Main Topic: The Great Debate: Micro Niche vs Generalist, Outbound vs Inbound with Charles Speck.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Additional Insights:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Strap in as we venture into the specialized realms of insurance agent branding: micro-niche vs generalist.
✅ Free step-by-step video series for generating inbound revenue for your insurance business from YouTube: https://go.ryanhanley.com/youtube
✅ For daily insights and ideas on peak performance: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryanhanley
✅ Subscribe to the audio podcast here: https://ryanhanley.com/podcast
✅ Charles Specht's LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/charlesspecht/
🌐 Charles Specht's Website: www.permissionsales.com
** More about this episode **
Have you ever felt like a small fish in the vast ocean of business? That's where the magic of micro-niching comes into play – a concept we dissect fervently in our latest episode.
Together with a special guest from the insurance world, we lay out how pinpointing your ideal client not only sharpens your brand but also draws in the behemoths of your industry. From personal coaching tales to our guests' experiences, we uncover that aligning with your customer's mindset is as crucial as getting your branding on point.
Property and casualty agents, this one’s for you: we examine how zeroing in on a specific segment, like pallet companies, can create a magnetic presence that pulls in tailored content and services like a gravitational force. But don't be fooled; it's not all about the industry lingo; we share the surprising truth that sometimes, a stellar marketing strategy and understanding your client's perspective can trump deep industry knowledge.
Wrapping up, we take a peek behind the curtain of sales team structures and the mighty influence of incentives on marketing efforts.
Our guest shares incredible insights from PermissionSales.com and dishes out success stories that prove why the right motivation can make or break your agency's growth. And we can't forget about the soul of business – our guest illustrates how intertwining faith with professional pursuits can elevate the bottom line and the spirit behind your brand.
Join us for an episode that's brimming with strategies to help your agency not just survive but thrive.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
I'm in a horse race. I don't want the prettiest horse. I want the fastest one. I don't care. I want the fastest horse. And if I've got access to a carrier right now that's just really good at one or two things, I'm going to ride that horse. And my micro-niche might switch a year from now. That's okay. Most agents pivot. That's okay. We can pivot. But what are we riding right now? I want to win as many races as I can. And so I want the fastest horse after all is said and done. Because like I said, micro-niching a lot. I'd say the first part of it, fairly superficial when it just comes to branding. But we have to figure out what we want to go after. The size of the account is usually going to be a big issue.
In a crude laboratory in the basement of his home.
Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the show. Today we have a tremendous episode for you. The Great Debate, Micro Niche versus Generalist, Outbound versus Inbound with the man, Charles Specht. Charles is the producer of the Millionaire Insurance Producer Podcast. He is the president and CEO of the Permission Network. And his coaching and consulting program is all about building micro niche production business. So helping producers through permission groups, you can go to permissiongroup.com, helping producers learn how to build a micro niche or as we discussed, multiple.
Charles is a great guy. I love having conversations with him. He is thoughtful and well thought out. He has an opinion. He has real production, real clients behind his thought process, which is who I love debating. I do not like people who just come at me with this traditionalist opinion based on the fact that we've done it this way for this many years and you don't understand. This is how I add value. That's all nonsense. What I want is someone who has done it, has done it a different way, who has success stories, case studies, et cetera. And Charles is that guy.
We go back and forth on LinkedIn every once in a while, all in good natured fun. But this is a really great conversation. You are going to get so much out of this. I know I did. I took two pages of notes during this conversation, just comparing and contrasting how Charles recommends and who he recommends his work to, versus my vantage point. I think what we get to in the end is a really solid business model for how you put our two philosophies together in a way that can rapidly grow agencies. I loved it. Love this conversation and happy to share Charles with you guys. If you're not following him, I highly recommend that you do.
When you listen to this, my friends, the Insurance Growth Masterclass will be live. It is live right now. Go to masterclass.insure. That's masterclass.insure today. You can learn more. You can join the program. Guys, this is my life's work in the insurance industry put into coursework, monthly lectures, a community, all sorts of free resources, an exclusive newsletter, et cetera. I want to help you build this inbound engine in your agency. If you're an individual producer and you want to add inbound to what you're doing, you can learn that too. But I'm telling you this, what I'm teaching in the masterclass is going to be innovative. It's going to be on the cutting edge. It's going to get you to think differently about your business.
In no way, so everyone who's listening knows this, and I'll say this a thousand times, I agree with everything Charles says. What I'm advocating for, what I'm teaching, what I'm coaching, the growth that I want to help agencies make is in this, is in the inbound side of the business, is entirely untapped, undeveloped, uncoached aspect of our industry and there is no one better positioned with more experience than myself to teach you. I hope you can tell from the tone of my voice and the pace at which I am talking right now how fired up I am to get this content in front of you. I've dripped it out at 10 and 15,000 feet in YouTube videos and podcasts and I will continue to do that. But if you want to come all the way to the ground, if you want to know how to get it done, if you want to be able to ask specific questions and get specific answers, the Insurance Growth Masterclass is my resource, my gift back to this industry to do that. I hope you will join today. Go to masterclass.insure. If you have questions, you can always email me at ryan at findingpeak.com.
Guys, with that, let's get on to the great debate, micro niche versus generalist with the all powerful, all seen Charles Specht. Here we go.
Transition to the interview
So what's going on, bud? I'm excited to have you on the show. I know the impetus was a few conversations we had on LinkedIn, and I want to get to that stuff, but I'm interested in what you have going on. I see you posting a lot of stuff about your mastermind, et cetera. What's up? Fill us in.
Charles Specht
Yeah, I appreciate that. Busy, kind of doing the same thing, but really just trying to accelerate what I've been doing. Getting a lot of people inside the mastermind where we're talking about how to 12X your book of business. From the standpoint of bigger accounts, how to prospect those, branding inside your micro niche, which is way better than being a generalist. I'm sure we'll probably talk about that a little bit. Just the whole idea of how do you accelerate yourself without having to have 300 clients.
