one, if you're positive on ETH itself, then that's the reason to do a Treasury strategy, especially over in ETF because the functions of a Treasury strategy let you get stack more ETH.
The second is ETH, I think actually because of staking and the proof of stake that these Treasury companies are essentially infrastructure companies and in exchange you're getting paid a yield for native staking and that makes them into real businesses. Like for instance, the over $3 billion worth of ETH that we hold today, you would earn native staking over 3% and that's essentially gap net income. But the third reason, of course, is that it's important to create scarcity. I think that the story that we have at BitMine is one of scarcity because we have a very clear strategy of trying to acquire 5% of ETH and we have a pristine balance sheet.
I think that's a big advantage and the stock is super liquid. It trades $1.6 billion a day which makes it the 42nd most liquid stock in the US stock market today. Actually Uber, we trade about the same as Uber every day and I'm just going to check Uber's market cap but I think BitMine's about $4 billion and Uber's market cap is $104 billion. So we trade as much as Uber despite a $4 billion market cap versus $183 billion. Tom, let's talk about that 5% number because I've heard you say that before and we're just adding up some numbers here. 5% of total ETH supply, so that'd be about $6 million or so ETH, you're at $833,000 now but have gotten to that number in like four weeks so you're moving very, very fast there.
Are you serious about 5% of all ETH from my recollection, MicroStrategy, they've been at this for a while since 2020, I believe MicroStrategy up to like 3% of Bitcoin or so and they've been dollar cost averaging in over time, 5% of all ETH, you know, I guess at the current market price is what like 20 billion or so but I assume you can't get there overnight especially at these prices, how in the world do you get to 5% and are you serious about that number or is 5% kind of a placeholder is just kind of like, yeah, we'd like to do someday 5% that sounds good or are you serious about it and do you have an execution plan to get to that 5% if so what does that look like?
What MicroStrategy is 3.2% of the networks circulating supply right now but you know MicroStrategy wants to get to at least a million Bitcoin which is about 5% and keep in mind that once MicroStrategy has a million Bitcoin they have a sovereign put, you know, they are strategically important to the Bitcoin ecosystem, I mean if the US wants to create a strategic Bitcoin reserve it's probably difficult for the US to buy a million Bitcoin in the open market because as soon as they announce it sellers are going to shrink and you know Bitcoin could go to a million dollars right away. So MicroStrategy might be an easier way for someone to get to a million Bitcoin so I call that a sovereign put.
MicroStrategy has achieved the 3% in 5 years so they were buying basically 16 cents worth of Bitcoin a day, every day for the last 5 years. Bitcoin is, if you look at it from inception now has added about 80 cents to dollar per day in Ethereum so it's about 12 times faster than MicroStrategy so we would be on a path to get to 5%, presumably like at 12 times the speed of MicroStrategy but it makes sense because you know we would be a benevolent entity in the sense that we are doing everything 100% compliant with what is the idea of a legally compliant, Ethereum is a legally compliant blockchain and everything that Bitcoin is doing is keeping every single piece of the operations in the United States so it is very compliant to what Wall Street and the US government would want to see in someone who is staking a lot of ETH and equally important you know ETH itself is going to be really where so much of Wall Street financializes on the blockchain so eventually I think someone on Twitter made the point that staking ETH for Wall Street is like gamers buying Nvidia that you would have done better to buy Nvidia as well as be a gamer or be a gaming company but in because of you know really how blockchains work it is actually that exact idea that Wall Street is if they're going to be tokenizing real-world assets from money markets to dollars to stocks that they're going to want to own ETH itself but then they want whoever staking it to actually be an entity that is really trying to further the goals of Ethereum so I think we really serve an important purpose by staking ETH you know Tom if you say you're you're moving at the current pace 12x faster than micro strategy I mean that puts you to 5% if you continue that pace in about you like one to two years basically which would be a break next speed do you think a same kind of sovereign put strategy exists for ETH through the asset as it does for Bitcoin for do you say that all of the you know commercial banks the JP mortgage of the world coming on chain genius bill stablecoin legislation this is effectively treasuries and the US central bank coming on chain with their their dollars Ethereum is of course leading the pack there is there a similar sovereign put type option where the US government or some other sovereign nation I guess you're legally compliant in the US you'd hope it would be the US government comes to you one day and says hi Tom a bit mine we noticed has a lot of ETH we want to buy ETH for the US treasury US central bank put it on our balance sheet and we know you have a lot can we do an OTC deal do you think that's a possibility here look I think everything you just said is actually rational it makes sense but let's say that our goal isn't to have a put like if you just fast forward and Wall Street right so genius act SEC wants to move the financial system onto the blockchain and Ethereum is the largest blockchain but it's also compliant with us laws it's a legally recognized blockchain but this blockchain of course can be used by other countries and others you know nations the US obviously wants to strengthen the US position and dominance on this blockchain and of course keep in mind that there's not just one storyline here coming on to Ethereum it's also AI right you know if you're going to tokenize whether it's robots or other things you know you want a blockchain that also again can be secured so tech and Wall Street are converging onto Ethereum does Goldman Section JP Morgan want Ethereum to be held in like millions of different wallets not that they're trying to centralize it but they want to make sure that the staking is done in a compliant way and not everybody is going to choose to do that but that's what we said from the beginning that the idea is that Bitmind has a pristine balance sheet super clean you know no no exotic capital structure and everything that is being done and we haven't announced our staking solution but we're taking our time because first of all you know three billion dollars of ETH it's a big decision but it's also going to be completely compliant with GAP and actually how the US would want that to be staked so I think it's a very thoughtful approach we're taking but yes I mean everything you just said like