Podcast Episode Summary
The podcast episode features an interview with Mark, the CEO of Meta, discussing the company's latest developments in AI, particularly the new version of Meta AI, Llama 3. The main topic of the episode is the advancements in AI and the potential impact on various industries.
Key Points:
Takeaways:
Participants:
Overall: The podcast episode provides a comprehensive overview of the latest developments in AI, particularly in the context of Meta AI and the metaverse. The discussion highlights the potential benefits and risks associated with advanced AI and the importance of open sourcing AI models.
Mark Zuckerberg on:
- Llama 3
- open sourcing towards AGI
- custom silicon, synthetic data, & energy constraints on scaling
- Caesar Augustus, intelligence explosion, bioweapons, $10b models, & much more
Enjoy!
Watch on YouTube. Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or any other podcast platform. Human edited transcript with helpful links here.
Timestamps
(00:00:00) - Llama 3
(00:08:32) - Coding on path to AGI
(00:25:24) - Energy bottlenecks
(00:33:20) - Is AI the most important technology ever?
(00:37:21) - Dangers of open source
(00:53:57) - Caesar Augustus and metaverse
(01:04:53) - Open sourcing the $10b model & custom silicon
(01:15:19) - Zuck as CEO of Google+
Sponsors
If you’re interested in advertising on the podcast, fill out this form.
* This episode is brought to you by Stripe, financial infrastructure for the internet. Millions of companies from Anthropic to Amazon use Stripe to accept payments, automate financial processes and grow their revenue. Learn more at stripe.com.
* V7 Go is a tool to automate multimodal tasks using GenAI, reliably and at scale. Use code DWARKESH20 for 20% off on the pro plan. Learn more here.
* CommandBar is an AI user assistant that any software product can embed to non-annoyingly assist, support, and unleash their users. Used by forward-thinking CX, product, growth, and marketing teams. Learn more at commandbar.com.
Dwarkesh Patel
Mark, welcome to the podcast. Hey, thanks for having me. Big fan of your podcast. Oh, thank you. That's very nice of you to say. Okay, so let's start by talking about the releases that will go out when this interview goes out. Tell me about the models. Tell me about Meta AI. What's new? What's exciting about them?
Mark Zuckerberg
Yeah, sure. So, you know, I think the main thing that most people in the world are going to see is the new version of Meta AI. Right. So it's and, you know, the most important thing about what we're doing is the upgrade to the model. We're rolling out Lama 3. We're doing it both as open source for the dev community and it is now going to be powering Meta AI. So. There's a lot that I'm sure we'll go into around Llama 3, but I think the bottom line on this is that with Llama 3, we now think that Meta AI is the most intelligent AI assistant that people can use that's freely available. We're also integrating Google and Bing for real-time knowledge.
We're going to make it a lot more prominent across our apps. So basically, at the top of WhatsApp and Instagram and Facebook and Messenger, Uh, you'll just be able to, um, you know, use the search box right there to ask, ask any question. Um, and there's a bunch of new creation features that we, that we added that I think are pretty cool that I think people enjoy. Uh, and I think animations is, is a good one. Um, you can basically just take any image and animate it. But I think one that, that, uh, people are going to find pretty wild is, uh, it now generates high quality images so quickly. I don't know if you've gotten a chance to play with this, that it actually generates it as you're typing and updates it in real time.
So you're like typing your query and it's kind of like honing in on, and you know, it's like, okay, here, you know, show me a picture of a cow, okay, in a field with mountains in the background. It's just like everything's popular. Eating macadamia nuts, drinking beer. And like, it's just like, it's updating the image in real time. It's pretty wild. I think people are going to enjoy that. So, yeah, so that I think is that's what most people are going to see in the world. Right. We're rolling it out, you know, not everywhere, but we're starting in a handful of countries and we'll do more over the coming weeks and months.
So that's that I think is going to be a pretty big deal. And I'm really excited to get that in people's hands. it's a big step forward for Meta AI. But I think, you know, if you want to get under the hood a bit, the Lama 3 stuff is obviously the most technically interesting. So, you know, we're basically, for the first version, we're training three versions, you know, an 8 billion and a 70 billion, which we're releasing today, and a 405 billion dense model, which is still training. So we're not releasing that today. But The 8 and 70, I'm pretty excited about how they turned out. They're leading for their scale.
We'll release a blog post with all the benchmarks so people can check it out themselves. Obviously, it's open source so people get a chance to play with it. We have a roadmap of new releases coming. That are going to bring multimodality, more multilinguality, bigger context windows to those as well. And then, you know, hopefully sometime later in the year, we'll we'll get to roll out the four or five, which I think is is in training. It's still training, but. For where it is right now in training, it is already at around 85 MMLU. And we expect that it's going to have leading benchmarks on a bunch of the benchmarks.
So I'm pretty excited about all of that. I mean, the $70 billion is... is great too. I mean, we're releasing that today. It's around 82 MMOU and has leading scores on math and reasoning. So I mean, I think just getting this in people's hands is going to be pretty wild.
Dwarkesh Patel
Oh, interesting. Yeah, that's the first I'm hearing this benchmark. That's super impressive.
Mark Zuckerberg
Yeah, the 8 billion is nearly as powerful as the biggest version of Llama 2 that we released. So it's like the smallest Llama 3 is basically as powerful as the biggest Llama 2.
Dwarkesh Patel
Okay, so before we dig into these models, I actually want to go back in time. 2022 is, I'm assuming, when you started acquiring these H100s. Or you can tell me when. We were like, stock price is getting hammered. People are like, what's happening with all this CapEx? People aren't buying the Metaverse. And presumably you're spending that CapEx to get these H100s. Back then, how did you know to get the H100s? How did you know we'll need the GPUs?
Mark Zuckerberg
I think it was because we were working on Reels. So we got into this situation where we always want to have enough capacity to build something that we can't quite see that we're on the horizon yet. And we got into this position with Reels where we needed more GPUs to train the models. It was this big evolution process. For our services, where instead of just ranking content from people who you follow or your friends and whatever pages you follow, we made this big push to basically start recommending what we call unconnected content, basically content from people or pages that you're not following.
So now kind of the... the corpus of content candidates that we could potentially show you expanded from on the order of thousands to on the order of hundreds of millions. So completely different infrastructure. And we started working on doing that and we were constrained on basically the infrastructure that we had to catch up to what TikTok was doing as quickly as we would have wanted to. So I basically looked at that and I was like, hey, we have to make sure that we're never in this situation again. So let's order enough GPUs to do what we need to do on reels and ranking content and feed. But let's also, let's double that, right?
Because again, like our normal principle is there's going to be something on the horizon that we can't see yet. Did you know it would be AI? Um, Well, we thought it would be we thought it was going to be something that had to do with training large models. Right. I mean, but at the time, I thought it was probably going to be more something that had to do with content. But I don't know. I mean, it's almost just the pattern matching and running the company is there's always another thing. Right. So I'm not even sure I had at that time I was so deep and just. you know, trying to get, you know, the recommendations working for reels and other content.
Cause I mean, that's just such a big unlock for Instagram and Facebook to now being able to show people content that's interesting to them that they're from people that they're not even following. But yeah, I, that, that ended up being a very good decision in retrospect. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. And it came from being behind. So then it wasn't like I was, you know, it wasn't like, oh, I was so far ahead. Actually, most of the times I think where we kind of make some decision that ends up seeming good is because we messed something up before and just didn't want to repeat the mistake.
