The main topic of this podcast episode is the concept of "Taking Children Seriously," an educational philosophy that views children as rational, creative, and capable beings who should be treated with respect and autonomy. The guest, Sarah Fitz-Clarege, is a writer, coach, and speaker who has developed this philosophy and has spoken about it around the world.
Key points discussed in the episode include:
Takeaways from the episode include:
The participants in the episode are the host and Sarah Fitz-Clarege, who is a writer, coach, and speaker who has developed the Taking Children Seriously philosophy. The conversation is engaging and thought-provoking, and raises important questions about the way we treat and educate children.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge is a writer, coach, and speaker with a fallibilist worldview. She started the journal that became Taking Children Seriously in the early 1990s after being surprised by the heated audience reactions she was getting when talking about children. She has spoken all over the world about her educational philosophy, and you can find transcripts of some of her talks on her website.
Watch on YouTube. Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or any other podcast platform.
Episode website here.
Sarah's Website: https://www.fitz-claridge.com/
Follow Sarah on Twitter. Follow me on Twitter for updates.
Dwarkesh Patel
What children should be learning is what they want, is what interests them, is how to solve problems. They don't learn that by being institutionalized for 12 years and bossed about by an authoritarian teacher who doesn't know very much. It's an insane idea.
Hey folks, and welcome to the Lunar Society podcast. Today, I have the great pleasure of talking with Sarah Fitz-Claridge. Sarah is a writer, coach, and speaker with a fallibilist worldview. She started a journal that became Taking Children Seriously in the early 1990s after being surprised by the heated audience reactions she was getting when talking about children. She has spoken all over the world about her educational philosophy, and you can find transcripts of some of her talks on her website at Fitz-Claridge.com. The link to that will also be in the description.
We had a very interesting conversation. I'm broadly sympathetic with Sarah's worldview, though I do have my differences, so I had a lot of fun playing devil's advocate. But whether you agree with her or not, Sarah is an incredibly original and first principles thinker about how our society treats children. So without further ado, here's Sarah Fitz-Claridge.
Sarah, can you explain what Taking Children Seriously is?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Taking Children Seriously is an educational philosophy that takes seriously the idea that human beings are fallible, and that includes parents. So instead of interacting with our children coercively, we are trying to create consent with them. We're trying to find solutions to problems that don't involve coercion, because coercion decides issues under an irrational institution. It embodies the theory that might makes right, which is false. So we don't do that.
It's actually a new view of children. The standard view of children is a bit like the view of women before they were emancipated, or black people when they were slaves in America. It's not that they're not people—they are people—but they're not quite able to control their own lives. They need a benevolent patriarchal parent, husband, or slave master to make sure nothing goes wrong for them. It's not that parents are trying to be dictators over their children; it's just that the whole world has this view that children are not quite the same as the rest of us. They're not quite rational and creative, so we need to manage and control them to make sure they turn out to be citizens who can be responsible for themselves.
I think instead that children are creative and rational from birth. We're born with human minds, not just animal minds. It doesn't make sense to think in terms of rationality and creativity being turned on at some later stage. It's there from the beginning. How does a baby learn language if they're not creative and rational? So Taking Children Seriously is a non-coercive educational theory. It's about raising children in a way that doesn't involve coercion.
Dwarkesh Patel
Just for the audience, my position currently is somewhere between yours and the conventional view. So hopefully you can nudge me closer to your view. One obvious counter-argument is that when it came to women or other races, we viewed them as a different kind of thing. But children are literally a different kind of thing, right? They're biologically different from adults. Doesn't this mean that they are entitled to different rights, perhaps fewer rights?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
That is the same circular argument that was used in the past about women and black people. "Well, their skin is black, so obviously they're not the same as the rest of us." "Well, they're women, so obviously there's an actual difference there." It's the same circular argument. It doesn't make any sense.
