In today’s podcast, Justin Drake and Tim Beiko help us explore Ethereum's uncharted roadmap.
You know about EIP-4844. You know about Proposer-Builder Separation. But the Ethereum roadmap does not stop there. It continues! Each component of the Ethereum roadmap has deeper frontiers than what you may be familiar with. 4844, PBS, these are just the first stops on a longer track of Ethereum’s Sci-Fi roadmap.
Other areas Justin, Tim, and David explore statelessness, how VCs are subsidizing Ethereum L1 R&D efforts, enshrined rollups, how all of this stuff leads to Ethereum needing fewer and fewer honest actors to work trustlessly, what quantum computing has to do with the Ethereum roadmap, trustless mempools and so much more.
----- 🏹 Airdrop Hunter is HERE, join your first HUNT today https://bankless.cc/JoinYourFirstHUNT
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦊METAMASK PORTFOLIO | MANAGE YOUR WEB3 EVERYTHING https://bankless.cc/MetaMask
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
👾POLYGON | VALUE LAYER OF THE INTERNET https://polygon.technology/roadmap
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku
----- TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 5:50 Ethereum Roadmap Completion 8:30 Immediate Dev Priorities 9:50 Danksharding & Rollups as 1st Class Citizens 11:50 Why Prioritize L2s 14:50 Snarkifying the EVM 17:39 Enshrined Rollup Use Cases 20:00 EVM to zkEVM 24:48 Summary So Far 27:15 EIP-4844 28:25 Proposer-Builder Separation 37:37 MEV Burn 40:38 Statelessness 43:33 Cryptography vs. Crypto Economics 45:00 Quantum Mechanics 50:25 Statelessness Ethereum Unlock 53:10 Cryptography & Sustainability 55:55 Closing & Disclaimers
----- RESOURCES
Justin Drake https://twitter.com/drakefjustin
Tim Beiko https://twitter.com/TimBeiko
Ethereum Discord https://discord.gg/CetY6Y4
----- Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
But there's also some really future thinking stuff, so, for example, upgrading to post-quantum cryptography. And even beyond that, there's something that kind of only opened up in the last few weeks. Not only should we defend against quantum computers, but we can harness them to make consensus even more robust. Welcome, Bankless Nation, to the Sci-Fi Roadmap to Ethereum. You know about EIP, 4044. You know about Proposer Builder separation, but you probably didn't know that the Ethereum Roadmap does not stop at these things. It continues. Each component of the Ethereum Roadmap has deeper frontiers than what you may be familiar with.
4844 PBS, these are just the first stops on a longer track of Ethereum's Sci-Fi Roadmap. In this episode, we're going to explore these deeper frontiers to Ethereum, with Justin Drake and Tim Baker, the two individuals who can probably see the furthest along the Ethereum frontier out of anyone. We're going to learn about what is statelessness, and how it's helping Ethereum make the furthest reaches of the Internet even more trustless. How Ethereum is going to absorb ZKTEC at the layer 1 level. How VCs are subsidizing Ethereum's layer 1 research and development efforts. What is an enshrined roll-up, and how is it different from all the other roll-ups that we're familiar with, and why does Justin Drake want it so bad?
How all of this stuff is leading to Ethereum needing fewer and fewer honest actors to work trustlessly. And what does quantum computing have to do with the Ethereum Roadmap, and no, it's not just that it breaks ECDSA signatures. And what are trustless mempools? Who do they protect? All of these things that I just mentioned are just the tips of the iceberg. You're going to learn so much in this episode, so much that you're going to need to put your gigabrain hat on, or else your brain might explode. But first, a message from our friends and sponsors over at Stater. Stater is a liquid-staking service provider.
You know what these are, but the unique thing about Stater is that it only requires for Ether for you to run a Stater Staking Ether node. So you deposit for Ether, 28 other people's Ether come in to your node, so they can stake with you, and then you charge them 15%. So you get extra yield for Staking Ether because Stater, the Stater Protocol, only requires for Ether. There's a link in the show notes if this has you peaked, so you can get started staking with Stater. I hope you enjoy this episode with Tim Baker and Justin Drake. This is the Sci-Fi Roadmap to Ethereum. And we're going to get to it as soon as we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make this episode possible, especially Kraken, our preferred exchange for crypto in 2023.
If the gigabrain friend tears scares you a little bit, don't worry, Kraken's got your back, you can DCA into your preferred crypto assets and the safety and security of Kraken. Let's go here from them right now. Kraken Pro has easily become the best crypto trading platform in the industry. The place I use to check the charts and the crypto prices, even when I'm not looking to place a trade. On Kraken Pro, you'll have access to advanced charting tools, real-time market data, and lightning fast trade execution. All inside, there's spiffy new modular interface. Kraken's new customizable modular layout lets you tailor your trading experience to suit your needs.
