A single Vitalik tweet just snapped Ethereum’s scaling narrative into focus: the rollup-centric roadmap is over, and a new path is here. Ryan and David break down what Vitalik actually said (and what he didn’t), why stage 2 plus rollup interop proved far slower than anyone hoped, and why L1 scaling, powered by ZK, may be Ethereum’s real reset button in 2026. Along the way, they unpack the quiet death of the “L2s are Ethereum” meme, the community’s whiplash reaction, and what differentiated “gen 2” L2s must do to earn their place in the alliance.
---
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
---
🔮POLYMARKET | #1 PREDICTION MARKET
https://bankless.cc/polymarket-podcast
🃏SHOWDOWN | NEXT-GEN POKER
https://bankless.cc/showdown
🏅BITGET TRADFI | TRADE GOLD WITH USDT
https://bankless.cc/bitget
👑BANKLESS PREMIUM | AD-FREE & BONUS EPISODES
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
🎯THE DEFI REPORT | ONCHAIN INSIGHTS
https://bankless.cc/TDR-pro
💰ICO WATCH | UPCOMING PUBLIC TOKEN SALES
https://bankless.cc/ico-watch
---
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 The Rollup-Centric Roadmap: 2020 → 2026
1:26 What Vitalik Actually Said
3:15 The Understated Bombshell: L1 Scaling + ZKVM
6:28 “Branded Shards” Are Over
8:12 “L2s Are Ethereum” Is Dead (But Not the Alliance)
12:29 Vitalik’s Follow-Up: Differentiation Wins
15:51 The Reaction: Praise, “I Told You So,” and Anger
18:23 The NATO Analogy for L2s
20:51 The Messaging Risk: Does Ethereum Push Rollups Away?
23:25 Why Did It Take So Long to Say This Out Loud?
30:09 Was Modular Wrong? What We Thought vs What We Got
33:20 Ryan’s Retrospective: Wins + Three Missteps
38:01 David’s Take: ZKVM Precompile = “Manhattan Project”
39:57 The Cost: Wasted Time, Misallocated Capital, Leadership Tension
45:39 What Happens Next: Base Leaving, New North Star, Anyone’s Game
51:04 Signs the Pivot Is Working
---
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Hey, Banclistation. We haven't done one of these in a while. It's a time for a Banclist takes, we're talking about the role of L2s in Ethereum. And you know you're a big deal in crypto. If Banclist will, it will, will spend an entire show on one single tweet. Okay. This is a Vitalik tweet that we're gonna talk about. This is a tweet I think that echoed around the world. It's pretty significant in my mind and your mind because it feels like it marks at the end of an era and the beginning of a new era. I feel like a bookend. Yeah. A bookend to a, not a tweet, but like another Vitalik post that we also did a dedicated podcast on in 2020 where he introduced the Roll-Up centric roadmap in October of 2020.
And now this is a episode about the conclusion of the roll-up centric mode map in 2026. And I think that's that in particular is important. We have to choose our words carefully because it's the conclusion not of the roll-up roadmap. The roll-up roadmap continues. But it is the conclusion of the roll-up centric. Because the centric word is being ejected. Exactly. And so the roll-ups for five years in Ethereum were the center point. That was the road. That was the focus. That was how we're going to scale Ethereum. And I think this tweet signifies something new. So let's get into it. What exactly did Vitalik say on what day was it?
February 3rd, 2026. What did he say? February 3rd. What did he say? And what he did not say is pretty important because there were a lot of opinions and takes on Twitter that we're just misunderstandings or bad readings of Vitalik's tweet. So what did Vitalik say? The punchline that I think Ryan and I agree of is like what this tweet, really, the punchline of this tweet is for both of these facts, we'll talk about what these two facts are. For both of these facts for their own separate reasons, means that the original path of layer twos and their role in Ethereum no longer makes sense. And we need a new path.
That's the ending of the centric part, right? Yes. That's the ending of the centric path. And so Vitalik is basically saying Ethereum needs a new non-roll-up centric road map. The two core bits of data as to why Vitalik comes to this conclusion, the two bits that he was referring to, is that stage two roll-ups and roll-up interoperability has been far more slow and difficult than previously expected. Stage two roll-ups essentially means that roll-ups get to the point where they are complete decentralized code-based extensions of Ethereum that they are the block space of a layer two stage two roll-up is given the full faith in credit of Ethereum security.
That's right. We cannot get there. We has been seemingly difficult as an industry to move our roll-up ecosystem into stage two. We seemingly are stuck on stage one and for good reason. Yes. That's one part of it. The security part of it. The second part of it is the interoperability part of it. And this is the vision of roll-ups and scaling Ethereum block space. I thought was shared liquidity across all of these roll-ups. And that's why Vitalik effects. Shared day. Shared. Shared. Shared. And it's not shared. It feels very fragmented. That's why he mentions interop as the second. So that's the first core bit.
What's the second? Have you checked out Showdown yet? Showdown is poker. Rebuilt from the ground up by some of the world's top players in hearthstone, magic, the gathering, and poker. With showdowns, action cards, an additional layer of gameplay is added onto the game of poker. Action cards give dueling players more agency, strategy, and tricks for winning the pot. Built on mega-eaths, real-time blockchain, showdown has completely abstracted away everything crypto. Prevy hides the wallet, there's seamless payment and deposit flows, and mega-eath makes everything happen in real-time and zero fees, making showdown ready to onboard your friends without any friction.