Dwarkesh Patel
This is a total detour, but I actually want to ask about this while we're on this. We'll get back to AI in a second. So you didn't sell for $1 billion, but presumably there's some amount you would have sold for, right? Did you write down in your head, like, I think the actual valuation of Facebook at the time is this, and they're not actually getting the valuation right? If they offered you $5 trillion, of course you would have sold. So how did you think about that choice?
Mark Zuckerberg
Yeah, I don't know. I mean, look, I think some of these things are just personal. Yeah. I don't know at the time that I was sophisticated enough to do that analysis. But I had all these people around me who were making all these arguments for how a billion dollars was... It's like, here's the revenue that we need to make and here's how big we need to be. And it's clearly so many years in the future. And it was very far ahead of where we were at the time. And I don't know. I didn't really have the financial sophistication to really even engage with that kind of debate. I just... I think I sort of deep down believed in what we were doing.
And I did some analysis. I was like, okay, well, what would I go do if I wasn't doing this? It's like, well, I really like building things and I like helping people communicate and I like understanding things. what's going on with people and the dynamics between people. So I think if I sold this company, I'd just go build another company like this. And I kind of like the one I have. So I mean, why? But I don't know. I think a lot of the biggest bets that people make are often just based on conviction and values. It's actually usually very hard to do the analyses trying to connect the dots forward.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah. So you've had Facebook AI research for a long time. Now it's become seemingly central to your company. At what point did making AGI or whatever, however you consider that mission, at what point is that like, this is a creek priority of what Meta is doing?
Mark Zuckerberg
Yeah, I mean, it's been a big deal for a while. So we started FAIR about 10 years ago. And the idea was that along the way to general intelligence or AI, like full AI, whatever you want to call it, there can be all these different innovations and that's going to just improve everything that we do. So we didn't kind of conceive it as a product. It was more kind of a research group. And over the last 10 years, it has created a lot of different things that have basically improved all of our products and advanced the field and allowed other people in the field to create things that have improved our products too.
So I think that that's been great, but there's obviously a big change. Yeah. In the last few years, when ChatGPT comes out, the diffusion models around image creation come out. And this is some pretty wild stuff that I think is pretty clearly going to affect how people interact with every app that's out there. So at that point, we started a second group. um, the, the gen AI group, um, with the goal of basically bringing that stuff into our product. So building leading foundation models that would, that would sort of power all these different products. And initially when we started doing that, um, The theory at first was, hey, a lot of the stuff that we're doing is pretty social, right?
So it's helping people interact with creators, helping people interact with businesses so the businesses can sell things or do customer support or basic assistant functionality for whether it's for apps or the smart glasses or VR, like all these different things. So initially, it wasn't completely clear that you were going to need kind of full AGI to be able to support those use cases. But then through working on them, I think it's actually become clear that you do in all these subtle ways. So for example, for Llama 2, when we were working on it, we didn't prioritize coding. And the reason why we didn't prioritize coding is because people aren't going to ask Meta AI a lot of coding questions in WhatsApp.
Now they will. Well, I don't know. I'm not sure that WhatsApp is like the UI that people are going to be doing a lot of coding questions. So we're like, all right, look, in terms of the things that, you know, or Facebook or Instagram or, you know, those different services, maybe the website or metadata.ai that we're launching, I think. But the thing that was sort of, I think, has been a somewhat surprising result over the last 18 months is that It turns out that coding is important for a lot of domains, not just coding, right? So even if people aren't asking coding questions to the models, training the models on coding helps them just be more rigorous and answer the question and kind of help reason across a lot of different types of domains.
Okay, so that's one example where it's like, all right, so for Llama 3, we like really focused on training it with a lot of coding because it's like, all right, that's gonna make it better on all these things, even if people aren't asking primarily coding questions. Reasoning, I think, is another example. It's like, okay, yeah, maybe you want to chat with a creator or you're a business and you're trying to interact with a customer. That interaction is not just like, okay, the person sends you a message and you just reply. It's like a multi-step interaction where you're trying to think through how do I accomplish the person's goals.
And a lot of times when a customer comes, they don't necessarily respond. know exactly what they're looking for or how to ask their questions. So it's not really the job of the AI to just respond to the question. It's like you need to kind of think about it more holistically. It's really becomes a reasoning problem, right? So if someone else solves reasoning or makes good advances on reasoning and we're sitting here with a basic chat bot, then like our product is lame compared to what other people are building. So it's like, so okay, so at the end of the day, we've got we, you know, we basically realized, we've got to solve general intelligence.
And we just kind of upped the ante and the investment to make sure that we could do that.
Dwarkesh Patel
So the version of Lama that that that's going to solve all these use cases for users, is that the version that will be powerful enough to like replace a programmer you might have in this building?
Mark Zuckerberg
I mean, I just think that all this stuff is going to be progressive over time. But in case, La Matin. I think that there's a lot baked into that question. I'm not sure that we're replacing people as much as giving people tools to do more stuff.
Dwarkesh Patel
Is the programmer in this building 10x more productive? I would hope more.
Mark Zuckerberg
But no, I mean, look, I don't believe that there's a single threshold of intelligence for humanity because people have different skills. At some point, I think that AI is probably going to surpass people at most of those things, depending on how powerful the models are. But Um, but I think it's progressive and I don't think AGI is one thing. I think it's, you're basically adding different capabilities. So multimodality is, is kind of a key one that we're focused on now, initially with photos and images and text, but eventually with videos. And then because we're so focused on the metaverse kind of 3d type stuff is important.
Um, one modality that I'm pretty focused on that I haven't seen as many other people in the emotional understanding. So much of the human brain is just dedicated to understanding people and understanding your expressions and emotions. That's its own whole modality. You could say, okay, maybe it's just video or image, but it's clearly a very specialized version of those too. There's all these different capabilities that I think you want to basically train the models to focus on as well as getting a lot better at reasoning getting a lot better at memory which i think is is kind of its own whole thing it's i mean i don't think we're going to be you know primarily shoving context or or kind of things into a query context window um in the future to ask more complicated questions i think that there will be kind of different stores of memory or different custom models that um that are maybe more personalized to people but I don't know.
I think that these are all just different capabilities and then obviously making them big and small. We care about both because, you know, we want to, you know, if you're running something like Meta AI, then we have the ability to, that's pretty server based. But we also want it running on smart glasses and, you know, there's not a lot of space in smart glasses. So you want to have something that's very efficient for that.
Dwarkesh Patel
What is the use case that if you're doing tens of billions of dollars worth of inference, or even eventually hundreds of billions of dollars worth of inference, using intelligence in an industrial scale, what is the use case? Is it simulations? Is it the AIs that will be in the metaverse? What will we be using the data centers for?
Mark Zuckerberg
I mean, our bet is that it's going to, this is basically going to change all of the products, right? So I think that there's going to be a kind of meta AI general assistant product. And I think that that will shift from something that feels more like a chat bot where it's like you just ask a question that kind of formulates an answer to things where you're increasingly giving it more complicated tasks and that goes away and does them. So that's going to take a lot of inference. It's going to take a lot of compute in other ways too. Yeah. Then I think that there's a big part of what we're going to do that is like interacting with other agents for other people.
So whether it's businesses or creators, I guess a big part of my theory on this is that there's not just going to be like one singular AI that you interact with, because I think, you know, every business is going to like, want an ai that represents their interests they're not going to like want to primarily interact with you through an ai that is going to sell their competitors customers so sorry their competitors products um so um uh so yeah so i think creators is going to be a big one i mean there are about 200 million creators on our platforms they all basically have the pattern where um They want to engage their community, but they're limited by hours in the day.