Pick and choose your favorite modules and place them anywhere you want in your screen. With Kraken Pro, you have that power. Whether you are a seasoned pro or just starting out, join thousands of traders who trust Kraken Pro for their crypto trading needs. Visit pro.kraken.com to get started today. Introducing Polygon 2.0, the value layer for the internet. For too long, the limitations of blockchains have held back app development and stifled user adoption. The internet allows anyone to create an exchange information. What's missing is a value layer that lets anyone exchange store and program value.
That's where Polygon 2.0 comes in. Polygon Labs has unveiled a series of innovations that will radically alter the Polygon ecosystem and Web3 as a whole by leveraging groundbreaking ZK innovations such as Polygon ZK EVM, the next iteration of the best-in-class plonky-to-proving system, and a first-of-its-kind ZK-powered interoperability layer, Polygon 2.0 will give users and devs unlimited scalability and unified liquidity. Right now, there is a polygon improvement proposal regarding a potential ZK-powered upgrade of Polygon proof-of-stake. If approved, Polygon proof-of-stake will become a layer to ZK EVM-villadium.
So make your voice heard on this proposal by joining the Polygon Discord today. You have a chance to help the Polygon community give the internet the value layer it deserves. Welcome to Right. So I'd say that Ethereum is prioritizing the friendliness to build roll-ups on Ethereum, because, you know, posting this data is the main bottleneck. But, and I guess one of the consequences here is that we're going to be able to scale the number of users on Ethereum maybe from 10 million to 100 million or maybe even hundreds of millions. And one of the things that I expect in the short term is we're introducing this whole new resource, which won't be like fully consumed at the very beginning.
And so we might see dynamics similar to what Arjun did a few years ago where basically the fees were so low that they subsidize the fees. So it's possible that for a period of time, maybe six to 12 months, we're going to be able to use roll-ups completely for free. And there's going to be this kind of this temporary subsidy almost that could act as a bootstrapping mechanism. I guess one of the things that I've been thinking of in the long term is how can we really have Ethereum native roll-ups? And we call those and shrine roll-ups. And what we're going to do in the long term is actually get an and shrine roll-up one instance by snarkifying the EVM.
So if you take the EVM today as it is, every validator has to verify every single transaction. But once we've snarkified it, all the validators need to do is just verify this one snark per block. And so it automatically becomes a roll-up. So the main net becomes a roll-up. Ah, okay. What does that mean for the other roll-ups that also already exist? So what I expect will happen is that there will be kind of nice complementarity because the the enshrined roll-ups will have best-in-class security. But on the other hand, and one of the things that they enjoy is access to social consensus. So if for whatever reason there's a bug in the EVM, then we're going to go and fix it.
Whereas if there's a bug in one of this one of the roll-ups, I know Arbitram, then kind of that problem. And so the way that the non-entrined roll-ups fix issues is with governance. And so really we don't need this governance token. And so this in a way makes it more secure because governance, it's a way for flexibility, but it's also an attack mechanism. Is this so if we're snarkifying the EVM and we're getting similar properties to what you would get from a roll-up. You can bundle up many, many transactions and have them go through much cheaper gas costs and much easier computation. Is that competitive with the current layer 2 landscape?
So the layer 2 landscape, I don't think we'll compete with enshrined roll-ups for a few reasons. One is on cost. So you can do certain things with application layer roll-ups that you can't really do with an enshrined roll-up. One of the things, for example, is batching. So if you are willing to settle, let's say, once every 10 minutes, you can take these bigger batches of data and then you have more efficient compression. Think of it as when you're zipping a file, you have better compression if you have more data to work with. Another thing that you can do with the non enshrined roll-ups is you can be very opinionated in terms of where the cash rolls go.
For example, optimism, they can decide to fund public goods. But with the enshrined roll-ups, the only real public good that we can find is economic security and economic bandwidth. And then another thing that you can do with the application layer roll-ups is that you can have whatever virtual machine you want. You don't have to stick with the EVM, and so there's going to be a lot of advantages there. And then maybe some other benefits could include services like pre-confirmations. It's relatively difficult to do pre-confirmations with an enshrined roll-up, but that's something that the application of roll-ups can do.
Where is this on the theoretical idea to EIP on the roadmap spectrum? So getting to one base roll-up is actually only the beginning, but it's like 90% of the work, and the reason is that we have to do the really heavy engineering to have these snog proofs for every single block. But then there's this really cool thing that we can do, which is maybe only 10% of the work, where we can expose, as an upcode, the verification of a snog proof for the EVM. So that means that anyone can deploy an enshrined roll-up at the application layer. So it basically opens up the possibilities to have as many copies of the Firm layer 1 EVM as we want, all with the exact same properties as the Firm layer 1.
When will that happen? My guess is that we're talking 5 to 10 years, but it did reactantly skip into the mid-to-long-term roadmap of Ethereum. Yes. But Al-Kavi had this that the development of snogs has always surprised me in the positive way. And so it could only be three, four years. Okay, essentially. And so I think a little bit with what you were saying is between the difference between an enshrined roll-up and the roll-up landscape that we know today, the optimism, arbitrum, ZK saying, all of these players, it's actually different use cases. Different use cases. They're similar in engineering, but will be expressed differently by how and why they will be used.