Still working with a number of agencies on retainer, doing some work with Constructive Risk and my network of insurance consultants, doing one-on-one coaching. Right before I got on with you, I was finishing up a podcast episode with one of my clients. He went from a $700,000 book of business to two and a half million now in just about five years. He'll probably be at three million end of this year, just going after the same type of business, just making a switch in the size of the accounts that he's going after.
It's a mindset, really understanding your ideal client, having that really defined. The overarching topic of that one is that you just really get clear on what you say yes to and what you say no to. Then you just don't cross. Just really having a defined approach on what it is that you do and what you don't do. So yeah, man, just kind of doing the same stuff.
Ryan Hanley
I like that you started the conversation with a really good anchoring point around how good micro branding is or micro niche are and generalist does not. So that's a good anchoring point that I now need to work off of.
Charles Specht
Absolutely. And it's micro niche, by the way, because that rhymes with rich. Niche is like quiche and that's just weird.
Ryan Hanley
I don't know where that came from. I can't stop it. I've tried for years. Cass has made fun of me for almost a decade now. I seemingly can't figure out how to not flip-flop between niche and niche. I say both. I went back and I listened to the episode that kind of spurred us getting on here. The episode of the show was "Independent Agents Are Doing Riches in the Niches Wrong." It was a solo episode. The point I was trying to make in that episode is that while I think industry class and micro niches are all very important and I'm not advocating against that in any way, shape or form, I was trying to be additive to the conversation in a way to say, I think we also need to focus on mindset of customers.
Throughout my career, I think I've made tons of mistakes with niche or generalist, et cetera. I have different viewpoints on that that I want to get to. The thing that I think has defined where I've been successful and where I haven't is when I was really focused on the mindset of the customer, the client that I was trying to attract. I think that probably goes to your idea of be clear on what you're going to say no and say yes to. When our niche is a mindset, either in and of itself or as part of a niche or micro niche, I feel like it allows us to move even faster.
What I found specifically at Rogue was that when we marketed to and filtered out as qualified a certain mindset, our service requests went down and our retention went up because people believed in the way we were doing business versus someone who maybe was the right fit from an appetite perspective but maybe didn't believe in the business the same way. Some of that too is we had a different kind of model. So I think there's a lot of nuance in this, but where I'd like to start is what exactly is a micro niche and how is it different from a regular niche?
Charles Specht
Micro niche, I don't know exactly when I started to refer to it, eight, nine, ten years ago maybe. I looked at it from the standpoint of when I began to realize where producers were writing a lot of business, I realized they were different than me. I started in the insurance business at an agency where most of the agents there wrote subcontractors that were about $2,500 bucks a commission. Just $250, $300, $500. That's what we wrote. We just wrote a lot of contractors, fencing, HVAC, different stuff. Some people had some general contractors, but I was in construction.
When I ended up at my second agency, which was a large alphabet house, I had a really good year and got invited to the president's club. The president's club is the annual celebration where they bring in all the producers from around the globe who did more than $300,000 of new business. The chairman of the agency went down the line. He brought in the top 10 who wrote the most business that year. I remember him holding the microphone, walking down. There's like 3,000 people in the room. He goes, "Tell me what industry you're in." Then they say something. Next one, "Tell me what industry you're in."
It was so interesting. I was 24 years old at the time, only been in business for about two years. I was expecting them to say, "I'm an insurance agent." But no, what they were saying was — I just remember a few of the examples. One would say, "I am in the women's garment manufacturing industry." Another one said, "I work with general contractors who build casinos." Another one said, "I do property insurance for large franchise restaurants." I began to realize that the people with bigger books of business who are having greater success are much more narrow in their focus.
I look at myself as I am niched inside construction, but maybe if I micro niched, if I went a little bit more narrow or deeper, I might have the ability to write more accounts, write larger accounts, maybe get more broker record letters and have greater success, maybe because people will see me as the obvious choice. I think that's where it came from.
Ryan Hanley
I have a couple of questions there. Do you think that prospects actually see or care that you are a niche specialist? Or could it be that it is more of the confidence that you get as a producer in knowing that industry so specifically that is what the prospect is feeling? Does that make sense of the question? Like, do you think the prospect is like, "Oh, you're the specialist in this. I have to work with you." Or do you think it's because I know this space? I know pallet contractors so well that when I present myself, I'm confident and they pick up on that.
Charles Specht
I would say the answer is yes and yes. For the individual person, but I would say a whole lot more yes on the second part. When it comes down to it, micro-niching comes down to branding. We'll speak from a property and casualty standpoint. If I'm going to go after pallet accounts, I'm going to have to figure out what carriers are writing it. Let's say I find five carriers. I want to figure out what the differences are.
Ryan Hanley
[Interrupting] Sorry to take you away from the episode, but as you know, we do not run ads on this show. In exchange for that, I need your help. If you're loving this episode, if you enjoy this podcast, whether you're watching on YouTube or listening on your favorite podcast platform, I would love for you to subscribe, share, comment if you're on YouTube, leave a rating review if you're on Spotify or Apple iTunes. This helps the show grow. It helps me bring more guests in. We have a tremendous lineup of people coming in, men and women who've done incredible things, sharing their stories around peak performance, leadership, growth, sales, the things that are going to help you grow as a person and grow your business.
They all check out comments, ratings, reviews. They check out all this information before they come on. So as I reach out to more and more people and want to bring them in and share their stories with you, I need your help. Share the show, subscribe if you're not subscribed, and I'd love for you to leave a comment about the show because I read all the comments. Or if you're on Apple or Spotify, leave a rating review of this show. I love you for listening to this show and I hope you enjoy listening as much as I do creating the show for you. All right, I'm out of here. Peace. Let's get back to the episode.
Returning to the interview
Charles Specht
My branding around that. I might create my LinkedIn persona or my Instagram persona to be a guy who focuses on pallets. I might start doing some reels or some videos on how CEOs from pallet companies can find the right insurance agent or how CEOs at pallet companies can find three more productive hours in their week. I just really start branding myself in that area. A number of things happen. I start going to those association meetings. The associations want me to do webinars. People are responding to my content that I'm putting out on YouTube or my email because it's resonating with them more.
