What's the point of points?? Why are all the projects developing a points program? How did we find ourselves here? Will they actually turn into tokens? What will the regulators say about it?
All of these questions and more are answered on todays episode of Bankless Takes, hopefully you'll get the point. ------ 🏹 USE PODCAST24 FOR 10% OFF https://bankless.cc/Citizen2024 ------ 🎧 Listen On Your Favorite Podcast Player: https://bankless.cc/Podcast ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
------ TIMESTAMPS 00:00 Intro 02:38 What Are Points? 06:16 Airline Points 09:53 Friendtech Points 14:50 Blur Points 16:14 Benefits of points 22:04 Lawyers and Regulation 28:13 Will The points Hold Value? 36:23 The Path Forward
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
BanklessNation, welcome to BanklessTakes. We want to give you our takes on points. David, what are points? What is the point of points? What are we covering in today's episode? Oh, we're covering points, this brand new innovation where we are issuing tokens on centralized databases. And it's this cool new thing that we're doing in this crypto world where we are just reverting back to servers to issue numbers that are on your screen. And it is sweeping the crypto world and everyone's doing it. Everyone's getting in on the points game. Everyone's earning points, everyone's issuing points, are just flying all over the place.
Do we know how many points there are? No, do we know what the total supply is? No, do we know what the monetary policy of and these things are? Absolutely not. But everyone loves them for some reason, even though they are completely backwards to everything that we stand for in crypto. So what the hell is going on? How did we find ourselves here? Will these points actually turn into tokens? What will the regulators say about it? Overall, what's our take on points? David, I got to admit, as we get into this episode, they just sound like worst tokens to me. Okay. So how do you got to do that? It's just the worst possible form of a token.
Yeah. And while we're discussing all of these different points, Ryan, I know you're a big Diablo II fan. Do you remember Diablo II Ultima's Ultimate Strategy Guide? Yeah, for Diablo II. Is that a book? That was a book. It was a big book and it taught you how to play the game and it taught you how to advance through the levels, like what you do when you get to this phase of the game. So this is what we are building at the Banclist Air Drop Hunter AKA the Banclist Point Score System. Yes. And so it teaches you how to score all the points in the games that you play. The walkthroughs. It's a walkthroughs.
It's a walkthrough platform to help you score more points. So depending on whatever game you're playing, maybe you're playing the swell game, maybe you're playing the eclipse game, the rainbow game. The Banclist Air Drop Hunter is AKA Point Score platform. Is it the place where you go? So you can learn how to score more points in this crazy world of crypto. There is a link in the show notes. There is also, I think this will be the last episode that we ever make this code valid. Podcast 24 will give you 10% off of the Banclist Point Score platform, AKA the Air Drop Hunter, as well as everything else about Banclist citizenship, including the ad-free RSS feed, and including the Banclist meetup at Eath Denver with me and the rest of the Banclist team, except for Ryan, will be at, if you guys want to go hang out at Eath Denver, Podcast 24 to join up and become a Banclist citizen.
They'll get those points, guys. All right, David, let's start at the foundation here. What are points? Here's a fantastic tweet thread from John Wu that goes into the details of this. What are we looking at? So this tweet thread was, I thought, just fantastically emblematic. Exactly what we need to understand points. John Wu at Aztec goes, points are a new incentive primitive that significantly increase the scalability and utility of ERC20 tokens, and will be the key innovation of this bull market. You can think of points as off-chain derivatives. Points essentially contain the right, but not the obligation to redeem for underlying ERC20s at a future date.
Points rely on highly performant, off-chain databases called servers to store and verify that's why you're smiling. This is kind of tongue-in-cheek. Is this a little satire? It's a little satire. All right. While servers require slightly higher trust assumptions, they are approximately 100 million times more performant than the Ethereum layer one. Network servers can be utilized to create redundancy and prove data guarantees, meaning points are scalable. So how do you earn points? Points are typically earned through on-chain actions, through wallets like Rainbow and Layer 2s like Blast, but they can also be assigned for non-blockchain use cases.
Imagine a payments card that rewards users and points that can later be redeemed for flights, hotels, or even meals. I've seen those before. I think you get where we're going with this here, right? Yeah. Yeah, so John Wu's take, it was not a take. It's basically just saying pulling the mask out of these points things. It's like, yeah, we're increasing numbers on a centralized digital ledger called a database, and it is the same thing that we've always had. This is how your Wells Fargo bucks work. This is how your airlines mile works, and this is how your credit card points works. And now it's also how your crypto protocols work, too.