let's say because I don't disagree and it just shows you Ethereum Treasury companies are critical infrastructure it's not just a Treasury play and in exchange for that you're earning a staking yield at a minimum but they could be earning other ways of generating income so I think you're highlighting that these Ethereum Treasuries aren't just like an alternative to an ETF they are playing a really important role in the ecosystem right one one thing I can't figure out Tom and I think some ETH bulls are with me on this is how in the world ETH is still trading under 4k when you just talked about in a month's time you have you now have 3 billion in ETH in your in the bit mine treasury so 3 billion in ETH purchases how does that not move ETH price be like 4k and above like how are you still getting a bid at you know 3500 ETH where's all this ETH coming from and how is it not moving our price here well we've learned a lot I don't really want to say too much because as you can imagine we we probably been one of the largest buyers of ETH and we've learned a lot and I would say in this short term where fair value for Ethereum is does not play into what ETH does short term I mean look at it last week it got to 3300 on because there are folks who have liquidation levels or they're doing pair trades or people think Ethereum is a dead chain so they're betting on another chain and trying to force levels of liquidation I think that that's the dynamic near term but wasn't that Bitcoin at a thousand dollars in 2017 like actually if people go back to 2017 because I think Ethereum is having its Bitcoin 2017 moment this year where Wall Street is finally getting behind ETH you know Bitcoin was a thousand in the early part of 2017 and it wasn't until August and then it went straight up I mean literally went straight up we've definitely haven't seen this level of Wall Street interest in ETH the asset and Ethereum the network in like four or five years now and I mean we're we're seeing the appetite from Wall Street coming in all different corners of the Ethereum ecosystem when people ask you about why ETH why buy an ETH treasury company over a Bitcoin treasury company if they're shopping around there because there are treasury company options out there there's been micro strategy this there's not only just micro strategy for Bitcoin there's others and then like as you alluded to there's like a hype treasury company there's an Athena treasury company so when you explain why why specifically ease like what what is resonant about ETH or the asset and the treasury company model over something like Bitcoin or any other alternative treasury company well first I I'm a big fan of Bitcoin you know I think Bitcoin is the way and I you know our work on the fun stretch side shows Bitcoin can get to the million million half dollar per coin so Bitcoin still has a huge story ahead yeah but Bitcoin and Ethereum operate on different parts of how the world is financializing and that's the principle difference to me because Ethereum represents the world financializing onto the blockchain which is not Bitcoin's goal and the AI world creating basically a digitally native way to bridge the real world and you know digital security so that's to me why Ethereum someone wants to own Ethereum treasuries because they're I would buy it micro strategy if I was looking at this and by the way it is a granny shot in the fun strat ETF but the reason is that micro strategy is growing your Bitcoin holdings every day so you're going to outperform Bitcoin Ethereum treasuries are really the only way for a US equity investor to get exposure to Ethereum unless they're buying ETH directly or an ETH ETF but if you're an institution and you this is the one of the biggest themes I don't think they're going to just say well in my fund my $50 billion large kept fund Ethereum's the biggest trade so I'll buy JP market they might but they're better off saying how can I be directly exposed to Ethereum and they can't really buy and eat Ethereum ETF because that's not within the parameters they're fun so I think to me the US equity market professional investor looks at Ethereum treasuries as really the only way to get exposure to eat as a macro trade and that's why you know you've seen like the Kathy Woods make a big investment in Bitcoin and Bill Miller today we announced that he made a major investment last week into Bitcoin so they're institutional investors they're both both of those folks are OGs and crypto realize this is the best way to have macro exposure to Ethereum in addition to just like the MNAF premium which has mostly been micro strategies strategy for bootstrapping itself into buying more Bitcoin and accumulating more Bitcoin Ether treasury companies have a bit of extra tools in their tool belt simply by nature of what Ethereum is right Ethereum has like an on-chain DeFi ecosystem that Ethereum treasury companies can actually leverage so my question to you is I mean what's your strategy for accumulating more eth using the additional tools at your disposal because all treasury companies are leveraging the MNAF premium in order to accumulate more respective assets under their balance sheet but there's other strategies beyond just kind of like extracting the the the premium to accumulate more ether what else what other strategies assuming assuming the ignoring the MNAF premium how else do you get ether on your guys' balance sheet yeah David of course you're asking a great question and I have many answers of which I can't really share most of them because whatever strategy we pursue you know is some of this is very proprietary but you know I would say investors shouldn't oversimplify their thinking around treasuries because we you know we've become the third largest crypto treasury in the world after Mara blockchain and micro strategy so we own more crypto than meta-planet and so then you realize that companies that are of significant size and liquidity don't simply have to be doing it's like singular things you know so that's probably the difference Tom why does an MNAF premium even exist can you can you talk about this because I've heard some investors talk about this and their basic view is the MNAF premium should kind of collapse somewhere around one maybe a bit above one of course in bear markets a good trade under one but why is there an MNAF premium in the first place for any crypto treasury company yeah can I walk you through that please okay because it's a very good question okay I want to start with a numerical thing and then give you the non numerical let's say that someone buys us and bit mine is very strict on cost structure so it's basically with $3 billion of Ethereum let's say oh you're like okay you're just an ETF so let's say you put it at one times NNAF okay but then there's a native yield of 3% and let's say you pay that out as net income but let's say you you you go oh well let's just give it a money market multiple so five percent you gross it up so it's a 20 times multiple of your 3% okay that's adding point six to your nav because of the what you earn on a yield does that make sense so we're already at 1.