And their community generally wants to engage them, but they're limited by hours in the day. So if you could create something where that creator can basically own the AI and train it in the way that they want and can engage their community, I think that that's going to be super powerful, too. So I think that there's going to be a ton of engagement across all these things. but these are just the consumer use cases. I mean, I think when you think about stuff like, I mean, you know, I run like our foundation, right. A Chan Zuckerberg initiative with my wife and, you know, we're doing a bunch of stuff on science and, and there's obviously a lot of AI work that, where I, that I think is going to advance science and healthcare and all these things too.
So I think that it's like, there's a, this is, I think it ended up affecting basically every area of the products and, and, and the, and the, the economy.
Dwarkesh Patel
The thing you mentioned about an AI that can just go out and do something for you that's multi-step, is that a bigger model? There'll be a version that's still 70B, but you'll just turn it on the right data and that will be super powerful. What does the progression look like? Is it scaling? Is it just same size, but different banks like you were talking about?
Mark Zuckerberg
I don't know that we know the answer to that. So I think one thing that seems to be a pattern is that you have the LAMA model, and then you build some kind of other application-specific code around it. So some of it is the fine-tuning for the use case, but some of it is just logic for how MetAI should integrate that should work with tools like Google or Bing to bring in real-time knowledge. I mean, that's not part of the base Llama model. That's like part of a, okay. So for Llama 2, we had some of that and it was a little more kind of hand engineered. And then part of our goal for Llama 3 was to bring more of that into the model itself.
And but for Lama three, as we start getting into more of these agent like behaviors, I think some of that is going to be more hand engineered. And then I think our goal for Lama four will be to bring more of that into the model. So I think at each point, like at each step along the way, you kind of have a sense of of what's going to be possible on the horizon. You start messing with it and hacking around it. And then I think that that helps you hone your intuition for what you want to try to train into the next version of the model itself. Interesting. Which makes it more general because obviously anything that you're hand coding is, you know, you can unlock some use cases, but it's just inherently brittle and non-general.
Dwarkesh Patel
Hey everybody, real quick, I want to tell you about a tool that I wish more applications used. So obviously you've noticed every single company is trying to add an AI chatbot to their website. But as a user, I usually find them really annoying because they give these long, generic, often useless answers. CommandBar is a user assistant that you can just embed into your website or application. And it feels like you're talking to a friendly human support agent who is browsing with you and for you. And it's much more personalized than a regular chatbot. It can actually look up users' history and respond differently based on that.
It can use APIs to perform actions. It can even proactively nudge users to explore new features. One thing that I think is really cool is that instead of just outputting text, CommandBar can kind of just say, here, let me show you and start browsing alongside the user. Anyways, they're in a bunch of great products already. You can learn more about them at commandbar.com. Thanks to them for sponsoring this episode. And now back to Mark. When you say into the model itself, you train it on the thing that you want in the model itself? What do you mean by into the model itself? Well, I mean,
Mark Zuckerberg
I think like the example that I gave for Lama 2, where, you know, we really, I mean, for Lama 2, the tool use was very, very specific. Whereas Lama 3 has the ability to, has much better tool use, right? So we don't have to like, hand code all the stuff to have it use google to to go do a search um it just kind of can do that um so and similarly for coding and and kind of running code and just a bunch of stuff like that and um but i think once you kind of get that capability then you get a peak of, okay, well, what can we start doing next? Okay, well, I don't necessarily wanna wait until Llama 4 is around to start building those capabilities, so let's start hacking around it. And so you do a bunch of hand coding and that makes the products better for the interim, but then that also helps show the way of what we wanna try to build into the next version of the model.
Dwarkesh Patel
What is the community fine tune of Llama 3 you're most excited by? Maybe not the one that will be most useful to you, but just you will just enjoy playing it with the most. They'll fine tune it on antiquity and you'll just be talking to Virgil or something. What are you excited about? I don't know.
Mark Zuckerberg
I think the nature of the stuff is it's like you get surprised. So I think any specific thing that I sort of thought would be valuable, we'd probably be building. But I think you'll get distilled versions. I think you'll get kind of smaller versions. I mean, one thing that I think is 8 billion, I don't think is quite small enough for a bunch of use cases, right? I think like over time, I'd love to get, you know, a billion parameter model or a 2 billion parameter model, or even like a, I don't know, maybe like a 500 million parameter model and see what you can do with that. Because I mean, as they start getting...
If with 8 billion parameters, we're basically nearly as powerful as the largest Lama 2 model, then with a billion parameters, we should be able to do something that's interesting, right? And faster, good for classification or a lot of kind of like basic things that people do before kind of understanding the intent of a user query and feeding it to the most powerful model to kind of hone what the prompt should be. So I don't know. I think that's one thing that maybe the community can help fill in. But I mean, we're also thinking about getting around to distilling some of these ourselves. But right now, the GPUs are training the 405.
Dwarkesh Patel
Okay, so you have all these GPUs. I think you said 350,000 by the end of the year.
Mark Zuckerberg
That's the whole fleet. I mean, we built two... I think it's like 22, 24,000 clusters that are kind of the single clusters that we have for training the big models. I mean, obviously across a lot of the stuff that we do, a lot of our stuff goes towards training like reels models and like Facebook news feed and Instagram feed. And then inference is a huge thing for us because we serve a ton of people, right? So our ratio of inference is, compute required to training is probably much higher than most other companies that are doing this stuff just because of the sheer volume of the community that we're serving. Yeah. Yeah.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah. That was really interesting in the material they shared with me before that you trained it on more data than is compute optimal just for training because the inference is such a big deal for you guys and also for the community that it makes sense to just have this thing and have trillions of tokens in there.
Mark Zuckerberg
Yeah. Yeah. Although in one of the interesting things about it that we saw even with the 70 billion is we we thought it would get more saturated at, you know, it's like we trained it on around 15 trillion tokens. Yeah. I guess our prediction going in was that it was going to asymptote more. But even by the end, it was... still learning right it's like we probably could have fed it more tokens and it would have gotten somewhat better but i mean at some point you know you're running a company you need to do these meta reasoning questions of like all right how do i want to spend our gpus on like training this 70 billion model further do we want to kind of get on with it so we can start testing hypotheses for llama 4 so we kind of needed to to make um to make that call and i think we got it we i think we got to a reasonable balance for for this version of the 70 billion um There will be others in the future where, you know, the 70 billion multimodal one that'll come over the next period. But yeah, I mean, that was fascinating that the architectures at this point can just take so much data.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah, that's really interesting. So what does this imply about future models? You mentioned that the LAMA-3 8B is better than the LAMA-2 70B, right? No, no, no. It's nearly as good.
Mark Zuckerberg
Okay.
Dwarkesh Patel
I don't overstate.
Mark Zuckerberg
But does that mean like the LAMA-4? In the same order of magnitude.
Dwarkesh Patel
Does that mean the Lama 470B will be as good as the Lama 3405B? What is the future of this?
Mark Zuckerberg
This is one of the great questions that I think no one knows. It's one of the trickiest things in the world to plan around is when you have an exponential curve, how long does it keep going for? Yeah. I think it's likely enough that it will keep going, that it is worth investing the tens or 100 billion plus in building the infrastructure to assume that if that kind of keeps going, you're going to get some really amazing things that are just going to make amazing products. But. I don't think anyone in the industry can really tell you that it will continue scaling at that rate for sure. In general, in history, you hit bottlenecks at certain points. And now there's so much energy on this that maybe those bottlenecks get knocked over pretty quickly. But I don't know. I think that's an interesting question.