And so perhaps they're unlocking new use cases, so not necessarily competitive, more just like a new landscape. They have way more flexibility. You can think of them as like, well, they are effectively smart contracts from Ethereum's perspective. So they can do anything even more than what a smart contract on L1 can do, but they're not bounded by like the capabilities of L1 and also the rate of change of L1. So it takes way more time to add a new opcode to Ethereum L1 versus if they say optimism wanted to add an opcode that's not on L1. They can do it much quicker than we can. Is the idea of an enshrined roll-up, like optimism, arbitrum, ZK saying polygon, everyone takes an opinion by default, like everyone is an opinionated application of technology.
Maybe the enshrined roll-up is the least opinionated type of roll-up that we can get, and because it's inherent ties to the Ethereum L1, it also expresses itself differently. Right. There's basically only one way of building an enshrined roll-up, which is to take DVM as it is and just knock it fight end of story. You can't be opinionated like doing an ad-rop, for example. You're also one of the biggest advantages of the enshrined roll-ups is that they won't have the first move advantage by a long shot, by five to ten years. And so a lot of the network effects might already be established so that the enshrined roll-ups maybe won't add that much value when they do come.
Okay. And then again, who is between the spectrum of theoretical idea to actually getting implemented into Ethereum? Like, who is working on this? Where is this in development? How early are we on this on this particular subject? Right. So ironically, it's to a very large extent the application layer roll-ups that are doing the development of the enshrined roll-ups because the whole snacked text stack is basically moving, is being subsidized almost by VC money, billions of it, accelerating it, and we'll just be able to reap the fruits. Okay. Beautiful. Okay. So waiting for, is it specifically the ZK roll-ups that are doing this engineering or is there optimism and arbitrum too?
It's mostly the ZK roll-ups. Mostly the ZK roll-ups. Okay. So that technology we're going to be able to, we're just letting the ZK roll-ups build and deploy, test the actual computation, test the technology. And then when it's time, when it's ready, we're like, hey, we can, we can unbundle that technology, apply it to the Ethereum at the layer one, snarkify the ZK, the EVM. Does this make, wait, does this make the EVM a ZK EVM? Is that what this is? Yeah, exactly. And one of the consequences is that, you know, the meme will be, you don't need to be a validator on your Raspberry Pi, you can be a validator on your smartwatch.
Can you elaborate on that? What does that mean? Right. So one of the, you know, the big computational expenses of being a validator right now, is you need to run a GF node and you need to verify every single transaction and whatnot. And that's, that's very expensive. When you have a ZK EVM, just verify a snark takes a millisecond, your smartwatch can do that. So it doesn't need, my smartwatch doesn't need that much computational power. You won't need much computational power to be an Ethereum validator. You talk maybe about today how like the proving and verification time works on L2 and why having high powered sequencers, you know, makes this more viable there than eventually have, like, what do we need to go from like a couple high powered sequencers on L2 producing and verifying these proofs to like every validator and every node and like client on L1 being able to do it, you know, within 12 seconds.
Ah, right. Okay. So like one of the, the big difficulties right now is basically the, the latency of producing the proof. So what happens is that there's only settlement, let's say, every 10 minutes or every hour. And the proving process is done on these huge like machines that are rented on AWS. And the proving is not very decentralized and it's very high latency. What's going to happen is that we have this technology called, um, called folding. And so we're going to be able to take this big computation, break it down into small pieces and, um, kind of maybe potentially give these small tasks to different low powered, uh, proofers.
And they can all collaborate trustlessly to make the proof. And one of the reasons why we're going to be able to reduce the latency dramatically is because, because we won't be working on these big, uh, chunks. So, um, we'll, we may be able to prove like one transaction at a time. And so the, the, the ultimate latency will just be of one transaction, but actually maybe it will only be the latency of one upcode. So you break everything down into upcodes and then you kind of stream the upcodes through. You're, you're taking the computation and making it into bite-sized trunks that can fit for more into a stream.
Yeah. And this is, this sounds a lot like the, the, the Nova technology that you and I were talking about. Is that what this is? Yes, exactly. Okay. There's a bankless episode for that. It's on you. And then the other aspect of this will be a hardware acceleration. Okay. You want to unpack that a little bit? Yeah. Okay. So we, we got it down to just proving one upcode. And that might take, I don't know, half a second. But once you have hardware acceleration, it might only take five more seconds. What, what does that unlock? If we're, if we're cutting off basically half of a second. How, what is that unlock?
Or is it just cool? Yeah. I mean, one of the complications, I guess, is, the one of the things that it unlocks is, it's decentralization in the sense that we might go from, you know, just one prover, which is distributed to a thousand redundant provers. And they, potentially, these provers can be at home. So, you know, you at home, you'll have this little box, which is the, the size of a shoe box. And you'll be able to single-handedly prove that Ethereum transactions are all valid and produce a snack. And if we have a thousand people doing that at home, and 99, 999 of them go offline, and you're the only one that's online, Ethereum can keep on running.
