Host Ashlee Vance visits Skyroot Aerospace in Hyderabad, India, to speak with co-founders Pawan Kumar Chandana (CEO) and Naga Bharath Daka (CTO) about their historic achievement: launching India’s first private rocket to orbit on its first attempt. The conversation covers Skyroot’s founding before commercial space was legal in India, its rapid and low-cost development of the Vikram-1 rocket, and the broader boom in Indian space startups.
> “We had a good amount of confidence on the hardware. Of course, we had early respect to the statistical odds. But as a vehicle from the ground qualification testing, we had good confidence.” — Naga Bharath Daka
> “We always say that raising capital in India was always like rocket science. Building the rocket is rocket science and raising capital for it is also rocket science because it was very new.” — Pawan Kumar Chandana
> “If there’s one thing that our launch has proven to the Indian entrepreneurial aspiring ecosystem is there’s no quest of deep tech passion that is unthinkable.” — Naga Bharath Daka
This week’s podcast takes place in India with the founders of Skyroot Aerospace, Pawan Kumar Chandana (CEO) and Naga Bharath Daka (CTO).
Earlier this year, Skyroot pulled off a remarkable feat. It flew its first rocket – the Vikram-1 – to orbit. In so doing, Skyroot helped India join the U.S., China and New Zealand as the only countries to have a commercial rocket successfully reach space and complete a mission. First rockets almost always blow up, and so Skyroot’s first-flight success makes it a historic rarity. It also built the Vikram-1 very fast and very much on the cheap.
Skyroot’s backstory is borderline thrilling. Commercial space was illegal in India when Skyroot was founded in 2018. The government wanted total control of the heavens. Skyroot’s founders kept designing their rocket anyway, betting that the government would change its stance.
Over the past few years, India did end up putting laws into place that allowed for commercial rocket and satellite companies. And Skyroot is now the shining example of what the country can do. It has inspired youngsters across India and triggered a commercial space boom with more than 400 start-ups arriving on the scene.
Skyroot already has plans for bigger rockets and hopes to one day fly humans to space.
As we discuss in the episode, India is in a prime position to become a major commercial space power. The country has a long history of doing big things in space through ISRO, its version of NASA. It is full of brilliant engineers and can build rockets and satellites much more cheaply than most countries. India is behind, but it has a chance to join the U.S. and China as the leading commercial space nations.
In this episode, we get into Skyroot’s backstory, its rockets and India’s potential as a tech power in the years ahead.
SPONSOR
The wonderful people at Brex helped make these stories from India possible. You can catch a taste of the adventures here.
I’ve worked at large companies like The New York Times and Bloomberg, and their expense systems were terrible. Brex’s expense management systems, by contrast, are fantastic. AI agents run around taking care of tons of stuff for you and give you back your time.
Your company should switch to Brex to make life better for everyone. Find out more here.
Timestamps
00:00 — Intro03:37 — Orbit on the First Try10:48 — Starting Before the Rules14:44 — What Does Orbit Cost?20:48 — Solid Fuel and Carbon Fiber27:22 — Competing With SpaceX Rideshare35:15 — ISRO and Private Space36:43 — Where Is India’s Risk Capital?41:23 — Why Did China Move Faster?46:14 — The Final Launch Countdown50:54 — India’s Hard Tech Moment
Ashley Vance
We are off to India in this episode to go to the headquarters of Skyroot in Hyderabad. Skyroot is a commercial rocket company in India. This was not even possible until relatively recently. The government wanted total control over the space program and laws have just come into place over the last three or four years that made something like Skyroot possible. Skyroot is an incredible story. They flew their first rocket earlier this year. First rockets typically don't launch, blow up, don't accomplish their mission. Skyroot bested just about everything that has come before. The rocket flew successfully.
It got to orbit. It put some satellites in orbit. It's an incredible feat. I think they did it for... I want to say around $80 million. I apologize if I got that figure wrong, but it's somewhere close. I don't think anybody has ever flown a commercial rocket that cost less than a billion dollars to get to that first rocket, somewhere around there. They have moved fast and done well and are this symbol of the rise of hard tech in India. Kids across the country saw what they accomplished and are now holding Skyroot up as a symbol of what's possible. I went to their factory. It was very impressive.
They've built a small, simple rocket called the Vikram-1 at the beginning, at this early stage, but already have plans for larger rockets. They hope to fly humans one day in addition to satellites, so very ambitious. They are part of a wave. A giant wave of commercial space companies now. There are four to five hundred space startups in India doing both rockets, satellites and things all around them. India has had a national space program for decades. It's incredibly accomplished. They've done missions to the moon and Mars but Like all government programs, they tend to move slow. They would be lucky to launch five or six rockets a year.
And now these commercial space companies are racing to help India compete against the United States and China in particular. And they're well poised to do so. The Russian space program is collapsing. Europe is antiquated and a complete laggard in terms of commercial space and modernizing space. India has some political advantages over the United States and China and could be a massive third player in an era where we Don't have enough rockets. People are trying to send up tens of thousands of satellites and we have a rocket shortage. So this is a huge opportunity for India. I flew to India to meet Skyroot's co-founders who I talked to in this conversation from inside their rocket factory.
It's an incredible story. You're going to enjoy these guys. We get into all the bits and pieces I just talked about. I am Ashley Vance. This is Core Memory. Off to India we go. [music] Introduce yourselves.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah, I'm Fava and co-founder and CEO of Skyrule Aerospace. Hello, I'm Bharat. I'm the co-founder and CEO of Skyrule Aerospace.