And so it's a little bit backwards, it seems, yet everyone is super stoked about it. Okay. So I get that primarily these are being deployed in kind of like a centralized database right now. So these are not being deployed, like tokens have been deployed as ERC 20s, okay? And so in that way, it's very similar to like airline miles or hotel points or that sort of thing. But like John's like use case for this is incentive, incentivizing consumer loyalty, that makes sense. Mining user behavior data and even scoring and ranking posts and forms. But also in a second tweet, he says this, points essentially contain the right, but not the obligation to redeem for underlying ERC 20s in the future.
So he calls this like an off-chain derivative. It's like, this is one thing that I think you're getting potentially in the crypto points world that you're not getting in the airlines world, which is people are expecting this to be redeemable for tokens at some point in the future. It's like an option for something in the future. Importantly, that option is a right held by the point issuer, not the point collector. So it's an option for the DeFi protocol, the crypto protocol to issue a future token, not for the users or collectors of said points to be able to redeem that into a token. That is an option retained by the developers, which I actually think is a very important point about points, because it is a protective shield around these point issuers.
Point, I don't know if issuers not even the right term. I think issue is more of like a legal nation state securities context. Point, point, I don't know, pointers. Scoreboard, whoever is issuing points gets to have control as to whether or not they turn this into a token or not. Okay, so this doesn't yet answer the question of why are we doing that? Which I hope we can get to, but I wanted to pull an analog from kind of the real world here, David, because I think most people listening will know about points in kind of the real world. We've been talking about airline miles. I came across this website on Nerdwallet, and it's a blog post about how much airline miles are actually worth, which I found somewhat interesting.
Like on a secondary market, let's say you could sell your airline miles, how much would they be worth? So I use a lot of American airlines, so I've had like airlines over the years there. American airlines points would be about 1.7 cents per point. That's what this website kind of values those point systems as, right? So I went in my American Airlines account, I had about 3,000 or so points. So you multiply that airline points, you multiply that by, you know, 17 cents and you get about 51 bucks. I've never actually gone through that exercise, but like there is a value of points in kind of the analog trad point world, let's call it.
And you can also, this is interesting. You could actually buy airline miles, I don't know if you know this, but I went through the American Airlines website, and I could buy airline miles, about 3,000 airline miles for like double the cost. So it would cost me like $150 to buy like the $50 worth of points that I actually had. And also interestingly, David, there's actually a place where you can resell your points. I don't know what it is. Yeah, airline points. It can resell your airlines points. Like I haven't researched this, I just kind of like, you know, typed it in Google and found a site.
This is milesbuyer.com, okay? That's milesbuyer.com, wow. Yeah, and what they will do is if you have excess points, you basically, it's so, wow, it's so non-automated, all right? Like you fill out your name, email address, how many points you have? You talk to a customer service for a representative. It's like the most inefficient form of like secondary market that I can conceive of. It's so old school, all right? But like you can actually sell points in like, you know, 25K point increments and higher, at least like American Airlines. And is this legal? Is this legal? Well, they have in their FAQ, they said, yeah, it's legal.
Well, they say it's not illegal. Apparently, it's like you talk. Apparently it's illegal in Utah. Yeah, yeah. So there are really crappy secondary markets, apparently, for your points, your airline points. And that's kind of the sentiment. The spread between the buys and sells of airline points has to be absolutely massive. I'm sure it is terribly efficient. It's a terribly illiquid market. Right. But like, I mean, you've had points in the past, right? You know, credit card points. And you know what always happens with credit card. They get diluted, right? Because I'll just call it the issuer.
They do whatever the F they want with it. There's like no secondary market, no one's got it. Like, there's no monetary policy. There's no kind of like... No assurances. In fact, I put up this tweet this other last week where points are just tokens going through their Fiat era. They're just Fiat points. Like Fiat tokens, excuse me. They're just like points. There's like, there's no assurance of monetary supply. There's no protection against dilution. You could just add a zero to airline miles. airline miles have been inflating for decades. Right. So I think probably to listeners, it's going to sound like we are slamming points up to this point in time.
But I think we've got a more nuanced take that we'll get to near the end. But David, could you just explain how crypto projects, like what the meta is, how crypto projects, when did this whole points trend start and how has it gone on in real world projects here? I think points, maybe points came before a friend tech, but friend tech was I think the project that really put points on the map. And friend tech, of course, it was the app where we could buy and sell shares of our friends. And every single week, everyone would get their points distributed to them in their wallet, or their friend tech wallet.
But it was just like a points tab, it wasn't a token. And then you just saw your friend tech points go up and people started to speculate about what activities inside a friend tech would make more points. And so there was like these all these tweet threaders and these like black box investigators about like, okay, how are points distributed? How are they allocated? Like how do we measure this thing? And it turns out that there are certain behaviors that friend tech was trying to incentivize. One of them was just TVL, just like how much ETH did you have in people's shares? And if you had more share market cap, more share network, you would get more points.
And people started to speculate on this. And it was in the airdrop tab of friend tech. And so people were just like, oh yeah, there's points inside of this airdrop tab. Clearly these points are just going to become tokens. It was a very easy conclusion to make. So it's kind of like a wink, wink points. Yeah, it's a point. Points, they're points, yeah. So far, there have been 90 million points distributed in friend tech. I think of all point issuer distributors, friend tech has been like some of the most transparent. And we all saw the absolute explosion that was friend tech, not exclusively on the back of points, but there was a very strong amount of speculation about the airdrop that everyone wanted to get.
So everyone started to hop into friend tech. People were also making money. This is not to say anything about the fundamentals of the friend tech app itself, which also incentivized its own behavior and attracted people. And also people came forward the points. And so this really just kind of set in the meta. In the first two months of friend tech, for example, there was a $412 million of trading volume. And then $126 million of trading volume over the next three and a half months. And so the point system is still alive and friend tech people are still kind of going after that. But the thing is, is that they set in a meta.
And now many other people have also started to play in the points game. Blur introduced a point system when it debuted in October of 2022. So that's actually even before friend tech. Yeah, so the points have been around for a while. I don't even know when the inception and points were. And the blur program was about creates issuing points for behavior. So season one had a particular goal. And you would earn points if you shared a blur referral link. And that was season one. Season two, they changed why points were to be issued. They focused on trading and loyalty. So if you were a trader on blur, you bid or you listed or you lent on blend, then you got points.
You also got loyalty points if you listed your NFTs on blur and nowhere else. So if you had a wallet that was not listing NFTs on OpenC, but you were listing NFTs on blur, you got loyalty points. And then season three of blur focus on more trading activity. So more points for lending than bidding, listing blue chips, loyalty scores can decrease if users listed elsewhere. And so really the TLDR is that blur issued points if users gave the protocol blur what it wanted. And what it wanted was determined by its founders. Okay, so there's a few, I want to come back to blur in a moment, but like zooming out for a minute, there's kind of like this feeling right now.
It's just like a better pay attention to points because this is how you're going to make generational wealth this bull market, right? Okay, the new thing is points. And there was a block article that came out that said, there have been 40 billion points for crypto projects so far. When will it end? It's the title of this. What's the value of those points? We have no idea because they're all basic, they're not ERC20s, they're all basically being deployed on centralized databases. Right? So we're kind of reserving a token for like its public and it's an ERC20 and right now, you can verify it in the supply.
You can verify who owns what. It's an internal database entry right now. But there is precedent. You mentioned blur being one of the first ones, right? Of course, front-tack may be popularized at more and sort of solidified it as a narrative, but blur was one of the first. The big question in my mind is, is there precedent for this assumption? The reason people are going points crazy, is not because they just want to like, I don't know, rise up the scoreboard and like use the app more, but like the reason is some expectation that there will be an actual token air drop and that points will be sort of a simple resistant way to reward users with that more valuable or like non-zero valuable token air drop that comes later.
And the question I have for you, David, is did blur do that? Like, is there any precedent for that? Because I think they did, right? 100% there was two blur air drops. After season one, $414 million of blur tokens were distributed towards point holders, pro-rata. And then season 285 million dollars also at that time. I think that's the big one, the big boom, big bang of points that were points turned into tokens. And it was all pretty explicit. Like everyone felt very secure that their points would eventually turn into an air drop of token with blur. Gido was the second one. So distributed 540 million Gido points, which was worth turned into $225 million for air drop participants.
I actually didn't even know that Gido had a points program until I was looking at the notes for this episode. And it was right under everyone's noses. It's the thing is like Gido's issuing points. And then also people were surprised by the Gido air drop. And then the reasoning as to why people were surprised by the Gido air drop even though they had a points program is, well, because everyone has a points program now. And so we have two examples of points turning into tokens. And we have like 200 examples of people issuing points, including like, just wallets are issuing points. And people are all kind of skeptical is like, well, how do wallets turn into tokens?
It's like, will they have to turn into tokens? Like, we don't know for sure, but there is some precedent. And I guess this is where I want to talk about some of the benefits of points maybe. For some of these projects, for sure, it's rewarding behaviors that they want to inspect, right? And like, it seems like even for users, oh, this is a nice precursor to getting a token air drop at some point in the future, right? And what's great about this is we've been looking for like a civil-resistant way to like reward usage of a protocol, actual usage of a protocol. And this gives us another lever to like create that, right?
Of course, people are on points like farming journeys right now. And there's kind of like some illegitimate activity around that and breaking of civil resistance. But it gives us another step before we issue a token to kind of analyze that data and see what the patterns are and hopefully reward real humans for actual activity that you want to see as part of your protocol. So in that way, it's kind of a benefit. And for protocols in general, like the growth has worked, there's the example of margin five who they introduced points in July. And within two months, the TVL for margin five was up seven acts, so just $21 million.
So it's like, as a growth, it went from $3 million to $21 million. So like this is in the worst of the Solana bear market. Like no one was paying attention to Solana. The amount of capital in Solana was zero. And going from $3 million to $21 million to actually like a decent drop. And then eventually after the Gido drop, people went from $20 to $400 million because people realized that points were real. And specifically, there was a repricing of the value of points on Solana after the Gido drop. I think the big, just outside success story is blur by far. In addition to all of the strong fundamentals and just like the value of the blur application, the leveraging of gamification and incentives, using points allowed blur to go from like 0% market share to like 70% market share, leading into most of Open Seas market share from like October of 2022 to April of 2023.
So like in three quarters, just like absolutely eating up Open Seas market share. Yeah, there's some game theory here. Like the thing with points is going to beat the thing without points, right? Yes, yes. And so that's what we're seeing in the data. Yeah, I'm granted. Like again, blur also answered to a particular population of NFT traders who were the population and actually stuck around in the bear market. So it's not just points, but I think it also kind of shows that like if you're a founder whose head is in the game and your eyes are on the ball, you are seeing the points meta develop and your hand is a little bit forced.
There's like, well, everyone is issuing points. And the thing is, since they're not tokens, since they're not financial assets, they are just numbers on a database. Founders have a decent amount of like security in issuing these penciled in supply of not tokens because if they F something up, if something's unfair, if their community doesn't like it, they can just go change it because they're points. It's on a database. It's on their database that they have control over. And so everyone is feels very legally protected and also protected from community pushback about like what would have been an air drop that needed to be better?
Well, you know, you can always just make it better because it's points and you can just like, oh, you guys are unhappy with this distribution or let me tinker with this a little bit and all of a sudden the distribution's better. And so no, no, duh, that everyone is issuing points. It's free to issue points and there's no obligation. So I wanna talk to you about this question of what do lawyers think about points? What does Gary get? So what does the SEC think about points? Is this just a reaction to regulatory pressures? We'll talk about that. And also I wanna get kind of your concluding take on points.
Is it net good? Is it net bad for crypto? What are the puts and takes of this? But before we do, we wanna thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our recommended exchange for 2024. That's Kraken, go check him out. Kraken knows crypto. Kraken's been in the crypto game for over a decade and as one is the largest and most trusted exchanges in the industry, Kraken is on the journey with all of us to see what crypto can be. Human history is a story of progress. It's part of us hardwired. We're designed to seek change everywhere, to improve, to strive. And if anything can be improved, why not finance?
Crypto is a financial system designed with the modern world in mind. Instant, permissionless, and 24-7. It's not perfect and nothing ever will be perfect. But crypto is a world changing technology at a time when the world needs it the most. That's the Kraken mission, to accelerate the global adoption of cryptocurrency, so that you and the rest of the world can achieve a financial freedom and inclusion. Head on over to Kraken.com, slash bank list, to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading, involves risk of loss. Crypto currency services are provided to US and US territory customers by payward ventures e.
k.pdi doing business as Kraken. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax for providing token awards for your team? Toku simplifies everything about managing token grant compensation, and you can get started with them for free. You'll have access to top notch legal and tax support to handle the distribution and management of tokens for your team. Toku caters to every step in the process from user friendly legal templates for granting tokens to tracking investing periods and calculating with holding taxes. Toku understands every grant structure, token purchase agreements, restricted token awards, restricted token units, token options, and all the other ones.
Toku is already simplifying this today for leading companies like Protocol Labs, DUIDX Foundation, Mina Foundation, and many more. You can learn more about how Toku can help you streamline your token management and get started for free. Visit Toku at Toku.com, slash bank list, or click the link in the description below. All right, David, let's turn it over to the lawyers and see what they think about points in the wider context. It's why are we doing all of this, right? We talked about some of the benefits, civil resistance, but we could do some of that with tokens. Why have we kind of shifted to points rather than tokens?
I think there might be a legal reason for this. We've got an article up that explains this. What's the take here? Yeah, this article title is Why DeFi Protocols love to offer points before air drops. And I think if you're following along in the crypto cycle for even just a year now, you can definitely understand why the points meta has emerged. In addition to there are some, I would say, strong, just benefits of issuing points before tokens for projects and founders in a vacuum as in without external influences. And I kind of named them like the temporary nature of it. It's like a, it's a pencil before a pen.
You get to innovate and experiment and tinker before you actually walk around and dress rehearsal. It's exactly right. It's a test net for a token. It's their token test nets, which I think is great and very useful as a tool. And I think probably the bigger reason is that issuing an air drop is politically dubious. Legally dubious, excuse me. Politically in favor in the crypto cycle. Legally scary. In the US, at least in the United States. Right, and so what have we done? Because people in crypto want tokens. We like tokens. We love playing with tokens. Tokens are fun. They come in all sorts of shapes and colors and sizes.
We like to pick our favorites. We like to watch them go up and down in price. We like to mainly watch them go up in price. But mainly we like to get more tokens. And this is something that we haven't been able to do nearly as much because of the SEC, because of security regulations. And this is, I would say, a thing, issuing and creating tokens is not just like a feature of the crypto space. I would call it something that's like at the core of like touching the metal of what it means to be in crypto. We are removing the permissions of creating financial assets from Wall Street and from the regulators.
And we are, we have a printing press for financial assets. We can make any sort of financial asset we ever want. We can, we can mint fake tokens that we are just going to throw away to the burner wallet. We can make tokens that are named after our dog or we can take a token and make it a cash flowing asset from a crypto protocol. We can do whatever we want. And this is our superpower. This is the thing that regulators don't like. And so I think as a reaction to the heavy handiness of the SEC being scared out of paying millions and millions of dollars of legal fees and then also still potentially having to pay tens of million dollars of court cases.
Developers, like especially United States based developers are just issuing points instead. It kind of as like a sandbox, like a test net. It's like, well, we're definitely going to issue a token. We don't know how, we don't know when, but we've learned that if we issue points instead, we get the benefits of issuing tokens but without actually doing that. So we get TVL, we get new users, we get activity, we get trading volume, everyone else is doing it, everyone's doing it. And so we're going to do it too. And it is a layer of protection because no one is actually issuing a financial asset. At least that's what the meta is currently.
And so I think lawyers are probably even more happy to issue, have their founders, their protocols, issue points over tokens specifically, maybe not points in the vacuum, maybe that's worth asking about. So a particular co-founder of a DeFi app in this one article that we're saying says, for a certain set of teams that are risk averse or in highly regulated jurisdictions, points are a way for them to sort of engage in marketing activity prior to having regulatory clarity. In order to issue a token, your legal counsel has to sign off on it and there's different opinions from different legal counsels.
Why they're still figuring that out, points offer them the ability to engage the market and get users, add liquidity into their systems without having to issue a token. Exactly what we were just saying. Yeah, as you were talking through that data, it's just picturing my head. You remember when Richie Torres asked Gary Gensler, if Pokemon cards were a security, right? I have the same image. I know exactly where you are. For every single asset class that we are kind of tokenizing, it's going to be the same sort of discussion. I can picture Richie Torres asking Gary Gensler our airline miles a security Gary Gensler during the next cycle as there's some conversation and Gary tries to make points like definitively a security, right?
It's like we're going to have this debate for every single thing that we want to tokenize because some regulators going to say tokenization, nope, that's mine, that's my area, that's my jurisdiction. I want to regulate that. What do you think the odds are that Gary Gensler and the SEC goes after some crypto protocol for issuing points? I think it's a lot harder to do that. I think it's much harder to do that. I think they still will. Oh, I think they very well could, right? It's just like they'll try to argue that points are just a stepping stone to these security is a gateway to that security game.
Right. Exactly, but like the further steps removed, the more and more like I think specious their arguments will become and I would love for them to kind of defend that point. I would love to see Gary Gensler try to say points or security. I would love for him to say that. Well, you're using it to speculate. Well, I mean, I could speculate on an airline miles if I want, if you shitty speculation, but I could go do that. And apparently it's not illegal to go trade in separate except in Utah in like secondaries, right? So there's a market for that. So I think that if we're talking about this from a crypto founder perspective and you're a crypto project, ask Americans, like there's been enough air drops that it's just like you can't receive them because you're located in the US, right?
So like sorry, you don't get the air drop. American listeners, would you rather have points or nothing? Because that's kind of like where we are right now and I think the answer for most crypto users is, okay, give me points. That feels good. Now hopefully it's kind of like, there's some social commitment there and hopefully these projects honor that in some way. Like there is a big bet that these points will become valuable over time as proxies for tokens or as some sort of like for some sort of utility inside of the ecosystem itself, that's not guaranteed. And so we might get it and we are going to get ahead of our skis on this.
There will be some progn. Major disappointments I think in the points landscape because points don't have all of the guarantees that tokens do, do they David? In fact, they have zero guarantees. They have zero investor protections. Tokens already have pretty poor investor protections and points have absolutely zero. But this is go back to what we were saying at the beginning, points are a right to issue a token but not an obligation to issue a token by the point issuing teams, not by users. So users are going to be subject to the choice of a point issuer about whether they want to elect to have that right exercised to issue a token off the backs of points.
And this is a shift in power towards development teams. It's a choice that they have and it's protection for them, which I think is good. Like let's protect developers over, like if we have to choose between these two parties, let's protect developers over users because the developers are the ones building the things in the first place that the users are using. And so they need to be legally protected the most because they're the people building this whole thing. What do you think about that? I, you're like, let me give my take. I think like you could say it's good but like I would more frame it as kind of a trade off because there's good parts about it and there's bad parts about it.
I mean, if I'm talking about kind of the bad parts, I put out this kind of long tweet that basically said what's happening is the SEC in Congress through inaction are basically boiling the actual utility out of tokens and they're leaving all of the speculation. This is a point that Chris Dixon made on our episode earlier this week, David. He's just like, here's what's so assinine about our current regulatory environment in the US is like they are making it such that all we get is useless futility tokens, right? Useless governance tokens. All we get are meme tokens. Like all we get as investors inside of this ecosystem of crypto projects are like points, right?
What we actually want are tokens that have some sort of governance guarantee that have some right to transfer to tokens. Tokens that look a bit more like equities, they have cash flows that you can realize on chain and the insidious trap here, like the bear case for this for points is basically they are trying to wall off all of our tokens and make them like shitty. And then they go and they go and they complain about the crypto casino, right? And they're like, it's just speculation, it's just a casino. And we're looking at, it's like, yeah, you've forced us into not being able to do cash flows on chain, no governance votes.
And you've forced us into like points and memes, right? So that's all speculation and you're boiling the actual utility out of this asset class. So in some ways, I'm a little bit sad that we're at the points stage. At least that's one way of looking at it. Like they're just putting up unnecessary speed bumps and you're right, we have less investor protections in a points paradigm versus a token paradigm. We have no governance rights, no right to kind of participate. So I worry about that, right? I worry about, it's back to the same old story. It's only a credit investors get asset to get access to the true investor protections.
You got to be rich in order to get actual tokens. And that's not right. Yeah, that's not ideal. And there are going to be examples of projects that like leverage that in the worst possible ways. But then also at the same time, like there are going to be some projects that all people who are all users who are farming points and capturing points are putting trust into the protocols that they're farming the points of in some particular way. Like they're giving up their opportunity costs of their ether or their stables or their whatever into that one particular defi app because they want those points.
And the points again is a right but not an obligation to issue a token and also issue a token in a fair way that the users feel that they are relatively fairly compensated for for their opportunity costs. And that will be just completely up to the development team. And so like user rights are like totally foregone and some of the better development teams will respect the trust that they've been given by point farmers and others will actually be leveraging it. Some people probably have spun up a points program just really nilly without actually thinking about like the long-term consequences of that without perhaps even thinking about issuing a token on the backs of that because they want the activity they want the users.
Perhaps it was do or die for them, they needed that. And so there's a little bit of a tragedy of the comments here but that actually doesn't actually stop good strong high integrity teams from actually falling through unlike the soft commitment of issuing a token fairly based off of points. No, I get that. My only worry is what if regulators prevent them from making a step like another way to put this for me is like retail deserves tokens not just points. So I like points but only in so far as they are stepping stone to something more powerful for retail, which is tokens. And I think in the final form, a perfect like DeFi protocol for me has a token that provides a guarantee to on-chain cash flows.
And that is kind of like the equity side of this. They might also have points that are just like in-app usage, kind of like the airline mile equivalents like you have two asset classes. One that are just like points, they're just for users, they're not somebody who's seriously investing the protocol. And then you might, you would also have these investable assets, which are like on-chain tokens. And that is what I hope is the final form. I just worry that regulators are going to kind of put some roadblock in. Like I worry that we won't go the blur route. If we get stuck on just points and we don't get the tokens, then to me that is a failure.
At least it's speed bump for us. Yeah, definitely, I definitely see that. It's also I think worth noting that there's been this conversation in the crypto space for as long as I've been in this crypto space, 2017. We're using the words regulatory sandbox. And that just means that like, hey, let's give founders and developers, company leaders, CEOs, a sort of trial period, some sort of like sandbox, where they can experiment and tinker with their tokens before they have to answer to some sort of like regulation about that token. So I think it was some proposals, no actual proposal has actually made it through Congress, but like proposals have advocated for like somewhere between like two and four years of this like regulatory sandbox, where if you are constraining your behaviors in a particular way, and you're not being like chili or scammy or like fraudulent, then you can issue a token and it won't be subject to SEC regulations.
And then at the end of four years, it will be. And it's all this like trial period of just like can you, you have four years basically to decentralize. And I think this is what the point system is really doing for teams, is they're allowing to build up users. And building up users is extremely necessary to actually getting to the point of decentralization, because if you don't have a point system, but then you issue your token and you only issue your token to like your seven users, well, then you're not decentralized. And so it's allowing apps to build up a foundation to actually get to the point of decentralization, which will be the issuance of a real token.
And hopefully that issuance of a real token comes at a time in which the team has built up enough of a foundation of community ownership, community participation, like hardness of the protocol, that the whole system is ready for a token, ready to decentralize the system. And I think points are just like the answer to the lack of a regulatory sandbox that we've been asking for for like eight years in crypto now. I think the sandbox works in other ways to David in that allows other value accrual experimentation, right? And so the one path, and I think this is probably the right path for a lot of protocols, is that points become tokens at some point in time.
Like there's some sort of transition. But you could also just stay on points and you could offer kind of in-economy value propositions, right? Again, American Airlines, where they give book hotels, like inside of the American Airlines economy, you get flight access and you get kind of like the first class seating and that sort of thing. And I think that is another value accrual mechanism maybe for these points, too, would you agree? Yeah, so once you issue a token, you can't go back. That is a one-way street. And I think some developers, some leaders CEOs of companies are going to fall in love with the flexibility that points give them, the protections that points give them, the control that points give them, over the app that they're building, the value that they're creating.
But they're still going to want some of the perks of tokens to be expressed in their app. And so I think one thing that could potentially happen is that some certain apps, some categories of apps decide that the points meta is their long-term home. And they only issue points, but their points actually like do things. Like they unlock doors inside of that application. Maybe they unlock like value flows, like explicit value flows because somebody wants to push up against the limits of these things. I don't know. But I think there's a very strong case where points stay as points and users are actually content with that choice based on the context and the nature of the application question.
Yeah, I agree, too. In fact, I don't know if you're familiar with warps on Farcaster. They seem to be kind of like a points inside of the Farcaster economy. And you could start to do things. You can mint things using warps. And I've been collecting some warps just by doing what the protocol wants me to do, which is show my referral link, right? Like you sign up and then I get some warps if somebody has used my referral. So I think there's that possibility, too. But let's close this out. So final take, David, points. Are they a net good for crypto? Are they a net bad? Where do you fall on this?
I see points as the next evolution of the arms race between token issuers and air drop farmers that significantly shifts the balance of power away from air drop farmers into token issuers. Because it is complete central banker control over their token, because it's not a token, it's a point. And I think that's a good thing. I think the balance of power ought to be with the party of the people that are developing the applications, creating the value. Will we see an inevitable re-swing of the pendulum back to the point collectors? Maybe, maybe. But I think it's here for at least this cycle. The next two years or so.