6 just because of each staking yield basically then the third there's two other components to value you have to account for velocity because when we started the ETH strategy on July 8 there was only four dollars of Ethereum help per share and now when we announced on July 27 there was $23 of Ethereum help per share and it's much higher today we haven't disclosed it but it's higher so it's grown by $19 a share in 20 days roughly that's velocity you have to give a velocity because when you do nav the nav is growing so you have to give a multiple to that nav growing micro strategy is getting a .7 for adding 16 cents of Bitcoin a day but we're doing it 12 times faster so if you did the theoretical math we should be getting more than it should be .
6 which is micro strategies premium but 12 times faster times 12 now I'm not saying that'll be what's price but think about that's like six points of nav so that's just velocity and then there's liquidity because you know after micro strategy trades about $3 billion trading a day we're the second most liquid crypto treasury out there because we trade we trade 1.6 billion a day like meta-planet for instance and I'm a big fan of what meta plan is doing but they're trading like I don't know $50 million a day so we have like a quantum log function of liquidity so that should be worth a premium too so I think like bit mine just should be one times plus the yield gives you .
6 so 1.6 and then how much value do you give for the velocity and we know micro strategy is getting .6 for 13 cents a day and we're 12 times faster and then what's the premium you should pay for liquidity because liquidity is how you can issue other instruments at lower cost so there's a liquidity premium to this product and a velocity premium yeah the liquidity premium you get by being kind of the biggest and baddest and kind of like deepest right but the velocity premium which is kind of interesting let's dig into that because there's the velocity of you in the first month you've moved 12x at the speed of micro strategy the question though is is that sustainable for the next you know let's say 11 months right for an entire year to talk about that so how are you able to but get that level of eth velocity in terms of the you're purchasing and can that level actually be maintained well that's a functional liquidity right so it's liquidity and velocity are like two aspects of the same characteristic we're able to have a lot of velocity because of our liquidity I'll give an example so today we trade like as of 2pm we've traded $800 million of dollar traded volume today and micro strategy has traded well 3 billion so they've gotten a lot but ether machine which is the third largest holder etherium traded $7 million today so we traded 100 times the volume of ether machine and then like BTBT I believe they're the fourth largest holder they traded $49 million today so you can see there's a huge difference in liquidity which affects your velocity because everything that you do to get velocity requires your stuff to be super liquid let me ask the same question for velocity though so if you're saying hey the velocity comes from liquidity and the question is where's the liquidity come from so like how do you get more of that yeah so I think well that's probably the synergy of the team because it's myself you know as chairman but I our lead investor in in bit mine from the private investment was mosaics and they're a really well-known very smart macro hedge fund but that's how we were able to attract folks like founders fund and you know a stand truck and Miller was revealed in the registration statement as a holder and of course the arcs and the bill Miller I mean you you have literally the biggest blue chip names in traditional markets and VC backing bit mine that's one element is that it's it's obviously the people believe the vision the second is that I've been a long time proponent of crypto you know and the convergence and and now and you know we really argued forcefully in 2017 that Wall Street would care about Bitcoin starting in 2017 that was really the year that it became an institutional product right and an ownership grew from there this is ethereum is experiencing it's 2017 moment right now and that's you know I think that is logical to the folks that know us and I think that that's helping want helping support what the ethereum treasures are all trying to accomplish of course I'm really supportive of like sharp link and what they're trying to do and and your keys because we're all doing the same thing we're trying to stake ethereum to make it a secure us blockchain I mean we're all really working together towards the same goal in the wild west of defy stability and innovation are everything which is why you should check out frax finance the protocol revolutionizing stablecoins defy and rollets the core of frax finance is frax usd which is backed by blackrock's institutional fiddle fund frax designed frax usd for besting class yields across defy tea bills and carry trade returns all in one just head to frax calm then stake it to earn some of the best yields in defy want even more bridge your frax usd over to the frax doll layer two for the same yield plus frax doll points and explore frax doll's diverse layer two ecosystem with protocols like curve convex and more all rewarding early adopters frax isn't just a protocol it's a digital nation powered by the fxs token and governed by its global community acquire fxs through frax calm or your go to decks stake it and help shape frax nations future ready to join the forefront of defy visit frax calm now to start earning with frax usd and staked frax usd and for bankless listeners you can use frax calm slash r slash bankless when bridging to frax doll for exclusive fraxial perks and boosted rewards the theorems layer two universe is exploding with choices but if you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens make your next stop uni chain first liquidity uni chain host the most liquid uniswap v4 deployment on any layer two giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like eth usdc more liquidity means better prices less slippage and smoother swaps exactly what traders crave the numbers back it up uni chain leads all layer two's in total value locked for uniswap v4 and it's not just deep it's fast and fully transparent purpose built to be the home base for defy and cross chain liquidity when it comes to costs uni chain is a no-brainer transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than ethereum mainnet slashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity want to stay in the loop on uni chain visit unichain.