It's also free to play and built without any pay-to-win mechanics. Players compete in the free market and with real money on the line. Showdown is played with mega-eaths USDM in the background, so when players deposit money into Showdown, it's converted into USDM, connecting Showdown to the USDM flywheel that all mega-eath apps contribute to. You can play Showdown for free, so you can practice and get good before you get comfortable with real USDM on the line. Experience poker like never before with Showdown. Check it out at alpha.showdown.game. What if you could trade gold, forex, and global markets with the same tools and speed that you use for crypto?
That's exactly what BitGetTradify unlocks. After strong beta demand, including over $100 million in single-day gold trading volume, BitGetTradify is now live for all users. Inside of your existing BitGet account, you can trade 79 instruments across forex, precious metals, indices, and commodities all settled directly in USDT, no platform switching, and no fiat conversions. This is BitGetT's universal exchange vision in action. Crypto and traditional finance side-by-side. You get deep liquidity, low slippage, and leverage up to 500x, letting you apply crypto strategies to macro markets. New to Tradify?
Start with gold. The gold USD pair is liquid, macro driven in a familiar natural bridge between crypto and traditional markets. Try trading gold on BitGetTnow at bitget.com. Click the link in the show notes for more information. This is not financial advice. The second core bit is that later on scaling is out now actually catching up to a meaningful degree. The ZKVM, which I think was an understated part of this tweet, and we'll go into why, but the ZKVM and overall layer 1 block space is going to, quote, projected to increase greatly in 2026. So, Vitalik just highlights like, actually, we can just do the things on the layer 1.
Not only can we scale the layer 1 in the traditional sense with more throughput and faster block times, but we also have this ZKVM thing, which will massively scale Ethereum far beyond what any other layer 1 could ever do ever. Let's go there. Let's go down that path. Yeah, that's the bullish piece, and that was not available, importantly, six of like five, six years ago. We thought the ZKVM, this five, six years ago, decade away, and turns out they were kind of here today. So, those are the two core bits why the roll-up centric roadmap, as it was in 2020, and as Ethereum, the track that Ethereum had been on no longer makes sense.
There's some more happening here, though, David. And this is some association of the question of like, what is Ethereum? The Ethereum brand, the values of the community, and both this tweet mentions that, and then he tweeted something later, a couple of days later, that we may want to touch on, too. But he said, L1 does not need L2s to be branded shards, because L1 itself is scaling, so that's the point we talked about. And he said, we should stop thinking about L2s as literally being branded shards of Ethereum, with the social status and responsibilities that this entails. Instead, we can think of L2s as being a full spectrum.
This gets into part of the reason, I think. This is my theory on why Vitalik felt he needed to tweet this at this point in time, because as we'll discuss later, a lot of the elements of this were already obvious to many, and indeed, the Ethereum roadmap had already shifted. I mean, you could already feel it, probably shift to 12 months ago. Let's see. Feels a lagged reflection of what the market and the industry has already digested. And actually, what I think Vitalik thinks at this point, I mean, I think he's thought this for quite a long time. Part of the reason or the psychology of why to tweet this publicly goes into, as is my take anyways, what is Ethereum?
And this idea of, like, Colin, I don't want to use words that are too strong, but a laundering of the Ethereum brand, or I think that's extractively very, very accurate. In many cases, it is, or a dilution of what Ethereum means, because if all of these L2s are Ethereum, but you're not getting Ethereum level guarantees and Ethereum network liquidity, how can you actually say they are Ethereum? And this gets into kind of the social piece of this, which there had been a meme that many Ethereum people had started with, that you and I even started with, I believe, because this was our core belief actually, L2s are Ethereum.
This is kind of like what we thought the roadmap was. This is what we thought we were building. You and I abandoned this meme, probably like 18 to 24 months ago when it became obvious, like, oh shoot, when I go into another chain, it's not Ethereum. I'm not getting all of the, it's not stage two, and I don't get the liquidity and we started pushing back on that, but that's been hard for the community to for sale. Yeah, and so there's, yeah, go ahead. I think with this tweet, we can formally say, L2s are Ethereum is dead. It was already dead now. Now, like, there's no way to, for L2s to be Ethereum, and this is what we are admitting to, and it's something like to go back into the shoes of October of 2020 when the roll up centric roadmap was introduced.
The plan here was that we would make stage two roll ups, stage two, being functional equivalent extensions of Ethereum block space without any sort of lack of, any sort of property rights or, or guarantees of Ethereum. The guarantees of the Ethereum layer one, because layer two is our stage two, get extended without loss, without loss, no lossiness. And then with interrupt, we would have these stage two extensions that would be shared, shared state, shared liquidity. And so therefore, with some extractions, we would be able to abstract everything and it would be one unified experience. That's right.
That was always the plan. So like stage two roll ups was like, yes, optimism, arbitrum, Z casing would build their roll ups, but with stage two and interrupt we would collapse everything into one shared experience. This is what we are saying that like this is not happening and we need to account for that. And therefore, when we say layer two's are Ethereum, that just cannot be accurate because now these branded shards are their own thing. And I think when he says we can consider these layer twos to be full spectrum, you know, full spectrum layer twos, it's kind of unlocking the potential layer twos to be anything, which was always the promise and always the compact potential of layer twos.
