Crypto's OG darling exchange, Uniswap is under attack after it received an enforcement notice on Wednesday, April 10th, 2024 from none other than Gensler's anti-crypto SEC.
Uniswap’s CEO Hayden Adams joins us on the podcast to share what happened, how they plan to fight, and what the industry can do to support.
------ 🦄DEFEND UNI | FREE MINT https://zora.co/collect/base:0x3cc5c167ff67ff31f8bee4b5523c684ce1172bfd/1
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🏙️ CONSENSUS | SAVE 20% WITH CODE BANKLESS https://go.coindesk.com/4cBztCA
🏠 CASA | SECURE YOUR GENERATIONAL WEALTH https://bankless.cc/Casa
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 3:15 Uniswap’s SEC Wells Notice 5:02 Comms Between SEC & Uniswap 7:23 Is $UNI a Security? 11:12 Supreme Court 13:13 Consequences of U.S. Crypto Entrepreneurs 22:01 Uniswap Labs vs. Uniswap Protocol 31:35 How Far Will the SEC Go? 33:55 Why Uniswap Is Important 39:08 Who Protects Investors More? 42:25 Are Hayden & Uniswap Ready? 43:16 Will Crypto Win? 43:29 How to Support 45:08 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Hayden Adams https://twitter.com/haydenzadams
Uniswap https://twitter.com/Uniswap
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
The big question in our minds and everyone's mind is are you going to win? The SEC is dropping a lawsuit on Uniswap. This is absolutely monumental. A massive escalation when it comes to the prosecution of crypto and more specifically this time, DeFi. We have Hayden Adams, the founder of Uniswap on the podcast today. Two different reactions. One could be I'm scared. They're coming for the most beloved, most enjoyed DeFi protocol with a United States founder, with offices in the United States. Oh no, what are we doing? Where is DeFi going? An alternative reaction is they are coming for our best example.
They are coming for our best people with the most amount of support. I am personally in the latter camp where I think Hayden Adams is going to take the SEC to the absolute ringer and because they represent Uniswap labs and Uniswap the protocol represents the purest form of DeFi. And so at the very least once this probably long court case wraps up, Uniswap will be claimed the victor, I hope. And we will have actually have some strong precedent about some of the things that makes DeFi tick. Let's go. It's fight time and Hayden Adams seems ready to fight. He's going to be right on. But before we get to the conversation, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our number one recommended exchange also engage with the SEC in the court battle.
Kraken, go create an account. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world class security and award winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos.
With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience. So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Welcome to consensus 2024. Consensus is one of the biggest hubs for all things crypto, blockchain, and web 3. This may, consensus is celebrating 10 years of decentralizing the future.
Going to consensus means being in good company, with over 15,000 attendees from over 800 countries. You have the opportunity to learn directly from the architects and advocates representing Bitcoin, Ethereum, Salana, along with the teams from popular layer 2s like mantle, arbitrum, optimism, base, and others. But consensus is more than just discussions and presentations. Badgeholders get access to it in his 10 professional karate combat fights, and one unprofessional one between myself and the Carter. For the visionaries, pitchfest is your spotlight, presenting a stage for the most promising early stage web 3 companies, and for the devs, the hackathon offers a unique chance to build your next project or take your existing project to the next level.
Immerse yourself in hundreds of side events and hacker houses scattered around Austin. Register for consensus 2020 for today, and save 20% with code bankless. Bankless Nation, the SEC versus crypto round like 74, but this time a little bit different. This time versus uniswap labs. Hayden, uniswap recently got a Wells notice from the SEC. Can you shed a little bit more light as to the nature of that Wells notice? What is the SEC concerned about? What are they coming to talk to you guys about? Why are they delivering you guys a Wells notice? This gets at the heart of everything that we do. Normally, it's up to Congress to set the rules, and then it's up to the SEC to enforce those rules.
But we're in this kind of strange regulation by enforcement era, where Congress has not set clear rules. In that absence, the SEC is essentially taking very aggressive substances and basically trying to shut down crypto and going after all sorts of projects. Uniswap labs, and uniswap, the protocol is the largest protocol in DeFi, and I think they ultimately think that it shouldn't exist, that DeFi shouldn't exist. They're bringing a case against one of the best actors in the space. I think we've seen that as a pattern. They didn't really go after FTX until it was way too late, but they went after Coinbase.
Now they're going after us. We think that we're on the right side of history. We think that everything that we we are a start of one of our first hires was our chief legal officer, employee number like six or seven, which is unprecedented in startup world. We've been very careful to comply with the laws since the very beginning, and the absence of very clear laws. This is the next step in this regulation by enforcement journey. But we think that we have a really good case. We think we're going to win. Were there any communications between Uniswap labs and the SEC prior to the Wells Notice, or was the Wells Notice the first instance of any sort of communication between the company and the SEC?
