Vitalik Buterin is the founder of Ethereum and a researcher at the Ethereum Foundation.
As the visionary behind the network, Vitalik's values are embodied within the ethos of Ethereum's community-centric nature.
Exploring quadratic funding, pluralism, and sybil resistance, we dive into why Vitalik cares about public goods and how we can utilize novel mechanisms to fund them elegantly.
Take the Green Pill, anon.
----- ✨ Subscribe to the Green Pill Podcast ✨ https://availableon.com/greenpill
🟢 Get the GreenPilled Book 🟢 https://greenpill.party/
Apple Show Link: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/greenpill/id1609313639
Spotify Show Link: https://open.spotify.com/show/0l6aXWC94dd0RA3tkKfxjd?si=5fdadfbcd8d34bd4
------ SPONSOR PILLS:
⚖️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🦄 UNISWAP | DECENTRALIZED FUNDING https://bankless.cc/UniGrants
💳 LEDGER | THE CRYPTO LIFE CARD https://bankless.cc/Ledger
🧙♂️ ALCHEMIX | SELF REPAYING LOANS https://bankless.cc/Alchemix
------ Topics Covered:
0:00 Intro 3:30 Vitalik & Quadratic Funding 7:06 Evolution & Problems 12:14 Vitalik GreenPilled 15:00 Crypto’s Endgame 19:54 Pluralism 24:59 Public Goods Mechanisms 28:55 Sybil Resistance in Argentina 33:30 Community Values 38:55 Public vs Private Goods 42:10 Net Positive Impacts 44:09 Closing
------ Resources:
Kevin on Twitter: https://twitter.com/owocki?s=20&t=A1yy1WYtQlNAOiSxXtGuNQ
Vitalik on Twitter: https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin?s=20&t=6oPk84CaEN12Es6e7Nze3A
Schelling Point Conference: https://schellingpoint.gitcoin.co/
-----
Music by WABI SABI - snowflake - https://thmatc.co/?l=7786B012
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets. See our investment disclosures here: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/p/bankless-disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Hello and welcome to the Green Pill. I'm Kevin Walkieve and this is the podcast about public good and regenerative crypto-economics. Today we've got Vitalik Booter and the founder of Ethereum and a research scientist at the Ethereum Foundation on the episode. Obviously Vitalik's influence on the space is massive having delivered the original white paper for Ethereum and being the visionary behind the Ethereum network and one of the things that I wanted to do on this episode was digging on why Vitalik cares so much about public goods. I think there's like counterfactual world out there in which Save Vitalik wasn't into public goods as much as he was and I think that the Ethereum community would be missing some of its vibrancy and community centric nature that it has these days because Vitalik's champion, because Vitalik has been champion public goods we don't have that world.
So I really wanted to dig in on how he views public goods, why public goods are good and which experiments in the community he thinks about having the most promise for funding public goods and the result of all of those things together. Obviously Vitalik, beyond just being a champion of the Ethereum ecosystem, also wrote the quadratic funding white paper with Glenn Wilde. As you all know, quadratic funding is a foundational part of GetCoin and I think that there's a lot of interesting surface area between GetCoin, the implementation of quadratic funding and the research that Vitalik and Glenn have done on quadratic funding.
So this was a fun episode for me. I hope that you enjoy this episode with Vitalik Buterin, founder of Ethereum. Enjoy! Alchemix is a DeFi app that offers self-repaying loans that lets you spend money and save money at the same time. Alchemix allows you to deposit the die stablecoin into its faults, which earns some of the highest yields that DeFi has to offer. You can then take a loan from Alchemix of up to 50% of the deposited die and that loan automatically pays itself back from the yield that is generated from your deposit. It's a savings account that the banks don't want you to know about.