org or follow at unichain on x for all the updates imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly that's what mantle is pioneering with blockchain for banking a revolutionary new category at the intersection of trad five and web three at the heart is you are the world's first money app built fully on chain it gives you a swiss iban account blending fiat currencies like the euro the swiss fronk the united states dollar or the rmin b with crypto all in one place enjoy real world usability and blockchains trust and programmability transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with trad five rails impact with integrated defy features you are transform mantle network into the ultimate platform for on chain financial services unifying payments trading and assets like the m i4 the meh's protocol and functions f b tc backed by developer grants ecosystem incentives and top distribution through the ur app reward stations and buy bit launch pool for mnt holders every economic activity in ur drives value back to you embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking that's x.
com slash mantle underscore official tom there's a lot of people listening who came to crypto later than twenty seventeen uh i'm not one of them i remember seeing you in twenty seventeen on cnbc and you appeared to me the only guy in a suit who would go on traditional finance bloomberg squawk box all of these things and talk about bitcoin and talk about it in a way that resonated i think to those in crypto and those that saw the the bitcoin story can you bring what you've made reference to twenty seventeen moment for ether and uh maybe you could bring folks back to what you mean by that twenty seventeen comparing it to bitcoin in twenty seventeen yeah and how it was perceived on wall street make that connection for us what what's uh what was twenty seventeen bitcoin like and how is this similar to ether right now yes um i'd be happy to give the backstory and um in twenty seventeen at funstrat funstrat is a macro and thematic firm so we write about big story arcs we began to do work um that led us to bitcoin which was we did two different studies one was we were studying millennials and in twenty seventeen millennials were in their the oldest was mid twenty's okay but we realized that they were going to be a huge driver of the us economy so that was eight years ago today it's accepted that millennials were big but our work that we did on millennials was actually so eye catching that we ended up partnering with snapchat to do several white papers talking about how millennials would be a cohort that you need to monetize snapchat was trying to convince advertisers than to to do Gen Z and millennial specific advertising believe or not like Pepsi these guys thought it was just about Gen X okay uh i know it sounds weird but that was the story and uh but the second thing we discovered was that um we noticed bitcoin like because i was at j moron was like a hundred dollars and i left in twenty fourteen and we talked about it in twenty twelve and then suddenly it was like a thousand i was like whoa uh you know it's a hundred billion dollars i've never seen anything go to hundred billion dollars that didn't have something behind it so we at fun strat we spent several months trying to understand bitcoin and i never fully understood it but i found that it was driven by two very two explainable things one is that it was ninety seven percent that move of bitcoin from a hundred to a thousand was the number of wallets and the activity per wallet i mean basically network value effect and we could simply say in the next couple years if more people use bitcoin it's going to go up exponentially again so we thought it would reach by twenty twenty two twenty five thousand but it could even go to a hundred thousand if it got to five to ten percent of the value of gold so we started to really push that story as wall street needs to understand bitcoin because it's digital gold and in your right ryan like maybe other people said it but we were really the first wall street firm to push it to the institutional universe and remember zero percent of institutions had ownership of bitcoin it was a hundred percent retail and as you know in the last eight years bitcoin has the biggest narrative is its digital gold that's a store of value you know of course it's a great payment system everything else but really what's resonated is that there's a group of people that own gold and we did studies back then to show gold was primarily owned by baby boomers so millennials would own bitcoin the way boomers owned gold so it was a generational story on top of a you know digital substitution story that's the sort of the back story and i did many webinars you know actually a fun strat believe it or not we lost we got fired from our institutional clients we actually had a decline in paying clients at fun strat because they thought we completely lost our mind they said how can you even recommend something that only drug dealers and dark web people to use use and you're saying it's a legitimate asset class and uh so our reputation was actually harmed but as you know bitcoin now is a hundred twenty thousand so it was a hundred twenty x our clients that invested it and followed us because we recommended one to two percent for some it became a hundred percent of their portfolio um so they've gone full degen as a result and i think that's happened with in theory i'm today because ethereum's been kind of a dormant chain people wanted faster networks uh you know or more novel ways to do essentially validation but ethereum's had zero downtime that is what matters to Wall Street zero downtime in ten years so i think that Wall Street has already decided ethereum is the chain they're gonna build Wall Street onto and it's lower than it was five years ago there's been a lot of recent things that has happened in the last like six months um the circle IPO was just absolutely gangbusters uh Coinbase stock has performed very well Robin Hood has launched uh or announced the incoming launch of its layer two on ethereum and then this word tokenization is just taking off like wildfire there's a lot of things happening that in the background are all supported by ethereum you know circles usdc grew and was born on ethereum coinbase the world the