So, this is this property, which is called strong-lifeness, where you only need one single person to be online and honest for the, for the Ethereum to keep on running. And, you know, it's a bit like the, the, the, the ceremony, the trusted, the trusted setup. Right, yeah. So, we just need one person to be honest. And, you know, at the minimum, we want a hundred people. But, you know, we feel much more comfortable as a thousand people. And we feel even more comfortable with our hundred thousand people, which is what we have right now. And I think having a thousand or maybe a few thousand people around the world, just like we have thousands of people running Ethereum nodes around the world, is going to be more than enough redundancy.
Okay. I'm going to do something, as, I'm going to do something a little ambitious, which is connect the dots from everything we started to where we just finished and see how much I just retained. I think I can do this. So, I'm here, here's, here we go. So, we have this roll-up centric roadmap of Ethereum. The optimistic roll-ups are, are well on their way. The ZK roll-ups are the, kind of, the newest frontier. Optimistic, the optimistic rolls are kind of competing on governance. The ZK roll-ups are the technology that we've been focusing on so far in this conversation. As the ZK roll-ups have matured, and again, that we have 4844, which is going to, like, take off the brakes for a lot of these things, which is how we entered this conversation.
The ZK roll-ups, like, ZK sync and Polygon, ZK tech, as well, is contributing to the ZK technology that, if the Ethereum layer one, will be able to extract the kernels of that technology and apply it to the layer one. And we are going to take the EVM, which is how Ethereum goes from block to block with execute new transactions. And we're going to turn that into a ZK EVM. And with further adaptations in cryptography, this Nova thing, again, there's another bankless episode for that. You combine that with the ZK EVM, and you kind of, like, shard computation. And so the ZK EVM, going from the Ethereum layer one EVM to a Ethereum layer one, ZK EVM, makes, like, proving blocks very, very simple and easy for the individual.
And then we can take that to step further, and we can take all of that proving and shard that out to many, many thousands of people. And so more people can participate in the proving of Ethereum. And the significance of this is that what we are doing is we are requiring fewer and fewer honest actors to make the Ethereum protocol work. And actors also can be devices too. And so the which devices can actually participate in making Ethereum function, honestly, that barrier becomes so low. And so, like, right now, there's a big, oh, there's always a conversation. It's like, how could Ethereum be stopped?
And at this point in time, too many devices have enough computational power to make Ethereum so decentralized that the answer of, like, how do you stop Ethereum is a similar question to, like, how do you stop water from flowing downstream? That was my summary of this. How was that? Perfect. Nice. Okay. Okay. So that was 4844. How, where did 4844 fit into that conversation? Because we started there, but does that really pertain to the ZK EVMing of the layer one, or is that more kind of a adjacent downstream of similar technologies? I think 4844 is kind of the initial motivation that got so many entrepreneurs and so much VC money to flow in to really push this technology development forward.
But yeah, we're going to reap the benefits as a community by having scaling in the short term. Like, initially, we were thinking of having, you know, these, these enshrined roll-ups, you know, so-called phase two in the roadmap much earlier on, and it would be done by Ragtag teams of developers that are not very well funded. There's not that many of them. And we would have never made it. So this was the correct strategic move to kind of open up, kind of slightly more of a commercial space, I guess. But, you know, we're going to go back full circle, and eventually we will have these, like, maximally credibly neutral and shrine roll-ups that have the exact same security properties as the Firmly one.
Okay. So with this conversation, I was trying to go short-middle long-term with the theorem roadmap, and it sounds like we did that specifically with roll-up technology. So we covered that vertical. So let's do that again with the next thing that I think is also in the short term roadmap, which is PBS, Proposar Builder Separation. So if you're a long-time analyst, you know what PBS is, but maybe we can start from the beginning, and what is in the short term for PBS, and then how does it extend into the future? Right. So one of the things that I expect in the short term is this concept of MEV rebates and optimal execution.
But right now, when you make a transaction on Ethereum, it goes to this public mempool, and basically you have, like, sharks eating at whatever flesh is available around that transaction, and it means that you don't have optimal execution. So for example, if you want to buy a token on Uniswap, you just don't get the optimal price. You lose a few percent. You get bit along the way. Right. And so there's this concept of an encrypted mempool, which gives you a rebate. So instead of publishing your transaction publicly, you publish it to this encrypted mempool. And the way that the rebate mechanism works is that you have so-called searchers, these sharks, that actually turn from bad guys to good guys.
So they try and identify all the flesh, and then they tell you, okay, here's all the flesh, you know, and they obviously pay you to put them to get the flesh. So they say, hey, here are your vulnerabilities. Here is where you are being an inefficient actor in your transaction. Here's where you're going to get arbitraged. Here's all your fleshy belly that you have exposed. I will pay you money to eat your belly. Yeah, I'll give you back all your flesh, except for a little bit. I'm taking a little bit. So the structure turns into a piranha, and you're like, you have one little nibble, and that's all you get.