Dwarkesh Patel
[Attempts to interject]
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
I think there will come a time in the future when people will look back at how we view children now and they will be as horrified by that as we are when we look back at the arguments people made in the past about black people and women.
Dwarkesh Patel
I actually do agree with that, especially given how the schooling system works. But to continue that argument: between different races, these are superficial differences. Between different genders, they're not entirely superficial but they're minimal when compared to the difference between a two-year-old and an 18-year-old. There seems to be such a difference in the kind of person we're talking about. It's entirely likely that a chimp is smarter than a two-year-old right now. Why is a chimp not entitled to the same rights against coercion?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
No, that's false. In the relevant sense, children of whatever age are the same because we have creativity and rationality. If you're talking about a baby who's just been born and knows nothing except genetic knowledge, like an animal has, that's basically all they have. But that child, by the time they are two years old, will be speaking and doing many other things that a chimp or any other animal will never do. That's because of this creativity and rationality. Something has happened in those two years—the child has been forming inexplicit conjectures about what words mean, about what we call different things, and about a huge number of other things. It's not just language. A chimp or whatever animal is doing none of those things.
If your question is suggesting that I'm saying leave a baby to its own devices, that's not what I'm saying. I'm talking about coercion versus not coercion. I'm not saying we don't assist our children. Of course we do. And we do know more than a baby. The question is, what do we do with this greater knowledge? Do we think it justifies coercing the child or not? When you're coercing, you're basically saying might makes right, and it doesn't.
Dwarkesh Patel
It would be useful to define coercion in this context. How do you think about coercion of children? What does that mean?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Coercion is causing someone to do something or not do something against their will, roughly speaking. There is more to it than that—we can look at more subtle issues—but basically, you're imposing your will on someone else against their will.
Dwarkesh Patel
I remember vaguely that they did an experiment where chimps and children were given something like an IQ test, but a very basic one. It turned out that chimps actually had higher working memory. But they obviously have a lower capacity to learn. Learning requires creativity. So the reason children are entitled to a right against coercion is because of the fact that they can learn, as opposed to just their pure intelligence. It's that they are creative and rational beings. A chimp has genetic knowledge which allows a certain range of behaviors and things it can learn, but it's limited. Human creativity is not limited, and that applies equally to children as it does to adults.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Although a two-year-old is limited, right? They can't do anything an adult human can do. Why don't these limits entail certain limitations on the rights that child has?
Dwarkesh Patel
I would say that children actually are more creative and rational than adults, not less. Especially young children. If you look at the enormous amount of stuff young children learn and how difficult it is for many adults to learn things, if anything, they have more creativity and rationality, not less.
If we're going to apply that criterion, there are many things adults can do that children can't. One of them is having formal verbal arguments and reasoning through different possibilities. You can talk to an adult and say, "Is this career choice the best for you?" and go through reasons, pros and cons. You really can't do that with a toddler. People would say this is the basic definition of rationality—can we engage in a conversation where we're both able to make explicit our positions and go through the different parts of our argument? We can't do that with children.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Actually, we can. But if you just define rationality to exclude young children, then obviously you're going to say young children are irrational. But rationality means your ability to actually learn and create new knowledge. As I said, babies are clearly rational because they learn language. That's clear evidence of rationality.
Dwarkesh Patel
We'll have to come back to that because that's going to be a longer discussion. Let's talk about something we probably both agree on: the treatment of people who are teenagers or younger, and the impact mandatory schooling has on people within this age range. I would say that people in this age range should have a presumption against coercion, and that the schooling system is a real affront to their rights against coercion.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
One thing I want to say about that is, if you're imagining you can raise a child from birth with a coercive, top-down, authoritarian dictatorship sort of relationship, and then suddenly switch at whatever age you think they become rational in your sense, by that time you've already wrecked your relationship with your child. We need to start from the beginning with a view of children as rational, creative, and reasonable, rather than thinking you can just change course at some later stage.