largest crypto public company is building an ethereum layer two robin hood a a traditional finance company is building a layer two if they're not even a crypto company they're a normal traffic company coming into crypto and like legitimizing some of the technology being born here does Wall Street understand that like ethereum is the backbone for a lot of the movements that are happening and is that why you think there are some there's just incredible tailwinds behind these eth treasury companies or is that like and narrative that i'm spinning up in my head well uh david you're everything you've described hundred percent logic fits um but Wall Street doesn't connect until they can start making money i'll give you an example many of your these listeners owned apple for years or amazon for years earn video for years in video is a great is a good example that is an exponential growth stock but as you know there have been times when envy is done nothing for a year like literally dead money or palantir dead money for years and then suddenly has a step function where the market's like oh wait not only do i get it we have to reprice it that's what's happened to ethereum now because we know on chain activity is searched all time highs right so ethereum is the community has been regalvanized because the price of course has recovered but also more people are using ethereum and then it's very obvious that the genius act really benefits a smart contract blockchain um as much as it benefits bitcoin but bitcoin you know won't host a stablecoin um so uh do i think that the fact that ethereum is not at 15,000 today is a bad sign i've seen this before i mean you know we've recommended tesla and we've recommended envy and it's a granny shot since 2019 it funds track capitals etf and it's been part of the research portfolio for a long time it has not tracked revenues it has moved in step functions and i think ethereum look i'd love to see it stay here for five years because that means we can acquire it at a much more attractive price i mean if it is at 17,000 that's much more expensive for the ethereum treasuries to acquire ethereum of course the their stock prices will benefit but to me it's actually a great that it's actually here so like like 2017 Wall Street did not understand bitcoin you're saying uh 2025 Wall Street still doesn't understand ether the asset maybe they're starting to get it and it's hard for me not to see the the fractal pattern because at that time i remember you back in 2017 and we're talking about like bitcoin price it was something in the 2000s 3000 something like this and you would go on traditional finance as you're doing with ether now but you go on uh squawk box or something and and say something that they thought was audacious you'd call you know 25k bitcoin price 40k bitcoin price those types of audacious numbers i'm not surprised to hear you say yeah a lot of people at Wall Street thought we were crazy and they stopped giving us their money for a period of time but that trade that investment proved incredibly right now we see ether at similar numbers right it's like bitcoin was you know around the 3000s in 2017 when you first started telling Wall Street about it well now ether is at at 3000 yeah which uh you know and you're calling for i i think some pretty high prices uh at least they're these are blowing minds and traditional finance for e do you think it could do a similar thing as as bitcoin did like what's your what's your kind of call for price for either right now i actually think that there's upside a bigger upside story to etherium um because there's more skepticism to start with bitcoin wasn't necessarily something people shorted they just didn't believe it um and so the upside case you know like when we wrote about 100,000 in 2017 it seemed insane but it didn't take that long from 2017 to now to get there you know it was within our lifetimes that it was a hundred x and etherium i think you're hitting its bottom is just like bitcoin in 2017 Wall Street is not professionally convinced etherium is even a surviving chain because there was some fair criticisms and you know and it did move to proof of stake and uh there might have been too much ether out there for a bit of time but it's being fixed and there's still skepticism that Wall Street going on to ether they're even going to stake ether or even use etherium everyone's kind of more there are probably more people who think that it's a layer two story that and nothing benefits the layer one and i think that that's what's going to be shattered and when it does it'll be a step function so i think the upside case for ether is actually higher then let's say bitcoin did a hundred x you know could etherium do a hundred x i mean joe lube and sort of has that kind of upside in his mind uh you know because joe and i are in dialogue i mean it you know we are really partners in trying to push ether as a treasury as a digital infrastructure and um i think that that could happen because there is probably a non a significant probability that etherium could flip bitcoin as well in terms of network value and then so then if you're you know someone thinks bitcoin's at a million then imagine what it means for etherium because it is not just Wall Street financializing onto blockchain but it's it's ai but it's also part of the us focus on ai dominance right etherium plays a strategic strategic role there now if if microstrategy had tripled the upside of bitcoin then that means in theory the etherium treasuries could triple whatever etherium could do so you know i'm like i don't think you're gonna go wrong saying that the etherium treasuries are a good investment class but if you're looking at what bitminds doing it's those other things i was saying distinguish it and and that's why you know maybe we will be at the front end of that but they should all do well because etherium itself is undervalued i think maybe you're blowing some minds with some of these calls even even in crypto terms so a hundred x of ethereum at this point in time would that be about forty trillion and you also uh you know said that there's the possibility here that ether actually flippens bitcoin which is not canon i would say among crypto natives though there are a lot of eth supporters and eth bulls who have believed this for a very long