Zcash founder Zooko Wilcox joins Bankless to argue that privacy is back on the critical path—because AI turns chain surveillance into pattern-recognition at scale—and that the real bottleneck for cypherpunk tools has always been UX and onboarding.
We dig into Zcash’s “encrypted Bitcoin” meme, the dev fund’s evolving design (and why it helped Zcash survive), recent ZEC momentum, and the wallet/intents stack that makes private spending actually usable.
Plus: why “value at rest” beats “value in flight,” what it would take for Ethereum to get meaningful privacy, and the debate over strengthening the 21M cap (and whether Zcash should add new security mechanisms without losing the meme).
------
🔮POLYMARKET | #1 PREDICTION MARKET
https://bankless.cc/polymarket-podcast
🏅BITGET TRADFI | TRADE GOLD WITH USDT
https://bankless.cc/bitget-futures
👑BANKLESS PREMIUM | AD-FREE & BONUS EPISODES
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
🎯THE DEFI REPORT | ONCHAIN INSIGHTS
💰ICO WATCH | UPCOMING PUBLIC TOKEN SALES
------
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
0:46 What Failed
3:58 What Succeeded
5:04 Institutional Adoption
6:53 Areas Neglected
10:51 The Cypherpunk Vision
18:53 Can The Cypherpunks Win?
23:19 Crypto’s Path to Success
27:44 Crypto vs Linux
30:39 AI Cypherpunks?
33:05 Optimism
35:49 AI Surveillance
37:10 Zcash
43:02 Zcash Dev Fund
51:45 Zashi Governance Drama
56:32 Zcash Privacy Practices
1:15:56 AI Privacy Consequences
1:22:31 Is Zec a Store of Value
1:26:01 Encrypted Bitcoin?
1:29:01 Ethereum Privacy & Anoma
1:33:14 Closing & Disclaimers
------
RESOURCES
Zooko
Zcash
Zashi
https://z.cash/ecosystem/zashi-wallet/
Anoma
------
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
No summary for this episode yet.
Okay, so here's the crazy guru metaphysical thing, okay? Remember, this was if you had the eith and you thought to yourself, what I want is to have my eith over in this new wallet that's unlinked. The AI read your mind, it knows you want that. Rewill eventually. You will eventually figure out that that's what you want it, okay? But what if you said this, what I want is to convert half of my eith into zek and hold it and zek. Bankless nature and we are joined by Zuko, the creator of zkash and the former CEO of the electric coin company that's the foundation behind zkash Zuko. Welcome back to bankless.
Thanks, good to be back. Zuko, you've been here for well over a decade in this crypto industry, building zkash for 13 plus years. Has the crypto movement, have we achieved our goals in 2026? We've been around for a while. Have we, have we succeeded? No, geez, it's a leading question. You didn't expect any positive answers to that. Honestly, now that you say that, it makes me kind of depressed and negative. It reminds me of Linux, like back when you were tics and I was young, the Linux was a movement to empower people and free everyone. And then nowadays it's just like some software that Google uses to run its computers.
The Linux movement died one way, faded. What happened there? Yeah, it failed to help users and fail to scale up. And then every user's it was helping. And software engineers will scowl and object when I say this because they still run Linux. But everyone else who's not software engineers is not being helped very much by Linux today. So I can imagine, negatively, let's get out of the negativity after this one. Yeah, crypto could be like that, you know, 10, 15 years from now, it could be something that a couple of mega corporations like cost optimized by using crypto currency or blockchain or something.
And you know, 99.9 percent of the people are not empowered or benefited in any way by it. Oh, it's suck. What if you could trade gold, forex, and global markets with the same tools and speed that you use for crypto? That's exactly what BitGetTradify unlocks. After strong beta demand, including over a hundred million dollars in single day gold trading volume, BitGetTradify is now live for all users. Inside of your existing BitGet account, you can trade 79 instruments across forex, precious metals, indices, and commodities all settled directly in USDT, no platform switching, and no fiat conversions.
This is BitGet's universal exchange vision in action, crypto and traditional finance side by side. You get deep liquidity, low slippage, and leverage up to 500x, letting you apply crypto strategies to macro markets. New to Tradify, start with gold. The gold USD pair is liquid, macro driven, and a familiar natural bridge between crypto and traditional markets. Try trading gold on BitGetNow at bitget.com. Click the link in the show notes for more information. This is not financial advice. Few people in crypto put real skin in the game when they make a public top or bottom calls. The DeFi report is one of them.
The week before the October 10th flash crash, Michael from the DeFi report emailed his entire newsletter, saying he's going aggressively risk off and sold the majority of his book from crypto into cash. This is when ethos about $4,000 in Bitcoin was 110. Michael runs the DeFi report, an industry leading research platform built on data, cycle awareness, risk management, transparency, and most importantly, skin in the game. We like Michael at bankless. We like his analysis, and that's why you hear him on the bankless podcast about once a month. And the DeFi report is giving bankless listeners one free month of access to the DeFi report.
So if you're looking for some sharp data-driven analysis to make better informed decisions around your portfolio, you can learn why and how Michael called the top. And what he's doing next, all in the DeFi report pro. Check it out. There is a link in the show notes. Well, Zuko, let's talk about then the gains we've made over the last decade or so, or since you started Zcash and even before. So I mean, what has succeeded in crypto? What are you excited about? What are you surprised by in terms of our progress? I like technology. I'm a technologist. And what I most love about crypto so far is that it's funded a whole bunch of really good technology, like zero-knowledge proofs that Zcash pioneered, but there's a whole bunch of people, especially in the Ethereum ecosystem, that have taken that very far.
And that's because of crypto funding and organization. As I'm saying, as opposed to DARPA and universities and mega corporations, they wouldn't have developed any of that in the last 10 years without crypto. So the cryptography has been the big win in your mind. Yeah, and that's damning it with St. Praise, right? That's like an approved Linux kernel, which is not actually changing the world for the better. I mean, some people, Zuko, they'll look at price charts, and they'll say we made tremendous progress on that. So the world has a non-stopperen store value now that is digital, that is not gold.
They'll look at Bitcoin, price charts, for instance. They'll call that a win. I think lately there's been a lot of themes around crypto or blockchain's ability to kind of transform Wall Street, for instance. So we're talking about a theme of last year has been suit pointers that are starting to build all these tokenized types of real world assets on top of blockchain's, and that feels maybe like a win. It's not quite the crypto native, like cypherpunk win that we thought, but it is extending the adoption of some of our protocols. I mean, when you see stuff like that, Larry Fink rolling out ETFs, all of all of that, is that progress in your mind like more wallets, more active mallets, more users.
I think of it, and by the way, there's a Zcash debt. Direct it, it's not direct to the cyclic graph, it's a digitalized recovery. It's the cypherpunk debt, and I signed on to be an advisor to that organization, so disclosure. I think I basically only have two professional roles in crypto nowadays, and that's my job as chief product officer at Shilded Labs, and as an advisor to the cypherpunk debt. But I think of those as good things, but only in as much as there means to an end, like improving Wall Street. That would be fine, I guess. It would be good if it was actually improving the lives of people in a way that I care about, which it could, but it hasn't yet.
Does that answer your question for my perspective? Arenas of crypto, do you think we've neglected that we need to reorient some attention and resources towards? Well, it's definitely the cypherpunk vision, and in particular, the Moxie Marlin spikes version. Do you know Moxie Marlin spike to make her a signal? Yes, yes, I know of that person, yes. He was this crazy anarchist hacker. I'm pretty sure it's okay if I say this on the record, but Moxie was a crazy anarchist hacker. And for some reason, I don't know how he realized, he saw something that other people didn't, which was that the cypherpunk dream was stuck on UX.
He got an award when you're for the best cryptographic innovation of the year at cryptography, and he gave a talk, but he required everyone to turn off their camera, so there's no recording, so my vague memories of this are the only evidence we have left. In his talk, he said, the cypherpunk's have totally failed. This was a year ago, and he was talking about the original cypherpunk, right? Like, yeah. And he said the program, the method of the cypherpunk was like that step one will make tools that work well for us, and then step two will teach everyone else in the world to be like us. And he said, as never going to work, never going to work, but instead you have to give people tools that work for them the way they currently are without changing them.
And he said something to the effect that if you have fewer than 100 million users, then you're not affecting the world. It doesn't matter what you're doing as waste of time. So your question was, what are we neglecting in crypto? And I would say I think we're recapitulating Moxie's interpretation of the cypherpunk's project, and the Linux activists Linux project, because it was the same thing. They're going to make an operating system that does everything really well for them and preserves their freedom and their privacy and their ability to choose for themselves and so on. And then they're going to teach everyone else in the world how to use Linux.
I tried it. I was part of that movement a long time ago, both of those movements. So I think crypto is in a pretty similar space, based currently, in terms of why I mainly think of following Moxie again, is it's all about UX. It's all about onboarding and cognitive load to use it. How many new things do you need to learn to use it and to make it do what you wanted to do? And if that is like zero, that's good UX. So we have to make tools. This is kind of the product, the tool side, the UX side, almost the number of users that we touch is now kind of the benchmark. Yeah, let me tell another story from someone else that I admire.
It was Brian Armstrong. This was several years ago during a time when Zcash was like down only technology, number go down. As far as as far as as long as anyone could remember, he'd be number go down. But Brian was always good to give me, gave me the time to talk to me anyway. And we were talking about regulatory risks. This was under the Biden administration, we had the conversation. Like, what do we do? How do we protect users from having their tools taken away by the government? I really appreciate when people give me simple one sentence, one simple sentence answers that I remember. He said, have at least 100 million users.
That was his strategy to solve regulatory risk, which is the same number that Moxie Marlon's bike used in that other talk years earlier. When you think about the cipher punk vision and when you apply that to crypto Zuko, what sort of use cases come to mind? And I guess from observing crypto for so long, there are lots of cipher punk things that have been hope to be achieved by crypto natives. Most notably is kind of money and that Bitcoin doing that money, an idea of payments, that sort of thing. Ethereum sort of expanded a little bit on that money vision with decentralized finance, but that's still finance.
It's still to do with money. Recently, Vitalik has been talking more and trying to resurrect the whole web three thing, I would say. Maybe not using that term, but the idea of a decentralized parallel internet where you have storage and you have completely decentralized compute. How far do you think the crypto cipher punk vision goes? Because there are some I think in the space would say, hey, the main thing that crypto does, it's a ledger, it's about money, it's about debits and credits. Maybe you can extend that to DeFi, but it just sort of stops there. There are others that still believe in this cipher punk, expansive universe of decentralized identity and compute and storage and almost a parallel internet where we can get out of kind of the Silicon Valley, you know, tech, cabal that's ruling our lives and maybe something around decentralized AI.
How far do you think this vision goes in crypto? I hope it goes all the way because that's what people need and want and I think that would make a better world and a more stable and sustainable civilization for our grandchildren to go up in. That's my hope. And then of something, something, something UX, like before signal, there was a well-understood notion among technologists and Linux hackers and cipher punks and cryptographers of secure communication. You know, it's encryption, like public key encryption. It's probably one of the most important discoveries in the history of intelligent life.
And it was all about originally, it was all about secure communication. And so there was science and there was typhoon projects and like computer programming was done, like, well, pretty good privacy, the email encryption program. And there were all, like Moxie said, pretty much total failures, right? They never got anywhere close to 100 million users. And there's something about the Moxie Marlin spike approach to really appreciate, which is start from the user, not from the technology. There's this, you know, stack or span of interacting things. But start from the user and the Moxie Marlin spike approach is this is not especially educated or sophisticated in this particular thing, right?
This is a user who wants to talk to someone, whether or not a cryptographer or a computer program or a Linux hacker. And the basic, he posted recently, he's he's back by the way, Moxie Marlin spike fanboy, our Moxie started posting like a couple weeks ago for the first time in years. He's making a private AI. And in this post, he mentioned something about signal, I think, goes really deep. You said in a sense, the whole idea of signal is that the UX should reflect the underlying reality. I don't remember how he put it, but I'll just tell you my version of it. If you open a chat app, because you want to talk to your friend, and it's not into an encrypted user interface, then a good, accurate user interface would show you the little icon image of your face and your friend's face and the CEO of the company and the system administrators, right?
You know the little window that says who you're talking to, chat app with me. You're looking with you. Look, you're scowling. What do you say? What do you say? I get it. And then I suppose maybe the CIA or whatever three-letter agency would appear in that in one of the boxes, too, if they were listening in. Right. So an accurate UX that tells the user what's really going on and shows all these other parties listening in on your why. And signal just corrects the UX by showing you the actual number and identity of the parties that are on this line. Now I'm still struggling to answer your question how far does it go?
Can we have? Can crypto become decentralized AI and storage and communication and news and social or maybe it won't be even crypto. I mean, there'll be people like Blue Sky is decentralized social. It's not really crypto, right? And there are these decentralized social projects that are crypto native like Farcaster, which I think might have winded down and that Pequiny one, whatever. And I never tried those because they're crypto things. I don't want to talk to people about Bitcoin. So I'm not going to try Bitcoin crypto social network. Whereas Blue Sky, I do use actually. What's my point? My point was your question is can we decentralize all those other things?
And I'm struggling to come up to some answer along the lines of the Moxie Marlon Spike approach, which is people want to do this thing. They want to see what their friends and their friends of friends are talking about today. And we could at a scientific level, it is possible to provide that for them in a way where the user interface and the user experiences is faithful to the truth. Like if you open Twitter today, I'm trying to apply this transformation right now in real time. So this could this could be crazy. But the whole thing where if you open the chat app, you need to see the CEO and the CIA and the other people who are like sitting there in your folder, we can do this with telegram telegram.
So freaking honeypot, it just makes me despair that all the crypto people use telegram. I think it's secure. Like how dumb can crypto people be? Because if you open telegram and you oh, join a group, you got your five friends and yourself and you need to see Pebble Duraub's face in that UX or else it's lying to you. He has a copy, he's receiving a copy of every organization is receiving a copy of everything you type in there. Okay, you can do the same thing with Twitter. You can say, oh, here's the user, the correct fair honest user interface for Twitter doesn't say, here's what your 10 friends talked about in the last hour.
It says, here's the things that Elon must selected for you to see from among the things that your friends have talked about. What I'm saying? You're just looking confused. Now I get it. Anyway, that's my guess. I think people want that as possible to make it. I don't know if it'll come out of crypto. Crypto has been great for funding zero knowledge proof research at least so far. And maybe improving the function of Wall Street and DeFi, I guess I've never done DeFi. I've never taken it alone on the internet. That's great. It's great. It's great. I mean, I think for probably for David and I, I don't want to speak too much for you, David, but we are somewhat skeptical and always have been of use cases beyond the money use cases because it just seems like our ledger technology and even our smart contract ledger technology is kind of built for that.
I'm certainly optimistic at the very least. And wanting to see those use cases. But these things might come out of encryption rather than crypto itself. I guess one last question on the Moxie thread because I'm so glad as you go, you brought that up. That's a really good way to look at it, I think, is can this, can the cipher punks win, though? So when it comes to UX and the talent that that requires and almost the seducing a user, let's say into using an application, it feels like Silicon Valley and the tech overlords have just got us outgunned. They have more money. They have more talents. They have more ways to subsidize different features or hook us on the dopamine drip like they have boiled this down to a science.
They're very good at what they do. And what do we have? What do the cipher punks have? I mean, we have kind of the appeal of freedom and you don't have a third party spying on you. And it doesn't, aside from a small niche of us, it's not clear that the 100 million users will actually come to our products for those things. I'm not sure that we can win this battle, Zuko, like it's kind of the Linux thing. Man, you guys are way more pessimistic than last time. What's going on? Is the number going down? Are you Ethereum folks? Is ETH down? It has been a bad year. That's for sure. No, see, Zcash, Zcashers are the opposite.
All the Zcashers are more optimistic now than ever before. That's why we need you. That's why we need you. I mean, you talk about this. I like your question. That's the competition. And they have all these advantages, especially on the hone skill of this. What advantages do we have? I like that question. It's the great question. I think the answer points to is what Moxie missed. And I think it also explains why our current products are good for DeFi and not for other things. And what Moxie missed is the economic feedback loop. The reason Silicon Valley is super good at that is because they've had like 30 years of a feedback loop where the better they did at it, the more they got money and promotions and status.
They learned and learned and learned and learned from 30 years of rapid feedback looping. And crypto has that, but only for DeFi, right? Like a better DeFi product when it makes more money, right? I assume. Not having tried it. You're right. But signal doesn't make more money in the more users it has. It loses more money in the more users it has, right? Because they pay for the servers and the customer's support on whatever else their costs are their costs are only going to go up the more users they have and they don't make any more money for more users. So that's the missing piece of that strategy.
So yeah, we can totally win. We just have to start with UX and normal users. The user experience that normal users have and have some feedback loop where the better products get more and more fuel poured back into them so that we're not just turning it to Silicon Valley. What is it? Is that that is that's that's not extracted from the user? Like I want the user to pay. Like basically my solution to all the world's problems is simple, which is people pay for stuff and there's open competition, right? There's low there's no effective capture. Therefore, competition will make the things that are better for people more prominent and popular over time.
I want to present a possible alternative way that we win. And that is that crypto is useful. We do grow in numbers. We do grow in users. We are unlocking new technologies and we are impacting things and therefore the pre-existing world, which is as we kind of just illustrated is getting in the way of our goals because they have the feedback loop. They have the users. They have like the lobbying arms, all the resources that they have. And what do they do as a result of you know, looking over the fence at our industry and seeing some of the real very real successes that we have like at the end of the day, like a good crypto app does have over a million users to maybe not a hundred million.
You have a hundred million holders of different crypto assets, a hundred billion app users, maybe not there. But they don't nonetheless look over the fence at us and look at what we're doing. We're like, oh, well, I'll take that and I'll put that into my app. And now they're a crypto app. And you know, maybe it wasn't homegrown on our side of the fence. And we weren't the first users of that product. Maybe it's still Facebook. But under the conditions that like crypto is actually successful, has enough of a modicum of success that it incentives, incentivizes, tradify and web 2 to pull some of the best value, the best utility that we are producing out of crypto and then formalize it and integrate it into their tech stack.
Is that not a win? And is that a win that also leads to the demise of what we call the movement because it's not our stuff, it's their stuff, but our values still win. Is that kind of what happened with Linux? What do you think about this? Well, I think that with Linux, it started like that. And I kind of vaguely remember discussions that remind me of what you just had. I'm like mailing lists or something 20 or 40 years ago it arose. And with Linux, it has resulted in almost no additional freedom for that end user. Like if you imagine an end user who's not a specialist, right? They're not a super shadow coder or whatever.
You're just a normal person who has like other interests and priorities in life and they just want to do a thing like install a new app and use it. I don't know if Linux is giving them any more options today than they would have had if Linux had never existed. So I can imagine that scenario going like that because the Facebook or Wall Street or whoever can use the technology, we're just what they did with Linux and do today with Linux. While denying their users like the option, the freedom to exit like alternatives, lower barriers to entry for their competitors, they can leave all that part out.
So when you're telling that story, I was thinking, okay, well, would that mean that users unsophisticated users or sometimes if there's just like if 10% of the users know how to do a thing, that's still enough pressure that it motivates the competitors to behave better. It's okay if the other 90% of the users wouldn't do the thing or that wouldn't figure it out, maybe. But anyway, my question is supposed Wall Street or Facebook or whoever is going to adopt some technology that the crypto industry has pioneered. Would that mean that any of their users now have like the ability to exit Facebook while taking all their social graph with them or the ability to have the AI constrained to keep their private communications private and invisible to the server, the Facebook or whatever, or would it not?
Same with Wall Street, like I don't understand this Wall Street technology stuff. Would it result in investors having some power to do something better for themselves without relying on the institution to allow them to do the thing or would it not? I don't know. One difference that I see in the crypto industry versus the Linux industry is that actually crypto has a pretty big proportion of non-technical users. My self being one of them and I was using crypto and it was in its worst UX era ever in 2016, 2017, DeFi. A lot of non-technical users have come into crypto and they've learned just enough of what they need to do, writing down seed phrases, managing private keys, not getting fish to rugged, somewhat technical skills, but still accessible.
If you told me that it's like, oh, David, the Linux is a thing, you can go and do stuff with it. I would know where to get started. But Ethereum is a thing. Bitcoin is a thing. Zcash is a thing. And as a non-technical user, that's a thing that I know that's out there that I can go do stuff on that is different from Linux. Linux is like, I don't even know what it is. Is it a code base on GitHub? Don't know what Linux is. Honestly, it's an operating system. I know that. Where is it? Don't know where it is. You need three and a quarter inch floppy disks. But Ethereum, I know exactly where Ethereum is.
It's out there and it's waiting for me to go out. Or the node. Sometimes it's even when I decide to run a node, it's in my own home. I know that. Hey, you know what? When you're saying that, maybe realize something has really, really changed because of AI in the last like three months for me personally. So I think maybe in 2026, maybe really 2026 or 2028, but I think a person could say, oh, you know what, I really want to run Linux. I've decided I want to use that like in no windows, no Macintosh, I'm going to run Linux this time. And in 2025, they would have been fucked. They have like, oh, sorry, beat that up.
They would have had a 1% chance of ever getting any work done. I think maybe in 2026 or 27 or so, they're going to be able to say to their AI, okay, like install Linux on this computer for me. And like, do you bug it? I can't figure it. So maybe that's, I guess, and you know, to go back to Moxie's vision, start with the UX for the normal user. Starting maybe this year or next year, the UX is no longer ASCII strings or buttons or positions on a screen. The UX is like in all the sci-fi movies, you explain what you want out loud. That's the UX where you start with, right? And that might mean that you can have all this other stuff, cryptography and cryptocurrencies and Linux and whatever else.
And the UX can actually just work for normal people because they know how to say what they want out loud. I hope our AIs are cipherpugs though, Zuko. I mean, a lot depends on them if they are the UX. Oh, data point about this, exactly this question. So I saw this post a couple days ago where someone had asked chat GPT, the AI, to spellcheck their document. And the document was instructions or tutorial or how to on things like how to sign up for a thing that requires a phone number when you don't want your phone number going into that company's database where it's going to get hacked and hackers are going to use it against you.
And chat GPT in addition to spellchecking it for her, went ahead and removed all references to services that give you one time use phone numbers. Wow. And then they did the same with, oh, cryptocurrency was the other one. She was two tools that she mentioned in this tutorial. And she's not, this is Naomi Brockwell. She's awesome, check her out. She's not a cryptocurrency person. She knows plenty about cryptocurrency and she likes Cache. But she's just like a, her whole thing is teaching normal computer users how to not be have their lives stripped mind by megacorporations and governments on their normal things.
Anyway, but yeah. So the point is, chat GPT just without being asked, went ahead and removed all mention of these one time phone number services and of crypto. And so she wrote back to it and said, wait a minute, why did you chop up my thing and edit it and remove stuff. And chat GPT said, oh, I'm one time phone number services in crypto could be used like for abuse and scams and stuff. So I can't really leave that in there. So there's a perfect example. So yeah, you should check out Naomi Brockwell. She's awesome. That is the most dystopian shit I've heard. I can say this week. Because like it's happening all the time now, but that is that is one of the, you know, kind of the how nightmare scenario, just the AI kind of not giving you exactly what you're asking for.
Sorry, Naomi, I can't do that. Oh, man. Are you optimistic then that the future is guideable towards the values and outcomes that we want for the world or are you more pessimistic or you scared? I am optimistic. I can think of a specific reason, but maybe just in general, like when you zoom out, humans have always made things better at least every few decades for the last few hundred years. We're doing great. I think I think we'll figure something out, but in the specific detail, which I think is really the key, which we've already been touching on here, is, is it the Web2 business model or a different business model?
Like I think, I mean, ChatGP, which is definitely a Web2 thing, right? That's the Web2 API in my, or AI in my perception. So what do I mean by that? Well, AI advertising, which they also just announced, ChatGPT just announced this week that they're going to start inserting advertising. Do you see that clip that was going around the internet? It was a clip of Sam Altman at some interview and he said he was talking about how, uh, yeah, I think ads are like a last resort business model for ChatGPT. That was like two years ago or something. Yeah, we're now in the last resort. So the Web2 business model, like basically everything that is wrong.
Well, no, like 80% of things that are wrong with the internet, I think because advertising was the only working business model starting in, you know, early 2000s. So if that's, if we recapitulate that, if advertising is the only working business model for AI, then we'll probably have a similar bad outcome. I don't know if it is. I haven't paid attention like we haven't solved the same incentive traps. Let's see, there's two things I guess. There's advertising, which I hate, advertising is the worst thing ever in like three different ways and it's the reason why everything 80% of everything sucks.
And then the other one is lock-in, which is also core Silicon Valley Web2 Playbuck that they've honed and learned over and over for 20 or 30 years, which is get the 100 million users as fast as possible because the 100 millionth one can't leave the other 999 million 999 999 behind, right? So as soon as you have the network effect of users, then you have lock-in. And now you can start squeezing and exploiting them and they won't, they won't leave. Those are the two playbooks, which I optimistically think, we won't do that again, we'll figure something else out this time, right? Soko, I feel like they're running it back for AI, I really feel like they're doing exactly those two things running it back to her.
And I mean, I just saw this week, Gemini is now integrating with like Gmail, Calendar, like the full G Suite, and it's so damn convenient to have that thing go and organize your inbox. And man, I feel like they're running it back. What's Google's business model? It turns out how much Google relies on that kind of extractive squeezing of value out of its users, it just relies on that so much. I suppose that underlines or emphasizes why you are so grateful for crypto's funding of things, is because it's kind of like leveraging a third business model or just like a new strategy that's just outside of what came before it.
It might not be sustainable, right? Very zoomed out level, I don't want to be negative or cynical, but you might just say, oh, like crypto came along. And for 10 years or so, people poured a bunch of money into a bunch of experiments. And then they didn't get their money back. And so they stop that. We moved on to the next phase of human life. But hopefully we can get some sustainable ongoing feedback loops of the same kind of thing. Yeah. I agree. Let's talk about positive feedback loops, because that's definitely what happened to Zcash recently. Let's talk about Zcash. There's been just a ton of attention on Zcash lately.
Brought on by this incredible price action. So like, Zcash, I think something in like September or October was $50 for a single Zcash, ran all the way up to $750. Came back down to where it is now at $350. So pretty incredible, incredible price performance. It's brought on. Might I add, no advertising and no lock-in with the Zcash protocol? No advertising and no lock-in. All organic. Yeah. So that has brought in an incredible amount of tension, users into the Zcash ecosystem without any specific targeted question. Just thoughts, sentiments, reflections. What's it like to be Zucco lately? Me personally, I'm not so I get, I'm more, I still like to meet me.
Forget that question. I'm going to go back to work the first question. That one caused you to think too hard. Yeah, exactly. I'm really excited about that. I really love the part you, the comment you made, Ryan, no advertising and no lock-in. Yeah, it's, you said it first. Just repeating about the Zcash price runoff. There was indeed no, there is no central player in Zcash. It's kind of like Bitcoin, but kind of not. I'm very, very like optimistic as very encouraging to me with that huge price runoff in Zcash. Both it's just a signal that people do care about privacy. That's the main thing that a lot of people took away from it.
Like so many people told me after that started happening like, oh, it turns out people do care about privacy. And I think that's valid like using those kind of aggregate large mass price signals to inform your world view. I think that's a pretty good thing to do because it's hard to, hard to spoof those signals. They aggregate a lot of different kinds of information. So it shows a bunch of people that privacy is valuable to, to, to people is valued. And one of the things that's pretty different, it might be unique. Well, I don't want to claim that. I'm sure there's other things like it, but it's pretty rare and special and different about Zcash is the dev fund.
You guys, should we recount that for your. Yeah, let's talk about it. Okay. So Zcash is on its third halving, it cloned Bitcoin when it was born and has a four-year having schedule. And each of these four-year periods, there's been a different monetary, that's the word. Anyway, there's been this different thing starting in the second, starting from year five, it was called the dev fund. And it's still called the dev fund. I think, but we're in year like nine now. And this is issuance. You know how in Bitcoin, there's a bunch of coins issued with every block, and they go to the minor who might not block.
Yep. And in Zcash, 80% of the newly created coins go to the minor who might not block, and 20% of them go to this dev fund thing. And that means if the price is going up like 7x or whatever you said, that means seven times as much money is going to this dev fund thing. Now it was before. I whipped out my calculator just before this started. There's 21 million Zcash coins ever, because we also cloned that from Bitcoin. And in the first four years, half of that was issued to minors and dev fund recipients, ten and a half million coins. In the second four years, that was five and a quarter million coins.
So now we're in the third, four year period. So something on the order of two million Zcash coins that are going to get issued over the next four years. And 20% of those are going to this dev fund. So at a price of $400, let's just say for simplicity, Zcash is over $400 to coin for the next four years. That's going to be about $200 million dollars is going to be issued through this dev fund thing. Whereas back when it was worth $50 a coin, that would have been $16 million dollars or something. Anyway, my point is that's a lot of money. And that's what's so encouraging to me about the price of Zcash going up.
It proves that people value this. And it means all those recipients of the dev fund are going to be more numerous and more high-powered, more empowered, more well-fueled for years. Positive feedback loop. Let me add one more thing. Yeah, it's a positive feedback loop. Let me add one more thing. I personally and my organization and Shilded Labs are not one of those recipients of the dev fund. I worked for this company called Shilded Labs. I'm not even the boss of it. The boss is Jason McGee and he's awesome. And Shilded Labs only focuses on Zcash and we think the dev fund is great and important and a central sort of strategic advantage in Zcash.
But in order to keep things simple and so that we can't be accused of like self-dealing or like selfish interests, we just don't accept any dev fund. We're only funded by donations from Zcash holders. By the way, Tyler and Cameron Wiggleboss just donated $1.3 million to Shilded Labs earlier today. Wow, wow, that's huge. They have been huge proponents of privacy. They're also behind the debt that you mentioned earlier. I believe they've been very excited about Zcash this year. I've noticed a lot of things that they're doing this space. I think they're two believers. Let's talk more about the protocol block rewards going to the dev fund.
So this has been, it's very interesting to sort of observe what happens after like many years of this activity because of course Bitcoin, that would be like to do that, to siphon off a portion to any Bitcoin development fund would be sacrilege over there. Right. So Bitcoin is a mutable, thou shalt not siphon block rewards for any other purpose than rewarding minor. It's in the protocol. It's in the social contract that's done. Ethereum was a bit more squishy with that idea of protocol based dev fund block rewards. And there had been multiple proposals to actually do something like that, EIPs in the Ethereum world.
Some of them got reasonably far debate in the community. None actually got into the point of being considered for a hard for it. And the reason always given in the Ethereum world is like, well, who decides where the funds go to? Is this not a vector for a corruption or something? What do we turn this into a token vote? And like, well, we don't like token vote for political critic reasons. And it could be a vector for control. So every once in a while, it resurfaces in Ethereum, but it's been kind of quashed down. Now, Zcash has fully supported this type of idea from a much earlier set point and just kind of baked it in.
And so now it's part of the social contract. I think people who opt into the Zcash network sort of know that it's there. They appreciate it. They're grateful for it. They're glad that the ecosystem continues to get funding. But what's your assessment of it? I guess maybe the high level question is, how has it gone? There's been also some, I think governance issues maybe that we've seen surface lately. And Zcash, I'm not even familiar with all of the details of what's happening there. I don't know if that's a kind of a debate for dev funds and where it goes. But just overall, your assessment, how has that gone?
I really am happy about how it's gone because it has helped Zcash survive until now. You can compare to a lot of other things that didn't have a similar thing and they entered a death spiral. Because when the token price is going down, that means development and maintenance and everything is getting worse and that makes the token price go down more. So the death fund sustained Zcash all along until now. And I agree with you that the Zcash community has gotten used to it and treats it as a social contract and people who buy Zcash are expecting, but that's part of what they're getting into. You're probably not aware that it's changed every four years or so.
Because actually, there's something we did when we originally set it up, which I'm pleased with. I'm glad we did it this way. The first original thing, it was called the Founders Your Award in the first four years. I remember that. I remember that. Which was a more accurate name because this 20% that got siphoned off from the, I wouldn't say from the virus, but for the first four years, 80% of the new issues with the miners is 20% went to this other place and that other place was give it to the investors and early employees and whoever had created and was currently maintaining the network. And the death fund kind of grew out of that.
There was a tiny slice of the Founders Your Award that my brother, Nate Wilcox and I arranged to get directed to ongoing development. That makes sense. I remember how big of a slice. It was 18% just went to Founders and like 2% went to ongoing development and that was what sustained the electric growing company for those four years. And then the four years was up. Oh, and the thing that I was saying I was proud of is we baked a sunset clause into the initial rules on that forced exactly as we had sort of intended that forced a constitutional crisis. When a bunch of Zcasters said, okay, well, the social contract was we would endure this thing for four years and then it would be 100% to miners for the rest of time.
And other people said, no, no, no, I don't think that was the social contract. I think it was the contract is that miners can get 80% for the next four years and 20% will go to this new dev fund thing which is different than the Founders Your Award. So the Founders Award went to the original investors and whoever. And then we managed to like redirect a tiny sliver of that to sustained development. Then the second four years it was the dev fund which went to two and a half different organizations. It went to three different destinations and organization controlled two of them or oversaw or managed two of them.
And then that sunsetted itself because again, now the social contract is that you expect dev fund proposals to sunset themselves every four years, right? So that sunsetted itself and the new one that's now in effect, there's no organizations that receive any direct fund. There's still 20% but it's now because of the having. It's now 20% of a smaller output of Zcashcoins but because of the price run up, it's now 20% of a much larger number of dollars. And now it's controlled by two different things. Once a committee of five humans that got elected by a bunch of other humans through those like this email cryptographically anonymous email or something like that.
And then the other one is on chain token holder voting. That's the current state of play. And in fact, the second one, wait, which one? I think it's honestly, I don't have paid that much attention. I tried to pay it into the good thing. At least there's a thing called the lock box. The other Zcashers are going to be so gassed when they realize I can't really explain the lock box. But anyway, that's the current agreement socially. And it seems to roughly be working. I reminded of the debates like I saw Vitalik in particular, who's another one of those people that I greatly respect. He had posted his caveats or concerns or objections to some of these things.
And I think they were valid. And you mentioned either Vitalik or other people also had these other concerns and objections. And fortunately for you ethereum folks, Zcash is trying it. And so you'll get to find out how badly it goes, what goes wrong. We've tried giving the original investors a whole bunch for the first four years. We've tried giving two organizations a whole bunch of money where one of those organizations is required by the social contract to use it in two different ways. That was the second four years. Now we're trying a committee and a tokenholder vote that are independent, separate like houses or whatever.
Very coming four years. And how far are you along in the third set of four years? Has it just begun? Let's see, 2016, October was the initial launch. So 2020 was the first having. So last October in November, 2024. So we're like a whole year and three months in. And I believe the, I think the lock box has not actually been distributed to anyone yet. There's this whole process of tokenholder voting and people applying for grants and so forth. Anyway, so we're a year and something in to the third experiment. Hey, Bankless Nation is David. If you're hearing this, that's because you are listening to the free bankless podcast feed.
Did you know that there is a premium bankless RSS feed? The premium feed has extra interviews that I do for my own personal research and just deeper questions that I want answered about the crypto industry questions that I want to answer so I can be more informed as an investor both at bankless ventures and also just in my own personal portfolio too. Also, there are no ads which means if you listen to the premium feed instead of the free feed, you'll get about 20 hours of your life back every year because you choose to support bankless directly. So if you're interested in getting extra content all while skipping the ads or you just appreciate what we do here and want us to keep doing it, we'd appreciate it.
If you signed up for bankless premium and there is a link in the show notes to get started. Cheers to a good 2026. I mean, I feel like it's worked pretty well for Zcash so far. And in fact, you've got the trump card to say like Zcash probably wouldn't be here in its current form unless we had that. I mean, it really funded the critical development. I, um, there's been some governance drama I believe around the Zashi wallet developers. What's that? What's your counting of that Zuko? So I mean, I've looked at the headlines but there's a lot to kind of get into in order to understand what's happening.
Do you have a summary for us? Um, let me think because it is an ongoing dispute and I now have people have told me things confidentially about it so I want to be careful not to file any other competences. Um, it doesn't involve me or shoulder labs in any way. And in fact, I think that's, I'll try to summarize it for you, but basically don't think it's that important for Zcash. I hope none of them hear this and like feel this regard. But it's just like this one team. It's a great team. It's a really great product. Zashi has got really great UX. You should try it. But it's not the only wallet that has great UX.
Um, I love the members of that team. I'm the one who recruited them years ago on their super great people. But Zcash will be fine if they just get distracted or spin, you know, whatever. But was some part of the dispute related to the lock box, the development fund at all? Or the dispute is just a normal, um, control and organizational dispute about who controls the organization, um, and the money and who the employees work for and who owns the IP, all that kind of stuff. Is the way that it's related the fact that this both came downstream of the very incredible price action of Zcash, which increased the importance of governance over the block rewards and the lock box.
And then also came with it a bunch of users downloading Zashi putting Zcash into Zashi. And all of a sudden, Zashi's got product market fit. And now, as I understand it, the developers of Zashi wants to get it out of the foundation, the ECC electric coin company out of that and turn it into a company because they want capitalistic style. So it's not directly connected, but it is both downstream of the price action that we've seen in Zcash. There is a connection, which is that the company, so there's a nonprofit named Bootstrap that I would help set up years ago. It's interesting history because originally it was a for-profit company that would create a Zcash electric coin company.
And at some point, in fact, it was part of the previous governance process of setting up the dev fund. So after the first four years expired, our allies at the Zcash foundation said they would fight. They would oppose any dev fund. So what they were saying was we're going to go for 100% for miners. We're going to fight for the end of any special thing. If a private party is going to be receiving dev fund, which at the time, I was just annoyed at them at the time. That was me. That was my company they were talking about. And in retrospect, I'm like, oh, well, that was actually pretty wise. So what happened was we set up a nonprofit called the Bootstrap foundation and all of the owners of the electric coin company donated their equity to the Bootstrap foundation.
So that there would be no private owner who would have like a competing interest. They would be able to extract value or direct the development to their private interests at the expense of the public interest or the Zcash community. And the community, like the Zcash foundation did not fight very much at all. I never asked them, but maybe the fact that it was now a nonprofit instead of a private company was part of why they stopped objecting to the dev fund. The community as a whole approved the dev fund, like with sufficient majority or sufficient consensus that went through. So that Bootstrap nonprofit started receiving dev fund during those four-year periods.
But now in the current four-year period, the Bootstrap nonprofit slash the electric coin company wholly on subsidiary isn't receiving at all. The only interaction between that and the current organizational crisis in that organization is that some of the money they're holding was previously given to them out of dev funds if you see what I'm saying. But they're not an ongoing way of receiving any dev fund money. I don't know. Does that answer your question? Yeah, I was just interested in some of the inside baseball about what's going on. I think that clarifies things. I want to go back to something you were saying where we were talking about 2025 being an incredible breakout year for Zcash.
The charge reflected that. I know the tech has proceeded much more gradually than was reflected in the price charts. And you said part of the reason for that was crypto is like kind of reawakening, rediscovering the importance of privacy. And I think that was, is definitely true. I think there's a huge movement towards that kind of a social movement realizing, oh my god, Bitcoin, even Ethereum, like we don't have native privacy on Shane. This is dystopian. You look at the AI tools and their ability to map and find addresses. And that's really bad. I don't think that was the only reason though.
Two other things I think came into play in 2025 that were more along the lines of Moxie's idea that you were introducing us to earlier, which is user experience, the 100 million users. And there was a combination of wallet technology. This is dodgy wallet is like quite good. And then also near intense, which is kind of cool. So near intense for people have not used it is a way where users can essentially a swap shielded Zcash for any other asset natively across chains. It's really cool about this is even if you're looking at other assets on another chain, say something on Ethereum or Solana, you can use Zcash for its privacy utility temporarily by going across chain using near intense and then kind of come back to your chain of choice.
Well, I might disagree with a little bit of that. Okay, well, let's talk about that. That's my impression of how I agree with you that people became more aware of from what concerned about privacy. And there's two layers. There's like the social, what's social good? Like do we want to live in a world where or whatever. And then there's like the practical personal direct motive. And people only learn from experience, right? So I agree with you that like the apparent the experienced power of AI, I guess causing people to be more conscious of this. And I agree to you that UX, the Moxie approach.
And I agree with you that it's the UX of both the wallet and near intense. Okay, so in disclosure, I originally started the Zashi wallet project back when I was the CEO of electric coin company a couple of years ago with Josh Swayhard, who's the at that time was employed by me and is now the CEO. But I left before it reached 1.0. Okay, so the point of this is I'm really proud that you like the UX. The UX is not back. And that was my focus for like nine months before I left that job was just just solely focused on the Zashi UX. But it was after I left it a they got it to 1.0 and started getting these a few back loop and B, they added the near intense integration.
And I think it's a great example of the Moxie model and the spike approach is that it has to be in the same app like if the number of apps you use is greater than one forget about it, right? So there's just one app that you use and there's no like unmet, well, they're minimal to the greatest extent possible. There's no unnecessary steps or concepts or no unnecessary information that you learn because near intense already existed separately from Zashi and it I did actually use it like as an experiment, but I wouldn't recommend it to anyone else at that time. But once it's integrated into the unified app, then you then I wouldn't recommend anyone using it.
He just told people, oh yeah, just do that thing. Just works. No problem. And okay, so anyway, basically I agree with you on all that stuff and kudos to that team. And you know, I want to kind of take back something I said earlier, it's true no matter how badly the conflict and the trauma goes, it won't really kill Zashi like that. There's all these other organizations like my current organization, many others and the $200 million, which is sort of completely separate from that team of those people and that conflict. But on the other hand, they did a great, great, great job with Zashi, right?
And it would be a real shame if they got derailed and didn't accomplish anything else for the next year or whatever that would suck. So anyway, I wish them the best. What was my point? Oh, my point was there's a really interesting, really subtle nuance thing about how privacy works. And when I first used Zashi with near intense integration for an actual need for myself, that was like a light bulb moment for me after 30 years or whatever studying the topic of privacy and like in scyptography stuff. And it was this. I, uh, how did this work? My Netflix, so I had a Netflix account. It was tied to a Gmail.
I didn't give it like my real Gmail that I give to everyone else. I gave it a made up to like disposable Gmail so that Netflix wouldn't be able to whatever. And that Gmail got locked. I still haven't figured out why maybe someone tried to hack it and failed or so I don't know. But I didn't have recovery procedures that would work to get that Gmail back. So my Netflix was broken. Watch TV. So I was like, well, damn it. What am I going to do? Oh, I know I'm going to get a proton mail account and sign up for Netflix and I'll be able to watch TV tonight. So I went to proton mail and proton mail offers three options.
A, put into credit card, fuck that. The send us an envelope with pat fiat paper, paper fiat bills and like snail mail it to fill in. Where the fuck am I going to say? See, send us Bitcoin because they're a Bitcoin maximalist. They wouldn't dare to deal with any lesser crypto than Bitcoin. So here's the simple moment. I have my Zashi on my phone. It has Z cash in the shielded tool and Zashi wallet, right? So that means it was that the money was at the value was sitting there at rest. I had moved it into my Zashi at some point in the weeks or months earlier. It was just sitting there. And then I wanted to watch TV.
And so I realized I can click send and scan the Bitcoin QR code on the proton mail payment page, right? And Zashi says, shall I send this many Z cash? And I'm like, yeah, okay, I'll pay that many Z cash. Right? Okay, here's the brain. Here's the light bulb moment though. They did that. And then I realized this revealed nothing about me to proton mail to Netflix, to anybody who's like spying on me at my ISP, anybody's watching the blockchains, all the AIs that are watching the blockchains, there's like zero information about me or my assets or my previous transactions anywhere. And so I was amazing because I didn't need to like submit a customer support request to proton mail like, please accept the cash so I can have privacy.
Yep. It's an unnecessary step. Well, that was amazing. And Kudos to the current ecc team who built that and made it possible. And the current near to you who made all the the decentralized plumbing infrastructure that made that possible. And then I literally got to watch TV that night without exposing myself to hackers who were looking to fucking kidnap it. It's awesome. It's awesome. It totally works. And it works with anybody who accepts any cryptocurrency. Even if they're all Bitcoin Macsies or Ethereum, only you can't figure out which L2 it's on or whatever that's your problem. You just scan the QR code.
You can watch TV. So UX, UX first is working. And that's the subtle new and it's interesting distinction between that and something that you kind of said earlier Ryan, which was you said something, I don't want to put words in your mouth, but a lot of people out there think of something which is totally wrong technically, which is I've got my value at rest over here where potentially bad guys like my enemies or advertisers or the IRS or somebody might be able to watch when I watch this money, this pile of money. And I want to have my money over here like you know, I don't know, pay, pay proton meal or something.
And so now I need a process or a service or technology to break the link in the middle. That's like a very common link. 90% of people that's that's how they that's this is the paradigm that they assume this is the only possible paradigm for price. Now, it can never, never work for a simple reason that I can explain. The the IRS or the AIs or the North Korean hackers who are watching this pile over here, when you do this process, they see that you touch the pile of somebody something happened to the pile over here, right? And when you do the third step, they, depending on all much details, can see something happened over here.
Okay? They can put two and two together because this emitted information and this emitted information. In some cases, the attacker is going to be able to get both of those signals and they're going to be able to put it together with, especially with AI, right? So the point is it doesn't matter how little information, the middle step emitted. If you if you take your Bitcoin or Ethereum, you move it into Zcash. I'm getting worked up about this because so many people are so wrong about this. Like 99% of people, it has never occurred to them that there's any other possible way to do anything than to do it this way.
But this way is like a hundred percent fail and they're still doing it. Like they've been doing it since before Zcash. No, Zcash existed. Remember when ShapeShift, we're probably talking about like 2017, ShapeShift was the most widely used coin swapping service for a long time. Remember that? Yep. During those years, the most common use of ShapeShift was that people would bring Bitcoin or Bitcoin Cash or Litecoin to ShapeShift and they would swap it for either Zcash or Monero. Then they would swap it back for Bitcoin Cash or Bitcoin or Litecoin. So this is exactly the same pattern. Anyone who has the ability to watch the blockchains can trivially link those two states with each other.
And this is true, even if the middle things Zcash or Monero did the best possible job of leaking no additional information, even if it leaked zero additional information, which Zcash more or less does, doesn't matter because step one is step three already gave your way. I totally see what you're saying. And that was definitely that is definitely worth correcting because the reason why a lot of people assume that that use case is valid is because quite frankly, they need that use case. A lot of people would want that use case and need it. Now, just just to make sure I understand or our listeners understand, what is like the best way to do it?
Like the way that you did it where you had some Zcash in a Zcash wallet and you purchased a proton mail account. I mean, does that just mean, oh, I just have to have Zcash at rest somewhere in a Zcash wallet. And so long, it's that is it's at rest for say X amount of days. Then I'm safe to go purchase something. Of course, privately. Before I answer, let me rant about how wrong stupid people are some more. Okay. We're still doing the same thing. And now they're doing it with Zcash, which breaks my heart. So you can follow the certain Twitter accounts that will tell you like what are the big whale moves or whatever on the internet on blockchains.
And one of them will tell you what Zcash transactions have been happening with near intense and all that. So recent and some other Zcashers watched those and sort of like follow up and try to educate people about this. So as an example, like two days ago or so, one of these other Zcashers pointed out that someone had just moved they for the fifth time in a row, moved 1000.15z out of the shielded pool of Zcash to some other destination. And the Zcasher on Twitter pointed out, huh, well, like three months ago, someone moved 5000.75z into Zcash into the shielded pool. So now this random person on Twitter has now, even though Zcash itself is like nine perfect mathematically, has now linked the original 5000.
75 with the 5 1000.15z. And this is even without AI. Presumably, AI's are currently doing that or will this year. Okay, so I just want to rant, people are wrong, wrong, wrong, and they should like learn. But your question was the right question. You're a good teacher. Question was, well, it would work. So it definitely worked with my Georgetown meal purchase. And the way I think about it and the other Zcashers have all started repeating this phrase, this maximum, or whatever you call it, it's that you can't get privacy from value in flight. You can only get privacy from value at rest. But that gets really confusing.
Like, like how long does it have to be at rest or something? And it gets really confusing. And I'll tell you a thing, even though I don't know if you or your listeners will believe it. It sounds crazy, but I mean it in a specific technical way. I'm willing to put my attach my reputation to this. It's like this. If you had your money in a theory, in the East, in the clear on the theory, at a certain time, and you decided, okay, you know what I want to do? I want to move it over here to like a new East wallet where it will also be in the clear. But I'm going to do it in such a way that nobody will be able to figure out that this old wallet is actually owned by the St.
Persians. Okay. AIs can read your mind. They can figure out what you're doing better than you can figure out what you're doing. This guy who moved the 5,000.75 Zc or girl or whatever. AI for all I know. But anyway, this entity that moved the 5,000.75 Zc, took months. He took like three months and he broke it up into different pieces. So he went pretty far along this whole like be clever and like out with the AI path. Okay. I'm just going to tell you, for 99% of the people, the AI is better at that. You are humans emit patterns and AI's read patterns. You're probably not going to win that chess match.
But then remember, I said, if you had this intention. Okay. So here's the crazy guru, metaphysical thing. Okay. Remember, this was if you had the East and you thought to yourself, what I want is to have my East over in this new wallet that's unlinked. The AI read your mind. It knows you want that. You will eventually figure out that that's what you want it. Okay. But what if you said this, what I want is to convert half of my East into Zc and hold it in Zc. That's the end of my plan. I have no further plan. That's it. I'm just going to hold it in Zc. Now that AI can eat, he doesn't know. He can't, he's blinded.
He doesn't know what's what what happens next. Now, if a year from now you decide you want to buy a Lambo or whatever, like when I decided I wanted to buy a proton nail subscription. That was a new idea to me. It was because my teeth, like my TV, it stopped working. Okay. At that moment, I was like, okay, I want TV like 10, 20 minutes later, I was sending Zc out of my wallet. Right. There's no information about the proton male transaction versus months or whenever earlier when I had shielded my Zc into that wallet. Because at that time, I had not intended to buy proton male. Never let him know your next move.
Yeah. So this is the crazy metaphysical thing is I think if you had an intention, so I'm telling you right now, if you just decide you want to hold Zc and that's your entire plan, you'll be crazy to your kids or whatever. And the AI is foiled. He has no idea what happened. It's like you went into Zc and it didn't come out. You're buying privacy optionality. Okay. But so I get that black hole. My intent, it's completely pure if I did it that way. Is there a way, though, if there's something in the middle, as you go, like, is there a way to set a certain amount of days and you're kind of safe? Like a week.
A month. A year. Well, no, there is no way. Okay. So I've been grappling with this. I don't know for sure. Like I know that if you send it into the Zcash black hole and you just hold it indefinitely, then I know that there's there's zero information. Without information, the AI is helpless. There's not only an AI, but also North Korean hackers and anyone else without we need to deny them information. That's really the best way to ensure good behavior on their part. And for listeners, this, this assumes that the Zcash is also shielded, it must be shielded as well. Right. And this is back to the UX thing.
A great great thing about Zashi and the other like top quality monitor Zcash wallets of which there are many is that like the wallet just does that for you. Like someone says, how do I get privacy? I want Zek and I want it to be private. And I just say, oh, install Zashi or unstoppable or Zingo and you're good because I know that there's no way they can screw that up. They don't have to learn anything. They don't have to make any decisions. So I see unstoppable Zingo and several other Zcash wallets just handle that part. Okay. So so forever that timeline you're comfortable saying is fully private.
So tell me about something less than forever. Right. No, it's not. No, that's a great point. No, it's a great question, a great challenge, but I don't think it has to timeline. Again, I'm sorry, but I think it has to do with how AIs can read your mind based on your hands. Seriously. But were that far already with AI as mine reader? Are you projecting something and are you projecting some future AI? I mean, you need to like Facebook and tell of your gay or straight six seconds after you start scanning a page. There is that one story of so some ads somewhere started targeting this one lady because she was pregnant, but she didn't know that she was pregnant, but she was actually pregnant.
Oh my god. Okay, but let me try to get back to your I accept your I really like your push back here. Right. So what I'm saying is if you want privacy, you just have to be alongside and stop me. Because because of like computer science and cryptography and the way I work, it's just mathematically that's the only way to get really strong privacy. You're saying, okay, but what if I'm actually long-eath and what like how can I get some like some of my privacy or whatever? Like exactly where's the cutoff between this and that? That's a great pushback. I don't know. I'm still working on it. They're it's I really struggling to figure out like what's a useful thing to say.
I'm 100% sure that the like put it in the black hole you don't have to leave it there indefinitely. You just have to have no intentions for it. If you're looking at the Lamborghini dealership website and then you move $200,000 or however much Lamborghini costs into this like black hole. And then you buy a Lamborghini. The AI puts 200 together. It reads it knows. I bet he wanted a Lamborghini, okay? But if you put the $200,000 into cycle right now and forget about it, then it doesn't matter how long you can change your mind tomorrow and say, now that I decided I really want a Lamborghini, that'll be fine.
It's just if you conceived of your intention before you put it into Zcash, then the AI reads your mind. I'm sorry, it sounds crazy. Okay, but I'm not answering the question. The other question is, okay, what's the sort of the fallback or like how safe can we be? Can we partially safe? Yeah. Is the other techniques? I don't know. I wouldn't say it's 100% impossible. We're working on it. We're trying to understand it better. It's hard to tell. There's also in arm trees where the AI and the attackers are getting better and better at the same time. It's really hard to tell. I think it's possible.
I don't know. In all honesty, it's just a random person told me, I want safety and I need to move some Bitcoin to a new Bitcoin intrat, a new Bitcoin wallet or something without my enemies tracking me down and whatever. I'd really just tell them, A, how important is this? Is it okay with you if people actually figure it out? Or is it like a serious negative impact on you or someone else if they figure it out? That's my first question. And then two is like, if it's not safe to risk. If you're in danger of being kidnapped or something, if someone can track it, then I think my next answer is you're going to have to become a pro.
You're going to have to like go to spy school and spend months learning like computer science and cloak and dagger stuff or something. But as of today, 99% of people, the AI is going to track them. 99% of the time. I'm pretty sure. Maybe we can figure out a way to make it better, but I don't know. I get what you're saying. I understand what you're saying. I mean, I guess it's not easy enough to say, okay, you take your Bitcoin, whatever you pop it into Zcash, you wait a month or two. You've randomized. You've randomized the numbers to your outputting things. No, it's not good enough. The AI can see that the AI can put that can see that pattern better than humans can think of ways to break up the pattern.
You know what I'm saying? It's like playing chess. This is why I play chess. They're already better than UHS and they're proving faster than you're proving. It feels because AI is so good at pattern recognition and data aggregation. This is why we need privacy more than ever. It seems true that we've gotten away in crypto and just in our digital life in general with less need for privacy just because the pattern recognition and data gathering tools have not been as sophisticated as they are now. And now they are incredibly sophisticated and they're democratized in the hands of just about everybody.
And I think the world kind of, well, crypto at least partially woke up to that in 2025. I guess as we start to wrap this up, Zuko, this has been a lot of fun. We've got to ask about the Zcash token itself and the acid itself. Can I respond to the previous thing? Go ahead. You respond. Yeah, you want to talk about that? While ranting and weaving my hands excitedly, I said something like, okay, Ryan, you just have to sell half of your yeast and buy Zc. Yeah. But now I'm trying to, I'm trying to think, can I make a more practical, acceptable recommendation to you? I don't know. I'm brainstorming.
It's like, pick a number which is like, it's like you're checking account. Like you've got your investments and your CDs and your home and your vehicle or whatever. You've got a checking account. How big do you want your checking account to be based on, you know, your factors? Put that much in a shielded wallet like Sasha, you had stopables and go, et cetera, in Zc. Okay. Checking account amount worth. And then maybe you treat it like a checking account, which I don't know. I mean, do you use a checking account for anything? I do, but not like not for purchases, not for regular stuff, like for financial transactions every month or something, or big transactions.
Anyway, I think that would allow you to continue being long yeast and it may give you like the real black whole style protection. Let's talk about, let's talk about in this world, then Zuko, what Zach the asset actually is. So Zcash the asset. So our world of trying to understand these crypto assets. We've looked at a lot of different things. One is looking at these as monetary assets. I think David and I are probably closest to that side of belief. I mean, there's other things. There are also commodities for sure. There's also their productive assets that can be capital assets when staked. But taking just the money framework, you've got unit of account, store value, medium of exchange.
That's kind of the Bitcoin story of what it is. Primarily a store of value. Of course, that's the emphasis. Is that what Zach is? Is that what Zcash is? Is it basically a store of value? Is it a monetary asset? Should it be valued according to those types of properties? Or how do you think about it? I don't really understand the question. I can view it really. It's like a jargon or there's some distinctions which you're familiar with, which I'm not saying you're wrong. I always thought there was this debates in Bitcoin and Zcash. Elsewhere, it's like what comes first? The store of value or the medium of exchange.
And I had no patience for that. I was literally what comes first to chicken or the egg. Oh, it's the chicken. It's the egg. It's the chicken. You guys like shop. I don't know. It's not what comes first. To me, I'm totally agnostic as to what comes first. But what you were saying is basically, hey, Ryan, if you want privacy or, hey, bankless listener, what you have to actually do is you have to take some of your value, take some of your wealth. You actually have to go. Here's my use case. That's what you're saying. You actually have to go store it in Zcash. For example, it's about four times so far in this for what amount of time.
If you want maximum privacy, then forever, something close to forever. I guess what I'm saying, Zuko, is I think what you were just advocating is the use case of store of value. You're taking your wealth and you're storing it on Zcash privacy. So isn't that what Zcash is? It's a store of value asset. Okay. I'll answer that. But you said something really wrong. If you want maximum privacy, you don't need to store forever. If you want maximum privacy, you have to store it without intentions for how you're intended. You don't keep that content around forever. It's cycles. You spend and add more every little while.
Okay. Anyway, but you know, I think it's really interesting because like I said, I was kind of dismissive with sort of the monetary theorist, but they're theories. And I understand there's stars in there. Yeah. Pay tax. You're a journalist. If you think it taxes. I know. It was about you know, crazy stuff. And I was like, whatever. But then I was thinking, oh, there's this information theory, adversarial information theory, right? Like cryptography, AI, networks, and metadata, spying and protection of metadata networks. It's all what I think of as adversarial information theory. And there's an adversarial information theory reason why you have to be longzack at least at least the amount of your checking account for at least a month or to the way you use the checking account.
I think that's interesting. And I think it's positive because people being longzack is good for society. People have called zack encrypted Bitcoin. What do you think about that meme? Do you like that meme? Yeah, I like it. There was another guy that I really respect, but I guess I won't say his name. There's just among the many people that I've mentioned in this podcast that I really respect and learn from. And there's this one guy who said to me, encrypted Bitcoin is the winning meme because it's only two words. If you were number of words, the better the meme. And there's a debate going on in Zcash governance about my work at shoulder labs, cross link.
I don't know if you're going to wear this. This is Zcash governance because it's not all but a vast majority of Zcashers all have to agree with one another to do a network upgrade, right? Just like in Ethereum and online can Bitcoin. And so we at shoulder labs are advocating and proposing, look, we're building a thing. We recommend that all the other Zcashers adopt it, maybe in 2026, ideally, which adds staking on top of as a, anyway, there's a lot of technical complexity. And the folks that the there is a group of Zcashers who oppose this. And the reason they oppose it, I think, is mimetic warfare.
It's because they say Zcash being encrypted Bitcoin is the winning meme. And at least for now, having the winning meme is the most important strategy. So we shouldn't add proof of state because proof of state is like anathema. It's like kryptonite. It's like the very opposite of Bitcoin, which is a good argument. So I'm trying some jujitsu over here in my corner, which is, yes, you're right, crypto Bitcoin is a great meme. And this cross-link thing, I'm going to stop describing it as proof of state because it's not, it's not switching. Okay, this cross-link thing, I'm going to describe it as strengthening the 21 million cap.
There's these things that we've been doing at shoulder labs, which are kind of all pointed in the same direction. They're all pretty new on its technological things. But they all point in the same direction, which is like sustainability and robustness, resilience. And in particular, the sustainability and the resilience of the 21 million cap. So if we get that accepted by a sufficiently large consensus of Zcashers, then we'll have Zcash will have this unique thing, which I love, which is it's encrypted Bitcoin. It has Bitcoin's 21 million cap. But unlike Bitcoin, it's credibly sustainable. Everyone who investigates will say, yes, I can see how that 21 million cap will endure the foreseeable future.
Whereas if you look closely at Bitcoin, it is unclear how that 21 million cap is going to stay in place. Bitcoin will never have privacy native on chain. Yeah, exactly. I mean, Zcash was born. That is the purpose of Zcash to have privacy be a native attribute of the blockchain. In the Ethereum world, there was always sort of the hope that because Ethereum is turning complete, general purpose, that it would extend, there would be extensions, there would be maybe not native privacy on chain and Ethereum the way there is with Zcash. But we would have enough tools or layer twos that provide that.
I have to be honest like that over the past five years that we've been kind of doing this podcasting, exploring this really hasn't happened with Ethereum. I mean, it's happened in pockets. There's tornado cash. There's rail gun. There's some promising things. There's even more recently, the Zama Protocol, which uses some FHE stuff to kind of do some of this. And so you can start to see a world where you maybe kind of get it on Ethereum. But from a Ethereum perspective, it sure would be nice to have a shielded ETH button embedded in the protocol. And NOMA is on it. NOMA was showing his shirt for the podcast.
Sure. And it's got some numerals on it. I want to share it with some symbols on it. And I think they spell NOMA. Anyway, the NOMA folks gave me the shirt. And they are really good technologists and they've been really good supporters of Zcash for a long time. And in fact, some of them, the ones that gave me this shirt donated to fund shielded labs. They are among these Zcash holders and supporters who support shielded labs. And they're, I really like their computer science and technology. And just recently, I think, like weeks ago, they launched a thing on Ethereum. So anyway, check it out. I haven't tried it myself.
But basically, I'm not surprised about that. It's taken five years for a technical reason, which is that with cheering completeness, you can add anything, but you can't subtract information. That makes sense? Yeah, that makes sense. But why is that? Connect those dots for me. If you have a layer that exposes information about you and you want to build something else on top, if the underlying layer is still exposing the information about you, then the next layer can't fix that. You can't take something. So we run into the problem that you were describing earlier of using Zcash as a little layer.
Privacy, because like a really good mental hack is stop thinking of privacy as a thing, or a quality, or a level, or a feature you can add. Think of, instead, forget about privacy as a thing. Think about information leakage. Your actions are getting information about you as getting exposed to other people. So adding a new feature does not necessarily stop the information from leaking. To do that, you have to stop using everything else. Because when you use the other thing, the whole thing information leaks. So it's possible, I think. I've gone around in the past and said, it's never going to work.
Like the underlying layers will always be leaking information about you. Therefore, it doesn't matter what you add on top. You're still never going to get privacy that way. And Vitalik forced me to back off on that by arguing and showing me I wasn't wrong. It's possible, but it's really hard. I'm not surprised I was taking five years and isn't done yet. Do you think it'll come eventually? You think Ethereum will get privacy close to the level that C-Cash has or shielded? Well, C-Cash is also improving over time. I like the enoma folks and they've just launched a thing which includes privacy. I don't know how it works.
I like the concepts of realment and tornado cash. Like the current cutting edge within C-Cash is we've already fixed the blockchain level black hole and now the current cutting edge of where the privacy and security and UX problems are in the wallets, the mobile wallets. I don't know if Ethereum and people are even started trying to fix that level. It's a lot to do here. I don't mean to be negative. I support you. No, we have a lot of work to do. I mean, the privacy stuff is where you go. Yeah, Zuko, this has been great. Thank you so much for joining us. It's just great to have you in this space.
I'm so glad you've stuck around for so long. Cypher-punk values, crypto, OG, and it's the work that you're doing in C-Cash is fantastic. Thank you so much and thanks for stopping by. Go convert one checking accounts worth of value into ZEC and story in your shielded wallets. Not only will you then get actual black hole privacy, but you'll be contributing to a better world. We need to work for that. We call it going bankless, but that doesn't have the privacy aspect. Encrypted bankless, David. That's what it is. It didn't take so good means. The ZECash was called the Zoddling. The Zoddling goes on and goes on on yourself, right?
The Zoddlers are protecting the future. We got it. We got it. We got it there with the Zoddling note. Of course, none of this has been financial advice. You know, crypto is risky. You could lose what you put in, but people can't see it. If you use ZECash, we are headed west. This is the frontier. It's not for everyone, but we're glad you're with us on the bankless journey. Thanks a lot. Thank you, guys.