Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features an interview with Jung Chang, a Chinese-born author who has written extensively about her experiences growing up in China during the Cultural Revolution. The main topic of the episode is Jung's memoir, "Wild Swans," which has sold over 15 million copies worldwide. The episode delves into Jung's childhood, her family's experiences during the Cultural Revolution, and her eventual escape to the West.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
A true honor to speak with Jung Chang.
She is the author of Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China (sold 15+ million copies worldwide) and Mao: The Unknown Story.
We discuss:
- what it was like growing up during the Cultural Revolution as the daughter of a denounced official
- why the CCP continues to worship the biggest mass murderer in human history.
- how exactly Communist totalitarianism was able to subjugate a billion people
- why Chinese leaders like Xi and Deng who suffered from the Cultural Revolution don't condemn Mao
- how Mao starved and killed 40 million people during The Great Leap Forward in order to exchange food for Soviet weapons
Wild Swans is the most moving book I've ever read. It was a real privilege to speak with its author.
Watch on YouTube. Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or any other podcast platform. Read the full transcript here. Follow me on Twitter for updates on future episodes.
Timestamps
(00:00:00) - Growing up during Cultural Revolution
(00:15:58) - Could officials have overthrown Mao?
(00:34:09) - Great Leap Forward
(00:48:12) - Modern support of Mao
(01:03:24) - Life as peasant
(01:21:30) - Psychology of communist society
Dwarkesh Patel
My father spoke up against Mao's policies. He was arrested, tortured, driven insane. My mother was under tremendous pressure to denounce my father. She refused. My mother was made to kneel on broken glass. She was paraded in the streets where children spat at her and threw stones at her. The desire to write never left me. In the following years, when I was working as a peasant and as a barefoot doctor, as a steelworker and electrician, I was always writing in my head with an imaginary pen. Today, I have the pleasure of interviewing Jung Chang. Her first book, *Wild Swans*, has sold over 15 million copies worldwide. The U.S. diplomat George Kennan described *The Gulag Archipelago* — he said, "This is the greatest and most powerful single indictment of a political regime ever to be leveled in modern times." And when I read that quote, I realized that this is exactly how I describe your books, *Wild Swans*, obviously, but also your biography of Mao titled *Mao: The Unknown Story*, both of which we'll talk about today. It is a true honor to speak with you.
Jung Chang
Thank you very much for having me.
Dwarkesh Patel
So we will get to Mao and his atrocities in a second. But let us begin by — would you mind laying the scene for us? What was it like? You grew up in China, under Mao. Let's begin there. What was it like as you started to grow up during this time?
Jung Chang
I was born in China, in Sichuan, in 1952. So I grew up under Mao. When I was a child, I led quite a privileged life because both my parents were communist officials. We lived in this compound with servants, cooks, drivers. It was a very class-ridden society, and I grew up so much taking class and privilege for granted that when I first came to Britain, I thought Britain was wonderfully classless. Of course, my views were slightly modified over the years.
Then in 1966, when I was 14, Mao launched his Cultural Revolution, which was his great purge. My father spoke up against Mao's policies. As a result, he was arrested, tortured, driven insane. He was exiled to a camp and died tragically and prematurely. My mother was under tremendous pressure to denounce my father. She refused. As a result, she went through over a hundred of these ghastly denunciation meetings, which were everyday features in China at the time. The victims were put on the stage, their arms were ferociously twisted to the back, their heads were pushed down, and they were kicked and beaten. My mother was once made to kneel on broken glass. She was paraded in the streets where children spat at her and threw stones at her. But she survived. Today she still lives in Chengdu, age 92.
My family was scattered, and I was exiled to the edge of the Himalayas and worked as a peasant, then as a barefoot doctor — a doctor without any training, because Mao had said the more books you read, the more stupid you become. Schools were closed, books were burned. China was literally a cultural desert without books, cinemas, theaters, museums for 10 years. Then I became an electrician. Again, there was no training, so I had five electric shocks in one month.
In 1973, partly after Nixon's visit to China, but more for internal political reasons, universities began to reopen, and I was able to get into Sichuan University to learn English. Our teachers had never seen foreigners themselves because China had been closed to the outside world after the communists took power in 1949. Our textbooks were written by these teachers who'd never been abroad. I remember the first lesson was "Long Live Chairman Mao." The second lesson was greetings. Because in those years, when we bumped into each other, we said, "吃饭了吗? 上哪儿去?" — "Where are you going? Have you eaten?" So those were the English greetings I learned. When I first came to London, I used to go around and ask people where they were going and whether they had eaten.
The only foreigners I had spoken to were some sailors in the port in South China, where we as English language students were sent to practice our English. That was when I was 23. We were at the port eagerly waiting for our sailors, and we had no idea what must be on their minds, how different this must be from their expectation of a port life.
In 1976, Mao died and China began to change. In 1978, there was a national exam to select people to go abroad. For the first time under communist rule, going abroad was based on an academic basis. I did very well at the exam, so I became one of the first 14 people to come to Britain. As far as I know, I was the first person to get out of Sichuan province — a province then of 90 million people — to come and study in the West. When I got my doctorate in linguistics at the University of York in 1982, I became the first person from communist China ever to get a doctorate from a British university.
So I was in Britain, and for 10 years I didn't want to think about the past because it was too painful. My father died, my grandmother who brought us up died. I just wanted to spend time enjoying the West. I had always wanted to be a writer. When I was a child, I loved writing. But under Mao, it was impossible to dream of becoming a writer, because nearly all writers were condemned, sent to the gulag, driven to suicide, some were even executed. Even writing for oneself was dangerous.
