Terra is exploding. Do Kwon and the Terra ecosystem are turning Bitcoin into their collateral asset of choice to backstop LUNA and the UST stablecoin. Over the last several weeks, the Luna Foundation Guard (LFG) have bought over 30,000 BTC... and they don't plan to stop there.
As the LFG climbs the ranks of bitcoin holders, Do Kwon has started playing empire games—claiming victory over the Curve Wars with the 4pool (which contains UST, Frax, USDC, and USDT), calling for the end of DAI, and attempting to build out the Terra ecosystem as the ultimate power in the universe.
Is Terra (UST) the future of crypto money? Or is it a ticking time bomb waiting to explode? Perhaps the truth is somewhere in the middle, so we're going to debate it. From the bull side is Delphi Digital's José Maria Macedo, and representing the skeptics is Selini Capital's Jordi Alexander.
------ CONSENSYS | M·A·C: NFT Collection for a Good Cause https://bankless.cc/MAC
------ SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ ️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
️ ARBITRUM | SCALED ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
ALTO IRA | TAX-FREE CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/AltoIRA
AAVE V3 | LEND & BORROW CRYPTO https://bankless.cc/aave
️ MAKER DAO | THE DAI STABLECOIN https://bankless.cc/MakerDAO
BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
------ Timestamps:
0:00 Intro 7:30 LUNA/UST Fundamental Properties 15:15 The Balance Between LUNA/ETH 20:00 Why Bullish/Bearish? 25:28 Why is UST a Successful Stable? 30:19 Are Algo-Stablecoins Unstable? 42:25 Anchor's Utility 48:02 Do Kwon $10B Purchase of LUNA 52:02 Is UST Becoming a Bank? 57:00 Risks of De-pegging 1:06:30 Has LUNA/UST Been Tested? 1:15:00 Do Kwon & Decentralization 1:27:50 Do Kwon's 4pool 1:39:05 Potential Nightmare Scenarios 1:48:04 Closing Arguments
------ Resources:
Jordi Alexander CIO of Selini Capital https://twitter.com/gametheorizing
Jose Macedo Founding Partner, Delphi Digital https://twitter.com/zemariamacedo
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey, Backless Nation, we are super excited to host this live debate. This is a debate on Terra, Luna, USD, the stablecoin, the bull versus bear case. I asked this question on Twitter, David, and I think this is the question for our debaters today. Is Terra the USD, the future of crypto money, or is it a ticking time bomb waiting to explode? Got a lot of responses on crypto Twitter as a result of that question. And then two debaters stepped up to the plate and were also nominated by the community to take one of two respective sides. One is the bull case for USD and the Luna ecosystem, Terra ecosystem, the other is the bear case.
And so we have two representatives taking that side. And we're going to try to get to, I guess, the truth, or at least hear the arguments from both sides in this conversation. David, who do we have on the show today? And do you have anything to add to that? Yeah, of course. Coming in, in the left side of the ring, on the bull case, we have a Jose Mercado from Delphi Digital. And then in the right side of the ring, you have Jordi Alexander, Chief Investment Officer of Selenie Capital for the bear case for Terra USD. And I think really this conversation hinges on the question of, do algorithmic stablecoins can they work at all?
And if they can work, has Terra USD, has USD cracked that nut? We've seen many Algo stablecoins come and go. Lots of algorithmic stablecoin experiments on Ethereum, empty set dollar, dynamic set dollar. But we have not tried the experiment as a layer one until Terra came along. And so far, that's been going pretty well with Terra. But there's still a fundamental question as can an algorithmic stablecoin work in the long term? And I think that's going to, either the main topic of what we are going to talk about today, along with all these other periphery topics as well, such as how is anchor involved with this, the 10 billion of Bitcoin Treasury that's being accumulated by the Luna Guard Foundation, and a few other things as well.
So Ryan, these are the focus of today's show. And here's why this is important guys. Luna's valued as something like $30 billion. Plus or minus, I'm not sure at the time of recording, USD is now $16 billion. It's definitely making its way into all corners of Define. So this is a substantial market cap for these assets. So we want to poke and see what's the viability look like for these assets? What do the growth prospects look like? Guys, before we get in a quick announcement for you, I want to tell you a little bit about a fantastic NFT drop opportunity. And I think this is an opportunity for maybe first time NFT buyers or early buyers who want to support a good cause.
So it is National Youth HIV and AIDS Awareness Day on April 10th. And the consensus NFT team, and also Mac, that's MAC, the makeup company, have partnered together to launch a set of NFTs from the iconic Keith Herring. Okay, art by Keith Herring. There are three different levels you can get in on this NFT. The first starts at $25. So all of the proceeds from this, here's the cool parts. All of the proceeds, 100% go to HIV AIDS issues involving youth to support youth who are affected by HIV and AIDS. So really cool cause. And now only 100% of the sales, but also all of the resale values. Remember the cool thing about NFTs, every time you sell an NFT, royalty can be collected.
In this case is 2.5%. That also on an ongoing basis forever goes to the same cause. So super cool opportunity. We will include a link in the show notes. But if you want to memorize this, it's banklist.cc slash MAC. That's all capital, MAC. And you can check this out. The next step is really just sign up, get on their list so that when these NFTs come out, you will be first to know. David with that, man, I'm really excited about this panel because I feel like I haven't fully explored the Terra and Luna and USD ecosystem in the way I've wanted to you. And I've been looking for an opportunity to sort of get both sides of the argument.
So I'm excited to learn along with the guests. I probably have some preconceived notions coming into this. And I want to check those and see if they're true or not. But this is going to be a very important conversation. Probably one of the most important conversations happening in crypto right now. So super excited about this. Do you have anything else to add? Yeah, it's extremely relevant. It's the talk of the town. The Terra community is full of energy at the moment. And so I think Ryan, if we can do this show right, it will both be a zero to 60 and understanding the Luna ecosystem, while also having a good back and forth debate as to the merits of the of the system as well as the risks of the system as well.
Well, there's your hype guys. We will be right back with our two debaters, our two panelists. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Arbitrum is an Ethereum layer two scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use DeFi and NFTs. Over 300 projects have already deployed to Arbitrum and DeFi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly. Some of the coolest and newest NFT collections have chosen Arbitrum as their home. All the wild DeFi protocols continue to see increased usage and liquidity. Using Arbitrum has never been easier, especially with the ability to deposit directly into Arbitrum through all the exchanges, including Binance, FTX, Quoby and Crypto.
com. Once inside, you'll notice Arbitrum increases Ethereum speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee. If you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users, visit Arbitrum.io slash developer to start building your DAP on Arbitrum. If you're a DGen, many of your favorite DAPs on Ethereum are already on Arbitrum with many moving over every day. Go to bridge.arbitrum.io now to start bridging over your ETH and other tokens in order to experience DeFi and NFTs in the way it was always meant to be. Fast, cheap, secure and friction-free.
The layer two era is upon us. Ethereum's layer two ecosystem is growing every day and we need bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a layer two life. Across is the fastest, cheapest and most secure, cross-chain bridge. With across, you don't have to worry about the long wait times or high fees to get your assets to the chain of your choice. Access are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously. Across bridges are powered by UMA's Optimistic Oracle to securely transfer tokens from layer two back to Ethereum. A token proposal is being deliberated as we speak in a cross forum where community members will decide on the token distribution.
You can have your part of a cross's story by joining the discord and becoming a co-founder and helping to design the fair, fair launch of the cross. If you want to bridge your assets quickly and securely, go to across.io to bridge your assets between Ethereum, Optimism, Arbitrum or Boba Networks. MakerDow is the OG DeFi protocol. The MakerDow produces die. The industry's most battle tested and resilient stablecoin. Using Maker, you don't need to sell your collateral if you need liquidity. Instead, you can spin up a Maker Vault and use your collateral to mint die directly. With Maker, the power to mint new money is in your hands.
The Maker Protocol is extremely hardened and operated by one of the most experienced DAO's in existence. They've been here since the beginning. They've seen it all and so you can mint die with the assurance that your collateral is safe. Soon, Maker will be present on all chains and L2s, so minting die can take place on oasis.app, zaryon, zapper or any other DeFi protocol that you use. Follow Maker on Twitter at MakerDow and learn from the oldest and most resilient DAO in existence. All right, ladies and gentlemen of the Bankless Nation. Here are our two panelists. Again, in the left side of your screen, we have Jose Masido coming in from Delphi Digital.
He is going to be arguing the bull case for Tara Luna and then on the right side of the ring. We have Jordi Alexander from Selenie Capital, arguing for the bear case for the Tara ecosystem and for UST Jose and Jordi. Welcome to Bankless. Thanks very much for having me. Big final to show. Hey guys, happy to be here. Cheers. Thank you guys for volunteering to do this. I think this is going to be pretty fun. And like I said, going into this, I think this will be an opportunity to go to teach a lot of the bankless listeners, the bankless community who haven't completely dove in to the Luna ecosystem all about Luna while also providing the pros and cons, the benefits and the costs, the bull and the bear case for Tara.
And so I'd actually kind of like to start at that high level of just kind of defining what we're actually talking about. And so Jose, I'd like to start with you. Can you simply just explain the fundamental properties of Luna and UST? Like what is the design philosophy and what are its goals and how does it achieve those goals? For sure. Yeah, I know it's an educated audience, probably more steeped in sort of Ethereum projects than Tara. So I'll try and use some metaphors there. So I think the easiest way to understand Tara is actually through its products, which is UST, right? So UST is a decentralized stablecoin.
You can think of it as something similar to die, but unlike die, which is built on top of Ethereum, UST exists on its own layer one, which is Tara, which is a tenderment proof of stake app chain. So for the ETH maxes or for the for people who understand ETH, you can say like it's as if MKR token didn't exist, right? So it's like ETH just ETH and die. And you have no MKR in the middle. So all the value would accrue to ETH and you'd have like die sort of built into the layer one level into the ETH layer one. And then so how does UST itself work? So in terms of mechanism design, it's actually different from MAKER, right?
So MAKER is a is a is a debt-based stablecoin. UST is more similar to an algorithmic stablecoin that has existed on Ethereum before. You mentioned some of them, ESD, DSD, etc., where basically the way you mint UST is by is by burning Luna and the way you burn UST is by minting Luna. And so this gives Luna a really interesting role in the Terry ecosystem, right? Where it's both the staking token, like it would be for a proof of stake chain, but it's also the share token and the governance token for this decentralized stablecoin, right? And so in a sense, it's secure as both the systems like technical sort of consensus risk, but also the stablecoin's financial and economic risk.
This also gives Luna unrivaled value capture, I would say, layer one, right? Because unlike most layer ones, which just capture value from transaction fees, Luna actually captures value in the growth of its main stablecoin. And since stablecoins are crypto's killer app on pretty much every chain, Luna basically verticalizes, it's vertically integrated, and it also captures the value from its main and most successful application. And then in terms of contextual data that might be useful to users, to your listeners, sorry, UST is the biggest decentralized stablecoin by Mark Cap, it's roughly 16 bill right now.