Right. Exactly. And the reason why they only take a little bit is because it's a competitive market. The searchers are competing against Trevor to retire as much flesh as possible to do user. Piranhas are known to be cannibals. I actually don't know if that's known, but I think it's a good metaphor. So yeah, that's kind of in the short term. I mean, in a way, it's almost before PBS. It's like user facing, and it's going to happen in the wallets. One of the downsides today of this approach is that we don't really have the technology to make it trustless. And so what's happening is we have 10 different companies that are each offering their centralized trusted encrypted mempool.
And this, who are these companies? So there's flashboards, there's block natives, there's blocks route, there's many, many others. And so this actually makes it difficult for the wallets. So for example, Coinbase wallets and Metamask, they don't know which one to connect to. And so really the users are not reaping the benefit only the very advanced users who know that they need to point the RPC endpoints to some other encrypted mempool get the benefits. And really, most users are unsophisticated. They're not going to change the RPC endpoints. And so what we need right now in the short term is a standardization effort in order to get everyone on the same page.
And then there's also going to be a technology phase where we'll be able to have a trustless or at least a trust minimized encrypted mempool. And the way that I see it is as a progression of technology. We have centralized encrypted mempools. The next step is SGX, trusted hardware. And this is what flashboards is working on with Suave. The step after that is threshold encrypted mempools, where you're trusting a committee of semi-trusted entities to kind of decrypt the transactions after they've been confirmed. And then there's kind of the end game which is delay encryption. Where you're not trusting anyone, you're only using pure cryptography and physics.
And the way it works is that you encrypt your transaction. And then through time, the transaction automatically decrypts itself after a few seconds. And you can't accelerate the decryption because of the laws of physics. Okay. Going back to the same question of where are we on this between theoretical cool sci-fi idea and EIP that gets put into Ethereum? Where are we on this landscape? Right. So I think tomorrow after tomorrow there's going to be this event and this dinner around the standardization. Tomorrow is July 18th for the day of recording. So I think what's going to happen is some of the big wallet operators are going to come together with the searcher community and say, okay, we need to come to standards because the users are not making use of that.
And instead of an EIP is probably going to be an ERC. Okay. There's going to be some sort of community standard that's outside of consensus. That's going to emerge. Okay. So remind me again how this fits into the PBS conversation. I guess it's related to MEP. It's before the builders actually. It's actually at the searcher and user level. But the reason why I mentioned it is that it's the main thing that's coming in the short term. Okay. We'll define short term for me. Next, within the next 12 months. Next 12 months. Okay. And the PBS is PBS coming inside of 12 months. So we already have a form of PBS called left boost, which is like off-chain PBS.
Off-chain PBS. Yes. And PBS, if you had asked me a few weeks ago, I was very, very scared because there's kind of this monster update very similar to the merge. Let's just keep growing and growing in scope. But actually in the last few days, we realized that most of that can just go away. And there's this kind of this core PBS that we can incrementally upgrade over time. So that would be kind of a medium-term thing, let's say two to three years, where we deploy core PBS and then all the adjacent things like inclusion lists, for example. Okay. Are you a Metamask user? Well, you're listening to bank lists.
So, of course, you are. The wallet you know and love just got a whole lot better. Metamask Portfolio is the ultimate one-stop shop for all of your crypto-nates. It gives you a holistic view of your crypto portfolio across multiple chains and multiple addresses all at once. You can easily view and manage all your coins, tokens, and NFTs in one convenient place just by connecting your wallet. Metamask Portfolio goes beyond just viewing your portfolio, though. Inside the portfolio, you can do all the incredible money verbs that make DeFi so powerful. You can buy, swap, bridge, and stake your crypto assets with ease.
It's like having a powerful battle station for all your DeFi moves, right, at your fingertips. So, if you're looking to do more in Web 3, your way, Metamask Portfolio is the answer. I already know that you have Metamask wallet, so go check out your Metamask Portfolio. Learn more at metamask.io slash portfolio. Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web 3 ecosystem, all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network. A brand new high-performance Ethereum layer 2, built using the OP stack, but uses eigenlayers' data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer 1.
Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web 3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web 3 onboarded, like Game 7 for Web 3 gaming, and buy Bit for TVL and liquidity in on-rounds. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure, and decentralize Mantle.
If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Arbitrum is accelerating the Web 3 landscape with a suite of secure Ethereum scaling solutions. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum 1, with flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. Arbitrum Nova is quickly becoming a Web 3 gaming hub and social apps like Reddit are also calling Arbitrum home. And now, Arbitrum Orbit allows you to use Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own layer 3, giving you access to interoperable, customizable permissions with dedicated throughput.
Whether you are a developer, enterprise, or a user, Arbitrum Orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible. Faster transaction speeds and significantly lower capacities. So visit Arbitrum.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first app with Arbitrum. Experience Web 3 development the way it was always meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. All right, so that's that's the PBS.