period of time but in the more immediate term i don't know of how distant that hundred x future is where do you see ether price going say the end of this year or maybe even the end of this cycle if you still think in terms of of cycles if you think this will play out in the next you know twelve to eighteen months let's say where do you think we go sure um well i think the near term price people should think about is ethereum getting to four thousand because ethereum should be is a better story that it was in December and it was four thousand a December so like to me we should at least reach cover to that level and then ethereum is a better story today than it was a year ago and a year ago ethereum was at point oh five ratio to bitcoin right it's to me it's a stronger story and and there's reasons people are using ethereum so it's like a narrative well at point oh five bitcoin it's like almost six thousand so just like saying give it credit for where it is a year ago versus a year ago it should be six thousand but of course there is going to be a lot happening um between now and year end including you know other ethereum treasuries starting to buy ethereum plus bitcoin goes up so i think before by the year end it's not unreasonable think seven thousand even twelve or fifteen thousand could happen and of course from there then in twenty twenty six the fed starts to follow through on its what it should be a double pivot so central bank liquidity is rising and so ethereum should do should build upon those price levels i don't know if there's a crypto cycle there should be it would play in our favor because again we'd rather ethereum i'd personally think that a ethereum treasury company wants ethereum to be flat for the next five years and then go up a lot but it's probably not it's probably just going to have a step function but again i just think of you an idea like when i first wrote about the smp in 2009 smp earnings were sixty five dollars in two thousand seven and i built a model at jabewarning that says we would get to sixty dollars by two thousand ten okay so remember the stock market fell it almost eighty percent i don't remember we had a huge decline and every one every strategist didn't have a recovery to all time high in earnings for five years and so the bicep was very skeptical of the idea of sixty dollars by twenty ten but that would imply the smp was at ten times earnings in at the bottom in twenty not two thousand nine and lo and behold smp earnings was over sixty by two thousand ten okay and today smp earnings are three hundred so smp earnings had grown exponentially that's just the traditional corporate world so the idea that crypto's network value could be twenty trillion for bitcoin it's we witnessed it in our lifetimes with equities so and also like crypto treasuries our asset base valued on their balance sheet you know micro strategies valued really on its balance sheet not on its earnings power keep in mind from 1990 to 2018 okay so one full generation of someone's career exon mobile was the top five largest company in the smb by hundred for that entire period nineteen ninety to two thousand eighteen you know there was internet all that but next time was top five it was never valued on earnings it was always price to prove in reserves so crypto treasuries are just the new exon Tom you talk about models and and trying to put some numbers behind reasoning about the valuation of crypto this i think it's one of our favorite pastimes here at bank list to to try and do this and at some point we also understand that you know to some degree these these things are inherently unmodelable uh you know like coinbase robin hood circle they're all building on a theorem layer two's are building on a theorem tokenization is on a theorem these narratives i think carry a lot of weight when it comes to the value of east of the current price of east but when you actually try and like unpack the price of east how how do you actually do that would do you think of this in terms of like the demand for ethereum with its transaction fees do you think about the demand for ether as a store value inside of defi apps or for people that want to stake it wait how do you unpack the value the price of east yeah that's a good question um i would probably positive this with david have you seen anyone spreadsheet model explain Bitcoin's price correctly i think it's a fun activity to try but but i mean in practical matter been done i don't think it's ever been done no or when you had no one's model has ever served to explain everything so i i would say people who are trying to model eth based on a spreadsheet are the same people that try to come up with an s and p price target based on their bottoms of earnings model or their ism and that's why no one gets the s and p call correct because to me there's a phrase i learned when i first started on last week which is it takes a whole lot of p e to offset e people spent too much time modeling the e that's the spreadsheet thing you're talking about right but it's actually always about pe ethereum's price is not going to be based on the contemporaneous transactions recorded in any single week it's really the recognition of where that number is five years from now so i would say i'm i don't think people should be building models and saying they can articulate an anchor of view on the price of anything and actually i i would say that about a stock because you know what people would have been stopped out of Palantir and tesla a long time ago and yet fun stretch been on the right side of that trade because we don't get grounded by that it takes a whole lot of p e to offset e so how then do you estimate the size of this market right do you do comp it so of course you you helped pioneer the 2017 bitcoin is digital gold there in the comp is what you know gold which is 20 trillion or so in value do you do comp ether to something like gold or to a commodity even like an oil you know calling ether a digital oil is is that the way you sort of talk about the ceiling value for this asset i think that that's part of it i've seen some work done i actually think eth is digital oil did a pretty nice job on their report i'm sure you guys have seen it um i know that the mosaics team has helped with doing uh two models for ethereum one is basically a banking