The theme for this week’s episode is tick, tick, boom.
America is running out of time to catch up with China on manufacturing, and we’re physically incapable of spending an hour together without bringing it up. Release the glorious machines please!! We also go behind the scenes on Kylie’s reporting on motors and actuators — the unglamorous parts that sit in every joint of a humanoid robot, account for roughly 60% of what that robot costs to build, and come almost entirely from China. Her piece profiles the two startups trying to change that. Plus a new proposed bill out of Congress that would kick Unitree’s robot doggies to the curb.
Then the rockets send Ashlee off on his space tangents. Jeff Bezos’ Blue Origin had an expensive mishap recently when an explosion took out the rocket, its launch pad, and possibly America’s dreams of beating China back to the moon. Ashlee walks through why a pad explosion can be a near-death moment for a rocket company, and why SpaceX — now flying roughly every two days while everyone else is grounded or behind — increasingly just wins by default. Plus the new Starfall capsule, SpaceX’s move into making medicine and maybe chips in orbit, and the wild logic behind a $1.77 trillion IPO.
We also got into the media drama consuming our X timeline: the firing of Scott Pelley from 60 Minutes. Ashlee tweeted an opinion, the trolls came for him hard, and he pleads his case here. We’re a little biased since, well, we’re off building this whole new-media thing ourselves. Will there still be a ticking clock and a man in a suit raking in views twenty years from now? Tune in for what we think, and leave your hot take in the comments.
The Core Memory podcast is on all major platforms and on our YouTube channel over here. If you like the show, please leave a review and tell your friends.
(Ed. Kylie - Don’t think I forgot to make you a playlist. “Lazy Eye” and “New Slang” were key to my college experience. I first crushed on Rivers Cuomo thanks to “Perfect Situation.” Listen to it here, and don’t forget to leave a comment to win tickets to their tour).
OUR SPONSORS
SendCutSend
Do you make stuff? Do you need metal parts fast and believe in truth and justice? Then head on over to SendCutSend where you’ll get a 15 percent discount thanks to Core Memory on whatever you’re trying to build. We believe in you.
Brex
The Core Memory podcast is also sponsored by Brex, the intelligent finance platform built to help companies spend smarter and move faster.
Did we go to Texas, find a telescope ranch and then obtain an entire nebula in Brex’s honor? Oh yes, we did.
We run on Brex and so should you. Learn more about Brex right here.
Timestamps
* 00:00:00 – Intro
* 00:02:05 – The American Actuator Crisis
* 00:06:51 – WestMag vs. Atlas Motion Systems
* 00:14:21 – Uncle Sam Pays Attention
* 00:16:47 – Chinese Robot Ban
* 00:21:16 – A Robot in Every Home
* 00:24:29 – Are You AGI-pilled Yet?
* 00:27:23 – Shoutout to Micayla Sortland
* 00:31:01 – Blue Origin’s Explosive Launch
* 00:42:52 – Low Earth Orbit Drugs
* 00:49:42 – The Two-Trillion-Dollar Elon Bet
* 00:57:07 – Founders Fund’s Viral “Mafia” Game Night
* 01:01:23 – Ashlee Braves His Notifications
* 01:06:12 – Legacy Media vs. The World
No summary for this episode yet.
Unknown
all right Kylie we're gonna save America this week we got all the answers we got them all I am Ashley Vance I'm Kylie Robison and this is Core Memory here we go all right we are indeed saving America
Speaker 2
We sure are.
Speaker 1
I think we started a movement for months now. I have been calling for America to make actuators. If you don't know what they are, you will find out here shortly. And they are a very important part of many industries. Turns out America was not making many of them. China was making a lot. And then I got Kylie completely filled into this cause and I genuinely think well okay we're diving deep on this in just one second but Kylie wrote this masterpiece story all about actuators about a couple startups who are trying to make actuators in the United States again I know these companies existed before we started our campaigning and tirade but I do think we I do think we helped foment a moment we did yeah I you've seen my progression of actuators on this very pod because I was looking back for my reporting because I was like obviously I was skeptical and then I became an acolyte and I went back to one of our pods where you say Kylie didn't even know what an actuator was and now I'm I'm completely pilled we are so
Speaker 2
fucked not enough people are paying attention to it and so we wrote this big big story on it yeah so let's explain it people if you haven't caught it on the site I mean we're going to talk about it here so you don't have to but you should read the story no you have to you do have to this is why America can't have robots and other nice things so where should we start you want to explain what an actuator is for the people yeah so this was my favorite part of the story because Ashley said I want you to ask every person you talk to to define an actuator And this was in the story when I asked Jordan Sanders, a co-founder of WestMag, one of the companies featured, he tried to make it into a haiku and got lost and I don't think he really defined it.
An actuator is a machine component that turns energy into motion. It can go linear one way up and down or rotary in a circle and they make up about 60% of the cost of making a humanoid robot in every joint. they are largely made in China and as you point out in your story the very broad I mean they're in laptops smartphones anything that moves more or less yeah I got hung up on this because of the humanoid robots because they are such a big part of the cost it's where all the the interesting stuff happens with the limbs moving
Speaker 1
anywhere you see a joint Anything like that. And as we were reporting for a documentary project on the rise of these humanoids, it became very clear that not only does China have way more humanoid robots than we have, but they make all the parts, the key parts that go into this. So in the actuator, there's a motor, an electric motor. And these two things are really joined together because it's the same problem that affects like the United States drone industry, for example, where we don't make any of the motors that help the propellers grow. So even if you have a United States drone company like a Skydio that's trying to revive the US drone business, you get in trouble pretty fast when you need these extremely important components.
Speaker 2
Do you know where they source their motors and actuators?
Speaker 1
I think they were with a Japanese or a Taiwanese or a Korean company, which you can, there are people in all of those countries who make motors actuators but china is cheapest is cheapest and just totally dominant and anytime i would ask anyone about why don't we do this like part of this is um it's not like it's like impossible to do the united states has plenty of smart people and the manufacturing capability to make these things the one of the main issues is cost and it's just this notion that It's pointless for the United States to even try to do this because even if we built these motors and actuators, they'd be 10 times the cost of China. But at some point, you sort of have to do it if you think stuff like drones and electric cars and humanoids are going to be a thing in the future, which I'm pretty sure they're going to be at only more. And this goes to weapons. This goes to all the things that are getting electrified. Then... You know, if you run into a situation, China and the U.S. clearly have tense relations and if things get more tense and China wants to cut this off, you've basically cut off like all of modern devices, manufacturing, everything.
Speaker 2
That was my point with the story is that you don't, need to know the specifics of what an actuator and motor are you need to really understand the stakes everything you know like the the modern comfort that we experience here is largely thanks to motors and actuators and they largely come from china and china didn't go out to like sort of dominate the motors and actuators industry they dominated in those markets you mentioned evs humanoids um So we were just kind of in drones and so we've sanctioned you know in all sorts of ways drones But you know, we're still not making the key components here and that's a huge issue exactly if You know, if you go to the American Dynamism Fund A16C webpage, they lay out sort of this fictional scenario of China taking Taiwan in 2027 and we're fucked. That is sort of the scenario I don't go deep on because we don't know, but it's the real critical issue of really how screwed we could be.
Speaker 1
Yeah. And you would just want to make all this stuff if you can. I mean, the other part of it is just we see the re-industrialization movement so we want to make we want to make the drones we want to make weapons we want to make um send cut send just just metal parts and and bring all that back again but then when you have some of these key pieces that you're missing sometimes you have to question if it's not like it's full-on theater like I've written about but I mean there's a element to it where it's like okay well You're doing a lot, but we're missing some pretty key parts that make the whole thing not pointless, but flawed.