It's also probably about to be the most liquid with the four pool, maybe controversial, but yeah, probably about to be the most liquid. I would also argue, and I'll argue later that it's the most decentralized in a certain sense. And then Luna has its own layer one ecosystem, which itself is thriving in the sense that it has around 30 billion in TVL. It's the second largest L1 by TVL. It has core primitives for a lot of the stuff that you see on Ethereum, savings, credit, exchange, perps, also on NFT, like a bunch of NFT marketplaces, a bunch of open fts. So yeah, that's, I'd say like a high level intro to Tara.
So Jose, I'm going to ask Jordi to add to that, but just to kind of summarize the taking from maybe the Ethereum paradigm, right? So it's, it's as if a layer one like Ethereum, that's what that's what Tara essentially is, had an algorithmic stablecoin, almost baked in, tightly coupled to its core protocol, and the value of that algorithmic stablecoin was somewhat sort of linked to in an algorithmic way, ETH, the asset. So the L1 asset itself. And it's like the senior, if the senior orage accrued to ETH, right? Like the growth and imagine if the growth and die all accrued to ETH, or in the centralized tables, all accrued to ETH.
Right. And that is not the only, USC, of course, is not the only application on Tara. Tara also has, you know, general purpose, smart contract layer, where it has other sort of DeFi applications as well. But it does have this special status, almost like protocol, almost protocol native. I don't know if that's too strong a term. Would I say, would you say protocol native, or do you still consider USD as separate app that is distinct from the protocol? No, it's, it's a native, it's protocol native for sure. So it's minted and burnt at the protocol level and Luna and USD are both the two protocol native tokens.
So that, that is helpful because we can't really talk about USD without talking about Luna. So I think for listeners listening to this, when we say, Luna and USD, you know, sometimes we'll use them somewhat interchangeably. But of course, USD is sort of the stablecoin pegged aspect, but it is almost a product of Luna. And these two things might be used somewhat interchangeably in this episode. Jordi, what would you add to this? Is there anything you would add to Hostage's description or anything you might disagree with? I mean, in terms of the analogy to Maker and some of the, you know, stablecoins that people might be familiar with like die, for example, that are over collateralized.
The difference is that in a way, USD is collateralized by the value of the underlying chain itself by the L1. But instead of a model where you are necessarily changing your USD for Luna, instead, it is adding inflation to the system. So imagine if somebody wanted to get rid of their die, instead of getting Ethereum from somebody, the system would literally just print new theorems and just kind of bestow those theorems onto the person that has die. So in a way, like the die is an extension of Ethereum where you could just get more Ethereum created from that system. Of course, the problem we know with inflation is that it reduces the price.
And that's kind of why historically, these things have always failed because as you create inflation, you reduce the price, you get into a desk spiral where, you know, the underlying price is going down and then, you know, people want to redeem more and then there's like a rush for the exit. And if you find that there is not enough exit for everybody, some people are kind of left holding the bag and usually things go to zero in that case. That's kind of what we've seen historically, at least. So I think to bolster this conversation, and Jordi, you just touched on it a little bit and Jose also touched on it, but I want to make this a little bit more formal.
There's a relationship between the value capture of the Terra ecosystem and then the Luna token and then also the USD token. And I want to kind of go back through this again. Jose, when the Terra ecosystem captures value, how does it manifest in the supply of USD versus the unit price of Luna as in like the market cap of Luna versus the total supply of outstanding USD when the Terra ecosystem grows and captures value, how does it get balanced between these two tokens? How does that happen? Yeah, so when there's demand for like excess demand for USD, USD will trade above a dollar, right? And at that point, there's an incentive for someone to go and burn some Luna in order to mint USD and then sell it on the market and collect the arbitrage, right?
With Luna providing kind of that layer one Oracle price that sets how you can mint and burn USD. And so as the supply of USD grows, there's more demand for Luna to burn it to mint to capture these arbitrage opportunities. And then obviously Luna also captures a staking yield, which comes from the fees generated on the network, the swap fees, and the actual just transaction fees on the network. There's actually Luna staking yield, which is pretty high. It's not inflation based at all. It all comes from from from network fees. And then Ejority with this mechanism, what are like the strengths and weaknesses in this particular mechanism that stand out to you, or just any comment on that mechanism and its sustainability?
The problem with, so you don't really see there's a problem until there's like a huge problem. That's that's one big issue where there's going to be a straw that's going to break the camel's back at some point where you know, you can keep backing, you keep backing, keep backing. And then there's a point where it's just like suddenly like nose dives. So it's not like, you know, you get to slowly notice that something's wrong and you get to adjust and fix it. So that's one of the issues that these things just certainly have. Like it looks everything's okay and then suddenly it goes bad. And the problem is if you have a lot of retail users and you have a few big whales, we'll get into this later.
But if there's a rush, yeah, like if there's a rush for the exit and you have a few very sophisticated players that own most of the coins and they get out first, then it's kind of bad luck for the people holding. Well, we're going to think. The only thing I would add to that, just on the historical metaphor that I think is important to note, is while I do think historical is important, the comparison and like the idea that it's all it was all okay at a certain point with like ESD or DSD or whatever, it's just like it's not true, right? But for anyone that was in those games, that thing traded at every price except the dollar.
Like it was it it was a $10 ESD at some point or like $5 and then it was and then obviously it went straight down all the way to whatever it is now like fractions of a fractions of a cent. So I don't think there's been any really algorithmic stablecoin that has anywhere near the track record of success of what USC has had, right? And like it's it's the comparison in a sense is a little bit disingenuous because like Titan ESD ESD, they really never maintains stability for more than for more than even a few weeks. And so whereas USC has maintained stability for for for over like a year in face some pretty some pretty serious and and testing market conditions.
So I think the metaphors while they're important in the design is similar, like the magnitude of success is just on a completely different scale where it's almost like in comparable. I feel like we're already like diving into some of the debate topics that we definitely want to want to reach. But while we're talking still about the interest in the summary to make sure the audience understands USD and Luna is the last important piece if you're coming from an Ethereum world that's different. I understand things already in Jose that Luna does not have a fixed supply the same way does not have a monetary schedule in the way that Bitcoin is 21 million and Ethereum is sort of you know basically based on parameter controls and validating those sort of things.
Luna will actually inflate its supply in order to like stable stabilize or respond to USD as a stablecoin the demand for USD as a stablecoin. So that is one big distinction from the Ethereum ecosystem the unit the Luna ecosystem the Terri ecosystem. So I see you nodding your head yes. So I think that's the case. Okay so um let's just high level before we get into some of these individual topics. I'm going to hear your high level summary from each of you on Jose why you are bullish and then Jordy why you are bearish and I think you've both hinted at some of these things but like just put it into kind of the the elevator pitch for us we'll start with you Jose why are you bullish on this design?
Yep um so I actually think Jordy and I probably are closer in views on this than than most other than than I would be with most most other bears but I want to do if just a few disclaimers before before doing the on the bullishness so I'm very bullish Luna in that most of my net worth is in Luna and Luna Alts right so that should tell you something about sort of my bullishness on Luna however that doesn't mean I think it's riskless I've consistently sort of outlined what I think what I think are the risks with it and also the mitigants to those risks. It also doesn't mean I'm a maxi right I'm really like as Delta Ventures we've invested like most of our investments and most of our our nav is is held in non-luna non-luna ecosystem stuff we've invested in other layer ones we're interested in other stablecoins like like fracks and face specifically or design that I'm interested in so by no means a maxi and then okay so in terms of the high level thesis for for Luna so maybe I'll do the high level and just go through step by step afterwards as well if that's cool I mean maybe cut me off with it if not so high level stablecoins are crypto's killer app I think this is this is hard to deny centralized stablecoins are in my mind a temporary stopgap that will be regulated away into a relevance the endgame is necessarily decentralized stablecoins which I think is arguably the biggest marketing crypto I think it's a multi trillion dollar opportunity USD is the largest decentralized stablecoin by market cap and it's also growing the fastest like the the second die is actually not growing it's it's declining and and and so and it's although decentralization is hard to quantify as I said I'll also argue that it's the most decentralized because it's the only one that doesn't rely on centralized centralize sensible collateral like USDC and and tether so that's sort of the the high level the high level thesis I can go in like in on step by step into like each of those points and add a bit more color to them if you want now or I can let you do here's all the better thesis yeah yeah I think that's perfect for now that's the perfect level of uh level of expression of the bull case that we need for now Jordy what's what's your bear case yeah I'll be like a very quick disclaimer as well I don't want Luna to fail I'm not like betting against Luna I'm not short Luna but I do see a lot of you know potential issues in the road and you know compared to the current euphoria around the Luna price that we've seen I think there's a lot of things that people may need to understand and make a Jordy are you a Luna holder I'm not a Luna holder oh sorry I'm I have no Luna long or short so I am an anchor right now I think it's uh we'll get into anchor later um you know presenting the bear case while being an anchor are not too distinct things I'll explain that I think anchor is like a huge marketing spend right now that um is a is a safe thing for investors potentially to to just say thank you and and take some 20 percent yield um while there's a lot of reserves and and we'll get into that later but in terms of the bear case there are huge amount of assumptions between here and the end game that Jose talks about and I understand the end game and I'm sympathetic to the end game um the end game is basically you know we want something decentralized as opposed to USDC USDT where the government can intervene uh the problem with something over collateralized is that it is very capital inefficient and cannot grow very fast while USD as we have uh been talking about has been growing extremely rapidly that also presents risks with it because you can get over your skis grow too fast and and gain being in a balanced situation um but the the main bear case is how far we are from here into execution are many many steps removed and then then people realize there's a lot of things that have to go right and there's a lot of assumptions that we don't know and there's two main ones one is will this peg hold in the meantime through volatility um and volatility can come either through a bear market or it can come through a reduction in demand once um you know the yield on anchor which I believe is extremely crucial to the growth of terror right now um reduces and we're actually the reality is nobody knows um what the effect of that is going to be um and another assumption is even if it doesn't depeg that's not the only bear case it is entirely possible that um as we have seen with you swap as we have seen with other successful protocols and defy like avay if something works people will try to make a better mouse trap and you might see other L ones issue stable coins against them and add some little tweak on it on top and they can offer a higher yield this is kind of what we've seen with sushi swap and that will be bearish for Luna price without necessarily depegging the coin okay guys thank you for those initial statements and I think we're gonna be touching on basically every single element that was discussed by each of you and uh this first one to to really start off the the detailed side of this of this show I want to go back to to Jose Jose you you talked a lot about how uh these other algo stable coins just have not performed in the same way that us t has and us t is in a league of its own simply by performance right we had empty set dollar come and not really work dynamic set dollar come and not really work how for what reasons do you uh ascribe the success of us t in the face of all the other algo stable coins that haven't worked like what are the properties what are the features of of tariff and us t that has made us t hold its peg and be so successful um and and what what are those elements what would you what would you say is the rational behind that yeah i'd say that the the main uh the main thing is just that most people treated algo stables as a mechanism problem design where actually it's it's a utility and demand problem right so like everyone sees the these things is just you design a mechanism you design out the coupon system of bonds whatever could be used you just alter that over time and and hopefully uh it can maintain the peg but actually the the main thing that backs a stable coin is demand for it right that that that's the main back of and they will be stable coin uh to take this sort of build it and they will come approach or like peg it and will come approach right as long as we keep the system safe and peg people will use this and what we've seen is that that that just hasn't really worked right and the the the approach that us t took sorry it says my connections is stable can you hear me all right yeah we can kind of hear you you're breaking up here and there um it actually might be beneficial if we actually just started from the beginning can you can you just start over yeah sorry about that so i think the big difference is that uh most so algo stables and stablecoins generally treat stablecoins as a as a mechanism design problem where in reality it's a demand problem right so you you can construct the most elegant mechanism you want but the main thing that backs the stablecoin is is demand for it and so where everyone else kind of focused on their their coupon mechanism or he's on building an economy and then around it and and so it's a lot of for example the make reproach which is sort of build it and they will come or get in there come where you know and when we've seen we've seen we've seen the struggles of that whereas us t the the approach was let's not just build um a stablecoin and with a clever mechanism let's build an entire economy of use cases around this centered around us t um which which which allows which creates that demand around it and obviously the first one was mirror which was allowed people to get exported to synthetic assets and i mean at a high level i would split sort of because us t is money right and and money you you want to use it for for two main things either spending or the furred spending right um which would which would be like investment so the furred spending is sort of all of defy and and t-fi like all these tools so mirror which gives exposure to to to traditional assets synthetic assets you have anchor which gives you a savings rate you have a support where you can exchange it for different assets you have um you know Mars Protocol is a credit protocol you have prison where you can split your yield all these primitives that make this investment ecosystem really compelling and that's only going to going to keep growing and then you have the spending use case which is how can I actually spend my us t in the real world right because i don't want to have this savings account that's separate from my for my spending account and and there you have all these neo banks come come come on line like kato like cash like Alice that are building all over the world and and sort of doing the work on the on the front lines on the regulatory front lines to make us t spendable everywhere and the the ultimate vision is to sort of close the loop right where you never have to leave uh this ecosystem you have uh like a really well developed financial system with with t-fi and then you also have a really well developed spending ecosystem where you can spend this stuff all over the world and and sort of make that really seamless and i think that vision is is the big difference between us t and and and all the other stablecoins and we're seeing some some of them understand this so for instance that the fey and rari merger i think is an admission of this right but it's difficult to have justice stablecoin you need to build you need to like verticalize and have your use cases on top of it and so you've seen fe like join up with rari and build these use cases on top you've seen fracks with fracks lending and i think the most successful ones are the ones that are able to do that but i don't think like that it would delete the to st has in terms of the system and just uh the the the community and everything i think it's it's much better positioned than than most of the others i want to throw this to jordan a second but one quick follow-up Jose on this um i i think your argument to summarize it is that the vanilla algorithmic stablecoin model i think you are in agreement that that like without utility algo stablecoins don't work you can't just have an algo stablecoin just have this algo stablecoin you need to actually imbue it with utility for it actually to be sustainable but my question to you is are we just adding like a utility layer around an unstable foundation like if we know that algo stablecoins are inherently unstable can you really solve that by adding just a utility layer around it or because in my mind i think an argument could be made about how you're just obfuscating the instability and the instability will rear its head at one day you've just obfuscated with utility between now and then and what would you say to that?