Alchemix also has ETH faults available so you can get a self-repaying loan that's denominated in ETH. Coming up in Alchemix V2 is a bunch of cool new features such as credit delegation, multi-chain expansion, and Dow revenue sharing and vote boosting. Alchemix lets you get your interest payments on your deposits paid to you up front. Check out the power of Alchemix at Alchemix.fi and make sure to join their extremely vibrant discord if you want to participate in governance or have any questions about the project. Bankless is proud to be sponsored by Uniswap. Uniswap is a new paradigm in asset exchange infrastructure.
Instead of a cumbersome order book system where trades are matched with other humans, Uniswap is an autonomous piece of software on Ethereum that lets you trade any token at the current market price. No human counterparties or centralized intermediaries, just autonomous code on Ethereum. Input the token you want to sell and receive the token you want to buy. The Uniswap Grants program is accepting applications for grants. Do you have something of value that you think you want to contribute to the Uniswap ecosystem? No matter how big or small your idea is, you can apply for a unique grant at Uniswapgrants.
org and help steer Uniswap in the direction that you think it should go. Thank you Uniswap for sponsoring Bankless. All right, welcome to the show. I am here with Vitalik Booterian, the founder of Ethereum and research scientist at the Ethereum Foundation. Welcome Vitalik. Thank you Kevin, it's good to be here. Great to have you. Vitalik, your background and how you came to found Ethereum is well documented in the infinite machine book and elsewhere. So in this space, I want to focus on your advocacy for public goods and your talk, things that matter outside of DeFi that you gave at ETHCC this year.
I think that the natural starting place for me and you to start talking about these themes is quadratic funding. Getcoin Grants is built off of the research paper you did with Glenwile on quadratic funding. How did you come to conceive of quadratic funding with Glen and how do you see it evolving in the future? I guess Glen originally came up with the idea for quadratic voting. He was one of the people who came up with that idea actually. It later turned out that there were a whole bunch of historical papers that pointed to very similar ideas which actually happens really often for the best ideas.
There's one from I think 1980 talking about why quadratic voting is the theoretically optimal voting rule. There might be a couple of other ones. But Glen made kind of the best and most detailed exposition and I think it was a paper that he published sometime between five and ten years ago. And quadratic funding was an adaptation of the ideas behind quadratic voting to the context of public goods. So I think one of the really big differences between quadratic voting and quadratic funding is that in quadratic voting, the issues that are being voted on are still fixed and you still need someone to choose what the issues are.
And it turns out that there is actually a lot of power in being the issue setter, right? Basically, if you are a majority that cares about something less and then some minority and you want to beat out the minority, what you can often do is you can just raise that the same issue in the different forms of huge number of times and just basically drain the other side's voting credits. So quadratic funding is a bit different in that it's kind of fully self-occupied system in that even the choice of questions is not something that needs to be kind of enshrined or pre-mind or whatever word you want to use for that, right?
Like anyone could create a project, anyone can contribute to a project and based on the quadratic funding formula based on how many people donate and how much the project gets matched. So this idea that even like what questions people are deciding on is so in this case like which public goods to give money to is also an emergent part of the mechanism is something that's really powerful. So Gwen and I get wrote the initial paper. I am also came up with a modified version called a pairwise bounded quadratic funding which just works a bit like is a bit more robust against collusion and against attackers like controlling a small number of accounts and I guess quadratic voting and finding have just gone from there.
Right of course. Well it's um I mean for me having built get coin with the mission of growing and sustaining open source software and having that be a primary focus for us and then launching get coin grants which use quadratic funding as the foundation. It's amazing to hear about the history of the back history of how we got here. I'm wondering I'm wondering how you see quadratic funding evolving from here. Quadratic funding on get coin we're using pairwise as a way of preventing collusion on the mechanism. I know that there's other projects out there that are doing really great stuff like CLR fund that are using macy on the mechanism.
Do you envision future iteration on the mechanism or is it just kind of down to solving civil resistance or other adjacent problems with quadratic funding? I could see some of both but like what modifications there would be to the mechanism it's like I do feel like we need to keep in open minds like I can't think of any that we would apply right now except maybe like tweaking the pairwise matching coefficient and one possible direction would be to try to go further in the direction of like trying to identify like which projects have support from the same group of people in which projects have really diverse support.