Dwarkesh Patel
Is that true? Most parents raise their kids, at least to a certain age, as if they are inferior to them and they must obey them. Most kids have a healthy relationship with their parents—maybe not healthy in the way you would define it, but they don't resent them in any explicit sense. There's not animosity there.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
I think there is actually a lot of resentment. I'm not sure I would say animosity, but there is a lot of resentment between parents and children, both ways. Parents as well, because they have this view of children that is not correct. It does create friction and pits parents and child against each other. It causes problems. Instead of solving problems, you're coercing the child. Sometimes parents who have this authoritarian mindset also tend to be self-sacrificing with their children. They think, "I've got to do this for my child," but it's not that the child is requesting something and they are sacrificing in that way. With coercion tends to come self-sacrifice. The whole thing is not rational. When problems aren't solved, it hurts people. That includes the parents as well, not just the children.
Dwarkesh Patel
Can you talk about what education would look like if you were parenting somebody or within a school-like context? How should children be educated?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Children should be supported to learn whatever they want to learn and however they want to learn it. Very few children would actually want to go to school. School is such an inefficient way of learning anything, and it's so authoritarian. The whole structure of the school system is incredibly authoritarian. I think the vast majority of children, if not under psychological or other pressure to lie, would say they definitely wouldn't choose to go to school. They might choose to go to some kind of formal education later when they have decided they want to become a doctor, for example. Then obviously they're going to go through formal education, but that might not happen until later. And it's not mandatory in the same sense.
Dwarkesh Patel
Absolutely not.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
The child gets to choose. The school system is a throwback to the past when people were trying to turn out good factory workers. We're in our knowledge-based society now. We're not looking for good factory workers who will obey and do mindless tasks. We're looking for people who are creative, who come up with new ideas that will solve problems so the world will be improved and progress will be made and suffering will be ended. The school system just damps down people's creativity. It's stultifying for the majority of people.
Dwarkesh Patel
The objection people have to this view is that even if you want people to be creative and come up with their own ideas, there's a certain base of knowledge they need to engage with problems on the frontier in the first place. Children are just not going to want to go through the preliminary steps necessary to get up to that high level where they can solve their own problems. Therefore, you need to coerce them at a younger age to learn the basics so they can eventually become creative.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
The problem with this "body of knowledge" idea is that if everyone has the same body of knowledge, where are the new ideas going to come from? In the past, before schools, new ideas came from people whose history was completely different from other people's, who had learned something for the sheer joy of learning that thing. They didn't think, "I have to study this body of knowledge, this foundation of knowledge, and then I'll have all the ideas I need to come up with something new." New ideas are more likely to come from people who haven't got the same body of knowledge as everyone else. I just think that idea is a mistake.
Dwarkesh Patel
Furthermore, even if that idea was true, the idea that the modern schooling system or anything that closely resembles it gives you a useful body of knowledge in the first place is rebutted by visiting school for one day. You're memorizing the difference between alliteration and assonance, or what date this battle was fought, while some person drones on. The idea that this level of coercion—deciding when you can use a bathroom or when you can eat—is necessary to give people a basic foundation to interact with the world seems improbable to me.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
I'm 100% with you.
Dwarkesh Patel
Brian Kaplan, who was actually my first guest on this podcast, wrote a book called *The Case Against Education* and he homeschools his own kids. The basic idea is that people are much less educated than you would expect given the 12 years of mandatory schooling they have. People don't know the basics about how government works, or the basics about math or science, once they leave college, to an astonishing degree. One thing he did say, though, was when he homeschools his kids, the one thing he coerces his children to learn is mathematics. He has noticed that children in the unschooling movement seem fine in every way except for the fact that they struggle with even basic arithmetic. He supposes that children are just not going to want to go through the basic steps of math, and math is an important subject required in many problem areas. So it's important to coerce your children to learn math.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
For a start, I don't think it's true that children taken seriously don't know how to do arithmetic. I think that's ridiculous. I don't know which unschoolers he's talking about. Some of them do have some strange ideas, such as not allowing children to learn or trying to stop them learning stuff until later. But in terms of the mathematics idea that we must coerce our children to learn mathematics, for a start, I disagree that most people need mathematics. I don't think that's true. To the extent that it is true, people learn it naturally anyway.