Now, Justin keeps on talking about encryption, so I'll throw him an underhandy. He's like, okay, but I can talk about ZK snarking that, or I can talk about encrypting that. So that's PBS and 4844. If you like, we've covered those pretty well. Well, one big thing around PBS is kind of the end game, which is MEV Burn. Okay, let's go there. Let's go there, because Justin, you had to talk yesterday about MEV Burn. Of course, we had that fantastic, bankless episode. Yeah, place us in history around MEV Burn, where is that coming and when is that coming? Right, so one of the dependencies that MEV Burn is in trying PBS, and inclusion lists is actually a requirement, and the reason is that MEV Burn is very opinionated.
It says that we will only include on Ethereum the most valuable blocks and nothing else. And so the most valuable blocks as defined by the free market, because the free market is the thing that comes to Ethereum and says, I will pay this much money for this block. Exactly. So the free market determines what is the most valuable block, but that has a down, well, it has actually upsides with sensitive resistance, but it also has a downside, which is now that there's a very clear price that you can pay to actually censor transactions. And if you just keep on paying this price, which is very, very high, but nonetheless, it's a possibility, you can just keep on censoring this transaction.
So if you're willing to pay, let's say, you know, one if per block or ten if per block, you can just censor transactions indefinitely. And we're burning that ether. We're burning that ether. So for a very, very high price of burning a lot of ether, you are allowed to censor transactions. Exactly. Yes. And but we don't like that. And so I know, I know, I know, I know, we like ether burn, but we don't like censorship, we'll take censorship resistance over ether burn. Okay. So there's some individuals out there, some stakers, for example, Vitalik, who just doesn't run MEV boost. He says, okay, I'm just going to build like dumb blocks that are not optimal, but at least we have sensitive resistance.
And so everyone's in the while, you know, Vitalik will be building the block. And then if it so happens that the center transactions, Vitalik will include them. But we don't want to be relying on altruism. We want, you know, it to be incentive compatible. And inclusionless makes it incentive compatible. It's basically a way to get censor transactions on chain to force them on chain without having to pay any financial penalty. So you get both the optimal block that the market gives you and you get sensitive resistance. And again, where is this in the roadmap? So I would say, you know, four or five years, because first we need EPS and then we also need inclusion list.
And then finally, MEV burn. Tim, I just want to throw to you like thoughts and reflections around like the holistic conversation that we've been having. I mean, I don't think I have anything to add on MEV burn and and ZK ZK and EVM and L2s. I think the other big part is the whole stateless bucket. Yeah, I don't know if you want to go there now, but yeah, so that's probably the other big incentive incompatibility in Ethereum now. So we have, so just for background for the listeners, the Ethereum state is all the addresses, all the contracts, all the data and the contracts. And it's the size of Ethereum.
Right. But just the current. So it's your balance at this block, not your balance, you know, a year ago. So everyone's balanced, everyone's NFTs, all the Uniswap pools, all that stuff. The working memory of Ethereum. Yeah, yeah, basically, you can think of it as like the RAM of Ethereum. And the problem is that writing to the state is like a one time cost, you know, you pay to do this, but then like nodes need to literally sort this forever. Histories, there's things you can do. You can just literally not store it and just verify that, you know, at this point, the history was correct and really deleted.
But the state, you need to know, because it's like, I need to know that your balance and this account is like this many. And ideally, we would like to bound this in a way so that as Ethereum grows as there's more users, it doesn't become like unmanageable to keep everyone's balances. And so the idea with stateless is to move to a world where the average node does not store the entire state, only like high powered builders have to store them. And when they produce a block, they produce a proof of the state changes that sort of only gives you, you know, the changes that happen in this block. And you can verify that like this is actually correct and, you know, no protocol rules are broken.
The challenge of getting there is today we store all the Ethereum data in a tree called the Miracle Patricia tree. It sort of looks like a Christmas tree. So it's like very like long and narrow. And so making your proof, you sort of have to go from the top all the way down. And those are like big proofs that gossip over the network. So what we'd like to do is move Ethereum's tree from looking like a Christmas tree. They're looking more like a bush, which is like wide and short. And then the proofs become just again, from the top to the bottom, like much smaller. And so this is probably one of the next big things we'll be working on after this then Cune upgrade is transitioning the tree like the database structure of Ethereum from one to the other so that we can eventually have the notes not store all the state.
So to put this in terms of computational resources, right now you need a Raspberry Pi for the computation, but you also need this pretty large hard drive. You need about a terabyte or two. And so statelessness is a way to remove the hard drive. And you can think of it as being an intermediary step to full ZKVM. It's kind of halfway through where you remove the Raspberry Pi itself and then you now you just replace it with a with a small watch. So the understanding some of the connections here, I think these things start to weave together. But we started with talking about with the roll up centric roadmap and how that turned into the ZKVM on the layer one and then try and roll ups.
And that's with the ZK technology, which is cryptography. Then the next thing that we talked about is encrypted mempulse, right, which is also cryptography. And then now we're talking about stateless clients, which is like pruning a lot of data with cryptography. It seems to be like and Justin, there's a line that you said once upon a time that really stuck with me. I think it's on your very first podcast episode that we did, which is if you can't do something with cryptography, do it with crypto economics, but if you can do it with cryptography, do it with cryptography. Exactly. And it seems like these all of these three tracks of Ethereum's roadmap seems to be very, very heavily focused on cryptography.
