SOL/ETH is up 300% YoY and ETH/BTC is down 50% over the last 2 years. Why is that? Why is ETH underperforming so bad?
Kyle Samani is the Managing Partner & Co-Founder at Multicoin Capital. Kyle and Multicoin have been one of the largest investors and proponents of Solana. They have been spearheading the ‘integrated blockchain’ investment theses even before the success of Solana redefined that corner of crypto.
This episode is not intended to be a debate like the Anatoly vs Justin Drake one. Ryan and David are mostly going to sit back and hear Kyle’s perspective and reasoning as to why ETH has been down so bad in this crypto cycle. Enjoy!
------ 🎬 DEBRIEF | Ryan & David Unpacking the Episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-the-kyle-samani-interview
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🦄UNISWAP | BROWSER EXTENSION https://bankless.cc/uniswap
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle 🌐 OBOL | STAKE ON DVs, SCALE ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/obol
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT https://bankless.cc/toku
------ ✨ Mint the episode on Zora ✨ https://zora.co/collect/zora:0x0c294913a7596b427add7dcbd6d7bbfc7338d53f/53
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 5:40 Ethereum in a Vacuum 10:10 ETH Vs. BTC 25:50 Broken Layer2 Interoperability 34:46 Value Capture 51:46 What Needs to Change 55:23 Decentralization 1:06:34 Solana 1:12:25 Steelmanning Ethereum 1:17:49 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Kyle Samani https://x.com/KyleSamani
Multicoin Capital https://multicoin.capital/
Paths To Tens Of Trillions Blog Post https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/paths-tens-trillions-kyle-samani/
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Kyle, let's want to give you a simulation, all of your bags magically turn into ETH. The only thing that you hold now is ETH. Let's call the nightmare, not a dream. What do you do next? Welcome to Baycliffe. We're going to explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. And today on the show, we are exploring the frontier of why the ETH price action has sucked. So bad. For at least a year. It's bad. Yeah. Just put some numbers on it. Soul ETH is up 300% year over year. ETH BTC is down 50% over the last two years, losing a half of its market cap valuation versus Bitcoin in the last two years.
And we went on a quest to answer the question, why? And so we were looking around and we were like, all right, who's the right guess to help answer this question? And a light bulb just came to one of us and turns out it's Kyle Simone to answer this question. You know, holders are in shambles when we go to Kyle to answer this question. This episode, Baycliffe station is intended to be more of a listening episode. Ryan and I are here to kind of just sit back and hear Kyle's perspective into reasoning as to why ETH is underperforming to see what there is to learn. Right now, the current valuation around the price action of Solana suggests that Kyle and the Solana investment thesis has been more correct than what earlier years of bank lists would have suggested.
And we want to discover why I said this at the end of the episode. And I think I want to say it again. I think this is probably going to be a frustrating episode for ETH bulls in several different ways. And I think that's good medicine for you. I mean, listen to the counter case. This is why we are doing this episode. I don't think it's the end of the conversation. So I think there can be future debates, maybe with Kyle, perhaps the community could set suggest someone else to enumerate Kyle's points and have a follow up episode on the counter side. So I don't think this is the end of the conversation.
Also, an investment disclaimer from multi coin that they need us to say, although our guest this week is a managing partner of a registered investment advisor, nothing in this podcast should be considered an offer of multi coins investment advisory services or should otherwise be confused for investment tax legal or financial advice. They wanted us to say that. All right, guys, let's get right to the episode with Kyle Somani. But before we do, we want to thank the sponsors that made it possible, including our recommended exchange, Kraken, go create an account. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world class security and award winning support teams, then head over to Kraken, one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world.
Kraken is on a journey to build a more accessible, inclusive and fair financial system, making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto. Kraken's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you, empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks. And there's an award-winning client support team available 24 seven to help you along the way, along with a whole range of educational guides, articles, and videos with products and features like Kraken Pro and Kraken NFT marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together. It's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience.
So check out the simple, secure, and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto, whether you're a complete beginner or a season pro. Go to Kraken.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be. Not investment advice, crypto trading involves risk of loss. The Uniswap extension is here. The self-custody wallet created by the most trusted team in DeFi, Uniswap Labs, designed to make swapping feel effortless. This extension lives in your browser's sidebar, letting you swap, sign transactions, and send or receive crypto without ever losing your place on the internet. Plus, with human readable transaction messages, you'll always know exactly what you're signing.
Navigate a multi-chain world effortlessly with support for 11 chains, like a theory mainnet, base, arbitragem, and optimism. No more chain switching or token importing. All your assets are right where you need them to be. The Uniswap extension is designed to level up your swapping experience with other Uniswap Labs products as well, easily onboard to the extension using the Uniswap mobile wallet to begin managing your assets across platforms and take advantage of smooth seamless synergies with the Uniswap web app. So go and download the Uniswap extension today by clicking the link in the show notes.
Just another way Uniswap is helping you swap smarter. Arbitrum is the leading Ethereum scaling solution that is home to hundreds of decentralized applications. Arbitrum's technology allows you to interact with Ethereum at scale with low fees and faster transactions. Arbitrum has the leading DeFi ecosystem, strong infrastructure options, flourishing NFTs, and is quickly becoming the Web3 gaming hub. Explore the ecosystem at portal.arbitrum.io. Are you looking to permissionlessly launch your own Arbitrum orbit chain? Arbitrum orbit allows anyone to utilize Arbitrum's secure scaling technology to build your own orbit chain, giving you access to interoperable customizable permissions with dedicated throughput.
Whether you're a developer, an enterprise, or a user, Arbitrum orbit lets you take your project to new heights. All of these technologies leverage the security and decentralization of Ethereum. Experience Web3 development the way it was always meant to be secure, fast, cheap, and friction-free. Visit Arbitrum.io and get your journey started in one of the largest Ethereum communities. Bankless Nation happy to introduce you to Kyle Somani, the managing partner and co-founder of Multicoin Capital. Kyle and Multicoin have been one of the largest investors in and proponents of Solana. Have been in spearheading the integrated blockchain investment thesis even before the success of Solana completely redefined that corner of crypto.
Kyle, welcome to Bankless. Hey guys, good to be on the show. It's fun to be here. David, that was really nice of you to call it integrated blockchain rather than monolithic blockchain. I know that this is the word that Kyle prefers. Thank you very much. I feel very welcome home. Yeah, well done. Kyle, it's kind of set to stage here. SolEath is up 300% year over year. Meanwhile, ETH BTC is down 50% over the last two years. The Bitcoin ETH ratio, I think, is on its 700s a day down in a row. I mean, it has had some depth days, but the trend is strongly downwards. Talking about Ethereum, first we'll bring in the conversation of how Solana has impacted the Ethereum valuation.
I want to start perhaps with Ethereum in a vacuum. When you see the weaker price performance of Ether compared to its approximate competitors, what's the first thing that comes to mind as to explain this price action that has been in a trend for over a year now? Yeah, I think probably the most important variable is what I'm going to call gravity. Making a large asset go up is hard. Ether is what call 300 billion ish plus or minus. There are not that many assets in the world worth 300 billion. If you exclude commodities, but just look at equities, there's like 20, maybe 40. There's just not that many.
And a lot of large numbers is a thing, and most companies or things as they get to that size, it just gets harder to sustain revenue growth and profit growth at large scale. I've got a data point for you guys. It's actually number four. You ever go to that total crypto, sorry, number 34. If you go to that total assets, largest assets in the world, kind of webpage, it's on like company's market cap. So it's number 34 in the world, whereas Bitcoin is number 10. There's only 33 assets that are larger than, you know, what is the Ethereum right now? 320 billion. Yeah, right. I think Visa is 400 or 500, right?