i would i would say that it's not that algo stables are inherently unstable it's just that most of them focused on ponsi incentives right versus utility and what that does is it is it it's really good at bootstrapping the supply of this algo stable which so right with the sd and the in the expansions you're you're getting like massive growth in the sd supply but actually like there's no real demand sustaining that and that when the market turns the outstanding stablecoins are actually a liability of the share token right the share token has to honor that and get cemented in order to satisfy that and so you have this situation where you've created loads of stablecoins through ponsi demand and yield and when that goes everyone wants to redeem at the same time right which is why it's really important for an algo stable you have to build demand at the same time as you build this this holder base because you need it you need it needed to be that when when sort of markets turn and people aren't you know collecting there like 10% you know seniorage a day or whatever on the sd there needs to be people that are actually using sd and so they're not redeeming it because they actually see utility in it and they're using it to do all this stuff and so it's not there inherently unstable it's just that they go ahead of their skis because they use ponsi incentives to grow supply loads without having the utility to actually like back that up in the contraction phase awesome that that's a fantastic illustration Jordi what would you say to that what are the thoughts that have risen to your mind um you know first of all um in terms of like the ponsi dynamics i would say that giving an unsustainable yield like anchor is doing is a little bit like that i understand why it is and it's sort of it's a marketing spend where you say okay if it's 15 billion dollars in repaying 10% above market we're spending a billion and a half dollars but if we're creating so much market cap then then it's sort of okay and it's a worthwhile investment um and there's a lot of assumptions baked into that i think Jordi can you take a minute just to explain what you're talking about with with anchors so this is some way to en elicit demand for us t as i understand it through yield which is maybe goes back to like what is what is a ponsi incentive but you're saying it exists in anchor could you explain that for the listeners yeah i think like let's take a quick step back and and tell the listeners what is on terror because it's been around a while it's not it it's not like it's just got created now even though the price has been going up recently um you know there there are there are some there were some fundamental fundamental billing blocks that the terror team built into the system one was chai which was a payment system the idea was um if you integrate the stable coins into real-world spending that will be a link towards long-term sustainability because there's people actually spending it it was great idea there's been a lot of issues with that and i think the chai experiment was fantastic regulation and other things in korea i don't think that you know us t's being spent for purchases so let's call that kind of like a good idea that didn't necessarily follow through then we had mirror protocol which was a synthetics competitor in terms of synthetic assets stocks bonds creating these like financial instruments on chain to give access to people around the world um also not something that's been extremely successful while we at sleen capital have been in in mirror for a very long time and we liked the protocol but the reality is both on the regulatory side uh as we saw with the SEC kind of um complaints about it and even on the stability side now um it it was doing very well and it's been doing less well and um the assets there are not necessarily very stable right now so another very good idea that has had problems executing so what is the killer app it is anchor anchor is your savings bank uh instead of getting 0.
1% at well as far go you get 20% that is something simple enough and desirable enough that it has created this huge huge surge in us t and it is especially a case now that we're out of defy summer we're out of the initial uh defy explosion where 20% yield was nothing right like you had very easy 80 100% yields like nobody cared about it and nobody was looking at anchor but since then we've had a huge contraction in yields um as you know the new protocols have figured out that maybe you shouldn't necessarily just give out all your tokens in the first week to predatory people who are just going to take them and leave um so that's reduced the risk-free yield in defy in general and if you call it 10% now the anchor is actually higher now and they haven't reduced it because they realize what's going on like suddenly like everybody wants to come to anchor now because it's 20 so we should not reduce it um George and we mean what do you mean by like they haven't reduced it who's in charge of reducing it and or increasing it and and also where does the 20% yield an anchor actually come from just just to um yeah i'm sorry i'm pretty pretty pretty good answer that actually it's just i think it maybe will be useful to uh i'm because i'm happy to talk about anchor but i think it it will be useful to have like the context of kind of a death spiral risk and the and the and like all of that and like that argument first because um so i don't know how how we want to do it because we look like there i think i think Jose i think we'll get there for sure what i do want to hear from Jordi though is like this uh you said something Jose which is um that it's based on utility like utility value is is the big differentiator with usc and i'm wondering if Jordi is getting to a point where he's saying well actually anchor is similar to some of the Ponzi game type economics that we've seen an empty set dollar i don't know if that's the point you're making Jordi but i'd like to hear you're kind of your full expression of what you're saying with anchor so where's the 20% coming from so the 20 i can't say um what uh those had to cloud some money but uh the 20 the 20% is i was a soundbarg joke by the way um so the the 20% is coming from the luna foundation guard it's coming from ultimately the the power is that be that control terror that have money to spend on marketing a way to look at it is they're saying you know we've made we have this money in the treasury uh we will keep topping up as long as we feel like we're getting a worthwhile return on adoption and we will keep topping up um this 20% yield above what you know maybe 10% is like a normal value for the yield given um you know some of the natural rewards rates where you're getting the yield from the assets that are being staked so it's it's a very expensive marketing spend um the problem i have with it is two fold one is the civil resistance is always impossible to solve for so yeah if you can actually give 20% to retail real people you know Alice and Joe and they actually have a savings count with $20,000 they want to get 20% and you think it's worthwhile to give them this extra $500 a year because you want to bring them into the ecosystem that makes a lot of sense but what you end up happening is uh dejan box for example which is like a a way to wrap mim and us t together and kind of magnify the yield and and kind of keep farming this like extra yield um that's kind of more the type of people that have taken advantage of of the offer so i don't think it's necessarily being super effective in terms of bringing in retail people um and it's so hard to do like this is the problem with crypto in general and with blockchain in general it's like how do you just direct the rewards that you want to direct to real human beings instead of just a huge corporation or you know some dejan box thing taking all of the incentives so so Jordi back to kind of david's root question here which is i think Jose was saying hey this is different than other algo stablecoin experiments in the past it's not empty set dollar it's not basis cash this is fundamentally different and so won't end up with the same fate i mean we have like a a field of gravestones as uh david said it uh pretty the show of other algo stablecoins do you think that usd is destined to join those do you think it will ultimately fall in the same ways or do you think this time it is different with usd um i think see some some people i talk to are completely convinced i'm not convinced i think it's sort of fifty-fifty eight hangs in the balance we have a much better team executing on luna like dokwan has an amazing like execution spirit to him you have jump you have like some some strong players that are backing that are not going to just let this thing die i think you know last may made 2021 where we had a big drop in the entire market and usd started to deep peg um there were some powerful friends that came in and and saved the day and and it didn't deep peg and you know one year later those guys are um kind of reaping their awards so it it's much stronger than like some of these prior experiments and i'm not sure it's going to deep peg but there are risks there's two risks one is luna uh price goes down because the entire market is going down people start worrying that there is not enough collateral in luna to absorb all the usd so if the entire market goes down 50-60 percent in a bear market including bitcoin which is kind of the collateral that that is now being accumulated which we'll get it we haven't touched upon um but you know god forbid the entire crypto market goes into like a really bad bear market there's going to be a loss of trust in usd because people are worried that there is not enough collateral to back it in terms of actual dollars the collateralization percentage goes down and there's a rush for the doors that's the one risk and then the second risk comes from the other side it comes from the dollar side where if um the 20 percent on anchor gets reduced to 10 percent and then people no longer care about it then you will see a like we talked about before they will burn usd that will mint more luna it will create inflation in luna and that's kind of a potential risk that starts to create the basis of a death spiral where you know if luna market cap is 30 billion and somebody burns 5 billion of usd it's not just that luna is going to go down by a 5 billion to 25 billion there is a multiplier effect so it'll be like times three to times eight or kind of like the estimates historically on like you know the effect of market cap like like we've seen now in bitcoin bitcoin has gone up 10 percent based on you know a few billion of buying it's not proportional to the market cap so that's kind of like the hammer that falls down and 5 billion of luna sales just wipes out the entire thing right uh Jose I'm about I'm about to throw this to you but just I think to recap that is uh Jordi I think what you're saying is that if you compare the outstanding supply of usd to the market cap of luna you're saying that there's no way that the luna has enough like ammo right that doesn't have enough capital to fully uh prevent a a death spiral uh Jose you're about to kind of illustrate I think the the case for a death a death spiral and can you also just illustrate how anchor you think Phil uh fits into that role did there's the utility that anchor providing uh to usd is that helping usd maintain its peg or do you also see a risk with with anchor and can you just illustrate some of your thoughts here on this yeah so so the first thing is like anchor uh the 20 percent right right now is unsustainable right the yield reserve is the pleating but simulations that have been done um and and now we can link to a few in the show notes show that the sustainable rate would be anywhere from seven to 12 percent right which is still much higher than anything else available in defy so so so the question is like how much do you need to pay for people to accept the perceived peg risk of usd right and the number that the ecosystem landed on to start with was this 20 percent which which is a really strong meme it's it's uh and and it's like the the number where people are like and even Jordi right who's who's who's uh who's a bear is uh it's sort of what the yield is high enough to compensate for him having some some USD in there so so the question is at what point and now a proposal has passed to to make the rate more dynamic