Main Topic: The podcast episode is a conversation with Andy Matheson, a former co-founder of Glovebox and now regional sales director for First Choice, a Marshberry company. The episode focuses on Andy's career journey, his decision to leave Glovebox, and his new role at First Choice. The conversation also delves into topics such as the importance of empathy, the value of networks in the insurance industry, and how to navigate the current market dynamics.
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Key Quotes:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Discover how Andy Matheson's leap from startup dynamo at Glovebox to the strategic role of a regional sales director at Marshberry's FirstChoice isn't just a career change—it's a testament to the pursuit of balance.
✅ Free step-by-step video series for generating inbound leads from YouTube: https://go.ryanhanley.com/youtube
✅ For daily insights and ideas on peak performance: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryanhanley
✅ Subscribe to the YouTube show: https://youtube.com/ryanmhanley
Join us for a compelling look at the personal side of professional transitions, where we unpack the delicate art of prioritizing contentment over the grind.
Andy's candid reflections set the stage for a broader conversation on the vital decisions we all face when our ambition and well-being seem at odds.
Embarking on a new venture can stir a whirlwind of responses. As I share the journey behind Finding Peak, you’ll hear how empathy and support play pivotal roles in weathering the storm of societal expectations and self-doubt.
From navigating criticism to embracing growth, this segment isn't just my narrative—it's a shared experience of resilience and the collective wisdom found in the camaraderie of like-minded professionals.
Beyond personal stories, this episode cuts through the static to illuminate the evolving world of insurance agencies.
We tackle the stereotypes of insurance networks and reveal their true significance in the industry's rapidly changing landscape. Insights into agency growth strategies, the importance of robust insurance foundations, and the implications of networking for independent agencies offer invaluable takeaways.
Whether you're an industry insider or intrigued by the transformation of professional ecosystems, this episode promises a wealth of knowledge steeped in authenticity and forward-thinking expertise.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Ryan Hanley
In a crude laboratory in the basement of his home. Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the show. Today we have an absolutely tremendous episode for you, a conversation with Andy Matheson, former co-founder of Glovebox and now regional sales director for First Choice, which is a Marshberry company.
I wanted to have Andy on because Andy worked for more than six years in a family-owned independent agency, Colorado Insurance. He then founds this incredible startup, Glovebox, which I'm sure many of you have heard about. For a whole bunch of reasons, which Andy talks about, he now has left Glovebox and become a regional sales director with Marshberry First Choice, helping agencies across the country grow and develop.
That type of move is a move that I think many would struggle with. I think many would worry about the perception of that move. Andy had to make this move for a lot of reasons, and those reasons are his. I think they're important. I think we all struggle at different times with how our professional life impacts our personal life. The Andy Matheson story is a wonderful display of a thought process on how to make the right decision for yourself and for your family, and how to prioritize meaning and happiness over public perception.
Andy's an incredible guy. I always love talking to him. I think you're going to love this episode, which is episode number 237.
Guys, I love you for listening to this show. Every week our show is growing. We have more subscribers, more listens, more downloads, more watches on YouTube. It's such a pleasure to bring you these conversations. Whether it's the solo episodes where I try to put a new reframed or contrarian idea in front of you that you can consider and think through, question some of the norms in our industry — some of which you can apply, some of which you can toss into the garbage. Not every idea works for everybody.
Then these incredible conversations with people like Andy who are so willing to come on and share their time, their story, their expertise, and their experience. It's a very meaningful process. I couldn't thank you more for being part of it. Even if you're just a one-off listener and you decide not to subscribe or be part of the community in a deeper way, I appreciate you for taking the time to consider the thoughts that are shared. Hopefully, in some way, they add value to you.
If you do want to go deeper down this journey, subscribe on whatever audio podcast platform you're using, or subscribe to the YouTube channel. If you have questions or comments, leave them on social or come over to the YouTube video. I respond to every single comment. It's a wonderful place to capture thoughts and ideas. If you want to go even farther down the rabbit hole, go to masterclass.insure. Put your name and email in, you'll get on the newsletter. As we get closer to launching the coursework — the first piece we're putting out is our one-call close process, what it means to be a closer, talking through how to fill your funnel with inbound leads — when that becomes live, you'll be the very first to know. That will also come with discounts to the program for choosing to opt in and be part of the free newsletter community. Masterclass.insure gets you there.
With all that said, I appreciate you. I love you. Let's get on to Andy Matheson.
Transition to interview
I'm good to see you.
Andy Matheson
Yeah, good to see you too, bud. What's the haps, man? What's going down?
Ryan Hanley
It depends on the moment.
Andy Matheson
Obviously a moving target with all the new stuff going on for me. But it's been outstanding. I'm in a very comfortable place now. I'll be honest, my stress level went from way up here to way down here for the first time in like seven years. So yeah, feels good. Needed that.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, I get it. You know what? You get it. You do.
Andy Matheson
Yeah, yeah, I do.
Ryan Hanley
It's funny. I was talking to a very good friend of mine — I have a mentorship call every other week, we're kind of accountability partners in the different things we're trying to do in our lives. I was sharing a story with him about how much stress and anxiety will allow us to believe anything our mind or body tells us when we're stressed or anxious. When you're in a good place, feeling good and motivated, your mind or body can say "I'm tired" and you push through. Or it can say "you need another drink" and you say "no, I'm crushing it." Then you hit a patch of anxiety and stress, and all of a sudden your mind says "why don't you have three glasses of whiskey tonight?" or "why don't you skip the gym today?" And your body says "I'm kind of tired, sleep in." You just say yes to all of it. You fall into a lot of traps.
Andy Matheson
Yeah. Then all of a sudden you wake up when that stress or anxiety gives you a little window — a window will open — and you look and go, "What am I freaking doing?" Dude, I had so many of those cycles from 2022 to the end of '23. It was just constant. It became so obvious that my brother and I had to have a heart-to-heart. It was like, "Dude, not that you're not bringing value to Glovebox, but we need to understand where your head's at. This in-and-out approach of being here, being gone, being here, being gone is draining to the company, and it sucks for you." I felt it worse than he did. I knew that was happening, and that sucks, and that's not what we set out to do.
