✨ DEBRIEF | Ryan & David unpacking the episode: https://www.bankless.com/debrief-the-raoul-pal-interview
------ Bankless Nation, we’re having none-other than Raoul Pal, a frequent guest on this show, who needs no introduction.
Expect to understand debasement, how to navigate the different crypto seasons, and Raoul’s secular thesis. Besides his key learnings, Raoul also gives a peak into his portfolio and shares some hot takes on the current state of AI.
------ 📣 SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24 https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS:
🐙KRAKEN | MOST-TRUSTED CRYPTO EXCHANGE https://k.xyz/bankless-pod-q2
🔗CELO | CEL2 COMING SOON https://bankless.cc/Celo
🏠 CASA | SECURE YOUR GENERATIONAL WEALTH https://bankless.cc/Casa
🛞MANTLE | MODULAR LAYER 2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle 🗣️TOKU | CRYPTO EMPLOYMENT SOLUTION https://bankless.cc/toku
🏙️ CONSENSUS | SAVE 20% WITH CODE BANKLESS https://bankless.cc/4aykesD
------ TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro 6:35 SEC Suing Uniswap? 9:57 US Regulation Handbrakes 19:48 State of the Bull Market 29:45 Navigating Interest Rates 35:40 Understanding Debasement 47:25 Crypto Adoption 57:11 Crypto Summer 1:03:12 The L1 Race 1:07:17 The Role of ETFs 1:13:37 The Next Winter 1:17:52 Crypto Skeptics 1:22:15 The Secular Thesis 1:26:20 Raoul’s Portfolio 1:30:47 Real Vision 1:33:01 The State of AI 1:36:31 Closing & Disclaimers
------ RESOURCES
Raoul Pal https://twitter.com/RaoulGMI
Real Vision Festival of Learning https://www.realvision.com/festival-of-learning
Raoul Pal The Journey Man https://www.youtube.com/@RaoulPalTJM
------ Not financial or tax advice. This channel is strictly educational and is not investment advice or a solicitation to buy or sell any assets or to make any financial decisions. This video is not tax advice. Talk to your accountant. Do your own research.
Disclosure. From time-to-time I may add links in this newsletter to products I use. I may receive commission if you make a purchase through one of these links. Additionally, the Bankless writers hold crypto assets.
See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
No summary for this episode yet.
The entire thesis is this market is going from 2.7 trillion to call it 12 trillion this cycle to 100 trillion by maybe the end of the 3032 cycle. Wow. Wow. So this is, I think in front of us, the largest fastest accumulation of wealth in all human history. Welcome to Bankless, where we explore the frontier of internet money and internet finance. This is Ryan Sean Adams. I'm here with David Hoffman and we're here to help you become more bankless. Guys, you know this, the bull market is here. The question on our minds in today's episode is what's going to happen next? We brought these questions on crypto on macro and on investing to Rao Paul, who's one of David and I's favorite guests, I think, on the subject, particularly at this part of the market.
And so we ask questions like, where are we in the crypto cycle? How long will this cycle last? Will it be different? Will it be similar to previous cycles? How high will it go? Which assets will benefit? And most importantly, how to make sure you don't eff it up. If you're looking for an episode to guide you on what to expect next, this is it. I think the reason why we keep bringing Rao Paul on is that he has this very clear north star. He's got these theses that he really loves. We also love theses and they keep Rao grounded and his feet on the ground while the just chaos of a bull market warps around him.
And that's also there's always something I appreciate like navigating through crypto without some sort of like north star something to keep your your boots on the ground without that is it's hard. It's hard. You kind of need to some level of some thing to keep you sane and we call this for us, Ryan, the bankless thesis, Rao, Rao has his names for his theses. And every single bull market presents some new thing right how do nfts fit into what Rao calls his his everything code is one of his theses. How does that fit in how do nfts fit in the bankless theses all these like things that happen as bull markets present like new curveballs can all kind of be mapped into a frame of reference a frame of understanding.
This is what Rao does and this is why we frequently talk to him about like all the new changes that are happening in the world and how it fits into the ideas that he has and so because he is so grounded he has come on the bankless why guess like six times now and I've enjoyed every single one. All right, we're getting right into our episode of Rao Paul if you want a debrief episode, which is the episode that David and I record after this podcast make sure you are dialed into the bankless premium feed that's where we'll publish that and David I'm excited to record that with you. I want to hear your thoughts on what Rao Paul had to say about the bull run we're going to get right to the episode.
But before we do we want to thank the sponsors that made this possible including our recommended crypto exchange for the 2024 and maybe 2025 bull run and that's crack it go create an account. If you want a crypto trading experience backed by world-class security and award-winning support teams then head over to Crackin one of the longest standing and most secure crypto platforms in the world. Crackin is on a journey to build a more accessible inclusive and fair financial system making it simple and secure for everyone everywhere to trade crypto. Crackin's intuitive trading tools are designed to grow with you empowering you to make your first or your hundredth trade in just a few clicks and there's an award-winning client support team available 24-7 to help you along the way along with a whole range of educational guides articles and videos with products and features like Crackin Pro and Crackin NFT marketplace and a seamless app to bring it all together it's really the perfect place to get your complete crypto experience.
So check out the simple secure and powerful way for everyone to trade crypto whether you're a complete beginner or a seasoned pro go to Crackin.com slash bank lists to see what crypto can be not investment advice to trading involves risk of loss. Cello is the mobile first EVM compatible carbon negative blockchain built for the real world driving real-world use cases like mobile payments and mobile defy and with opera mini pay as one of the fastest growing Web 3 wallets. Cello is seeing a meteoric rise with over 300 million transactions and 1.5 million monthly active addresses and now Cello is looking to come home to Ethereum as a layer 2 optimism polygon matterlabs and Arbitrum have all thrown their hats in their ring for the Cello layer 2 to build upon their stacks.
By the competition the Cello layer 2 will bring huge advantages like a decentralized sequencer off-chain data availability secured by Ethereum validators and one block finality. What does that all mean for you with Cello layer 2 gas fees will stay low and you can even pay for gas natively using ERC 20 tokens sending crypto to phone numbers across wallets using social connect but Cello is a community governed protocol. This means that Cello needs you to weigh in and make your voice heard join the conversation in the Cello forums follow Cello on Twitter and visit sellow.org to shape the future of Ethereum.
Picking self-custody of your crypto is one of the most important things you can do on your bank list journey. It's also one of the hardest things to get right with huge consequences if you don't. If you want help going bank lists talk to Cosa Cosa helps you take custody of your crypto assets so you don't have to wonder whether you're doing it right. Cosa is a one stop shop for doing self-custody the right way. With Cosa vaults you can hold ether, bitcoin, stablecoins all with one simple app and multiple keys for the ultimate piece of mind with a support team to help you every step of the way.
But it doesn't stop at self-custody because even though crypto is forever you are not. We all plan on making life changing wealth in crypto but with Cosa's inheritance product life changing wealth can elevate to generational wealth. For your kids and your loved ones who don't know anything about crypto. With Cosa you won't lose your private keys and you won't accidentally take them to the grave either. Click the link in the description to get started securing your generational wealth. Bankless Nation Weeks said to have Raul Paul back on the show. He is the co-founder and CEO of Real Vision which is a financial median education platform.
It's focused on macro investing in crypto. Raul himself is a fantastic investor. I always learn a lot from him. I think in today's episode we're trying to get a sense of the 2024 bull market what the shape of this will be what the contours are. David and I have going to this episode Raul just listed a whole bunch of questions we want to ask you anyway welcome back to bankless is great to have you. Great to be here guys as always. All right so we got to start with this though because this was breaking right before we jumped into. We're already going off script. We're already going off script and this seems to happen with Raul Paul episodes I remember like the one time we recorded this is back in 2022 it was the middle of terror Luna breaking down.
That's right. This also feels to me at least like it could be some pretty big news. The SEC is now suing uniswap so this is a like a fortune article that just came out. I'm not sure the details are very the time of recording literally minutes ago. Yeah so I'm not sure if they're like suing like the foundation or labs or what the details of this are I haven't had a chance to get caught up but this feels very much like a shot across the bow for DeFi like a big one so they're not just shot into the whole of DeFi. Yes it's it's just like do we know what do we know this substance of this yet we don't we don't know because you know sometimes they do this and it's kind of a ends up being a clarification issue is like we'll absolve you of your past sins move forwards you know we don't really know yet I haven't seen I haven't seen the details at all.
Yeah I I may actually pay for the fortune crypto pay well to just get this and actually read this entire article here. But I guess some context here uniswap feels like the the poster child for DeFi. It's not only that it's a U.S. like developed project Hayden Adams U.S. citizens lived here the team is based in in New York I believe and it's really been a flagship predical like they have done the right things in order to decentralize the pieces that should be decentralized and for the U.S. as a regulator to go after uniswap bring them to court in this way rather than inviting Hayden Adams to the to the to the White House for you know like a celebration of him as an entrepreneur in that team what they're doing in crypto this is akin to like taking Google to court or altivist or something like this in the 1990s like why why are we doing this and I know you're not living in the U.
S. Raul but like collectively I'm just speak on behalf of people in the U.S. who are crypto users why are we doing this to our best and brightest like American projects you know they they're all terrified of DeFi. So we don't know what I mean you know we've only just heard about this so we don't know whether it's about the KYC elements which we understand has been an issue for DeFi as an industry because it didn't have it set up in the way that they wanted it we don't know whether it's to do with the token change you know I don't know anything yet so but some people watch this world but all sounds stupid because everyone will know what the details were and we don't know anything but it's a pain in the ass but I kind of figured they were going to come off the DeFi anyway they just they're uncomfortable with it when you say me you can have a bank well the authorities put it that way you know what do you mean you can have a bank without bankers what do you mean you can have you know you can have an exchange without people what you know you know to them this is to alien concept because it is really the antithesis of the existing system so they've never been comfortable and then they use the ridiculous KYC AML thing which really all KYC AML is to increase tax takes so everyone has to declare everything that's really what that's about wasn't really about terrorism financing and stuff like that it's really about they need to know where your money is at all times so you can't leave the system okay fine we live in their countries they want those rules it is what it is but they're they just don't like this whole system yet so it sounds like uniswap was prepared for this so they just put out a tweet thread saying today uniswap labs received a Wells notice from the SEC and we are ready to fight this is the latest political effort to target even the best actors in crypto like uniswap and coinbase and then they follow up saying all uniswap products and the uniswap protocol are unaffected and then they go on in a short little thread it's again sounds like the details are still uncertain here but it also sounds like uniswap I mean they've received a Wells notice so they were informed that the SEC intends to sue them that's what a Wells notice is sounds like they got this Wells notice at least at least a number of days ago if not a couple of weeks ago and hopefully they've got the resources to take the fights to the courts I mean because that seems to be the only way here and I think that's purposefully done I think it's to create speed bumps you know the SEC kind of often knows it's going to lose but it does it to slow the whole industry down this is the take that Jake Stravinsky gave me when I talked to him last that it might be the opinion of some of the more deceleration as regulators especially the Biden administration who I would classify this as is that like they might want the SEC to be even more hostile to crypto as a whole up to the point of like you have to lose in court and that's how regulation is determined so if you aren't fighting and losing then you're not trying hard enough so go ahead and take as many people to court as possible and then the law will what what is is okay and is not okay will be determined by in which court cases does the SEC lose and that's how regulation is set according to one philosophy which seems to be how these issues are closed everything down which suits everybody right because if they're all terrified about it you can see you know the almost every other central bank in the world of of certain size is working on CBDCs the US won't because it's terrified of making the move and the US has a history of this and I wrote some threads about this in the past so after the US left the gold standard right everybody now needed to exchange currencies with each other and the US was like well we don't really want to be involved in this because they were worried about what was going to happen to the dollar so the UK started the foreign exchange markets and it became the biggest market the world has ever seen and the UK dominated that market ever since second was the second one was the offshore lending in dollars so the US was really worried about dollar circulation outside of the US didn't know what how to deal with it same thing with a reserve currency we're on the fuck this up so they just basically restricted US bank lending to various entities so the UK started the euro dollar market which is the offshore dollar market and it siphoned through other global banks it became the largest market the world has ever seen the US missed all of those so that's why LIBOR the London Interbank Offered Rate is the interest rate for the entire world or was until I've just changed to sofa then it happened again in the very late 80s where the derivative market in the US was basically the Chicago mercantile exchange and the Chicago border trade but then the swaps market was developed and it was an OTC market and it required bank regulatory capital the US regulators to protect their own exchanges said you're going to we're going to make it so hard for you to do that you're not able to so the UK started the swaps market which then became the whole the OTC derivative market which based out of the UK which became a 1.
4 quadrillion dollar market so the US has a history of doing this in its fear of screwing up I get it you're the incumbent you've got a fear factor the UK has an innate ability to arbitrage that so they see the opportunity that's why the city of London is so big the UK stopped market small it's because they took all of the business from the US and what was very interesting is they see the US fumbling the ball yet again with crypto and the UK stood up and said we want to regulate this properly we want to bring it here to the city and we want to turn this into a huge market and they've done this this would be the fourth time and you know I remember speaking to the guys at Coinbase about this I think it was Brett who runs their institutional sign I'm like he grew up like me in the traditional finance industry back in the 90s all of the main offices of all the US banks was London Goldman's biggest office London JP Morgan's biggest office London Morgan Stanley's biggest office London all of them because of this and slowly after Basel 3 regulations came in in the early 2000s capital went back to the US because the US didn't put such string stringent things on to the balance sheets of the banks so money flew float back so it just feels that the opportunity here is this whole thing to happen all over again it sounds like it and I guess when you when you paint the history like that it does seem like the US has often pulled the handbrake on you like financial kind of changes and technologies and kind of like been a laggard with respect to that but there like if you look at this from a non finance lens and look at this from a lens of it's a technology like the internet the US has also had a history of being kind of first movers dominant like the 1990s when like building Silicon Valley all these things yes and no when you're in a monopolistic power situation look at Google's inability and I know the Google Web 3 team well they understand it yes they do I think it's great but even the CTO of Google as far as I'm aware is a huge Web 3 fan but they can't do anything because it's going to disrupt their own business it's so this is classic innovator's dilemma type of stuff where you wear this thing incumbent monopoly of money global money and it's fearful of changing its system in case it loses control of the system so this is why they've kind of if you think about it on this kind of spectrum Coinbase good Binance bad yeah because Coinbase is within the walls they've now given they've blessed them with a monopoly basically and shut out Binance which is the world's largest exchange which is probably Chinese controlled in as much as Coinbase is US controlled and there in lies the separation much like Chinese tech firms US tech firms this so this game is being played out literally everywhere we see even the ETF for them it's quite funny because the ETF they think of is keeping the money within the system right so it has to go through the intermediaries and the middlemen and all the checks and balances that they've got so they know where it goes I actually think of it differently I think it's a Trojan horse of crypto land put into fear world because what you do is you give people a taste of what this is and they will move out the risk curve they always do and they'll come into crypto land so I think the SEC and the US government think that it's a victory to channel assets through the ETF I think it's a victory for crypto land as a Trojan horse a pure victory then I so so we're out for the rest of this episode I think we're going to be zoomed out and maybe we could just kind of like zoom out on on this issue do you think that these types of hand breaks that US regulators are pulling right now well that's slow us down at all and in particular when we're looking at the bull market that we're in right now in 2024 well that's slow down the bull market could it disrupt the bull market is this an impediment in the medium to long term no firstly obviously it's a global marketplace secondly Bitcoin's got the seal of approval ETH will get the seal of approval at some point what you've now created is capital inflows now this is not direct investment because it doesn't go directly into crypto land it's like a trade deal that money gets recycled in the crypto economy and out the risk curve profits get recycled into VC VC creates new products which create the new opportunities for the next cycle so I don't think it slows it down because that still continues you know mum and pop in Ohio are not going to be using Uniswap to trade you know some hundredth token so I don't think it really matters the issue actually is as you alluded to is I just feel sorry for US innovators right I mean that's the that's the issue in that they're having to move you know I'm off to token 2049 in Dubai shortly Dubai is attracting a ton of talent Singapore slow down a bit Hong Kong getting talent back again Europe getting talent bizarrely Switzerland's got some great talent going on there in in crypto valley UK's getting talent and others are moving offshore elsewhere so it's a shame as we enter this bull market roll you've seen your fair share of crypto cycles this one's already manifesting differently we Bitcoin past all time high before the happening which is this like hallmark of like what a crypto cycle is like first the happening happens and then Bitcoin hits all time high sometime like nine months later well now that orders happening in reverse also this Bitcoin ETF thing is like perhaps the reason why that's happening overall there are some things about this particular bull market that are different and this I think would be expected as time goes on in the crypto industry matures things are going to change like we can't be having this like four years like 300 percent cycles over and over and over again like we have to like be less insane as an industry in order to get mainstream adoption but overall like how are you how would you characterize the flavor of this particular bull market as with the data that we've been able to have so far so you know as I've spoken here before this is all driven by the liquidity cycle it's actually a macro cycle driven by the refinancing of government debts because everybody reset interest rates to zero in 2008 they set their government debts all at three to five years gives us a four year cycle that was the exact point the launch of Bitcoin it's also the US presidential election cycle it's all the same thing and election cycles they give out candy to the kids which is their way of stimulating so it's all part of the stimulus cycle and debt for refi cycle so I don't think that changes because the debt issue is still too big okay so what is the nuance of the cycle normally normally we've only got three data points but the crypto spring which is the first year after the bear market this was been a strong one you know Bitcoin was up 150 percent or whatever so that's pretty strong because we've brought an extra source of demanded as you alluded with ETF but that actually came later but it was front running by hedge funds and participants yeah yeah is that what we're in by the way now well is crypto spring like the year we're just transitioning to crypto summer which is okay coming to in a sec okay so crypto spring transitions to crypto summer and that's usually happens after the halving and after the halving you see something that I know everybody's getting shittful right now is if you go back to 2020 after the halving what happened ETH Bitcoin bottomed right and then it started out it's slowly based and then it started out performing right that's when the market takes on risk and goes out the risk curve and that's when you start to see Bitcoin dominance coming down all of that kind of stuff that's what the summer is it's also altcoin season it's when we hit what I commonly refer to as the banana zone when everything goes bananas right the bit of crypto magic now this banana zone is interesting to me because we've got this new source of demand this is the most reflexive market ever because the more people join the network the more the price goes up the more encourages people to join the network the more the price goes up and obviously that reflexivity works in reverse which is why we get strong bear markets but basically the world is underweight this asset because it's still a new asset and it's an adoption curve so over time more and more people join the network as investors or users so I think we can see a second wave of panic into the Bitcoin ETF from people you know I was speaking to a good friend of mine who's a kind of very well-known hedge fund manager or ex hedge fund manager and one of the billionaire crowd and he's like when do you think Bitcoin hits 100,000 I said probably the summer you know with the kind of demand and ETF kind of feels like the sometime in the summer he's like he's like you know so much wealth is getting made in crypto it's making the billionaire class nervous I said were you talking about what and this was a lovely insight he's like okay there's two groups here who all they care about they're so rich all they care about is where they fit on the rich table right there can't be the Silicon Valley guys but there's this whole group that that compete with each other for how wealthy they are so even about right when you're in the top 10,000 you can kind of count your way to the top and you really know exactly where you are and so he said they're all going to panic that they're going to lose relevancy so they're going to panic in they're going to panic into a Bitcoin you know the Bill actments of this world and you know all of these people so I thought that was funny but he also said the other group is the billionaire property developers he goes these guys are losing relevancy fast because of commercial real estate and these guys have been lauding it around you know Palm Beach and everything else as the kings of the hill and they're worried about their relevancy because you know once you've once you've worth five billion dollars you know it doesn't it's not about it's not a wealth game anymore it's like am I richer than my neighbor that's all they care about and so he's like you know I think that they'll probably get involved as well and I think that mindset is pretty true everywhere right people see Bitcoin going up and then you hear that you're made to play gold for having a drink and he made money in it and then you think I've got to make money in it and this is the reflexive loop so that's what crypto summer is all about it's the FOMO the madness the insanity that crypto becomes but it also drives adoption drives money into the VC again it flushes money through the system allows people to build new product which is the next cycles gains and all of this stuff so that's great and then we go into fall and this is where the complications lie crypto fall which we historically 2025 they generally finished at the end of the year we don't really ever know exactly I think this cycles maybe started a bit earlier I don't know and falls can be the most tricky part this summer is the easy bit you just shut up and do nothing a number go up fall is tricky so if you go back to 2013 we got a 50% sell off people thought it was done because it already gone up I don't know 20x or something stupid it then corrected 50% everyone thought it was over and then it moon rocketed in a just a way you can't comprehend then you get to 2017 same 2017 everyone kind of thought it was over early summer and then it did I don't know 10x from there it was bananas right that is really hard to deal with because 2021 was a stunted cycle we never got the accelerated final leg we had the huge correction it went up poked his nose back up in the highs collapsed everyone's got PTSD from that the real money was made in those previous two bull markets in terms of percentage returns everyone now assumes it can only go up three x from the all time high there is actually no evidence of that maybe something was weird in the last cycle because the other ones did a lot past the all time highs so I I'm slightly so how I think of it is a distribution curve middle is it kind of does what it's supposed to do until sometime mid h2 2025 it tops out okay that would be normal that would be Bitcoin as a price target of call it 200,000 something like that you know three x the all time high kind of thing that I would give a 60% probability I think there's a 20% probability that people who calling this a left translated cycle I we brought forward demand because of the ETF it dries up we're over performing for this stage in the cycle I think people saying that tend to be one cycle people because they only saw the last cycle because others have out performed earlier on so anyway okay there's a 20% chance of that then there's a 20% chance that this turns into a full bone bubble cycle a 2013-2070 because of this new dynamics you throw in an ETF as well you throw in you know the 65 billion dollars of VC that went into the last cycle somebody comes up with some killer applications before you know it there's 200 million people playing a game there's you know stuff like this going on okay that could create something crazier and I'm continuous assessing these probabilities in my head and because I there's so many people who I've noted have PTSD from the last cycle the stunted top it's less translated they're going to take it away from us starts to move my probabilities that you get a correction and then a spike you can't predict that because everyone's going to hate you if you're wrong like I got hated at the top last time by thinking we were going to have that right so it's it's like a it's and it's also very difficult to manage so it's a it's complex I would say but we don't have to care this year which is lovely so I want to add one one one bring up one conversation here about the the stunted cycle of last cycle 2021 and end of 2022 we had the rise of interest rates which perhaps it was the cause of the stunting right like we had we maybe were on our way to do just another stereotypical cycle that we've seen in the past but then we had the fastest rising interest rates that we've seen in 30 years and perhaps you truncated the whole entire bull market to which the interest rates are still high to this day we haven't really seen interest rates come down Ryan and I for an episode not too long ago we were looking at the supply of M1 in United States the US dollar and it's pretty like insane how much the monetary the M1 monetary supply expanded post covid when they like issued like four trillion dollars in the very short amount of time semi checks going everywhere the supply of M1 like quadrupled it went from like four trillion to 16 trillion dollars inside of 2020 and then you can see when they turn the interest rates on and you started to see that supply kind of like turn over and come back down but like to say it came back down is just like it's not even a blip in comparison to the quadrupling of the M1 supply that happened like we are just starting to marginally make a dent and it's almost not even and so like really just the emphasis here is that like all that money that we printed in covid is still out there it just went into like money markets it went closer to home it went closer to the federal reserve it created into big commercial bank deposits on the on the the federal reserve it stayed risk off because everyone just got walloped in 2022 in the markets and so to add to the case that this is the 20% more bullish scenario since that money is still out there with it's just waiting in my opinion just waiting for the flood gates to open back up and for that to all of that real capital that's inside the traditional system to work its way back down the risk curve and it just needs a lowering of interest rates in order to add the jet fuel onto the fire is there's there's where there was $4 trillion in M1 in 2020 in 2020 there's now 16 trillion dollars of M1 out there now which could all end up moving down the risk curve we just haven't seen that move yet look I think that's that's very valid but let's look at the scenario where rates don't come down much because that's what people are worried about right we don't need to worry about a bubble cycle it'd be nice if we get one but what we have to worry about is the other stuff I'm trying to figure this out so a lot of people on Twitter saying well rates are never going to go down not with inflation at this slow right a inflation lagging all of the heavy stuff of inflation rents and stuff lags significantly so it should continue to deflate when you look at the true inflation index it keeps falling so you know I still think that game is still to be played out but let's assume it doesn't get back down to the levels and they don't cut well they cut a little bit because they've got to finance the debt right this is the problem but this is what gold is sniffing out right now is how are they going to make the interest payments on the debt at five and a half percent rates well it becomes a compounding of new debt issuance and they'll lose control of the bond market which means they have to do yield curve control which would be printing of money but within this let's assume that they do manage to get squeeze in a few rate cuts 75 basis points well that reminds me a lot of 1995 in 1994 we had a massive moving rates it banks went under same situation markets puked they hated it and the fed everybody thought there'd be a recession didn't get one and the fed cuts twice or three times 75 basis points no in near where it would come back from and they kept them on hold basically until 1998 when the Asian crisis came they'd cut it bit and then raised it once and then cut but nothing really it was basically stable rates so everyone's like well if they lead rates here well that's that's nightmare for the markets well a the cost of 5% interest rates in a market that does what e does about 175% a year annualized so 5% interest rates are irrelevant which is why you can have funding rates of 65% and people still pay them secondly back in 1995 96 97 into 98 the market went up the S&P went up 160% and that's when people would say inflation kind of rebounded a bit all of the usual stuff was not bad the markets don't like rate of change stability more than happy with everybody adjust their cost of capital and everybody carries on their business now obviously if you bring rates lower and they bring it lower faster and they push more liquidity liquidity is actually the big thing in the system and you know there's various ways of measuring liquidity but liquidity has been rising global liquidity not by much but enough that bottom the crypto markets and everything else and the forward looking indicates a suggest liquidity continues to come into the system and that liquidity ends up flowing down the risk curve or acts as a debatement of of fear because there's a global liquidity measure which optically pushes up the price of assets so you're saying that even if they don't decrease rates it's still kind of bullish crypto I mean the base case is that they don't put them up another 50 yeah 50 base points that rate of change is low right it's not really a problem for markets to digest as we're still kind of looking at the backdrop of this crypto bull market and the summer that maybe we have now recently entered Raoul I'm curious on this this word debatement because that is always looming in the background from a macro perspective and the birth of Bitcoin was sort of based on the debatement story I saw a tweet you recently put out while everyone is worried about 3.
5% inflation which is our current inflation rate the real issue is the ongoing 8% per annum debatement of currency on top of inflation here's the kicker your hurdle rate to break even is around 12% what do you mean by hurdle rate does that mean like the amount that I have to earn in the market with my investments in order to not get debased so let's first understand what debatement does debatement of fiat currency overall so I'm using a global liquidity index which is the 8% means that as the central banks create more fiat currency assets optically rise particularly US assets because it's the US dollars the global reserve system however variable income doesn't go up fixed scarce assets go up so scarce assets go up versus your wages prices go up versus earnings P ratios go up once you understand this you stop fighting P ratios and saying the market's expensive no it's debatement it pushes up the P and keeps the E growing roughly in line with the economy that's the difference so when you understand that what they are doing here is essentially creating liquidity to buy the government bonds to finance the deficits that's they're all doing that is a 8% a year and has been ongoing since 2008 it was basically a agreement amongst all the central banks that the only way out of this this is this whole everything code thesis that I've been working through is that the only way out of this was to use liquidity from the central banks to finance the government you now hear a new word which is really the everything code but there's a new fancy expression called fiscal dominance which means central banks become more attuned to helping the government finance their deficits then they are about unemployment and inflation fiscal dominance is a fancy word for the everything code which is let's debase the currency to pay the bills these these to call that MMT do they not call that yeah MMT is another way of yeah MMT is kind of another way of doing it it's all the same thing is I'm going to magic money to pay my bills now if we could all do that we do that too you know you can't help yourself you can't help yourself if you've got the magic printer button you can't so that's the 8% so your wages aren't going up as much as asset prices are rising so why does that matter well what is an asset an asset is a vehicle for your future consumption you've deferred your consumption today to be able to use that money in the future now why do we invest is we take on a bit of extra risk to make that money worth more than it would have been because we're taking the risk of locking up our money in an investment for a long period of time we need to get paid for it okay and then you add in the generalized inflation rate I took like global inflation is maybe 4% so that gives you this 12% hurdle rate okay that's fine what is the return of the S&P 500 annual license 2012 12% and I've shown these charts over and over again divided by the balance sheet none of these assets are gone anywhere there's only two assets in the world that have gone anywhere technology stocks which are 17% a year but even if you pay taxes on capital gains you're probably just about breaking even on the S&P are actually negative then you've got crypto which is like an alien asset class that does something like 175% a year if you're taking ETH as your benchmark 175% a year including down 80% markets so that's how you get to this understanding of debatement what you're trying to do is make sure your future self thanks you for the decisions you make today is that correct every time you try and buy something it's now getting more expensive versus your wages so many people of your age are seeing this with housing so fuck how are we ever supposed to do that that whole equation of the mismatch of asset prices which is your future self and where you are today is what's driving the speculation economy so US citizens spent 108 billion dollars on lottery tickets last year 108 billion so 1 in 300 million probability of winning the big lottery and maybe winning a million bucks is I don't know the actual odds but let's call it one in 50 million okay you can take those odds or you can go to the mean coin casino of the wild west and you will get better odds and that's what people have done they've done it with single day options in tech stocks they've done it with options in general and they've done it with crypto and it's much easier to speculate in something that has a trend as opposed to a random distribution right so if it's trending even if you buy generalized shit you can make money in crypto at this point but that's not an endorsement for that at all it's an endorsement for the speculative behavior because they don't get a chance and this is what people also don't understand is okay so we try and educate them so listen if you want just buy some bitcoin or some eth let's use bitcoins easy numbers so they've got 10 grand in savings they can't buy a house they can't make a deposit they can't do any of it so then they look at Bitcoin and so where do you think Bitcoin's gonna go a million dollars okay that's a 14x my 140 grand in five years time probably still won't get me the deposit on a house so what do they do they look for bigger risk rewards and they're not given the tools because a lot of people in new investors don't really know this is one of the things that you guys do and we do it real vision is really trying so okay if you're gonna speculate you're gonna take more risk well I'm gonna judge you for it but we're gonna try and help you do it yeah and this is this whole don't fuck this up thesis that I've got my t-shirt what is that thesis but don't fuck this up it's something that's actually been been now trending all over twitch in fact somebody's even started a mean coin completely against the idea of it so don't fuck this up it's like this is the biggest gift the biggest macro opportunity of all time right it's been ongoing really since like 2010 but investibly for most of us 2013 or so this is the biggest thing of all time what what is specifically like crypto investing in crypto is the fastest adoption of any technology the world has ever seen except for AI that's just come the fastest accumulation in value of any asset class and all recorded history the fastest growth of number of users i adoption of any asset class in history the largest price appreciation in returns of any asset class in history right this thing is an alien and it is the biggest gift to people and I've talked about this for almost a decade now oh from a decade from when we started real vision this is a absolute fucking gift so what are you supposed to do to take the gift don't fuck it up and what that means is own the large crypto that have proven network effects there are only three with network effects right now that are fully proven out Bitcoin, ETH and Solana has has come into that fray and has got provable network effects there are many others that have some elements of network effects that are slightly lower down okay but let's assume you could put your money in those three you'll be fine put 90% of your assets there they will go up well if you did an equally weighted basket you'll do very well thank you very much 10% feed you're in a DGEM do it the fuck you want to coin and you will learn you will learn very quickly like all of us have you will end up with a wallet of shame in 2026 and you'll look at it and go really did I own that shit but you'll have had fun doing it you'll learn to bunch of lessons and who knows you might get the 100x you probably won't you know you'll see somebody on Twitter getting it and you think it can be me it can be me and you'll do the rotations at the wrong time but this way you get to participate in the madness because it's kind of fun but what can you lose 10% what's the rest of your portfolio gonna do 5x you'll be fine so don't fuck this up is that is one secondly don't use leverage leverage is just a way of you to have your coins taken away from you your one job is not to lose your coins right you just hold them for the longest period of time the more money you will make over time so just don't let anybody have your coins that's why I don't use DeFi you know anything that is involving yield is taking an extra risk staking is different you've got the currency risk in staking which is your eth goes down your soul goes down or whatever it is but I assume people are prepared to do that because they're already in those assets anyway but once you start getting to restaking or all sorts of different stuff you're assuming a different risk from the market in which you may have to part with your coins that is rule number one don't park with your coins do that mean a 10% bucket run a play around DeFi do that but just don't park with your coins this is the same thing about what happened with all the sexes and the centralized exchange is what happened with everything is that the other thing is self-custody at worst leave it on Coinbase it's a government monopoly but at best self-custody don't park with your coins I've had money in mf global when that blew up as a bank I lost all of my investments and it took seven years of court cases to get them back and everyone's going through that now in crypto don't lose your coins so it's it's pretty simple that's the don't fuck this up he says it's like hashtag dt f you and people resonate because so many people fucked it up last time around yeah I think I think that is incredibly let me just plus one that is incredibly practical advice and I think you're you're right in in terms of especially first and second cyclers they need some portion of their portfolio to play the games it almost sounds like a you know a sex ed type class right is the reason abstinence never works you know you got to teach them kind of a safe investing basically and that's what we're talking about here in these cycles I want to get back to you that comment that you said because some people will say well you're actually wrong about this you're saying crypto is being adopted even like faster than the internet but like we don't see it where the real use cases yes we see it in gambling we see it in in meme coins how so how when you think about adoption you say it's being adopted faster than the internet faster than any technology aside from AI how do you measure that I was looking at a tweet and I think the the source of this is crypto users maybe crypto dot com study in partnered with world bank crypto users versus internet users yearly growth and then it kind of charts over a 10 year time period what crypto is on a trajectory to do as compared to the early internet and I think they measure this by the number of people around the world who are holders of crypto assets is that how you measure is that a fair proxy they're using and everyone will debate this but but that's very mid curve what this is is okay we're looking at rates of growth so it says 516 million I think the number now is 550 or something million people okay there is not 550 million people it's 550 million active addresses but what are we comparing it to the internet what are those numbers IP addresses how many IP addresses do you have I have no fucking clue how many wallets do I have I have no fucking clue it's a lot right compare them that's all you're trying to do so that's you know anybody argues in the middle is just again mid curving it oh well there's not that many users so let's go back to the use case wealth is a use case people are making money that money gets recycled to the economy that's good so creating something that has value all value is a mimetic it's perceived value it doesn't have to be utility value gold is a mimetic religion is a mimetic so don't overthink that again very mid curve when people start talking about what is the value okay stable coins what are stable coins remember the story of the euro dollar market well the euro dollar market is great for companies who need to borrow and lend dollars because most 87% of world traders in dollars what about people you ever try to go in the bank in the Philippines or India and try and get dollars is not easy but now they've got a fractionalized euro dollar market okay I mean this is dollar dominance writ large right okay so that's super interesting but it gets more interesting than that because stable coins are being used by corporations so there's there's capital controls in Indonesia and Malaysia and in China but those two nations trade with each other a lot so as opposed to filling out all the paperwork for capital controls you know having to do all of this they're using stable coins for instant payment Brazil is doing a lot of this as well so we're seeing a lot of uses of this globalized dollar market which is the stablecoin market it's on crypto rails it's like private sector cvdc's but for dollars okay fine that's great and that's big then we've got you know we're obviously seeing the beginning of deep in that's interesting you know some of these are getting quite big helium's getting pretty big hive map is getting pretty big so very interesting we've got to mark that down as okay there's some real use cases of bootstrapping networks by using tokenized incentive systems and building on a web3 stack great um we are seeing the financial system building on top we know because they've all said and this is my thesis from 2013 the entire financial system will go on tokenized rails why is it not already because it doesn't work fast enough yet just it cannot simply support at the level of security the financial system just can't do it now we're getting one step closer with when fire dancer comes why fire dancer matters jump trading they understand the game are we there yet with ethereum no so it has to be a settlement layer okay that's fine there and works well as a settlement layer but will they use a regular layer two for this what for the entire futures industry no they're going to have to find something now whether that's a NASDAQ layer two well we've just seen that with base okay that's interesting so look everything is coming into place for that and we're seeing asset managers testing out this thesis by tokenizing stuff but we we haven't even started that game yet but when Larry think the world's largest asset manager tells you he wants to tokenize every single thing I tell you that every single firm in history understands this too how big of a deal is that that's been new this cycle you know I remember all the previous cycles of institutions are coming and like one meme what is more institutional than blackrock and Larry think saying right where policy is like I knew all these people in 2020 I was talking to them all they're all building goldman JP Morgan Morgan Stanley blackrock Apollo I mean every single firm has a web 3 team a blockchain team all of them so they know it's coming but they've got the same speed bumps that we've all got to face which is the bloody US regulators well do they do they have some leverage there I've always thought that you know the black rocks of the world would be a heat shield would be sort of like they would absorb they would push the the US government apparatus in a certain direction right I know it's not kind of one in the same when they're ready when they're ready there's no point pushing for the tokenization of all assets when we don't even have a blockchain that can support it I mean that that would be done we would score an own goal and so would they now you know Australia tried to tokenize their exchange gave up for anyone work for London stock exchange they looked at it for a number of different things many of the futures exchange have looked at it we're just not there yet we're just not there yet so you know there are some protocols that are getting closer you know sweet which I'm on the foundation of just so disclose that object-based move protocol is is bloody fast as a layer one and very interesting they've got chance so but we're still not there yet the compute's not big enough to do to manage it all you know we've just seen Solana with its scaling problems you know ETH went through this last time around if you go back to the you know 2020 2021 ETH was had the same problem massive congestion issues bitcoins out at before it's normal that's what adoption looks like but we're just not ready for it yet so it is coming gaming that's another one and people like people don't really understand why we want games feels like a force narrative but the force narrative will reveal itself over time once you realize that the assets that you own in one world may be transferable to another world or just transferable into money mantle formerly known as bitdown is the first Dowled web3 ecosystem all built on top of mantle's first core product the mantle network a brand new high-performance Ethereum layer 2 built using the OP stack but uses eigenlayers data availability solution instead of the expensive Ethereum layer one not only does this reduce mantle networks gas fees by 80% but it also reduces gas fee volatility providing a more stable foundation for mantle's applications the mantle treasury is one of the biggest Dow owned treasuries which is seeding an ecosystem of projects from all around the web3 space for mantle mantle already has subcommunities from around web3 onboarded like game 7 for web3 gaming and buy bit for tvl and liquidity in on-rounds so if you want to build on the mantle network mantle is offering a grants program that provides milestone based funding to promising projects that help expand secure and decentralized mantle if you want to get started working with the first Dowled layer 2 ecosystem check out mantle at mantle.
xyz and follow them on twitter at 0x mantle are you launching a token is it already live how are you managing the legal and tax obligations for providing token grants to your team it's no secret that token management gets complicated between learning all the legal language and tax obligations in every country that your team is in token grant management can feel like an obstacle course but it doesn't have to that's where toku steps in toku provides practical tools to handle token grants allowing for effective oversight of token distributions and payroll tax compliance for employees contractors advisors and investors they also handle tax withholdings through their realtime tax calculations that can be done by toku or integrated into any payroll EOR providers in any jurisdiction toku is a trusted provider of protocol labs dydx foundation mean a protocol and many more get started for free and make token compensation simple at toku.
com slash bankless welcome to consensus 2024 consensus is one of the biggest hubs for all things crypto blockchain and web 3 this may consensus is celebrating 10 years of decentralizing the future going to consensus means being in good company with over 15,000 attendees from over a hundred countries you have the opportunity to learn directly from the architects and advocates representing bitcoin ethereum salana along with the teams from popular layer 2s like mantle arbitrum optimism base and others but consensus is more than just discussions and presentations bachelors get access to it in his 10 professional karate combat fights and one unprofessional one between myself and the Carter for the visionaries pitch fest is your spotlight presenting a stage for the most promising early stage web 3 companies and for the devs the hackathon offers a unique chance to build your next project or take your existing project to the next level immerse yourself in hundreds of side events and hacker houses scattered around awesome register for consensus 2024 today and save 20% with code bankless so the contours of the bull market that we're in you think it'll be a four four seasons bull market like the previous three right so where where we have our our spring which we've had in our summer and then our fall in our winter and the the timeline will roughly roughly correspond to the previous in these four years cycles and not because of the happening more because of kind of like global liquidity and election cycles and what the rest of the world is doing just happens that the happening kind of is on that same schedule as well that's kind of your your your base case for the cycle and in in in the seasons themselves so we aren't now in summertime the assets that will appreciate most do you think is this kind of like blue chip bitcoin ethos salana or you also said kind of like moving out to all coins or is it impossible to predict is it kind of like these narratives that pop up over time what benefits have observed is things that are getting adoption that are earlier on the reduction curve outperform so if killed it last cycle as a chain going from it's been proven now it's gone for its bad times Lindy effect in play okay now it then exploded 47x from the from the low right and then establish itself firmly as the second most dominant player in the space if you remember last cycle there's three breakouts really well four one was lunar that went three breakouts one was salana one was avalanche and the other was probably polygon now who was the winner well the one that got the most adoption end up being salana it was the one that came from the bottom down 97 and a half percent from this cycle like ethos the previous cycle it's gone into now accepted as an adopted ecosystem at scale who's the next one who's the next salana the next eth of this cycle that's where the real money gets made because those first cycle you've got nothing to compare it against you can't say oh it's helped already up five x versus all time high you've got nothing just blue sky charts and that's why you tend to get these ridiculous first first time runs like salana last time and i'm very interested in what that's going to be i've got two or three ideas what it might be but who the hell i mean i'm just not good at this get i'm good at the next bit which is see what's getting adoption properly and then that one that trade is relatively easy this trade is is more difficult to figure out what is it going to be did you want to share any thoughts you have on like what it's going to be yeah listening to people like christ binesky melton de mires seeing what i've seen with stuff like the two e foundation i go with the thesis that there are two ecosystems that are probably going to be in the race here the layer one race you know the big adoption because layer two is a different conversation it's i think it's the move protocol that's the sui aptos you know may the best man win kind of game there because it's different has a lot of different use cases and then there's cosmos um celestial and others that those feel like okay that's the game to be played maybe avalanche again but doesn't feel like it should have happened it got it last cycle doesn't feel like it's getting full-scale adoptions kind of in that lower tier you know layer two's that's a whole different game being played out but that's not this game um so that's that's how i'm thinking about it and there could be something else entirely that i've missed just because it's not on my radar screen because you know when it happens it happens fast well do you think retail is here uh like the meme coins that we were mentioning earlier is that example of retail or is that just like crypto natives playing games yeah it's us lot fucking around does retail come during the summer or like what's gonna bring them yes so cast your mind back to the previous time okay where are we april 10th half of everybody was still in lockdown at that point we hadn't had the halving and in fact Bitcoin was still on its way down i think by april 10th i can't remember what that flush out date was it was maybe now maybe it was at april 10th 2020 i can't remember it was something like that so i would say yes it's early for retail i don't get many messages i still have cynical friends only got to be careful with this stuff you know i don't get them foe mowing yeah we will know because you get those messages i've had a few but a lot of them because they you know whether it's family members and stuff they've kind of kept an eye on this thing for a while but otherwise no retail's not in and you know how i can tell the easiest way is coin-based active wallets right so they have 110 million wallets or accounts sorry and as of about six months nine months ago there was nine million active i haven't checked the last quarterly numbers but let's assume it's like 10 or 11 million and speaking to the guys at coin-based they're like yeah probably assuming the market doesn't grow which of course it will it should be at 35 40 million now okay the ETF takes some of that but you know most young people won't just buy Bitcoin it doesn't take long before they're straight out the risk of buying whiff and then derivatives of whiff and then you know it just doesn't take only with that 10% though right well i want to go back to the conversation we were previously touching on which is like the the layer one race the layer one game because i think you identified a pattern that i really want to talk about a little bit more where you have like Ethereum had its breakout year in 2017 and then it's like maturity year in 2021 where we discovered 600-gay gas prices and then like the first reactions to Ethereum Bitcoin went through that same cycle one cycle earlier right it had its breakout year in like 2014 and then its maturity year actually like coming into its like it's like more modern shoes in 2017 Solana had its breakout year in 2021 that was its first big introduction into the into the and now it's having its maturity year you're suing you're seeing this with like just the the the bottleneck that's being hit with the failed transactions in the Solana ecosystem so now it's having its maturity year and you're kind of just saying like hey like cycles repeat every single bull market we seem to get like a new layer layer one player entering the game and then there's like a handful of contenders here do you think that this is a game that just always is played like every single cycle we get like a new layer one to really be a new plate new valid player we go back to our previous conversation about where are the use cases for blockchains and do we have suitable blockchains there yet the answer is no probably not in their current form now many of these evolved like Ethereum keeps evolving it gets better and better it makes great opportunities it created this time around the great opportunities for the two's by collapsing the fees and all this kind of stuff right we're getting there but there is still space probably for four or five blockchains that dominate and then over time maybe it migrates down to three whoever they may be we have no idea because even Bitcoin has come into the race by actually allowing some developmental thing now right finally grandad woke up and so I think it repeats for a bit then we're going to get at some point whether it's this cycle or next cycle we're going to say we're going to have to ask ourselves have we overbuilt block space because every capital cycle comes through this right the mobile phone cycle the 3g the 5g that the broadband fiber optic I mean they all do it so maybe that's just means that the you know everything passed number three four or five just never recovers even close again maybe that's one way or maybe we miss a cycle at some point because we've got so much excess capacity don't know I'm still thinking that one through yeah well at the very least at least we will be able to know what crypto can really do when it has abundant block space that's always been a mystery because we haven't really seen what's what we can do with like literally free transactions there's been like a number of startups the number of chains and other projects that that we look at in this space that are now actually getting into the world of just like oh we're going to just pay our users transaction fees we're just going to eliminate that from their entire experience because block space is so cheap so you don't know what that unlocks I mean cloud compute did this right exactly the same you know if you just step back is all of these people in the business of selling block space with an incentivized token to do so right it's no different than any other network structure cloud computing being one of them and in the end there's still quite a lot of cloud providers but 80% of the markets in three different companies and then there's you know others that you'll use there's a general level of introperability on the internet generally and it kind of work it feels like it's going to be that and then the excess capacity of cloud means that it just costs us nothing now you know we're storing you know terabytes and terabytes of stupid photographs that we'll never look at again because it costs us like two dollars okay so well it's fantastic that we have entered this world of abundant block space supply and finally we get to like really take off the the breaks of what it means to be like a blockchain developer using you know trustless block space to do your crypto things I do also want to put identify a line in the sand that's being drawn here that like you identified earlier which is like the ETF line Bitcoin has its ETFs I think Ethereum will get its ETFs is pretty well assumed that Ethereum whether it gets it's in made at the May deadline or November at the November deadline or in 2025 like whatever it doesn't really matter it's just assumed that Ethereum is getting its ETF and then down below the ETH in ETH network in the market cap stack like any other network is like minimum three years plus before getting an ETF and three years is like very optimistic like first you have to get your futures ETF and then you have to get your spot ETF and so they're like a line that's being drawn between Bitcoin and the rest of the market how do you how do you think about this particular part of this phase of crypto I don't think it matters okay between Bitcoin and ETH you capture the essential entire narrative of the space which is internet compute you know the the value layer of the internet all of the big picture ETH stuff and with the Bitcoin narrative the store of value the anti debatement though whatever right so you've carried you've covered both the technology investment and the money argument now I know everyone fights over all this shit but let's just simplify it so you you put the RAAs the boomers through this channel the millennials can put it into their 401k which is actually a very big deal and may change what the structure of their markets look like because you can put every two weeks your paycheck into this interesting and then what that creates is the whole ongoing risk curve you don't need Solana or avalanche to be tokenized it just I mean to be ETF created an ETF it doesn't make a difference it doesn't need the direct flows to win the narrative needs the direct flows to win and it comes through out the risk curve the other side so I just don't think everything needs an ETF so you're kind of you're saying as long as the pipes to the top of the market the Bitcoin ETF so long as those pipes are sufficiently wide then capital will get recycled and the benefits the tailwinds will be blown down the market cap stack and so like all of the other chains will also experience the network the positive effects of the ETF yeah yeah yeah exactly now at some point we will get an index ETF that's interesting it's just explaining a little bit more about that an index like you're talking about the logo of the entire crypto market cap or like a selected basket or just a little bit more because of the complications of how many things are in it you don't want it for everything but you know the top there's meme coins I would exclude from from that index yeah like 99.
99% of them but call it top 10 top 30 you know because you want to get some of the non-layer one layer two stuff you want to get some of the deep in and gaming and AI and stuff so call it top 50 yeah top layer you get app layer network layer because that's those are the two things here it's the applications layer in the network layer yeah you just have like a black rock crypto 30 or something right you know how I think about this and you know what you know I've got an asset management company exponential age management we have a fund of funds which are investing crypto hedge funds the entire thesis is this market is going from 2.
7 trillion to call it 12 trillion this cycle to 100 trillion by maybe the end of the 30 32 cycle wow wow okay that's just that log adoption curve that I showed you the internet it backs out same numbers same numbers if you back out the logarithmic regression channel of Bitcoin right you get to these numbers so this is I think in front of us the largest fastest accumulation of wealth in all human history I know it sounds bananas now but when you double you know we double a 2.7 trillion market cap 5 whatever but once you double a 12 trillion at the peak of the cycle it's 25 trillion double it again okay these numbers are getting lol that's exponentials for you so you need to capture the two parts of this equation which is the network layer which is where that value really gets accrued and the applications layer the applications layer is twofold one is some of its token ice and other is the equity layer that you guys at a VC firm so you are capturing a lot of the applications layer and all I'm trying to do here is is is capture that these are this is why it's so important that hold don't fuck this up it's like just it's not hard it's not it's not complicated right it's the one is but it won't be but it won't be eth and bitcoin the the crews you know they they get to a certain level but it's the whole tale of the space being worth more as you start building use cases and whatever that's where the real game gets played in the end the real anchoring is here and that's why index will do very well over time and we've seen that from the NASDAQ new technology comes in ends up becoming Microsoft at the top of the pile and it starts moving the whole index and then it concentrates and then more money flows into the index it flows into those and before you know you've got this reflexive loop going on so but we don't have that ability right now so you know it's a complex game which is what we farm out of hedge funds to do it because they're job and give 14 hedge funds other people I mean there is a tokenized I haven't used it but there is a tokenized index somebody's got token I don't know how legal it is what we can do there's also the bitwise I've got a product but then those are closed and funds and that has its own set of problems so it's not solved yet to make it super easy oh we've talked about the seasons of spring summer and fall we haven't yet talked about the next winter and I don't want to be a buzzkill on this episode but I'm interested in what you think the next winter will actually look like and you mentioned something interesting just in passing you said just the existence of a Bitcoin ETF means millennials can maybe dollar cost average paychecks into 401k and that's different are there any factors that make you think that the next winter whether that comes in you know 25 2026 something wherever the timeline is do you think that that will be different or do you think we end up with something like 2022 and man 2022 or shallow winter yeah it was painful we had scammers we had grifters we had insolvency I'm glad we're done with that I don't know if it's the worst winter the ICO mania bull bust was a bad was bad but like this seemed also pretty bad are we in store for another long like Game of Thrones style winter here well they all lost the same period of time to wait didn't didn't the 2022 2023 I thought that one was meaningfully shorter than the 20 a 17 to 20 20 bear market 2018 they're all generally a year they just feel like misery and death right you feel the six months really bad it was literally six months peak to trough of eight was six months yeah so but we like this narrative oh my god it's fucking drama it's like listen cycles are a function of the space everybody is so scarred if you're in this for the long run accept them don't even care about them I didn't do a damn thing over the last down cycle because I've been through on before so I skipped one I've done two out the three so I've got my stripes but I did what I didn't do the first one I did properly this time which was I bought as much as I could given whatever cash flow I can I could get in the depths of the bear market and I bought two things one was the Ethereum and one was Solana and I did exactly that and it compounded my returns so before anywhere near the markets were through all time highs I was through all time highs I did the right thing and people think they can be clever and cute they think I'm going to time this thing we've already talked about how difficult crypto fall is do you have a spike does it finish early you don't know the easier game is to say I don't care I'm just going to continue buying it but then there's another thing is like some people it they're particularly in the first cycle or even the second cycle it starts to really matter like I can do with this cash I want to buy a house one do it do that if you're lucky enough you could sell half your portfolio completely secure lifestyle gains in whatever that means to you and then you just run the rest and enjoy the bear market for the ridiculousness that it is all of the drama who's going to go bust whose leverage got caught out all of that just go with it this matter as long as you're self-customing your tokens it really none of it touches you you just kind of laugh at it and then try and add to it so you take some off the table if you want I didn't purposely because I did not want to take anything off the table I wanted to just keep adding to it because here's a different thing so let's say you've put a thousand dollars in it goes up to ten thousand dollars you're feeling amazing and you time the top you time the top you take it out your thousand dollars means a lot to you and the market's now down 75% you will not put in a thousand dollars you just won't do it everybody psychologically thinks well I just take out top and buy it back then you won't you'll put in a hundred dollars and then before you know you're chasing it all the way up and you've just fucked the whole thing up to start with just you just don't need the stress so take some chips off the table just run the rest and then add when you can well the the way we're articulating this it's like you know this is our the fourth time around for crypto and you said this is the biggest wealth generating opportunity and it's the most obvious trade maybe to like to ever exist in our lifetimes and yet and yet smart investors quote unquote are still missing this and there are many skeptics you're like you mentioned you still have friends who who text you and and you have these skeptics you put out this tweet that said I find it interesting that most of the world's greatest macro investors are big crypto and tech investors both public and private markets so you mentioned a standee a drunken miller Paul Tudor drones Alan Howard Steve Cohen some of these but you said many macro posters I think you you're saying who wish to emulate them on x are still skeptics it's a posters or poses yeah so there's a lot of posters out there posters on x who are still skeptical yet some of the brightest macro minds are bought into crypto some are not though we're quote unquote smart investors what is keeping the skeptics away from this asset class who still remains to be convinced so if you are an equity stock picking hedge fund manager who's famous for his long short bets to admit that there's basically a free trade that's been on the table questions your whole purpose it just that sounds like just ego oh yeah well don't forget you've got thousands of investors you're managing 50 billion of their capital and you just go you know what this better this trades better I'm off okay that there's a real psychological hurdle to admit that long short value investing whatever doesn't prefer outperform and what you get is that plastic bell curve that I now find everywhere it is the most important chart of all time is like number go up on the left number go up on the right in the middle is now it's impossible to can't you see the risk you're taking don't you know it's cyclical it goes down 80% blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah they're all in the middle of the bell curve because they don't know except the simple stupid facts that a network that attracts more people is worth more and in crypto you happen to be able to own that network it's just it's built for number go up but they just think well this is crazy you know this yes it really is that easy if you are actually and that's why if we talk about why you don't the top three over anything else it's because those networks have been adopted so just adding incremental people in number incrementally go up it's just not complicated but God people complicate this whole game and they find it as if there's a philosophical war that they have to it's because it questions everything you know I got to this that in 2021 and I started really uncovering this everything code and the debatement and everything else and I divide everything by the bed balance sheet and I saw that technology and crypto were the only things out before that shattered my macro old school beliefs that everything that tech itself crypto I've been in forever but tech was a bubble that it was it was just always overpriced and can't people see and one day it's all going to crash and blah blah blah and then I realized no it's just network effects these companies just keep growing and it took me a while to completely abandon my framework where I would be looking for the down cycle to make the gains because they come fast in a down cycle if you're sure and completely switch mind most people won't do that I completely changed my framework and then when I started dividing Nasdaq by Bitcoin because it's got the longest history it's like it's down 99.
97% so what the fucking point is the road and anything else only anything else even adjusted for the 97.5% for the 85% for the 75% for the even adjusting for all of that it's beaten the Nasdaq by 99.97% well I was trying to figure out coming to this I was going to not be made by 97% Nasdaq's underperformed by 99.97% I was going to ask you coming into this at the end is just get to kind of summarize how you think of yourself as an investor if you're to sort of classify yourself you know there's fundamentals investors there's you know long short types of investors maybe you're a macro investor but in hearing you talk this way I feel like maybe my observation is like maybe you are doing two things like really well one is like you are a debatement avoider so you look at debatement and you try to avoid all of that stuff so that you can preserve your wealth and that seems to allow you to pick the asset classes that are most interesting for avoiding debatement without any ideology yeah without ideology and then what you do is you layer a second layer of analysis here which is like you're looking for network effect and you're measuring that network effect like through some metric pretty obvious metric that's out there and open in public and then you are disciplined with those so you're avoiding debatement picking your your asset classes and then you're looking for network effect and investing in that well well is that like an accurate kind of framing of how you think about the world and what you do or what would you add to that so what you've done there is identify my secular thesis so I'm actually a long-term investor that uses a secular thesis I used I used to always have a secular thesis and then use the business cycle more and be in the time frame of the business cycle this would be like when am I going to time the top in crypto but I now actually an 80% weighted to the secular thesis because that's where all the gains are and it's a bit mid curve to be fucking around with the business cycle too much it was great to get me my entry into eth and soul in 2022 because I used my liquidity cycle framework the business cycle framework great it'll give me some idea of when I might want to take some lifestyle chips off the table so I don't run everything through the winter not because I don't want to because I want to take some chips off the table to do some lifestyle stuff okay fine so actually I'm a secular long-term thematic investor that have broken it down to a couple of simple KPIs because I like to keep things super simple and then I use a business cycle and a bit of charting to help me understand where I am in that journey well what's the secular part secular trend is a long-term trend so demographics right that this is all driven by demographics because it's the demographics that drove that it was World War II that drove people to have too many kids which drove the wages never going up because there was too many baby boomers in the workforce at the same time which drove the American dream dying so they borrowed more money to make up which drove the use of monetary policy and ongoing debatement of currency which then the whole and that was the birth of Bitcoin because the banks blew up it's all driven actually by the demographics post World War II that's a secular thing India is the opposite demographics right 28 years old average population 1.
4 billion 28 year olds pretty smart probably going up because GDP growth equals population growth plus productivity growth plus debt growth India has low debts productivity is increasing as you come out of the fields and into the productive economy particularly India because it's it's got this whole fintech layer and then you add population growth well they got plenty of those and they're 28 years old so secular themes long term you know decade decade two decade themes those are really investible make that easy they make any idiot money technology all you have to do is by the fucking NASDAQ so all you have to do you have to one trade in your entire life which is by the NASDAQ and you've done absolutely fine and outperformed 99% of all hedge fund managers half the VCs on the planet and and every active fund pass I mean it's one again it's just what a secular trend so what is your portfolio like these days like in terms of like percentage crypto percentage and you know what I know your style like we're not looking for anything exotic right unless you write unless you want to disclose but a boring portfolio can be a fantastic portfolio but I'm curious how do you think about allocation across different crypto non crypto asset classes and then just things generally so people shouldn't emulate me because I've got a lot of experience with risk taking and I'm comfortable with the risk that I'm taking don't use I don't use leverage you know I use external custody multi sig all of the things you know so and I'm very focused on my thesis which is your dead right it's the network thesis so I then look at charts of assets relative to each other so I was looking at the Bitcoin ETH chart which I follow closely which has been unfolding and I think it's basing as we talked about but the chart to me that there's a standout in 2022 was the sole ETH chart and that was the chart that got me buying Solana and then going all in much like I went into ETH all in in about no September 2020 2020 right I just did it earlier in Solana and so I am 90 80% sole all of my ETH is now NFTs I've been buying high end art NFTs I then have a bunch of the portfolio in the fund of hedge funds in exponential age asset management and I have 1% in stupid shit like with like with those and bonk goal of those but that's 1% so even when I post about on Twitter I'm sure some guy is going to some joker in 2026 and saying you were recommending with just to be clear I've got like in all of meme coins and everything else 1% of my portfolio I'm 90% 80% Solana well what if like part of our target audience I think is the up-and-comer up-and-coming investor who might be on their second cycle like maybe even their first cycle and I think a lot of people are entering crypto for that once in a lifetime opportunity right and they're focused on how can I become financially independent besides kind of the don't effort up strategy which is a good kind of like you know general advisor maybe that's the ticket how do you think they should invest like how do you think they should approach investing in general in terms of where they should allocate their time resources all of these things I think the important thing is the DTFU strategy number one second educate yourself educate yourself from the right people so get your source of information from the right people and actually do some education there are yeah available courses you know that are free or paid that are valuable like in fact coming up next week we've got the festival of learning and real vision there's tons of people coming to that and it's free and we're there to teach you how to trade in mean coins how to trade in NFTs and we've got a bunch of people who really know this stuff there's a whole thing on Solana there's a whole bunch of other stuff all about learning so I got a real vision.
com forward slash festival I think it is and it's free go and do that educate yourself because then eventually let's set cycle two you two can take the eth best of the last cycle the Solana bit of this cycle whatever it is I'm still not good enough to do the next bit which is like who's going to be the next one of this I can do that who's going to be the number three that's easy easier but you can't do that without educating yourself studying the space understanding the players listening to the narratives finally out where the opportunities are so that's the key DTFU just keep it simple stupid but learn and next time around you'll really make money.
Well this has been a lot of fun thank you for guiding us through this this cycle and giving us some context here I think you're the perfect guest to have on this so aside from the festival of learning which you just mentioned what else you guys up to at real vision yeah look the other thing is I've got a youtube channel called the journey man and if you heard me speak you can hear that what I'm actually looking at is a very big secular thesis about where this is all going and why it matters so the journey man is my journey to the nexus of macro crypto and the exponential age of technology because we're all going to that place which I think of as some sort of economic singularity which is something I'll come back on and talk another time to you guys about but I interviewed some incredible people on that and to nudge people along and I also do some other stuff like some lifestyle stuff this and longevity interviews I've got one about wine coming out just because we're all in this journey together right and we want to have some fun we want to learn some stuff on route and so that's what the journey man is all about so if you if you haven't watched it just go over there subscribe to that you get some killer content we will include a link for sure in the show notes I'm curious says the AI bug gotten to you Raoul is a you know part of the exponential age for sure it's a huge tech theme I was probably the first of the kind of major podcasts of stuff to cover this because Emma Mosteck who started stability AI but you you guys know yes yes yeah we just had a mom yeah and Emma was an old friend of mine who's a global macro investor subscribe oh wow no way I'm ready for like 15 year so we had him on before chat GPT three came out before everything just as he was launching and so yeah I've been I've got a whole a whole research service called the exponentialist with another person called David Matin it's paid service where this is all it's about now blockchain technology is part of it but it's the whole exponential age it's AI it's robotics it's EV it's Internet of things it's blockchain technology it's genetic sciences it's the science of longevity it's all of that and we cover it all this portfolio all of that stuff it's really really I wish see you know the one thing I wish about all that the AI stuff the cool stuff that's going on it was it is that it was I wish it was a bit more accessible for under credit investors for kind of retail that that has been the beauty of crypto right anybody in the world anywhere can buy Bitcoin doesn't matter how much like a net worth they have or whether they're at credit investor status whereas you know the open a eyes of the world the chat GPT is it's all VC stuff and it's much less accessible for kind of the up-and-comer you know learning investing in this field I it's even worse than that nobody gets a look in an open AI yeah right this is basically a monopolistic play and they've created a monopoly alongside another monopoly which is Microsoft Facebook have their own monopolistic play with Lama you know there's there's no look in here now there's another issue that I've got with this entire space I think open AI are using some form of early stage AGI to build product Sam Altman has said all the way through is I can't take you to there without going through steps because you're not ready I think they know what there is and what you do with an AGI is like how do I get the world ready for AGI well you build out these incremental things and this look at 500 people 500 people build products across so many verticals and every three months destroy all competition every single time if you just observe what the fuck is going on here we've never seen anything like this this rate of innovation speed of market and total disruption of existing players that happens makes me concerned that as it becomes normal to use AGI or AI to build product so Ryan and David have this new cool product this is amazing you know looking decentralized application with funky UX and it's really interesting I just give it to my AGI and so just copy that but do it for the Indian market it's bigger and it would say I don't do it for India do it for this this in this market because this market's great and you'll get it up what world is that how long does anything last everything becomes like a mean coin at that point so I don't think I worry actually about things like venture capital in 2030 something 2030 I've used as the date beyond that I I don't see how vehicles for long-term capital cycles will work in very short capital cycle markets I think the only way is to tokenize this stuff and it becomes how much attention is the product get before it gets disrupted it's you know that again this is a lot much longer conversation we should all have that I can't do today but this is where I think the world is going and this is just part of the big picture that I call the economic singularity and so this AI thing I think it's good that it's not investable as well I think it's going to destroy so much capital because of this dynamic the dynamic is everybody gets replaced by who's got the fastest and best AGI and then you're going to get into what the hell is a financial market when there's an AGI how do we even stand a chance yeah there's a but this is a topic that stuff I write a lot about in the exponentialist it's super interesting well I think we'll have to leave this episode then since for a short of time I'm going to to be continued and I'll have to bring you back and talk about the intersection of your AI and even crypto maybe maybe crypto's got some tools up its sleeve to kind of stave off some of that capital destruction at least one of my greatest mid curve moments this year I've been trying not to mid curve things I've been trying to be done with this cycle I've been trying to be dumber and it was the dumb one is is like we all saw world coin everyone laughed at it blah blah and they were here in Cayman because their foundations here and they asked me to come on this panel with them and I was chatting to them I'm like why what what are you doing why did you just create the world's worst narrative possible and they're like yeah we've kind of got it wrong we're still down what it is you're doing to me please because I can see you've got this passport and this net thing and it's proof of humanity blah blah and they just answered with such perfection well Sam figured out in 2020 that the AI he's building is going to create a huge problem on the internet when nobody's going to know who's human and who's AI so he built world coin I'm like if you just said that he woke up 50 x in the first few days but they didn't and so and then I I walked away from that thing thinking and it it had been stuck at like dollar and a half rages and I'm like I should buy this you know because this makes sense to me and then I mid-curved it yeah but what is the hardware worth doing it is there approach right blah blah blah what are people going to say next minute it went up 10x I'm like more on rail Sam Altman says goodbye simple you know what sometimes I feel like our service as podcasters is to take the stuff that right curve people say really really smart people say and then distill that so left curve people can actually understand it invest in the concept uh so I don't I don't know if we're providing that service sometimes on bank list but that's what we seek to do um Raul this is always excellent to have you on the show thank you so much for joining us and uh enjoy summertime we're in summer so it's just kick back and relax and we can just enjoy this thing at least for a few months exactly we don't this is not the year we have to worry of course they'll be gut checks they'll be complications generally summer summer times the living is easy there you go a bankless nation this has been Raul Paul gotta end with this of course you know crypto is risky you lose what you put in but we are headed west this is the frontier it's not for everyone but we're glad you're with us on the bank list journey don't effort up you