So you can be anything. You can be you can have any sort of relationship with Ethereum that you want. And it doesn't have to be any sort of constrained. You must be a layer two. You must conform to the interop standards. You must be an extension of Ethereum. And we're kind of like opening up the design space and going away from layer twos or Ethereum. That's right. And I think there was there's a concession here. And we've read it earlier when Vitalik said L2 progress around full security of Ethereum and Indrom has been slower and more difficult than originally expected. I think that's true. I don't think that there was something there's something insidious about the roadmap.
We're going to launch all these L2s and we're going to invest in all these L2 tokens and VCs are going to get rich. And you know, we always knew this wouldn't work out. I genuinely think the Ethereum community, Vitalik as well, all the participants of that L2s and all the teams we talked to in those early days, they thought they were building a mirror of Ethereum L1 block space. Indeed. That was what they were trying to build. The tech just couldn't get us there. That's my perspective on it. I don't think there's anything insidious here going on. But now that we are in 2026, the meme of L2s are Ethereum does not ring true.
And so we have to recognize that. And probably it's never been true. That was the ambition. But we have to recognize that we are never going to accomplish that full ambition. Now, I do want to put an asterisk here, which is it's also not true that L2s are just sidechains. So if you want to like, I mean, this is not in the medic form, but L2s do inherit some of the security guarantees and a little bit of the liquidity, I guess, preferences of Ethereum. So they do inherit some of it. You can't put that in meme form, but there are things here that are, I guess, more nuanced than just saying. No, there is a symbiotic relationship between the layer 2s and the layer 1.
That's right. That's right. And so we could swing too far in the other direction. I guess the second Vitalik tweet also he put a tweet out a couple days later. He said he's been following reactions to what I said on L2s one and a half days ago. And he clarified a few more things here. Actually, I felt like he was mostly restating what he had already said, though in clear terms. And a part that we missed in his original tweet is he sees a role for L2s to fill a very differentiated, a much more differentiated place now in the updated, you know, L2 road map of 2026 called these Gen 2, L2s, which is it's less an EVM clone of Ethereum that you kind of hook an optimistic bridge to and you port all the apps from Ethereum over into these L2s.
And it's more differentiated chains, things like app chains, like lighters or privacy chains, like Aztec, like bringing something net new to these, this alliance of chains that Ethereum L1 does not already have, especially when it's in scaling mode. Differentiation, I think, is the key word here. Back in 2022 to 2023 when the layer 2 era was really in full swing, there was a huge push for Ethereum equivalents, EVM equivalents. I mean, I was I was pushing for that because that's how I saw we get to this, you know, roll up ecosystem. That is one big, one big shared pool of state and liquidity. That is dead.
Ethereum equivalence is dead. It's the same thing as layer 2s are not Ethereum. Ethereum is Ethereum. EVM equivalence is now just redundant. And now it's go to the opposite end of the spectrum and be very, very differentiated. Have a specialized VM like Aztec or Starknet. And do things that the Ethereum layer 1 can never do, like scale, like mega ease, be an app chain, like lighter, just don't do the same thing that Ethereum is doing because Ethereum is going to do that thing. Vitalik sums it up like this in this second follow tweet. Basically, number one, do something if you're an L2. You might advise for L2, as he says.
Number one, do something that brings something actually new to the table. Number two, the vibe should match the substance, degree of connection to Ethereum. Your public image should reflect the degree of connection to Ethereum that your thing has in reality. And that second point gets to the laundered reputation of Ethereum, right? If you're like a stage 0, L2, do you get to call yourself part of Ethereum and sort of wander the reputation of Ethereum with that brand when you don't offer the things that Ethereum is actually offering? Yeah. And we saw that one of the worst examples of this was the movement layer 2.
The move VM as a layer 2 on Ethereum, a whole project ended up just being an unsavory grift to use harsh words. And like, this was what was allowed when we don't control what the future of Ethereum scaling looked like is like, there are barbarians at the gate. And if the Ethereum community allows branded charts to come in and raise VC dollars and promote themselves as extensions of Ethereum to the Ethereum community and the Ethereum community praises them because all layer 2s are good. This isn't a failure mode. And that started to happen and went too far. Agreed. All right, let's get to the community reaction and then you and I can give our takes on what this means and what happens.
So what was the community reaction to this? Yeah, like five different categories. There was just like praise for Vitalik's honesty, adaptability, and truth seeking. There were a lot of, I told you so's and criticisms and frustration over delays and wasted effort. John Sharper now had this tweet where he tweeted out this meme saying, sorry about all the mean shit I said when I was right. I think he gets that tweet. He gets to tweet that tweet. I'm not going to complain. Max Resnick, who was one of the original like layer 2 roadmap is broken. He just tweeted out. He just kept it. Yeah, he tweeted out.
I'm very much enjoying reading this app today, which is just like a coded of just like I'm drinking my tea and enjoying like reading all this. Those are two individuals. I would say that, you know, heart and mind have defected someone to the more manual. They just acted because they were like this layer two shenanigans is bullshit and we should change it. And then when they realize it's not changing, they went to Solana. That's what happened. Yeah. There was agreement that layer two's aren't a theorem. Steven Goldfeather had a very good tweet thread where he started off with our retrim. CEO of Arbitram.
We should say CEO of Arbitram. Number one, number one tweet in the thread starts off with Arbitram is not Ethereum, which is a divergence from previous rhetoric. Sure. And so like previously Arbitram was a theorem. Now Arbitram is not a theorem. And like I think this is the correct thing to say. The cool thing about Arbitram is that, you know, despite Arbitram also being in the EVM equivalence camp, they were like the one of the first ones, them an optimism to be EVM equivalent. Arbitram also established its own unique identity and culture. Yeah. That was distinct from Ethereum. And I think that has served them very, very well.