Most people know by now, but I'm a single dad, stressed as fuck, can't lead a team anymore because I'm constantly being torn on every angle of my life. It was weighing on me. I had to make the right choice for the company and for myself. I'm so thankful that I'm in this seat right now. It feels a lot better.
Ryan Hanley
Dude, one, I'm happy for you. I know you don't need this, but I'm very proud of you for making this decision. Also a single dad, also having gone through a lot of shit — I completely feel you. It's funny, since I started Spiny Peak, the coaching and consulting company that is now what I do, the number of people that have reached out to me on the side and said, "Bro, what's this? Just another thing you're going to do for six months? You always do this. You're always changing. You've never committed to anything." The freaking people that come out of the woodwork and question your decisions.
It took me a second. I was taken back. I called Jason Cass, who's probably been my oldest friend in the industry. I shared with him my struggles, as I'm sure you share with your brother or whoever else. I said, "Dude, I don't understand why. All I've ever wanted to do — and I know this about you, it's why you and I are friends, it's why I connect with you — all you want to do is add value, build things, help people, lead people. This is what you're trying to do with your life. And life throws these curveballs at you, and you just have to make tough decisions."
That's what I want to get back to with you. The lack of empathy, lack of understanding, or complete callousness that people will have when you have to make a life decision that isn't on some linear expected path based on what you were doing previously. It's the real world. Being able to get through that is a superpower. I'm sure you've gotten some of it. That's what I'm really interested in at the beginning here. I'm sure you've gotten both sides — "Hey man, so happy for you, glad you're in a place where you're killing it" — and then the other side — "Dude, how could you leave this company?" I'm sure you've got both.
Andy Matheson
Literally just yesterday.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah. How do you deal with that? That's really interesting to me. The empathy piece is really interesting because typically people hear things — it doesn't matter what the topic is — and they have an immediate opinion. It's like, "How could they possibly do A, B, or C?" For me, I always try to give the benefit of the doubt that they didn't consider what people actually go through on a daily basis. My first reaction now, because I'm calloused as well, is "Okay, they just don't get it. It's fine." The false narratives are all over the place. I have to be okay with the reality that people are going to think what they're going to think. I don't have to recreate the narrative. I don't necessarily need to even tell my story. However, I want to.
Yeah, yeah.
Andy Matheson
There are a lot of things that happened in the past 24 months that have been entertaining. Interesting to get a different perspective on. I have some insight into what other people do that I've never realized before. At the end of the day, that has made me a very well-rounded expert in the industry. Going back to your original question, it gives me an opportunity to get in front of more people, talk about more things. These are icebreakers, man. They're just icebreakers because now we lead into other things together. I've just taken it as opportunities. That's really all it comes down to. I'm not going to control what other people think, but I will turn it into an opportunity.
Ryan Hanley
A good buddy of mine, someone I've known for a while, Aubrey Knight, said to me the other day, "Dogs don't bark at parked cars." That's how I've always wrapped my head around this. I take a lot of shit, and I deserve some of it because I'm very open and honest with my opinions. A lot of my opinions are contrarian. So I deserve to have people push back on me. It's part of the job. But sometimes people will say things and it'll get under your skin a little bit.
I heard Tony Robbins on a clip the other day talking about this. I thought, "Oh my God, I'm so glad I heard this." If people can still get under Tony Robbins' skin, it's going to feel so bad when people get under mine. I was sharing this with Aubie. I said, "I don't want to tell the Rogue story anymore. It is what it is. All the details will never get out, for both legal reasons and because I don't think it's necessary for people to know. I think everybody in that situation made what they thought was the next best decision. It just is what it is." But I have caught a significant amount of blowback from people about it. I was sharing that with Aubie. He just said, kind of off the cuff — and Aubie's a great dude, for those that don't know, he's the executive director of the Big I of North Carolina — he said, "Dude, dogs don't bark at parked cars."
I was like, "What exactly?" You're a guy who, when people meet you, they know you, they see you. You have energy. You're thoughtful. You understand the industry. You have experience in the industry. The key is, for as much as you may or may not need to hear this, if you hadn't built a reputation and people didn't see you as someone withstanding, they wouldn't say shit to you. The move would go unnoticed. The fact that people are noticing it, both positive and negative, speaks to the impact that you've had even at a relatively young age.
Andy Matheson
It's a similar quote to "the lion doesn't concern himself with the opinions of a sheep." It comes with a respect factor. Well said. I can appreciate that.
Ryan Hanley
So you said you had a story you wanted to tell. Let's hear it. What parts can you go into detail on, or not? Maybe just lessons you've learned, things you've seen. I'm interested in your perspective. Then I want to hear more about what you're doing with Smart Choice. I want to get into that as well. But I'd love to spend a little bit of time on this.
The reason I'm so interested in this — and I don't want to over-index on it — it's not just because I've been through it, although I feel like I have a master's degree in having my life upside down. I think there are a lot of people who go through life and are so nervous about a big change like this. Maybe they're sitting in a job they don't like, that isn't fulfilling them, or they're not making enough money, whatever the issue is. I think a lot of people allow others' potential perspective or opinion on a move to stop them from doing what's best for them and their family. Obviously, you have made a fairly large transition to do what's best for you and your family. I'm interested in what takeaways you have from that so far. What lessons? What thought process have you picked up during this time?
Andy Matheson
Really good setting of the stage. For those that don't know, it's very clear and obvious now — single dad, had a tough separation, divorce. That allows me to look at things differently as far as how I'm going to handle my business, how I'm going to raise my kids, and honestly how I want to treat people because of the empathy thing. That's the back burner there.