so it's gonna it's gonna adjust every month and so the the the yield's gonna lower and so the question is like what is the the rate at which this uh people start saying you know this isn't um this isn't worth the risk anymore and for for me that would be like below 10 percent that's my sort of estimate there um because i think anchor's still going to be the highest rate in in the five for for the foreseeable future and i think with its model probably forever in terms of the combination of stability and high yield i think anchor will continue to to be that and then the other thing to say is it's it's unsustainable um just like paypal giving away 20 bucks to everyone the used paypal initially was unsustainable right it's it like Jordi said it's marketing spend and i i totally disagree with with the idea that it's that it's been not that successful that the goal was to attract retail in my mind it's been massively successful because it's grown USD supply to 16 billion it's increased USD liquidity and i don't i don't necessarily buy this thing that we need to attract retail or like this is a sort of a separate argument uh i think like Jordi is the user like now Jordi's using USD and so are a bunch of other big funds in this face they have exposure to USD and and you have this magic thing that happens where when when the capital went into anchor um that's when it with people saw USD is most risky because it was completely uncollateralized and so that they needed that 20 percent but now there's a Bitcoin reserve right and what if by the time it and though can fund this this yield reserve for a long time and so what if by the time the yield reserve is is the yield comes down the USD is like 80 percent backed by reserves right then suddenly you have this magic trick where people came in because they wanted the high yield the really high yield and they needed that high yield to compensate them for the risk but now there's a magic trick that happens and you're like well i kind of trust this thing now you know it's been around for a while the four pools the most liquid pool and in defy this thing has all the trading pairs there's exchanges on layer two like zigzag that you're using this actually i want to i want to keep my USD and so it's achieved exactly what it's set out to do right and and for me it's the most no-brainer marketing spend ever like if you can spend 500 million to top up a reserve and get 16 you know or like 10 billion in additional USD and get everyone using it and talking about it and then you can collateralize it in the meanwhile and increase the trust in it um i just think it's like just a genius move in my mind and so that those are sort of my thoughts on the on the anchor sustainability piece on the uh you you indicated something like a 10 percent real rate real yield coming from people that are actually paying uh into into anchor and then it goes up to 20 percent when you add in like the the rewards right it's basically like a yield farming incentive program uh not not exactly like that but yeah it's it's just that um basically the the rate that could be succinct because the the anchor rate is sort of a liability for the anchor platform right because they have to generate enough borrowing in order to be able to pay that rate to depositors because the depositors are right so and so the the simulations that have been done is given current borrowing activity how much uh how much yield can actually anchor actually pay out and so anchors maintaining 20 percent rate not through any it's not like a yield farm it's just it's just literally uh you know uh LFG sending sending some money to the yield reserve which which allows it to keep depleting and paying out that that liability of the platform right but and you said that if if uh the fun stopped paying stopped incentivizing the yields it would come down to something like seven to 12 percent I think you said yeah that is so high above the the rest of the industry I think like USEC is two to three percent where does so much demand to borrow out of anchor come from yeah I mean uh it's it's it is the best place to borrow most uh proof of stake layer one assets right the model is that you you give up your your proof of stake yield on on your layer one asset and in exchange uh you you borrow um very very cheaply and you have the anchor incentives on top so there is some like this model uh it uh is like like any model of stuff like this has its flows for instance it obviously has to assume an anchor price and the incentives that are being paid out to borrowers and stuff like that and there's some reflexivity all all the way through but yeah that's that that's how it does it I think we're going to talk about maybe the probability of um DPEG risk in just a minute because I think uh Jose you sort of um underweight that a little bit you think it's overstated maybe uh and I'm guessing Jordi you probably believe the opposite but I do want to just zone in on this question because you you brought it up Jose is the fact that LFG which is a fund associated with with Luna in kind of um at that ecosystem and helping to like prop up the the value of that economy and specifically USD uh there's been recently in in crypto news uh doquan purchasing you know up to ten billion dollars worth of of Luna and just before this call as I saw a LFG fund purchase which is kind of an acting uh org uh for for doquan in the territory ecosystem purchasing about two hundred million or something Bitcoin like they're doing this um this is one thing I don't understand personally which is is the fact that they're having to buy a foreign asset this is kind of to me like a a bank reserve or a central bank reserve maybe going and buying a foreign asset an off chain asset to Luna the fact that they're buying Bitcoin is that not an admission that the model isn't sustainable and doesn't work tell me about that Jose what how do you respond yeah I just don't I don't really get that argument like for instance like Ethereum is is where is is the fact that if Ethereum is moving uh to e2.
0 proof of stake charting an admission that Ethereum as it currently stands doesn't work no Ethereum as it currently stands works it's just e2.0 is way better right um it's it's a better design and so like Luna as it as it existed for for for its history as a pure algorithmic stable worked there's it's hard to deny that it worked it's it survived uh contractions it grew like exponentially it created a lot of use cases around it but as it gets into this next stage of adoption and trust that Bitcoin reserve backing is super important in order to in order to bootstrap that trust and increase that trust and allow it to scale further Jordy do you want to comment on this before we move to systemic risks and then deepag risks specifically um I think it was universally agreed even by the bears that um using Bitcoin as collateral and not only Luna is the right decision it was a very smart move it makes even if you say it's fairly highly correlated to Luna um it's not going to be one to one correlated so it is adding potentially some diversification and stability to the system versus having just Luna um it just adds a Bitcoin risk and people will always be looking at you know what the big like if Bitcoin goes down they'll be saying well you know Luna took a one billion dollar loss today because they have eight billion in Bitcoin and it went down 10% and that could create um some fud that you're kind of opening up to but I think that move in itself was not a bad move and Jordy that that Bitcoin itself that's custody is it not like where does that Bitcoin live so this is like when I talked at the very beginning that we are so far from like division which I like division but look we are so far from the vision there are so many things to figure out um even for these like super smart people they're trying to figure it out they're extremely complex like you have Bitcoin, Bitcoin's on the Bitcoin network you want to have Bitcoin on the Luna network so that it automatically in a decentralized fashion will be able to be redeemed at 98% of a USD and we can explain why it's 98% not one to one but um you know there's we've seen all the hacks with bridges we're gonna see what solution ends up being found if it's rent BTC or what what version of wrapped Bitcoin they end up using but this is an execution risk that in my mind is far from being solved and is not without risks we've always like unbankless I would agree with that yeah I'm curious your thoughts it's like always unbankless we've we've always been I mean the show is called bankless right but we've we've we've always been in the mindsets that the the moment the asset starts to have trust assumptions and get custodyed is the moment you start to turn into a bank and I'm wondering maybe maybe Jose like you're take on this is what Tara is creating with USD now it's bringing in foreign asset reserves basically how's this different than a bank um yeah so I'm by the way I'm a I'm a director of LFG so one of one of seven directors of LFG this is a kind of disclosure um and yeah I agree it's it's an unsolved problem to to Jordy's point how to how to bring Bitcoin to terror in the most trustless way possible there are solutions out there there's Axelar I think is is an interesting solution it's pretty trustless there's obviously Torchain but none of them are ready for multiple billion dollars of Bitcoin and so at this stage the Bitcoin is custodyed by by the foundation itself which is which is not ideal and then in terms of whether bringing in an asset like ads makes it a bank no I don't I don't think so because like the there's already an asset there there's Luna right and that asset is is like the native asset of the network the only thing that it adds is trust assumptions for sure in terms of bringing Bitcoin over to the network but I don't think trust assumptions make it a bank right a bank is literally the bank controls it it's a centralized legal entity that controls these assets that this like what depending what solution is chosen is going to be much more of a decentralized process and obviously with its own with its own set of additional trust assumptions that that's that's not much is like inevitable I'd say I want to ask a similar question just from the the perspective of the protocol though Ryan said that when you use Bitcoin to help backstop UST you're kind of admitting that you need external help to make the protocol sustainable and I think this really goes into one of the design philosophy differences between Ethereum and Tara where Tara seems to be totally okay with like tapping into the power in the market cap of Bitcoin to help bolsters ecosystem but in my mind that is one protocol that Tara the Luna protocol saying that we need security from external we need external help for security for the protocol as in the protocol can't sustain itself we need to tap into the power of Bitcoin in order to make this thing long term sustainable and I don't think in my mind that you don't really as a layer one protocol it's it's a risk it's a risk to tap into something that you don't have control over in order to help maintain the functioning of your ecosystem like Bitcoin can do things that are outside of the control of Tara because it's outside of the protocol.
Do you see these concerns? Not really because like maker you know dies backed by Bitcoin and actually a very weak form of Bitcoin right with with with very weak trust assumptions which is WBC which is basically a Bitcoin multi-sig it's also backed by USDC right which is which is literally like centralized stablecoins or an IOU for dollars in a bank account right like if if the US government calls calls circle and and obviously it's not I'm not saying it's going to be a phone call but like there's processes in which those funds could be frozen USDC's blacklisted addresses before like it's it's very vulnerable and I would argue much bigger vulnerability than than the Bitcoin one and I still don't agree with this admission article argument sorry because it's not an admission it's it's sort of a growth of the model and I don't think Bitcoin's going to be the only asset that backs USD either in the future I think there's going to be additional layer one assets as they prove themselves that that the community might think would make for good reserve assets so yeah I don't see it as an admission I see it as an evolution of the model in the same way that if they're in 2.