This idea is patently false if you think about it. Every new idea in mathematics, every discovery in the field of mathematics, was discovered by someone who was not being coerced to learn maths. It was discovered by someone who found mathematics a joy, a delight, fascinating. That's how they came to discover it. It might be the case that most people don't feel like that about mathematics, but probably a lot of that is to do with the horrendous coercion in school about mathematics. It's enough to give anyone a lifelong aversion to it. Even apart from that, assuming it's true that most people just are not into maths, most people don't need maths. I just don't think it's true that we have to coerce anyone to learn anything. People who haven't been coerced, who've been taken seriously, have no trouble at all learning whatever they need to learn when they realize they need it. We don't need to go through 12 years of torture, or even a year or two of torture at home with home education under coercion, to learn mathematics. That's ridiculous.
Dwarkesh Patel
I'm of two minds on this. On the one hand, I think you're right. I remember reading about a superintendent who decided that children would not be required to learn math before the seventh grade. It turned out that the children who learned math in the seventh grade were no more behind after eighth grade than the people who had been learning math since first grade. So maybe you can pick it up at a later date. But I worry. There will always be people motivated to learn math, and maybe for those people who are going to make advancements in mathematical knowledge, they'll be able to do that without a coercive education system. But what about the people who would want to become programmers, but realize by the time they become 18 that they just don't have a strong enough grasp on mathematical concepts to take further steps towards becoming an engineer, or even towards balancing their budget?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
I don't think that's true. I think that when people are pursuing their own interests, it just all happens naturally. If someone wants to be a programmer or an engineer or a doctor, and maybe they only suddenly realize this later on in their childhood—although I think in many cases people have this kind of drive earlier on—even if it is later, people can learn later. For example, Karl Popper's PhD thesis was not in philosophy, it was in educational psychology, and yet he became one of the most important philosophers ever. That's an example of someone who changed his direction relatively late in his life. I think the same is true for maths. I just don't agree with Brian Caplan about this.
Dwarkesh Patel
I do agree with you that the presumption shouldn't be to just coerce children in case it happens to help them. My position is probably a little milder than yours, but I think there should be a very good reason to coerce children, not just in case they happen to need this skill.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
If there's a very good reason, surely you can persuade your child of that reason if it is a good reason.
Dwarkesh Patel
Children are not known for being easily persuaded.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Maybe that's because of the way they are thwarted left and right throughout their childhood, and so they don't trust the adults around them. How is a child who's been thwarted and coerced their whole childhood to know when you're saying something that actually is important, that is actually in their interest, rather than just another thwarting for some silly reason?
Dwarkesh Patel
Another worry about this way of raising children is the view that school teaches people, even if the knowledge itself is not useful or necessary, just the act of getting instruction and following it teaches people self-control, discipline, executive function. It lets them know how to engage with authority and with hierarchy when they enter the real world. So they'll know how to interact with their boss or exist within the company, within the community.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
That's ridiculous. To the extent that they will encounter authority in work situations later on, they can learn how to navigate that kind of thing then. The idea of teaching children self-discipline by coercing them, by disciplining them, is an equivocation on the word "discipline." It's suggesting that the self-discipline that a concert pianist or an MMA fighter has is the thing you instill by coercing children. That's rubbish. In the case of the Olympic athlete or the MMA fighter or the concert pianist, this is something they live for. It's their own passion, and they are pursuing it fully, wholeheartedly. That is a completely different thing from disciplining children. Disciplining children says, "Don't pursue your passions wholeheartedly. You need to do what I say." It's the opposite. It's actually training children not to be able to follow their passions with full heart and really go for it.