Like pairwise matching already does some of that but you could try to look I guess push even harder in that direction. Another direction is obviously to like go back to exploring this question of negative votes at some point which is I mean obviously super controversial but like on the other hands there I do think that there's a risk that there are some things that all just that like there needs to be some kind of negative feedback responding to. Like especially if you know binclists that or get going or whoever starts really good at getting into media like there you know there is such a thing as like media that just actually reduces the quality of public discourse.
Right. So yeah but that's like the first time it was tried in round finds five you know there is a lot of controversy for obviously and so it's the sort of thing that would be good to try carefully but like that you could even be very different mechanisms for doing positive and doing negative it's possible that anything negative would just require much more privacy. So that's one of those areas that probably should kind of keep being experimented in slowly and carefully at some point. Aside from that I would say yeah obviously simple resistance I'm obviously privacy with Macy. Yeah I mean otherwise it's just a bunch of small tweaks so like I actually think keeping the mechanism relatively simple and keeping the tweaks low is the right thing to do like just that you know it builds more confidence that kind of sets the precedent that the mechanism is what it is.
So amazing. Well it's great to hear sort of that purview from the author of the quadratic funding paper. One thing I wanted to run by you is that we're actually having a little bit of a hard time scaling the pairwise mechanism at Bitcoin right now because we're doing 700,000 contributions per quarter and with pairwise you have to pairwise bond each contributor to each contributor. Well wait 700,000 contributions how many contributors? I think it's on the order of 30,000 off to double check but yeah it would scale exponentially at the same size of the contributor set. Quadratically it should be.
Yeah. So we're 30,000 by 30,000 that's still 900 million like that seems like this sort of thing that like maybe you'll have to write it in like see instead of Python but okay I'll keep that in mind we'll try and think if there are like algorithmic tweaks. Totally yeah we're looking for I think instead of n squared like log log n or or linear would be great but yeah C++ or maybe moving into a GPU and memory or something like that is is something that we'll be exploring enough. Well I mean I think the other thing is that eventually like with macy all of this stuff is going to have to be snarked and so the efficiency will kind of go back down and so I do think that there is room for algorithmic tweaks of some kinds but no this is a good intellectual prompt I will think about this more.
Great. Well I just found the exact number it's 27,000 contributions or contributors in good clone grants around 12 so. I'm amazing okay so you got a lovely 27,000 by 27,000 matrix with 700 million entries almost all of which are zeros. Yeah. Yeah recording this for a broad audience but to the engineers on the get coin team who are trying to scale that I'm sure they'll feel seen that we that we talked about this very briefly. We'd love to we'd love to zoom out and go from quadratic funding which is I think where you and I have the most in common to the entire set of areas where where crypto and web three can be used for good and for public good so I guess I want to know since I've been following you Vitalik and since I've seen your talk about about crypto you've talked a lot about public goods I think as long as I as I've as I've been reading your writing so I want to know how did you get green pill what got you into public goods.
I think it was just that looking at the crypto space so long enough and seeing that like there's basically these two big problems in the crypto space that where one of them is that a lot of things that are public goods like we really do get underfunded and you see these crazy imbalances where there's projects that are spending hundreds of millions or billions of dollars on security or liquidity mining or whatever but then like they can't grab together you know a few million to pay for some research or development and then the other thing is that often when proper public goods don't get funded what happens is that the market comes up with centralized substitutes and you basically create an ecosystem that actually becomes much more much more centralized than it needs to be.
Even open source software there's a good example of this right like the open source stuff is a public good and so it's more difficult to come up with the incentive to contribute to it but then if generally often what happens is that someone just creates a yes software package that like works halfway but it's because it's closed source and so it has a business model to actually keep being developers and trying to come up with a better solution to those problems was definitely something that I have been always for a long time fairly passionate about. Another way to look at this is that I've been really interested in this concept of DAOs and I guess they were called DACs before I called them DAOs to be more general decentralized autonomous corporations organizations and figuring out how to actually do decentralized governments like what's saying decentralized governance mechanisms will go quick and it just still happens that like public funding public goods is like one of the most important governance problems or at least one of the most important things that any sane governance mechanism will inevitably end up doing and so at some extent they just end up being the same problem.