0 isn't an admission that if that theorem doesn't work because clearly a theorem works it's the most successful network in crypto it's just that it this is a better model does this require is it for this to really work does this kind of require like a trustless bridge ecosystem to be sufficiently built out like we don't really want the long-term system to really just be dependent on like trusts right we're like we want to have these things baked into smart contracts using trustless bridges is that kind of the model for how we would get all these layer one assets also backing USD yes uh yeah we need we need good trustless bridges but that there are other design opportunities right like you could create synthetic assets um so sort of at the layer one level with with with an Oracle at the layer one level there's a design space here which has different trust assumptions and and different trade-offs but I don't think that that's the only possible solution okay Jordy uh let's move on to like um the DPEG risk here because that's um there's something we've seen with other algo stablecoins you know that's spiral DPEGging and um eventual kind of like a tombstone at the end of it um what are the risks of a DPEG event in the USD Terra ecosystem uh yeah right and I think uh it's the two that I touched upon so one is there is a reduction in USD demand and um you know I think even Jose said how important that that demand is and the the role um that the Luna team has is to sustain that demand because of the demand goes down that really kind of creates a problem um so a reduction in demand because of anchor having to reduce its yields and then people finding higher yield somewhere else like I said it's entirely possible that another layer one designs the same mechanism and gives a slightly higher yield and back and create a relative I mean I agree with Jose like it can't just be like a totally like new layer one that exists out of thin air because people won't trust it and we've seen something similar recently with waves which is not new but is um it's kind of had some issues with a similar model but um and existing layer one can try to start seeing how successful this design is can just start doing it themselves and increase uh yield a little bit so there's a lot of ways that the demand for USD can go down now what they're trying to do in the meantime I don't think it's exactly marketing spent I think what uh what an effect they're doing is buying time they're buying time on the Luna site to say we we will do this for a year and in that year we will go like all out and integrate as many places as we can in the DeFi ecosystem we will get on curve we will get on the pools we will try to have USD perpetual trading instead of USDT tether perpetuals for trading venues we will put USD everywhere to the point where we try to like it's sort of a bet that you can create enough use cases where people will just like you know we've been living with uh tether risk for years right because we need we need it we need it to exist uh trading venues needed finance needs it and it's been it's kind of been supported by the whole community and in a way I think the plan is make it similar to that make it similar to tether and not in the central ii sense but in the sense of the community accepts that yeah maybe it's not we don't we don't know if it's a hundred percent back but we're just gonna go with it and and it's a gamble and you know um it's I'm not saying it's a bad gamble it's a gamble um i don't know if you guys have Korean friends i have i have Korean friends and they love to gamble and they're you know it's it's fine but that's we should we should say what's going on it's funny one one person's uh fake it till you make it is another person's like let's just bootstrapping and so i'm curious Jose what your response would be to the deep the deepagging and um i guess uh death spiral risk in usc do you think it's overrated or underrated well the the first thing i'd say is uh it's important to concede that there is a risk right and people need to be aware of that risk when they both use usc and when they use luna because there is that risk it's it's a design where that's happened in the past and and obviously that's that's there but but um what what i would say is that like first of all even even before the the Bitcoin reserves actually maybe if we go from from from a little bit higher level um when you have a design like die well you even higher level actually so all these things have risks right uh die as safe as the overclassicalized design is nearly blew up on on in you know black black Friday or whatever black Thursday whatever it was because of congestion on the at the chain level like all these things have risks even things that you don't think have risks and have smart contract bugs and things and so and and and then also um decentralized tables that use centralized collateral have a complete other set of risks right which is that actually the collateral they're using could be censored um and if if if we go pvp with governments which is a real pvp rather than the pvp against each other that that's like a very real risk so there's there's like a spectrum of risks and it's not it's not that usc is the only risky stablecoin it's that stablecoins have different sets of risks and trade-offs that they make right and so the trade-off for me between die and usc which are the own like the two biggest decentralized stablecoins is that die prioritizes uh safety and like protection from tail from tail risk over growth and usc prioritizes growth and capital efficiency over downside risk right and so what we've seen with with die is um it's really hard to grow it because demand for for for die actually doesn't grow the supply of die it's the demand for leverage that does and so maker ends up competing with other lending platforms for this which is why they've had to add centralized collateral like like like like usc right um and so that that's that's a problem in in in itself right and then usc obviously as we've seen can grow much quicker but the trade-off is this this downside risk that we're that we're talking about this tail risk that can happen with the with the reflexivity that spiral and just like Jordi explained it really well but there's kind of two scenarios right with it with a death spiral one is like Luna Bear market or like that or like um crypto bear market Luna crashes people are like oh shit I don't know if Luna can can that's where I'm this and if not just maybe you can believe it out later uh uh uh the uh yeah Luna crashes everyone's like I don't know if Luna can can can like honor all its liabilities in usc they start redeeming their usc more Luna gets minted the price crashes further more people want to redeem usc etc and the second one is it starts with usc instead right there's a large contraction of demand for for usc which means a lot of Luna price goes down um and then and then the death spiral can starts that way um and so the first thing I would say is that like Luna is backed by an every stablecoin but Luna specifically is backed by by three things right the first and most important one is the demand for itself uh non speculative demand is is really the holy grail of of backing for for a stablecoin and that's what backed Luna for most of its history um other than in certain contractions where Luna had to come in so and so the second thing the backs Luna is is Luna itself right in that it absorbs um shifts in demand for usc when when when demand goes down Luna gets minted to absorb that and now we have this this this third layer as well which is this bitcoin reserve which effectively acts as an escape hatch and breaks that reflexivity spiral right because now when people want to redeem usc and there's there's there's a there's a large contraction sharp contraction demand instead of having to mint Luna they have this ability to that this escape hatch this escape valve which is bitcoin where they can they can redeem it for bitcoin right which reduces the pressure on Luna and breaks that like reflexive death spiral which is which is really the problem now uh so so that's all that's all clear um that the valid question to ask about this is um whether three billion is enough right like given that UST is now at sixteen billion is three billion actually enough reserves to to um to to protect it and I think the honest answer is that no one knows it's it's it's it's impossible to to model these things like reflexivity is really hard to model right all the all these things you have variables that that aren't independent they all actually like are recursive and depend on each other so it's it's really hard to model um what I would say is the system survived up till now with with no reserves and so I think the psychological impact of this is going to be huge and then I would also say that what the LFG raise really shows is that people understand like investors understand the the upside of the UST which is the other side of the tradeoff right which you can which is that you can grow faster stablecoins are a network effects business um there's going to be one or a few big winners on this there's there's a bunch of network effects liquidity um Lindy and so it's it's really difficult to to um to unseat a stablecoin and what we've seen is that when you start with collateralization you don't necessarily get the man but when you start with the man you can get collateralization that's what the LFG raise proves right and what we're seeing right now I have good reason to believe uh there's enough demand on secondary markets to bring Luna above sort of 50 to 75% in Bitcoin reserves just right now right through through through transactions on the secondary market and so my my view is that basically three billion um I don't know if it's enough but if it isn't I think Luna can can collateralize itself over time both through these these secondary sales and collateralize the wrong word um reserves is really the right word but it can grow those reserves over time both on the secondary market and through these through these um through through seniorage so changing the mechanism so that instead of all the Luna being burnt part of it's actually used to acquire Bitcoin over time so that the reserves can grow organically over time um that's my view on it yeah I have a one quick question then we're going to have to pause or break and I look guys if you're okay with it we want to go over time because this has been such an insightful like conversation we still have a few more topics to cover is that cool absolutely more time after the break okay uh just one quick follow up on this Jose I mean you mentioned uh Lindy effect right and you also mentioned uh you'll maker uh being tested in 2020 part of me wonders about this has USD actually been tested because the real test of I think any stablecoin design algorithmic or otherwise is how does it sustain not during the good times but during like the bad times as Jordi was saying earlier the the tail risk events and when maker uh had that like ETH price drop with you know exorbitant gas use and everything in uh the the covid drop of a black Thursday in March of 2020 that was a huge testing event for maker and like people didn't know how it would fare because it never had felt something like that before but it made it out it sustained it on the other side I'm curious whether lunas actually been tested in your mind like it's one thing for an algo stablecoin to work during the bull run and lunas had an absolutely massive secular bull run for the last year or more that's one thing but that's easy mode that's not what a stablecoin is uh meant to be built for it's meant to be built when there's earthquakes and tornadoes and hurricanes and the entire world is shaking uh you know around you um has it been tested in that way and do you think that is a an important piece in terms of building the credibility of this system a hundred percent I think so our equivalent or the the tarot communities equivalent of the of the maker black Thursday was was May 2021 so May 2021 last year where Luna dropped from uh there was a contraction in UST supply at the same time as there was sort of some some coordinated um fought around around Luna not to say coordinated in the sense of like that there was anything malicious just that there was it all happened at the same time right it was at very adverse market conditions Luna dropped from 20 plus dollars to three dollars in that time there was a contraction in UST supply uh but then you know uh buyers came in for for Luna in the in the system the system survived right and there was a lot of lessons learned from that both in terms of all the on the mechanism side increasing on chain liquidity changing some of the parameters for fermenting and burning um and and and also other other lessons that have been that have been learned there now the UST was much smaller when that happened so I do think there will be there will be other tests um I don't think like the UST or Luna journey is going to be up only so I think I think they're going to be other tests for it but certainly it's been it's been battle tested like think about how uh you know think about using oh yeah the other thing that was really actually promising during the May that May drop was that while Luna was dropping and like uh and and and sort of the the death spiral was underway effectively you actually saw uh deposits on anchor increase which means that there were some people they were actually selling Luna for UST fleeing to safety right and so what that shows and it's like a really positive thing I think psychologically is that some people already see UST as their safe haven you know when when shit hits the fat on chain they're actually fleeing to UST and going into anchor and saying I need a break you know I'm I'm gonna I need to go into stables and so like imagine anyone doing that with like ESD or uh or DSD right like no one is fleeing to the safety of ESD or DSD.
