Prineha Narang is one of the rising stars of science and the field of quantum technology.
She earned her PhD in applied physics at Caltech, taught materials science at Harvard and now has her own lab at UCLA. The lab focuses on quantum materials, non-equilibrium dynamics, photonics, quantum information science and other easily digestible areas. Beyond her academic career, Narang is a science advisor to the government and a venture capitalist at DCVC.
As you might imagine, we get into quantum computing and quantum technology in this episode. Quantum vs. AI, the US vs. China, when quantum tech will break encryption, quantum sensing and whether or not quantum technology actually has a bright future. The quantum sensing portion of the chat was all new to me and rather astonishing.
Since Narang is also a competitive runner and mountaineer, we provide some top tips on gear because that is just the kind of all-purpose podcast that we deliver.
And, if you can’t get enough quantum computing, come check out our video episode on PsiQuantum building the largest quantum machine in history.
Enjoy!
OUR SPONSORS
SendCutSend
You know who else makes stuff for America? That would be SendCutSend. If you want to celebrate our great nation by building a metal part, then head on over to SendCutSend where you’ll get a 15 percent discount thanks to Core Memory on whatever you’re trying to build. We believe in you!
Brex
The Core Memory podcast is also sponsored by Brex, the intelligent finance platform built to help companies spend smarter and move faster.
Did we go to Texas, find a telescope ranch and then obtain an entire nebula in Brex’s honor? Oh yes, we did.
We run on Brex and so should you. Learn more about Brex right here.
Narang Lab at UCLA:
https://naranglab.ucla.edu
DCVC:
https://www.dcvc.com
Oratomic (the Caltech neutral atom spinout):
https://www.oratomic.com
Atom Computing:
https://atom-computing.com
Mesa Quantum:
https://mesaquantum.com
Google's work on the cost of quantum factoring: https://blog.google/security/tracking...NIST Post-Quantum Cryptography: https://csrc.nist.gov/projects/post-q...DARPA Quantum Benchmarking Initiative: https://www.darpa.mil/research/progra...Hyperlite Mountain Gear (the Dyneema packs Prineha swears by):
https://www.hyperlitemountaingear.com
Timestamps (they link out to YouTube)
00:00 Intro02:17 The Physicist Who Almost Became a Pro Runner13:39 A Cold Email, a Full Ride, and the Road to Caltech26:15 How Video Game Chips Quietly Took Over Science31:56 Is Quantum Losing the Spotlight to AI?40:50 "I Still Don't Believe in Quantum": Answering the Skeptics46:28 The Google Result That Could Break Encryption53:44 Is It Time to Panic About Q-Day?1:06:48 Quantum Sensing and the Case of Who Sneezed1:17:30 Does Consciousness Run on Quantum Rules?1:22:28 The Advice She Gives Terrified Students1:30:20 So When Does Quantum Actually Get Real?
No summary for this episode yet.
Speaker 2
okay we are heading off into the quantum realm we're going to talk quantum computing we're going to talk quantum encryption sensing quantum verse ai all the quantum stuff it's fascinating area science technology to explore it's always a bit daunting to understand but we have a great guide with us today praneha narang is a professor at ucla she is an incredibly accomplished scientist and academic she has done her studies at caltech she's worked at mit and harvard and now obviously ucla she advises the government on quantum policy she's also a venture capitalist at dc vc where again she's helping out on their strategy around quantum technology in this episode i'm always curious what's real about quantum even though it's come so far it still feels like as time goes on it's unclear um if there are tons of things where it's useful or if we're getting we're getting quite far on our own and so we get into all that we obviously get into where quantum and ai competes or complement with each other and on this quantum sensing stuff which is an area of extreme expertise for Praneha it's just fascinating the idea of being able to use these quantum properties to detect things out in the world beyond being an incredibly impressive overachiever in her academic and professional career Praneha is also a she's a competitive marathoner ultra runner mountaineer everything she does she does with maximum effort and she's a wonderful guest i am ashley vance this is core memory off into the quantum realm we go pre thank you for coming thank you of having me here how are you doing you're you're always traveling all around
Speaker 1
well it's just been a very very exciting few weeks for quantum it has been yeah
Speaker 2
so we got we've got some news items that i was gonna i was gonna jump into and then obviously we're gonna do all sorts of quantum things i was gonna start us off a little more on you because just just some of your background i tend to cover fairly exceptional people with rather extraordinary backgrounds what i noticed with yours is a i mean you're a fast forwarding life you you've accomplished uh rather large um remarkable things in a short period of time both professionally and then i noticed um last time you were here we were just hanging out having lunch you had there's this bag that i think you take on these these ultra hikes or camping and then you know if anyone digs in to your background there's so much about you were going to be perhaps a professional athlete you're deeply into to running and i i noticed you strike me as somebody who who does just about everything you're into quite intensely and this this made me curious about when i see this it always makes me curious about somebody's background it just just you know sometimes these things just happen and then sometimes there's forces well not a professional athlete i wanted
Speaker 1
to be one realized you have to be really really fast as a runner to even sort
Speaker 2
of make it yeah and you wanted to be a marathon runner you know i ran track
Speaker 1
and i didn't know that marathons are where most track athletes end up but i thought i'd be a you know fast track athlete and it's just all going to work out and then i realized wait could i have this physics thing too right yeah well
Speaker 2
and i saw there's an anecdote about all this but before we get to that so where'd you where did you grow up i grew up in
Speaker 1
the east coast i don't normally talk about my early life too too much outside of uh athletics and the fact that i think i've always been obsessed with physics always been obsessed with science and for a very short amount of time i thought i'd be a mathematician then i realized proof-based math is its own thing yeah so anyways that was my uh how did i get to this part of science story i'll ask this delicately then is there
Speaker 2
a reason you don't talk too much about your your background it's just
Speaker 1
a little complicated and you know just uh i i don't have family anymore so i try not to talk about that okay okay it's nothing nothing nefarious nothing too exciting it's just uh yeah
Speaker 2
yeah and so you were you okay so clearly you were into athletics as a kid and then and then obviously math and science i mean were you a like this picture i was portraying were you quite a driven teenager and you you were feeling compelled that you were gonna go into to math or science or i think competitive yeah you know like
Speaker 1
the typical athletic competitive kid i wanted to be first and i cared about that for some reason and you know with science there's always okay there's this thing called the physics olympiad which is basically track and field for physicists and so i was like well i want to be good at that i want to win that what does that look like and i think in all of these things i started to develop what we now call problem solving skills you know how do you look at something that's framed as this like awkward physics problem and i'm going to use my hands to describe it because at least all the physics olympiad problems from my era were classical physics and that meant these weird pulleys and weird masses and different spots here's that had to go from this picture to like equations to then solving something and i didn't realize but my desire to be winning this whatever that meant uh also meant that i was learning how to actually problem solve okay
Speaker 2
and i mean i interviewed lots of people who've done the math olympiad i don't run into too many who've done the physics so that that sounds daunting and horrible
Speaker 1
to me it's same idea you know people come up with more and more complex problems to solve every year and the physics olympiad is actually interesting because you can't do um quantum mechanics it's not fair game okay so so i do all of this and i now do zero classical mechanics but at the time i thought all the physics is classical mechanics and you know you have these textbooks they have complicated problems you go to the next one and it's it's really the analogy with athletic endeavors is very very uh clear if you know you you look at these and you're marked on these problems and then you can um i'd say graduate from one to the other if you actually can complete all the problems in some amount of time so uh that's at least when i realized i enjoyed physics a lot okay and this this is
Speaker 2
in your high school years so you're you're super competitive you're running track doing i'm very unpopular were you you were were you a nerd yes that's putting it mildly yeah yeah i mean you know meaning um you're just off studying all the time and and not socializing a lot or yeah i think
Speaker 1
the social skills maybe you know if all the things that could make the 24 hours that was not making it okay and so that required some development later in life
Speaker 2
and then i mean there's a story you tell of of and i couldn't tell i think this was probably in high school where one of your track coaches in early high school okay so you're you are thinking i want to possibly be an athlete and and this track coach i don't know if it's a man or a woman is like it's a guy yeah he's a guy and he's like maybe you should uh focus on the academics or you know i think somebody put him up
Speaker 1
to it i think somebody probably said you know you gotta redirect this person and they're not gonna take advice from anyone that isn't a coach i actually have you know this immense respect for coaches i i still have a run coach and i can't even if i try call him by his first name without saying coach it's name is blue so i call him coach blue and folks are like well you know you can like once you're not in high school call coaches
Speaker 2
by their first name nope this is this is your coach like you you still run all
Speaker 1
the time i i still run i still think i can be you know reasonably fast what do you
Speaker 2
what do you do do you do the long distance stuff
Speaker 1
i am training for a few different marathons and trying to hit some ambitious time goals and uh coach blue's whole philosophy is you know leave everything out there but for adults okay so that's uh yeah trying to see what i can make happen is coach blue at ucla or no um la based and i used to coach i think the nike team and now is with a different shoe brand and doesn't really coach anymore but took me on as this hopeless but will not give up athlete so that's at least uh what what is what's
Speaker 2
a good marathon time for you
Speaker 1
what's a good marathon time for me or what is a time that i really want what are you aspiring to well the otq standard for women is 237 so that is my goal i'm a little ways from that i have a sub three but not you know the delta at that level is pretty significant otq is olympic trick is that for the trials lots of people run the trials and it's uh like i want to say hundreds maybe even a you know a thousand women will run the trials and the time standard is just a time so it's not you know there'll be some folks who are elite elite and then a lot of folks who are like me who are just kind of obsessed okay
Speaker 2
but yeah i mean it sounds like you're no no joke
Speaker 1
well see you know and it was one of those things and actually saying it out now publicly oh at least on air yes it feels like it's real but i had it in my mind i wanted this goal and i didn't really know if i could even tell anyone this it's like they'll probably think i'm not going to focus as hard on work if i'm doing this other thing um so anyways that's when i brought on coach blue who specializes in
Speaker 2
people who also have work okay okay well and i'll stop badgering you about all this in a second but i i was just struck the last time you seem very passionate about all this and so what's what's the as far as the outdoor stuff goes what's what's kind of like your best adventure you've been
Speaker 1
on okay my most recent which tends to be how i rank these because it's hard to compare which mountain is more you know beautiful or i was just in ecuador uh this past december and i got a chance to have this gorgeous sunrise summit of corpaxi and that was another one of these goals that was on my list and that it's not a very very technical mountain but it was erupting for a while turns out volcano active erupting can't climb so uh it worked out for various reasons and i was really happy with like this uh
Speaker 2
sunrise summit i'll send you a video okay okay okay so you do the you do climbing
Speaker 1
and camping along the way yeah yeah it's it's like you know i'm not so much into what is the most technical route i could find uh it's more you know what's up there yeah i get up there oh could it be
Speaker 2
a little more challenging yeah i think okay have you ever done like the ultra marathon things
Speaker 1
uh everyone keeps asking me this um it's it's on my list to do one of these like insane long runs actually this past weekend was the speed project where folks ran from la to vegas i was at the start line and you know folks are like are you running that's kind of you know there are many ways to get from la to vegas running seems like one of the harder ways yes you can bike there maybe but you know it's 300 plus miles yeah so i'm contemplating what how i feel about these long distances but after i hit one
Speaker 2
of these faster time goals yeah okay i remember i read that what was that born to run that book um about the barefoot yeah yeah i mean it sounded like such a it's not something i would do but it sounded like a very interesting world
Speaker 1
a very very intense set of people out there and i think as you track folks and their times you realize they're not really running slow they're still running you know a 6 30 7 minute pace they can just do that yeah
Speaker 2
for days yeah i'm not quite there yet okay okay okay well i will drag us now towards towards quantum land uh you from high school you went to drexel university did you i mean obviously you're doing physics in high school so was that what was always calling to you when do you start to to make this push towards quantum i mean did you know that that's what you're gonna do once
Speaker 1
so i didn't i you know got to university i actually went to drexel they gave me a full ride and kind of actually paid for me to go to school which is really important to me and i just thought i'm gonna do something that is practical and so it's going to be more you know engineering physics maybe something that's hands-on and i really wanted some experience in a lab so i wrote completely out of the blue an email to francis ross at ibmtj watson and she's now in the faculty at mit but she'd run a group there for some time and she's doing in situ electron microscopy so effectively ways of looking at how things change under the microscope electron beam but doing that in a way that you could also do some liquid cell electron microscopy and i knew very little about all these things but i said i'd really like to you know have some experience in the lab tj watson everyone's heard of it and would you you know take a chance on me and i have no idea why she responded i've asked her that question she's like it just felt like something that you could work on and i had a project for you so i you know did an internship with her and then that actually became something that i did my senior year as a part of my senior thesis as well and looking at how materials behave um you know really really at the atomic scale trying to figure out the kinetics of these different processes so you have electron beam and you're putting in a lot of energy but it's um in this like closed liquid cell kind of watching how things change and I realized okay to model this system you actually need to do this quantum mechanically a simple you know kinetics model or something that you can do that semi-classical is not sufficient I'd taken like quantum mechanics at that point but i hadn't done enough to actually be able to address this problem okay so i again at lunch would see all these really senior theorists and they would talk about well here's a textbook here's a paper you should go read and i started looking at these papers it's like man there's a lot of jargon here a lot of things that i've never seen in a classroom and that's actually what got me excited about going to grad school and i didn't actually know how you know folks think about you know you have to do all these things in undergrad to get to grad school i didn't have folks who walked me through that so i just you know applied to a few places all in california i had at this point decided east coast not for me yeah um so three schools in california uh i'll let you guess which ones admit me and uh two are in the bay area and one is in socal yeah and i visited caltech and caltech at the time actually didn't have uh just a visit weekend they would call it an interview weekend it's since become the same as a regular visit and i had never been to pasadena i didn't really know the fact that you know pasadena is this like tiny town it's not really la it's about an hour away from what people think of as the city of la so i got there absolutely fell in love with it and decided i'm gonna go to grad school and do something that involves something quantum but still something practical and it's got to be a little bit mathy so probably theory but i didn't know yet
Speaker 2
all right what do we do at core memory we cover innovative fast-moving forward-thinking companies which is why core memory is sponsored by brex because brex is the intelligent finance platform for many of these companies 30 000 companies from startups to the world's largest corporations rely on brex's technology for their finances they've got smart corporate cards high yield business banking and expense automation tools that are fantastic i hate doing my expenses and brex's ai's and software run right through those expenses figure out where we're spending money and take care of so much stuff for you so you don't have to waste your time on it yourself go to brex.
com slash core memory to learn more and just you know get with the program let's get going let's get out of this archaic finance software and move toward the future core memory and brex in what year did you graduate from trexel uh 2011 2011 and so it's like a it's a pretty interesting time for the quantum field you already had i guess d-wave had had just gone whatever definitely de-stealth that had come out in the world and said we think we've built a quantum computer and you started having um i mean for people who don't follow this stuff i always hate doing this because i feel like you have to define some of these terms and then it still doesn't doesn't get us very far but but in traditional computing we have bits um ones and zeros and obviously all modern semiconductors are are based on on this principle and have been since the 1960s and then in the quantum world we have qubits which are again hard to define but but start to get you into these quantum properties that are different than the traditional bits and i remember back in that period around 2010 2011 i mean you did have a company like d-wave which i remember as being the first quantum startup to get a bunch of attention but it was still like the quest was really just can you build qubits can you build can you build one can you build four can you build eight can you build 16 and you have all these labs trying to try to do that i mean that that's how i remember that time but i'm so the experience on
Speaker 1
the grad school side was totally you know disconnected from what was happening in the startup ecosystem and at caltech there was what became the core set of faculty that would be the institute for quantum information and then eventually an m was added so it became from iqi iqim information and matter okay but there was a core set of faculty that were kind of starting to me stuff was happening as a graduate student you walk into a faculty member's office you're kind of nervous like um i want to work on this or that or really anything that you think is exciting so i talked with a few different faculty members and i ended up working with harry atwater who is known for work in photonics more recently in quantum photonics and i just said okay this seems practical enough that we're gonna like somebody's gonna build this device something's gonna happen it's measurable we seemed a little scary from you know some of the other very very abstract iqi conversations um it wasn't iqi at the time it was just the same set of faculty anyways um so i i wanted to do something that i thought would be useful what i didn't realize is that as soon as you start doing theory it's kind of a little bit separated from something that will be immediately useful and turns out i'm better at theory than experiment okay just how it happened um so i wanted to you know focus on things that were like how do we describe uh dynamics so these uh collective excitations plasmons effectively where photon couples to matter creates this joint excitation and said well you could always talk about it in a classical limit but what if we talked about it in a quantum limit what would that look like uh started kind of building up what i eventually put in my thesis as like a framework for describing such collective excitations and that then brought me closer and closer to condensed matter and that you know eventually both of those things became part of the um we do quantum information to understand and simulate many body uh phenomena so that's that's kind of the the journey okay i mean it seemed like you'd
Speaker 2
from everything i was reading the last couple days it just seemed like you are fascinated by the edges of matter and and what is happening when you do strange new things to uh to atoms
Speaker 1
and um absolutely you know so you start putting photons into some of these uh systems and you can create non-equilibrium states which is a fancy way of saying a state that really isn't easy to describe by every equilibrium theory which turns out most ways of describing stuff is in equilibrium so i got really fascinated by you know can we develop a non-equilibrium framework for some of these types of correlated quantum matter so correlated again you know something that has long-range interaction I was very very surprised when you know I would ask hey has someone developed some code or way of simulating it can I just use it and realized well folks have done some things their demonstrations in some of their papers and then there's another set of folks who are out there developing these general codes right and whether they come from condensed matter or quantum chemistry they're kind of developing these for large supercomputers um without thinking about a specific process there was like two completely different uh communities okay and the second the community that was developing these methods and codes for supercomputers actually is now the same people who are developing you know the algorithms for quantum computers and that is just it's its own thing right um how do you work on a part of the code somebody else does some other part of the problem and it goes all the way from you formulate an equation that you think is a good description of the type of system you want to simulate then you go from that to like functioning scalable code and this sounds straightforward but actually it's far from because you know you start looking at things and say well that's not really uh problem that can you know be a finite element problem can't really use this kind of math solver for this equation and so there's a lot of different fields that come together to go from that like i have formulated an equation to i have code that runs on you know first it was uh titan then the summit supercomputer now frontier i'm actually really proud of the fact that i've accessed each of those uh generations of computers um and you know it just kind of became like how do you scale this thing what is efficient code um and and not just is it efficient from a you know software standpoint but actually um there's a big difference between i can write something for a toy problem and it will still take the entire supercomputers time for a month versus i can do it in a slightly different way maybe make a different approximation and then i can do a real system something people care about in um a reasonable amount of time so and what's there and so and
Speaker 2
as you're digging into all this stuff i mean in this this i mean maybe this is stupid question or maybe it's not one or the other but you like in this moment you've done all this research like trying to push things to their limits and and um exploring the edges of these fields and then separately there's just the promise of of quantum computing and what it could unlock for the world and and different sets of problems were you being just pulled mostly by your interest in the nature of of matter and what you could do with it or you were you're you were buying into to quantum you know as as a whole and and where this field was going to go
Speaker 1
i actually was more in that first category thinking how can we leverage these devices seems like i know a fair bit about how to use conventional supercomputers and i'd say it was pretty early to the game on you know adopting gpus in the context of computational physics sounds weird to say that now, given that no one would do it any other way. But at the time, if you came from a traditional physics program, it was not obvious that you wanted to use the largest GPU systems, which is what Oak Ridge hosted at the time. So I thought this is another tool, another approach. Maybe it's the same problems can be just written slightly differently. You could have some cool algorithms. I didn't really think of it as quantum computers. I hear, let's not do classical compute. It was more, how do we simulate some of these systems? How do we simulate these systems better than you could do on the biggest, baddest classical computer?
Speaker 2
so i think i remember this moment i mean you're talking about like the early days of nvidia starting to sell these these gpu code processors for the supercomputers exactly it is it's funny how all this started all
Speaker 1
of those um you know that that quantum chemistry community i mentioned i mean they were writing and i think that this still exists like this you know old fortran and folks were like oh we got to migrate things over and this is eons before a clod code type situation so you know folks are trying to figure out, okay, CUDA, how do you take advantage of some of these new approaches and do that for simulating the same problems that the communities cared about for a while?
Speaker 2
No, I remember all this moment well. So I was at the New York Times and I was talking to Jensen and he had just, he was really pushing this CUDA idea hard. It was far from a mainstream thing by any stretch of the imagination. I'd be covering the supercomputing race for ages i used to always write every year the the top 500 you know how it was shaking out um and and you started to see this rise in the top top 20 systems of of these massive super computers that then had like a bank of gpus that that you could tap into and i remember pitching this to the new york times um you know i was like there's this kind of interesting phenomenon going on all these scientists are starting to use these video game chips to to speed up scientific code and and um you know and jensen this guy from nvidia and nobody i mean they kind of knew it's funny but not really yeah it's really i have a story from 2008 i think and and the times was like um i don't think anyone cares about this we're gonna put this on like b8 of the the business section and and then you know and then the you know what are we then almost less than 20 years later it's the most valuable company in the world based on this this bet
Speaker 1
yeah well you should dig up that article i'm sure exists somewhere in the archive i've got it i've got it um but you know also there was this sense that these very very uh complex physics problems you know physics chemistry i kind of use that interchangeably when it comes to many body uh quantum simulation nobody really thought that gpus would be the route initially yeah um i definitely felt like some of the more distinguished members of the community would look at folks like me and say like oh yeah cool but you know it should be elegant you should have a an analytic solution for the whole thing and i just eventually thought maybe you maybe the physics doesn't support that you know have we thought about that never said that publicly till some of these distinguished colleagues have now retired so now i feel bold and i can go out there and say this but you know they were reluctant to kind of think of this new compute architecture and that story kind of repeated itself with the era of quantum algorithms as well where folks said well look this is not really going to do something practical yeah and i think quantum is now at that point where well we are actually showing something that you can't trivially do using you know most of the classical resources that you can get access to via a doe proposal so you know we're at that point i'd say very similar to that uh you know first dgx1 kind of moment
Speaker 2
all right pod friends i am here to tell you about send cut send they are a manufacturing phenomenon whether you're working on your own car or you're a giant automotive company a rocket maker if you need metal cut machine or bent you're going to send cut send they'll do it for you right and they will do it for you fast go to sendcutsend.com slash core memory for a 15 discount on whatever you're trying to make we love send cut send go visit them today well let's dig into that a little bit more and i'm trying to keep this at a level where we're we're nerding out i want this to be as accessible to as many people as possible which is always it's just like inherently hard with quantum because it's just i think it's hard for me even though i've covered it for years to fully wrap my head around some of the concepts i get the gist of things and then so i just always find i've done a video about this i just i find it's quantum is like especially hard i think for people to to kind of latch on to but but so let me let's take into this like a little bit more and let's go broad maybe at the beginning but you know if i go back 10 years um the even though there are these signs of where the gpus are heading classical computers are by far dominant um and and quantum really is sitting there as like our next best option and and it hasn't been fully developed yet but people can see where it's going and it's like okay if there is a massive future of computing new things to be unlocked it's almost definitely going to be through quantum computing but we have a lot of work to do in those 10 years clearly everything we've talked about the the gpus have risen as this extra engine to do a certain class of new computing work that happens to be like kind of the dominant or close to the dominant you know computing work that's happening now ai and then and then we've made huge strides with quantum computing where we have dozens of startups we have what we were talking about before where qubits used to be rare the science experiment where a lab would be like oh we did four last year and now we have eight qubits people are making qubits all the time yeah so so we've kind of dialed that in and you've got startups claiming different things but there is part of me that feels like over this 10 year period because ai has risen so dramatically because gpus have risen so dramatically that i don't know if it's like some of the luster around quantum computing has has gone away it just it somehow seems like oh well this other thing appeared that's really interesting and it's doing a lot of stuff and maybe we don't really know where ai is going to go maybe it's just going to solve all these problems you know that were hard anyway and so yeah i mean like you sitting there in this chair you know in 2026 how should we be feeling about quantum in this moment where where it's kind of realer than it's ever been in a lot of ways but it's it feels like the attention of of maybe where the future of computing everybody's kind of looking over in this other spot now is that does that seem fair yes and maybe okay so you know um
Speaker 1
a few years ago the most popular question on a panel used to be is ai or quantum going to be first right and it was framed as a competition what we've seen in the last maybe three years is that everyone thinks of quantum and ai is going together as part of this next wave of compute in fact you know we don't really care if you're dealing with ai chips that are special purpose silicon is it photonics is it a different architecture most people out there not interested in how the chips are designed what's the underlying hardware and that has actually helped quantum a lot because you can think of quantum as just being part of this set of computational tools that we have these computers and some of them look like they have giant lasers in them some of them look like they need to be cool to really low temperatures but our understanding of what looks like a computer has actually changed because of ai that's one thing that you know i'd say you know the attention has not shifted away as much as it's it's not that you are solving the problem using a quantum computer you're solving it using some form
Speaker 2
of next-gen computer it's like we have these new tools at our disposal which makes a lot of sense i mean the x86 architecture that most of computing was based on is quite old right so so this makes sense um so there was that and
Speaker 1
the other thing that i think is really really helped quantum and this is where my maybe uh answer came in because you know we care about the energy of compute so so much right and the first set of results in quantum were all about time to solution right if you go back to the original google quantum supremacy experiment they had both the metrics for time to solution and the energy to solution they published time to solution because they were like well that's going to be the more striking result if you say it's going to take the age of the universe on classical compute and we can do it now everyone's asking what is the energy to compute and how are we you know in this era of bring your own power um if quantum can bring that workload down by say 10 percent 20 percent it just becomes part of that solution as part of that you know ai supercomputer
Speaker 2
that you deploy what do you like what do you think that number has to be for somebody to go to all the effort to put their energy towards quantum like is 10 enough or does it have to be 10x
Speaker 1
I think in this case a few percent is sufficient and you know some examples of that are where folks are thinking about neutral atom quantum computers that are very efficient from an energy standpoint being incorporated into a larger classical you know AI focused supercomputer or data center okay and they're actually now places building such systems out again as recently as about two years ago there was a question of if you co-locate these devices is there a compute advantage right no one's talking about that anymore it's more is there an energy advantage at all of taking uh some of these devices and deploying them concurrently and if there is we should do
Speaker 2
that okay and then yeah i mean every time anyone talks about quantum computing the the problems that tend to get listed are things like it will help us deal with materials science you can you can look at molecules the interaction of chemicals in ways that you just cannot do with a traditional computer encryption solving these very difficult problems that would take decades if not hundreds of years on with all the compute power in the world you can do this on a quantum system it's always it's this um i always feel like it gets lumped into this this bucket of complexity and there is just part of the natural world which just cannot be represented in a traditional computer and quantum gives you access to play because you are dealing with with entanglement and and quantum properties it lets us tap into a world which does have quantum properties as a huge part of it and so it lets us model um these complex interactions of the way the world operates is this is that still like when you're talking about having these systems to solve working alongside traditional computers is that still kind of like the bucket of problems we're after or have things yeah have things narrowed as gpus have gotten better and ai has come along
Speaker 1
so i think it's always the problem that we could address using quantum computers is actually broadened okay and part of it is that you know there's hybrid quantum classical compute which is very popular for a while because the quantum devices weren't you know at this fault tolerant threshold we'll come back to that threshold and uh some of the encryption results that have recently come up but um but the idea was okay you do some core part of your material molecule simulation that is the most quantum on the quantum processor and the rest you can do classically and you have a workflow that essentially brings it all back together now of course we have quantum devices uh and these are across different modalities where folks have shown that you can actually you know simulate a very very complex quantum system you can do many body dynamics on these systems and that's just been really helpful but you can also think of that as generating kinds of data that you can then train models on which is not originally something that folks had anticipated right so synthetic data you can generate all day every day but it's data that models have already seen it's not actually solving the data bottleneck in ai whereas you do a simulation of a spin liquid on a quantum computer and suddenly you have an exciting new data set and i think that is unlocking the um you know some of the things that physical ai that folks have uh articulated
Speaker 2
on on your show in the past okay okay um this is a terrible question because i cannot intellectually back it up myself but i think i was telling you last time i remember i was sitting with george hotz who's you know he's quite eccentric in some of his ideas um but we we were like having a a drink um at some some event and i don't know we're just shooting the shit and and you know he's he's just like i still don't believe in quantum i i do not actually think these people could point to like any problem um that that we actually need solved that that we we can't do otherwise uh i mean just like a huge skeptic um and and you know you do get that from oh i yes yes yeah absolutely but so to them you just say they are incorrect like there is definitely classes of problems
Speaker 1
that you believe yeah yeah and and we have you know um this is where the the mathematicians will say we have strong conjectures but we don't have rigorous proof okay speaking of things that are not accessible to the general public i think that statement is completely lost on a physicist too where we say yeah you know that's fine in physics we're okay with strong conjectures in fact we're okay with we think and we intuit and it'll work out and that's you know most of physics kind of goes that route of course uh people come from a complexity theory uh or from a computer science and and math formal math background will tell you we don't have rigorous proof that this class of problems can only be solved this way and there's a whole set of folks that are pushing that frontier right they're looking for which problems might be and again within the simulation of quantum mechanical systems materials molecules they might be types that are easier some that are harder and you know folks on the complexity side need to chip away on that problem really excited for them to do that and then there's a larger set of folks who are like let's try and let's see if we can solve some problems that are we think are well suited for quantum computers and we'll be able to make progress we know we have new algorithms and we can try some of these problems today even on you know nearly fault tolerant but not quite over that fault tolerant threshold systems and this is i think something took me you know several interactions with folks in the pharma side to understand you don't need to do drug discovery 100 times better or even 10 times better one to two percent is still a meaningful advance in that field and you know there are so many and it's not just discovering the structure of a new drug but also the kinds of interactions can we and this is something we do in my research group where we think about open quantum systems so how does a quantum system interact with its environment how do you simulate that exactly it turns out that you know how drugs behave in the human body how you think about dosage for folks going through chemotherapy those are real problems and there are problems for however you want to solve them whether it's gpus whether it's quantum computers whether it's a new computer architecture they're important enough problems that you know we need to go after them and we don't need to wait for somebody to come up with a complexity theory argument for
Speaker 2
those problems well i mean but that okay so that is like one part what that i was interested i mean if you look at the results of the last couple years um whether it's like alpha fold things that deep mind is doing or i mean i'm just seeing i never know how much to believe some of this stuff but it looks so promising in the biotech space where you you see people doing these you know they're they're changing the structure of a virus and they're coming up with millions of permutations and then and they're finding ones that the body um that really work when you make a drug based on this virus like a gene therapy and and now used to take us decades to to even find one or two and they're just they're just sending it off on this this llm and and cranking these things out and and i mean there's still a ton of work to do to see um really how how well all this stuff plays out but the the results at least so far are dramatic i mean that was always things in my head that i was told i felt like i was told we're gonna need a quantum computer to do to do stuff like that that was kind of a little bit of the heart of my question i think is is as you're looking at some of what has poured out of the ai race i mean you answered it already but it does it just feels like the the quantum pitch just keeps getting narrower to me to me but like you were talking about pharma companies and so um maybe i am misinterpreting or maybe there's just there's so much work to be done that there is still this enormous swath where they would still want a quantum computer to push that type
Speaker 1
of thing even farther yeah you know you see quantum on their roadmap when they talk about next-gen compute and you know it's back to that point where it's it's just not separating out that this is quantum it's all in this and i think the word ai has now you know become a catch-all for all next-gen compute yeah right and it's physical ai world models lms you know you like know all of that from the ai ai side and then there's stuff from the quantum side is how do we actually accelerate some of these it's it's all one big bucket now so when somebody tells me now that i you know have AI supercomputers on our roadmap i just assume that quantum is rolled into that
Speaker 2
unless told otherwise okay okay okay um and the oh there's so many things i want to ask you about because you i really want to get into quantum sensing and some of these other areas let's do the news real quick yeah okay yes i don't know exactly when this will air but um roughly in the time that this airs i mean there was a massive announcement um out of google uh i mean please i'll take a crack and then you can you can do it justice but i mean what i read um rather briefly was that according to some of the research and simulations they were running there's always been this fear or this idea that these quantum machines will come along and just obliterate our current scheme of encryption and data protection and that they'll be so good at the math that sort of this very fundamental part of our economy of the way computing systems works will get undermined basically overnight and this would be quite devastating to to money and information security and all types of things and it seemed that google was saying well we kind of thought this would everybody thought this would take quite a while and the road map that we're looking at says this is actually going to happen much sooner than we thought and we will crack this is that was at the heart and i remember we were texting i know i know oh gosh you were getting bombarded
Speaker 1
so okay so there there are two results that came out but before i even talk about those results i want to say that you know everything we think about for encryption currently is based on either RSA or ECC and all
Speaker 2
of our elliptical curve cryptography i screwed you up i can always say just once but
Speaker 1
if you know we keep saying it ECC right so all of everything we know from our friends in crypto actually comes from all of that relies on ECC and so when we were texting, what folks were sending me was like, is quantum coming from my crypto wallet? And I just thought to myself, no, let's not put that out there. Let's think about the fact that there's this thing called resource estimation. Okay, and I'm gonna explain this because this is at the heart of this whole issue where somebody, lots of somebodies, people actually, this is a subfield, estimate based on quality of qubit reconfigurability all of the types of gates types of circuits you can construct with all of that what is the total cubic count that you need and you know then you assign thresholds for error rates etc it think of it as like making a very very complicated perfect cocktail and somebody comes up with this is their recipe and then there's a number at the end of it now what has happened is that there are advances on the algorithmic side that have brought this resource estimate down and there are advances on the hardware side that have brought this resource estimate down so there's a class of quantum error correcting codes called qldpc quantum low density parity check code this actually you know so how we think about error correction was all based on these surface codes right and so there was a resource estimate that people could give and i was like you need this in order to do this right well somebody said well what if we don't do a surface code why don't we do one of these other codes or actually and then this this field kind of took off um that plus people being able to do more reconfigurable qubits in the neutral atom community now folks in the silicon spin qubit side being able to figure out shuttling all of those things have brought this resource estimate way way way way down so you can see a plot in a paper that came out of the caltech group they are spinning off a company called or atomic based on this okay where they show that this resource estimate now is about 10 000 qubits okay with a reasonable runtime for ECC and a not so reasonable runtime for RSA, okay?
And now you look at that trajectory, I'm like, whoop, 10,000 qubits, neutral atom. Hmm, I can get one of those from atom computing. I can, you know, place an order. This is like, and it's for a system that's expensive as a private citizen maybe, but you know as an enterprise you can buy one of these for less than 100 million which sounds insane to say it's affordable but it it is for a lot of the folks who think about you know buying large-scale compute so suddenly folks say okay well you can buy these computers how do we think about that and how do we think about the migration to post-quant post-quantum cryptography, PQC, right?
As a Google paper, two things. First, some of those initial data points that brought this resource estimate down came from Google. you know team there that's been working on it and quantum for ages as well yeah there's a whole set of folks who are on the neutral atom side and then there's the algo folks including these qldpc codes like iceberg that are just hammering away on this problem right so with all their powers combined now we we see a path that looks like hmm with whether it's 10 000 whether it's 30 000 but not in our order of magnitude higher it's in that range you actually have a credible threat to ecc you have a credible threat to rsa and um this is exactly what you know folks would call a technical surprise on the uh intelligence national security side of things because every all of these fields existed but nobody quite saw how it was all going to come together
Speaker 2
so fast okay okay yeah because it sounds like you're saying there were signs of all this was happening and then the google team just just
Speaker 1
sort of put everything yeah they um i'd say the neutral atom folks um two teams or atomic as well as atom computing have both put out these numbers and some of it also came up in the context of a darpa run program called qbi quantum benchmarking initiative which started to look at these complex complex scorecards of all of these things right i gave this analogy of a perfect cocktail well that's still might have 1,000 ingredients if you're really fancy. These scorecards have tracked more vectors than that. And you can see that, OK, advances in every one of these has actually moved things from the yellow or red to the green category. And that's exciting.
Speaker 2
So you kind of buy into these results.
Speaker 1
i think they're enough for multiple people you know if it was it if it was just the google team just or atomic team just the you know pick your favorite um company out there i'd worry but the fact that the entire field has been showing this and these resource estimates track what is in the darpa qbi program um that that gives me pause right and again not
Speaker 2
panic just pause yeah let's talk about that for a second what what the number weren't they saying it was like four to eight years or something like
Speaker 1
that yeah so that again that's like at 10 000 qubits now you say well with slightly better qubits and slightly more what happens at 20 000 qubits yeah and you know if you look at the roadmap say from folks on the uh trapped ion or neutral atom side and you know those numbers are in the next two to three years. And you think about a system that's about 100,000 qubits. And this is, again, comparing qubits across different modalities is hard, but roughly the same number of logical qubits across these. You find that we'll get to that threshold and this will also roughly coincide with when we hit false tolerant quantum computing which is kind of the threshold that everyone in the field has been waiting
Speaker 2
for okay i know you've been asked this question i'm sure a hundred times but look here you are and and we've had this this moment um of of this research coming out and you're you're a what is the the title is science envoy i think right um you know you have to look at these things for the united states in terms of global competition but yeah i mean this is a thing that always comes up with quantum is okay so if they break that encryption um you know you said maybe not time to panic but i mean people have flagged us as a moment to very much panic possibly because um for all the national security and and um you don't know financial now we're seeing oh well this is looking more concrete and it might be going quite a bit faster than we thought why would we why is it not time to panic yeah
Speaker 1
so i think and what are we doing so there there's a class of algorithms that you know nist has been validating these nist is a organization that sits under the department of commerce and they've been looking at these post-quantum cryptography pqc uh algorithms right so they've been looking at ways that you might not rely on rsa or ecc but you should start migrating to these and what everyone's now saying is maybe migrating to these should migrate up your to do list right and that's why it's not so much panic but more like start doing that migration in the asap time frame okay okay and um within pqc and this will come up you know these algorithms of course the ones that nist is looking at and these are being produced by the entire community so it's not just that nist is coming up with them they've you know got these from the community it's a it's a game of cat and mouse somebody comes up with something that somebody comes up with a clever way of breaking it that is actually what it was like in the early days at least from you know what i've read it wasn't around for rsa and
Speaker 2
i mean all this stuff is usually open source really right i mean that's kind of
Speaker 1
the idea right you want exactly yeah and so so that's what's happening with some of these algorithms and people put something out there and then you know 48 hours later you see somebody else saying well this is you know issue with it and it's not as safe as folks claim and so now i think that process is happening right now and we'll have a robust set of you know algorithms to migrate to the same way that rsa didn't become the standard overnight and went through a lot of you know testing and uh a lot of uh let's say being punched around and then folks said okay uh so you know even if you can run shores algorithm on a fault tower on quantum computer that doesn't mean that there aren't other ways
Speaker 2
of encrypting information all right i'll embarrass myself possibly here i mean just as you're talking and i'm thinking back through this i mean you know for decades there was this interplay between the government and and technology but you know if you look at the 50s 60s 70s 80s i mean so much of this interplay was was out in the open i mean it was it was developing standards like unix like rsa like tcpip these protocols that all became the underlying force of computing and and the internet many of which have their origins in defense and government work but but was quite out in the open and and nurtured by industry um and then clearly you have to get to some kind of standard in order to have this this network of networks that we all rely on um functioning but at the same time china has made quantum computing
Speaker 1
a national priority clearly anything yeah it's in their 15 year plan um
Speaker 2
if you've yeah yeah it's like one of the highest highest things and then and then obviously um you know if you had some edge on on information security within your military or government you could you could use that so i mean like is this this next race kind of begins and we're trying to address these issues i mean is the thinking um this has to become a global standard because that's how we operate and and and we need this for all these systems to function or are we and i'm sure people dive in i i just don't know i mean or is the thinking oh we're heading to some kind of new world where if china gets there first or the u.s gets there first then you're you're keeping that secret for some period of time and and um using it yeah it's definitely
Speaker 1
a race right and i think we maybe in some of the areas that you pointed out previously didn't have near pure in terms of at least technology uh competitors the way we do now
Speaker 2
right it was like academic i mean it's just a different flavor
Speaker 1
to it yeah now you know we see that at least in quantum from day zero it has been framed as a global race um i think it's because shore's algorithm was introduced you know mid-90s and folks recognize this is important and this is important to national security and that is something that has always been there in the dna of you know people working in quantum the other thing you're trying to see now is that you know every country has launched a an initiative of some sort strategy whatever they want to call it and it articulates you know we want quantum computers we want them here we want these to be on prem we want to think about supply chain for these we want to think about who and what can you know access these um should we think about the supply chain equivalent for algorithms there's a lot of different stuff that we're talking about now that we didn't in previous eras of technology because there just wasn't really a reason to i mean
Speaker 2
and maybe you're biased or maybe you could speak freely since you're an academic but i mean since you are involved in some of these government discussions i mean are you impressed with the level of thinking around this or are you underwhelmed and and it's this is yet another area where um the u.s you know perhaps has a less coherent strategy than
Speaker 1
than china you know i've been very impressed by the american strategy in quantum science and technology in fact nqi was you know part one originally signed into law in 2018 during the president's first administration there's a big effort now to do a bunch in quantum there's you know lessons from the ai action plan which also the president introduced early in the term this time. So I think there are a lot of people focused on quantum in the administration. I'm not going to get political about this, but just say that there are so many technologists who are in roles at Commerce, DOE, ARPA-E, and of course, OSTP that are focused on quantum. There's a big effort in the DOW and the NatSec ecosystem. really looking at the technology we talked about the draft by qbi program so i think folks are focused on it and uh the right folks are focused on it i said that could more people be more focused on it could there be you know more uh support for uh some of the companies and companies have raised a lot of private capital but you know could there be more of a demand signal that also comes from government absolutely and i think the new results that we saw should you know uh get everyone uh
Speaker 2
are we considered to be like neck and neck with china ahead behind from everything
Speaker 1
that is publicly known i think near peer neck and neck with the prc is uh you know the wisdom again that is just what is known publicly and it's um it's hard to say you know if somebody puts out a prl immediately following another result that comes from um you know an academic group you know were they sitting on that results are they ahead they're just putting out the result now or did it just so happen right yeah so without kind of having that full transparency we won't know and i think in this particular technology we just won't know yeah okay okay and
Speaker 2
then this might not be apples to apples i mean when i used to cover supercomputers for the longest time the biggest machines were sitting in government labs and they were used to simulate nuclear weapons do weather modeling these these national um initiatives as time went on still some very large computers but you know most of them most of the world's largest computers are not actually getting ranked and they sit inside of google data centers and um microsoft and amazon and the government you know can still build very big machines but i think i think it's fair to say that these trillion dollar companies have the world's biggest most impressive computers at their disposal now and it changes this balance of power around where's the most innovative work happening if something like you had this massive breakthrough um around quantum computing would it you know traditionally it would have happened at a government lab or a university now it's almost definitely going to happen within a company um and and i guess in the u.s i mean there is some you know there's interplay between the companies and the government but i mean it's it's just a different dynamic
Speaker 1
in this new era yeah and all of the companies you just mentioned that have amazing classical compute that's not ranked to also have significant quantum efforts yeah investments also in other startups that you know i'm sure have some relationship with supplying devices and supplying maybe the first devices so i think we'll see a lot of breakthroughs and the breakthroughs in this field are actually coming from industry big and small and i think there's a very productive partnership with the national labs now there's this big initiative that undersecretary dario gil launched the genesis mission is actually uh you know it's a big executive order and it was exactly towards this right like how do we form these partnerships that bring in the best of what the doe labs have to offer what academics have to offer and yes what private industry has which is really really hard to replicate maybe there's no reason to replicate in uh these other settings so i think it's bringing the the full you know um complement of of uh what we can all do uh to yeah
Speaker 2
to this problem is the thinking that like if if some tech company cracked encryption first i mean are they required to tell the government they've done this or they well google was very transparent right
Speaker 1
with how they're um thinking about this how they're being very thoughtful about who has access so that it doesn't turn into a free-for-all. And they have a plan, and I really appreciated that they put this out there in the form of an archive paper. So I think that's good. There are probably other companies that will follow their lead and put stuff out there, IBM, Microsoft, and that's helpful. I think it's something you'd want to know though you know all my data sits with these companies anyways yeah they have access it's like you don't need
Speaker 2
to break break any encryption no i just i mean there is like a sci-fi novel in in uh it's the same thing in the ai world is like you know if google or anthropic got there first it's like do you uh tell everyone or do you kind of use this super intelligence for yourself for a while to uh to either make some money or do some interesting things you know before um
Speaker 1
before everyone else yeah well nothing interesting happening with my data yeah that's just you know you want the academic papers maybe just read
Speaker 2
the archives yeah um well there's a million places we could go i just want to be mindful of time because there are a couple of things i just wanted to talk to you about it was the last time we talked you you were having lunch and you brought up quantum sensing and i have to confess confess i i really didn't know what that was i did a little reading over the last couple days and it was like fascinating to me i mean from what i read and then again i'll get you to fix everything i mess up but um i guess clearly we have sensors in the world to track things like air quality and and water and and all this stuff and and obviously they're taking some measurements of molecules and and what's going on and then it just seems because quantum systems are so incredibly sensitive um you know when we build a quantum computer you have to like shield it from that outside world in order for it to work and so so just from what i was reading it sounded like these systems are so sensitive that you could actually pick up on like the tiniest change in a whatever it was if you're trying to track like a virus spreading or some pollution or is this like the general idea
Speaker 1
behind quantum sensing you know crappy qubit makes great quantum sensor and because it couples to the environment and actually turns out our best measurements of the fundamental constants of physics to the you know 10th or beyond digit are actually based on quantum sensors. And there's a field, position, navigation, and timing, that is thinking about how you can use effectively measurements of these same fundamental constants of physics, gravity, magnetic fields, et cetera, so that you can know where you are and you can have really good timing actually our timing standards also from this come from you know atomic clocks quantum sensors and the the idea is sure you don't need gps if you can do quantum sensors on platforms now the challenge historically has been that you know quantum sensors also like quantum computers
Speaker 2
form factor is hardly portable you need like a giant a building or not a building
Speaker 1
but some encased mini building that was all that was true and you know if you had said we're going to have a network of atomic clocks these are going to be launched into space folks would look at you and say right on what would we launch a room kind of didn't make sense but everything that folks have done in semiconductor manufacturing everything that's happening in all these other fields has actually brought the form factor down to you know poker chip size there's a company mesa quantum they're actually based out of playground here they are making these and they're at you know they started with something that was more like a coffee mug went to poker chip size now they're going to something that is blueberry size what does that mean
Speaker 2
though it's like it's what it's just like one quantum chip somewhere in there
Speaker 1
so yeah so it's in in their case it's doing some local measurement of magnetic fields and based on that and based on some analysis you can actually you know so with some useful edge compute you can say ah i'm hanging out in california and you can do that without actually being able to without needing to access the gps satellites okay okay and it's but it's a
Speaker 2
and you work on this in your lab right you're doing quantum sensing
Speaker 1
we think about solid state quantum sensors which is slightly different from you know the types of things that make clocks so quantum sensors also come in all shapes and forms but if you think about say a spin state a defect in a material like diamond or silicon carbide it is very very sensitive to um external magnetic fields so it becomes a really really good quantum sensor oh okay okay and you can use that and we've thought about how you can of course it's not as simple as i you know put this sensor there and suddenly measure something but you have to have some way of initializing you have to have some way of reading out same things you want to do for compute but slightly different constraints if you can do that you have ways of actually you know being able to do a measurement out in the air um i had for um the last few years a program with the national science foundation also with uh ditra that was focused on how can we deploy set sensors not just single but network of these sensors and use that to you know say do anomaly detection or other kinds of uh interesting sensing problems like so that is the idea right is
Speaker 2
that you'd have i mean maybe i'm totally wrong but you would you would put these sensors all yeah in the real world in the real world and then and then some um some bioweapon is is there's some some maybe just somebody sneezes okay
Speaker 1
okay and it's a and say there's one person that sneezes in a large airport okay in the interest of not making people let's just say you want to know who is the person that you know is the is the reason everyone else got the flu. Now you could do that if you have a very high sensitivity way of doing a measurement, but that itself is not sufficient. You also need to know things like where was the person spatially? You'd want to know, you know, was it that person or the person slightly next to them? And so that actually becomes a problem that is known as data fusion. So I can have all kinds of sensors. Maybe I have some, you know, cameras and it's an airport. maybe i have a temperature sensor so i can tell one of these people seems warmer than the others and i have this very high sensitivity thing that picks up when this person sneezed and that is what that sensor is picking so it could be a molecular sensor i get data from that and i fuse it with the data from all these other sensors and something my group has worked on and then i can answer a question that somebody might have which is who sneezed
Speaker 2
and the idea is just that the quantum sensor is so much more sensitive to these changes that um you're getting that initial data read on where something started very very exactly it's very very um
Speaker 1
low, in the signal to noise kind of language, this is something that would normally be below the threshold of a classical sensor that could also do similar molecular sensing, but you'd need to be above some number. And quantum sensors actually operate below what is confusingly called the standard quantum limit. which is the limit of a classical sensor where everything is operating at its best quantum limit right so SQL and people in quantum sensing by the way talk about different bounds and saturating different bounds between SQL and the Heisenberg limit which is set by the uncertainty principle there's orders of magnitude so effectively you know you can do a lot of interesting quantum sensing and very very high sensitivity measurements what's important here is that these are now sensors that can be deployed in the real world they're not just you know sitting in my lab or a few other people who work in the field and that makes them i'd say useful yeah
Speaker 2
so you're saying i mean your lab's doing this there's already a startup doing this um so like how real is this
Speaker 1
you know there are actually multiple companies uh different types of sensors focused on different problems so mesa is very focused on position navigation timing they're targeting you know can you put these sensors on drones can you put them on other kinds of flying platforms maybe on subs that's a different kind of problem space then there are companies that are thinking like can we use this to you know detect a person sneezed um so the form factor and then the constraints of how you package the sensor look different. You could also imagine some of these eventually becoming part of wearables, right? We're not there yet, not there yet, both from a form factor and price standpoint, but not something that the field is
Speaker 2
okay and so you would do you do location it's this is like magnetic field it's you're super
Speaker 1
sensitive it could be uh you know a response to a specific kind of molecule uh those would be different kinds of sensors it could be gravity these are all different looking quantum sensors and
Speaker 2
the atomic clock is a quantum
Speaker 1
yeah yeah it's an example of a very old quantum sensor of course there you're using and of course atomic clocks also come in different forms of what they actually sense but yeah those are you know so we have timing standards that are set based on clocks that nist hosts
Speaker 2
okay okay am i going too deep on this like what is the quantum thing at play in a in
Speaker 1
a atomic you know it's it's um so atoms are so i'd say stable and also so versatile and how they get used in different things right you think about neutral atoms you're using the spin states to do some kind of encoding you could also think about using some of the lines you could think about the using the nuclear properties of these and actually there's a pretty big advance that came out of NIST that was focused on you know these kinds of nuclear transitions these atomic transitions are just really really stable right and they don't they don't move so they set that's everything that you know you'd expect in terms of drift anything that is sensitive to temperature environment etc well atoms behave the same way okay regardless right and so you can kind of use some of these transitions as a very very precise sensor okay okay um this is me trying to explain like two semesters of uh atomic clocks and i i confident folks that work on this will say oh gosh my whole fields and by the way you know no prizes have been given yeah
Speaker 2
lots of these things i had no idea so i just got interested um the
Speaker 1
the i i just know any of my colleagues that i i send a link to will say really that's that's what you say about my life's work anyways how in
Speaker 2
the uh when i was when i was digging around to prepare for this um you could also seem like you were, I was curious if you still are, I mean, quantum biology was a field of interest. Is that, does your answer?
Speaker 1
Yeah, so we don't so much do quantum biology and we just do quantum plus molecules and some of those molecules are relevant in biology, but I have to be honest, I know very little actual biology. I get into trouble every time I even try and name one of those molecules, but you could think of these same sensors being embedded in the human body. Go ahead.
Speaker 2
Can we go broad on this for a second? Let's do it. When I was reading about it, it was saying stuff like photosynthesis, how birds navigate might have these quantum principles to them. I interviewed someone for this show, and I think Richard Penrose is maybe... which I know is people are divided on that but so there's this idea maybe it's not even an idea I mean is this just known that things like photosynthesis like some of these massive processes in the world just have quantum things that we don't fully understand yet or this is like a field of uh of uh we're trying to figure out if that is there are certainly molecules that
Speaker 1
or you know biomolecules that have quantum properties right and the question that always comes up is is it coherence coherence by itself is actually a classical phenomena or is there something truly quantum is that long-range entanglement and so it kind of gets into this like very um I'd say esoteric world of how do we quantify quantumness in these systems? And people have strong feelings when that comes up. But ultimately, you could think of quantum sensors as ways to couple to these systems and maybe shed some light on these types of questions. I mean, molecules are ultimately quantum mechanical. and there's no doubt right so the question really is how much of those properties persist to classical scales and does that then become the dominant behavior of the system and that's where you know there's a lot of debate whether it's maybe mesoscopically it's quantum which we you know have other examples of maybe somewhat macroscopically but at a system level you could understand it classically and then there's some people who say no you should really include these effects so that's i mean that's
Speaker 2
where i get excited and maybe i'm just embarrassing myself no no please this is like a fun topic i know panrose is controversial on this stuff but i mean there is there is totally this chance right that we've been whatever the number is the last 80 years kind of had this like dominant physics that we understood a bit better and it was like playing out in the world and we have these rules we're going through but yeah but we know that there's these other properties to things and we've just sort of had less time to explore them we've had less machines to poke around yeah on and like when he's talking about well maybe consciousness has this roots and in some quantum realm. And that's what we need to unlock these new understandings about ourself. And I mean, this could be true. Like there could be all these things in the world that we,
Speaker 1
we start to certainly, you know, have folks who are thinking about these problems and working on these as serious research topics. I think, uh, there's, you know, how do you, and this is actually in itself a question, how do you go from like a loosely framed problem to something that is mathematically crystallized, and then you can propose concrete experiments that people can try. and you know this is the kind of blue sky work my work on quantum sensing you know the more applied stuff was from actually believe it or not the nsf but all of the crazy ideas i had support and still have support from the gordon and betty moore foundation and it's all been focused on you know are there things here that we missed and to ask exactly you know you keep saying might embarrass myself well i you know i embarrass myself uh by design and some of these grant proposals where i say well you know this isn't a serious topic certainly not something that's ready for prime time not ready for nih nsf but you know blue sky let's ask the question yeah and maybe it's a naive question maybe the question itself is how do you mathematically sharpen it and that's exciting to look at and then you know can we propose experiments where somebody can on ambiguously say that it is or isn't right and i think that's the whole point
Speaker 2
of science okay okay be honest because i can edit this out are you okay on time are you am i am i torturing you no no i'm okay on time okay there's a couple other things i just want to ask you about please go ahead okay so if we had to if i'm if i'm a college student coming to ucla and i'm like you know god i mean there's such big questions about where the world is heading but it's like should i be diving into ai or is is like quantum you know the place i should i'm trying to find kind of the most exciting cutting edge era of you know where i want to dive into next and maybe it's business like certain personalities are going to go other ways but do you feel like you have to kind of pitch some of these kids on on kwanzaam or there's plenty of people are they're like man this is the most interesting thing i could be working so it's you know
Speaker 1
so interesting this is uh the time of year where students commit to which school they're going to go to and you know folks are in that i'm going to be there this fall so the pitching starts around now and something i've noticed this year which i had not really seen previously folks are scared of tech they're you know worried that they're coming into this very fast moving um fields and what if they place just the wrong bet and then they're working on something that isn't relevant in four years and i i honestly have not you know seen folks have that kind of fear and what i i'm a you know there's a lot of optimism here but i i in this case i think it's it's well placed i tell folks this is the most exciting time ever to be in tech in all of human history and we you know get to invent new stuff we get to work on new fields you might work in a subfield that isn't the one that you've look at when you graduate but as long as it's developing some of these other skills you'll be able to kind of you know path find after so you don't have to think about your major you don't think about you know your first research project all of these things is setting you on some trajectory that you must then follow for all time yeah there's going to be a lot of path finding and that's of course a very hard answer for students that have done everything right to get admitted you know to have their life all planned out right and i'm basically telling them that's great but you know we don't have a crystal ball it's not even a hazy one now it's just completely gone so you just have to actually do the thing that you enjoy doing yeah and i that that's got mixed reception so far so if you have ways i can pitch that better please well i was just having
Speaker 2
the same experience because my oldest son is about to go off to undergrad and we were at a college this weekend with the the president of the school was giving her pitch to all you know the students that have already been admitted and then i was fascinating to me to listen to the parent questions because i live in such a bubble here in the valley and this was a school in the midwest and you know like one parent was like um she's like oh if my kid goes here you know what are their odds of getting into law school is this like a strong enough school to help their chances of getting a lot and i just remember thinking in my head like i was like bro i'm like please don't go i can't go to law school i i in my head i was just like that's that's this is the future i'm not sure you should be worrying about you know and then and then some of the other yeah and then some of the other parents were you know they just went straight to like the ai question and it was it's always interesting when you get out of the valley bubble and I was just the stark reality of how scared these parents were of what was going to happen and then at this school they were pitching like oh well we've just started this critical thinking around AI program because this is a liberal arts school to sort of pride themselves on trying to shape the politics of the world a little bit they're like at least you know we'll have a chance to like shape the way the AI is developing and I was just like what a weird existential time to be yeah going to school and
Speaker 1
then there are some folks asking you know what am i gonna get in a classroom um i mean i think there's you know a complete reset of how we think about information and that is going to propagate into academia in all ways right it's not just publishing i get this question a lot i'm editor of a journal where, you know, folks ask, well, you know, how do you distinguish human or AI written? How do you think about reviews? And it's all that folks are asking similar questions in the classroom. I think our relationship with information has just changed it has that's to me it's very exciting i can see if you're not a tech optimist or as in the tech bubble as we are you might not have that view but that is something i try and communicate to the next generation that regardless of you know what you learn in a classroom like your development your education is very very important and it will be important even if you don't end up using exactly what you learned in that you know writing class or uh one of my courses yeah and just my son go
Speaker 2
through this process i i've just been battling with that i mean i'm pretty pro-college for a whole bunch of reasons like it's just sort of the experience of being right with a bunch of kids and and like having that four years to to to grow but i mean to a lot of what you said i remember you know i'm old enough to remember the dot-com boom and it was like when google really came along with first the internet and then google just this idea that you had all the world's information at your fingertips but then you know i've been playing with clod agents so much in the last like two or three weeks and i was like my god i mean i'm trying to put myself in my kids shoes i'm like i could learn so much more about what i'm interested in so much faster i don't care how good the school is at this point if you're just in if you know what you're into or you're trying to accomplish i mean you just have we went from the world's all the world's information to just this like tutor who's just at your disposal to be commanded as you wish
Speaker 1
you know and so you can think about research experiences that students can have at the undergraduate level experiences with types of you know hardware things that you couldn't do in that way and i think that involves of course universities completely more or less overnight revamping the curriculum and i'm deeply uh you know sorry if folks were getting ready to just uh run the same uh class for another two or three years before uh you know they they retired but you know to all of those folks i'll say that's just not gonna cut it nobody's gonna come to that class nobody's gonna sit in and you know what a student learns from an active research active or industry active or something you know faculty members so different from somebody who's just kind of doing the same thing that they have for years
Speaker 2
that's i think you just articulated what i was feeling which is the old college experience feels so sedate compared to what it will have to be
Speaker 1
if i said that i might get you know a tsunami of emails from uh my leadership saying wait what did you say about us
Speaker 2
but i mean it feels like it will have to be this active experience to to really get something out of it you know because it's just the idea
Speaker 1
of yeah just asking uh questions or solving you know
Speaker 2
the same old problems that's just not gonna cut it yeah yeah okay okay um i've asked i could ask you questions all day uh you're so fun to talk to is there anything i mean there's a million places we could have gone is there um writ large in the quantum computing field everyone always wants to know when it's going to be real we've talked about this in different ways to that i have
Speaker 1
an answer okay so the threshold and i promised we'd get to this right fault tolerant quantum computing that is the threshold at which you can do meaningful error correction and all of these problems that are utility scale let's say on the algorithmic side become accessible become available. And that first set of FTQC, right? One acronym you walk away with from listening to this, FTQC, that is on the horizon. And for some modalities, it might be as soon as 28. For some others, it'd be, you know, before 2030. and um you know the first fault-tolerant quantum computer we have will not be the last there'll be multiple modalities there'll be you know this is another question i get which modality will win yeah we will have fault-tolerant quantum computers that rely on different physical modalities light superconductors right um neutral atoms uh of course you know a lot of photonics um semiconductor spin i mean there's just going to be and of course straptide it's going to be um different types of quantum computers they're going to look different and what we will find out is if they're all good at all problems or if some of them are good at some problems and some at a different set of problems we just don't have an answer to that yet on that but so
Speaker 2
so 2028 2030 things are are kicking off and like a new a new yeah i think
Speaker 1
the slope has changed yeah
Speaker 2
okay okay okay um again million things we could do anything like super top of mind that we didn't i think that was it okay okay and when so when when is your marathon when's you when do we find out how you did it okay um i have
Speaker 1
a set of races end of the year okay um and then a few more early next year so i have time i have to hit disqualifying standard before 28 yeah yeah before there's a fault tolerant quantum computer okay let's say i have to hit this 237 standard or at least give it what i think is uh you know my best shot and this is
Speaker 2
a standard are you trying to make the olympics well this is just to run the trials right okay that's it but you might want you
Speaker 1
because it's no no no okay it's even though the course is going to go right by where i live yeah it is not on my again between 237 and what the female pros run which is more like a you know 215 218 that's like a world of difference so i would just you know consider myself an athletic success if i do everything i can to hit the standard and if i hit the standard i'm pretty sure i'm gonna like cry at the finish line and if i get to run the trials i'm gonna be really really happy
Speaker 2
okay okay i had one more question it's out there left field should i picture how your mind works um oh no yeah no but like do you do you do do you visualize stuff well in your head i do is
Speaker 1
that how you yeah i visualize i can yeah like very spatial and you kind
Speaker 2
of always been that way yeah yeah i think so so like when you were in high school doing all this stuff i mean
Speaker 1
physics just made sense to you yes yeah i think that was one of the ways i knew that proof-based math wasn't the way to go i enjoy types of math that's closer to the physics which is more you can see a beginning and an end and is something
Speaker 2
that goes with it okay so were you like that like as a really young kid i don't know you don't know were you uh were you a big reader were you or you always drawn to math and science and i did a fair bit
Speaker 1
of reading yeah but i wasn't like it's like i'm gonna read everything
Speaker 2
the word cell shape rotator uh do you know this yeah i know i'm just trying
Speaker 1
to think back to like i i don't know i i think the the other stuff just came easy i could look at something be like oh we need to end up here okay this is going to be relevant and then there's like i do this version of something in my okay sorry no i don't know if that's helpful i was picturing
Speaker 2
because i just i was i always try to put myself in in people's shoes and just kind of get a feel for them okay last very last thing last time you were here you had this bag yes we should give people like a top tip maybe all your clan already know this because you guys all use this equipment but what was what was the brand
Speaker 1
so um it's hyper light but the material itself is this ultra light material dyneema okay and i think it's a feat of material science because it's exceptionally strong and it's exceptionally light and now folks are incorporating dyneema into all kinds of things so you know it used to just be climbing rope and things that both needed to be very secure and light and you didn't kind of care as much about um you know the the cost yeah and then somebody figured out how to do dyneema maybe more scalably so it's still not cheap i would not buy a backpack for um you know school right that is made out of dyneema but it's really really light so you can um you know have climbing packs uh shoes if you're into you know ultralight uh running or climbing shoes and folks are trying to you know make everything dyneema so i'm not sponsored by hyperlight or dyneema but folks if you're listening which could be please merch is welcome
Speaker 2
so does everyone in the hiking world already know about all this
Speaker 1
or this is I don't know if everyone ever you know so hikers also there's the weekend hikers and you know their maybe weight is not as much of a thing if you're going to carry something for days in bad weather conditions suddenly you know there's this climbing phrase grams make ounces ounces make pounds pounds make pain so you know depends on what kind of hiker but yeah i'm excited for new kinds of materials to make their way into climbing and running gear
Speaker 2
it was super cool i had never heard of that before so there we go we're just trying to give some practical practical advice in the midst of a quantum computing discussion i feel like we've done we've done a service to the world then um pre thank you so much for coming in it's been really cool getting to know you um just over the last like month or so so i can't thank you enough for all your knowledge it's been fun awesome thank you the core memory podcast is hosted by me ashley vance and or kylie robison or both of us together it is produced by me and david nicholson our theme song is by james mercer and john sortland and the show is edited always by the john sortland thank you so much to brex and send cut send for all your support and thank you most of all to everybody for listening and thank you and we'll see you again