So I mean it's amazing to hear from you the example of open source software because that's why I founded Gikkoin was to grow and sustain open source software and I think that these the underfunding of our digital infrastructure leads to these systemic imbalances between people who can create value and those who can capture value. So I guess I'm wondering you know what do you think the end game is for crypto and public goods like do you think it's possible that we'll do a better job of funding the underfunded public goods in the Ethereum ecosystem and what would have to be true to expand that out to all digital public goods or maybe all public goods in the world using mechanisms that have been innovated in crypto.
Yeah it's a good question I do think that going out further into more and more digital public goods is important. I guess the two main challenges that you're going to have one of them is scalability. I mean actually I forget it's like the new like the D-grants was said on polygon right now or yeah I can do deploy to any EVM compatible network but it's on right. Right deploy to any EVM compatible right but basically I think even though the way you're two is due needs to like keep getting cheaper and keep getting more scalable before because like the crypto space I think is made up of fairly wealthy people who are fairly comfortable paying transaction fees that are quite high by most than normal people standards but people outside the ecosystem are not and like I personally do actually believe that like doing the macy thing and actually sticking kind of the encrypted record of the votes on chain is something that's really valuable and it really improves the security properties of the whole system but you know it could be it's actually just be made that be made technically sustainable right and then the other issue um would probably be um let's see well one is just that people outside the theater big with system are less familiar with quadratic finding and the other big one is that blockchains have like very yeah these very big pools of money that are almost like seeking for incredibly neutral way to deploy them right right like it's uh like for a big project it's easy to come up with a yeah and I'm half a billion dollars and it's harder to come up with a mechanism for for figuring out how to spend it that the community would actually accept and that's not a problem that like that's not the problem that most people have right like most people like don't even have the way of getting half a billion dollars um like I guess uh governments like I'm like have a local taxation and all of them and all of those things um though even there like you know you'll have to get pretty far before people are going to be willing to experiment on the same scale as I think even the Ethereum ecosystem itself is willing to experiment uh but maybe it can happen I mean if it if it does happen then great uh there and then ecosystems that like don't have either a cryptocurrency or a government behind them like some like a non-cryptocurrency open-source software package like there's this question of I mean oh where does where does the finding coming from and realistically y'all like if that's the big problem then the way you'll have to end up cooperizing is by finding a funders who uh or the fun the the most eager funders you'll find are funders that have strong opinions about what should be funded and and so the quadratic kind of everyone contributes to deciding thing that would not get a chance to shine as much um so though like those would be the worries that I predict um but at the same time I do think that there is a lot of promise and uh so you know strongly yeah support any yeah efforts to keep expanding and ultimately like the only thing the only way this thing ever succeeds is by just like basically powering through the issues and like some of it might take one or two one or two more years of uh working on the technology or working on the means but like that's fine you know like the the U.