I agree. And so Steven, many of the Ethereum community used to go around saying that L2s are Ethereum or Stephen has said in the past, Arbitram is Ethereum. And I just want to point out that while that's not correct, that's also not entirely wrong either. Correct. So the truth of that is Arbitram is partially Ethereum. Or it's like Arbitram is an ally of Ethereum. Or like, Arbitram will lap in the Venn diagram. Yeah. Arbitram is part of the Ethereum alliance. So I don't think it's necessarily dishonest to like say Arbitram is Ethereum because it is, it's just like not the complete story here.
You have to put Nastrix and you have to explain what you're actually talking about there. Arbitram flies the flag of Arbitram and it does so inside of the Ethereum empire. That's kind of right. Okay. So the way if we want to analogize this to nation states, which I love doing as you know, David. Okay. So I think it's less a state in the union. The way Colorado is a state in the union of the United States. And it's more like an ally. It's more like, you know, Sweden being part of NATO, which is protected by the United States of America and being this network of allies is sort of like the alliance of Ethereum rather than sort of the nation, the coordination state of Ethereum.
The laws of Ethereum. Exactly. So that's one analog. But laws of Ethereum would have been able to have been established if we had come up with very strong interoperability standards. And that would have been a much stronger binding alliance between layer two's. But we didn't. That's right. Stephen's whole post, I thought, was fantastic. And it's pretty long and we don't have to read all of it. But there's some more worth pulling out here. What else does he say? There's two that I liked that he said, Vitalik is correct that the roll-up story has evolved over time in 2018. Roll-ups were primarily created for scaling.
This is true. We're like, oh, we're gonna scale with roll-ups. He finishes and says, today, there are as much about customization and dominion as they are about scaling. That is to say, even if a layer one could scale infinitely, there are plenty of institutions that nevertheless want their own customized environment. And this is the market sector that Arbitram is really penetrated into. Why did they win Robinhood as a customer of Arbitram Orbit technology? Because Arbitram Orbit technology is part of the Ethereum EVM tech stack, which is extremely robust, extremely developed. The best developer ecosystem in crypto undoubtedly.
It's the Microsoft Excel for blockchains. And Arbitram gets to customize it as they see fit and they get to control it. They get to own it. It is their ledger. And that's the customized ability that Vitalik also echoed in his tweets. This is all about customized control. This is not about scale. You're not scaling Ethereum. You are able to customize things to fit your specific needs. And that's what Arbitram is, Steven, is identifying where Arbitram has bent towards. I think that's right. And I want to get into a critique that I've heard from some in the Ethereum community, other than a critique that maybe you'll express later, which is like, why did it take so long to say this out loud?
You got that eagerly you're trying to get to that point. Okay. But the other point is like, Vitalik, you could have said it in a different way. And this is how Steven expresses this. So there, if there is the perception with the way Vitalik said things maybe of the communication that he thinks L2s are a dead end or dead, right? This is Steven's worry. He says, I worry that if Ethereum is perceived as being hostile to roll ups, it will push them away from the ecosystem to be clear. It won't push them to launch on a Ethereum L2 L1. Instead, they'll launch their own L1 like arc and tempo. And Ethereum will ultimately lose out.
This is a delicate communication balancing act, right? And so some have criticized Vitalik's tweet for being too aggressive or like trying to push L2s out of the ecosystem or that it's just like, that's not how I read it. That's not how I read it. Some people read it this way that it's just like not a good commercial stance for Ethereum to say these things because at a time when we're trying to attract L2s, we want to give them the good graces of Ethereum. We want to say you're good and you're okay. And like, welcome to the community rather than kind of like push them away for not being, quote unquote, pure enough.
I don't think that's a valid conclusion of Vitalik's tweet. There was a lot of bad readings of Vitalik's tweet. And I consider anyone who was like, oh, Ethereum is abandoning its L2s, just did not read the tweet correctly. Okay. Well, let's get to some more takes here. This is one from Polychain. What is this? Oh, excuse me. Polygon. Polygon. It just retweeted out the retweet of Vitalik and they just said, dude, to market conditions, we now identify as a sidechain, which is like a facetious admission of kind of like what Polygon is a sidechain. And finally, we can talk plainly about that. I think that's one of the benefits of this tweet is like, people are finally just like ripping off this aspirational ideal for what the layer two roadmap could be.
And now just speaking plainly about what it actually is. That's refreshing to refreshing to me. It is funny because Polygon is an ally for certain. For sure. They did so much for Ethereum in terms of investment, in terms of just like mind share in terms of onboarding during previous cycles. They've done so much for Ethereum. But they're not kind of in the alliance of L2s, right? Because they are. Right. So they're not a part of NATO, but they're still an Ethereum ally. Again, it's nice to be able to just redefine these terms and for them to be able to say it. John Charbonneau, again, he said, don't shoot the messenger.
Is he just? Okay. This is a tweet that I've really, really enjoyed because there are there were people stating this exact problem that Vitalik eventually stated in this tweet in 2026 in 2021 and 2022. So the part of the industry, part of the frustration here is that different people who have identified this problem in Ethereum and then got loud about it started in an order that was like very unpalatable and offensive to the Ethereum community and has slowly worked its way to inside the community of more palatable people and eventually gets all the way to Vitalik. So starting with Kyle Samani, who identified this problem and then invested heavily in Salana because of what he identified as a market weakness in the Ethereum strategy.
Kyle, like enemy of the state number one to the Ethereum community. The next person after that, Max, Max Resnick, very offensive individual kind of just like didn't, Max doesn't do himself any favors. Also said the same thing, Gosa Salana. John Charbonneau, like closer to the Ethereum community, still offensive to many, and then like I'll even throw then after John comes somebody like us, like Bankless, we're in 2020. I definitely think that. So in 2024, we were like, hey guys, I don't know if this is working out for us. Actually, okay, so here's the thing. I think that Kyle, obviously team Salana, obviously like always paints Ethereum in the worst possible light and that there's no use case in all of these things.
Like Max at some level, I mean, as evidenced by him defecting to Salana too, he's not sort of in the camp of rooting for Ethereum and hoping for its best. John is someone who is investor, so he's somewhat more pragmatic about it, but doesn't actually believe that ETH is a store of value asset and can compete against Bitcoin. Bankless, we however do. We are like half a team Ethereum for a very long time. We do still believe, you know, even though the market is telling us otherwise that ETH is a store of value asset and has the biggest opportunity to compete against Bitcoin on that. Even when we were saying it, it kind of, it was not.
We got not everyone, obviously, but we got branded, we got called enemies of Ethereum. During the years of 2024, when we brought Max and John on the podcast in Kyle Salmani to talk about this problem, and then we got bankless as an enemy of Ethereum because we were saying, guys, this roadmap ain't working for us. Let's talk about what parts aren't working. And then after us, maybe Anthony Sazono, I don't think he really ever did that, but then it goes to Vitalik. Now that Vitalik is saying it's finally palatable for the Ethereum community, which I find frustrating because there were, and I'm sure there were other people listening to bankless who are like, guys, why are you so naive about this?
Kyle Salmani, Max and Resnick and John Charbonne have figured this out years ago. Why are you guys taking so long? Yeah, but that's just how things happen. I mean, I think that's how opinions change. That's how it happens, right? Imagine listening to Kyle Salmani about everything on an enemy. You just shut the project down. You'd believe that decentralization doesn't matter. You'd believe there's no such thing as either the monetary asset. You just why not shut it down if you listen to everything that that says, okay? So you have to process it and you have to filter it, but if you did take a while for that to happen, there's another take here you've got from Patrick McCory.
Yeah, yeah, I enjoyed this. I read this this morning. He says that his interpretation of what Vitalik is saying is that it's not that rollups have failed. In fact, it's the opposite. Rollups have differentiated themselves relative to Ethereum and have succeeded hugely, but this is just not what was anticipated in the original vision. Oh, yeah, it's a very big point is like rollups are doing great. They are just doing their own thing and it's not the Ethereum thing. They are. And you even see and I mean, rollups are scaling Ethereum like a right now. Even sort of the closest EVM match to L1, they are there.
Ethereum is what? Forty transactions per second now. Bases, you know, pushing 800, something like that. Arbitrum is about like a thousand, right? And they're scaling too. I mean, that is helpful. And then you're right. We already do have these differentiated L2s that have popped up. Do you just do to market forces? And then the last take that I like came from my friend, John Sturlocky. Sturlocky, do you I think you are watching foundation? Yes. Yes. The foundation TV show. Yes. Yes. Also a book series, mainly known as a book series, but now a TV show. Isaac Asimov. Isaac Asimov, yeah. So like this requires to understand this a little bit, but I'll do my best to explain.
He goes, the Harry Seldon approach to leadership doesn't work. Okay, what's the Harry Seldon approach to leadership in this TV series? It's a very deep cut. It spans over like a thousand years. And so people go into like cyber sleep and they extend their lifespan in order to do this inter-collactic huge coordination problem across vast amounts of time. And Harry Seldon is this guy who comes up with this plan for the next thousand years of how we come to like coordinate across this very future problem that we need to like prepare for this a thousand years multiple generations in the future. So the idea here is centralize predictive long-term master planning by a single genius or small elite fails in practice because the real world is based on messy human systems.
You can't set a grand plan in motion and expect it to unfold perfectly via predetermined interventions. Real leadership needs to be adapted responsive and decentralized account for chaos, individual initiative, black swans are unpredictable actors, not rigid top-down orchestration assuming people will behave by predict like predictable particles over reliance on inevitable trajectories or this plan will save us leads to detachment from reality or failure when the anomalies appear. So I think this is such an astute comparison as to how and how the layer to roadmap got implemented and why it failed.
I actually think that that's exactly what's happening though. This is like top down in bottom up discovering that this didn't work from a market perspective and adjusting. So this is just like not making the harry seldom mistake the harry seldom mistake would be now in 2026 we are not we are learning to not make the harry seldom mistake but I think for the last five years of time it has been that a little bit but as evidenced by this pivot it's all fine. This is how it works out we went we tried something it's later than it needed to be but it's not too late we'll get to some takes on this let let me ask you some questions just to prompt three options for you.
Was the roll up centric roadmap wrong the whole idea of remember modular versus monolithic right in theorems going the modular pass and you know other chains going the monolithic plan let me give you three options one it was dead wrong two it was partially wrong three it was still the right play at the time what do you think somewhere between partially wrong and still the right play at the right time at leaning towards more partially wrong the more correct thing would have been to identify the roll up roadmap not ever say the word centric and run with we we the ethereum ecosystem has a monopoly on smart contract chains sure and we need to make sure we never give that up and now that everyone is on the ethereum layer one we need to aggressively scale the layer one as fast as reasonably possible without accurate without sacrificing ethereum's values and in parallel because we love doing things in parallel we will also develop the roll up roadmap in parallel and it will not have the word centric in it we will keep and point the word centric at the ethereum layer one that would have been the best figured out we got to figure it out but here's why I'm probably more three it was still the right play at the time but also part two because we could have adjusted sooner is because hindsight is 2020 man we had no idea how this was going to work out like yeah it's really rich of us like six years later to be like hey 2020 idiots you should have seen this coming but the thing is like some people did some people did see it earlier but not in 2020 let me go through another thought exercise with you which is I put this together what we thought versus what we got and see how much you agree what we thought this is back in 2020 the thought right is that L2s would fully scale ethereum block space and scaling would be salt what we got instead was fragmented liquidity not ethereum level security on our L2s and this idea of like sidechain plus which is kind of what L2s ended up being so here's another one thought what we thought L2s would unleash new use cases naps but what we got is mostly a lot of defy on L2s that was similar to that one yep what we thought was stage two would be a breeze we'll get there it's no problem what we got is it really really freaking hard and it do chains and users even want it I'm not sure that I want I think we know that we do not that can't be corrected or updated if there's a bug what we thought L2s would bring value cruel to eth the asset either as money eth is money people using it in the ecosystem refugees what we got instead was low fees generated by L2s and also other assets starting invading some these L2s right tokenized Bitcoin is a thing stable coins are a big thing so we didn't even get the money monetary value cruel what we thought is eth would go to 10k this cycle and what we got was barely and all time high barely and we got bleeding on the eth bitcoin ratio we were beaten at some level ethereum was beaten this cycle by app chains in particular a pure store of value app chain which is called Bitcoin Bitcoin what do you think of those you agree that those are all right I agree with all of this all right let's give our takes and a retrospective you want to go for it okay you want it okay indulge me now I'm I'm happy to go for it I've got some stuff I don't know I got to jump soon so we got a constrain our time we probably have like 15 minutes I'm gonna zoom out give you my take on the retrospective so okay there were definitely some wins over the last five years in L2s and I don't want to downplay that massive wins we had this successful alliance of chains we delivered ZK EVM tech discovered ZK flesh that tech tree out it's freaking awesome that's coming back to the L1 without the L2 roadmap we wouldn't have had that we had massive user onboarding on base and Arbchum it's all EVM network effect it's all good and plus I would say this might have been the only option at the time in 2022 if you're going to scale ethereum and also keep the decentralized promise and the decentralized promises Bitcoin level decentralization were better that was the only option in in 2020 okay so we preserved that through all of this that's in the win column there were three missteps I think that maybe the first one we could have seen the most and prevented the first was we missed an interrupt strategy with future so is the biggest miss if we were doing the L2 roadmap we totally could have done this the theorem totally could have done this it could have prioritized shared liquidity and you're not an L2 you're not connected to the theorem network unless we have a liquidity standard here and it shared from Ethereum the L2s now I don't know the technical like how this could have been made possible but there should have been at least a standard for this Adam like or sorry the Cosmos ecosystem they had a standard they had it like ICP standard we could have done something much more here and we didn't so we didn't transmit Ethereum's killer DeFi liquidity network effect to L2s and it became this war of all against all where the L2s didn't really share liquidity and so they're all competing each other with each other and it felt more like a bunch of side chains rather than a true alliance number two that was the first mistake number two it took us too long to figure this out we could have of course corrected probably 24 months sooner I feel like yeah and we didn't we could have realized that the coordination glue just like wasn't there to make a tight united chains of Ethereum which was the vision we we had this more fragmented loose alliance and then we could have pragmend pragmatically adjusted the strategy but instead we're still too hopium filled we were a little probably work out there's so the last thing I gotta say this too I feel like we lost some focus on the use case so the core use case for max decentralized block space we've seen this it's been enough time in crypto we've seen this it's slow DeFi it's money it's eth as a store of value that is the single most important app for Ethereum we chased all the secondary narratives right you know social and all of these other things that could be enabled by altos and we forgot the core narrative we didn't make that a shelling point for Ethereum hey builders we have a store of value on eth we have DeFi we have deep liquidity come build your money thing here I feel like leadership could have pushed that a little bit more it is not as bad as it feels I think these mistakes and the feeling that we have right now probably due to price it's a lagging indicator so 12 months ago the course started to correct and the pivot started to happen actually and so we're not now just waking up and realize this things have already been put in motion to course correct we also have zk which is a gift from the gods it is Ethereum's Uno card I think it's going to totally mail out any mistakes yes yes yes I totally agree with that and I do think that backlash is too like the backlash is too flashy right now in other words like the reports of altos demise are greatly exaggerated okay and so there's this counterswing of the pendulum being like okay well I guess altos are useless they're not useless the wins are actual wins for corporate for change that want their own sovereignty for some of these app chain type use cases net net altos are good for a theorem they have been good for a theorem we've distributed a whole bunch of the theorem development to well funded highly competent teams that's a massive win as well and it's a core advantage no one else is building altos on any other chain they're all on a theorem and that this partial side quest is a huge win that a theorem will bring forward all right that's my rant that's my take that's I agree with all of those some some of mine overlap with yours and so I'll start with mine I have I have the good and the bad side for mine the good is the zk vm precompile that needs to be a theorems like merge or 4844 dank sharding like we need to elevate the importance of the zk vm hard fork that's going to come where we put zk vm scale and a theorem scales at a thousand x is current speed as our new north star like the Ethereum community is a rally around that like we once did this is native relapse right this is native relapse yes the ethereum layer one is going to become a zk vm and is going to be so fast and so scaled that it's it's the Manhattan project that once we deploy this like no other layer one will ever come after that fact because the ethereum layer one will be so scaled and so I think we need to as a community elevate that focus that strength yes focus on it in and and deploy it that's that's the good and I think that was understated in vitalk's tweet the other the other good thing is that the layer two business model is undefeated none nonetheless despite whatever this tweet is about we are taking the centric away from the theorem the layer twos are still the best business model in crypto you don't need to pay for the infrastructure the very costly infrastructure to run your chain you don't need to issue your assets to pay for validators the day after vitalk's pay which is a celestial based app chain becomes an ethereum migrates to becoming an ethereum roll-up the business model will be undefeated this is why a lot of the layer twos like some people might be worried about like is base going to become a layer one is like arbitral going to be a layer one no they don't want to pay for the infrastructure costs the bit layer two business model is still as good as it ever was and the other good thing that I really like is that layer twos our ethereum is dead we don't have to ever mention about that we can sweet that into the bargain predict the bad yeah waste of time and lost effort this is my main gripe like so many people have been like a response to this is this has just been obvious for so long like Mary tweeted out this has been obvious for years clouded tweeted out something that I thought was was outlined with the annoying part about the vitalical layer two shenanigans for me is like thanks for having hundreds of billions of dollars of our industries liquidity going into funding these layer twos over the past three years while on chain defi choked as fatalic called it or a boros and then Joseph DeLong got even spicier and said ethereum kind of feels like fatalic's little orbit test side project building a temple to nothing and this is kind of how I feel there are like there was a two large amount of capital mismanagement and poor capital allocation and we didn't course correct in time and a lot I don't know dude a lot of people's lives went into building this future that the ethereum community led by vitalic identified and sure like if we got it wrong and course corrected in time I like excusable what's not excusable is that like so many people identified this and like nonetheless capital continue to be mismanaged like people continue to spend their their lives working towards this vision that like much of the industry had identified as obsolete and this is what fatalic does he like waits until he's like a hundred percent sure and like there's this fundamental disconnect in timing where fatalic is like happy being overly patient to make sure that ethereum eventually gets to the right spot and he doesn't have the position that the rest of the industry wants him to be in which is some sort of like CEO execution leader who's ready to be aggressive and take risks and there's just like a mismatch of of urgency that people like you and me is like we have competition like there's competition out there so long as competing with us they're taking advantage of our weaknesses and that's the that is the time cadence that most people are on and metallic is like I'll wait until I'm 99.
9% sure that this is the right thing before I tweet this and it waste money and time and it's it's so inefficient and and it we as a community get hurt as a result of that and like I think everyone would appreciate it if he was in a little bit more of an executional position that had a stronger feedback loop of signal where he could actually push forward on the gas a little bit more aggressively and I don't think that's that crazy to ask for well now that you got that out you doing okay David okay I feel like that was some venting yeah dude this is the community venting yes yes like so it was okay so I get that and I also think that the you know the the weakness in the trade-off that you're pointing out is basically disillusionment and you see people that kind of loot like leave yeah people like Joseph paint like saying this I join a theorem to displace the banks not this kind of like side project thing that just like I don't know what it is that same style that Vitalik has I also think is a massive strength sure sure it's like because it's just like slow to consensus it's kind of like slow defy right so you end up getting in the right direction and also the trade-offer like Vitalik is Ethereum has preserved the thing that it set out to preserve which is max decentralization yeah okay and so Vitalik is not willing to sacrifice that and he's done so I think as a leader with integrity I don't want him to be the CEO of Ethereum like I like him in the in the in the place that he is which is he has spiritual guidance and sort of social like here's what we should do and he's willing to course correct I don't know it's the problem is he occupies the space of the CEO of Ethereum and he doesn't allow anyone else to inhabit it just by being I get the I get the challenge right it's sort of the what's that that famous essay the tyranny of um structurelessness structurelessness this is Vitalik's pattern is that he leads he leaves of voids of power he knows power vacuums wherever he goes which is what the layer two centric road map always was is a a power vacuum that layer two's tried to inhabit with their own standard their own branded chart there's a tyranny of structurelessness but there's also a upside of experimentation on structurallessness like we are letting the market decide and we are trying all of these things and this is why I think you can come with more confidence that as long as Ethereum has preserved decentralizations and the core values it's somehow managed to preserve it didn't go down the trap of trying to scale through shortcuts right yeah the market will kind of figure it out as long as Ethereum adapts it will take on these technologies and make it system better and that's the benefit of like let a thousand flowers bloom but unfortunately 900 of those flowers are going to go die and people are yeah that's the solution the process that's people's jobs that's people's lives that's like hundreds of billions of dollars of malinvestment like that is a very significant cost that feel it feels like an unforced error it doesn't feel like a double edge sword again feels like an unforced error I'm partially there and partially not I see the trade off with with the good there but let's talk let's bring this to a close David and ask some remaining questions of that I think are significant and talk about where we go from here and where this leaves Ethereum hey bankless nation is David if you're hearing this that's because you are listening to the free bankless podcast feed did you know that there is a premium bankless RSS feed the premium feed has extra interviews that I do for my own personal research and just deeper questions that I want answered about the crypto industry questions that I want to answer so I can be more informed as an investor both at bankless ventures and also just in my own personal portfolio too also there are no ads which means if you listen to the premium feed instead of the free feed you'll get about 20 hours of your life back every year because you choose to support bankless directly so if you're interested in getting extra content all while skipping the ads or you just appreciate what we do here and want us to keep doing it we'd appreciate it if you signed up for bankless premium and there is a link in the show notes to get started cheers to a good 2026 few people in crypto put real skin in the game when they make public top or bottom calls the D5 report is one of them the week before the October 10th flash crash Michael from the D5 report emailed his entire newsletter saying he's going aggressively risk off and sold the majority of his book from crypto into cash this is when ethos about $4,000 and bitcoin was 110 Michael runs the D5 report an industry leading research platform built on data cycle awareness risk management transparency and most importantly skin in the game we like Michael at bankless we like his analysis and that's why you hear him on the bankless podcast about once a month and the D5 report is giving bankless listeners one free month of access to the D5 report so if you're looking for some sharp data driven analysis to make better informed decisions around your portfolio you can learn why and how Michael called the top and what he's doing next all in the D5 report pro check it out there is a link in the show notes so there is the question of if you don't have the social blessing of Ethereum and kind of the L2 beat things saying that hey we love you you're part of the alliance right here or if that weakens at some level is there enough network effect to keep base on Ethereum to keep arbitra slash robin hood on Ethereum or do they get enticed to go the tempo direction or the circle arc direction and go launch their own token and split out of the alliance they don't have that liquidity as a thing holding them into Ethereum is like shared security cost savings enough that's a standing question i think some people are asking i don't see that at least in this present moment like i said the layer two business model is undefeated like it's not it's not an alignment thing to say that you are saving millions of dollars a year by not having to do layer one validation which is an extremely expensive and inefficient thing to do okay so that's one outstanding question the other is i think if the roll up centric road map is over if that era is over what has replaced it and i think we're getting glimpses of what's your place the zkvm precompile i know that needs to be more specific i think you made this point earlier that needs to be merge level focus the entire community now rallies around it yep we have pivoted so let's talk about now not the mistakes of the past let's talk about the thing that we are doing and excited about and there's not yet enough enough of that i think there will be more in the months to come but that needs to be the rallying point for me to z is to meme the zkvm precompile that's right the other question i think and this is maybe where the skeptics come in is i'm assuming my tweet i feel like a theory i'm coming to the last cycle i had like if it got shared network liquidity correct across all of the altos it would have had a thousand year rain as the d5 platform we would have been we would have hidden k like yeah some ground was lost this cycle all right and some people look at that and say well this aetherium it it's now anyone's game so you have other chains that are you come with ranks may like salon and be in b chain who knows what else now a theorem is lost it's lead or at least things have leveled off and it's someone's game right now so that's one take and that's what the the bears would would say about a theorem the other take someone i'm more sympathetic with is no aetherium actually stacked some wins in this l2 partial side quest it did stacks and genuine wins that are totally differentiated we've made these points and it has preserved the thing the only thing that matters in crypto which is bitcoin level decentralization and by the way the whole zk thing soon to be better the bitcoin level of decentralization if you can have rather than 15,000 validators you can have hundreds of thousands of validators because you can run them on a mobile phone for instance and you have smart contracts you are delivering on the bitcoin plus smart contract vision that i think is the core of crypto and is the thing that aetherium set out to do so it's preserved those things despite the side quest which is the only thing in crypto worth preserving that's more my take yeah yeah that's right and about like did aetherium lose like the aetherium market cap which is the does scoreboard is at 240 billion dollars the next closest thing is Binance at 88 billion and then the next closest thing after that is salon at 52 if it was going to get flipped because of this incorrect north star for the last four or five years it would have already happened and nothing came close and now like that was the window of opportunity for somebody like salon or Binance to to to win against aetherium and flip aetherium did not happen and now i actually think like now finally aetherium is on the right track and is going to figure out how to cement its lead and increase its market share so let's close this out and let's call this cycle sort of a partial win not a full victory for aetherium but a partial win and i'm going to be looking for these signs of whether the new strategies work you're not first of all you got to look at our more corporate chains actually onboarding as l2s for that sovereignty it's been mixed so far we get some of them not all of them so look for more of that also app chains and these new gen 2 l2s that are differentiated will they win some traction we'll see about that we've got some promising signs but still pretty early things like lighter other chains launching we'll see existing l2s like basin robin and will they stay it's part of a theorem if they do that is bullish if they start to fracture i don't know i mean that's a breaking of the alliance it's not great aetherium also needs to ship like hell on scaling l1 now and lean aetherium in the ck vision you need to look for signs of that and i also think i threw this in there but aetherium the eth alliance needs to win a i i think that's the next billions of users for aetherium and that's sort of white space right now anybody could come in and sort of win that and lastly i think from a price perspective eth needs to bounce back next cycle it needs to prove itself as a store of value asset not just a revenue asset next cycle we can't have just a partial win there you go a banquet station none of this has been financial advice we're gonna end it there crypto's risky you could lose what you put in but thanks for hanging with us on the bankless journey we'll see you next time