The first part of being a micro niche producer really comes down to branding. It's how you're presenting yourself out there. The next step is taking it to the point where you start developing services for them. I could put together a loss control program that's specific to pallet companies. I might put together a 12-video safety program for companies that are pallet companies for their guys who are picking up pallets so that they don't get slivers. I'm just thinking off the top of my head. I can start to create services for that.
What happens is that your reputation will get around. You will end up starting to write two accounts, three accounts. Before you know it, you've got 16 pallet companies. Now you kind of have a big brag statement. "I've got 16 different pallet companies that represent $4.7 million. I'm writing it because of this particular safety program that we have for pallet companies." It just starts to get momentum as you're going through it.
Ryan Hanley
No, I see it. I think that if that's what you want to do, I think part of my struggle with that is that bores the shit out of me personally. I also have hardcore ADHD. I look at that and I'm like, "Oh my God, if all I ever did was write the same line of business over and over and over again, I would want to shoot myself in the face." That's personal though. I a hundred percent believe in what you're saying from the standpoint of building a brand. When I talk about this topic, I am never arguing against what you just positioned. Never. I think what you just said is wholly accurate, 100%. If that is what you want to do and who you want to be, I think you're right on point and that makes complete and utter sense to me.
I think the argument that I want to make to the industry and what I have found so intriguing in terms of pushback, specifically from traditionalists — and this does not include you in the way that you position your argument — but there have been many others who love to take a stance on this when I say, "I would rather personally do everything you just said, but around a mindset agnostic of industry." Now I do think that at a certain size account, there are specializations in coverage that matter. But from my position, depending on what you consider big, most accounts are under $150,000 in premium. So I guess this would probably be smaller for you. You don't need to be a coverage specialist. They're all the same.
Charles Specht
Honestly, with standard carriers, the business kind of knows. Not too many differences in the coverages overall.
Ryan Hanley
I think this is a big — I don't want to say lie because that insinuates people are doing things nefariously, and I do not think that at all. I think it's something that we logically all know to be false, but we continue the myth because it feels good and it's what we've always been told. That a $100,000 premium warehouse is somehow different from a $100,000 premium law firm, which is somehow different from a $100,000 premium electrical contractor. My experience has always been in the smaller middle to small business market. That's where my expertise is. When I look at that space, which is the space that the majority of agents write in, I just don't think there's any difference in the coverage. Nor do I think there is enough significant difference that being over-indexing on any individual niche or micro niche plays any significant value at that size.
If you have a $100,000 pallet contractor and you're the expert, but I'm better at marketing and maybe I've also marketed that person on mindset and not just my industry knowledge, I think I can beat you the majority of the time. Larger accounts, I do not think that's the case. I think that things get squirrely. I think there are all kinds of nuance to the coverage. I think services matter immensely. Services don't matter on accounts that size. We offered early on at Rogue. I did a deal with a buddy of mine to offer nurse triage services for our workers comp accounts. I was all jacked up because I've seen all the stats. Nobody cared.
Charles Specht
Nobody cares.
Ryan Hanley
I've seen the stats. I know what it does for workers comp accounts. I believe in it. I have secret shopped them. They're great. I'm thinking I'm going to go to the market and take this enterprise level service and bring it down market to 10 to 30 employee accounts. They could give two flying shits. Honestly, it meant nothing to them. When you really did the math, it didn't help. There wasn't that significant of a discount.
Charles Specht
Even with that service though, work comp is just insurance. That's not micro niche. Everybody's got comp. Somebody might have a high X mod. They might have a low X mod. At the end of the day, I would tell you even most insurance buyers don't understand it. Most insurance agents don't understand comp and X mod. I agree with you. Smaller accounts, it's really hard to help them to see the significance of a service that you're offering if it's just purely insurance related because the pain isn't really there. If there's 17 carriers that are right in this business, they usually don't have a lot of pain from a premium standpoint. Having an additional work comp service, no big deal.
I agree when you start getting bigger, the services matter. But it's also on a case by case basis. There are definitely insurance buyers out there who want to work with somebody who knows them. It's the old adage: people do business with those they know, like, and trust. If they can see me as somebody in their industry who just happens to sell insurance policies for that industry, that's different than just saying, "Hey, I'm working with an insurance agent who can write business in that particular industry." It's a completely different way of looking at it.
Ryan Hanley
Let me ask you this. When you define — say I were going to come to you as a client and I'm all about what you're teaching. I want to be a micro niche producer. We'll go back to pallet contractors. I don't know where pallet contractors came from, but let's just say I'm in the Midwest. I know there's a couple of really nice accounts. I got a buddy who works in one. Maybe I got to my first account. I potentially have a decent in. Charles, help me. I know there's all kinds of triggers here. Take this just as the framing of this size part. When you start to say, "If you're going to come be part of my program, follow what I do, become a true micro niche producer, I want you focused on accounts that bring in X revenue or have X amount of revenue in their top line." How do you start to define for them where you believe this type of mentality can work anywhere? Where do you see the turning point, the escape velocity in size account for this type of methodology?
Charles Specht
It all starts there. I kind of liken it to putting the cart before the horse and the horse before the cart. If I've got an agent in North Dakota who says, "Charles, I want to write a bunch of pallet companies," I'm like, "Yeah, good luck to you because there's like four." So you're either going to have to expand your geographic territory or you're going to have to go after some other business as well. Having one micro niche, I actually don't tell too many people to have one. I usually tell people to have two in two completely different industries that have nothing to do with one another. You can spend half your day prospecting in one and half in another. That also insulates you from problems in the future. If something goes haywire in one industry or a new carrier comes in and they flat out won't appoint you, right? I think three is doable, but that's hard.