S. as uh in a uh 225-year-old constitutional framework so sometimes these kinds of things take time um right did it say 225-year-old amid 245-year-old well yeah yeah a lot of uh experimentation and iteration and evolution uh over that time frame over the years and and and that actually is like a good segue into my next question which is you know how do you see uh in the ethereum ecosystem we talk a lot about client diversity which is making sure that the base layer clients that are going to power the network once we move to proof of stake our diverse in implementation which prevents any sort of fault in the network if one of the clients has a bug in it um or a security hole and i'm wondering how you think about pluralism of mechanism and of implementation when it comes to the public good stack over the last year you've been talking to the optimism team about retroactive public goods funding which uh i think is an amazingly complimentary mechanism to what get coin grants is doing and uh within the quadratic funding ecosystem there's obviously get coin their CLR funds and uh uh and you get an amount of diversity in the public goods funding stack from that and there's also other intersubjective consensus tools that are starting to be built in dials like coordinate that are meant to build mechanisms for how you fund your contributors to a dial i'm wondering how you think about pluralism of mechanism and of implementation in the public goods funding stack for the ethereum ecosystem and how does that relate to the client diversity and the pluralism of eth clients that we want to have in eth post eth 2 so how do you think about pluralism generally and in those two subject matters actually like there there's two different like types of contexts where pluralism is important right like one of those contexts is where something that's too powerful going wrong can cause a lot of problems and the so the thing like the thing that you're risking from not having pluralism like basically just is like this kind of this this downside risk from one thing being too powerful and then the other situation is where your risk is missing like out on an opportunity to do something right and i think a lot of public goods funding especially in the software space are a lot of the second right like it's uh often much less bad to waste uh ten million dollars on funding of the wrong thing then it is to miss out on spending ten million dollars on something that turns out to be quite important and so you know um like that is a like a really big argument for for pluralism as well right um so I guess in the second but that's which is exactly why like I yeah support there being many different kinds of mechanisms right like you know you have uh get going grants with its quadratic funding you'll have optimism retro funding um you know we can have uniswaped out in some various other towers a couple of centralized organizations um that are led by um you know hopefully high quality leaders that are trying to execute on their own coherent visions and really we as an ecosystem only need like one of them to uh kind of be right in order to get the important stuff covered um so that's um so that's one way or one of the kind of reasons why I think it's important and then the other thing it's the reason why it's important this is about um kind of creating the more diversity in order to prevent like this risk of what happens if uh you know what one client gets too powerful and that's uh obviously in the case of east of east to clients that's uh a bit a really big deal or I guess are there consent to sway our clients and execution of our clients right I mean it's a big deal uh because uh you know if you have prism that has more than two thirds and if prism is wrong they could just immediately finalize a block that's wrong and that's going to be really hard for the ecosystem to get away from and then another example of this might also be like political balance of power um right because uh like if there is uh um one very concentrated political elite that has a lot of power and like figuring out like how a protocol moves forward or even or even has like a lot of veto power um and then that ends up kind of really yeah constraining things and just training the protocol's ability to evolve in a different vision or recover from the possibility that that group of people is wrong so yeah so both of the yeah both of those are just like really important to um keep in mind and uh and uh and really important to foster so you know I'm happy that we have all of these east to clients and then there's just big movements to try to get like people and uh not just people also applications like things like tap node that a lot of secrets to rely on it to support all of them right um and then obviously the uh more distributed public goods funding efforts I uh I feel like they have uh improved things in the Ethereum space quite a bit already um right like even you know bank bankless uh museum major early recipients of uh get coin grants right funding yeah so you know we need both we need uh a lot of this and public pluralism right amazing yeah I'm wondering other than the mechanisms that I mentioned uh which just to refresh the audience's memory were retroactive public goods funding coordinate CLR fund get coin grants quadratic funding what other mechanisms are you excited about and do you think are under explored for funding public goods if any one of the ideas for public goods funding that does not depend on a central funds allocator that I've tried to push on a couple of occasions is like actually doing a better job of having a using NFTs to fund public goods um yeah like uh we uh like so far it feels like um you know we have these really expensive NFTs that uh often support things that like are often actually interesting and fun uh but it would be cool if uh we have the get fts that support things that are interesting and fun but also meaningful um there is uh I think they're like they're the model that I had uh supported um back when I wrote that post on legitimacy a while back right what's this idea that you could have NFTs that work kind of uh an artist partnering with a charity where the artist kind of provides the art the charity I provide some legitimacy and the revenues end up end up being split between the two uh and uh you know the NFT becomes kind of both art and a way to like show that you care about a particular charity um I know that um opti punks right it's like a sped off