So it's kind of like in the same general ballpark, something like that. So like, I think that's actually the thing that if people probably don't appreciate is just like, it's just hard to grow at that size. Obviously, there are exceptions in video, like it's the most recent high profile exception. They went from like 200 billion to 2 trillion, like real fast, but like you're finding gravity. And that's kind of one part of it is I'll call it the gravity is just a function of size or a lot of large numbers. And then the other part of it is a tweet that I put out maybe a couple weeks ago, which is like, with the higher your market cap, by definition, the higher the markets expectations of you to produce incremental performance in the future.
Or very, very simply like someone who makes 200,000 or makes $500,000 a year, you expect them to be more economically productive than someone makes $50,000 a year, like obviously. And the same is true of market caps of companies or of equities or of tokens. You should hold it to a higher standard. And so it's just hard to, you know, I think given either call it 300 billion, which is pretty exceptional. It's number 34 in the world is Ryan just said. And then, you know, if you're at that scale, you want to really have a pretty clear understanding of what the risks are to support an asset of that scale.
And in my opinion, like, either as a fundamental open question about is DA and settlement valuable or is contend as an execution valuable. I've often very clear about my views there. We can dive into that. But like, for my vantage point, being a 300 billion dollar asset and like not having clarity around your basic mechanism of value capture, to me, is very tenuous. And I think that's really weighed on on ETH for the last year or two. Just put a pin in that first conversation about gravity. That's not anything exclusive to a theory. I mean, you're just saying anything of that size is going to experience difficulty expassing some sort of like, you know, 300 to 500 billion dollar level.
No matter what, like exclusive to a theory, it just happens to be that a theory was in this like valley that like all assets that will eventually have to like go through this trial of like trying to figure out how to get to the first T level. Yes, that I wouldn't think about it as a valley is just like, it's harder to go from a base of 300 than from a base of 50 mathematically. That must be true. The only actually weird exception of that is Bitcoin. Because Bitcoin's whole thing is like, oh, store value. And so weirdly, it's like the special snowflake. Again, I have my views of Bitcoin, which I think Bitcoin is nonsense.
But that's a whole separate thing. But like if you subscribe to Bitcoin's value proposition, then it is actually the only thing that is exempt from the kind of not perfectly exempt, but I'd say at least partially exempt from the gravity theory. All right. So Kyle, this is why I want to dig in here. So yes, it is an exception to the rule. But I will say that this is kind of the expectation of the average ETH holder bull case like proponent, including probably like David myself, which is like, um, Bitcoin is number 10 in the world, right? Ethereum is number 34. And it's market cap at the time of recording is like 1.
2 trillion with a T. It reversed gravity or entropy or whatever external force is on the world with large market cap assets. And it got to the trillions. And the Bitcoin bull says it's actually on track to surpass the number one asset on this chart in the world, which is gold at a 16.7 trillion dollar market cap. And so it's on that trajectory. And I think a lot of ETH bulls have been wealth Bitcoin, you know, can achieve these heights. Then why not Ethereum? Because Ether is like Bitcoin except better, except more programmable. I guess maybe this gets into your take on whether Bitcoin is actually worth 1.
2 trillion. But I'll just open up that question and get you to respond. Why is this possible for Bitcoin and not Ethereum? Yeah. So so the entire value proposition of Bitcoin is that it is a special snowflake. It's, you know, sound money. Um, it's the first one. It's simple. It doesn't do anything risk of breaking is low. Proof of work is like objective. Whereas proof of stake is fun. I'm not a subjective. You can like slice this cat in a bunch of ways. But like there's the net of all of them is Bitcoin is special. And even like among crypto people, it is generally taken for granted that Bitcoin is special.
I reject that premise. I don't think Bitcoin is special. But like I understand that I am the weird one and that everyone else in the world thinks Bitcoin is special. So I for now, I'm not not interested in trying to convince the world that Bitcoin is not special. I will take on that fight at some point, but that time is not today. But like for now, I'm under I understand that everyone else thinks Bitcoin is special. So like fine whatever that is what it is. Like don't hate to play or hate the game. That's the game that everyone thinks like cool. Fine. It is what it is. Ethereum and Salana are obviously not Bitcoin.
And like they are not special in the way that Bitcoin is. Like very definitively. And Ethereum and Salana are explicitly discussed as like functional things. And we're talking about finance and we're going to reshape global finance and democratization of access and like all these other funding, you know, asset insurance and tokens and all these things. So like they the fundamental lens through which you talk about the theory of and Salana is like they are changing finance like the rails of finance and the rails of payments. And so naturally, well, if you look at like BlackRock visa stripe, there's always obvious companies that are like relevant in the discourse of, you know, those two major parts of the economy.
And so it's quite reasonable to think of Ethereum and Salana as text docs or as growth assets that are competing against in weird different ways. The list of names I described as well as some others. And so I think it is fundamentally correct to think of Ethereum and Salana as equities not in the literal sense of like the C Corp and the CEO and the comp structure and all that stuff. But in terms of like they have a function they like they have a product. There's needs the users have in the world. They serve those needs and like they produce cash flows as a result of that. And so I think of Ethereum and Salana as equities in that kind of sense.
Yeah, one framing that Dave and I have used in the past for this is just like you have the difference between capital assets which produce cash flows. So these are things like equities or maybe you have property and it's like kind of rental income. And so that asset is a productive asset. It's a capital asset, right? And then you have other types of assets like commodities and these are consumption type goods. So these are generally used in the course of making another product. And then you have a finally store of value types of assets. And these are things that are the special snowflakes of the world.
So gold is a special snowflake you might say because it doesn't you know throw off any cash. It's not a capital asset. It's not really used that much when it comes to you know commodity types of ingredients to build other products. And it's mainly valuable because people think it's valuable. I actually want to just double click on that really quick. Like I don't know how much this will come up again in the course of the rest of this this episode. But I think it's worth asking because you are a bear at Bitcoin. It sounds like at a 1.2 trillion dollar market cap. I assume you'd be a bear of Bitcoin sorry at like a 10 trillion dollar market cap as well.
Like you'd be even more bearish. But like then my question to you Kyle is like isn't it enough to have the narrative and the story for an asset like Bitcoin if enough people believe that it is a special snowflake. And if the crypto world believes it's a special and if Larry thinks starts believing it's special. And if the the new incoming president of the United States starts believing it's special and puts it on the US treasury balance sheet like in a permanent way and starts purchasing it. If enough people think an asset is special then it actually becomes special. And this is like a reflexive loop that like it's pretty hard to deny isn't it like if is it this explanation that would account for the like 1.
2 trillion in Bitcoin right now. And are you like disputing that kind of I guess law that we've seen in asset markets to date. Do you think that there's something wrong with this? To answer your question and anything actually refute something you said as part of it. Which is talking about commodities capital assets and store value. Commodities are distinct. We have oil. We have wheat. We have whatever all the obviously inputs into the basic economy. We have capital assets, things that just produce yield right and then use that sort of value as separate and distinct. And I reject the premise that their category should exist because I don't I don't believe we should have a reason to have non productive assets.
What the one exception is is like cash because you need a denominator to like denominate things. People need to know coffee is $2 and not for bushels of wheat or whatever. It's actually useful to have an abstract concept that is a universal unit of account. Which happens to be what the government's tell us it is and like I'm not here to fight the government. But I reject the premise that store value should be separate. The fundamental argument that like gold is valuable a Bitcoin is valuable is the government can't print more of it. And I'm like, okay, yes, I understand. But I think that's that's a silly way to think of store value because there are plenty of assets that are naturally inflation resistant and that produce yield.
The most obvious of which in the context of the United States would be Walmart and Amazon. If the price of goods go up, like they raise the prices of the goods. And so like they're like excluding AWS. I'm talking just like the retail business. And like it's not a perfect hedge in the sense that like they could become more competitive or less competitive against other retailers like sure. But like you can if you believe that you can buy a basket of retailers. But like there are very obvious businesses. The most obvious of retailers that are intrinsically inflation resistant in like the scope of what they do.
Again, not in exactly the same way that gold is or Bitcoin theoretically is. But in a way that is like very mechanical and tangible to how the businesses operate. And I think of like the theory that like gold or Bitcoin are inflation resistant is like strictly automatic basis. And like yeah, like the gold chart like has some more reverse correlation with inflation than certainly than Bitcoin does. It has Bitcoin is no effective anti correlation with inflation over any long period of time. Gold arguably does. But like I don't I cannot tell you why that must hold true. Other than like hopefully we all keep doing that same trade over and over again in the markets at many trillion dollar scale, which I think will fall apart.
So I reject the premise of the SUV as a standalone. Again, I understand other people, you know, believe it. And like, I don't really care. You do. It's fine. I just from my own balance sheet management. Don't believe that to be the case. Having said all that, I own some Bitcoin and the phone multi coin phone known to Bitcoin, which I can get separately, but I am intellectually short Bitcoin on that premise. I'm not mechanically financially short, but I'm an intellectually short Bitcoin at 1.2 trillion. I will continue to be intellectually short, but coin at 10 trillion. There's something a little bit like Buffet like about that in that investment strategy, which is like very value driven.
Like I think you're you're just like a productive asset kind of guy. Like you understand value and that's just kind of like the frame of reference that you invest in. And you kind of think that that can actually the productive asset framework can actually swallow the store of value framework. Correct. Yes. Absolutely. And by the way, I wrote a blog post about this in 2018. I think it was called paths to 100 trillion or paths to 10 trillion. There's something I'll find the link and I'll send it to you guys. But basically, that's the the store of value thesis, the utility thesis or the stablecoin thesis of like how to get crypto assets to that to that kind of scale.
It'll be fun to reflect on that from six years ago. Yeah. And I think another way to think about what you said is you still believe that humans will want to store their value. They're just kind of spread it over those two other asset classes of like capital assets. And it'll kind of be built into the price of capital assets and also commodity assets. And we don't need a distinct separate category of all of these assets that have this one function, which is a store of value. Like I get that. And I get that that's kind of like your world in you know, Kyle's way of thinking about it. And it's also worn Buffet's way of thinking about it as well.
But it strikes me a little bit like it's almost like a kind of like an atheist like going and telling all of the religious people like there is no God. You just you have to convince them of that, right? And so like I think that because store of value is such a mimetic human consensus type of game, it's like likely that we'll always have it. This is maybe just how humans are hard wired. Like would you accept that that idea, even though you're not into it personally, I guess this this plays out in your fund in that you don't you don't intend to short the store of value religion. Do you of Bitcoin?
And you can understand why it goes up. I mean, I think at some point we will short Bitcoin in size. Definitely not in the foreseeable future. But like on a lot of some long enough horizon, I expect to have a massive Bitcoin short. But that's that's still pretty far away. So I just sent you all the link to the utility app on this blog post. So you know, I was probably included for the podcast when it goes out at six years old. So I'm sure a lot of the terminology is going to read pretty weird and stuff because pretty old. But I think it actually kind of captures the core of the belief, which is that crypto is funny in that like we have this weird path dependency that happened, which is like Bitcoin came out and like it is kind of functionally incomplete.
Low transaction throughput, no defy, all these other things like proof of work doesn't give you fast finality. So it's like very hard to build a functioning financial system on top of Bitcoin. And then the story became, you know, because of the like the block size wars like digital money, hard gold doesn't change. It's stable. We're like cool Bitcoin. Here's special snowflake. Yeah. Meanwhile, there's an Ethereum thing happened like some of them reviews later. And the Ethereum's thing was like we can make finance better. Because it turns out that having heterogeneous financial rails for payments of different sizes, like whether it's ACH versus credit cards versus wires, and then obviously across all the various countries of different effects and then they have all the asset markets, bonds, stocks, equities, commodities, all of those things that I just rep, you know, alluded to are all managed on separate rails, like they are separate database servers with separate APIs.
And it is really fucking heterogeneous and it's really confusing. And there are none of them are 24 seven and obviously you have time zones. And so like when you need to move between them across time zones, it like gets very slow and miserable and terrible. And crypto like naturally is global and like the APIs are permissionless. And you have this like court notion of ownership via cryptography. And it turns out that like we need have this cryptography thing with this permissionless consensus. You just have an arbitrary API to represent assets. Whether those assets are commodities, bond stocks, equities, fake tokens, mean coins, whether it doesn't matter.
And it turns out that like it's as much simpler to have a universal API for all assets, right? Like it's just that by definition is true. And so I think the story of crypto when we look back 20 years from now will be this Bitcoin thing came out and we're like, oh, it'll go cool. But really the story will be we built better financial rails. And it will take 10 to 20 years to basically get the rest of the world to acknowledge we have better financial rails. And to start moving assets over we can see just the beginnings that happening now with their BlackRock middle fund and Hamilton Lane and Paypal and you're starting to see this and you know little increments here and there.
And I think that that will that will be a story you'll see over the next 20 years. There's crypto rails are just objectively way way way better than the traditional rails. And so as more and more of that activity moves over to crypto. And then we're also going to have like maybe gaming crypto gaming is a thing. I don't know. I haven't really seen it yet. But maybe deep in is definitely a thing. And I think we'll continue to be a thing. And I think most of that stuff is going to happen on Ethereum and slona. Or maybe apthos or sweet or whatever else some defy some more contract thing. And I think at some point it, you know, call it five years from now, maybe 10 years from now, most people in the world will look at Ethereum slona, sweet apthos, whatever.
And they'll say, wow, like this clearly runs the world in like a very literal sense like all of the world's assets and finances will be represented on these systems. And then look at Bitcoin. Bitcoin will be the same thing as today, which is funny. It's just this digital, you know, rock. It sits under your bed. It doesn't do anything. And they'll start to wonder. They'll say, you know, these things have some common thread. And that like the assets don't, you know, like live in the DTC and don't come from that world. And like, they use a lot of the same terminology, cryptography, permissionless consensus, like, hum, like, I don't know, like, why is Bitcoin special?
And it does nothing. And it's worth $2 trillion, $5 trillion, $10 trillion, whatever do worth of that moment in time. And slona or Ethereum is here. It's worth $300 billion or $50 billion or whatever. At some point, I think people will say, wait a minute, like one of these is a super set of the other. And one of them is dumb and one of them is useful. And at some point that I think will become the consensus view, I don't think we're anywhere near that moment in time. And at that point, you're going to short Bitcoin at that point, not until. Yeah, like I got to see how the discourse evolves. But I do expect to put on a large Bitcoin short at some point.
This part of the conversation that we just have gone through in the last 20 minutes actually wasn't an intended part of our agenda. But I think it actually kind of does frame how you think and how you model things. And I think we'll help illustrate the meta question that we're trying to answer here, which is like, according to this valuation framework and understanding of how crypto will evolve. Why is the ETH price sucking eggs over the last two years? There's like a list of reasons as to Ethereum shortcomings that I think might be relevant here. And I'm just going to run through them. Maybe it's missing some, which you can bring up Kyle.
Maybe you think some are more important than others. Pick one out of the six that I'm about to read. And we'll pick, we'll start with that one first, whichever one comes to mind. And I think it's the most interesting first. And then we can pick through the rest as we so choose afterwards. Number one is Ethereum Layer 2's force application developers to have to bet on the success of that layer two that they choose. Solana devs don't have to think about this at all. They just build on Solana. Number two, devs don't care about blockchains. They just care about speed and latency. Number three, the Solana virtual machine over the Ethereum virtual machine is just better to build on this Solana virtual machine.
Number four, layer two's are not Ethereum and they do not benefit Ethereum's value capture. Number five, a lack of clarity on what Ethereum scaling plan actually is because 4844 is insufficient by several orders of magnitude. And then number six, broken layer two, interoperability. There's perhaps more, like I said, but like which of these kind of like stands out to the most, which you want to unpack first? I think the one that's probably most directly impacting price is number six, which is the interoperability problem. And this and like the derivative are just at the downstream impact of that is a lot of people use Ethereum obviously.
And they hate bridging and they hate paying the fees and they hate waiting and they're waiting for the thing to confirm to get over there. And they have to, you know, every asset ledger is distinct. Your Binance asset ledger is distinct from Coinbase, which is distinct from Ethel1, which is distinct from Arbitrum and Base, which is distinct from Solana. These are all just asset ledgers. These are those systems keeps track of what you own. And it turns out to be really convenient that when you're on Solana, like everything just works. And then when you're in Ethereum, that's just not the case.
Obviously we have like Lifi and some other systems that like try and, you know, offer that. But like for anyone who understands how Lifi or any of you as a bridge aggregator things work, like you are paying slippage for the privilege of doing that. And like that's a shitty feeling. And so I think the lived experience of most crypto users today is interoperability sucks. I don't like it. And like on Solana, I don't have to deal with it. And I think that's probably the root cause of what's caused a lot of people to rotate their ETH position into their sole position. Is there lived experience using both systems?
So an ETH Bull might respond to that and say, yeah, but Kyle Ethereum is going to fix that. In fact, there's a roadmap to fixing that. They could name a number of different things on the roadmap. They could talk about, you know, different layer twos creating their own, you know, superchains and consolidation in layer twos. They could talk about shared sequencing. They could talk about based rollups. You know, Vitalik put out a tweet and he said, hey, we're actually pretty close. All we need is kind of the adoption of a few EIP type standards to just make the wallet experience smooth. And for this to feel like the same Ethereum chain, how do you respond to that?
Do you think Ethereum will, yeah, there's a problem right now. And I think most ETH Bulls would concede, but it won't be a problem in the future. Yeah, a few comments there. One, I don't think there is a solution to this problem. Because polygon and optimism and startware and I was showing all these guys, they're all building their own little like interop standards within their own ecosystems, which is obviously true. There is none that I understand works across all of them. Yeah, none, none, that I'm aware of. And like, even if like Vitalik proposes one, which by the way, I'm not actually sure as possible given like how assets are sort of the underlying bridge contracts between ZK saying and startware and optimism is an arbitrary.
I'm not sure it's like possible to like get to a point where interop between all of them feels like Solana. I could be wrong there, but like it's just extremely difficult. But even if that proposal exists, there's no guarantee that it's going to get implemented and manifest, which you need all of those guys to agree to implement it. And like, there's no guarantee that they're going to agree. So like, you have a fundamental, like this is fundamentally a standards problem. And it turns the problem with standards is you have to get everyone to agree to the standard. And like, there's actually very obvious incentives why people will not agree to the same standard.
So I don't take it for granted that it's even doable. Even to the extent it is doable, there's very obvious diverging economic incentives of why it won't get implemented. And then the third and actually arguably the maybe the most important is if you're even as nine years old, it just turned nine like a few weeks ago. And that's a long time. For going to SpaceX, like at the first rocket out in like six years, I think, the successful one, not that I think the first three blew up, like the fourth one, which was successful, was like six years, maybe six and a half years, on like a total of a hundred million dollars of CapEx or maybe 80 million dollars of CapEx.
Like again, in that in that general range, you'd only add 180 million. And he was the only money in SpaceX at the time. And you know, Ethereum is nine years old and there's like, I don't know how many billions have gone into crypto R&D. So I think there's like a fundamental general sense of impatience of just like eyes, like why is it taking so long? Like we've been here forever, you know, and then the second part of it is like, it's not in production. And like I think, if you're a three hundred billion dollar asset, like don't tell me, show me. And like, why should not, you know, it's like, that's the bar that you have to operate at when you have a three hundred billion dollars of market cap behind you.
So it's no longer just five researchers running around the London, like, you know, DevCon zero kind of a thing. You made some emphasis on the lived experience of people. And this broken L2 intro probability is like when, when users come to touch the chain, this is the thing that they like run into. It's in their face. It's like a choice that they are confronted with. And so it's very much like, you know, it's the part of the iceberg that's like above the surface. How much, how important do you think that part is in like actually pricing, like the East Bitcoin ratio, the East salon ratio, the East dollar price when it comes to like actually being like the emotional way like users actually engage with these chains and like the frustration that they feel when they see like slippage and bridging frictions like how much of that actual like in your faceness about about this experience on Ethereum actually shows up in the price.
I think that is the largest input is dollars that are in crypto or as it's a wealth that is in crypto that is using Ethereum and is using Salana. And obviously, in some sense 100% of capital was Ethereum and not Salana, like if you go to like prior to the Salana chain launching. And like that that ratio has like adjusted generally speaking in one direction over the basically since the launch of Salana. And the I think very obvious reason that capital has gone from 100 zero to call it like 80 20 is like roughly the split in relative wealth is I think because of lived experience. I think I think it took a long thought of people a long time to come to two conclusions.
One, bother to use Salana and like have enough stuff to do there enough NFTs enough assets enough stuff to play around with like it's even worth getting out of bed set up a wallet and go do it. And again, different people will have different thresholds for experimentation at which they will bother to go do those things. And then to realize like very definitively one is just a better experience than the other. And then the second is to then also the look at the roadmap of Ethereum and say well, I can see why Ethereum is all of these advantages. But I cannot understand how it's going to compete with Salana in my basic lived experience.
And I think there's been a judge the general progression of different people coming to that realization at different points in time over the last call it four years. And once again, for Bitcoin, it's just like different rules apply because I don't know if any users are like using the actual Bitcoin chain or using Bitcoin wallets, but it's just like it's not very pleasant. But people are buying Bitcoin for other reasons. Correct. Bitcoin is a special snowflake. I don't think it is like intellectually, but like I understand why socially it is. And again, like I'm not going to fight people on that today.
We can go into Bitcoin L2 thing. I think they're interesting. I think they'll do some stuff I don't understand how any Bitcoin L2 thing is going to compete with Salana or even Ethereum in their respective like long-term states. Okay, so that was the broken L2 intrapability part of this conversation. I named five others. I can rename them if you want, but you know off the top of your head, like which one you might want to be put as the second most impactful on this whole like price laggardness. Yeah, I think the second would be the I think it was number three, which is the DA is value capture for DA and set on a value capture versus consensus and execution.
Or maybe the way you framed it was like L2 capturing value instead of L1s or the parasitic thing. I have been very public and said on many occasions L2s are parasitic L1s. I stand by that claim. We all use software all day every day. I mean, if you're listening to this podcast, you're obviously on an iPhone or on your computer or whatever, you're using software. The lived experience of everyone who uses software all day every day is that the marginal cost of software is zero and software is free and beautiful and accessible and like that is the economic revolution of software is marginal cost of software is zero and like we all this really understand that.
And then blockchain came around and we're like, ah scarcity of throughputs can't have marginally free software. We're going to have few markets and like that was like very obviously had to be economically true, especially in the earliest days when like the scalability was absolute garbage. Bitcoin is like four TPS or whatever and like L1 was like seven or whatever was. And so like it had to be true given the like extreme technical inefficiencies of the V1s of these systems. Today obviously where by no means in some perfect theoretical, you know, state where like transaction costs are zero, but very clearly transaction costs are going towards zero.
And like a whole point of L2 is that it's cheaper than L1 that's like getting close to zero obviously. I believe transaction costs, I model them is zero for the purposes of valuation. Obviously today they are mechanically not zero on salana or sweet or aptos or eth or whatever or altes. But like for the purposes of valuation, the intellectually conservative approach is to model them is zero because that is the history of software and the lived experience of using software every day is that the marginal cost of software is zero. So I don't believe DA under that pretense, I don't believe execution is worth anything and I don't believe DA is worth anything.
And like, yeah, look, maybe I'm like being a little hyperbolic and like the cost don't get to zero, they're like asymptotically approaching zero, but like whatever. It's like you're close to zero that doesn't matter. Just model it as zero for the purposes of finances. Now if you're market maker, you need to balance you to how much sugar paying for gas fine. But like as a sole versus e-tholder and the valuation model for those assets, model transaction costs is zero. It's the conservative assumption. The only other fundamental input to valuation is MEV. And MEV is just a function of entropy and financial markets.
And entropy will always exist in financial markets. And the more assets you have and the more people are trading assets, the more entropy, the more MEV. That will always be true. There's obviously ways to mitigate MEV. You can direct the value capital of MEV to different places depending on system design and there's a bunch of people working on that in both Ethereum land and salon land these days. But MEV will always exist. And I think MEV is the only value driver for L1 assets or L2 assets. And the L2 center growth matter for Ethereum is very explicitly for going MEV. Now you might say this base roll-up thing is going to solve the problem.
I don't fully understand how base roll-ups work, but I kind of think it's path-dependently unlikely to happen because we have all these big L2 teams now. They raised all this money. They have resources. They have brand. They have assets. They are now attracting customers, whether it's base or arbitrary or whatever else. And they're not going to forego MEV back to ETL1. So yes, the EF may make base roll-ups and they may have some nice libraries and they may tell people please come use my base roll-up. But the leading teams we're building L2s today are not going to opt in because they would just destroy their own revenue.
So do I have to question of valuation? That's the core thing that matters. Yeah. I don't think anyone can really deny it. The cash flows that are going into the arbitrage from treasury, the optimism collective. We talk about the revenues that Coinbase is making off-base on the weekly roll-up at least once a month. And whether or not it is stealing this value away from the Ethereum layer one is I think perhaps up for debate, I think the way that an Ethereum bull, the way that we have framed it, is that we are creating induced demand. This is actually net new economic activity that has been created for these layer 2s that Ethereum wouldn't have been able to capture in the first place.
Yet nonetheless, totally take the point that it's a one-way street. The argument that the Ethereum bull would make is that we've got base, we've got arbitrum, we've got optimism. And then soon we're going to have all of the ZK EVMs. Like the polygon, the ZK sync, like eventually the whole idea of Ethereum just turns into a blockchain for blockchains is and that creates all of this entropy. Look at all this entropy that's flying around the optimism, arbitrage, maybe they're fragmented, but nonetheless they are still growing their revenue. They are cash flow positive. And just by in proxy of just producing this network, ETH has a value associated with it.
That's the Ethereum thesis in a nutshell, perhaps not to perfectly articulate it, but how would you refute that or are you against that? Well, yeah, you're not capturing the MEV. The MEV is going to all of the L2s, and that's my fundamental problem. And I believe transaction costs go to zero. The notion of paying Ethereum transactions is what 50 bytes of data, 100 bytes of data, I mean, it is truly a rounding error given what you can buy a terabyte hard drive for. You know, it's very close to it. Yeah, you have a replication factor, like a thousand X or even 10,000 X like on the network, but like it doesn't matter.
Like it's still zero. And so I don't understand how the transaction fees support the value. It's a $300 billion asset. So like what are the fees to support that asset? And the generic answer is, oh, eat this money. And I'm like, all right, man, it's like, look, you're not telling me it's special snowflake. It's Bitcoin. And like, right, it's very circular. But the problem is, is that like Bitcoin, that there's enough social consensus that it is special snowflake. And like it kind of is like reflexively fine. The problem with Ethereum is Ethereum faces competition. And like there is salana, and there is aptos, and there is screen, there is say, and these other guys are like, look, my system is better.
And like you may disagree that it's better or not. But the point is that there is something that there's enough other things that exist that explicitly reject the framework that ethos is special snowflake because these systems are functionally equivalent. And like, I think that's the empirical proof that ethos is not a special snowflake. And I don't think anyone thinks ethos is special snowflake in the way the Bitcoin is. Okay, so yeah, you kind of like skipped right to the end of that conversation, which like I was going to bring up like Polenia has developed this thesis of like all the execution moves to layer 2s.
And then eth becomes a unit of account that exists in all these layer 2s. And even though Ethereum layer 1 value capture isn't all that high, the unit of account value is money. They would say that like money is like the biggest value that exists. And but like, we already went through 20 minutes of this first entire podcast where we determined that you do not accept that that valuation whatsoever. And so do you just fundamentally disagree with the roll-up centric roadmap as like an architecture? Yeah, look, people can do roll-ups. There may very well be places for roll-ups, the most obvious of which may be a Purptex.
So that I'm not like fundamentally opposed to their existence. There may be a, there may be very bespoke applications that can like intelligently leverage them. TBD if that is the case or not, the most obvious category to me is the Purptex. So like they may exist, betting the farm on the L2 centric roadmap for Ethereum, and then specifically making a bunch of design decisions that forego scaling the L1 with an explicit intention of pushing activity to L2, I think was a catastrophically bad decision. And like it's, look, we don't know if the EF is going to try and roll that decision back or try and like reverse course a little bit.
It certainly is, it believes being discussed now in public purview, who knows what decisions will end up being made. But even to the extent they like assume they got the fairly aggressive case of like they meaningfully try and undo that and like say, no, no, no, no, come back to L1 and we're going to fix all these things or whatever. I kind of think this, the chip is sailed. Like all of these other teams are incentivized. Like if the EF is like, no, no, guys, everyone come back to L1, JK, L2 roadmap, not going to happen. If they say that, well now all of the L2 teams are now in explicitly direct conflict with L1.
In the way that like right now, they're like, Kumbaya, we're friendly, eat this, whatever, fine. I've always said that's nonsense. I don't think it's true. But like there's been this Kumbaya thing. Like that Kumbaya is gone. I think what you're saying Kyle, if I were to summarize it, it's like, and there is intellectual consistency to it, like at least from my perspective, what you're basically saying is that the theorem layer one has outsourced all of its MEV, all of its execution to layer two. And that was a bad idea. Actually, sorry, sorry. One more important is that it's MEV. It specifically is state.
Like the source of MEV is state. And that is very directly fungible assets. So stable coins are the EF, whatever it's NFTs, it's LP positions, it's borrow lens. But the state of Ethereum is explicitly leaving and going out to the place. It's execution state specifically. So that includes smart contracts, that includes assets, all of this. And that is the source of MEV. It's outsourced that to layer two. And that was a bad idea, like according to your telling, because all of the money, if you value these assets as cash flowing assets, all of the value is made from block ordering. It's basically made from MEV.
It's made from execution. So this entire game is about which chain can go acquire the most state to then extract rent, let's say, maybe that's a negative connotation. But in the form of MEV and pay back asset holders, that's what makes an asset worth value. Theorem just woke up one day and said, hey, this cash cow, we're giving that to other chains. And you think that was a bad idea. And even if they swing the pendulum the other way, and Ethereum basically says, okay, we did the L2 thing. Now we're going to bring execution back to Mainnet. We're going to enshrine some ZK EVM or something like that.
Your point will be, well, now you've just empowered a whole bunch of different chains that actually don't want that to happen. And they have kind of an adversarial relationship. So that's going to be a hard thing to get through. And anyway, that's not in the near term roadmap. And because you don't believe Ether is money. And you don't believe in the notion of monetary premium for any like asset period, whether it's gold or crypto or anything else, you don't take the ETH Bull line that, yeah, Ethereum has traded off this temporary cash flow position in exchange for being the monetary unit in the Ethereum economy.
And what's the Ethereum economy? It's all of these layer 2s. And eth as an asset will have special status in those layer 2s because they have to pay settlement fees, DA fees back in ETH. And so it's kind of like a form of a tax as it were. And it's the only kind of decentralized, neutral money in these systems. And therefore it will elevate to the status of the asset that receives monetary premium. You think that's all hogwash because there's no such thing really as store value or monetary premium. Am I capturing this? Yes, with one additional statement, which is, money is what you buy coffee with.
If you ask a normal person, what is money? And you forget about getting into the intellectualization of unitive account, union of exchange for value, they're just like, I don't know, I go to the coffee shop and I buy coffee. In a very basic sense, that is what people understand money as. And ETH will never be that because ETH is volatile against dollars. And like, if we're talking about the world where like dollars are no longer a thing, I'm like, all right, that's a different world. And you can talk about the state of the world. I'm not interested in that state of the world. I don't want to live in that state of the world.
I think in that state of the world, we have a lot of big problems. So I know the pretense that at the minimum, US dollars exist. ETH is not money. It is psychologically incongruent for normal people to denominate daily lifestyle expenses in an asset that is volatile against what they perceive to be the asset that they denominate their wealth in, which is dollars. This is actually further codified in terms of that contracts, which have done over time, that have liabilities that are in the unitive fixed unitive account. Because those then basically read a network effect of money is long term contracts denominated in that asset.
And there's been a lot of discussion of like, oh, China's trying to get like oil contracts denominated in R&B and stuff is like all under the same pretense. Daily lifestyle expenses and surely a major commodity inputs are not going to be denominated in ETH, which therefore means that it is financially incorrect to denominate your wealth in ETH. Even if you choose to say eat this money, like you were just ignoring the reality of everything else that's happening around you. So I actually think that these two topics that we've brought up so far, the first the broken layer two interoperability, which is users lived experience.
And then layer two's are not a theorem. They don't benefit ETH value capture is kind of like more of the wealth and investment, the underbelly of the iceberg part of the conversation. These two actually kind of pair pretty well. Because it's like users and how they feel. And it's investors and how they value. And when you pair these things, how much do you think this explains the whole entire story? Because there's like four other things I also listed. But if we were to just to talk about these two, like are we talking about 80% of the story behind the lagging ETH price over the last two years?
How much do you think this counts for? Yeah, 80, 90% those two variables. That sounds right to me. New projects are coming online to the mantle layer two every single week. Why is this happening? Maybe it's because mantle has been on the frontier of layer two design architecture since it first started building mantle DA powered by technology from eigen DA. Maybe it's because users are coming onto the mantle layer two to capture some of the highest yields available in D5 and to automatically receive the points and tokens being accrued by the $3 billion mantle treasury in the mantle reward station.
Maybe it's because the mantle team is one of those helpful teams to build with giving you grants, liquidity support, and venture partners to help bootstrap your mantle application. Maybe it's all of these reasons all put together. So if you're a dev and you want to build on one of the best foundations in crypto or your user looking to claim some ownership on mantle's D5 apps, click the link in the shown up so getting started with mantle. The OBLE collective is up and running and is maybe one of the most important collectives that you've never heard of. OBLE is bringing distributed validators or DVs to the Ethereum staking stack.
Distributed validators allow multiple parties of people running multiple nodes to create a single virtual Ethereum validator together. This makes participating in Ethereum consensus more accessible, more affordable, and more inclusive. It is a strict improvement to the Ethereum staking tech stack. With collaboration from Lido, EtherFi, eigenlayer, and 50 other entities and thousands of individuals, the OBLE collective is working to scale and decentralize Ethereum using DVs. And now you can get involved introducing the OBLE contributions program. Visit OBLE.org slash bankless to stake on DVs, either through a partner staking protocol or at home.
Earn access to future governance and ownership in OBLE while contributing to retroactive funding for projects that are actively decentralizing Ethereum. This is your opportunity to secure inclusion in one of the most important projects working to scale Ethereum's foundation for future growth. Visit OBLE.org slash bankless to get started. That's OBL.org slash bankless. Launching a token, don't let complex legal and tax issues slow you down. Toku provides specialized support to optimize your launch and ensure that you as a founder and your team and your investors get the most tax-efficient outcomes.
The Toku team understands the crypto space inside and out and will ensure your token launch is fully compliant while maximizing tax efficiency. Toku can connect you with the best attorneys if you need them to make sure that you have the best advice and Toku can help to optimize your taxes so you pay the least possible amount of taxes while still maintaining legal compliance. With Toku's guidance, you can concentrate on building your company while Toku handles the logistics. Token launches don't have to be complicated. Talk to Toku today to get a free initial token valuation. Okay, so Kyle, let's want to give you a simulation.
All of your bags magically turn into ETH. The only thing that you hold now is ETH. That's called a nightmare, not a dream. What do you do next? What do you want to see change to the Ethereum roadmap? How do you want to see the trajectory of Ethereum changed? Wait, David, in the simulation is he locked into those bags? Does he have to hold them? He's locked in. He's locked in. He's locked in. He's locked in something for something else. No Kyle. 10-year vest. In that state of the world, I would ask Vitalik to re-assume the role of the devil and dictator and to attempt to build an interoperability standard that figure out how to get all of the L2 guys to agree on a common and drop standard.
That would be objective number one. And then the other thing I would do is I would... Actually, no, I take that back. That's incorrect. I was trying to figure out how to scale L1. I don't appreciate the mechanics of what, you know, Vitalik and ETH core, how they would approach that technically. I'm not here to prescribe that the technicals to those guys because they're way more technical than me. But I would tell them, figure it out, and he's figured out now. And then the other thing I would do is I would talk to your customers. Mark Zeller just went on to, I think, the bell curve podcast recently, like in the last week or something.
I just listened to it yesterday. And in the podcast, he said, I've never spoken to anyone who works at the Theorem Foundation. I've never spoken to Vitalik. None of them have ever reached out to me. And like he today is like the primary person stewarding Awe. And Awe is the number one application on Ethereum in terms of like sheer dollars in the system. It's like 20 billion tv out or something. It is massive number. And I find that totally preposterous. Like, how can the core people who are supposed to be building the future of Ethereum do so without talking to their core constituents? And like Awe is, in my opinion, Awe and Uniswap are like the top two.
And like, you're not talking to them. And I think that's insane. The Sloan Foundation, there are people who are like, you know, the DeFi team and the deep end team and the stablecoin team. And like, it's like very obvious like groups of people who like are designed to interface with all these various stakeholder groups, like take their input and figure out what you need to build on stuff. And you see that manifest very clearly with like token extensions and other things that they've launched are like directly a fun like an output of those functional units out of the Sloan Foundation. So I would tell the EF, talk to your fucking customers and like listen to them and figure out what they want.
I can tell you for sure if you did that in 2020, then like Awe would have been like, wait a minute, you're going to have 10 or 20 or 50 instances of Awe. They're going to be separate collateral pools. That's going to be really weird and messy. And if you take all of you in a swap, they would have been like, so they're going to have a, I'm going to have an ETSDC XYK curve, but I'm going to have 50 of them and not one. They would have been like, what are you talking? No, that's not good. And like, look, maybe you would have ended up going in the L2 roadmap. I don't know, but I can promise you just like very objectively from the perspective of those two applications, they would have been like, this is bad for the functioning of my app.
Now again, you could have chose to override them or not, but like the fact that that engagement's not even happening, I think is pretty damning. I think one of the reasons for all of this Kyle is this word that maybe I'd love to get your take on, which is decentralization. And I totally agree that this is a charged word. There's almost some like a purity test that occur with it. And yet it's not a useless word because it is a term and a feature that does have some function when it comes to preserving censorship resistance or inflation resistance or some sort of corruption resistance. Those are the actual valuable features that I think fall out of a concept like decentralization.
And I think if you talk to an Ethereum bull or even the EF about the decisions that they made with respect to roll up centric roadmap, it would come back to some form of this word. It's basically like we're looking to preserve a decentralized validator set. We can't let the node requirements get too large execution and state and many of these things are a heavy task. So we're put in this position to outsource that to layer 2s and have them like use the theorem as a like DA like we all know kind of how we got here. And it strikes me that when you were kind of describing the use case for blockchains earlier in the conversation when we were talking a little bit about Bitcoin, you're kind of describing this world that Ethereum promised.
I think the phrase that came to mind I was typing in David and chat was like Kyle very much believes in open finance. But I'm not sure that he believes in decentralized finance. And here's kind of what I mean by that is basically like we're talking about this world of open AI, open financial AI like a sorry API where all of the apps and all of kind of the atomic units could you know talk to one another. But I'm not sure that you were describing a world that was like decentralized and had like property rights imbued in the way that a Bitcoiner might describe them like they can't be censored or snatched up by the state.
I think you were describing something a bit more like NASDAQ plus all of tradify if it had one API that everyone that was permissionless that everyone could connect into. And so I think there might be a difference in envision here, but I'll just get you to kind of respond to that line of thought. This idea of decentralization that's embedded in Ethereum and the concept of DeFi, real decentralized finance versus just open finance. What do you say to this? I agree with your fundamental diagnosis which is a difference in what I'm not actually called values. And Ethereum Bitcoin has a set of values.
And like you can like the promise of Bitcoin there's like a few promises of like temperature persistence and transaction inclusion and stuff. But like the defining promise of Bitcoin is 21 million. Like that is like if you read the sum up all of Bitcoin in the one word like that is it. Fixed supply, 21 million. And Bitcoin definitively offers the strongest future guarantees about monetary support in like inflation policy. If you wanted to get into like quantitative terms, you would say Bitcoin provides like nine, nine of certainty about the future supply schedule. It can't be 100% because like whether there's a bug in the system or some crazy shit happens, but like call it nine nine, like just like an exceptionally high amount of certainty about the supply schedule.
And Bitcoin offers a higher guarantee about a stronger guarantee about future supply schedule than any asset in human history, including gold. Because we don't know how many gold units are in this across the earth. And we don't know if we're going to mine gold from asteroids. So like definitively Bitcoin offers a higher guarantee around supply schedule than anything else. And it's very clear in that promise. Now I take contention with that because I think optimizing for nine nines of guarantee around future supply schedule is just unnecessary. Like each incremental nine of certain futures earned that you provide is by definition 10X less important than the prior nine because you're asymptotically approaching 100%.
And like I don't know if the correct answer is two nines or three nines or four nines. I don't really know. I don't really care. I think Ethereum and Solana today both offer somewhere between two and four nines of certainty about future supply schedule. And yeah, I think Ethereum to be clear offers probably more well. It probably offers higher degrees under your own future inflation. Obviously given the burn dynamics and stuff, you don't know what the other side of it is, but let's ignore the burn side for a second. Just just talk about the inflation side. Ethereum offers probably a higher guarantee than Solana does.
I agree with that statement. I think both of them are somewhere between two and four nines. And I think that's a good enough. And I think optimizing beyond that for guarantees around future supply schedule is just unnecessary. It's the wrong optimization. You do need a base level of certainty because otherwise it's like, well, now we're just back to fiat and people are fucking randomly printing money and stuff. And that's obviously bad. I want to catch all that in the context of values. Bitcoin's value is clear. Ethereum and Solana, I think on that that arc or in that range, two or four nines.
Then the next version of other values beyond supply schedule. And it seems like the core value that drives Ethereum is decentralization of validator set. And like if you wanted to maybe capture that in one word, you'd probably call it like solo staking at home or at home staking or whatever. I'm not sure that's correct, but I think that's probably a fair characterization based on my understanding of what drives. And I might add that the feature that corresponds with that may be as censorship resistant. And like no invalid kind of like state changes. Well, yeah, censorship resistant invalid state changes are mechanically very different things.
I'm like obviously the L2s. There's currently today single entities that are controlling all censorship for all of those obviously. And they may may change. We'll see if they figure out the decentralized sequencer sets or whatever. But as of today, very definitively on the L2s, like they're N of one. I don't want to get into that semantics. My point is that like it seems like Ethereum's core value prop is maximal node count, which includes at home solo staking for validation of the L1 chain thing. That is a value to like optimize for. I think that is if your goal is to win, I think that it'd be wrong value to optimize for.
These systems are financial systems at their core. From day one, and until I was clear, decentralized NASDAQ, like we are here to build the world's best, most permissionless, accessible financial market in the world. And a byproduct that does also do industry payments, because like what is what is a financial market is like two atomic payments is like a trade. So like payments is implicitly included in financial market for everyone in the world to access. And we will make the slana has been very closely designed making decisions architecturally to try and be the world's largest global financial exchange with permissionless access and you know cryptography cryptographically secured asset ownership and all that stuff.
And like, but those are two different value sets. One is like about the validator set. And that may potentially provide certain guarantees, maybe it's around censorship resistance, although given the L2 road map, that's not the case. Maybe it's around valid state transitions, which is like is fundamentally rooted, I think correctly, and increased validator count. Versus like, hey, let's build the best atomic state machine or financial markets, so that everything just magically works atomically in a single state. And like, and so once a very user-centric perspective of like functionally what do users want or we think they may want.
And one is like, there's more abstract notion of like CR and state transition validity. One final comment I'd make there is like I just said Bitcoin offers let's say nine nines of certainty are on future supply schedule, which I believe is unnecessary. You can argue Ethereum is optimizing for let's say nine nines of guarantees around state transition validity. Right. Let's kind of implicit in this frame. This is going to one of those things that I think is intellectually and academically like a way to think about the world, but I think is like the incorrect way to think about the world. What matters the most important actors as it pertains to the validity of the state of any chain are the centralized entities that interact with the chain.
So that was primarily stablecoin issuers and centralized exchanges because like those are the people who are taking user deposits, crediting the user account and then letting the users withdraw fiat or anything else that's off chain. And so like those entities have a very important place in the functioning of these systems because trad five fiat systems are going to exist for a while. Maybe not in 50 years who the fuck knows I don't know, but like for the foreseeable future, let's say minimum five, I mean minimum 10 if that 20 years and who knows a lot much longer. Those other systems are going to exist.
And the majority of wealth in the world will be denominated in those other systems. And we have this crypto thing and the crypto thing is growing obviously. And like there's a very important bridge that connects those two things. And like the two most important stakeholder groups are stablecoin issuers and C5 exchanges that very obviously provide those bridges. And like the reasons Coinbase runs a node to accept your deposits and then ultimately allow you to withdraw dollars to bank account or the reason circle runs nodes to accept stablecoins. And then if you want to redeem a stablecoin for the dollars then they'll send you to dollars.
Coinbase and circle do not care how many other nodes there are. They only care about what the state of their local node says as it pertains to consensus. And the business logic of all of those organizations is explicit in that. They have some web to database to keep track of whatever. And they say, way, what is my local blockchain node tell me about the state of the salon network or the state of the pyramid network or the state of the arbitration network or whatever. And they use that to determine what we'll go in or out. And they don't care how many other nodes say, well, they care about consensus.
Obviously the state needs to be updated. So you do care about the two thirds thresholds to get to that state quate so that you get the consensus finality. But like once you get the consensus finality, they don't care if there's one other, there are five other people or five thousand or five million other people who agree with them. So long as they know they're on the tip of the chain. And those people are the bridge to do reality for all practical purposes. And so I believe that optimizing for the my ability at home to know my own valid state is the incorrect variable to optimize for given the need for this bridge thing back to tradify.
Well, I remember when I went to Solana break point in Amsterdam not terribly long ago, I was it was my first foray into the Solana community meeting what like a Solana builder was like understanding the archetypes of these different crypto tribes is like one of the more fascinating things that I think this crypto industry offers people like Bitcoiners or Bitcoiners, Ethereum's or Ethereum's. And now Solan Solanians are Solanians. I don't know, I don't know whatever what word that is. And like one thing I've noticed is that like Solana and the builders on Solana tend to be much more business oriented.
They they understand their customers, they talk to their customers at that kind of archetype. As you've said, they they they do that very very well. Whereas builders on Ethereum, like I'll pull out like rune christian sin for example, even though like eventually microdowel will fork like it's been a little bit more of a cipher punk archetype where trying to actually like maybe for example, I don't think you would ever see rye being built on Solana. Like why would you build rye on Solana? This super governance minimized like censorship resistant not stable stable coin for those who know what rye is.
And there's like there's a cipher punk ethos to some of the defi apps that you find built on Ethereum that I don't think the Solana builder would build because I think they're more interested in building a business on Solana. And starting to like chop away at some of the nines away from decentralization moving it slightly towards centralization because it allows them to move fast and break things. And that's kind of I think like the Solana culture with one I think you're kind of like alluding to. And maybe to even win for example, when I think rune christians sin proposed like the maker dow new path the end game.
Part of it was spinning out a brand new blockchain and kind of like leaning in towards centralization. And that was the same day like fatalic like sold all of his mkr is kind of like planting the flag of like I don't really agree with these choices. There's an old article of italic indefensive bitcoin maximism which he wrote on april first, which he talked about like having these nine nines for security, which I think Ethereum was truly optimizing for security is like a file of gagerial where it's a light that will light the dark for you when all other lights go out. And so I think maybe this is kind of like the values difference between the Solana builder that I think the ethereum critiker would say like you can only build Solana when times are good.
But when times get dark, you need ethereum and you need like kind of the cipher punk values because those extra nines of security are going to like maker break whether the network actually like operates and whether the apps on top of Ethereum actually operates. Like that was a bunch of vibes thrown at you like what reflect on on any of that as you see fit. I mean optimizing actually this comes back very mechanically to the rant that is one of our coinbase in circle. Like look that Solana's validator count decrease in the wake of FTF like that's the let's talk about crisis like the validator count decrease.
I assume the answer is yes. I don't actually know, but let's just say it's yes for simplicity. The number of assets in market cap go down obviously by a lot. TVL went down by a lot. I think stablecoins you should run that like a lot of things went down. A lot of soul was unstaked. If you look in like the December period, this actually was like a huge amount of fun on Twitter right in December of 22 of like huge amounts of soul being unstaked so that people presumably could sell it there. We internally were like oh my god, you know huge amounts of solar coming on stake. Is it going to be a consensus problem?
Is it going to fail? Is some other catastrophe? Is there going to be some sort of cascading failures or whatever? None ended up happening. And so I guess my point to you is like it's like optimizing for that. The solo staker at home, I don't think is like functionally useful. Obviously you want there to be bug free code. Obviously you want things to collapse and break. If there are things around like rate of unstaking that can impact and sense of safety, you want to understand those. And like to declare ETH is actually a much more rigorous framework around that than solar. Soul has no framework around that.
It's actually very primitive around unstaking and consensus safety. Turns out at least so far empirically that's not that important. Maybe that changes in some future crisis, I don't know. But like we demonstrally lived through one and like it was irrelevant. And you know like what matters is what do the CFI bridges think? Like that is actually the correct anchor of trust in a blockchain weirdly is the CFI bridges. And that's a very unintuitive thing to tell crypto people because we all want to believe it's like no, it's like it's endogenous to like this crypto economic security versus system and the consensus and all this shit.
And like in a very mechanical sense that is true obviously because like the network has to come to consensus, which is strictly an endogenous function of the state of the network based on a proof of state system. But it is incomplete because what matters is the system will live in isolation. They live in the context of planet earth in 2024 and the vast majority of economic activities happening in the old rails. And like the bridges from the old rails and the new rules of paramounts to the functioning of the new system. And so those players are the ones that matter. And so coming back to like your whole values thing of like well like you can optimize all those values and like fine.
But I just don't think that's the functionally relevant set of values to optimize for. I think there's generally a most empirical evidence would support my side of that. Again you can always say well there's rear tail risks and whatever. And like yes you can keep getting down going down the nines towards the asymptotic failure cases. But like there's also a certain point of like well if we're trading off functionality and we're trading off value capture and we're trading off ecosystem agility as a whole for like the fifth nine and the sixth nine and the seventh nine or whatever you're trying to guarantee.
Like is that is that the correct optimization? Kyle this has been really good. And I can already read the tweets coming out of this episode. This is going to be a bunch of youth bulls that were a super mad at David and myself for not pushing back at various times during this episode. And I actually think the purpose of this episode and maybe by the way that this marks the the bottom of the bottom of it. This is the bottom take. Okay. For you youth bulls out there. Now we're doing an episode with Kyle Simone. He's telling us what we got wrong about Ethereum. So maybe there's hope here. But I think the purpose of this episode was just to get kind of your take on it because like the markets right now at least at this point in the cycle are sort of showing ether being squeezed between Bitcoin and the strength of its monetary premium type narrative and also.
Yeah. Yes. The snowflakeness. Although I don't think Bitcoin is like to be called snowflakes David. So maybe we got to revise that. They really don't. Yeah. And then the the slant aside which is coming out with like meme coins and utility and it's easy to use and there's no fragmentation. So this has been very helpful from that perspective. I'm going to get you to do one last thing for us Kyle if you're if you're willing and that is to steal man the opposite argument for a second here. So if you're wrong about Ethereum and the strength of its roadmap and the value of ether as an asset. How might you be wrong?
What are the best arguments against yours? It has privileged regulatory status that sold does not have that's obviously correct. The total size of the Ethereum ecosystem is larger than slant ecosystem. And specifically I think the size of TVL is actually not like what I think matters. What matters is human capital and like there's clearly more raw IQ points in the Ethereum camp than there is in slant camp just as a function of like number of people. I'm not making any comments about mediums or averages that I don't know or even think is actually the relevant variable. But there's just like clearly way more super high IQ people in Ethereum than there are in slant camp that has been true and is still true today.
I'm not sure it will be true tomorrow but it's true today and look like what drives the world forward is like super smart people like doing things. Quite frankly average people doing things does not what like drives incremental progress in the world. It's like super fucking smart aggressive motivated people working really hard and making should happen that that is like how innovation happens. Ethereum has more of those people than slant it does. But I think the human capital argument is like a legitimate one. Now I think that human capital argument faces these constraints around system design that I think are like fundamentally hindered human capital but like the quantum of human capital is definitively still in favor of Ethereum.
Those are probably the two I think they're probably the two best ones. Do you think there's anything to the layer two? Do you think salon is going to start adopting layer two's in any form? People will ship well layer two's on slant eclipse. Well I guess the clips is like bridging the ether or whatever but like there's people working on slant altes. We've obviously got a bunch of pictures for them. We've passed on all of them. Will they exist? Yes. Will they be used in any meaningful scale? I'm quite skeptical. Well like their permissional system. So obviously they will exist. I suspect they will find I suspect they will find some niches.
I actually think that's like reasonably likely outcome. I am quite skeptical. They will replace a meaningful amount of the total economic activity. Hi, what's your favorite Ethereum layer two? They're all to me the same which is actually I think like one of the most damning things about all of them is like they like spend all of his energy trying to be different and like do they're all like almost 100% the same EVM with the same apps and like the so like they're functionally they're fungible they're fungible to me. Kyle David is trying to get you to say something nice about Ethereum towards the end.
So why don't we end with that question? Say something nice about Ethereum. Okay. At least mentality. Say something nice. I like the intellectual capital part. That was pretty nice. I think the EF. These assets are not like I talked about thinking about them in terms of equities in the context of valuation which I do think is the correct way to think about them. But like there are very real social and political and mechanical differences between being a steward of an L1 or an L2 versus being the CEO of a company. And I think the EF very much led the way in creating a lot of the correct norms and standards around being the steward of a system that is ostensibly credibly neutral or this credibly neutral ish.
I think they went too far in a lot of them but like I mean like the original split of the core Ethereum founders like Charles versus Vitalik was like corporate versus like nonprofit kind of a thing right? And I think that they made the definitely the right decision at that fork in the road moment in time and created a lot of the norms and standards that are valid and that most L1 foundations have adopted and should adopt. And I mean that was actually quite impression. Okay. Thank you so much for joining us on bank list today. This has been a fun episode. We appreciate you giving your take as an ETH poll myself.
I hope this is the bottom tick. But you never know. Of course these are opposing thesis. But thank you so much for spending some time with us today. Guys, thanks for letting me come on the show and pollute the minds of all your Well, we've got to end with of course our usual disclaimers. None of this has been financial advice. Crypto's risky. You could lose what you put in but we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bank list journey. Thanks a lot.