Binance listing fees, finally out in the open. CJ Hetherington, Founder of Limitless, published the offer he received after no NDA. 8% of total token supply and $250k. We dig into why the founders accept deals like this, the hidden sell pressure, and how onchain price discovery can replace CEX gatekeeping. CJ also breaks down Limitless on Base, instant-settlement price markets, and the path to Coinbase via Aerodrome.
------
📣IMMUNEFI | CRYPTO SECURITY OS
https://bankless.cc/Immunefi
------
BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🪙FRAXNET | MINT, REDEEM, EARN
https://bankless.cc/fraxnet
🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN
https://bankless.cc/unichain
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR L2 NETWORK
https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🌳KGEN | REQUEST A DEMO
https://bankless.cc/KGEN-podcast
💠BIT DIGITAL ($BTBT) | ETH TREASURY
https://bankless.cc/bit-digital
We’re being compensated by Bit Digital (NASDAQ BTBT) for this segment promoting their company and BTBT. The compensation is paid in cash as a one time payment. You can find additional information about Bit Digital and BTBT on their Investor page at https://bit-digital.com/investors
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Centralized Exchange Listing Fees
3:08 The Binance Drama Unfolds
3:41 Introducing Limitless
5:00 Conversation with CJ
15:28 The Hidden Costs of Listing Fees
25:17 The Future of Onchain Markets
28:44 Building on Base
32:39 Limitless: A New Prediction Market
43:43 Exploring Limitless Features
53:10 User-Generated Markets & Censorship
1:06:10 How to Engage with Limitless
------
RESOURCES
CJ
https://x.com/cjhtech
Limitless
https://x.com/trylimitless
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Welcome to Bankless, where today we are talking about centralized exchange token listing fees. There has been some drama on the crypto twitter timeline as it relates to probably one of the more important subjects when it comes to the release and liquidity found around tokens, newly launched tokens. This drama got started when the founder of a prediction market project on base released the details of an offering that he claimed he got from Binance about the token listing fees for what it would be required for to launch his token on Binance. This token doesn't exist yet, but it's in the project of a TGE.
And apparently, the token listing team at Binance sent this individual, this founder, CJ, who you're going to hear from on the podcast today. They sent him their offer of, this is what it takes to get listed on Binance. And they did that before they sent him an NDA. And so he just released the offer on Twitter. Now, everyone knows that there are centralized exchange listing fees and everyone has murmured about the gargantuan take rate that Binance charges startups about their tokens. If you want to get listed on Binance, this is what you have to pay. I don't think these deals are cookie cutter.
I think every deals kind of made based on the facts and circumstances of the project. But broadly, people understand these things to be very, very large. We've never really gotten confirmation or details or like explicit truth about what a deal like this looks like because no one has released this information. But it seems like because of a slip up on the Binance side, the NDA was not sent. Therefore, this individual was free to disclose on Twitter in public what exactly that deal was. And the deal was egregious. This particular startup for for limitless CJ was charged 8% of the total token supply in $250,000.
That was the offer. CJ sounds like he's not taking it. And instead, he just took that offer to Twitter and be like, look Twitter, look what they are asking for, which is kind of egregious. Now, plenty of founders have taken this bet. And I asked CJ why he thinks that is. Why give 8% of your total token supply up to Binance. And the calculus behind that. And the conversation is pretty important. CJ seems like he's a pretty big on-chain Maxi. And things that like, well, so Binance really need to be charging these things. And this is even good for founders at all. And if you are a founder that believes in your project, why would you give up 8%?
And he does illuminate that the calculus does shift if you're a founder who doesn't believe in your project. And you are trying to join Binance and kind of just getting cashed out. Overall, that's kind of the theme of the drama on crypto Twitter over the last 48 hours. If you go on to crypto Twitter, CZ and Binance are explicitly naming this startup founder kind of a big PR mistake from Binance. And it's like the 800 pound gorilla in the room who owns all the liquidity kind of going after the startup founder on base. And so entertaining at the very least. And I think this is also a very important discussion for liquidity and fees when it comes to startup founders trying to find liquidity for their new token to attract investments.
Pretty important conversation. I think CZ does a great job giving his perspective as a founder and just giving his advice to other founders in this space who are also going like him going through some of these conversations. So before we get into the conversation with CJ and in addition to everything I just said, we're also going to talk about limitless his prediction market startup on base. We're going to talk to some of our friends and sponsors over at Immunify, one of the most trusted brands in Web 3 security, they're a security company that helps secure over $180 billion in value from different apps that they secure.
They've averted over $25 billion in hack damage over across 650 leading Web 3 protocols. And they are delivering the first security operating system for the on chain economy. It's designed to deliver complete on chain security in just a single command center. So Immunify's edge comes from advantages that no one else can replicate. Distribution, data and trust. Immunify already protects the core infrastructure crypto Ethereum, Optimism, Chainlink, Arbachon, Bitcoin, and a hundred other protocols. And Immunify AI is powered by the largest data set of real-world exploits, bug reports, and mitigations in crypto.
Every new security event improves Immunify's intelligence creating compounding advantages that drives sharper detection, faster response, and proactive defense. There is a link in the show on us for you to get your app protected if you have an app that has customer deposits. You need protection. Don't go without protection. And so there's a link in the show on us for you to learn more about Immunify. With that, let's go ahead and get right into the conversation with CJ. I'm here with CJ from the limitless prediction market, CJ. How are you doing, man? Hey, David, how are you? Thanks a lot for having me on the show.
You are the main character today. At least over the last 48 hours on crypto Twitter. How do you feel? I definitely don't want to be the main character, so that's necessarily a bullish signal. Maybe that means I should tone it down a whole bit. Okay, so for listeners who aren't on crypto Twitter, there's been an ongoing conversation about the role that centralized exchanges have in providing liquidity to tokens, especially when it comes to listing fees. And this concept of centralized exchange listing fees has kind of been this like nebulous topic that no one has ever been really able to define because no one knows what the true listing fees are.