system proxy model and then another is payment proxy um but you know at the end of the day if there's anything i've learned in the equity world you can't be grounded by a rigid framework and that is the mistake people make and i think people have tried to pin me on the s and p like tom you realize what remember when the s and p fell in april and we're at the tariff lows i had everyone say tom earnings are going to get cut so your s and p is going to get massacred by the way you notice every strategy is cut numbers for the year except us and then they said it won't recover because the feds not going to save you so there's no fed liquidity put and i said it didn't matter because it's a waterfall decline and guess what it didn't matter we met we had a v shaped recovery that was not something that anyone built a spreadsheet for but it really isn't understanding of how markets work and their resilience and so i would to say for the listener i'm not against trying to build frameworks but to me eat at thirty six hundred dollars it's kind of ridiculously undervalued so maybe that's the most important takeaway and not trying to give someone a spreadsheet to build for five years and try to understand it i know it sounds like i'm not giving an answer but i think that's actually the best answer to give tom do you think at some point these crypto treasury companies bitcoin eth other asset treasury companies get a little overheated and so you know maybe this is the crypto PTSD talking but we many of us live through the gbdc kind of like trade and the thuros capital blow up and how that infected the rest of markets and looking at these treasury companies and all these new entrants going on in this premium to mnav and some are even comparing it to kind of investment trust companies of the 1920s and of course we know how the 1920s stock market era ended do you think that there's a chance that this gets into bubble territory that this gets uh overwrought that the premiums become um reflexive up and then suddenly in a elevator you know down kind of uh lose all of this value and and cause more systemic effects and crypto into the broader economy like are you worried about this um well uh just it's a lot to process there um one to going into the liquid equity world this is the most hated v shaped rally you know we still most of our zooms with our institutional clients as people telling us why the stock market shouldn't be going up and why it's expensive and every time we get off it it strengthens the case for stocks to go higher because it's a non consensus view that we should be going up that's you need skepticism for markets to go up if everybody was bullish in the liquid world that's the top just because digital asset treasuries have gone up and you don't own it doesn't mean it's a bubble a bubble is just your friend making money a bubble is truly created when everyone is bullish so if you're bullish not you but I'm saying the listener is bullish and then they don't go up and everyone's bullish then that's a bubble now the only way these crypto treasuries get into trouble is if they use leverage so I would say anyone who's doing exotic instruments debt structures unless they're scarce microstragic can do a lot of things because they've changed the world and same thing with meta-planet they've changed the world but the ones that haven't maybe they they're the ones to get into problems but from what I can see most crypto treasuries are pretty plain vanilla so what happens they just go down and price I don't think that that's actually could cause a stock market crash the stock market crash is usually a debt problem you know I mean or an exogenous shock I'd say we're a long way from bubble I mean if if things were if the cost of capital was low you know I always Bitcoin treasuries some of them are trading it now so it's hardly a bubble in fact the market's betting that it's oversupplied already you know so they only go up if Bitcoin goes up but you're right at some point something is a bubble but I think that people always declare a bubble and everyone always rings the bell you know fourth inning to the ninth inning everyone's ringing the bell at the top you realize like you don't really have a top until no one's bearish and right now everyone's bearish bear on e everyone's bearish on Bitcoin because of last week and everyone's bearish on stocks because of last week I mean it's if you if if we were at a top last week's five consecutive bearish and golfing days everyone should have said oh nothing but you know everybody says this is the top when you have conviction that paper thin you're never you're nowhere near a top just keep that in mind so what's your conviction with respect to macro here Tom because that's the other thing that could throw throw these crypto markets off as if there's some sort of macro event you know tariff you know recession I think last year we actually had you on it was around August as well we had this yen kind of carry trade that sort of evaporated into nothing I think you're you were bullish that and you said this would all go away and and so it has what's your outlook right now when it comes to macro anything in the waters that concerns you or do you think we're we're in a good place yeah I I am I I'm very worried about how institutions are becoming politicized I mean the Fed independent should be and the BLS is independent should be they make a lot of the BLS revisions are very peculiar but I don't think it's the BLS being political look the economy to me is very strong but when I speak to clients the institutional owners they think we're in a recession now people on this podcast here in here they'd be like Tom you're so off base if everyone thinks when a recession you're the one that's wrong because you can't say this economy is strong but reality is I don't think in my 30 years anyone's ever called a recession correctly when everyone says we're in a recession guess what it's not a recession because a recession is a sudden change in business conditions that catches everyone off sides that's how you get a recession you get a housing bubble and a burst you can't get a burst when everyone's cautious ISM has been below 50 for 29 months corporate America is cautious I I'm just going to say that would literally be the first recession in the history of the ISM where