They've been going, I think that you probably saw there with a Wall Street Journal article back in 2021. There's been years of collecting information, but at the same time, they sort of investigate everyone in crypto. It's been reported they're investigating the Ethereum Foundation. Almost everyone in crypto has been investigated by the SEC, so it doesn't really mean a lot. But I think that the difference here is that we've now received a Wells Notice, which means that they're intending to bring a case. By the way, when you did ask earlier, I wasn't trying to avoid when you asked what the case is about.
What the case is about essentially is three big things. I'm sure there will be a lot more details public, especially once, or if slash when they actually bring a case. The Wells Notice is sort of just a first step to getting there. But it essentially gets at three core issues. The first one is whether or not our interfaces, both the wallet and the web app, are a broker, and this is the thing that they just lost in court on two weeks ago, with Coinbase, where and they didn't just lose in court. It didn't go to trial and they'd lost in court. It lost at the earliest possible stage that you can lose at.
A judge threw it out. It wasn't even worth discussing in court. It was so clearly not a broker. It got to that point. It was very... No, don't waste our time. It's not worth discovery. It's not worth arguments. It's just like this thing is clearly not a broker. Our wallet is very similar to the Coinbase wallet. We have a fewer features. And then our interface is again very similar, at least in terms of how it comes to trading and interacting with tokens. The interface, meaning the Uniswap frontend, like Uniswap.app, the website is the interface is what you're talking about. Yeah, exactly. And then it's going to get at whether or not...
So we think very obvious when there. I mean, we think obviously in every step of the way, but that's sort of one of them. Next kind of big bucket would be is Uni, a security. And there's a pretty strict definition of what is a security. You have to meet all the prongs of the how we test. And we're very confident that it is not. So there's no contract between labs and the community of hundreds of thousands of people. The tokens were air dropped to the community for free. There's no investment of money. I think that you can go through all of it, but the point here is it's not surprising that they're bringing this case, despite how obvious it is to us that it's not, because they also think ethos is a security.
And they're going after eth, or we think. At least that was sort of there was some news around that in the past few weeks. I'm pretty sure you guys covered. And so if they think they basically want to dramatically expand the definition of what is a security to encompass all digital assets. Or that's at least my impression. A very kind of salient example here is that when you, I don't know if you saw that, there was a, I'm sure you did, but there was a court hearing where a congressman asked you or a Pokemon card security. Richard, Richard, Richard. Yeah, there was no, but then it was like, well, if you put a Pokemon card on a blockchain, is it a security?
And it's like, well, maybe, it's like facts and circumstances. If it's like, it's just a file format. It's like, you know, if it's like, it's so obvious that the difference between whether or not something's as security is not whether or not it lives on a blockchain, you know, the vast majority of tokens are very clearly not securities, you know, commodities, you know, eth bitcoins, you know, stablecoins, meme coins, right? Like whatever it is, there's, there's just, it's very clear. So we also think very, very good case there. Final one gets at really the heart of DeFi and open source code, you know, it's basically is the Unuswap Protocol on registered securities exchange.
Wait, wait, wait, wait. You think that they are going after that as well, the actual smart contract code on chain that is, you'll basically, you guys don't have any access keys to. I think it's, it's, it's not, there's no, I mean, I think it's, it's more like, you know, is Unuswap Labs operating in unregistered securities exchange because this protocol exists. Are we somehow like, they publish code? Yeah, they help yeah, exactly. So it gets at the heart of like, you know, publishing, is publishing code operating in exchange? We don't think so. So it's really going to go, you know, and this is where I, when I talked about like, there's probably engines, the Supreme Court or whatever, it's, it gets at these like very fundamental things.
And we think that when you deploy open source code to a decentralized blockchain that is not operating or managing in exchange, it's very obvious to me. I'm not a lawyer, but I have a rudimentary understanding of the technology, which is something that maybe they don't. I will add on to this one that I think that they know this as well, probably, because there was this exchange rulemaking. Not sure if you guys saw that, but basically like earlier this year, or I guess last year, they tried to redefine what an exchange was to be like dramatically broader to the point where like it captures all sorts of things, like all sorts of various systems for transmitting information.
It's just like very broad redefinition that, you know, is going to have to go through and would, you know, I assume if they eventually tried to like go through with that would also be challenged in court. But you know, the fact that they kind of had to try to read it, like they sort of in parallel to trying to bring a case and claim it already is one, they're also trying to redefine what an exchange means because I think they ultimately know that it's not, but they're bringing in the case anyway. And that's again just my impression. Do you want this to go to the Supreme Court? Just because like, hey, let's just settle this.