What I'm going to get at is when we were at our agency from 2012 to 2019, things were honestly pretty comfy. I was single for half of that. I got married in the second half of that career piece of the agency career. When I would come home to a support system that allowed me to do things really well at my agency, it made life very easy. Things couldn't have been easier when I was at my agency because we had our operations in place, our staff in place. I could come in, do my job, come home, have a great life.
We sold our agency in 2019. We had an influx of cash that we reinvested into Glovebox. When we did that, we actually had no paycheck for 18 months. We were paying our company instead of our company paying us. Very odd concept right there. That's a perspective in and of itself. It changes the way you go about your daily life, what your spending habits are, how you start a family. That's what I was doing — starting a family and starting a company at the exact same time. We can go into detail about what I saw at Glovebox, but what I'm getting at is that trajectory of my career has had bumps and bruises because of my support system at home.
Long story short, when you go through trials and tribulations at any phase of your career, you've got to have some sort of grounding. My grounding was my family, my friends, my colleagues, my business partners, my referral partners, etc. Conversation, insight, knowledge, advice — take it all. It's like reading books all day every day, but you're doing it with real-life scenarios with real people. I was doing that throughout the time at the agency, the startup company, and now here at what I do now.
To come to a conclusion on this topic, it only makes sense when you can grasp what everyone is doing and turn it into reality for yourself. Put it in perspective. Everything is perspective. Now I can look at myself honestly, look at myself in the mirror and say, "I'm doing well. Everything I'm going to do going forward is based on my experiences and how hard the challenges have been. Honestly, it's going to be okay. It's never as good as it seems. It's never as bad as it seems." That's where I've been getting at with all this. A comfy lifestyle at the agency, stressful times at the startup company for capital, turning it into a successful company, moving on, and doing what I'm doing now. Kind of a long version for that answer.
Ryan Hanley
No, I love it, man. I'll recommend this to the audience — if you haven't read this book, *The Gap and the Gain* by Benjamin Hardy. He wrote it in partnership with Dan Sullivan. It's a Strategic Coach original idea. The concept is very simple. The book is a good quick read with some depth, but the top-level concept is simple. I explained it on the show a couple of weeks ago, but I will again because sometimes these concepts hit you and I feel like they're first-principle ideas. I can't help but continue to bring them up.
Basically, we have where we started and we have our ideal. The misconception — when we logically think about this, what I'm about to say makes complete sense, but emotionally, I think most of us assume we're going to go from start to ideal in a linear line over some period of time. Everything will just work out. That's what happens, right? Here, everything's good, and I get to this point. That's not the way life works at all. We've all seen that meme of what people think success is — a straight line — and what it really is — a tangled mess, like spaghetti.
The idea of the gap and the gain is that we have our start, our ideal, and where we actually are. Stress and anxiety are the result of measuring ourselves between where we are and our ideal. Dan Sullivan recommends that all his entrepreneurs who come through the Strategic Coach program measure themselves not by the gap from where they are to the ideal, but from where they are from where they started. If we're constantly measuring — and this is written in the book over and over again — always measure backwards.
Think about it. Who was I in 2012, that first day I walked into my family agency? Probably a little disorganized, slightly more cavalier, brash, unpolished. Then you refine yourself, learn the agency business like the back of your hand, start this tech company, go through all those experiences. You look at yourself today and think, "Oh shit, my job now as part of — and I want to hear what you're doing at Smart Choice in detail — I now have this job with the largest network in the country. I now have this decade of wins, losses, beats, stories, experience to pull from that make me this incredibly unique value provider to members of Smart Choice."
You could be like, "Oh, I didn't exit Glovebox for $20 million." Maybe that was your ideal in a moment. You could have all that anxiety on yourself. Or you could say, "Holy shit, I have a decade of experiences that no one else has. Now I get to be this tremendous value provider." No anxiety. That to me is something I constantly have to remind myself of because I'm nowhere near my ideal. But when I look back at my experiences, I'm like, "I have a PhD in this industry." People can believe that or not, but I see the same thing from you. I see very similar moments in time.
Here's the key, and I'm interested in your take on this: I literally have to remind myself of these things every day, or I wake up riddled with anxiety. Every day I have to go, "Look, man, here's where you're at. Here's the value you provide. Go get it." Reset. Let's go. Feel great. The days where I forget to do that, maybe I get to two or three o'clock in the afternoon, and I'm like, "Holy fuck, Finding Peak is never going to be anything. No one's ever going to respect me. I've screwed my career up. My kids are going to hate me. I'm never going to be able to make the payments on my new house."
Interruption — Ryan addresses audience
Sorry to take you away from the episode. As you know, we do not run ads on this show. In exchange for that, I need your help. If you're loving this episode, if you enjoy this podcast, whether you're watching on YouTube or listening on your favorite podcast platform, I would love for you to subscribe, share, comment if you're on YouTube, leave a rating review if you're on Spotify or Apple iTunes. This helps the show grow. It helps me bring more guests in. We have a tremendous lineup of people coming in — men and women who've done incredible things, sharing their stories around peak performance, leadership, growth, sales — the things that are going to help you grow as a person and grow your business.
They all check out comments, ratings, reviews. They check out all this information before they come on. As I reach out to more and more people and want to bring them in and share their stories with you, I need your help. Share the show. Subscribe if you're not subscribed. I'd love for you to leave a comment about the show because I read all the comments. If you're on Apple or Spotify, leave a rating review. I love you for listening to this show. I hope you enjoy listening as much as I enjoy creating the show for you. All right, I'm out of here. Peace. Let's get back to the episode.
Return to interview
Then all of a sudden you're vibrating and you can't wait to go get drunk that night to ease the pain. These little thoughts — I don't know, they're so important.
Andy Matheson
I think the fairytale ending is what you hope to achieve. But how many people get the fairytale ending? Honestly, I don't even know if that's ever a reality.
Ryan Hanley
Sorry for your Bills.