Dwarkesh Patel
That's a good point. There's a concern that why should we expect the passions that children have to reflect the actual skills and knowledge they should have to function well in the world? People have plenty of passions, but maybe there are certain things children need to learn regardless of what their passions are, and the child is not in a good place to understand what these things are because they have not been exposed to the world yet to know what problem situations will arise.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
If you have a non-coercive relationship with your children, then you can talk about these things. You can express your concerns about needing to know this because of that. You can have a conversation. You can persuade by reason. If you just impose it, the child probably is still not agreeing with you. The effect of that is not predictable. You might find that these little bits of coercion that you want to get in there because you're worried about some future thing that might never happen sort of make everything go wrong in the present. What matters is how we're living in the present. We can have goals and things we think are important for the future, and we can have those conversations.
But if you're making life miserable in the present, then what you're teaching the child is that life is miserable and that you can't actually solve problems or get what you want, so you might as well just give up. That is not conducive to anything important the child will want to do. Doing something important doesn't help to have coercion added to it. It tells the child that he can't trust himself, that he has to just live for the approval of someone else. That's not the kind of state of mind that concert pianist or Olympic athlete is in.
Dwarkesh Patel
Is there where we can actually know the psychological impact of the conventional way of raising children? I am skeptical that it has a traumatic effect on most people. Changing people's personality or the way they interact with the world is very hard to do. There's a lot of literature with twin studies where twins separated at birth and adopted by different parents, regardless of how different the parents are, the twins are usually pretty similar even if raised in different households. So I'm skeptical that raising children this way will make them significantly different than they would have been otherwise. That doesn't mean it justifies the current treatment of children—you don't change adults by coercing them, but that still doesn't make the coercion of adults okay. But it does mean I doubt there's some deep psychological harm done by the conventional approach.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Suppose you're right that it makes no difference. Does that make immoral behavior unobjectionable? No.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah, that's what I said.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
When it comes to adults, we're not looking at the adult and saying, "Well, there's no ill effect from coercing my wife. I think she needs to be kept under control. Show me the studies that show there's a bad effect, so it's fine." Obviously, when it comes to adults, we don't use those arguments. We don't say, "The research shows that corporal punishment of children causes a problem later, and therefore you probably shouldn't do it." We don't say that when it comes to adults. We say it's wrong to hit someone. So thinking about the effects is not the point. That is an example of this different view we have of children that I think is a mistake.
Dwarkesh Patel
You don't get to lock somebody up for 11 years in an institution and say it's not a big deal because we can't tell if there's any long-lasting effects from that. That's an immoral argument. You wouldn't make the same argument about an adult.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Right.
Dwarkesh Patel
So how do you respond to the needs and wants of a very young child who might have unreasonable demands, or even a nonverbal toddler where it's hard to know what the needs and desires are?
Well, for a start, I don't think it's unreasonable. As I said, I think that children have reason just like we do. So with pre-verbal children, I think this is another example of the difference in view. Most people have this view of babies as just being unreasonable and crying and so on. They're not paying attention to the signals that the baby is giving. The baby's signals are ignored, and so the baby starts really screaming. Then parents do things like, "I'm going to force the child to learn to sleep through the night by ignoring her cries."
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
The problem with that is, number one, you're teaching the baby that the baby can't have an effect on the world, that problems are not soluble. But also, as I say, you are causing this conflict-ridden relationship to be created. Whereas if you're taking your baby seriously, then you're paying attention and you are trying to make conjectures about what it is that the baby might be wanting or not wanting. You're responding positively at a much earlier stage, and so you don't have the screaming. The terrible twos and temper tantrums—that doesn't happen if you're taking your children seriously. It just doesn't happen, because you're never getting to where it's that kind of a problem. You're actually responsive to your child.
Dwarkesh Patel
You have more experience with children than I do, so I'll defer to you there. I just don't have a strong position on how children turn out based on how they're raised. My null hypothesis is that, until I see the evidence that it makes a difference, or the evidence that kids won't have temper tantrums if they're raised this way, it seems safe to assume that they will. But you probably have experience in life that will let me know otherwise.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Why would someone end up that upset if their needs weren't being ignored at a much earlier stage?