And Jesse from base will go on Twitter and say Coinbase has no listing fees and then representatives from Binance will be like Binance has no listing fees. But then in the background, anyone who's ever talked to a founder is like, oh, yeah, centralized exchanges have totally have listing fees. When Jesse from base says that, I kind of believe him. I don't really have that same sort of relationship with Binance or I don't really know anyone in the Binance world, but like everyone, everyone talks about the magnitude of Binance's listing fees. But no one has ever been able to put numbers behind them.
What are these things? What are the actual fees? Now, the story as I understand at CJ is that you have a startup. It's limitless. We're going to talk about limitless prediction market on base. And you are exploring your TGE, future incoming token, a sale round was going around on Kido. And so I would imagine you talked to Binance about like, hey, what about getting my future incoming token listed on Binance? And it sounds like as I understand it, they sent you the listing fee information, but they forgot to send you the NDA that would legally bind you to not disclose the listing fee information.
And so then you just put it out onto a tweet. And everyone on crypto Twitter was like, we finally have the numbers. And the numbers were like egregious. It was like 8% of the total supply of the tokens, plus like a quarter million dollars fee on top of that. And so finally, for the first time, we were able to like look at these numbers and be like 8% of a total supply of a project. Holy hell, that is a lot. I'll pause there and give you the microphone in case I got anything wrong. In case you want to add any color to that. But I think on behalf of the crypto industry, I think everyone is kind of like, hey, thanks for publishing, for posting that information.
Do you have any color you want to add to that? Yeah. So I mean, the first thing I would love to say is I really respect CZ and I really respect Binance. And you know, I really hope that this is a window for not only Binance, but for centralized exchanges in general to be open to construct a feedback from the community. Like yes, I'm a builder, but before I was a builder, I was a community member. And I think it's very important that this feedback is heard by centralized exchanges. And I think it's very important that if centralized exchanges want to exist five years from now, that they, you know, really take heat and start to adopt, you know, more sustainable and fair and equitable models.
In terms of the situation, like what happened, I mean, in terms of the end, all of that. Well, FOMO is, you know, I mean, you probably understand a lot about this, in your capacity as a venture investor. FOMO is a very interesting emotion that drives us to do very wild and unprecedented things. And I mean, during the token 2049 was very wild time for limitless. I mean, coming from like six months ago where almost nobody wanted to fund us. And I was, you know, having a very hard time trying to secure funding for the future of the company to like right now, you know, we had our Kaito cell, which was like 200 X over subscribe, like 200 million in community pledges.
And then also venture funding round that was like 2.5 X over subscribed as well. And so I think that, you know, I didn't apply for any Binance listing. I didn't submit any due diligence forms. I think usually what happens is projects engage Binance through their listing application or through their due diligence form channels. And if I'm not mistaken, as part of the due diligence forms, there are some kind of like confidentiality clauses or something like that. But the situation between Binance and limitless unfolded a little bit differently. And I would say was probably driven by FOMO in that, you know, exchanges are, you know, looking to list tokens that generate, you know, demand and trading fees for them naturally, right?
And so I think they were potentially like just excited and open to work with limitless. And that's why, you know, we kind of have this situation where the proposal was shared without, you know, any confidentiality agreement in place. Now, I don't actually be grouch. You know, Binance for doing that, in a way, I actually respect their hustle. Like, you know, we're all, we're a startup, right? We appreciate like moving fast. And, you know, not getting tight up in like red tape and like corporate processes. So I appreciate actually that they did that. And I think the reason it's not right to say that, you know, this information has never been made public before just because of confidentiality agreements.
I also would say that, you know, and this is something that, you know, we maybe don't want to admit, you know, necessarily, but it's not only centralized exchanges that are at fault here, right? I mean, there are also a lot of founders and market makers who have kind of been part of this process and part of this, like, you know, manipulation and extraction games. And I think like this is kind of, you know, a well-kept secret in a way that this is how these things work and how they operate and how they play out. But honestly, limitless is not really interested in that. And, you know, we're not in the space for that.
And I think, you know, you're the same as Oz in that way in that, you know, we're building on-chain apps and marketplace is because we believe in the power of them and what they can actually do. And we don't think that like, you know, giving away a huge percentage of supply and rationalizing that with kind of a mega dump on retail, essentially the best way to move this industry forward. And probably that's why, you know, we've been able to share this information. I really hope that, you know, this is a turning point for the whole space. And like I said, you know, I really respect CZ and Binance for everything they've done so far.
But the current status quo, if we want to make it as an industry, my opinion is not good enough. And we need to level up. And, you know, at limitless, we have a very like open, hard feedback culture. I mean, with each other, with my co-founder is with our team. And that's, you know, what helps us to improve and get better. And this is something that we would like to see applied more broadly to the industry, especially when, you know, essentially, you know, real hard-wearing people with skin in the game that we're talking about here. Yeah, it's probably worth highlighting why this fee is allowed to exist in the first place and why founders historically have taken this fee.
Whereas just like, you know, liquidity on Binance, which is also, you know, distribution, distribution for your token is incredibly valuable. It can add tens, hundreds, perhaps even a billion dollars of market cap onto a project. And so, you know, what's 8% of a sacrifice if you're going to add 100 plus million dollars to your potential market cap? Granted, it might be a deal with a double over the long term, but like so many founders are trying to just go from zero to one. And maybe they think that that 8% token supply listing fee to Binance is the way to just like, to get ahead. And also, to Binance's credit, like as you've highlighted, you know, Binance as a single institution has probably brought more people into crypto than anyone, anyone ever, not even close.
And so, you know, they have helped grow the industry, distribute the industry, make the industry safe, you know, haven't lost any customers funds. And so, like, we could go on and on and on about the value that Binance has brought to the table for the industry, which is why they can say, hey, like, 8% is the entry fee of your total supply of your token. That's illustrative of the value that they are bringing to the table. I think what we are thinking now is like the value is starting to flip and it's starting to be more extractive than what should be fair. And perhaps one of the reasons why this open secret has remained, you know, pretty well behind, like, we knew as an industry that these fees exist, didn't really know about them in detail.