From the standpoint of an insurance agency, that's a different story. I think agencies can have multiple micro niches. But one producer, it's different. You have to look at the size of the account you want to write. If I'm talking to somebody in Los Angeles about the size revenue that they need, that's different than if I'm talking to a guy in North Dakota. They're completely different. From the size of the geographic territory that they're going to go after, if they're only going to prospect in their county, it's just not going to work. If you say, "I'm only going to do walk-in visits. I want to see people face-to-face. That's my primary way of prospecting," I don't know if micro-niching is going to work because there's only so many in your pond.
I typically work with agents when they're trying to figure it out. We do a bunch of brainstorming. We put lists together. "These could work. These couldn't work." I have them talk to underwriters and sales reps at the carriers they want to write the business with. I want to find out which industries are you really competitive at? Do you want to write a lot of this business? I liken it to the example of I'm in a horse race. If I'm in a horse race, I don't want the prettiest horse. I want the fastest one. I don't care. I want the fastest horse. If I've got access to a carrier right now that's just really good at one or two things, I'm going to ride that horse. My micro niche might switch a year from now. That's okay. Most agents pivot. That's okay. We can pivot. But what are we riding right now? I want to win as many races as I can. I want the fastest horse after all is said and done.
Like I said, micro-niching a lot. The first part of it is fairly superficial when it just comes to branding. But we have to figure out what we want to go after. The size of the account is usually going to be a big issue. If I'm trying to write accounts that are $20,000 of commission, but you just don't have enough of them, it's not going to be a fit. I say, "Sorry, scratch it. Take it off the list." You can like it, but it's not going to be a good fit. Someone might say, "I really like boating companies. Do you have any carriers that represent boating companies?" No. Cross it off. Either you're going to get appointed with the carriers that are going to be really competitive or you're going to find something else.
The conversation is absolutely different, Ryan, for every single agent that I speak to because every agency is different. If I'm talking to a smaller agency, like when Rogue started out, you probably didn't have access to too many carriers at the beginning. You were trying to write with whatever those carriers were going to write. That's where everybody's at.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah.
Charles Specht
But think about it from this standpoint. Everybody is micro-niched. It's just how micro-niched are you? I'll put it to you this way. You decided to be a property and casualty agent instead of a life insurance agent. You micro-niched yourself. You also decided not to be an EB agent or do Medicare. You micro-niched yourself in there. You also probably focus on accounts that are likely general liability and workers' comp, but not really D&O. Maybe not even major cyber liability types of coverage. You were going to go after stuff that was going to be your main general liability work comp, but not really D&O. You're micro-niched. You're also micro-niched from the standpoint that you're writing stuff in your pond. You're not even going outside. My micro-niche is these types of accounts in this geographic territory that are of this size.
Even carriers micro-niche. They say, "We write this stuff. We don't write all these things." Everybody is micro-niched in the insurance business. It's just how far down are you micro-niched? You can micro-niche yourself down to the point where you don't have any fish in the pond. I can say, "I'm going to write pallet companies that are working with $30 million size accounts here in North Dakota." Nope. They're done. Doesn't work. You've got to find something that actually works.
Depending upon the agent, the size of the agency, what markets you have available, all this different criteria, we can usually find about two to maybe three that are going to be a really good start going forward. That first part is just picking what you're going to go after. I also tell agents, if an account comes in and says, "Hey, I want to do business with you" or they're referred to you, if it's a good account, write it. I'm not going to say no to good business. Absolutely not. But I know that I only have so many hours in the day in which to prospect. I might as well prospect on accounts that are much more likely to see some value in me that resonates with my marketing. They say, "Maybe this guy's got something." I maybe make more appointments. That's the first superficial layer of branding inside your micro niche. You just set more appointments that way. You just literally do.
Taking it to the next step, that is where the expertise and the maturity of the producer and the agency leadership come into play. We're taking that to the next step where we're really setting up our services. We're getting involved in the associations. We're doing webinars, different things like that. That's where insurance agents start building a million, $2 million book of business. I don't see too many agents that have a very large book of business that are very much generalists anymore. Anybody can write a $200,000, $300,000, $400,000 book of business by being a quasi generalist. Absolutely. But being micro niche, you will write fewer accounts, but they'll be significantly higher after all is said and done.
Ryan Hanley
There's a bunch in there too, and that was great. I like that you recommend multiple micro niches because one of the things that I've always taught is that diversity creates sustainability.
So I never wanted to over-index because I don't trust carriers. I don't trust politicians. I don't trust the economy. I don't trust the weather. I don't trust any of them, right?
So all that being said, I've had – just in the four years that Rogue Risk exists – I had carriers come into my office. This is not a knock on carriers. This is the way the business is, but it's a reality. They come in and go, "We want this." Okay, let's go. You just walked into one of the few guys in the industry who can put a marketing campaign on a dime and go get it. Let's go. Then I go do it. Two months later, "Oh, we don't want that anymore." And you're like... That literally happened twice in a four-year period. One was within two months and the other one was in four months. All of a sudden, they didn't want it anymore. So I just put all this effort, time, energy into building this, getting flow, starting to place business, only to have you change your mind.
Now, that is not a knock on carriers. That's the business and they made their decision. So it's just simply, I don't think carriers should trust agents. I had this conversation with someone on LinkedIn where they were hammering me about our responsibility to carriers. And my thing was: carriers only have a responsibility to pay me commissions for the business I place. And I only have a responsibility to place business that I believe is accurately underwritten with them. Outside of that, there is no responsibility between us. I don't have it. You're not my partner. I'm not your partner. I'm your distribution. You're my supplier. We can have a tremendous relationship.
This is a little tangential here, but it's going to get to the sustainability thing. I believe there was a time when carriers and agents were true partners in this business. I do not believe that is the case anymore.
Charles Specht
Yeah, different age.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, it's a different age. And that's not a knock. That's not to say carriers are wrong, agents are wrong, whatever. It's just a different time in our evolution. And I think we both – from the carrier perspective down to agents and from the agent perspective to the carriers – we need to realign our value proposition. Carriers are suppliers. Agents are distribution. We need to hold up our end of the bargain to the contract that we sign between us.