Dwarkesh Patel
I guess you're going to ask the same thing. Let's take a person who's an adult but is mentally ill. He might have tantrums. You could say a better explanation for what's going on is that he's just mentally ill. There are probably some things that are upsetting him, but the proximal cause of his tantrums is the fact that he's mentally ill. You can say the same thing about a two-year-old. There might be things that are upsetting him or her, but the proximal explanation is just that these are the terrible twos.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
It's not true. That is a myth. If you do raise children non-coercively, you will discover that's just a myth.
Dwarkesh Patel
Yeah, I'll have to find out if I mess up at some point.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
When you're paying attention to your very young child, then you're noticing when people are not completely happy, when there's a problem. You see it in their eyes. Why is the parent not noticing that there's a problem until the child is in a screaming, traumatic, traumatized state on the floor? Why is that happening? It doesn't need to happen. It just doesn't need to happen. Children who have experience of their needs being met and not being thwarted trust that their needs are going to be met.
Dwarkesh Patel
My parents' philosophy on this—they explained it to me at some point, and you'll disagree with this very much—their idea was if you respond to tantrums, you're teaching the child that the way you get a response is by throwing a tantrum. Whereas if you ignore the tantrums and then respond to the child when he or she is being more reasonable, then you're teaching the child that tantrums are not the way you get what you want. If you're in another mood, then that's the way you should interact with the world.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Using dog training techniques on children is immoral. If you think about it from a young child's perspective, what that is doing when you are shunning them, ignoring them, you're basically withdrawing love. For a young child, that is absolutely terrifying. I think that if parents could put themselves in their young children's minds and see how it is for those children, I don't think that they would want to do that. We are not animals—I mean we are animals, but we have a human mind. The question is whether you want to be training your children by dog training techniques, by behaviorist operant conditioning or classical conditioning, or whether you want to use reason. Coercion decides issues under an irrational institution, and so you can't get the right answer that way.
Dwarkesh Patel
One objection that I've encountered when I talk about these ideas is that people worry that children in their natural state are uncurious, lazy, or not necessarily lazy but just unmotivated by the kinds of things that would probably make them have a better life when they're adults. They would probably spend all day watching TV or playing video games. They aren't going to do the things that we would optimistically hope they would do with their free time if we just let them non-coercively spend their days. They're not going to be exploring and learning and reading.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Speaking as one who was raised in the standard way, not the way I'm suggesting, I tried to do everything I could to escape from the coercion and the fighting. My time was school and homework and ballet lessons and piano lessons and violin lessons and acrobatics and all the other stuff. I would escape to my room whenever I could. In my case, this was before computers and computer games, so it was reading. I think it's in no way surprising if children raised in the standard way need an escape into things like video games. Who wouldn't? It helps people to relax and calm down. I think that a lot of what you might see as laziness or doing something mindless—although actually I don't think it's mindless at all, I think it's very educational to play video games—is just needing to calm down from all the stress of life in the coercive family and with all the schooling.
So for a start, I don't think it's true that children left to their own devices—not coerced—would do nothing but play video games. But even if they wanted to do that, I think that might well be a positive thing. It is possible that it could be a negative thing. It could be that a child has no other real options, in which case that's a mistake. The parent is not giving the child enough real options that are interesting, that engage the child's interest and attention. But apart from that, with that caveat, I think that doing things like playing video games and watching television are incredibly educational. If an alien came from outer space, what would the quickest way to learn about our culture be? It would probably be watching soap operas on television rather than someone trying to teach them in a school situation. They would learn much more from watching television than they would get from lessons about it.
I think people are mistaken about how educational these things are, and it's completely mistaken to think that children who aren't coerced are not curious. It's entirely the opposite. Do we not notice how children's curiosity when they're young seems to just disappear in their later childhood? Could it not be something to do with the way that they're educated and raised?