And like, why is that true? Well, Binance has no incentive to illustrate how much of a fee that they are taking, how much cream they are just cutting off the top. Founders probably don't want to disclose that they gave 8% to Binance. Like, they did that. Like, that's kind of like, you know, they just don't want no one in the inner circle like market makers, they don't want to talk about how much of the share of the token that they received either. No one wants to really reveal these details. It's not in anyone's best interest. And so, this secret kind of just stays quiet, stays a little bit mum, even though everyone on the outside kind of knows the contours, the loose cuprod contours of what is happening.
No one really knows. And no one's really incentivized to kind of like give up these details. CJ, when you posted the tweet with like kind of line items of just like one percent of tokens go to this, one percent of tokens go to that, $250,000 goes here. I'm assuming they gave you an actual document. Why not actually just release a document itself? Well, I did in the end, I did in the end share that it was in a telegram group chat, it's really a very very crypto native way of sharing your proposal. And by the way, I do believe that there was room to negotiate. And that there was also was expressed.
So potentially, the deal terms could have been improved somehow. I think that centralize exchanges almost rely on the fact that a lot of founders are not very familiar or very well versed in liquid markets. And they kind of use that through their advantage. And I would even go as far as saying that the way the proposal is structured, it's kind of inherently pretty confusing. You have to just kind of sit for a minute and understand exactly like, okay, there is this percentage there, there is that percentage there, then there is a cash feed, then there is security deposit, and kind of piece it all together.
And I would probably suggest that that is also kind of intentional. And I think that a lot of founders actually don't know what they're getting into with the kind of deals that they make with centralize exchanges. And like, you know, they just probably assume like, okay, that's like what it costs. And you know, that's it. We actually, you know, we want to go with a different approach. You know, we believe in like unchained capital markets, unchained capital formation in community building, and kind of driving acquisition and activation of our product through skin in the game and co-ownership the community.
And we think that, you know, centralize exchanges need to, you know, if they want to, you know, last, they have to become a gateway for the unchained world. And not just can it be this almost gatekeeper, right, which is, you know, using, you know, this, this floor to extract Max Mullian, you know, like the situation that just happened with this like cascading like liquidation event. I mean, it's impossible to blame anyone directly for that. But I don't believe that that was kind of healthy or ordinary market activity. You know, in some cases, like liquidity was completely vanished from different artifacts.
And I think that there was pure market manipulation. And it was a pure, orchestrated assault on retail. And, you know, there was the case where hyper liquid has been reported as having the most liquidations in terms of like dollar amount. But it's also kind of, you know, another well-kept secret that centralize exchanges on the report, their liquidations for the sake of like community sentiment. And I truly think that moving these markets on chain makes them more transparent and makes them more, more fair and equitable by default. And that's actually what people even and why we're here. We don't just want to recreate the same wall gardens from the traditional financial system, but throwing a few blockchain calls here and there because that doesn't actually meaningfully upgrade anyone's life or the underlying infrastructure.
Yeah. And really just to add on to that, you know, Binance has a number of like trophies, like relics, like golden goose is that they get just because of how dominant they are. Like 80, 85 percent of like total volumes are on Binance's spot volumes and also dribbed of volumes. And when that happens, like there are just like a number of like second third order consequences effects that Binance gets to enjoy. One, being the very high token listing fees, like if you have all the liquidity, you could charge very high fees. Two, a lot of like startups and even like a theory in protocol development considers like sex, sex, arbitrage.
Like what that really means is like the price on Binance versus the price on Uniswap. And we are considering the price on Binance versus the price on Uniswap. When we think about when when Cerella Labs thinks about how to design their decks or, you know, uni chain is thinking about TEEs and going at like 200 millisecond blocks to go very, very fast. All of this, many of much of this is motivated by the fact that Binance has pricing power. Like price discovery of Bitcoin, of ETH, of any material asset happens on Binance because it doesn't happen on chain. And like where are tokens getting listed and where are fees being paid?
Being paid to Binance because that's where liquidity is because it's not on chain. And so like in 2025, the year of our Lord 2025, like centralized exchanges still have so much bargaining power because price discovery and liquidity is on Binance. It's not even like a sex versus decks illustration like if Binance went away, would it go to Coinbase? Maybe. But it's really just like Binance versus like, I mean they have Binance chain. But even Binance chain doesn't have the volumes that Binance has. So like price discovery moving away from Binance and centralized exchanges and formulating on chain is just good for everyone because then the whole system is auditable.
The whole system is transparent. What are hyper liquids listing fees? Pretty sure it's zero. In fact, I think you actually can get paid to list the tokens because you get some of the trading fees. And that's like, that's what we're here to do. That's like, yeah, you like you should get paid to list your token, not the other way around because that's the nature of what on chain is. Like there are so many different on chain applications that should be competing for CJ for you to like list your token on hyper liquid or base or whatever. There's no question there. But like, what are your sentiments about that?
Yeah, for sure. I think that like fundamentally all markets will move on chain. Of course, I'm excited about prediction markets. But I'm also excited about like part markets as well. I think they're a great way to continuously price real low assets as well as crypto assets. And yeah, I think we're really at a turning point. And I think centralized exchanges like Coinbase, are kind of, you know, making really like welcome steps forward here because, you know, doing things like putting airdrome inside of their man application and giving users access to like Bitcoin lending that's built until we're with DeFi protocol.
I think this is very much the way that the world is going. And I think it's it's very much like kind of general border or get left behind kind of situation for a lot of the current incumbents. And also, I mean, in terms of, you know, what you mentioned with with Binance having a monopoly on all, I mean, I would also take a look at the Korean exchanges, like, you know, a bit in bid home. I think that there is also a lot of users in career who actually don't use Binance. I think from our Kaito sale, around 30 or more than 30, 35 million of the total pledges actually came from career, which was, you know, the largest for any single jurisdiction.