So to that extent, carriers are always and should always do what is in their best interest. Agencies should always do what is in their best interest. So that being said, I think that diversity is enormously important to sustainability at the agency level.
I think the bifurcation that needs to be made – and I think this is really where what you're saying and what I'm saying layer on top of each other really well – is that at the producer level, the individual producer level, one, possibly three micro niches, becoming an expert, becoming the guy or the gal for that thing in that space, absolutely is a great way to go. But I think as agency principals, owners, et cetera, we need to remove our producer hat and put on a business owner hat and say, "Hey look, I'm going to have a small battalion of these external hunter producers that are going to go out and fight in these niches where we have good relationships with either the associations or they have industry knowledge."
And I think – this is what I'm trying to push in our space – I don't think that can be the only way we bring business into agencies anymore. I think there has to be an inbound flow. That inbound flow is traditionally going to be smaller business. Now, I will say a few of my coaching clients have done substantial high-ticket inbound prospecting and get leads every single week in their niche and do real legitimate business.
Here's how I think about it. If we just work off of our producers' outbound production, what we get is – yes, we're building up that retention base – but new business production is this spiky line. We have a couple of big accounts and then nothing this month and then bam, this spiky line. What I'm saying is I want the big hits from my hunter killers to be the gravy that gets my spouse the 7 Series, not the monthly production that comes in. And if we can have an inbound team of closers, that's what I call...
Charles Specht
That's the key right there. That's the key. Everything you're just saying, that has to be the key.
Ryan Hanley
Yes. You have to have a separate team of the inbound closers. It's a separate team. You asked me this question and I didn't realize I didn't respond to it. I responded to it in my head.
Charles Specht
That's right, slacker. I knew we were going to talk about it, so I'm hitting you here. Let's go.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, yeah. You asked me this question on LinkedIn, and then in my head, I responded to it. I didn't hit publish. But to answer your question, I think it has to be two separate teams. You put a hunter killer on inbound leads, they will look like they have no idea what they're doing. Vice versa. You take someone who has a closers mentality and you put them out on the phones, and you're going to be like, "This person's a loser."
I think there are three production positions in our business. There are account managers – retention, relationship, cross-sell, et cetera. You have your hunter killers, your producers. Those are the two traditional spots. And I think what we've kind of quasi-pioneered at Rogue and really perfected over my career – and this is what I'm teaching – is that there is this third position called a closer. They aren't going to be great outbound but are too sales-oriented for an account manager. They sit in the middle and just close inbound business.
And what you get – and if you're listening at home, you can't see this really awesome graphic that I'm doing with my hand – but you get this consistent flow of business that just kind of slowly creeps up as you create content and you get more integrated into different referral sources. And this baseline of production that you can count on, like taxes. You get this baseline growth, nice and steady. And then all of a sudden those big hits from your producers are like, "Whoa, we had a huge month this month." And that's kind of what I've been trying to advocate. The stuff you're teaching is gold, but we're missing this foundational piece. And that's what I'm trying to teach people.
Charles Specht
Well, man, when you say we're missing this foundational piece, I don't know, what is it? 0.0001% of agencies have people like that? Here's what I normally see, Ryan. I'll have an agency that says, "Man, we want our producers going after bigger accounts." I'm like, "Okay, so we create what's called a small business unit." We say, "Okay, we're going to have our producers only get paid on these accounts going forward. And so we're going to put all these accounts in the small business unit." Well, great. Who's going to close those? Who's going to do that? "Oh, we're just going to have the CSR." Really? Then just say goodbye to about 70% of that business over the next couple of years because your account manager is an account manager. They are not a closer. They can't close renewals like a producer could.
So I just feel like what you're saying in regards to that small business closer, inbound marketing – it can be an absolute gold mine to an agency and most agencies don't have it. Literally, that's why I said like 0.0001%. I have no idea.
Ryan Hanley
So I think there's some... I agree with you that percentage is probably who actually classify and have the right person in that seat today. However, I do think there are a lot of these people out here. What you hear is, Charles, "I got this guy. He sounded great in his interview and he just won't pick up the phone. He just won't pick up the phone." And then you talk to him and your first impression is probably the same. "Jesus, guy seems dynamic and he seems smart and he knows the business. What's the issue?" And now we get into this psychology. Come to find out, the guy just for whatever reason has the outbound hiccups. The outbound whatever it is that just terrifies some people.
How I know this is today I'll make an outbound call, but I'm 18 years into my career and now I'm past 40. So I don't give a what people think anymore. You hit 40, you don't give a crap. So I've hit that age, so I'm good. But at 25, 26 when I started, dude, it would literally – I would have a physical reaction in my arm to picking up the phone to cold call. My hand would literally be shaking when I would go to pick up the phone. I could close all day long, but outbound, man, I was terrible.
So I think two things. One, we have some producers who we think aren't good producers, but actually would make amazing closers. And the other thing – and this is what we really started to do towards the end – every new producer, regardless... Now if they were coming over with a big book of business, different. But anybody who wasn't coming over with a book of business, even if we thought they were a gangster killer, they started in the closer position. And we watched how they handled things, how they got used to the system. And then we would either rapidly promote them or figure everything out. It creates a proving ground to a certain extent. You got to put people in their skillset at the end of the day.
Charles Specht
Right. Because here's the thing – and I think I was just sort of fortuitous that the two agencies that I went to work with – I never input an app in the system ever in my life. I've never processed a cert. I couldn't do an ACORD app inside the system. I never had a password. And I'm grateful because if I did, I probably would have quit and I would be someone else because I am not that kind of guy. That's not my skillset.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah.
Charles Specht
You're finding these people. There's people that work at a clothing store who can close a customer who walks in, but they're not going to go out and find customers to come buy some jeans. Completely different skill set.