Speaker 2
What did you think of? So one of the approaches in the piece, there's two companies, West Mag. They are making the motors and actuators in America, in South San Francisco, the industrial city. I went to their office. They have a Chinese humanoid robot in their lobby, which we'll get into later. And then there's Atlas Motion Systems. And the plot twist there is that they design them in Long Beach, California, but they manufacture them at scale in the Philippines. So I was wondering what you think of that approach.
Speaker 1
Well, I mean, the Philippines is an interesting choice. So Atlas is in SoCal. And yeah, so both companies are relatively the same age. I guess West Mag is maybe a little bit older. We've got some swag here they're they're noted for their swag i don't i mean it just it just has this it's kind of like what iconic uh it's just so how it started is i tweeted that we need american actuators i've been pilled and everyone started tagging david hansen the co-founder of west mag and he immediately dm'd me and sent me merch and i was like what do they do are they a merch company and then i was telling you that they'd be interesting to cover and you're like what do they build i was like i know
Speaker 2
it's not just merch yeah so well okay so yeah there's these two different philosophies that you outlined um i mean the atlas got okay well both companies are very interesting when you when you wrote your story and then just on x you see that everyone's like wow west mag this guy david and his team they know everything about this stuff they're gonna do it atlas felt a little younger in terms of the the company and and then the
Speaker 1
founders are they've just come from other hard tech companies and so and and one of the founders has ties to the Philippines he also worked to the like adjacent side of the US military and spent time all through Asia so he's building off this firsthand knowledge that when I've talked to him I got the feeling he just agrees with this thesis of like yeah it would be great to build them here but I just don't even know that that's that's actually gonna happen they
Speaker 2
both think The other one is kind of dumb in their approach. I understand the Atlas approach, which is we're just not going to make it at scale here in a way that's efficient, good quality, and quickly. So go to a treaty ally country and build there at scale. And then you have to wonder why that has... Because it has happened to a degree.
Speaker 1
I mean, South Korea... Japan, these are countries. Taiwan, well Taiwan is problematic, but the Philippines is problematic too. It's in that part of the world. I just think if things kick off, it's don't you run into similar problems you're not going to be able to have boats just cruising I was going to say look at the Strait of Hormuz right now right and so so that part I mean I get their logic 100% and maybe a lot of all of this is like you have to start somewhere you know because I see people on the story they're like well they're building the actuators and the motors but we still need the rare earth magnets and this whole thing is flawed which is true but it's like you have to start somewhere you have to start somewhere both companies are trying to get to this like critical mass and you can you can 100% see a world where Atlas even gets going in the Philippines and then you can also have stuff in the US as well somebody just needs to make a lot of these the big difference that I don't know that everybody sees because they'll see Tesla making humanoids or figure and a couple other companies is is just that the difference is even if Tesla got to a massive scale and by the way, Tesla at least buys its prototypes from China for these parts.
They're still a flaw because they don't sell their products to other companies. Whereas in China, Unitree will sell a robot to whoever wants one. And then there's 10 companies like Unitree. And so unless I just, when you start thinking about where the volume of all this would go and if humanoids really take off then the US needs a general purpose supplier of these things to many many companies and it's it's like every startup the same thing happened in the rocket business where everyone wants to make their own engine because it's like the it's seen as the key part and that's like where you make a difference versus other companies but then Time and again the engine just bankrupts every company because it's really expensive it takes a long time to build and the motors and actuators aren't as bad but you point this out in your story or I think it was David maybe who was is that the Silicon Valley yeah Instinct is to be like wow i'm gonna make a better actuator than you and then i see the merits of that but then you can't have 50 companies do it it's just a lot of wasted you just need to make a shit ton which both companies plan to do in
Speaker 2
different ways but they both understand you just need to make a ton For Atlas, they have software, the woo-woo AI software that David says isn't necessary. Atlas uses to, you know, design these bespoke parts and then mass manufacture them in the Philippines versus Westmag wants to just do a generalized standard process, standard motor, and then, you know, sort of design around it once they're good at that.
Speaker 1
What was the software called again? Vector. Vector. So I only got to see it when they showed it. Yeah, I've never played with it. I only got to see what I didn't get to play with it,
Speaker 2
but they did show it to me and I'm not mechanical engineer. So it's a very long page with all these specs and all this math. It's very, very pretty. I bet it's very sexy to someone who works in that field. It looked cool for I have reported on companies like Ansys before which makes software that all types of manufacturing companies use when you want to you create your computer aided design prototype and then you can actually put what materials you're going to build this wing of a plane out of and it's it's grabbing the materials properties it's helping you with these simulations and so they've essentially built some AI infused motor actuator specific version of that type of software it looks really cool in that you're supposed to be able to go to them and say I want my motor to accomplish these tasks it's got to push something that's like this big and then the software goes in designs a motor and then it checks to
Speaker 1
see
Speaker 2
if it works for your system.
Speaker 1
Do we actually have these parts on hand at the ready? This is how much this would cost. And all the time with this type of software, I get a little nervous until you've actually seen it in action and know that it works, but it did look fancy.
Speaker 2
Like part of it too, is, you know, say you are at like Boston Dynamics and you have figured out a new architecture for your motor and you want to test that on your humanoid. And these, I don't want to say they break easily, but if you're testing them all the time, you're going to run through a bunch of these. So you've designed a new one, you want to get it and you send it off. It's going to take a long time for that to get back. And then you've already moved on to something else. So that's sort of the problem they want to fix is that you make this design and rather than like take months of engineering and designing you have it in a few minutes and then they go manufacture it and get it to you in a week right now it's eight weeks to get it which was really funny to ask them I was like how long would it take and they're like well yeah we need a lot more money it's about eight weeks but we're trying to get it down to a week so that would be really interesting and there's definitely something going on here I'm not um I
Speaker 1
don't know if I'm uh well I am a true believer in the People trying to re-industrialize for all the reasons we've outlined. I've been skeptical about which bits and pieces. But when you add up companies like Senkatsen, you see what Atlas and Westmag are doing. And then after we did our story, there's folks like Knox Metals in Detroit, all these people popping up. It does seem like something interesting is happening where I think it's on a tiny scale compared to China. But again, you have to start somewhere and everyone's building these different parts of the supply chain.
Speaker 2
Totally. I was just thinking of Gresham Whitmer visiting all of these companies. Her LinkedIn post that's in my story is she visited West Mag. She also visited Astra Mechanica, which I was like, oh my gosh, that was in my San Francisco episode coming soon. And, you know, this like reindustrialization of America, it feels like the government is finally catching on. And they're like, David says this in the story, like, you know it was chips and drones what else does this apply to and robotics motors actuators seem to be having a moment yeah she needs to they need to get Michigan to put some money instead of just doing a bucket of money yeah all right what do we do at Core Memory we cover innovative fast-moving forward-thinking companies which is
Speaker 1
why Core Memory is sponsored by Brex because Brex is the intelligent finance platform for many of these companies. 30,000 companies from startups to the world's largest corporations rely on Brex's technology for their finances. They've got smart corporate cards, high yield business banking and expense automation tools that are fantastic. I hate doing my expenses and Brex's AIs and software run right through those expenses, figure out where we're spending money. and take care of so much stuff for you so you don't have to waste your time on it yourself. Go to brex.com slash core memory to learn more and just, you know, get with the program. Let's get going. Let's get out of this archaic finance software and move toward the future. Core Memory and Brex. Well, you did the story. Anything else that jumped out at you that maybe didn't make it into the piece or?