And so there were a lot of users, retail users and retail flow in regions like Korea who don't even use Binance. And I'm not sure the market share is 80 or 90% at least for perps, I think it's more like 60%. I haven't initially checked it recently. I know hyper liquid has been doing a really good job. But I think in general, you know, like you mentioned arbitrage because you have like very much kind of perennial principles here where a small number of customers drive the majority of like volume and revenue. Like jump is like 15 million dollars per day in these different exchanges or something like that.
Obviously, they're making way more than that, but also like one of the core ways that they monetize is from trading like spreads across different exchanges, right? And so I think that's why we always kind of do see multiple venues emerge with deep and comparable liquidity and open interest. And I do think that, you know, as more and more retail flow and attention actually comes on chain, which is very much bottleneck by, you know, like regional regulations and like unwrapping infrastructure and stuff like that. I think as these kind of barriers are slowly broken down, we're going to see more and more users on chain.
And we're going to see, you know, less and less need for these gatekeepers. And that's what I'm like deeply excited about. And yeah, I just hope that exchanges, not only climate, but other major exchanges can also be like open to this constructive feedback and can embrace the on-chain world and the kind of revolution, I would say, which is happening. Introducing at Frax USD, the genius aligned digital dollar from Frax. It's a secure, stable, and fully backed by institutional grade real world assets, custodyed by BlackRock, SuperStay, and Fidelity. It's always redeemable one-to-one, transparently audited, and built for payments, DeFi, and banking.
The best of all worlds. At the core is FraxNet, an on-chain FinTech platform built to align with emerging US regulatory frameworks where you can mint, redeem, and use Frax USD with just a few clicks. Deposit USDC, send a bank wire, or tokenize treasuries, and receive programmable digital dollars straight to your wallet. FraxNet users benefits from the underlying return of US treasuries and earn just by using the system. Whether you're bridging, minting, or holding, your Frax USD works for you. Frax isn't just a protocol, it's a digital nation powered by the Frax token and governed by its global communities.
Join that community and help shape Frax Nation's future by going to Frax.com slash r slash bankless. Frax, designed for the future of compliant digital finance. Bit digital, ticker, BT, BT is a publicly traded ETH Treasury company that combines the two biggest metas of our time, Ethereum and AI compute. Bit digital believes that ETH will power finance, and AI compute will power everything. Bit digital gives you direct exposure to both. Bit digital holds more than 150,000 ETH with institutional great staking and validator operations. On top of that, the company owns roughly 73% of white fiber, an AI infrastructure business that runs high performance of GPU data centers that has a meaningful exposure to the growth of AI compute with over 27 million shares.
This is an ETH Treasury backed by real operations designed to capture staking yield today while positioning for the future of intelligent computing tomorrow. The ticker is BT, BT. This ad is not financial advice. Do your own research, learn more about Bit digital and try their MNAF calculator at bit-digital.com. That's bit-hyphen-digital.com. Bankless is being compensated by Bit digital for this ad. You can find out more information by clicking the link in the show notes. Ethereum's layer 2 universe is exploding with choices, but if you're looking for the best place to park and move your tokens, make your next stop, Unichain.
First, liquidity. Unichain hosts the most liquid Uniswap V4 deployment on any layer 2, giving you deeper pools for flagship pairs like ETH USDC. More liquidity means better prices, less slippage, and smoother swaps, exactly what traders crave. The numbers back it up. Unichain leads all layer 2s in total value log for Uniswap V4, and it's not just a D. It's fast and fully transparent, purpose-built to be the home-based for DeFi and cross-chain liquidity. When it comes to costs, Unichain is a no-brainer. Transaction fees come in about 95% cheaper than Ethereum maintenance, slashing the price of creating or accessing liquidity.
Want to stay in the loop on Unichain? Visit Unichain.org or follow at Unichain on X for all the updates. Are you worried at all, CJ, that you kind of have kicked the hornet's nest? There's an 800-pound gorilla and it's called Binance. Now Binance doesn't like you. They've made some PR blenders along this path here, but none the less. You've picked a fight with CZ. You've picked a fight with Binance. Does that scare you at all? Like I say, I really respect CZ and Binance for everything they've done off of space. 800-pound gorilla fighting with anyone. Generally, it's not a good look for the 800-pound gorilla.
I probably would not recommend to keep engaging because I don't think that it has gone so well so far. Your limit list is built on base. In your tweet where you disclosed all of the deal structure for the Binance listing fees, you concluded with, and this is why I build on base, throwing a very favorable bone to Coinbase and base and Jesse. Can you just illustrate that? Give that a little bit more color. What's it been like being a builder on base? Yeah, even if we abstract away all of the context and absolutely everything else, and I just compare the experience of what Coinbase would ask for for a listing of what Binance typically asks for, that was just a pure comparison that I wanted to make.
I know that there have been some tweets online like the Andre Cronge from Year in One or X Year in Rather that was saying that Coinbase had charged in millions back in the day and then you also have people saying that they were listed on Binance for free and all of that. I think that probably both of those instances are actually true. I think we're just saying that probably that is true. Why would we give you 8% of our tokens? In terms of base, they've been really supportive for projects that are building natively on base and we've kind of seen this pathway where you have the error drone, on-chain launch, price discovery, fast follow with the Coinbase listing and they literally don't ask for anything.
I can confirm that at least if you're a meaningful part of the base ecosystem and you actually build something that matters and have real users and bring value to the ecosystem in community in some way, which I think it should be all about. It's like I just don't understand the calculus unless you are trying to go out and dump a bunch of your tokens on their one, which fundamentally we're not trying to do, because we actually believe in Limitless in a long term. We're not trying to just generate a bunch of liquidity from a Binance listing and sail away into the sunset. If that is your goal, I understand the calculus behind why you would do that.
For us, we want long term value alignment we want to be part of an ecosystem which believes in all of the important values about crypto, about decentralization, about building on-chain and actually we want to be here for the longer run. If we think about this from a more longer term perspective, then earning 8% of supply for a day of long-listing on Binance isn't a good calculus. Once it's an airdrome, it's available on the front end of Coinbase. It's not listed on Coinbase, but nonetheless, retail consumers can find it on Coinbase and purchase it on Coinbase using an external wallet. Maybe it's a little bit more cumbersome than if you just had got listed directly on Coinbase, but nonetheless, it's pretty sick to be quote unquote listed on Coinbase on day one via airdrome.
Is that your plan or are you still kind of formulating this idea? We're definitely preparing for a fully on-chain launch and fully on-chain price discovery. That's our strategy and I believe that we'll set an impression with this and many will follow. On the other side, if you are building a meaningful app on base, you absolutely can get that they want Coinbase listing. I'm not talking about airdrome. I'm talking about Coinbase listing. The real listing with real market managers. For sure, there's on the table. If you actually build a meaningful app on base, you can be listed on Coinbase on day one and they will support you.
It just depends on your preferences and also how you think about design. Again, there are a lot of bad actors in this space. Even a lot of tokens and communities suffer because of bad deals that are made between not only centralized exchanges but also market makers. I think that the launch strategy and the amount of supply, which is kind of dead on day one, is a litmus test for does the founder of this product or company or community or ecosystem do they actually understand liquid markets or not? Because if they don't understand liquid markets, then the chances are that they're getting bug by market makers.
They're getting bug by centralized exchanges. In the end, that translates to retail ultimately facing the hardest consequences. I do want to get into a limitless and just kind of pop open the hood of limitless and see what's under the hood there. But I have one last question on this whole listing drama. There's a thought out there that Andre from yearn, when he listed the, who created the yearn token, it was the coolest thing since sliced bread back in 2021. Yeah, crazy time, very nostalgic. And so then he earned that finance listing for free because everyone wanted to trade yearn anyways. That's not the typical case.
The typical case is probably something closer to your startup where you have a relatively new startup that's gaining traction and a like a finance listing would actually be a huge win for your startup. And so the founder is like considering doing that, considering paying that paying that fee, paying that 8%, maybe it's higher, maybe it's lower, you said potentially it's up for negotiation in theory, you could negotiate it down. But then also in theory, you could see another startup being offered like give us 15% of your token supply out of something like that. And a lot of, like I said, a lot of founders take this bet.
They just take this gamble that like, okay, this is an acceptable trade. This is like positive EV for me. And that's why I'm going to do this. The thought is that because of so much of the token supply goes to like, you know, inside of the finance ecosystem, like, and what are they doing with that? In the fullness of time, they're selling it. And so that's 8% of sell pressure that your startup has to overcome in order to survive. And so yes, you get the liquidity, you get the day one pop, maybe you even get the year one pop, but eight, like anywhere between five and 15% of like sell pressure is hard to overcome.
I don't know if you have any, like you're again, limitless is pretty young in its, you know, TGE arc. But like, I would imagine that that would be almost destructive for projects, for many projects out there. Just like, can you overcome 10% of your supply getting sold before, like in the first one to three years of your startup? And like, maybe this is just like actually kind of a trap that may maybe founders think that it's positive EV, but it's actually negative EV in the grand scheme of things. I don't, again, I don't have, I don't have an experience you have never listed token, but I don't know if you have any thoughts on that.
So yeah, so this is, this is pretty rough. But it's, you're right. It's impossible for this to be like positive EV, I mean, of course, there can be like, insane amount of, of by pressure, which, which does happen for, for, you know, some, for some tokens. I think like Solana probably is a great example of like an absolute kind of home around like from, from zero to hero and like random test of time, right? But like, the thing is, you're expecting that founders are actually thinking about this game from a two or three year perspective. In fact, what they're doing is dumping on day one. So the, the founders, the founders, the founders, oh, oh, so everyone is, oh, so the founders in on it.
Yeah, that's what I'm saying. That's actually what, when you understand that the space is even worse than you thought it was, because, and that's why. And so if you, if you go and you look at my mentions, right, over the last 24 hours, the founders who are like, backlashing me for this are guilty. And the founders who are, you know, supporting exposing the truth are much more valuable line like with you and I. But probably collectively, we have, they say, I never meet your heroes, right? Like collectively, we have higher expectations of people than what is the reality. And the reason why this calculus makes sense is because they're dumping on day one.
Right? So however they structure that is, you know, very much a gray area. But that's why people are taking these deals, because they are also dumping, right? So this is, this is a positive EV. But in a sense, it's almost like blood money, right? It's positive EV for, for a specific founder, but at what cost to the community? Right? That's positive for a smaller circle of people and it's negative EV for the long term of the health of the project. They're not thinking about like two, three years can we recover from this? Right. They're thinking about like, can I buy another portion next week? And that's what I'm trying to call out here.
You know, I want us to be aware of that. And I want us to be open about that so that we can move the space forward and kind of drain the space of these bad actors. Okay. Okay. So yeah, it's not just, it's not just Binance charging. It's good actors. It's just essential. It's bad actors who are also saying, hey, I don't care about that fee because by the time that that chicken comes home to roost, I'm out of here. Yeah. And that's what changes the calculus. So when you think we're truly that doesn't make sense, that's why it makes sense. Because people are worse than you think. Yeah. If anything has, if those taught me anything, it's that group of people are worse than I thought.
Yeah, exactly. And that, you know, that's what we're trying to call out here. Like, you know, and then when you see people are going against us on this, probably now you clearly understand why. Because we're not just going against the centralized exchanges. We're going against bad actors in general. Well, CJ, there are many. Yeah. It takes some Grande Cajones to go after Binance and CZ. And so I think at the very least, thank you for the entertaining 48 hours on Twitter. And then also, hopefully, thank you for what can be, hopefully, a turning of the ship moment for the crypto industry. Like, sometimes we just need details.
And we need information for us to all be able to like, yeah, we are all looking at this. We all know that this is true. Everyone else knows that this is true now. Let's adjust our strategy broadly. And let's not like continue on down this path. And let's let's do something different. So if that's what gets catalyzed, as a result of these, just the last 48 hours on Twitter, that would be a huge level up for the industry as a whole. So for the very large role that you played in that, just thank you. Thank you for doing that. Yeah, thank you for for supporting. And yeah, I think I really hope that like from this, we can, you know, from this transparency and from kind of like ripping off this bandaid, we can start to rethink, you know, token designs and the relationships that centralize exchanges have with all in gym world, like from first principle, so that we can move the space forward.
Introducing Cajun, aka Verify. The world's largest verified distribution protocol or VDP. If you're trying to grow a real protocol or app, you need real users doing real actions. If it's not Verify, it's just noise. At the core of Verify is Poggi, Cajun's identity and reputation framework. It helps you reach humans, not bots, and proves what your users actually did. So your budget goes to the right people. With Verify, you can run Verify user acquisition with confidence, keeping people coming back with retention tools like loyalty rewards, quests and achievements, and even power AI training and evaluation using trusted verified user groups, ensuring your models learn from clean data.
And when it's time to reward your community, there's the K store, a global rewards marketplace where users can redeem perks that connect directly back to your app. Put simply, when growth is built on real users, you grow faster, and that's exactly what Verify delivers. If you're building a web3, AI or gaming, request a demo to grow your protocol at www.cajun.io slash demo. That's www.kgen.io slash demo. Imagine a world where traditional finance meets the power of blockchain seamlessly. That's what mantle is pioneering, with blockchain for banking, a revolutionary new category at the intersection of TradFi and Web3.
At the heart is you are the world's first money app built fully on chain. It gives you a Swiss iBand account blending fiat currencies like the euro, the Swiss fronc, the United States dollar, or the Remimbee, with crypto, all in one place. Enjoy real world usability and blockchain's trust and programmability. Transactions post directly to the blockchain compatible with TradFi Rails and packed with integrated DeFi features. You are transformed mantle network into the ultimate platform for on-chain financial services, unifying payments, trading, and assets like the MI4, the MEs protocol, and functions FBTC.
Backed by developer grants, ecosystem incentives, and top distribution through the UR app, reward stations, and buy-bit launch pool. For M&T holders, every economic activity in UR drives value back to you, embodying the entire stack and future growth of this super app ecosystem. Follow mantle on x at mantle underscore official for the latest updates on blockchain for banking. That's x.com slash mantle underscore official. All right, let's get into the second half of this episode. Let's talk about limitless, man. So limitless is a prediction market. I think when I say the words prediction market, people are going to think polymarket or call she, how is limitless different?
What's the, what should people know about limitless? Well, limitless is limitless, first of all. I think that we are the simplest way in the world for users to get access to high leverage. What I mean by that is they don't have to learn about liquidations or funding rates or configure stop losses or learn about options pricing Greeks. So the learning curve for limitless is very, very insignificant in that everything that you need to know to get started is inside of a single mobile optimized page. Right now, we focus on like daily and hourly price markets. So it's basically like, will Bitcoin be above this price in one hour or will Tesla be above this price in one hour?
Now, because it's a kind of vanilla prediction market and that it trades from like zero to a hundred cents throughout that time frame. If you look at like Bitcoin, for example, you might have a basis point move in underlying Bitcoin price in 20 minutes. But you might have bought prediction market shares of like one cent and they went all the way to a hundred cents. And so we call this implicit leverage and that there's not a margin lending in a traditional sense, which is very high leads to a lot of liquidations and also has high chance of manipulation as we saw recently. These are fully collateralized swaps.
But because of the time decay and the kind of binary payoff structure, it means that retail can get access to potentially very high returns. Of course, there is a lot of risk as well. And I think users are comfortable with that. But you know, instead of having to go on this like years long hero journey of like trying to figure out how to trade and like losing money anyway, all the user has to do is come to limitless on their phone. They can be like hiking and mountain or in the metro or in between sets at the gym. And all they actually have to do is pick a side. Right. And picking a side is a fundamental human behavior.
We love to pick a side. We love to support a football team or like be a fan of like a music group. And this is something that comes naturally to us and we get emotional and defensive and fiery about. And you know, all the user has to do is choose like above or below. So for example, Will Bitcoin or Will Tesla be above or below this price. And you'll be surprised the amount of conviction that a casual user can build in any of those arbitrary statements. But you'll also be surprised that, you know, some of the extent of the payoffs and you know, the amount of returns. I mean, just yesterday, I posted a screenshot on X, someone made 5,000 percent ROI on an hourly market betting that B and B will go down after these and so it's very, very simple for average user to get involved in this thing.
And we think that this can be a giant new derivative category that will drive trillions of dollars in volume in the coming years. And something else that's interesting is we just did a kind of analysis. We're exploring to build like a suite of structure products on top of these kind of price prediction markets. What we found is over 70 to day period is you'd help Bitcoin. I think you would have been down around like 5 percent. If you invested in a cover call strategy using derivative options, you'd be up 3 percent. And if you invested in a synthetic cover call strategy that accumulates limitless prediction market shares instead of options contracts from derivative, you'd be up 49 percent.
So not only can we give this super simple trading experience to casual users, but if users don't want to trade at all, we can also give them access to kind of high yield products where all they have to do is deposit stable clients and be done with it. And then also you know after this like crazy cascading liquidation event, which happened where Ed She saw I believe more liquidations than we ever saw before in crypto, which again is in my opinion this is an orchestrated assault on retail. And this is pure market manipulation. But we actually saw that there a bit who Coinbase has just acquired for like $3 billion or whatever.
Actually it was cheaper and more efficient for you to come and bet on daily Bitcoin price using limitless than which is $3 billion entity. And so you know this kind of is an upgrade and a very kind of new kind of market structure that we're very excited about and we're basically focused on like leading mainstream adoption of this around the world and particularly right now focusing very much on the Asian market. So regions like South Korea, Hong Kong, Taiwan, etc. I want to understand a little bit more about this mechanism. So I'm on the page right and every hour this updates right. And so right now we are six minutes past the hour at the time of recording.
And so right now there's a baseline Bitcoin price of $111,146. So that's the price to be above or below. And right now we are basically at that price. So 1146 is the price. Oh, we just popped up. Now we're at 1163. And so right now like a share on Willoughby Up or Willoughby Down is about 50, 50. But you're saying like when it goes down, when it goes down very, very low, it might be the price between a yes or above or below share would be dislocated to like maybe 90, 10, 95, five. And that's where the leverage comes from. Is that how it works? Yeah, exactly. So like they're like again, we talked about FOMO earlier and how that drives people.
And not very kind of powerful behavior sphere. And I think that as you mentioned, it's pretty close to the baseline. Now imagine it was close to the baseline, but there were 30 seconds to go, instead of 50 minutes to go. And with that time to care, that's when things start to get a lot more kind of fun and wild and crazy. And we start to see those kind of more more exceptional return profiles. You were talking about being a like comparing purchasing Bitcoin spot, purchasing Bitcoin on Derribate, holding Bitcoin on Derribate or doing this through limitless. But these markets turn over every hour.
So how would it be like a Bitcoin investor if this market closes every hour? We also have daily markets and weekly markets, monthly markets, interest that there we go early and daily markets are by far our, I mean, I would describe them as kind of self-sustaining, atomic network trading communities, where I actually see self-reinforcing network effects and people just kind of have a huge demand for these markets and they keep coming back for these markets. Like our week one retention is only over 50%. And so and we don't have like pension notifications yet. Like we're a startup, right? We're trying to build as much as possible as best as possible and test as many assumptions as possible as fast as possible in as few steps as possible.
But ultimately takes time. And so we're far from perfect. You know, we have a far from perfect product. And like we don't even have basic things like pension notifications or email marketing or we didn't introduce like gamification yet or social features. And we have very compelling retention just because users fall in love with this kind of content form factor and they keep coming back and they keep wanting more of it. And so I think there's really a way to go in terms of improving like limitless as an offering and the core product experience that will kind of strengthen these metrics and this retention and engagement level even more.
And at the same time as well as kind of improving the product and trying to make it more sticky. We're going out and we're trying to solve much deeper liquidity for these markets so people can trade in larger sizes and this is kind of an ongoing like snowballing process like just have great meeting today with one of the largest like training firms in the world. And we're actually going to be the first prediction market that they're integrating with and that's super exciting. But more on that later. I think all prediction markets have to cross this chasm from being a like niche retail um gambling platform for again like very niche instruments.
And that's where all prediction markets start. And then all prediction markets want to become a financial instrument that like is CFTC approved and Wall Street leverages because it helps them express a trade in a particular way. And they are pumping billions of dollars of volume through that one prediction market. And call sheet and polymarket are on their way there but they're not even close to getting that far yet of being like a Wall Street like a financial instrument that Wall Street is accustomed to and it's part of their like you know daily exercise and like daily routine and part of their overall broad strategy.
Limitless like I'm I go on the website and be like okay like what do I want to gamble on do I want to gamble on Bitcoin being up or down over the hour to me like that that looks like I'm just going to like have some fun at the casino. What is your conviction? Why are you why do you have conviction that we can get limitless to a like hardened financial instrument that Wall Street will be able to use? Why is this a financial instrument and not just like a gambling platform? So I think fundamentally Wall Street um you know we'll we'll go where the people go ultimately right loving or hidden. And our focus today is actually not on Wall Street.
Our focus is like I would say like on people not not actually right now in the US although we are building our licensing as I mentioned we're focusing heavily on Asian markets right now and then in like that particular part of the world but trading is so hard and so complicated like perps are hard to use um like and you know for you or I you know we made like sit and argue that you know they're actually not that hard or whatever but that's also quite a um I would say like out of touch position from the average user because it is hard for people to understand like what is an artibook or what is a stop loss or what is a funding rate or why they should pay it or why they just got liquid it like I literally remember when I was 16 years old and I discovered somehow Bitmax um and I was like wow 100x leverage like surely I'm going to be rich by tomorrow I don't like I'm done with everything like I can get a hundred x more bang for my buck like what is the where's the cash here right uh and then obviously within about five minutes or maybe even a one minute um I got liquid it and I can instantly oh that's that's the cash like I got it okay don't have anybody now like my party money is gone right um and you know I think that trading product like I mean have you like um like Robin Hood is pretty good but like have you ever used like the European like brokerages um like they suck man like they can't yeah I don't know I have no interest in using a European brokerage let me tell you but like if you try to build a bad product you would build a better one than you know most of the uh you know with the exception of like for example on Singapore they also have kind of like pretty decent um like retail brokerage products but like if you use like interactive brokers like in in Europe I mean like it doesn't even make sense you can't even buy the SPY right you have to buy some like obscure version of it that has a pricing delay so because of the like European market hours or whatever it has like a one day lag on actual pricing so if you bought best on news you actually would lose out right and all these kind of like um I would say like systematic mods of extraction of rigging the game against retail um and so like the trading experience like globally is like broken uh perps are like not that bad in comparison but they're still very complicated um if you want to learn how to trip perps though as I said you know you need to understand like all this stuff like funding rates liquidation stop losses or the bugs um then like also options like I mean it takes a long time to understand how options pricing Greeks work and what they mean and you know like how to trade different like you know Kunder butterfly strategies or whatever takes a lot of time takes years probably to master it um but as I mentioned you can come to limitless and instantly intuitively understand how to play and how to participate um you know and and you can get started with a couple of clicks and because we're building on chain we have stable clients we're instantly in hundreds of markets you know globally without having to go and grind you know licensing in each particular jurisdiction um and I think that's a huge unlock and I think that you know these factors together means that limitless will actually build the largest exchanging human history yeah yeah big statement uh so we'll limitless always be focused on these uh pricing markets uh if you because again uh not to compare you guys to college your polymarket but again this is what listeners uh this is what their frame of reference is they go on to on to polymarket and they see like are the Seattle mariners going to win the world series like 37% uh so like uh you know truly anything uh so are you focused on these like pricing markets or like are there other theoretical markets that you haven't introduced yet or like what's your plan there so I believe there is trillions of dollars in volume uh in price prediction markets only right right now we focus on hourly and daily markets also want to introduce like five minute markets one minute markets 50 minute markets we recently introduced like 30 minute markets but there is a lot of experimentation to be done in terms of durations there's a lot more ticker to be added um and then you know and so I I do believe that that in just by itself is a giant thing also what we see is like users who like sports markets want more sports markets right users