Dwarkesh Patel
It would be astonishing if millions of years of evolution decided that the best way to produce a survival machine would be to have something that lays around for the first 18 years of its life and does nothing. From first principles, you can anticipate that there's probably a reason we spend the first part of our life as children. You would just expect evolution to have trained us to be curious and to explore, because that's probably the reason we're children in the first place.
As far as the video games go, I always tell my friends when they make this objection that they're just going to play video games all day: where's the evidence that this is any worse a way to spend time than going to school? If you just look at the studies on the efficacy of school, they're wasting their time there anyway. But the fact is that they're suffering while they're spending their time there, so at least they're not suffering while they're playing video games.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
I think it's more positive than that, but yes. What children should be learning is what they want, what interests them, how to solve problems. They don't learn that by being institutionalized for 12 years and bossed about by an authoritarian teacher who doesn't know very much. It's an insane idea.
Dwarkesh Patel
I think back to my years in schooling, and the amount of not only wasted time where I was bored or just didn't want to be there, but also the opportunity cost—the things I could have learned at a much younger age.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
There's also the fact that children have a different sleep cycle than adults, so they're sleep deprived, and that's probably messing up their development. There's also the fact that you're using all their time with homework and schoolwork. In the US, it's like an average of three hours a day of homework, after eight hours of schooling. Where's the time for the child to do the kinds of things that would make them grow and help them develop? As Pollyanna said in the book of the same name, "When will I have time to live?" That was after her aunt had told her that she was going to be having lessons in the morning.
Dwarkesh Patel
Another point from the twin studies literature actually makes the case against the sort of coercion of children. If forcing your kid to take Taekwondo lessons, making them go to school, getting them extra tutoring and homework—if this stuff doesn't make a difference anyway, why are you making your child suffer in this way?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
I think all these expedient arguments and trying to make a science of it are a mistake. We didn't end slavery because the studies said such and such. We didn't emancipate women because the studies said such and such. The arguments were moral and philosophical. I think people can get into some very dark territory when they start thinking that they can turn everything into a science that isn't science—it's scientism.
Dwarkesh Patel
Speaking of the treatment of women, one question to ask is: how could it be that every society that has ever existed has been wrong on this very basic moral question? But the response is that every society before the enlightenment, before like 100 years ago, was very wrong on the treatment of women. So it's not that surprising that societies would universally get a moral question wrong. Now the response is: well, at least there was a way where one part of the population did not have to experience the pain of another part of the population, and so could oppress them in this way. But when it comes to children, we've all been children. If we all experienced the coercion and the trauma of the conventional way of raising children, why are we not realizing that as adults?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
With regard to how this could have evolved, you might want to read David Deutsch's *The Beginning of Infinity*. I think it's Chapter 16, "The Evolution of Creativity." I think the interesting thing is how we got from a static society to the enlightenment and creativity and all the rest of it. I think of taking children seriously as like the final phase of the enlightenment—or maybe not the final phase, but it is certainly one area that we haven't applied enlightenment thinking to. I think that in time, people will look back on 2021 and how people viewed children, and they will be as horrified as we are when we look back at how women were viewed in the past.
Dwarkesh Patel
Do you have an idea for why, despite having been children ourselves, when we grow up to become adults, most people still adopt the same authoritarian practices that they experienced themselves and presumably suffered from?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
This is something that is in *The Beginning of Infinity* by David Deutsch—the idea of anti-rational memes. Rational memes replicate themselves with criticism. Criticism doesn't hurt a rational meme; it's wonderful for a rational meme to be under critical scrutiny. But anti-rational memes disable their holder's ability to criticize them. People brought up in this anti-rational way develop the same hang-ups, the same anti-rational memes, that cause them to do the same thing to their children. Not that it's a hundred percent. If you're aware of the idea of anti-rational memes, you can criticize and, using creativity, at least to some extent overcome them. That's how we have, over the years, things have liberalized somewhat for children. But we still have this view of children that is pre-enlightenment. So yes, anti-rational memes is an explanation for why people grow up and do the same thing to their children.