Speaker 2
You know, the China approach. I was also thinking of like the government taking notice because, you know, they're going to know more than us. This, you know, civilians about what's happening and escalating around the world. it seems to me like do they um it seems to me that things are escalating and I'm slightly concerned I had a lot of people reach out about the actuator story and someone who works in robotics was like this is really important for people to care about and I haven't convinced anyone to care about it like how do you get people to care and I was like I'm a writer you know it was like you know the two narratives but by the end anyone who didn't know what a motor actuator was you don't have to know they understand like we have a manufacturing problem here and that really you know seemed to reach people in an interesting way and another thing too is I am very hardware pilled I was covering AI for so long I couldn't imagine pivoting out of it which is funny because before that I was covering Twitter the Elon Twitter and I couldn't imagine pivoting out of that and with this one it feels like not enough people are covering it whatsoever it's kind of shocking we wrote this week about a new act a new bill proposed by Congress and no one not a major publication covered that and that just doesn't happen in AI like every single movement and quote is covered but not in this yeah the bill came right after your story about a day or two and was is aimed at setting the groundwork for more or less having a way to ban Chinese robots from US soil much like we've done
Speaker 1
with drones and Huawei on networking equipment and it's early rumbles and they're just they're they're doing the thing they always do i i covered the whole huawei um yeah you get to this point where so huawei makes networking equipment now they make a whole bunch of other stuff but the us didn't want all this chinese networking equipment and data centers and in telco racks and everything and so they always come out with the same thing which is it has back doors that people can spy on and then you're like you're like wow is anyone spying what do you mean and then they they never give you actual details I mean you and your reporting on this did find I mean there were researchers who I did not know about those exploits in unitries so the bill you know is basically the same way we banned drones in Huawei as you mentioned like you put it on the covered list the FCC covered list and that means it can't come into the United States we can't sell it but you know with DJI you know it's still kind of you know floating around america consumer markets but bit of a problem when you actually want a drone exactly so uh so to essentially do that and they were really targeting unitry specifically a china humanoid robot and
Speaker 2
they do quadrupeds the robot dogs they were really targeting them and they were like they have back doors they're going to spy on us they are spying on us but they didn't say how or what any of those instances were in the actual bill or the press release and then when I went hunting I actually found some of those exploits which I didn't know about before I'm you know sort of like are they actually spying I guess I would lean more to yeah we should be cautious but that is the sort of brunt of their their press release in the bill is like we should be fearful when in actuality as I wrote you know we haven't built it ourselves and fear is the best way to sort of catch up it seems the nightmare scenario being that China does dominate the human robot market we have them all in our homes and factories and
Speaker 1
then China decides one day to weaponize them or they're just listening to everything that's going on. The great flaw with our politicians on this plan is that even if we wanted to replace these robots, we really kind of couldn't do it right now. So it's like, wow. it's the same as in drones I mean all these police departments fire departments they use DJI because they're really cheap and good and they do your job and we don't even make enough to supply everyone yeah Unitree was first they're fast they're better and we just don't really have an equivalent you've covered some of the American equivalents but they're very young it's still like a really nascent market because I want to say between 13 and 18,000 humanoids were sold last year around the world it's still very small yeah mostly for research so for research yeah so you're skeptical I always see your skepticism you wrote in the story you don't think a humanoid will be feeding your cat by like 2030 yeah we're 2026
Speaker 2
You think a humanoid will be feeding my cat by 2030? I hear a lot of 2030 sci-fi at this point and I'm like, I'm not so sure guys.
Speaker 1
What's the problem? The problem is still the hands and then the thought that you have this big giant machine that just goes bonkers.
Speaker 2
No, you know what? I'm not so fearful of the machine. I mean, I live in a studio Can you imagine that clomping around my downstairs neighbor would fucking kill me? No, I just I don't see us figuring that out in America like I don't need a Unitree robot something small consumer grade the the bill does not cover wheeled robots so I'm thinking of like sort of the Black Mirror-esque wheeled robot that is not banned but by 2030 no I don't I don't see that really happening and the humanoid market well when you look at these things that was like my first week at Core Memory I was deathly sick we all were and I went to what was the robot shoot
Speaker 1
Yeah, we did at least one at the Wreck. Was it the big battle?
Speaker 2
No, it was the humanoid sit-down interview. Right. With David and Kamen, and it was...
Speaker 1
Oh, the Phantom.
Speaker 2
Is it Phantom?
Speaker 1
Foundation.
Speaker 2
They have a Business Week cover where it's like Terminator style.
Speaker 1
Right, right. Yeah, keep vamping. So we went there and I had never really seen a humanoid like that up close.
Speaker 2
And that one is like...
Speaker 1
It's the Phantom robot made by Foundation. Foundation. Yeah. that was like that robots like what like six foot something yeah I mean it's and it's it's broad-shouldered it's a big robot it's a big robot I think they had it on hooks basically and they were taking apart from the video but that thing was freaky and it doesn't help that they have like the magazine cover on the wall that's like this thing's gonna kill you basically I'm not really scared but something like that
Speaker 2
I don't see like in a consumer market anytime maybe within five to eight years, maybe a decade, but yeah, not by 2030. Skeptical.
Speaker 1
Super skeptical. I won't get into this because I didn't really listen to everything he had to say, but I did laugh. Bernie Sanders did his, we should give half of AI companies away to the American public, which, you know, I don't know, but I do laugh because he's got his DJI microphone on his lapel and I find comedy in all of this.
Speaker 2
the sweet irony of it all. We just got our senator miked as we're passing all this legislation about robots spying on us.
Speaker 1
Our senator's in his office with his DJI mic. You don't even need a back door. He's just miked up. He's giving it to you.
Speaker 2
Yeah, there's something else I was going to say about the robotics front. I think, you know, it's having a moment it's really interesting I'm still pilled like I'm still really really fascinated by the progress this market is making I just don't see like this broad consumer use of them anytime soon we have been trying to fold a t-shirt for a very long time oh that's the that's the other thing too is what I'm really pilled about coming from AI is something that's touched on in the actuator story which is if you're AGI pilled and you think like you know we're going to reach AGI and it needs a physical you know body to exist and learn and I don't think I've talked about on the pod too much but world models really interest me me and David had a good debate about this actually on the SF shoot because he's not as and he thinks world models aren't going to work I think it's like a fascinating new avenue to create new intelligence it's how we learn through the world that's interesting if we reach something like we're reaching self-improving AI anthropic said today I think in a headline then it being in robots makes sense to me but that is a little, that's when it gets a little scary.
Speaker 1
Seems like it's going the driverless car route where you have 80 85 90 percent of things solved but the last 10 percent are really important and kind of make everything work and the hand and being dexterous yeah is one of these and then the safety and um even when what is it 1x was selling that robot I think they're still remotely monitored and and this is it's not going to work like that so maybe it takes maybe it's the same thing I mean we've just Even though a lot of money has been poured into this over the years we kind of like just hit the phase where it's that many many billions of dollars and many companies trying like we saw in self-driving land so yeah this could be like 10 years also fun fact remember Ben Katz from my story yes he did you know he works at Pi no isn't that interesting yeah so I mentioned this guy Ben Katz he had a thesis I believe he was a researcher at MIT a graduate student and he made it was the Tiger motor and he was like China should steal this because I want it to be everywhere and we can't manufacture it and they did and they did so that's like sort of the basis both for West Mag and a lot of motors out there and actuators and yeah he
Speaker 2
works at Pi working on those hands yeah okay well that makes sense um well all right we'll move on that is but you guys should all read the story and we did our duty you'll probably read that exact same story in the New York Times and I would imagine like 18 to 24 months yeah so I and I promise you that will happen yeah I'm not sure exactly I literally had nightmares about it as I was so excited about it last I'll say about this I was so excited about it because opening I just released a position to be an actuator engineer as I was writing the story and I was going to bed I was like if the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal write about this in 18 to 24 months and don't credit us I'm going to throw a fit they will and they won't they'll probably get there quicker now that we've put it out there I know yeah always interesting to see their fall of speed I'm going a little off route for one second because we have to congratulate Michaela Sortland John Sortland as you all know is our wonderful
Speaker 1
podcast editor and the drummer of The Shins his wife has just been elected to the Nevada City Council Nevada City is not in Nevada it's in California we just went to shoot part of an episode there last week because half of our employees work in Nevada City and it is this strange very artsy musical it's an old gold mining town it's very well preserved it has lots of tourists who come visit because of this beautiful downtown and it's in the mountains but then it has this strange um cultural streak to it where there's just a lot of famous musicians who have come out of it artists and Michaela is is in bands John is in multiple bands including the Shins when we were there I got to hang out for a little bit with Joanna Newsom who a lot of people listening to this will know she's a singer and a harpist and they named whatever it was the day we were there like the Tuesday or the Wednesday it became Joanna Newsom day forever she got the key to the city and and gave this riveting speech and then uh and then Michaela was running for office while we were there then she won yeah incredible I'm from Northern
Speaker 2
California so love Nevada City love a gold mining town makes perfect sense to me that they're weird and hippie it's fucking rad and we got to go the shins well they got the whole the shins together to do a thank you concert for Michaela to a hundred people and I got to just basically walk right up to the very front of the shins playing more or less a concert just for for us and it was amazing I got to to hang out with James Mercer the lead singer and and all the band members I think James and I are chums now and it's very cool we'll have an episode coming for everyone but just give a little shout out and this reminds me all right we're gonna do it for like a couple weeks more the shins are going on tour with Weezer and Silver Sun pickups
Speaker 1
and it starts in September and it's big and we need you to leave more comments and likes on Apple Spotify wherever you listen to this and if you whoever leaves the best one from our judgment will get two tickets to to this concert and you know from what I saw they are prepared they're prepared to play I just decided I need to make a playlist of my favorite songs from all of these groups because I really love the shins in Silver Sun pickups I
Speaker 2
listened to them so much in college Weezer was my entire middle school experience. I am stoked to go to this concert and you guys should listen to their music. So I'm going to make a playlist of my favorites.
Speaker 1
I have also been digging in on the shins since hanging out with them.
Speaker 2
It's so good.
Speaker 1
All right, pod friends. I am here to tell you about Send, Cut, Send. They are a manufacturing phenomenon. Whether you're working on your own car or you're a giant automotive company, a rocket maker, If you need metal cut, machine, or bent, you're going to Send, Cut, Send. They'll do it for you right, and they will do it for you fast. Go to sendcutsend.com slash core memory for a 15% discount on whatever you're trying to make. We love Send, Cut, Send. Go visit them today.
Speaker 2
Where should we go next? Rocket Land.
Speaker 1
We can go Rocket Land. It was probably, I want to say about a week. whatever who knows when this will come out but recently a Blue Origin New Glenn rocket exploded on the pad at Cape Canaveral this is always terrible news when a rocket explodes so violently on the pad because it creates tons of damage it's also extremely bad timing for Blue Origin they were after many years of going much slower than SpaceX had just started to hit their stride yeah it looks like maybe spacex would have a genuine competitor on the horizon i think they still will but this is problematic because historically it's taken anywhere from a year to two years to rebuild all the infrastructure you need to redo this rocket blue origins ceo david limp was saying he hopes to fly by the end of the year Eric Berger who's one of the best space reporters around for Ars Technica interviewed a bunch of space spacex went through a pretty similar thing oh I forget the year I want to say it was like 2012 to 2014 somewhere in there spacex had had a few successful launches of the Falcon 9 then they had this brief really bad run where two blew up in pretty quick succession same thing they had major pad damage and it was one of those moments where it was like oh okay maybe you guys can't actually do this and Facebook had a satellite on one of those rockets and Zuckerberg was really shitting on Elon about it all it was a bad public relations thing on top of everything and I don't know if it was a full-on life or death moment but it was probably if they'd had one more explosion in that window it could have very well been because you start to lose all trust people are going to give you money and maybe you just don't have things figured out and so blue had finally hit this moment it was very exciting we everybody wants to set up satellites now we're doing data centers in space we need lots of rockets there's there's really not still that many rocket companies that figured this out and so this is this is this is kind of like bad news for blue it's very good news for spacex is probably good news for rocket lab they are coming with their neutron rocket that's a bit smaller than what spacex and blue origin are doing but rocket lab has this great track record and and people just need rockets and so it looked like for a minute it looked like blue might kind of outflank rocket lab too just just in terms of having resources in this this big rocket and so yeah bad news for uh jeff bezos and crew In my neck of the world of people my age who hate technology I saw a lot of people saying like fuck Jeff Bezos I'm so glad this blew up blah blah blah they just think it's a rich guy's hobby which I totally get and if I wasn't you know sitting across
Speaker 2
from the guy who did the book maybe I would think the same but you know I also think of sort of the parallel between that recent space mission with NASA Artemis and how excited we were for humanity and our future and like that really hit home but we see something like this we're like oh you know that rich guy who cares and it's just really interesting because we do need rockets we do need this innovation it is incredibly important and I do think some of the richest people in the world should be the ones backing it
Speaker 1
Well, people get views sometimes because Blue Origin does have the space tourism portion, which is the New Shepard rocket. And then it has this, which is New Glenn, which is all the things you were talking about. This is much more on the industrial, if you want to go that way, patriotic end of sending up things the U.S. very much would like to have in space, whether it's military or infrastructure. And it is essentially SpaceX versus China right now, unless Rocket Lab, Blue Origin all come along as well.
Speaker 2
Does China send up a lot of rockets? I actually have no idea.
Speaker 1
They do. So, I mean, they have a relatively young space program in the big scheme of things, but then now have become the clear number two in all of this all. And it really is SpaceX versus China. China's been catching up extremely rapidly. They have government backed rocket companies and then they have these quasi SpaceX where it's like a private company that's kind of like owned by the government and the rockets look awfully similar to SpaceX's rockets. But on things like reuse, SpaceX still way ahead, Blue Origin even ahead, although China's catching up. And then they're willing to do the stuff that we're only, Rhetorically willing to do and then and then maybe financially which is you know they are hardcore moon and and want to be and will they will beat the U.
S. back to the moon with a person I mean the U.S. says they won't but they will and and so that's going to be a even though we've been there before it's going to be this massive PR hit for the United States and and so Trump everyone's been desperately this is what people want to find a way to help the U.S. get a human to the moon before China but it would take a miracle of timing and China's been working on this faster and then they're doing exploration too so the US still because of SpaceX SpaceX does more launches than the rest of the world combined and then plus multiple times but China's second after that it used to be Russia and then Russia's space program has been undermined by both corruption and obviously the war and the war has cut off a lot of customers for them but still very strong Europe launches about usually like one rocket a month um don't leave Canada out like a good year Canada's coming you've got Japan India those are other space powers and then New Zealand because of Rocket Lab um why does it matter that China would get to the moon first on this next go
Speaker 2
around People are divided on this because it's like we did it so many decades ago. And so it's kind of like, you're just doing what we've already figured out. But I think because it's just, you get seen as being innovative, pushing the limits.
Speaker 1
We're going to this next stage of, we're not just going to the moon to stand on it for a few minutes, but we want to make a colony there.
Speaker 2
NASA put out a thing that we're going to have a moon base. And you were like, no, we aren't. Well we will we just won't I don't know if NASA will be the one who actually builds it I mean they'll try but I think if we were going to bet on things we would want to bet on the companies but I think it's really that next era of the moon and if
Speaker 1
this is going to be some strategic industrial kind of thing. It's like if China gets there first and they're really doing stuff, they're not going to be real happy when it starts all this crap all over again. This is this like territorial. And so I think the moon went from a science project, this curiosity, this, you know, public relations, we can get there to becoming much more of like an economic and strategic sort of thing. And so so that's the big deal. And that's just, yeah, it's going to look bad because the U.S. I think if the U.S. had been like, oh, we don't even want to go back there. We're like all Mars or something. And China's doing like the old thing. Maybe they could have saved face that way. But we did. We said we want to go back too. And now we're going to we're not going to get there before them. So, yeah. Did you get into rockets similarly how I feel about hardware right now where I'm
Speaker 2
like, no one's covering this?
Speaker 1
I mean, I was it was really I started. Well, I just got interested in Elon out of People forget, I mean, Elon had been, he'd kind of like been a thing because of PayPal and then he was a thing when he first announced SpaceX and Tesla, but that was around like early 2000s and then kind of like 2008, SpaceX flew its Falcon 1 successfully for the first time and Tesla was trying to make the roadster and so it was like, oh, this Elon guy, he's doing all this crazy sci-fi stuff but then there was this like long period of time where nothing was really working the roadster had all these delays spacex was a little more quiet and um so by the time like 2012 came around then I got I just kind of got into like oh I didn't really I'd never covered Elon as like a beat or like he wasn't like um um unknown to me but I really didn't know that much and then I decided I wanted to do a magazine story and so I went to SpaceX to interview Elon in his I guess it was like a giant cubicle I was in the office and then I was like holy shit this is not what I was expecting it was in Los Angeles right by LAX so you're like you're in the you know this was not just some weird remote outpost it was like right in the heart of the city and I totally thought it would be like one rocket and there'd be a few people trying to get this thing.
And this factory was just like full of rockets and thousands of people. There's like heavy metal music. You just feel this palpable energy. And so I was already hardware pilled. And then this felt like the apex of hardware-ness. Like, oh, this is cool. I did not, I don't know. You hear some rich person trying to take on NASA. I was just as skeptical as anyone.
Speaker 2
No, there's nothing more tantalizing than the manufacturing floor. yeah this was this was on this this grand I mean it was just it was just way bigger and cooler than anything I'd expected and so then no because I was just not a space dork I knew nothing yeah and I just got into rockets yeah that's like I think another thing that's made me so excited about this beat like I didn't I don't necessarily didn't necessarily like choose to cover hardware but once you go to these factory floors it's so different from a software company like I won't name them but you just go to their office and it's like sort of 2012 bean bags and chips but he's manufacturing floors it's just guys covered in grease and you know building stuff blasting music and you can actually touch and hold like the first prototype what they're building now you can click it together if you want and it's just like wow this is fucking rad I have one you have you have no I mean
Speaker 1
you're 100% I think you're totally right there's some awesome software and there are cool stories to be had but there's there's something especially as a reporter just gets to like hang on to a physical thing it just it's it feels real and it's a real deep feeling yeah it's like wow this is just I don't know rich it's it and the people are working hard and they are you wrote it was your lead on your story yeah they're very humble they're just a different breed yeah it's just software can get I guess all of it can get a little repetitive I suppose but I I a little uptight yeah you know and and um you're just having your you're having your lunch at their fancy office and yeah it's sort of it makes you a little comatose after a while which you know I again I there's no love lost for software it's just when you enter the hardware world it's like wow and it's like guys you can have beers with and you know just talk shot I don't know it's just a different feeling you haven't even blown shit up yet oh you did well in Canada you almost well and uh with uh astromechanica yeah yeah that was an engine test but no blowing shit up not yet that's the that's that's the key and then okay so related to all this space stuff SpaceX announced they I think there was like a FAA filing that went out so they have this this Starfall capsule this really caught my attention it looks like people have to go hunt a little bit to find these these pictures of this thing but it's essentially sort of a laboratory you would put into orbit it reminded me a lot of a startup called Varda and we've written about Varda they are okay there's this thing that happens in low earth orbit which is fascinating which is that atoms arrange themselves in different ways than they do on earth without gravity pressing against them they go in these very precise formations and we've known for many years and have proven that you can make medicines different chemicals than you can on earth yeah but the problem has been the only place you could really do these experiments was on the ISS and it was like Procter and Gamble or some scientists would pay for some astronaut to like fiddle with some atoms and and they some atoms yeah but you know they proved they proved this works but then it was like what do you how do you make this bigger and so Varda's whole bet was we'll make essentially like a biotech lab that's pretty big in low earth orbit and then they send up they go run the experiment they mix up the chemicals they try to make a medicine so there's been a lot of medicines that have failed that were promising but then they like their shelf life was bad it was like earth was you could see all the promise of the molecules but then they had flaws and so Varda's been trying to take these compounds to space and see if in this different environment, maybe we can get around this.
So they do all the experience, they make the chemical, the molecule, and then they bring it back to Earth. They kind of like freeze it in time, and then they bring it back to Earth. And so Varda's flown maybe like five or six times, which is actually pretty good. They've gone a lot faster than most space startups do. They are backed by Founders Fund. Founders Fund is one of the biggest backers of SpaceX. I find this interesting that now spacex is more or less saying hey we're gonna get into this business too and and this is all stepping stone towards manufacturing in space so you start with chemicals and molecules but you're more or less sending up this laboratory this mini factory into low earth orbit and trying to see what you could do people also think you can make um semiconductors differently in space that we could like make chips there's this hope of like all these things that is sick it's pretty sick i did not know anything about any of this that's dope it's been it's just been really hard for all the reasons you would expect is yeah it's like somebody has to build all this stuff you got to like fly it up and down and get it back and it's got to go through the earth's atmosphere and so spacex is doing exactly that they're getting into it i Delian who's the you know one of the co-founders of art is very outspoken on X I didn't check to see if he had tweets about this SpaceX star fog capsule the it reminded me that SpaceX has been so focused on the core of its business was sending up satellites really for other companies and countries so did that for many years then The run of the last two, three, four years has been doing that but also setting up a lot of its own satellites for Starlink and then Mars was always looming in the back as the main mission which was about setting up a colony and then SpaceX ignored all the other things that startups were nipping at which would be space habitats, things like this making factories, things that Jeff Bezos talked about a little bit more, but also was not doing yet.
And now I just wonder as they become a public company, are they going to trample over everyone in every one of these businesses? We have an episode coming on vast space, which is making a commercial space station and it will be flying on a spacex rocket and then in tandem with the dragon capsule that takes the people to this so they're kind of like a partner wow but and all this stuff costs money i don't i don't even know that i mean it's elon and spacex is about to raise a ton of money so maybe they could do all these things each one of these things is like a multi-billion dollar project and and you don't know if it's actually going to be a going business but i do now when i saw that i'm like oh man I just I saw this as a signal that spacex is kind of like we would also like to get into these industries that's a good thing it's a good thing for spacex is probably a terrible thing for everybody else because spacex unless something changes just wins because they have the rockets and none of these other companies have rockets they're all looking for rides so spacex can turn up and turn down historically like in competing against Starlink SpaceX would even fly so OneWeb is a competitor Starlink Amazon has been trying to compete SpaceX would fly their competing satellites for their space internet because it was happy to take their money basically saying I don't think you can actually compete with us but like if you want to give us money for a ride we'll take it and then now they've been cutting that off and so Blue Origin for the reasons we talked about before Amazon's trying to build a competitor to Starlink you would think it would fly on Blue Origins rockets because it's like on the Jeff Bezos family they were gonna fly on Soyuz rockets they can't because we can't fly in Russian rockets with the war going on they've been really limited and they will remain rate limited on how many satellites they can put in to orbit even worse now with this explosion and then you know if you're Varda you're probably fine for the foreseeable future rocket lab is coming with neutron it's bigger rocket but anyway no I mean this is this is like people are so far from I should give numbers because people don't know all this stuff I mean traditionally like a government the government rockets have been the what how you got to space and and almost everyone a great year was one a month it was like so 12 a year I mean SpaceX is up at like somewhere between 160 190 they're flying almost every two days whoa yeah so this is this is drastically different and and so if you want to ride on any of this stuff you're beholden to SpaceX and we can't American companies can't use Chinese rockets Russian rockets are grounded Europe hardly ever flies you can go to India you're just very limited on your options so um so we'll see what happens in SpaceX I think Rocket Lab is a little behind now on its Neutron rocket.
If they are able to fly that and start getting closer to flying all the time, life could be pretty good because Rocket Lab is very neutral and willing to help people out. It's funny I'm thinking about my second week at Core Memory which was I was hanging out with you in the office and we were talking about the HBO Wild Wild Space and I hadn't seen it I went home and watched it I was like this is funny I was just with
Speaker 2
my boss all day and now he's on my fucking laptop I'm sorry no it was also awesome because I could just text you like oh my god this is crazy and this is crazy but when that rocket did it blow up it didn't reach the orbit was supposed to reach the first rocket lab yeah yes oh my god that was the most heartbreaking thing I'd ever seen because they they were just so close you're so on that founder's side and then just screwed yeah yes I feel like I've been prattling
Speaker 1
on without space but that one was Peter Beck is a perfectionist Nobody ever gets a rocket right the first time. He was very much gonna get a rocket right. The American regulators, the safety officers were there to monitor the situation. I believe if I remember right installed their software wrong and so the rocket was not they didn't see it where it actually was so they blew it up and otherwise Peter Beck pretty much would have been the first person in history to get it right like mere seconds or something he was so close it was so messed up yeah yeah what is it rocket science can't be that hard it was just that one was just uh software software bug yeah this is what this is the problem with software people show up I know messing everything up um okay well that's all I have to prattle on about SpaceX although I will say the IPO still oh my god shall we the IPO I mean we talked about it a little last time I think now I've had time to marinate I mean these numbers are insane the there is if you are a if you're like a purely rational investor you should not in any way shape or form be participating in this SpaceX IPO when you look at like the revenue versus profits versus valuation there would have been nothing like this in history the only reason this makes sense and the reason there's this premium is the Elon of it all however If you go to all the things we just talked about, there is actually some scenario.
I mean, this is a long-term bet that you're making, but it's a bet on what I wrote about in my last book. So I do believe in this, that there's a giant economy to be built in low Earth orbit and beyond. And I am just always skeptical on the time scale of where that plays out. Will we have data centers in space? Yes, one day. Will we have Tons of data centers powering the immediate AI boom in space. That seems far-fetched to me.
Speaker 2
Shall I give some statistics for our listeners? SpaceX has set its IPO price at $135 a share, aiming for a record-breaking valuation of approximately $1.77 trillion.
Speaker 1
Right. So, and this is like, okay. I mean, we only have a handful of companies valued at a trillion dollars. NVIDIA is a hardware company. All the rest are essentially software or services, which is what you would expect. I mean, it is hard to say that like a hardware company doing rockets, which is not even like a very profitable hardware business. But yeah, so, you know, you have to look at things like Starlink, which is a telecommunications subscription service. That's good. That makes sense. data centers would fall. Anyone who makes money in space, you make it from doing a service in space.
And so there is a world where all this makes sense. If SpaceX, if these businesses take off, it is unclear that really any other rocket maker would be there to compete. And so maybe SpaceX just has a monopoly over everything happening in space. Would that be worth $2 trillion? Probably. I mean, maybe. Would that happen in three years? maybe like 20 I think that even seems optimistic I don't know so you know the Elon is able that's sort of the thing is like he is able to plant that seed of possibility that this actually could happen unlike anybody else it's so funny to see this trajectory because I was covering the Elon of it all at for Twitter at fortune and it's so weird because now that's a part of spacex twitter is i don't know what happens there is it just for you know training data but yeah the elon of it all it's uh there's still still whether you guys like it or not nobody like him for all that yeah anyway i mean i mean it's funny because i covered space for so long and it's just it's there's a couple businesses that have worked and they've been great but all the rest of the stuff is just like a uh graveyard of lost hopes and dreams and money.
So to be betting all in on this is a lot.
Speaker 2
The first time I learned about key man risk was Elon. I was just thinking, I mean, he's not old, but he's getting up there. And, you know, this is a very, very long term bet. So you're really betting on Elon at the end of it.
Speaker 1
I mean, that guy. Well, I don't want to say it. he lives a stressful life he does I'm thinking of the key man risk if you're betting on the Elon of it all I don't know anyone who could replace him quite honestly like him or not SpaceX Quinn Shotwell has run it so well but it's all those ancillary things it's the mystique it's the taking insane risk and finding insane amounts of capital I guess he might never have to do this again as far as
Speaker 2
like IPO Yeah well just having to talk people into the vision to take that next big giant gamble because Tesla's already public Every earnings call once a quarter Yeah but I mean you're getting like your pile of money from the IPO and then it's kind of like it's just nice to have the stock price up to keep employees happy and stuff like that but you're not going to get your bag I mean this is his last bag because he's
Speaker 1
put all the companies into it I don't think he needs more bags I mean he always seems to there's always like another another thing I guess eventually I'm sure Tesla and SpaceX merge into some yeah yeah Mike Solana is a genius and so he works at Founders Fund and did this great thing where um They're playing Mafia and they got together like just the all-star.
Speaker 2
Have you played Mafia?
Speaker 1
I've played Mafia with my family, but like once or twice and not. Yes.
Speaker 2
So it's a very tech employee game. Like I was only introduced to it through the tech world and I'm bad at lying. It scares me.
Speaker 1
Remind me how it works.
Speaker 2
So Mafia. So I watched this episode last night. The Founders Fund put out of all these all-stars playing Mafia. and it goes something like this there is a sheriff there is an angel there are three mafia people and then the rest are just townsfolk the goal so it's kind of like heads up seven up you close your eyes and the MC will be like okay all the mafia wake up who do you want to kill and they all agreed to kill one person and then they go to sleep and then the angel wakes up who do you want to save angel tends to save themselves just so they can continue playing they go to sleep sheriff wakes up and it's like who do you want to interrogate and everyone goes to sleep and then you know someone dies he's like so-and-so died in a mine explosion who did it who's the mafia and then they all get to interrogate each other they choose people they think are the mafia they get 15 seconds to plead their case and then they get to vote the person off so Founders Fund did this with people like Sam Altman Palmer Luckey Trey Stephens Stevens Bryan Johnson just an all-star cast of the co-founder of Signal the Dylan Field yeah Dylan Field from Figma Figma and Boxy Marlon Spike was there the co-founder or inventor of Signal he's a total character it was kind of like who you would want all people who
Speaker 1
pride themselves on their intellect there a bunch of them are um try to find the right word I mean are are like into strategy yeah gameplay and their executives their investors their people who know how to do game theory and talk about it a lot that's kind of they do game theory like in their life yeah and so to see to see Sam there we're all expecting him to be a mafia person and lie through his teeth a master of game theory and then Palmer Palmer plays D&D every Sunday. He has done it for many, many years. A little different. And then I remember I played Magic with Trey one time. I mean, Founders Fund is really in all this. all this competitive stuff and Mike came up with his ideas genius I'm so jealous I wish I thought of this it was so good I was skipping it because I was like oh I don't know like I don't want to watch a bunch of CEOs talk thinking it would be like a boring panel sort of deal but it was so entertaining and I won't ruin it for who won how it went but watching these people like sort of lie that's the game and just become incredible actors it was it was so good and there's more episodes
Speaker 2
coming out it was very well done i love to see brian johnson has evolved so much over the years he's quite funny and charismatic he used to be a little shyer and uh buttoned up i enjoyed seeing him doing that they i i guess it won't ruin to tell you who everyone was because that's what they first the cards that they're dealt um trey was mafia brian was a townsperson so was palmer um dylan field was the sheriff um the signal inventor was the angel and yeah Brian and Palmer Brian was a little bit more quiet and people were like oh you're mafia and he's just like by you know sort of constitution a little bit more reserved but yeah it was so cool awesome anyway I want to check that out and I wanted to take a brief moment to talk about 60 Minutes oh my boss stepped in it I lost what appears to be some number of thousands of Twitter followers with my tank on 60
Speaker 1
Minutes, which did get a little hostile. It was late and I...
Speaker 2
I'll explain 60 Minutes. So 60 Minutes, the television show I used to watch with my grandma when I was younger. They have new management. Paramount hired Bari Weiss to lead CBS and the program. And she just hired Nick Bilton, who's going to be their new producer. But they've had a lot of tumult. They have gone through a lot of their correspondence, their on-air anchors. They have been fired or they have quit. the last executive producer either was fired or quit so it's been really really you know tumultuous and Scott Pelley one of the last standing correspondents and someone you would recognize as like the 60 Minutes guy he was fired by Nick Bilton and Barry Weiss and they put out this statement saying like he was not willing to work with us it was clear he didn't want to be a part of this team so we had to let him go and people were up in arms about it i had texted ashley like this is crazy and then well yeah well yes there's a lot of things going on here i mean people think bari is has been trumpified and and trump's done all this stuff to cbs and and larry he hated 60 minutes owns it david ellison now owns paramount and well everything
Speaker 1
really um and so Clearly the thinking is they will become stooges of this administration. 60 Minutes is the, meant to be the highest form of journalism that we have left. And so, and then, okay, here's what I, here's where I diverge. I get all that, I get all that. And that is, that is, it's grim. if that happens i think nick built it i've worked with him we work together at the new york times he's a friend um so whatever take that with for all it's worth and i just don't think there's just i know he's not an ideologue and there's no evidence that he's an ideologue okay if barry's his boss and she's giving some commandment that things have to be this way okay you know i fully see that i see them firing these people scott pelly wrote this letter that he said They were trying to make him put falsehoods into stories.
Is all of that alarming? Yes, it is. It seemed a little... Maybe I took this too personally. I don't know. I just think Scott had this huge tirade against Nick on his first day. I just don't think Nick... I just don't think you were going to assume that he is some toady for these people. He's not like that. There's no evidence of that. Nick is ambitious. He's got an ego. He's going to want to make his mark. I don't know. That doesn't mean he's going to do better than what was there before but he will try to do something original that was a huge point of contention was his lack of experience people were really dogging on that yeah but you know Nick has been like really entrepreneurial with his career and and I I do yes okay so they're dogging on his experience the dude has written like best-selling books that were really well reported he's like not naive to what it takes to report a story this was my other contention is that I appreciate everything that 60 Minutes has done God knows I celebrate a reporter that's like willing to put their life on the line people that are going to spend all the time to really report something out and fact check it please understand I'm not trying to undermine that I also find it to be it's a little too precious I mean they've done lots of good stuff but it's like we're holding this up like it's okay first of all When they do those stories, it's fantastic.
Most of their stories are not that. They're very formulaic. It's somebody who has a sit-down interview. Scott Pelley takes a little slow stroll with someone for like 20 feet and then they go on a little bit of a field trip. I find it all pompous and I find Scott Pelley quite pretentious in his delivery. of things i think it hasn't changed in a long time they always get celebrated because they have such great ratings it's like they follow cbs sunday football which is the biggest thing you could possibly be attached to in this era like if you actually think that 60 minutes on its own in a in a moment when tv is just fading into oblivion would be some money-spinning juggernaut of ratings i think you're Insane and so like the idea that they want to maybe change things up a little and Put some new energy in the show.
I just I do not find that offensive so where I empathize With your argument is that we both came from sort of the gray lady institutionalized media world and both of
Speaker 2
us and aren't so precious and don't take things so seriously we take our reporting seriously but we don't take ourselves so seriously and so we're both kind of allergic to that pompous energy and people saying like well we need to keep that because that is like what real journalism is and how dare this guy come in and change that I empathize with that being really annoying of an argument what what I get is the whole trumpification of it all and Firing Scott Pelley is like kicking a puppy in front of all of America it's just like you it's like why would you kick the puppy in front of all of America when you're trying to like sort of unify this network and get it all back together when there's been drama completely fragmenting it so many people are leaving there was reporting that the whole staff could quit after this it's like dude that was an unforced error But I agree with like the sort of the pompous energy. It's like, dude, like media is different. We can be different. We can approach it differently. It doesn't have to be this age old thing. That's like, you know, so precious. I get that. And I really empathize with that opinion. I agree. But yeah, it was an unforced error.
Speaker 1
I mean, they run like, you know, every ad that runs against 60 Minutes is some pill that you take when you're like seven years old. I just do not believe, I think they've convinced themselves that they're doing a much better job than they probably are. I know. the salaries and the expenses of this thing must be so bloated and tied to like we've already been through this in in print journalism which is like there are no magazine jobs that used to exist where you just got to go off for like four months and stay in a five-star hotel and and then report you're like two stories I missed this whole I worked at two magazines I will tell you I was the last person to do it I set expense report records that this does not happen anymore and I think they're because they have been because they are iconic and they they were like holding on to that last spot I'm sure that cost structure is still in place and I I honestly believe they're sort of protected by this this football thing and where they sit and so the idea that Scott Pelley is getting paid five million dollars a year and is somehow at like 68 I'm sorry irreplaceable as a talent.
I don't think he's that talented. I'm sorry. I just don't. I appreciate everything they've done. I just, I think this is way too precious. What I did not expect, my God, was like the... You kick the puppy, man. Dude, people are emotionally attached to the show. So maybe everything I'm saying is wrong, but the, oh my God, people are like sending me death threats. They're like unfollowed. I'm like, it's just an opinion on a fucking TV show. what I didn't really understand is just how inflamed this argument has gotten over 60 minutes I used to watch this with my grandma in the summer like it was nothing I would fall asleep during it you know it's people are very precious about it I think it's sort of you know a symbol of how screwed everything really is and like it's the one thing you can attach to and be like dude like we can uproar about this but
Speaker 2
then making a boxing ring at the White House right now is just so ridiculous that none of us can process it. But this, it's like, how dare you? How dare you, you know, infringe on our entertainment and our journalism? I agree with the whole, you know, is he irreplaceable? You just can't, you just got to read the room when people are inflamed and just not poke the bear. But you like poking the bear sometimes.
Speaker 1
Yeah, I was pretty happy to poke it on that one. I didn't That's some of the severity of the backlash. I remember when I wrote for the New York Times. This is what 60 Minutes reminds me of. It's like when you're writing for the front page of the Times, it's in some ways the most prestigious thing you can do while you're there and the worst experience. Because if I was writing for the business section, it was mostly me and one editor. really doing the vast majority of the work. The story was the story that I wanted to tell, more or less. By the time it gets to the front page, it might be like 12 people have had their way with this.
It has to read to the widest possible audience. It becomes a caricature of the story you were originally trying to tell. by nature of it being on the front page it cannot have the detail that you had set out to do and so you feel like you're kind of like it's the pro side of okay as many people as possible now are aware of this thing that I cared enough about to report on this the downside is it's like the jokey you know worst version of the way I would have told the story I almost don't recognize it yeah 60 Minutes anytime they've reported anything that I know anything about it feels like that and I get it they have to speak to like everybody so you cannot be talking about you know actuators on some crazy deep down detail you have to do the most basic version of that I just imagined them doing the actuator story yeah you know this piece this is a motor this is the one component tonight 60 Minutes so I get it all I'm at this point where it's like I mean because there is power in that it is important you have to like reach people where they are you want it's like the closest thing I guess we still had to that era when the country there were so few networks that like everybody kind of knew something yeah and but you know then when I maybe it's just me it's not just me it's just the way the world is heading it's like when you I'm like is Scott Pelley better than some YouTuber who is actually nerding out on the thing and you're you're like okay if I care about this thing I'm gonna learn way more about what's actually going on from this person sitting here for 40 minutes it's it's it's like apples and oranges to a degree it's also where the world has shifted I think where like people who are 60 Minutes is still that thing where they're like telling you what's important whereas the rest is kind of like I'm into this I'm going to go look for it and 60 Minutes would be like the last place you would want to go to learn about imaging satellites because I remember them doing a story on Planet Labs and I was just like, this is very bad.
Speaker 2
What are the grandmas and grandpas in the retirement homes gonna do? They're not gonna watch YouTube.
Speaker 1
Right, okay, but so this is the problem. It's like, what's the bet you're making then? So are you usually keeping 60 minutes around for as long as possible to sell those ads, keep those baby boomers fed with what they want, or is CBS and Barry and Nick doing the right thing which is like there's this great institution we have to find out what's the next chapter are you telling me like in 20 years there's gonna be a fucking clock ticking with somebody sitting there in a suit it kind of makes me sad to think that there won't be for some reason even
Speaker 2
though like I am incredibly allergic to the legacy media of it all where you know my experience with magazines too it's a completely stripped down version of your story to be palpable to CIOs in their 60s or whatever and it's just like this isn't the magic this isn't the story I wanted to tell or the story even at all but there is something to be said of like you know providing that information to a really really general audience that we're allergic to but there's clearly a market for But the reaction to it was so loud and overblown that was a little hard to understand.
Speaker 1
Well, people see this as the last vestige of all these traditions. I see all that. I get it. The crap that Trump's been doing with CBS and everything is like revolving. I don't want Trump anywhere near anything to do with news. And I think that's the reaction is they're like, oh wow, like Trump is just owning this network.
Speaker 2
They're taking the last vestige of truth, you know, that we have and he's owning that and destroying that. That is completely a valid argument. But the specific Scott Pelley of it all was just a little intense. Your replies were insane.
Speaker 1
They were, I was like, You guys are putting way more energy and emotion into this than what was the little tweet that I crapped out in like two seconds as I was just barely thinking about this.
Speaker 2
The moment I saw it, I was like, oh, oh, buddy. And then the next day you're like, it's gotten a little attention. And I went and looked and I was like, holy crap, people want you dead.
Speaker 1
I did. I made it into a Business Insider story. Really? What smart people are saying about this?
Speaker 2
I was like, oh, oh. Oh, God. Was I? I... yeah I think I even on that last point though I mean this is the thing I feel like there is more garbage and things have gotten politicized in gross ways but I think that's the central contention I'm making is that I think there's actually like more good stuff that never existed like it used to like just be 60 minutes yeah now you
Speaker 1
have all these really clever people who are super into stuff doing actually way better. I just think there's options now. I don't think I don't know.
Speaker 2
We're very biased because there is a very specific reason I'm not any, you know, legacy media outlet. Like I was just telling someone at The Times because they were saying there's an open role. And I was like, they would kill me with rocks. Like I could not. be happy and thrive there and write my actuator story in the way that I would want to because we're doing something new and we get to do it on our own terms and we both experience the uphill battle of getting these weird stories in print so we're just sort of biased in that way I think 60 Minutes should survive I would love to see it in 20 years still clock ticking just because it reminds me of my childhood but I think the reaction to it is just not even grounded in reality whatsoever I
Speaker 1
wonder if that will happen in 20 years yeah uh I don't think so at this rate we'll start doing it this week on core memory the hour the hour I did see somebody I saw that tweet that was the other thing so I was like Scott Pelley's just go on YouTube like uh Katie Couric and uh Megan Kelly and I was like I know you like Scott Pelley yep highly I don't think people would follow Scott Belli.
Speaker 2
I'm not sure I would either.
Speaker 1
And this is the other part of my argument. I do not think Scott Belli is the talent. It's weird how when you're like one of those correspondents. That was the other thing. It always reminds me of the times where you become a columnist like Maureen Dowd or Tom Friedman. or uh what's the other guy david brooks and you're just like locked in for like 50 years it's like do we just have to hear the opinions from these like six people how many times can you have an opinion on things before you just run out is that it's funny to me how i don't think these jobs should be institutional i don't think they should be uh locked in for that like I think Leslie Stahl does an amazing job do I just need to hear from her for like 40 fucking years yeah no I don't know That's another thing I'm a little biased about is that I didn't go to journalism school.
Speaker 2
I studied tech. I've only been in this world. This is my version of journalism. I don't have a ton of high respect for TV anchors. That's not like the pinnacle of journalism to me, except for like, you know, war correspondence, like, you know, going out there into the world and reporting on dangerous, scary, you know, topics. That's important. But just like a TV anchor is not my... pinnacle of journalism so when they do those war stories they got to put themselves in the danger yeah gotta go through all the like grime and creative that's the peak of journalism travel right and then you do the the confrontational interview and you got to be good at that you got to you know be able to pull it off but to your point it's the producers that are doing exactly exactly by the time Scott Pelley's
Speaker 1
talking on camera it's somebody else's yeah you know found the story reported out the story arranged everything and that part always bugged me it bugs me what I don't know that was sort of it's I feel like it's quite obvious to everyone but when I found that out that they don't even do their own stories I was like no I don't think it is this is why and everyone's like oh Scott and then I'm like somebody else's is is doing a lot of the you're you're like okay you're not fully a meat puppet but you're a bit of a meat puppet I am see we're we're making things worse for ourselves but that it that's just my opinion man I mean I do this job I had people can accuse that but like we we we actually report out all our stories and and and to the on-camera stuff yeah so
Speaker 2
anyway sorry Scott Pelley from Ashley Vance I was a fan I just I don't like poking the bear I see you when things are inflamed I'm like never tweet man why is yeah no I was willing I was willing yeah anyway all right um
Speaker 1
I think they're the you can't I think if Nick had been a proven ideologue historically then Scott's like overreaction in this initial meeting might have been justified I just don't think you could come into the new guy who's probably actually well-intentioned and just trying to like totally undermine him on I feel like there's a different way to go about it Is it the first time an old white man paid five million dollars a year as a TV
Speaker 2
anchor has yelled at everybody above him? Is it the first time ever?
Speaker 1
Well just don't expect to like keep your job though.
Speaker 2
They always do. I mean like it is just such an unforced error. You're entering the 60 minutes legacy media zone and Scott Pelley's gonna yell at you. He's gonna call you an idiot. It's like literally the history of like TV anchors that are paid too much. You know that's just it. And then firing him for being sub subordinates. Like dude Scott Pelley he's gonna yell at ya he's gonna yell at ya well I'm sure you'll be able to see 60 Minutes cover actuators here soon um off we go you should all read
Speaker 1
Kylie's story oh and I don't mean to just be uh atlas is sending us yes i don't mean to be giving west mag attention at the expense of atlas um we're neutral here and they're sending us stuff i had tweeted that i'm i'm stoked on all the little machinery items i get for my travels and they messaged me they're like we're sending you stuff don't you worry okay amazing um kylie thank you as always thank you ash we will have exciting things coming for you all kylie's working on scripts she's going to be appearing on the youtube shortly as always please check out our Substack our YouTube channels our podcasts leave the likes and reviews and we love you all love you guys the core memory podcast is hosted by me Ashley Vance and or Kylie Robison or both of us together it is produced by me and David Nicholson our theme song is by James Mercer and John Sortland and the show is edited always by the John Sortland thank you so much to Brex and Send Cut Send for all your support and thank you most of all to everybody for listening or watching we love you please leave us a like a review a subscribe all those tremendous things thank you and we'll see you again