I would, I mean, it's not what you mean by what I what I want is, I think that the technology that we build is good for the world. We think it's empowering. We think it, you know, creates fairer, you know, more transparent systems, more secure systems. And we want our, and we think that our technologies should be used and widely adopted. And if that means we have to take this to the Supreme Court, we will. We would rather not have to. And that, you know, we would rather, you know, more clear laws be put in place that make, you know, make it clear that this technology is legal. And again, we, we, you know, think that laws are already clear there.
But we would rather, like more, you know, that to be made more explicit versus having to, you know, take to the Supreme Court. But, you know, if, if I have to wear unisocks to the Supreme Court in three years, as the culmination of all this, that's, that's where we're going to end up. Please do. I mean, three years, what a whole bunch of wasted time, though, I would say. And it's going to be like tens of millions of dollars. It's going to be crazy. And it's going to be, you know, thousands of hours of time. So it is really, you know, disappointing and frustrating. I will say that, you know, the communities sort of support and reaction on, on, you know, Twitter and more broadly, was really motivating, because it is like a really long battle.
And today's like, and like, you know, we're kind of, you know, we're sort of like motivated. We like, we stand by what we do, and we're excited to defend ourselves. And I think to some degree, like this sort of like potential looming threat versus just like, we know what we're up against and being able to talk about it and face it head on is really nice. And sort of like a good moment for us. But at the same time, it's like also really, you know, frustrating. And if we were a smaller, like a lot of, for a lot of startups, this would just like completely shut them down. And they wouldn't be able to operate.
And so there's sort of this like chilling effect on other people. But so that's part of why we want to really be vocal and public and defend ourselves. Oh, can you talk about this? Because it wasn't long ago. And you were that kind of the bright, bright eyed, like a startup founder in, in DeFi. It really wasn't that long ago. And I remember having discussions with you in the early days of that. And like, I'm wondering how you, what you think this does to a US-based entrepreneurs, crypto entrepreneurs, DeFi entrepreneurs, people who were exactly in your shoes, you know, five or six years ago. Yeah.
So like, I, you know, I love living in New York. I live, you know, it's my home. And I, you know, love the country that we live in. And at the same time, like, I would never recommend at this point anyone who's starting a crypto project to, you know, base their operations here. I will say that like, there's sort of a broader thing, which is, you know, even if like, it's not just like, are you base there? It's like, do you have any US users? Like, there is sort of this broader nexus, right? They, they can still go, you know, if you have US users, they still can kind of claim and go after you. And so I'd say that like, there's definitely, it seems like there's this desire by the SEC to just like shut it down.
And be like, we don't want this thing to exist. Whereas like, it's very obvious to me that, you know, this technology is here to stay, right? It's the, you know, it's like, it's like kind of almost imagine it, you know, in the earliest days of the internet, and you don't even have to imagine it's actually what happened. And like, the very earliest days of the internet, there were efforts to be like, oh, like, people can just like, you know, like, buy and sell things on the internet. Like, that's horrible. Like, we should, like, that should be illegal, right? So there were efforts to like stop e-commerce.
And, you know, imagine what would have happened. And then what ultimately happened is almost like a safe harbor-esque thing was put in place, because this was under like, Bill Clinton there, which was basically like, well, for this technology, like, this technology is clearly so powerful. We don't want it to all go abroad. We wanted to be built in the US. And what did that allow? It allowed like all the tech companies to be built in the United States. And so you have like the Googles and the apples and the Microsofts. In part, because like, the internet was recognized as an important enough technology to give it some space to grow while the, you know, the things that came around it were really complex.
What we're seeing, unfortunately, with crypto, which is very obviously like the next evolution, where the internet, you know, democratized information and made information more programmable and accessible. And what we're doing with blockchains is make value and ownership more kind of universal and standardized and accessible. But what we're seeing this time around is essentially some, essentially a few like rogue government agencies or like a rogue government agency and a few kind of like even like not, I don't even know if it's the majority, but like politicians essentially for political reasons, like trying to shut it down and not recognizing like it's important to the future of this country.
And so it's really not good for the country. I think that like ultimately, you know, like the internet, it's inevitable. And it's just being made more painful and what you'll end up happening is a lot of the innovation. We'll start happening abroad and then like the taxes are going to other countries and whatever, you know, all that. And so it's not good for America in my opinion, but it is completely great. So I'm just curious to take on why they're doing it then. Like is it we just have different leadership at the home, right? So like my parallel is you look at the 90s internet, it was birthed in the US.
And mostly all we needed from legislators lawmakers is just to kind of get out of the way of the entrepreneurs in the US. And it's helpful to get some regulation. But can you imagine if the FTC, for example, regulates, you know, communications in the US, if they went to Google and brought them to court in like 1990, circa 1999, imagine how bad that would be for American internet entrepreneurs. And it seems to be the approach that the US is taking to the internet of value. I'm just curious, like why is it because the US has too much vested interest in their inherent in their financial system that they didn't have for a communications protocol?
Like why is this happening in crypto? Yeah, I think that like sometimes in crypto, we tend to like try to produce something then, and I'm like, well, it's like all this like one massive coordinated thing. Whereas I think that what is really happening is you have a combination of factors. So you have like, I'd say like a kind of slightly like a kind of like a rogue government agency with political, you know, that it's sort of more dictated, their strategy is more dictated by like creating headlines, you know, bringing cases against Kim Kardashian or whatever, versus going after, you know, real bad actors that are harming people are not saying, I don't, again, not kind of getting into that specific thing, but I'm just saying that like they're sort of like a political motivation from what I can tell for the SEC.
And then I'd say within, you know, within Congress and whatever, there's like varied levels of support and interest. I think a lot of it is like some degree it's almost like, some of it is almost like disinterest or deference or just like, okay, we'll let them deal with it. And like then some of it is, you know, probably more, you know, politically motivated. And then some of it is probably like, you know, misunderstanding or ignorance around the technology. There is certainly some support. I think some of it is like sort of like, I think the one thing that I hope for our industry in this moment is that we can do a little bit of a better job telling our story.
I think what we've seen historically is that a lot of other people have sort of been able to portray crypto in a certain type of way. Probably like the one of the biggest moments in like shifting of crypto narrative was actually like, you know, almost like it was like actually when like met at the time Facebook, you know, announced Libra and was going to do their stablecoin to compete with the US dollar. And I think that was like a moment where suddenly like for an entire contingent of the political spectrum, it almost like associated like crypto with like big tech, whereas what we actually are is more of a like our grassroots kind of bottoms up movement, which is often more in line.
And so I think that there's like these like a lot of it, a lot of, you know, politics is just like knee jerk tribalism and and reactions and oh, like my side thinks it's one thing about this one thing. So I think this thing too, like what we really need to do is better tell our story about how we help people. And I think that like one really interesting thing that came out of that I've seen in the past two days and I tweeted about this yesterday was that shockingly to some degree, but not totally entirely shocking. Like the media reporting of round this case, the mainstream media reporting was actually some of the best that there's ever we've ever had.
Like in a few years ago, it would have been like, you know, crypto project, go, which is, you know, primarily used for illegal money laundering and whatever like, you know, now sued for obviously like versus like this time around, like you have, you know, the fortune piece was really good. You also have like things like the Wall Street Journal explaining that this is an automated system that runs on a blockchain, whereas like you have like a much higher quality. Some of the like reporting around it has actually given us a more fair representation. It's not perfect, but it's like I think people are starting like more and more people are starting to recognize that, that you know, there is like a more important story here that there's a more important technology here.
And so I think the past sometimes is it's like very adversarial stance crypto takes against the world, which can make sense in certain contexts, but I think at the same time like part of it is we actually have to like still build bridges and like explain it. Like when you build something that is like good for the world, like we believe what we're doing is good. We believe it's empowering. And so when you do that, it's like part of it is just about how can we explain things to people in a way that they, you know, understand in a way that they recognize the value of. And the more we do that, you know, the more like the more support we have and so like in the, and I think that like that.
So there is like a there isn't some reality to like the quote of public opinion and like just like the like public sentiment around crypto, you know, voter sentiment around crypto. It's it doesn't necessarily like there's still like going to be an ongoing court case that will play out in the that will matter most there is the law and we think we're right there as well. And on the right side, we're thinking we're on the right side of the law. But when it comes to like the, you know, the world's adoption of crypto and sort of the understanding by policymakers and et cetera, like the more, you know, voters care about it, the more the more clear the benefits are to people, which we don't know, you know, and understand.
But I think I haven't always made the best case to the world about it. Can I just read the fortune title that you tweeted out, Hayden? It's the SEC wants to sink one of finance's most innovative technologies. That's from fortune. That's that's that's a great headline. Doing a zoom out though. And because while the education has gotten better and as evidence by this fortune article, this brand, Uniswap and this court case with the SEC is it's going to become one of the bigger court cases that will be in them in the halls of crypto history. And yet, there's still like plenty of work to do about like public understanding about what is exactly going on in the crypto world.
So like maybe with it's going to be like I'm, I'm sure Hayden, like some web to try to find reporters journalists like listening to this just to like get their grasp as to what's going on here, who actually still might not be familiar with the nuances of a decentralized exchange on a crypto protocol versus a centralized exchange like Coinbase. And so the SEC is suing Uniswap Labs, the LLC inside of United States. There's also this Uniswap protocol on Ethereum as a decentralized exchange. And this is like the new ones that we have been trying to educate about the for the outside world for years and years and years now.
So maybe just like starting and zooming all the way out and starting from base principles, like what should people know about the differences of this structure? And like the Uniswap Labs relationship with the Uniswap protocol and how it's similar and also very different from like actual centralized exchanges like the NASDAQ or Coinbase. Yeah, so I think that you know a lot of like the current world of tech and finance and whatever relies on trust, right? Users need to trust the institutions that they're interacting with, right? If you're interacting with a bank, you really need to trust the bank if you're interacting with whatever platform it, right?
Because the platforms themselves tend to have full control over the assets underlying them and over the logic of the systems that they're building. And the transparency for those systems comes through the form of things like audits, quarterly audits every three months, you know, or public disclosures in the form of and and these are real systems that do help create better transparency within a world of centralization. Part of what is and I think that you know part of what blockchain and crypto enables is things that you know it kind of goes from like Google had this model of like don't be evil and I think crypto could take on as model of like can't be evil, right?
Because we can build systems that don't rely on the goodwill of you know centralized entities to for people to to to know what's going to happen with their their their money or whatever it whatever it is their assets. Instead we can build systems where anyone with access to the internet can verify the integrity, can verify the underlying accounting, can choose where their funds are custodyed. So right like when you interact with a centralized exchange you also have to custody your funds with that centralized exchange to sort of this like all in package. And so if the and and you're sort of trusting that that system but here you can kind of like separate out and break out the system into components and people can choose to the self-custody they can choose to custody with someone who whatever entity they trust while still being able you know trade with with other people as an example.
I think that you know what the part of what this all gets at is like you know this sort of internet analogy I gave before which is like much of what the internet did is create a standard set of essentially what are called protocols to standardize how you transmit and interact with information. This is part of what enabled the the this is part of why what makes the internet empowering right. So an example of this is that you know you have this protocol called SMTP which is the protocol that underlines email. And so every the reason that you can that Gmail can speak to I can fairly think of another email client hotmail which Gmail is pretty pretty popular but the reason that like different email or proton mail that's a good one.
So the reason that different email clients can speak to each other is because they're using standard underlying infrastructure that is sort of inherently like you know neutral and that's what allows like anyone to create a competing email client but they all work together. The world of like ownership of assets and finance is very different from this every single and by the way that that that system creates you know very good competition. If you had to like own if you had to recreate SMTP to create an email client then it would be much much harder to compete with Gmail or to compete with whatever the early email clients were that ultimately lost to Gmail.
And then when you have in the world of like asset ownership of assets and finance it's so different from the internet. By the way it also did like you know this email but it's also like this HTTPS which is like why all websites work in all browsers right. And so when you get to the world of finance and ownership it's so different from the internet it's so siloed the technology is so like old and broken and it doesn't fit together and the end up the like the there's all these like different regulations rules put in place to try to create some sense of safety within a system that is like extremely opaque, extremely outdated, extremely non-standardized right.
Every different asset class has a completely different set of rules a completely different set of you know infrastructure and in crypto we have this sort of standardized you know protocols for how you like transmit and interact with value. And that's sort of like the like the basis of the technology and what you can do when you have that is you can create like better fairer systems on top of it. And so examples are like for the youths what protocol you know it dramatically lowers the barrier of entry to creating a marketplace, to creating liquidity, to trading you know it's sort of like you know and that sort of gets it like you know what is the difference between like the world of like you know like movies getting launched in theaters like one by one like how hard was it to create a movie versus how hard is it to create a YouTube video.
And what is like what has that enabled it's enabled all way more people to create content and monetize it and access it. And so it's the same thing like the world of finance has very bad competition. It doesn't have good like competitive dynamics. It doesn't have good technology. It doesn't have you know it's there's very high barriers to entry. And so what we're trying to do with with decentralized finance is to you know fix that problem and to dramatically improve it to an addition like you know create like radical transparency by you know blockchains you have like all of the code all the transaction histories are in real time publicly available.
So you know we think it's really powerful we think it's really good for the world and so that's why we stand by it. And to really drive this point home what's Uniswap's labs relationship with the Uniswap protocol and all the people trading on it and the all the assets inside of it on top of the Ethereum blockchain. Yeah so you know something that I'll I'll answer that but something to like analogize here is like if you remember like years back like like or even like last year for example like Reddit closed off some of their API and a lot of projects built on top of Reddit had to shut down or they made their API more expensive.
And like a few years back Twitter closed their API or changed their API and a lot of projects that were building on top of Twitter very hard for me to say the word X. You know Uniswap X is the best X but derailing myself but the you know the Twitter API closed off and all these projects you know that were building on top of the Twitter API were essentially you know what we would say crypto were rugged they they could no longer you know operate. The cool thing about the Uniswap protocol right is that there's nothing that I can do to the protocol that you David cannot right like the you know it is it is the code it simply open source code published to a blockchain that is running you know autonomously so you know the the only way to shut it down would be to shut down every blockchain node the only way and and so you know it's not something that I'm operating it's not something that I'm running it's a you know it's just a piece of software that runs automatically and then different people can interact with it in different ways and so we have our interface but the cool thing about it is that even though we have like maybe the most popular interface because we put a lot of work into making it really nice.
Other people there's dozens of other interfaces that are also integrated with the same protocol and if our interface had to shut down there would be other interfaces that would continue running and that kind of speaks at the like the the you know why this is better right like we built this protocol but we don't have exclusive access or exclusive rights to it and speaks up part of why it's different like you know why it requires different thought different rules of regulations because you know we can't you know if we if we can't prevent someone else from building an interface that like inherently creates a more fair playing field.
Yeah the Uniswap protocol doesn't enshrine your front end anymore than it does anyone else's it actually doesn't even know that there's a Uniswap labs company that's built the front end as it's differentiated from any of the other front ends that also happened as well. Yeah we're like a software development shop we we've done some of the core development of the protocol for beef you know they start to be more other people contributing to that and then in addition you know we also have built a an interface to the protocol that we run but many many other people have done the same. It's kind it's kind of an interesting exercise that I think people have to get their heads wrapped around so it's like even if some regulatory agency like the SEC forced Uniswap labs to shut down okay in order to shut down the quote unquote like Uniswap protocol that you're talking about the code that's deployed on chain how far would they actually have to go you have to shut down Ethereum you have to block US users ability to access the internet you have to like shut down the internet itself how far is the SEC prepared to go to like control this decentralized exchange that's kind of the question teams entering people's homes right you're going to come get all the bankless listeners listening to this episode like yeah which guess it why like this like sort of like the rules are clear we just need to enforce them like narrative from the SEC is like kind of ludicrous right it's very clear this technology is so different and it's you know the sort of scale of like like you can just go after you know essentialized thing and shut it down but you can't hear and so it's very clear the rules have to be different and it's very clear that like yeah so it it's pretty crazy my my favorite way to sort of understand because I think what what happens in in sort of mainstream consciousness is people associate like just the average American and by the way you're gonna have the opportunity here as this escalates to make your case in front of the American people which David reframe this for me a bit it's like at first I was incredibly disappointed like how could America do this what's wrong with our regulators think thank you how dare you touch hate and Adams yeah how dare you okay another Adam sorry and but now I'm just like wow this is a tremendous opportunity to make the case for Uniswap who better than Uniswap to actually be like brought to the forefront to make their case in in front of the American people I think people right now have a tendency to associate crypto with the bad crypto actors as well right so SBF but what Uniswap provides is a SBF can't f you up you know because it's Uniswap there is no SBF in the Uniswap Protocol and you have the opportunity to tell that story your tweet yesterday was really cool you said this when you build technology that improves people's lives you don't need to hide you don't need to hide I hope that is still true in America Hayden and I want to ask you maybe just address the average American citizen who has no idea about SMTP protocols now the internet was made they just enjoy like the fruits of the internet okay what's your case to the average American the average you know Joe public where where where you get to say this is why Uniswap improves your life why it's good for the world yeah look we're what we're doing simply and it's in the early oh DeFi is like a nice is a good early industry it's in its like infancy it's like the internet you know 20 maybe more like 30 years ago so we're in the earliest stages but what the internet ultimately did is it empowered people it it you know it and not every aspect of the internet was good right the internet has been used for good and bad but like very few people could argue that it didn't provide far more you know far greater access to information and it was like a fundamentally empowering technology and what we're trying to do the mission of you know of what DeFi is and what Uniswap is is really trying to do that for a world for the like you know the world of like of essentially finance and and other forms of like ownership and digital ownership we're trying to make you know it more accessible to make it more fair to level the playing field and to you know improve the technology behind it and we think that's like a worthy cause and a good mission and really you know when you look at look there it's not like it's it's in the early days and when something is early it's like inefficient right until when something is early it's you know and I think when people like people hear about crypto and they hear about this way of like oh I've heard Bitcoin burns more energy than Norway or whatever right but then like you know I don't know it but like what you have to understand is that like this this technology is in its early stages right Ethereum you know is now whatever 99% more energy efficient than it was two years ago with group of stake that's just an example and I know people kind of even crypto don't like that example on both sides but whatever the point is that like part of our job you know as crypto people is to to speak to people who don't know and understand everything that we do and so what I'd say is that like yeah this is in its early stages but it's it's competing with um you know it's competing with like massive entrenched financial interests right like today the world of finance um and and much of the you know and what much of the the uh internet which is oh we i'm not going to go up to it is like uh you're controlled by very few dominant players and it's uh there's there's some really like negative like okay a very simple example is that you put your money in a bank uh they pay you like 0.
0 to 5% interest they take like you know they make like 5% interest or something right like like the like just like there's just like a this massive like value redistribution like redistribution from like society and people like everyday people towards like the people that own the like systems that you know are sort of entrenched and part of what we're trying to do is build systems uh that you know allow you know people to really own their own assets and have access to the same opportunities you know we want people you know we want everyone to have access to the same yield opportunities that banks currently you know take with other people's money right like things like that we're trying to build like a more level system a more level playing field um and you know uh yes it's it's it's early on yes there are like things that we have to figure out to make it better to make it you know more reliable et cetera to make it faster it can be you know like the same way like dial up with slow and kind of expensive relative to like you know the the fiber we have today or whatever like and you know there are parts of crypto you might like use it and be like oh this is kind of weird and slow and I don't quite get the user experience and we're working a lot of people like you know literally tens of thousands of people around the world are working to make it cheaper faster more accessible easier to use and like the end result of what we're working towards uh in in you know my view is like a far better uh far fairer system um is that uh you know and and so it it there is sort of like there are steps along the way and I think part of what we have to do is is show people like like one thing to note is that like a lot of people um trust they're like in the United States for example a lot of people trust their bank um for better for worse and I think we saw maybe uh you know with with uh all some some stuff last year that that indicated some you know banks or maybe at risk as well but um you know a lot of other countries around the world people don't trust their banks and uh they have far and they don't trust their currencies and so having access to you know like today there are many countries you know where currencies are being do value did a very rapid rate and honestly even the US dollars sort of has some like pretty significant inflation but ignoring that um I think that like there are countries where like inflation is in like the hundred percent per year or more and so like access to these tools are already helping people around the world right like Uniswap and and and Ethereum is already like saving people's lives uh in countries that have far worse financial systems that we do today and so to throw all of that out and to try to like make it really hard to build is is actually really damaging to people around the world uh who don't have the same opportunities so uh that's you know and and then ultimately the end result uh maybe further out is that like it should be better for everyone one of the parts of your tweet towards the end says the SEC's mission is to protect investors maintain fair and orderly and efficient markets facilitate and facilitate capital formation this is a noble mission you say and you also say I argue that Uniswap does a far better job of this today than the SEC and this is one of the core premises of this entire industry we actually regulate safety into the code we protect investors via code we say uh rather than saying we let's not be evil let's say let's actually like tie our hands to the mass and enforce no one to be able to be evil using using code and I think this is why so many um economies on the long tail benefit from applications like Uniswap and systems like Ethereum is because of this uh structure given the opportunity do you see do you see this as an opportunity to actually like leverage this point in court how how might you elevate this during this like ongoing proceedings with the SEC yeah look I think that you know uh like regulation I I wanted to put put that in there I wanted to like kind of well I guess like the main point yeah the main thing there is really that like I wanted to highlight like the mission of the SEC is actually like a inferior good like it's a good it's a good mission like you want we're honestly like a maybe in some ways a more accurate like we have our mission statement but like until some degree I actually like it almost even more for us than our current like it's a pretty good mission statement right like you know it's about making making the system more fair and better and protecting people and uh you know but like the way that it is enacted in the centralized system it's the only way you can enact in the centralized system is you like if something is centralized and closed off you have to force people to disclose things but when you have you know and and so like disclosures are a good thing and you know but like when you have but but you have to recognize the technology and in the like it you can't just like square peg every round hold right like like it's a it's it's it's it's like it can be a square peg for a square hole but when what you know swap is like a different thing and so if you have an entire system that's aimed to like disclose how something works and then you know swap has like entirely open source source available code and when you have like systems that try to like reveal like the balances on people's balance sheets and then you just swap like every transaction in the entire history is public on chain in real time like the rules are like you have you can't just like like you just want better is you just want to be more transparent than you know in how it works and how it functions in the the balances and the transaction history then like almost anything that has ever come before it and so so if I'm trying to get into this other regime that is designed for for like you know creating transparency within opaque centralized system that just doesn't make sense in some way if regulators were doing their job they'd they'd push more traffic and more liquidity to Uniswap then it's you know you know yeah or they would like you know try to create like best practices for what you know for like you know the security auditing for protocols