of crypto punks for optimism I saw that they were spent like putting some of the revenues from selling the punks into the the retro funding pool or something like that yep that's right they did they did fund around and we're very thankful for that um we've also been experimenting with this project called moonshot bots at get coin dow which is uh an NFT where all of the sales of the primary sale went to public goods and then worked with nouns dow on releasing an NFT that was for public goods so actually get coins have been kind of experimenting with fundraising in in this category uh a little bit so it's interesting to hear you say that especially with the explosive growth of NFTs in 2021 well it makes me really happy to hear great well yeah we're always um you know I say that quadratic funding is just this really amazing elegant mechanism but the two kind of catches that come along with it are solving the civil inclusion problem which is somewhat complex and then also the continual need to fund a matching pool are just like the two kind of like adjacent things that you need to do in order to keep that steam engine of quadratic funding rolling and um you've traditionally been sort of an advocate for let's not choose spend too much money in each round and let's make sure that the community knows is there's can that continuous quadratic funding that's gonna happen over time so that they can start to expect it and adjust their behavior to work more on public goods from there so um I'm wondering if you think I got those two mechanisms those those two sort of like catches right with quadratic funding it's the ability to uh innovate on how you fund the matching pool and the ability to innovate on on fraud detection is there anything else that you would include in that category of of like quadratic funding adjacent uh implementation problems quadratic let's see uh those are probably the big ones right um yeah like there's uh the kind of making sure the mac and what category one is uh making sure the mechanism is sound which would yeah include collusion resistance similar resistance like the cryptography all of that stuff and then the other one is uh finding funding sources um I do want to uh yeah whether or not uh if you if you if you don't have anything to add there I was gonna sort of pull on the thread of civil resistance and um I know that you recently spent some time in Argentina with saunty we talked about that in his episode a little bit proof of humanity I think is an amazing protocol for creating civil resistance on the ethereum ecosystem and I'm and I'm wondering what you think the ecosystem what kind of new mechanisms the ecosystem could invent one civil resistance has proliferated across the ecosystem so basically moving from one token one vote dowels or which I know you've said one to one coin voting can be plutocratic two more one human one vote type systems how excited are you for civil resistance to be widely available and what kind of new mechanisms do you think that will enable in the ecosystem lots of things in governance uh definitely um in other aside the main non-governance use case that I think is important for crypto has to do with coin distribution and I think that there is uh right now um you know obviously there are air drops um but also there's uh a bit of a backlash against air drops for a couple of reasons so like one is that they don't discriminate between people who will actually care a lot about a project the people who would barely care at all um and like that stock you know like that won't be solved with um like proof of fraud personhood that might require some other solutions like I'm uh increasingly a fan of the word to earn stuff um as a substitute for just like unconditionally giving people coins um the other one uh but then the other problem is that they just get farmed to death by uh VC funds and like whatever air drop mechanism someone comes up with it can basically only safely be used once and like that's a problem right um so I think uh like having air drops that are dated by proof of personhood is uh something that could really uh help and uh improve things and like it could even be a hybrid right it could even be like the number of coins you get is the square root of how much of how many dollars of liquidity you contributed um um so yeah more things like that um I yeah think could help projects a lot because I do think that there is a very genuine desire to have a very wide distribution but at this and at the same time a very genuine desire to have a uh meaningfully allocated uh distribution where you're not just throwing coins away and there's like increasingly effective tools for people to click one button and dump all of them um so yeah I think uh proof of personhood can do a lot there right it seems like reading between the lines from your answer Vitalik that um mechanisms that can figure out who is creating value for a protocol are going to be really important in a learn to earn type sense where you can be have a continuous token distribution to the people who are adding value to an ecosystem so basically anything that for a Dow or a learn to earn ecosystem can add value to that ecosystem could then be plugged into a public goods funding mechanism for that ecosystem is is that actually exactly I think so cool so maybe there's a whole category of tools that we'll see uh that are designed to help figure out who's adding value and measure in in that in different ways and I could see a whole bunch of innovation coming out of that really helps out living a bankless life requires taking control of your own private keys not your keys not your crypto that's why so many in the bankless nation already have their ledger hardware wallet but the ledger ecosystem is much more than just a secure hardware wallet ledger is the combination of the ledger hardware wallet the ledger live app and soon the cl crypto life card powered by ledger the cl card powered by ledger is a crypto debit card with powerful features like an instant exchange to fiat where crypto assets are only sold at the moment that you swipe your card and also credit from crypto collateral where you can collateralize your crypto assets in order to get a higher credit limit you'll be able to manage your cl card powered by ledger inside the ledger live app right next to all the defi apps and services that you're already used to using making it the ledger live app your one-stop shop for all of your financial needs go to ledger.