I don't know I don't know if I I don't know I mean just interrupt like I don't know if you can say that like it's that's proof that like smart people are like you know the smart money's doing it it's within the Terry ecosystem within people who are lunatics it makes sense you know they're like should I have the variable one or the stable one and like I'm going to stay within the ecosystem I'm not going to bridge out I'm not going to like find a way out I'm just going to move between the two I'm not I mean I agree with a lot of what you said but I'm not sure that that necessarily proves um something that like you know smart people are doing that um no comment on the on the smart people thing but but it does prove Lindy right it proves that for some people it's it's it's a stable coin it's it's safety it proves that there's like a psychological sort of belief in it that that that some people have and it's hard to hard to deny whether you would do it or and whether you think it was it was smart for them to do it fair enough fair enough fair enough I'm trying to say every community like a Cardano you know Cardano community whoa there was a market crash they would do the same every community that that is a community that is a layer one they will be people within that community within that layer one that that seek to do that um but I'd say it's I'd say it's slightly different I agree but I'd say it's slightly different because that one thing is buying Cardano when it drops and you're like Cardano to them I'm happy the price dropped you know I get to buy more or whatever the the coke stuff the people if you say at those points another thing is is buying the actual stable coin right because that that shows that you trust the system it's not even that you want it doesn't you're not buying it for profit or you're buying the dip you're actually just like using the system as it's meant to be designed so like I think it's slightly like different point I agree it's like different and I do want to ask you would you not say that in terms of lindiness the upcoming like you said the yield reduction in anchor is going to be a whole new different type of test that we we don't know yet what's going to happen with that yeah I would I would say so I'm pretty positive on that I don't I don't think it'll matter that much for the reason I said before but I agree it's going to be a big big test and the test space now we much bigger than than the ones faced previously for sure awesome guys that thank you for going on that back and forth I was immensely interesting there are a couple of subjects which we haven't touched on yet which we definitely need to before we wrap up this show the pool four is definitely clamoring being talked about throughout the ecosystem both on the maker side and on the on the terrorist side it seems to be that the word maker just creates a bunch of just very strong emotions according to the YouTube chat that I've been watching they do not like that word so we're going to have to talk about the four pool there's also we want to talk about doquan himself the level of key man risk that is associated with us t and and doquan the guy has a ton of confidence lately and I want to get your guys his perceptions as to the level of risk and there's also the conversation of just simply being too big to fail and is this an actual intent intentful strategy by the terror ecosystem just to become so large that it becomes too big to fail and what does that even mean so these are the the remaining topics that we want to get your guys his opinions on and we'll get there right after we talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make the show possible if you're trying to grow and preserve your crypto wealth optimizing your taxes is just as lucrative is trying to find the next hidden gem also IRA can help you invest in crypto and tax advantage ways to help you preserve your hard earned money also crypto IRA let's invest in more than 150 coins and tokens with all the same tax advantages of an IRA they make it easy to fund your alternative IRA or crypto IRA via your 401k or by contributing directly from your bank account there is no setup or account fees and it's all you need to do to invest in crypto tax-free let me repeat that again you can invest in crypto tax-free diversify like the pros and trade without tax headaches open an alto crypto IRA to invest in crypto tax-free this goes to alto IRA dot com slash bankless that's a l t o i r a dot com slash bankless and start investing in crypto today the brave browser is the user first browser for the web 3 internet with over 50 million monthly active users control your digital footprint with built-in privacy and ad blocking inside the brave browser you'll find the brave wallet the first secure crypto wallet built natively inside of a web 3 crypto browser web 3 is freedom from big tech and wall street more control and better privacy but there's a weak point in web 3 your crypto wallet the brave wall brave wallet is built natively inside the brave browser no extension required which gives the brave wallet an extra level of security versus other wallets with the brave wallet you can buy store send and swap your crypto assets and it can even manage your NFTs and connect to other wallets and defi apps all from the security of the best privacy browser on the market whether you're new to crypto or in season pro it's time to switch to the brave wallet download brave at brave dot com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started ava is the leading decentralized liquidity protocol and now ava v3 is here ava v3 has powerful new features to enable you to get the most out of defi including isolation mode which allows for many more markets to be launched with more exotic collateral types and also efficiency mode which allows for a higher loan to value ratios and of course portals allowing users to port their ava position across all of the networks that ava operates on like polygon phantom avalanche arbitrum optimism and harmony the beautiful thing about ava is that it's completely open source decentralized and governed by its community enabling a truly bank this future for us all to get your first crypto collateralized loan get started at ava dot com that's a ava dot com and also check out the ava protocol governance forums to see what more than a hundred thousand down members are all roving about at governance dot ava dot com hey guys we are back with hose and jordie this is the best debate i've ever heard on this topic you know just fantastic so we we appreciate these two for for going over time with us but we just wanted to make sure we covered all of the topics the best inform you here's another topic some i think the the bears of the critics of luna and us t would say that there's a lot of key man risk some might even say like is this like banker type risk uh dokwan is appearing more and more as kind of an elan musk type of figure i would say in the community and take that for the kind of the good and the bad side of things but definitely somebody who uh makes statements like by my own hand die will die when uh like talking about the competition between maker and the die ecosystem and uh us t um some have talked about how maybe uh dokwan is is flying a bit close to the sun with with some of these statements and uh maybe some of the regulatory risk that that's going on as well of course the sec is in play but um like when you have a centralized you would say decentralized i think hose but when you have a stable coin uh of this type you might attract some unwanted attention from regulators as well and all of this kind of comes down to uh dokwan and sort of a smaller operating team would be the criticism i'm curious first of all maybe the bear case for for all of this uh from your perspective jordi do you think that there's some key man risk that um the us t terror ecosystem is as dealing with you think there are some centralization vectors how would you talk about this piece of it yeah i'm glad you said centralization vectors because i think that's the bigger issue um in terms of dokwan i think he's phenomenally intelligent he's been making very good decisions and he's the reason why this has gone as far as it's gone compared to like you know the things that are not even gotten out of the gate obviously there's key man risk if he gets hit by a bus here in Singapore tomorrow will everyone's gonna sell like that's a problem i don't have a huge problem with that because we are early stages and he's building something that eventually is supposed to kind of run itself um i don't think it's a question that right now there is a key man risk i don't want to personally focus on that because anything like you could say that about ilan tesla like does that mean like tesla should not exist because um you know ilan there's key man risk i don't think it's a big deal in itself um i do want to touch on the second point about centralization i don't know if Jose wants to answer about dokwan first though he he's obviously with him when i have and maybe he can answer about that nah good go ahead i probably agree with with your with your take on a pretty pretty closely so yeah go ahead on the centralization point and then i can answer i can answer both yeah i mean the the bigger issue i have um is we're talking about decentralization it's decentralized stablecoin i don't know that there is enough diversity in the ecosystem and the people who are building and supporting the ecosystem yet and i'm not talking about though i'm talking more kind of like the jump uh jump capital jump crypto whatever they call themselves now um they are such a huge backer and supporter that i think overshadows um obviously delfi as well but i'm sure you you're behind the scenes you kind of know what i'm talking about um it's a bit less organic than um some of the other layer ones and that's going to take a while to change and i don't know exactly how we get from point a to point b where it is a community fully decentralized kind of run thing as opposed to you know you have one brilliant founder and and like a very powerful uh kind of company that's really how do you get from point a to point b yep uh do you want me to comment on that now yeah go ahead respond uh Jose cool yeah so so the first thing to say is i obviously really believe in decentralization like i wouldn't be in this space if i didn't think uh that was super important however um i do think i believe in like progressive decentralization right and i do think projects need to decentralize over time and in the right way um and i think the way like um especially for a stablecoin because a stablecoin requires a lot of like uh like get shit done energy you know you you need to you need to push integrations you need to build products around it you need to do all the stuff that that kind of doughcoin has been has been so good at doing um and i think what we see with like when you decentralized too early is sort of what you're seeing uh in my mind by the way this is my opinion on the maker governance forums um and i'm a huge fan of maker it was my first altcoin that i bought after ethereum i learned loads on those maker forums back in the days so like big big fan of maker but to me to see their governance at work now is is is is is a huge disappointment right it's a it's a massive bureaucratic mess um there's committees for everything people aren't well paid uh like communities weighing in and and commenting on things they're very focused on risk assessment versus growth uh you know ruin the founder of maker kind of admitted he he doesn't understand the the curve wars which which are sort of like the lifeblood of liquidity for for stablecoins in a decentralized world they seem to have that like a sort of an arrogant attitude towards DeFi generally that it's old punsies and the only thing that matters is these real world assets and and green bonds and all this so like i do think that that decentralizing too early is is a problem and for me the the the right way to to decentralize is actually to do what what terror is doing and on board like these big organizations with skin in the game that act as like a separate a participant and stakeholder in the ecosystem right and there's a bunch of those now obviously jump is is Jordi pointed out is is is a big one i would say Delphi labs um so the the part of Delphi that i head up is is another big one sort of contributing to projects in a terror ecosystem in the recent round we had some really good additions with with three arrows and others there there's someone um behind the scenes that they're they're doing a lot of work in the terror ecosystem and i do think that's the right way to decentralize right with these big organizations that are that are focused that have skin in the game and then and the other thing to remember is like we're literally decent like decentralizing now would be so early because USD market cap is 16 billion and this is a multi trillion dollar market right and the the the time to to like it's much easier to grow fast when you're more more centralized than it is decentralized and so for me the plan should be to progressively decentralize over time grow supply loads and then uh once once once you have that lindia effect and once you once you've grown uh decentralized and and focus on robustness and obviously there's a balance but that that's sort of my it might take and i do think decentralization in crypto uh unfortunately often gets used is is sort of um away for for for founders that have made it to kind of like semi-retire right and and and and become contributors and like pass it off to the community when really the project isn't ready for that and it needs the founder it needs that founder energy um to kind of push things forward not not that they should be a centralized point of control and though isn't right the system would work without him but they need that energy of contribution and that inspiration uh inspirational leadership to push it forward um and then in terms of key manorisk clearly there's key manorisk around though uh he's a machine like uh i worked with a lot of founders in the space i'd say though is is the best one maybe along with like stanny um he's he's like a really good mix of sort of a great engineer and like a very very sharp engineer and grain with hustle vision and then he's obviously like made it several times over but it's still incredibly motivated worked harder than me you know it takes takes less all it is and i do um so it's clearly key manorisk around that um hard hard to avoid in an in an early stage project.