Andy Matheson
Thanks, man. We're in the Super Bowl conversation right now as far as timeframe. These teams made it to the ultimate goal of getting to the Super Bowl, and that's their fairytale ending of hopefully raising that trophy. For me, it was start an insuretech company, sell it for a billion dollars, and ride off into the sunset. By the way, I still had an outstanding experience. I left on amazing terms. I am going to have a positive ending to that story, just along the same lines. It's just not going to be that fairytale. My fairytale was realigned. That expectation went from here to here. It's okay because the new reality is still what you just described. Everything in between — the blood, sweat, tears, the monetary earnings at the end of the day — still in a good place. Everything is actually going to work out just the way it needs to, with exception to the trajectory of the scale. The scale just shrank. That's okay because now there's a new scale and a new opportunity.
I'm always realigning expectations. I think that's what you're getting to. The anxiety kind of grounds you a little bit. It's okay to have anxiety because I think it makes you aware of what's going on.
Ryan Hanley
Yes.
Andy Matheson
In the middle of the day, you get in your groove, and you kind of jump back out of it with anxiety. But I think it's okay to constantly bounce ideas off people so that you can recalibrate once a month, if not more. That's where I'm at. The fairytale is just a new fairytale.
Ryan Hanley
I love the idea that anxiety keeps us aware. I do think that's true. There's a threshold where you don't want to put yourself in places that go too high, but I do think we want to keep a constant level of stress — we'll put anxiety in that category — because otherwise we're not actually pushing ourselves. If you're showing up every day and everything is easy and you have no stress, you are not growing as a person.
This plays into my next question for you. Do you think there's even a fairytale ending? People ask me, "Where are you trying to go?" I don't fucking know. Honestly. I don't have a 10-year plan where I have a second house in Florida and a boat. I plan on working forever. I love doing certain things. My fairytale is more about being able to work on the projects that I choose to work on as often as I can. But is shooting for a fairytale or even having that as a goal a worthy pursuit? Is that something we really want? Is anyone truly happy if they have nothing to do but put their feet up and drink colorful drinks out of umbrellas? Is anybody really happy long-term in that life? I don't know. I wouldn't be.
Andy Matheson
The only exception would be if I'm playing golf every day. That'd be fun. Like insurance agents typically do. No, I'm just kidding.
Ryan Hanley
No, I mean, yeah, you're onto something. Then what you do is you kind of look around at your peers and you think to yourself, "What are they going through? What does their trajectory look like? How am I going to relate to that?" Why do we always have to compare ourselves to that notion?
So I'm okay with where things are. I think that's a perfect way to transition into your new role. It's just this idea that I see this in agencies all the time. It's in everybody. So I'm not singling out agency owners or even producers. But I think too often we see chest thumping on LinkedIn. And I can tell all of you listening to this with 100% certainty that most of the people constantly chest thumping on LinkedIn are doing some small portion of what they say or present online. Just so we're all clear. I know a lot of these people and I know the backstories. It doesn't mean they're not good people and it doesn't mean they're not successful. Just be careful that we idolize people that are chest thumping.
I'll give you an example. I post on Instagram a lot of videos of me working out. One, that is not for the audience. That's for me. I go back and look at them to check my form. I put a little inspirational shit on top of it just to make it interesting. But I suck at boxing and I know I suck at boxing. And I put the sucky boxing videos out there to show people that you don't have to compare yourself. I don't compare myself to good boxers, but I still go three times a week and hit the bags for the workout.
I think what we need to stop doing is saying, "Because I'm not as good as so-and-so at cold calling, I'm going to be unhappy," or "I'm not going to cold call because I'm not as good as him or her." We just have to think about our own personal growth. If we just think about the gap and the gain, everything seems to work out the way it should.
Dude, I think if you consider what it looks like for others to see your posts, your story, and listen to what we're talking about here, it's okay to understand that everyone is going to have a different opinion of you. And as long as you're doing right by the industry and your peers, it's going to be a good reflection of who you really are and what you stand for. And that's okay to me. I don't want to be an influencer. I don't want to be this insurance celebrity. I want to do right by my peers, work hard for insurance agencies, make good money, and have a good life. And that's okay.
I love that, man. So that's where I'm at. So let's talk about that. Based on your experience, your history, who you know, you had options on what your next move would be. And you chose Smart Choice. Talk to me a little bit about that.
Andy Matheson
I'm at Marshberry.
Ryan Hanley
Oh, Marshberry. Sorry. Marshberry First Choice. Guys, I apologize. Marshberry First Choice. Sorry. I completely apologize.
Andy Matheson
No, it's fair. So, yeah, you're right. The free agency market when I hit the market was kind of funny. 10, 15 folks immediately said, "We must talk. We must definitely set aside some time." I knew in the first couple days who would rise to the top as far as who I'd want to talk to. You're talking everything from insurance carriers to other insurtech companies to networks to everything outside the industry—mortgage companies, other insurance agencies, both publicly traded and smaller mom and pops. It was pretty interesting to take on every conversation to realize what the next five to ten years is really going to look like and what I actually want to do to make it most effective for myself.
I have two core pieces of logic for my next phase of my career: doing what I do best, which is marketing, lead generation, professional networking, and challenging myself to learn something new inside the industry. I've had experience in the agency space, now at the startup space in the insurtech world, and now in the network space. What I really wanted to accomplish—because honestly, networks were always fascinating to me. The business model, everything you can do for agencies.
There's a big gap. Just like good insurance agencies and bad insurance agencies, the big gap is the value they bring to the client. I heard this term the other day and I was cracking up. What was it? Oh, "commission clubs." Networks are just commission clubs. I heard that and I was cracking up because I thought, "Okay, clearly the reputation for networks or groups is that all it's doing is giving you market access and enhanced commissions." That's probably the more antiquated, old-school approach and reputation for what networks and groups are. But the good ones are doing way more than that.
So I was looking for things like: How can I help agencies operate more effectively? Give them legitimate guidance into tech stack and how they can operate with technology and the next version of what a modern agent looks like. How can I help them advise? I just want to be an advisor because that's honestly what I can bring to the table at this point. Great advice. Consult. Lead by example. I've done it. I can show you what I did. I can show you what other people are doing. I talked to thousands of insurance agencies at Glovebox. I saw what they did wrong. I saw what they did right. Everything in between, a lot of gaps, a lot of overlaps.
Here's the reality: a lot of these agencies really are just insurance agents that happen to own an agency. That is okay. That's great. The problem is you can't be an expert in everything. You're worried about sales and service and marketing and commission statements and carrier relationships and training and recruiting. There's no way you're going to be an expert in all that. So it's okay to lean into your resources, which for me was the network space.
I've known First Choice for years. I've watched them grow. They are the number one premium aggregator in the country. When Marshberry acquired First Choice in 2022, it was a huge opportunity. You have one of the best insurance agency consulting firms now owning and operating, helping provide distribution across the nation for the aggregation side of the house. Now I can team up with a great reputable name brand, represent them the way I want to represent them. It's all conducive to my first goal, which is helping independent agents succeed. Everything just fit the bill.
It was funny going through all those recruiting conversations, hearing what I could possibly do. It was easy to eliminate. It was very simple and it only took two weeks. I knew what I was going to do. Honestly, the first conversation I had with First Choice, it was a done deal as far as I was concerned.
Ryan Hanley
So that's awesome. It's so exciting when you feel that connection and you can dive into it and really feel like you're being successful.
Andy Matheson
Yeah.
Ryan Hanley
I don't know what it is. I'm sorry for everyone listening. For some reason, when I do hand gestures, the video creates these little bubble things, which is weird. I've got to figure out how to turn it off for the YouTube people. They saw it and this is all just wasted time for them.
I want to go back to your comment around the "commission club" thing. Have you heard that term? I was cracking up. I have not heard that term before, but I think I can hear agents saying it. It sounds like something agents would say about networks.
Here's one of the things I always—I was part of two different networks. We were originally part of Indium, and then when we were purchased, we had to leave Indium and we were part of SIA. I would always get people reaching out: "Why did you decide to join Indium? What's it like being part of SIA? What's it like being part of a network?" People in other networks trying to compare. I never got "commission club," but I would get basically, "Oh, they don't add any value. They take more money."
I'll be honest with you, in both scenarios, when I did the math, if it was just a commission club, it was still worth being there. So I've never completely understood why—
Andy Matheson
Revenue is revenue.
Ryan Hanley
Yes. So I could understand someone saying, "Geez, they don't do anything but aggregate premium. It's a commission club." Okay, but I make more money than I would if I wasn't part of it. So I'm not really sure—if they were solely that, which neither one were. Both had their own set of services, just like Marshberry First Choice. I just never understood why that is used as a negative.
Andy Matheson
I think it's because of the language in the contract. You must remain independent. You're an independent agent for a reason. Don't join a group if you don't think you're going to remain independent. If that group has aspirations of acquiring you or getting equity stake in your agency or taking your commissions—personal preference, don't do it. I think that you lose independence. You lose autonomy. You're actually working with a true partner, not even a silent partner.
Groups and networks that are benefiting an independent agent allow them to stay independent. We're a silent partner. We don't touch your business. We advise. We give you better opportunities with these carriers. We get you the access you deserve. We give you some outlets to lean into. So that's kind of where I'm going.
Ryan Hanley
No, I am—just to be clear, I'm not saying there isn't a hierarchy of value that different networks give you. For sure there is. I guess I just assume that most networks, at face value, at a minimum, if you do the net net, you make more money being part of most networks. I definitely think there are networks where that is not the case. And I also think there are networks that add more value than others.
I think to your point, which is very important and probably the most important part: before you join any network or any agency cluster—there's all these little five and six agency clusters forming—I have heard some people say it's the best thing I ever did, and I've heard other people have horror stories. It's because we don't look at the exit clauses. You brought this up, and I think this is the most important part of all these contracts: what happens if everything goes wrong?
It's awesome to talk about the good stuff—this commission level, this split, this bonus structure, you get to fly to Hawaii if you hit President's Club. Amazing. All those things are amazing. What happens if things don't go right? What happens if the agency principal gets hit by a bus and his or her spouse, who doesn't want to run the agency, now wants to fire sale? How does that work? How do they get out? Do they get screwed? The exit clause in these contracts is so important.
The people I know that have the biggest beefs with any network, it always comes back to: you didn't really read the exit clause. They have gripes. Maybe those gripes are legitimate, but you didn't read the exit clause, and that's why you're pissed. And that's the sign of an agency owner that needs help. I keep saying this: it's okay. That's okay. You're not an expert in everything. Neither am I. Neither is Ryan Hanley. It's okay. So I think leaning into networks is vital.
Actually, did you know 70% of independent agencies are a part of a group in 2024 and beyond?
Andy Matheson
I didn't know it was that high, but I knew it was more than 50%.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah. Which is interesting. So any agency of any size—we're talking $250,000 in revenue, we're talking $200 million in revenue. I think that's interesting to assume as well because every agency is using it for different reasons, and that's something that I keep an eye on as well. Thankfully at First Choice, we have a lot of reasons why we would get a big agency involved versus a small agency. We're talking about the Marshberry ecosystem at that point, but we don't need to dive into it. It's just that if we're leveraging our value adds for every agency, it's not one size fits all.
Andy Matheson
Yep.
Ryan Hanley
You need this. You need that. I'm going to advise you according to who you are, the makeup of who you are, your aspirations, your goals, and what you're actually looking to accomplish. Is it perpetuation? Is it sale? Is it just to benchmark myself against another agency and understand what are my peaks and valleys, my gaps and overlaps? There's a lot to be said for every agency being treated uniquely, and that's not something I think every network does. So that's another big point to observe.
Andy Matheson
Yeah, no, I think it's a great point, and I love that you brought up that stat. I did not know it was that high.
What I think is really interesting—I wrote an article or created something, probably a podcast, around the idea that when I first joined Indium, which Cat Turns now runs and is doing a great job with—it's a much better run organization under Cat. She's doing a tremendous job compared to when I joined it. Just getting in and getting my hands up, the first time I had ever been part of a network because my previous agency that I worked for wasn't in a network. They were very against them.
There was this idea that my ex-father-in-law was like, "If you have to join a network, then you're not a good business owner. You're failing or you can't sell."
That happens a lot.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, but that happens a lot. And then I joined Indium and I was like, "Wait a minute." I get access to these four carriers that I need but probably don't have the ability to feed enough. So that's an advantage. I get contingencies on this carrier immediately day one that I wouldn't have gotten commission contingencies on for another year. I give up only the contingency point. Whatever the deal was, I can't remember exactly. There were some discounts on a couple of technologies. I remember going, "Okay."
I wrote an article at that time that said there may come a day in the not-too-distant future when you cannot do this alone anymore. Part of starting an agency, part of choosing your AMS or your CRM or your phone system, one of those primary decisions pre-launch, is going to be which network or aggregation system am I going to join upon launch? Do you believe that day is coming? Obviously, there'll always be exceptions, but could you see this number 70 going to 90 someday?
Andy Matheson
Here's an interesting way to respond to that. I think we're at the mercy of the carriers. I do, because I think they're starting to frown upon small groups—the five-person groups, the ten-person groups. They're saying to themselves, "If I'm Progressive, why am I giving the benefit to these five agencies where they're really not bringing anything different to me than they were on an individual basis?" There was nothing differently they're doing for me with these five specific agency groups. So the smaller groups could potentially fade just based on the mercy of the carriers. They're the ones who are going to dictate whether these groups are worthy of the higher splits and the profit sharing incentives.
To answer your question, I think it's a wait and see. I think the big ones are in the clear as far as their relationships with the companies, their ability to get the most out of them, and this mutual benefit to both the agency and the carrier. But the small ones may have this plateau where they can no longer grow because they're at the mercy of the carrier. So I think we should watch that. That's something to watch.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, I think—it's not breaking news that there is a lot of downward pressure on agencies, particularly smaller agencies, for production. I've heard from a bunch of my agent connections—we were seeing this a little bit at Rogue pre-moving over to SIA. Obviously that changed everything because of their scale in terms of the pressure that we had. But we had some pretty substantial pressure before we made that move from a few of our carriers on production. I was like, "Guys, I'm getting you in now because I need you to believe in what I'm trying to do five years from now." But because the market was changing, we were starting to get the, "Yeah, but we still need X amount of production to keep your appointment."
I've heard from a few of my friends who either run smaller agencies or are closer to startups that that downward pressure has continued and is starting to go up the book. Maybe before, if you had $250,000 in premium with a carrier, they were kind of pushing on you. Now it's like $500,000 or $750,000 that they're starting to push on you a little more. That market dynamic—how high that pressure goes, what size book—I think is going to determine a lot of the network adoption.
If carriers say, "If you have over $500,000 premium with us, you're good. We're happy, just keep producing." But if that starts to creep up and now it's, "If you're not at $750,000, we're going to have to evaluate this," or "If you're not at a million, we're going to evaluate this," that's going to push a lot of agents into the network discussion because they're going to want to keep writing that carrier, but they're not going to want to deal with the downward pressure all the time.
Andy Matheson
Dude, not only that, but there's some confusion right now. With these unprecedented times and the way this market is, you're hearing from carriers things like, "Hey, we no longer offer these products. And we don't really offer those bonuses anymore, so don't worry about that. And by the way, you actually didn't grow with us last year. And oh, by the way, can you write more business with us?" There's this confusion. We've pulled opportunities from you. You have to become more niche. You're not going to get paid the same on that niche. And by the way, I need you to do a lot more business with us. It's very conflicting. It's pulling the rug out from under you and making you get back on your feet immediately and do better than you did previously.
So I think it's a bit of a confusing time we're in. What that's going to do, piggybacking off of what you said, is possibly force agencies to join because then they really aren't going to have to have that pressure of production. They're not going to have to worry about these conversations as much. The confusion will probably dissipate because now that's the group's problem, not the individual's problem. So I think it's a strange time.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, no, it's definitely a strange time. I have two questions for you. I'm going to ask them both at the same time because I'm a bad podcast host. So just deal with that, and then you answer them in the order that you want to.
One, you said we have to become more niche. I'm very interested in that because considering the market dynamics, I actually think it will pay dividends and create sustainability in agencies if they become more of generalists. Let me articulate, and then we'll go one at a time because this is kind of a big question.
I push back on that from the standpoint of: if I have three carriers and I know what goes where and they have appetites and I've been growing with them, then all of a sudden the last two, three years happened. This hard market comes in and now there's holes in all those appetites because those carriers—and I'm trying not to bang on carriers as much because I know they're businesses. We have to deal with the reality of who they are. So they're looking at profitability and they're starting to pull out of markets or jacking up pricing. Now you have these three, four, or five classes of business that you wrote really well. You know where they went. All of a sudden, you don't know where to put them.
If instead you wrote 20 classes of business instead of five—broad stroking the numbers here, don't hold me to five versus 20—but if you became more of a generalist and said, "We know how to write these five really well, but what we're going to do is add five more or ten more classes that we write really well," now all of a sudden your pool becomes bigger and you have more opportunities. Does that make sense? By broadening our appetite as agents, we are giving ourselves the flexibility to move with the market. Maybe all of a sudden we can't write those auto repair shops anymore that we've been killing it with because so-and-so carrier doesn't want them. But we could slide into bakeries for a while and crush because they'll still write bakeries. So I guess that's just my thought. What do you think about niching more versus going more generalist as a way to weather this storm?
Andy Matheson
Well, it changes your business model. If I'm an insurance agency and I do one thing really well—for us, that was always personal lines, professional networking. That was my mission. Carriers come in and say that's just no longer the way we're going to take on business. Obviously, personal lines is a mess. You've got to change your business model. Scratch that idea. I can't proceed with my current referral partners. My professional network changes. My day-to-day changes. I think it sets an agency back a little bit as far as how they're going to recalibrate and reassess how they're going to accomplish what a carrier wants.