com grab a ledger and download ledger live to get all of your defi applications all in one place arbitrum is an ethereum scaling solution that's going to completely change how we use defi and NFTs over 250 projects have already deployed on arbitrum and arbitrum's defi and NFT ecosystems are growing rapidly arbitrum increases ethereum speed by orders of magnitude for a fraction of the cost of the average gas fee when interacting with arbitrum you can get the performance of a centralized exchange while tapping into ethereum's level of decentralization and security if you're a developer who wants low gas fees and instant transactions for your users visit developer.
offchainlabs.com to get started building your application on arbitrum if you're a user keep an eye out for your favorite defi apps or NFT projects building on arbitrum many of your favorite apps are already live with many more coming over soon you can find these apps portal.arbitrum.1 and you can bridge your assets over to arbitrum using bridge.arbitrum.io in order to experience defi and NFTs the way it was always meant to be fast cheap and friction free all right well i think that we're coming up on the half hour here so i'm going to get into my closing questions i would love to know if there's anything that i didn't ask you that you want to say about public goods or regenerative crypto economics or that part of the ethereum ecosystem see we talked about NFTs so we talked about humanity getting and oh one other direction that i think quadratic funding might need to evolve eventually is that right now the mechanism doesn't really discriminate much between like people who are part of a community and people who are not part of a community and like if you make a get coin rounds for like say you know optimism there's nothing distinguishing like there's nothing giving an actual member of the optimism community more build like a greater ability to have an impact on where the matching pool goes then the someone from the arbitrum community and one way to look at this is like well the point is that the mechanism is flat because like it's by being willing to don't kind of throw money into the system as a contributor that you are demonstrating that you care about optimism the other way looking about the at this though is that like in practice and you know especially with some of these purpose and limits it is like it might be possible that some of these project end up being vulnerable to brigading and it's like and this is a problem especially if like you have funders that like actually actually care right because like quadratic funding the mechanism was originally designed as this kind of very unusual mechanism it just says funds all funds be all the public goods and so in from that like like it makes sense why are you why you know you want to try to be completely unusual between everything but when you have like sources of funding that wants to be more specific then does it make sense to find a way to try to make the mechanism be more be more more specific like what would that what would that actually take like what would happen if you know an optimism person tries to like make a or let's say any world where get going the grant is fully automated and then someone an optimism person submits a project applying for funding from the arbitral pool where that project actually just sends the money to do some optimism stuff and this is transparent to everyone knows about it and then they just invite a whole bunch of optimism people to like throw a dollar in and get some and get some of the arbitral matching funds like how would you actually prevent that like what it actually would it be some kind of like gated participation thing where if you're not like one of the community members then either you have like a smaller matching allocation or just or you just don't get matched would it be something else would the matching pool be able to like specify some group participants that have free credits like I don't know but that's just like one of the things that would be interesting to look at eventually right like this I think I get into the broader this question of like we talk how we talk about there is this binary of private and public goods but the reality is that nothing is fully private or fully public like there's medium scale public goods that that benefits some people but don't benefit other people and then there's people and sources of funding that care about some ecosystems and not our other ecosystems and how to actually create mechanisms that care about all of those things it's going to be an interesting challenge now I think but you know I think it's also really important one right well yeah I think that's a really important one as good Quinn grants has we've we've been scaling vertically which means bigger matching pools but now we're starting to scale what I call horizontally which is out into these other ecosystems like Uniswap and then Polygon and then we've also been doing cause rounds for climate change and longevity and journalism and I do think that you know being able to figure out whose voice matters within the public goods of each of those ecosystems now that we're not just having general public goods is the problem I heard back from you and that's that's an interesting problem to solve but I want to tug on the officer go ahead no no you go ahead