Main Topic: Agency Accounting and Financial Management for Insurance Agencies
Key Points:
Participants:
Takeaways:
Recommendations:
Became a Master of the Close: https://masteroftheclose.com
Unlock the secrets to a thriving insurance agency with a deep dive into the world of accounting, where precision meets profitability.
✅ Join over 10,000 newsletter subscribers: https://go.ryanhanley.com/
✅ For daily insights and ideas on peak performance: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryanhanley
✅ Subscribe to the YouTube show: https://youtube.com/ryanmhanley
AgencyPoint website: https://www.myagencypoint.com/
Aaron Stocks on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/aaroncstocks/
Mick Hunt on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mickhunt/
Chris Paradiso on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/christopherparadiso/
Carrie Wallace on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/carey-wallace-393a8620/
Join me and my expert panel—Carrie, Chris, Mick, and Aaron—as we peel back the layers of financial management that can make or break your agency's success.
From the indispensable nature of meticulous financial reporting to the nuanced world of agency valuations, we traverse the fiscal landscape that underpins our industry's growth and sustainability.
Discover the profound impact of getting your numbers right and learn why delegating accounting to specialists like Agency Point can lead to revelatory growth and efficiency.
This conversation is a goldmine for anyone entangled in the web of commission reconciliation and financial evaluation, as we share war stories of unpaid commissions and the hidden wealth often overlooked in an agency's books.
My personal journey from hands-on financial wrangling to the strategic move of outsourcing unravels the critical importance of a hawk-eye on your financial health. We dissect the common issues plaguing insurance agencies and offer up a treasure trove of tactics to ensure you're capturing every dollar you deserve, all while providing insights into the transformative power of specialized accounting services like those offered by Agency Point
But it's not all numbers and spreadsheets; our chat brims with humor and camaraderie as we introduce you to the personalities behind Agency Point, your potential allies in navigating the financial intricacies of the insurance world.
We discuss the partnership synergy that benefits both established agencies and those with an eye on expansion. By the end, you'll emerge equipped with the knowledge and strategies to shepherd your agency towards financial clarity and success, proving once again that when it comes to business, it's all about the bottom line.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Episodes You Might Enjoy:
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
In a crude laboratory in the basement of his home... Hello everyone, and welcome back to the show. Today we have an absolutely tremendous episode for you. A conversation about agency accounting. Something that everybody wants to talk about. I say that laughing because accounting is horrible.
00:00:30
However, having done four years as the CEO and founder of Rogue Risk, and having been an executive multiple times now—and actually, most people don't know this about me, but I used my math degree and was a consultant for one of the top five accounting firms, RSM and Gladry, for almost five years—I've always appreciated how important accounting is. I hate it. I absolutely hate thinking about it. To me, I want to see the numbers. I want to see the financial statements. I want to see the numbers. Numbers are important. You can't operate your business without knowing your numbers.
00:01:00
And we talk a lot about that today with this crew of absolutely amazing people who I just adore. But I hate the work of accounting. So that being said, this solution we're talking about today, AgencyPoint, is a rebranded version of a solution I've actually used. And I talk about that. I want to be upfront: PFS, we were a client of PFS and Aaron Stocks for about two years. When I sold to SIA, they took us off of PFS. But we were a client. I was incredibly happy. I love what they're doing. I love this crew. I think this is an important topic.
00:01:30
These guys are not paying me to be here. This is not an advertisement. I love Carrie. I love Chris. I love Mick. And I think Aaron is amazing. While I don't know him as well, I enjoyed being a client of his company. They helped us clean up our accounting a ton. I just think this topic is so important that I want to get it in front of you. Whether you use these guys or don't, it means nothing to me. They're not an advertiser. I want to be very clear and upfront about that.
00:02:00
I just think this topic—for most business owners, it's not something you should be doing. If you are an agency owner, you should not be doing this work. Someone else should be doing this work for you and delivering the reports to you so you can make good business decisions. But you should not be doing this work. Every minute you spend on this type of work as an agency owner is time that you are losing to actually running your business, to growing your business, which is where your focus should be.
00:02:30
So with that, I love you for listening to this show. Guys, this is a highly tactical episode. It's a wonderful episode. I think you're going to get a lot out of it. If you do, I would hope that you could share this episode. We are trying to grow. As we came off of the Agency Intelligence Network, we are rebuilding our listenership. We're gaining more followers every day. We're gaining more listeners. Our audience is growing. We have the YouTube version of the show if you're not watching there. We're going to have some audio exclusives coming. So if you're not subscribed to the podcast, you're not going to get those audio exclusives.
00:03:00
Diving more into this content work and really being a true information, concept, thought, framework, idea, statistic, trend provider for you guys is something that I love doing. It's what wakes me up every day. In order to continue doing that work, we have to grow the audience. That shows me that this is good stuff. So if you enjoy this, share it with a friend. Subscribe if you're not subscribed. I love you for listening to this show. Let's get on to Carrie Wallace, Chris Paradiso, Mick Hunt, and Aaron Stocks.
00:03:30
Music transition
All right, party people. I'll be honest with you. When you guys wanted to do this conversation, I was obviously very excited. But I didn't mentally prepare for the powerhouse squad that would be on the call here. I was just kind of like, Carrie was like, "Hey, we're doing this thing." And I was like, "Of course, let's talk about it. Sounds amazing." And then I just didn't wrap my head around that we would have four power brokers at one time on the call. Normally you have to pay for this kind of thing—like some of those backroom deals that Paradiso does when he visits New Orleans.
00:04:00
So this is a very interesting and exciting time for me, just a guy trying to make his way through the podcasting world, to have so many power players. I think we're going to talk about something that as a former agency owner of a small agency coming up, I want to talk about the importance of the accounting function in general. I want to talk about some of the mistakes that we're making and seeing. And then I want to get into, as we go, what the impetus was of pulling all this together.
00:04:30
Before we get in, I just want to be clear for everyone. I've actually used Aaron's company, PFS. We used them at Rogue Risk. We are a former client. Some people will see on the AgencyPoint website that there's a testimonial for us. We've worked directly with these guys and we have first-hand experience—or had first-hand experience—with Rogue Risk. That's why I was excited for pulling this all together.
00:05:00
But Carrie, I'd like to start with you and talk a little bit about where did AgencyPoint come from? Why was now the time? We'll jump around to everybody—not everyone has to answer the same question—but why now? Why pull something like this together? Why create an offering and a company of this nature? What was the timing here and why did you think it was important?
Carrie Wallace
Yeah, it's a great question, Ryan. As you know, I work with lots of independent insurance agencies. One of the first questions I ask them in order to do the work that they're engaging with me, I have to have clean financials. I need to understand their business from a dollars and cents standpoint. Very often it is a pain point. It's an area where agencies struggle. Either they're using someone that they think is fantastic, and once they send me the financials, I am the fortunate person that needs to point out otherwise, sadly.
00:05:30
There is such a huge need for quality people that understand independent insurance agencies and businesses enough to provide accounting services so they can run their businesses and make strong choices. Just because you go to an accountant that's down the road does not mean they understand your business. Even a CPA down the road may not understand your business.
00:06:00
So why now? It came up so often in my work that this is such a need. I actually explored building it myself. But as a person who's worked in several startups, building everything your own is not necessarily the smartest thing in the world to do. As I explored and talked and thought about it, I think partnering made a ton of sense in order to help agents and continue to stay focused in my own business. So that's why now for me. I found someone—I found Aaron, I found Chris and Mick—all were around this organization that's been serving so many independent agents very, very well. It made a lot of sense to partner together in order to bring these services.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Carrie just used the term "clean financials." What is clean financials? What does that actually look like? What does that mean? I'll say firsthand experience, and I feel bad for your team when they first started working with us. Obviously, we got things together after a couple of months. But I remember at the beginning, you guys were like, "Hey, we're going to get you into QuickBooks and whatever." And I was like, "OK, guys, go." I kind of just threw that. They had 10,000 questions, as they rightly should, because we hadn't processed things or tagged things properly.
00:07:00
I think a lot of agency owners probably feel like their financials are good enough, or they don't see a problem, or it's one of these unknown unknowns kind of things. What do clean financials actually look like? What is the goal of actually getting to clean financials? What does that output actually look like for you guys when you're working with a new client?
Aaron Stocks
It's a good question. It's going to vary depending on the size of the agency on what clean financials means. But for a typical agency, the clean financials would have everything classified correctly on the income statement and balance sheet. One of the biggest things that people miss, which we'll probably get into later, is having their trust account reconciled correctly, where they're breaking up the fiduciary and non-fiduciary funds, picking up the non-fiduciary funds as income—whether that be retained commission or fees—and then properly classifying the rest of the income and expenses. That's the typical clean financials for a small to mid-sized agency. As they get larger, that could change. They might have GAAP standards they have to comply with or things like that. But that would be a short answer.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
I want to ask about the GAAP standard stuff. I had an experience where we had always run off a cash accounting basis for the obvious reason. Maybe it's worth explaining why most agencies, especially when they first begin, but even as they grow, stay on a cash accounting basis. But then if you take certain levels of investment, if you join certain organizations that have to be held to a GAAP standard, that changes.
00:08:30
Maybe this is a very personal question just because I had to experience this head on and had a very strong opinion on it. When you do have to comply with GAAP standards, do you need to keep two sets of books? My opinion was that in order to accurately understand where the agency is, we always have to be on cash. If we need to, we could add an accrual set of books that are run off an accrual basis in order to hit GAAP standards. But in order to just know exactly where we are at any given moment, we need to stay on cash.
00:09:00
Is this something agencies need to be thinking about? At what point do they need to think about this? Because you can see very different snapshots at very different times using the two different methods. Because our product is earned over time and not necessarily something you can book at the moment, I know accrual accounting becomes very difficult in a standard retail agency. This might be getting super nerdy, but this was something I dealt with head on, and I'm very interested in your take being a pro. I'm kind of an armchair accountant. I worked for an accounting firm for a time, but I don't actually know what I'm doing. I'm not just a member, I'm also a client. How does that work for people? When do they need to start thinking deeper about this?
Aaron Stocks
Most agencies will probably never have to think about it unless they're acquired or take on a large amount of investment where there is a covenant—either from a bank or a private equity firm, or just lenders in general—that require a GAAP standard or an annual review or audit. Most agencies can stay in what we call income tax cash or income tax accrual basis, where it's relatively simple accounting and it's the most cost effective.
00:10:00
When you get into GAAP, you have FASB, the Financial Accounting Standards Board, which regulates all the standards that you have to comply with. That could be ASC 606, ASC 842. When you get into those things, it's very costly because you have to analyze things a lot deeper than cash comes in or cash goes out.
00:10:30
To get to your point of do you have to run two separate books if you move over to GAAP to know your cash inflows or outflows, the answer is no. You can run other reports like the statement of cash flows or even convert your GAAP financials into cash or accrual in order to get the numbers that you're seeking on a cash basis. That has to be done anyway because people don't typically file taxes in a GAAP basis. That's not a basis that's checked on the tax return. It's either cash or accrual. So you already have to do some type of conversion, at least on an annual basis, from GAAP to cash or accrual.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Nice. Okay, cool. I know that was kind of nerdy. I was just thinking about when I fought this battle, I was probably like 60% right and 40% wrong in my take on that particular issue. I'll take the W just because it's my podcast and no one will ever call me on it, but I think I was at least partially wrong. So I appreciate that answer.
00:11:00
Mick, looking at the agencies that you've worked with—obviously you've been an agency owner but have done a substantial amount of work in the segment of the market—having your books be accurate is important all the time, no matter what stage or season of your agency. But there's definitely a heightened level of importance as you start to grow to a particular size because you're starting to deal with... There was a period of time at Rogue where it was just like, as long as I had more money in the bank account at the end of the month than expenses, we were winning. That didn't always happen, but it was a victory. There wasn't really even any accounting happening. It was just like, okay, the credit card is $2,200 and we have $2,300 in the bank account. Victory. On to the next month.
00:11:30
But obviously we all grow out of that at certain points. How do you actually see this with a lot of the agencies that you're working with at Premier Strategy Box or Patty, et cetera? How does this—to me, this feels like something we don't talk about enough—how does this impact how agency owners should be thinking about their accounting? How does it impact how they lead? Where does having these accurate financials, understanding your numbers, come into from a leadership perspective? How can you actually leverage that information to run your agency more efficiently?
Mick Hunt
Yeah, that's a good point. To piggyback on some things that Carrie was saying, a lot of agency owners are just afraid to actually know their numbers. You can't make real decisions on where your agency is going. Where do I spend money? Where do I take money out? How do I prepare my taxes?
00:12:00
For me, that was the biggest thing as an agency owner—having everything categorized so that at the end of the year, the beginning of the following year, I could have real life conversations with whoever's doing my taxes who isn't in the insurance world. Most accountants, most tax accountants, aren't in the insurance business. So we have to explain a lot. If we don't know the categorizations of what our P&L is saying, other than just the summed up totals, we're at a loss.
00:12:30
For me, I think that was the biggest thing that was important. That was what partnering with PFS meant for me—just the ability to help agency owners be owners. Because there is information that we must know. So again, to me, that's the biggest impact that I see.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Chris, this comes as something that I've always been envious of—your ability to stay focused working on the business instead of getting too deep in the business. I know this has been something that you've worked through and it's been a period of time, it's not like it just happened overnight for you. But I think you do a very good job of being both involved in your agency, not separated from it, but also continuing to manage and work on your business.
00:13:00
Coming off of what Mick just said, that's kind of what I heard—using these numbers, using financials, understanding what your numbers are, it allows you to focus your time working on the business. Is that an accurate representation? And how do you actually implement this in your own agency?
Chris Paradiso
Well, to back up to answer that a little bit, first is I used to do it in-house. I came to the conclusion that the in-house person wasn't working out. We decided to depart from each other. It was quick—within two weeks. So then I was kind of in a jam. Where do you go? Where do you find somebody? Finding somebody in the insurance space that actually understands the financial aspects is not that easy. You can find people in other industries, but it doesn't transfer over well.
00:13:30
I ended up outsourcing to a company, and that company ended up...
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Did I lose you guys?
Chris Paradiso
Nope, you're still there. I just made you the primary person. That's all. No worries.
So what ended up happening was the books got so screwed up, Ryan, that I was fortunate enough to know enough people in the industry. I started calling some friends, and a good friend of mine says to me, "Call Aaron Stocks." So I picked up the phone. I called Aaron, and we started with PFS and we started dissecting.
00:14:00
One of the key aspects that I realized, unfortunately, was 10 years in—more than that—we weren't reconciling our commissions on a monthly basis per carrier. Yes, I hired a company to do that, but it wasn't getting done. PFS found over $66,000 in one year of unpaid commissions. Am I accurate about that, Aaron?
Aaron Stocks
$67 if you round up, but yeah.
Chris Paradiso
It was a lot of money. How many years did I lose commissions? We chose to only go back, I think it was what, 24 months, Aaron?
Aaron Stocks
Two years, yeah.
Chris Paradiso
Yeah, we didn't go back years, which we should have. It was just too costly, and that's a tall task. But in order to be able to run a business and to work outside of my agency, you really have to know the numbers.
00:14:30
So how does this play a role? Every single month, I'm fortunate enough to have PFS be able to do the back numbers. And then my front numbers are being done by Carrie as a fractional CFO. The key aspect behind that is that allows me to be able to do what I need to do, which really is to try to make it rain for the agency. So I'm fortunate to partner with the right people in the right organization. That's how this all came about. I feel other agencies need this just as I needed this in order to get to that next level.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
This is one of the things that blew my mind. Chris has shared the story, the reconciliation story, with me before, and it blew my mind when he was telling me. I was always under the impression before owning Rogue Risk—and actually, we found a small amount, I mean we were brand new, but I think we found like maybe two or three accounts that we owed...
00:15:00
Recorded segment begins
What's up, guys? Sorry to take you away from the episode, but as you know, we do not run ads on this show. In exchange for that, I need your help. If you're loving this episode, if you enjoy this podcast, whether you're watching on YouTube or you're listening on your favorite podcast platform, I would love for you to subscribe, share, comment if you're on YouTube, leave a rating review if you're on Spotify or Apple iTunes. This helps the show grow. It helps me bring more guests in.
00:15:30
We have a tremendous lineup of people coming in—men and women who've done incredible things, sharing their stories around peak performance, leadership, growth, sales—the things that are going to help you grow as a person and grow your business. But they all check out comments, ratings, reviews. They check out all this information before they come on. So as I reach out to more and more people and want to bring them in and share their stories with you, I need your help. Share the show. Subscribe if you're not subscribed. I'd love for you to leave a comment about the show because I read all the comments. Or if you're on Apple or Spotify, leave a rating review of this show. I love you for listening to this show, and I hope you enjoy listening as much as I do creating the show for you. All right, I'm out of here. Peace. Let's get back to the episode.
Recorded segment ends
00:16:00
After we started working with you, or we were owed commissions on—it wasn't anything like Chris's number just because we're not nearly been in business or have as many clients—but I was always under this impression, and I've heard this said at conferences, that carriers don't miss commissions. This is what they do. You always get paid. When's the last time you didn't get a check from Travelers or whatever? Not to knock Travelers, but these are the kinds of things that you'll hear thrown around different conferences. These ideas get perpetuated to the industry. And then all of a sudden you find a situation like Chris's, where you don't realize that you're down $66,000 that you haven't been paid in a 24-month period just because you haven't been reconciling properly.
00:16:30
Is this something that agencies need to be worried about? Is this something that you find fairly common when you first dig in with a client and you start to do some of this reconciliation for them? Is this a common thing that you find—lost revenue that you're owed but haven't been paid?
Aaron Stocks
There's probably always a percentage. Probably not as large as Chris's. His was probably a more unusual example of how large something could get if you're not reconciling it. It's a tough balance because new agencies don't necessarily have producers they have to pay. So reconciling their commissions isn't a huge priority. And it also isn't cheap. It could maybe 30 to 40% times your normal bookkeeping fee—that's what it costs to reconcile. So it's not cheap. You need to find balance between, "Is it worth reconciling to find missed revenue?" or "Am I going to start paying producers that I have to reconcile anyway?"
00:17:00
But as soon as we start reconciling, there is typically always some commission that is missed. That could be for a number of reasons—user error, maybe the carrier did something incorrectly. But when we reconcile, there's usually always something that is missing. I can get into a little bit how we find it, but there's usually always something that is missing.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Before you get into how we find it, because I do want to know that, do you see more of this issue in agency bill stuff that's premium financed or direct bill? Or does it not correlate?
Aaron Stocks
It just depends on the agency and the state and the carriers that they're using. It could be in both. Obviously, agency bill can have more user error because a lot of times there's retained commission that never got retained or something. But the same issues exist in direct bill.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
I would love for you to dive a little bit deeper into how do you actually go find this stuff. What does that process look like?
Aaron Stocks
There are really two steps to verify that you're paid what you're owed. The main point of commission reconciliation that most agencies use it for is to pay producers. But to verify that the commission income is coming into you correctly from, let's say, direct bill, it's twofold.
00:18:00
One is you need a list of all your carriers to ensure that you're receiving a deposit from those carriers each month. If you don't receive a deposit that month—whether it's a check or ACH—then you need to go to the carrier side or get the commission statement to see if you were negative or if you had chargebacks where you're not going to receive commissions. Having a list of all your carriers and commission statements actually reviewed to see if you should have received the check that you never did is step one. That would be checking your general ledger and making sure you have a deposit from every carrier.
00:18:30
After you do that, you would then reconcile your commissions in your agency management system. Whatever system you're using, you'd reconcile the commissions, which would then mark off what you've been paid by policy. After that, you can produce what's called a leftover report. That's what we call it—every policy that was unpaid. Usually we'll say give us that 30 to 60 day leeway because the carriers take a while to pay. But if it's over 60 days, then we should find out why it wasn't paid. Most of the time on those reports, it was a cancellation that didn't get updated in the AMS or something like that. But sometimes you'll find out, "Hey, this didn't get paid on. Let's find out why from the carrier," and then you get paid on it. That's the process that you take.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
The first time that Chris told me the story about his particular situation, I was just blown away. Completely naive. I just didn't think that that didn't... You think of all the things you have to think about as an agency owner—how much it takes to actually bring the revenue in, make sure everything's operating properly. And then you're like, "And now I have to worry about getting paid? Actually getting the check?" It just starts to get overwhelming.
00:19:30
Carrie, when you're sitting down with an agency owner and they're maybe interested in evaluation or they're interested in whatever their particular reason is for starting to sit down with you, what are some of the first aspects of the financial statements that you start to dig into that we really want to make sure are accurate so we have a good understanding of what's going on in that agency? Obviously, we want to make sure all the numbers are accurate, but what are some of those first numbers that you dig into to go, "Man, if these are good, then we have a good feel for where we're at"?
Carrie Wallace
Let's talk about valuation. That is a very common thing, and that's one of the ways that I get to know agencies really, really well. I ask for five years of financials, and I'm looking for a trend over that five years—their growth rate and revenue, their expense highs or lows. What I'm trying to get to is what is a reasonable expectation of the ongoing operation of this agency. What does it take to run this agency?
00:20:00
To piggyback off of what Mick said, if it's not classified the same way year over year, that's going to be a mess. I'm going to have a really hard time seeing trends. So number one: are there trends, and can we actually explain the trends? If we can't, we need to dig in and get it consistent.
00:20:30
The second is agencies have a tax strategy and an operating strategy. Sometimes there are expenses that are being run through an agency to minimize taxes. We totally get that. It depends on your tax structure, how much you run those expenses through. But we've got to get to what does it really take to run this agency. That is something that every agency owner should know. What is a tax strategy in your P&L and what is your true profitability? Because at the end of the day, that cash flow and that profitability is what drives the value of your business and should be the thing that drives decisions you're making.
00:21:00
That is a huge part of what we do—how do we pull out the discretionary funds that you might be running through your business and get to that true north? Because the reality is you might make different decisions about how you spend those discretionary funds in order to grow your business and maximize your value. So those are the two main things that I do when I look at people's financials.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
By discretionary funds, you mean—and I'm sorry, just one second—you mean like instead of having a vehicle under your personal name, you're running your car through your business, your business owns your car, et cetera, your cigar club membership, like Chris has got all those go-go clubs that he is part of, that kind of stuff. Another American flag for the office, that kind of expense. All those things.
Carrie Wallace
Yes.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Okay. Gotcha.
Chris Paradiso
I was just going to give a real example of what you said, Carrie. Hey, Chris, I'm looking through your numbers. Why is this $10,000 here? What is this for? I said, "Oh, this was one of the agents made an error. Our deductible for our errors and omissions was $25,000. So it was a $4,300, $4,500 claim. We had an attorney draw up an agreement. We paid the gentleman to keep everybody happy. We couldn't declare whose real fault it was. It was miscommunication either way." And Carrie says, "Why do you have it under errors and omissions?"
And I was like, well, it's part of errors and omissions. And she says, no, because your errors and omissions, if it costs you $50,000, and let's just say you covered another $30,000 of these small, you know, avoiding errors and omission claims, it shows $80,000. Well, it should show $80,000 every year or a little bit higher because your E&O doesn't usually go down. And I was like, great example, Carrie. So we had to start a separate funnel for that because that should not be classified under errors and omissions. And that was a real learning experience that happened to me. And my accountant says, "Hey, I didn't realize that." And that's why my accountant's 85 and I'm moving over to PFS, because this would have been caught earlier if we utilized somebody who specifically knew insurance agencies, like AgencyPoint.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
And Chris, how does catching that help you? When you say, like, how does that help you? What does that then allow you to do now that you have that broken out properly and you can look at it? Is it allowing you to budget better? Is it allowing you to better understand? Like, what is that allowing you to better understand?
Chris Paradiso
Just a lot of things. But I'm going to let Carrie answer that because I know.
Carrie Wallace
Yeah, please go. Let's just say if I didn't dig in and I didn't understand that. And I also, let's say I'm a valuation person that values all kinds of different businesses. So to me, $80,000 in an insurance business insurance account makes sense. And I say, "OK, it's a reasonable expectation that it's going to cost $80,000 to insure this business." And I don't correct it. Well, that's $50,000 that did not drop to the bottom line and did not get multiplied by the appropriate multiplier to determine the value of Chris's agency. So if I didn't take those one-time expenses out and right-size his P&L, he is going to have a skewed impression of what the potential value of his agency is.
And let's not—that's a unique one. But what about someone who's branding, who's changed their name or has decided to change their logo? A one-time thing you do that will not repeat. And it's in a fund that's pretty large, which is marketing, and can vary greatly. We've got to get to what is an ongoing expense that makes sense. And you have to do that in every single account to make sure that you get to what's reasonable, because that's what a potential buyer is going to do. And if you don't know it yourself as the seller and you don't catch it, guess who's going to benefit from dropping that to the bottom line in the sale? It's going to be the buyer, and you just left major money on the table.
But the other part is, what if you don't discern that and you plan for next year and say, "I can't hire a producer"? Well, you can, because what you actually are going to budget will be far less if you take those one-time expenses out.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Gotcha. So again, I'm kind of the layman here. If I'm looking at it and I take the one-time expenses, it can skew the valuation because what we're doing is taking what we see in these buckets and projecting them into the future to get a better understanding of what the value should be. And if all those one-time expenses are included in there, then what it looks like is it costs more to run the business than it really does, which ultimately hurts your valuation. So by doing the work of properly categorizing things and putting them in their proper buckets, even if it means creating a couple more, what it allows you to show is here's the actual baseline amount that it takes to run this business, which gives you the maximum valuation—the ability to project out into the future accurately, which will give you the maximum valuation. Does that sound right?
Carrie Wallace
That is correct. That is correct. Yes.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Oh, that's very interesting. Layman's by the way, yeah, that's pretty good.
Carrie Wallace
Yeah, that wasn't so layman's.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Well, it was just—I'm kind of like, you guys are the smarties, I'm just the everyman here. So I'm just trying to put it down into language that we can understand.
Carrie Wallace
So Ryan, if there's an agent out there that's listening to this and they're like, "But I'm not selling, I'm not buying, I don't—why does this matter to me?" There's also the reality that if you want to use the industry benchmarks that are out there and you're not classifying your expenses the same way, you could actually be led down a path to think that I'm doing fantastic or I'm not doing so well. If you're comparing yourself to benchmarks that have expenses classified differently than your own, it's important if you want to use the information in our industry the right way to make sure that you're actually aligning with the way that they're classifying the expenses.
And again, that's another part. That's how I actually determine which accounts to dig into. If you're way outside the benchmark, most likely you're classifying your expenses differently than the benchmark. And we've got to figure it out.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
So in this case, it would actually make sense to really align with the industry. So then everyone's speaking the same accounting language, essentially. You don't want to have to try to translate your version of accounting buckets and classifications because it'll just confuse people and possibly make them a little more hesitant.
Carrie Wallace
Correct.
Chris Paradiso
Very, very interesting. Well, think about today if your books aren't accurate, Ryan. You get 22, 25—I mean, the rate increases are tremendous. How many people at the end of the year are going to say, "Well, I made a million last year. I grossed a million. I grossed 1.25. I grew by $250,000. I grew by 25%." That's simply not true because of the increases. What is the real truth of your growth? How many clients did you lose? How much premium did you really increase, put on the books versus just taking the carrier increases? So what is the true health of that agency? And what is the true health of you moving forward? What kind of year did you really have?
Carrie Wallace
Yeah, well, not to go off topic, but that's also why I think these hard market situations should be full throttle growth. Because so many agencies sit on their numbers because they see revenue increasing just because of rate increase. And they're not necessarily pushing into their accounts. There's so many people whose antenna is up from a customer perspective right now. If you're not tracking both revenue and, like you said Chris, total accounts gained—netting out the increases in premium—then you could actually have a down year where you technically make more on the top line growth. And that's a scary thought.
For the agencies that are working with Mick or Patty or doing some of these other high-end trainings and really pushing hard and really investing in this time, they're just capturing, capturing, capturing. And when everything starts to settle, it's going to be like a trampoline effect for those who have put in the work right now. So I know we're not on here to talk sales, but I can't help but bang the drum of now is the time. There's so much opportunity out there.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
So, I guess one of the things that I get asked about a lot just because of my time at Rogue and the fact that I have been open about trying a whole bunch of different commission structures—I get asked a lot of questions about how to compensate people. I am not a compensation expert in the industry. I just get asked this question quite a bit. Happy to share what I did and what I found worked. But to me, it seems like if you have a good feel for your numbers again—and Mick, I'm going to toss this one to you because I'm interested in your take on this. How can we use an accurate and clean understanding of our numbers to properly incentivize our team to hit these numbers, to grow our agency? Because you and I have even talked about this before. This idea—I feel like there's so many misunderstandings, so many different philosophies, and so many agencies' incentive structure on compensation, particularly for producers, is so misaligned to growth. How do we start to use this stuff to build compensation programs that are actually going to help our agencies grow?
Mick Hunt
Yeah, that's a great question. And yeah, we had a ton of conversation about that, right? So let's go to the producer model first. If you don't have your commissions reconciled, you really don't know what you're paying your producers. I don't care what model you have. You could say 35 new, 45 new, 50 new, whatever. If you're not reconciling, you have no idea because odds are you're leaving money on the table or you're throwing money away. One of the two.
So, you know, you and I had this conversation—and I'll just throw Ryan under the bus. Ryan, why should I put my commission percentages for every line of business with every carrier in my management system? And I said, "Because if I'm a producer for you, I want to be able to know what I'm getting paid and how I'm getting paid." So for me, having that structure is critically important.
And then when we talk about staff incentives, if you put out a 5% growth target or even a 5% profitability target, how do you know? If you're not truly looking at your accounting structure, how do you know where that money is coming from? Because maybe leaders aren't incentivized on percentage of revenue, right, which they shouldn't be, to be honest with you. Because you have operational leaders where growth from a revenue perspective or new sale perspective might not be a target for them. But cleaning up or shoring up some of your expenses could be. So if you don't really understand that and if you don't have it classified right, what are you doing?
Chris Paradiso
I'll tell you, the other thing you can do, and this is just personal experience going through this. And I'm sure Mick and Chris and Carrie, you've dealt with this too. I would get all these questions from my producers because they constantly would have problems with how much they're being paid. Because they're doing gorilla math on their notebook—"I'm due all this money." And you're like, "Wait a minute. I don't even have that much money in my bank account. I don't understand."
If you don't have your commissions properly reconciled—once we started doing it the proper way and with the proper percentages, we go, "Well, here's how much we've been paid. And here's your percentage of that. And here's how much you get. And that's why you're getting it." Because it never lines up appropriately. And then you get people paying you commissions on a monthly basis versus an annual, or if it's a six month term, and there's all these different structures.
I found we were overpaying our producers every single month until we started reconciling. And they were even unhappy with how much they're getting. And then when we started properly reconciling, they were even more unhappy, except they didn't have an argument. Because I literally was like, "Here, I can show you exactly what came in for your accounts. You get paid when we get paid. Here it is." And I didn't have that defense before. And it ended up saving me cash flow every month because I was overpaying them all. Ultimately, it would get squared over the course of a year. But on a month-to-month basis, it was really impacting our cash flow because we were overpaying everybody every month because we were kind of guessing at what we should send them. Which is crazy to say. But we were kind of guessing. And it's scary to think back to that time. I'm glad we eventually fixed it. But I can't be the only one doing this.
Mick Hunt
Can I sell for you? I like the overpay. This is why everyone loves working for me. I just overpay everybody.
Carrie Wallace
Chris, here's literally what I saw with Ryan. I said, "Ryan, you do know you don't get commission on taxes and fees, right?" He's like, "What do you mean?" I'm like, "Dude, you're paying your producers on money that you don't actually collect revenue on."
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Oh, Lord have mercy. Hold on, I want to be fair. Some of this—there are certain tasks which my brain has a hard time slowing down to do. So what I was doing—I know, just for the record, I do know you don't get paid commission on those. However, what I was not doing, to Mick's point—he's 100% right about this—I was not slowing down long enough to pull out the taxes and fees. I was just paying based on the top line number because, well, this is just the way that I am.
Carrie Wallace
And you're not the only one. So can I just—
Host (Ryan Hanley)
You're not the only one. I promise you.
Carrie Wallace
Yeah. There's probably 30% of the people listening, if they're being honest, they're like, "Holy crap. You need to go back and look because I promise you're giving it away." It adds up.
Chris Paradiso
I mean, especially—and this is why Mick used to bang me over the head with this. We were like a 45 to 47% agency bill agency. So the taxes and fees on that stuff really adds up over time. So you're taking that percentage on paying commission on that over time. And that was when I had to bite the bullet. I didn't pull all that commission out and I didn't want to not pay them. So I think we did like a—I figured out a percentage where I just kind of ate a percentage of what I had overpaid them just to make everybody happy. But think about that. I mean, that's a real expense to our bottom line that I had to eat because I wasn't properly reconciling and paying commissions in the right way. And it's scary to think that I did that for a long time.
Carrie Wallace
So Ryan, you're sitting here talking about this and all I can think is it's Ryan Hanley that's doing this. So let's just think about this for a moment. You are a natural born salesperson. There's no two ways around that. You're a marketing genius and you sell. And that's true for a lot of people that run agencies. They are salespeople, relation people. They are not financial people. It's actually uncomfortable for them to look at a spreadsheet, be in numbers, and have to slow their brains down enough to actually think about the crazy details that we're talking about on this podcast.
So the reality is you're one of the most valuable people as the owner inside the agency. If you spend your time thinking about debits and credits and commissions and all of these things, you are not serving your agency well. You're not at your highest and best. But it's always the owner that does it. They are the ones that hold payroll. They are the ones that actually look at the financials. It's not often that you delegate that until you get to a certain size. Not outsourcing it is one of the largest expenses inside an agency because of the opportunity cost loss. There's no two ways around that.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
I think that this is an incredible point. I think this point transcends so many activities in the agency, but this one in particular. And it's why when both Chris and Mick referred me to PFS originally—I think I asked both of you and you both said PFS and I was like, "If these two guys say yes, then this is where I'm going." But it was one of the biggest awakenings for me as an agency owner. Because one, I wasn't doing it to begin with. I was passing it off to someone else in need because we had a fairly transparent and open system for the most part. I mean, obviously, we had some HR stuff that you couldn't share, but our system was fairly open and would probably make most agency owners hurl at the level of transparency that we had.
But when that ultimately got outsourced and we just got financials sent to us every month by Aaron's team, it was literally a game changer. Because it's not just the time. It's the brain cycles. It's literally the brainpower that you have to spend that isn't going towards training a producer or working with an account manager on renewals or whatever true revenue generating activity you could be doing. You're wasting brainpower on this stuff versus when you get it in the email at month end and you comb through it and you go, "OK, this looks good. OK, this is up. OK, what's up with that? Maybe ask a few questions. Boom." And now you know where you are and off you go. It is a game changer. And I think that there's so many activities like this, but this is one of the key ones.
Carrie Wallace
One other key concept that was heard on this podcast is you're a genius, Ryan Hanley.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Yeah. I blushed a little bit. For those that aren't watching the video, I was like, "Oh, that feels kind of good." I stood up a little bit. He paid me. It's all good. That felt really good.
Laughter
So, okay. So we've talked a lot about this whole thing. So the four horsemen of the accounting apocalypse here that I have on the call—you guys all form like Voltron and AgencyPoint comes out. So what is the idea behind AgencyPoint? I know it says "Powered by PFS Global." Like what is it? How does it all work? And what is the offering that you guys have that people should know about? Aaron, you want to toss that up to whoever wants to take it?
Aaron Stocks
I'll take it. Yeah, so we decided that PFS wanted to make a big push into the insurance space. We were already primarily insurance, and I think it's super underserviced in that industry specifically. And so we wanted to do that. We wanted to come out with a brand for the insurance space. So we decided on AgencyPoint. So AgencyPoint is PFS. PFS is AgencyPoint. But it's how we're going to market to the insurance space because it's very underserviced. PFS already has similar names in the industry, so we didn't want to get it confused. So we chose AgencyPoint as our way to market to these independent agents.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Awesome. Okay. So you're getting PFS in all the services and people and expertise. This is like a branding and sculpting place so that people can get a very clear—this is for insurance agencies, this division, these individuals focus on it. It's just a more focused department inside of PFS as a whole. Is that essentially it?
Aaron Stocks
That is correct. Exactly.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Yeah, I do like the name too. That's cool. So how do people—obviously we've talked a lot about it. For anyone listening at home, I wanted to talk about this topic in general, but I also having been a user and believe in—and obviously I have not just deep friendships, but also believe in the four individuals that are on the call as well and have been a client of PFS. So I wanted to get this out there. How do people get a hold of you, Aaron? How do they work with you? And maybe just break down real quickly what the sweet spot is for an agency to come work with you. Because I know even though we were a client, we were on the smaller side and you guys were kind and you brought us in and you helped us at a time when we really had a need. It seemed more like charity than anything because we were probably a pain in your butt. But I know you do have a sweet spot client or segment of the market that you can really do your best work for. Maybe describe that and share a little bit about how people can get a hold of you.
Aaron Stocks
Sure, absolutely. So we don't say this to discourage people. Like your agency, you are looking to grow, and that's really what we're honing in on. If you're a smaller agency looking to grow to the next level, we would absolutely love to do your accounting. So it's not charity. It's a mutual relationship that will be beneficial for both of us. Our sweet spot is revenue of $750,000 or greater is our sweet spot. Again, if you're smaller than that but you're looking to grow, please reach out to us for sure. We can help and get you to $750,000 and above using accounting.
To get a hold of us, very simply, you can go to myagencypoint.com and get all of our contact information. You can call us at 909-294-7372 or email us at info—I-N-F-O—at pfsglobal.com.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
Yeah, awesome. And I will have—PFSonline.com?
Aaron Stocks
Yeah.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
And I will have all the links and stuff in the show notes as well. So if you're listening in audio and missed it, you can just go to the show notes page and get linked over and connect with everybody. I'll have everyone who's on the call linked in there as well.
Guys, I appreciate you coming on. And I think we could talk about this topic all day. I think that this is one of those things that people gloss over because it's not sexy and fun like sales and marketing. And I'll be honest with you, I didn't even respect the accounting enough until I started Rogue. Even as an executive in companies, you're just handed financials from the accounting department and you look at them. But until you're the one that's actually responsible for putting them together, responsible ultimately, I think you don't have a true appreciation for what this can do.
And if you haven't worked with someone like AgencyPoint and seen what clean financials look like—the work that has to be done, properly categorized expenses, properly categorized income—when you start to see it, all of a sudden you kind of discount it, discount it, and then you see it and the light goes on. You're like, "Wait a minute. I wish I had had this for years." So I just think this is wonderful. I'm glad that you are focused on the insurance industry. I have always been an advocate for what you've done. And I've referred some people over to you over the years. So I appreciate it and appreciate all your time and everybody sharing their experience. Thank you so much.
Aaron Stocks
Thanks for having us.
Mick Hunt
Thanks, Ryan.
Chris Paradiso
Thanks, Ryan. We appreciate you.
Host (Ryan Hanley)
But this was not free, by the way. I don't know what the free stuff was you were talking about at the beginning of the call. Is my check in the mail? Hold on. You said this was like a friend thing. I don't understand.
Laughter
All right, we're out of here. Thank you.
End of interview
[Advertisement] Narrator: Closed twice as many deals by this time next week? Sound impossible? It's not. With the One Call Close system, you'll stop chasing leads and start closing deals in one call. This is the exact method we use to close 1,200 clients in under three years during the pandemic. No fluff, no endless follow-ups, just results fast. Based in behavioral psychology and battle tested, the One Call Close system eliminates excuses and gets the prospect saying yes more than you ever thought possible. If you're ready to stop losing opportunities and start winning, visit masteroftheclose.com. That's masteroftheclose.com. Do it today.