You have a comment on that. Exactly. I mean, in all three cases, we're starting with kind of the the economic side of things and then we kind of incrementally upgrade with cryptography. If you take the EVM, we just went through the economic way of everyone needs to pay the cost of doing the verification. And then we removed this trust assumption that none of this majority is all agreeing on the state. And the same with the encrypted mempulse, we're starting with totally centralizing cryptography mempulse and then we make them trustless. Yeah, that is the theme. And one of the amazing things I didn't even realize it was possible until a few weeks ago, we can completely solve safety of blockchains with cryptography.
So there's two things that consensus traditionally solve is safety and liveliness. And one of the aspects of safety is this thing where you can revert finality. So right now, today, we have this notion of economic finality. It's a very, very strong notion, which says that if you have two inconsistent financial checkpoints, meaning you had a checkpoint that was finalized and then it got kind of reverted and you got another financial checkpoint. One third of the valid data will get slashed. One third of all state eth will be burnt, which is building the dollars. Yeah, something like 13 billion dollars.
And so it probably won't happen. But it turns out that with pure cryptography, you can have perfect finality, which is impossible with the laws of physics and cryptography. And the key unlock was quantum mechanics, which was a big surprise to me because for the last five years, we've been doing research on defending against quantum computers. But now we can actually leverage their power, their very unique properties to be constructive about it. And the key primitive that I'm looking at right now is called one-shot signatures, which was discovered in 2020. There is this amazing paper which kind of pretty much went unnoticed for three years.
But it solves finality. It gives us perfect finality. Another consequence is that we can reduce the threshold for finality from 66% to 51%. It solves trustless delegation, meaning that we can have protocols like LIDO and rocket pool that have no trust whatsoever in operators that don't need any collateral. And it potentially also solves restaking. It also gives us this notion of quantum money, which is a way to do the lightning network without routing. So one of the big complications, the lightning network, is that you need to find this route of channels between the sender and the recipient. And more often than not that's just going to not be enough liquidity in those channels.
Whereas with quantum money, you just need one hop and you don't need these channels with liquidity. And then kind of another kind of crazy application is proof of location, where because you have these keys that are unclonable, you can prove to the world that you're in a specific geographical location using latency and the speed of light. So the way that one-shot signatures, so what they are is basically a way to have a private key which can only sign a single message and then it destroys itself. How does it work? Sorry, it's a quantum innovation. Yes, it's quantum computing that we're talking about.
Yes, it's a quantum innovation. And there's two key properties of quantum mechanics that we're leveraging here. The first one is no cloning. So your secret key is an unknown superposition of state. And you can prove that it's unclonable. So you can't have two copies of it. And then the second property of quantum mechanics is the destructivity of measurement. Once you measure the private key, which you need to do the signing, it collapses the state effectively destroying it, meaning that you can't sign a second message. So quantum, the word quantum, it starts to get, like people will probably perceive that be like it's so far out there that it's so abstract.
But this is not a, this is not a research and development problem anymore. This is just like, we just have to build it, correct? It's a known quantity. No, it's very much R&D. But we know it's possible, right? It's not like the radical. We have a possibility result, and now, you know, confidence shoots up to actually do the R&D. Okay, right, right, right. That's what I mean. This is a sure thing. We know that it works. We know that it works this way. Now we just have to build it. Exactly. And now it's possible in theory. Now we can just go ahead and try and build in practice. And, you know, in the very, very long term, maybe 30, 40 years, we can have one shot signatures at the layer one.
But the cool thing is that these things can provide a ton of value outside of consensus. And we don't need, you know, many quantum creatures. We just need one. Because now we have this one entity that, you know, we can delegate to, and we know for sure that they're not going to rug us. And so they're kind of this trustless quantum entity. And so the, just again, a single shot signature, like, there's that old Call of Duty game, one, one in the chamber. You have one bullet in the chamber. As soon as you fire it, it's all you got like, you throw it away. And so they're like disposable addresses that only have one signature.
And I think what you're saying is that the assurances that you get from one single address only being able to sign one transaction once or one signature once provide, like opens up a world of new use cases that provides a lot of trustlessness. Exactly. Now traditionally, you could do these one shot signatures with trusted hardware. But that kind of sucks. You want to do it with pure cryptography. And for a very long time, I didn't think it was possible. But it is. Cool. Okay. Again, again, on the theme of Ethereum has a lot of cryptography in its roadmap. There's one thing I want to touch on that I want to go back to talking about statelessness.
When we have stateless Ethereum, how does that change how Ethereum is expressed? Like from the end users, like what does it mean? It's due to Ethereum. Like what can we unlock with that? I want to make sure I round out that conversation. So the biggest, I guess if you think of the end users as a person sent into transaction, hopefully nothing. Okay. So if you're using a wallet sending a transaction, hopefully nothing changes. And that's good in terms of just UX. If you're running a node, the idea is that the amount of disk paste that you need doesn't grow to infinity. And if you think of it like, you know, through the economics angle, this is like the last broken thing on Ethereum in a way where you pay once and then you get the like be on everyone's hard drive forever.