Dwarkesh Patel
What does the world look like where there aren't these bottlenecks? You know, suppose like progress just continues at this pace, which seems like plausible. Like zooming out. They're going to be different bottlenecks. Right. So if not training, then like, oh yeah, go ahead.
Mark Zuckerberg
Well, I think at some point, Over the last few years, I think there's this issue of GPU production, right? So even companies that had the models, sorry, that had the money to pay for the GPUs couldn't necessarily get as many as they wanted because there were all these supply constraints. Now I think that's sort of getting less. So now I think you're seeing a bunch of companies think about, wow, we should just like really invest a lot of money in building out these things. And I think that that will go for some period of time. I think there is a capital question of like, okay, at what point does it stop being worth it to put the capital in but i actually think before we hit that you're going to run into energy constraints right because um i just i mean i don't think anyone's built a gigawatt single training cluster yet right and um and then you run into these things that just end up being slower in the world like getting energy permitted is like a very heavily regulated government function, right?
So you're going from, on the one hand, software, which is somewhat regulated. I'd argue that it is more regulated than I think a lot of people in the tech community feel, although it's obviously different. If you're starting a small company, maybe you feel that less. If you're a big company, we just interact with people. Different governments and regulators are, you know, we have kind of... Lots of rules that we need to follow and make sure we do a good job with around the world. But I think that there's no doubt that energy, and if you're talking about building large new power plants or large build-outs and then building transmission lines that cross other private or public land, that is just a heavily regulated thing.
So you're talking about many years of lead time. So if we wanted to stand up just some massive facility to power that, I think that that is... That's that's a very long term project. Right. And so I don't know. I think that that's I think people do it. But I don't think that this is like something that can be quite as magical as just like, OK, you get a level of AI and you get a bunch of capital and you put it in and then like all of a sudden the models are just going to kind of like it just like I think you do hit different bottlenecks along the way.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah. Is there something, a project, maybe AI related, maybe not, that even a company like Meta doesn't have the resources for? Like if your R&D budget or CapEx budget was 10x what it is now, then you could pursue it. Like it's in the back of your mind. But Meta today, and maybe you could like, even you can't even issue a stock or bond for it. It's like just 10x bigger than your budget.
Mark Zuckerberg
well i think energy is one piece yeah right um i think we would probably build out bigger clusters than we currently can if we could get the energy to do it so i
Dwarkesh Patel
think that that's um that's fundamentally money bottlenecked in the limit like if
Mark Zuckerberg
you had a trillion dollars it's time yeah right um Well, if you look at it in terms of, but it depends on how far the exponential curves go, right? Like I think a number of companies are working on, you know, right now I think, you know, like a lot of data centers are on the order of 50 megawatts or a hundred megawatts or like a big one might be 150 megawatts. Okay. So you take a whole data center and you fill it up with just all the stuff that you need to do for training and you build the biggest cluster you can. I think that's kind of, I think a bunch of companies are running at stuff like that.
um but then when you start getting into building a data center that's like 300 megawatts or 500 megawatts or a gigawatt i just i mean just no one has built a single gigawatt data center yet so i think it will happen right i mean this is only a matter of time but it's it's not going to be like next year right it's um i think that some of these things will take i don't know some some number of years to build out and then the question is okay well if you i mean just i guess put this in perspective i think a gigawatt it's like around the size of like a meaningful nuclear power plant only going towards training a model
Dwarkesh Patel
didn't it didn't amazon do this there's like they have a 950 gig a megawatt uh yeah i'm not exactly sure what you did you'd have to what they did you'd have to ask them um But it doesn't have to be in the same place, right? If distributed training works, it can be distributed.
Mark Zuckerberg
That I think is a big question, is basically how that's going to work. And I do think in the future, it seems quite possible that more of what we call training for these big models is actually... more along the lines of inference generating synthetic data to then go feed into the model. So I don't know what that ratio is going to be, but I consider the generation of synthetic data to be more inference than training today. But obviously, if you're doing it in order to train a model, it's part of the broader training process. So I don't know, that's an open question is to kind of where what the balance of that and how that plays out.
Dwarkesh Patel
If that's the case, would that potentially also be the case with Lama 3? And maybe like Lama 4 onwards, where you put this out and if somebody has a ton of compute, then using the models that you've put out, you can just keep making these things arbitrarily smarter. Like some Kuwait or UAE or some random country has a ton of compute and they can just actually just use Lama 4 to just make something much smarter.
Mark Zuckerberg
I do think that there are going to be dynamics like that. But I also think that there is a fundamental limitation on... on kind of the network architecture, right? Or the kind of model architecture, right? So I think like a 70 billion model that kind of we trained with the Llama 3 architecture can get better, right? It can keep going. Like I was saying, it's, you know, we felt like if we kept on feeding it more data or rotated the high value tokens through again, then, you know, it would continue getting better. But And we've seen a bunch of other people around the world, different companies basically take the Lama 2, 70 billion base, take that model architecture and then build a new model. It's still the case that when you make a generational improvement to the kind of Lama 3 $70 billion or the Lama 3 $405 billion, there's nothing open source, anything like that today. I think that it's a big step function and what people are going to be able to build on top of that I don't think can go infinitely from there. I think there can be some optimization in that until you get to the next step function.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah. Okay, so let's zoom out a little bit from specific models and even the many years lead times you would need to get energy approvals and so on. Like big picture, these next couple of decades, what's happening with AI? Does it feel like another technology like metaverse or social or does it feel like a fundamentally different thing in the course of human history?
Mark Zuckerberg
I think it's gonna be pretty fundamental. I think it's gonna be more like the creation of computing in the first place, right? So you'll get all these new apps in the same way that when you got the web or you got mobile phones you got like people basically rethought all these experiences and a lot of things that weren't possible before now became possible um something that will happen but i think it's a much lower level innovation it's um it's it's going to be more like going from people didn't have computers to people have computers is my my sense um But it's also... I don't know. It's very hard to reason about exactly how this goes.
I tend to think that in the cosmic scale, obviously, it'll happen quickly over a couple of decades or something. But I do think that there is some set of people who are afraid of... you know, it really just kind of spins and goes from being like somewhat intelligent to extremely intelligent overnight. And I just think that there's all these physical constraints that make that so that that's unlikely to happen. I just don't, I don't really see that playing out. So I think you'll have, I think we'll have time to kind of acclimate a bit, but it will really change the way that we work and give people all these creative tools to do different things that they Yeah, I think it's going to really enable people to do the things that they want a lot more, is my view.
Dwarkesh Patel
Okay, so maybe not overnight, but is it your view that on a cosmic scale, if you think humans evolved, and then AI happened, and then they went out through the galaxy? Or maybe it takes many decades, maybe it takes a century, but is that the grand scheme of what's happening right now in history? Yeah. Sorry, in what sense? In the sense that there are other technologies like computers and even like fire, but the AI happening is as significant as humans evolving in the first place. I think that's tricky.
Mark Zuckerberg
I think people like to... The history of humanity, I think, has been people basically thinking that certain aspects of humanity are like really unique in different ways. And then coming to grips with the fact that that's not true, but humanity is actually still super special, right? So it's, um, it's like, we thought that the earth was the center of the universe and it's like, it's not, but like, it's like humans are still pretty awesome. Right. And pretty unique. Um, I think that another bias that people tend to have is thinking that intelligence is somehow kind of fundamentally connected to life and it's not actually clear that it is right i think like like people think that um i mean i don't know that we have a clear enough definition of consciousness or um or or life to kind of fully um interrogate this but I know there's all this science fiction about, okay, you create intelligence and now it starts taking on all these human-like behaviors and things like that.