And one of the other unique things about points, Ryan, is previously, if you wanted to speculate on apps, you would have to sell your eth and then buy a token by the apps token. And now with points, you actually just take your eth and you deposit it into a different app. So it's actually a completely new meta. You actually aren't selling your ether. You're not taking a taxable event. You're just transferring your ether from one app for those points and going over to a different app for those points. So I actually really like that when I tell my friends, like, hey, here's what I'm doing, I'm not telling them to sell something and buy something else.
I am actually telling them just to go transfer your ether and earn different points. So I kind of like that. And I think you just have no idea how valuable the points will be. That's the, I think the mystery box. We're speculating on our opportunity costs, not on our principle, which is I think a much better, more healthy place to be. And lastly, I kind of think that the potential for innovation and experimentation with points, I think we're at the very beginning. I think we're going to see a lot of innovation around points, especially over 2024. So as the points meta really heats up, I think crypto people should probably be prepared to look really cringe to the outside world because we were once crypto people and now we're points people.
And these are not the same thing. But I think that might just be the thing that defines 2024. So overall, I'm a fan of points. I like points. I think I agree. I mean, caveats aside and some of the objections that we talked about this episode, I do think points are a net good for crypto. And the big reason why for me is because it's just like the way I've seen crypto inevitability is it's just like kind of a river, you know, like water, finding its way to the ocean. And there's a tree in the way. And so what does crypto do? It kind of carts a path and routes around that tree. It follows the path of least resistance.
Well, we've got a tree here and his name is Gary Gensler and kind of the SEC, right? And so like what do we do? Well, this is crypto's way of kind of routing around that and leading to the inevitable future, which is it's going to make it to the ocean, right? So whether it's good or bad, I don't know, but it is us routing around some of the objections and some of the issues that we have and finding a clean path to value a cruel here and to propagating crypto. So from my perspective, that is a net good thing. And I cannot wait for the upcoming defense by Gary Gensler of why all points he's seen are securities, right?
Why are you not sure that's coming? Skeptical about points. A good luck with that argument. So that's going to be entertaining. David, we should end with this meme here. What are we looking at? We are looking at, this is a meme from D's that came in my replies when I made a tweet about points. I asked like, what's your favorite points that are out there? And he goes so hot right now. Apparently D's is a Chick-fil-A Red member. Because he has 9,282 points. I think the other meme could have been just like, corporate wants to find you the differences between these two pictures and one is like crypto points and one is like Chick-fil-A points and then they're like, these are the same things.
I hope that gets these a sandwich or at least something for those 9,000 points Chick-fil-A. Guys, gotta let you know of course, crypto is risky. So is the journey with points? I don't know if it's risky or not. Are our points risky? I definitely don't know what you're getting. I'll say that, but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone. But we're glad you're with us on the bank with Journey. Thanks a lot. Mantle, formerly known as BitDow, is the first Dow-led Web3 ecosystem all built on top of Mantle's first core product, the Mantle Network. A brand new high-performance Ethereum layer to built using the OP stack.
But uses EigenLayer's data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one. Not only does this reduce Mantle Network's gas fees by 80%, but it also reduces gas fee volatility, providing a more stable foundation for Mantle's applications. The Mantle Treasury is one of the biggest Dow-owned treasuries, which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web3 space for Mantle. Mantle already has subcommunities from around Web3 onboarded, like Game 7 for Web3 gaming and Bybit for TVL and liquidity and on-rats. So if you want to build on the Mantle Network, Mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone-based funding to promising projects that help expand, secure and decentralize Mantle.
If you want to get started working with the first Dow-led Layer 2 ecosystem, check out Mantle at Mantle.xyz and follow them on Twitter at 0xMantle. Cello is the mobile first EVM compatible, carbon negative blockchain built for the real world. And now something big is happening. Introducing the Cello Layer 2. It's a game-changing proposal that's going to bring Cello's rapidly growing ecosystem home to Ethereum. Vitalik has shared his excitement for the Cello Layer 2 on the Cello Forum, so has Ben Jones from Optimism. But why? The Cello Layer 2 will bring huge advantages, like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, and one block finality.
Which is all that mean, rock solid security, a trustless bridge to Ethereum, and more real world use cases for Ethereum without compromise. And real world adoption is happening. Active addresses on Cello have grown over 500% in the last six months. With the Cello Layer 2, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas using ERC20 tokens. But Cello is a community governed protocol. This means that Cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard. Join the conversation in the Cello Forum. Follow at Celloorg on Twitter and visit sellow.org to shape the future of Ethereum.