So this allows kind of the economics to match this where like we can decide that only the block builders need to keep the full state. You can keep a copy. So you know, say that you have all these like balances and all these contracts that you're in. You could have your own like local copy of just like David's stuff or just Justin's stuff. But you don't impose that cost on everyone. And so that means that like yeah, running a node, you know that you're never going to need like a terabyte of RAM or a terabyte of like or an ever growing amount of storage just to keep up with not even the chain history with what's on the network today.
I think a big theme of the Ethereum roadmap has always been about sustainability. Like how do we make this thing sustainable? And that's been about like, hey, let's go from proof of work to proof of state because proof of state is more efficient. It makes this system more sustainable. And then the whole state growth side of Ethereum is this conversation. Like I remember throughout 2017 through 2020, we were all bullied by the Bitcoiners because they said that we could never run a Ethereum node and that our state growth or the Ethereum node would run to too many terabytes. Turns out that never happened.
But also we had the solution always in the back pocket, which was statelessness. And so what you're saying, Tim is like, when you make a transaction, that is data that goes on to the Ethereum blockchain, that grows the size of the Ethereum blockchain. And I have to pay one gas fee. And then every node across the the world has to download my data and store it forever. And so that is not sustainable because it's one cost for one person once. And then it's also a one cost for every node operator now until the end of time. Like it's just unbalanced. Exactly. Yeah. And so this makes this more sustainable because of statelessness, you can prune the blockchain and still have complete trustlessness.
And it's not even when you say the blockchain, just to be clear, it's not like the past history, the past blocks. It's like you, David, can prune everyone except yourself. Right. But then if you get a block, if I make a transaction in the block, there's just a little proof attached that says, hey, Tim actually had the one that he spends or the one NFT that he sold. Right. Yeah. The this is I love how this is all cryptography based one theme about cryptography that I think if listeners aren't familiar with, we should 100% pull out is that it shifts power to the individual. It fundamentally makes individuals have the same amount of capabilities as large scale institutions.
And so while we're talking like while it's cool that all of these themes that we're talking about on the Ethereum Robap is like, here's what we can do with cryptography. I bet if we ran back this conversation, we could do it again through the lens of, and this is how it benefits the individual. This is how it protects the individual and elevates the individual to be a first-class citizen no matter what their resources are. That's my intuition here. Right. And one of the few things that doesn't use cryptography is the monetary policy. And the word sustainability here is just so important. And kind of you mentioned Bitcoin as it is kind of ironic because their monetary policy is just not sustainable because it doesn't provide this guaranteed security.
And so the way that I see the kind of end game for the monetary policy of Ethereum is kind of this two-phase component that are summarized as sustainability. On the one hand, we have minimal viable issuance, which means that we have also perhaps maximally sustainable issuance. Sure, because it's not unnecessary dilutive, and it gives us the security that we need. And then on the other hand, we kind of have the maximum viable burn. So whatever economic value that is being provided on Ethereum, we get to capture it as a community. And it started with EIP1559, where we basically, the network is able to capture congestion fees.
The next step is MEV burn, where we can capture the value from contention. Basically, transactions contending to be at the very top of the block. And then the final the final thing is restaking yield, which it turns out we can also burn. And so in a way, the minimum viable issuance, we've reached the end game with the proof of stake and the merge. But the burn, we actually only in one of three phases. Okay, so the economics of Ethereum is going to say the same as a meme, like we've gotten there, like we were at the minimally sustainable issuance, but maximally sustainable issuance, or yeah, but we get to improve upon it across many more vectors to make it even better.
Right, exactly. Specifically on the value capture part of it. Just in Tim, this has been a great exploration into this sci-fi future of Ethereum. So thank you for helping me navigate. I think I learned a ton, and I'm sure the bank list nation has as well. Thank you. Have a nice. Yeah, thanks. Merci. Merci. If there's any information or people, like where should people point to if they want to learn more? Twitter. So how much you want to learn? Just lots of updates. Twitter's probably a good place. If you actually want to work on this, the Ethereum R&D discord is a great place. E3 searches as well.
Just show up there in one of the threads, and yeah, you'll get to work with Justin. Yeah, you can reach me on Twitter. I have opened DMs, and more often than not, I'll reply to questions. But there's a bold commitment. One thing that I do enjoy as well is just random people telling me, oh, hey, I've heard about this one shot signatures. And actually, I just had lunch with someone who came to me. And so if you are interested in this cool technology, do, do, do, do reach me out. All right. We will put all of their Twitter's in the show on this bank list nation. You guys know the deal. Crypto is risky.
Ethereum is risky. DeFi is risky. Probably cryptography might be the less risky thing that we do, but also perhaps not. I don't know. You can lose what you put in. We are headed west as a frontier, and it's not for everyone, but we're glad you are with us on the bank list journey. Thanks a lot.