you were you didn't break above 50 and then you had a recession so I I think this is going to sound very strange everything I look at empirically we're mid-cycle or even early cycle on the economy and the tariff was the recession tariff was such a shock it reset confidence in the business sector and that's how you prevent a recession you get everyone so scared they don't spend money so that's why look look at the data look at the corporate earnings S appear they've been great no one's like seeing demand collapse this because everyone's cautious Tom I'm just guessing that you've been inundated with just phone calls from people on Wall Street every billionaire in Wall Street is calling Tom Lee to ask about Ethereum and just to learn more about it what is the biggest misunderstanding that Wall Street still has today about either crypto broadly or Ethereum specifically that's a great question I'm glad you're asking David because Wall Street likes to build spreadsheets and so every call starts with Tom can you give me the model on how gas fees are going to change with stable coins so give me your assumption on how much stable coin volume is how much goes to e how much won't be layer two and how much gets paid and I and I'd say that's the reason people if when you give someone a spreadsheet then you get the analysis paralysis because then suddenly you you don't see the bigger picture that ethos literally the legally compliant blockchain and I think it's a big stumbling block for people but it's the same with the S&P like imagine you ask someone all right you you're Harvard MBA and you use chat gbt and you're a genius all at once analyze a stock market and then the mods are going to be like well S&P median PE long term is 16 times and earnings margins are at all time high so margins should go down S&P should be 3000 I mean literally I'm sure everyone of your guests tell you see that and I'd say maybe you should try to align whether their view has worked in the last 50 years and you'd realize like that analysis literally never made your money okay my analysis on the people coming to you with a spreadsheet is that they're doing their basic CYA work they're covering their own ass they need to justify to their boss and to their boss's boss why they're about to buy a ton of eith or buy a ton of you know BMNR and so they need to do this spreadsheet just to check that box how can we all provide them a different CYA checkbox yeah that does that job yeah I mean that's fair question all right so one thing is you know fun stress evidence based research but we're not anchored by ISM to us is not rule of law the jobless claim number is not rule of law fed funds is not rule of law where the tenure is because they don't they're not these are not never in equilibrium and just as proof of evidence fund strat launched an ETF last year called granny shots it's only been eight months but year to date granny shots is up 17 percent it's a lot only buys S&P constituents S&P is up 7 percent so we outperformed the S&P by a thousand basis points morning star ranks as the top 30 out of 1400 funds so we're in the we're literally top 2 percentile of large cap equity funds year to because we use an evidence based approach but it's not anchored by like this is what earn you should be and but we our stock selection is very disciplined if someone asked me what an ethereum treasury companies were okay and I'm not going to talk about bitmind specifically you should start with your ethereum health per share okay and then do the four things I just added velocity okay liquidity and scarcity you know how unique is what they're doing like the largest one should get a premium obviously right because there's a network effect then you should just say what is ethereum what's your upside downside if someone is doing precision of eth to the penny or even a hundred you know their analysis won't ever work because ethereum's never in equilibrium but you should say if ethereum's thirty seven hundred what's your downside case you know should it be the low of this year okay I'm seventeen hundred but what's your upside case a ratio of Bitcoin from five years ago so that gets you like twenty thousand each so now you have asymmetry on your risk reward and you know the eth per share so you do future eth per share plus velocity and liquidity and scarcity and that's how you should get to your price and that's not using a spreadsheet that's really using what would happen in real life right in real life if eth is at twenty thousand what is it these companies worth but if it goes to seventeen hundred it gets cut in half and the one let's see eth goes gets cut in half but this company doubles your eth per share in that same period of time the stock will be flat so the one with the velocity is the best bet because they're going to stack your eat Tom I believe you're rocking a Pudgey penguin an unofficial Pudgey penguin profile picture on on Twitter do you own any oh is that's a real one yeah look at this screw made this for us yes oh great what do you own any other ethereum NFTs or just what do you think about NFTs generally speaking well I have a lot of punch Pudgey penguin merch it's cool stuff yeah it's it's it's it's really hard to keep my office because everybody here wants a wants a piece of it if so Pudgey Pudgey penguins are your favorite ethereum NFT well I you know what I what really strikes me about Pudgey penguins is really unique is it's actually quite popular in Korea and Korea is also a big equity culture you know it's one of the most heavily traded stock markets in the world and you know I spend a lot of time and of course it's a big crypto culture so to me Pudgey penguins I think it's extra validation because it's so popular Korea Tom Lee this has been exceptional thank you so much for joining us I got to say I did not anticipate you being so fully into the ethereum fold but very glad to have you and excited to have you aboard as you're kind of evangelizing and really sharing what you can do for the world particularly to Wall Street so excited to see bit mine continue to acquire more eth into the future up towards 5% so let's go yeah look forward to it gotta let you know bankless nation of course none of this has been financial advice crypto is risky you could lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot