“The U.S. is trying to disconnect from Ethereum," that’s what Joe Lubin the CEO of Consensys said in today’s conversation. He was talking about those in power trying to unplug Ethereum from the citizens.
The SEC is going after Kraken, Coinbase, Uniswap and Metamask. They’re trying to turn every non-custodial wallet into a broker-dealer.
We brought on Joe Lubin, a crypto OG and CEO of Consensys the company behind a number of massive crypto projects including the popular Metamask wallet, and Matt Corva, the General Counsel at Consensys, leading the charge against the SEC
Joe and Matt are producing evidence that the SEC is coming after Ethereum itself. Sending discovery requests to Ethereum core developers, threatening their employers - pushing a coordinated effort to claim Ether is a security so they can control it.
So Consensys is taking them to court to settle the issue. If they’re successful it’ll be the first time we get a clear court ruling that Ether is a commodity and not a security.
------ 📣 TRANSPORTER - SECURED BY CHAINLINK CCIP | TRY IT OUT transporter.io
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
🌐 CARTESI | APPLY FOR A GRANT https://bankless.cc/CartesiGovernance
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🏠 CASA | SECURE YOUR GENERATIONAL WEALTH https://bankless.cc/Casa
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🏙️ CONSENSUS | SAVE 20% WITH CODE BANKLESS https://bankless.cc/4aykesD
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 6:35 SEC vs. Ethereum 9:45 The Uniqueness of This Case 11:15 88,000 Pages to the SEC 12:11 SEC Going After Devs? 14:47 The Wells Notice 16:27 ETH ETF 17:58 Outcome of Consensys Winning 21:29 U.S. Law Process & Timeline 25:55 Ether Isn’t a Security 34:50 Gary’s Confidence Conspiracy 41:17 MetaMask Isn’t a Broker Dealer 47:10 What is Prometheum? 51:10 How Can the SEC Win? What Happens to Crypto? 55:49 What the Crypto Community Can Do 59:50 What Happens Next? 1:03:15 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Consensys Complaint https://consensys.io/crypto-regulations/defend-ethereum https://assets.ctfassets.net/gjyjx7gst9lo/Bu1bK7DF3tSig9Atde0lM/2fcaadea2b111a8c3f3ebce4a6a2386c/Consensys_sues_the_SEC_in_defense_of_the_Ethereum_ecosystem.pdf
Joe Lubin https://twitter.com/ethereumjoseph
Matt Corva https://twitter.com/MattCorva
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
This regulatory scrutiny is great because it gives us an opportunity to share how powerful and wonderful the technology is and can be and it gives us a platform effectively. To speak with politicians and regulators, help them understand that it's not just this action, we need many, many actions to reform the laws in the United States and on the planet so that the world can embrace this technology. And so if we want it, we're all going to have to fight for it. The US is trying to disconnect from Ethereum. That's what Joe Lubin, the CEO of Consensus, said in our conversation today. And he was talking about those in power, trying to unplug Ethereum from the citizens, from we the people.
And I got to say, the evidence for that increasingly seems to back up that statement. DCC is going after Kraken, Coinbase, Uniswap, Metamask, we've done episodes on many of these. They're essentially trying to turn every non-custodial wallet into a broker dealer. You already know some of that story, but here's what's new. Joe and Matt are producing evidence that the SEC is coming after Ethereum itself. The SEC is sending discovery requests to Ethereum core developers threatening their employers. They're pushing a coordinated effort to claim Ether is a security so that they can control it. But this time we're going on the offensive.
Consensus is taking them to court to settle this issue once and for all. And if they're successful, it'll be the first time in a US court we get a clear ruling that Ether is not a security, it's a commodity. Before we get into the conversation with Joe and Matt, a message from my friends and sponsors over at Transporter. Transporter is a bridging app powered by Chainlink's CCIP in the background with some of the most intuitive UX in crypto. So if you want to try out the new bridging app transporter, try it out at transporter.io. You can bridge ETH, link, USCC, and other assets. There's a link in the channels to getting started with Transporter today.
Both Matt and Joe are interesting characters that we had on the episode today. And for bank listeners that aren't from as familiar with Joe Lubin, he is the founder and CEO of Consensus. He has been building critical software that Ethereum has really needed in order to actually be a usable system. Many of the products that have been built out of Consensus have made Ethereum usable. Metamass being the big one in Fira, but many other projects as well. Getcoin was incubated out of Consensus. And Joe, I think for people who aren't familiar with him, I appreciate Joe because he thinks in cosmic scales.
He thinks he's a very big thinker. He's like he understands the way of the universe, the way of the world, very like Ray Dalio, Esk in the way that things move forward across time. And then we also have Matt, the legal counsel of Consensus who is a lawyer, very grounded, very pragmatic. But each of these two guests take turns putting on the conspiracy hat a little bit, which I thoroughly enjoyed. So these are the two guests on the show today. And they each bring their perspectives to the show, which I thought we've done these shows before, like SEC suing company, company suing the SEC, but this is different.
It's different when it's Joe and it's different when it's Consensus. Yeah. And what I appreciate about them, both of them, is they came here on this episode and they're here to fight. They're here to push back. They're here for the resistance. So guys, we're going to get right to that conversation. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made this episode possible, including our number one recommended crypto exchange, a place to join the resistance. That is Kraken. Go create an account. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams, then head over to Kraken.
One of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos. With products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT Marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together, it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience.
So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro. Go to Kraken.com slash banklists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. Have you ever felt that the tools for developing decentralized applications are too restrictive and fail to leverage advancements from traditional software programming? There's a wide range of expressive building blocks beyond conventional smart contracts and solidity development. Don't waste your time building the basics from scratch and don't limit the potential of your vision.
Kartezi provides powerful and scalable solutions for developers that supercharge app development. With a Kartezi virtual machine, you can run a full Linux OS and access decades of rich code libraries and open source tooling for building in Web3. And with Kartezi's unique roll-up framework, you'll get real world scaling and computation. No more competing for block space. So if you're a developer looking to push the boundaries of what's possible in Web3, Kartezi is now offering up to $50,000 in grants. Head over to Kartezi's grant application page to apply today. And if you're not a developer, those with staked CTSI can take part in the governance process and vote on whether or not a proposal should be funded.
Make sure your vote ready by staking your CTSI before the vote is open. Taking self-custody of your crypto is one of the most important things you can do on your banklists journey. It's also one of the hardest things to get right with huge consequences if you don't. If you want help going banklists, talk to Kartezi. Kartezi helps you take custody of your crypto assets so you don't have to wonder whether you're doing it right. Kartezi is a one-stop shop for doing self-custody the right way. With Kartezi vaults, you can hold ether, bitcoin, stablecoins, all with one simple app and multiple keys for the ultimate piece of mind with a support team to help you every step of the way.
But it doesn't stop at self-custody because even though crypto is forever, you are not. We all plan on making life-changing wealth in crypto, but with Kartezi's inheritance product, life-changing wealth can elevate to generational wealth. For your kids and your loved ones who don't know anything about crypto. With Kartezi, you won't lose your private keys and you won't accidentally take them to the grave either. Click the link in the description to get started securing your generational wealth. Bankless Nation, we have Joe Lubin. He is a crypto OG. He's the CEO of Consensus. He's been on the podcast a number of times.
Consensus is the company behind a massive number of crypto projects, including many we know and love such as the popular Metamask Wallet Joe. Welcome, Bankless. Thanks, Ryan. Thanks, David. Matt Corva is here for the first time. He's the general council at Consensus. He is leading the charge in this case against the SEC. Matt, welcome to Bankless. Thanks, David and Brian. All right, guys. Give us a rundown. What is going on at this point in time? The high level, it sounds like the SEC is maybe coming after Metamask, coming after Ethereum in general, and you guys are taking them to court instead.
That's the high level TLDR. Can you tell us what's really going on? First, you, Joe. So at a high level, we feel that the Ethereum ecosystem is under threat, that the United States effectively is trying to disconnect America from Ethereum. We've been tracking this issue for quite a while, and we believe that the stakes are now clear and much higher than more existential than we previously believed. And it seems that the SEC is intent on using surgical enforcement actions, granular enforcement actions, to try to cast Ether, recast Ether as a security, even though it's been very clear for quite a while, based on statements made by SEC officials and CFTC officials in the way our ecosystem in the world has been operating, but Ether has been classified as quality for a long time.
And worse than that, we're seeing, and Matt can flush this out a little bit, we're seeing scrutiny of the technology, we're seeing scrutiny of actions that software developers are taking and building out the protocol. And that's either a merit based evaluation that the SEC is engaged in. And I think, I think Chair Gensler was on video a short while ago, saying something like the technology is too volatile, too volatile or unstable or something like that. And essentially by classifying Metamask as a broker dealer, which they've indicated that that they're moving towards, it makes the entire industry without, without even making it clear that Ether is a security, it makes the whole platform unusable, because again, by gaslighting, by refusing to utter that if there's a security, they're effectively treating it behind the scenes as a security and they're going after us and many others.
And if Metamask is a broker dealer in the eyes of regulators, then pretty much all software on the Ethereum platform, which engages with the Ether token, swapping, doing other things with it might have to go in and register with the SEC. And that's obviously going to chill all software development in the US and usage. Matt, this isn't the first case that we've seen either with the SEC versus crypto or crypto versus the SEC. But I think there's also just some new elements here. What about consensus's case first, the SEC really stands out. What's the unique properties about this particular case?
Yeah. So our case is really about three things. So the headline thing is Metamask, right? That's sort of what Joe had talked about as well. It's the subject of our wells known as Metamask, while at the swapping feature and the staking feature. The real differentiator, we think in our case is that some other actions which have been about challenging agency rules or about specific company operations is Ethereum itself. Ethereum itself is under attack. As Joe said, the narrative we sort of like to talk about internally is we think they're seeking to unplug Ethereum and we think that's just wrong.
They have sort of deputized themselves, sort of the police of open-source technology in a way that we think is outside of their agency authority. So we've gone in front of a court in the Fifth Circuit of Texas to say, look, Judge, they are wrong here. Ethereum's a commodity. Everybody knows it's a commodity. The SEC has said it's a commodity. The CFTC has said it's a commodity. The facts show it's a commodity. They are outside the scope of their authority. On Ethereum, our complaint details that they have sought testimony from our developers and our professionals and document production over 88,000 pages that we've produced to them over the past few years.
Can we catch that? So you have produced 88,000 pages to the SEC. What is that? Is that sort of discovery? Have they asked for? Yeah, exactly. It's that document production and I think perhaps most alarmingly, a lot of that document production is contributions to GitHub. Show me your work on GitHub and contributions to Ethereum or protocols or clients or things like that. It's not just us and that's sort of what led us to take action in a lot of ways. We think, believe this action against us is imminent, but we've heard this throughout the ecosystem. It's been reported on that they've sent similar letters to the Ethereum Foundation and individual open-source developers.
For me, that was a bridge too far in what we'd be willing to passively tolerate while they went through their process. That's why I thought we had to stand up as a leader in the space protected developers who contribute open-source code. Matt, I really want people to hear that because this was actually, I skimmed the complaint. It's 36 pages. We'll include a link in the show notes. This is the complaint for injunctive relief. I might be getting the legal terms wrong, Matt, but it's your case against the SEC basically. What was most startling to me as I skimmed through this is, of those 88,000 pages, the SEC is asking for a list of contributors from consensus, from other organizations that have contributed to EIP.
That is, Ethereum improvement proposals that went into the eth 2.0 merge. You can see them trying to make a case that this isn't decentralized open-source software with a permissionless open group of contributors, but it's somehow, I don't know, some cabal, some centralized group that's actually running the show. The level of detail that they're going to hear, it does seem like they are going after directly open-source developers in a way. That to me was incredibly startling and shows the breadth of this. It's far beyond just the Metamask wallet. It's actually looking at Ethereum from an open-source developer perspective and who's contributing and what codes go into EIPs.
That was incredibly alarming to me. It's almost like the SEC believes they have a mandate to regulate technology. It's almost like they have a mandate to assess technology on its merits. This action is related to what they've told us they're going to sue us for, but it goes further. It focuses on getting clarity from the courts regarding how the US should classify ether. That's something that we would not get if we sat on our heels and let the SEC sue us. Chair Gensler has been really careful not to contradict what has been said before because that would be ridiculous, but instead to sort of gaslight our industry and act as though a reclassification has been done without actually doing that.
There is a theory that we can get into that this is related to the shift to a proof of stake, but it's a full theory. Zooming out and identifying the pattern that I'm seeing here, first part of the details of this case we've mentioned in passing, but just to make it explicit is that the SEC sent consensus a Wells notice saying, hey, we intend to sue and consensus is just replying to that with, we're going to sue you guys first because we think we have a stronger case. That's how I'm reading this. Matt, do you want to clarify something? I wouldn't say that's accurate. This is an action we've thought about taking for a long time.
We've been thinking about this for a while. They just so happen to send the Wells notice in the process. The Wells notice was informative of the fact that we don't think we're dealing with a reasonable party who has allegiance to the law. You guys also saw the Coinbase wallet decision regarding their swapping features. To get a Wells notice alleging that Metamass swaps, which was the leader in the space and was doing that thing first. The Coinbase wallet facts are very similar is violating the same laws. A judge just said did not apply to the wallet. That was perhaps another triggering factor in our decision to file, but we've thought their action was imminent for a while against us prior to the Wells notice.
This is something we've been preparing for and has been well thought out. One thing we didn't want to do is harm the prospects of the approval of the ether spot ETF. While we could have started this action a while ago, we wanted to sit back and read the two leaves and make sure that if the SEC was going to open that floodgate because it would probably change everything that we did not get in the way of that. Are you saying by filing this complaint, you're thinking that the ETF approval, like the SEC is just not going to approve an Ethereum ETF and that kind of factored into. We thought it was over based on various communications that we have with people in the industry that they weren't going to approve in 2024.
The inverse is probably true Ryan. We thought that we would need to bring the Ethereum action if the SEC was going to approve the Ethereum ETF because that's your best evidence to say, look, Ethereum is obviously not a security. This is just another instance of the SEC saying it's not in approving the ETFs, which would be a commodity-based ETF product. That was really what we were thinking about in relation to the ETF. You're just waiting for them to do the right thing and hoping that they would. They did. That is a very good description. If they did the right thing, as I said, it would open the floodgates similar to how the Bitcoin Spot ETF affected our industry quite positively.
We would see the rush of lots of capital into an attention on our space. That would be a game changer, I think, for the Ethereum ecosystem. It would be something that would be likely to grow the ecosystem bigger and faster than it's grown before. Effectively, there'd be no gaslighting at that point. It's been pretty clear from the actions that we're observing of the SEC that they just don't want that to happen. There's two elements to this case that I'm seeing. There's the narrow things that the SEC is accusing consensus of. Metamask is a broker-dealer. It's something that they are accusing or believing that that is the case.
Metamask disagrees. Most people disagree. There's evidence to say that that's disagrees. That's the narrow case between consensus versus SEC. You guys are also just zooming out and seeing the pattern of the SEC as a whole, including the information that they are not disclosing the cards that they are keeping close to their chest, which is the pattern, which is that Joe, I think you said it very well. The SEC is trying to unplug the United States from Ethereum. That is not something that they have said that they are doing. It's not something that they are articulating that they're doing, but with all of the evidence of the other court cases and the behavior of the SEC, I think this is something that you guys have believed that you guys have enough evidence for to present in court case.
This is actually the bigger battle. It seems to be consensus believes, and Matt, check me if I'm wrong, that there's enough evidence out there to show that the SEC has some unspoken mandate to unplug the United States from Ethereum and that we can actually push this as an issue into court and get a judge to actually agree with your guys' position. If that is the case that you guys do prove this, what's the outcome of that, Matt? How does that improve things? Our case doesn't really rely on the overall narrative, because we can just look at the isolated facts regarding their involvement in Ethereum.
We can look at their multi-year investigation following the Hinman speech about Ether following the CFTC position about Ether following the fact that it's been around for so long. Why don't you just say, this is the point some congressman have said in the past few days after learning about this. If you've changed your position on Ether, why don't you just communicate that to the market? Why are you doing this in secret? This is a $400 billion asset class. This is no way to conduct business in the United States, but our case doesn't rely on the overall narrative. We'll take the position and we believe the court will agree with us that it's appropriate for the court to declare that Ether is a commodity, and therefore all SEC investigations into the asset, Ether, and as a result, things like their investigation into who contributes to the open source code would be outside agency authority, because they don't have authority to regulate assets that are not securities.
We think that will be very impactful and similar to the judge-failure opinion regarding Coinbase wallet, explaining that broker dealers' laws do not apply to software interfaces that do the types of things that Metamask does and most popular DeFi apps do. Getting another judge on the record, looking at that issue and saying, yes, I agree with what Judge Faila said. This is correct. We'll be another line of defense for the industry to the extent the SEC continues to try and file these cases that are outside the scope of law. We think it will obviously be helpful for us, but we'll help set precedent for a lot of other companies in our industry.
Matt, the outcome of winning the case is you would get a judge to say, get a court to say, Ether is not a security, it's instead a commodity, and non-custodial wallets, like Metamask, aren't broker dealers. That's the outcome you're trying to argue for. Yeah, that's correct. If that is achieved in a court case, how does US law work? Is it done then? Are we finished or does this get escalated? Can the SEC somehow appeal? How long does this process possibly take? Parties can always appeal, and we can always hope that it will be finished in the sense of, just like we said, when we saw the Faila opinion about Coinbase Wallet feature, we said, hey, they've been investigating us about the very same thing that they just lost on.
It's done. Obviously, they didn't think it was done. Judicial interpretation and precedent relative to agency action. I think if you are an agency and you have adherence to due process and you're acting in good faith, you're going to look at those decisions and say, hang on, let us take a step back from our regulation by enforcement approach. Maybe this isn't working. We're not getting the results we want. We need to either do rulemaking, notice and comment rule making, good agency practice, or what probably needs to happen is discussed in our complaint. We need to go to Congress and say, Congress, we don't have the authority to sort this out.
The courts have said we don't have the authority. We think there needs to be some regulation, and let me be very clear, consensus is not anti-regulation. We think there's lots of room for good regulation to help improve the crypto space. That's for Congress to sort out at this point, not for one agency to declare itself police of the open source internet and regulate the entire stack. How does the process unfold? We hopefully win in Texas. That will be a win in the wind column for the crypto industry. To get to the higher courts in the US, you need something most often called a split circuit on issues.
The court in Texas resides in what's called the fifth circuit. The court in New York resides in what's called the second circuit. To the extent the second circuit and fifth circuit disagree on issues of law. That is how you get to higher courts in the United States most quickly, most often. You can deal with the court of appeals and potentially ultimately get an issue up to the Supreme Court if it's big enough. For example, how these applications to crypto is how the right right test is how even the right law should exist. People have sort of been theorizing, how does that happen with crypto?
It's a Supreme Court. It's a many year process and we're hopeful that people will see reason before dragging it out all the way that far. What does that mean? Let's a many year process to get all the way to the Supreme Court if the SEC sort of digs its heels in. What's a what's a happier scenario? You win this case and maybe the SEC just backs off. It could that happen? That could happen. It could certainly change their approach. Look, I think everybody has been pretty sober about the fact that this has been the approach from this SEC and this sort of chairs agenda regarding the crypto industry.
As Joe said, he said lots of negative things about the crypto industry after being a professor teaching about it for a while. I guess perhaps somewhat ironically. That's in the complaint, by the way. There are clips. If you haven't seen this bank listeners, there are clips from Gary Gensler, MIT professor Gary Gensler, acknowledging. You can go watch the video, acknowledging that ether is not a security. Theorem is not a security as well as like Litecoin. I think he lists Bitcoin cash. You said go watch the clips. This is from recent history as well. Matt, was it like 2018 or something like this?
It was sometime around that era when he was a professor at MIT and these things just sort of point out like why we had to take this action for a while. We felt like we were living in a bit of like a loony tunes type scenario. You're going to flip flop. You're going to flip flop this way. What's going on? Court says this. Now you're going to say the opposite thing. We've seen alarming things like the debt box case where some SEC professionals were sanctioned. It was all too much for us and that was sort of that paired with the imminent of their attack on us. It was led us here to try and get the clarity.
I used the phrase to borrow a phrase from Chair Gensler, cop on the beat. Chair Gensler, that's one of his phrases regarding crypto, that it needs a cop on the beat and he's there to be the cop on the beat. We view ourselves as the cop on the beat now in this scenario, the cop on the beat to regulate agency overreach and to help clean this up and try and bring a resolution. Matt, let's do a scenario here. Imagine you're making the case in a courtroom. You've got two arguments to make. Again, I'm sure your case would be much longer. We're looking for a faster bullet point abbreviated version. You're making the case that Ether is not a security.
Then you're also trying to make the case that non-custodial wallets like Metamask aren't broker dealers. Let's start with the first. Ether is not a security. What are the bullet points of that case for a courtroom to hear? The Ethereum protocol on the Ether asset, which is needed to use the protocol, is just an open source piece of technology. It is decentralized. Officially decentralized as Bill Hinman said, no party exerts control over the protocol. Development is done in public to the extent you think that development could impact asset prices. That's no different than other large commodity industries, gold, diamonds, etc.
We think they're great similarities between oil as probably the best example as a consumptive commodity that people invest in, but also use in daily life. Ethereum is just another version of that on a very important iteration of open source internet protocols. That's the core legal argument, but I think it's even easier than that. It's not a security because the CFTC has already done the homework to say it's a commodity. The SEC has already done the homework to say it's a commodity. One chair sort of post-hoc review of that process and his attempt to rewrite history will fail because for the factual reasons, it's not a security, but also because lots of people have done their homework and reached the same conclusion.
Here's what I don't understand. We have ETF futures for either the asset that have been CFTC blessed and the CFTC governs over commodities. Is that evidence that just says basically this is already recognized? Ethereum is already recognized as a commodity? That's certainly evidence, but there's even better evidence than that Ryan that's talked about in our complaint in October of 2023. Just last fall, the SEC accelerated the effectiveness of Ethereum futures ETF product. That was a big thing. That was the sort of, again, it didn't just go effective. The SEC accelerated the effectiveness. That's them taking in a firm bit of step to again list a futures based Ethereum futures based ETF product.
They can't do that if they don't view it as not as a security, if they view it as a commodity. They have a standard and hopefully they'll get it right in this sort of brief. To do that accelerated approval, they have to take in the public interest and investor protection. That's the legal standard they're held to. In October and doing that, they're saying, hey, we're going to approve this and we're taking in public interest and investor protection and doing this. Now a few months later, they're going to say the asset that they just said was fit for approval as a commodity based futures ETF product is actually an unregistered security.
Please make it make sense. That's why we're taking this action. You have the history of CFTC and even the SEC all along the way telling you it's a commodity. It is very confusing. It feels like a reasonable judge would just look at this and just be like, this is so odd. Why are they about facing here? Why are they hitting the hand breaks here? Joe, do you have anything to add to that first case? Let me get Matt to comment on the non-custodial wallet like part of the argument, but on the just ethers, not a security case. The broader context is that our ecosystem is likely perceived as a threat by factions within the US and other parts of the world to how they have been doing business for millennia.
Certainly, big banks in the US don't love the idea of dissentral mediation and decentralization. We've had millennia of authorities governing the world and the US is top dog right now through intermediaries. The decentralized protocol industry comes along and says, dissentral mediate all the things. We can build better systems and reduce the need for trusted third parties. There is a concerted effort. It appears in the United States to make sure that they can conduct business as usual. There are certainly factions that believe that decentralization is consistent with free market capitalism and Western liberal democratic philosophies and perhaps that's why we're in this quantum state where certain entities are seeing things clearly.
The court's judicial system, the CFTC has been seeing things clearly. The previous SEC administration saw things reasonably clearly. The current ruling party seems to want to preserve their ability to run the world through different kinds of intermediaries, financial intermediaries in particular. It does appear that the major banks in our industry who've worked really hard to get their hands on levers of control would prefer to continue winning in that context rather than playing a little more fairly in a more decentralized context. The mantle treasury is one of the biggest Dow owned treasuries which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the webfree space for mantle.
mantle already has subcommunities from around webfree onboarded like game 7 for webfree gaming and buy bit for tvl and liquidity in on-rounds. So if you want to build on the mantle network, mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone based funding to promising projects that help expand secure and decentralized mantle. If you want to get started working with the first Dow led layer 2 ecosystem, check out mantle at mantle.xyz and follow them on twitter at 0x mantle. Launching a token? Worried about the IRS? Talk to Toku for five minutes to learn how to save hundreds of thousands of dollars for you, your team and your investors.
Now if you do an initial consultation, Toku will cover the cost of your token valuation which is what you need for your launch. So don't wait, reach out to the team right now at teamattoku.com. That's teamattoku.com. Selow is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world. Driving real world use cases like mobile payments and mobile defi and with opera mini pay as one of the fastest growing webfree wallets, Selow is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.5 million monthly active addresses. And now Selow is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer 2.
Optimism, Polygon, Matterlabs and Arbitrum have all thrown their hats in the ring for the Selow layer 2 to build upon their stacks. Why the competition? The Selow layer 2 will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer, off-chain data availability, secured by Ethereum validators and one block finality. What does that all mean for you? With Selow layer 2, gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC-20 tokens, sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect. But Selow is a community governed protocol. This means that Selow needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard.
Join the conversation in the cello forums, follow Selow on Twitter and visit sellow.org to shape the future of Ethereum. Welcome to Consensus 2024. Consensus is one of the biggest hubs for all things crypto, blockchain and web3. This may, Consensus is celebrating 10 years of decentralizing the future. Going to Consensus means being in good company, with over 15,000 attendees from over 800 countries. You have the opportunity to learn directly from the architects and advocates representing Bitcoin, Ethereum, Selana, along with the teams from popular layer 2s like mantle, arbitrum, optimism, base and others.
What Consensus is more than just discussions and presentations. Badgholders get access to it and is 10 professional karate combat fights, and one unprofessional one between myself and the Carter. For the visionaries, pitchfest is your spotlight, presenting a stage for the most promising early sage web3 companies, and for the devs, the hackathon offers a unique chance to build your next project or take your existing project to the next level. Immerse yourself in hundreds of side events and hacker houses scattered around Austin. Register for Consensus 2024 today, and save 20% with code banqueless.
Joe, one of the big mysteries I've always had about the Gary Gensler in the SEC is where does he get his confidence from? Go toe to toe with some of the biggest. I say that all the time. Who's, why does he feel like he has covered to do this? Who's giving him the authority or the mandate? Between me and Ryan, I'm the one who is very willing to put on the tinfoil hat and go out there. I'll do that here. The big banks, the incumbents, rather than just looking at the narrow details, you can zoom out and see just incentive structures in the old world that doesn't want things to change. This is a pattern throughout him in history is that the people that are in power don't like change because that's disruptive to their status quo.
There could be some sort of pipeline between the incentives of those power structures into the current political party that put Gary Gensler in power in the first place. That is the perceived blank check that Gary Gensler has to do some of the things, the harassment that he's done of this new power disrupting industry. Is that where you're saying the way he has this blank check from incumbent power structures? Yep. With conspiracy caps on, one has to wonder, first of all, he's a very smart individual. His brother Robert, we understand is very smart and possibly libertarian and possibly own some crypto, I mean, possibly possibly own some crypto.
And so thanksgiving at that family's should be just fascinating. Little brother, why are you putting my bags? I would love to be invited to that. So very smart, politically, been engaged the top tiers of the financial industry at Goldman at the CFTC for a very long time. Was he smart enough to position himself to be a MIT professor, an expert of blockchain by himself or was that coordinated in some way to give him legitimacy to take the role? He's also done some research on AI and I think he's written written some things. So either way, we find ourselves in this position. And as you're aware, Elizabeth Warren has been placing people in positions of power in the current administration.
John Deaton, who is now going up against Elizabeth Warren, he referenced on I think it was Fox business a few days ago that there's an entity called the Bank Policy Institute that I don't know much about, but probably they're a banking industry think tank. So all he did was reference that and so I started paying a little attention to them on the internet. And there is a coordinated effort involving Elizabeth Warren and those banks that she used to attack quite strongly to make sure again, the banks can continue to operate businesses usual and the US government can continue to operate businesses usual.
I, you know, I'm not usually like on the tinfoil hat side at Bankless, you know, David has that territory covered for us, but I got to say just like observing sort of what's been happening with crypto, it's hard to not see this as part of a coordinated effort against crypto. It's almost as if Gary comes to Chairman of the SEC and he's sort of tapped by somebody, some group basically says, hey, what can you do to just like slow this down, right? I'll work with these other agencies and like we'll do other things to slow it down, but the SEC, like how can you gum up the works, right? You throw in the court system, like what can you do here just to buy us more time to figure out how we fully stop crypto?
I mean, if that conversation happened either explicitly or implicitly, we would see the actions essentially that Gary Gensler is taking now and it would be a rational explanation because apart from something like that, it is hard to find a rational explanation for not only the actions he's taking, but the degree of confidence that he is like taking, taking these actions with as you and David were just saying, Joe. Yeah, so slowing it down is one thing and maybe it's not even a terrible thing, so slow it down for the benefit of big financial institutions so that they can get involved or maybe slow it down because the the discontinuity that we could face if Ethereum, the platform, and Ether the token just rocket from here as a result of the floodgate of the Ether spot ETF being opened, that could be pretty jarring to a society and so maybe these kind wise souls who are running the government are just thinking about smoothing the transition to a rigorously decentralized future.
I don't think that's true. I think more likely they're trying to maintain the structure of control in the US and across the planet and try to figure out how to co-opt the technology and dumb down the technology and make it sort of either an American style decentralization where you got a register and there's significant regulation and back doors and things like that and so we it's basically a clash of civilizations at this point between those who want to maintain top-down command and control and those who believe in rigorous decentralization. 2023 and 2024 has certainly felt like that. I want to get back to Matt in the court case he was making conspiracy.
So we got to take that off because these are things that may be going on and likely are likely going on, but we can't prove them necessarily. We don't have the evidence of kind of the back room conversations necessarily. So Matt's role is to bring evidence to the courts to prove that Ether is not a security and also the second aspect that I want to get to that non-castodial wallets aren't a broker dealer. So Matt what would you say to a judge about as evidence for why or what's your case for why Metamask is not a broker dealer? So I think it's very plain and clear non-castodial wallets themselves can never be broker dealers if you think about what they just do.
They're self-hosted software that let you manage your private keys and author transactions can't be a broker dealer under any sort of conception of the law or history of broker dealer laws. More specifically even better for the industry, services that have developed around utilities like swaps or Metamask Staking, which allows you to connect the LIDO and Rocket Pool protocols. So if you want to participate in those protocols as an individual user of Metamask, you can use the Metamask Staking feature and connect with those protocols. The SEC says that mere connection to LIDO and Rocket Pool, two services they allege are offering unregistered staking products, is broker dealer activity.
And so why is this all wrong? For the reasons that you all touched on it in the conspiracy segment, which is that the world has evolved around intermediaries and the government and our history of laws regulate intermediaries and for good reason, right? Intermediaries are historically where things have gone wrong. If you think about the number of transactions that happened through Metamask and then imagine that happening through a human, what would the propensity for fraud be? It would be very high, right? Because it's not autonomous, it's not software enforced, it's not transparent, it's not audible, it's not verifiable.
You would think that you'd get screwed in those transactions. It's probably a high number of times. But software is different, it's disintermediated and all it's allowing is the technology service for user to transmit instructions to their own instructions to where they want. I want my instructions to go to Uniswap and I want to tell Uniswap, I want five USD for a corresponding amount of tokens I'm willing to sell and verify that logic is actually happening and being enforced exactly how the user said on the blockchain. And so why can these things not be broker dealers? Because the broker dealer laws regulate human intermediaries that perform human discretionary acts.
They negotiate on behalf of customers, they seek prices on behalf of customers, they custody customer assets and of course our services and similar services offered around the industry don't do that, right? They're software based, they're non-custodial, they rely on code, they are not exerting the authority that the broker dealer rules for good reason seeks to regulate because it is not needed in this context. And I think that's what Judge Phila and the Quinn-based wallet really started out. She said like, hey look, this thing doesn't, it's a very preliminary stage in the case. This is software, this isn't regulated broker dealer activity, aka human activity in some way, they're not doing broker dealer things, they're doing technology things and that's not what these laws are meant to regulate.
Matt, it's just software and also what I can't get my head wrapped around, this is just like the Lehman's conclusion. So I have let's say a hardware wallet ledger wallet and I use that with Metamask. I have custody of my property, the entire time. I'm not giving that custody to any third party intermediary. There's no kind of like broker in that entire transaction. Any more than like a vault I might have somewhere in my house is like a broker dealer. That's just a place where I store my assets and so like that part just doesn't pass the common sense person on the street test in any way. And back to Joe's comment, I want to get people to give people the sense of what it would mean if all unhosted wallets, if all non custodial wallets were labeled as as broker dealers because it would be pretty severe.
Joe earlier in the conversation said, if Metamask is a broker dealer, then all software on Ethereum has to come into the SEC and register. What's the alternative? So let's say the SEC wins and in their world, all non custodial wallets are broker dealers. Like what would that actually mean for all of the stuff that we have on top of Ethereum today? I think from a legal perspective, I'll just answer and say like it doesn't have to mean anything bad per se, but it does because we haven't done the rulemaking and we haven't done the homework. If the SEC wanted to create a framework such as those previously sort of developed by Commissioner Purse, a former guest of the podcast, then I think crypto industry favorite, people have had ideas of how do you regulate these things in ways that don't block the technology.
The problem with the SEC's approach is to say, hey, I want to classify this thing as a security or a broker dealer and then not promulgate any rules for that technology to work because again, those rules, historical rules require intermediaries, they require transfer agents and all these humans and they require things that the SEC has not provided guidance or rulemaking on, including the guidance or rulemaking to even register. You couldn't register Ethereum today even if you wanted to. You couldn't register token. It's very confusing, despite what the administration has said. You can't just come in.
It's not a form on the website. You can't just come in and talk to us and register. Many legal hours have been poured over trying to figure that out. So it's not catastrophic to the extent we develop a framework, but there's been a refusal to develop that framework and I think that's a huge problem. So if the SEC wins, apparently we could purchase ether or at least custody, maybe our ether, at an organization called Prometheum. So speaking of this, this assimilation, interesting name Prometheum rhymes with one of my favorite protocols. Can we just tee that up for a second? Because I don't know if you have any takes on this on what Prometheum is.
So it came on our radar. I was actually talking to David about, like, should we do a podcast on this weird Prometheum thing to try to explore and find out what it is? But it felt like a digestive exercise in journalism. But Prometheum, and the guy who runs it, it seems like it's this exchange that has been given SEC regulatory approval to list ether, but listed as a security. And the CEO is making the rounds basically saying, I have the only registered crypto exchange, like only in America and ether. And on my exchange, I'm calling Ethereum a security, and therefore it's a security. And look, everybody, I can get a registered exchange in the US where everyone else in crypto says it's impossible.
Aren't I a good boy? All of these things. Meanwhile, he has no liquidity. No one's using it. It's a really bizarre story. I don't know if you have any takes on what this thing actually is. Bankless folks can go find their own information about it, but do you have a take on this? But I think it might be an attempt to create an American style decentralization, a limited version of using these protocols to enable tokenization. Larry Fink likes the idea of tokenization. I hope Larry Fink and BlackRock really like the idea of radical decentralization. Matt, can you make any sense of how they could possibly have approved Prometheum?
So maybe it's my turn for the tinfoil hat. Yes. We get the lawyer. Yes. So Chair Gensler is actually brilliant in a lot of ways. In many ways, he's very smart guy. People who know him, nobody will dispute that he's extremely smart and well thought out. The Prometheum approval, which is just approval of a narrow sort of purpose broker dealer. The only one who's received such approval to deal in crypto, I think is factually correct. So many have applied, but only Prometheum has received his approval. Drop just a few days before Gary Gensler testified before Congress on the need for crypto regulation.
As a convenient way to say, hey, we don't need regulation. We've approved these things. They just have to come in and register just like my friends here at Prometheum. And he gave testimony. The CEO of Prometheum gave testimony from Congress. Exactly. And tracing it back to our complaint, this is something Congress has picked up in the past few days. Chair Gensler went before Congress to testify about the need for crypto asset regulation again in 2022. If you look at the timeline in our complaint, as we talk about the Ethereum order, sort of this order, deputizing the staff to go after sales and trades in Ethereum as a securities transaction, mere days before he appeared, before the Congress had that infamous exchange with McHenry, where he refused to answer whether Ethereum was a security.
I will leave it to you to interpret whether all of these timing things are coincidences, notably right before Paul Graywall was set to testify. Cohen basically gets hit with a lawsuit, right? So there's one instance, coincidences, several instances, maybe part of a trend, part of a plan. And so Prometheum could just be upon in this sort of, let's just try and slow things down, let's try and convince people. Here's the bizarre thing about all of this and why like I am convinced it'll, they'll never, it'll never work like they can't win. It's because no one wants to use that product. No one wants to use Prometheum.
We already have a, a centralized financial like structure in the US. And it's like it's working great. People want to use Metamass. They want to use Uniswap. They want to use the Coinbase exchange because it's like a five to 10x improvement. So like, how can they win when no one's going to use their products? They can, they can win by chilling activity. Two decades ago, the BitTorrent Protocol looked very promising. The Record Industry Association of America, the Motion Picture Association of America began sending, I guess, cease and desist letters or, or taking children and their mothers to court.
And that really put a chill on that technology. It continued at a low level for quite a while, but that was a decentralized protocol technology. And it effectively was rendered relatively harmless in the American country. But for people, don't remember this time, I remember stories of somebody's grandmother who would receive a notice from their ISP that their grandson was downloading a legal music and a scary letter comes in the mail with fines. Someone you know, Ryan? Yeah. We'll cut that from the episode. We've all had our lime water days. I mean, so that's kind of the chilling effect that they could have.
But back to, I guess, the broader conversation here, Joe, where you feel like this is maybe in the context that these cases are part of a coordinated effort to unplug the US from Ethereum. That doesn't mean Ethereum gets unplugged. It just means the US is less tapped into Ethereum. Our developers have to be shadowy super coders and go underground. Our entrepreneurs have to move offshore to different jurisdictions. But other jurisdictions will probably promote. We'll fill in the gap. We'll fill in the vacuum. Do you have any take on, let's say things go bad, they get worse. Maybe we lose these cases.
Maybe something like bad happens. What happens to Ethereum and to the crypto movement? So, so currently, let's say the US is anti-aetherium. And in relation, other nation states are a little more pro-aetherium because Ethereum decentralization levels the playing field for those nation states against the US. Yet the US has a very long arm and can influence other nation states quite significantly. And it's a long game. This isn't about the next few years. This is about perpetuating the system for as long as possible in certain people's minds. And so one could imagine, again, I said it's a clash of civilizations.
This is about whether decentralization, disintermediated systems are allowed to persist, allowed to continue to make life better, or whether they're stamped out in favor of the current system. We're in a world of so many threats, existential technological threats that are relatively inexpensive to acquire for small groups. And from that perspective, you could see that it might make sense to people who like top-down command and control because they can use very rigorous versions, very controlling versions to stamp out existential threats to humanity. The problem with that is even if they're well-intentioned, we end up moving into something that feels a little bit like a present planet or planet of effectively slaves to the system rather than building a world in which we all have much greater economic and political agency and where we can all benefit from permissionless innovation and access to financial innovation.
So Joe, I know no one listening wants to live in that dystopia. No, no prison planet. Okay, so like we are definitely not team prison planet on on bankless, but we are. But here's the insidious thing is even I was scrolling the bank list discord this morning. Someone said I'm really excited to hear about kind of the consensus versus the SEC thing, but like I got to be honest, like you guys are having one show about regulatory issues per week and it's hard for me to tune into like more than one. And I feel like this is a almost like DDoS attack against our industry. Okay, so like look at who the SEC is coming after right now.
