Fiskantes and Matti of Zee Prime Capital join us to share a glimpse of their collective crystal ball into the future of crypto. How does our industry go from bear to bull market again and what does the future of the space look like? Fiskantes and Matti have the answers.
------ Galxe | Explore Crypto’s #1 Credential Network https://bankless.cc/Galxe
------ SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER: https://newsletter.banklesshq.com/ ️ SUBSCRIBE TO PODCAST: http://podcast.banklesshq.com/
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
️ ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
ACROSS | BRIDGE TO LAYER 2 https://bankless.cc/Across
BRAVE | THE BROWSER NATIVE WALLET https://bankless.cc/Brave
NEXO | CRYPTO FINANCIAL HUB https://bankless.cc/Nexo
LEDGER | NANO HARDWARE WALLETS https://bankless.cc/Ledger
️FUEL | THE MODULAR EXECUTION LAYER https://bankless.cc/Fuelpod
------ Timestamps:
0:00 Intro 7:30 Are We Lost Right Now? 10:36 What Era Does This Feel Like? 17:25 Product Market Fit 23:25 Narrativeless For Now 28:02 Macro 38:00 Are Tokens Dead? 46:50 Bitcoin 54:31 Bear to Bull Market Theories 59:17 Actual DeFi 2.0 1:02:49 Web3 E-Commerce 1:07:48 Tokenizing IP 1:11:16 Web3 Social 1:16:00 Best Advice 1:22:12 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Resources:
Fiskantes https://twitter.com/Fiskantes
Matti https://twitter.com/mattigags
Matti's Article https://wrongalot.substack.com/p/the-next-big-crypto-narrative
----- Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
No summary for this episode yet.
Thank you. David, what are you excited about getting into in this episode? Yeah, crypto runs on narratives, right? As we know, and even when those narratives are very real and very based on fundamentals, sometimes they are, sometimes they aren't. We still have narratives no matter what. And I think post merge, everyone feels a little bit lost. Like we've run out of roadway. Like what is the next narrative? all we can really see right now is just a bunch of macro bad weather. And that's not a narrative. That's scary. And so while we are going through this bear market together, we're looking, we're searching for what is the next big narrative.
And I actually did a Layer Zero with Fiskantes forever ago that was on the rotating narratives of the crypto space. And so Maddy and Fisk are just two of the best people to talk to about this kind of conversation as to where is where is the narrative because we need one without one we feel lost and so i'm excited for all of this and you're muted ryan guys before we get into the episode um i want to tell you about our friends and sponsors at galaxy because they're inviting you during this crypto bear market to take an adventure with them into crypto and also get rewarded this is um almost like gamified crypto learning, which I really love, David.
I know both you and I are like big gamers back in the day. I don't have as much time for it because crypto has become my real life video game. It's the game, yeah. Because I can win like real coins rather than just like, you know, gold in World of Warcraft. But anyway, what Galaxy is, is an epic way, they call it learn to earn, to level up on crypto. There are these things called campaigns, which are like task-based things that you do in crypto that different protocols and organizations sponsor. And you could do these things and get rewarded. I'm going to show a few screenshots of this, David.
Maybe you could say a few more things about Galaxy. Yeah, Galaxy. It's basically a passport for you to collect a bunch of digital credentials that show that you did something in the metaverse. And so there's a bunch of, We use the frontier terminology here at Bankless. There's a bunch of things for you to do, campaigns to go on the frontier and explore the metaverse. And Galaxy gives you little credentials for having proven that you have done such things. Optimism Quest, of course, is also one of these things that you could go do. So you go and you sign up for Galaxy. You get your little Web3 passport.
You go on some campaigns. You get some credentials. And you prove to the world and yourself that you are a pioneer. And you can do that all with Galaxy. There is a link in the show notes to get started. What I love about this is it takes you through all sorts of different chains, too. There's like 10 different chains supported, David. So definitely a lot to explore. And once again, click the link in the show notes and you can start the Odyssey. You can start diving into what Galaxy has to offer. All right, David, one last question before we get into the episode with our guest today is what should people be looking for out of this episode?
Yeah, so we're of course going to talk about the various new possible narratives that could come about. And we should all be dubious as to when we propose narratives, right? Because no one proposes the narrative. A narrative finds you. It's like a hypothesis. It's a hypothesis, right. And some narratives are going to resonate with you, the individual, the listener, more than others. Some might be your narratives, the things that you really care about, and others might not be so interesting to you. Like, are you a frontier, ZK roll-up, low transaction fee DeFi person? That might be an interesting narrative to you that's different from like the tokenization of IP from the NFT side of things.
So what narratives are possible narratives around the horizon seem likely and also resonate with you, I think is something to consider. Yeah, for me, it's not just what resonates with me. I want to know actually what resonates with the market because I want to plan my like investment decisions. And so at some level, like if it resonates with me, that's OK, but that's not necessarily the signal. Right. And sometimes I can get deluded by that. So I want to find out what the Zee Prime folks think about this bear market, how we're going to tap into the next market validated narrative and what the fundamentals are behind that.
So let's look for that as well. Guys, we'll be right back talking about the next big crypto narrative. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible. Arbitrum One is pioneering the world of secure Ethereum scalability and is continuing to accelerate the Web3 landscape. Hundreds of projects have already deployed on Arbitrum One, producing flourishing DeFi and NFT ecosystems. With the recent addition of Arbitrum Nova, gaming and social dApps like Reddit are also now calling Arbitrum home. Both Arbitrum One and Nova leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum and provide a builder experience that's intuitive, familiar, and fully EVM compatible.
On Arbitrum, both builders and users will experience faster transaction speeds with significantly lower gas fees. With Arbitrum's recent migration to Arbitrum Nitro, it's also now 10 times faster than before. Visit arbitrum.io where you can join the community, dive into the developer docs, bridge your assets, and start building your first dApp. With Arbitrum, experience Web3 development the way it was meant to be. Secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. The Brave Wallet is your secure, multi-chain on-ramp into Web3, and it's built directly into the Brave privacy browser. Gone are the days of managing multiple wallet extensions that put you at risk of phishing, spoofs, and tracking.
With the Brave Wallet, you can securely manage your crypto assets across more than 100 different chains, including Ethereum, Layer 2s, Solana, and more, all without downloading risky extensions. The Brave Wallet is easy to set up and removes the headache of jumping between wallets and extensions. It's lightweight but packed with great features like built-in token swaps, buying and holding NFTs with a gallery view, and support for hardware wallets. But also much more than that, because Brave is shipping new features every single month with a mission to make Web3 easier to navigate for its over 55 million users.
Wallet extensions are a thing of the past, so get started with Brave's Web3-ready browser today and experience a decentralized web seamlessly without all the clutter. You can download the browser at brave.com slash bankless and click the wallet icon to get started. Nexo is your financial hub for all your crypto needs. Nexo lets you buy crypto instantly with your credit or debit card or via bank transfer. They also have an awesome advanced trading platform called Nexo Pro that pays you rewards when you swap crypto assets. And Nexo also lets you earn interest on your crypto in Bitcoin, ETH, or other assets.
And they also give you an instant crypto line of credit with as low as 0% APR. And they also give you access to a crypto-backed MasterCard, of course, earning you more crypto when you use it. So enhance your financial life with Nexo, who ensures all credit lines are over collateralized with insurance on all custodial assets. Nexo, the right place for your crypto. So click the link in the show notes to join over 5 million users who are getting the most out of their crypto. Hey guys, we are back talking about the next big crypto narrative. Are we lost as the big question for today answered hopefully by the four of us.
Maddy and Fiscantes are partners at Z Prime Capital. This is a hedge fund VC firm in crypto. I respect a lot of the ideas that these two put forth. They have kind of independent ways of looking at things. I can't really pin them down into a specific crypto tribe, but I do know they are crypto bulls to the max and they've got great head on their shoulders when thinking about this space. Matty recently wrote a post called The Next Big Crypto Narrative. I think we're going to draw a lot of inspiration from that post as we talk about what the next big crypto narrative might be. Matty Viscantes, welcome to Bankless.
Hello, happy to be here. How's it going, guys? And for the YouTube viewers out there, we have two anons here. So we have their profile pictures instead of their actual video cameras. And so Maddy is the ghost from Pac-Man and Fiscantes is the... What character is that, Fiscantes? It's Hisoka from Hunter x Hunter, this psychopathic Joker magician character. But I added, I mean, not me, but some artist on Twitter added a beard to it. So I'm kind of making it my own and stealing this character. beautiful well Fuscanti's it's in the top right Maddie is in the bottom left uh and so now now you know and that was Fuscanti's voice just now um but let's kick this off with the first question maybe I'll throw it to uh to you Maddie um because you were at the post um are we lost right now um I wouldn't say that we're necessarily lost I think that you know we're just hitting like a you know peak reset um as opposing to the you know opposing to the uh peak ape or peak imitation that we had and i think it it could feel like that but um i think it's time to you know we're now dismissing the old ideas and we're sort of acknowledging that imitation took place and we do our little witch hunt you know doe and the whole there are things who and kyle and whatnot and now we're heading into you know this big idea dispersion or at least we should head there so some novel concepts should be tried and and because of that you know it may feel like we're lost but you know being lost because forking olympus dao and dumping on retail don't work it's you know it's not really being lost i think that old concepts um you know have been banished now People don't think those will work.
And now the ideas will not come from the masses, from the chatter, but from within the founders. And I think that only those really mean it will stick around and build solutions to the real problem. So we're looking for ideas, I would say, right now. So we're not lost. I think that I probably felt the bear market creep in, obviously, after the Terra Luna crash and fiasco. And I was like, okay, we're entering, this is something new, right? You know, something's been burst year. And then we had three hours capital, et cetera, right into the summer. But I think the, maybe the longevity of this potential bear market probably hit me post Ethereum merge.
Cause it did feel like throughout the summer, at least we had this one catalyst, which was Ethereum is going to merge and maybe something could, even, even though the macro clouds in the sky are very, very stormy. Like there is this bright spot of the Ethereum merge. And now that we've had that, right? I mean, we have other things. We have like the ZK EVM coming out. There are other developments and such. But like the Ethereum merge didn't really move the market at all. And that after merge where I saw prices still down, like ETH off $500 from what it was even like pre-merge, that's when I feel like I fully capitulated into the length of time of this bear market.
And I'm wondering, Matty, to you, because I know you've been in crypto for a while, what does this feel like? Are there any analogs from the past? Is this like 2018 to you? Is this like 2019? Is this a whole different thing that we've never felt before? When have you last felt like this about crypto? To me, it feels familiar, I would say. If I would map it to a year in the past, would be 2018 for sure and um yeah i yeah i remember back then i mean it's funny i and i wrote about it is is is you know the merch narrative and everything like we're trying we're begging the market to recognize the fundamentals where we were happy to ignore them all the way through through the bull um so to me to me and to us at z prime we're we're um Yeah, it's very familiar territory.
And I think that we need to feel the pain a little. Everyone in the space kind of remind ourselves, you know, that we need to build more things and more useful things. And yeah, I guess it's a good reminder. But I don't think this is a new territory for us. I mean, it's always new, right? Like the more the world changes, the more it remains the same. So I guess that all the cycles are in some way different in some way. They are the same on the top and at the bottom as well. So no, I wouldn't I wouldn't say that, you know, that this is the macro looks scary, but you know, there's always there are always things that, you know, make you go sort of very pessimistic.
But I wouldn't say that this is something that these are uncharted waters. Fisk, what's your take on all of this? what does this feel like to you it's have you fully capitulated that this is a a bear market is this like 2018 have you or is this different i mean i wasn't fully present in crypto at that time but to me it feels a bit more like 2013 um antigox uh crash because uh in In 2018, I don't really remember anything that was fundamental to the market structure break. We had many ICOs popping up, but nothing really broke, nothing big and important really broke. In 2013, Mt. Gox was the pillar that held Bitcoin together as a liquid and tradable asset.
in 2022 like this year we had three arrows and all these centralized entities borrowing uh three arrows and uh maybe luna partially as well kind of as this like group of centralized entities that in a way held the market structure together in a sense in a very toxic unhealthy way but still um so like fundamentally it feels a bit more like this sort of crisis of confidence in the market structure a bit more um but the good thing about this is that uh like d5 held on uh well when it comes to like infrastructure um and how it works how it provides liquidity to the system and we kind of we were able to move on from this like pretty um huge uh volatile couple of events quite fast like of course we there are still like uh things unfolding in many of the centralized entities but like it feels like we are just like building on and moving on much faster than we did in 2013 or even 2018 um like we have we speak to many founders who are definitely not lost and have very clear vision i mean many of them will probably be wrong about their vision but they have it they don't feel like oh i don't know what to build now i just copied the the other guy i don't think this is the case so couple of these founders will be right and they will find the new gold vein I would say.
Yeah, I think the biggest differentiator is the level of macro pessimism. Yeah, we didn't have that in 2013. We didn't have it in 2018. We have it now with like Twitter regularly talking about risks of nuclear war and shit like that. So I guess this is the new factor that kind of influences everything. And when it comes to merch, like that's kind of funny that it really worked out in the best possible way it could when it comes to the implementation or the tech side, but it's still dumped. And I don't know, I kind of, I don't feel so jaded about it because it was some sort of a sell the news event.
And I remember in bear market, even in 2018, even good news were basically bad news. The only good news were no news in the bear market because everyone tries to sell the news and dump and there is onto the other guy because everybody has fear and they want to accumulate cash. So I would say like merge, maybe as a narrative, narrative sort of catalyst kind of failed, but as a fundamental improvement that will have huge impact on the price of eat and maybe market in general, it will succeed, it will just need a bit more time, the same way as like Bitcoin halvings usually don't really just cause a huge pump right after it happens, but it kind of gradually, gradually accumulates this momentum and the reduced supply will kind of reflect in price over a longer period of time.
That would be my take. So Fisk, I really like you like pulling from past these two different bear market eras. And, you know, I think I maybe gleaned something as you were talking from what you're saying. So you're saying this is a bit more like 2013 rather than 2018, right? And so 2013 was really the cause, the catalyst of the bear cycle. The reason was we had a major crypto bank blow up. That was Mt. Gox blew up. And you're kind of likening that, I would suppose, to all of the things that went on with Three Hours Capital and Celsius and Terra Luna, like stuff blew up in crypto in the same way.
And so you think it's more like that. Now, 2018, to me, was a bit more crisis of use case. So we didn't have a central bank blow up. But the whole, we have one app, and it's called the ICO. There was really no notion of DeFi at the time. There was this, I think, internal crisis of, does crypto actually have any use cases? Besides Bitcoin, you can hold it. But like this whole smart contract thing, it seems like the only thing smart contracts are doing, Ethereum is doing, is launching these worthless ICOs. And so we had a whole crisis of use case there. You're not seeing that crisis of use case right now, are you?
So, I mean, some people that are not as in-depth and not crypto bullish are standing back looking at crypto from the outside looking at it and still saying that you guys aren't really producing any valuable real world apps. This thing you call DeFi is just a tiny sliver, a niche. And by the way, regulators are probably going to shut that down. And then NFTs, what was that? Cool. You have JPEGs, like digital pictures of animals. By the way, they're down 99%. Are you sure that we're through the gauntlet of having identified our actual use cases? Do we have product market fit this cycle? Or is this also still a 2018 style of crisis where we actually don't have enough useful real world apps?
I'm not 100% sure, but I feel, I don't know, orders of magnitude more confident that crypto has many possible use cases and is here to stay than I felt in 2018. Like in 2018, I was kind of jaded about it. I felt like, okay, there is Bitcoin, maybe Bitcoin already proved it makes some sense. It's like this permissionless thing you can send to people and store value in it somehow and nobody can stop you from transacting with it. And everything else is maybe just like a toy for geeks, if anything. But right now, I don't really feel like it. I mean, it's the depth of crypto market it's like really yeah uh everyone is jaded on twitter and uh on-chain volumes are super low but at the same time we still see people i don't know trading on gmx and of course it's just a speculation but people are trading on gmx instead of centralized exchanges more and more um we see uh still some people trying to play some games or uh collect some nft is not because not only because speculation although granted it's 95 of the use case but also because they actually want to collect them and they want to either play this game or be part of this community of uh i don't know penguins and uh like you know share this sort of uh ownership tight uh identity with with others i kind of feel that the use case is there it just uh didn't reach the level of adoption that would really validate it in front of uh biggest skeptics but yeah i'm super optimistic about cryptos use case of course prices are a bit different thing like yeah vast majority of nfts are worth zero so even though they are now down 99 they are still massively overvalued and yeah that's that will be true for almost anything but i don't know i don't have any doubt in my head that crypto now has many possible use cases with potentially validated product market fit.
It just needs adoption on scale. I think I agree with you, Fisk. And I want people, so a lot of people listening, they haven't been through those previous cycles, right? This is kind of like their first, you know, bear market. And I want people to realize, like if you weren't here in 2018, 2018 really felt like we didn't have any apps. Like there was no, we had no product market fit at the time. There was no such thing as DeFi at the time. It was all theory. And this is so much different. So in order to get kind of an accurate view of the crypto world, I think probably, you know, at least based on this conversation, kind of the most accurate model I can come up with is we've got some 2013, like a crypto banks just blew up.
So we got some of that going on. We've got a little bit of crisis of use case where we have to kind of go back and reset, double down on the things that are working, but like, let's discard kind of the, you know, the strange like Ponzi, former DeFi 2.0, things that weren't really DeFi 2.0 and kind of reset the clock a little bit. And then what's different about 2022 versus other crypto bear markets is we have macro. Macro is punching us in the face repeatedly. It was a little bit of this in 2018, but nowhere near what we see today. That to me is what our world looks like right now. David, you were going to ask something.
Yeah. And Fiske, you said something that I want to latch onto and hang around for a little bit where throughout 2018 to 2020, having a narrative wasn't actually a good thing because it turned into a sell the news event because people just could not get it into their psyche to be bullish. and so for like a while now like you know ether would bounce between 100 and 300 bitcoin would do the same and as soon as we got to 300 like it would just people were like okay we're out and selling and we go back down to 100 and anytime we found something kind of like new to latch on to it seemed to it seemed to do that and so i'm wondering and maddie i want your thoughts on this too maybe perhaps for a while it's good that we don't have a narrative maybe we should be okay it kind of feels like mindfulness meditation a little bit for the industry as a whole it's like hey let's all be okay with not having a narrative like let's see what happens in a void and spend some time here narrative-less while we do some soul searching that kind of seems like a healthier way for a bear market to progress for all the market participants Matty what do you think about this?
Yeah I think that one thing that we have forgotten is that the dot-com bubble burst, which, I mean, crypto wasn't around, but I think it's the crisis of use cases and the macro backlash that was definitely there. Also, the world was on fire in 2001 after 9-11. So that could be also a nice analogy. And yes, it took a while for Web2 to emerge after dot-com crash. So I think that we have many instances in the history that are now sort of we're trying to project it onto the future or onto the current market. And I agree with the fact that we need to pause and we need to, as I said earlier, we need people to come up with better ideas, better applications, better product market fit.
And I definitely see a crisis of use case. and and you know we said in 2018 there wasn't if i will that there was maker right and it was under pressure um at the end of uh 2018 when when each was crashing i think that there were some huge liquidations back then it wasn't that much in terms of absolute numbers but it was like 10 of the die volume or something like that right so it's i think that everything is happening um at the same time right now whether it's 2013 2000 2000 or 2001 and also 2018 and um we need we definitely need to take a break to sort of consolidate our applications, our use cases.
And we shouldn't, yeah, we definitely need some time. We shouldn't rush it. And those expecting a quick turnaround, I think it's just hopium. We need at least, you know, two years or something to go back to the drawing board and improve on what we have already. And then even the old both concepts will be power charged by that. Two years. Yeah. I mean, is that, is that a number that you just kind of threw out there or is that, is that like something that you kind of thought have thought about? Yeah, that's how I feel. Uh, I mean, it's, I mean, you're starting from when, um, I don't know if this is, if we just do it, you know, very, um, you know, like, uh, one potato, two potato method.
Um, if this is 2018 map it to the day to the month, then, um, we got, We got two more years to go. And I'm okay with three more years. Guys, I just want to talk about, just really quick on the years though, okay? So like two years, are you sure that's not crypto hopium? I mean, you just went back to like the 2000 crash, right? And then we had 9-11 after that, okay? Amazon lost 95% of its value after the dot-com crash, 95% down. and it took seven years until 2008 for it to reach all-time high. Yeah, but that's normal, Marcus. Crypto moves faster. Yeah, I said at least two years. So that's, yeah, it's funny that we're also dependent on the macro.
growth. But I also think that we think crypto, we're sort of even even worse in terms of then than than traditional finance people in terms of being being buried and being sort of just apocalyptic thinking and whatnot, because we inherently don't trust the markets as in the traditional markets, the central banks and whatnot. And when we see this, the things are not going that well. we're immediately in overdrive saying, oh, this is going to hell. We're done. The system will collapse. So maybe we shouldn't be that pessimistic and we should think about better apps. So the one narrative that people have latched on to is the Fed pivot, which is an external narrative.
That's something that is outside of the control of the crypto industry. It's not something we're innovating on. It's not some sort of new crypto frontier. It's the macro. And we are just hoping for the Fed to pivot. And I think people are kind of placing their bets as to like, all right, when the Fed does pivot, which assets are going to like rocket out of that bear market once the Fed has formally pivoted? But that's really the seemingly like large looming like catalyst or narrative of a catalyst that we have. And it is the macro. And so Fisky, I'll throw this one to you and Maddy, I want your thoughts on it too.
Is it even possible to have an internally native crypto narrative while macro is so overwhelmingly loud? Is this silence of the crypto narrative here until macro smooths over and we stop being at war? I definitely think it's possible. and I also think that we even today we have some crypto narratives but they are not narratives that move the prices they are these are the narratives that kind of make us argue or agree on what crypto is about like currently I would say one of the dominant narratives in crypto is this OFAC sanction list and censorship connected to it and it's a narrative that probably won't move the price directly in the next couple of months, but it can have huge impact on markets, on how crypto works and potentially on prices too in general in like next two years or more, as Mati said.
So I think that we just deal with different types of narratives and narratives that make us care more but don't make us as rich as fast. That being said, it's funny with FedPivot and all of that, how for the last 10 years, mostly Bitcoin maximalists, but also crypto enthusiasts in general, kind of were betting on Fed not doing any pivot or anything, just like failing. They were betting on Fed failing. They were betting on US dollar, let's say, losing its global power and crypto kind of replacing that. I mean, in retrospect, this ideal feels a bit maybe like childish or naive. At the same time, I still kind of feel that there is a slight chance that in longer time horizon, maybe like one or two decades, we will see dollar not, you know, kind of being as strong as it is today, like in the global scene.
So that's for me is probably more interesting question. The less interesting question is what Fed will do in next one to three months or even a year, because that's kind of predictable. They will keep curbing inflation until the economy is hurting too much and then they'll switch. That's like they will tell you the sky is blue and you look up and the sky is really blue and you still try to figure out if they are not lying. It's pretty It's pretty obvious what they try to do, what they will kind of try to influence, but it's not obvious what else will happen that will have probably bigger impact on the market.
And one of the questions is like, what will happen with geopolitical situation in Asia and Russia and Ukraine? What will happen with US dollar in this world where many big countries are no longer so happy to to hold its reserves in dollar you know this these kinds of questions are probably much more impactful but their um certainty is much lower than what that will do and like of course when fed decides to stop curbing inflation and start sprinting more money we are going up and that's not really an interesting question to me or like topic of debate maddie you have any thoughts on this what was the original question i got lost when uh his key was speaking does uh crypto do we even need to be bothered with producing our own narratives while macro is just so overwhelmingly in the driver's seat well i think that um one potential narrative but it's a macro narrative is for the longest time we we have been um talking about uncorrelated asset class and then after 2020 we're like yeah this is this is very much correlated and um you know if you if you decouple you will decouple in the downside i think like when the markets are going down um you know this is the time for crypto to shine it i mean this has not materialized but if we if we're if we're able to um um to not fall further if um you know the uh the the markets fall down um then we have something that we can grab on to and it's a it's a macro thing but i think that um from within when we need better ideas and we need better products.
Even though it's hard to admit right now because, you know, for us on the inside, it's all, you know, magic. But I think that we need to sort of have more impact on normies. Like what sort of good did crypto do to regular people outside of like giving them a four year for two months and then leaving them in debt? We have to be more reflective about what we bring to the world as an industry. And that's why we shouldn't even care whether macro is doing well or not. Because on one hand, this should be the time when the times are rough, you should come up with the greatest idea and then change it.
right we should we should come up with an idea that's that will not make us care about macro at all um this all this macro talk is kind of making me feel a bit worried that we lost our independence right there was this there was this meme circling around you know this uh this meme where the guy is talking to the monkey and it's like you're such a dumb animal yes and yes and and there was one when the monkey was like you're waiting for the fed to tell you how much value your anti-establishment digital currency will lose right this is this is not that good and you know people are saying that they're not worried about crypto um that much compared to 2018 right because there's so much money in the space there's um so many developers and whatnot and actually that makes me worried more because back then we were under pressure to create now we're kind of complacent um so you still think we're complacent yes yes yeah i think we're complacent um maybe i'm just you know being too hard and um on on the industry but yeah i do think that we need to um create sort of more than we do and you know I I feel that it's getting better now than then you know a couple months ago because people are suddenly having new ideas because the old ones don't work but yeah even though it's funny because when I when I speak to people from traditional finance that are now say invested in crypto or have been following a crypto they're like yeah Cryptos, who just say 2018, they were like, crypto's gone.
Like this is not doing anything. Now they're, they're optimistic about crypto. You even hear guys like, uh, like Drac, right. Stanley Dracon Miller talking about this. Um, well, I'm more concerned. You're more concerned than Stanley Dracon Miller is about crypto's longevity. Um, not necessarily longevity because we have like the high level use cases, but maybe those really functional applications that that that free that we're talking about, like that is something that sort of I I need to see more from people. I want to see more creativity on the founders side. I want to see totally new application because I remember 2017, 2018, even 2017, like people were even though those ideas were crazy because we didn't even have a tech to kind of support that.
But these days it was very much, I would say, self-referential token feedback loops that make you feel like this is value being created, but was it? I think you brought to light another thing in my mind, Matty, as you were talking about that's a differentiator from 2018. And this is interesting because I'd not thought about it in this way before, but in 2018, I think builders, particularly DeFi builders, were hungry. a lot hungrier maybe than they are now. Like the depths of that bear market was just like, you know, Hayden Adams and Uniswap couldn't fund a team. He got a grant for like 80,000, 140,000.
It was 10,000 at first from the Ethereum Foundation, right? It was just him hacking away, hungry to prove out an idea. I still think the private markets, like the VC money is definitely flowing into early stage projects. And you're right. I don't actually, I've never thought about this, but I don't actually see quite the hunger. Let me ask you one other thing before we, we do want to get to the bright spots here and what the future narratives might be. And I know you've got a lot of thoughts on that, the two of you do. But one question I had for you is just a particular asset, which is the token, call it the DeFi token.
That has gone from troughs of disillusionment to like peaks of euphoria, hasn't it? I remember in 2018, tokens are dead. They're all futility tokens. Nobody buy a token. Well, it turned out that was probably among the best times in crypto history to ever buy a particular set of tokens. Synthetix, LINK came out of that world with massive highs. Once again, it feels like people are fading tokens. And I see the reasons, right? Bad governance is killing tokens. There's no value accrual mechanism. I even think regulatory has a massive effect on this. SEC regulatory threats. Now we've seen in the US anyway, the CFTC coming after DAO token holders in a particular way.
Are tokens dead? What do you think about that? First, I'll throw it back to Matty and then maybe Fisk. Yeah, I don't. I actually was. After 2018, I called it token minimalist. I changed my mind after seeing Synthetix. I think that was a big breakthrough for me personally and for us as an investment firm too. So I don't think tokens are dead. I think that we went through an iteration cycle on tokens. Now we have much more information about what is a good token or what might a good token look like. And I think that in the next couple of months, years will come with better models because, you know, it has been mostly a user acquisition tool these days.
And it's time to change it to bacon, more of the value accrual, perhaps, and all of that. So I think that it's going to get better. The token models will only get better. and as the next iteration cycle ahead of us. So tokens, I think, will stay here for, yeah, it's a new asset class. Fisk, what's your take on tokens? We can have a round two. Yeah, like bearish current model of governance tokens. That being said, most of the arguments you hear about them is that they are basically just placeholders for future sort of token value capture and kind of deflection of responsibility from devs to users to be able to say that the project is decentralized in the face of regulators, which, I mean, I'm not sure, I'm not a legal expert.
I would also say that DeFi founders in general are much more jaded, not only because of regulatory backlash against DeFi, but also because the actual bad stuff that happened in the last couple of years, like before that when Haydn was building Uniswap it was just this like cool thing everybody can use to provide liquidity now DeFi is like this thing this like minefield where if you build your thing with some bug or something that some like vulnerability someone will exploit it and your users can potentially use millions of dollars and people kind of didn't know about it back then or didn't care because it didn't happen but now it happens regularly and I would say that that's why DeFi founders are not as bold as they used to or it's one of the reasons I mean the the big visions are definitely moving out of DeFi into some different verticals which we can talk about later but yeah tokens are definitely not that they will just yeah they will evolve it's like an evolution insect is not insects are not that they just like evolve into different types of bugs and flies and stuff that is better suitable to adapt in new environments um yeah and they will always be um and tokens are representation of anything fungible non-fungible social um hardcore economically backed by any cash flow or whatever uh we might uh ascribe them to or some like assets in reserve or i don't know what else so tokens are here to stay they will evolve and there will be probably a couple of models that will have 90 of the use cases and then there will be long tail of weird use cases but yeah definitely i think i'm more bullish on tokens than ever um just because we see multiple successful models um and yeah i i'm actually most bullish on those that are not afraid to kind of break some laws in a way because these are the ones that kind of carry the space forward if you need to design your token around some particular regulation i think you are just like doing your community and your project a huge disservice because then you are optimizing for the wrong things and yeah i know it's hard for me to say i know the founders don't want to end up in jail but at the same time innovation kind of needs to move faster than regulation at all times otherwise we are dead i really like that metaphor of tokens are insects because that whole part of the animal kingdom does mutate really, really fast.
And that's what we saw coming out of 2017 into the bear market of 2020 is that some tokens mutated and then they pumped like 1,000x, like SNX, LINK, LEND turned into Aave. And so, Fiske, I really like that mental model to latch on to. Maybe I'll ask you about a few of these potential tokens that you see doing some good mutations in the bear market. But also, Maddie, in your blog post, you threw out some candidate narratives out there that we might be able to latch on to. DeFi 2.0, Web3 Commerce, Web3 Social, Decentralized Science. And I also want to ask you guys about where Bitcoin narratives land.
What is Bitcoin's biggest narrative? Where is it in the world of latching on to a purpose? So I want to get to all these conversations and more right after we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible. In all of my years in crypto, I've never been hacked, scammed, or lost money to a thief. And a lot of that credit goes to my Ledger hardware wallet. The Ledger Nano X and the Ledger Nano S Plus hardware wallets allow users like you and me to secure and manage all of our crypto assets and our NFTs, all with the security of storing users' private keys offline and out of reach from hackers.
The Ledger Nano X is the perfect hardware wallet for managing your crypto and NFTs on the go because it connects to your phone with Bluetooth and has a nice big screen for easy transaction readings. Ledger has also upgraded the iconic Ledger Nano S and made the new Ledger Nano S device more DeFi and NFT friendly, making it the perfect hardware wallet for beginners. Ledger has truly maximized for both ease of use and security. So discover which Ledger device is best suited for your journey by going and visiting shop.ledger.com. If you've been listening to Bankless, you know that we're fans of the modular blockchain thesis.
The idea that blockchains will separate execution from data availability and consensus, allowing all three to become the best versions of themselves. And Fuel has built the fastest modular execution layer in the industry. By supporting parallel transaction execution, Fuel unlocks significantly faster throughput for the web-free world. Fuel also goes beyond the limitations of the EVM with its own Fuel VM, which is more efficient and optimized, opening up the design space for developers. And lastly, Fuel brings a powerful developer experience with its own domain-specific language, Sway, and a supportive toolchain called Fork.
With Fuel, you can have the benefits of smart contract languages like Solidity, while adopting the improvements made by the Rust tooling ecosystem, letting the fuel development environment go beyond the limitations of the EVM. If you want to learn more, there's a link in the show notes to see how you can get involved with a fuel network. The Layer 2 era is upon us. Ethereum's Layer 2 ecosystem is growing every day, and we need Layer 2 bridges to be fast and efficient in order to live a Layer 2 life. A cross is the fastest, cheapest, and most secure cross-chain bridge. With a cross, you don't have to worry about high fees or long wait times.
Assets are bridged and available for use almost instantaneously. Thank you. Polygon, Arbitrum, or Boba Networks. I think, and the Fed kind of signaled that it was going to start getting pretty aggressive with interest rates and all the crypto markets just went super south. People lost the Bitcoin is an inflation hedge narrative and it doesn't really have, it hasn't really picked up anything in its place. So how do you guys think about Bitcoin in this current phase of the world and what its narratives is and what its role is to play in the world? Has it lost its way like the rest of the crypto industry.
Fisk, I'll throw this one to you. Yeah, Bitcoin as an inflation hedge is a very interesting topic to me because I kind of feel that Bitcoin was a good inflation hedge, but it's from trendy inflation. And I think in this regard, like Bitcoin maximalist, at least these Bitcoin maximalists that are more like Austrian economics educated, it, they were talking about how this monetary policy of Fed and the world we live in when it comes to using debt as main growth vehicle, how this can blow up. And Bitcoin was growing throughout the whole period of this criticism going on. And I feel that it was a good inflation hedge just from trendy inflation.
It was better inflation hedge than stocks that also went up. But if you held Bitcoin, you would be now... Like if you bought Bitcoin when these critics started to point out that this sort of monetary behavior is unsustainable, you would now be like hedged for life, right? If you bought like insubstantial amount. So it just depends how you look at it. But I would say that it's not exposed hedge against inflation. It's like, you know, front running hedge or it used to be. I'm not sure what will happen now. Narrative-wise, I kind of feel that the big guys are like full steam on Bitcoin. Druckenmiller, Ray Dalio, even, who was a huge crypto skeptic, he's mentioning Bitcoin as an alternative to like fiat currencies in some of the podcasts he does.
And these guys have like ears of most of traditional finance world. So I would say that narrative-wise, these like old, powerful, smart dudes uh will kind of lead the crowd to discover bitcoin and bitcoin is still the biggest crypto brand right like when you ask random normie about crypto they will tell you about bitcoin about how much energy it burns and maybe they know about this other thing called uh etherum or something but yeah most of them will still like mostly talk about bitcoin and ask about bitcoin even to these days so i don't see bitcoin putting away narrative-wise what if we steal man argument a a little bit though fisk rather than saying inflation hedge because i think that distracts people it's like debasement hedge okay because cpi inflation in inflation is kind of different it's like a lot of factors that drive that but like debasement that is the bitcoin you bowl thesis is if a country and the fiat systems are printing money that is the supply of their base money is going up bitcoin will hedge over the long run not over the short to medium term but over the long run against that debasement.
Do you still think that that thesis holds? I'm not sure because I don't know how big this debasement can be and how much growth Bitcoin has. Again, these big guys like Druk and Dalio think about Bitcoin as sort of a competitor to gold in this regard. And they are saying that maybe the reasonable market cap of Bitcoin is some percentage of market cap of gold something like 10 20 30 and I would say I'm I haven't done the numbers but I would say Bitcoin is kind of close to that already so I'm not sure how much upside is left from this regard um I don't know like I I feel that Bitcoin is saturated in terms of being this um investment or like speculation that can give you like 100 or nothing as it used to be the days, a couple of years ago, and now it's more it behaves more like a major tech stock.
So that's it's kind of weird space Bitcoin is in right now. But I think like narrative wise, it can have multiple narratives going on for it in this world where maybe some countries even trust banks or some other governments or the fiat currencies less than they used to. I just don't have enough insight into this world of global geopolitics when it comes to settlement of currencies to be able to give you any coherent thesis about Bitcoin becoming some sort of pseudo settlement layer for some international commodity trade or something like that. But I can see that happening. Narrative wise, I just think that Bitcoin is a great toy for Tratfi because you cannot really do that much with it in a non-custodial way.
So all these custody providers will push Bitcoin and they are the ones that spin the narratives in front of their clients. And I can see that happening and kind of carrying Bitcoin a bit forward. But I don't think it's as interesting as it used to be from like this capability of creating new narratives. Maybe I'm wrong and I will be happily wrong, but maybe my imagination is not as great as it used to be. Or maybe I'm just focusing on other things. But I just don't see any super new, exciting narrative around Bitcoin happening apart from what traditional finance pushes. And FratFi is generally very unimaginative.
So there is that. Matty, do you have any thoughts to add on to what Fiske was saying about Bitcoin narratives? I would just say that Bitcoin at its core is a sort of defensive ideology and a technology that... I mean, I would say the narrative is about like way back in the 70s, we screwed up and we have to go back and change all of it. So it's very revamped in nature. Whereas the rest of crypto or especially, you know, ETH, DeFi and other ecosystems are much more optimistic and they're not as defensive. They're thinking about the future, whereas Bitcoin is kind of thinking about the past and what went wrong.
So in that respect, these two are not the same. They're very much correlated in price, but they're not the same. And Bitcoin, all it can do is search for a macro narrative. So it's a very macro reactionary, whereas we should be more independent in the rest of crypto, looking to the future. and Bitcoin sort of, it feels like it cannot do that. I mean, probably liquidity because liquidity, so it will still be a thing. It's potential. I think Ryan called it the basement hedge. I think that can still be valid, but I don't think there's too much to talk about. We just have to wait what the market will do and what they will come up with in terms of their narrative market fit.
So Matty, in your blog post, you put out a bunch of candidate narratives that I think we want to run through. But before we do that, I want to lead into that part of this conversation with a theory that I want to run by you guys. And this is my surface area theory for bull markets. And if we go back in time, back to when MakerDAO was being built, first there was Maker, we had DAI, it was a decentralized stablecoin. That was something cool that we could point to. Then later came Compound, later came Uniswap, Aave got really big. DYDX came out. There was a bunch of just like things that started to happen during 2018 to 2020.
And it was like laying tinder. It's like the forest was growing. There's a brush burning up. And just like tinder was being laid all over the place. And even during this time, I remember being in the Ethereum space, trying to shout out to the rest of crypto, not even the outside world, but to the rest of crypto say, hey, why aren't you guys paying attention to this DeFi thing more. Like even the crypto industry itself hadn't really like latched onto it. But we had all of these applications that had like so much surface area. Uniswap was surface area for trading tokens. MakerDAO put out the decentralized stablecoin, which ended up being like a very commonly used asset inside of DeFi summer.
Like there was a surface area, surface area, the application layer of Ethereum where this bull market hadn't really happened yet, because it was just ICOs, had just a bunch of surface area. And so that's kind of like my model for how this next bull market, however it comes out, will look, is that there will be a bunch of Tinder being laid over the next one, two, three years. And it's going to look like a bunch of surface area. And this is why I'm particularly bullish on something like ZK EVMs with like ultra low transaction fees, opening up brand new use cases that we haven't seen. but it's gonna it's got to be in the app layer right because bull markets always start in the app layer uh because that's what we saw defy summer was defy summer was an app layer bull market then the alt layer one like competition avalanche solana tried to and also after the nft also an app layer bull market in ethereum then like all of these alt layer one solana avalanche like a phantom had these protocol bull markets but first first app layer and so i'm wondering if you accept that as a model.
First, we have all this Tinder being laid in an app layer. Something happens. Some catalyst happens. It was COVID that was the catalyst for the last bull market, a bunch of money printing, sadly a macro thing. But that lit the match. And then we had DeFi summer, and then that triggered the NFT boom. And that was all in the app layer. And so as we go forward, and the idea to take away from this is as we go forward into 2023, 2024, there's a bunch of new app layers out there. There's a bunch of like layer twos that are supporting all these low, cheap, easy transactions. And I'm hoping that the way that this plays out is like a bunch of just surface area gets built all over the place.
And then one day there's a catalyst and it ignites a bull market. And that's and then we're off to the races once again. That's kind of my model for how these things forward. And Maddie, in your article with all these candidate narratives, I'm seeing a bunch of just like surface area that could potentially ignite into a bull market. But before we get into those specific candidate narratives, I wonder how you resonate with that kind of idea of this is how this bearer to bull market is going to go. Maddy, what do you think about that? So what you're saying is that we're going to build a bunch of stuff, which will be useful, but will not get that much attention.
But once there's a magic touch of liquidity in the markets, then we're going to ignite it and it's going to be on fire. that's what you're saying right yeah yeah i think that totally makes sense uh even you know like the fundamentals don't get recognized by the way they need some reflexive action and uh for that we need um sort of better i don't want to say macro environment but definitely we need we need people not to be scared to invest in stuff and buy stuff fisk any thoughts on this before we go into the actual specific candidate narratives Yeah, I mean, I would say that the next bull run should be more about app layer, like capturing end users.
I mean, infrastructure is always moving forward and it's always being improved and yeah, we will have many tools and many layers that will enable new use cases. But me now it starts to be much more about the apps and the things that people will interact with and it will materially improve their lives day to day so maddie the first candidate narrative that you put in your blog post was actual d5 2.0 uh why is this the candidate narrative and what is what is actual d5 2.0 well it's actually something new right um meaning that it's uh it's the next level because i think d5 uh d5 1.0 is is mostly this um self-referential uh token feedback loop right um yield and whatnot and i think that um what uh what 2.
0 could be um it could take it closer to potentially production economy um it could uh we could find a way how to create more sustainable yields we can we can think about it although this is a bit tricky and maybe not a good time to think about this but uh i'm collateralized lending um or you know under collateralized lending um i think that we're ready for uh for um um something that uh olympus dao has been trying to do and that's uh sort of fiat independent um reserve currency i don't think they're that there yet but there might be other people and other projects building this so yeah i guess that um we need we need more than just tokens to pump to say that this is this is a new era so much more um much more utility for uh for regular people not only crypto heads um and uh defy has been rather um you know just inward looking and we can think about how to make it more accessible to uh to the real economy the way i go back to kind of defy is like if we're really going to eat finance then we have to eat finance right and the way we've long for a long time captured this on bankless is kind of through different money verbs like things people want to do with their money and so right now i feel like defy has um We have the ability to send it.
Now you can send it in stable coin format. Okay, cool. So we've got send as a money verb and pay. There's lots of progress we can make on pay. And then we've also done some borrowing and lending. But that's only been like collateralized borrowing and lending. and most of the real world borrowing and lending that you do say on a credit card like if you're a consumer it's all credit based so what you're talking about is uncollateralized lending is like bringing credit systems to defy we we haven't even tapped into that and then the other thing i guess we do in defy fairly well is like trading and we scratch the surface and maybe some you know derivatives and that sort of thing but like i think what you're saying with defy 2.
0 is it's not going to be a different, more gamified, ponzi-ed sort of scheme to make token number go up. It's not going to be liquidity farming. The new DeFi 2.0 is actually going to be building things that eat traditional finance, that real world people want to go do. Is that what you're saying? Am I onto something there? Yeah, I think that is spot on. I would maybe add that we have built tools for finance, but we need also tools for commerce. And that could be a powerful link where if you can, if you have actual commerce going on in chain, that gives you much more space to create new financial products that are not just, you know, that could be related to some cash flows and those types of things.
Well, let's talk about Web3 Commerce, because that was another possible future narrative you mentioned. getting people to spend money inside of the blockchain seems to be maybe a crucial element. I know we've long talked about the use case of being able to buy Starbucks with your Bitcoin, right? It's probably not going to come in that form. But I think you've mentioned a couple of other forms it might take. GameFi being one, commerce in GameFi, maybe tokenized IP as well. Can you talk a bit more about this commerce use case? It's very vague, I would say, at this point. I do believe that Gamify offers a low hanging fruit in that respect so purchasing in-game items I actually we were discussing this maybe 2019 with the team that we can imagine that you have games built for actual items that you purchase so you can take an item that you bought in-game throughout different games so that it's given more powers.
And I think that that's something that people would spend money on. And obviously it's just entertainment and the question is, do we want to just entertain ourselves to death? But I would definitely want to see some potentially a link to World of Atoms and commerce that, you know, I don't know how web-free commerce could facilitate commerce better than the existing one. But maybe I'll leave this to Fiske because he is bullish on the metaverse thing and that is commerce for sure involved in that one. So maybe he has an idea. So I mean, we tapped into multiple things at the same time. I would kind of separate them into like payments it's funny to me that payments was probably the first use case everyone thought will be massive in crypto and it never really happened i mean we can pay for stuff and we can send money to our friends or even to some vendors but it's it's not something that's like big at this point even 10 years in um and we have stable coins we have block chains with low fees we have all that and we still are not regularly paying with crypto or with using blockchain as an underlying infrastructure at least.
We are not really doing that and I really wonder why. It feels that traditional fintech and banking rails have a huge mold in people's heads about how we and we use like cards and payments which are maybe reversible maybe maybe thinking about crypto payments should be thinking in which cases we benefit from having irreversible payments and if we don't benefit from having irreversible payments within commerce commercial context um can we build layers application specific chains or tools to make payments under some um some conditions reversible that's maybe one question maybe other questions as is the last mile adoption like are payments today really something that needs improvement when we have cards we have apple pay we have all this um what does crypto bring to make make them 10 times better for people to adopt it i think there are ways uh that crypto makes uh payments better but i'm not sure how much better and when it comes to um metaverse i just need i just think that we need like a regular economy which is based around digital assets and which is largely non-speculative meaning that there are many people who want to build not not build we want to buy and hold these like metaverse assets nfts digital items not for speculation purposes but because because they really want to hold them, they want to collect them, they want to use them, they want to flex with them.
And when this economy is created, I think many of Generation Z and younger generations will kind of be naturally inclined to start using crypto more and more as a financial tool rather than just purely speculative tool. and then it can spill out into other areas connected to physical world, which will cater mostly to these young generations. But over the decades, you know, young generations are becoming older generations or they enter productive age. And I think this is how we get the adoption, not necessarily pushing this mainstream real world crypto use cases on boomers, but kind of building the world for the future generations and kind of making peace with the fact that my dad will probably never need crypto to pay for anything.
Maybe me neither. One thing that we definitely know that is happening is that brands, big brands, are leaning into NFTs and tokenizing IP very strongly. We saw a job report, job listing for Disney to basically more or less pivot the whole entire company into being like token NFT enabled or whatever that means. But they have this job listing out there that's asking like, hey, for this is relevant to like Disney parks, Disney like media, Disney movies, Disney IP. We need an NFT person to guide the company into like this world. and that's disney and like adidas is already doing this and so i'm wondering what one of the uh the candidate narratives uh that you put in there maddie was a tokenized ip and and also fisky i think you were talking about how like so much of crypto has been like internally facing like hey let's build crypto products for the crypto degens which is like fun for us on the inside but it doesn't reach out to the outside i'm wondering if a if you guys think that it's possible that we actually like the next phase of crypto development doesn't actually come from the inside and that's actually how we actually onboard a bunch of people is that we actually don't have crypto natives building crypto native products we actually have normal companies normal brands doing stuff in crypto but building it for their use users their fans their their their foundations and that seems to be a much more reasonable way to onboard much more people rather than like hey, like go put Ether into MakerDAO and borrow DAI.
Instead, it's just like, oh, buy this like SpongeBob NFT. And the on-ramps there seem to be much stronger. So I'm wondering how strong you think that this potential narrative, if you will, but also just like fundamental driver of crypto use cases might actually play out into the future. Matty, what do you think about this? So I think it's a powerful way to onboard new users, but they will not come up with new stuff. or they will only adopt the ways and the models that we will lay out for them so it's very important um and uh we have you know sort of we came up with a bunch of good ideas um that mostly lifestyle brands are using um these days but i think this cycle will bring will potentially bring new ones that you know more brands and more companies will be able to adapt and and onboard new users into crypto without them necessarily coming into crypto right they will never be crypto heads or crypto bros but they will just be users of applications that are of value to them and that is a that is one way of putting it and um i think that it's it's good that we have this wave of adoption that's for sure i think that's such a good point maddie that um the established brands aren't really going to innovate though here they're just going to sort of copy the things that the builders on the frontier in crypto are actually doing and so they're going to notice oh that crypto punks thing is successful board apes really interesting now how can we emulate that for our brand so they're they're actually not going to be like building kind of the new things they're going to look to us, the crypto industry, to really lead the way.
One last use case maybe to touch on is Web3 Social. What do you think about this, Maddy? What's happening here? We see things like Lens, for example, that are forging new directions. We also see Meta, Facebook, integrating NFTs into their platform. What is Web3 Social? Do you think that this is a powerful narrative that could rise in the 2022 bear market? I think it's a very interesting idea or a narrative because everyone agrees or everyone, well, there's a consensus out there that we need a next generation of social media or we need to improve on the existing ones. And I think that it's when A6 and Z, when they talk about the free, they talk about like read, write and all.
And I think that in social media, it's more like separation of read and write because we've created this this this powerful platforms that probably will be will be broken down by regulators or by innovation, innovation. And usually it's innovation that kind of gets them. And even though, you know, Meta is doing something, I don't really care or Twitter is doing something I don't necessarily care that much. So I think that today you come to Twitter or Substack and you publish there, right? They own your graph, your distribution, and users can read on the platform and you can only write and publish on that very platform.
And what I think could happen is that you will be able to write your ideas or produce your content on various platforms that will be competing to provide the best production experience. there will be other platforms that will compete to provide the best distribution so you write an essay uh you want to make it an nft so be it you make this um essay into an nft and then um you know this tool would enable you to to write it is is you know it's a tool but you're able to sort of make it this this nfp thing um and perhaps there will be other that will have you know better better experience better graphics additional things and once you export it um on the spriting platform you will be able to attach different identifiers to it um you create an on-chain identity for that for this piece and it can have you know various attestations and um uh so the identity of the of the piece and the author can be defined by this attestation and this could be anything like from i'm followed by vitalik on twitter too it can even say i am matti on Twitter.
But there might be other sort of playful ones and more sophisticated, like I'm a first 100 user on Lens or something like that, right? And then you have these read platforms that will compete to distribute this NFT essay with these other stations. And these read platforms are basically different relevance algorithms that readers use to sort of search for the most relevant content to them. And, you know, read platforms and write platforms, they will get a cut from whatever, you know, the monetization you choose or, you know, from the traffic that you get. And this way, you as a content producer are a client of these various platforms and you're not a, you know, sort of a slave to one or you're not at the mercy of one.
And of course, there will be different platforms focusing on different readers um left right bitcoin eat maxi whatever uh the point is that no one owns an exclusivity to distribute and and you know no one is banning speech or anything like that so um i guess that is something that that i envision the question is how how economic it'll get what what are the incentives what are the monetization methods But to me, it's definitely a separation of read and write and indexing this contact through new novel protocols. That's fascinating. The separation of read and write, you didn't even mention the own verb there, which is kind of the token verb there.
And that's a re-emphasis because I think, you know, others that have approached Web3 social have bled with kind of token first. Maybe that's not the way to do it. I mean, we've talked about a few interesting possible narratives of the future. And when we say narratives, we don't want people to get distracted by that term, because I think what we're talking about is fundamentals that become price-driving narratives into the futures. But first, you have to look at the fundamentals. I know that's what you guys do at Zify Prime. Maybe I should kind of leave this as we start to close out with some of the final words in your post there, Maddie, which is maybe the most exciting part.
You write this, there may be other narratives that will carry us into the future as many founders are working on, that many founders are working on that I can't think of. Does not mean that if things failed in the past, they can't work in the future. It's best when we actually get surprised by the imagination of builders. In the meantime, let's not get overly pessimistic. I love that line. It's best when we actually get surprised by the imagination of builders. We are probably not anticipating the future use cases that will spur on the 2024, 2025 crypto bull market, are we? I think we will get surprised as we have these crypto investors, crypto journeyers in this space again and again.
Parting advice, Viscantes, could you give us your best advice for someone who's listening to this episode and they want to stick around. They're a settler in crypto. They're not leaving. What's your best advice for someone looking for the next new thing to bet on? How can they find the right bets in this sort of environment? Fiscantes, what would you say? I would say, first of all, walk off from Twitter. Because it becomes a huge echo chamber, especially during bear market when there are less people and the ones there are there are very jaded and salty most of the time but it's like i don't remember last time i i read really new and like let's say non-mainstream idea on twitter so yeah logging off twitter definitely helps um and yeah then just i don't know like for builders i guess it's just like trying to solve of interesting problems that people may have around them even.
And for people who just want to bet or invest, I guess that's much harder right now because when you just go scroll through CoinGecko, all the ideas you see there are all the projects that are either successful or not, but you don't really see any inspiration for something groundbreaking new. So I just guess I don't know, like read stuff, read weird stuff. that's maybe not even directly about crypto, but about technology in general. For example, and I'm not saying this is something that will bring us any new groundbreaking narrative, but one way to look at crypto gaming or investments into crypto native gaming, which is like one of possible narratives that can carry us, is to not go to crypto conferences, but go to gaming conferences and talk to game designers and gamers there.
So maybe doing something like that, stepping out of the crypto bubble and looking around what's happening in the world. I'm not now saying anything about like bearish macro, but looking around in different trends, in different other tech or innovation verticals. Yeah, if there is any, I mean, everyone should have some sort of passion that is not directly connected to crypto or trading. and i don't know if the passion is uh health and biotechnologies or something rather than definitely that's one way to start looking or this this can be the lenses for you to start looking at crypto with like how could i use this weird set of tools that crypto is right now to improve something from these other areas what could be interesting in that regard um and then i would I would say DAOs are interesting in general, not in a way that you can invest in them easily or in their infrastructure, but starting a DAO should be super easy.
I think the most innovative way for non-crypto people to get into crypto is to just form some sort of DAO around anything interesting, essentially making a Discord group with some money under its management that can finance stuff or play with it. So like joining any sort of interesting DAO and be collaborative there, I think is advice I give all the time because I feel it's timeless. And I'm not saying that this is something that will make you a lot of money easily, or maybe you will be even, you will become a bit jaded because the DAO will not be as functional as you imagined because it's decentralized, there is no leadership, no leadership but at least you know how the sausage is made and then you can have better idea about uh you know uh what will be the next thing because you see what failed and how it felt so i guess this but it's hard i would say that anything that influences like us even talk about uh may not necessarily be the big thing and the big things are almost always something that people don't really expect that easily but let's see log off twitter start a dow stop listening to all the bears cross pollinate get out of the crypto bubble that's fiscanti's advice maddie same question to you how do people survive the bear market come out stronger and how do they find the next big thing during these times i think the most natural thing is don't try uh just don't push it um i say follow your curiosity not not the money trail do not let the money trail determine your opinion on things um sometimes it's you know it's actually those things that are not under the light the spotlight that are the most interesting ones or the breakthrough and i think that it's important to to to to realize that um i think chris dixon he he wrote this a long time ago he He said that what the smartest people do on the weekend is what everyone else will do during the week in 10 years.
And because you're not a builder, it doesn't mean that you cannot become a builder. Everyone can become a builder. And I think that if you see something that should be built, just build it. And don't focus on resources, but focus on the creativity. And yeah, I guess that's my advice. Well, and they're fantastic advice. And I will say everyone who I know who's been early on anything, certainly been early on crypto, got there as a result of following their curiosity, this innate interest for the subject matter. And I think that's the best way to find the next big thing, as it has always been. Maddy Fiscantes, thank you so much for joining us.
I think we have some more clarity on the next big crypto narrative, what that might look like into the future. We appreciate you guys. Thank you for having us. Thank you, guys. Action items for you, Bankless Nation. We will include a link to the next big crypto narrative. That is Fiscanti's post. Excuse me, Matty's post. And it's an excellent on his sub stack. It's called Wrong A Lot. So it's okay to be wrong a lot as well. But I don't think he's wrong on this one. A lot to be optimistic about for the future of crypto. Of course, risks and disclaimers, guys. My time to tell you, ETH is risky.
so is Bitcoin, so is DeFi. You could definitely lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Stay curious.