Now, although going back to the original question, being more of a generalist is better long-term for the health of your agency. In the near term, I think it's a hindrance on your success rate, which ultimately hinders your revenue, which hinders your growth, which hinders your ability to hire and do well with your tech. I think we're in this very funky state of the industry. It's putting a halt and saying, "Reassess yourselves. Come back to us in a little bit, and then you can realize what you're going to do for us as a company."
Ryan Hanley
Dude, I love that perspective. I actually agree with you, and I think that's a really good perspective. I would completely agree that if you had three to five niche markets that were your primary specialty, if you followed my advice in the most straightforward manner, it definitely would set you back. I think that's a very fair assessment, and I'm kind of thinking about this in real time. I love that you said that.
But if I were to game plan that, what I would say is: I think the earlier you can create a base, an inbound base that can—what I'm advocating in general with my consulting agency is that creating an inbound flow and base of business gives you the sustainability to ride these out because you've created a mechanism to place a wide range of accounts that come in on their own accord because they've chosen. It's easy to close, high converting, but you have to cast a little wider net, and that's what I teach people to do.
I had an awesome conversation with Charles Speck, who is going to be a couple episodes before this one comes out, where we were talking about how the answer is probably—today you're going to face some turmoil, but I think this really is the answer for agencies moving forward. We need to have this layer, this inbound layer, that creates a steadily increasing foundation of revenue generation. Inbound is never going to give you—it is very rare that inbound is going to give you these huge monumental growth moments. What it does is incrementally increase every month, and then all of a sudden, two, three years later, you pop your head up and you're like, "Holy crap, I'm doing nothing and bringing in X amount of premium every month." That's awesome.
Andy Matheson
Yeah.
Ryan Hanley
And what Charles and I kind of got to—and you said this and it just set this thought off in my head, I think you're so right—is that both are necessary. We pick our three to five niches. He recommends one to three max. Say we have those, and those are our big wins. Those are the accounts we crush. Those are the ones that put those big spikes in revenue on the board. But underneath that, having that base layer of inbound allows us to ride out these types of storms. If you haven't built it today, you're going to feel some pain. But understanding that the market doesn't feel like it's going to become any less dynamic in the next five to ten years, considering what's going on politically and economically, that feels like the formula. Have your nice base layer and then these targeted big wins that you go after with maybe an outbound program. Does that sound like what you're saying?
Andy Matheson
Yeah, and I think that base layer you're talking about is probably only attainable if you are part of something bigger because it might not be something you can achieve on your own. That's why I'm advocating a network. It's okay to lean into the network for the foundational stuff that you're talking about that can no longer be accomplished with the way the market is. And it's okay to be niche when you feel like you already have that access and relationship with the people and companies that you know you can get done. But then you're talking two different business models in one.
Here's what I would advise. If you're an agency owner and you do have this issue, start to hire producers for the niches that you're trying to grow in. For example, if you're a commercial lines shop, you have your specific producer—one or two individuals who specifically go after roofers and plumbers and contractors. Then you work on another individual who goes after the habitational stuff and maybe the cannabis stuff. Then you have individuals that represent your niches, and you can grow those verticals within your organization. They know their markets. Some are going to lean into the network access, and some are going to lean into your individual access that you have as an agency. That allows you to be versatile because now you're not relying on one vertical or two or three. You can lean into your specific silos of production. You're looking over here with these producers. That's the right way, in my opinion, to grow your agency long-term because now you're not worried about these market influxes. It's just, "Okay, some are going to drive more revenue today. Some are going to drive more revenue tomorrow. And I'm just going with the punches."
Ryan Hanley
So what I hear you saying as well is being intentional about the thought process. From a sustainability standpoint—I have this concept and actually shared it in a solo video that will have also been out by the time this one comes out. It's this idea of how I used to pitch people who'd push back on me about the value of insurance. At Rogue, we wrote a lot of startups. Even when I was back at the Murray Group, we wrote a lot of startups or new businesses. A lot of times, people who have been in business for ten years completely respect insurance, listen to you, take your advice. New in business? Know everything they've ever needed to know about insurance. You're an asshole and you don't know anything.
Totally. So they would call and I'd say, okay, man, here's my pitch on why insurance is important. Insurance provides the foundation in which you build growth. You can't grow without insurance. And I could almost hear them on the phone, like taking that in. And depending on the response, I'd be like, look, here's the deal. If you don't have workers' compensation insurance, you can't hire more people. You want to add a professional element to your business? You need E&O. You want to go raise money? Now you have a board of directors? You need D&O. You want to expand the size of jobs you work on? You need a commercial umbrella. So your growth, your top-line revenue growth that turns you on, none of it is possible without this foundation.
Andy Matheson
I've never heard anyone say it like that. That's outstanding.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah, and everyone can steal that or just join Finding Peak today. Learn even more tidbits like that. Ba-dum-bum, dynamite drop. So, I think this foundation to growth analogy is great. My only thing I would add is that you also need to have a closer—a completely different position with a completely different psychological profile—who handles your inbound accounts. It's like creating a generalist inbound niche. If you were to hire me to come work at your agency, I would not be amazing at cold calling. I don't want to do it, and I wouldn't be great. However, you put me as a closer, just have my phone ring and have me close. I'll close 90% of the accounts that come in because that's what I'm good at. There are other people who couldn't do that but dominate as outbound producers. So we almost have to think about this inbound position like another niche that just gets us this consistent flow of business. And then we have these other people who are going after those $10,000, $5,000, $20,000 revenue accounts.
Andy Matheson
And when they pop, they pop.
Ryan Hanley
Yeah. And then that way, no matter what happens, you're protected. The ebbs and flows don't impact you as much.
Andy Matheson
I see what you're saying. But I don't think you can accomplish that without your network because you're fighting your carriers all day. I want to reiterate that point—I hope people didn't lose it. For inbound to work, you have to have a decent carrier set. Two or three carriers and inbound is not going to help you. At Rogue, the day we closed, we had 61 markets. That was too many, way too many. I get that. But what it allowed us to do was place business. We had 221 industry classes that we placed. So I'm not advocating for 62 markets. But I do think finding a network that matches your value structure is important if you don't have a broad portfolio of carriers directly. That allows you to place the business exactly where it's supposed to go versus trying to wedge it in somewhere. Speaking specifically to inbound, you're going to have a broad set—a bakery, then a contractor, then a marketing consultant, then a delivery person. Having a broad set of carriers, which I believe is probably only possible through some sort of network relationship today, is the only way to get that done.
Ryan Hanley
That is a perfect opportunity for me to transition over to something real quick. Because I think it's just as important—you can't plan for your business without some sort of financial guarantees. With the lack of personal lines new business and our commercial lines in and out of niche opportunity, you are banking on your current revenue, but that can fluctuate so strongly with regards to your production and your retention. If you are part of a network, you have a little bit more guarantee that you're going to know your financial outlook every year because there are profit sharing guarantees, contingency bonuses, and commission enhancements specific to each company you write with. That allows you to plan ahead for building up those silos we talked about, hiring, training, and getting software in place. So a network also financially benefits you because you have some guarantees behind the way you're planning your business.
Andy Matheson
I want to ask you one more question specific about this before we wrap. The way I've seen a lot of network memberships pitched to agencies—and I'm not just talking about Indium or SIA, I've been part of different conversations with a bunch of different stuff—it usually boils down to owner income. It comes down to, hey, overtime, discounts, relationship, whatever your value things are, you can make more money as an agency owner by being part of this network. My question is, do you think in the times we're in today, that pitch should change from owner income improvements to growth? If I were pitching a network today, I would focus on growth. I would say, look, the only way to get through these times is not to maximize your personal income. It's to grow your agency. And the best way to do that is to be here. Ten, twenty years ago, when the markets were really stable and soft, it was owner income, owner income. You're going to grow regardless. Prices are always coming down, owner income. Today, I feel like that needs to be changed to growth, growth, growth. Is that wrong? Do you disagree?
Ryan Hanley
No, it makes me think of a really good point that my brother Ryan actually mentioned to me just this morning. And I'm just going to read it because it's sitting right here in front of me. It says, building a business fast is way easier than building it slow. And what Ryan meant by that is twofold. Growing agencies have a tendency to take profits out of the company far too early—put it in their own pockets at the sacrifice of the agency's growth. When you're in pure growth mode, reinvest most of the profits back in to fuel the growth. Pour the gas on the fire now in favor of larger returns later. The business is going to go through waves of growth where you figure out strategies that just seem to align with the market at the right time. It's important to triple down on what's working and put the blinders on because you don't know how long that specific wave is going to last. When Ryan said that, I was like, yep, that's completely what agency owners should be focusing on right now. You are not in a market to make money for yourself today. You are in a market that's allowing you to take opportunities, do whatever you can to grow now because your benefit is triple down the road.
Andy Matheson
Yes, dude, I literally love that. Guys, go back, hit the back button 30 seconds and listen to that again. I couldn't agree more. I had a former employee at Rogue kind of troll me on the internet and make a comment about how Rogue wasn't profitable. I don't engage with trolls, but in my head I was like, that is such a stupid statement. We were a three-year-old agency. If I were to put our growth rate against any other agency in the country, we would blow everyone out of the water. It wouldn't even be close. The things we were doing were insane. And yes, we weren't profitable because we were a three-year-old agency.
I wanted to grab as much market share as I possibly could as fast as I could. You can always cut expenses out of a business, but it's really hard to put revenue on the top. So I could not agree with that more. This hard market—if you are complaining about not being able to grow, I know there are extenuating circumstances and I'm not saying it's easy, but this is an opportunity. Small gains today will spring forward in the future. All of a sudden you'll look up and you'll be light years from where you are. Now is not the time to take profits. Reinvest hard, harder, double, triple down. It's time to become a wartime general.
If you are not a wartime general, find someone in your agency or find someone you can bring in who is, or find a coach or a mentor or a consultant who can come in and be a wartime general for you. That is what you need right now. The people who do what you just said are going to be the ones we have on pedestals three, five, ten years from now. I love it.
Ryan Hanley
I'm glad we covered that. That's really important right now. All right, dude, I appreciate the hell out of you. I love this. Where can people connect with you personally? And if they would just want to learn more about what you're doing or Marshberry Smart, FirstChoice, where do they go?
Andy Matheson
Always on LinkedIn. Andy Matheson on LinkedIn is the best. If you want to get in touch with me, chat with me, DM, and we can set something up specific. I think you're going to be pleasantly surprised at what networks are doing right now. It is not what you thought five, ten years ago. So consider that. Don't just think your agency doesn't fit the mold because of what you think it is. Get some education, understand what it really means, and then you can make an educated decision.
Ryan Hanley
Dude, appreciate the hell out of you. I'm so happy for you. I'm proud of that journey. Not that you need to hear that, but just as someone who cares about your success, I'm proud that you're in a place that you feel better. I can see it in you. The last couple of times I saw you, you could just see the stress on you a little bit.
Andy Matheson
I love it. I've heard that from a few people. I feel it too. I feel that sense of relief. And I'm very appreciative that you would come on and share your story, share your emotions, to hear that stuff.
Ryan Hanley
Awesome, bud. Let's get out of here.
Andy Matheson
Awesome. Good to talk to you, man. Talk to you soon. Thank you.
Ryan Hanley
Thank you.
Promotional segment begins
Close twice as many deals by this time next week. Sound impossible? It's not with the One Call Close system. You'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we used to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle-tested, the One Call Close system eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclose.com. That's masteroftheclose.com. Do it today.