I wrote my first poem on my 16th birthday in 1968. I was lying in bed polishing my poem when I heard the door banging — some Red Guards had come to raid our flat. If they had seen my poem, I would get into trouble and my family would get into trouble. I had to quickly rush to the bathroom to tear up my poem and flush it down the toilet. That ended my first venture in writing. But the desire to write never left me. In the following years, when I was working as a peasant, as a barefoot doctor, as a steel worker and electrician, when I was spreading manure on the paddy fields and checking electricity supplies on top of electricity poles, I was always writing in my head with an imaginary pen. But I couldn't write in China.
When I came to Britain, for 10 years I didn't want to write. Then my mother came to stay with me in 1988, and for the first time she told me the stories of her life and stories of my grandmother. While I was listening to my mother, I thought I must write all this down. I realized how much I wanted to be a writer and how much I had always wanted to be a writer. After my mother left, I transcribed the tapes she left for me — 60 hours of tape recordings. Then I wrote *Wild Swans*, which was published in 1991. I became a writer.
Dwarkesh Patel
Saying you became a writer is understating it. The global impact of *Wild Swans* has been tremendous. A former guest of mine, Sarah Payne, recommended it to me, and I read it. It's the most moving book I've ever read. It's truly tremendous. Let me begin by asking what it was like growing up there in terms of the psychology of living in a totalitarian system. You mentioned in the book that until very late, you could not even bring yourself to question Mao despite seeing the consequences of his policies and the cult of personality. Tell me about the psychology of living in a system like that.
Jung Chang
When I was growing up in China, we were all subject to intense brainwashing and indoctrination. When we were children, Mao was like our god. If we wanted to say what I say is true, we would say, "I swear to Chairman Mao." Mao had been given this godlike status. At the same time, we could see how dangerous it was to question Mao. In China there were these periodical political campaigns, and many people were victimized. The biggest crime was to question Mao. My father, in the Cultural Revolution, suffered tremendously, and it was also because he questioned Mao.
When I wrote my poem when I was 16 years old, I had already started to doubt and to dread the society I was in. We were always told socialist China was paradise on earth. I thought on that day, if this is a paradise, what then is hell? My parents were away being detained. My grandmother was weeping next door because she'd heard the ghastly things being done to my mother. I questioned the society, but Mao never entered my mind. He was beyond questioning.
This may be difficult for people in the West to understand. But in China in those days, there were two most important things that enabled this brainwashing. One is the complete isolation of the society from the outside world, from alternative information. Even parents never told their children things that were different from the party line because they were worried about the future of their children — if children blabbed, it would be disastrous for the children as well as for the family. So no alternative information. The other is terror — this intense terror that really scared people into suppressing any unorthodox thoughts.
I was living in that kind of society, and it took me a long time to question Mao. Since my 16th birthday thought in 1968, for many years I blamed what was happening in China on Madam Mao and the so-called Gang of Four, who were basically assistants of Mao's. But I never dared to question Mao. I remember very well, in 1976, I had learned a little English and a friend showed me a copy of *Newsweek*. There was an article about Mao with two little pictures and the caption, "Madam Mao is Mao's eyes, ears and mouth." Suddenly Mao's name was spelled out for me. I suddenly realized, of course, it was Mao. Without Mao, none of this could have happened. Mao was responsible. I'm an intelligent person, but it took me eight years — from the moment I said to myself, "I dislike the society," to the moment that I felt Mao was responsible.
Dwarkesh Patel
You mentioned that your father was purged because of his criticism of the government. Your father's story through the book is a tragic tale. What I found interesting was that the way he criticized the party was to go through the official mechanism. He wrote a letter to Mao, which suggests that he even then still believed the mechanism of the party worked. It would be like somebody having a problem with the North Korean government today and writing a letter to Kim Jong-un — obviously you're going to get in trouble for that. Tell me about how your father thought about that. In retrospect, what should a high official like your father — he was the governor of a region, then by the time of the Cultural Revolution in 1966 he was a head of a department of the Sichuan party government — what should he have done when he realized things were going wrong?
Jung Chang
Well, there was nothing one could do. If you tried to spell out your thoughts to other people, you would be instantly denounced and probably executed. Nobody was allowed to say anything against Mao. Theoretically, in the charter of the Communist Party, a party member had the right to write to the leadership. My father was using that as the theoretically permitted way to voice his dissent. That's why he wrote to Mao. In any case, the atrocities, the violence — only Mao could stop them. Writing to Mao was the only way he could express his opinion. He also said something in the context of denunciation meetings, but those were outbursts rather than well-thought-out expressions of dissent.
Dwarkesh Patel
This is something I found confusing when reading accounts about the Cultural Revolution. China is a society that has rebelled in the past — against emperors, against the Japanese occupation. The nationalists were at one point in charge of large parts of China. The communists rebelled against them. How was Mao able to instill a regime where that became unthinkable, despite the fact that it was an incredibly chaotic and destabilizing time? How did the Chinese, who have a great sense of history, allow this to happen?
Jung Chang
That's a very good question. That is the key of a communist society, of a totalitarian society — the control, the organization. Neither the emperors nor any other rulers under the nationalists, under Chiang Kai-shek, had China so thoroughly organized down to the grassroots, controlled by layers of party organizations. It was totally thorough. That's why 20th century totalitarianism was very different from previous authoritarianism. The key was the control, this total control of a society, with power highly concentrated at the very top, in one person.
Dwarkesh Patel
The thing that's really interesting is Mao is obviously a person who doesn't understand economics. We'll talk about that greatly and the disastrous consequences it had because of his complete ignorance when it came to economics and industry. But what he did seem to have an incredible sense for — and Stalin and other totalitarian leaders as well — is the psychology of people and how to organize a society of 800 million people so that every society has petty, sadistic, arrogant, and cowardly people, and how to organize them so that they're elevated and you use them to your advantage. There is no nook or cranny in the entire society where a single person can have a dissenting voice or even have an independent life. Maybe you can talk about the commune life and the way in which — how can you possibly have a society of 800 million people where each person is under such strict totalitarian control? How is that even possible?
Jung Chang
In the Cultural Revolution, for example, Mao used the young people and used the bad things in their nature — they're prone to violence, destructive, sadistic. Any society has these people, but they were given license to indulge their bad instincts in the Cultural Revolution. This took place for a couple of years. Then Mao reigned them in by using the army. The Red Guards, particularly the most militant, aggressive, sadistic, and violent ones, were dispersed and sent to the villages, sent to the mountains. The disobedient ones were condemned themselves — they became the targets of the second round of purges.
All the time, Mao made sure that the barrel of the gun was in his hand, the army. He always needed a person to control the army for him, to make sure he could wreak havoc and maintain control. He always used Lin Biao until 1970. Lin Biao was completely cynical. He would come to Mao's rescue when there was dissent from Mao's other colleagues, like during the famine and when Mao started the Cultural Revolution. Until the day he fell out with Mao, which was why Mao was suddenly a bit lost — he lost the arm with which he controlled the army. That's why in 1972, after Lin Biao died trying to flee out of China, things suddenly became better. Mao had to rely on another person to control the army for him, and that person was Deng Xiaoping. Suddenly the universities began to reopen. Things were much better from 1972.
Dwarkesh Patel
This is a great instance of — as soon as Mao dies, the Gang of Four is rounded up and arrested, and the Cultural Revolution stops. That goes to show you this was Mao's doing. This is also an interesting example where you have these cases — whether it's Stalin in Russia or Mao in China — where when the tyrant dies, the system automatically improves because nobody else is as crazy as that guy. What does this show us about if Kim Jong-un died? Should we expect a reversion to a more sane set of things? Again and again we see tyrants die and things are not as bad as they used to be.
Jung Chang
I haven't studied North Korea, so I don't know the inner workings of the regime. In that sort of Stalinist society, so much depends on one person. The Kim dynasty has arranged their succession — the first Kim Il-sung died, his son succeeded, and the grandson then succeeded. Now it seems the grandson has begun to look into a succession by grooming, perhaps, his daughter or someone close to him. Stalin couldn't do that, couldn't do the family dynasty thing, partly because his children were not like the Kim children. Mao also — he only cared about how he could enjoy life while he was alive, indulging his desires, which was mainly power. He didn't care about what comes after him. He was completely materialistic in that philosophical way. For example, when he was in Moscow and visited Lenin's tomb, he said, "It's all very well visiting Lenin's tomb, but Lenin can't feel anything. He's dead. It doesn't matter. It means nothing to Lenin." So Mao, when he died, didn't leave a well-structured legacy. He didn't even care about his own legacy.
Dwarkesh Patel
I thought the entire purpose of the Cultural Revolution was that he was concerned that because of the Great Leap Forward, his legacy would be destroyed in the way that Khrushchev denounced Stalin. That was the entire point of the Cultural Revolution — to protect his legacy.
Jung Chang
That may be a factor, but the main factor was that Mao's policy had led to the great famine of nearly 40 million deaths. It was so unpopular that his number two, Liu Shaoqi, spoke up against him. There was no way even for Mao's number two to topple him, because under this tyrant, his colleagues couldn't get organized, which was necessary to topple him. They couldn't lay their hands on the army, which was controlled by Lin Biao.
What Liu Shaoqi did was that in January 1962, when Mao wanted to continue his policy of exporting food in exchange for arms industries in order to build a superpower so he could dominate the world, Liu wanted to stop that. He used the occasion of a party congress to speak to the 7,000 party officials in that conference hall. My father was in there. These party officials spread all over China — the vast majority were against Mao's policies that had led to the famine. They suddenly found Liu Shaoqi as their champion. Together, they managed to stop Mao's policies, which was how the famine was stopped from 1962.
Mao was furious. He didn't like being thwarted and being ambushed, which he called an ambush. This was why he launched the Cultural Revolution in 1966 — to punish Liu Shaoqi and the party officials. That's how this great purge took place. For Mao, it was calculated because he wanted to have his way, he wanted to purge these people. But there was also the gut feeling of revenge. He wanted revenge on his number two, who died in the most appalling way in the Cultural Revolution.
Dwarkesh Patel
Sorry if this question sounds naive, but if you have somebody like Liu Shaoqi and Deng Xiaoping and these other party officials who are seeing what is happening — in the case of Liu Shaoqi, he was denounced before he was officially purged and removed from power. There was a time when he knew he was going to be purged, but he was still in power. It's confusing from the outside why at that time you don't — if you can't control the army because Lin Biao is in control of it — try to tell the people what is actually happening. Go to the *People's Daily* and say, "You've got to publish this article about what Mao was actually like." Go to all the communist officials, organize a coup. Why didn't that happen?
Jung Chang
It did happen. In Mao's biography, I have a couple of chapters about Liu Shaoqi exactly about what you're suggesting he should have done. I'm going to expand it in my next book. Basically, Liu Shaoqi knew Mao was going to purge him in 1962 after the Congress, because he had ambushed Mao. He started to build his own power base. First, by stopping the famine, making himself popular among the party officials — only they mattered; the ordinary people were too far away from power. Liu Shaoqi became very popular.
In 1965, a few years later, when Mao tried to purge Liu Shaoqi, he found he couldn't do it. Liu Shaoqi had been powerful enough to put up a resistance. Mao did this horse trading with Lin Biao, and Lin Biao spoke very forcefully in support of Mao. There was all that going on. But Mao didn't make it public. He first created this gigantic upheaval in China in order to create the kind of terror that people would only obey him — not Liu Shaoqi, not even the party, but only him. That's how he operated.
That's why in the Cultural Revolution, his first victims were school teachers. I was in a secondary school in China. I saw how the teachers were being abused, beaten up, denounced, driven to suicide. Mao didn't even dislike teachers. He said to Edgar Snow that he'd like to be known as a great teacher. He was a school teacher in his youth. He didn't even care about them. But he used them because the teachers were the obvious target to excite, to arouse the passion, the violence, the atrocities in the young Red Guards. He used them as victims in order to rouse the victimizers, which were the schoolchildren. That's how he maneuvered. He spent quite a few years before the atmosphere was ripe for him to be able to purge Liu.
Dwarkesh Patel
Maybe for context, it'll be helpful to start talking about the Great Leap Forward. The number you gave was around 40 million people. This becomes a statistic for people — you just think, "Oh, 40 million people died. Whatever. It's a number." I want to make it concrete for people how much tragedy and suffering is involved in just a single person dying from starvation. Can you talk about the months-long agonizing process of what starvation is, where you see it happening to you, your family, your children, your spouse, your village? What was peasant life like during the Great Leap Forward?
Jung Chang
During the Great Leap Forward, my family was among the privileged, so I personally didn't starve. But there was a lot of starvation around us. For example, when I went to school — I was eight or nine — one day I was munching a steamed bread, and a young lad, a boy, darted over and snatched the bread from my mouth. He stuffed it into his mouth and disappeared. Afterwards, when I told my father, he was very sad. He touched my head and said, "You were very lucky. Other children are starving."
Another thing that happened near home was our maid, our domestic help, who'd come from a village. Her family had been classified as "landlord," which was one of the categories destined for discrimination and horrible treatment. I remember very well one day, after a visit to her family, she came back weeping. We lived in this courtyard, and she had so many floods of tears that the frogs that were thriving in the courtyard were leaping up and down. That stayed in my memory as a child. My grandmother, with whom she was very close, was sitting in the mosquito net and also crying and said, "The communists are good, except all these people are dead." Because this was so much against my indoctrination about the communists, that's one of the few things I heard that made me really scared.
Before her whole family died, her mother came to see her to report the news that her father and brothers had died. Her mother, as soon as she came into the house, threw herself on the ground and called out to my mother and said, "Thank you for having saved my daughter, otherwise she would have been dead." Soon after the mother went back, she died herself. But when she came, she was already like a skeleton, as though any wind could blow her away. It was just terrible.
One thing that made my father speak up during the Cultural Revolution, only a few years later, was he felt so guilty. He volunteered to go stay in a village, and he saw these horrible things that I didn't see. One day a man was walking on the ridges of the paddy fields unsteadily, and suddenly he disappeared. My father rushed over, and this man had died. Just like that. For just his month of living in the village, my father came back very seriously famished and suffering from an illness called edema, which was because of lack of food.
Even my family — we all drank this little thing, this little seed that fed on urine. I remember we all had to collect urine. We didn't throw away our urine. We collected urine in order to grow this seed, which was supposed to have a lot of nutrition that could sustain people. I remember how revolting the taste was. I didn't suffer much because my family put all our food together and the adults were starving. I knew my mother, my father, and particularly my grandmother starved in order for us children not to starve.
Today, if you read the memoirs of China's super-rich, I think most of them have a memory of my generation — of the generation who had lived in the countryside. They all remembered being hungry as children in the villages. That was partly what gave them the impetus to change.
Dwarkesh Patel
While we're on this, let me ask about this before we return to the Great Leap Forward, now that you've mentioned it. Xi Jinping actually had a very similar experience to you. His father is also a high communist official. He also gets denounced and purged. Xi Jinping also has to go through these denunciation meetings and then work as a peasant. There's a story where he tries to come back to his family to get a meal, but his mother chases him away and denounces him. It's gruesome stuff. Then when he gives these speeches, he talks about needing to return to Marxism-Leninism and Mao Zedong Thought. How is it possible that somebody who has gone through your experience can still have any sort of sympathy left for Mao or Marxism-Leninism?
I actually don't understand. I'm trying to understand.
Jung Chang
I'm afraid I don't understand either. I mean, don't fully understand. Everybody is different. A lot of people had similar experiences and they still worship Mao and want to return to the Mao era. I think only not seriously return to Mao era, but they dreamed of perhaps the control or something of the Mao era, but not really.
Everybody was different. There were more indoctrinated people than others under the same indoctrination system. Maybe he was just more thoroughly indoctrinated. There were many reasons among the communist officials whose parents suffered. A lot of them identify Mao with the rule of the Communist Party, and they don't want the Communist Party to be discredited because they are the beneficiaries of communist rule. This is not necessarily Xi, but in a more general sense. I haven't studied Xi. I don't know the inner workings of the regime.
But I think a lot of children of the old communists, in spite of the sufferings of their parents, still want China to be under this one-party dictatorship. One reason now is this made them a lot of money. All the corruption, if you are associated with the regime, you stand to gain. So I think that is one very important reason. They would not have all the privileges if the party ended its one-party dictatorship.
Dwarkesh Patel
In no other society is a tyrant like Mao still respected by the current regime. With Germany, nobody is yearning for the days of Hitler. There are a few people in Russia, for example, Stalinism is because of Putin's changing of the curriculum. But it's not a common thing. Whereas in China, the regime officially derives its legitimacy from Mao. It hangs his picture off Tiananmen Square. This is doubly insidious, not only because this is a gruesome mass murderer who killed 50 million people, more than anybody else in history, but because his victims were the people of China. The people who are expected to bow down to his figure and respect him are his own victims or the children of his victims. It would be like if a picture of Hitler hung off the Temple Mount in Israel.
So I guess maybe the question is, how are the Chinese people who this happened to in living memory, how are they okay with having the figure of Mao up on Tiananmen Square? Why is there still respect for Mao in China?
Jung Chang
Well, first of all, China is still a communist regime. For many years, the memory was fresh. Partly in the 1980s and 90s, the memories were fresh. I think that was probably the main reason. Gradually after that, the memories of pain were fading. Particularly a generation, two generations have grown up without suffering.
Given that there is no religion for people to worship, unlike any time in Chinese history, before Mao there was Confucianism. You could have something to hang on to. Then there was Maoism, which didn't obviously openly endorse violence and atrocities. It could sound quite attractive, which was why Mao's Little Red Book was in vogue for a period in the West. People hung on to that.
In the post-Mao time, money was the god. A lot of people made money, but a lot of people lost money. In a society where there was no proper regulations and law, people who were not very savvy with money lost out. They were conned. So there were some people who probably yearned for a more simple life, where you were given what you were given. They wouldn't like to be starved and they wouldn't like to be a political victim. But a lot of people could live a very simple life of just being fed. There may be a certain nostalgia.
But the most important thing, of course, is the promotion of the regime, particularly since Xi came to power. You are taught from school all these lies about Mao. People grew up with this regarding Mao as God, like back to my childhood.
Dwarkesh Patel
What has been the impact of your books? *Wild Swans* sold 50 million copies. Your biography of Mao is also a bestseller. I know they're banned in China, but have they secretly been able to access them? How has that revised their understanding of their own history?
Jung Chang
When these books were first published in the 1990s and the 2000s, there were lots of ways to get them into China. Hong Kong, for example, and Taiwan, pirated editions, which there were many, many, many. But now, since Mr. Xi came to power in 2012, 2013, China has a total clampdown of banned literature. You could go to jail if you possess these books. For an official to possess banned books, including mine, you could face ghastly punishment. For the general population as well.
When you enter China now, you see on this screen warnings not to bring in bad literature, particularly not to bring in books that said not very nice things about the previous revolutionary leaders or revolutionary martyrs. Total clampdown, forbidding people from doing research on history, trying to understand the history, which created another generation of brainwashed people.
Also one very important thing: the Chinese are very pragmatic and they don't want trouble. They're very different from a lot of other peoples. Parents who had bad experiences under Mao tend not to tell their children. So a lot of children are just genuinely not getting any alternative information from the official line.
Dwarkesh Patel
I do want to get back to the actual Great Leap and Cultural Revolution in a second. But on this theme, Xi Jinping's own daughters studied at Harvard. Chinese elites, their kids are studying in America. When they take power in a generation or two, will they still be devoted Marxist-Leninists? I can't imagine them coming back from Harvard and still believing.
Jung Chang
Well, in the West, in American universities, there are a lot of Marxists. A lot of people, if they're interested in the subject, come to the West to have their views confirmed. For example, when our Mao biography was published, there were some academics who even published a book, a collection of their criticisms against our book. The title was *Was Mao Really a Monster?* The preface was written by someone who was a senior lecturer at the LSE, London School of Economics. The language was Maoist language. Mao was a great revolutionary, a great Marxist, Leninist. The West would certainly not put off a potential Mao successor.
Dwarkesh Patel
I'm glad you brought that up. I read that book in preparation for this interview. I wanted to see if there were criticisms that I should be aware of. There were certain quibbles about the part before Mao got into power, about the Long March and stuff, which I don't know enough about to comment. But when they start talking about the important things, the Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution, they are not at all contesting the facts. It is the most sort of excusatory language.
It is the same sort of stuff that is said about Cuba and Stalinist Russia: all the literacy went up and this and that. North Korea today has high literacy. Are you going to say that North Korea was OK? Actually, can you talk about this? What do you think explains the Western, some parts of the left who want to find excuses for these regimes, whether it's Venezuela or Edward Snow writing his book about Mao? There's a sort of need to excuse these communist regimes and socialist regimes. What explains this?
Jung Chang
From what I know, I think there were people who had illusions about these regimes. A lot of the academics who were kind of controlling the faculties to do with Mao in the universities probably got their illusions because they had access to Edgar Snow's book. They were radicals in the 1960s. They want to hang on to their own. I'm faltering on this because I don't know. I don't know why they are like that. They don't know the facts. They don't care to know the facts.
Also, I think probably some people think China has always been awful under the empress and so on. Somehow the Orientals must feel different today. I know when Deng Xiaoping visited America in 1979 and established diplomatic relations with Carter, he was seated at the banquet with some deluded film star. People were saying to him that when they visited China, they'd seen professors who'd been subject to forced labor, but they were told that they enjoyed it because all these hardships had turned them into new men. Deng Xiaoping just said they were lying. To the Westerners who didn't know the truth, they just took their words for it. They didn't know people couldn't tell them the real truth.
Even in the case of Stalin in Russia, there was a famous *New York Times* reporter doing the Russian coverage. Reports would come in about the Ukrainian famine or these other atrocities, and he would write his columns: no, this is not happening. There was a famous headline that says "Russians are hungry, but not starving."
Dwarkesh Patel
Let's talk about Deng Xiaoping. During the Cultural Revolution, he is exiled and purged. His son, because he is known as one of the "five blacks" — that's one of the racist sides of Chinese society, black is bad — his son is chased out of a window by Red Guards. The doctors refuse to operate on him because he's Deng Xiaoping's son, so he's paralyzed for life. He's forced to do manual labor, this guy who was basically running China under Mao, doing manual labor out in the countryside.
When he comes back into power after the Cultural Revolution, from the outside, I don't understand how he doesn't immediately denounce Mao, talk about the horrible things he did. There's a quote from him: "We must be careful not to overemphasize the crimes of Mao." For somebody who was so personally harmed by Mao, how is he not immediately condemning Mao? This is something I don't understand.
I also think he made a big mistake. If he had dissociated from Mao, like Khrushchev had with Stalin, it would not have just been the right thing to do, but it would have been the popular thing to do. There was a great groundswell of sentiment for denouncing Mao, or at least dissociating from Mao, not just from the population, from the victims, which virtually everybody was in China, but from the leading elite, from most of his closest colleagues. For the few elders who were in favor of Mao, he could easily have dealt with them, like Khrushchev had dealt with the Stalinists. But he chose not to. What got into his mind?
Jung Chang
I haven't studied him very carefully, but I did know something about him. I think he was probably thinking that if you reject Mao, it's inevitable that communism will collapse in China. Unlike Khrushchev's time in 1956, he could denounce Stalin without endangering the communist rule in Russia. But Deng, at his time, could not, or at least probably he thought, could not have denounced Mao without endangering the rule of the party. We're talking about 1980s, late 70s, 80s. It's near Gorbachev's time. So I think that's probably his devotion to the party.
Dwarkesh Patel
He might have been right. In Russia, in the 80s, when they have Glasnost and Perestroika and they talk openly about the Gulag system, that is one of the main contributing factors. People say, how can a regime that allowed this to happen be allowed to exist anymore? How can this be a governing regime? And that does lead to the collapse.
Jung Chang
Yes, exactly. Which is why Mr. Xi's argument, because he was against Gorbachev, against the perestroika and glasnost, is exactly that. The communist regime would collapse. In today's terms, that is the wealth, the money associated with the power.
Dwarkesh Patel
In the book, you point out that Mao is acting in his self-interest and selfishly doing all these things. But it seems to me that a strong, if not motivation, at least enabling factor and organizing factor is definitely provided by the ideologies of communism and socialism, which organizes society. Otherwise, it doesn't make sense to collectivize farms and to close down shops. It also necessitates the purges because communism is a science. It has to work. If it doesn't work, there must be internal capitalist saboteurs who must be condemned, brought out, and killed. Do you think communism and socialism are at the heart of the issue here?
Jung Chang
I think some people undoubtedly think that way. But having researched Mao for 12 years, my conclusion about him was he was highly pragmatic and the communist ideology suited him. He joined the Communist Party not because he was a passionate believer, but because it gave him a livelihood. He was asked to open a left-wing bookshop selling communist and left-wing literature, and his life was changed. Before that, he was poverty-stricken.
The few things about the ideology that you mentioned, for example, the collectivization, it's highly conducive to what Mao wanted, which was food. He wanted this food from the peasants. If they had been private farmers, they would farm their food first and pay tax. It's far more difficult to control these hundreds of millions of peasants than to organize them into units, into communes. Then it's much better to control. Mao said so himself. The great advantage of collectivization, the communes, is easier to control. 便于管理. This was not just an abstract ideology, but for what he wanted to get.
Dwarkesh Patel
But then at least we can say one of the problems with the ideology is that it attracts and is highly conducive to opportunists like Mao and Stalin and the Kim family.
So let's go back to the Great Leap Forward and to these communes. These communes are really what it's like to be a peasant is like chattel slavery. Can you talk about the working conditions, how hard they worked while not being given food, the punishments? Tell us more about what the peasant life was like.
Jung Chang
I was working in the commune for several years during the Cultural Revolution in two places. Our lives consisted mainly of work. There were fixed hours. You were allocated food, fuel, and other things depending on how many hours you worked. Your life was centered on work. The commune controlled everything. If you want to travel to go somewhere, you need the commune to give you a kind of note, a kind of passport to allow you to travel. If you want to get married, you have to get permission from the commune.
During the famine, this is how Mao ensured that the peasants didn't rise up in arms because of the control from the commune. Every now and then the regime would issue stiff orders to stop peasants fleeing their villages. If the peasants did manage to flee into the cities and beg for some food, the communes were told to get them back. The commune is this thing to control our entire lives.
When I was in the communes, I was again in a privileged position because when we were sent down from the cities, we were guaranteed a certain food. But basically, the commune is the organization. It may be in some ideology, but in reality, it's how the party controls China's 500 million peasants. There were only some few tens of thousands of communes. Imagine this highly concentrated organization. People were no longer individual farmers like what they were before communist rule. This is exactly also what happened in Russia. When the famine happens, they're not allowed to leave Ukraine. They're forced, there's roadblocks, and they're forced to starve there.
Dwarkesh Patel
You have this really remarkable anecdote in the book about talking to these peasants about what life was like during the Great Leap Forward while you're working there. Now there's no fuel left. All the trees are taken down. So many in the village starved because they were all distracted keeping the furnaces. Talk about how the effort to double steel output and what catastrophes that caused.
Jung Chang
Basically, Mao's ambition after he took power in China was to build a superpower to dominate the world. He needed to buy these machines, military industrial complexes, mainly from Russia and from Eastern Europe. But he didn't have the money to pay. China wasn't rich as today. So he exported the food. He needed a lot of food. Whereas in China, traditionally, we never produced enough food to feed the population. The emperors banned food export and bought a lot of food into China. Traditionally, China was a food importer for a few hundred years, and Mao stopped that. There was always a food problem throughout his rule.
The Great Leap is basically to import vast quantities of technology and equipment mainly from Russia. That's why it's called the Great Leap. He wanted to build an industrialized system in a few years, to be fast, fast, fast. His demand for food was vastly elevated. This food had to come from the peasants. He basically seized this food to export to Russia and Eastern Europe, knowing his people would die of starvation.
There was a time Mao kept saying seemingly philosophically, "Death is a good thing. If we don't have death, the earth can't contain us." These seemingly philosophical things were taken at face value by some academics. But what he really said these things to his officials in order to harden their heart when they went to seize the food from the peasants, seeing how pitiful their conditions were. That's the origin of the famine. It's as simple as that. It's food export.
Liu Shaoqi, his number two and his main target in the Cultural Revolution, it was thanks to a visit back to his old village that made up his mind to stop Mao's policies. He went back to his village. His brother-in-law had died of starvation. His sister was on the edge of dying of starvation. He saw the villages, saw the just heart-rending things. He opened the lid of a wok, a saucepan, and he saw there was nothing, just water, a few drops of grain. He did a very unusual thing. He bowed to the peasants and said, "I'm very sorry." It was after this, in 1961, he made up his mind to stop Mao's policies, which led to the Cultural Revolution and his tragic death.
Dwarkesh Patel
You also talk in the book about how these peasants, not only was all this grain being exported, which caused them to starve, but they weren't even allowed to harvest their grain because they had to turn their own woks and their own stuff into iron and spend time doing that instead of farming.
Jung Chang
Mao was partly defeated by his own ignorance about economy. When you want to build a modern super industry, you need steel. Steel was the most important thing. China's steel producing capacities in the 1950s was very low. So he had this idea of making the whole population make steel. It really is quite ridiculous.
I was a primary school student. I was six years old. I remember that my main occupation was my contribution to steel. Every day we walked on the street trying to find little nails, cogs, something as steel, to hand in to our teachers because there was a backyard furnace in our school. All the teachers had to feed things into the furnace. The furnace had to be kept going 24 hours a day. It couldn't go off. To feed that furnace consumed everything.
In my village, we struggled every day to find a little fuel, fast forwarding to 1960s, because the mountains which used to be covered with great trees had been laid bare for the fuel to feed the backyard furnaces. The teachers were exhausted in my school, and we were organized to babysit for them when I was a child. It was hugely wasteful. For all this effort in 1958, most of what the backyard furnaces produced were completely useless.
Mao died thinking of himself as a failure because China was still poverty-stricken at the time of his death. He felt himself a failure, but he was partly sabotaged by his own ignorance about the economy.
The other thing about Mao's ignorance: because food was so important and because sparrows eat food, he ordered the whole population to kill sparrows. As a child, I sat with other people in our courtyard. We beat the suspense to make a tremendous noise so the sparrows would drop on the ground. All these people would go and catch the sparrows. It was a catastrophe because it not only killed the sparrows, but many other birds as well. The worms, the pests, insects, they flourished without their natural enemy. It's an unbelievable situation that consumed China for more than two decades. The complete lack of sense. It would honestly be a joke if it didn't lead to 40 million deaths.
In the West, I indirectly know somebody who was a steel magnate. He was a great steel producer. And he thought Mao's steel backyard furnaces were a brilliant idea. Talking about people in the West, not just academics, but many other people, completely irrational. I think maybe in their eagerness to find an alternative to Western capitalist democracy.
Dwarkesh Patel
Say more about that. I know we did touch on that earlier when we were discussing why people are still defending Mao. But what motivated at the time and even still now, people were so disillusioned with Western capitalism that they thought they would rather have Mao?
Jung Chang
I think there were a lot of people like that with a young generation. They grew up after the collapse of the Soviet Empire. A lot of facts have come out. People are no longer probably so starry-eyed and so wishful thinking about the communist regimes. But there was a time in those years when communism seemed to be going strong in so many countries. There were a lot of wishful thinking Westerners. As I said, they may be pursuing an alternative to a society they have a lot of discontent with. They so wanted for such a miracle to happen, and they believed in what they otherwise might have rejected as fantasy.
Dwarkesh Patel
Speaking of which, tomorrow I'm interviewing Neil Ferguson, who has written a biography, volume one of his biography of Kissinger, and volume two, which will cover this period, will come out later. What should Kissinger have done differently? Should they not have tried to open up China under Mao? What should have been the policy of the United States at the time?
Jung Chang
China was not opened up by Kissinger and Nixon. I lived in China then. I knew after Nixon and Kissinger's visit in 1971, 72, China was not opened up. All the liberalization, relaxation after Nixon's visit was mainly because of the collapse of Lin Biao. Mao lost his arm with which he controlled the army. So to say Nixon and Kissinger opened up China is wrong. That's not the case.
Kissinger is a very, very smart person. I think he probably was too fascinated with power. Mao had the kind of power that could turn the lives upside down of a quarter of the world's population. I think he was very fascinated with Mao. He said nice things about Mao. Even after Mao died, when the regime was reviving Mao, there were a few people reviving Mao, like the current Mr. Xi and his political rival Mr. Bo, with whom Kissinger seemed to be very close. He attended these rallies to eulogize Mao, big rallies, lending his status to the Chinese regime's effort to stick with Mao's legacy. I think that's unforgivable.
The other thing is China's opening up to the West. That happened only after Mao died in 1976 and Deng Xiaoping came to power. I knew this very well because I was one of the first Chinese to be able to leave China in 1978. That's the very beginning of the opening up. I think it's a good thing. China has grown. Teaching Mao's economic lunacy and the ideology that has wrecked China, the Chinese people are leading a much better life today. All this could not have happened if the country had not opened up.
Through all this contact with the West, any attempt to go back to the Maoist time would be futile. People knew what the West was like. People don't want to be isolated again, to lead a life of Mao's time, no matter how they may say they worship Mao, no matter how they make pilgrimages to Mao's birthplace. Deep down, I think nobody wants to go back. So I think that's a very good thing, this opening up.
Dwarkesh Patel
But then a country may grow into a menace to the world. That's another matter. It's a challenge that the world needs to face now. But it's certainly not true to say the West shouldn't have allowed China to open up. You can't just dismiss a billion people coming out of poverty. It's the best thing that's ever happened in history.
Jung Chang
Exactly.
Dwarkesh Patel
So let's go back to the Cultural Revolution. One thing that I find really interesting about communism, especially in China, is the need for the victims to then incriminate themselves, to confess. Even Hitler wouldn't have the Jews in Auschwitz talk about renouncing their Semitic ways. So explain why it was important that the victims of these purges had to then talk about, "Oh, I'm guilty, I'm complicit." Why couldn't they just be ostracized?
Jung Chang
I think Mao knows people's psychology very well. He uses this as a weapon to break people. To humiliate them and to break them. Even his opponents then started to doubt their own opposition. I think that's the main thing.
In China, when I lived in China, I wasn't denounced, but we all had to attend criticism and self-criticism meetings. It really stirs up some very basic discomfort and unsettling, upset feelings if you have to criticize yourself. You couldn't do it cynically because nobody has reason to understand the whole thing in order to be cynical. You start by being quite sincere. It certainly breaks people.
It also makes people turn against each other. When people are criticizing each other, you create a lot of animosities among the people, which is one reason why no opposition can get organized. People don't dare to talk to each other in case they were denounced. It's a psychological warfare against his own population, which is quite effective.
Dwarkesh Patel
So meaning that it wasn't just a campaign against political opposition. It was literally every part of your life.
Jung Chang
Yes.
Dwarkesh Patel
Even in the book you talk about embracing your family is anti-Maoist because it shows you're closer to your family than you are to Mao.
Jung Chang
Exactly. It's this warm feeling. I was constantly criticized because of my feelings for my family. Deng Xiaoping, when he wrote to Mao about his son, the son you talked about who was crippled, he wrote to Mao to ask Mao to allow his son to join him so he could look after his son, he and his wife, who was so heartbroken seeing his son, she wanted to kill herself. Deng had to preface his appeal with, "I'm afraid I'm committing warm feelingism, but could you allow my son to join me to be looked after?"
Yeah. It's a device that really separates a society, making people against each other and being on guard against each other. Earlier you were talking about why can't people get together? Because this other person at the next criticism or self-criticism meeting could well say, "So-and-so had said this to me and I hadn't reported to the party, therefore I'm guilty."
Dwarkesh Patel
And talk about the way in which it forced good people to be immoral. You have these quota systems where if you're in charge of a department, Mao says 5% are rightists, 5% are capitalist roaders. If you don't give 5% of names who are going to get denounced, then you must be a rightist yourself.
Jung Chang
Well, the result is you are in a tremendous dilemma of either sacrificing yourself, your family, or other people. This is another way of breaking these people. These are all his weapons, psychological weapons, to force people to do what he ordered them to do.
Dwarkesh Patel
Why was there such a big reservoir of support for communist ideas and also the personality cult that formed around Mao in China? People give different explanations—emperor worship beforehand, peasant rice farming. What explains why China got taken over by this ideology?
Jung Chang
It's, again, not an ideology. Mao himself said in 1923 he didn't believe that the Chinese would go for communism. He thought communism could only be brought to China by the Russian Red Army. And he was right. In the earlier years, the Comintern—Moscow's representatives to China and other countries—said China was a lost cause. People were the last to go for communism. Much easier in India, for example.
So Mao was wise. After the Second World War, the Russian Red Army invaded China and occupied the north and northeast of China, a large hunk of land that was more than the entire Eastern Europe. With this land, Stalin then supported Mao to fight a war against Chiang Kai-shek. Mao, of course, was the main man who ensured his success. During the war against Japan, all his colleagues wanted to fight Japan, and Mao was the only person who was against it and tried everything he could to take advantage of the war, which destroyed Chiang Kai-shek's government, whereas Mao's forces grew. Mao was very smart. This is one reason why Deng Xiaoping and a lot of other communist leaders were so totally devoted to Mao—because they realized if it were not for Mao, they would never have come to power.
Dwarkesh Patel
By the way, what do you make of the analogies people make when they say what happened in the U.S. and other countries a couple of years ago with the BLM movement?
Jung Chang
Of course, it's not at all comparable. The Cultural Revolution—I think maybe people just saw statues being toppled. A few superficial things. The Cultural Revolution was nothing like that. Nobody could even comprehend the horror of the Cultural Revolution in the society. The fear, the destruction. China was really totally destroyed. There was no antiquity in private hands—wiped out, taken by the regime. For 10 years, there were no books, no cinemas, no theatres. My mother was in... Cinemas and theatres were turned into prisons and torture chambers, and my mother was imprisoned in one. I knew how difficult it was to get hold of one book. That was 10 years of the Cultural Revolution. It's nothing like what happened in the West.
Dwarkesh Patel
[To audience] Hey, everybody. I hope you enjoyed that episode. As always, the most helpful thing you can do is to share the podcast. Send it to people you think might enjoy it, put it on Twitter, in your group chats, et cetera. It just splits the world. Appreciate you listening. I'll see you next time. Cheers.