and for you know like like or like for how did like you know like the ways and formats which you publish like the code like this they think they could do that would like but yes I mean that's the thing there's such appetite to partner with regulators yeah to like toward the same mission and they're not opening those doors but Hayden this has been like fantastic thank you for debriefing on this I think we have one last question for you are you ready for it yeah look honestly the thing that makes me most ready for it is just how like the the community reaction the community support when we announces we talked about it publicly was really motivating and really inspiring and it's really appreciated just having like like we can't do it alone but I am ready for it with like the community like like with the in the context that we have which is like you know a whole industry that is sort of behind us and on the same side and oh so so Hayden that wasn't actually the last question I was asking if you're ready for the last question here's last question Hayden was just really saying he's ready to fight I know you're ready for it but big question in our minds and everyone's mind is are you going to win yes yes we are going to win we plan to win we have a we have a we're on the right side of the law and well we are excited about this and I guess maybe in conclusion here you've got a lot of people in obviously the bankless community and the entire crypto community who has benefited from the open permission list decentralized nature of uniswap uniswap has never defrauded anyone no one has lost any funds using this crypto tool and because of its existence I think it's saved folks a lot of money and brought a lot of democratization to finance is there anything we can do to help you like what do you need from the crypto community honestly just like keep keep spreading the good word keep talking about you know the benefits of the technology just you know I listened actually already listened this morning to your previous coverage which I was that was really good and really appreciated so you know honestly just like keep up the keep up what you do and keep kind of like sharing I think like definitely like there's this you know leaning into the like like what I was talking about earlier around like continuing to like build bridges and continuing to explain like the technology and how it benefits people which is what you guys do but like just like really leaning into that you know in making the case to the to the world the American people and and as opposed to like like they sort of this like tendency sometimes for crypto like want to just like be like fighting all the time and if fighting is we want to fight with you know the right people and then we also want to build bridges with the right people and kind of can show up really well in the world and I think you guys do a good job of that but just continuing to kind of like elevate the you know absolutely regulators on the podcast Hester purse has been on so many times she's engaged with the community Gary Gensler you're welcome to come on as well let's let's have a discussion about this just come just come come into the podcast Hayden thank you so much I got to end with this we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot let's take them to court mantle formerly known as bit down is the first down led web 3 ecosystem all built on top of mantle's first core product the mantle network a brand new high performance Ethereum layer to built using the op staff but uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one not only does this reduce mantle networks gas fees by 80 percent but it also reduces gas fee volatility providing a more stable foundation for mantle's applications the mantle treasury is one of the biggest Dow owned treasuries which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the web 3 space for mantle mantle already has subcommunities from around web 3 on board it like game 7 for web 3 gaming and buy bit for TBL liquidity and on ramps so if you want to build on the mantle network mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone based funding to promising projects that help expand secure and decentralized mantle if you want to get started working with the first Dow led layer 2 ecosystem check out mantle at mantle dot xyz and follow them on twitter at 0x mantle cello is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world driving real world use cases like mobile payments and mobile defi and with opera many pay as one of the fastest growing web 3 wallets cello is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.
5 million monthly active addresses and now cello is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer 2 optimism polygon matter labs and arbitrum have all thrown their hats in the ring for the cello layer 2 to build upon their stacks why the competition the cello layer 2 will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer off chain data availability secured by Ethereum validators and one block finality what does that all mean for you with cello layer 2 gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC 20 tokens sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect but cello is a community governed protocol this means that cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard join the conversation in the cello forums follow cello on twitter and visit cello dot org to shape the future of Ethereum launching a token don't let complex legal and tax issues slow you down token provide specialized support to optimize your launch and ensure that you as a founder and your team and your investors get the most tax efficient outcomes the toku team understands the crypto space inside and out and will ensure your token launch is fully compliant while maximizing tax efficiency toku can connect you with the best attorneys if you need them to make sure that you have the best advice and toku can help to optimize your taxes so you pay the least possible amount of taxes while still maintaining legal compliance with toku's guidance you can concentrate on building your company while toku handles the logistics token launches don't have to be complicated talk to toku today to get a free initial token valuation