what are we talking on yeah I just wanted to tug on the the sort of like binary between public and private goods and one of the things that I've been struggling with from a governance perspective is that a lot of these projects that are on getcoin are public goods in some way or private goods in another way and I look at these things as maybe a double-sided or triple-sided marketplace in which one side of the marketplace is a public good and the other side of the marketplace is a private good something that you have to pay for and you know like the example that I would that I would sort of use is you know I think like E and S the ability to find anyone out there and like figure out what their eth address is based off of a name that you can remember like I'm a walkie dot eth and being able to find me that is a public good but the ability to write to the E and S system costs eth and so on that side of the market it's it's like gated by some amount of of of money it's it is excludable and it is rival risk and so I'm wondering you know how do you think about that spectrum of pure public goods and private goods and is their capacity for nuance in how we fund these public goods and you know how do you think about that is it a binary or is it a spectrum to you it's definitely a spectrum to me okay yeah I know I say it's again it's definitely a spectrum I think it's not showing itself as a spectrum yet and the reason why it's not showing itself as a spectrum yet is because like the amount of funding to that's there for public goods it's still like nowhere near as high as it should be and so when the funding is scarce like it just gets distributed to the things that really really need it the most which are these very pure and very underfunded public goods that just have no chance of having a business model otherwise but as the funding increases and as the ecosystem saturates a little more like I think it fully makes sense for public goods funding mechanisms to also like intervene in places where there are kind of mixed public and private concerns right like eventually if you know if like an entire government to look starts running on on quadratic funding then you know maybe like yes it should just like give subsidies to businesses who take more effort than others to make sure that their products are environmentally friendly or you know to like health insurance companies that like do more to ensure that their offerings are fully universal and open to everyone like that's you know like there again the real world there are a lot of like mixed private and public goods like that and I think you know that's you know definitely part of the complexity of the of the world that we're trying to build for which is which is totally fine so what I heard there is maybe a crypto economic incentive for things that you the businesses may have externalized things like environmental impact or access to health care to people who are not profitable adding adding a crypto economic incentive to not externalize those things into bear those costs and using quadratic funding mechanism as a way of creating that incentive did I hear that that correctly exactly okay yeah one of the things that we've been talking about in the regenerative crypto economic space is sort of defining an impact out as anything that has a net positive impact on the world whether that's a financial social or other type of impact on the world and I'm wondering what you think of that of that definition of like building an we're I'm trying what I'm searching for as an atomic building block of regenerative crypto economics and the best I've come up on is is one that has a net positive impact and externalizes good for for the world it what do you think about that definition and and can we build a composable building block for more regenerative systems and how would you define it if not can we build a building block for more regenerative systems I feel like there's lots of building blocks for more regenerative systems like this is a sort of thing that's like the difficulty to reduce the one component right because there's public goods funding and there's different kinds of public goods funding and even different dependencies to public goods funding like we talked about like identity yeah some of the cryptographic aspects there is like decentralized governance there's there's like some kind of arbitration and all of these systems kind of depend on each other in complicated ways yeah so yeah I think there's probably like at least half a dozen building blocks if not more than like if we were to try to drive a diagram of all of this like we would see them right yeah I was kind of looking for the lowest common denominator like for example with ERC 20 you can have a token that's a governance token that's a utility token that's a security any ERC 20 is the lowest common denominator and my attempt at a lowest common denominator for this stuff is impact out is something that has a positive externality and that could be implemented in the market yeah I think that's uh yeah I think that's uh so probably the course of course as uh you can get it's a great place to be right yeah I sport impact house cool uh well Vitalik thank you so much for coming on the regenerative crypto economics show and looking forward to seeing you at euthdember and through 2022 thanks so much Vitalik thank you too you