But I actually think that the current incarnation of all this stuff, at least, kind of feels like it's going in a direction where intelligence can be pretty separated from consciousness and agency and things like that. That... I think just makes it a super valuable tool. So I don't know. I mean, obviously it's very difficult to predict what direction this stuff goes in over time, which is why I don't think anyone should be dogmatic about how they plan to develop it or what they plan to do. I think you want to kind of look at each release. It's like we're obviously very pro-open source, but I haven't committed that we're going to release every single thing that we do.
But it's basically, I'm just generally very inclined to thinking that open sourcing it is going to be good for the community and also good for us, right? Because we'll benefit from the innovations. But if at some point there's some qualitative change in what the thing is capable of and we feel like it's just not responsible to open source it, then we won't. So I don't know. It's all very difficult to predict.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah. What is a kind of qualitative change, like a specific thing? You're training Lama 5, Lama 4, and you've seen this. You know what? I'm not sure about open sourcing it.
Mark Zuckerberg
I think that it's a little hard to answer that in the abstract because there are negative behaviors that any product can exhibit that as long as you can mitigate it, it's okay. There's bad things about social media that we work to mitigate. There's bad things about Lama 2 that we spend a lot of time trying to make sure that it's not like... helping people commit violent acts or things like that, right? I mean, that doesn't mean that it's like a kind of autonomous or intelligent agent. It just means that it's learned a lot about the world and it can answer a set of questions that we think it would be unhelpful for it to answer.
So I don't know. I think the question isn't really what behaviors would it show, it's what things would we not be able to mitigate after it shows that. And I don't know. I think that there's so many ways in which something can be good or bad that it's hard to actually enumerate them all up front. If you even look at what we've had to deal with in in social media and the different types of harms. We've basically gotten to, there's like 18 or 19 categories of harmful things that people do. And we've basically built AI systems to try to go identify what those things are that people are doing and try to make sure that that doesn't happen on our network as much as possible.
So yeah, over time, I think you'll be able to break down this into more of a taxonomy too. And I think this is a thing that we spend time researching too, because we want to make sure that we understand that.
Dwarkesh Patel
So one of the things I asked Mark is what industrial scale use of LLMs would look like. You see this in previous technological revolutions where at first they're thinking in a very small scale way about what's enabled. And I think that's what chatbots might be for LLMs. And I think the large scale use case might look something like what v7 Go is. And by the way, it's made by v7 Labs who's sponsoring this episode. So it's like a spreadsheet. You put in raw information like documents, images, whatever, and they become rows and the columns are populated by an LLM of your choice. And in fact, I used it to prepare for Mark.
So I fed in a bunch of blog posts and papers from Meta's AI research. And as you can see, if you're on YouTube, it summarizes and extracts exactly the information I want as columns. And obviously mine is a small use case, but you can imagine, for example, a company like FedEx. has to process half a million documents a day, obviously a chatbot can't do that. A spreadsheet can, because this is just like a fire hose of intelligence in there, right? Anyways, you can learn more about them at v7labs.com slash go, or the link in the description. Back to Mark. Yeah, like it seems to me it would be a good idea.
I would be disappointed in a future where AI systems aren't broadly deployed and everybody doesn't have access to them. At the same time, I want to better understand the mitigations. Because if the mitigation is the fine tuning, well, the whole thing about open weights is that you can then um remove the fine-tuning which is often superficial on top of these capabilities like if it's like talking on slack with a biology researcher and again i think like models are very far from this they're right now they're like google search um but it's like i can show them my petri dish and they can explain like here's why you're a smallpox sample didn't grow um here's what to change um how do you mitigate that because somebody can just like fine-tune that in there right yeah i mean
Mark Zuckerberg
That's true. I think a lot of people will basically use the off-the-shelf model. And some people who have basically bad faith are going to try to strip out all the bad stuff. So I do think that that's an issue. The... The flip side of this is that, and this is one of the reasons why I'm kind of philosophically so pro open source, is I do think that a concentration of AI in the future has the potential to be as dangerous as kind of it being widespread. So I think a lot of people are, they think about the questions of, okay, well, if we can do this stuff, is it bad for it to be out wild? Like just in kind of widely available.
I think another version of this is like, okay, well, it's probably also pretty bad for one institution to have an AI that is way more powerful than everyone else's AI, right? So if you look at like, I guess one security analogy that I think of is, you know, it doesn't take AI... to basically, okay, there's security holes in so many different things. And if you could travel back in time a year or two years, right? It's like, that's not AI. It's like you just, let's say you just have like one year or two years more knowledge of the security holes. You can pretty much hack into like any system, right?
So it's not that far fetched to believe, that a very intelligent AI would probably be able to identify some holes and basically be like a human who could potentially go back in time a year or two and compromise all these systems. Okay, so how have we dealt with that as a society? Well, One big part is open source software that makes it so that when improvements are made to the software, it doesn't just kind of get stuck in one company's products, but it can kind of be broadly deployed to a lot of different systems, whether it's banks or hospitals or government stuff. And like just everyone can kind of like as the software gets hardened.
which happens because more people can see it and more people can bang on it and there are standards on how this stuff works, the world can kind of get upgraded together pretty quickly. And I kind of think that a world where AI is very widely deployed in a way where it's gotten hardened progressively over time and is one where all the different systems will be in check in a way that seems like it is fundamentally more healthy to me than one where this is more concentrated. So there are risks on all sides, but I think that that's one risk that I think people, I don't hear them talking about quite as much.
I think like there's sort of the risk of like, okay, well, what if the AI system does something bad? I am more like, you know, I stay up at night more worrying. Well, what if like, some actor that whatever it's like from wherever you sit there's going to be some actor who you don't trust if they're the ones who have like the super strong ai whether it's some like other government that we that that is sort of like an opponent of of our country or some company that you don't trust or whatever it is um I think that that's potentially a much bigger risk.
Dwarkesh Patel
As in they could overthrow our government because they have a weapon that nobody else has?
Mark Zuckerberg
It would just cause a lot of mayhem. I think it's like... I mean, I think the intuition is that this stuff ends up being pretty kind of important and valuable for both kind of economic and kind of security and other things. And I don't know. I just think, yeah, if someone who you don't trust or is an adversary of you gets something that is more powerful than... I think that that could be an issue. And I think probably the best way to mitigate that is to have good open source AI that basically becomes the standard and in a lot of ways kind of can become the leader. And in that way, it just ensures that it's a much more kind of even and balanced playing field.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah, that seems plausible to me. And if that works out, that would be the future I prefer. I guess I want to understand mechanistically how if somebody was going to cause a mayhem with AI systems, how the fact that there are other open source systems in the world prevents that. Like the specific example of somebody coming with a bioweapon. Is it just that we'll do a bunch of R&D in the rest of the world to figure out vaccines really fast? What's happening?
Mark Zuckerberg
If you take the computer, the security one that I was talking about, I think someone with a weaker AI trying to hack into a system that is like protected by a stronger AI will succeed less. Right. So so I think that that's I mean, that's like in terms of how do you know everything in the world is like that? Like what if bioweapons aren't like that? No, I mean, I don't know that everything in the world is like that. Um, um, I, I think that that's, I guess one of the bioweapons are one of the areas where I think the people who are most worried about this stuff are focused. And, and I think that that's, uh, I think it makes a lot of sense to think about that. Um, I mean, I think that there are certain mitigations. You can try to not train certain knowledge into the model, right? There's different things. But yeah, I mean, at some level, I mean, if you get a sufficiently bad actor and you don't have other AI that can sort of balance them and understand what's going on and what the threats are, then that could be a risk. So I think that that's one of the things that we need to watch out for.
Speaker 4
Yeah.
Dwarkesh Patel
Um, is there something you could see in the deployment of these systems where, uh, you, you observe like you're training llama for, and it's like lie to you because it thought you weren't noticing or something. And you're like, Whoa, I, uh, what's going on here? Um, not that you, this is probably not likely with alarm for test system, but is there something you can imagine like that, where you'd like be really concerned about deceptiveness and if like billions of copies of things are out in the wild?
Mark Zuckerberg
Um, Yeah. I mean, I think that that's not necessarily, I mean, right now it's, we see a lot of hallucinations, right? So I think it's more, more that, um, um, I think it's an, it's an interesting question how you would tell the difference between a hallucination and deception, but yeah, I'm not, look, I mean, I think that there's a lot of risks and things to think about the, um, The flip side of all this is that there are also a lot of... I try to, in running our company at least, balance what I think of as these longer-term theoretical risks with... With what I actually think are quite real risks that exist today.
So when you talk about deception, the form of that that I worry about most is people using this to generate misinformation and then pump that through, whether it's our networks or others. So the way that we've basically... combated a lot of this type of harmful content is by building AI systems that are smarter than the adversarial ones. This kind of informs part of my theory on this. If you look at the different types of harm that people do or try to do through social networks... There are ones that are not very adversarial. So for example, like hate speech, I would say is not super adversarial in the sense that like people aren't getting better at being racist, right?
They're just like, it's, you just like, okay, if you kind of, that's one where I think the AIs are generally just getting way more sophisticated faster than people are at those issues. So we have, and we have issues both ways. It's like, People do bad things, whether they're trying to incite violence or something. But we also have a lot of false positives, right? So where we basically censor stuff that we shouldn't and I think understandably make a lot of people annoyed. So I think having an AI that just gets increasingly precise on that, that's going to be good over time. But let me give you another example, which is like nation states trying to interfere in elections.
That's an example where they're absolutely they have cutting edge technology and absolutely get better each year. So we block some technique. They learn what we did. They come at us with a different technique. Right. It's not like a person trying to, you know, say mean things. Right. It's like it's it's there. They're basically they have a goal. They're sophisticated. They have a lot of technology. Right. In those cases, I still think the ability to kind of have our AI systems grow in sophistication at a faster rate than theirs have, it's an arms race. But I think we're at least currently winning that arms race.
So I don't know. But this is like a lot of the stuff that I spend time thinking about is like, okay, yes, it is possible that... whether it's Lama four or Lama five or Lama six. Yeah. We need to think about like what behaviors we're, we're observing. And it's not just us. I think part of the reason why you make this open source is that there are a lot of other people who study this too. So yeah, we want to see what other people are observing, what we're observing, what we can mitigate, and then we'll make our assessment on whether we can make it, um, open source. But yeah, I think for the foreseeable future, I'm optimistic we will be able to.
And in the near term, I don't want to take our eye off the ball of what are actual bad things that people are trying to use the models for today, even if they're not existential, but they're like they're like pretty bad kind of day to day harms that we're familiar with and running our services. That's actually a lot of what we have to, I think, spend our time on as well. Yeah.
Dwarkesh Patel
Actually, I found the synthetic data thing really curious. I'm actually interested in why you don't think, like current models, it makes sense why there might be an asymptote with just doing the synthetic data again and again. If they get smarter and you use the kind of techniques you talk about in the paper or the blog post that's coming out on the day this will be released, where it goes to the thought chain that is the most correct and Why this wouldn't lead to a loop that... Of course, it wouldn't be overnight, but over many months or years of training potentially with a smarter model, it gets smarter, makes better output, gets smarter, and so forth.
Mark Zuckerberg
Well, I think it could within the parameter of whatever the model architecture is. It's just that at some level... I don't know. I think like today is eight billion parameter models. I just don't think you're going to be able to get to be as good as the state of the art multi hundred billion parameter models that are incorporating new research into the architecture itself. But those will be open source as well, right? Well, yeah, but I think that that's, I mean, subject to all the questions that we just talked about. But yes, I mean, we would hope that that'll be the case. But I think that at each point, I don't know, it's like, you're building software there's like a ton of stuff that you can do with software but then at some level you're constrained by the chips that it's running on right so there are always going to be different physical constraints and it's like how big are the models is going to be constrained by how much energy you can get and um and use for inference um so I guess I'm simultaneously very optimistic that this stuff will continue to improve quickly and also a little more measured than I think some people are about I just don't think the runaway case is a particularly likely one.
Dwarkesh Patel
I think it makes sense to keep your options open. There's so much we don't know. There's a case in which it's really important to keep the balance of power so when nobody becomes a totalitarian dictator, there's a case in which you don't want to open source the architecture because China can use it to catch up to America's AIs and there is an intelligence explosion and they win that. A lot of things seem possible, just like keeping your options open considering all of them seems reasonable. Yeah. Let's talk about some other things. Go for it. Okay. Metaverse, what time period in human history would you be most interested in going into? 100,000 BCE to now. You just want to see what it was like. It has to be the past?
Mark Zuckerberg
Huh?
Dwarkesh Patel
It has to be the past?
Speaker 1
Oh, yeah. It has to be the past. Um,
Mark Zuckerberg
I don't know. I mean, I have the periods of time that I'm interested in. I'm really interested in American history and classical history. And I'm really interested in the history of science, too. So I actually think seeing and trying to understand more but how some of the big advances came about. I mean, all we have are like somewhat limited writings about some of that stuff. I'm not sure the metaverse is going to let you do that. Cause I mean, it's, um, you know, we can't, it's going to be hard to, to kind of go back in time for things that we don't have records of. But, uh, actually not sure that going back in time is going to be that that that important of a thing for them i mean i think it's gonna be cool for like history classes and stuff but um that's probably not the use case that i'm most excited about for the for the metaverse overall i mean it's um i think the main thing is just the ability to feel present with people no matter where you are i think that's gonna be killer i mean there's um i mean in the ai conversation that we that we're having i mean it's uh you know, so much of it is about physical constraints that kind of underlie all, all of this.
Right. And you want to move, I think one lesson of technology is you want to move things from the physical constraint realm into software as much as possible because software is so much easier to build and, and evolve. And like, you can democratize it more because like not everyone is going to have a data center, but like a lot of people can, can kind of write code and take open source code and modify it. Um, The metaverse version of this is, I think, enabling realistic digital presence is going to be just an absolutely huge difference for making it so that people don't feel like they have to physically be together for as many things.
Now, I mean, I think that there are gonna be things that are better about being physically together. So it's not I mean, these things aren't binary. It's not going to be like, OK, now it's you don't need to do that anymore. But but overall, I mean, I think that this it's just gonna be really powerful for socializing, for feeling connected with people, for working, for. I don't know, parts of industry, for medicine, for like so many things.
Dwarkesh Patel
I want to go back to something you said at the beginning of the conversation where you didn't sell the company for a billion dollars and like the metaverse, you knew we were going to do this even though the market was hammering you for it. And then I'm actually curious, like what is the source of that edge? And you said like, oh, values, I have this intuition. But like everybody says that, right? Like if you had to say something that's specific to you, how would you express what that is? Like why were you so convinced about the metaverse?
Mark Zuckerberg
Well, I think that those are different questions. So, I mean, what are the things that kind of power me? I think we've talked about a bunch of the themes. So, I mean, I just really like building things. I specifically like building things around how people communicate and sort of understanding how people express themselves and how people work, right? When I was in college, I was... I studied computer science and psychology. I think a lot of other people in the industry studied computer science, right? So it's always been sort of the intersection of those two things for me. But I think it's also sort of this like, really deep drive.
I don't know how to explain it, but I just feel like in the constitutionally, like I'm doing something wrong if I'm not building something new. Right. And so I think that there's like, even when we're putting together the business case for investing like $100 billion in AI or some huge amount in the metaverse, it's like, yeah, I mean, we have plans that I think make it pretty clear that if our stuff works, it'll be a good investment. But you can't know for certain from the outset. And so there's all these arguments that people have, whether it's like, you know, with advisors or, or different folks.
It's like, well, how, how could you like, it's a, how are you confident enough to do this? And it's like, well, the day I stopped trying to build new things, I'm just done. I'm going to go build new things somewhere else. Right. It's like, um, it's like, it is, I I'm fundamentally incapable of running something or in my own life and like not trying to build new things that i think are are interesting it's like that's not even a question for me right it's like whether like whether we're going to go take a swing at like building the next thing it's like it's like i'm i'm just incapable of not doing that um and i don't know i and i'm kind of like this in like all the different aspects of my life right it's like we built this like My family built this ranch in Kauai, and I just worked to design all these buildings.
We started raising cattle, and I'm like, all right, well, I want to make the best cattle in the world. So it's like, how do we architect this so that way we can figure this out and build all the stuff up that we need to try to do that? So I don't know. That's me. What was the other part of the question?
Dwarkesh Patel
Look, Meta is just a really amazing tech company, right? They have all these great software engineers and even they work with Stripe to handle payments. And I think that's just a really notable fact that Stripe's ability to engineer these checkout experiences is so good that big companies like Ford, Zoom, Meta, even OpenAI, they work with Stripe to handle payments. Because just think about how many different possibilities you have to handle. If you're in a different country, you'll pay a different way. And if you're buying a certain kind of item, that might affect how you decide to pay. And Stripe is able to test these fine-grained optimizations across tens of billions of transactions a day to figure out what will convert people.
And obviously conversion means more revenue for you. And look, I'm not a big company like Meta or anything, but I've been using Stripe since long before they were advertisers. Stripe Atlas was just the easiest way for me to set up an LLC. And they have these payments and invoicing features that make it super convenient for me to get money from advertisers. And obviously without that, it would have been much harder for me to earn money from the podcast. And so it's been great for me. Go to stripe.com to learn more. Thanks to them for sponsoring the episode. Now back to Mark. I'm not sure, but I'm actually curious about something else, which is, so a 19-year-old Mark reads a bunch of antiquity and classics, high school, college.
What important lesson did you learn from it? Not just interesting things you found, but there aren't that many tokens you consume by the time you're 19. A bunch of them were about the classics. Clearly, that was important in some way. Yeah.
Mark Zuckerberg
I don't know. That's a good question. I mean, one of the things that I thought was really fascinating is so when Augustus was first, so he became emperor, and he was trying to establish peace. There was no real conception of peace at the time. People's understanding of peace was it is the temporary time between when your enemies will inevitably attack you again, so you get a short rest. And he had this view, which is like, look, like we want to change the economy from instead of being so mercenary and like in kind of militaristic to like actually this positive something. It's like a very novel idea at the time.
I don't know. I think that there's like something that's just really fundamental about that. It's like in terms of the, the bounds on like what people can conceive at the time of like, what are rational ways to work. And, um, I'm going back to like, I mean, this applies to both the metaverse and the AI stuff, but like a lot of investors and just different people just can't wrap their head around why we would open source this. And it's like, are you like, like, I don't understand. It's like open source. That must just be like the temporary time between which you're making things proprietary. Right.
And it's, but, but I actually think it's like this very profound thing in tech that it's has actually, it creates a lot of winners, right? And it's, and so I don't know, I don't want to strain the analogy too much, but I do think that there's, there's a lot of times I think ways where you can, that are just like models for building things that people can't even like, they just like often can't wrap their head around how that would be a valuable thing for people to go do or like a reasonable state of the world that it's, I mean, it's, uh, I think that there's more reasonable things than people think.
Dwarkesh Patel
That's super fascinating. Can I give you my answer of what I was thinking? Sure. You might have gotten from it. This is probably totally off, but just how young some of these people are who have very important roles in the empire. Caesar Augustus, by the time he's 19, he's actually incredibly one of the most prominent people in Roman politics. He's leading battles and forming the second triumvirate. I wonder if you're like the 19 year old is like, I can actually do this because like,
Mark Zuckerberg
I think that's an interesting example, both from a lot of history and American history. Yeah. I mean, it's, I mean, one of my favorite quotes is it's this Picasso quote that all children are artists and the challenge is how do you remain an artist when you grow up? And it's like, basically I think, cause when you're younger, I think it's just easier to, have kind of wild ideas and you're not, you know, you have no, there are all these analogies to the innovators dilemma that exist in your life as well as your company or whatever you've built. Right. So, you know, you're kind of earlier on your trajectory. It's easier to pivot and take in new ideas without it disrupting other commitments that you've made to, to different things. And, um, so I don't know. I think that that's an interesting part of, of running a company is like, how do you, how do you kind of stay dynamic?
Dwarkesh Patel
Going back to the investors in open source, the $10 billion model, suppose it's totally safe. You've done these evaluations. And unlike in this case, the evaluators can also fine tune the model, which hopefully will be the case in future models. Would you open source that, the $10 billion model? Well, I mean, as long as it's helping us, then yeah. But would it? Like to $10 billion of R&D and then now it's like open source for anybody?
Mark Zuckerberg
Well, I think here's, I think, a question which we'll have to evaluate this as time goes on too. But... We have a long history of open sourcing software, right? We don't tend to open source our product, right? So it's not like we don't take like the code for Instagram and make it open source, but we take like... a lot of the low-level infrastructure, and we make that open source, right? Probably the biggest one in our history was Open Compute Project, where we took the designs for kind of all of our servers and network switches and data centers and made it open source and ended up being super helpful because, you know, I mean, a lot of people can design servers, but now, like, the industry standardized on our design, which meant that the supply chains...
basically all got built out around our design. The volumes went up, so it got cheaper for everyone and saved us billions of dollars. So awesome, right? Okay, so there's multiple ways where open source, I think, could be helpful for us. One is if people figure out how to run the models more cheaply. Well, we're going to be spending tens or like $100 billion or more over time on all this stuff. So if we can do that 10% more effectively, we're saving billions or tens of billions of dollars. Okay, that's probably worth a lot by itself. Especially if there's other competitive models out there. It's not like our thing is giving away some kind of crazy advantage.
So is your view that the trading will be commodified? I think there's a bunch of ways that this could play out. That's one. The other is... is that so commodity kind of implies that it's going to get very cheap because um because there's lots of options the other direction that this could go in is qualitative improvements so um so you mentioned fine tuning right it's like right now it's it's um you know it's pretty limited what you can do with fine tuning major other models out there and there are some options but generally not for the biggest models um So I think being able to do that and be able to kind of do different app-specific things or use case-specific things or build them into specific tool chains, I think will not only enable kind of more efficient development, it could enable qualitatively different things.