So yes, I just feel that for whatever you might call a small agency – let's just say it's a million bucks of revenue or less – what you're saying is if I didn't have any producers who are outbound, you could create a mammoth pot of gold into an agency if we could set up an inbound marketing system and get these people to close business. Because it can be done in a number of different ways. But having that as a set...
Ryan Hanley
I do think, dude, they also need very much... I think every agency needs at least two producers. Take that with a broad stroke, right? We're best practicing. Just take that comment with a broad stroke, everyone that's listening, before I get bombarded with "We can't afford..." whatever. I think in a best case scenario, every agency over say $500,000 in revenue – under that you probably just need one or whatever – should have one outbound and one inbound. Because an outbound has a minimum threshold similar to what you're talking about. So they're doing the things you're talking about. They're building that micro niche. Hopefully it's associated with what the agency likes and writes.
Because here's what happens with the inbound guys. You call me and you're that talent contractor and you're $250,000 in premium, and you're going to have some vehicles and all this stuff. If I, as the inbound closer, try to take that account, it's going to bog the entire system down. That closer position is a problem solver. And people misconstrue what I'm saying because they get into monoline and whatever. There's a whole system for making sure that they don't renew monoline because I completely agree – the numbers are unavoidable. But they have to know what you're teaching. I firmly agree.
Because that big account comes in. That closer needs to kick that to the guy or woman that you're training because they're the ones who know. I know the questions to ask. I know how to work with supplementals. I have the space in my schedule to go out and see them. Different world.
Charles Specht
Yes. Now you're on the road. You might not even be in the office ever. You could say, "Hey dude, where are you? I'm 20 minutes from you. I just got an inbound call. I told the guy you can stop in." Now they're going over. Different world.
Ryan Hanley
Yep.
Charles Specht
And if I can take it a step further, let's flip the coin. I'm going to talk to one of my clients in about an hour and a half from now. And I already know the conversation and it's going to frustrate me to death because he's at an agency that has a few producers, but he has to also handle stuff that comes in inbound. Frustrates me to no end because we have his entire process set up and he's focusing. He's like, "Well Charles, I got to do these quotes for this small little restaurant." And I just want to put the agency owner in a headlock and punch him in the nose a few times because he's just killing his own agency on how he's setting it up.
So from that standpoint, that's why the agency needs a small business unit of closers so that the producer who's going out and writing the bigger accounts does not have to waste his or her time doing that. One, they don't even know all the markets, which is another issue. You get all these accounts coming in, you don't know the market, so you really have to spend some time, which wastes time for being able to do your outbound prospecting. It is a catch-22 that frankly is a plague to insurance agencies. And I feel like that's why it's one of the things that needs to get figured out. Because as soon as agencies can figure out how to get a team of closers to do that on the inbound, man, skyrocket hockey stick profitability to the agency.
Ryan Hanley
I completely agree. But I also would tell you, going back to the micro niche for a moment, there's ways that a producer can do this. But also agencies – because you only have so much time in the day to prospect. Making phone calls, doing a walk-in visit, driving somewhere – that just takes time. So I usually have my producers work on three different types of buckets. I do an alpha bucket, a beta bucket, an omega bucket.
Your alpha bucket is your primary type of account you're going to go after. That's your main micro niche. Whatever your goal is – $100,000 of new business, $150,000 – we're going to hit that in the alpha. The beta bucket though is another micro niche of stuff we're going to go after. I'm not going to waste my time making phone calls on it. I'm just going to be doing email marketing. Only email marketing to that particular beta group with my micro niche brochures and branding. And then when I get somebody who is interested, when they reply and say, "I want to know some more," great. I'll set it up. But I don't spend my time doing my main prospecting for that. That's my beta bucket.
And then the omega bucket is usually the really big accounts that might not even be in any of my prospect lists. They're just local. They're really huge accounts local where I can actually go and walk into those accounts. I just feel like that is a smart way in which to do business. Having an agency that does what you're talking about, doing the inbound, is a completely different agency, a completely different structure, a completely different set of skills.
Charles Specht
It's a different comp plan.
Ryan Hanley
It's a different comp plan. It has to be. You can't comp people exactly the same. You have to comp them differently for sure.
Charles Specht
Yeah.
Ryan Hanley
I love the three buckets, dude. And I think I'm really glad that in your process – because I think other people who are our producer coaches tend to shy away from digital prospecting. Not that they're against it, but they don't necessarily advocate for it. And that's not a knock. It's just a difference of opinion. And I love your beta bucket too because some days when I did cold call, it's very taxing, even if you're good at it. Even if you're used to it, it's taxing.
Charles Specht
You only do it for so long, right? How long are you going to make cold calls before you're dead?
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, yeah. It's a pure drain out of your body. Now granted, if someone picks up the phone and they're like, "Hey, I've got a $100,000 account. You want me to BOR it over to you?" Yeah, maybe get some energy there. But most days it's very taxing.
One of the things that we did at Rogue as well was we used Loom and we did outbound one-to-one cold email prospecting using Loom videos and a flyer. And we found that to be – now, again, email delivery, whatever, there's all the nuances – but I found that let's say a producer could make 30 cold calls in a day and they were drained. If you go over 30, they could do 30, and let's just say for whatever reason maybe it's 50, maybe it's whatever. Let's just say they could do 30 and they're drained. What they could still do and have the energy for was maybe then send out 10, 15, 20 Loom videos because it doesn't seem to drain the energy as much from the individual. Which now all of a sudden you're getting an extra 15, 20 touches that you wouldn't normally get.
Charles Specht
Right. And I love that. And the reluctance isn't there because you're not seeing people. People aren't actually rejecting you like they would if you were doing a walk-in visit or a cold call. If somebody rejects you, all they do is delete it and you don't even know. So it's a completely different way in which to prospect.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah. I always equated it to putting little landmines out there. You're just putting these things out there, putting them in their LinkedIn, putting them in their email. They're very personalized. And then all of a sudden – and I'd say, "Guys, this is going to happen. Just be ready for this." You might go two weeks without them opening your email. Then all of a sudden you're going to get that notification from Loom. "Hey, so-and-so just watched your video. Hey, so-and-so just watched your video three times. Hey, so-and-so just watched your video three times and forwarded it to someone else in their organization." Pick up the phone. And that stuff starts happening.