who like geopolitical markets want more geopolitical markets users who like prices markets or even it does more granular than that users who like hourly markets one more hourly markets users who like daily markets want more daily markets and so we kind of see like network effects forming um for the specific like different categories um but look like limitless is a very powerful underlying infrastructure and I certainly don't roll out expanding to other markets in future or right now we believe as a startup um you know we can kind of um have the best experience for end user by making a very concentrated bet on the particular thing uh that they like him one more else how much like volume or just like user interest talk to me about the traction of limitless so far yeah we did around like 80 million uh in volume uh last month uh we almost at 80 million already so far in October so it looks like we're gonna never halfway through yeah so it looks like we're gonna bug some uh solid growth as mentioned we have very compelling retention uh like like 50% first week um and also yeah we had around like 40 000 traders uh last month and this is kind of growing exponentially very cool uh congrats on all the success I want to uh pop open the hood and talk about the on-chain component of of limitless uh what is actually on-chain uh there are you know the USDC deposits and and it's on base uh but like what what other logic is on-chain yeah like all of the custody um all of the execution um settlement um and like resolution of markets it's like a real time price feed I think another core problem with prediction markets actually takes a little bit of time to get your money back due to the whole like kind of resolution games that are going on with limitless is much simpler right and the markets resolve uh instantly and people kind of keep going into the next market right I would imagine if I'm betting on like an hourly market or a five minute market I might want to bet on continuous five minute markets over and over and over again so you need to resolve very quickly so I can have my money back so I can bet exactly yeah yeah and you get that from just price oracles yeah exactly we're using pith network right now and they have a lot of different assets like not only crypto but also stocks commodities um like you know gold are best few why or basically anything okay so limitless itself is is bankless you know there were it's a non custodial platform so everyone's self-custody is everyone brings their own wallet the price oracles are autonomous uh and you know resolution autonomous so what like layers of trust are left inside of the system um what we have uh ordim matching um which is off-chain um just because it's very kind of high performance thing this hard to put on a like standard uh UVM blockchain uh so right now ordim matching can it happens off-chain but all the execution settlement and custody happens on chain and that's the same for polymarket too right yeah yeah that's right yeah okay so you guys have pretty much a similar trust set up to like polymarket where uh the like execution is on chain it's non custodial usc deposits uh polymarket doesn't have oracles because it's not priced and so their oracles you're like um a but that's only in the unhappy case and the happy case i think it just resolves uh sounds like a pretty similar trust set up to polymarket yeah with with the exception that we have the kind of instant uh price feed uh resolution but it's yes we don't have the the more subjective markets currently so much easier to deal with yeah yeah this might be like outside of the realm of like what limitless like focuses on but i'm really into i guess maybe maybe in this way it's what it won't be the conversation of censorship resistance and prediction markets i think is actually pretty important to me and i think is under discussed in the con in the conversation of prediction markets both calcium and polymarket don't let users spin up their own market uh and there's you know plenty of good reasons why but also there are plenty of good reasons why you should allow users to spin up their own market like prediction markets are truth speaking mechanisms say they're the the connection of markets and truth and maybe with pricing actually is uh for like the asset pricing is actually uh the first maybe a first prediction market where you know you could give users the power to like hey like there's not a market for this let's give that power to the users have you thought about that yeah for sure i mean that's that's definitely a low hanging fruit uh actually when we started um you know building and prediction markets one of the initial assumptions we were super excited about was user generated markets um kind of like as it means as it means to scale uh user choice and uncover like more information and can it be like almost like an Amazon of prediction markets um i i mean i still see like companies now raising precedes for similar ideas i think there was one of them like just like a week ago or something um the problem is when you have long tail information on markets um there are no conventions about how you price those markets um except from using entire information um right so like how do you price whether pd is a practice or not or if like yeah right yeah it's it's a pretty hard thing to price right yeah uh or like if like tellers with album gonna like sell like some out of copies i mean like you can build models for that surely um but there are no kind of conventions and there's also no way for you to like hedge your exposure because a lot of market makers like to run delta neutral strategies and kind of you know earn from the from the spread um and so that creates uh like a new set of problems which is like how do we actually kind of create liquidity for these markets and academia right the assumption was always that you should pay people for reporting information so because insider information is effectively how these markets are priced you should put up like a pool of money they can incentive ice people to come and report information uh to the market um and so it's very much like either like put liquidity and like lose like 99% or a good percentage of it from people who actually are better informed than you um or kind of subsidize this in some way um to get it started and so our calculus was like well okay instead of subsidizing this forever right probably we should look for like a more sustainable model um and as our own kind of creator of markets we had a set of market which like well will the price of Bitcoin be uh on Friday uh and like for PM Eastern time for example um and then like my my co-founder uh said to me like oh why don't we like test these markets daily to see if it boosts retention i was like sure why not like so on a Saturday I created market like what will the price of Bitcoin be today and for PM Eastern time and then we started to see that these were basically like kind of you know zero days to expiry options and there was a lot of late in demand uh globally for such products and then you know since then we also kind of branched out to hourly's and saw break out like demand and interaction for those as well um so yeah it's been a very interesting story well CJ well it's been a fun arc to to watch limitless grow uh if people are peaked about limitless uh where should they go to learn more or go use the app yeah just go to limitless.
exchange and the start trading pick a site pick a site pick a site that's a great line uh and I mean maybe they just want to learn more about you or I don't know if they want to go join the community read the docs maybe there's some like prediction market nerds where else can they go uh yeah like just just go to limitless start exchange and uh you'll you'll you'll find you'll find the way further well well CJ thanks for coming on the show today and and again appreciate all of the information that you've given the community on twitter and also the app that you're building on base as well thanks a lot David thanks for for having me and uh yeah let's keep in touch bangles nation you guys know the deal crypto is risky you can lose what you put in but nonetheless we are head to west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we are glad you're with us on the baked journey thanks a lot