Just just look at it. What's happened in the last few months? It's cracking, it's coin base, it's uniswap, it's metamask, right? Are these the bad guys that they should be pursuing? Are these the true crypto villains? It's absolutely bizarre, but because they attack on all angles, it feels like a DDoS attack. And what people are feeling is almost powerless to kind of respond. So people are frustrated because you know, they get geoblocked. It's like Iran, North Korea, and America can access a particular airdrop token. How bizarre is that? But they feel powerless. They don't exactly know what to do.
So you could be like, I guess, you know, you could say something like call your congressman, but like everyone knows, I mean, you call your congressman when it's supposed to do that weekly, where does that, where does that message go? That's why we get behind cases like this where it's so good to see consensus actually going on the offensive here rather than being defensive. And we can rally around that. But I think a lot of listeners want to know like, what can we do? How do we, how do we support this? How, how do we keep our attention? Is there something we can do in this case? Do you have any advice for just like the crypto native who's listening and feels very powerless, concerned, but also powerless?
So as one of our close colleagues, Pat Berduchi likes to say, this is a special moment in time when Ethereum started I and other people realized that that we were going to be causing a clash of civilizations. I'm sure Satoshi felt felt similarly. And we knew that we had to have heads down and build as much and as fast as we could because when the people who run the planet realize what's going on that they would not be able to run the planet through the levers that are currently in place and that it would likely be a much better system for the 99% they are certain to Bach. And this is great. What's happening right now?
All this regulatory scrutiny is great because it gives us an opportunity to share how powerful and wonderful the technology is and can be. And it gives us a platform effectively to speak with politicians and regulators, help them understand that it's not just this action. We need many, many actions to reform the laws in the United States and on the planet so that the world can embrace this technology. And so if we want it, we're all going to have to fight for it. This is the case that David makes to me when I'm feeling pessimistic about all of these things. He's always like on the flip side, look at who they're suing.
I'm like, look at who they're suing, David. He's like, yeah, exactly. Look at who they're suing. It's some of our best companies. It's the Avengers. They just do crack in coinbase, Uniswap and Metamask. And now you guys are taking them to the offensive. And I guess that's the optimistic take. Maybe this goes to the Supreme Court. Well, that will cause a national discussion on what it means to own your own property, your own digital property. And yeah, I guess that's the positive way of looking at all of this. Matt, as we progress into the future with this court case, maybe you can simulate what this might look like in terms of like time frames, milestones.
Is there like a default scenario that you can kind of articulate? It's going to be a multi-year process, most likely and frankly, it's largely up to the SEC as to where it goes from here. At this point, we are happy to be the plaintiff in the case. And we've stated our case and now it's up to them to respond. So in Texas, they've got a couple of options. They'll unfold. It'll be clear probably over the next 60 days or so, which approach they're going to take. They may try and dismiss the case. They may say, hey, let's just argue the case here. We want to argue it about the merits and we'll get into what you usually see.
And you've seen the ripple cases and the coinbase cases that exchange briefs. Here's why they're wrong. Here's why they're right. Here's why they're wrong. Here's why we're right. And then the judge hears the arguments and it progresses. And so we think that Texas case could play out over the next, let's call it one to two years depending on timeline and how it goes. The SEC may also continue to file their own cases around the country. They seemingly have limited resources. Somebody joked to me the only people they go after are crypto and Elon Musk these days. So they have lots of trial lawyers sitting around.
It seems like to deploy on these things and they can continue to bring their actions that they want. We'll see what Congress does. Does Congress get more active? We've heard a lot from Congress. Hey, we're going to clean this up. We're going to sort this out for you. They haven't done that yet. Congress is the quickest path to resolution. The courts are path to like a final clear picture, but they're slower. And so hopefully Congress front runs this and we don't have to be so inefficient. We can focus on building people can build confidently in this country. Joe talks about it all the time. It's a matter of national economic security, you know, U.
S. involvement in Ethereum is you guys pointed out these are all U.S. companies that are leaders in this space and they're trying to throw them out of the country and put them out of business. It doesn't make a lot of sense when you think about the big picture. And so hopefully people come around to that sooner. But if not, the court case will play out. Yeah, so I think the best we can expect is probabilistic finality as some of these cases make their way up towards the Supreme Court and with gridlock in DC as Congress fumbles and tries to understand the technology and hopefully weighs in. In the meantime, these two civilizations are proceeding in parallel.
Our civilization, the decentralized civilization is growing quite dramatically in value and in number of participants. And so if we can keep things going in the U.S. and other places, then our world can grow and hopefully grow really fast. Hopefully in 2025, the SEC is forced to approve. The Ether Spot ETFs, that'll be a game changer. And frankly, the legacy world needs to continue to operate and service the cohorts that are most comfortable in that world as more and more people spend their work and leisure time in the decentralized protocol ecosystem. So we can we can just grow our way into real finality.
The grand irony of this whole relationship with the SEC is that Matt, you talked about like the SEC's like seemingly infinite resources. Well, those come from our tax dollars ironically. And also the thing that the SEC is preventing is GDP growth inside of the United States. So it's really a double whammy bullet to the foot that we're kind of causing ourselves here because another consideration is that there's so much debt in the system that the U.S. and other nation states need to engage in financial repression, which means they need to pay off the debt of the inflated currency devalued the dollars.
And they don't want a whole bunch of us escaping to a founder, an ultra-sounder currency that they want us all to shoulder the same pain that has been caused over decades. Yeah. Well, Joe, Matt, thank you guys for coming on and illuminating some of the path for us and also going toe-to-toe with the SEC on I think some of the the biggest issues that we all know are bubbling behind the scenes. Now you guys are kind of bringing them to the forefront and making them explicit. So thank you for doing what you guys are doing. Let's do this. Let's win. Are we going to win? We're definitely going to win.
We wouldn't have done it if we didn't think we were. There we go. Beat of it. Big win. Awesome. Well, thank you guys. This has been great. You got to remind you a bankless nation. Of course, none of this has been financial advice. I guess Matt would call me to say it's not legal advice either. Crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but we are headed west. This is the frontier, not for everybody, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot.