Are L2 tokens worthless governance coins? Will they accrue value? Are L2 tokens bullish? Ryan and David dive into the details in this week’s episode of Bankless Takes.
----- 🏹 USE PODCAST24 FOR 10% OFF https://bankless.cc/Citizen2024
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle
⚖️ARBITRUM | SCALING ETHEREUM https://bankless.cc/Arbitrum
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/Toku
------ TIMESTAMPS & RESOURCES
0:00 Intro 3:03 L2s Numbers https://www.growthepie.xyz/fundamentals/daily-active-addresses https://l2beat.com/scaling/summary https://defillama.com/chains 16:55 Tokens Worthless? https://x.com/RyanSAdams/status/1745919415604883725 32:30 P/E Ratios 36:05 Token Valuations 38:40 Alt-L1 Bull Case 44:40 Summarizing 47:00 Closing & Disclaimers
------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
Why are L2 tokens bullish? That is the topic today on Bangalostates. Bangalostates is an episode where David and I just speak our mind on whatever we want to talk about. And today, we decided to talk about... We want to talk about layer two tokens. Yeah, are they bullish? Are they bearish? I mean, that was kind of a question. A few things we're going to take on. The question of are L2 tokens worthless governance tokens? That is narrative going around. Will they accrue any value or are they actually bullish? Brian, before we get into the conversation, why are we having this conversation? Where did this come from?
Well, you were out mountain climbing, David. There was some robust discussion in the Bangalostates and Discord. As there always is, by the way. So if you are a Bangalostates and doing, you should join a great discussion. Anyway, the question was posed exactly as I stated. Like, are L2 tokens going to go up? Are they bearish? Are they bullish? Are they just worthless governance tokens? How should we think about them? How do you guys think about them? And so this is essentially my answer to this. And I want to see how much you agree with that answer. And we may as well record it as an episode. Sound good?
I think we should do it. And we'll get right into that conversation. But before we do, a moment to talk about some of these fantastic sponsors that make this show possible, especially Kraken, our preferred exchange for getting off and on the layer twos that we're probably about to talk about here in this episode today. Let's go here from Kraken right now. Kraken knows crypto. Kraken's been in the crypto game for over a decade. And as one of the largest and most trusted exchanges in the industry, Kraken is on the journey with all of us to see what crypto can be. Human history is a story of progress.
It's part of us, hard-wired. We're designed to seek change everywhere, to improve, to strive. And if anything can be improved, why not finance? Crypto is a financial system designed with the modern world in mind. Instant, permissionless, and 24-7. It's not perfect, and nothing ever will be perfect. But crypto is a world-changing technology at a time when the world needs it the most. That's the Kraken mission, to accelerate the global adoption of cryptocurrency so that you and the rest of the world can achieve financial freedom and inclusion. Head on over to Kraken.com slash bankless to see what crypto can be.
Not investment advice, crypto trading, involves risk of loss. Crypto currency services are provided to U.S. and U.S. territory customers by pay-ward ventures, eke, pvi, doing business as Kraken. Are you launching a token? Is it already live? How are you managing the legal and tax for providing token awards for your team? Toku simplifies everything about managing token grant compensation, and you can get started with them for free. You'll have access to top-notch legal and tax support to handle the distribution and management of tokens for your team. Toku caters to every step in the process from user-friendly legal templates for granting tokens to tracking vesting periods and calculating with holding taxes.
Toku understands every grant structure, token purchase agreements, restricted token awards, restricted token units, token options, and all the other ones. Toku is already simplifying this today for leading companies like Protocol Labs, DUIDX Foundation, Mina Foundation, and many more. You can learn more about how Toku can help you streamline your token management and get started for free. Visit Toku at Toku.com slash bankless or click the link in the description below. All right, David, so the first place and if we're going to talk about L2 tokens we have to see if there's zombie chains or not.
Like, is anyone actually using these things? And it's been a few days since I've looked at some of these metrics. But in-depth probably, you're like a few weeks and it's maybe worth a review to look at some of the core metrics. So I've got a website pulled up. Yeah, it's at the table. It's called GrowThePy.xyz and a fun fact, David, you can get a lot of L2 metrics, layer two metrics on the internet these days. All right, there's a series of great places. I know, it's a series of fantastic sites that put this out. The first is GrowThePy and let's take a look at daily active addresses. So you can think of a daily active address, almost like a bank account.
It's true that like a user can have multiple addresses. That is also true. So it's like a one-to-one simulation. Probably have like, I don't know, thousands. Probably. But this gives you a sense of, you know, the number of addresses on the chain. ZK sync era is right now leading in daily active addresses. So these are kind of bank accounts as it were using the chain, 428,000 daily. Arbitrum right behind that, 185,000, linear, right behind that, 88K, OP main net, 66, base 63, scroll, 44K, on down, Zora, Polygon are also in their immutable X, et cetera. Polygon, POS is not in there because, not technically a layer two.
It's a side chain. Yeah, it's a side chain, but that is in the process of being converted to a layer two. I expect we see that sometime in 2024. Anyway, that gives you a sense of some of the activity. And it's kind of up only, David, if you look at sort of the maximum, look at this. I mean, it's growing. Now, I should probably say not all of this activity it corresponds to one like user. I think some of these chains are like airdrop hunting, airdrop farming as it were. The chains that have not issued tokens have probably a significant premium of activity from people who are just using the chain to hunt the token.
And you can probably see that both in the daily active addresses and also the transaction counts for some of these chains. And which ones would those be? Like ZK, ZK ZK is the big one. Linnea also very big. Base is probably not being airdrop hunted because I don't think people are really like thinking about a base token. And so there's opportunity cost to hunt the base token when you could be hunting. Like ZK ZK has been talking about their token for like 2019 or something like they haven't been shy about that. And so probably base is more or less above 95% organic. So good numbers on that. And certainly up only on the transaction count we're seeing kind of up only numbers as well.
So you'll notice some massive spikes here too. Like see this arbitrage is going to be in inscriptions, inscriptions, right? Inscriptions. How is this spike that took down the arbitrage from chain? Exactly. This was also was the number one largest transaction volume of any layer too. Yeah. So really stress tested arbitrage actually stress message. So this is definitely a metric of for usage, but it can be gained in like all various ways that we've sort of seen. One transaction is does not equal one transaction. Not all transactions are the same. But still, I mean, you want to see an up trend line over time and you'll see spikes for volatility.
It's also good stress test of how many transactions these networks can actually handle before falling over. So ZK sync era right now is the current lead with 1.3 million transactions on a daily basis. Arbitrum is second with 720,000 right now. Did you hear the report as to a Y Arbitrum toppled over when the inscription attack got it a little bit? Yeah, I don't recall the details. I think it was something like super trivial. It was like an out-of-date prism client. And once they updated it, it was like, oh, it's done. We fixed it. That's the problem. You just have one sequencer as well, right?
Which multiple sequencers can start to fix. Liveness failures. OP main net is next 369,000 and then base and immutable X is on there. Linnea is on there as well. Congratulations to Arbitrum for passing 500 million transactions. I don't know if that makes them number one in total raw transaction count. It could be, they could be number one in that. That's pretty cool for layer twos, yeah. That's pretty cool. And Arbitrum probably has the highest ratio of total transactions to total organic transactions because they've had a decent amount of activity post token launch. They've been around for a while too.
Stablecoin metrics as well. So Arbitrum has about $2 billion worth of stablecoins on chain. OP has 610 million and then base. All right, this is one to watch for stablecoins. You know that coinbase is going to send some love bases. We're going to put the USTC on the base chain. Yeah, where it's going to go and then circle, which coinbase owns 25% of is going to go public. And then base is going to be the visa competitor. That's my prediction. That feels like a good solid prediction. So this is at 300 million right now. But I expect that to like 10x, you know, 50x. I don't know something like that.
It's going to be pretty large. Then a total lock value locked. This is a pretty astounding statistic. Wow. So yeah, so if we look at the total Arbitrum chart, 22 billion across all layer twos, all right. But so Arbitrum has about half that at 10 billion. OP has about 6 billion and then base 750 million. So pretty respectable ZK sync era. I really like having base metrics here because they feel so pure. Optimism in Arbitrum probably pure pretty damn pure too. Arbitrum I think recently has some liquidity incentives going on that are kind of juicing some numbers. But like the base, they're not going to juice liquidity.
They're not launching a token. So like the base just feels like it gives us like a control to compare against. Yeah. I think I really useful like metric to have. I agree. Anyway, this is we're talking about the big ones, but there's this massive long tail of layer two is that aren't even listed on this website, right, that are kind of like trying to compete. Like we haven't even talked about mantle. That's been a massive grower lately. Remember another metric which I think is useful, which is on chain profit. Okay. This is the kind of the punch line that we're getting to, right? I think so. This is going to be part of like how we talk about L2 tokens and why they're valuable.
But this says Arbitrum yesterday is about 60K in on chain profit. And you could see like look at these massive spikes. So there was a day where a base was making let's see 380K per day. That was July 30th. So this must have been a friend tech. It must have been like launch. Yeah. Launch around that like a series. So it's spiky. Right. This is these are leads. It's not smooth. Yeah. So many averages are not necessarily kind of like the annual averages, which would be. This is a seven seven day rolling average. It says. Okay. Seven day rolling average. So one still spiky by the way. It's seven days.
We should explain what profit is. Okay. So what profit basically is, why don't you explain it, David? Well, I grow the pie website has it actually pretty laid out. Strongly, pretty strongly here because they have this economics section of the tabs that we're looking into. And page number one in this section is fees paid by users. AKA layer two gas fees. The next page is rent paid to the layer one. AKA the gas fees paid by the layer to to the layer one. And then the third page is on chain profit. And if you take the first fees paid to users to the layer two, subtract the second, which is fees paid by the layer two to the layer one, you get the third on chain profit, the difference.
And so I'm pretty sure if we just go through these pages, you'll be able to calculate the numbers. Yesterday, Arbitrum pocketed a difference of $61.5,000 between the difference of what the users paid to Arbitrum versus what Arbitrum paid to the layer one. Let's go check how much Arbitrum was collected revenue from users yesterday. So Arbitrum, if you could click on that tab, Arbitrum collected $188,000 yesterday from users who paid for Arbitrum block space. And then yesterday Arbitrum paid Ethereum. How much? Let's go to that tab. Arbitrum paid Ethereum $126,000. And so if you subtract those, that number from the from the from the first, you get the profit, which is $61,000.
And this is the profit in a pre-protodang charting pre full dang charting state, where a lot 95% of the costs for these layer twos are data availability. And that goes down with proto dang charting, which is coming in March, and then we'll like almost approach a very low number. I don't want to say zero, but a very low number with full dang charting, which is coming 2025-ish. Maybe no one knows. And they'll pass these savings onto the user, right? So what I love about this is this such a simple model. It's like a valid reseller type of model, right? So you have a supply of block space that Ethereum sells wholesale.
It's like, hey, who wants my block space? I'll sell it to you. And a bunch of layer twos are bidding on that block space. What do they do? They buy that block space from Ethereum, and then they resell it. Where they resell it to users, dApps, they resell it, they add their bit of value on top of it, which is execution layer value. And then on that delta, they make a profit. So they have revenue, they have expenses, and they have profit. It's a P&L business. This is something Larry Fink could understand, okay? This is a real street. It's like, it's not hard. And the interesting thing about this is they're all profitable.
And we'll talk about where that revenue is. By default, they're profitable by default. Yeah. Now, of course, we're not taking into account like how much it costs to run the sequencers. We're not taking into account how much it costs to like develop the software. Do the marketing for these chains. All of that is additional costs that is outside of this type of that P&L, right? But you can clearly see profits are being made. And like, if you turned off everything else, you would have a profitable business right here. As long as you kept the sequencer running. All right. So one last thing to show you.
And then we'll get to the question of our layer two tokens, gray or do they suck? And what do we think about this? This is a total value locked across all chains. So this is kind of one metric that's kind of important. Because I think you want to do is you want to start benchmarking layer twos. And you'll have how much value that they are accruing right now and managing right now versus maybe alternative layer ones or Ethereum itself. So right now, Ethereum is over 50%. Let's see, it is about 55% in total value locked, right? Next is the Ethereum layer one. Ethereum layer one. Next is Tron. All right.
And this is because I would never not laugh at that. David, there's 50 billion dollars worth of tables primarily on Tron. There is 69 billion dollars. Nice. Instables on Ethereum. And there's 50 billion dollars on Tron. And Tron doesn't even have DeFi. It just has payments. Exactly. So that's an interesting sort of, I guess, like edge case, but is really utility for some people. Binance Smart Chain. Let's see, Binance Smart Chain is next with about 6%. And then Arbitrum, 4%, 4.6%, Solana, about 2.5%, Optimism, 1.5%, Polygon, 1.5%, Avalanche, 1.5% on down. So Arbitrum is about double the size of Solana, and in the same ballpark as Optimism right now.
And Avalanche is roughly the size of Polygon from total assets and management. So all told, alternative layer ones, if you exclude Tron and Binance Smart Chain, it's primarily going to come from Solana and Avalanche right now. And it's about 4% of total value locked in the market right now. So that's the kind of benchmark the size that we're looking at. Certainly, the layer 2 ecosystem is probably what, like, this looks like about 7% or 8% of total value locked. So it's about double the size of alternative layer 2s right now. That makes sense. Yeah. The way I would perceive TVL on chain on chains is a little bit like potential energy.
Just having TVL on chain doesn't actually natively produce any economic activity. Like you can just hold all your stables on Arbitrum and not do anything with it. And you actually won't make Arbitrum any money because you won't be spending any gas fees. But having TVL opens up doors for reasons to have economic activity. So it's not a perfect one to one. It's a correlation out of causation. But just if you have a bunch of TVL, you have a bunch of opportunities for economic activity. And so there's like a loose coupling. Yeah, for sure. Sure. It's a gamble metric. It's a metric you can't fully rely on when the native token goes up.
Like it's going to spike in terms of TVL, right? We've saw that with the salon. Are we counting native tokens in TVL here? Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah, we are. Yep. Oh, OK. It's a, it's all like total value locked on these chains. OK. Like soul token goes up. You're going to get a massive increase in TVL. Well, that makes sense. That makes sense for the native asset of a layer 1 on a layer 1. It does. But like if OP goes up, and there's opian optimism, I guess TVL, I guess, yeah, TVL optimism goes up. OK. Sure. All right. So that's kind of the baseline setting of state of the L2s from a metrics perspective.
So the big question that we're trying to answer here is, are L2 tokens going to go up in price? Are they just worthless governance tokens? This was the question posed in the in the bankless discord that I mentioned earlier. And I want to give you some takes here, David and see how much you kind of agree. And maybe we'll take this in pieces here. But just to set the stage, I do have a bias, I would say, OK. And like everyone, hopefully if you're an investor in the space, you're not just being whipped around by the wins of like whatever the most popular narrative is. Hopefully you have a season bias.
AKA a thesis, like you have some sort of conviction concept for understanding the world. Yeah. And so my biases, let's call them are one long term time horizons. Right. So I'm not a narrative trader. I'm talking when in the context of this two to seven year intervals, OK. This is different. If you're doing narratives, you're doing like three to 12 month time horizons. So for the listeners, this may not be your time horizon. You want to do narrative. There's a different play. What I'm saying probably is just like not relevant to you because you know, it's a different time horizon. The second thing I would say is I weigh something called fundamentals, highly in my investment.
And I don't want to like sound. How do I put this? I have a specific. Yeah. High and mighty. Oh, here's now fundamentals. What do you? I'm just an narrative trader. Fundamentals. Yeah. Because there's holes with the idea of fundamentals, right? So your fundamentals are not everyone else's fundamentals. Exactly. And fundamentals are just like a consensus technology at the end of the day. And right. So what I'm trying to do is get everyone else to agree to my fundamentals. So my my fundamentals are better than your fundamentals. Yeah. Exactly. But mine are better. No. That's why we talk about them.
My specific definition of fundamentals is for chains that sell blocks, right? This would be an alternative layer one or a layer two. A long term profitability. That's the fundamental I look, which we just talked about what that means. It's the revenue that the chain brings in by selling blocks less. It's costs, which are the amount that it pays for for a gas to the parent chain or the amount that it issues. Like, remember, alternative layer ones, they have to pay for their security. They don't pay Ethereum for their security. So what do they do? They issue block rewards. They issue new supply of their token to pay for that security.
Okay. That to me is the most ungainable metric profitability is the most ungainable metric for proof of value creation for a chain. All right. This may not be flows from elsewhere into your vault. And you can measure that. That is fundamentals. I mean, this is kind of how equities like are valued, right? It's like, I, you know, of course, there's no value. It's the growth ratio. It's counter cash flows over time, right? That is at least some utility value consensus that the market kind of believes, right? So, but this may not be the way the market decides to value blockchains anytime in the near future.
Or even in the fullness of time, I don't know. Maybe there's some other fundamental that becomes more important, right? Maybe active addresses become kind of the metric or something else becomes more important. So I'm looking at this from a PNL perspective. So caveat aside, my take on L2s is that they are positioned incredibly well for their tokens to accrue value. All right. So are L2 tokens bullish? Are they going to go up in price? My take is, when I look at this, yes. All right. And here's why the three reasons for this. One, and this is probably the most important. David, they have a hundred X, more advantage in the block space profit game because they don't have to pay for their security through issuance of the base token.
All right. It is a cheat code. They're just value added resellers, right? Instead of like, you're doing the hard work. Instead of bootstrapping their own military and, you know, court service and police force and all of these things. Right. And means security and smart contracts and ecosystem. Exactly. They just take all of that and then they resell it. And they can resell both layer one block space and data availability block space. So they could go take Celestia and resell it. They could go take Ethereum and resell it. Yeah. They could go take eigenDA and resell it. And that's what they're doing.
And so they're always going to be more profitable than somebody who is issuing their native totally. Just look at the PNLs. Just look at Costco. So they have an advantage there that I think is hard to compete with. Now, this is a caveat. And this is where the kind of the second comes in, right? It is dependent on their ability to attract users and capital to their execution environments. So if they get outplayed by an alternative layer one or some layer one that is better able to capture users and capital. Okay. I share adoption trust brands. It won't matter. An L2 zombie chain is just still a zombie chain and it's not producing revenue or profits.
And if an L alternative layer one is able to kind of capture that value, then they won't. Now, I would just say, what have we just seen? I mean, we looked at the numbers. We've seen traction for Arbitrum, for OP, for Polygon, for Base, for ZK Sync. And they have shown that their rates of accruing users and interaction are even exceeding their L1 competitors. So I don't think you can say alternative layer ones are just going to attract users and capital at a far faster rate. I think that's already been disproven at this point of the market. Like, nah. It's being disproven as in it's the only strategy that can do that.
It is still happening. It's still in the mix, for sure. So for people who are valuing layer ones who are negative in economics, as in they're issuing more tokens than they are accruing in fees, the market is assigning a growth premium, a PE ratio for layer ones who are operating at a loss in order to incentivize growth, which is a tried and true strategy that we've seen for decades. And so, yeah, people generally I would say ascribe high PE ratios to layer ones. Exactly. And so I'm just making the case that L2s are not positioned to be a valueless governance tokens. Not necessarily that they will exceed alternative layer ones, but you can see that they're doing a lot in terms of traction.
The last piece on this kind of worthless governance stakes is I am not bearish on governance tokens. So if you think about equities, David, what are equities? Governance tokens with cash flows. Governance certificates with reference to the paper. Exactly. But they have some sort of legal guarantee to cash flows. So long as the governance token has a code based guarantee eventually to cash flows to me, that is a value accruing device. Okay. Well, contrast this with something like the uni token right now does not have a fee switch. There are transaction fees and value crawl mechanisms that can happen outside of the protocol.
It is closer to like a worthless governance token, although I do think the fee switch will be turned on. I think for for layer 2s, it's going to be much closer to layer ones in that you have a sequencer which accrues all of the profit basically. And that profit is just going to be passed on in the form of staking, let's say, or in the form of like a work utility token. Right. This is what Matic is is moving towards for poll. And I think we see other chains kind of moving to this type of model to essentially enable the token holder to participate in that on chain cash flow. So is a governance token with cash flows.
I think that's what we're seeing emerging here. And that's why I would say it's different. So what's your what's your what or that's what that's why I would say. L2 tokens are actually bullish as long as they continue to have this these positive revenues, new user base, you know usage. And that number goes up and I see the token current value. What's your take on that? Yeah, you said L2 tokens are governance tokens with cash flows. I would just amend that just a slight in a slight way just to L2 tokens are governance tokens over cash flows. That's the thing that they govern over. And so like the base case is what I would say the arbitrum currently is, which is you can go look at this mark contracts of arbitrum and you can see ether flowing into the arbitrum sequencer vault, which is governed by the arbitrum Dow.
And so if you are an our token holder, you have some amount of say over where that money goes. And I think it's really the next phase of the value capture conversation is like well, it's up to governance to apply that capital in value added ways in the most are in the highest ROI possible. And so sitting in the treasury is one thing, but you know, let's take Amazon, for example, what did Amazon do with its money? It just sent it right back into the company, it incentivized growth, which was a good strategy. Is that arbitrum strategy? I don't know, arbitrum governance will have to determine what is the best way to incentivize growth using the capital that is receiving.
The thing is like arbitrum is cash flow positive. And so now it's kind of up to arbitrum treasury management and just like Dow governance, which is, you know, what crypto is to apply that capital in a way that grows is a creative to arbitrum even more. And we're so early into crypto. What is it? It's 2024 arbitrum is how many years old? Actually, wow, five years. In the grand scheme of things, we're at the very beginning of these things. And so we still have, I don't know, 98% of the world left to capture 99% of the world left to capture and get on chain. And so these treasuries, these positive treasuries that are being accrued by layer 2s need to go to capture the remaining 99% of people that are not on chain yet.
I mean, when it's in treasury, you can distribute it by almost like a dividend to those who are staking those token holders. So this is kind of, I think the convergence of this is we will have a kind of a network type equity or an internet type equity that returns funds to the holders of these tokens in the same way that like equities in traditional capital markets are a right for governance over cash flows. And so like that's similar to me. And the last thing is listeners might say, well, but like none of that matters right now. Like PNLs don't matter. No one's actually looking at it like this.
Here's a reason I think people might start to like look at it like this. Block space fees, David. They're going to commoditize and collapse to zero. That is my belief. Layer two fees are going to zero. Yes, for all chains, except master settlement chains like Ethereum. Because Ethereum is doing a different service. It is providing settlement. It's taking its block space and it's selling it to a whole bunch of chains. But the chains themselves, right, the rollups, the layer 2s themselves, their fees will collapse to zero. You just see it right now. Look at the DA layers. We were just talking about library.
Just a very beginning of the DA wars. It's getting it was like what 99% cheaper or 90% cheaper. 95% cheaper. And then eigenlayer DA comes in that's going to make it another like you know 90% cheaper again. We've got paralyzed VMs, which are going to increase our transaction throughput. We've got massive advances in compression. Vitalik has talked about this. We've got ZK tech. The bottom line is I think block space execution layer block space is going to turn into a complete commodity product. And so if you're an L1 and you're trying to generate profitable block space in this environment or you're trying to differentiate yourself on low fees, I don't think that's going to be a differentiator for you anymore.
Right. And it's like it is true that block ordering MEV can be a source of revenue. And I think that that could be a source of revenue in the future for alternative layer ones. But it is also a source of revenue for layer 2s. And if you have too much MEV extraction and block ordering users are going to leave your chain. They don't want the slippage cost. They don't want the same much attacks. They're going to go to somewhere where they don't have those types of hidden let's call them transaction fees. So that is like the last point I would say on how this I see this game evolving from a blockchain commodity perspective.
I think everything we've talked about Ryan is the bottom of the pyramid, if you will, the fundamental foundation that all value future value capture of layer 2s stands upon. The reason why these layer 2s work at all over the longest amount of terms is what we've talked about so far in this episode. I call that the bottom of the pyramid because then there's another layer of why will tokens go up, which is a more of a medium short term narrative trade. So the reasons why people are going to buy these tokens now in the cycle 2020 cycle the short term amnesia that crypto has when it's a bull market.
And so I think there's plenty of reasons which are valid reasons by the way like brand is one of these reasons. And so I want to talk about that middle section the narrative trade. I'm not a trader. You're not a trader. I don't look at charts. So that's not what we're going to talk about. But I want to talk about like kind of the next shorter term phase of like what happens when you have fundamentals. So we're going to talk about that as soon as we talk to some of these fantastic sponsors that make their show possible like mantle, which is a layer two, which is what we've been talking about all today.
But it's also a layer two with a liquid stake token mE. So you can stake your eith with mantle can also use the mantle layer two. Let's go here for mantle right now. The mantle formerly known as bit down is the first Dow lead Web 3 ecosystem all built on top of mantle's first core product the mantle network a brand new high performance a theorem layer to built using the op stack. But uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expensive a theorem layer one not only does this reduce mantle networks gas fees by 80% but it also reduces gas fee volatility providing a more stable foundation for mantle applications.
So the treasury is one of the biggest Dow own treas which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the Web 3 space for mantle. mantle already has subcommunities from around Web 3 onboard it like game 7 for Web 3 gaming and buy it for TVL and liquidity and on rounds. So if you want to build on the mantle network mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone based funding to promising projects that help expand secure and decentralized mantle. If you want to get started working with the first Dow lead layer to ecosystem check out mantle at mantle dot XYZ and follow them on Twitter at 0x mantle.
Cello is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world and now something big is happening introducing the cello layer 2 is a game changing proposal that's going to bring Cello's rapidly growing ecosystem home to Ethereum. Vitalik has shared its excitement for the cello layer 2 on the cello forum so has been Jones from optimism. But why? The cello layer 2 will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer off chain data availability and one block finality which is all that mean rock solid security a trustless bridge to Ethereum and more real world use cases for Ethereum without compromise.
And real world adoption is happening active addresses on cello have grown over 500% in the last six months with the cello layer 2 gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas using ERC 20 tokens. But cello is a community governed protocol this means that cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard join the conversation in the cello forum follow at cello org on Twitter and visit cello dot org to shape the future of Ethereum. Ron, we talked about in the first half of the episode for a little bit PE ratios growth metrics go growth multipliers that I think the market perceives upon many chains layer one.
You call a growth metric that is basically the amount that investor is paying for like future growth that's kind of like a metric because it's price that you're paying over earnings which is profit in the future and that can be applied to layer 2s. Right so it is a perceived metric as to like what is the premium that the market is paying for a particular asset and if it's a high premium it's implied that there's a lot of growth baked into these things and so for layer ones that are negative economics as in their issuing more than their capturing fees technically they have like infinite PE ratios.
As soon as it turns positive then PE actually turns into a number but the idea is like there's a premium here and different I think different all different assets that have cash flows will all have this PE ratio. What factors impact a layer two tokens or layer one token PE ratio I think one of the big ones is brand. And I think the very high PE ratio that Solana has currently comes from the brand of Solana which is growing in strength growing in mind share the universal composability idea is in being accepted into people's heads and so people are paying a very high premium for Solana because they think that Solana has a lot of growth potential so has a very high PE ratio.
Optimism for example I think has the brand of a the OP stack which has been forked you know like a hundred times now and we will talk about actually the OP collective fee that the OP collective charges OP stack chains that are part of the super chain but really I would say the forking of the OP stack and the adoption of the OP stack by companies as large as coin base which is a huge vote of confidence is a huge plus one to the brand. Of optimism to the trust of optimism and humans place a lot of value on trust and so there's this what there's a narrative that like oh well if coin base has selected the OP stack to spawn the base chain a Fortune 500 company that's public.
Then they are leading the way for other large companies to also use the OP stack and that is a narrative that could over time morph into fundamentals if it comes true but these are kind of the mind share metrics brand and awareness conversations that I think people will be paying attention to as the ball market continues and the price of attention the value of attention is like at a hundred premium in a ball market I think these are kind of some of the things to pay attention to in the short term. Speculative nature of the ball market what say you about this yeah I think there's tons of narratives to kind of latch on to if you want to do sort of that that shorter time horizon type of trade right including like what like what happens if black rock launches like a side chain that you know like.
You know maybe they would you like who knows what could happen I've been constantly surprised but I mean back that type of thing can happen I also think layer two's are in general kind of having a. Renaissance from a narrative perspective because people watched an alternative layer one run up and they're like layer two's are looking pretty good now from evaluation perspective I mean just look at this David this is let's go to coin gecko actually. And let's see what the valuations are I'm going to turn this is fully diluted valuation right so can you go to arbitra. So arbitra is here 21 billion for arbitra.
And arbitra recently reached all time highs this is not my analysis but it makes sense to me is like traders have started to purchase arbitra. On the hype of proto dank sharding e ip 4844 that is coming in my I think that's a possible narrative for sure and I think this is totally possible narrative anytime I find myself like aligned with traders I'm like huh weird. Yeah this is one of the things that happens like they are traders have decided that there is a shelling point around the growth of a narrative about the growth of a fly of a fundamentals and so sometimes like the pyramid of the traders on top the narrative layer in the middle and the foundation fundamentals at the bottom like a line in stars and I always think that's like a funny time in crypto and like everyone's like lined up.
Well that's nice yes nice when you're fundamental. It's very fleeting it doesn't say very long that's already in the rear view mirror at last a few weeks and then you get sad again. Well he says my experience but okay so arbitrum is the number one highest value layer two right now at 21 billion next to that would be optimism 15 billion. They have a ton of tokens that are locked up right and so that's why a market cap is so different than fully diluted valuation because fully diluted is like the full market cap that I can say yes yeah yeah and so and like those are the top two and notice that they are well where's Mattic on this list.
They should definitely make a presence here it is. Mattic has a pump to a billion yeah point four billion. Mattic has been lagging behind. So it's less than half arbitrum and also look at salana 55 billion. So it takes two arbitrums to make premium. Salana right which is interesting just how the market is is valuing all of this at this point time and so to I guess zoom out to say I do think that there are some narratives that might. They should shift this a little bit and there could be an L2 season Renaissance and I'm not sure exactly what those like narratives might lead to that that someone else's specialty but Prank charting could be like base using a layer to more traction in general for these layer to use or just price pumps can just cause narratives to be told for why the price is pumping right and the prices don't need a reason to pump sometimes they just do it's just time for that specific asset or token.
One thing though I want to say David is and I want to actually now give the case to you for why I think alternative layer ones could be more bullish. Then it first appears under this thesis right so okay so this is still within the bounds of the framework and I want to give you a bullcase for alternative layer ones. So far we've said from a fundamentals perspective profitability of block space is the thing that matters in our armchairs. So layer ones alternative layer ones like salana and avalanche remember they always have the ability to become layer twos if they want okay so I don't know all of the like technical engineering behind this but we we know we've already seen with seller network which was an alternative layer one now starting to use a theorem for settlement.
It's not a large technical lift to be switched from being a layer one to a letter layer two all you do is post data elsewhere. Yes and so here's what that means it means every alternative layer one already has an option is the fact that Ethereum exists they have an option to become a layer to any point in time if they choose to exercise that option and they will choose to exercise that option game theoretically if it will increase the value of their token and their ecosystem. But they can they are done on being Amazon and want to start being Apple you mean like once they are done that growing and they are trying to then in turn into profit.
Yes so you know Amazon the story of famously Beth Bezos was like hey I'm not going to return any property we're going to lose money every year we're going to make fantastic revenue but we're going to lose money and all the shareholders who said but profitability bezels it's not even. What are you doing you're driving this this this chain into the ground yeah they left they left right all of those kind of winers left and what he had is probably like sick get out of here. Yeah because what he had was a whole bunch of people who were along the ride for unprofitable block space okay and so like here's a way Solana could win for instance right.
If something like Solana if they're their model is just grow and grow and grow and capture my chair. All fraudsters just like we're just going to acquire users I don't care about profitability. We're going to paint out the market yeah just acquire users acquire apps get network effects dilute so holders along the way. So holders won't care because numbers going up in the in the interim it's a bull market everything's going up. And then when it becomes an issue like when the market starts to say hi you really need to solve that issuance problem because so holders are getting deleted who aren't staking well then they just succeeded so well that they've captured two thirds of the internet yeah there's no longer very that many more people to capture and all of a sudden they're like are we've won we've captured the users let's become profitable.
And we're saying Solana because that's had the like a big run for the last six months but it could be not on ad. It could be sui it could like it could be any of these avalanche knows it could be any alternative layer one well then all they have to do it's it's about the game is now profitable. Okay hey yo we're a layer two now we're just going to sell on the theorem and they no longer have to issue their token. So from that perspective that's what's always so genius about the Ethereum like fundamental model is it's like yeah fees bro high fees. Yeah well like I do think that so okay this is you know like the theorem fundamental kids it seems likely that Ethereum will win in any case now.
So you're like Solana and alternative layer one may decide to play the settlement chain game too they could start to launch they could try to compete as a money okay the last chain to compete with eth as a money do you know that chain was David. Terrell Luna oh that that was the last chain to actually try to compete with Ethan Bitcoin as money okay so a chain could do that. What happened a chain could do that be a settlement layer compete with eth as money. Or it always has the option to like pivot into profitable block space by starting to use the theorem as a settlement chain. So in my opinion if your chain wants to be money you must also be a settlement layer for other chains.
I think that's going to be true. I also think that's going to be true that that feels like a like a core kind of first principles ground up doesn't don't even have to say the words the theorem. If your chain is money other chains settled to your chain. But do you see how like under this lens you can actually start to be like okay the value of Solana or avalanche at 55 billion for Solana. Alright that that's definitely assuming that it out competes a whole bunch of the layer to use and becomes like a dominant player and execution layer. But like the block space P and L thing it doesn't matter because Solana still preserves the option option to always switch and start settling on a theorem.
So it may as well recycle all of the so called profits and goodwill and brand narrative and all of these things back into growing the chain. And if it can marshal that capital to acquire users apps and network effects. Then it has a path to winning and maybe out competing all of these layer to use that kind of quote unquote did it the right way. Right right right. What do you think about that? That I think that is a crazy scientist theory that I'm totally on board with. I yeah anyway I think I think probably I've missed that sort of component of this for a while. And I think a lot of you know fundamentals analysts like or each maximalist and maybe miss that that vantage point.
But like sure very much could be the case so I'm on board. That's what I got man anything else so so what where do we summarize all of this right so we've got we've got L2 tokens out there. And the question was posed where are they worthless governance coins. I don't think they are. It seems like. Yeah how would you summarize all this. Yeah maybe before I summarize all this I'll say a little bit more about the layer to upside case. I think we've presented the vanilla layer to upside case the case that is true for all layer to tokens. But I think in addition to that every single layer to token will also adapt a more specific strategy.
The optimism collective strategy is to spawn the super chain. Create a shared standard for what it means to be a part of the super chain create some sort of ecosystem. Benefits a union for why you join the super chain and then being a part of the super chain requires a 15% of your sequence for fees to the optimism collective. That's the optimism upside case. The polygon upside case is different they have the the work token medallion model about the this the interoperability chain that they have in addition to other mechanisms as well. Which is completely different from the optimism upside case.
Arbitram orbits I think still has some fleshing out to do with its upside case but it has a similar 10% fee to join the collective type of model. The stock net has gas fees paid in the stock token and that's a ZK EVM or not a ZKVM is Cairo base but it's a ZK chain. A stark stark chain and what is what is the upside model for that it is a different flavor and so in addition to just like the value added reseller case which is true for all chains. There's also more specific chain specific strategies businesses for what they are actually doing and why they're capturing about it. Each one will kind of develop its own way of navigating the the world right and it's their this own business model.
Antel for example has M.E. there's there because they the mantle treasury is just absolutely massive and so they made their own liquid staking token they're probably also going to do a liquid resaking token calling it why wouldn't you. That's a mental strategy and so in addition to just the fundamental case that we laid out in this episode each layer to has the opportunity to kind of make their own additional way of capturing value. Yeah I think that's what's so exciting about the space right now is all of this is emerging and maybe the place I'll leave us with is kind of the opening for another set of questions that are questions in my mind for 2024 and I know they're in your mind as well which is okay.
Now we have kind of this new block space thing that we've created in fact I would say that's like that's the core innovation that crypto is created is a trustless censorship resistance block space what can you do with block space. Banking system you could do sound money you could do store a value you could do property rights online all of these things right you can do all of these things with this commodity that we created called block space now we have. Separated out the block space supply chain in kind of three different levels of like value accruing tokens if you will there's the consensus settlement layer right which like a theorem is is trying to dominate very much.
And the case for like ether or some asset as a money or as an internet bond right there's that layer and then there's the data availability layer which a theorem is also a player trying to sell its blocks base as a DA provider but then you also have Celestia in there and you have. I can layer DA which takes its cut and then there is a veil from from formerly polygon founders like taking its cut near is competing for the DA layer and then you have the execution layer which is where the majority of these layer 2s are really competing that's where users calm that's where states are that's where you can create like super chains is where it's an app acquisition game.
Salana is playing full stack but also very much on the. And so the question there is now in my mind and think a major topic for 2024 is okay where's the value going to cruel and the answer is all three okay all three are going to recruit some value but are we going to get more fat protocol we're going to get more value of crew at the at the bottom of this pyramid or is it going to be an upside down pyramid that's where some people think where like value of crows actually tiny at the settlement layer and it's like bigger at the DA layer and even bigger at the execution layer and that in my mind is the major fundamental question for this asset class as we move into has always been the big question has one of the questions that we started to try and answer and it is a four years later and still asking question is better defined.
But the answer is still just as opaque yeah well now the question has three parts to it right we have three different components so bankless nation we're going to be exploring this this year and thanks for hanging with us on the bankless takes we should mention a couple of hot episodes that are coming down the pipeline on this John Charbonneau and Neil Somani from Eclipse doing an episode titled is DA a good business model so we're attacking one of those points on the triangle head on followed by an episode co hosted by John Charbonneau replacing you Ryan by with Sri Rom from from eigenlayer and Nick White from Celestia comparing the differences between eigenDA and Celestia as a DA construction layer so we're doing some exploring.
Let's go figured out it's as always bankless we're trying to bring you guys to the frontier should disclose before we end this episode we're investors in a whole bunch of the L2s and other tokens that we mentioned today we also hold some eith as you'll know you can access all of our disclosures bankless dot com slash disclosures and to got to end with this we have no idea what prices will do in the short run crypto is just generally risky you could lose what you put in but we're headed west this is the frontier not for everybody but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey thanks a lot you