Jose with the the spectrum of centralization and decentralization uh i'm wondering if you agree with this take right so like you've you've got like a big coin and a theorem which are maybe on the the far left side of the decentralization spectrum like bearing towards most decentralized right and then you have like the traditional tradfly system that's called that called that kind of the right side of the spectrum right and then you have like crypto banks you have the uh fdx's of the world and you have the coin bases of the world that you know are a bit left of the uh the traditional finance because they're using decentralized crypto networks to settle things and that sort of thing um some people have compared uh the terri ecosystem to almost like this hybrid mix it's sort of like fintech ish meets block chain and placed it kind of somewhere in the middle is this hybrid sort of blend do you think that's where you'd place it in the decentralization spectrum do you think it's like or do you think it's more uh kind of toward the left more decentralized over time and maybe competing with uh layer ones like a theorem and bitcoin yeah i think uh even putting decentralization on like a linear spectrum is really tough because there are ways in which a theorem is extremely decentralized but then also it's it's main stablecoin uh is is entirely centralized and actually the biggest stablecoins in a theorem are completely centralized they're just i'll use for dollars in a bank account and those are the undercurrent of all of ethereum defi and so if those go down ethereum is it really has like a big centralized attack vector in the centralized stablecoins so like technically and in terms of node count and all of that theorems extremely decentralized but then it has this very you know centralized attack vector and i think that's why it's hard to put it on like a spectrum um in terms of terra i would say the system itself you know from from a technical perspective is fairly centralized you know um nowhere near as decentralized as a theorem in terms of node count and all of that but it's a it's a tenderment chain right so it's it's a proof of stake tenderment chain um what i would say is centralized um is just like there are organizations in the ecosystem who um who have like a can make a big impact on the successor or failure of this like jump um like uh you know tfl like though if you if you if you'd agree with that like lfg um but now increasing there there's an increasing number of those to the point where that is becoming a decentralizing force in itself so that's kind of my take on like i think the system is decentralized but there are some uh there there are some you know centralized entities that are that are a big sort of um part of of its success does that make sense yeah that's a good take david's on mute all right thank you uh yeah thank you for that Jose what thoughts have come to mind before we go on and move on to any other subject anything that's come up to your brain i mean in terms of like you know you start centralized and you make incremental steps i fully believe in that um in terms of the ecosystem the fact that like to main big groups are building a lot of the primitives um i have mixed feelings about it like i know one team that's been working hard to try to get like one of the options protocols out on Terra and they just realized that oh there is a there's they just launched one that's backed by the founding team how are we going to compete with them when they're backed by dough and these guys and we you know we wanted to launch the same thing so you're going to have a lot of the ecosystem be kind of you have that little bit of salana but not as much i think you know salana has quite a diverse group of founders that ultimately are not necessarily all um you know ftx related etc um or jump related um but look out the end of the game like does it really matter what ecosystem Terra has if the the key thing is the stablecoin like for me it it might not even matter it might just matter what what what they manage to do in terms of going to other chains and getting us t on other chains and making it spread everywhere as opposed to necessarily building all the primitives on on Terra if they do really good ones then it could work um it's obviously got the narrative right now so i don't um i don't have a strong opinion i guess well okay talking about us t on other chains i think it's exactly where we want to go next uh recently dokwan uh proposed the four pool a new curve pool between us t frax usdc and usdt uh so that's of course uh Terra usd the frax stablecoin usdc and then tether um uh most importantly pushing out die uh moving removing die from from the the curve pool uh and uh he was claiming that the curve wars are over and that all emissions are going to the four pool meaning meaning that all the incentives are going to be towards adding liquidity to the four pool rather than the previous pool with die in it so uh uh Jose i want to get your perspective on this uh dokwan tweeted out by my hand die will die which is a pretty aggro thing to tweet out like what's his deal with maker like why does he not like maker so much and what's the what how does this four pool from curve kind of fit into the story um i think though like at least this is my interpretation i'm i don't i don't you know pretend to speak for though it is just that maker and and generally there's there's sort of group of people on twitter that are constantly um making some pretty malformed arguments against us t and also just calling it like a punzy and referring into it and stuff like that and i think it must be frustrating as a founder who who's put their life's work into this and created something pretty incredible which is an algorithmic stablecoin that that is worked and is now you know and doing everything that he's doing uh i think it must be pretty annoying to to keep hearing that um and i think maker has been pretty pretty arrogant about it and and and sort of dismissive of it and i think that's that my interpretation is that that's rubbed him him the wrong way um i don't know if that's accurate or not but and then in terms of the four pool it's it's a huge move right uh the three pool is the biggest and like most most liquid pool on on curve so it ends up being the bridge pool for a lot of stablecoin swaps and then the bridge pool for a lot of swaps generally especially it's curvy too and the volatile assets becomes bigger with this so and and and fracks had it had its own pool which it was participating in the curve war so like buying a lot of convex in order to to influence and then terror had its own pool that again it was doing it was doing the same thing and they've basically like teamed up right they've they've kind of cartelified um and and they're along with with redacted and there's also i think if you others joining this coalition in order to put in this four pool which will be you know fracks um ust uh tether and usdc and and send all incentives towards this pool which should make it the most liquid pool in a stablecoin pool in defi and become the bridge pool so that so that uh fracks and and usd become the reference decentralized stablecoins uh across chain so pretty huge move uh i was really taken aback by it i'll be curious to hear what Jordy thinks about it actually because yeah it seems seems like a big thing yeah i mean we've been talking about the curve wars for a while now and now we've actually seen somebody make a move and try to get you know consortium together and and pull something like this off um i think it's interesting uh you know we're very much an experimental phase here and um you know seeing Olympus join in is you know you're having these like strange bellows here where you're kind of getting the votes and we're we're an experimental land um i'm interested to see how how it all plays out um yeah i think this is fully like my popcorn on this one.
Jordy do you think this will like result in the full saturation of ethereum defi with uh usd? uh no i don't think it's that straightforward i mean we're there's so many assumptions like first of all the assumption that centralized stablecoins um are problematic right now uh i mean i agree with Jose like eventually like we have to create something for when the day comes and and we need and we need to have something decentralized but um i don't think that the vast majority of usdc being used on ethereum is is gonna stop uh being utilized i'm not sure about dies prospects obviously um that's a different story and i'm not i'm not an expert on it so i can't comment on on dies prospects but in terms of like usdc uh being outstripped by usd i don't i don't think we're at that stage right now i don't think we're at that stage either but i do think uh centralized like if you just zoom out to the long term which is like what the way we we work at Delphi as we just try and figure out what's the future of crypto going to be what should it be and then we just try and both figure it out to invest in it but also just build towards it right and for me it's pretty clear that centralized stablecoins will not be the long-term solution for for a bunch of reasons right like their bank accounts can get frozen and suddenly they're insolven um they can get forced to freeze uh transactions they have the power to unilaterally like freeze uh balances right and they can get forced to do that by governments but then there's even smaller things like they're facilitating you know like hundreds of billions of dollars of transactions for clients that they know nothing about right and that that's going to be a problem for nation states like at some point they're going to be like hey who are these people that they're transacting like is there any KYC here and stuff and you you can't do that for dire for usd in the same way and if those products become KYC they just become way less relevant right and it's not the case that it'll get regulated and it'll go at once i don't think that's not necessarily going to happen what's going to happen is let's say suddenly uh they start freezing balances from from people who didn't pay their taxes right governments find um some links from centralized exchanges to people who who didn't declare it on their taxes they find out they have USDC they contact uh circle and get them to to freeze their balance suddenly um that doesn't just affect people who don't pay their taxes right and first of all it affects all the people who don't pay their taxes so i think is uh is a is a is a big is a big amount of people but also affects everyone else because suddenly you're like damn when i hold these stables these this isn't actually crypto it becomes very visceral right this isn't crypto um and and so that will cause the slow move and then if they do something like KYC that'll again cause more of a move and so i think like slowly over time it'll it'll all move to to decentralized stablecoins that's kind of how how we're positioning ourselves um and then just one thing i wanted to touch on that Jordy said before about other layer ones uh being able to copy the the design i agree that they they should do it uh i think it's a really good i think it's a good idea because you you literally own your biggest use case right you verticalize and and like own when you when you when your biggest use case is rather than letting someone else build on top of it and rather than letting it become centralized as well which is another big big problem i do think it's going to be really tough for the reasons uh mentioned before that it's not a mechanism like it is a mechanism but it's much more than a mechanism it's actually the economy and the demand that's built around it and so the layer one would end up having the same problem where it has to go through all its applications and ask them to integrate it right um and so i think you need both uh a layer one that's willing to do it and like a visionary or a group of visionaries that can build all these use cases around it and get people to actually use it because otherwise uh you risk blowing up your layer one as well right uh with with with something like this as yes d and dsd did so and and also that you you can fork the mechanism you can't fork the reserves you can't fork the lindy you can't fork the experience of a year and a half of running this so i do think that's much tougher than than uh then generally copying a mechanism is but i was i one one uh question i have for you is like a bit about the first point about amlkyyc and uh like yeah having a decentralized stablecoin being important to to stand up against like the usdcs of the world why do you think the same fate won't befall uh usd right so there are many centralization vectors the lfg group being one of them certainly the jump capitals of the world are highly regulated institutions um some of this is uh you know executed via bridges which also could be a kind of a centralization vector uh i think someone who is very into like the consensus layer of chains might even say sort of you know proof of stake validators that uh are run by um you know third parties and not by users you know from their own homes or another centralization vector can you give me the case for why this just isn't also just happened to us usd yeah it's just a good question there's an important distinction which is in luna no one can seize assets or freeze balances right there's no one you can sapina but you you can sapina jump and be like hey you know i want you to freeze this wall this this this dude doesn't pay the taxes they they can't do that right neither can though neither can tfl no one can do that in in usdc there's a clear entity circle uh which which is actually a us entity and so like uh in in in the usd restriction that can freeze balances and if they receive a sapina and in order by the us government they are able to do it so it's a case of you trusting whether they will or won't whereas with with tarry you can't so there are there are centralization vectors you can hit and make things difficult so you could say no one can integrate usd because they're not doing kysc in the us or something like that but you can't actually like destroy it in the same way that you could with something like usdc or tether i do want to get back into and just to wrap up the conversation around the four pool uh Jose can you like measure for us the significance of the adoption of the four pool in lieu of the three pool like how critical of a how big of a w would that be for usd and how big of an l would that be for die um like ruin made it yeah it would be a massive when i i don't have like um stats off the top of my head but it would be a massive win right like curve is the liquidity help for stablecoins and defi um and and basically dies is with through the three pool is the most liquid decentralized stablecoin on curve this would make it not the case right it would make usd and fracks the most liquid decentralized stablecoins on curve so it's a it's a huge thing because if you want to bridge from from stablecoins to to other stablecoins or just if you want access to the usd ecosystem um everything becomes way easier when when you have the most liquidity and liquidity is one of the biggest modes with um with decentralized stablecoins now rune and i also think maker's response is is sort of like classic which is just they point out that um unlike something like this happening to usd this isn't a threat to the die peg right which is true like but dies design means that it losing a huge amount of utility and demand isn't a threat to its peg but is it it is a threat to its stablecoin right so it is a stablecoin and like it's not enough to just be pegged like you have to grow to win in this market like stablecoins are going to be huge and if you're not growing if you're just pegging that's not enough like these aren't uh risk management products you know that that's one one side of it but there's the other side which is the adoption of utility and the man which i feel like it's is just not being considered um and the response to me is like sort of symptomatic of of what i see is the problem with them and obviously people will disagree and some people are very bullish on the real world assets strategy at it yeah so just might take let's talk about maybe the the last thing we haven't talked about all of this which is uh what would actually happen during a deep pegging type scenario i think both of you acknowledge that there is some risk there and uh Jose would rate it uh far lower than the majority but i think of course we're all in defy as we end every bankless podcast with um this is risky you could lose everything right uh and and certainly algo stablecoins have been risky in the past and so we just walk through like a a nightmare scenario for you why why people are maybe worried about this critics are worried about this like the U.
S.T. fails like it could drag the entire industry down with us but let's say there is some big deep pegging event massive liquidation bunch of investors um get liquidated all across you know chains lots of people lose a lot of money and the next thing you know Elizabeth Warren is on CNN saying hey i told you guys the shadowy super coders were going to take from retail and here they are again right and we have to regulate this industry we have to clamp down on it we have to outlaw it uh until we understand what's going on it can't be the wild west anymore uh and it drags the entire crypto space down with it that is what some people would say is kind of the the tail event risk of uh something like usc growing too big and then suddenly collapsing i'm curious Jordi what you think about this do you think this is a possible scenario is this something that you worry about or do you think even like bears and critics who say that are getting a bit over their skis and then we'll get Jose to respond as an aside i like how i used over the ski thing early like a introduction and since then i've noticed like everyone's used it in the languages mimetic my friend um look all right it's a risk we like we just said and i don't think that me and Jose are in huge discrepanied about the chance of the risk maybe a little bit but not not to a huge extent um in terms of the Elizabeth Warren thing she's been bringing up you know wonderland she's what whatever it's been going on that's negative in crypto she'll bring up now if if something happens in the next few months i don't think it's necessarily a big deal i mean it's a big deal but it's it's not going to be the end of the world if it happens in a year where like you know everyone is already assuming that usc is um is money it's it's it's it's equal to a dollar uh and and something for whatever reason happens at that time yeah it'll shake the foundation of a crypto a lot of people might get hurt and uh the thing that i hate about it the most um you see how these things play out we've seen them recently we've had mim wonderland so we've seen like the curve pool there there's a certain amount of liquidity that you can get out of and what ends up happening is out of nowhere you just have like element out one of these like huge whales just max the whole thing for five hundred million or whatever it takes everything out they'll take a hit you know they'll lose uh they'll take a fifty million dollar loss because they've they've accepted the slippage that comes along with such a big order but they will just unilaterally suck all the liquidity out and that's the signal for everybody else to panic but it's kind of too late because the money's already gone there's not much usc usc t left in so uh in that nightmare scenario the thing that i hate about the most is that the big players um who are like the big whales you know we don't need to like talk who they are we'll have we'll probably like be able to swipe the curve pool first they'll take out the best price and then the the system that Luna has for um uh you know until the bitcoin system comes along right now they just uh we'll we'll use Luna as the collateral there's a cap every day this is what we saw back in last May there's 20 million dollar cap now even if that's increased a hundred million the reality is that the retail guys are not going to be able to get any of that 20 million per day it'll just instantly be taken out every day by million dollars but yeah 20 million Luna or 20 million usc um we can go check this out i don't think the cap of daily cap is 20 million usc but we can go we can go check that afterwards okay i'm pretty sure back in May that it was only 20 million dollars of uh usc but back then the price of Luna was so small that you may be right maybe it was just because it wasn't that far from a dollar at the time that uh maybe the point being um there is some cap and i don't think it's 20 million Luna um i know it's not 20 million but i don't i don't know yeah but we'll get the exact numbers for listeners maybe finish up my understanding is uh it used to be 10 million and then jump into 20 million and there's been discussion about getting it to a hundred million uh and what we see in times of demand like recently is every day it's capped at the at the max every day but in the in the other direction people are trying to get into terror because they want to get on anger so it's capped every day and someone's making a lot of money on the arbitrage because they can make 30 40 bips you can go to Binance sell it for 40 bips above the peg and somebody is getting like all 20 right away and and making like 40 bips on it the reverse is going to happen in the bad scenario where the first the people who are actually able to get out are going to cap the supply those are going to be like the sophisticated whales so you'll have the curveful taken out and then you'll have the max supply every day so that's a nightmare scenario i hope doesn't happen but unfortunately if it does happen it won't be uh it won't be very equitable so uh Jose back to you Jordi is uh like manifesting some 20 uh 2008 energy where retail is once again left holding the bag for a tail risk event like this um how do you respond to maybe that that that moral risk the moral hazard here of uh experiment like usc getting too big yeah um it would definitely be catastrophic i think right now would be mainly catastrophic for terror itself uh so obviously like lunar holders lunar with with uh you know death spirals at you know some asymptotes towards zero i suppose um usc would would would do the same so be very catastrophic for terror itself there is a lot of usc on on ethereum and liquidity pools but i don't think uh you know most of the effect would really be on on terror itself that actually changes with the four pool right where the effect would be more systemic in that case because it would be the the reference currency for defy as a whole but um i don't really um agree with uh with the idea that uh retail would get screwed because retail is just like smaller sizing right so it would be much easier for for them to get out with lower slippage than it would for some of these big funds where some of these big funds would literally just not be able to to get out in size because of what you say where the liquidity would just dry up on the on the curve pool so i think i'll be obviously don't be faster yeah exactly it depends who gets out first like if they wait too long and somebody all like i agree it's a lot easier to go through the door if you're small but you need to know you need to know to get through the door you need to know but i absolutely but but i think there's also going to be like right now most of the liquidity is on curve i think uh astroports going to be spinning up its own stablecoin pool says going to be liquidity on on terror too so users will be able to kind of exit that way um so i don't know yeah i agree that the whales will know first um but they'll also uh suffer a lot more slippage and they'll also that we've also seen a few times where whales exited suffered slippage for something that wasn't the that spiral they were looking for so yeah i i'm i'm sensitive to the to the moral argument obviously but but i do think uh two things there's a more moral argument for us t as well right there's a moral moral argument for decentralized stablecoins like actual decentralized stablecoins they can't be stopped by by by nation states uh so that's the first thing i think that's really important and then the second thing is that everything in this space has uh failure risk these these are all experiments you know including something like that like i mentioned before almost blew up in in uh in on on black Thursday right and that would have been at that time catastrophic for the for the space uh obviously we have the Dow hack from back in the day which was something that shouldn't have had shouldn't have even been that risky but was because i had a smart contract bug in it so i think like as you say at the end right this is the frontier um we we we all kind of accept that risk when when we when we when we play here but i do think um one thing that is important is that everyone and especially if you have a platform and your your bullish lunar your bullish us t um you should be honest about the the risks right and that's something that we're we're very careful to do it at delf i you know and when we when we present it we're always careful to disclaim it uh in in products that we that we help incubate and contribute to it it's always present in the in the disclaimers and so i think being honest about the risks so people know them is super important because that's actually what makes me bullish about this it's not that it's not that i think it's a risk list it's that i understand the risks and think but think the upside is you know far far outweighs it uh bull case bear case it's time for closing arguments right now and since we started with hosea i'm going to flip to uh jordie first uh you're closing arguments for why you think it makes sense to be bearish on lunar slash usd yeah i mean we've used them interchangeably but i'll just recap that i think they are a little bit different um the bear case for lunar first assuming that usd is okay is that the demand um gets kind of uh dwindle down because other chains do something similar because somebody does a better mouse trap there's ways that lunar price itself suffers without a deep peg um so um that's kind of half of the equation the other half is obviously on usd so um there's a lot of risks the the btc bridge risk hasn't been figured out there's market risk unfortunately btc might go down and then like a lot of the reserves that have been built up the narrative will change um btc could go up and then like hosea said everything it just looks completely different but we have to be aware of the risks um we have to be aware that there's centralization right now there's big funds that are going to be able to uh kind of pull strings and have inside information and and know things a lot earlier um so i'm i'm very happy that hosea gave like a full disclaimer i think that's the most important thing um there is indeed a moral moral argument for it succeeding and having something like that succeed my full bear case is that we are very far away from that endpoint there's a ton of stuff to figure out even with having such a good team working on it we have no idea what's going to happen even in like in a few months when anchor yield goes down there are so many unknowns um so that's that's the main bear case like we we can't just consider it a foreground conclusion that we're going to get to this end state hosea i'd love to hear your final thoughts your final closing statements as to the the bowl case for for Luna and the chat is also asking since they are perceiving this show as to be focusing on the bear case i just want to give you just a few extra minutes a few extra time to really just with with confidence give out give us the bowl case for Luna just to make us all Luna maxis yeah absolutely all right so first of all i think you guys have been pretty good thank thank you very much for the for the platform and for for opening this up to to other opinions um i think as one thing to note is as lunatics um we need to be like accepting uh of other communities in educating them on on lunatics because luna actually relies on like us he is relies on being the reference stablecoin for defy as a whole not just for terror so it needs to be on a theory and it needs to be everywhere and being antagonistic and like hating on people and and and and criticizing and stuff is is not the is not the lunatic way i know that though uh sometimes counters that with with with some of his uh twitter spice which is which is i love his ruinous spice but it's almost directed at a person right it's never directed at a community and that's really important like we the there's no reason why we should we should we should hate a theorem or hate any of the other chains that that are uh we're we're we're all gonna make it basically um and then so on the on the luna bear argue of bull arguments sorry so one of the biggest things that makes me bullish is how misunderstood it still is and in controversial and also how bad and like repetitive some of the fun is so like i think we the pegfud and the anchor sustainability fog to me is is like actually pretty weak um i i sort of explain my arguments for why i think that's the case i think there's stronger arguments against us t i think probably the key man risk and the just the technical which we didn't we didn't cover but just the fact that tara isn't a particularly scalable layer one and maybe that's not the end game um i think they're they're sort of counter arguments to that as well but i yeah that all our best investments have always been controversial and and how controversial this is and it is is one of the things that makes me super bullish um and then in terms of of us t itself so i think people just over index and focus on this pegris can just repeat it over and over again without focusing on the upside right on the on what happens if it works um and what happens if it works is you have the the us t as the biggest decentralized stablecoin also in my mind the most decentralized in the biggest marketing crypto which is money right decentralized stablecoins are literally going to be a multi trillion dollar industry i think most most people that are in crypto can agree with that and us t currently is the is the fastest horse in the in that race and so it in the internet and and if we agree that stablecoins are a network effect business right um you need liquidity you need linda you need people to trust it then you want to bet on the winners and you want to bet on whoever's growing fastest and us t's model while more vulnerable to tail risks as we've as we've spoken about allows it to grow much faster and that that's that's a big deal you know because if you grow fast in a in a network effects business you win which is why the anchor yield reserve subsidy makes so much sense similar to the paypal strategy right of the subsidizing its initial users and why this this whole strategy makes makes makes so much sense to me um and so for me it's like you have a stablecoin that was already working really well growing really fast that's becoming even stronger with a bitcoin reserve a bitcoin reserve that that we're going to be finding ways to grow over time both through additional sales for which there's uh you know quite a lot of appetite from from from from investors still um and then also from just growing it through seniorage and continuing to buy bitcoin and so i think you have a model that can grow super fast and that's also becoming more and more resilient by the day with the addition of this of this lfg reserve and so and then when you when you when you combine that with the layer one that's thriving where i continue to see some of the smartest builders that uh that i that i've that i've seen anywhere on on crypto building on building on terra whether it's and completely new primitives as well that haven't succeeded on ethereum like prism right which is a yield splitting primitive there's a p1 and pendulum ethereum but they're really haven't succeeded whereas i think prism has not a much better job nailing that um there's other things like parps with with with order book uh you know forex parps that are coming with vertex uh there's parps that are coming with lavana there's a holico system around gaming and nfts that that does putting a lot of effort into and so when you when you combine all of this uh i just think there's there's there's no uh faster horse in the decentralized stablecoin race than than u.
s.t and when we like to bet on winners there you go uh bankless listeners this has been the bull and bear case for luna usd um probably the most comprehensive i've ever heard i want to give a special thanks to both hose and jordi for joining us and having such a civil informative uh well argued debate we appreciate you guys so how much guys really appreciate it thank you bankless nation we will uh link to some of the things that that hose in particular referenced in the uh the show notes as soon as we have some links that's you know links to long-term anchor yield i think you've referenced something there uh few other stats we might link to as well but as always got to end with this none of this has been financial advice right i think our panelists were very clear that there are risks in crypto there are risk in defi there's just everywhere but we want to let you know that you could definitely lose what you put in we're headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot hey we hope you enjoyed the video if you did head over to bankless hq right now to develop your crypto investing skills and learn how to free yourself from banks and gain your financial independence we recommended joining our daily newsletter podcast and community as a bankless premium subscriber to get the most out of your bankless experience you'll get access to our market analysis our alpha leaks and exclusive content and even the bankless token for air drops raffles and unlocks if you're interested in crypto the bankless community is where you want to be click the link in the description to become a bankless premium subscriber today also don't forget to subscribe to the channel for in-depth interviews with industry leaders ask me any things and weekly rollups where we summarize the week in crypto and other fantastic content thanks everyone for watching and being on the journey as we build out the bankless nation