Here's one analogy on this. So one thing that I think generally sucks about the mobile ecosystem is that you have these two gatekeeper companies, Apple and Google, that can tell you what you're allowed to build. And there are lots of times in our history... So there's the economic version of that, which is like, all right, we build something and they're just like, I'm going to take a bunch of your money. But then there's the... The qualitative version, which is actually what kind of upsets me more, which is there's a bunch of times when we've launched or wanted to launch features, and then Apple's just like, nope, you're not launching that.
I was like, that sucks, right? And so... The question is, are we kind of set up for a world like that with AI, where you're going to get a handful of companies that run these closed models that are going to be in control of the APIs and therefore going to be able to tell you what you can build? Well, for one, I can say for us, it is worth it to go build a model ourselves to make sure that we're not in that position, right? Like I don't want any of those other companies telling us what we can build. Um, but from an open source perspective, I think a lot of developers don't want those companies telling them what they can build either.
Um, so the question is what is the ecosystem that gets built out around that? What are interesting new things? How much does that improve our products? Um, I know there's a lot of cases where if this ends up being like, you know, like our databases or caching systems or architecture, we'll get valuable contributions from the community that will make our stuff better. And then our app specific work that we do will still be so differentiated that it won't really matter. Right. It's like, well, we'll be able to do what we do. We'll benefit in all the systems, ours and the communities will be better because it's open source.
There is one world where, um, Maybe it's not that. I mean, maybe the model just ends up being more of the product itself. In that case, then I think it's a trickier economic calculation about whether you open source that because then you are kind of commoditizing yourself a lot. But from what I can see so far, it doesn't seem like we're in that zone.
Dwarkesh Patel
Do you expect to earn significant revenue from licensing your model to the cloud providers so they have to pay you a fee to actually serve the model?
Mark Zuckerberg
Yeah. We want to have an arrangement like that, but I don't know how significant it'll be. And we have this... This is basically our license for Llama. Yeah. You know, in a lot of ways, it's like a very permissive open source license, except that we have a limit for the largest companies using it. And this is why we put that limit in, is we're not trying to prevent them from using it. We just want them to come talk to us because if they're going to just basically take what we built and resell it and make money off of it, then it's like, okay, well... If you're like Microsoft Azure or Amazon, then yeah, if you're going to be reselling the model, then we should have some revenue share on that.
So just come talk to us before you go do that. And that's how that's played out. So for Lama 2, I mean, we basically just have deals with all these major cloud companies and Lama 2 is available as a hosted service on all those clouds and everything. I assume that as we release bigger and bigger models, that'll become a bigger thing. It's not the main thing that we're doing, but I just think if those companies are going to be selling our models, it makes sense that we should share the upside of that somehow.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah. With regards to the other open source dangers, I think I have genuine legitimate points about the balance of power stuff and potentially the harms you can get rid of because we have better alignment techniques or something. I wish there was some sort of framework that Meta had. Other labs have this where they say, if we see this concrete thing, then that's a no-go on the open source or even potentially on deployment. Just writing it down so the company is ready for it, people have expectations around it and so forth.
Mark Zuckerberg
Yeah, no, I think that that's a fair point on the existential risk side. Right now, we focus more on the types of risks that we see today, which are more of these content risks. So we have lines on we don't want the model to be basically doing things that are helping people commit violence or fraud or just harming people in different ways. So In practice for today's models, and I would guess the next generation and maybe even the generation after that, I think while... It is somewhat more maybe intellectually interesting to talk about the existential risks. I actually think the real harms that need more energy being mitigated are things that are going to have someone take a model and do something to hurt a person with today's parameters and the types of more mundane harms that we see today. Like people... kind of committing fraud against each other or things like that. So that I just don't want to shortchange that. I think we have a responsibility to make sure we do a good job on that.
Dwarkesh Patel
Meta is a big company. You can handle both.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Dwarkesh Patel
okay so as far as the open source goes I'm actually curious if you think the impact of the open source from PyTorch React Open Compute these things has been bigger for the world than even the social media aspects of meta because I've like talked to people who use these services who think like it's plausible because a big part of the internet runs on these things um
Mark Zuckerberg
It's an interesting question. I mean, I think almost half the world uses our... Yeah. So I think it's hard to beat that. But no, I think open source is... It's really powerful as a new way of building things. And yeah, I mean, it's possible. I mean, it may be one of these things where... I don't know, like Bell Labs, right? Where they, you know, it's like they were working on the transistor because they wanted to enable long distance calling. And they did. And it ended up being really profitable for them that they were able to enable long distance calling. And if you ask them, five to ten years out from that um what was the most useful thing that they invented it's like okay well we enabled long distance calling and now all these people are long distance calling but if you ask a hundred years later maybe it's a different question so um i think that that's true of a lot of the things that we're building right reality labs um some of the ai stuff some of the open source stuff i think it's like the specific products evolve and to some degree come and go but i think like the advances for humanity persist and that's like a i don't know a cool part of what we
Dwarkesh Patel
all get to do um by when will the llama models be trained on your own custom silicon um
Mark Zuckerberg
Soon. Not Lama 4. The approach that we took is first we basically built custom silicon that could handle inference for our ranking and recommendation type stuff. So reels, newsfeed, ads. And that was consuming a lot of GPUs. But when we were able to move that to our own silicon, we now were able to use the more expensive NVIDIA GPUs only for training. So at some point, we will hopefully have silicon ourselves that we can be using for probably first training some of the simpler things, then eventually training these really large models. But in the meantime, I'd say the program is going quite well and we're just rolling it out methodically and have a long-term roadmap for it.
Dwarkesh Patel
Final question. This is totally out of left field, but if you were made CEO of Google+, could you have made it work? Google+, oof.
Mark Zuckerberg
Well, I don't know. I don't know. That's a very difficult, very difficult counterfactual.
Dwarkesh Patel
Okay, then the real final question will be when Gemini was launched, was there any chance that somebody in the office uttered Carthaga Delinda Est?
Mark Zuckerberg
No. I think we're tamer now.
Dwarkesh Patel
Cool, cool.
Mark Zuckerberg
Awesome, Mark. Yeah, I don't know. It's a good question. I don't know. The problem is there was no CEO of Google+. It was just like a division within a company. I think it's like, and you asked before about what are the kind of scarcest commodities, but you asked about it in terms of dollars. And I actually think for most companies, it's of this scale, at least, it's focus, right? It's like when you're a startup, maybe you're more constrained on capital, right? Um, you know, you, you just are working on one idea and you, you might not have all the resources. I think you cross some threshold at some point where the nature of what you're doing, you, you're building multiple things and you're creating more value across them, but you become more constrained on what can you direct and to go well.
And like, there's always the cases where something just random awesome happens in the organization. I don't even know about it. And those are, that's great. But like, but I think in general, organization's capacity is largely limited by what like the ceo and the and the management team are able to kind of oversee and and kind of manage it's i think that that's just been a a big focus for us it's like all right keep the as as i guess ben horowitz says keep the main thing the main thing right and and try to kind of stay focused on your key priorities.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah. All right. Awesome. That was excellent, Mark. Thanks so much. That was a lot of fun. Yeah, really fun. Thanks for having me. Absolutely. Hey, everybody. I hope you enjoyed that episode with Mark. As you can see, I'm now doing ads. So if you're interested in advertising on the podcast, go to the link in the description. Otherwise, as you know, the most helpful thing you can do is just share the podcast with people who you think might enjoy it. You know, your friends, group chats, Twitter, I guess threads. Yeah, I hope you enjoyed and I'll see you on the next one.