Charles Specht
That's the beauty of email, isn't it? Because on a cold call, they're going to delete that thing for the most part. It's rare they're ever going to go back and listen to it. But I know myself – I have emails that are close to a year old, maybe a year and a half. I'm eventually going to get to it. I just, it's not yet. So send that email. Your prospect will leave it there until they come up for renewal in six months. I just know that happens all the time.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah. Dude, I'm carrying 26 emails right now. Social media, it's gone. A cold call's gone. A walk-in visit's gone. But the email will sit there.
Charles Specht
Yeah. I'm carrying 26 emails right now that are things I want to get to eventually, but I can't do them today. It's like a to-do list. It stays there, man. It stays there. I know all the efficiency and organization nerds who are listening are having a panic attack hearing that we're carrying over emails or using our emails to do this. But I love it.
Ryan Hanley
Dude, I think this marriage, this flow of outbound... I think you need these people. You have strong-willed, energetic, hungry gals and guys who want to go out and want to write business. You have to have them. They are very energizing to an agency too, especially if you create a culture where they are not holier than thou. They're very energizing to an agency, especially when you bring in a whale account.
I found that – and I'm sure your people do too – when one of our outbound people would bring in a big account into Rogue, even the people who had nothing to do with client service, you could just see everybody would be, "Oh, so-and-so wrote a $250,000 account." Everyone's head's bobbing, they're getting jacked up because it feels good to have a nice win. And then the same thing, but on an account number basis for the inbound people. They'd be like, "Oh, so-and-so wrote 27 accounts this month or 40." I think our biggest month by an individual producer was 63 individual accounts that one producer wrote.
Charles Specht
In a month?
Ryan Hanley
In a month, yeah.
Charles Specht
Dude, that's crazy. That's a lot.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, $217,000.
Charles Specht
All commercial?
Ryan Hanley
All commercial accounts. Yeah, all commercial. We only wrote commercial. So yeah, it was... And he just worked the process. He was the true believer. And everyone was funny. That month changed the game for us because when he worked the process and he hit those numbers, everyone went, "How did he do it?" And I was like, "Surprisingly, he's working the process I've been teaching you guys. Follow the rules. It works." Yeah, then everyone started to work the process. And we started seeing things as well.
And just what you just said – I just had a conversation with somebody who said his largest client is now $600,000 of commission. It started out around five grand, which is still a decent size account. But those accounts that you're writing in that small business, you never know. They just might take off.
Charles Specht
Dude, small accounts become big accounts.
Ryan Hanley
They do. Yeah, they absolutely do. On my grave, maybe on the back, it'll say, "Small accounts become big accounts." It's like Ryan advocating for small business insurance for 20 years. Everyone's been telling me...
Charles Specht
I'll tell you when I first started that agency, I had this chip on my shoulder around the ID. I've been to – I can't even tell you how many conferences I've been to. I've spoken – I counted the other day – I'm north of 300 speaking engagements in the industry now. It's somewhere between 305 and 315. I can't figure it out. I went back as far as I could in my email to try to figure it out. It doesn't matter. I've heard so many times – I can't even wrap my head around how many times I've heard "Small business insurance isn't profitable. Can't make a margin on small business insurance." And I was like, "You know what? I don't believe that to be true. I just feel like we haven't been doing it properly."
And that's where the whole human optimization structure comes in. Can't pay somebody 50% and make it profitable. Can't be doing that. What ultimately worked – and I'm not going to give the percentages because I don't want to give away whatever for people – but what we ended up doing was over-indexing our new business commission and then just giving a trickle on renewals. Which forced our math to really focus on retention, which we did. And I tell you, for the volume that we were doing, our retention was slightly above industry averages, but well above other digital competitors. That doesn't matter today. But my point is, that's how we got there.
We said, "Look, I'm going to feed you. I have a machine. It's me and so-and-so and our process, and we're going to feed you stuff. So you just close, close, close, close, close. You're going to get paid a base that keeps you alive, this really nice new business, and over time, you're going to build up this little growing asset."
And that's where I started talking about incentives dictate action. When we don't understand... I'm super interested in your take on compensation and thinking through this. But it took me a long time to understand how misaligned incentives misalign action to the agency. So if you wanted people to write new business, you have to incentivize new business. If you want people to be bought into this, you have to incentivize them around that thing. I don't always mean straight monetary compensation. But if your people oftentimes are not taking the actions you would like them to take, the first place I would start is in how are you incentivizing them? What are the incentives that you're putting in front of them? They might be doing an amazing job to a set of incentives that you didn't necessarily understand you were incentivizing them to do these things you didn't want them to do. That's my point there.
So I love your thought. A gal comes to you. She's like, "Charles, this is what I want to do, blah blah blah. I'm negotiating or this is what they're like." How do you talk them through if you're going to do this under the assumption you're a hard worker and you're going to be successful?
Ryan Hanley
How should agency—let's frame it from the standpoint of agency principals, ownership—how should they be thinking about bringing in and compensating a producer that would work with you doing your system? How should they think about that?
Charles Specht
Okay, well, I'll try and answer a few different ways. If I'm talking to a producer, and if they're my client, I'm going to try and tell them bigger splits after all said and done. But if we're looking at it from the agency ownership perspective, here's the kind of commission split that I like. If I was going to start an agency today, what I would likely do is pay producers 65% up front, 10 to 15% on renewal. I feel like a four to five times that on the front end is going to keep them focused on new business.
The problem I see is agencies that have like a 30/30 split. I don't have any incentive. They're like, "Go out and write new business, then." I'll get my book where I'm happy. I'm good. But if I have a really high commission split up front, this is good for a couple of different reasons. One, most agents don't stick at an agency very long anymore. So I want them to put as much business on the book as possible so that when they leave, great, I've already got it on the books. Now I'm keeping 100% of it now that they're gone. If they stick around, great. I want them to stick around if they're going to be writing a lot of business. But at the end of the day, worst case scenario, they write some business, then they leave. I've got it on the books.
I feel like that is a pretty good model for anything that you're kind of talking about. For that sort of inside closer, we're going to bring some accounts, larger accounts. I might have a different commission split on anything that was a certain commission above, just because I know that it's going to take that person's time more. I've had accounts where I wrote them and never saw the shirt, never. I have an example of when I was $55,000 of commission, I literally never saw them. It was always by email. Probably the most profitable thing I ever had, never had to touch it. It was just done. But then there are others that were just high touch.
So I like the fact of having a very high commission split upfront, certainly for what I would feel are non-tested agents. They're just not tested yet. They're going to make a small salary to begin with, but I'm going to give them the incentive to go out and write the business that I want. And then they're going to have a small little book that they're making over the course of time. But if I'm a producer, knowing what I know today, that would never work for me if I'm looking at trying to build a book of business. At the same time, if I had a producer who was writing $200,000 a year in new business commission, making 60% on the front end, maybe making 10% or 15% on the back end, they're still going to make a whole lot of money doing that. So it just kind of depends upon the person. I feel like it's one of those things where it depends upon the individual agency and what their goals are going forward.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, I think that's the perfect way to conclude it. We all have maybe our preferred scenarios, but those preferred scenarios always come with the caveat of, "This is how I would set up service, and this is what I would expect them." And I agree with you. I think that if you over-index on renewal commission on small business or personal lines accounts, you disincentivize new business growth hardcore. Hardcore.
The flip side of that, when I look at a producer who comes in and writes that $55,000 revenue account, I want you touching that account. I want you incentivized to make sure that I'm getting that 55K every year. So in order to do that, we have a higher retention. And maybe you say, "Look, I'm good, Charles, with you having 25 accounts. If those 25 accounts bring in $2 million in revenue, rock and roll. You can sit." This is the other thing I don't understand. People get upset—I've heard principals, sometimes in larger regional or super regional agencies—get upset with a lack of new business production from producers who have these multimillion dollar revenue books. I don't understand that at all.
Charles Specht
I was waiting for you because I wanted to say that. You just hit it. Ryan, this is it. You know what I hear all the time? "We've got 10 producers, but four of them are basically semi-retired. They're not writing any new business anymore." Immediately what I know is that they have a bad compensation model. That's what I know. If they had a good compensation model, that wouldn't be happening any longer. It's that they've got people who got very comfortable because now they've got a really big renewal split.
Granted, if I'm a producer and that's all I am, I want a really high renewal split. That's where I'm at. But if I'm an agency owner and I do that, then I'm basically handcuffing my agency in the future. That's what you're doing. Or you just have to say, "I'm going to have to build a bigger team." Let's say you make that mistake. I saw this—I wasn't being asked my opinion in a consulting role, but I was speaking and the president of this regional agency came over and said, "Hey, blah, blah, blah." He had three producers all with seven-figure revenue books who had 50/50 splits, and none of them were producing new business.
I said, "Well, why would they produce new business? All of them are making between $500,000 and $750,000 every year for keeping their buddies. They're going golfing, they're taking them on trips, they're doing all these things together." Only in America, man. And I said, "Why would they?" And he's like, "I know. What do I do?" And I said, "Dude, just hire more people. Is the other 50% profitable for you?" He said, "Yes." I said, "Okay. So what you just told me is you have this amount of revenue locked in. You're not going to get any more. I would actually say, don't screw with that."
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, grandfather that in and switch it for the next.
Charles Specht
Absolutely. That's what it is. Yep. Now hire three more guys or gals. Hopefully people at home know I don't do the woke thing, and I mean everybody, not just guys. And just give them a revenue split that incentivizes what you want, which is growth.
And it was funny. I'm not knocking this opinion. He was frustrated not just at the producers. He was frustrated at the situation. And I was just like, "Dude, don't mess with it. You have three guys with seven-figure revenue books with their commission splits? No, don't change it. That doesn't sound like a good idea to me. No, man. Count that as good, solid, foundational revenue that you're going to have that you can build on, and then just go hire some more people."
Ryan Hanley
Yep. 100%. Got to do it. I love it. Dude, this has been an awesome conversation. It always is when you come on the show. I'm so glad we could hash this out. I'm going to try to come up with a super clickbaity, aggressive title that will get people to click and then listen to this wonderful conversation that we had.
I appreciate the work you do. I love your perspective, man. And I also love—and I'll just say this, I know it's not relevant to the insurance side—but I love how much and how vocal you are with your faith and how much you share it. I think that is tremendous. I think our world needs more people who are vocal and upfront about their faith in a way that, I've never found you to be pushy. It's just, "Here's who I am and what I believe." I love that. I'm so happy that you do that. Happy for you. And I hope more people who have faith will continue to share it and follow your example.
Charles Specht
Appreciate that, man. Thanks.
Ryan Hanley
With all that being said, how do people get ahold of you? If they're interested in your program, how do they join? How do they learn more? Where do they go?
Charles Specht
Yeah, definitely check me out on LinkedIn, Charles Specht. That's where I spend the bulk of my time for business. But go to permissionsales.com. That's where you're going to see everything: the mastermind, digital course, one-on-one coaching. I'm serving as a chief sales officer for a lot of agencies. I'll be able to help you with the outbound. And who knows, maybe Ryan and I can collab. He'll do the inbound and I'll do the outbound, and we'll get you guys to be a million-dollar-more agency real quick. But yeah, LinkedIn or permissionsales.com. Super fun, dude. Appreciate the hell out of you.
Ryan Hanley
Cool, thanks man. I'm going to shop booze.
Closing music begins
Announcer
Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not. With the One Call Close system, you'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Close system eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclose.com. That's masteroftheclose.com. Do it today.