Ashley Vance
Fantastic. Thank you guys so much for letting us come here. I'm really honored and excited. I think I immediately got over my jet lag. Anytime I go to a rocket factory, it's exciting. But then I could tell on our getting ready for our trip and We've come here to sort of get into hard tech in India and this shift that's taking place from obviously a super successful country with technology, but this next level of like inventing new things, pushing the limits of what's possible. And you guys are sort of the, I could tell the shining example for everybody. For people who've never heard of Skyroot, Maybe just tell us where we are and some of the basics of the company.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
So first of all, I'm really honored to have you as well at Skyroot. And looking forward to all the interaction. And for everybody who doesn't know or not yet heard about Skyroot, we are a rocket company, as we say. And we have launched India's first private rocket to orbit. It was just like 45 days ago. And today we have three factories which can build one orbital rocket every month. And our aim is to open space for all. This is just the beginning where we start off with launching smaller satellites It's like a business jet for satellites, where they can book the entire rocket and launch to their own destination whenever they want, wherever they want. And eventually, the dream is to launch larger rockets, regular cargo to space, maybe humans to space, and make open space for all.
Ashley Vance
Fantastic. And you guys, so you launched for the first time in 2022. I think that's kind of a model. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
That was a suborbital mission.
Ashley Vance
So suborbital. And you started in 2018, We started in 18. Okay so we make this four-year journey to get to that. And then just this year went orbital. Yeah. And we're successful, I think, both launches, right? You haven't had a... Yeah, yeah. Successful and all, both launches. Which never happens. Yeah. Super rare. Super rare. Very rare. And then this year, just like you said, you're going to launch maybe in a couple... Where are we? We're September, so maybe. Yeah, yeah. Before the end of the calendar, we'll launch again. OK, so that would also be an incredibly fast cadence from first successful orbital launch to the second. Second.
Naga Bharath Daka
Yeah, so how are you doing this? While we were making the first rocket itself, we had a good amount of confidence on the hardware. Of course, we had early respect to the statistical odds. But as a vehicle from the ground qualification testing, we had good confidence. So we produced our second Most of the hardware for second rocket in parallel with the first rocket. That's the reason why you can see the hardware ready for integrated testing on the floor for the second launch. And even the third and fourth launches also a lot of hardware is in making. And thanks to the fortunate success of the first launch, getting it first and great, we were able to push the pedal down on the production of the next launches in the next one year ahead.
Ashley Vance
It's still incredible, though, because, I mean, I remember Rocket Lab, I mean, Peter's sort of a perfectionist, and he wanted the first one to be a success, and, you know, they had some issues with regulators who were watching their launch kind of blowing it up maybe a bit early because of a software error, but then Rocket Lab launched, and then they had a decent gap, you know, between the following launches. Yeah, I mean, it's a really hard thing to do Just from being here this morning, there's some things that remind me of you guys, of each other, which is like a quite young workforce and many people who, Hadn't launched a rocket before. So I don't know. So it stands out as remarkable to me that you've had the successes there. It's very hard to do. So is there something about the culture? How did you figure this out from the beginning?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah. So one thing is I think both of us were rocket scientists before. So we were at the Space Agency. We were part of the team, you know, which built India's largest rocket called LVM3. So we had, you know, we are, I think, fairly deep in what we are doing. And we also have very complimentary He's the hardware, electronics and software guy. So I'm the mechanical and propulsion guy. So we went quite deep into our verticals, which covers almost the entire rocket. And we also handpicked the right team and got exceptional set of people. In fact, average age of our team is just 28 years. And 95% of our team never worked on rockets or space before.
95% had not worked. So what do you think they came from? They had a tech background. Yeah, they have a tech background. They're engineers in other fields, other sectors, some freshers, right out of college. So we had to all bring them on to the rivers of engineering. And that's why we always had been like a company with very strong attention to details. Very strong attention to details. You know, every small thing, you know, we ensured that the design, because if you see the reliability of the rocket starts from the design, how it's conceptualized, the choices of the technology, Design, how it is done, then the manufacturing, testing, everywhere.
The flavor of reliability is in every step of the rocket building. So we were, I think, good enough to ensure that from the conceptualization, from the choices of technology to how we design it, how we test it, everything is incorporated. That rigor, I would say, has been pretty deep, hardcore engineering.
Ashley Vance
But neither of you had run a company before, right?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
You were at this room for like what, almost a decade before? Six years. Six years, okay. Yeah, yeah.
Ashley Vance
Okay, so I'm always just curious about, it's not an easy skill to just start a business and know how to put those types of things.
Naga Bharath Daka
Yeah, yeah, yeah. So being a distro helped us to know what kind of talent is required to, like, that exposure helps us, like, what it takes to build a rocket, what kind of talent is there to build a rocket. So we're much more positioned well when we started, at least to hide the right kind of talent and skill sets required. Okay. As Pan mentioned, like, 95% of the people are outside. They have not worked in the space industry, but other than the propulsion systems, for all other systems, we can have a lateral entry, be it structures design, avionics design, software design. Everyone can laterally enter and learn This safety critical engineering mindset has to be grown and they can become a rocket field engineer. So that knowledge of knowing the right gaps and having the right talent helped us build a good team to be able to execute this.
Ashley Vance
When you guys started, I mean, ISRO is the, for people who might not know, it's the government, sort of US equivalent of NASA in some ways, the government space program, tremendous track record of doing quite extraordinary things. Obviously, all government space programs, I think it's fair to say, move a bit slower than private industry. But you guys started around 2018, and it wasn't even... I don't even think there was like a legal framework in India to allow for a private company, right? But you guys still, the way I understand the story is you sort of started the company and then hoped that the law would catch up. I mean, so that is true. And then what? You just, you had a sense that India would head that direction. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But it must have been a huge...
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah. So in fact, started the company and I was 27 at that time. And then like, you know, we thought like we should, that's the time to take risks. Okay. And then in fact, we were ready, even if it takes 10 years We were ready, even if you're not raising much capital, we'll make some progress, small progress over time. So we were all in. I mean, like, ready to take the flunge, basically. Okay. And then, and I would say, if you're looking back, actually, a lot of things worked in favor, right? The policy has come very quick than what we expected. Capital has come in faster than what we expected.
Ashley Vance
And the policy was just, they just said private space is okay.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah, it's okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So that was announced in 2021 or so. And it was formalized in 2023. So that's when we actually are allowed to do what we are doing. But that went parallel to how our development is. So we didn't have a huge delay, I would say, because of the policy not clinging in.
Naga Bharath Daka
Because policy is just about operating a launch vehicle, not developing a launch vehicle. So you could make it, if you That's right, okay.
Ashley Vance
And I guess part of it... At least when I've dealt with U.S., I mean, it's basically an ICBM of some form. I mean, was that India's concern or they just weren't sure they wanted private companies doing space?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
India thought that we have all the ingredients to build a large space economy from India, because the market is global. And the government space agency's focus is mostly about government missions, meeting the requirements of the government. But this capability of the infrastructure and the ecosystem which exists, for example, the rocket which we launched, has 400 suppliers. The majority of them, all of them in India. That is built toward the ecosystem. The supplier ecosystem is very strong and is built over decades. So there's a lot of ingredients which can help to build a strong private ecosystem. So government thought like it will generate more employment, it will generate more revenue to the country, it will create more strategic talent pool for the country and also position India very strong global in space. These were the four parameters which the government said that let's open up the sector to private players because we have a great history of space in the past. We can continue it beyond or accelerated further with more private investments coming into the picture. And just in the last three, four years, a billion dollar private investment And the reason they
Naga Bharath Daka
haven't done sooner also is not because of any concern. It's always a chicken and egg problem. There's nowhere regulation can proceed the initiative. Of course, as Pan mentioned, there's a huge supply chain ecosystem privatized already, but there's no end-to-end system design initiatives that were ventures that have been started before. So once they saw enough initiatives starting in this domain, they just opened up this is the right time, and we are poised to take it off, and they've announced it. That makes sense.
Ashley Vance
As long as I've covered space, it's a notoriously good way to lose a lot of money, and it's a very high-risk investment. How much did you raise at the beginning, and how did you convince people to come on this journey?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
When we started in 2008, we were both technocrats. We never built a company before. In fact, I didn't even know what is equity. No idea how to raise capital. So I had to Google a lot of things, what is the term sheet, et cetera, et cetera. So we learned on the go. And then what we did is we pinged everybody on LinkedIn, created a LinkedIn account, pinged everybody on LinkedIn, which says Angel Investor, and pinged almost everybody. Yeah. Many people rejected us. And then there's one entrepreneur who built a big e-commerce company called Mintra, which was acquired by Flipkart, which is the Amazon equivalent of India. So that entrepreneur, his name is Mukesh Bansal, and he was very fascinated because he wanted to do something in deep tech. He wanted to invest in next growth of India. And he thought, like, you know, we're the right fit for them. And he was very passionate with space. And he wrote a first check of $1.5 million in 2018. And over a LinkedIn message, that's how we got the capital. And that's how it started.
Ashley Vance
Yeah, 1.5. And then I might, hopefully I won't get this wrong. Have you raised a hundred million to date?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
We've raised close to 155 million.
Ashley Vance
155 million. And I think you're the first space you valued at a billion. And the four year
Naga Bharath Daka
of journey also, the 2018 to 2022 was most difficult journey because there was a COVID date and the regulation also only came in 2021. So rising our next round, Series A was a lot more difficult than what we anticipated because it took a lot convincing and with the regulatory risk in place, institutional capital is very difficult to raise. So we have a lot conviction even in our second round came from entrepreneurs that had conviction on this field. Okay. Post-2021 when the reforms have been announced, 2022 is the first initial capital we raised and that is the moment from which most of the orbital launch vehicle development has actually kick started. 80-90% of the development of Vikram 1 launch is in the last four years.
Ashley Vance
Would you guys say how much, I don't know if it's easier to put a value on this or sort of where you are today, but would you say how much you spent to get to the first orbital vehicle?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
So I think we want to spend less than $70 million.
Ashley Vance
$70 million. So, you know, I mean, that's an incredible figure because usually it's on the order of a billion dollars historically to get to that. But Rocket Lab might have been a bit under, but many others were not. And I was looking at some of this math before we were chatting. I mean, is that... I'm sure you'll tell me it's because you're running the company very officially, which I'm sure you are, but are there inherent advantages in doing this in India that helps? Because I think you have like over a thousand employees and still if you've only raised a hundred, what was it? 135? 155. I mean, that's still for all of this and that many. Yeah. So is it cheaper to do this in India or you're just running the company very well?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
No, I think both. I think both. In fact, it's cheaper to run it in India, number one. And in fact, we're running it very efficiently. You know, typically, you know, you see you'll have a few failures. And because the first one succeeded also, we lose less money here. I would say because of that. And the third thing is that we had very less failures on the ground testing as well. Now we have typically a lot of capital gets consumed in ground testing, where you see failures to make the next iteration, next iteration. But I think our ground test campaign has also Tremendously successful. We had mostly successful ground testing campaigns. Because we were very prudent on what we build. We build something, we want to make it work. And generally it works. So I think that way we saved a lot of time. And time is money. A lot of time. And because of the success rate, we saved a lot of capital as well.
Naga Bharath Daka
And we should send the government policy also that opened up the public infrastructure in ISRO. Yeah. So we're going to test like all other ways capital intensive test infrastructure was available. We could test our solid population stages in ISRO facilities. We could launch from ISRO facilities without building our own launchpad.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
So you didn't have to build a test dam.
Naga Bharath Daka
So a lot of capital investment has been saved. We went to a first launch without needing to have our own launchpad, which we will not need also because of the launchpad infrastructure. India has already built it.
Ashley Vance
Did they lay you on the main, the same pad as the BSLV? They did?
Naga Bharath Daka
Yeah, yeah, yeah. They got confidence and only then they let us. That's brave. Okay.
Ashley Vance
That's pretty good. This episode is brought to you by Brex. I spend all of my time inside of the world's most ambitious companies making rockets, semiconductors, robots. Very often the business is struggling and then all of a sudden things click and take off. Then the company's expenses spin out of control. They either have to clamp down, start counting pennies, or cross their fingers, hope for the best that the quarter or the year comes out okay. Brex was built to handle exactly these situations. It helps you move fast, spend smarter at the same time. They've got credit cards, banking, expense management all in one place. They've got A.I., Technology, looking over everything, taking care of tasks for you. No more chasing down receipts. We use Brexit Core Memory. It has been a godsend in giving me back so much time. Giants like Anthropic and Zoom use Brex as well, and so do tens of thousands of startups. You should use Brex, and you can find out exactly how to do that by going to brex.com slash Core Memory. It seems like with the first rocket and even the first orbital, I mean, so you're going, it's a four-stage rocket for the orbital vehicle.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
It's actually three core stages. The other one is more like an orbital. Like a kick stage. Yeah, like a kick stage does orbital, orbit changes. Okay. Right? And it's essentially three core stages.
Ashley Vance
And maybe we should explain that to people. So three stages to kind of get you to space and then the last one is to help with the satellite in the right place. And so the first three are using solid rocket motors and the fourth is liquid. I mean, this is kind of where I was going with my question. It seemed like you, so, oh, we should explain this for people too who are not space junkies, but so you can usually either go solid rocket motor or liquid. Solid is traditionally, I think, a little bit easier They're less complicated going on. But once you light it, you're all in. You can't stop it. You're going to go. And so people who might be familiar with SpaceX or Rocket Lab, they've used liquid rockets because you can turn it on and off. It just gives you a little more control. And it seemed like you guys picked solid because it was like the quickest path to prove that you might know what you're doing. Is that fair?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
No. In fact, looking at the first principles thinking, Actually, the lowest fast orbital rocket you can afford for the payload mass we're looking at. Quickest path to development. Fast is low, quickest path to development, fairly more reliable, and also very good to mass produce. So today we're getting the second launch very quick, and we're getting more launches next year. Still with the solid rockets? Yes, because it's mass producible. Okay.
Naga Bharath Daka
It's one of the best architectures for the small expendable launch vehicles.
Ashley Vance
Right, but most of the small rocket companies, they all went... Liquid, yeah.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
So exactly, we didn't want to do the same thing, you know, because they also had their own struggles to mass produce, they had their own struggles to action scale to larger rockets with reliability, so many other factors, because we started the company in 2018. And we can't do the same or similar thing as anybody else. We have to have something different, something which can make us quicker, cheaper, faster. So that way, I think we've made these choices more like first principle And that's what actually made us get to launch this very quick. And the first thing I said, like, you know, one is, of course, it's cheaper to operate in India. They also had a good successful ground campaign and also the choices we made in technology. Yeah. You know, because, for example, the first stage has only one engine, right? So typically, like, if you have a sick build, you need, like, so many engines to build. You need a production line and you have so many components. It's so much testing to go on. Solid Field, the beauty is that you test only once and lifetime. That's it.
Ashley Vance
And then you 3D print the liquid engine, which is common practice now. Carbon fiber for the body is a little bit more of a divisive. Some people do it, some people don't. So what made you pick carbon fiber over metal? Because I guess for some of the reasons you outlined that solid rocket motors make sense, you could argue carbon fiber does it because it's sort of harder and more expensive.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
I think the rocket will become much bigger if it was metal. And carbon fiber, we love how the manufacturing is so scalable. And it's very tough to crack. The moment you crack it, it becomes very scalable. And it's in fact, every year the technology is improving, the cost is going down. And it's very, very competitive. I mean, it's far better than we believe what metals can bring in. So the rocket becomes more efficient, more manufacturable, more mass-producible.
Ashley Vance
And I know I'm not an expert here. I mean, when I think of countries with long expertise in carbon fiber, I would think of maybe the United States a little bit in Europe and then anywhere associated with America's Cup sailing team like New Zealand oddly has a lot of carbon fiber expertise. I mean, was this something India had a track record with or you've had to figure this all out?
Naga Bharath Daka
No, no. The carbon fiber expertise is something we had to develop from scratch. A lot of us, we spent a lot of time on the codes to actually provide and the methodology to manufacture processes. Has been developed from scratch. And then Indian government issues have some heritage. But what India lacks currently is only the ability to produce the carbon fiber source, which we need to import. But all the manufacturing expertise, both with respect Layup activity or composite filament binding activities. Everything is totally indigenized skill set. And we are one of the good center of excellences in the country, we can say, in the carbon fiber composites.
Ashley Vance
So I think there's a machine we can't film back there, the winding machine. So do you buy that? Because usually those come from like Germany or, yeah.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah, no, no, I think we have multiple sources. And now the new machine we have is from India. Okay. So, in fact, most of the machinery we build, there's also one advantage. I think most of the machinery is localized, right? So we build it within India. Some machines we import, depending on the quality, size, timeline, so many other details. But almost every machine can be built in India, and a lot of infrastructure also is built in India, which also has both the cost benefit and also a good timeline benefit as well.
Ashley Vance
But if you were picking... In those early days, I get it for all the reasons you said. I mean, it's lightweight, it's stronger, the rocket's going to be smaller. But that seems, if you're picking solid rocket motors because you know that's going to be a quicker, easier path, this seems like a huge bet to go carbon.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Not exactly, actually, because we did it in very quick time. But how did you know it was going to work?
Naga Bharath Daka
We want it to be efficient also. Otherwise, we would need a much bigger rocket for the same payload capacity we were targeting. Okay. The 0 to 1 problems are okay to crack and once this is cracked, the 1 to 10 problem is very easy. We can easily scale the production and in a fully liquid expendable launch vehicle, even the 1 to 10 scaling becomes harder as I have seen. And that is the advantage where we're targeting it to make the 1 to 10 journey easier, even though there's a zero to one we need to spend some time. And even that is reasonably short of time compared to the other alternatives.
Ashley Vance
So you guys, you started in 2018 and it's, I mean, it's a really interesting time because you had SpaceX, From this period of like 2012 onward really hits its stride. Yeah. Falcon 9's launching more and more, reuse is getting dialed in, but then you had this wave of small rocket startups that Sort of thought they would be able to launch quicker and service this need that SpaceX couldn't. We knew a lot of people had a hunch we were going to have to launch a lot of satellites and that you would want this. You didn't always want to wait for a big rocket. But then things have sort of shaken out in a little bit of a different way than people thought.
SpaceX is launching so often. And then they started doing rideshare. And really undercut the small rocket players. And then you're kind of coming in at this stage where there had been a bunch of companies, especially in the U.S., that had a massive head start. And so, I mean, I can see it 100%. It's like even if India alone wanted this capacity, that's probably good enough. And then you have customers that you can get as well. But I mean, it is like a high... So high risk, I guess at that time it would have made a lot of sense. How do you feel now as things have shaped? Because I think everybody who started with a small rocket now is moving to a big rocket if they want to survive over the long term.
But it is a chicken and egg because you sort of have to prove that you can do something before somebody is going to give you $10 billion to make a giant rocket.
Naga Bharath Daka
If someone would have given us like $300 million on day one, Of course, we will, but there's a lot of opportunity, market opportunity for even now, for this small rocket, a lot of interest, because as you know, even the bookings for SpaceX from 2028, the ride share program has been in limbo. Yeah. There's a lot of uncertainty for small satellites to get the right to. Even now it's hardly, other than Rocket Lab, there's no operation, regularly operational private player. So it's still heavily supply constant market and small satellite operators are still We're still looking for a reliable, regular, right-share space. And that is some opportunity we're going to unlock, not just in US, but a good amount of European market we're seeing, a good amount of APAC market we're seeing, because they need to go to very unique orbits to serve their nations, which only the geographies of India can serve, basically. So that's also one good market we'll be capturing.
Ashley Vance
It's always the what if. I mean, what if Starship really does work the way Elon says that it's launching Rocket Lab's entire history I mean, how does that factor into your thinking?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
I think the Falcon 9 Starship is a different market. So basically, they can't go to a unique orbit for one satellite. For example, one or two satellites, they want a very unique orbit, then it is specific L-10 or specific orbital parameter. They can't book the entire Starship or entire Falcon 9, which was a bomb for launching just one or two satellites. So better if they book with smaller rocket companies, book the entire rocket for a few million dollars. Think of it like a business jet. Market business jet is different from a commercial airliner, but the market is not very large. The time of this is probably 10% of the overall launch time.
Ashley Vance
Launching rockets is very sexy. It's a horrible business, usually, because even Rocket Lab, which is easily the most successful after SpaceX and the best at everything you just described, they don't really make most of their money. From launching rockets.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah, yeah, yeah. But if you see both of them, whether it's SpaceX or Rocket Lab, will launch regularly. Their launch businesses have been fairly profitable. That's what the numbers, Sean, say. So that means, Once you get a good operational cadence, and when you have the customers going, I think it's fairly a profitable business. So if you can get there faster, quicker, with better differentiation, better price points, or even more customer requirements than what was possible And I see the biggest challenge more than the market is actually getting the rockets going, you know, sustainably, reliably. How can we have multiple launches going well in a sustainable manner? There's a different problem statement to solve.
Ashley Vance
It's like you said with Rocket Lab. I've seen it time and again. People do one, two launches. SpaceX and Rocket Lab are still the only ones to figure out how to do it over and over again. That's a big problem.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Exactly. That's a big challenge to solve. And that's where we are in. I mean, like, you know, we did the first launch, but that's the next step. You know, we get to a high cadence launching, continuous successes. And then once we get there, I see, we see based on, I think, the kind of, you know, interest or the launch. I mean, it looks like, you know, market may not be such a big risk. But like getting the sustainable launch is always a risk. And we have put the first launch, which is very rare to succeed. But that doesn't mean that like, you know, we'll have like continuous successes at scale. While even though we can get to scale, I mean, like as we built today, the second launch is happening in a few months and we're building, we are manufacturing the third, fourth, fifth at this peak. So it's under production, but I think getting them sustainably successful in a long-term fashion is a problem to crack, which we are on it.
Ashley Vance
And you're, I mean, the future of the company is liquid fuel rockets and it is bigger rockets and it is heading hopefully maybe to human, like very big satellites and possibly even humans. Do you have any timeline on this? Yeah.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah, I mean, it's difficult to put the timeline on rockets.
Ashley Vance
It's a horrible game to play.
Naga Bharath Daka
Because there will be newspaper articles where we claim that we're going to launch in 2024, end of 2024, end of 2025, and we ended up doing it in 2025. You guys did great.
Ashley Vance
That was very good.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
So yeah, we're very careful with the timeline, but I would say we're making Significant progress. Really good progress. And a lot of learnings on this will go on that. And in fact, we have an upgrade of this vehicle called Vikram 2, which puts over a ton to orbit. And it uses some metal locks, you know, metal locks very, you know, cycle for the engine and then... Is that being built already? Yeah, it's been built.
Ashley Vance
And that's at the other... You have three factories. One's not too far from here, which we're going to see. Is it at that one?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah. So in fact, we do a mix of outsource and insource. So for example, all the carbon components we do insource. And 3D printing, quite a lot of it goes from already built-in So we outsource and as we scale further, we'll have a lot built in-house. So it's a mix of in-house and outsource. And that's how it is. Anything super critical and what's not available fully in the outside ecosystem, we build in-house. And that's all we use outside whatever ecosystem exists and build really good suppliers and have really long-term contacts with them or long-term relationship with them.
Ashley Vance
So you had Prime Minister Modi congratulate you. Like I said before, I mean, you can tell the country's excited. I think even when similar things were happening in the US with SpaceX, at least early on, I mean, there was still tension between SpaceX and NASA over how's this going to play out, who's going to do what, and... It was kind of split half and half where half of NASA wanted SpaceX to exist and half didn't. What's the relationship between ISRO and now that they see what you guys are doing? Are you a threat? Is the same sort of tension exist?
Naga Bharath Daka
No, no, because the space policy has made it very clear. So the singular objective of the space policy is to chart a path for India to gain reasonable market share in the space economy. And that the government truly believes that it can only happen by active participation of private industry. So any business, any activity of space that has commercial opportunity, be it launching satellites through orbit, be it space-based, every aspect of space-based commercial opportunity has to be explored So if industry is already
Ashley Vance
capable, they can
Naga Bharath Daka
execute if they're not capable, the mature technologies that ISRO will transfer to the industry so that the commercial opportunity can be pursued by the industry because the mandate of ISRO It's not the commercial exploitation of the technologies they develop. They're the frontier research organization. So they will still be working on the frontier technologies, interplanetary missions, human space missions. All those things are tremendous challenges in front of them to be able to execute over the next decade.
Ashley Vance
Okay, but if India is trying to gain more market share, you're competing against, SpaceX has become so dominant, and then you've got, obviously, incredibly deep pockets with Jeff Bezos. You've got everything the
Naga Bharath Daka
US does.
Ashley Vance
The billionaires, you've got venture capital, and then you've got NASA and the government supporting. China has clearly made this a massive priority, and I suspect it's probably outspending everybody, just about. And then after that, it gets pretty good. Europe's Pretty fucked. I would see India having a major chance, but when I look at how much you got, if that is the national priority, I mean, this is your chance to ask for more money. Why are people not pouring billions of dollars into what you're doing? It seems like if that's the goal, there should be a lot more capital coming in.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
I think we always say that raising capital in India was always like rocket science. Building the rocket is rocket science and raising capital for it is also rocket science because it was very new. The entire sector was very new and we were more like the poster company. Every round we raise was the largest, almost the largest trust in the sector. Pushing the boundaries. And we face the brunt of being the first player, typically. So I think breaking that, and it's also very beautiful, actually, You need to build in constraints. When you have a lot of capital, billions of dollars of capital, you think differently. When you're a resource constrained, you think differently. You have to make things work. You have to make things fast. You have to use less. You can't be inefficient. It really builds a different company. I think that's really helped us a lot because everywhere we were resource constrained at every point of time.
Ashley Vance
That part I can see, because if you look at SpaceX versus Blue Origin, I think the SpaceX culture is dramatically different of what comes out the other side. But when you're competing against nation states that are very committed to doing well in space, it feels hard. This is part of what I want to do on this trip, is to try to get to the heart of some of this. Remains quite unique in this risk tolerance. I think maybe you can see China's embracing it a bit more. Israel, I feel like had to go through a couple generations of people going to Silicon Valley, making a lot of money, seeing how the venture capital business operated.
Coming back, being a little more willing. But even there, I mean, the US, I travel the whole world. It just remains unique in how much money people are willing to gamble. Like intuitively, I would think India would be perfect for this because there's Indians running the largest companies in Silicon Valley, many generations of venture capitalists. And people that go back and forth, but it still doesn't seem, you know, when I'm talking to like these 20 year olds starting these companies, they're very frustrated at how much they can raise. I mean, so what, is it a, is it just like a cultural, I'm always trying to get to the heart of why this is.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
I think you're right in saying that risk capital is very high in the US. But the point is that the awareness is just building up now. I think the awareness is just building up now. Now we see a huge interest. That is one. And then the other thing is also that they have to have built... They should have trust in the Indian ecosystem because when they put their money here, they should have themes here, they should have a thesis for India, they should see how the geopolitics is moving. So it's like a fund which is traditionally in the US always, Everything in India needs to have a thesis. I see some companies actually building it because now the opportunity is also here.
So I think it's just a matter of time it comes where there is capital in some of it. I mean, of course, not a major portion of it, but some of it can actually come to India and risk capital in India also is growing. After, for example, our success, there will be a few more successes coming, and there's a huge government push coming. So I think that gives confidence to investors that companies can scale to a level of global competence, or at least can have the potential to go global in the future, and the market is global. So I think there is risk capital also growing in India. What we've seen in 2018 to now...
Naga Bharath Daka
It changed a lot. There's absolutely no risk capital at seed level also. Now, there's a lot of seed stage, early stage risk capital. And of course, the growth stage risk capital is something that is still a problem to be solved at scale. But I'm sure by the end of this decade, that transition also would have rather happened.
Ashley Vance
Maybe I'm being unfair. It just feels like it took a long time. If I think about China's reputation over the last 30, 40 years, obviously it started out like, oh, you're copying technology. That went on until relatively recently. I think maybe people were sort of naive to how much progress they were actually making. And clearly today, I mean, innovative on all sorts of fronts from China. Hardware to biotech, to energy, you name it. And in my head, India has a much longer track record of tech success and of seeing what the U.S. did that made a lot of this work. Yeah, I mean, is there something I'm missing or it just takes... I'm curious why it seemed to kind of like Transition faster in China when it feels like China was coming from much further behind.
Naga Bharath Daka
Is that fair? There is some truth to stereotype, as every stereotype is half truth and half exaggeration. There's some truth to it in the sense of The big corporations in India were always more, the prime focus was always on the business opportunity than investing on the R&D that actually can scale the opportunity for them, can open up the opportunity for themselves in the future. So like basically outsourcing call centers. Exactly, depending on the extent so that has So even that mindset, even among the corporations, it's changing. And general, there's a cultural aspect change also a decade ago. Most of the people are not Groomed to look up to entrepreneurship as a big goal. So that also has changed. There's a big moment started by the government of India called Startup India who actually not make starting a business a taboo because the golden target for most of the children growing up is actually study well and get a good job in a big corporation. So that mindset change of actually aspiring to be an entrepreneur also has changed now. So I agree that it has taken time, but we are in the transition and it's going to just bloom much bigger.
Ashley Vance
That is the single biggest thing I see, which is the US is the... It might still be like maybe the only place where you can fail and it is not seen as a disgrace. Because when I go to a lot, people don't want to become an entrepreneur. They'd rather take the safe job because if you go do your business and it fails, you might never get another chance or you're kind of looked down upon. Whereas in the U.S., God, the more money you earn through, the next time you get, you get to go again. And for some reason, we're okay with that and nowhere else seems to be.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
That's, I think... That ecosystem is what I think built the US to where it is today. In fact, recently I was watching an interview of Jeff Bezos asking what makes the US US because of the risk capital it has. I mean, people ready to You can find completely out-of-the-box ideas, completely new breakthroughs, and writing large checks even for companies, breakthrough tech, which we can't even think is too risky, but still below that. So I think that has made the ecosystem so well. So innovative, large initiatives with the largest corporations in the world, right? I think in India, I think that ecosystem, the Silicon Valley type of ecosystem needs large success stories coming to a picture. So it's always a cycle, right? So I think we need some companies pushing the boundaries, some investors pushing the boundaries, and then it's not going to be immediate. It's going to be a completely cultural change.
Ashley Vance
But you guys would be like... Maybe, yeah. Yeah. The model, yeah. Are you... It's probably a hard question to answer, but when I go to New Zealand, I mean, Peter Beck, maybe like now, but for a long time, he was not like Elon or Jeff Bates. Nobody really knew him, even though I always thought he'd be like a celebrity or something, because it's like, God, this guy from the middle of nowhere is launching rockets from this country that's never been to space. I mean, do people know you guys on the street? I don't know.
Naga Bharath Daka
Yeah, after the launch... The news is fresh in the memory. Maybe after a month, people will forget because after the launch for a week, it was all of the news. For most of the common public, it's fresh in my memory from what they're watching TV. So we see some people... Did you do all the news shows and things like that?
Ashley Vance
Yeah.
Naga Bharath Daka
Unless it's continuously there, everyone will forget. In two months, I'm not sure as many people will recognize. Okay.
Ashley Vance
What was, um, I'll let you go in a second, but, um, I mean, walk me through the, you could pick the suborbital or the orbital, whatever. I'm just curious of your personal experience because it's such a nerve wracking moment. And I know, especially rocket companies in particular, hardware companies are different to software and rockets, I think are the most difficult of Showing the entire world whether you've made it or you haven't, right? And then often, if that first rocket blows up, that might be your last chance and everybody got to see that it didn't work. It's very different to launching a software product and getting to wait months to see. Yeah, so what was it like when you're in Sreeharikota? Like for people who don't know, you need rockets launch off the East Coast of the country on this island, Sreeharikota. I imagine you probably went there and were, Probably there for weeks or something waiting for the launch. And then, yeah, I mean, walk me through before you push the button, before the computer automated over there.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yes, absolutely. I think definitely the orbital launch was, you know, a lot of, I think it's a different feeling of tension and excitement because we knew that we've done a good job, but there's always tension because The permutation combinations of things can go wrong in a rocket launch is so many. And we're using the PSLV launch pad, for example. There's a lot of infrastructure involved. There is a lot of first launch tension always. So it's like a sleepless nights on what did we do wrong? Have we forgot something? Have we not taken care of some particular system? It's like last, I think, few weeks were like, I think, filled with this kind of tension across the team. And when, I think, a few minutes before the launch, you generally become like a little bit blank and very silent. The mind becomes so silent in the moment. And in fact, just before the launch, we had five minutes before there was a hold. It was all being telecasters across.
Ashley Vance
What happened?
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah.
Ashley Vance
Oh, sorry. What happened? There was a hole.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
There was a hole. A hole? Yeah. So we had an automatic launch sequence. OK. Oh, a hole, a hole. Yeah, yeah, yeah. A launch hole. So just five minutes before liftoff, we had a launch hole. And there was a small software glitch in the ground software, which we had to fix. And then we were back again. In 30 minutes, we took off. So it was just like a lot of suspenseful events. And then the takeoff went well. And then the rocket stayed in the right direction. I was half relieved when the rocket turned in the right direction. And then there was state separation, and then second state separation. I thought it was beyond the expectation already. And then every event was phenomenally done, like clockwork. I think more than 1,000 systems, more than tens of thousands of components all have to work together to make it successful.
Ashley Vance
Yeah, for people who don't know, Not exploding on the pad is kind of goal number one. Max Q. That's all we prayed for. Yeah, because then you're in deep shit with everybody. Max Q. Max Q is sort of the next stage. This is what this building is named after. And it's the moment of maximum pressure on the rocket. Then you want to reach orbit. You want to fly as long as possible, get as much data as you can. Stage separation, reach orbit. And then like... If all these miracles have occurred and you're actually able to put a satellite somewhere, that's the part that's especially unheard of. So how did you deal with the situation?
Naga Bharath Daka
As you rightly pointed, it's all one high propensity event of failure after the other. As we post lift off, we'll just be anxious about the next thing and there's absolutely zero emotion in mind. We're just looking out for the next uncertainty after the next uncertainty until we almost reach orbit.
Ashley Vance
I like how you guys have named your buildings. So this is Max Q, which I would think of getting through all of that.
Naga Bharath Daka
Then you immediately went to infinity.
Ashley Vance
So not holding back.
Naga Bharath Daka
Yeah, we thought of some other name in the rugged descent phase, but nothing looked great and we chose the infinity. Just went for it.
Ashley Vance
Okay. I think we get to hang out. I'll try not to keep taking it. One last question. If I'm on this quest and I'm being told India's turning this corner, it's the hard tech, we're not just kind of mimicking things, we're Innovating and pushing things forward. And so I'm going to be going to see drone companies, other people doing carbon fiber machines and all this stuff. Yeah, I mean, so how, I mean, how encouraged are you by that? How much do you really believe and buy into this idea that it's a little hard for me? So I love the enthusiasm, but then I've got this 20 year old kid telling me he's Doing carbon fiber better than anybody in the world on these drones. And I'm like, well, maybe. I mean, it's possible, but I'm a little skeptical. What's your outlook for maybe how long this takes or what you're seeing from these? And they complain, again, the same thing, that they're not getting enough money for what they're trying to do. So, yeah, I don't know what's your general feeling for this moment in time.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Yeah, yeah. No, I think like just unleashing of the potential, which already exists. You know, we had like a great engineering talent available in the country, which is a large land tab. We're just stabbed by global institutions actually, you know, but not tapped in building innovations in India. Just because the risk capital doesn't exist, the policies were not very convenient, and the people didn't choose entrepreneurship and pushing the frontiers. All three are coming together now. So I think the fundamentals are in place and successes need to come. So like, you know, more like, you know, previously we were telling that we will reach our bear.
And we will do it in the shortest amount of cost, in the shortest amount of time. But the launch proved it. So we need these moving moments. And now we have to get to scale. So all these companies which are doing, I think Potential already exists. And they can do a phenomenal job. And then they have to get to those milestones. And these milestones have a ripple effect. So they'll make more people think that they can also do. And more risk capital comes in because they think that people and companies can scale and investors can make money. So I think it's just a cycle. I think India is the North's journey.
And now I think the time has come where all the ingredients are coming together for a great ecosystem. And I'm very optimistic and hopeful that this will all turn into something great.
Ashley Vance
What do you think it was about you two that at this young age, you were the two that were willing to do this?
Naga Bharath Daka
No, it is not understood. We were one of the early movers in the deep tech and space tech ecosystem, but if there's one thing that our launch has proven to the Indian entrepreneurial aspirin ecosystem is there's no quest of deep tech passion that is unthinkable. So people are much more encouraged now, to actually self-encourage, not to even start something obscenely difficult, what is very, very otherwise very, very difficult, and that fear actually stops. That energy and that confidence to try out extreme deep tech initiatives in the private sector has grown. And that is something we are happy about, that this accomplishment has created that ripple effect in the deep tech ecosystem in India, so that we can go one notch higher and quicker.
Ashley Vance
I'm excited to see it. Thank you guys so much. I always get excited, but something like this where it's like, It's not just doing a rocket. There's a lot that comes with it is extra exciting. And, um, I think I suspect this podcast will run. Before the video episode is done, so everyone should come back and watch the video episode where we tour around the factory and see some of the launch footage and get into more of the history. But thank you so much for letting us come and hang out here. We really appreciate it. Thank you.
Pawan Kumar Chandana
Thank you, Ashlee. Pleasure, pleasure having you. And also, I think the kind of person you ask clearly knows that you have been riding with rockets for space nerd. It was a very pleasure, pleasure, you know, having you here and also talking with you. Thank you.
Ashley Vance
The Core Memory Podcast is hosted by me, Ashlee Vance, and or Kylie Robison, or both of us together. It is produced by me and David Nicholson. Our theme song is by James Mercer and John Sortland. And the show is edited always by the John Sortland. Thank you so much to Brex for all your support, and thank you most of all to everybody for listening or watching. We love you. Please leave us a like, a review, a subscribe, all of those tremendous things. Thank you, and we'll see you again. [music]