Dwarkesh Patel
Is there a way you expect the evolution of these ideas will go? Will it be enabled by, for example, in the United States and maybe elsewhere as well, there's a growth of something called Montessori schools, which kind of approximate this philosophy of children, where they can and will learn just by their own curiosity. How do you expect this movement to grow?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
I think that the shift will come in a similar way to the shift that came when women were emancipated. It wasn't all in one go. Women got the vote—I don't know which order things happened in actually—but it didn't all happen at once. The idea of women in the culture changed gradually. Then there were certain things that happened, like women got the vote, that did make a difference. But for example, even in 1933, my own grandmother lost the job that she loved when she told her boss that she was getting married. She said that's just the way it was—if you were married, you couldn't have a job. So even in my grandmother's lifetime, things were still changing quite some time after women had got the vote in England. I think it's going to be a similar kind of thing.
I hope that my book might make a difference. Once you see this view—that our view of children is like our view of women was in the past and black people in the days of slavery—once you see that, you can't unsee it. It's sort of "wow." I think that people are going to start to see it, and then that's going to start making a difference. It'll be a sort of domino effect, and then gradually children will be taken seriously more and more.
Dwarkesh Patel
Is this book coming out soon?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
I keep thinking it's nearly finished, but I'm doing another rewrite. So I'm not sure when it will be, but I hope not too long.
Dwarkesh Patel
I'm excited to read it. I'd love to have you back on once it's published so we can talk about it.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Absolutely, love to.
Dwarkesh Patel
A question that occurred to me while you were talking about the treatment of women. One of the ways that society coerced women and oppressed them was they weren't allowed to work, because they were seen as incapable of making the decision to work or to be able to perform well. Should we get rid of child labor laws if this similar kind of coercion and similar kinds of rights are also to be expected of children?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
I suspect—and this is just a conjecture, although I am a libertarian, I'm not a utopian libertarian, I'm a Popperian libertarian, so I don't actually know what the future will look like—but I would imagine that at some point in the future some of these things will change. The child labor laws definitely do cause problems for young entrepreneurs. I've met someone who was a brilliant person and started a business at the age of 11, and he had to lie about his age. Now he's been banned from that particular online financial service that he was using because he lied about his age. Those laws do make it very difficult for children. Although it's weird because when I was a child, lots of children worked—not in full-time jobs because obviously they were at school—but lots of children worked a lot more than they do now, especially in America. I think that's one of the things that will change.
Dwarkesh Patel
People have this idea, because of when child labor laws were banned, of the kind of dangerous jobs that children were doing. But that's not the kind of jobs that 11-year-olds would be doing if they were allowed to now. Just imagine the job that a 14-year-old does when he's allowed to—like a clerk at HEB or Walmart. He would just be allowed to do that at 11. I would expect that that's far more pleasing to the child than to be forced to stay in an institution, whereas he gets to choose to work and he gets paid for his labor. He has a voluntary relationship with his boss and so on.
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
Obviously in the past, parents forced their children to work in dangerous conditions out of desperation for survival. The people who brought in those labor laws obviously had very good intentions. It's just that we're in a different problem situation now, and certainly going into the future, things will be different. I'm sure that will change.
Dwarkesh Patel
How about sexual consent laws? Age of consent laws?
Sarah Fitz-Claridge
At the moment, because people have this view of children that is problematic, those laws do at least try to protect children. But I can imagine some time in the distant future when children are taken just as seriously as everyone else is taken, when they might also not be needed. I think that any kind of sexual relationship where there is a differential of power and authority is going to be dangerous. I don't know what it will be like in the future, so I'm just speculating. But many of these laws obviously were needed to protect children, and maybe still are in some respects, but may not be in the future when children are taken seriously.